California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 15, 1999
Little Lake City School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 1254-99 · Hearing Officer Glenna Eubank deCamara
Little Lake City School District's offer of a special day class at a non-home middle school rejected; home-school placement with resource support ordered.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted. The student remained in his 1998-99 elementary placement under a stay put order while the hearing was pending.
Summary
Little Lake City School District filed for hearing. It asked the Hearing Officer to find that its 1999-2000 placement offer provided FAPE in the least restrictive environment. The student was an 11-year-old boy with Down syndrome who was entering sixth grade. Through elementary school he had been included in general education about 95% of the day, with an aide, an inclusion specialist, speech, and adapted physical education. The District offered two periods a day in a special day class (SDC) at Lakeside Middle School, which was not his home school, plus four mainstream periods. The parents wanted Lake Center Middle School, his home school, with one to two periods of resource specialist program (RSP) support.
The Hearing Officer applied the four-factor Rachel H. test. His poor progress in fifth grade happened because staff let him choose his own activities to avoid disruptions. The District never held an IEP meeting or revised his two-year-old behavior plan. His few self-help and vocational goals could be addressed at the home school. Attending school with his sister and longtime classmates had real nonacademic value. The District's claim that he was too disruptive also conflicted with its own plan to mainstream him four periods a day. The student prevailed. The District was ordered to place him at his home school with RSP support, an aide, an inclusion specialist, and a modified curriculum. It also had to complete a functional behavior reassessment and hold an IEP meeting within 50 days.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied the Rachel H. factors to compare two partly mainstreamed options. It treated the home school as part of the LRE analysis. It also held that removing a student for behavior was premature when the district had not revised an outdated behavior plan or held an IEP meeting about new behaviors.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedDistrict-filed: implement IEP
Issue 1. Does the District's offer to place Student in a middle school special day class (SDC) with mainstreaming constitute a free and appropriate education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE) for the 1999-2000 school year?
Under the Rachel H. factors, the offer of two SDC periods at a non-home campus was not the LRE; the student could be educated at his home middle school with one to two RSP periods and supports, and removal was premature because the District never revised his behavior plan.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 30 days of the decision, convene an IEP meeting to place the student at his home middle school.
- Placement ordered. Placement at the student's home middle school (Lake Center Middle School) with one to two periods per day of resource specialist program (RSP).
- Order to provide or change services. IEP team to implement supplemental aids and services: (1) a consulting inclusion specialist; (2) an individual aide for core academics in RSP; (3) a modified curriculum for general education classes supervised by the inclusion specialist or RSP teacher; (4) aide assistance as necessary in general education classes; (5) APE and speech services as determined by the IEP team.
- Order to assess. Within 50 days of the decision, conduct a functional behavior reassessment.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 50 days of the decision, convene an IEP meeting in compliance with 'Education Code Section 3001(h)' to address the student's avoidance of school assignments and any behaviors that disrupt his classes.
Key authorities
Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel H. (Holland); Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District; Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education; Murray v. Montrose County School District; Schuldt v. Mankato School District; Roland M. v. Concord School Committee; Briggs v. Board of Education; 20 U.S.C. §1412(a)(5); 34 CFR §300.552(d); 5 CCR §3001(f), (h); 5 CCR §3042(b)
People named in the decision
- Darin Barber, attorney for District, Whittier Area Cooperative Special Education Program
- John Hess, executive director, Whittier Area Cooperative Special Education Program
- Edna Morales, principal, Jersey Elementary School
- Jackie (Jacquelyn) Leigh, school psychologist; assessor and author of behavior intervention plan; District witness, Whittier Area Cooperative Special Education Program
- Robin Perencevic, itinerant teacher of the severely handicapped / inclusion specialist; District witness, Little Lake City School District / WACSEP
- Blair Roger, independent inclusion specialist; expert witness for Student (also referred to in the decision as Blair Robin and Ms. Rogers), Independent consultant
- Mr. Pope, educational advocate for Student (non-attorney)
- East Los Angeles Regional Center, regional center; early intervention services and earlier behavioral assessment
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Glenna Eubank deCamara, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Whittier, California, on August 23 and 24, 1999.
Petitioner Little Lake City School District (hereinafter Petitioner or District) was represented by attorney Darin Barber, counsel for the Whittier Area Cooperative Special Education Program (hereinafter WACSEP ). Also present on the Petitioner's behalf were John Hess, executive director of WACSEP, and Edna Morales, principal of Jersey Elementary School (hereinafter Jersey).
Respondent Mr. Parent (hereinafter Respondent or STUDENT) was represented by educational advocate Mr.Pope. Also present on Respondent's behalf were his parents, Mr. and Mrs. Parent.
The Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify: Jackie Leigh, school psychologist, and Robin Perencevic, itinerant teacher of the severely handicapped (SH).
The Respondent called the following witness to testify: Blair Roger, inclusion specialist; Mr. Parent, Respondent's father; and Mrs. Parent, Respondent's mother.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of written closing arguments. The Hearing Officer received the written closing arguments, the record was closed, and the issue was submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
At the commencement of the hearing, the Petitioner objected to the admission of all of the Respondent's evidence. The District correctly maintained that the evidence had not been submitted in a timely manner pursuant to the statutory provision requiring the exchange of evidence five business days before the hearing. A discussion followed, during which the District acknowledged that granting its motion would merely result in a postponement of the hearing until a future date that complied with the five-business-day rule. The District there upon withdrew its objection to the admission of the Respondent's evidence and, instead, asked that the late submission of evidence be noted on the record. The Hearing Officer granted this request.
