California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 4, 2004
Student v. Rocklin Unified School District et al. (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 1185-04, SN04-00520, SN04-01185 · Hearing Officer Christian P. Hurley
Rocklin Unified and Placer County Office of Education denied FAPE with interim preschool offer, but April 2004 STEPS class offer upheld.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
On March 24, 2004, Hearing Officer Vincent Pastorino granted the student's stay put motion in part, ordering services conforming to the last IFSP but not requiring the same providers. On May 26, 2004, the District-filed case SN04-01185 was consolidated with the student's case SN04-00520.
Summary
The parents of a preschooler eligible for special education under "autistic-like behavior" filed for due process. The District and Placer County Office of Education (PCOE) then filed their own case seeking to assess the student, and the two cases were consolidated. Before age three, the student received about 27.5 hours a week of Early Start services: in-home applied behavior analysis (ABA) through the Lovaas Institute (LIFE), plus clinic-based speech, occupational, and music therapy. In September 2003, the District and PCOE offered an interim placement in PCOE's STEPS preschool class. The offer included one goal and about 18.75 hours a week. Hearing Officer Christian Hurley found that offer was not a FAPE. It did not conform to the student's family service plan, and the required 30-day review and assessment plan never happened. The Hearing Officer rejected the parents' claims that their input was ignored at both IEP meetings. The parents also argued the District needed a transition plan before changing providers under a stay put order; the Hearing Officer ruled the law does not require one. The April 2004 offer was upheld as a FAPE in the least restrictive environment, including ESY. That offer included the STEPS class, an ABA-trained one-to-one aide, school-based speech and OT, and 17 measurable goals. The Hearing Officer added four hours of consultation to its transition services. He ordered reimbursement through April 23, 2004 consistent with the District's own offer. He denied reimbursement after that date and compensatory music therapy. He also allowed assessment without parental consent, including a comprehensive apraxia assessment.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied Education Code section 56325's 30-day interim placement rule when a toddler moves from Early Start to a district program. The interim offer had to match the family service plan. It also shows SEHO declining to award compensatory music therapy where the parents' private services were reimbursed.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1a. Did the District commit a procedural violation and deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to consider information presented by STUDENT's parents and his providers at the IEP meeting of September 12, 2003?
The team reviewed and considered the parents' and providers' reports, and the mother identified nothing she was prevented from presenting, so there was no procedural violation.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1b. Did the offer set forth in the IEP dated September 12, 2003, constitute a FAPE (October 12, 2003 to April 23, 2004)?
The interim offer had a single transition goal and 18.75 weekly hours, compared with about 27.5 hours of IFSP services. It did not conform to the IFSP, and the required 30-day review and assessment plan never happened, so the offer denied FAPE.
- District prevailedStay put
Issue 1c. Did the District and PCOE deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to develop a transition plan for purposes of stay put?
Stay put law does not require a transition plan when an LEA offers different providers. Stay put only preserves the status quo.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 2a. Did the District commit a procedural violation and deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to consider information presented by STUDENT's parents and his providers at the IEP meeting of April 23, 2004?
Staff reviewed provider reports at a pre-IEP meeting and summarized parent and provider input in the IEP. There was no procedural violation.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2b. Did the District substantively offer STUDENT a FAPE at the IEP meeting on April 23, 2004 (goals, STEPS classroom and teacher, speech and OT setting and provider qualifications, music therapy, behavior intervention, transition services, LRE)?
Under the snapshot rule, the 17 measurable goals, the STEPS class with an ABA-trained 1:1 aide, and school-based speech and OT made up a FAPE in the LRE. Music therapy was not required. Transition services were found adequate once four added hours of consultation were included.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 2c. Did the offer set forth in the IEP dated April 23, 2004, constitute a FAPE for the 2004 ESY?
The first four-week ESY session mirrored the regular-year FAPE offer. The second session, 20 hours a week of in-home ABA from Advance Kids, was designed to prevent regression.
- Not reachedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 3a. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for expenses incurred for behavioral intervention services, speech therapy, and/or occupational therapy for the period from October 12, 2003 to April 23, 2004?
The District and PCOE offered in writing and on the record to reimburse this period, so the Hearing Officer did not decide the issue or name a prevailing party. The order still directs reimbursement consistent with that offer.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 3b. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for expenses incurred from April 23, 2004 to the date of this Decision?
Because the April 23, 2004 offer was a FAPE, there is no reimbursement after that date.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education in the form of music therapy services?
The student received appropriate private services that will be reimbursed and does not need music therapy for FAPE, so no compensatory music therapy was awarded.
- District prevailedDistrict-filed: assess without consent
Issue 5. Are the District and the PCOE entitled to assess STUDENT as identified in the assessment plan dated April 23, 2004, and updated on June 3, 2004?
The District and PCOE had never assessed the student, the assessments were necessary, and the plan met Education Code section 56321. They may assess without parental consent, and the assessment must include a comprehensive apraxia assessment.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to provide or change services. Transition services under the April 23, 2004 IEP offer shall include three hours of consultation/observation between Advance Kids staff and LIFE staff, plus one hour of consultation between Advance Kids staff and the parents, to ensure a smooth move from the in-home ABA program to the school-based program.
- Reimbursement. The District and PCOE shall reimburse the parents for educational services obtained from October 12, 2003 to April 23, 2004, less any amount paid by the regional center, consistent with their May 13, 2004 written offer and their offer on the record. That offer covered up to 23.5 hours per week of in-home discrete trial therapy, up to 2 hours per week of speech therapy, up to 1 hour per week of OT, and up to 1 hour per week of music therapy. No dollar amount was stated.
- Order that district may assess without consent. The District and PCOE may complete their assessment under the plan dated April 23, 2004 and updated June 3, 2004. The assessment must include a comprehensive assessment under Education Code section 56320 et seq. to determine whether the student has apraxia. Parents must get at least five calendar days' notice of the assessment dates and must make the student reasonably available.
Key authorities
Rowley; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education; Florence County Sch. Dist. Four v. Carter; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist.; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Adams v. State of Oregon; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H.; Andress v. Cleveland Independent School District; Stacey G. v. Pasadena Independent School District; Zvi D. v. Ambach; Hoeft v. Tucson Unified School District; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education; Cal. Educ. Code § 56325
People named in the decision
- Jan Lucas, director of special education, Rocklin Unified School District
- Susan Watts, special education administrator, Placer County Office of Education
- Betty Di Regolo, program specialist, Rocklin Unified School District
- Melanie Roy, speech and language therapist, Placer County Office of Education
- Larry Moses, assistant superintendent, Rocklin Unified School District
- Brodi Wetherbee, private speech-language pathologist, Speech and Language Therapy Associates (SLTA), nonpublic agency
- Linh Giang, private occupational therapist, Speech and Language Therapy Associates (SLTA), nonpublic agency
- Tara McConnell, private music therapist, McConnell Music Therapy Services, nonpublic agency
- Scott Cross, clinical director, witness for Student, Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE), nonpublic agency
- Caprice Schweiger, former director of operations, Sacramento office, Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE)
- Theresa Stratton, LIFE instructor, Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE)
- Linda Hess, speech and language therapist, Rocklin Unified School District / Placer County Office of Education
- Laurie Ferrell, occupational therapist, Placer County Office of Education
- Jean Crouse, preschool special day class (STEPS) teacher, Placer County Office of Education, Sierra Elementary School
- Lori Jo Paulin-O'Donnell, school psychologist, Placer County Office of Education
- Romona Burton, associate governmental program analyst, witness for District, California Department of Education
- Mary Gwaltney, private educational psychologist, witness for District, Assessed student at Regional Center request
- Michelle Wenell, executive director, behavior services provider, witness for District, Advance Kids, nonpublic agency
- Diane Ashton, Ph.D., private educational consultant, expert witness for District
- Michelle Heffernan, speech and language pathologist, Rocklin Unified School District
- Rachel Firchau, private music therapist, SLTA
- Jenny Grounds, SELPA representative, Placer-Nevada SELPA
- Jill Boxler, regional center representative, Alta California Regional Center
- Dr. Linda Copeland, developmental pediatrician, Kaiser Permanente
- Vincent Pastorino, Hearing Officer who issued stay put order, Special Education Hearing Office
- Vista Child Therapy, private occupational therapy provider, nonpublic agency
- Speech Works, private speech therapy provider, nonpublic agency
- U.C. Davis M.I.N.D. Institute, private speech therapy provider
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Christian Hurley, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law. The matter proceeded to hearing in Rocklin, California, on June 8, 17, 18, 30, and July 8, 9, 13, 14, 15, 16, and 20, 2004.
STUDENT was represented by attorney Roberta Savage of Varma & Clancy. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was his mother, MOTHER. STUDENT’s father, FATHER, also attended a portion of the hearing. The Rocklin Unified School District (District) and Placer County Office of Education (PCOE) were represented by attorney Marcy Gutierrez of Girard & Vinson. Attorney Dianne Marshall-Freeman and paralegal Aaron Anderson also attended portions of the hearing. Also attending portions of the hearing on behalf of the District and PCOE were Jan Lucas, director of special education for the District; Susan Watts, special education administrator for the PCOE; Betty Di Regolo, program specialist for the District; Melanie Roy, speech and language therapist for the COE; and Larry Moses, assistant superintendent for the District.
Student called the following witnesses: Betty Di Regolo, program specialist for the District; Susan Watts, special education administrator for the PCOE; MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother; Brodi Wetherbee, speech and language therapist with Speech and Language Therapy Associates (SLTA), a certified nonpublic agency; Linh Giang, occupational therapist with SLTA; Tara McConnell, private music therapist; and Scott Cross, clinical director of the Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE), a certified nonpublic agency.
The District and PCOE called the following witnesses: Linda Hess, District speech and language therapist; Laurie Ferrell, PCOE occupational therapist; Jean Crouse, PCOE preschool special day class (SDC) teacher; Betty Di Regolo; Lori Jo Paulin-O’Donnell, school psychologist for the PCOE; Romona Burton, associate governmental program analyst with the California Department of Education; Mary Gwaltney, private educational psychologist; Caprice Schweiger, former director of operations for the Sacramento office of LIFE; Michelle Wenell, executive director of Advance Kids, a certified nonpublic agency; and Diane Ashton, Ph.D., private educational consultant.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The parties submitted written closing briefs. Thereafter, the case was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUES
1. Did the District and the PCOE offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from October 12, 2003, his third birthday, to April 23, 2004?
2. Does the District and the PCOE’s offer set forth in the IEP dated April 23, 2004, constitute a FAPE?
3. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for expenses incurred for behavioral intervention services, speech therapy, and/or occupational therapy for the period from October 12, 2003, to the date of this Decision?
4. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education in the form of music therapy services?
5. Are the District and the PCOE entitled to assess STUDENT as identified in the assessment plan dated April 23, 2004, and updated on June 3, 2004?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Student contends that the District and PCOE’s offers, as set forth in the IEP documents dated September 12, 2003 and April 23, 2004, failed to offer him a FAPE, both procedurally and substantively. With respect to procedural violations, Student maintains that the District and PCOE failed to comply with the procedural protections afforded by the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) when they allegedly impeded the participation of STUDENT’s parents in the development of STUDENT’s IEPs in September 2003 and April 2004. Specifically, Student argues that his mother attempted to participate in the IEP development process, but the District and PCOE ignored both her input and the input of STUDENT’s educational providers, which effectively denied his parents participation in the development of his IEP.
With respect to the alleged substantive violations of FAPE, Student contends that the District’s offered programs for the 2003-2004 regular school year, 2004 ESY, and the 2004-2005 regular school year were not designed to meet his unique needs or reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. Student maintains that the September 12, 2003 IEP, which set forth the District’s offer for the 2003-2004 regular school year, was not designed to meet all of STUDENT’s educational needs or reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit because it only contains one goal, which addresses STUDENT’s transition needs. Student contends that this IEP completely ignores his needs in numerous areas, including academics, gross motor, fine motor, social skills, play skills, and behavior. With respect to the 2004-2005 school year, Student contends that the IEP of April 23, 2004, did not constitute an offer of FAPE because: (1) STUDENT had already mastered most of the goals, and would master all of the goals set forth in that IEP by July 2004, (2) some of goals set forth in that IEP are not measurable, (3) the IEP did not contain any behavioral goals or goals that would continue his progress in the Lovaas Reading and Writing program, (4) the teacher and staff assigned to STUDENT lack the appropriate knowledge and skills of techniques, such as applied behavioral analysis (ABA), to provide instruction to him, (5) the transition plan offered by the District and PCOE is inadequate, (6) the offer does not include music therapy services, (7) the speech and occupational therapy are not offered in a clinical setting and the speech therapy would not be provided by a therapist trained in addressing apraxia, and (8) the one-to-one aide and behavior consultation services are inappropriate.
Student contends that he requires a continuation of his current program through the following nonpublic agencies: Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE), Speech and Language Therapy Associates (SLTA), and Tara McConnell, his music therapist. He argues that these programs and services would continue to meet his unique needs and provide him with educational benefit. Student also seeks reimbursement for the costs of these services during the period from October 12, 2003, to the date of this Decision and an award of compensatory education in the form of music therapy services for the hours he missed for the time period from his third birthday through the first week of June 2004, when he began to receive music therapy again pursuant to a stay put order. Finally, Student argues that the District and PCOE should have developed a transition plan when they sought to change Student’s providers pursuant to a stay put order issued by the Hearing Office on March 24, 2004.
The District contends that the programs offered for the 2003-2004 regular school year, the 2004 ESY, and the 2004-2005 regular school year were both procedurally and substantively appropriate. With respect to the alleged procedural violations, the District and the PCOE maintain that their members of the IEP team seriously considered the information provided by Student’s parents and providers at the IEP meetings of September 12, 2003, and April 23, 2004.
