California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 25, 1998
Las Virgenes Unified School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 1326-98, SN 1601-98, SN 1602-98 · Hearing Officer Glenna Eubank deCamara
Las Virgenes Unified's offer of the home middle school was appropriate for twin boys with autism; limited IEP meeting ordered.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The decision notes that the parents' own due process cases on the same site dispute were still pending, and that a stay-put order kept the boys in their elementary placement.
Summary
Las Virgenes Unified School District filed two consolidated cases against twin 12-year-old boys. Both are eligible for special education because of severe autism. The parents agreed with the boys' IEPs, which included a special day class, a separate room for the two boys and their full-time aides, speech-language services, and adapted physical education. The dispute was about the school site for middle school. The District offered A. E. Wright Middle School, the home school. The parents wanted Lindero Canyon Middle School, which was about 1.6 miles from home. Their reasons were that Wright's open gates near a parking lot, a bus yard, and a creek were unsafe for boys who run off, that the boys could not handle a bus ride, and that walking to school burned off energy.
The Hearing Officer found Wright appropriate. The District's consultant, Tracee Parker of Autism Partnership, had worked with the boys since 1997. The Hearing Officer found her more persuasive than the parents' one-time expert, Scott Shepard. The boys had never run off a school campus, and trained aides escorted them at all times. They had ridden buses on field trips without problems. The walk to Lindero along a busy boulevard was itself dangerous. Wright also had the separate room the IEPs required, while Lindero was overcrowded. The Hearing Officer held that neither the home-school location nor distance from home decides placement by itself. The District was ordered to hold an IEP meeting within two weeks to address gate safety and to write measurable bus-riding goals.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO analyzed a dispute over which school site to use when the parents agreed with the IEP itself. Under Rowley-era standards, the Hearing Officer asked whether the offered site could carry out the IEP safely. Closeness to home or a parent's preference did not decide the question. The Hearing Officer still ordered IEP changes to address the parents' safety concerns.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedDistrict-filed: implement IEP
Issue 1. Did the District offer Student 1 and Student 2 a free, appropriate public education when offering the site of A. E. Wright Middle School for the 1998-99 school year?
Wright, the home school, was an appropriate placement. Its campus was no less safe than the parents' preferred school, bus transportation with aides was appropriate, and Wright had the separate classroom the IEPs required. The Hearing Officer ordered a limited IEP meeting on gate safety and bus goals.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order that district's offer may be implemented. A. E. Wright Middle School is an appropriate placement for both students for the remainder of the 1998-99 school year.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within two weeks of the decision, the IEP team must meet to develop procedures that address the parents' safety concerns, including the open gates between the classroom and the parking lot. The team must also develop goals and objectives for getting the students on the school bus in the mornings and for behavior and safety issues on the bus. The bus goals must include clear, measurable, short-term goals that allow frequent assessment of transportation needs.
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Poolaw v. Bishop; Barnett v. Fairfax County School Board; Fisher v. Rochester Community Schools; Murray v. Montrose County School District; Schuldt v. Mankato School District
People named in the decision
- Joe Nardo, director of pupil services / director of special education, Las Virgenes Unified School District
- Dr. Donald Zimring, deputy superintendent, Las Virgenes Unified School District
- Ronald Kaiser, principal, Lindero Canyon Middle School, Las Virgenes Unified School District
- Steffi Brantly, instructional assistant / 1:1 aide and relief aide (also spelled Brantley in the decision), Las Virgenes Unified School District, Sumac Elementary School
- Diane Squire, special day class teacher, Las Virgenes Unified School District, Sumac Elementary School
- Andrea Lafazia, special education teacher, Las Virgenes Unified School District, Sumac Elementary School
- Tracee Parker, autism consultant hired by District; developed program and trained staff, Autism Partnership/Behavior Therapy and Learning Center
- Scott Shepard, expert witness for Students (autism consultant), Avenues / Visions (decision names both)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Glenna Eubank deCamara, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Calabasas, California on December 15 and 16, 1998.
Petitioner, Las Virgenes Unified School District, (hereinafter Las Virgenes or District) was represented by attorney Andrew Arczynsi of the law firm of Filarsky and Watt. Also present was Joe Nardo, director of pupil services for Las Virgenes.
Respondents Student 1 and Student 2 (hereinafter students or Respondents) were represented by attorney Marcie Gladson of Protection and Advocacy, Inc. Also present on Respondents’ behalf was their father.
Las Virgenes called the following witnesses to testify: Dr. Donald Zimring, deputy superintendent of Las Virgenes; Ronald Kaiser, principal of Lindero Canyon Middle School; Steffi Brantly, instructional assistant for Las Virgenes; Diane Squire, special education teacher for Las Virgenes; Andrea Lafazia, special education teacher for Las Virgenes; Joe Nardo, director of special education for Las Virgenes; and Tracee Parker, Autism Partnership/Behavior Therapy and Learning Center.