The Respondent requested that he be allowed to submit the curriculum vita (CV) of his expert, Ms. Blair Robin, into evidence during the course of the hearing. The Petitioner stipulated to the admission of this document in exchange for the Respondent's agreement that the CVs of the District witnesses, Ms. Leigh and Ms. Perencevic, would also be admitted into evidence. Accordingly, the CV of Ms. Robin was marked as Respondent's Exhibit 25 and the CV of Ms. Perencevic and Ms. Leigh were marked as Petitioner's Exhibits "H" and "I" respectively. It was further agreed that the record would be left open for the submission of the CVs of the two District witnesses as they were unavailable at the time of hearing. The District's attorney provided these CVs to both the Hearing Officer and the Respondent's advocate after the conclusion of the hearing.
ISSUE
l. Does the District's offer to place Student in a middle school special day class (SDC) with mainstreaming constitute a free and appropriate education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE) for the 1999-2000 school year? (Footnote 1)
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The District filed for this due process hearing seeking a determination that its offer to place Student in a middle school SDC two periods per day, with the remainder of his classes in a mainstreamed environment, constitutes the offer of a free and appropriate placement for Student. The District contends that when Student transitions to a middle school, his needs cannot be met through the full inclusion educational model he was provided in elementary school. The Petitioner maintains that Student ‘s behaviors interfere with the education of the other students and that he requires greater special education support to meet his Independent Educational Program (IEP) goals than can be provided in general education classes with supplemental aids and services. The District's middle school SDC program is located at Lakeside Middle School (Lakeside), a District campus that is not Student ‘s home middle school. The District proposes that Student attend Lakeside with two periods per day in an SDC class and four in general education classes.
In his Statement of Issues, the Respondent defined his issue for hearing as "Parents want Student to attend his home school, Lake Center, which is a middle school." However, at the hearing the Respondent's parents also contended that Student ‘s home school was the LRE and expressed their desire that Student continue in a "full inclusion" program as he had throughout elementary school. The Respondent's expert was his only witness to provide testimony of his specific educational needs in middle school. Her testimony supported an RSP program with mainstreaming rather than full inclusion
All participants used the term "full inclusion". However, the evidence established that the District is proposing SD classes with mainstreaming on a non-home-school campus, and the Respondent proposes resource classes with mainstreaming at his neighborhood school. (Footnote 2) The Hearing Officer will therefore not consider a full inclusion program, but, instead, will address the appropriateness of the District's offer of two SDC classes with mainstreaming at a non-home-school campus, versus the appropriateness of the Respondent's request for one to two periods of RSP with mainstreaming on his home school campus.
BACKGROUND FACTS
Student is an eleven-year-old boy with a diagnosis of Downs Syndrome. Student should have entered middle school for sixth grade when the 1999-2000 school year began. However, he currently remains in his 1998-99 school year placement on an elementary school campus pursuant to a Stay Put Order while this hearing is pending to determine which middle school placement is appropriate for Student.
Student initially received early intervention services through the East Los Angeles Regional Center until he reached the age of three. Thereafter, he attended preschool during the 1991-92 school year in an SDC at Aeolian School. Student was integrated into a Head Start preschool for the 1992-93 school year where he received direct and consultative special education services. In kindergarten (1993-94 school year), Student was enrolled in the Los Nietos School District (hereinafter Los Nietos) in a regular education class with support from the severely handicapped (SH) special education staff on his school site and a resource aide. He was also provided with adaptive physical education (APE) and speech services.
During the first grade, Student had duel enrollment in both a severely handicapped (SH) SDC and a general education first grade class within Los Nietos. However, he was mainstreamed with his regular first grade class 95% of his school day. He continued to receive speech and APE services. It was reported at his annual IEP meeting that Student worked best in structured situations and when included with his peers in classroom activities. During the first grade, Student ‘s behaviors of biting and aggression toward his peers, throwing himself on the floor while crying and yelling during tantrums, and noncompliance resulted in a behavioral assessment conducted by the Regional Center. It was noted that at home and school his behaviors occurred with the following frequency: biting/aggression, one to two times per week at school; tantrums, two to three times per day at school and two to three times per week at home; and, noncompliance with directions, five to ten times per day at home and school. The Regional Center's assessor created a home behavior intervention plan (BIP).
In second grade, Student remained in the Los Nietos School District and continued his duel enrollment, with mainstreaming in his second grade class 95% of the school day. According to his annual IEP for that school year, Student ‘s full inclusion program was very successful. Appropriate modifications were in place to ensure his participation in the general curriculum, and he was demonstrating better classroom behaviors. Near the end of this school year (1995-96), Student and his family moved into the Little Lake City School District. It was agreed that despite the family's move into a new school district, Student would finish second grade with his class and then begin third grade in his new school district.
