California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 5, 1997
Student v. San Mateo Union High School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 1183-95, SN 1266-95 · Hearing Officer Mark Paxson
San Mateo Union High School District's offer of a Burlingame High special day class with county mental health services upheld.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted in the decision.
Summary
San Mateo Union High School District filed for due process after the parents of a 16-year-old student refused to consent to her IEP. The parent also filed a case, and the two cases were consolidated. The student was eligible for special education with a specific learning disability, with attention deficit disorder listed as one of her processing deficits. Assessors also noted significant social-emotional concerns. The parents did not consent to the District's proposed placements and later enrolled her in a District continuation school, where she got no special education services and attended only a few days. No one appeared for the student at the January 1997 hearing, so the Hearing Officer dismissed the parent's case without prejudice. On the District's case, Hearing Officer Mark Paxson relied on testimony from Dr. Barbara Kammerlohr and tutor Dr. Joanne Rossi, along with the assessors' reports. All of them agreed the student's emotional needs were keeping her from using her academic skills. The Hearing Officer found she needed a small, structured class focused on social skills, plus mental health services. Applying the Rowley standard, the Hearing Officer held that the special day class at Burlingame High School, together with counseling and teacher collaboration from North County Mental Health, met her needs and was reasonably designed to provide educational benefit. Resource specialist services were too little support for her. The District prevailed on both issues and was ordered to prepare an IEP that includes this placement and these services.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled a district-filed case when no one appeared for the student. The Hearing Officer still applied the Rowley test and found that mental health services were needed for the student to benefit from her education. The order told the district to prepare an IEP that included both the special day class and county mental health services.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedDistrict-filed: implement IEP
Issue 1. Has the District offered an appropriate placement for STUDENT?
The special day class at Burlingame High School, combined with mental health services, met the student's unique needs, matched the June and October 1996 IEPs, and was reasonably designed to provide educational benefit; resource specialist services were not enough given her social-emotional needs.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. Does STUDENT require mental health services to benefit from her education?
Unanimous evidence from witnesses and assessors showed the student requires mental health services (counseling and collaboration with teachers) to benefit from her education, so those services must be part of any placement.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order that district's offer may be implemented. District shall prepare an IEP consistent with the decision, including a special day class at Burlingame High School and additional services provided by North County Mental Health.
- Parent's case (Case No. 1266-95) dismissed without prejudice after no one appeared for the student at the hearing.
Key authorities
Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175; 20 U.S.C. 1401(a)(16), (a)(18); 34 CFR 300.550; Education Code 56031; Education Code 56340 et seq.
People named in the decision
- Dr. Barbara Kammerlohr, director of special education; District witness, San Mateo Union High School District
- Dr. Joanne Rossi, director and private tutor/evaluator; District witness, Foster City Reading Institute
- Jacqueline McEvoy, principal; District witness, Peninsula High School
- Herb Slavit, school psychologist (psychoeducational assessment), San Mateo Union High School District
- John Weatherman, resource specialist (observation), San Mateo Union High School District
- Kathleen Bargman, speech pathologist (speech-language screening and assessment), San Mateo Union High School District
- Dr. Linda Halog, psychologist (social/emotional assessment), Not stated
- Mary Ellen Hirsch, home teacher; resource specialist, San Mateo Union High School District
- Dr. Brauer, private psychiatrist and neurologist (diagnosis), Private
- Chip Friedman, private psychologist (diagnosis), Private
- Foster City Reading Institute, private tutoring provider and academic evaluator, Private
- North County Mental Health, county mental health agency (AB 3632 assessment and services), County mental health
