California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 17, 1998

Student v. Windsor Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1276-97 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote

Windsor Unified must repay private tutoring and counseling costs for 1995–1997; nonpublic school reimbursement for 1997–98 denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 5 of 18 issues (2 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parents of a 12-year-old sixth grader filed for due process against Windsor Unified School District. He was eligible for special education because of learning disabilities in reading, written language and math. The parents had placed him at New Horizon, a nonpublic school, for 1997-1998. They sought repayment for that school, private tutoring, private counseling and nine independent assessments. The District asked to assess his social-emotional functioning over the parents' objection.

The Hearing Officer found the District denied a FAPE in 1995-1996. The resource specialist program met his academic needs. But his IEP had no goals or services for the low self-esteem the District's own psychologist had noted, and his growth that year was minimal. In 1996-1997 he made real academic progress, but the IEP still ignored his emotional needs, so FAPE was denied on that ground through April 1997.

The 1997-1998 offer was appropriate and in the least restrictive environment: 90 minutes of resource help four to five days a week at Windsor Middle School. The parents had also turned down counseling the District offered. The District's 1995 assessment was appropriate, so no assessment costs were repaid. Claims before 1994-1995 were not considered. The District's request to assess was denied. The District must repay tutoring by Kim Kobre (August 1995–August 1996) and therapy by Barbara Turner (April 1995–April 1997).

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO treated a learning-disabled student's documented self-esteem problems as an educational need the IEP had to address. Private counseling was repaid for the years the IEP ignored those needs. Repayment stopped once the parents rejected counseling the District offered.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1(A). Did the District commit procedural errors, from the second semester of 1993-1994 through the end of 1996-1997, that resulted in the denial of FAPE? (Claims covered child find, present levels in IEPs, failure to consider the Children's Health Council assessment, and access to records.)

    The child find claims before 1994-1995 were not considered for lack of evidence and under the three-year limitations period. The IEP present levels were adequate. The IEP team's failure to consider the CHC report caused no loss of educational opportunity, and there was no evidence that records were withheld.

  2. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1(B). Did the District provide an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1995-1996 school year?

    FAPE was denied. The RSP program met his academic needs, but there were no goals or services for his documented self-esteem and emotional deficits, and his growth that year was de minimis.

  3. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1(C). Did the District provide an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1996-1997 school year?

    The expanded RSP program met his academic needs and he made meaningful progress. However, the IEP did not address his emotional needs, so FAPE was denied on that ground from the start of the school year through April 1997.

  4. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1(D). Did the District offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1997-1998 school year?

    The offer of 90 minutes of RSP four to five days a week at Windsor Middle School, using a multisensory approach, was appropriate and in the LRE. The parents had rejected the counseling and self-esteem goals the District offered.

  5. Issue 2. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT's attending New Horizon, a certified nonpublic school, during the 1997-1998 school year?

    Reimbursement was denied because the District offered a FAPE for 1997-1998.

  6. Issue 3. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private tutoring by Kim Kobre from August 1995 to August 1996?

    FAPE was denied in 1995-1996, and Ms. Kobre's multisensory tutoring was appropriate, so reimbursement was ordered under Burlington.

  7. Issue 4. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private counseling by Barbara Turner from April 1995 to the present?

    Reimbursement was ordered from April 1995 through April 1997. It was denied after that because the parents refused the counseling the District offered and the District offered a FAPE for 1997-1998.

  8. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 5. Did the District conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT?

    The April 1995 assessment met Education Code sections 56320 and 56324. No reassessment was required before the triennial due in April 1998.

  9. Issue 6(A). Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent assessment by Children's Health Council?

    Denied because the District's assessment was appropriate and no further assessment was warranted.

  10. Issue 6(B). Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent assessment by Nancy Cushen White?

    Denied because the District's assessment was appropriate.

  11. Issue 6(C). Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent assessment by John Stewart McGovern?

    Denied because the District's assessment was appropriate.

  12. Issue 6(D). Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent assessment by Barbara A. Turner?

    Denied. The District's assessment was appropriate and no written report was provided.

  13. Issue 6(E). Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent assessment by Jennifer Vitrano?

    Denied. The District's assessment was appropriate, no written report was provided, and the assessor did not testify.

  14. Issue 6(F). Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent assessment by Kim Kobre?

    Denied. The District's assessment was appropriate and no written report was provided.

  15. Issue 6(G). Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent assessment by Isaac Gardner?

    Denied. There was no written report, no testimony, and little evidence of the assessment.

  16. Issue 6(H). Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent assessment by Jill Markham?

    Denied. There was no written report, no testimony, and little evidence of the assessment.

  17. Issue 6(I). Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent assessment by Milton Harris?

    Denied. There was no written report, no testimony, and little evidence of the assessment.

  18. Issue District 1. Is the District entitled to assess STUDENT in the areas of social and emotional functioning over the objection of his parents?

    Denied. There was no significant change in his functioning, and the District proposed the assessment only after the nonpublic school placement. The triennial was not yet due.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Within 20 calendar days of receiving proof from the parents, the District must reimburse the costs of Kim Kobre's tutoring from August 1995 through August 1996. No dollar amount stated.
  • Reimbursement. Within 20 calendar days of receiving proof from the parents, the District must reimburse the costs of Barbara Turner's therapy from April 1995 through April 1997. No dollar amount stated.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479; Alexopulos v. San Francisco Unified School District (9th Cir. 1987) 817 F.2d 551; Dreher v. Amphitheater Unified School District (9th Cir. 1994) 22 F.3d 228; M.C. ex rel. J.C. v. Central Regional School District (3d Cir. 1996) 81 F.3d 389; Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16 (3d Cir. 1988) 853 F.2d 171; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489; Landgraf v. USI Film Products (1994) 511 U.S. 244; Education Code §§ 56320, 56324, 56329(b), 56345, 56504, 56507

People named in the decision

  • Richard X. Mazzara, advocate for Student (non-attorney)
  • Cassie Bouchard, advocate for Student
  • Lawrence M. Schoenke, attorney for District, Windsor Unified School District
  • Pam Moulton, special education coordinator, Windsor Unified School District
  • Jennifer D. Vitrano, private speech-language pathologist (independent assessor)
  • John Stewart McGovern, Ph.D., private clinical psychologist; independent assessor and witness for Student
  • Barbara A. Turner, private marriage, family and child counselor; therapist and witness for Student
  • Kim Kobre, private tutor; witness for Student
  • Nancy Cushen White, Ed.D., private educational therapist; independent assessor and witness for Student
  • Children's Health Council, certified nonpublic agency; independent assessor
  • Nancy Elizabeth Sullivan, Ph.D., licensed psychologist; conducted psychological portion of CHC assessment; witness for Student, Children's Health Council
  • Vicki Humphrey, school psychologist (also spelled Humphry), Windsor Unified School District
  • Pamela Fitt, RSP teacher, 1995-1996, Windsor Unified School District
  • Terry Junemann, RSP teacher, 1996-1997, Windsor Unified School District
  • Patricia Dearth, fifth-grade general education teacher, Windsor Unified School District
  • Joe Taylor, principal, Brooks Elementary School, Windsor Unified School District
  • Sharon Yvonne Houg, RSP teacher, Windsor Middle School, Windsor Unified School District
  • David Whitehead, sixth-grade math/science teacher, Windsor Middle School, Windsor Unified School District
  • Cyndi Heidl, sixth-grade teacher, Windsor Middle School, Windsor Unified School District
  • Isaac Gardner, independent assessor (did not testify)
  • Jill Markham, independent assessor (did not testify)
  • Milton Harris, independent assessor (did not testify)
  • New Horizon, certified nonpublic school (parents' unilateral placement)

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Santa Rosa, California, on November 13 and 14, and December 8 and 9, 1997.

STUDENT was represented at the hearing by advocate Richard X. Mazzara. Advocate Cassie Bouchard was present on one day of the hearing. Also present on behalf of STUDENT were his parents. Windsor Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Lawrence M. Schoenke. Also present on behalf of the District was Pam Moulton, special education coordinator.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments on January 20, 1998, the case was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

STUDENT’s Issues (1) Did the District provide STUDENT with a free, appropriate public education (FAPE)?