The Respondent continued the duel enrollment that had been instituted by Student ‘s prior school district, and he attended his regular third grade class for 95% of the school day. He was also provided with an aide, speech and language therapy ninety minutes per week, and APE two times per week for thirty minutes per session. During this school year, the District developed concerns about Student ‘s classroom behaviors of opposing the staff, kicking, hitting, and spitting on his peers. At an IEP meeting held on February 25, 1997, the District recommended that Student ‘s placement be changed to an SDC, and it initiated a Hughes Bill functional analysis to create a positive BIP.
The report generated for the BIP by Jackie Leigh, a District school psychologist, contained a review of Student's records that documented the following behavioral history: (1) at the age of three, he showed aggression toward his younger sister, biting other children when upset, and crying while throwing himself to the floor, (2) by the age of five, Student showed improvement and was vocalizing when frustrated rather than biting, (3) when he was six years old, Student was displaying oppositional behaviors, an inability to control his anger or adjust to changes, running away, throwing himself to the ground, biting, spitting, and acting aggressive toward his peers. (4) at the age of seven, behavioral IEP goals were improving Student ‘s behavior; however, he continued to be easily distracted by others, was often noncompliant to verbal directions, and had difficulties that could result in biting when transitioning from outdoor to classroom activities, (5) by the age of eight, Student was showing marked improvement with his social/behavioral issues although he continued to have episodes of oppositional and defiant behavior which would escalate if a power struggle ensued between him and an adult in a position of authority, (6) by the time Student was nine years old and in the third grade, his oppositional behaviors, running out of the classroom, refusing to do requested schoolwork, hitting, kicking, spitting and verbal inappropriateness were reported to have escalated.
The BIP dated April 11, 1997, identified the above-described inappropriate behaviors and their antecedents. Behavioral interventions were implemented through the BIP that included replacement behaviors, aide support, instruction and role playing to develop social skills, academic modifications, relaxation techniques, teaching alternate methods of responding to stress, and negotiation training. The BIP also addressed methods to reinforce desired behaviors, appropriate staff reaction during and following the targeted behaviors, the supervision necessary to implement the BIP, measurements of success, the environments where the BIP would be used, the criteria for discontinuing or reconvening an IEP meeting to revise the BIP, frequency of review, and the behaviors that would necessitate a nonviolent physical intervention by the staff. This BIP of April 1997 remained in effect for the remainder of Student ‘s third, fourth and fifth grade years without modification.
Three months into his fourth grade year, another IEP meeting was held. Student ‘s behavior had improved significantly according to his teacher and the behavior data collected. For the majority of the time he was participating in the regular fourth grade curriculum with modifications, and his attention span had increased. The District revoked its recommendation to remove Student to an SDC. The IEP team agreed that the BIP of April 11, 1997, would remain in effect and that he would continue to be educated with his general education peers. By April 1998 of his fourth grade, Student had accomplished the majority of the annual IEP goals written for him the prior year. He had met six of his seven IEP behavior goals and the seventh had been partially met. He did not meet his sight-word reading goal. He did accomplish his goal to follow the rules of a game and take turns with his peers with one-on-one support and verbal prompts. He could not work on his goal to do class work with a peer unless he had one-to-one support from the staff. Student met his APE goal as well as two of his three math goals. Although he would become physical when he felt threatened and he displayed inappropriate behaviors in unsupervised or unstructured situations, his overall behavior was reported to be greatly improved. He displayed good manners in class and in assemblies, his language had increased, and he was becoming more a part of his class. The IEP team recommended that he remain primarily in a fifth grade regular education class the following school year with the continued support of an itinerant inclusion specialist, instructional assistant, APE, and speech services.
At an annual IEP meeting held on March 15, 1999, it was reported that Student had improved his "in-seat" behavior, could use a calculator when provided the numbers to enter, could copy uppercase letters, and was independent with the computer when utilizing familiar software. He continued to require goals to improve his written language, classroom behavior, relationships with adults and peers, phonology, and articulation. Of the yearly IEP goals that had been written for Student in his prior IEP of April 1998, he had not met any of his six reading goals and had accomplished only one of his eight math goals. No annual social or behavioral goals had been written for Student in his IEP from the prior year. At the March 15, 1999 IEP meeting, the inclusion specialist presented a report in which she concluded that Student would benefit from the daily support of a special education teacher when he transitioned to middle school for the sixth grade. She further recommended that a functional skill curriculum be added to his academic curriculum to increase his independence.
Concluding that Student ‘s behavioral, academic, and functional skill needs could not be met at his home middle school, the District offered to place Student at Lakeside, where he could attend an SDC for two periods per day. The SDC staff would also be available to assist Student throughout his day. For the remainder of his classes, he would be mainstreamed with the regular education Student s. Student ‘s parents have rejected this offer, preferring that he attend Lake Center Middle School (hereinafter Lake Center), his home middle school.
ISSUE ONE
Does the District's offer to place Student in a middle school special day class constitute a free and appropriate education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE) for the 1999-2000 school year?
DISCUSSION
"Special education" is defined as "specially designed instruction at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability . . . " 20 U.S.C. §1401(25). Under both federal and state law, Student s with disabilities have the right to a free and appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. §1401(8), "free and appropriate public education" means special education and related services that meet the standards of the State educational agency and conform to the Student 's individual education program.