With respect to the alleged substantive violations of FAPE, the District and PCOE argue that they offered STUDENT appropriate programs and services for the time periods at issue. Specifically, the District and PCOE contend that the IEP of September 12, 2003, was an interim offer for the purpose of transitioning STUDENT into the school setting, conducting diagnostic evaluations, and further developing his goals and educational program. As a result, the District and PCOE maintain that it was not appropriate to design every detail of Student’s transitional IEP offer without first conducting diagnostic evaluations of him in the STEPS classroom. They argue, however, that the interim placement and services offered at that IEP meeting were designed to meet STUDENT’s core areas of deficit. The District and PCOE also contend that the IEP document of April 23, 2004, constitutes an offer of FAPE. Specifically, they maintain that: 1) the teachers, staff, and related services providers are appropriately qualified to provide services to STUDENT, 2) the goals and objectives appropriately address all of STUDENT’s identified areas of need, and 3) the STEPS classroom provides a variety of ABA and other instructional methodologies and team collaboration to provide educational benefit to STUDENT.
The District and PCOE further contend that reimbursement is not an issue, that STUDENT does not require compensatory education in the form of music therapy, that he did not require a transition plan with respect to stay put providers, and that the District and PCOE are entitled to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability. With respect to reimbursement, the District and PCOE contend that Student is not entitled to a determination regarding reimbursement for services between the date of third birthday and April 23, 2004, because this issue was resolved prior to hearing by means of an offer by the District and PCOE to reimburse Student’s parents for the costs of educational services incurred by them during this period. Thus, the District and PCOE maintain that the issue of reimbursement does not require a determination by this Hearing Officer. They also maintain that STUDENT does not require music therapy to benefit educationally and that an award of compensatory education in the form of music therapy would therefore be inappropriate. The District and the PCOE further contend that they offered appropriate stay put services at the IEP meeting of April 23, 2004, and that these services did not require a transition plan. Finally, the District and the PCOE argue that they are entitled to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability because they need to establish baseline data, update his present levels of performance, and make any necessary program modifications. They maintain that the District and PCOE presented an appropriate assessment plan and that they have qualified staff to administer the assessments.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
1. Motion to Limit Evidence at Hearing
On June 2, 2004, the Hearing Office received a motion from the District and PCOE to limit evidence at hearing. By this motion, the District and PCOE sought to exclude any and all evidence offered for the issue of whether the District and PCOE offered Student a FAPE prior to April 23, 2004, on the basis that a controversy no longer existed on that issue. Specifically, the District and PCOE argued that the issues of FAPE or reimbursement between the date of Student’s third birthday (October 12, 2003) through April 23, 2004, have been resolved in that the District and PCOE have offered any and all relief Student may be entitled to if he prevailed on that issue at a due process hearing.
On June 7, 2004, the Hearing Office received Student’s opposition to the District and PCOE’s motion. Student argues that the evidence should not be limited at the hearing because evidence of Student’s program and services from his third birthday through April 24, 2004, is relevant to the broader issue of whether he was offered a FAPE for the entire period of time at issue, i.e. from October 12, 2003, to April 22, 2005. In addition, Student asserts that he is seeking compensatory education in the form of music therapy, in addition to the reimbursement for the costs of services that his parents obtained for him during that initial period, and that there has been no resolution of the compensatory education issue in this matter. (Footnote 1)
When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is appropriate in light of the purposes of the IDEA. Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district fails to provide a FAPE, and the placement or services are determined to be appropriate under the IDEA. Equitable considerations may be weighed in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting such relief. (School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 358.) Among the factors to consider is the conduct of the parties. (W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist. (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1486.) Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See Lester H v. K. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.) There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for-hour compensation for missed services. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated with the meaning of the IDEA.” (Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496.)
In this case, while the District and PCOE have offered to reimburse Student for all expenses incurred during the period from October 12, 2003, to April 23, 2004, the issue of compensatory education in the form of music therapy has not been resolved. To determine whether Student is entitled to the remedy of compensatory education, the Hearing Officer must first determine whether the District and PCOE failed to offer Student a FAPE. To determine whether the District and PCOE denied STUDENT a FAPE, the Hearing Officer must receive evidence relating to STUDENT’s unique educational needs at the time the offer was made, as well as the nature and extent of the educational program and services offered to him. Moreover, the IEP documents, assessment reports, and progress reports prepared during the period from October 12, 2003, to April 23, 2004 are relevant to his present levels of performance for purposes of determining whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE at the April 23, 2004 meeting, which issue both parties agree is still in controversy. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer denied the District and PCOE’s motion to limit the evidence in this matter.
2. Motions to Strike Portions of Each Party’s Closing Briefs
A. Student’s Motion to Strike Portions of the District and PCOE’s Brief
On July 28, 2004, the Hearing Office received a motion on behalf of Student to strike pages 41 through 43 and all attachments of the District and PCOE’s closing brief. Student contends that the Hearing Officer ordered a limit of forty pages for each party’s closing brief and that the District and PCOE’s brief exceeds this limit. That same day, the Hearing Office received the District and PCOE’s opposition to Student’s motion to strike. The District and PCOE argue that Student’s motion to strike should be denied because Marcy Gutierrez, counsel for the District and PCOE, experienced a medical emergency that required hospitalization on July 27, 2004, the day the briefs were due, and that, as a result, she was unable to complete her final edit of the closing brief in order to ensure compliance with the page limit. The District and PCOE further contend that they considered requesting an extension of the due date of the brief from the Hearing Officer to allow time for a final edit, but ultimately submitted the brief without final edits due to the time constraints on the Hearing Officer to render his decision in this case. Finally, the District and PCOE maintain that it was their understanding that attachments and charts were not to be counted towards the page limit imposed by the Hearing Officer.
Student’s motion to strike pages 41 to 43 of the District and PCOE’s closing brief is granted. The Hearing Officer did order a limit of forty pages and the District and PCOE’s brief exceeded that limit by three pages. However, Student’s motion to strike all attachments to the District and PCOE’s brief is denied. In reviewing the record, the Hearing Officer notes that he did not indicate whether the page limit he was imposing included or excluded attachments such as charts, graphs, and the like. Because the Hearing Officer’s instructions in this regard were not clear, he will not strike the attachments to the District and PCOE’s brief.
B. The District and PCOE’s Motion to Strike Portions of Student’s Brief
On July 28, 2004, the Hearing Office received a motion by the District and PCOE to strike pages twenty-nine through forty of Student’s closing brief on the ground that the District and PCOE had only received pages 1 through 28 of Student’s closing brief by 5:00 p.m. on July 27, 2004, the deadline imposed by the Hearing Officer. On August 3, 2004, the Hearing Office received Student’s opposition to Respondent’s motion to strike. Student contends that his brief was transmitted in full, via facsimile, to the Hearing Office by 4:40 p.m. and that the transmission of his brief to the District and PCOE began at approximately 4:49 p.m. and was expected to be fully transmitted to the District and PCOE by the 5:00 p.m. deadline.
The District and PCOE’s motion to strike is denied. The Hearing Office received both parties’ briefs prior to the 5:00 p.m. deadline. Upon receipt of briefs by the Hearing Office, the record closed. Moreover, the Hearing Officer did not order the parties to submit any rebuttal briefs in response to the other party’s closing brief. Therefore, the District and PCOE were not prejudiced by the receipt of a portion of Student’s brief a few minutes after the time it was due.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
STUDENT is a four-year-old preschool child identified as eligible for special education and related services as a student with autistic-like behavior. (Footnote 2) He has been diagnosed with autism and apraxia. , (Footnote 3, 4) As a result, STUDENT has deficits in the areas of academics, expressive and receptive language, motor skills, social and behavioral skills, self-help, and sensory processing/integration. These deficits adversely affect his educational performance.
STUDENT has resided within the jurisdictional boundaries of the District and PCOE since at least age three. He has never attended a public school. Both prior to and following his third birthday, STUDENT’s educational program has been provided by several certified nonpublic agencies. STUDENT’s current educational program consists of in-home applied behavior analysis (ABA) instruction through LIFE, music therapy through Tara McConnell, and clinic-based speech and language therapy and occupational therapy through Speech and Language Therapy Associates (SLTA). Prior to SLTA, STUDENT received occupational therapy from Vista Child Therapy and speech and language therapy from Speech Works and the MIND Institute.
When STUDENT was two years old, his mother referred him to the Alta California Regional Center’s (Regional Center) Early Start Program due to concerns regarding his communication and social skills. He underwent an Infant-Toddler Developmental Assessment (IDA) on October 22, 2002. The assessment covered eight domain areas: gross motor, fine motor, relationship to inanimate objects, language and communication, self-help, relationship to persons, emotions and feeling states, and coping behavior. According to the assessment report, his developmental skills ranged from thirteen months to twenty-seven months. His strengths included gross motor, fine motor, and relationship to inanimate objects. These areas were at or near his age level. Areas of concern included relationship to persons, communication, emotions, and coping behavior. Recommendations by the assessor included evaluations in the areas of audiology, speech and language, occupational therapy, and developmental pediatrics.
On November 6, 2002, the Regional Center assessed STUDENT in the areas of speech and language and occupational therapy. The speech and language assessment report indicates that STUDENT’s strongest area of communication at that time was in his play skills, which was at the fifteen to eighteen-month age level. He showed significant delay in all other areas of communication, including pragmatics, use of gesture, language comprehension, and language expression. According to the report, the language delay negatively impacted his ability to communicate his needs and wants and to express himself appropriately. Speech therapy services were recommended to increase all areas of communication. The occupational therapy assessment report indicates STUDENT had age-appropriate fine motor skills, with minimal to negligible delays in gross motor skills, primarily with coordination activities. He appeared to have some difficulty with sensory processing.
On November 8, 2002, Dr. Linda Copeland, a developmental pediatrician with Kaiser Permanente, diagnosed STUDENT with autism. On November 18, 2002, an Individualized Family Service Plan (IFSP) meeting was held. STUDENT was found to be eligible for services under the California Early Start Program. The IFSP document reflects the continuing concerns of STUDENT’s parents regarding his expressive communication and social skills. The early intervention services offered at the IFSP meeting included special instruction to STUDENT and his parents two times per week for sixty minutes per session, speech therapy for one sixty-minute session per week, a diagnostic evaluation by an educational psychologist, and sixty hours per quarter of respite care. The IFSP also set forth four proposed goals in the areas of play participation, communication of wants and needs, interactive play, and gross motor/vestibular activities.
On November 23 and 25, 2002, educational psychologist Mary Gwaltney conducted a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT at the request of the Regional Center. His parents expressed concerns about his lack of language development and social skills. Ms. Gwaltney described his strengths as visual discrimination, completing puzzles, fine and gross motor skills, receptive language, and nonverbal problem solving. STUDENT displayed significant developmental delays in the areas of communication and social/emotional development. He also demonstrated impaired social interaction, manifest by marked impairment in the areas of eye-to-eye gaze, facial expression, body postures, gestures, and the development of peer relationships. He further demonstrated an inflexible adherence to specific nonfunctional routines or rituals and preoccupation with parts of objects. Ms. Gwaltney indicated that STUDENT appeared to qualify for special education services under the eligibility category of autistic-like behavior and suggested that he would benefit from a special education program with possible goals in physical and verbal imitation skills, following simple one-step commands, and developing functional communication using a system such as the Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS). (Footnote 5) She also recommended the use of visual or object schedules, support of self-help skills, and exposure to typically developing peers.
In December 2002, STUDENT’s parents requested services from LIFE and he was accepted into LIFE’s Sacramento clinic-based program on December 6, 2002. On December 31, 2002, Caprice Schweiger, direction of operations for LIFE’s Sacramento office, and Scott Cross, director of clinical services for LIFE, conducted an assessment of STUDENT at his home. They observed STUDENT during independent play, directed play, and structured discrete trial activities. In their report dated January 2, 2003, Ms. Schweiger and Mr. Cross recommended that STUDENT initially receive 15-25 hours of one-to-one in-home behavioral intervention per week, with the hours increasing to thirty hours per week by the time he reached three years old. They further recommended that instruction be devoted to teaching skills in areas such as language, self-help, socialization, play, and reduction of interfering behaviors. They noted that a regular classroom placement should be considered once he could follow simple instructions, receptively and expressively label objects, and demonstrate basic play, social, and conversational skills. In their report, they set forth proposed IFSP goals for STUDENT in the areas of learning readiness, imitation skills, language skills, socialization, visual/spatial skills, and self-help skills.
At an IFSP meeting on January 22, 2003, the team reviewed STUDENT’s LIFE assessment and discussed his other Early Start services. The team recommended an in-home program of fifteen-hours per week beginning January 31, 2003, with continued speech therapy from Speech Works, a nonpublic agency, and a referral to Vista Child Therapy (Vista), another nonpublic agency for occupational therapy services.
In February 2003, an occupational therapist at Vista conducted an occupational therapy assessment of STUDENT and prepared a written report dated February 19, 2003. The therapist reported that STUDENT demonstrated difficulty with sensory processing and modulation, attention/organizational behavior, postural mechanisms and fine and gross motor skills. She further indicated that he had significant difficulty with the processing of sensory input, in particular tactile, proprioceptive, (Footnote 6) and vestibular (Footnote 7) input. She recommended that STUDENT receive two sixty-minute sessions of occupational therapy per week to address these areas of need.
In a LIFE report dated April 4, 2003, STUDENT’s progress for the month of February was summarized. The report indicates that STUDENT was working on six programs: (1) “come here,” (2) nonverbal imitation—gross motor, (3) matching, (4) non-verbal imitation with objects, (5) puzzles, and (6) play skills. During the month of February, STUDENT acquired new responses in all of the programs except imitation skills. According to the report, STUDENT exhibited tantrum behavior (Footnote 8) in 95 percent of all instances when brought to a workstation and in 50 percent of all play time opportunities. This behavior was placed on “extinction,” meaning that no reinforcement or attention was delivered to his tantrums.
On April 9, 2003, an IFSP meeting was held to review STUDENT’s assessments and current progress in all areas of development. The IFSP document reflects that, at that time, STUDENT was participating in an eighteen-hour-per-week in-home behavioral program with LIFE, one hour per week of speech and language therapy with Speech Works, and additional speech and language therapy through the MIND Institute. Vista had not yet scheduled occupational therapy sessions for STUDENT. According to the IFSP, the school options offered for STUDENT included District classes that focused on speech and language needs in a preschool setting and PCOE classes such as the STEPS preschool class, described as a five-day-per-week, four-hour-per-day, nine-student (maximum) class with one teacher and two aides. An IEP meeting was scheduled for September 12, 2003, with visitations by STUDENT’s parents to the District and PCOE classrooms scheduled for May 1, 2003.