(A) Did the District commit procedural errors during the period STUDENT attended school in the District, from the second semester of the 1993-1994 school year through the end of the 1996-1997 school year, that resulted in the denial of a free appropriate public education to STUDENT?

(B) Did the District provide an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1995-1996 school year?

(C) Did the District provide an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1996-1997 school year?

(D) Did the District offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1997-1998 school year?

(2) Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT’s attending New Horizon, a certified nonpublic school, during the 1997-1998 school year?

(3) Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private tutoring by Kim Kobre from August 1995 to August 1996?

(4) Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private counseling by Barbara Turner from April 1995 to the present?

(5) Did the District conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT?

(6) Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent assessments by:

(A) Children’s Health Council?

(B) Nancy Cushen White?

(C) John Stewart McGovern?

(D) Barbara A. Turner?

(E) Jennifer Vitrano?

(F) Kim Kobre?

(G) Isaac Gardner?

(H) Jill Markham?

(I) Milton Harris?(Footnote 1)

The District’s Issue (1) Is the District entitled to assess STUDENT in the areas of social and emotional functioning over the objection of his parents?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a 12-year-old student in the sixth grade. He is eligible for special education because of learning disabilities in reading, written language, and mathematics. For the 1997-1998 school year, STUDENT’s parents enrolled him in New Horizon, a certified nonpublic school (NPS), in Santa Rosa, California. STUDENT’s parents also provide him with private counseling from Barbara A. Turner, a marriage, family, and child counselor (M.F.C.C.), in private practice.

STUDENT entered kindergarten in the fall of 1991. He attended kindergarten and the first half of the first grade in a private school. In September and October of 1992, while STUDENT was attending the private school, Jennifer D. Vitrano, a private speech and language pathologist, assessed STUDENT at the request of his parents. Ms. Vitrano found that STUDENT’s expressive and receptive language skills were delayed approximately one year, which she concluded was affecting his ability to read. Ms. Vitrano also found that STUDENT exhibited poor auditory processing and discrimination skills, poor attending skills, a short attention span, and memory problems, making it difficult for him to “understand, process, integrate and utilize language effectively.” (District’s Exhibit 25) Ms. Vitrano recommended that STUDENT receive speech and language therapy for 40-minute sessions, three times per week. Thereafter, Ms. Vitrano provided STUDENT with private speech and language services.(Footnote 2) In 1993, STUDENT’s parents enrolled him in the District for the second half of the first grade. In a second report completed in June 1994, Ms. Vitrano recommended that STUDENT’s parents seek an evaluation from the District to determine eligibility for speech and language therapy and resource services to address continued deficits in speech, language, reading, and spelling. (District’s Exhibit 24) The parents did not request an assessment from the District at that time.

In December 1994, when STUDENT was in the third grade, John Stewart McGovern, Ph.D., a licensed clinical psychologist in private practice, assessed STUDENT at the request of his parents because of their concerns regarding STUDENT’s lack of academic achievement. Dr. McGovern found that STUDENT’s cognitive skills fell in the average or above-average range and that his academic achievement was hindered by learning disabilities and the lack of self-esteem in academic arenas.(Footnote 3) Dr. McGovern’s recommendations included providing STUDENT with support services from a specialist in remedial education of students with learning disabilities; placing STUDENT in a class with a small student-to-teacher ratio and a structured environment; and providing him with supportive counseling to improve his self-esteem in academic areas. Dr. McGovern also recommended that STUDENT be taught to use “convergent modalities” to process new information because of difficulties in aural and visual processing. (Student’s Exhibit O)

STUDENT’s third-grade teacher and his parents referred him for a special education assessment. The District completed its assessment in April 1995. The assessment confirmed that STUDENT had average intellectual abilities with significant delays in all areas of academic achievement. The assessment report notes:

STUDENT has strengths socially, including a charismatic personality and leadership skills. Of concern, however is his self-esteem and self-confidence which appear to have been significantly impacted by his academic difficulty.

(Student’s Exhibit J)

On April 7, 1995, the Individualized Educational Program (IEP) team determined that STUDENT met eligibility criteria for special education because of learning disabilities. The team drafted goals and objectives, and recommended that STUDENT receive instruction in the resource specialist program (RSP) for 60 minutes on four days of each week. STUDENT’s initial IEP included goals and objectives to improve reading, word analysis skills, and written language. The IEP also called for STUDENT to receive support from the RSP teacher in mathematics, as needed. (Student’s Exhibit F) Also in April 1995, STUDENT’s parents initiated therapy for STUDENT with Ms. Turner to address frustration and anger. Beginning in August 1995, STUDENT’s parents procured private tutoring for STUDENT from Kim Kobre. Ms. Kobre saw STUDENT for two, one-hour sessions each week for approximately one year.

STUDENT received the services called for by his IEP dated April 7, 1995, throughout the fourth grade. On February 16, 1996, Nancy Cushen White, Ed.D., an educational therapist in private practice, conducted an independent assessment of STUDENT. Ms. Kobre had referred the PARENTS to Dr. Cushen White because of their ongoing concerns regarding STUDENT’s reading and spelling skills. Dr. Cushen White’s assessment included a number of recommendations. (See Student’s Exhibit M)

The IEP team met on April 22, 1996, and recommended increasing STUDENT’s RSP to 120 minutes, four times per week. The IEP also called for STUDENT to participate in a modified regular classroom program. Goals and objectives continued to address reading, written language, and math. (Student’s Exhibit E) During the 1996-1997 school year, Terry Junemann, RSP teacher, was in STUDENT’s regular education class four days per week for 45 minutes during reading and written language and for 15 minutes during mathematics. STUDENT also received instruction in the RSP room for 45 to 60 minutes four days per week to address reading and written language deficits. STUDENT also received 60 minutes per week of RSP support in mathematics.

The IEP team met on November 7, 1996, at the request of STUDENT’s parents. The PARENTS presented various requests to the IEP team, including: enrollment of STUDENT in a program that offers texts on tape; use of new technology, such as Voice Type Dictation, to help STUDENT with written expression; and use of remedial strategies such as auditory Discrimination in Depth, Reading Recovery, or Project Read to address STUDENT’s reading deficits. They also requested that an occupational therapy (OT) assessment be undertaken to evaluate STUDENT’s visual perceptual and visual-motor functioning. The IEP team, including STUDENT’s parents, agreed to continue with the then-current IEP goals and objectives and placement. The District agreed to take the parents’ suggestions into consideration in providing STUDENT’s educational program. (Student’s Exhibit D) The IEP team met again on January 27, 1997, to review STUDENT’s progress. The IEP addendum drafted on that day states: “Parents are requesting more evaluations & will discuss this with V. Humphry.” (Student’s Exhibit C)

In a letter dated April 15, 1997, the PARENTS requested that the District fund a nonpublic school placement for STUDENT because of “his lack of academic progress coupled with his declining emotional status . . . .” (Student’s Exhibit AA) The IEP team met on April 18, 1997, for the annual review. The IEP indicates that STUDENT had met a majority of the objectives from his IEP developed April 1996. (Student’s Exhibit E) District members of the IEP team recommended that, for the 1997-1998 school year, STUDENT receive 90 minutes of RSP services four to five times per week. STUDENT’s father attended the meeting. He did not consent to the proposed placement at that time. (Student’s Exhibit B)

On April 29, 1997, the Children’s Health Council (CHC) assessed STUDENT at the request of his parents. The CHC is a certified nonpublic agency that conducts diagnostic testing of school-age children. The report of the academic portion of the assessment contains the following recommendations:

STUDENT would benefit from a highly structured multisensory integrated curriculum. one that teaches through his intellect and provides ongoing remediation and compensatory strategies for his learning disabilities. In addition, STUDENT would benefit from individualized tutorial support from a credentialed learning disabilities specialist.