Respondents called the following witnesses to testify: Scott Shepard, Avenues, and the father of Respondents.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of closing arguments. The Hearing Office received the closing arguments, the record was closed and the issue was submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
At the outset of the hearing, the parties requested that the cases of Las Virgenes vs. Student 1 and Student 2 (SN 1601-98, SN 1602-98) be heard together. Although the parties recognized that each of the children’s educations is individual, they agreed that the facts and the issue presented were the same for both children. It was therefore ordered that the cases be consolidated and the evidence presented by each party would be applicable to both cases unless specifically identified as pertaining to only one child. For purposes of identification, the District’s exhibits were admitted without an objection as Exhibits A 1-15 for Student 1 (SN 1601) and Exhibits B 1-13 for Student 2 (SN 1602). Respondents’ exhibits were admitted without an objection as Exhibits 1- 4 for both cases.
Respondents requested that the Hearing Officer make a site visit to each of the two middle schools at issue. The Petitioner did not object, but requested that the boys’ elementary school also be visited. The Respondents concurred with this. The Hearing Officer visited A. E. Wright Middle School, Lindero Canyon Middle School and Sumac Elementary School accompanied by the parties and their attorneys pursuant to Education Code §56505.1(c).
ISSUE
Did the District offer Student 1 and Student 2 a free, appropriate education (hereinafter FAPE) when offering the site of A. E. Wright Middle School for the 1998-99 school year?
BACKGROUND FACTS
Student 1 and Student 2 are twelve-year-old twin boys who have each qualified for special education since February 1991 with a diagnosis of severe autism. In May 1991, the Respondents began school in a special day class (SDC) at Ladera Elementary School in Conejo Valley Unified School District. Their next placement, beginning in October 1993, was the Ventura County Program at Conejo-Triggs School. In 1995, Student 1 and Student 2 transferred to Sumac Elementary School, within the Las Virgenes Unified School District, and attended an inclusion program for their third and fourth grades.
Student 1 has little spontaneous speech but displays some receptive language. He imitates adult speech occasionally and can be echolalic. Student 1 can sometimes independently complete tasks given to him with only verbal prompts. He usually has difficulty attending and requires frequent redirection from his assistant. Student 1 engages in self-stimulatory behavior. He typically ignores other individuals in the classroom and plays alone when in a group. Social reciprocity is an area of great difficulty for him. Student 1 can catch and throw a ball. Academically, Student 1 can write his first name and follow simple verbal and nonverbal directions with prompts. He is sensitive to sound. Behaviorally, he gets into things that have doors, so doors must be kept locked. He is a “runner” (often attempts to escape his location or assistant) and shows little safety awareness.
Student 2 shows interest in the activities of others and can play simple interactive games. He sometimes imitates adult phrases and movements. He does not laugh or smile appropriately. Student 2 shows affection for familiar people and can address them by name. He shows a preference for some friends over others. Occasionally, Student 2 uses sentences of several words and he can listen to a story for at least five minutes. He demonstrates an understanding of language by following requests and making choices. He likes to help with some activities. Student 2 is fascinated with cars and tries to get into them at every opportunity. Student 2 is also a runner and has very little awareness of danger in his environment.
When the boys were in the fourth grade, a behavioral assessment was conducted to address problems in the inclusion classroom. The boys were spitting, throwing things, pulling their fingers, running away from and pushing their assistants. A behavior plan was developed to address the disruptive behaviors, noncompliance and elopement (elopement is another term for running). The District also hired a consultant to assist with the creation and implementation of programs for Student 1 and Student 2. Individual Education Program (IEP) meetings were held on June 17, 1997, for both Students. Present levels of functioning were addressed at these meetings. The meetings were then continued until the District’s hired consultant Tracee Parker of Autism Partnership/Behavior Therapy and Learning Center, provided staff training on August 19-21, 1997. Specific curriculum, goals, objectives and a setting were to be addressed at the continued IEP meetings. On August 21, 1997, the IEP meetings for both children were reconvened. The IEP teams, including Tracee Parker, developed a specific program and drafted goals and objectives for both Students. The Autism Partnership Recommendations Curriculum Plan (APRCP) was to be utilized to increase attending, communication and play skills. Discrete Trial Training and Positive Reinforcement techniques were also to be used. Each boy was to receive adaptive physical education two times per week for 30 minutes and speech and language services 30 minutes a week. Their full-time aides, who had previously been provided by the District, were continued. Student 1 and Student 2 were placed in an SDC for the severely disabled. It was determined that the boys required a very small, structured environment to work on their goals and objectives. A room was designed for the exclusive use of Student 1 and Student 2 and their instructional assistants pursuant to the recommendation of Ms. Parker. Mainstreaming was to occur 5% of the day and would begin in the SDC. With the parents’ agreement, this program continued throughout the fifth grade. The boys have consistently had extensive school absences and tardies because it is difficult for their parents to get them ready and to school in the mornings. Las Virgenes has delayed the time at which the Respondents begin school in an effort to accommodate this problem. However, the extreme number of absences continues and affects the boys’ ability to benefit from their educational program.