On August 19, 2003, an IFSP meeting was held to review STUDENT’s quarterly progress report prepared by LIFE. The IFSP document notes that STUDENT had several ear infections, stomach flus, and sleepless nights during the previous quarter, but that he continued to make good progress with his goals. His strengths continued to be in matching and puzzle skills, while his needs continued to be in the areas of imitation and verbalizations. He had started using PECS and was then requesting twenty or more items from his PECS book. At the time of the IFSP meeting, he was receiving two hours of speech and language therapy per week, one hour of occupational therapy per week, and one hour of music therapy per week.
STUDENT’s progress for the period of January 31, 2003 to August 31, 2003, was summarized in a LIFE report dated September 2, 2003. According to the report, STUDENT was participating in a total of twelve programs through LIFE: (1) “come here,” 2) community, (3) non-verbal imitation—gross motor, (4) non-verbal imitation—with objects, (5) PECS, (6) play skills, (7) puzzles, (8) reading & writing—word to word, (9) reading and writing—object to word, (10) self-help skills/tolerance, (11) sibling play, and (12) story time. With regard to behavior, the report indicates that STUDENT hit his instructor two times during this seven-month period and that he engaged in tantrum behavior a total of 48 times.
On August 13 and 20, and September 3 and 5, 2003, music therapist Rachel Firchau conducted a music therapy assessment of STUDENT at the request of the Regional Center. In her report dated September 10, 2003, Ms. Firchau indicated that STUDENT demonstrated a strong motivated response to music therapy strategies and suggested that music therapy would assist him in reaching his educational goals.
On September 10, 2003, SLTA occupational therapist Lin Giang prepared an occupational therapy progress report. Ms. Giang states that STUDENT made gains in therapy. Specifically, he demonstrated increased transitioning skills and tolerance to movement activities. He continued to experience difficulties with sensory processing, particularly with regard to the vestibular and tactile systems, and with organization of behaviors and self-regulation. She recommended that STUDENT participate in the following activities: (1) swinging, jumping, and bouncing throughout the day to facilitate development of the vestibular system, (2) joint compression and heavy work (e.g. deep pressure to shoulders, carrying a box of toys, doing wall push-ups, playing tug-o-war) to help normalize his sensory processing system so that he is able to self-regulate and organize his behaviors, (3) use of equipment such as swings, trampolines, scooter boards, ball pits, and slides to help facilitate the development of his sensory system, and (4) continued one-to-one clinic-based occupational therapy once per week for sixty minutes. Finally, she set forth three long-term goals for STUDENT in the areas of sensory processing/modulation, sensory processing/vestibular, and fine motor/visual motor.
At an IEP meeting on September 12, 2003, the IEP team reviewed STUDENT’s present levels of performance and the District and PCOE members of the team developed and presented an interim offer of placement and services for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 regular school year. The following persons attended the meeting: STUDENT’s parents, Michelle Heffernan, District speech and language pathologist; Jean Crouse, PCOE STEPS class teacher; Betty Di Regolo, program specialist for the District; Susan Watts, special education administrator for the PCOE; Rachel Firchau, private music therapist; Caprice Schweiger, director of operations for the Sacramento office of LIFE; Theresa Stratton, LIFE instructor; Jenny Grounds of the Placer-Nevada Special Education Local Plan Area (SELPA); and Jill Boxler of the Regional Center.
At that time, STUDENT was two years, eleven months old. The IEP document indicates that, at this time, STUDENT’s oral communication skills consisted of several words and “babbling,” that he was beginning to use PECS, that he followed simple directions with prompts, and that he was leading his parents to desired items but demonstrated frustration in his inability to communicate at times. With respect to his behavior, the IEP states that he had occasional tantrums at transitions, did not tolerate physical prompts to initiate tasks, and did not engage in games with the therapist. A representative from LIFE reviewed STUDENT’s current programs, which included safety skills, imitation skills, PECS, preacademics, and social skills. The IEP team also reviewed an occupational therapy progress report and a music therapy assessment report by SLTA.
The District and PCOE’s offer consisted of placement in a preschool SDC designated as a “Strategic Teaching by Educators and Parents for Students” or “STEPS” classroom at the PCOE’s Sierra Elementary School and related services in the form of two thirty-minute one-to-one school-based sessions of speech and language therapy per week and one hour of one-to-one school-based occupational therapy per week. The IEP included one annual goal: “STUDENT will independently transition from one activity to the next using a picture schedule system and verbal cue on 8/10 [occasions] over three consecutive days.” The District and PCOE recommended an interim placement during which “all goal areas will be developed to reflect school-based services.” STUDENT’s parents did not agree to the offer and he continued to receive home and clinic-based services from the nonpublic agencies, which were paid for by STUDENT’s parents and the Regional Center.
On March 10, 2004, the Hearing Office received a request for a due process hearing and a motion for stay put in this matter on behalf of Student. Student contended that the District and PCOE failed to offer him a FAPE for the 2003-2004 regular school year and the 2004 ESY. Student further argued that he was entitled to either a stay put placement in conformity with his last IFSP or a comparable program to be offered by the District and PCOE. Student argued that the program offered by the District and PCOE at the IEP meeting of September 12, 2003 was not comparable to his in-home ABA program and related therapies provided by SLTA. The District opposed the motion, arguing that: (1) Student is entitled to stay put placement at a public school, not a private in-home program selected by his parents, (2) stay put does not require continuation of services by agencies selected by Student’s parents, and (3) the District and PCOE satisfied their stay put obligation by offering placement and services in substantial conformity with Student’s in-home program.
On March 18, 2004, the Hearing Office received a stipulation from all parties to continue the hearing in this matter, scheduled for April 1, 2004, to the next available hearing date. The hearing was rescheduled to April 27, 2004.
On March 24, 2004, another Hearing Officer issued an order granting Student’s motion for stay put in part and denying it in part. He found that Student was entitled to a program in conformity with the program that was funded by the Regional Center immediately prior to STUDENT’s reaching his third birthday, and held that the program offered by the District and PCOE at the September 12, 2003 IEP was not in conformity with the last IFSP. He ordered the District to provide a stay put placement with the following components: (1) twenty three and one-half hours of in-home services in conformity with the services provided by LIFE, (2) two hours of speech therapy, (3) one hour of music therapy, and (4) one hour of occupational therapy, with all related services to be provided in a clinic-based or in-home setting in conformity with the services provided by SLTA. The Hearing Officer denied Student’s request to have the same service providers continue working with STUDENT during the stay put placement, noting that the laws governing stay put do not require this.
By letter dated April 1, 2004, Jan Lucas, director of special education for the District, offered STUDENT stay put services. The District and PCOE elected to offer different providers for these services. Specifically, they offered: (1) in-home behavioral intervention therapy for 23.5 hours per week as a 1:1 direct service by Advanced Kids, a nonpublic agency qualified to provide such services, (2) speech and language therapy for two hours per week provided as a 1:1 direct service by a District certified speech and language pathologist in the home, (3) occupational therapy for one hour per week provided as a 1:1 direct service by a District registered occupational therapist in the home, and (4) music therapy for one hour per week provided as a 1:1 direct service by a nonpublic agency qualified to provide music therapy in the home. STUDENT’s parents rejected this offer of stay put services, with the exception of the services of music therapist Tara McConnell, whom the District and PCOE ultimately offered to provide stay put music therapy services to STUDENT. LIFE and SLTA continued to provide the rest of STUDENT’s educational program. On April 23, 2004, the IEP team convened at the request of the District and PCOE. At the meeting, the team reviewed STUDENT’s present levels of performance and areas of need. The District and PCOE members of the team then prepared an assessment plan, and developed an offer of placement and services for the remainder of the 2003-2004 regular school year, the 2004 ESY, and the 2004-2005 regular school year. According to the IEP, STUDENT’s strengths continued to be in visual skills such as matching letters, shapes, colors, words, and names. He could take turns in a structured situation with prompts, but had difficulty with self-direction and did not appear to understand choices. Transitions between tasks could elicit tantrum behavior, such as crying or falling to the ground.
The offer set forth in the IEP included the following: (1) placement in the PCOE’s STEPS program, (2) the related services of speech and language therapy and occupational therapy, (3) a one-to-one aide trained in ABA behavior intervention techniques from Advanced Kids, a certified nonpublic agency, (4) ten hours per week of one-to-one behavior intervention services at school; (5) co-treatment provided by a speech and language therapist and an occupational therapist; and (6) staff training in ABA, functional language and generalization. For the 2004 ESY, the District and PCOE offered a four-week program which essentially continued the program offered for the regular school year. A second four-week ESY program was also offered and consisted of twenty hours per week of in-home one-to-one ABA behavior intervention services. The IEP contained seventeen annual goals with fifty-one short-term objectives/benchmarks in the following areas of need: academics, social/emotional/behavioral, self-care, recreation, communication, and motor skills. With regard to behavioral support, the IEP called for supervision during unstructured time, cues/prompts/reminders of rules, and the implementation of a behavior support plan in conjunction with the ABA program. STUDENT’s parents did not accept the offer for the regular school year or the ESY. They did not consent to the District and PCOE’s assessment plan either.
On May 18, 2004, the Hearing Office received a request for due process hearing on behalf of the District and PCOE. This matter was assigned Case No. SN04-01185. On May 26, 2004, the Hearing Office issued an order granting the District and PCOE’s unopposed motion to consolidate Case No. SN04-01185 with Case No. SN04-00520 on the grounds that the cases involved the same parties and common issues of law and fact. The hearing for the consolidated cases was scheduled for June 8, 2004.
On June 3, 2004, the District and PCOE provided STUDENT’s parents with a revised assessment plan, which called for a functional analysis of STUDENT by Advance Kids and an observation of STUDENT’s home program by District, PCOE, and Advance Kids staff. STUDENT’s parents did not consent to the revised assessment plan.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue 1: Did the District and the PCOE offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from October 12, 2003, his third birthday, to April 23, 2004?
Student contends that the District and PCOE denied him a FAPE in three respects during this time period. First, Student argues that the District and PCOE committed a procedural violation and denied him a FAPE when they failed to allow STUDENT’s mother to participate in the IEP development process by ignoring both her input and the input of STUDENT’s educational providers at the September 12, 2003 IEP meeting. Second, Student maintains that the District and PCOE substantively failed to offer him a FAPE at the September 12, 2003 IEP meeting because that offer was not designed to meet all of STUDENT’s educational needs or reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. Specifically, Student contends that this IEP completely ignores his needs in numerous areas, including academics, gross motor, fine motor, social skills, play skills, and behavior and instead only offers one goal in the area of transitions. Finally, Student contends that the District and PCOE failed to offer him a FAPE when they did not provide him with a transition plan for purposes of transitioning STUDENT from his in-home and clinic-based providers to stay put providers selected by the District and PCOE. The District and PCOE contend that the offer dated September 12, 2003, was both procedurally and substantively appropriate and that a transition plan was not necessary for purposes of stay put. Each of these contentions is addressed separately below.
Under both the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.) The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(8).) When a child reaches the age of three years, the IDEA and State law shift responsibility for formulating that child’s special education program from the regional centers to the local education agencies, including the school district. The special education program transitions from an IFSP to an IEP.
The determination of whether a student has been offered a FAPE is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to decide whether the requisite procedural steps have been followed and whether the proposed placement is substantively appropriate. (Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley) 458 U.S. 176, 200 (1982).) The Hearing Officer will address the alleged procedural violation first, and will then turn to the alleged substantive violations of FAPE.
A. Did the District commit a procedural violation and deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to consider information presented by STUDENT’s parents and his providers at the IEP meeting of September 12, 2003?
Student maintains that the District and PCOE failed to comply with the procedural protections afforded by the IDEA and denied him a FAPE when they allegedly failed to consider information regarding STUDENT’s needs presented by STUDENT’s parents and his providers at the IEP meeting of September 12, 2003. The District and PCOE contend that the information presented by STUDENT’s parents and providers at that meeting was seriously considered by the members of the IEP team. Specifically, they contend that team reviewed and considered the reports prepared by: (1) Caprice Schweiger, STUDENT’s case supervisor from LIFE, (2) Brodi Wetherbee, STUDENT’s speech and language therapist from SLTA, (3) Linh Giang, STUDENT’s occupational therapist from SLTA, and (4) Rachel Firchau, STUDENT’s music therapist from SLTA.
The IDEA provides procedural protections to children with disabilities and their parents. The Supreme Court noted in Rowley that “Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation” at every step “as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP.” (Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 205-206.) The courts have held that the procedural safeguards of the IDEA are important and that certain procedural violations, including those that result in a loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s participation in the IEP process, may result in a denial of FAPE. (W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992).) (Footnote 9)
The Hearing Officer finds that the District and PCOE appropriately reviewed and considered the information presented by STUDENT’s parents and his providers at the IEP meeting of September 12, 2003, and that, therefore, no procedural violation occurred. The IEP document, both in the “Present Levels of Performance” and the “Discussion” sections, summarizes information presented by PARENTS and LIFE representatives who also attended the meeting, as well as information set forth in the music therapy assessment from SLTA. MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother, testified that she brought these reports to the meeting and that they were “briefly” reviewed and summarized by the providers at the meeting. Moreover, she did not cite any information in her possession that she unable to present at the meeting as a result of any actions of District or PCOE staff at that meeting. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that no procedural violation occurred.
B. Did the offer set forth in the IEP dated September 12, 2003, constitute a FAPE?
As set forth in the IEP dated September 12, 2003, the District and PCOE’s offer, to be effective upon STUDENT reaching his third birthday and becoming eligible for District services, included placement in the STEPS classroom for 3.75 hours per day, five days per week, plus related services to include classroom-based speech and language therapy for one hour per week, classroom-based occupational therapy for one hour per week, and transportation. Thus, the services offered by the District and PCOE, one-on-one and otherwise, total about 18.75 hours per week.