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in San Mateo, California, on January 7, 1997. Petitioner San Mateo Union High School District (District) was represented by attorney Diane Finkelstein. Also present on the District's behalf was Dr. Barbara Kammerlohr, director of special education. No one appeared on behalf of Respondent STUDENT. The following individuals testified on behalf of the District: Dr. Barbara Kammerlohr; Dr. Joanne Rossi, director, Foster City Reading Institute; and Jacqueline McEvoy, principal, Peninsula High School. Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision. ISSUES (1) Has the District offered an appropriate placement for STUDENT? (2) Does STUDENT require mental health services to benefit from her education? PROCEDURAL MATTERS On November 27, 1995, the District requested a due process hearing to address issues of assessment and placement relating to STUDENT. By letter dated the same day, but not received by the Hearing Office until December 27, 1995, MOTHER also requested a due process hearing on behalf of STUDENT (Case No. 1266-95). MOTHER indicated that the issues for her hearing would also relate to assessment and placement. On January 17, 1996, the two cases were consolidated. On January 31, 1996, by agreement of the parties, both cases were taken off calendar. On November 19, 1996, the District requested that these cases be scheduled for hearing. This matter convened for hearing at 9:30 a.m. on January 7, 1997. At that time, no one appeared on behalf of Respondent. As a result, the District requested that Case No. 1266-95 be dismissed. The Hearing Officer granted the District's request and Case No. 1266-95 was dismissed without prejudice. SUMMARY OF RELEVANT EVIDENCE STUDENT is presently sixteen years old and in her third year of high school. She is eligible for special education services due to a specific learning disability. STUDENT is currently enrolled at Peninsula High School, a continuation school. In July 1995, STUDENT was diagnosed with attention deficit disorder (ADD) by Dr. Brauer, psychiatrist and neurologist, and Chip Friedman, psychologist. On October 2, 1995, STUDENT was assessed by Herb Slavit, school psychologist. (District Exhibit No. 1) Prior to October 1995, STUDENT had not received special education services. Mr. Slavit administered a range of tests, including the Wide Range Achievement Test-Revised (WRAT-R), Peabody Individual Achievement Test-Revised (PAIT-R), and the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Revised (WISC-R). On the PIAT-R, a test to assess reading comprehension, STUDENT received a standard score of 62 and a grade equivalent of 3.7. On the WRAT-R, STUDENT received standard scores of 87 in Reading, 72 in Spelling, and 68 in Arithmetic. On the WISC-R, STUDENT received a Verbal IQ score of 85, Performance IQ score of 96, and a Full Scale IQ of 89. Regarding these, Mr. Slavit concluded that the results were questionable and not completely valid because of emotional and attitudinal factors. Mr. Slavit stated in his report that STUDENT "lacked motivation to do well on the tests and did as little work as possible or the minimal amount in her responses." Mr. Slavit also administered several tests relating to social/emotional needs. Included among these tests were the Mooney Problem Checklist and the Incomplete Sentence Blank, tests designed to assess a child's concerns and feelings. He also administered projective tests but did not report the results because he considered them invalid. Mr. Slavit concluded that STUDENT had processing deficits in memory, visual memory, and retention of factual information. Mr. Slavit also reviewed the DSM-IV criteria for ADD and concluded, based on information from STUDENT's mother, that STUDENT's behaviors were consistent with an ADD diagnosis. Mr. Slavit compared his results with those from an earlier assessment in 1993 and concluded that STUDENT could meet the eligibility criteria for a specific learning disability. Mr. Slavit also expressed the opinion in his report that there was sufficient information to consider SED eligibility. Mr. Slavit pointed to STUDENT's unhappiness, moodiness and depression, which he stated has been "major, chronic, severe, marked, intense, existed over a long period of time and has adversely affected her educational performance at school." In conjunction with Mr. Slavit's assessment, John Weatherman, resource specialist, conducted an observation of STUDENT and prepared a detailed report of his observation. (District Exhibit No. 1) Mr. Weatherman concluded that STUDENT could be found eligible for special education as either learning disabled or SED. Mr. Weatherman observed incidents of depression, oppositional-defiant behavior, and passive-aggressive behavior. Both Mr. Weatherman and Mr. Slavit recommended referral to North County Mental Health (Mental Health). Kathleen Bargman, speech pathologist, completed a speech and language screening on October 10, 1995. Ms. Bargman concluded that STUDENT demonstrated sufficient speech and language skills that she did not need a comprehensive speech and language assessment. Following the assessment, an IEP meeting was held on October 26, 1995. (District Exhibit No. 2) During that meeting, STUDENT's regular education teacher reported that STUDENT had very low work output and that she did not take advantage of accommodations that had been made for her in the class. The IEP team noted that there had been "an amazing downward trend this fall," that STUDENT had been rude to her teacher, and that she had indicated to the assessors that she did not want to be in school anymore. The IEP team adjourned without reaching a decision on eligibility. The IEP team reconvened on November 23, 1995. The team determined that STUDENT had a specific learning disability, with ADD as one of her processing