On February 25, 1998, an IEP meeting was held to plan for Student 1's and Student 2's transition to middle school in the fall. The District proposed that their current IEP remain the same and be implemented in the boys’ home school, A. E. Wright Middle School (hereinafter Wright). The parents agreed with the proposed IEP but disagreed with the proposed school site. They wanted their children to attend Lindero Canyon Middle School (hereinafter Lindero) on an intradistrict school choice program, as had their daughter. The parents’ request for their children to attend Lindero was denied by the District due to overcrowding at the school and the consequent inability to provide the individual room required for Respondents’ IEP programs. Thereafter, Mr. and Mrs. Parent filed for a due process hearing on behalf of their sons and obtained a “stay-put” order continuing the children in their elementary school placement. These cases are still pending. Las Virgenes filed the instant cases, naming Student 1 and Student 2 as respondents, over the same issue of site placement. The boys currently remain on an elementary campus pursuant to a “stay put” order. All parties agree that this is an inappropriate campus for boys who are chronologically and physically the age of middle school children.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Las Virgenes contends that it is offering an appropriate placement at their home school where the Students can continue their agreed upon IEPs. The boys each have their own full time aides who are trained to work them and monitor safety concerns. The District states that it cannot implement the boys’ required program at the school site requested by the parents because that school is overcrowded and there is no area available for the separate room required by the Respondents and their aides. The District further alleges that it denied Respondents’ request for an intradistrict transfer, in the normal course of business, pursuant to the district’s intradistrict transfer policy.(Footnote 1)
Respondents contend that the site proposed by the District is not safe for them to attend. It is not a secure campus and has many open exits that lead to a parking lot, a public street, a creek, the District’s bus maintenance area, new home construction and an ambulance company. The Respondents further contend that they must walk to school to eliminate excess energy before school begins. Wright is farther from their home and attendance there would require a bus ride. Their school of choice, Lindero, is approximately 1.6 miles from their home and a familiar walk to them. Finally, the Respondents state that it would be dangerous for them to ride the school bus each day to attend their home school, Wright middle school.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Did the District offer Student 1 and Student 2 a free and appropriate public education (hereinafter FAPE) when it offered placement at A. E. Wright Middle School for the 1998-99 school year?
Under both federal and state law, students with disabilities have the right to a free and appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. §1401(8), “free and appropriate public education” means special education and related services that meet the standards of the State educational agency and conform with the student’s individualized educational program. “Special education” is defined as “specially designed instruction at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability. . . . ” 20 U.S.C. §1401(25).
The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective and supportive services which may be required to assist a child with a disability benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. §1401(22). California Education Code §56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” Included in the list of related services are speech and language, orientation and mobility, physical and occupational therapy, counseling, health and nursing services, social worker services, adapted physical education and psychological services. Additional services may include behavioral intervention services and case management.
In the case of Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. vs. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175, (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child’s potential. The Court held that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.” Rowley, supra at page 201.
In determining whether a district has offered a free, appropriate, public education, one must focus on the adequacy of the district’s proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307 (9th Cir. 1987). If the district’s program is adequate, the district has offered a free, appropriate, public education, even if the parents prefer another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would likely result in greater educational benefit to the child than the district’s program.
Special education law also requires that a student must be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment may occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. §1412(a)(5)(A); Education Code §56031.
An application of special education statutory law and the Rowley decision results in a four pronged method for determining whether a child was offered an appropriate placement under IDEA: (1) the placement must be designed to meet the student’s unique needs; (2) it must provide the student with some educational benefit; (3) it must conform to the student’s individual education program, and; (4) it must be provided in the least restrictive environment. Rowley, supra; 20 U.S.C. §1400 et seq.
The parties agree that the majority of the Respondents’ unique needs have been properly identified. The IEP team has determined that the Student’s needs are in the areas of increasing their attending, compliance, follow-through skills, improving their language and communication, developing play and social skills, enhancing task completion and stress management abilities, as well as increasing their safety skills. It has also been decided that Student 1 and Student 2 need designated instructional services in the areas of adaptive physical education and speech and language. Each boy requires his own trained instructional assistant for the entire school day to help with his IEP goals. An assistive technology assessment was obtained and a computer has been provided by the District for the boys’ home. Computers are also to be utilized in the school environment. The IEP participants feel that it is mandatory that the boys have a “home room” of their own where they can work on their IEP goals with their aides without distractions. They also need this private space to control and calm their behaviors and to keep themselves and others around them safe. Opportunities for as much mainstreaming as each boy can tolerate is to be provided. Mainstreaming attempts are to begin by including the boys in a special day class whenever possible. The school hours for the Respondents have been decreased to accommodate their poor attendance and tardiness.