Student maintains that the September 12, 2003 IEP, which set forth the District’s offer for the 2003-2004 regular school year, is not designed to meet all of his educational needs or reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit because it only contains one goal, which addresses STUDENT’s transition needs. Student contends that this IEP completely ignores his needs in numerous areas, including gross motor, fine motor, social skills, play skills, and behavior.
Witnesses for the Student, which included MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother; Lin Giang, STUDENT’s occupational therapist; and Brodi Wetherbee, STUDENT’s speech and language therapist, all testified that STUDENT required goals and objectives which addressed all the domain areas, not just transitioning between tasks. They maintained that the offer, with only one goal, was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. In addition, Dr. Diane Ashton, one of the District and PCOE’s witnesses, expressed concerns that the IEP only contained one goal.
The District and PCOE contend that the IEP of September 12, 2003, was an interim offer for the purpose of transitioning STUDENT into the school setting, conducting diagnostic evaluations, and further developing his goals and educational program. As a result, the District and PCOE maintain that it was not appropriate to design every detail of Student’s transitional IEP offer without first conducting diagnostic evaluations of him in the STEPS classroom. They argue, however, that the interim placement and services offered at that IEP meeting were designed to meet STUDENT’s core areas of deficit.
Witnesses for the District and PCOE, which included Jean Crouse, the STEPS teacher; Susan Watts, PCOE administrator; and Betty Di Regolo, program specialist for the District, testified that the purpose of the September 12, 2003 offer was to transition STUDENT to a school setting, where they could conduct evaluations in order to identify his needs and establish baseline information in a school setting, and further develop his goals and program. These witnesses maintained that it would not have been appropriate to design every detail of STUDENT’s transitional IEP offer without first conducting assessments of him in the classroom. The District and PCOE cite Education Code Section 56325 and two prior decisions issued by the Hearing Office for the proposition that the IEP of September 12, 2003, was an appropriate interim placement for STUDENT, who was transitioning from a home-based program to a school setting. (Footnote 10) Finally, The District and PCOE contend that they intended to address the goals that LIFE was working on with STUDENT during the thirty-day transitional placement.
When a dispute arises regarding a student’s initial IEP, the Hearing Office relies on Education Code section 56325, which provides for an interim placement for special education students transferring from one school district to another. In transfer situations, the receiving district must immediately, and for a maximum of thirty days, provide the student with an interim program that is either in conformity with the student’s prior IEP or provide the student with a new IEP, developed in accordance with a written assessment plan as set forth in section 56321. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56325(a).) (Footnote 11) Before the expiration of the 30-day period, the IEP team must review the interim placement and make a final recommendation on placement and services for that school year.
Here, the District and PCOE elected to present STUDENT with an interim offer for 30 days. The Hearing Officer finds, however, that the District failed to provide STUDENT with an interim program that is in conformity with his prior IFSP. That IFSP, dated November 18, 2002, contains four outcomes or goals in the areas of play, communication of wants and needs, and gross motor skills/vestibular activities. The IFSP was reviewed at meetings on January 22, April 9, and August 19, 2003. Those reviews reflect STUDENT’s participation in an IFSP consisting of ABA instruction by LIFE staff, which included goals in the areas of matching, puzzles, imitation, verbalization, and communication, including the use of PECS. According to the LIFE treatment summary dated September 2, 2003, STUDENT’s in-home LIFE services had increased to 23.5 hours per week by August 2003. The treatment summary states that in addition to the LIFE services, by August 2003, STUDENT was receiving services from SLTA. The SLTA services, at that time, consisted of 2 hours of speech therapy, 1 hour of music therapy, and 1 hour of occupational therapy, per week and all in a clinic-based setting. (Footnote 12) Collectively, STUDENT’s services as of August 2003 totaled about 27.5 hours of direct therapy per week.
In contrast, the offer set forth in the September 12, 2003 IEP contained one goal, which addressed the area of transitions, and would only have provided 18.75 hours per week of instructional services to STUDENT, as opposed to the 27.5 hours he was receiving through his IFSP. (Footnote 13) The single annual goal set forth in the IEP states that “STUDENT will independently transition from one activity to the next using a picture schedule system and verbal cue on 8/10[attempts] over 3 consecutive days.”
It is undisputed that STUDENT has deficits in the areas of academics, expressive and receptive language skills, gross and fine motor skills, social and behavioral skills, play skills, attention, self-help, and sensory processing/integration. The District and PCOE’s offer of September 12, 2003, essentially left STUDENT without an educational program until such time as the District and PCOE conducted assessments, held another IEP meeting, and prepared a formal offer for the 2003-2004 regular school year. The IDEA and State law clearly require the District and PCOE to provide STUDENT an educational program consistent with the program he was receiving prior to entering the District during the thirty-day transitional period. The single goal and reduced number of educational hours offered by the District in the September 12, 2003 IEP are not consistent with the goals and programs STUDENT was receiving at that time. The District and PCOE’s contention that they intended to address the goals that LIFE was working on with STUDENT during the thirty-day transitional placement does not change the fact that the IEP contains none of those goals, nor does it indicate an intent to implement those goals during the transition. (Moreover, that representation is only set forth in correspondence from Jan Lucas, director of special education for the District, to STUDENT’s mother dated October 3, 2003.)
Finally, the District and PCOE did not prepare an assessment plan or hold another IEP meeting within 30 days of the interim offer as required by section 56325. Indeed, they did not do either until April 23, 2004, more than seven months after the first IEP meeting. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District and PCOE’ offer was not in conformity with his IFSP as it was being implemented at the time of the IEP meeting and therefore that the District and PCOE denied STUDENT a FAPE.
C. Did the District and PCOE deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to develop a transition plan for purposes of stay put?
Student contends that a transition plan was required when the District and PCOE sought a change in STUDENT’s current educational providers under the stay put order issued by the Hearing Office on March 24, 2004, and that the District and PCOE should have held an IEP meeting for this purpose. Student argues that the evidence establishes that a transition plan is critical to program development for STUDENT. The District and PCOE contend that they appropriately complied with the terms of the stay put order by offering the frequency and duration of services called for in that order. They maintain that no evidence was presented which suggests that STUDENT required a transition plan for the offered stay put services.
On March 24, 2004, Hearing Officer Vincent Pastorino issued an order granting Student’s motion for stay put in part and denying it in part. He held that STUDENT was entitled to a program in conformity with the program that was funded by the Regional Center immediately prior to STUDENT reaching his third birthday, which program must include twenty-three and one-half hours of in-home services in conformity with the services provided by LIFE and two hours of speech therapy, one hour of music therapy, and one hour of occupational therapy in a clinic-based or in-home setting in conformity with the services provided by SLTA. Hearing Officer Pastorino denied Student’s request to have the same service providers continue working with STUDENT during the stay put placement, however, noting that the IDEA and State law do not require this. The stay put order is silent regarding the need for a transition plan if the District and PCOE elected to change providers. (Footnote 14)
By letter dated April 1, 2004, Jan Lucas, director of special education for the District, offered STUDENT stay put services consistent with the stay put order. The District and PCOE elected to offer different providers for these services. Specifically, they offered: (1) in-home behavioral intervention therapy for 23.5 hours per week as a 1:1 direct service by Advanced Kids, a nonpublic agency qualified to provide such services, (2) speech and language therapy for two hours per week provided as a 1:1 direct service by a District certified speech and language pathologist in the home, (3) occupational therapy for one hour per week provided as a 1:1 direct service by a District registered occupational therapist in the home, and (4) music therapy for one hour per week provided as a 1:1 direct service by a nonpublic agency qualified to provide music therapy in the home.
Student does not contend that the District’s offer of stay put fails to comply with the stay put order issued by the Hearing Office. Rather, Student contends that the District and PCOE should have gone beyond the requirements set forth in the order and included a transition plan when they sought to change Student’s stay put providers. But Student cites no statutes, regulations, or case law that set forth such a requirement, nor could the Hearing Officer locate any. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the IDEA and State laws governing stay put do not require a local educational agency to prepare a transition plan when it offers stay put providers different from those being used by the student at the time the offer is made. Indeed, those laws do not even require a finding that the stay put placement constitute a FAPE for the student. Rather, the purpose of stay put is simply to maintain the status quo of the student’s educational program pending resolution of the due process hearing. (Stacey G. v. Pasadena Independent School District, 695 F.2d 949, 953 (5th Cir. 1983); Zvi D. v. Gordon Ambach, 694 F.2d 904 (2d Cir. 1982).) For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District and PCOE did not deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to develop a transition plan for purposes of stay put.
Issue No. 2: Does the District and the PCOE’s offer set forth in the IEP dated April 23, 2004, constitute a FAPE?
Student contends that the offer set forth in the IEP document dated April 23, 2004, denied him a FAPE in two respects. First, Student argues that the District and PCOE committed a procedural violation and denied him a FAPE when they failed to allow STUDENT’s mother to participate in the IEP development process by ignoring both her input and the input of STUDENT’s educational providers at the April 23, 2004 IEP meeting. Second, he contends that the offer is substantively inappropriate with respect to goals and objectives, placement, related services, behavior intervention, and transition services. The District maintains that its offer constitutes a FAPE, both procedurally and substantively.
To determine whether the District offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education, one must first focus on the adequacy of the District’s proposed programs. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F. 2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).) In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208.) The Court stated that school districts are required to provide a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Id.) De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. (Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F. 3d 119, 130 (2d Cir. 1998).) A child’s academic progress must viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. (Mrs. B v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997).)
An IEP is a written statement that must be developed, reviewed, and revised for each student with a disability. The IEP must include a statement of the goals and objectives, of the special education and related services, and of the program modifications or supports for school personnel that are to be provided to enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum, and to be educated and participate with disabled and nondisabled peers in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347; Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343, 56345.) “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student, including instruction conducted in the classroom, in the home, in hospitals and institutions, and in other settings. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).) The term “related services,” which is also referred to in California as “designated instruction and services” (DIS), includes developmental, corrective, and supportive services that may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363.)
Finally, special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56342(b).) 20 U.S.C. section 1412(a)(5)(A) specifically provides:
To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.
To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program must meet the following three substantive requirements in order to constitute an appropriate educational program. It must: 1) be designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs; 2) be reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit; and 3) comport with his IEP. Finally, the District must have offered him a FAPE in the least restrictive environment. (Footnote 15)
The Hearing Officer will address the alleged procedural violation first, and will then turn to the alleged substantive violations of FAPE.
A. Did the District commit a procedural violation and deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to consider information presented by STUDENT’s parents and his providers at the IEP meeting of April 23, 2004?
Student maintains that the District and PCOE failed to comply with the procedural protections afforded by the IDEA and denied him a FAPE when they allegedly failed to consider information regarding STUDENT’s needs presented by STUDENT’s parents and his providers at the IEP meeting of April 23, 2004. The District and PCOE contend that the members of the IEP team seriously considered the information presented by STUDENT’s parents and providers at that meeting. Specifically, they contend that team reviewed and considered reports prepared by: LIFE, SLTA, the Regional Center, and Ms. Gwaltney prior to the IEP meeting as well as information presented at the meeting.
As set forth, supra, the courts have held that the procedural safeguards of the IDEA are important and that certain procedural violations, including those that result in a loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s participation in the IEP process, may result in a denial of FAPE. (W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992).)
The Hearing Officer finds that the District and PCOE members of the IEP team appropriately reviewed and considered the information presented by STUDENT’s parents and his providers at the IEP meeting of April 23, 2004, and that, therefore, no procedural violation occurred. Jean Crouse, Laurie Ferrell, Susan Watts and Betty Di Regolo all testified that they participated in a pre-IEP meeting where District and PCOE members of the IEP team reviewed progress reports from STUDENT’s providers and prepared draft goals and objectives based upon the information contained in those reports. Moreover, the IEP document, both in the “Present Levels of Performance” and the “Discussion” sections, summarizes information regarding STUDENT’s deficits and his present level of performance presented by PARENTS, Caprice Schweiger of LIFE, and Brodi Wetherbee of SLTA. Finally, MOTHER did not cite any information in her possession that she was unable to present at the meeting as a result of any actions of District or PCOE staff at that meeting. Therefore, there was no procedural violation.
B. Did the District substantively offer STUDENT a FAPE at the IEP meeting on April 23, 2004?
Student contends that the IEP of April 23, 2004, did not constitute an offer of FAPE because: (1) STUDENT had already mastered most of the proposed goals, and would master all of the goals set forth in that IEP by July 2004, (2) some of goals set forth in that IEP are not measurable, (3) the IEP did not contain any behavioral goals or goals that would continue his progress in the Lovaas Reading and Writing program, (4) the teacher and staff assigned to STUDENT lack the appropriate knowledge and skills of techniques, such as applied behavioral analysis (ABA), to provide instruction to him, (5) the transition plan offered by the District and PCOE is inadequate, (6) the offer does not include music therapy services, (7) the speech and occupational therapy are not offered in a clinical setting and the speech therapy would not be provided by a therapist trained in addressing apraxia, and (8) the one-to-one aide and behavior consultation services are inappropriate.
The District and PCOE contend that the IEP document dated April 23, 2004 constitutes an offer of FAPE. Specifically, they maintain that: (1) the goals and objectives appropriately address all of STUDENT’s identified areas of need, (2) the STEPS classroom provides a variety of ABA and other instructional methodologies and team collaboration to provide educational benefit to STUDENT, and (3) the teachers, staff, and related services providers are appropriately qualified to provide services to STUDENT.