(Student’s Exhibit K)

Additional modifications recommended by CHC include: allowing STUDENT to use books on tape; utilizing word processing for written language activities; diminishing timed elements of academic tasks; and de-emphasizing spelling. Nancy Elizabeth Sullivan, Ph.D., a licensed psychologist, conducted social, emotional, and cognitive testing for STUDENT as part of the independent assessment completed by CHC in April 1997. Dr. Sullivan, who conducted the psychological portion of the CHC assessment, recommended increasing STUDENT’s resource time to 49% of his school day. She also recommended employing teaching strategies such as Slingerland or Orton-Gillingham and individual cognitive-behavioral therapy. (Student’s Exhibit L)

The IEP team reconvened on May 30, 1997, to plan for STUDENT’s transition to Windsor Middle School for the 1997-1998 school year. The IEP calls for 90 minutes of RSP on four to five days per week. The IEP includes the following statements:

1) Participation in a collaboration class for math/science. 2) RSP--Language Art with carry-over for Project Read. 3) Parent to visit school to observe. 4) Continue goals as written, no new goals added. 5) Parents to meet with P. Moulton to discuss test results wk of June 23.

(Student’s Exhibit A)

The parents did not visit Windsor Middle School. They did meet with Ms. Moulton in June 1997; however, they did not reach an agreement regarding STUDENT’s placement for the sixth grade. STUDENT’s parents continue to disagree with the placement proposed by the District. They contend that New Horizon is providing STUDENT with an appropriate placement. They request that the District fund the costs of STUDENT’s attending New Horizon. The District contends that it has offered an appropriate placement for STUDENT.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

STUDENT’s Issues

ISSUE NO. 1: Did the District provide STUDENT with a free, appropriate public education (FAPE)?

Under both state law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400; Education Code § 56000.)(Footnote 4) The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18).) “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).)

The term “related services” includes transportation and other services that may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(17).) California Education Code § 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. V. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court determined that the students individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provided instruction or services that maximize the students’ abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Rowley, 458 at 207-208.)

In addition, special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a student from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in regular education classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (34 C.F.R. 300.550(b)(2); Education Code § 56301.)

In summary, when taken together, the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley require that an appropriate placement: (1) be designed to meet the unique needs of the student; (2) be designed to provide the student with educational benefit; (3) conform to the student’s IEP; and (4) be provided in the least restrictive environment. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176.) The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parents’ participation in the IEP process may result in the denial of a free appropriate public education to the student. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479 IDEA. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176.)

These requirements are discussed below as they relate to whether the District has provided an appropriate placement to STUDENT. Because STUDENT’s parents have requested reimbursement for the costs of independent tutoring provided to STUDENT by Ms. Kobre from approximately August 1995 to August 1996, and for therapy provided by Ms. Turner from April 1995 to the present, it is necessary to determine whether the placements provided by the District during the 1995-1996 and 1996-1997 school years were appropriate. The appropriateness of the placement offered by the District for the current school year is also at issue. The parents have requested that the District fund the costs of STUDENT’s attending New Horizons, a certified nonpublic school.

ISSUE NO. 1(A): Did the District commit procedural errors, during the period STUDENT attend school in the District from the second semester of the 1993-1994 school year through the end of the 1996-1997 school year, that resulted in the denial of a free appropriate public education to STUDENT?

The PARENTS contend that the District committed various procedural errors that resulted in the denial of a free, appropriate public education to STUDENT.

First, STUDENT’s parents contend that the District failed to timely fulfill its obligation to identify STUDENT as a student with a disability. Both state and federal education law include provisions requiring educational agencies to establish policies and procedures to locate, identify, and evaluate children within their jurisdictional boundaries who are eligible for special education. Education Code §56300 et seq.; 34 C.F.R. § 1412(a)(3). The PARENTS testified that they provided the District with copies of reports following independent assessments by Ms. Vitrano in the fall of 1992 and in June 1994. In each of these reports, Ms. Vitrano identified deficits in STUDENT’s speech, language, and reading skills, and recommended that he be fully assessed. (District’s Exhibits 24 and 25)

Little evidence was presented at the hearing regarding STUDENT’s educational needs or his academic achievement during his first, second, and third grade school years. None of his teachers during those years testified at the hearing. Ms. Vitrano, who assessed STUDENT in 1992 and in 1994, recommended that the parents contact the District to obtain an assessment of STUDENT; however, Ms. Vitrano did not testify at the hearing. Therefore, the basis for her recommendations is uncertain and cannot be relied upon to establish that the District should have assessed STUDENT for special education following Ms. Vitrano’s assessments. There also was no evidence that the District was requested to assess STUDENT or refused to assess him. Moreover, claims related to school years prior to the 1994 school year may be barred by a three-year statute of limitations. Alexopulos v. San Francisco Unified School District, (9th Cir. 1987) 817 F.2d 551, 555. In Alexopulos, the student requested an administrative hearing in 1985 to address issues relating to the school district’s alleged failure to provide an appropriate education in 1979, some six years earlier. An administrative law hearing officer found that the student was no longer eligible for special education due to the student’s age and, therefore, denied the student’s claim. On appeal, the district court found that all claims under the IDEA were time-barred and granted the school district’s motion for summary judgment.(Footnote 5) The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the district court’s ruling. The Court concluded that any cause of action which Ms. Alexopulos may have had would have accrued in 1979 when she “knew or had reason to know of the facts underlying it.” (Footnote 6)

In this case, the parents were aware in June 1994 that they could request that the District assess STUDENT for special education services. There was no evidence that they made such a request or that they requested a due process hearing on this issue prior to October 17, 1997. Issues related to the District’s obligation to assess STUDENT or to provide him with special education services prior to the 1994-1995 school year shall not be considered in this decision because there was insufficient evidence on which to reach any conclusions during that time period. Consideration of these issues is also barred by the three-year statute-of-limitations.

The second assertion by the PARENTS is that STUDENT’s IEPs are deficient because they do not include descriptions of the present levels of STUDENT’s performance. They assert that the District should have reported subtest scores from standardized testing rather than broad scores. They also assert that because of the ways the scores were reported, the IEP team did not fully understand STUDENT and his educational needs. Special education law requires that a student’s IEP include, among other things, the following: present levels of the student’s educational performance; annual goals and short-term instructional objectives; specific special education instruction and related services required by the student; the extent to which the student will participate in regular education; and objective criteria, evaluation procedures, and schedules for determining, at least annually, whether objectives are achieved. Education Code § 56345(a); 34 C.F.R. 300.346(a). There is no requirement that all subtest scores be included on the IEP document. As determined below, the placements for the 1995-1996 and 1996-1997 school years were found to be substantively deficient because they did not include goals, objectives, or services to address STUDENT’s self-esteem and other emotional deficits. Given that determination, the only IEP that needs to be addressed on procedural grounds is the one developed on April 18, 1997, for the 1997-1998 school year. On page three of the IEP, present performance levels include cognitive, academic, speech/language, health/developmental, social/emotional, and fine/gross motor. Each of these areas includes text describing STUDENT’s performance levels. For these reasons, the parents’ contentions fail.

The third assertion by STUDENT’s parents is that the District failed to consider the independent assessment from CHC as required by Education Code § 56329(b), which provides:

If the parent obtains an independent educational assessment at private expense, the results of the assessment shall be considered by the public education agency with respect to the provision of free, appropriate public education to the child. . . .

The testimony of the PARENTS and Ms. Moulton establishes that, upon receipt of the CHC report, the PARENTS and Ms. Moulton met on June 5, 1997. Ms. Moulton reviewed the CHC report; however, the IEP team has not had an opportunity to consider the report. As determined below, the District proposed an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1997-1998 school year. Therefore, the fact that the full IEP team did not consider the CHC report did not result in a loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT.

The final assertion by STUDENT’s parents is that the District did not provide them with all of STUDENT’s educational records in response to their request. Education Code § 56504 provides:

The parent shall have the right and opportunity to examine all school records of the child and to receive copies pursuant to this section and to Section 49065 within five days after such request is made by the parent, either orally or in writing.