deficits. The team recommended a referral to Mental Health for further assessment. The team also recommended placement in the resource specialist program for two or three periods per day. STUDENT's parents refused to consent to either the placement or the Mental Health referral. Due to the refusal of STUDENT's parents to consent to the IEP developed on November 23, 1995, the District submitted a due process hearing request on November 27, 1995. On January 31, 1996, the parties met in mediation. At that time, STUDENT's parents agreed to an assessment, including speech and language, social/emotional by the school psychologist, and a referral to Mental Health for a 3632 assessment. (District Exhibit No. 5) Pending completion of the assessments, STUDENT was to receive home instruction. (District Exhibit No. 6) Based on the results of the 3632 assessment, Mental Health recommended counselling, collaboration with the school, and a medication evaluation. (Testimony of Dr. Barbara Kammerlohr and District Exhibit No. 10) The Mental Health assessors found that STUDENT presents as a very angry and depressed 15-year-old adolescent with significant attention deficit, impulsivity, and very impaired judgment which has resulted in her becoming involved in very dangerous even life-threatening situations. She has been quite oppositional both at home and at school. She is easily frustrated and embarrassed. The psychologist who conducted the social/emotional assessment, Dr. Linda Halog, concluded that STUDENT could qualify for SED and that she needs individual and family therapy. (Testimony of Dr. Barbara Kammerlohr and District Exhibit No. 11) Dr. Halog administered the Child Behavioral Check List, Ferenbach Sentence Completion Task, Thematic Apperception Test, Rorschach, and Youth Self Report Form. Dr. Halog's conclusion from these tests was that STUDENT had "conflictive familial and peer relationships, poor self-esteem, passive defiant behaviors and depressive feelings." Dr. Halog recommended an intensive special education setting incorporating therapy, collaboration with mental health professionals, and structured instruction for her learning deficits. Ms. Bargman conducted the speech and language assessment and concluded that STUDENT did not meet the criteria for speech and language services. (District Exhibit No. 9) On April 22, 1996, the District convened an IEP meeting to review the assessments. (District Exhibit No. 12) The District offered placement in a special day class (SDC) for learning disabled students at Capuchino High School "or at another school," and Mental Health offered services. The IEP team agreed to additional academic testing by Foster City Reading Institute. STUDENT's parents agreed to the placement at Capuchino and sent STUDENT to the SDC there. Less than a week after enrolling in the SDC class, STUDENT was unilaterally withdrawn by her parents because of concerns relating to students threatening STUDENT. Dr. Kammerlohr agreed to provide home teaching until an alternative placement could be agreed upon. (Testimony of Dr. Kammerlohr) On May 22, 1996, STUDENT was evaluated by Dr. Joanne Rossi, director of the Foster City Reading Institute (FCRI). Dr. Rossi recommended one-to-one tutoring for STUDENT to work on upgrading skills, and to learn strategies for reading, writing, focusing and concentration. Dr. Rossi also recommended that STUDENT continue receiving Mental Health services to address the social and emotional issues that were interfering with her ability to benefit from her education. Following the evaluation, Dr. Rossi began providing individual tutoring for STUDENT one hour per day, two to three days per week. Initially, STUDENT was very nonresponsive, and it took Dr. Rossi several weeks to establish rapport with STUDENT. During this time, STUDENT did not maintain eye contact and engaged in a significant amount of oppositional behavior. Dr. Rossi also had weekly contact with the home teacher provided by the District and the home teacher reported the same experiences with STUDENT. When STUDENT did do the work, she did very well. In several areas, including comprehension and inferential skills, her academic work exceeded what her testing showed her skill level was. STUDENT was most productive when she was writing on the computer and could write for up to 45 minutes. (Testimony of Dr. Rossi) On June 18, 1996, the IEP team convened to discuss placement options and review Dr. Rossi's evaluation. (District Exhibit No. 18) The District offered an SDC at Burlingame High School or an SDC at Hillsdale High School. STUDENT's parents agreed to visit the classes to observe them. They did not sign the IEP to enroll STUDENT in either of the proposed placements. The parties agreed to keep STUDENT on home teaching and FCRI tutoring until her parents had a chance to visit the proposed placements. The parties also agreed that Mental Health would continue providing services. On August 2, 1996, STUDENT's home teacher, Mary Ellen Hirsch, completed a progress report for STUDENT. (District's Exhibit No. 19) Ms. Hirsch, a resource specialist, indicated that STUDENT needs improvement in attention, attitude toward learning, conduct, initiative, punctuality, seeking help when needed, and work habits. Ms. Hirsch further commented that STUDENT did not want to do summer school. She usually took 15-20 minutes after