The parties have reached agreement on the goals and objectives for Student 1 and Student 2. They also agree that the IEPs are being implemented and that the boys are receiving educational benefit. There is no dispute concerning the need for an individual classroom for the Respondents nor a claim that this is contrary to the requirement of providing education for disabled children in the least restrictive environment. The issues in dispute are the potential dangers at the Wright middle school site, transportation and the boys’ need to walk to school. The District also contends that the availability of an individual classroom renders Wright a more appropriate placement. Respondents contend that the District must make space available at Lindero. The District believes that Student 1’s and Student 2’s programs should be implemented at their home school. The Respondents feel that Wright is unsafe and attendance at that campus necessitates a bus ride. They believe that the appropriate campus to meet their needs is Lindero. The Hearing Officer will therefore limit the discussion to whether the proposed placement at Wright is safe, whether the Respondents can be transported to school by bus verses walking to school, and whether an existing, available single classroom at Respondent’s home school is a relevant factor when determining an appropriate placement for the boys.
Neither a determination of the home school location, as argued by the District, nor a finding that a particular school site is the closest distance to a special education child’s home, as asserted by the Respondents, by itself, determines the most appropriate placement. The ultimate question is whether the proposed placement is the least restrictive, meets the child’s unique needs and enables implementation of their IEP See: Poolaw v. Bishop, 67 F.3d 830 (9th Circuit 1995) finding that placement 280 miles from the student’s home was necessary to accommodate his needs and not a violation of 34 C.F.R. §300.552(a)(3), which requires placement as close as possible to the child’s home; Barnett v. Fairfax County School Board, 927 F.2d 158 (4th Circuit 1991) rejecting the parents contention that placing their child in a school five miles farther from their home was inappropriate; Fisher v. Rochester Community Schools, 780 F. Supp. 1142 (Michigan 1991),which held that there was no home school entitlement for a special education child; Murray v. Montrose County School District, 51 F.3d 921 (10th Circuit 1995) finding that although the neighborhood school is preferred, it was appropriate to place a child in a school located ten miles from their home when the child’s IEP necessitated placement at that location; Schuldt v. Mankato School District, 937 F.2d 1357 (8th Circuit 1991) holding that the IDEA did not require school districts to place a disabled child in the school closest to their home, but rather, at a school that could implement their program.
Respondents claim that Wright is inappropriate because it does not provide a safe environment for their particular disabilities. One of the manifestations of a Respondent’s autism is elopement. The children may attempt to escape from their room or the person accompanying them. Mr. Parent testified that the area by the boys’ proposed classroom at Wright is immediately bordered by a parking lot that also provides the access to the District’s bus maintenance yard. The fence separating the classrooms in this area from the parking lot has multiple gates. The maintenance yard itself is located behind the middle school. This area also has several gates between the school and the maintenance facility. The school’s parking lot is used for access by an ambulance company to get to its parking area. A bank descending to a creek runs behind the maintenance yard. The front of the school faces open, undeveloped rolling hills. The school is set back from a two-lane road with a 45mph speed limit. Mr. Parent testified that this road is a main thoroughfare to the ocean. Mr. and Mrs. Parent are very concerned that their children could run away from their aides, escape through an open gate and suffer harm from a vehicle or other danger.
