California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 29, 1997
San Jose Unified School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 1246-96 · Hearing Officer Mark Paxson
San Jose Unified may reassess a home-schooled student without parental consent, but only if he re-enrolls in the District.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
San Jose Unified School District asked for a hearing so it could do an overdue three-year (triennial) reassessment of a 13-year-old boy without his parents' consent. It also asked to hold an IEP meeting afterward. The boy was in special day classes until his parents withdrew consent to special education in 1993. Since then his grandmother had home-schooled him, except for a few months in a general education sixth grade class at Hoover Middle School in fall 1995. The decision does not state his eligibility category. His grandmother represented him. She asked the Hearing Officer to dismiss the case, saying the parents wanted general education with Section 504 accommodations and would not consent to any assessment or special education. The Hearing Officer denied the request, and she left the hearing.
District staff testified, without contradiction, that he struggled with reading, attention, motor skills and working in large groups. The Hearing Officer found the District had enough educational reasons to assess. But the boy was not enrolled, and the District cited no legal authority for forcing an assessment on a child whose parents had removed him and were not asking for services. So the order lets the District do a comprehensive assessment only if he enrolls in the District. In that case his parents must make him available. After any assessment, the District must hold an IEP meeting to decide eligibility and, if he is eligible, develop a program.
Why it matters
The case shows how SEHO handled a district's request to assess without consent when the parents had removed the child to home school and wanted no services. The Hearing Officer found that the district had good reasons to assess. However, the district could assess only if the child re-enrolled, because it cited no authority to force an assessment on a child who was not enrolled.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailed in partDistrict-filed: assess without consent
Issue 1. Is San Jose Unified School District entitled to conduct a triennial assessment of the student?
The District showed enough educational reasons to assess. However, it cited no authority to force an assessment on a child the parents had removed from public school, so it may assess only if the student enrolls in the District.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 2. If the District is entitled to conduct an assessment, is the District also entitled to convene an IEP meeting upon completion of the assessment to determine whether the student is eligible for special education services?
Under Education Code section 56340, if the District assesses, it has the right and the duty to hold an IEP meeting to decide eligibility and, if he is eligible, develop a program.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order that district may assess without consent. If the student enrolls in San Jose Unified School District, the District may conduct a comprehensive assessment of his educational needs, and his parents must make him available for it.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. If the District assesses the student, it must convene an IEP meeting to decide his eligibility for special education and, if he is eligible, develop an appropriate educational program.
Key authorities
Education Code section 56300; Education Code section 56302; Education Code section 56320; Education Code section 56506(e); Education Code section 56340; 34 CFR 76.650-76.662
People named in the decision
- Barbara Granato, sixth grade general education teacher (language arts and social studies), Hoover Middle School, San Jose Unified School District
- Debrah Lindstrom, school psychologist, San Jose Unified School District
- Mike Barbaccia, physical education teacher, Hoover Middle School, San Jose Unified School District
- Jackie Blackwell, director of student services; District representative, San Jose Unified School District
- Pamela Johnson, program specialist, San Jose Unified School District
- Kathy DuShane, assessor (1991 comprehensive assessment), San Jose Unified School District
- Diagnostic Center for Neurologically Handicapped Children, state diagnostic center; field-based assessment (1992), State of California
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in San Jose, California, on December 19, 1996. Petitioner San Jose Unified School District (District) was represented by Jackie Blackwell, director of student services. Respondent STUDENT was represented by his grandmother, GRANDMOTHER. Testifying on behalf of Petitioner were Barbara Granato, sixth grade teacher at Hoover Middle School; Debrah Lindstrom, school psychologist; Mike Barbaccia, physical education teacher at Hoover Middle School; Jackie Blackwell, director of student services; and Pamela Johnson, program specialist. Oral and documentary evidence was received, the record was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision. ISSUES (1) Is San Jose Unified School District entitled to conduct a triennial assessment of STUDENT? (2) If San Jose Unified School District is entitled to conduct