There was no evidence at the hearing to substantiate that the District failed to respond to a request from the parents for documents. If any documents were omitted from the ones provided to the parents, there was no persuasive evidence that there was a resulting loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT or infringement upon the parents participation in the IEP process.

ISSUE NO. 1(B): Did the District provide an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1995-1996 school year?

In order to determine whether the District provided STUDENT with a FAPE during the 1995-1996 school year, it is first necessary to have an understanding of his unique and individual needs at that time. There is no dispute that, at all times, STUDENT’s primary learning disability has been in reading. He also has deficits in written language and mathematics. STUDENT has at least average cognitive abilities. Kim Kobre, who tutored STUDENT from approximately August 1995 through August 1996, testified that he had poor handwriting skills and weaknesses in phonological processes.(Footnote 7) Vicki Humphrey, District psychologist, who assessed STUDENT in 1995, identified deficits in auditory and visual sequential processing and spatial relationships. Taken together, the above describe STUDENT’s unique and individual needs in academic areas during the 1995-1996 school year.

Many of the witnesses described STUDENT as a warm and friendly person with good social skills and a charismatic personality; however, the same witnesses, including Ms. Humphrey, the District’s psychologist who assessed STUDENT, also expressed concerns about STUDENT’s lack of self-esteem and self-confidence and the relationship of these deficits to his academic achievement. Ms. Humphrey additionally testified that STUDENT was “overly sensitive to criticism and troubled by his academic difficulties.” On the other hand, Pamela Fitt, one of STUDENT’s RSP teachers during the 1995-1996 school year, testified that he did not exhibit social or emotional problems during the time she worked with him. In response to Ms. Fitt’s testimony, STUDENT’s mother testified that if school personnel did not have observe STUDENT’s self-esteem and emotional problems, it was because STUDENT was unlikely to “let his front down” at school, whereas at home, he readily expressed his emotions. MOTHER testified that for a number of years, STUDENT exhibited low self-concept and other emotional problems related to school. She testified that, by the second grade, STUDENT did not want to go to school and complained of headaches and stomachaches, and told her that he hated school and was stupid. MOTHER testified that STUDENT had a complete emotional breakdown in the third grade. She testified that when STUDENT was in the fourth grade, concerns that he was clinically depressed and potentially suicidal prompted her to arrange for STUDENT to receive therapy from Barbara Turner, M.F.C.C. in April 1995.

Ms. Turner testified that when she initially saw STUDENT, he exhibited low self-esteem, depressive symptoms, low energy, and complained of somatic stomach aches and headaches. Ms. Turner attributed these symptoms to STUDENT’s academic difficulties. She testified that STUDENT held the perception that he was stupid. Dr. McGovern, who conducted an independent assessment of STUDENT in 1994, concurred with Ms. Turner’s assessment of STUDENT. He testified that because of learning difficulties, STUDENT was suffering from psychogenic anxiety and lacking self-confidence. He also stated that STUDENT exhibited suicidal tendencies. Dr. McGovern conferenced with STUDENT’s family and recommended counseling.

Additionally, the District’s report of its initial assessment of STUDENT specifically cited emotional issues as the reasons for parent and staff referring STUDENT for a special education assessment. The report described STUDENT as lacking “self-confidence, overly sensitive to criticism, cries and gives up easily.” The report of Dr. Windsor’s assessment, in which he identified self-esteem problems that were interfering with STUDENT’s ability to achieve academically, was available to the District’s assessors and to the IEP team. Similar concerns were, in fact, described on STUDENT’s initial IEP in the section regarding current level of social/emotional functioning. (See Student’s Exhibits F, J, and O.)

In summary, STUDENT’s parents and all of the persons who assessed STUDENT prior to the 1995-1996 school year, with the exception of Ms. Fitt, expressed concerns regarding STUDENT’s lack of self-esteem and self-confidence. Based on the substantial evidence, including the findings of a District psychologist who assessed STUDENT, the Hearing Officer concludes that emotional issues were affecting STUDENT’s ability to benefit from his education and, therefore, needed to be addressed as part of a FAPE.

STUDENT’s initial IEP included goals and objectives to address deficits in reading, word analysis, and written language and called for placement in the RSP for 60 minutes on four days per week. Ms. Fitt testified that to address STUDENT’s goals and objectives, she provided direct instruction to STUDENT using a multisensory approach. She selected specific skills to teach him through small, sequential steps. Ms. Fitt testified that she would introduce the skill to STUDENT by demonstrating the skill, by going through the skill with him, and then by having STUDENT do the skill himself. Ms. Fitt testified that STUDENT learned best when he received information both auditorially and visually. For example, when teaching STUDENT a new word from the Dolche list of frequently used words, she would have him write it on a white board, write the word in the sky, and also tap out the word. STUDENT would then use the targeted words in a story, in sentences, and in games. Ms. Fitt testified that she used a program called Signs for Sounds to teach STUDENT phonetic patterns and rules. Ms. Fitt testified that STUDENT had to look at the word as she said the word. STUDENT then circled words having a particular sound. Ms. Fitt also used a program called Scholastic Skills to teach STUDENT proper language construction and made a booklet for STUDENT of tasks in areas of deficit that she had identified from testing. Ms. Fitt testified that she worked on basic mathematics facts and on money and time concepts with STUDENT. Ms. Fitt testified that she utilized a number of materials to develop STUDENT’s visual-perceptual skills, including Frostig workbooks, Reversals/Rotations, Ann Arbor tracking exercises, picture completion tasks, and mazes. Ms. Fitt testified that STUDENT’s fourth-grade teacher accommodated STUDENT’s learning disabilities by reading tests to him, providing him with one-to-one instruction, reading social studies materials to him, preparing outlines and key word lists for various subjects, initiating a buddy system to help STUDENT, seating STUDENT in the front row of the classroom to minimize distractions. Ms. Fitt testified that she consulted with STUDENT’s regular teacher two times per week.

A comparison of STUDENT’s academic needs, as identified by assessors, with the RSP program as implemented by Ms. Fitt, establishes that STUDENT’s placement for the 1995-1996 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs in academic areas. In particular, Ms. Fitt’s testimony established that she employed specific teaching techniques, including use of a multisensory approach, that were both consistent with the recommendations of the assessors and that met STUDENT’s identified academic deficits. The placement also provided STUDENT with individual and small-group instruction to help STUDENT acquire specific skills in reading and written language. Ms. Fitt’s testimony also established that modifications made to the fourth-grade curriculum allowed STUDENT to participate in the regular education curriculum within a regular fourth-grade classroom with his regular education peers, which was appropriate for STUDENT as a student with at least average cognitive abilities. All of these components of STUDENT’s 1995-1996 placement are consistent with the recommendations made as a result of assessments by the District and by independent assessors obtained by the parents. However, conspicuously absent from STUDENT’s placement were any goals, objectives, or services to address STUDENT’s low self-esteem and other deficits related to his emotional well-being as discussed above. The lack of goals, objectives, or services in this area resulted in a program that failed to address all of STUDENT’s unique and individual needs.

Moreover, there is some question as to whether STUDENT derived sufficient benefit from his placement during the 1995-1996 school year. Ms. Kobre, who tutored STUDENT privately, testified that he made substantial gains during the period she worked with him and that, by the end of August 1996, STUDENT knew most of the letter sounds and was able to decode works. Ms. Kobre also testified that STUDENT also was able to independently create simple sentences and to read in phrases. Ms. Fitt testified that, by her observations, STUDENT made progress in the reading, writing, and mathematics curriculum used in his regular classroom and in the RSP. On the other hand, Ms. Fitt testified that on tests administered at the end of his first year of special education services, STUDENT’s scores on standardized tests showed minimal growth, except in written language, where his scores showed greater improvement. Ms. Fitt testified that test scores are not the sole criteria by which to measure growth. Nancy Cushen White, Ed.D., assessed STUDENT at the request of his parents in February 1996. Dr. Cushen White testified that STUDENT made minimal or no progress and that, whatever growth STUDENT may have made was insufficient to allow him to catch up. Dr. Cushen White, Dr. Sullivan, and Dr. McGovern all expressed their opinion that, even if it could be construed that STUDENT made progress during the 1995-1996 school year, it was de minimis and far less than the level of growth that would be expected, given his average to above-average cognitive abilities. A comparison of the scores STUDENT received on the 1996 administration of the Woodcock-Johnson Revised test with his scores from the 1995 administration of the same test shows that STUDENT’s standard scores in broad reading declined two points and his standard scores on broad mathematics declined 10 points. STUDENT’s percentile ranking in both broad reading and in broad mathematics declined. The only scores that did not decline were in broad written language.

