California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 25, 2002

Student v. Ocean View Elementary School District et al. (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 1394-01, SN00-01316, SN01-01394, SN01-01634, SN01-02087 · Hearing Officer Vincent L. Pastorino

Ocean View Elementary offered FAPE through a partial special day class placement at Marine View and may assess without parent consent.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

Footnote 1 says the decision was amended to correct typographical errors, including school-year designations in the Issue 3 headings and wording fixes; the decision states these changes do not affect its substance. A related District-filed assessment case, SN 462-01, had been voluntarily dismissed earlier.

Summary

A 13-year-old boy with autism attended the Speech and Language Development Center (SLDC), a nonpublic agency, under a 1999 settlement with Ocean View Elementary School District and the West Orange County Consortium for Special Education (WOCCSE). The family filed three cases, which were consolidated with a district case. For 2000-2001 and 2001-2002, the district offered Marine View Middle School. The offer combined Linda Franklin's special day class (SDC) with general education periods, a full-time one-on-one aide, speech-language therapy, consultation services and community-based instruction. The family wanted full inclusion at Spring View, the neighborhood school, with no SDC. In February 2001 the father removed the student from SLDC and started a home program.

After 23 hearing days, the Hearing Officer found that both offers provided FAPE in the least restrictive environment. He applied the Rachel H. factors and gave more weight to SLDC staff, who had taught the student for nearly two years, than to the family's experts, who had seen him only briefly outside school. He rejected requests for more speech therapy, sign language, horseback riding and aquatic therapy. He also held that a laptop could wait for an assistive technology assessment. The district did not violate stay put, and failed IEP meetings resulted mainly from the father's own actions. The claims for reimbursement and compensatory education were moot. The district may conduct its September 4, 2001 triennial assessment without consent, and the father must make the student available within 30 days.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO applied the Rachel H. factors to a full-inclusion request. It gave more weight to staff who had taught the student in a classroom than to experts who saw him briefly at home. It also shows a district winning an order for a triennial assessment over a parent's demand for an ecological-only assessment.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1. Did the District offer a FAPE to the Student in the least restrictive environment for the 2000-2001 school year?

    The Marine View SDC-based offer with integration, a full-time aide and related services met the student's unique needs and was the LRE under Rachel H. The District did not violate stay put when the father removed the student from SLDC. Failed IEP meetings and the lack of an assessment did not deny FAPE.

  2. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2. Did the District offer a FAPE to the Student in the least restrictive environment for the 2001-2002 school year?

    The July 9, 2001 offer (2 SDC periods, 4 general education periods and 2 vocational periods at Marine View, plus services) provided FAPE in the LRE. Missing a general education teacher at the May 7 meeting and the classroom observation dispute did not deny FAPE.

  3. Issue 3. If the District failed to offer the Student a FAPE in the least restrictive environment for the 2000-2001 and/or 2001-2002 school years, is the Student entitled to reimbursement for private services and/or compensatory education?

    Moot because the District offered FAPE in both school years.

  4. Issue 4. Is the District entitled to complete the triennial assessment proposed in the assessment plan dated September 4, 2001, submitted by the District and WOCCSE?

    The plan met Education Code requirements and appropriately combined standardized and ecological assessment. The District may assess without parent consent.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order that district may assess without consent. The District may conduct a triennial assessment under its proposed assessment plan dated September 4, 2001 (D/W Ex. A-2, as explained in D/W Ex. A-14). The father must make the student available for the assessment within 30 days of the decision.
  • All of the Student's requests for relief are denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist. No. 23; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H.; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Andress v. Cleveland Independent School Dist.