my arrival for home teaching for her to get ready (out of bed). She did not do much reading homework, but always did her math and writing assignments. She shows signs of being disturbed (head shaking, inability to communicate, turning her back to the table, throwing items, etc.). She also cooperates on doing her work, reads aloud, and tackles math. Written comprehension is good. In October 1996, the parties again met in an IEP meeting. STUDENT's parents had not observed either SDC offered in June 1996. To give STUDENT's mother a chance to look at the placements, the IEP team agreed to continue home teaching, tutoring from FCRI, Mental Health services, and transportation to FCRI. Since being found eligible for Mental Health services, STUDENT has only attended one or two sessions of counselling. (Testimony of Dr. Barbara Kammerlohr and District Exhibit No. 20) On December 2, 1996, STUDENT's parents unilaterally enrolled STUDENT at Peninsula High School, a continuation school in the District. Dr. Kammerlohr requested an IEP meeting to develop transition and RSP services at Peninsula for STUDENT. However, STUDENT's mother refused to participate in an IEP meeting or to consider special education services for STUDENT at Peninsula. (Testimony of Dr. Barbara Kammerlohr) STUDENT has not received any special education services at Peninsula. During STUDENT's interview prior to enrolling at Peninsula, she was very negative, did not want to answer questions and expressed anger at Jacqueline McEvoy, although they had never met before. (Testimony of Jacqueline McEvoy) From December 2, 1996, to the date of the hearing, STUDENT attended school at Peninsula on December 2, 3, 4, 5, 9, and 11, and was absent on the remaining days. STUDENT has refused to participate in physical education. (Testimony of Jacqueline McEvoy) It should be noted that STUDENT's IEPs continue to identify her as eligible for special education services due to a learning disability. Eligibility has not been expanded to include SED because STUDENT's parents have refused to consent to eligibility based on SED. In addition, although STUDENT has apparently refused to participate in Mental Health services, Mental Health has continue to make those services available to her. DISCUSSION (1) Has the District offered an appropriate placement for STUDENT? (2) Does STUDENT require mental health services to benefit from her education? Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. 1401(a)(18), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the students individualized education program. "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child. . . ." 20 U.S.C. 1401(a)(16). Central to the development of a child's special education program is the individualized education program (IEP). California has established detailed requirements for IEPs. Education Code 56340 et seq. In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the student. 458 U.S. 175, 200. Based on the foregoing, a free appropriate public education must meet the following three requirements: (A) The placement must meet the child's unique needs. (B) The placement must conform to the child's IEP, which must meet certain legal requirements. (C) The placement must be reasonably designed to provide the child with educational benefit. The District has proposed several different placements for STUDENT: an SDC at Burlingame High School for students with severe language disorders, an SDC at Hillsdale High School for learning handicapped students, and resource specialist services with transition tutoring from FCRI at Capuchino High School. Both SDCs were proposed at the June and October 1996 IEP meetings. The resource specialist services have not been offered since STUDENT was first found eligible for special education in 1995. While the District has proposed these three options, the testimony of the District's witnesses, primarily Dr. Kammerlohr, establishes that the District believes that the SDC at Burlingame is the most appropriate placement for STUDENT. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will analyze that placement first. (A) The placement must meet the child's unique needs. Dr. Kammerlohr testified that STUDENT needs to learn appropriate social skills and how to interact with other children. Dr. Kammerlohr testified that STUDENT has not been successful in a regular education program and has even had difficulty working with a one-to-one teacher at home. Dr. Kammerlohr pointed to STUDENT's failure to regularly attend class at Peninsula as additional evidence that she cannot succeed in a regular education program at this time. Finally, Dr. Kammerlohr testified that STUDENT's social and emotional needs are preventing her from using her academic skills. For these reasons, Dr. Kammerlohr testified that STUDENT requires placement in a special day class. Dr. Rossi testified that STUDENT is probably the most difficult student she has worked with in 31 years of teaching. Dr. Rossi testified that STUDENT's emotional issues override her academic issues and that, if STUDENT did not have such significant emotional issues, she would be able to function very well in a regular education environment. Dr. Rossi recommended a special day class with emphasis on social interactions. Dr. Rossi also testified that STUDENT needs Mental Health services for any placement to work for