Rowley does not require that a special education student be provided with the best education available; however, a student must receive more than de minimis benefit to meet the “some” benefit standard set forth in Rowley. (See M.C. ex rel. J.C. v. Central Regional School District (3d. Cir 1996) 81 F.3d 389; cert. denied (1996) 117 S. Ct. 176; Polk v. Central Susquehana Intermediate Unit 16 (3d. 1988) 853 F.2d 171, cert. denied (1989) 488 U.S. 1030.) The Hearing Office concludes that STUDENT’s growth during the 1995-1996 school year was de minimis which, therefore, does not satisfy the requirements of FAPE pursuant to Rowley. This is not entirely unexpected, given STUDENT’s emotional deficits. There is no dispute that the program STUDENT received was consistent with his IPE; however, because STUDENT’s program neither addressed all of his unique and individual needs nor provided him with sufficient benefit, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT did not receive a FAPE during the 1995-1996 school year.

ISSUE NO. 1(C): Did the District provide an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1996-1997 school year?

STUDENT’s needs for the 1996-1997 school year did not change significantly. He continued to have significant deficits in reading, as well as, in mathematics and written language. According to Ms. Turner and STUDENT’s parents, concerns persisted regarding STUDENT’s lack of self-esteem and self-confidence during the 1996-1997 school year.

Ms. Fitt testified that, to address STUDENT’s learning deficits, goals and objectives for the 1996-1997 school year in the areas of reading level, word analysis, writing mechanics, and mathematics were written with more specificity than were the goals and objectives contained in STUDENT’s IEP for the prior school year. The IEP team also added goals and objectives in reading comprehension and editing. The IEP team doubled the amount of RSP services STUDENT had received the prior school year. The IEP called for STUDENT to receive 120 minutes per day of RSP on four days per week. Mathematics was added to the academic areas in which the RSP provided direct instruction to STUDENT. STUDENT’s IEP also called for modifications to his regular education program. (Student’s Exhibits C, D, and E.)

The goals and objectives address STUDENT’s areas of deficits and the program described by STUDENT’s teachers establishes that the RSP and modified regular educational program were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs as a student with learning disabilities. His program allowed him to receive one-to-one and small-group instruction to help him develop the skills he needed. He also was able to participate in the regular education curriculum with modifications, which allowed him to cover the same subject areas as his regular education students. Patricia Dearth, STUDENT’s fifth-grade teacher, testified that for the first month of school STUDENT appeared nervous, complained of stomach aches and headaches, and frequently went to the restroom. Ms. Dearth testified that after that time, STUDENT became more comfortable and fit into the class “very well.” Ms. Dearth testified that STUDENT had a lot of friends, was liked by his peers, and was accepted socially. She testified that she did not refer STUDENT for counseling because there was no need to.

The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s program, particularly with the expanded RSP time and the additional goals and objectives to address mathematics, was designed to meet his unique and individual needs in academic areas; however, STUDENT’s program did not include any goals and objectives or services to address his lack of self-esteem and, therefore, did not address all of his unique and individual needs.

STUDENT’s parents, Dr. Sullivan, and Dr. Cushen White contend that STUDENT did not make sufficient progress in the District’s RSP program. They testified that his academic performance continued to fall significantly below age expectations and that his progress was less than expected. Dr. Sullivan compared percentile rankings STUDENT obtained on measures of academic achievement in 1995, 1996, and 1997 in support of her position. Dr. Cushen White also testified that STUDENT’s goals and objectives did not change very much from year-to-year; however, Ms. Fitt, STUDENT’s RSP teacher, testified credibly that the goals and objectives changed in small increments because the steps are progressive and must be mastered in order to attain higher skills.

The evidence does not support the parents’ contention that STUDENT did not make educational progress during the 1996-1997 school year. STUDENT continued to exhibit significant deficits in reading, written language, and mathematics; however, unlike the prior school year, during the 1996-1997 school year, he made progress when evaluated by a number of measures. He met all of his IEP goals and objectives, except for two in reading. Ms. Junemann, STUDENT’s RSP teacher during the 1996-1997 school year, testified that STUDENT made good academic growth. Ms. Dearth, STUDENT’s regular education teacher, offered her observations of STUDENT’s progress. She testified that STUDENT initially took tests with the RSP teacher; however, by the end of the year, he would complete as much of a test by himself before finishing with the RSP teacher. Ms. Dearth testified that STUDENT’s writing skills improved. Ms. Dearth testified that STUDENT appeared to understand that it was acceptable for him to make mistakes and, by the end of the school year, he was comfortable asking for help. He also was utilizing strategies that he was taught during the school year. STUDENT’s report card from the 1996-1997 school year shows that he earned “capable” marks. (District’s Exhibits 27 and 28)(Footnote 8) During the last trimester, STUDENT earned “capable plus” in reading, writing, and social science.

On the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement-Revised (WJ-R), STUDENT’s standard scores of reading increased from 69 in April 1996, to 80 in April 1997. When reported as grade equivalencies, STUDENT improved from the second month of the second grade to the third month of the third grade. STUDENT’s standard scores in mathematics increased from 62 to 80, during the same period of time. The change, when measured by grade equivalencies, shows an increase of one year and 11 months. STUDENT’s scores in written language, as measured by the WJ-R, also show slightly more than one year of growth. STUDENT’s RSP and regular education teachers testified that STUDENT made academic progress during the 1996-1997 school year. They also credibly described his decrease in frustration and increase in self-esteem. Both described STUDENT as socially appropriate. Based on the growth STUDENT demonstrated during the 1996-1997 school year on a number of measures, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT benefitted from his placement in a regular education classroom with RSP services during the 1996-1997 school year.

There is no dispute that STUDENT’s program comported with his IEP. Although his reading and other academic skills remained below grade level, STUDENT did derive benefit from his placement in the District during 1996-1997 school year; however, not all of his unique needs were being addressed by the District’s program. In April 1996, when STUDENT’s IEP was developed and the placement for the 1996-1997 school year was offered, STUDENT continued to have emotional deficits, including low self-esteem and poor self-concept. The fact that STUDENT’s social and emotional status improved during the school year was based, at least in part, on the services provided privately by Ms. Turner, given that neither the IEP nor the services set forth in the IEP addressed social/emotional issues. Because the IEP and educational services provided by the District did not address all of STUDENT’s unique and individual needs, it did not satisfy the requirements of a FAPE under IDEA and Rowley.

ISSUE NO. 1(D): Did the District offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1997- 1998 school year?

The 1997-1998 school year follows enactment of the amendments to IDEA, and the appropriateness of the District’s offer of placement must be analyzed under the provisions of IDEA 1997. The requirements of FAPE and LRE set forth in the IDEA 1997 are similar to those set forth in the IDEA prior to the amendments.(Footnote 9) (See Issue No. 1 above.) Pursuant to IDEA 1997, "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that:

(A) have been provided at public expense, under public supervision and direction, and without charge; (B) meet the standards of the State educational agency; (C) include an appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education in the State involved; and (D) are provided in conformity with the individualized education program. . . .

(20 U.S.C. § 1401(8)(A)-(D).)

“Special Education” is defined as “specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability. . . .” (20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).)

Taking these requirements into consideration with Rowley, it is necessary to address whether the placement offered by the District for the 1997-1998 school year is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, is designed to provide him with educational benefit, conforms to his IEP, and satisfies LRE requirements.