It is preferred that handicapped Student s be provided with an appropriate education within the regular education setting. United States Code §1412(a)(5) provides:
To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular educational environment occur only when the nature or severity of the disability of the child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplemental aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.
The Court in the case of Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education, 874 F.2d 1036 (1989), held that the law demonstrates "a strong preference for ‘mainstreaming' which rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption." The mainstreaming presumption does not, however, also mandate placement of the disabled child in his or her home/neighborhood school. Geographical proximity is but one factor to consider when making an appropriate placement. See Murray v. Montrose County School District, 51 F.3d 921 (10th Cir. 1995); Schuldt v. Mankato School District, 937 F.2d 1357 (8th Cir, 1991); Hudson v. Bloomfield Hills Public Schools, 23 IDELR 613 (Mich. Cir. Ct. 1995)
The courts have provided guidance for determining whether a proposed offer of placement is appropriate where the issue is the extent of a disabled child's participation with his nondisabled peers.
In considering whether the District has proposed a placement. . . that complies with the Act, the court must determine what is meant by the requirement that handicapped children be mainstreamed "to the maximum extent appropriate." Because the Act does not define this requirement, cases interpreting the Act guide the court's analysis. The federal appellate courts have recognized the following factors as relevant to determining if a placement is appropriate: (1) the educational benefits available to the child in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared to the educational benefits of a special education classroom; (2) the nonacademic benefits to the handicapped child of interaction with non-handicapped children; (3) the effect of the presence of the handicapped child on the teacher and other children in the regular classroom; and (4) the costs of supplemental aids and services necessary to mainstream the handicapped child in a regular classroom setting. Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel Holland, 786 F. Supp.879 (1992); Adopted by the Ninth Circuit in Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel Holland, 14 F.3d 1398 (1994).
Both the Petitioner and the Respondent have proposed that Student be mainstreamed for the majority of his classes. The dispute is whether a portion of his school day should be spent in an SDC located on a campus that is not his home school, or whether he should attend RSP classes on his neighborhood campus. Both parties propose no more than two special education classes, with the remaining four in general education. Thus, the primary issue becomes which proposal places Student in the least restrictive environment (LRE) where he can, to the maximum extent possible, be educated in the regular education environment with his nondisabled peers. USC §1412(a)(5). The Ninth Circuit has applied the four Holland factors when evaluating whether a proposed placement complies with the requirement that a disabled child be educated in the LRE. "We've recently adopted a four-part test to determine whether a disabled Student 's placement represents the least restrictive environment. See Sacramento City Unified Sch. Dist.v. Rachel H." Clyde K. v. Payslip School Districts, 35 F.3d 1398 (9th Cir. 1994). As the Ninth Circuit Court has applied the Holland factors when analyzing cases to determine whether a district's proposal constitutes an appropriate education in the LRE, the Hearing Officer will apply them to this case. (Footnote 3)
A. The academic benefits of placement in a mainstream setting.
The District maintains that Student has unique needs in all academic areas, as well as the need to enhance his social, behavioral and functional skills. It claims that these educational needs cannot be adequately met at his home school and that Student requires the more intensive services of a middle school SDC staff. Through the testimony of its witnesses, the District established that it is offering to place Student in an SDC two periods a day to receive direct instruction on his IEP goals and his core curriculum. The remaining periods Student would be mainstreamed with his general education peers. The four inclusion periods would be physical education (P.E.), a nonacademic elective, and social studies and language arts with the same regular education teacher. Student would also attend lunch with his general education peers. In support of its position that this offer constituted an appropriate placement, the District offered the testimony of Jacquelyn Leigh, the school psychologist who tested Student in June 1997 and wrote his BIP. Ms. Leigh has a bachelor of arts degree (B.A.) in psychology and a master of arts (M.A.) in psychology. She is credentialed as a counselor and as a school psychologist. She has been employed for the past sixteen years by the WACSEP as a school psychologist. Her responsibilities include conducting assessments, drafting BIPs, attending IEP meetings, and consulting with the special education staff.
Ms Leigh testified that according to the Kaufman Brief Intelligence Test (KBIT), Student ‘s composite Intelligence Quota (IQ) was 51 (+ or - 7). On the Arthur Adaptation of the Leiter International Performance Scale (LEITER), Student ‘s cognitive development was four years, two months when his chronological age was nine years, two months. These tests placed him within the mentally retarded range. Ms. Leigh further testified that at the time she performed these tests in l997, while Student was in the third grade, she concluded that he was "out of place in his class placement and not benefitting from the third grade curriculum." According to the testimony of Ms. Leigh, Student continued to experience some difficulties with the modified regular education curriculum throughout the third, fourth, and fifth grades. However, his behaviors and resulting classroom performance generally improved with the implementation of the BIP. By the fifth grade, Student was not meeting his IEP goals. Ms. Leigh stated that this was partially because when Student was required to perform his work, he would act out and disrupt his class. Thus, his teacher would allow him to choose his own activities. In addition, Student is primarily a visual learner. As children enter the higher grades, the majority of their education is provided auditorily. Thus, the academic gap between Student and his general education peers grew wider and he received less and less benefit from a full inclusion program. As a result, Ms. Leigh testified that to receive educational benefit from his school program, Student now requires instruction from a staff that has the training, experience and judgement to work with severely handicapped Student s. In addition to the appropriate staff, the SDC program located at Lakeside also has all of the special education materials needed to modify his mainstream curriculum. Moreover, the SDC program has been located on the Lakeside campus for several years. The general education teachers are therefore familiar not only with the special education support available on campus, but also with the needs of Student s like Student when they are mainstreamed into their regular education classes. Ms. Leigh believes it is especially important for Student to be assisted by knowledgeable SDC personnel because his test results show that he has greater potential then he has demonstrated through past achievements.