1. Identification of STUDENT’s Deficits and Unique Educational Needs
To determine whether the program offered by the District and PCOE at the IEP of April 23, 2004, was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs, the Hearing Officer must first identify STUDENT’s areas of deficit and his unique educational needs at the time of that offer. There does not appear to be a dispute between the parties regarding STUDENT’s educational deficits and his needs. He has been diagnosed with autism. As a result of his autism, STUDENT has deficits in several domains, including academics, expressive and receptive language, gross and fine motor, social skills and behavior, play, attention, self-help, and sensory processing/integration.
a. Academics
Student, the District, and the PCOE agree that STUDENT has deficits in the area of academics and requires instruction in the areas of receptive and expressive labeling of objects in his environment, such as body parts, colors, shapes, letters and numbers. Witnesses for the Student, the District, and the PCOE testified that he needs intensive instruction in these skills as a necessary precursor to reading and writing.
b. Speech and Language
Student, the District, and the PCOE agree that STUDENT requires the related service of speech and language to address his deficits in the areas of expressive and receptive language. STUDENT has a limited ability to produce vocalizations and requires alternative communication techniques to develop his communication skills. They further agree that he requires a frequency of two hours per week of direct one-to-one therapy. They disagree as to the appropriate location for the therapy and with respect to the training and qualifications necessary to provide such therapy to STUDENT. These disputed issues will be resolved below.
Finally, the parties’ disagree as to whether STUDENT has apraxia, and therefore whether he has unique educational needs related to apraxia. Brodi Wetherbee has been licensed as a speech and language therapist since December 2003, has been employed in that capacity at SLTA since January of 2003, and has served as STUDENT’s speech and language therapist at SLTA since May 2003. In February of 2004, she diagnosed STUDENT with apraxia using the Verbal Motor Production Assessment for Children (VMPAC). She defined apraxia as a neurological disorder that affects the planning and production of speech, specifically resulting in a loss in ability to voluntarily position the articulators (e.g. lips, jaw, tongue) on a consistent basis while speaking. According to Ms. Wetherbee, the VMPA assesses a child’s oral motor movements and how those movements relate to speech ability. She stated that STUDENT scored below the fifth percentile in each area tested. To address STUDENT’s apraxia, she utilizes pivotal response training, which she described as a hierarchy of prompts to provoke a muscle response instead of forcing a response. As an example, she demonstrated how to use pivotal response training to get a student to form the sound “o.” She stated that she would first determine whether the child could imitate the sound without physical prompts. If the child was unable to do this, she would touch the middle of her top lip to get the child to form the correct mouth position or physically move the student’s lips to the correct shape. Ms. Wetherbee further testified that STUDENT requires a quiet environment for his therapy as he is easily distracted by noise or the presence of others in the room.
Linda Hess has been employed by the PCOE as a speech and language therapist for twelve years and has a total of nineteen years experience as a speech and language therapist. She questioned Ms. Wetherbee’s diagnosis of apraxia for STUDENT, noting that apraxia is a rare and often misdiagnosed disorder, particularly with autistic children. She testified that autistic children can exhibit “apraxic-like” behaviors due to their autism, without actually having apraxia. She expressed concern that the diagnosis of apraxia was based upon a single assessment, rather than on several different assessments. Ms. Hess maintained that to properly assess for apraxia, an assessor would need to obtain twenty to fifty word utterances that would be used to determine error patterns. The assessor would then differentially diagnose apraxia from other causes for speech delay. She maintains that these steps were not taken in Ms. Wetherbee’s assessment of STUDENT.
The Hearing Officer finds that the evidence presented regarding the issue of whether STUDENT has apraxia is inconclusive. The Hearing Officer finds that a single assessment, without more, is unpersuasive as a basis for a diagnosis of apraxia. The evidence presented at hearing indicates that a more comprehensive assessment should be conducted in this area. The Hearing Officer therefore orders that the District and PCOE’s assessment of STUDENT, which is addressed in Issue 5, shall include a comprehensive assessment, consistent with the requirements of Education Code section 56320, et. seq., to determine whether STUDENT has apraxia.
c. Occupational Therapy
The Student, the District, and the PCOE agree that STUDENT requires the related service of occupational therapy to address his deficits in the areas of fine motor, gross motor, visual motor, and sensory integration. They further agree that he requires a frequency of one hour per week of direct one-to-one therapy. They disagree as to the appropriate location for the therapy, which is resolved below.
d. Music Therapy
Student contends that he requires music therapy to address his areas of deficit, in particular the area of expressive and receptive language. The District and PCOE argue that he does not require music therapy and that the combination of speech and language therapy, co-treatment with the speech and language and occupational therapist, and the instruction in the STEPS classroom will appropriately address his deficits.
Tara McConnell is a music therapist who began providing music therapy services to STUDENT on June 9, 2004. She operates McConnell Music Therapy Services, a nonpublic agency. She described music therapy as utilizing music activities and experiences as a tool to elicit behavioral, physical, cognitive, psychological and emotional outcomes. She is currently assessing STUDENT’s needs and has not yet developed goals for him. According to Ms. McConnell, her sessions with STUDENT begin with a “hello song” which is designed to encourage eye contact, vocalizations and social greetings. During the session, she and STUDENT sing, play different instruments, such as drums or a kazoo, dance, and draw to music. She stated that playing instruments and dancing facilitates body tone, fine and gross motor coordination and socialization. She testified that drawing to music helps with auditory stimulation and pre-handwriting skills. According to Ms. McConnell, the goals she will develop for STUDENT will be similar to those developed by STUDENT’s last music therapist, Rachel Firchau. Ms. McConnell acknowledged that other providers, such as LIFE and SLTA, were currently addressing STUDENT’s areas of deficits with ABA, speech therapy, and occupational therapy, but expressed the opinion that he would be able to reach the benchmarks on his goals in those programs more quickly with music therapy.
Jean Crouse, the STEPS teacher, testified that STUDENT did not require music therapy and that his needs could be met through the related services of speech and language therapy, co-treatment with the speech and occupational therapists, and through activities in the STEPS classroom. Ms. Crouse testified that she was familiar with music therapy and that, in her opinion, the long-term goals of music therapy are similar to those in speech and language therapy. She testified that many of the activities utilized in music therapy are also used in the STEPS classroom. For example, during circle time in the STEPS classroom, the students sing a good morning song. She testified that the class sings at least five songs on a consistent basis and that the class plays maracas, drums and bells on Fridays.
The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT does not require music therapy to address his deficits. While music therapy may, as Ms McConnell testified, increase the rate at which STUDENT meets the benchmarks for his goals and objectives in various domains, there was no evidence establishing that STUDENT needs music therapy in order to meet those benchmarks and goals. Indeed, witnesses for Student, including Scott Cross, clinical director of LIFE, and Brodi Wetherbee, STUDENT’s current speech and language therapist, testified that STUDENT was making good progress on his goals in the LIFE program, speech and language therapy, and occupational therapy during the period from September 2003 to April 2004, when STUDENT was not receiving music therapy services.
e. Behavior, Social, and Play Skills
All parties agree that STUDENT has deficits in the areas of behavior, social, and play skills for which he requires behavior intervention and instruction. The parties agree that STUDENT requires instruction in play activities and social skills, including greetings. With respect to behavior, he engages in tantrums, aggression, throwing objects, and self-injurious behavior. Witnesses for Student, including Scott Cross and Caprice Schweiger, testified that the behavior support plan (BSP) developed by LIFE staff addressed STUDENT’s tantrums, aggression, and self-injurious behavior by targeting those behaviors for extinction and redirecting STUDENT to more compatible behaviors. Common antecedents for these behaviors include asking STUDENT to perform an undesired activity, the removal of a desired item or activity, and frustration with a task or activity.
Michele Wenell, the executive director of Advance Kids, testified on behalf of the District and PCOE. Ms. Wenell stated that STUDENT requires a functional analysis assessment (FAA) to understand the functions of STUDENT’s problem behaviors. The FAA would consist of observations and data collection regarding STUDENT’s behaviors. Following the FAA, she indicated that a positive behavior intervention plan (BIP) should be developed to address the behaviors, with the initial focus to be on his aggressive or injurious behaviors. According to Ms. Wenell, if the severity of STUDENT’s behaviors was great, a BIP might have to be developed without a full FAA.
The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT requires instruction in play activities and social skills and further requires either a BSP or a BIP in order to address his behavioral needs and to reduce his tantrums, aggression, throwing objects, and self-injurious behavior.
f. Transition from Home Program to School-Based Program
All parties agree that STUDENT would require assistance in transitioning from a home-based program to a school-based program due to his autism and related deficits. The parties disagree as to whether the transition plan offered by the District and PCOE will meet his needs in this area.
****
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has deficits in the areas of academics, expressive and receptive language, fine motor, gross motor, visual motor, sensory integration, behavior, attention, self-help, and social and play skills. His resulting educational needs include instruction in pre-academics, speech and language therapy, occupational therapy, a behavior intervention program, and instruction in play and social skills. Additionally, STUDENT’s service providers, including Ms. Wetherbee and Ms. Giang, persuasively testified that STUDENT is easily distracted by visual and auditory stimuli and, therefore, requires that his placement and services are provided in a quiet and relatively distractionfree environment.
2. Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Needs
The Hearing Officer must determine whether the District’s offer in the IEP dated April 23, 2004, is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs.
The District’s offer, set forth in the IEP dated April 23, 2004, includes the following: (1) placement in the PCOE’s STEPS program, (2) the related school-based services of one-to-one speech and language therapy for two hours per week and one-to-one occupational therapy for one hour per week, (3) a one-to-one aide trained in ABA behavior intervention techniques from Advanced Kids, a certified nonpublic agency during the school day, (4) ten hours per week of one-to-one behavior intervention services at school after the regular school day, (5) co-treatment provided by a speech and language therapist and an occupational therapist for one hour per week, and (6) staff training in ABA, functional language and generalization. The IEP contains seventeen annual goals with fifty-one short-term objectives/benchmarks in the following areas of need: academics, social/emotional/behavioral, self-care, recreation, communication, and motor skills. With regard to behavioral support, the IEP calls for supervision during unstructured time, cues/prompts/reminders of rules, and the implementation of a behavior support plan in conjunction with the ABA program. STUDENT’s parents did not accept the offer for the regular school year or the ESY.
Student contends that the IEP of April 23, 2004, was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs because (1) STUDENT had already mastered most of the goals, and would master all of the goals set forth in that IEP by July 2004, (2) some of goals set forth in that IEP are not measurable, (3) the IEP did not contain any behavioral goals or goals that would continue his progress in the Lovaas Reading and Writing program, (4) the teacher and staff assigned to STUDENT lack the appropriate knowledge and skills of techniques, such as applied behavioral analysis (ABA), to provide instruction to him, (5) the transition plan offered by the District and PCOE is inadequate, (6) the offer does not include music therapy services, (7) the speech and occupational therapy are not offered in a clinical setting and the speech therapy would not be provided by a therapist trained in addressing apraxia, and (8) the one-to-one aide and behavior consultation services are inappropriate.
The District and PCOE contend that the IEP document dated April 23, 2004, constitutes an offer of FAPE. Specifically, they maintain that: (1) the goals and objectives appropriately address all of STUDENT’s identified areas of need, (2) the STEPS classroom provides a variety of ABA and other instructional methodologies and team collaboration to provide educational benefit to STUDENT, and (3) the teachers, staff, and related services providers are appropriately qualified to provide services to STUDENT.
a. Goals and Objectives
Student contends that the goals and objectives are inappropriate for STUDENT because STUDENT had either met these goals by the time the April 23, 2004 IEP meeting took place, or by the date the hearing in this matter commenced on June 8, 2004. In addition, Student maintains that the offer set forth in the IEP failed to include goals in the areas of behavior and communication. Finally, he contends that some of the goals set forth in the IEP are not measurable. The District and PCOE argue that the goals and objectives are appropriate and are based upon the information available to them at the time of the IEP meeting.
The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal has adopted the “snapshot” rule, which holds that the actions of the school cannot “be judged exclusively in hindsight…an IEP must take into account what was, and what was not, objectively reasonable when the snapshot was taken, that is, at the time the IEP was drafted.” (Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (1999), citing Fuhrman v. East Hanover Bd. of Education, 993 F.2d 1031, 1041 (3rd Cir. 1993).) Accordingly, the Hearing Officer examines the IEP at the time it was developed.
The District and PCOE’s offer included seventeen annual goals with fifty-one short-term objectives/benchmarks in the following areas of need: academics, social/emotional/behavioral, self-care, recreation, communication, and motor skills. With regard to behavioral support, the IEP called for supervision during unstructured time, cues/prompts/reminders of rules, and the implementation of a behavior support plan in conjunction with the ABA program.
The following annual goals were included in the IEP: (1) STUDENT will participate in a variety of instructional environments to include 1:1 instruction and small group structured teaching sessions with reinforcement and minimal prompting. (Footnote 16) (2) He will increase independence in an educational setting by transitioning between activities independently and completing work tasks independently. (3) He will engage in imitative play in an educational setting with a variety of instructors and peers. (4) He will request a variety of desired items using a picture exchange system for functional communication within an educational setting. (5) He will greet his instructors and peers in an educational setting by gesturing and/or saying hi and goodbye when initiated by an instructor or peer. (6) He will receptively identify and expressively label preacademic concepts including body parts, colors, shapes, letters, and numbers. (7) He will increase non-verbal imitation skills in an instructional setting to include imitation of gross motor, fine motor, and novel motor imitations within a song. (8) He will increase oral motor and verbal imitation skills in an educational setting. (9) Pending further assessment to determine current levels of performance, STUDENT will decrease oral defensiveness and improve strength/mobility to his lips, tongue, and jaw. He will participate in graduated oral-motor exercises, tolerate facial massage, intra-oral pressure and participate in blowing activities. (10) He will increase spontaneous speech and expressive language by completing routine phrases in an instructional setting and labeling common and reinforcing objects. (11) In a structured instructional setting, STUDENT will increase knowledge of common object labels in his environment. (12) He will follow at least five receptive instructions involving object manipulation, and non-object instructions in and out of the instructional setting (table and chair). (13) He will take off his jacket/sweatshirt on request, and hang the jacket on the designated hook in an educational setting with minimal physical assistance. (14) To increase efficient sensory processing for increased participation in art, he will participate in a tactile-based activity (with sticky substance like glue or shaving cream) for two minutes without cues in four out of five attempts. (15) To demonstrate improved fine motor control for increased preacademics and academics, he will near point copy a + with a writing tool in 4/5 attempts and only one verbal, physical, or tactile prompt. (16) To improve self-care for greater independence during lunch and snack time, he will independently use a spoon or fork for ten or more bites eighty percent of opportunities. (17) To demonstrate improved motor planning and participation during recess, he will walk across the S-shaped balance beam alternating feet for five feet with minimal assistance in four out of five trials.