Scott Shepard was hired by the Respondents to provide an evaluation. He is employed by a company called Visions. He has a bachelor of arts degree in psychology with a master’s degree and a teaching credential in special education. His work history is in the area of autism. Mr. Shepard spent time one Saturday at the home of Student 1 and Student 2 and walked to Lindero school with them. He also visited the two middle schools at issue. On the subject of elopement, Mr. Shepard testified on direct examination that on the walk to Lindero, Student 1 started running to apartment doors and Student 2 would run to cars and try to get into them. The children attempted to run frequently, so traffic safety was a big concern. It was necessary to try to anticipate their movements. The boys’ pace varied between a walk, a jog and a run. Mr. Shepard also testified that the boys would find an opportunity to exit regardless of the school they attended because “they are gifted at escaping.” He confirmed that one time on a highway could result in great danger to the boys and that they had no awareness of traffic speeds. He stated that the parents had told him that The Respondents “go AWOL” from their home several times a month and the police must be called to locate them. On cross-examination, Mr. Shepard testified that the walk from the Student’s home to Lindero was approximately one and one-half miles each way along a four-lane thoroughfare. There are two intersections controlled by traffic signals and numerous residential street crossings. For the last 3/4 of a mile of the walk, Student 1 settled down somewhat and did not run to as many doors. Student 2’s attempts to run never diminished throughout the walk. Both children attempted to dart into the street. Mr. Shepard stated that he had no knowledge that the boys had ever attempted to escape their school campus.The District points out that the Respondents have never eloped from their campus. They are accompanied at all times by one-on-one aides who are trained to supervise their safety. Several witnesses called by Las Virgenes provided testimony pertaining to the childrens’ inclination to run. Steffi Brantly has been both the aide and the relief aide for the Respondents. She confirmed that the boys could quickly run away. She also testified that the eloping had decreased during the prior year and that she could always catch the boys. Ms. Brantly stated that the boys had never attempted to run into a street or leave the campus and that, if they did take off, it was toward other classrooms. However, Student 2 was particularly intrigued by a red sports car that parked in the school’s parking lot and he would try to reach it. Diane Squire is an SDC teacher at the boys’ elementary school. She has been a special education teacher for eleven years. Ms. Squire testified that the Students always had direct supervision at school. She further stated that the boys had never attempted to elope from campus, although there had been occasions when they eloped to other parts of the campus. Joe Nardo, director of special education for Las Virgenes, testified that although the boys were runners, they had never attempted to escape from their unfenced campus. He also testified that the aides received training in all of the boys’ needs, including their propensity to elope. As a result of this training, they were far more successful at controlling any attempts by the boys to run. Ms. Parker also testified on the issue of safety. As previously stated, Ms. Parker is from Autism Partnership and she is the consultant hired by the District to assist with creating programs for the Students, drafting their goals and objectives, and monitoring their programs. Ms. Parker has worked with the boys since 1997. When questioned about the physical layout of a campus as it related to the safety of Student 1 and Student 2, Ms Parker testified that she could “take almost any environment and make it safe.” Although Ms. Parker agreed that safety was a primary concern, she felt she could work around any safety concerns presented on a school site. Ms. Parker stated that community safety was a significant issue on the boys’ IEPs. Consequently, anyone who worked with them was trained that they were never to give Student 1 or Student 2 an opportunity to elope. Allowing them to escape should not happen because chasing them when they ran became a reinforcer for them to attempt to escape again. Therefore, their aides escorted them at all times by walking arm and arm with them. The goal was to reduce this physical connection as they began to respond to verbal commands. According to Ms. Parker, Student 1 and Student 2 have been showing significant improvement in the area of safety. Ms. Parker meets with Mr. and Mrs. Parent once a month and visits the boys’ classroom once a month. She also attends their IEP meetings as well as any other necessary meetings. On her most recent visit with Student 1 and Student 2, they were doing well with their ability to respond to verbal commands rather than needing complete arm-and-arm escorting to prevent running. Ms. Parker stated that she observed them stop on command and felt that this developing skill should be further encouraged.
When considering the testimony of the Respondents’ expert, Scott Shepard, and that of the District’s witness, Tracee Parker, the Hearing Officer finds Ms. Parker to be more persuasive regarding the safety needs of The Respondents. Ms Parker has worked with Student 1 and Student 2 for a substantial period of time. She is the autism expert whom both parties agreed to utilize, and upon whom they relied upon in creating and implementing programs for the boys. She has drafted IEP goals and objectives for the Respondents as well as the strategies to accomplish them. Her information about the boys comes from her own knowledge and observations as well as from the parents and school personnel. She has provided training for the parents and the District staff who work with the Students. Ms. Parker testified that she could address any safety concerns on the Wright campus. In contrast, Mr. Shepard was retained to provide a single consultation. Thus, his familiarity with Student 1 and Student 2 is extremely limited. All of his historical information was essentially provided by Mr. and Mrs. Parent. Although he had read some reports about the Respondents, he had not spoken with any of their teachers or aides. He was advised of the Respondents’ preferred campus in advance of his consultation and knew the dispute over the campus was the purpose of his retention. His instructions were to go for a walk with the boys, do a behavior assessment and view both Wright and Lindero middle schools.