In response to questions from Student ‘s advocate, Ms. Leigh testified that, in addition to his core curriculum, Student also requires instruction in vocational, social and self-help skills. She said that Student s such as Student are more successful in acquiring these types of skills when they are specifically taught; they do not usually generalize or learn job, social and self-help skills from being around the general population. These skills are addressed in an SDC, and are not provided in general education middle school classes. On cross-examination, Ms. Leigh acknowledged that it would be possible to utilize an itinerant SDC teacher or a one-on-one instructional aide to work with Student on vocational, self-help and social skills by pulling him from his class. However, she elaborated that Student needs to learn to generalize the skills he is taught by using them in his environment. Part of the SDC program at Lakeside is to have a staff trained and experienced with severely handicapped Student s take them into the community to work on their job and social skills. These opportunities would not be available to him at his home school. Ms. Leigh also summarized additional areas of instruction that would not be readily available at Student ‘s home school. She stated that in the SDC program at Lakeside, Student could be taught to: (1) appropriately respond to people in authority and take directions, (2) remain on task, (3) organize his tasks, (4) be responsible for himself, (5) appropriately respond to his peers, (6) better deal with his anger and loss of control, (6) increase his independent living skills, (7) develop vocational skills, and (8) follow through on required lessons without his teacher giving into his behaviors to prevent disruption of the entire class. He would also benefit from a small class size and a staff trained to work with severely handicapped Student s.
Robin Perencevic is the severely handicapped itinerant teacher who has worked with Student throughout elementary school. Ms. Perencevic has a B.A. in speech communication and an M.S. in special education. She has California teaching credentials as an elementary school, severely handicapped and learning handicapped teacher. Since 1976, she has held positions as a teacher, program specialist, adjunct professor, and an inclusion specialist. Ms. Perencevic testified that although they typically see a 70% to 100% success rate on IEP goals from fully included Student s, Student essentially failed to meet any of his IEP goals during his fifth grade school year. His reading is at a kindergarten level. He cannot decode words, and he does not attach meaning to letter symbols. With practice, he can rote memorize some simple words. He cannot identify the numbers one through ten, although he can match written numbers to the same numbers on a calculator. He cannot add numbers together. In Mrs. Perencevic's opinion, Student is not working to his potential in a regular education class and he would have achieved a higher skill level had he been receiving instruction in an SDC.
Blair Roger testified on behalf of the Respondent as an independent consultant and full inclusion expert. Ms. Roger has a B.A. in cultural anthropology. She has a California multi-subject teaching credential and she is also credentialed to teach severely handicapped and learning handicapped Student s. Ms. Rogers was a special education teacher for several years. Since the mid-1980s, she has primarily worked as a full inclusion specialist. Ms. Roger provided testimony in the district court on behalf of the Student in the case of Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel Holland (supra). Based upon her review of Student ‘s records, interviews with his parents and her observation of Student, Ms. Roger testified that he should not be removed from his neighborhood and placed in a more restrictive SDC on a non-home-school campus before additional attempts are made to address his behaviors and educational needs through an RSP on his neighborhood campus. It is her opinion that Student ‘s academic needs can be met on his home school campus in an RSP/regular education program with an aide assigned to his general education classes. Ms. Roger testified that Student would also require an individual aide to assist him one to two periods per day in an RSP class. His time in the RSP class would be used to review his general education curriculum, and to provide math and a reading program. In her view, the RSP teacher would be Student ‘s special education teacher of record, and a consulting inclusion specialist would support her. The RSP teacher and the inclusion specialist would work with Student ‘s other teachers to modify his curriculum to meet his individual needs. Ms. Roger testified that although the general education core curriculum should be addressed when individualizing Student ‘s academics, the emphasis should be on Student ‘s needs and how they can be met in each of his classes. Speech and APE services are available at Student ‘s neighborhood middle school and both should continue to be part of his program as presently proposed in his IEP.
Both District witnesses testified that they believed that the best placement for Student in middle school was an SDC with a staff trained to work with severely handicapped children on functional, academic and life skills. They maintained that Student ‘s test scores indicate that he is capable of learning more and that he would be far more likely to reach his potential in an SDC. The Courts, however, have not found that a program that provides academic superiority trumps the value of integration with nondisabled peers. This issue was addressed by the district court in the case of Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel Holland (supra). The court held "the Acts requirement of integration, based on recognition of the nonacademic value of such integration, is not overcome by a showing that a special education placement may be academically superior to placement in a regular classroom." See also Roland v. Concord School Comm., 910 F.2d 983 (1990).