Although STUDENT made educational growth during the 1996-1997 school year, his skills continued to fall below grade level in reading, mathematics, and written language. Witnesses testifying on behalf of STUDENT, including Dr. Cushen White, testified that for the current school year, STUDENT needs to be provided a combination of remedial and compensatory strategies. He also needs a systematic total language arts program that integrates reading, spelling, and writing, and use of a multisensory approach. Dr. Sullivan testified that CHC recommended that STUDENT be educated in a highly structured environment that provides him with a multisensory approach to teaching and individual “tutorial” support. These recommendations were not disputed.

As to STUDENT’s needs in social/emotional areas, Dr. Sullivan testified that STUDENT continues to have a poor image of himself with respect to his ability to learn. She recommended ongoing individual therapy to provide him with cognitive strategies to reduce anxiety and frustration. Ms. Turner testified that she continues to see STUDENT because he needs to “grieve the loss of his self-capacities” and to learn how to integrate his abilities so that he can successfully function in the world. The rationale for therapy put forth by Dr. Sullivan and Ms. Turner is not persuasive. Neither of their testimonies establishes that STUDENT requires therapy to benefit from his education. Neither Dr. Sullivan nor Ms. White observed STUDENT at school or contacted his teachers to obtain their input regarding his social and emotional status at school. The Hearing Officer finds that the testimony of school personnel who worked directly with STUDENT during the 1996-1997 school year, including his teachers and Joe Taylor, principal of Brooks Elementary School, establishes that STUDENT’s noted improvement in academic achievement was accompanied by improved self-esteem. Their testimony also establishes that STUDENT no longer requires counseling services to benefit from his education.

Moreover, the testimony of Ms. Humphry and Mr. Taylor, both of whom were present at the IEP meeting on April 18, 1997, establishes that the IEP team discussed ways to address the parents’ concerns about STUDENT’s self-esteem and offered counseling services, which were rejected by the parents. Ms. Humphrey and Mr. Taylor testified that the IEP team also discussed additional options available at Windsor Middle School, including peer tutoring, school counseling, therapy from a school psychologist intern, and a mental health program, which were also rejected by the parents. Written notes on the IEP reflect the team’s discussion of school counseling. The IEP also states that, based on the concerns of the parents, the District offered to add goals and objectives regarding self-esteem; however, the parents also indicated that they did not want additional goals added to the IEP. Therefore, even if it were determined that STUDENT would have required counseling or some other service to address self-esteem problems, the evidence establishes that the parents rejected the District’s offer to provide such services.

The IEP goals and objectives drafted for the 1997-1998 school year continue to address STUDENT’s deficits in reading, written language, and math computation. The IEP specifically calls for use of a multisensory approach. (Student’s Exhibit B) Sharon Yvonne Houg, the RSP teacher at Windsor Middle School, testified at great length regarding the program STUDENT would receive at the District’s proposed placement and the way in which his goals and objectives would be implemented. (See also District’s Exhibit 26.) Ms. Houg testified that her understanding of STUDENT is primarily based on speaking with STUDENT’s previous RSP teacher and attending the IEP regarding his placement. Ms. Houg testified that she currently has 25 students on her case load and that STUDENT’s skills fall approximately in the middle of those of the other students. Ms. Houg testified that the RSP program at Windsor offers a combination of pull-out services, collaboration with the regular education teachers, directed teaching, and modification of the regular education curriculum. The pull-out services generally address a student’s deficits that are depriving the student of access to the core curriculum.

Ms. Houg described the schedule proposed for STUDENT. First and second period include instruction in mathematics and science. The teacher is David Whitehead. Mr. Whitehead begins the math class with an ungraded “brain teaser,” which Ms. Houg described as an activity the students try to solve. Mr. Whitehead then provides direct instruction to the students and models problem-solving for the class. The students then work on problems. Ms. Houg testified that she and Mr. Whitehead circulate around the classroom and provide individual help to the students. One of the teachers explains the homework and also models for the students. Students can then begin working on their homework so that they have an opportunity to get clarification regarding the assignment from one of the teachers. Ms. Houg testified that she modifies homework assignments for the RSP students as needed. She also goes over basic skills with the students and provides additional instruction as needed. Following a 10-minute snack period, STUDENT would be in physical education. STUDENT’s fourth-period class would be a program called “Reading Renaissance,” which would be followed by electives. Sixth-grade students participate in a “wheel” of electives in which they are exposed to various subjects. Lunch is after fifth period. Sixth and seventh period are taught by the other sixth-grade teacher, Cyndi Heidl. Ms. Houg proposed working with STUDENT during sixth period. She planned to continue utilizing Project Read, which she described as a multisensory, phonetic-based approach to teaching reading that takes into account the learning styles of the student. Students learn specific strategies. For example, a new word is taught to the student by showing the word to the student, saying the word to the student, and then having the student physically reproduce the word in the air, in sand, and on paper. Students also practice reading independently and orally to Ms. Houg or her assistant. Ms. Houg testified that she planned to have six students in STUDENT’s group. Ms. Houg testified that she also would work with STUDENT on spelling. She proposed to develop a list of words for him based on his own spelling errors and from words in his reading. She also would have STUDENT write sentences or a story using the spelling words. Ms. Houg testified that she would work individually with STUDENT to help him edit and rewrite written language assignments. Seventh period is social studies. An assistant is available during seventh period to assist the RSP students.

Ms. Houg testified that STUDENT’s goals and objectives related to written language would also be addressed through direct instruction followed by an individual activity with STUDENT. To meet STUDENT’s goals and objectives in mathematics, Ms. Houg testified that she would begin the year with a review of math computations skills. She provides individual assistance within the mathematics classroom to ensure that the students understand the concepts being taught and will reteach concepts as needed. She also may modify homework assignments, if needed. Ms. Houg testified that she uses “Slam Math” to help students with division. Slam math involves drawing arrows to show where to place the numbers involved in the process. Ms. Houg responded to the list of needs provided by the parents at one of the IEP meetings. She testified that two computers are available for the students’ use. She has a program that teaches typing, and there is a word processing program for writing projects. Ms. Houg testified that books on tape are available. She testified that she prefers to read with the students so she can check their comprehension skills; however, she testified that tapes of core literature books allow the students to obtain grade-level information when the books themselves are above the students’ reading levels. Ms. Houg testified that tests can be taken in the RSP room. She testified that the sixth-grade teachers present instructions in writing and orally. She may also pair an RSP student with another student who generally understands the instructions. Ms. Houg testified that she and the aide are also available to clarify instructions. Ms. Houg testified she or an assistant may “pre-teach” social studies and science information so that the student is prepared for the classroom instruction. Ms. Houg testified that she also employs “graphic organizers.”

Ms. Houg testified that it is not unexpected that STUDENT would have some self-esteem problems because of his learning disabilities. Ms. Houg testified that the RSP program is designed to provide opportunities for STUDENT and the other students to be successful. The students participate in regular education classrooms with their peers and receive help from the RSP program to develop their skills and to gain understanding of the concepts presented in the regular classes. She also teaches the students organizational and generalization skills.

Pam Moulton, District coordinator of special education, also testified about the District’s proposed placement. Ms. Moulton has had several meetings with STUDENT’s parents, met STUDENT on one occasion, and attended the IEP meeting in May 1997. Ms. Moulton testified that STUDENT’s goals and objectives can “easily” be implemented in the RSP at Windsor. She testified that the program offers STUDENT an environment that is structured, predictable, and safe. In Ms. Moulton’s opinion, Ms. Houg is a very competent teacher whose strengths include building the self-esteem of her students.