an assessment, is the District also entitled to convene an individualized education program meeting upon completion of the assessment to determine whether STUDENT is eligible for special education services? PROCEDURAL MATTERS At the beginning of the hearing, GRANDMOTHER, STUDENT's grandmother, appeared on behalf of STUDENT and requested that this matter be dismissed. GRANDMOTHER contended that STUDENT's parents do not want special education for STUDENT and that they will educate STUDENT on their own if the District does not grant their request for a regular education program with Section 504 accommodations. GRANDMOTHER indicated that STUDENT's parents will not consent to an assessment, to an IEP, or to any special education. In response, Ms. Blackwell contended that STUDENT is overdue for a triennial assessment. Ms. Blackwell further contended that the District tried Section 504 accommodations last year and that STUDENT needs special education services. Respondent's request to dismiss this matter was denied based on the District's identification of issues that are appropriate for a special education hearing. Following the Hearing Officer's ruling on the dismissal request, GRANDMOTHER left the hearing and did not return. SUMMARY OF RELEVANT EVIDENCE STUDENT is thirteen years old and currently receiving his education through a home school program taught by his grandmother. STUDENT received special education services for several years until the fifth grade during the 1993-94 school year. It is unclear from the IEPs submitted into evidence what STUDENT's specific eligibility was for special education. However, it appears that in February 1993, during STUDENT's fourth grade year, he was transferred from a special day class for severely handicapped students to a special day class for learning handicapped students. (District's Exhibit No. 4) On January 24, 1991, when STUDENT was seven years old, the District conducted a comprehensive assessment of STUDENT's educational needs. (District Exhibit No. 1) The assessment included results from the Test of Early Math Ability, Test of Early Reading Ability, Woodcock-Johnson Achievement Battery, Leiter International Performance Scale, Woodcock-Johnson Scales of Independent Behavior, Sentence Completion, and Draw-A-Person. On the Leiter, STUDENT's IQ score was 55, a score that falls in the severely delayed range. On the academic testing, STUDENT's scores fell in a range from less than three years and up to five years, eight months. STUDENT's speech and language ability was at the four year age equivalent. STUDENT's social, communication, and personal living skills were also at approximately the four year level. The assessor, Kathy DuShane, recommended that placement in a special day class for severely handicapped students be considered for STUDENT and that his education involve a multi-modality approach. Ms. DuShane also recommended that STUDENT receive speech and language therapy. On February 5, 1992, the Diagnostic Center for Neurologically Handicapped Children completed a field-based assessment of STUDENT. (District Exhibit No. 2) The assessment was conducted at the District's request and with the consent of STUDENT's mother. The Diagnostic Center identified numerous areas of deficiency, including academic, speech and language, peer interaction, and social behavior. The Diagnostic Center also made numerous recommendations regarding STUDENT's education. These recommendations addressed learning environment, independence, attention, functional academics, perseveration, speech and language, and home issues. The sum of these recommendations result in a picture of a child who is in need of a small group educational setting that includes a significant amount of assistance from teachers, aides, and speech and language therapists. At the time of STUDENT's IEP dated February 1993, he was in a fourth grade special day class for the learning handicapped. (District Exhibit No. 4) At that time, STUDENT was reading at the kindergarten level and could correctly respond to comprehension questions approximately 50% of the time. In math, STUDENT could match numbers up to seven. Weaknesses at that time included speech and language, academics, and fine motor skills, while strengths were identified as "likes animals, drama, will work hard for a goal, loves P.E., good participation." He had also shown growth in on-task behavior, speaking at appropriate times, and peer interaction. In language, [STUDENT] demonstrated adequate sentence structure and use of word forms such as verbs, pronouns, and comparatives. However, he appears to have difficulty sequencing thoughts to formulate ideas adequately when communicating with other people. Also, when he is engaged in communication with other people he has difficulty staying on topic, blurting out answers, and perseverating on topics of his choice. STUDENT's weaknesses in language included reduced semantics and pragmatics. The rationale for STUDENT's placement in the February 1993 IEP was that he "needs one to one and small group instruction with a multisensory approach." STUDENT also qualified for extended school year services. (District Exhibit No. 5) In September 1993, STUDENT's parents withdrew consent to continuing special education services and STUDENT was placed in regular education. During the 1994-95 school year, STUDENT was removed by his parents from the District and received his education