The relevant issue, therefore, is not whether Student can receive a better education in an SDC program, but whether he can receive an appropriate education in the LRE at his home school campus with the use of supplemental aids and services and RSP assistance. U.S.C.§1412(a)(5)(A). With the exception of a period of time in the third grade before a BIP was created, Student has been successfully integrated into a general education class since first grade. During those years, he consistently made progress on his IEP goals and improved his classroom behavior. At an IEP meeting held on September 11, 1998 (beginning of fifth grade), the notes state that "Student ‘s behavior improved dramatically in his fourth grade year due to many opportunities for positive interaction and attention from his classroom teacher and instructional aide and peers. Student benefits from valued responsibility in class and in inclusion in all aspects of classroom activity even if participation is partial or adapted." Thus, the District has acknowledged that when provided with appropriate support services and modifications, Student receives educational benefit from association with his nondisabled peers. Only in the fifth grade did he fail to accomplish his goals. However, according to the testimony of the District's own witnesses, no attempts were made to ensure that Student focused on his own schoolwork. When he resisted doing the work requested of him, he was allowed to do anything he chose so that he would not act out and disrupt his classmates. An IEP meeting was not convened to discuss alternate methods of responding to the behaviors that were interfering with Student ‘s education, nor was his BIP modified. It was inevitable that he would not succeed in mastering his IEP goals when he did not work on them. Since steps were not taken to respond to Student ‘s refusal to complete his assigned work and the resulting behaviors that disrupted his class, it is premature to remove him from his neighborhood and the Student s with whom he has attended class throughout his school career and to place him in an SDC program outside his neighborhood.
The District next argues that Student requires vocational and self-help skill instruction that can only be provided in an SDC. However, the only goal included in the proposed IEP dated March 15, 1999, relevant to self-help skills is a goal to follow locker room procedures in PE. The District proposes PE as a mainstream class for Student. The sole vocational goal is to improve Student ‘s functional use of money in a meaningful setting. This is a skill that Student could work on during a math class, or by purchasing food with his aide's assistance at lunchtime. This skill could also be reinforced during his time in an RSP class. The remainder of Student ‘s IEP goals are to improve his articulation, classroom behavior, participation in class activities, independence in completing his assignments, keyboarding, and written language. These all appear to be goals that can be addressed in a regular education setting with DIS speech services and RSP/inclusion assistance. Therefore, the arguments by the Petitioner are not persuasive reasons to place Student in an SDC program.
Based upon the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that Ms. Roger provided the most thoughtful analysis of Student ‘s educational and social needs at this time. To remove Student from his home school so that he may attend two periods in an SDC at a non-neighborhood school, when he has no IEP goals that mandate an SDC placement, is unwarranted. Student can receive educational benefit from an educational program on his home school campus with appropriate supplemental aids and services for the majority of his classes. He will, however, require one to two periods per day of RSP, with an individual aide, to reinforce his academics. Student ‘s services should include curriculum modifications, the continued availability of an instructional aide assigned to his regular education classes, an inclusion specialist, an RSP teacher, and DIS speech and APE services.
B. The nonacademic benefits to Student of a mainstream placement at his neighborhood middle school.
Ms. Leigh testified that although Student would know student s at his home middle school, it is difficult for him to sustain peer relationships without adult intervention due to his decreased cognitive and social skills. In addition, leaving known students has never been a problem for Student. She also stated that severely handicapped student s do not generally establish friendships without intervention. Moreover, based upon her observations, Student did not imitate the behaviors of the other student s in his class and, therefore, the benefit of appropriate role models was minimal. She has, however, observed him imitate some play behaviors on the playground.
Ms. Perencevic testified that Student is not upset that his work is different from that of his peers and he is proud to show his work to the class. She also said that Student is embarrassed by his behavior after he acts out in class, but that he is unable to use the knowledge that he will be embarrassed to control his behavior before it occurs. She finds that Student is interested in things in his class, but that he does not participate. Ms. Perencevic also expressed concern that allowing Student to do whatever he chooses to prevent misbehavior which disrupts the class is teaching that there are no requirements or parameters for him.
Ms. Roger emphasized that the social component of Student ‘s educational program is very important. She stated that it would be best for him to attend school with his sister and the other children who have known him throughout elementary school. She also testified that when determining the appropriate educational program for a disabled child, it is very important to incorporate his or her family's desire to have the child included in his or her neighborhood community. Ms. Roger concluded that these social factors and the program that could be developed for Student at his home school outweigh any benefit of placing him in an SDC on another school campus.
Mr. Parent testified that his educational goals for his son are for him to learn as much as he can, and, if possible, to learn to read and write. His primary goal, however, is for Student to "learn to respect who he is, even though he has a disability." He wants Student to attend the neighborhood middle school his sister will enter next year and to which the majority of his elementary school classmates have transferred. Mrs. Parent testified that she hopes that in the future her son can "be the best he can be, have a job he enjoys, be well liked, and make and keep friendships." She also wants Student to attend the same school as his sister as they are very close. Mrs. Parent acknowledged that the District had offered to provide an interdistrict transfer to allow Student ‘s sister to attend Lakeside with her brother. However, she felt this would be unfair to her daughter because it would require her daughter to leave her own friends. She stated that full inclusion has not always been easy, but it has provided many important memories for her family. Mrs. Parent testified that in addition to the District's educational goals, as his parents, she and her husband also have goals for Student. They want him to be accepted for who he is rather than how he looks, and they believe that he can best accomplish this through his attendance at his home school.