Respondents argued in their closing statement that Lindero would be easier to escape from than Wright. However, they claim that once they did escape, they would be safer in the Lindero neighborhood because it is residential. This is not a convincing argument. The District established that Lindero middle school shares its campus with an elementary school. The school operates on a staggered attendance schedule to accommodate this duel use of the campus. Lindero is surrounded by narrow residential streets that must absorb the substantial traffic resulting from a total of four pick-up and drop-off times. In contrast, Wright has its own drop-off road between the playing field and the buildings of the school. The students do not enter from a public street. Because the Lindero campus houses both an elementary and middle school on the same site, there are several times during the school day when the walkways are extremely crowded during transitions between classes. These crowded conditions could make it easier for the children to get away from their aides and be harder to see if they did escape into a crowd. The boys’ classroom at Wright would be near a fence with open gates that access a parking lot. The District states that these gates can be locked if necessary. To reach the bus maintenance area behind Wright, the boys would need to transverse the length of the parking lot or walk past the school buildings and cross an open grass field. The vision of the aide who always accompanies them would be unobstructed in both of these directions. It would be difficult to lose sight of them even if they did break away from their assistants. This is different from Lindero where the immediate surrounding neighborhood is very densely populated with many places in which the boys could be lost from view. The Respondents’ contention that Wright is not a safe campus for them is premised solely on an allegation that they could escape from the campus and encounter off-site dangers. Despite this concern expressed by Mr. Parent, neither Student 1 nor Student 2 has ever eloped from a school campus, nor have they attempted to do so.
An analysis of the above facts persuades the Hearing Officer that Lindero, the campus advocated by Respondents, is not safer for Student 1 and Student 2 than their home school, Wright. On the Wright campus, the Respondents would be accompanied at all times by aides who are trained to prevent elopement. All of the parties agree that neither Student 1 nor Student 2 has ever left a District campus. Ms. Parker testified that the attempts by the boys to escape had diminished and she had observed them respond to verbal commands to stop. Mr. Shepard testified that “the boys will find an opportunity to exit whichever school they go to.” He further testified that any environment has the potential for danger and there can be no complete guarantees of safety. Recognizing the validity of Mr. Shepard’s statement that there can be no absolute assurance of anyone’s safety, the Hearing Officer must consider the known facts rather than speculation of potential dangers the boys might encounter.
The Respondents also object to taking a bus to school. They feel they may be unable to properly behave on a school bus. Respondents further contend that Lindero is located only a mile and a half from their home and that they should attend the school that is in closer proximity to their home. Attending school at Wright would require a bus ride of several miles. Respondents claim that riding the school bus may be very difficult for them and could create even more problems with attendance. In addition, walking to Lindero with their parents each day would familiarize them with the stores and people they encounter in their neighborhood. They also maintain that riding a bus would deprive them of the relaxing benefit of walking to school. Mr. Parent testified that walking to school is necessary for Student 1 and Student 2 to burn off energy before school begins and could help them be better behaved when they arrive at school.
In the opinion of Mr. Shepard, walking to school would be a good strategy for Student 1 and Student 2 to gain community awareness and for the community to become more familiar with them. He also stated that walking to school could help with their attendance problems, because the parents would have more flexibility in getting them to school. If they attended Lindero and they were late, they could still walk to school, but if they missed the bus for Wright, they might miss school entirely. He felt the bus might not wait for them because it would contain other children on a schedule. If the Respondents were not ready and they missed the bus in the morning, it would “just be too bad.” Mr. Shepard also expressed concerns about the boys’ safety on a bus. He provided hearsay information, conveyed to him by the parents, that the children had problems when riding in the family car. He also expressed a concern that if the boys were not well-behaved on the bus, the District would attempt to put them in harnesses to restrain them. On cross-examination, Mr. Shepard stated that he could not say without observing a bus ride, whether riding a school bus would be more dangerous than walking to Lindero. He did not know that Student 1 and Student 2 had ridden school buses on field trips without incident. However, he stated that he did not find this information helpful because the boys could be well behaved at first, and then later becoming disruptive as the ride ceased to be a novelty. He stated that the Students might grab the steering wheel, hit, pull hair or act out in other aggressive ways as they reportedly had done in the family car. Although Mr. Shepard recognized that each child would have his own aide on the bus, he thought that even this might not be adequate. Mr. Shepard knew that the boys presently walked to their elementary school and admitted that this had not improved their serious attendance problems. He also acknowledged that the benefits gained from walking to school could be addressed with equal success by providing an exercise time when the Respondents arrived at school. Mr. Shepard stated that another purpose of having the childrens’ school closer to their home was that the parents could reach them sooner if an emergency arose.
Las Virgenes presented three witnesses who provided testimony about Student 1’s and Student 2’s behavior on a school bus. Steffi Brantley, a special education aide at Sumac Elementary School, recalled a field trip the boys attended that required a twenty- to a thirty-minute bus ride each direction. She stated that both of the Respondents sat quietly with their aides the entire ride and did not cause any problems. Diane Squire, a special day teacher at Sumac, also testified about the field trip bus ride. She said that the Students did not have any problems on the bus despite the potential distraction of having special education children from three different schools on the bus. Their aides sat next to them and they were very compliant. They seemed to enjoy the ride and liked looking out the windows. Andrea Lafazia, another special education teacher at Sumac, testified that she had been with the boys on two different bus rides. Both times, Student 1 and Student 2 sat in their seats, they were well behaved, and they displayed no inappropriate behavior. Mr. Parent testified that the decision to attempt the field trips on the bus followed several discussions between the parents and Sumac school staff. On both occasions, prior to putting the children on the bus, he and Mrs. Parent took them to a fast food restaurant to eat and play. By prior arrangement, the parents brought the boys home after the field trip.