through a home school program taught by his grandmother. At the beginning of the 1995-96 school year, STUDENT returned to the District and was placed in a regular education sixth grade class at Hoover Middle School. In December 1995, STUDENT was again removed from the District by his parents and, since that time, has received his education in the home school program taught by his grandmother. (Testimony of Jackie Blackwell) Barbara Granato taught STUDENT in her sixth grade language arts and social studies classes from September through December 1995. During that time, STUDENT had difficulty with reading and staying on task. He knew the alphabet but could not read simple books. He also talked to himself, rocked in his chair, and made odd gestures with his hands. An aide worked with STUDENT once a week for one hour in the language arts class. (Testimony of Barbara Granato) In STUDENT's physical education class, he demonstrated gross motor skills at the second or third grade level and was always talking to himself. STUDENT could not stay focused in the large physical education class and was not able to use his locker. (Testimony of Mike Barbaccia) On November 27, 1995, an IEP meeting was convened. Nobody attended the meeting on STUDENT's behalf. The IEP team concluded that STUDENT should receive special education services. (District Exhibit No. 8) On January 16, 1996, a student study team met to determine if STUDENT needed 504 modifications to his regular education program. The student study team concluded that 504 modifications would not be sufficient and that STUDENT needed special education services. (Testimony of Jackie Blackwell) During the meeting, the team identified the following concerns: (1) Lack of reading/writing ability. (2) Perseveration -- continues with one thought for extended periods of time. (3) Math -- unable to write down assignments. (4) Lacks fine motor skills, as well as gross. (5) Seems to lack initiative to try on his own. (6) On occasion, major discrepancy between class work product and homework done at home. (7) Coming to class without proper supplies. (8) Poor attention span. (9) STUDENT does not feel important. (10) Repeats inappropriate things he has heard. (District Exhibit No. 13) STUDENT's grandmother attended the meeting and requested that STUDENT be enrolled in regular education with special education services three times per week in the regular education classroom. After she made this request, GRANDMOTHER left the meeting and did not participate in the team's discussion regarding strategies for meeting STUDENT's needs. The conclusion of the team was that STUDENT needed special education services. (District Exhibit No. 13) On February 6, 1996, an individualized education program (IEP) meeting was held with STUDENT's grandmother, GRANDMOTHER, in attendance. With the exception of GRANDMOTHER, the IEP team concluded that STUDENT was eligible for special education based on teacher observations, STUDENT's behavior and functioning level, and past assessments. GRANDMOTHER did not consent to eligibility or placement in special education. (Testimony of Pamela Johnson) As stated above, STUDENT's grandmother, GRANDMOTHER, stated that STUDENT's parents do not want him to receive any special education services and will not re-enroll STUDENT in the District if special education services are forced on him. GRANDMOTHER indicated that STUDENT's parents want STUDENT to be educated in the regular education program with 504 modifications.(Footnote 1) DISCUSSION (1) Is San Jose Unified School District entitled to conduct a triennial assessment of STUDENT? Education Code 56300 requires that school districts actively and systematically seek out all individuals with exceptional needs, ages 0 through 21 years, including children not enrolled in public school programs, who reside in the district or are under the jurisdiction of a special education local plan area or a county office. Section 56302 provides that [e]ach school district ... shall provide for the identification and assessment of an individual's exceptional needs, and the planning of an instructional program to meet the assessed needs. Section 56320 provides that [b]efore any action is taken with respect to the initial placement of an individual with exceptional needs in special education instruction, an individual assessment of the pupil's educational needs shall be conducted ....Section 56320 goes on to list the criteria under which such assessments should be conducted. Included in the criteria is that the student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability. Pursuant to 56300 and 56302, the District has a statutory obligation to seek out all children within its jurisdiction who are in need of educational services, regardless of whether those children are enrolled in public school or nonpublic school. While the statutory language does not provide specific criteria under which the District should assess children, the language of 56320(f) establishes that assessments should address suspected disabilities. Therefore, if the District has reason to suspect that a disability exists which is affecting STUDENT's ability to benefit from his education, 56300 and 56302 impose an obligation to assess him under certain circumstances. In cases where a school district believes an assessment is necessary and the parents of the child refuse to consent to the assessment, 56506(e) grants to the school