STUDENT. Based on the foregoing testimony and the comments of the various assessors described above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires a small, structured classroom environment that emphasizes social skills and appropriate interactions. The testimony of Dr. Rossi compellingly establishes that STUDENT's primary issues at this time are social and emotional issues which are interfering with her ability to utilize her academic skills and benefit from her education. Therefore, any placement for STUDENT should address the social and emotional issues which are preventing her from benefitting from her education. The testimony of the witnesses, along with comments of the assessors who evaluated STUDENT, was unanimous with respect to STUDENT's need for Mental Health services. Based on the unanimity of the evidence on this issue, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's unique needs include Mental Health services and that any placement should include such services. According to Dr. Kammerlohr, the proposed special day class at Burlingame High School provides a small, structured environment for students with severe language disorders. The emphasis of the class is on the pragmatics of social interaction and remediation of academic deficits. The class incorporates a significant amount of class discussion and group work focusing on social skills. At the same time, Mental Health has continued to offer Mental Health services in the form of counselling and collaboration with STUDENT's teachers. The Hearing Officer finds that the combination of the special day class and services offered by Mental Health are designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs. (B) The placement must conform to the child's IEP, which must meet certain legal requirements. Under the circumstances of this case, the issue is whether the District's proposed placement includes a legally appropriate IEP. STUDENT's parents last consented to a proposed IEP developed by the District in June 1996. However, at that time, STUDENT's parents consented only to the summer placement and the first two weeks of the school year. The District's proposed placement in, among other classes, the special day class at Burlingame High School and Mental Health continued to offer services. It appears that total consent to this placement was contingent on STUDENT's parents visiting the class. It is the dispute over the June 1996 IEP, and also the IEP proposed in October 1996, which has given rise to this hearing. There were no allegations made that the IEPs proposed by the District are not appropriate IEPs for STUDENT. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement in the Burlingame SDC is in conformance with the IEP dated June 1996, and is also consistent with the proposed placement contained in the IEP dated October 8, 1996. (C) The placement must be reasonably designed to provide the child with educational benefit. It is always difficult to determine whether a program in which a child has not yet participated will provide him or her with educational benefit. However, it is possible, with the input of professionals who have worked with the child, to determine whether a placement is reasonably designed to provide educational benefit. In the present case, the opinions of the educators and other professionals who have worked with or evaluated STUDENT were unanimous that STUDENT requires a small, structured environment that focuses on her social skills and interactions with others. Furthermore, all agreed that STUDENT requires Mental Health services to benefit from her education. Based on the unanimity of the testimony and other evidence on these issues, and the components of the District's proposed placement and Mental Health services, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement is reasonably designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires Mental Health Services to benefit from her education and that the District has proposed an appropriate education.(Footnote 1) Federal and state law include a requirement that students with disabilities be educated in the least restrictive environment. See 34 CFR Ch. III 300.550 and Education Code 56031. The resource specialist program offered by the District, if appropriate, would be a less restrictive environment than a special day class. However, the evidence establishes that STUDENT presently requires a more restrictive environment than a resource specialist class. Therefore, the resource specialist program would not be an appropriate placement for STUDENT. PREVAILING PARTY Pursuant to Education Code 565057(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statue: Petitioner San Mateo Union High School District prevailed on all issues heard and decided. RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code 56505(i). ORDER San Mateo Union High School District's shall prepare an individualized education progrma consistent with this decision, including a special day class at Burlingame High School and additional services provided by North County Mental Health.DATED: February 5, 1997 _______________________________ Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1) Based on the finding that the Burlingame SDC is appropriate, the Hearing Officer does not address the question of whether the Hillsdale SDC would be appropriate for STUDENT.