The Hearing Officer finds unpersuasive Student’s argument that the goals and objectives set forth in the April 23, 2004 IEP were not designed to meet his unique needs because he had met these goals by the time the April 23, 2004 IEP meeting took place, or by the date the hearing in this matter commenced on June 8, 2004, particularly when considered under the snapshot rule. In support of his argument, Student relies on LIFE reports and on the testimony of STUDENT’s mother and Scott Cross, clinical director of LIFE. The LIFE reports relied upon by Student, however, are dated after the April 23, 2004 IEP meeting and were therefore not available for consideration by the IEP team at that meeting. STUDENT’s mother testified at hearing that STUDENT had already met many of the goals set forth in the IEP by the date of the IEP meeting, but there was no testimony at hearing suggesting that she raised this concern at the IEP meeting and the IEP document, which contains a section for parental comment, does not reference such a concern being raised either at the IEP meeting or in the days following it. Moreover, there was no testimony at hearing and no indication in the IEP document that anyone expressed a concern at the IEP meeting regarding the statements of STUDENT’s baseline performance for each goal set forth in that IEP. Finally, Scott Cross, who also testified that STUDENT had already met many of the goals set forth in the IEP by the date of the IEP meeting or shortly thereafter, did not attend the April 23, 2004 IEP meeting, and no evidence was presented which suggested that he or anyone employed by LIFE advised the IEP team, either at the IEP meeting or in the days following, that the goals and objectives were inappropriate for this reason.
Rather, the evidence demonstrates that the goals and objectives are based upon the baseline performance information in the IEP, which in turn was derived from the assessments, written progress reports, and verbal information provided by STUDENT’s nonpublic agency providers both prior to and at the time of the IEP meeting. The District and PCOE witnesses, including Betty Di Regolo, Susan Watts, Linda Hess, and Jean Crouse, persuasively testified that the seventeen goals and objectives set forth in the IEP document are designed to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs by addressing his areas of deficit as reflected by the information provided to them by STUDENT’s providers. These witnesses further testified that these goals and objectives will be reviewed and revised once the District and PCOE have an opportunity to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability.
The Hearing Officer also concludes that the goals and objectives contained in the IEP adequately address STUDENT’s needs in the areas of behavior and communication. With respect to behavior, goal number one and its three benchmarks call for STUDENT to participate in a variety of instructional environments in the absence of tantrum behavior. Goal number two addresses STUDENT’s deficits in the area of transitions between tasks, which witnesses for Student, the District and the PCOE testified was one of the primary causes of his tantrums. While there are no goals and objectives that specifically target physically aggressive behavior and the throwing of objects, the evidence, in the form of the LIFE progress reports and the testimony of Mr. Cross and Ms. Schweiger of LIFE suggests that, in comparison to the tantrums, these were not high incidence behaviors. In addition, the offer calls for a functional analysis assessment of STUDENT’s behaviors and their functions, along with the development of a behavior intervention plan to address those behaviors. The Hearing Officer finds that these measures, along with the provision of an ABA-trained one-to-one aide for STUDENT in the classroom, are designed to meet his needs in the area of behavior.
With respect to communication, the Hearing Officer also finds that the goals and objectives are designed to meet STUDENT’s needs in this area. As set forth above, STUDENT has deficits in the areas of expressive and receptive language. The Hearing Officer was persuaded by the testimony of the District’s and PCOE’s witnesses, along with the written reports and information provided at the IEP meeting regarding STUDENT’s present levels of performance, that the goals and objectives appropriately target his areas of deficit and that these goals and objectives will be fine-tuned following assessment of STUDENT. The goals and objectives address STUDENT’s functional communication deficits by continuing his PECS program, address his social communication deficits by working on his greetings in the classroom, and address his oral motor, sound imitation, and expressive and receptive communication deficits by working on mouth and tongue movements, imitation of sounds and words, expressive and receptive labeling of objects, and following instructions.
Finally, the Hearing Officer found the testimony of the District and PCOE witnesses persuasive that the goals and objectives set forth in the IEP are measurable. Specifically, each of the annual goals provides that objectives will be considered mastered when STUDENT is successful on 80 percent of presented opportunities over three consecutive days. In addition, each annual goal contains three short-term objectives or benchmarks which are also subject to the same measurement criteria. Student argues that the annual goals do not have specific targets. For example, Student points to goal number seven, which calls for STUDENT to “increase non-verbal imitation skills in an instructional setting to include imitation of gross motor, fine motor, and novel motor imitations within a song.” However, the short-term objectives or benchmarks for these goals do have specific annual targets for STUDENT to meet during the course of the school year. For example, benchmark number 7a for goal seven states, “in an educational setting, STUDENT will imitate 5 novel gross motor actions.” The Hearing Officer is persuaded that the targets for these benchmarks will allow STUDENT’s progress to be measured appropriately.
For all of these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives set forth in the April 23, 2004 IEP are designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
b. The STEPS Classroom and Instructors
Student contends that the April 23, 2004 offer is not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs because the STEPS classroom is too noisy and distracting for STUDENT and the teacher and aides are not appropriately trained to provide instruction to him. The District and PCOE maintain that the distractions and noise in the classroom can be minimized so as to ensure that STUDENT’s deficits can be addressed. They further contend that the teacher and staff assigned to the STEPS classroom are appropriately trained and qualified to provide instruction to STUDENT.
Witnesses for Student, including his mother, Scott Cross, and Caprice Schweiger, testified that STUDENT would be easily distracted by toys or other items stored on shelves in the STEPS classroom and by the noise and presence of other students in the classroom during the school day. They stated that such distractions would interfere with his instruction and asserted that he requires one-to-one instruction in a quiet environment free of distractions, such as STUDENT’s home. Mr. Cross also testified that the STEPS instructors, including Ms. Crouse and an instructional aide, were not implementing behavior intervention and discrete trial training techniques correctly in the STEPS classroom. Mr. Cross based his testimony on a forty-five minute videotaped session of Ms. Crouse’s STEPS classroom that was prepared for Dr. Diane Ashton, an educational consultant who testified on behalf of the District and PCOE.
Witnesses for the District and PCOE, including Betty Di Regolo, Susan Watt, and Jean Crouse, testified regarding the structure of the STEPS classroom and program. They testified that the majority of the students in the STEPS classroom are preschool-aged and diagnosed with autism spectrum disorders. There is currently one teacher, two aides, and eight students in the class. The addition of STUDENT’s proposed one-to-one aide from Advance Kids would bring the total number of aides to three. Ms. Crouse testified that STUDENT’s daily classroom instruction with the other students would last approximately three hours and forty-five minutes per day and would include rotation through various stations, including (1) one-to-one instruction of new skills, as set forth in the student’s IEP, (2) a structured work station where students complete structured tasks based upon previously mastered skills, (3) an independent work station where students work independently on previously mastered skills, (4) a directed play area where an aide works with students to expand their play and communication skills, (5) an art/fine motor station, (6) a sensory/gross motor station, and (7) a therapy station where the speech and language and occupational therapists provide therapy. According to Ms. Crouse, the stations have partitions surrounding them in order to minimize visual distractions and the noise level in the classroom is fairly low. The students also participate in circle time group activities each day, which include a good morning song, attendance, and stories. According to Ms. Crouse, she and her staff utilize a variety of teaching methods, including ABA, discrete trial training (DTT), PECS, Treatment of Education of Autistic Related and Communication Handicapped Children (TEACCH), incidental teaching, and natural language.
Ms. Crouse testified that she has been teaching the STEPS class since March of 2003. Her prior teaching experience includes three and one-half years teaching an SDC for severely handicapped preschool students, a year teaching a sixth to seventh grade SDC for severely handicapped students, and six months as a one-to-one aide at a nonpublic agency providing behavior support services to a severely handicapped autistic student who was transitioning from a nonpublic school to a public school SDC. She holds a master’s in special education and has received training in several instructional methodologies used for students on the autism spectrum, including TEACCH, PECS, DTT, and ABA.
The Hearing Officer finds that the STEPS classroom and instructor offered to STUDENT is designed to meet his unique needs. While a classroom with eight children and three adults is likely to pose more distractions than STUDENT’s home, the evidence demonstrates that the distractions in the classroom can be minimized through the use of partitions between the different work stations and Velcro covers to block STUDENT’s views of toys or other distracting items. Linh Giang, STUDENT’s current occupational therapist, testified that she successfully implemented similar strategies at her clinic when STUDENT became distracted by other people in the therapy room during his sessions. The Hearing Officer further finds that Ms. Crouse is appropriately qualified to provide instruction to STUDENT. As set forth above, she is a special education teacher who has taught autistic children and received training in several instructional methodologies used to teach autistic students.
c. Speech and Language Therapy
Student contends that STUDENT should continue to receive clinic-based therapy because the STEPS classroom would be too noisy and distracting an environment for STUDENT. In addition, Student contends that Linda Hess, the District’s speech and language therapist lacks the appropriate training to address STUDENT’s apraxia. The District and PCOE argue that the STEPS classroom is an appropriate location for STUDENT’s therapy and that Ms. Hess is qualified to provide speech and language therapy to STUDENT.
Brodi Wetherbee, STUDENT’s current speech and language therapist, testified that STUDENT requires a program which addresses his oral motor needs, the production of speech sounds and combinations, voice elongation and his receptive, expressive, and social communication skills. According to Ms. Wetherbee, STUDENT is distracted by noises such as other adults or children talking, laughing, and crying and by visual items such as toys. She stated that, for this reason, STUDENT requires individual sessions in a room separate from other children.
Linda Hess, the PCOE speech and language therapist, testified that she spends two days per week in the STEPS classroom offered as part of STUDENT’s program and has been providing therapy to students in STEPS classrooms for four years. She provides therapy in a partitioned area of the STEPS classroom designated for speech and occupational therapy. She testified that she uses a variety of methodologies and techniques in her sessions, including PECS, pivotal response training, rhymes, music, singing, books, puppets, and toys. According to Ms. Hess, the use of PECS will assist STUDENT in communicating his wants and needs and will facilitate verbal spoken language. Ms. Hess stated that she would focus on increasing STUDENT’s oral motor and speech sound production and developing a functional communication system for him. Ms. Hess testified that she has experience in addressing oral motor-based communication disorders and utilizes horns, whistles, straws and other instruments to help students organize their articulators and to facilitate sound production.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires one-to-one speech and language therapy for a total of two hours per week. The Hearing Officer further finds that the therapy can be either clinic-based or school-based, provided that the environment is sufficiently free of distractions to enable STUDENT to benefit from the therapy. While the classroom setting may pose more distractions for STUDENT than a clinic setting, the Hearing Officer was persuaded by the District and PCOE’s witnesses that measures would be implemented to ensure that such distractions would be minimized and would not impede STUDENT’s instruction. The Hearing Officer further finds that the co-treatment by the speech and occupational therapists, as set forth in the April 23, 2004 offer, will also address STUDENT’s deficits in the areas of expressive and receptive language. Finally, the Hearing Officer concludes that Ms. Hess is appropriately qualified to address STUDENT’s needs in the area of expressive and receptive language. Specifically, she holds a masters degree in speech pathology and audiology; she has received training in several methodologies, including PECS and TEACCH, which are used to facilitate communication and social interaction with autistic students; and she has nineteen years of experience in providing speech and language therapy to special education students, including autistic students.
d. Occupational Therapy
Student contends that STUDENT requires clinic-based therapy because the STEPS classroom would be too noisy and distracting for STUDENT. The District and PCOE argue that the STEPS classroom is an appropriate location for STUDENT’s therapy.
Linh Giang is employed by SLTA and has served as STUDENT’s occupational therapist since May 2003. She testified that the primary focus of his therapy has been to improve his sensory processing/modulation, organization of behaviors, motor planning, fine motor and visual perceptual skills. During therapy, STUDENT engages in activities such as drawing, matching colors and shapes, jumping, bouncing, swinging, throwing and playing with balls, and engaging in textured play with rice, beans, foam soaps, putty, and paint. She testified that STUDENT still experiences difficulty transitioning to therapy and between tasks during therapy. He also has difficulty with maintaining attention to task and with tantrums. According to Ms. Giang, occupational therapy at school would be difficult for STUDENT due to his distractibility and the presence of noises and visual stimuli, such as toys, posters and other students talking, laughing, or yelling. She admitted on cross-examination, however, that people walk in and out of the therapy room she uses with STUDENT during sixty to seventy percent of their sessions and that there are almost always at least three other people in the room during his therapy sessions, including another therapist and that therapist’s client. She testified that she occasionally puts up a screen or barrier to help STUDENT focus and to eliminate visual distractions.
Laurie Ferrell is a licensed occupational therapist employed by the PCOE and provides occupational therapy to students in the STEPS classroom at Sierra Elementary. She has been employed as occupational therapist for seven years and has worked at the PCOE since September 2003. According to Ms. Ferrell, approximately ninety percent of the students she services are autistic. She testified that she has vestibular, proprioceptive, sensory integration, and visual perception equipment and activities in the STEPS classroom and the room next door, including swings, a trampoline, therapy balls, a “hippy hop,” scooter boards, a net swing, a lycra tunnel, a body sock, a weighted ball, and bins with beans, rice, and shaving cream. According to Ms. Ferrell, this equipment and these activities would address STUDENT’s deficits in the areas of fine motor, gross motor, visual motor, and sensory integration. According to Ms. Ferrell, if STUDENT became distracted by other students during his therapy, she could schedule his therapy to occur during recess, when the other children are out of the room.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s occupational therapy would be appropriate in either a clinic-based or school-based setting, provided that the therapy area is sufficiently free of distractions so as to ensure that STUDENT will benefit from the therapy. The Hearing Officer was persuaded by Ms. Ferrell’s testimony that the STEPS classroom would be an appropriate setting for STUDENT’s therapy and that if the presence of other students caused STUDENT to be distracted, his therapy could take place at a time when those students were not present, such as recess.
e. Behavior Intervention Services
STUDENT exhibits the following behavioral deficits: tantrums, aggression, throwing objects, and self-injurious behavior for which he requires behavior intervention. To address STUDENT’s behavioral deficits, the District and PCOE offered to conduct a functional analysis assessment of STUDENT’s behaviors, create a behavior intervention plan, provide him with an ABA trained one-to-one aide during class and for two hours after class each day, and provide six hours per week of consultation and supervision, in addition to parent training. The one-to-one aide would collect data on targeted behaviors, assist STUDENT with transitions between activities, and provide ABA therapy on a one-to-one basis.