district the right to conduct the assessment only if the school district prevails on the issue of assessment at a due process hearing. In the present case, the District has requested a due process hearing to determine whether it has the right to conduct an assessment over the objections of STUDENT's parents. The District contends that STUDENT's needs cannot be met in a regular education setting and that STUDENT needs special education services. The District contends that it needs to assess STUDENT to develop and offer an appropriate program which will meet his educational needs. The evidence establishes that there is reason to suspect that STUDENT has a disability which is affecting his ability to benefit from his education. The assessments completed in 1991 show that at that time STUDENT was delayed in numerous areas, including cognition, academics, speech and language, social behavior, and communication. The testimony of his teachers from fall 1995 establishes that STUDENT continued to experience problems that were affecting his ability to benefit from his education. These problems included difficulty with reading and staying on task, delays in reading, poor motor skills, and an inability to function in large groups. STUDENT was significantly delayed in many of these areas. In addition, the student study team which met in January 1996 expressed many of the same concerns. The report indicated STUDENT had problems in reading, writing and math, perseveration, motor skills, and attention. In January and February 1996, it was the opinion of the school personnel who had worked with STUDENT and who attended the student study team and IEP meetings that a regular education program could not meet his educational needs, even with modifications. These same individuals testified at the hearing that STUDENT continued to need special education services. The evidence presented by the District establishes that STUDENT is in need of special education services. No evidence was submitted to contradict the District's evidence or to demonstrate that STUDENT no longer needs special education services. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has established sufficient educational reasons to request an assessment of STUDENT. The present case, however, presents a question of whether the District may force STUDENT to submit to an assessment when he is currently not enrolled in any District program. While there are provisions of federal law which require in certain circumstances that school districts provide special education services to eligible children enrolled in private schools when their parents request such services, it is unclear whether special education law allows public schools to force such services on children who have been unilaterally removed from the public schools by their parents and who are not requesting any such services from the public school. See 34 CFR 76.650-76.662. The Hearing Officer finds that if STUDENT's parents wish to return him to the District, there are sufficient educational reasons to conduct an assessment. In such a case, the District has the right and legal obligation to conduct an assessment. However, the District did not provide any legal authority for the proposition that it can force STUDENT to participate in an assessment while he is refusing to accept any educational services from the District. Therefore, the District's right to conduct an assessment is contingent on STUDENT's returning to the District. (2) If San Jose Unified School District is entitled to conduct an assessment, is the District also entitled to convene an individualized education program meeting upon completion of the assessment to determine whether STUDENT is eligible for special education services? Special education law requires that school districts develop individualized education programs for all students eligibile for special education services. Education Code 56340. Therefore, if the District conducts an assessment of STUDENT, the District not only has the right to, but is obligated to, conduct an individualized education program meeting to determine if he is eligible for special education services and, if he is eligible, to develop an appropriate educational program for STUDENT. ORDER (1) If STUDENT enrolls in the San Jose Unified School District, the San Jose Unified School District is entitled to conduct a comprehensive assessment to determine his educational needs. (2) If STUDENT enrolls in the San Jose Unified School District, his parents shall make him available for an assessment to be conducted by the San Jose Unified School District. (3) If San Jose Unified School District conducts an assessment of STUDENT, it shall convene an individualize education program meeting to determine his eligibility for special education services and, if he is eligible, develop an appropriate educational program. PREVAILING PARTY Pursuant to Education Code 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: To the extent that the District has established its right to conduct an assessment and convene an IEP meeting if STUDENT enrolls, the District has prevailed. RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code 56505(i).DATED: January 29, 1997 _______________________________ Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1) GRANDMOTHER left the hearing prior to the introduction of evidence and did not testify or present any evidence on STUDENT's behalf.