The Hearing Officer concurs with Ms. Rogers and Mr. and Mrs. Parent regarding the social importance of allowing Student to remain with his sister and the children with whom he has attended school for years. The Hearing Officer further does not find the fact that Student requires adult assistance to interact with his peers justification for moving him to an SDC program on another campus. Strategies can be developed to provide Student with opportunities to participate with his classmates, even if it such things as passing out papers to his classmates. Moreover, Ms. Leigh testified that Student interacted with other student s on the playground and imitated them when playing kickball. Ms. Perencevic testified that Student enjoys sharing his work with his classmates and wants to imitate what they are doing in class. She further testified that he is making an increased effort to communicate verbally and the more "you are around him," the easier it becomes to understand his speech. This indicates that Student is aware of his peers and wants to model them. It is also important that Student attend his home middle school with children who essentially have grown up with him, and his sister with whom he has a close relationship. Because Student is familiar to them, it is reasonable to assume that they will be more accepting of him. They also have had an opportunity to gain an understanding of his communication skills. All of these reasons are important nonacademic benefits to Student as he learns to live in his community.
C. Student ‘s effect upon the teachers and children in the regular education class
The District claims that a primary reason Student requires placement in an SDC is that his behaviors have a disruptive effect upon the regular education class. Ms. Leigh testified that when she conducted the behavioral assessment in 1997, Student exhibited inappropriate behaviors that interfered with his class, which included crawling under the tables of his peers, biting, refusing to return to class after recess, and not following the instructions of his teacher. As a result, Ms. Leigh stated that she developed a BIP on April 11, 1997, to address his behaviors. With the implementation of the BIP, Student ‘s behaviors improved in elementary school. He continued to require an instructional aide assigned to his class who was always available for Student . However, during the fifth grade (1998-99 school year), Student ‘s teacher could not get him to perform his work without resulting behaviors that disrupted the entire class. As a consequence, the teacher "backed off" making him complete his work so that the remainder of her Student s would not be adversely affected. In Ms. Leigh's opinion, Student requires an SDC where a trained staff is not "held hostage" to Student ‘s behaviors and they can implement "well-planned, well-supervised inclusion." Ms. Leigh testified that children in general do not move forward when they are allowed to do whatever they want and that they need adult assistance to set limits. Student , in particular, needs a skilled staff and an appropriate environment to accomplish this. Because Student uses his behaviors to avoid doing his assigned work, they are interfering with his learning. They also contribute to the fact that he is not performing to his potential or meeting his IEP goals.
Ms. Perencevic testified that Student disrupts his class with behaviors such as walking up and down the rows of desks and touching the other Student s' papers, making noises, and crawling under the desks of the other Student s. He also is noncompliant, becomes physical, and has attempted to leave the campus. According to Ms. Perencevic, Student ‘s general education class continues only because they allow Student to chose his activities to avoid disruption of the entire class. When questioned regarding the reasons Student has not achieved his IEP goals, Ms. Perencevic testified that Student "imitated school." She said that this meant he insists on doing the exact work that his peers are performing and he refuses to work on his modified curriculum. Because attempting to make him do his assigned work results in behaviors that disrupt the entire class, his teacher instead allows him to choose his own work. As a result, Student is not learning effectively in general education classes. Ms. Perencevic concluded that they had exhausted all options for addressing Student ‘s behaviors in a regular education setting, other than excluding him to the back of the classroom.
Ms Roger stated that the District had done a "tremendous job" in developing a positive BIP for Student . She also acknowledged that a disabled child's behavior could become too disruptive to allow him to be included in a regular education class. However, she did not find Student to be at that point. Ms. Roger testified that before he is removed from the less restrictive neighborhood school to the more restrictive alternate campus with an SDC, the District should first try to modify the existing BIP with new interventions and provide the necessary support services. Ms. Roger testified that the IEP team should focus on methods to prevent Student ‘s inappropriate behaviors. The team should also attempt to determine why Student does not want to do his own work and institute strategies to help him accomplish his goals.
The Hearing Officer agrees that the District is proposing to remove Student to an SDC without an adequate effort to address his behaviors, and finds that Ms. Roger's testimony is most persuasive on this issue. To remove Student from the general education setting at his home school after years of improving behaviors, and without developing strategies to attempt to respond to the disruptive behaviors that he developed last year, would violate the rationale of utilizing BIPs to increase social interaction with the nondisabled population. California Code of Regulations, Title 5, §3001(f) states:
"Behavioral interventions" are designed to provide the individual with greater access to a variety of community settings, social contacts and public events; and ensure the individuals right to placement in the least restrictive environment as outlined in the individuals IEP.
The testimony from the District's witnesses established that Student ‘s fifth-grade teachers did not attempt to change his behaviors; instead, they gave in to them. The IEP in effect for the majority of the fifth grade (IEP of April 16, 1998) did not contain any behavioral goals, yet an IEP meeting was not convened to address the behaviors which so disrupted the class. Approximately three months before the end of his fifth grade, at his annual IEP meeting in March 1999, behavioral goals were included to improve Student ‘s ability to follow directions from a nonfamiliar adult, accept assistance from a classroom adult, participate in class activities with his peers, and to increase his ability to independently complete class assignments. At that time, Student ‘s BIP was approximately two years old. It was not modified, nor were alternate strategies implemented to address the behaviors that so disrupted his class. Despite the District's assertion that requiring Student to perform his school work resulted in behaviors that negatively impacted upon the remainder of the class, the IEP of March 5, 1999, stated that Student "has a Hughes Bill Positive Behavior Intervention Plan which is still appropriate and an attachment to his IEP."