The Hearing Officer finds that the behavioral intervention services are designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The Hearing Officer determined, above, that STUDENT has behavioral deficits that need to be addressed by means of an FAA and a BIP. The Hearing Officer was persuaded by the testimony of Ms. Crouse and Ms. Wenell that a one-to-one aide will assist STUDENT with problem behaviors, transitions, and staying on task. Ms. Wenell, the executive director of Advance Kids, holds a bachelor’s degree in psychology, with an emphasis in applied behavior analysis. She is a board-certified associate behavior analyst. She has approximately eleven years of experience working on behavioral programs for autistic students in both home and school environments. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the behavioral intervention services offered by the District and PCOE are designed to meet his needs.
f. Transition Services
At the April 23, 2004 IEP meeting, the District and PCOE offered transition services to assist STUDENT in the transition from his home and clinic-based programs and providers to a school-based program and providers. The transition services include: (1) one hour of consultation/observation of STUDENT by Ms. Hess, the District/PCOE speech and language therapist, and Laurie Ferrell, District/PCOE occupational therapist, during therapy sessions conducted by the SLTA speech and language therapist and occupational therapist, (2) One hour consultation/observation by Ms. Hess and Ms. Ferrell at a music therapy session conducted by STUDENT’s music therapist, and (3) one hour of consultation/observation by Ms. Crouse, Ms. Paulin-O’Donnell, Ms. Hess, and Ms. Ferrell of an in-home ABA session conducted by LIFE staff.
The Hearing Officer finds that the transition services offered will meet STUDENT’s needs, with the addition of three hours of consultation between Advance Kids staff and LIFE staff and an hour of consultation between Advance Kids staff and STUDENT’s parents. Michelle Wenell testified that the transition plan would address STUDENT’s needs, if these additional fours hours of consultation were included. She testified that this additional consultation would enable Advance Kids to ensure a smooth transition from his in-home ABA program provided by LIFE to his school-based program by giving her staff an opportunity to observe LIFE’s ABA program with STUDENT and to consult with STUDENT’s parents about his eating and sleeping patterns. The Hearing Officer found her testimony credible, given her experience in transitioning autistic students between providers and programs. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the transitional services offered to STUDENT would be designed to meet his unique needs with the addition of these four hours of consultation.
3. Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
The Hearing Officer found above that the District and PCOE’s offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The evidence similarly demonstrates that the offer is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit. Specifically, the goals and objectives target his areas of deficit which include academics, expressive and receptive language skills, gross and fine motor skills, social and behavioral skills, play skills, attention, self-help, and sensory processing/integration; the classroom size and design, together with the provision of a one-to-one aide, allow STUDENT to stay on task and learn in a school-based setting by minimizing the risk of distractions and promptly addressing targeted behaviors; the classroom teacher, aides, and the Advance Kids staff working with STUDENT are all experienced in addressing the needs of autistic students; and the transition services offered ensure that STUDENT will be able to continue to progress in his program upon his transfer to the STEPS program.
4. Comport with the IEP and Least Restrictive Environment
STUDENT’s parents did not accept the District and PCOE’s offer and STUDENT remains in his in-home program. Because the educational placement and services offered to STUDENT have not been implemented, the question of whether the program provided to STUDENT comports with his IEP is not at issue.
Student did not argue that the District and PCOE failed to offer a placement in the least restrictive environment. Rather, Student contends that STUDENT should continue his in-home program, a more restrictive placement than the STEPS classroom. The District and PCOE argue that they offered STUDENT an educational program and services in the least restrictive environment—the STEPS classroom.
In determining whether a placement is the least restrictive environment, the courts have indicated four factors to be considered. Those factors include: (1) the educational benefits available to the child in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared to educational benefits of a special education classroom; (2) the non-academic benefits to the handicapped child of interaction with nonhandicapped children; (3) the effect of the presence of the handicapped child on the teacher and other children in the regular classroom; and (4) the costs of supplementary aids and services necessary to mainstream the handicapped child in a regular classroom setting. (Sacramento City Unif. School Dist. v. Rachel H. (9th Cir. 1994) 14 F.3d 1398.)
The test set forth above, however, is designed to determine whether a child should be placed in a regular education classroom or special education classroom. Here, the issue is whether the District and PCOE’s offered placement constitutes the least restrictive environment or, if as STUDENT contends, he requires a continuation of his in-home ABA program and clinic-based related services. (Footnote 17) The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT does not require the more restrictive in-home and clinic-based program. As set forth above, the Hearing Officer has found that the District and PCOE staff have measures in place to ensure that STUDENT’s needs are met and that he benefits educationally from the STEPS classroom, including partitions in the classroom, Velcro covers to hide distracting items on shelves, alternative locations and times to provide instruction in the event noise is a factor, and a one-to-one aide to assist STUDENT in staying on task and in transitioning between activities. In addition, the Hearing Officer found persuasive the testimony of the District and PCOE’s witnesses that the STEPS classroom would offer STUDENT greater opportunities to interact with other students his own age than would a home and clinic-based program. The evidence established that the primary child STUDENT plays with during his instructional day at home is his sister. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the STEPS classroom offered to STUDENT is the least restrictive environment.
C. Did the offer set forth in the IEP dated April 23, 2004, constitute a FAPE for the 2004 ESY?
For the 2004 ESY, the District and PCOE offered a four-week program which continued the program offered for the regular school year. This initial four-week program included the following: (1) continued placement in the PCOE’s STEPS program, (2) the related school-based services of one-to-one speech and language therapy for two hours per week and one-to-one occupational therapy for one hour per week, (3) a one-to-one aide trained in ABA behavior intervention techniques from Advanced Kids, a certified nonpublic agency, (4) ten hours per week of one-to-one behavior intervention services at school; and (5) co-treatment provided by a speech and language therapist and the occupational therapist In addition, a second four-week program was also offered and consisted of twenty hours per week of in-home one-to-one ABA behavior intervention services to be provided by Advance Kids.
Student contends that the District and PCOE failed to offer STUDENT an appropriate ESY program. Student’s arguments mirror those raised above for the 2004-2005 regular school year. The District and PCOE maintain that they offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004 ESY.
Extended school year programming is educational programming that extends instruction beyond the normal school year to prevent serious regression over the summer months. (Hoeft v. Tucson Unified Sch. Dist., 967 F.3d 1298, 1301 (9th Cir. 1992); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(b).) In California, a school district is required to provide a special education student with ESY programming when the student requires special education and related services in excess of the regular academic year or the IEP team has determined the need for ESY programming. (Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043; compare with 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(a)(2).) Where a child has been determined eligible for ESY services by his or her IEP team, the written IEP must include an ESY program. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(b)(3); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(b)(1)(ii).)
The parties do not dispute STUDENT’s need for an ESY program. As a student with autism, the possibility of regression exists for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer has found, above, that the program and services offered to STUDENT for the 2004-2005 school year constitute a FAPE. Since the same program and services were offered for the first four-week portion of the ESY, the Hearing Officer finds that this portion of the ESY offer constitutes an offer of FAPE to STUDENT.
The Hearing Officer further finds that the District and PCOE’s offer of placement and services for the second four-week ESY constitutes an offer of FAPE. As set forth above, the Hearing Officer found that Ms. Wenell and her staff at Advance Kids are appropriately trained in behavior intervention techniques used to provide instruction to autistic students and are qualified to provide behavioral intervention services to STUDENT. The Hearing Officer found persuasive Ms. Wenell’s testimony that the twenty hours per week of in-home one-to-one ABA behavior intervention services to be provided by Advance Kids, together with speech and occupational therapy, is designed to prevent STUDENT from regressing during this four-week period.
****
The evidence established that the District and PCOE’s offer of April 23, 2004, constitutes a FAPE. The programs, both for the regular school year and the 2004 ESY, are designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of academics, expressive and receptive language skills, gross and fine motor skills, social and behavioral skills, play skills, attention, self-help, and sensory processing/integration and are reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit in these areas. Finally, the programs are offered in the least restrictive environment.
Issue No. 3: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for expenses incurred for behavioral intervention services, speech therapy, and/or occupational therapy from September 12, 2003 to the present?
Student contends that his parents are entitled to reimbursement for costs or obligations incurred as a result of his educational program through LIFE and SLTA from September 12, 2003, to the date of this Decision. Specifically, he seeks reimbursement for all expenses pertaining to his in-home ABA program through LIFE and his clinic-based speech and occupational therapy through SLTA.
The District and PCOE contend that they offered, in May of 2004, to reimburse Student for expenses incurred as a result of his educational program through LIFE and SLTA from October 12, 2003 to April 23, 2004. They maintain, however, that Student is not entitled to reimbursement for such costs incurred after April 23, 2004, because: (1) they offered Student a FAPE on April 23, 2004, and (2) even if they did not offer him a FAPE, the services he received from LIFE and SLTA did not constitute an appropriate program.
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under IDEA and are reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Student W. v. Puyalllup School District, 131 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994).) The Burlington rule of reimbursement is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parent are found to be the exact proper placement or services required under the IDEA. (Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 790 F. 2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986).) In Florence County Sch. Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13, 114 S.Ct. 361 (1993), the Supreme Court expressly exempted parents from having to meet certain requirements of the IDEA in their unilateral placements. For example, parents are not required to conform their unilateral placement to the content of the student’s IEP or provide a placement that is certified by the State. (Id. at 13-14.) The Court recognized, however, that the parents’ placement must still meet other requirements of the IDEA, such as providing a placement that addresses the student’s needs and provides the student educational benefit. (Id.) In summary, to be entitled to reimbursement for the cost of private services, it must be determined that 1) the student was denied a FAPE, and 2) the student’s private placement or program addresses the student’s educational needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him or her with educational benefit.
A. The Period from October 12, 2003 to April 23, 2004
On May 13, 2004, the District and PCOE offered, in writing, to reimburse Student for costs incurred to provide him with educational services from October 12, 2003, his third birthday, to April 23, 2004, less any amount paid by the Regional Center, for the following services: (1) up to 23.5 hours per week of in-home discrete trial therapy, (2) up to two hours per week of speech and language therapy, (3) up to one hour per week of occupational therapy, and (4) up to one hour per week of music therapy. At hearing, representatives for the District and PCOE confirmed that this offer was still available. Student has not formally accepted this offer, nor has he contended that this offer was inappropriate in terms of the nature and extent of the services to be reimbursed. No evidence was offered by Student suggesting that this offer of reimbursement was inappropriate or inconsistent with the services he actually received from his nonpublic agency providers during the period at issue. Given the offer by the District and PCOE, which is both in writing and on the record in this hearing, it is unnecessary for the Hearing Officer to reach a determination on reimbursement for this time period.
B. The Period from April 23, 2004 to the Present
The Hearing Officer found that the District and the PCOE’s offer dated April 23, 2004, constitutes a FAPE. Accordingly, Student is not entitled to reimbursement for the costs of services incurred after the date of this offer.
Issue No. 4: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education in the form of music therapy services?
Student contends that he is entitled to the additional remedy of compensatory education in the form of music therapy because the IEP dated September 12, 2003, did not address his educational needs in the areas of academics, expressive and receptive language, gross and fine motor, social skills and behavior, play, attention, self-help, and sensory processing/integration. Student seeks an award of thirty-two sessions. The District and PCOE contend that STUDENT did not require music therapy to receive a FAPE. They argue that many of the song, dance, and instrument techniques that STUDENT’s music therapist employs in her sessions are also used by District and PCOE teachers and therapists in the STEPS program. Finally, they maintain that no evidence was presented establishing that STUDENT has regressed due to a lack of music therapy.
When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is appropriate in light of the purposes of the IDEA. Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district fails to provide a FAPE, and the placement or services are determined to be appropriate under the IDEA. Equitable considerations may be weighed in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting such relief. (School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 358.) Among the factors to consider is the conduct of the parties. (W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist. (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1486.) Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See Lester H v. K. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.) There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for-hour compensation for missed services. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated with the meaning of the IDEA.” (Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496.)
The Hearing Officer has already determined above that the District and PCOE’s offer set forth in the IEP dated September 12, 2003, does not constitute a FAPE. Student contends that he is entitled to compensatory education in the form of music therapy as a remedy for the failure of the District and the PCOE to offer him a FAPE during this period. Student has neither alleged nor established, however, that he failed to receive any necessary educational services during this time period, other than music therapy. The testimony of Student’s witnesses, including his mother, Caprice Schweiger, and Scott Cross, establish that STUDENT continued to receive his in-home ABA program through LIFE as well as his speech and language and occupational therapy during this period. Student does not contend that these services failed to meet his needs or provide him with educational benefit. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that an award of compensatory education is unnecessary to remedy the failure to offer a FAPE because STUDENT received appropriate privately obtained services for which his parents will be reimbursed. (Footnote 18) In other words, STUDENT does not require any additional programs or services to make him whole. As to Student’s specific request for compensatory education in the form of music therapy, the Hearing Officer notes that such an award would be solely for the purpose of compensating STUDENT for music therapy sessions he did not receive during the time frame at issue because the evidence establishes that he continued to receive all of the other components of his program. As set forth above, the Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT does not require music therapy services in order to receive a FAPE. Therefore, his request for compensatory education in the form of music therapy is also denied.
Issue No. 5: Are the District and the PCOE entitled to assess STUDENT as identified in the assessment plan dated April 23, 2004 and updated on June 3, 2004?