Ms. Parker testified that in May 1998 she felt that both Student 1 and Student 2 were doing so well with community safety that she recommended community outings and taking the bus. At that time, she thought that the Respondents should begin taking the bus home from school with their aides accompanying them. Ms. Parker testified that she had emphasized the importance of Student 1 and Student 2 learning to ride the bus as it would probably be their primary mode of transportation throughout their lives. Mrs. Parent was uncomfortable with this suggestion, so the goal was not implemented. When Ms. Parker was asked about the boys walking to school rather than riding the school bus, Ms. Parker responded that they did not need to walk to school to burn off energy. Each of their IEPs already included physical activity to address this need when they arrived at school in the morning. Both Students enjoyed movement, so opportunities for extra physical activity were also used as a reward. Ms. Parker felt that because the aides would accompany the bus, riding the bus to school could be used as a way of solving the problem of getting the children to school on time and it would relieve some of the pressure on their parents. It could be necessary for the aides to actually go into the home and assist with getting Student 1 and Student 2 on the bus. Another option would be for them to begin taking the bus home from school and then adding the morning bus ride as appropriate.
Again, the Hearing Officer finds Ms. Parker more credible on the issue of bus transportation. The Hearing Officer is also persuaded that it would be beneficial for Student 1 and Student 2 to develop the ability to ride a bus. Ms. Parker has been advocating familiarizing the Respondents with the bus since May 1998. She believes their skills have improved to the point where this is a legitimate goal. It is especially important for them to learn to ride a bus since she expects them to rely on bus transportation for community activities as they mature. Ms. Parker also thinks that riding the bus to school will improve the attendance of the Respondents and reduce the pressure on Mr. and Mrs. Parent. Where Ms. Parker’s testimony was predicated upon her familiarity with the Students, Mr. Shepard’s testimony regarding potential consequences of transporting the boys to school by bus was often speculative. Mr. Shepard’s opinion about how the children might behave on a school bus was an extrapolation from information the parents provided about their behavior in the family car. He acknowledged that the boys’ behavior in a car did not predict behavior on a school bus when each was accompanied by their own aide. His prediction that the boys would misbehave on the bus once the bus ride ceased to be a novelty was not founded on facts and it disregarded the evidence of their actual good behavior on a bus. Mr. Shepard did not address the importance of learning to ride a bus to the boys’ future independence. He was unable to explain why walking to middle school would improve the attendance of Student 1 and Student 2 when it had not reduced their frequent absences in elementary school. Mr. Shepard’s description of his walk with the boys was intended to establish their propensity to elope. Instead, it emphasized the dangers they would be exposed to on a street. Unlike the safety risks the Respondents would encounter twice a day on the walk to Lindero, riding a bus to Wright would shelter them from traffic. His allegation that the District might restrain Student 1 ane Student 2 on the bus was complete speculation based upon his statement that other districts had done so. There was no evidence presented that the Las Virgenes school district intended to restrain these children.