It is difficult to understand how Student ‘s BIP could have remained appropriate when his behavior had deteriorated to the point that his teachers allowed him to choose his own activities to avoid his acting in ways that interfered with the entire class. Moreover, retaining the same BIP without convening an IEP meeting and adjusting the BIP in light of serious concerns about new behaviors that intrude upon others and prevent work on IEP objectives is contrary to California Education Code §3001(h). This Code Section requires that a BIP be "developed when the individual exhibits a serious behavior problem that significantly interferes with the implementation of the goals and objectives of the individual's IEP." By the teachers' assenting to Student ‘s inappropriate behaviors, he learned that certain behaviors were an effective method of avoiding activities he did not want to perform. Thus, he was not required to work on his IEP goals. This is the type of behavior that interfered with the implementation of his IEP as defined in §3001(h) and required modifications to his existing BIP. Because this was not done, it is untimely to remove Student from his home school without first attempting to identify and change his problem behaviors. In addition, the District's contention that Student is now too disruptive to remain in general education classes relies upon faulty logic. The District purposes placing Student in a mainstream environment four of his six periods per day. If he were too disruptive to attend regular education classes, he would be a disruption for all classes, not merely two out of six.
D. The costs of mainstreaming Student
This issue was not raised by either party, and the Hearing Officer will therefore not consider it as a relevant factor.
CONCLUSION
When comparing the District's proposal for two SD classes at Student ‘s non-home-school, to the parent's preference for two RSP classes on his neighborhood campus, the Hearing Officer is persuaded by the testimony of Ms. Roger and agrees that the LRE is the home campus. Both placements offer two special education classes with the remaining classes in general education. However, placement at Lake Center also provides Student with the nonacademic benefits of attending his home school with his sister and the Student s with whom he went to elementary school. This complies with California's preference for placing a disabled child in his or her home school unless removal is justified by the IEP team. Title 5 CCR §3042(b). Federal law also favors educating a disabled child in the school that he would attend if he were not disabled. 34 CFR §300.552(d).
With the implementation of proper supplemental aids and services, Student can succeed, and he should be allowed an opportunity to enter his home middle school. Student spent his elementary school years in a program in which he was 95% included with his nondisabled peers. This program provided him with both academic and nonacademic benefit. With the exception of the fifth grade, his classroom behaviors improved each year and he made progress on his IEP goals. However, during the majority of the fifth grade, Student did not have behavioral goals and his teachers allowed him to avoid his work by acting out. His BIP was not modified to address these behaviors. Without first providing him with an opportunity to be mainstreamed on his home school campus, with appropriate services and a BIP that responds to Student ‘s behaviors, it is premature to remove him from his neighborhood school and into an SDC on another campus.
ORDER
1. Within thirty days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting and place Student at his home middle school with one to two periods of RSP. The IEP team shall also implement appropriate supplemental aids and services which include the following: (1) a consulting inclusion specialist; (2) an individual aide for his core academics in RSP; (3) a modified curriculum for his general education classes with supervision from the inclusion specialist or the RSP teacher; (4) aide assistance as necessary to his general education classes; and (5) APE and speech services as determined by the IEP team.
2. Within fifty days of the date of this decision, the District shall conduct a functional behavior reassessment and convene an IEP meeting, in compliance with Education Code Section 3001(h), to respond to Student ‘s attempts to avoid his school assignments and any behaviors he displays that disrupt his classes.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code §56507(d), this decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement:
The Respondent prevailed on the only issue heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code §56505(i).
Dated:_________________________ _________________________________________ GLENNA EUBANK deCAMARA, Hearing Officer, Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law
FOOTNOTES
1. In his issue statement, the Respondent also raised the issue of additional speech services for a stuttering problem. This issue was not mentioned at the hearing, nor did the Respondent present any evidence concerning speech therapy. The Hearing Officer will therefore not address this issue.
2. There is frequently confusion regarding the legal definition of the terms "mainstreaming" and "full inclusion" as they relate to the education of disabled children. Briggs v. Board of Education, 882 F.2d 688 (2nd Cir. 1989) defined mainstreaming as educating a handicapped child with nonhandicapped peers. The district court in the case of Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel Holland, (supra) adopted the following definition of full inclusion: "The handicapped child is a full member of a regular education class . . . .The child need not be in the classroom 100% of the time. . . .(T)he child may be removed from that class to receive supplemental services such as physical or speech therapy when these services cannot be provided in the classroom. Under full inclusion, the child's primary placement is in the regular education class, and the child has no additional assignment to any special class for handicapped children."
3. In the Clyde K. case, the Ninth Circuit changed the wording of the first and second prongs of the Holland factors to "(1) the academic benefits of placement in a mainstream setting, with any supplemental aides and services that might be appropriate; (2) the non-academic benefits of mainstream placement, such as language and behavior models provided by non-disabled Student s," (emphasis added).