The District and PCOE argue that they are entitled to assess STUDENT in the areas of pre-academics, cognitive ability, adaptive behavior, communication, motor development, health, social/emotional, pre-vocational, and behavior. As part of these assessments, the District and PCOE seek an opportunity to observe STUDENT’s in-home ABA program. They have never assessed STUDENT and contend that they require assessments in these areas to obtain further information on STUDENT’s present levels of performance and make any necessary adjustments to STUDENT’s educational program. They maintain that they prepared an appropriate assessment plan and have qualified staff to conduct all of the proposed assessments.
Student asserts that assessments are not warranted at this time because the evidence presented by STUDENT’s current educational providers is reliable information about his current educational needs. He further maintains that the request for assessments by the Distinct and the PCOE was for the purpose of litigation, not for developing a program for STUDENT.
School districts are required by statute to “systematically seek out” all persons under the age of twenty-two who reside within their boundaries and have exceptional educational needs. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56300; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10).) To implement this “child find” obligation, each local education agency is required to provide for the identification and assessment of an individual’s exceptional needs, and the planning of an instructional program to meet the assessed needs. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56302).
Before any action is taken with respect to the initial special education placement of a student, the student must be assessed in all areas of suspected disability. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320). The process for assessment begins with a written referral for assessment by the parent, teacher, school personnel, or other appropriate agency or person. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56302, 56321(a); 5 C.C.R. § 3021). Within fifteen days of referral, the parent must be given a written assessment plan which explains the types of assessments to be conducted and meets certain other requirements. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56321). The parent then has fifteen days to consent in writing to the proposed assessment. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(c).)
In Gregory K. V. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1315 (9th Cir. 1987), the Ninth Circuit stated, “if parents want [their child] to receive special education under the Act, they are obligated to permit such testing.” In Andress v. Cleveland Independent School District, 64 F.3d 176, 178 (5th Cir. 1995), the Fifth Circuit concluded that “a parent who desires for her child to receive special education must allow the school district to evaluate the child…there is no exception to this rule.” (See also Vander Malle v. Ambach, 6673 F. 2d 49, 53 (2nd Cir. 1983).)
While the law provides that a school district has the right and obligation to conduct these assessments, parental consent for an evaluation is required before a school district can assess the child. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(1)(C)(i); Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(c).) However, a local educational agency can overcome a lack of parental consent for an evaluation by establishing at a due process hearing that an assessment is necessary. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(c), 56506(e); 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(1)(C)(ii).)
In summary, the District and PCOE must establish that the assessments are necessary and that the assessment plan conforms to the legal requirements set forth in the IDEA and State law. Each of these areas is addressed separately below.
A. Necessity of Assessments
The Hearing Officer turns first to the question of whether an assessment of STUDENT is necessary. State and federal law require a school district to assess in all areas related to a student’s suspected disability including, if appropriate, health and development, vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general intelligence, academic performance, communication, self-help skills, orientation and mobility, career and vocational interests and abilities, and social/emotional status. (20 U.S.C. §1414(b)(3)(C); 34 C.F.R. § 300.532(g); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f).) The purpose of an assessment is not only to identify a student’s unique special education eligibility category but also to assist in identifying the student’s unique educational needs. (See, e.g., Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56320(e), 56321(a); 34 C.F.R. § 300.532(h).).
The District and PCOE’s witnesses, which included Betty Di Regolo, Susan Watts, Michelle Wenell and Mary Gwaltney, credibly testified that the District and PCOE require assessments in the areas of pre-academics, cognitive ability, adaptive behavior, communication, motor development, health, social/emotional, pre-vocational, and behavior to establish baseline data, update STUDENT’s present levels of performance, and make any necessary program modifications. The District and PCOE have never formally assessed STUDENT before. The Hearing Officer finds unpersuasive the Student’s contention that the assessment and progress reports from STUDENT’s nonpublic agency providers serve to provide the District and PCOE with sufficient information about STUDENT’s areas of disability. Specifically, the assessments performed by LIFE, which consisted primarily of observations and parent interviews, are distinguishable from those proposed by the District and PCOE, which must comply with the requirements of Education Code section 56320. There was no showing that the assessments conducted by LIFE or SLTA staff complied with these requirements. Finally, the Hearing Officer finds unpersuasive the Student’s argument that the purpose of the proposed assessments is for litigation only, especially when the assessments will have been conducted after the issuance of this Decision. The Hearing Officer found the testimony of the District and PCOE’s witnesses persuasive, particularly in light of the fact that they have never formally assessed STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the assessments proposed by the District and PCOE are necessary.
B. Conformity with Legal Requirements
Having determined that the proposed assessments are necessary, the Hearing Officer must determine whether the assessment plan satisfies the legal requirements set forth in the IDEA and State law.
Education Code section 56321(b) requires that the assessment plan (1) be in language that is easily understood by the general public; (2) be provided in the primary language of the parent; (3) explain the types of assessments to be conducted; and (4) state that no individual education program from the assessment will result from the assessment without the consent of the parents. Once the assessment is provided to the student’s parents, the parents must be allowed at least fifteen days to respond to the assessment plan. Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(a).
The Hearing Officer finds that the District and PCOE provided STUDENT’s parents with an assessment plan which met these requirements. First, the assessment plan is in English, the primary language of STUDENT’s parents, and it is in language that is easily understood by the general public. Student did not present any evidence establishing that STUDENT’s parents did not understand the assessment plan. Second, the assessment plan explains that the following types of assessments will be conducted: pre-academics, cognitive ability, adaptive behavior, communication, motor development, health, social/emotional, pre-vocational, behavioral issues and observations of his home program. Third, the assessment plan clearly states that no individual education program from the assessment will result from the assessment without the consent of the parents. Finally, the initial assessment plan was provided to STUDENT’s parents at the IEP meeting of April 23, 2004, and they were allowed the requisite fifteen days to respond to the plan. The amended assessment plan, which was identical to the first plan but for the addition of a functional analysis assessment to be conducted by Advance Kids, was presented to STUDENT’s parents on June 3, 2004. STUDENT’s parents were again allowed fifteen days to respond to the plan. (Footnote19) For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the assessment plan satisfies the requirements of Education Code section 56321.
The assessments themselves must meet the statutory requirements set forth in California Education Code section 56320, et. seq. The Education Code requires that assessments shall be conducted by individuals who are both knowledgeable of the student’s disability and competent to perform the assessment, as determined by the local educational agency. (Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56320(g), 56322.) The tests and assessment materials must be validated for the specific purpose for which they are used, must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory, must be provided and administered in the student’s primary language or other mode of communication unless this is clearly not feasible, and must be administered by trained personnel in conformance with the instructions provided by the producer of such tests. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(a), (b).) A psychological assessment must be performed by a credentialed school psychologist. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56324). Moreover, a school district must assess a student in all areas related to the student’s suspected disability, and no single procedure may be used as the sole criterion for determining a student’s needs. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320 (e), (f).)
Here, the April 24, 2004 assessment plan, revised on June 3, 2004, lists the areas to be assessed and identifies the job titles of the individuals who will test STUDENT. The plan proposes to conduct the following assessments: pre-academics and pre-vocational by the special education teacher; cognitive ability, adaptive behavior and social/emotional by the school psychologist; communication by the speech and language specialist; motor development by the school psychologist and the occupational therapist; health by the school nurse; behavior/functional analysis assessment and in-home program observation by Advance Kids and District/PCOE staff. The testimony of Ms. Crouse, special education teacher; Ms. Ferrell, occupational therapist; Ms. Hess, speech and language pathologist; Ms. Paulin-O’Donnell, school psychologist; and Ms. Wenell of Advance Kids established that these individuals are knowledgeable of STUDENT’s disability and competent to perform the designated assessments. Their testimony further established that the assessments satisfy the remaining requirements of section 56320. Finally, the evidence established that the assessment will be in all areas of suspected disability that are related to STUDENT’s areas of deficit, including pre-academics, cognitive ability, adaptive behavior, communication, motor development, health, social/emotional, pre-vocational, and behavior. Student did not argue that the assessment plan or the specific assessments proposed therein failed to meet the legal requirements set forth above, other than the requirement that the assessments be necessary. As set forth above, the Hearing Officer has found that the assessments are necessary. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the proposed assessment plan dated April 23, 2004, and updated on June 3, 2004, conforms to State and federal legal requirements. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District and PCOE are entitled to assess STUDENT as set forth in the amended assessment plan.
ORDER
1. The transition services to be provided to Student pursuant to the offer set forth in the April 23, 2004 IEP shall include the following: three hours of consultation/observation between Advance Kids staff and LIFE staff and one hour of consultation between Advance Kids staff and STUDENT’s parents in order to ensure a smooth transition from STUDENT’s in-home ABA program to his school-based program.
2. The District and PCOE shall reimburse Student’s parents for the cost of the educational services obtained for Student during the period from October 12, 2003 to April 23, 2004, less any amount paid by the regional center, consistent with the District and PCOE’s offer of reimbursement as stated in correspondence dated May 13, 2004, and on the record at the hearing of this matter.
3. The District and PCOE are entitled to complete their assessment of Student pursuant to the assessment plan dated April 23, 2004, and updated on June 3, 2004. The assessments conducted shall include a comprehensive assessment, consistent with the requirements of Education Code section 56320, et. seq., to determine whether Student has apraxia The District and PCOE shall inform the Student’s parents of the assessment date(s) at least five calendar days in advance so that Student can be made available for the assessment. Student’s parents shall make Student reasonably available for the District and PCOE to conduct the assessments.
4. All of the parties’ other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
1. Did the District and the PCOE offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from October 12, 2003, his third birthday, to April 23, 2004? The Student prevailed on this issue, except with respect to the issue of the need for a transition plan for purposes of stay put providers. The District prevailed on that specific issue.
2. Does the District and the PCOE’s offer set forth in the IEP dated April 23, 2004, constitute a FAPE?
The District and PCOE prevailed on this issue.
3. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for expenses incurred for behavioral intervention services, speech therapy, and/or occupational therapy for the period from October 12, 2003 to the date of this Decision?
With regard to the period from October 12, 2003 to April 23, 2004, the issue of reimbursement was not heard and decided and therefore the Hearing Officer does not make a finding as to a prevailing party. With regard to the period from April 23, 2004, to the date of this Decision, the District and PCOE prevailed on this issue.
4. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education in the form of music therapy services?
The District and PCOE prevailed on this issue.
5. Are the District and the PCOE entitled to assess STUDENT as identified in the assessment plan dated April 23, 2004 and updated on June 3, 2004?
The District and PCOE prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).)
Date: November 4, 2004 ___________________________________ Christian P. Hurley, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
At hearing, the District and PCOE confirmed that their offer of reimbursement did not include any compensatory education in the form of music therapy.
2 STUDENT turned four years old on October 12, 2004.
3 The Code of Federal Regulations defines autism as “…a developmental disability significantly affecting verbal and nonverbal communication and social interaction, generally evident before age 3, that adversely affects a child’s educational performance. Other characteristics often associated with autism are engagement in repetitive activities and stereotyped movements, resistance to environmental change or change in daily routines, and unusual responses to sensory experiences….” (34 C.F.R. § 300.7.)
4 According to Brodi Wetherbee, a speech and language therapist at SLTA, apraxia is a neurological disorder that affects the planning and production of speech, and results in a loss in ability to voluntarily position the articulators (e.g. lips jaw, tongue) on a consistent basis while speaking.
5 Witnesses at hearing, including Scott Cross, Jean Crouse, and Michelle Wenell, described PECS as a program that allows children with autism and other communication deficits to initiate and develop functional communication of wants and needs. It begins with teaching a student to exchange a picture of a desired item with a teacher, who then provides the desired item. It goes on to teach discrimination of symbols and developing simple sentences.
6 According to Laurie Ferrell, PCOE occupational therapist, proprioception concerns the ability to sense the position, location, orientation, and movement of the body and its parts.
7 According to Ms. Ferrell, the vestibular system is the system in the body that is responsible for maintaining the body’s orientation in space, balance, and posture.
8 The report defines “tantrum behavior” as consisting of crying, screaming, falling to the floor, throwing toys, material or furniture, kicking the door, and/or trying to escape the room for thirty to forty-five seconds with varying intensity.
9 The IDEA and State law assures the parents the right to participate in the IEP process. (20 U.S.C. § 1400(c)(5)(B); (Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b)(1).)
10 Respondent cites the following decisions issued by the Hearing Office: Student v. Los Angeles School District, SEHO Case No. SN03-01391 (2003) and Lucia Mar Unified School District v. Student, SEHO Case No. SN02-00226 (2002).
11 California law specifies that “IEP” means an “IFSP” when the educational program pertains to an individual with exceptional needs who is under the age of three years. Cal. Educ. Code § 56032.
12 In addition to the above, STUDENT also received, during some unspecified period, one hour of speech therapy, per week, at the U.C. Davis M.I.N.D. Institute.
14 Additionally, Student did not raise the issue of the necessity of a transition plan for purposes of stay put providers in the written briefs they submitted to the Hearing Office in support of the motion for stay put.
15 There are additional requirements that a program must meet in order to constitute an appropriate educational program, including preparations for independent living, which are not at issue here.
16 Unless otherwise indicated, for each of the enumerated goals, the IEP indicates that objectives will be considered mastered when STUDENT is successful on 80 percent of presented opportunities over three consecutive days.
17 No one contends that STUDENT should be placed in a regular education classroom at this time.
18 As previously set forth in this Decision, STUDENT’s parents shall be reimbursed for the costs of STUDENT’s program pursuant to the offer by the District and PCOE which was presented both in writing and on record at the hearing, 19 The hearing in this matter commenced on June 8, 2004, but no evidence was taken on that date and the hearing was continued to June 17, 2004, so that a procedural issue could be resolved. Accordingly, STUDENT’s parents had approximately fourteen days to review the updated assessment plan before evidence was taken in this hearing. While this was one day less than required by law, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s parents had sufficient time to review and consider the updated assessment plan, particularly in light of the fact that counsel represented them during this period.