A parent’s decision to walk his or her child to school is not usually discussed by the Hearing Officer. However, here, the Respondents argue that walking to school is one of their unique needs and, therefore, they must attend a school that is close to their home. One of the primary reasons that Mr. Parent and Mr. Shepard felt the Students should attend Lindero was that walking to school would eliminate excess energy and better enable them to focus in school. However, Mr. Shepard agreed that this could also be accomplished by scheduling physical activity as the first part of their school program. Ms. Parker testified that this had already been incorporated into the IEPs of Student 1 and Student 2. Unlike a substantial portion of Mr. Shepard’s testimony, his description of his actual walk to Lindero with the Respondents was not speculation, but rather, direct, credible observations that caused concern for the Hearing Officer. Student 1 has an attraction to doors and Student 2’s attraction is to cars. Mr. Shepard stated that Student 1 ran to many apartment doors. Student 2 ran to cars and tried to get into them. Both boys attempted to run frequently and the adults had to try to anticipate their movements to keep them safe. He stated that the boys are “gifted at escaping” and they are unaware of traffic speeds or traffic safety. The street on which Student 1 and Student 2 would walk to Lindero is a four-lane boulevard with turn lanes. There are two signal lights and numerous residential streets to cross on the way to the school. Both children darted into the street, which Mr. Shepard acknowledged was a dangerous activity. Mr. Shepard could not state whether it would be safer for Student 1 and Student 2 to ride a bus or walk to school. The Hearing Officer finds that the dangers inherent in taking the walk described by Mr. Shepard two times each day, outweighs the speculations of dangers which could exist on either the school bus or the campus of Wright middle school.(Footnote 2)
All of the parties agree that the Respondents require their own classroom. Ms. Parker provided informative testimony on the importance of this separate space to the boys’ IEP goals. She testified that Student 1 and Student 2 require a room for themselves and their assistants to use as a home room. This room is necessary so they will have a place to go when they are experiencing stress, exhibiting difficult behaviors or in need of a quiet environment and the absence of distractions. The home room also keeps the boys and others around them safe. Ms. Parker stated that the home room continues to be an integral part of both childrens’ programs. When the Respondents were fully included, they had extensive problems with acting out that included hurting others. The goal is for Student 1 and Student 2 to “venture out” as they are capable and to provide them with as many integration opportunities as they can handle. Ms. Parker stated that it is critical that the boys have a home room to which they can return. She believes that the availability of a self-contained room on the campus attended by the Students is far more important to their goals than the physical layout of the campus. An individual classroom, required for the implementation of Student 1’s and Student 2’s IEPs, is available at Wright. Wright is the preferred “home school” that they would attend if they were not disabled. This is additional evidence that the District’s offer to place the boys at Wright is an appropriate placement for Student 1 and Student 2.
CONCLUSION
For the above reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has offered Student 1 and Student 2 an appropriate placement at Wright middle school. However, the Hearing Officer also recognizes the genuine and heartfelt anxiety Mr. and Mrs. Parent have about the safety of their sons. The parties have never convened an IEP meeting to discuss the concerns expressed by the parents regarding transportation and safety on the Wright campus. They must do so. IEP goals and objectives must be drafted specifying how the bus transportation for the boys will be accomplished with clear, short-term methods for evaluating its success. Goals and objectives are also necessary to respond to the issue of open gates and other safety concerns enumerated by Mr. and Mrs. Parent.
ORDER
1. A. E. Wright Middle School is an appropriate placement for Student 1 and Student 2 for the remainder of the 1998-99 school year.
2. Within two weeks of the date of this decision, the IEP team shall meet and develop procedures to address the parents’ safety concerns, including their specific concern that the Respondents may escape through the open gates located between the boys’ classroom and the parking lot. The IEP team shall also develop goals and objectives to assist with getting the children on the school bus in the mornings and to address any behavior and safety issues which may arise on the bus. The IEP goals pertaining to the bus transportation shall include clear, measurable, short-term goals to allow frequent assessment of Student 1’s and Student 2’s transportation needs.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code §56507(d), this decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement: The District prevailed on the only issue heard and decided, with the exception of the limited modifications that the Hearing Officer ordered to the IEPs of the Respondents to address the issue of open gates and bus transportation.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code §56505(i).
Dated:_________________________ _____________________________________ Glenna Eubank deCamara, Hearing Officer, Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law
Footnote 1:The District offered substantial testimony pertaining to its intradistict transfer policy. It is undisputed that Wright is the home school for the Respondents. The District’s policy for approving intradistrict transfer requests is based upon space available at the receiving school and the application of priorities assigned to the requesting students. Las Virgenes’ evidence that Lindero’s student population is beyond its intended capacity was uncontradicted. The Respondents made no claim to any of the classifications that give priorities to students requesting an intradistrict transfer. There was no evidence that Las Virgenes applied its school choice policy toward the Respondents in a biased manner, as alleged by Mr. Parent. However, the relevant question is whether the District’s offer to place the boys at Wright satisfies its obligation to offer a free and appropriate education under the IDEA, not whether the District followed its internal policy on intradistrict transfer requests. The Hearing Officer is not persuaded by the District’s argument that the Respondents cannot attend Lindero school because District policy prohibits this transfer. As will be discussed, the pertinent question is whether it’s offer of the Wright middle school site meets the unique needs of Student 1 and Student 2.
Footnote 2: The Respondents argued that the District must make any necessary modifications so that their preferred campus, Lindero, could accommodate them. Because it has been determined that the District offered the Respondents a FAPE, it is not necessary to address this issue. The Hearing Officer notes, however, the case of Schuldt v. Mankato, supra, which contained a similar issue. The parents in Schultz were seeking structural modifications of their neighborhood school so their daughter could attend that school in her wheelchair. She also required additional space for her equipment and a private room for her therapy and medical needs. The court held that the IDEA gives “the school district discretion in selecting the location where it will educate a handicapped child.” The court went on to state that “by busing Erika to one of several nearby schools, the school district is already providing Erika with a fully integrated public education, thereby meeting its obligation under the act.”