It was determined above that STUDENT has benefited from placement with regular education peers and that he can benefit from a combination of instruction in RSP and regular education classes. STUDENT is a student with average cognitive potential who benefits from instruction in grade-level subjects. Numerous witnesses described STUDENT as getting along well with his peers and enjoying their social exchanges. For these reasons, STUDENT continues to benefit from placement in a regular education environment with his typically developing peers, who also provide him with appropriate behavioral models. There is no persuasive evidence that STUDENT requires a more restrictive placement. No one recommended that STUDENT be placed in a special day class (SDC). Dr. Sullivan specifically testified that an SDC would not be an appropriate placement for STUDENT because SDCs typically serve students with emotional problems or those who have significant disabilities. Ms. Houg’s extensive testimony establishes that the instruction and services offered by the District will address STUDENT’s learning disabilities in a variety of ways and will provide him with individual and group instruction using a multisensory approach. Ms. Houg’s testimony also establishes that the program she proposed for STUDENT is consistent with the recommendations of the CHC and other witnesses who testified on behalf of STUDENT in that it is structured and offers remedial and compensatory techniques.

Neither STUDENT’s parents nor anyone else testifying on behalf of STUDENT has observed the program proposed for STUDENT for the 1997-1998 school year. The concerns expressed by STUDENT’s parents and their witnesses regarding the ability of the District to provide an educational program from which STUDENT would benefit was based on the premise that STUDENT should have shown more progress than he did over the prior school years. It was determined above that STUDENT did, in fact, benefit from his education during the 1996-1997 school year. Although this may be one indicator of the appropriateness of a similar RSP program proposed for the subsequent school year, it is necessary, in any case, to determine the appropriateness of the placement offered for the 1997-1998 school year on the IEP goals and objectives, specific class, and the services offered for that school year.

None of the witnesses appearing on behalf of STUDENT contradicted Ms. Houg’s testimony regarding the ways in which she would implement STUDENT’s IEP or provide him with instruction in the RSP to meet his unique and individual needs. Therefore, based on the essentially unrebutted testimony of Ms. Houg, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement offered by the District for STUDENT for the 1997-1998 school year was designed to meet his unique and individual needs and to provide him with educational benefit. There is no dispute that the placement comports with STUDENT’s IEP. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District offered an appropriate placement to STUDENT.

The District’s placement also offers the least restrictive environment for STUDENT. At the hearing, Dr. Sullivan proposed that STUDENT be placed in private school, which is generally considered a more restrictive placement than a comprehensive school with a combination of regular and special education classes. Dr. Sullivan’s recommendation for placement at the hearing was inconsistent with her recommendation for placement following her assessment of STUDENT. At that time, Dr. Sullivan recommended that STUDENT be placed in an RSP. She apparently changed her recommendation for placement based on the erroneous conclusion that STUDENT had not benefitted from his placement the past two years in the District’s RSP. Dr. McGovern also made placement recommendations for the 1997-1998 school year; however, he has not seen STUDENT for a number of years. Neither Dr. Sullivan nor Dr. McGovern has observed STUDENT at school or the program offered for STUDENT. They also have not consulted with the persons who have worked with STUDENT in an educational environment. Therefore, the testimony of Dr. Sullivan and Dr. McGovern is less persuasive than that of the teachers who worked directly with STUDENT during the 1996-1997 school year. STUDENT’s abilities fall within the range of the abilities of the students served by the program at Windsor and his deficits are not so significant that he needs to be educated in a separate school away from his regular education peers. Therefore, for all of these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s RSP also satisfies LRE requirements.

ISSUE NO. 2: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT’s attending New Horizon, a certified nonpublic school, during the 1997-1998 school year?

Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under IDEA and are reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. In addition, equitable considerations may be considered in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting such relief. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496.

It has been concluded that the District offered an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1997-1998 school year. Moreover, even if the parents prefer another program and the parents’ preferred program results in greater educational benefit, the District is not required to reimburse the parents for their private placement when, as in this case, the District has offered a FAPE pursuant to the requirements of Rowley and the IDEA. Therefore, the request for reimbursement for New Horizons is denied.

ISSUE NO. 3: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private tutoring by Kim Kobre from August 1995 to August 1996?

The parents contend that they are entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent tutoring they procured for STUDENT from Kim Kobre. The District contends that it is not required to reimburse the parents for Ms. Kobre’s tutoring because STUDENT did not require the services to benefit from his education. Ms. Kobre provided tutoring for approximately one year, beginning in August 1995.

In Issue No. (1)(B) above, it was concluded that the District did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1995-1996 school year. The parents obtained Ms. Kobre’s services in seeking to provide appropriate services for STUDENT to address his significant learning disabilities so that he could benefit from his education. Ms. Kobre testified that she has received training in Slingerland and Orton-Gillingham multisensory approaches to teaching students with learning disabilities. Ms. Kobre testified that she provided STUDENT with one-on-one tutoring on two days per week in one-hour sessions to address his deficits in reading and written language. Ms. Kobre testified that she employed multisensory techniques to teach STUDENT language patterns and their usage. She also worked with STUDENT on phonics. Ms. Kobre testified that STUDENT showed improvement in the limited areas she addressed with him. Ms. Kobre’s testimony establishes that the services she provided to STUDENT were appropriate because they addressed his identified learning disabilities. Therefore, under Burlington, the parents are entitled to reimbursement from the District for Ms. Kobre’s services.

ISSUE NO. 4: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private counseling by Barbara Turner from April 1995 to present?

Petitioner seeks reimbursement for the costs of therapy provided by Ms. Turner to STUDENT from April 1995 and continuing. As discussed above in Issues No. 1(B) and (1)(C), the District did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 1995-1996 and 1996-1997 school years. A principal deficiency noted in the District’s program during those school years was the lack of goals, objectives, and services to address STUDENT’s emotional deficits. The Hearing Officer concluded that such services were necessary to allow STUDENT to benefit from his education. (See Issues No. 1(B) and (1)(C) for further discussion of STUDENT’s deficits in self-esteem and self-confidence.) The PARENTS testified that they obtained the services of Ms. Turner, a licensed marriage, family, and child counselor, to address significant emotional problems they were observing at home with STUDENT. Ms. Turner described the ways in which she worked with STUDENT to address his self-esteem and self-confidence. She also addressed STUDENT’s frustration and symptoms of anxiety and depression. The methods Ms. Turner employed with STUDENT included play and sand tray therapies. (See also Student’s Exhibits Q and R.)

The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Turner’s testimony establishes that the services she provided to STUDENT were designed to address identified deficits in emotional areas. Based on STUDENT’s need for services to address these deficits and the lack of the services from the District, the Hearing Officer concludes that the parents are entitled to reimbursement for Ms. Turner’s services to STUDENT beginning in April 1995 and during the 1995-1996. They are also entitled to reimbursement from the beginning of the 1996-1997 school year to the date of the IEP in April 1997, when the PARENTS refused counseling services offered by the District.

STUDENT’s parents also seek reimbursement for Ms. Turner’s services for the 1997-1998 school year. The Hearing Officer concluded above that the District offered a FAPE to STUDENT for the current school year and that the evidence was not persuasive regarding STUDENT’s need for social/emotional counseling or other services to benefit from his education. Additionally, STUDENT’s teachers, the school principal, and even Ms. Turner described STUDENT’s emotional growth during the 1996-1997 school year. Ms. Turner’s stated reason for continuing to see STUDENT--because he needs to “grieve the loss of his self-capacities” and to learn how to integrate his abilities so that he can successfully function in the world--does not establish that he requires Ms. Turner’s services to benefit from his education. Moreover, the evidence establishes that when the District did offer to include goals and objectives on STUDENT’s IEP in social/emotional areas and to provide him with counseling, the parents rejected the District’s offer. The provision of FAPE by the District and the rejection of services by the parents weighs strongly against reimbursement to the parents for Ms. Turner’s services for the 1997-1998 school year. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer limits the parents’ reimbursement for Dr. Turner’s services to the 1995-1996 school year and through April 1997.

ISSUE NO. 5: Did the District conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT?

A parent has the right to obtain an independent educational assessment of the student. When the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public educational agency, the parent also has the right to an independent assessment from qualified specialists at public expense unless it is established in a due process hearing that the public educational agency’s assessment was appropriate. Education Code § 56329(b).

For the District's assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of California Education Code § 56320, which states in relevant part that testing and assessment materials and procedures must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; provided and administered in the student's primary language or other mode of communication; administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; and validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. Additionally, individually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning must be administered by a credentialed school psychologist. Assessment and testing materials must also not measure the student's impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills unless that is what the test purports to measure.

Subsection 56320(e) states that no single procedure shall be used as the “sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for an individual with exceptional needs.” Subsection 56320(f) requires that the student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional status. Pursuant to subsection (g), the assessment must be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the student's disability. Psychological assessments must be conducted by credentialed school psychologists, and health assessments must be conducted by a credentialed school nurse or physician. These assessors must be trained and prepared to assess cultural and ethnic factors appropriate to the pupil being assessed. Education Code § 56324(a) and (b).

The District’s initial assessment of STUDENT took place in April 1995 and is contained in Student’s Exhibit J.) Ms. Humphrey testified that, as a part of STUDENT’s assessment, she reviewed his history, obtained health and developmental information from STUDENT’s parents, considered vision and hearing assessments by the nurse, observed STUDENT, and administered tests. Ms. Humphrey testified that her assessments measured STUDENT’s cognitive abilities and his visual-motor integration, visual-perceptual skills, and visual-auditory memory skills. Ms. Humphrey also utilized portions of the Piers-Harris Self-Esteem Inventory to assess STUDENT’s social and adaptive skills. Ms. Humphrey testified that she administered the Test of Nonverbal Intelligence (TONI) because STUDENT had recently been assessed on the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-III (WISC-III). She also testified that she relied on her administration of intelligence testing rather than on the results reported by Dr. McGovern because Dr. McGovern did not administer the WISC-III in a standardized manner. Ms. Humphrey also considered the results of academic achievement testing administered by the RSP teacher.

There was no evidence presented at the hearing to challenge the appropriateness of the District’s assessment. The testimony of Ms. Humphrey establishes that STUDENT was assessed utilizing a number of instruments. Therefore, the District did not rely on one single criteria to establish STUDENT’s need for special education services. Ms. Humphrey’s testimony also establishes that the District assessed STUDENT in all areas of suspected disabilities, namely, in academic, perceptual, and social/emotional areas. The District’s assessment was conducted by an appropriately qualified school psychologist, a nurse, and by an RSP teacher, all of whom possess knowledge regarding learning disabilities. Absent any evidence to the contrary, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s assessment satisfied the requirements set forth above in Education Code §§ 56320 and 56324.

A reassessment of a student must be conducted every three years or more frequently, if conditions warrant, or if the parent or teacher requests an assessment and development of a new IEP. In this case, STUDENT’s initial assessment was in April 1995. Therefore, a triennial assessment was not due at the time of the hearing. There was no evidence that STUDENT’s teachers or parents had requested an assessment. At the end of each school year, the RSP teacher administered measures of academic achievement to STUDENT. There was no persuasive evidence that any additional testing was warranted because of a significant change to STUDENT. It was concluded above that STUDENT did not make sufficient progress during the 1995-1996 school year; however, it was not from the lack of identification of his needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the district was not under an obligation to further assess STUDENT following his initial assessment until the time his triennial will be due, which the Hearing Officer notes is April 1998.

ISSUE NO. 6: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of an independent assessments by the Children’s Health Council, Nancy Cushen White, John Stewart McGovern, Barbara A. Turner, Jennifer Vitrano, Kim Kobre, Isaac Gardner, Jill Markham, and Milton Harris?

It was determined above that the District conducted an appropriate assessment of STUDENT and that no further assessment was warranted. Additionally, the PARENTS did not provide written reports of assessments by either Barbara Turner, Jennifer Vitrano, Kim Kobre, Isaac Gardner, Jill Markham, or Milton Harris. Ms. Vitrano, Mr. Gardner, Ms. Markhan, and Mr. Harris did not testify at the hearing, and there was little, if any, evidence regarding any of their assessments. For all of these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that the parents are not entitled to reimbursement for any of the independent assessments they have procured.

The District’s Issue

ISSUE NO. 1: Is the District entitled to assess STUDENT in the areas of social and emotional functioning over the objection of his parents?

The District contends that further assessment is warranted of STUDENT’s social and emotional functioning to clarify his needs in these areas. The District also asserts that it has a right to have evaluations completed by persons known to the District staff. In the District’s closing brief, the District acknowledges that it did not see a need for further assessment of STUDENT and only proposed further assessment following the parents’ placement of STUDENT in a nonpublic school program.

There was no persuasive evidence presented at the hearing that either STUDENT’s learning disability or social/emotional concerns have changed significantly. If anything, STUDENT’s functioning in each of these areas has improved, particularly during the 1996-1997 school year. The District has assessed STUDENT’s academic achievement annually. The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT’s triennial assessment was not due at the time of the hearing. For these reasons and lacking evidence to the contrary, the Hearing Officer concludes that an assessment of STUDENT’s social/emotional functioning is not warranted at this time.

ORDER

(1) Within 20 calendar days of receipt of proof from the parents, the District shall reimburse the parents for the costs of Ms. Kobre’s tutoring services from August of 1995 through August of 1996.

(2) Within 20 calendar days of receipt of proof from the parents, the District shall reimburse the parents for the costs of Ms. Turner’s therapy from April 1995 through April 1997.

(3) All other claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

STUDENT’s Issues (1) Did the District provide STUDENT with a free, appropriate public education (FAPE)?

STUDENT prevailed as to the 1995-1996 school year. He also prevailed as to the District’s failure to provide for his emotional needs from the beginning of the 1996-1997 school year through April 1997. The District prevailed as to the 1997-1998 school year.

(2) Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT’s placement at New Horizon, a certified nonpublic school?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(3) Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private tutoring by Kim Kobre?

STUDENT prevailed on this issue.

(4) Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private counseling by Barbara Turner?

STUDENT substantially prevailed on this issue.

(5) Did the District conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(6) Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent assessments by the Children’s Health Council, Nancy Cushen White, John Stewart McGovern, Barbara A. Turner, Jennifer Vitrano, Kim Kobre, Isaac Gardner, Jill Markham, and Milton Harris?

The District prevailed on this issue.

The District’s Issue (1) Is the District entitled to assess STUDENT in the areas of social and emotional functioning over the objection of his parents?

STUDENT prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: April 17, 1998 ________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1) The parents identified an additional issue requesting reimbursement for "advocate/attorney's fees." California special education law provides that the Hearing Officer shall determine the extent to which the parties prevailed on the issues heard and decided. (Education Code  56507(d).) Education Code  56507(b) also provides that attorneys' fees may be awarded to the prevailing parent or pupil only by agreement of the parties following the hearing process or by a court of competent jurisdiction. There are no provisions in special education law for the Hearing Officer to award advocate's fees and, according to information provided at the hearing, Mr. Mazzara is not a member of the Bar of the State of California. For these reasons, the right to reimbursement for the costs of representation at this due process hearing is not determined in this decision. 2) Ms. Vitrano continued to see STUDENT through June 1994.

3) Dr. McGovern also reported that, with "examiner assistance," STUDENT scored in the high-average range of cognitive abilities. 4) In 1997, the IDEA was amended (IDEA 1997). Issues 1, 2, 5, 6, and portions of issue 7, are related to the provision of FAPE or are requests for reimbursement for assessments that occurred prior to June 4, 1997, the effective date of IDEA 1997. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will apply the law in effect at the time these disputed events occurred, in accordance with general rules regarding retroactivity. (Landgraff v. USI Film Products (1994) 511 U.S. 244.) 5) The student also raised issues under section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973. The district court also found that these claims were time-barred. 6) The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals also addressed the applicability of a statute of limitations to IDEA claims in Dreher v. Amphitheater Unified School District (9th Cir. 1994) 22 F.3d 228. As in Alexopulos, the court applied the state's statute of limitations for liabilities created by statute. 7) Phonological processing includes the matching of sounds and symbols. 8) The following descriptors are used to evaluate a student's academic performance: outstanding, strong, capable, and developing. 9) LRE requirements are found at 20 U.S.C.  1412(a)(5()(A).