People named in the decision

  • Marilou Lundberg, coordinator of special education, Ocean View Elementary School District
  • James Hemsley, director, WOCCSE
  • Diane Browder, Ph.D., expert witness for Student (special education)
  • Judith Heumann, witness for Student; former assistant secretary of education, U.S. Department of Education (former)
  • Cameron Malotte, principal, Spring View Middle School
  • Lynn Trittipo, school psychologist, Ocean View Elementary School District
  • Bernadette Kennard, speech and language specialist, Speech and Language Development Center, Buena Park
  • Dawn O'Connor, program director, Speech and Language Development Center, Buena Park
  • Wayne Sailor, Ph.D., expert witness for Student (inclusion), University of Kansas
  • Terri Olsen, special education classroom teacher, Speech and Language Development Center, Buena Park
  • Kathleen Gee, Ph.D., expert witness for Student (special education), St. Mary's College of California
  • Evelyn Del Rosario, occupational therapist, Speech and Language Development Center, Buena Park
  • Carol Atkins, clinical audiologist, witness for Student
  • Anthony Busacca, therapeutic horseback riding instructor, witness for Student
  • Patricia Tipton, supervisor of speech-language pathology, Speech and Language Development Center, Buena Park
  • Lou Brown, Ph.D., expert witness for Student (special education)
  • Julie Appel, physical therapist, witness for Student
  • Patricia Pfeiffer, speech-language pathologist, Speech and Language Development Center, Buena Park
  • Blair Rodgers, independent consultant, witness for Student
  • Ann Carr, inclusion facilitator, Ocean View Elementary School District
  • Elizabeth Williams, principal, Marine View Middle School
  • Judy Acocello, R.N., school nurse, Ocean View Elementary School District
  • Linda Franklin, special day class teacher, Marine View Middle School
  • Jennifer Caruso, adapted physical education specialist, Ocean View Elementary School District
  • Patty Mulcahy, occupational therapist, Ocean View Elementary School District / WOCCSE
  • Tricia Larsen, speech and language specialist, Ocean View Elementary School District
  • Karen Anne Sheetz, deaf and hard of hearing specialist / itinerant teacher, WOCCSE
  • Gina Cataldo, school psychologist, Ocean View Elementary School District
  • Kathy Dryden, speech-language and assistive technology specialist, Ocean View Elementary School District
  • Presta Perez, general education teacher at July 9, 2001 IEP meeting, Ocean View Elementary School District
  • Lou Barber, classroom observer identified by father
  • Speech and Language Development Center (SLDC), Buena Park, nonpublic agency; student's placement 1999–February 2001
  • California Ranch School, home-school program administering student's home program
  • College of Optometry, Fullerton, proposed vision assessor in assessment plan

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, on April 11, May 22, 23, 24, 29, 30, and 31, June 12, 13, and 29, October 16, 18, 19, 23, 24, and 25, November 27, 28, 29, and 30, and December 4, 5, and 6, 2001, in Huntington Beach, California.

Petitioner/Cross-Respondent (STUDENT or Student) was represented at the hearing by attorneys Steven Wyner, Richard Teitel, and Carol Hickman Graham.(Footnote 2) Also present on behalf of the Petitioner were his father, FATHER, and STEPMOTHER.(Footnote 3) Respondent/Cross-Petitioners Ocean View Elementary School District (District) and West Orange County Consortium for Special Education (WOCCSE) were represented at the hearing by attorneys Bridget Flanagan and Benjamin Kim from the office of Miller, Brown & Dannis.(Footnote 4) Also present on behalf of the District was Marilou Lundberg, coordinator of special education for the District. Present on behalf of both the District and WOCCSE was James Hemsley, director of WOCCSE.

The Student called the following witnesses: Ms. Lundberg; Diane Browder, Ph.D. in special education; Judith Heumann, former assistant secretary of education, U.S. Department of Education; Mr. Hemsley; Cameron Malotte, principal at Spring View Middle School (Spring View); Lynn Trittipo, school psychologist at the District; Bernadette Kennard, speech and language specialist at Speech and Language Development Center in Buena Park (SLDC); Dawn O’Connor, program director at SLDC; Wayne Sailor, Ph.D. in psychology; STEPMOTHER; Terri Olsen, special education teacher at SLDC; Kathleen Gee, Ph.D. in special education; Evelyn Del Rosario, occupational therapy (OT) specialist at SLDC; Carol Atkins, clinical audiologist; Anthony Busacca, master level therapeutic horseback riding instructor; Patricia Tipton, speech and langauge pathologist at SLDC; Lou Brown, Ph.D. in special education; Julie Appel, physical therapist; FATHER (father); Patricia Pfeiffer, speech and language pathologist at SLDC; and Blair Rodgers, independent consultant.

The District/WOCCSE called the following witnesses: Ms. O’Conner; Ms. Pfeiffer; Ms. Del Rosario; Ms. Lundberg; Ann Carr, inclusion facilitator at the District; Elizabeth Williams, principal at Marine View Middle School (Marine View); Judy Acocello, school nurse at the District; Linda Franklin, special education teacher at Marine View; Jennifer Caruso, adaptive physical education specialist at the District; Ms. Trittipo; Patty Mulcahy, OT specialist at the District; Tricia Larsen, speech and language specialist at the District; Karen Anne Sheetz, deaf and hard of hearing specialist at WOCCSE; Gina Cataldo, school psychologist at the District; Kathy Dryden, speech and language and assistive technology specialist at the District; and Mr. Hemsley.

Extensive oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open until the Hearing Officer’s receipt of written closing briefs on January 11, 2002.

PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

Case No. SN00-01316 was filed on July 19, 2000. Generally stated, the issue in that case was whether the District failed to offer the Student a “free appropriate public education” (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment for the 2000-2001 school year, as required by the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 U.S.C. Secs. 1400 et seq., and as required by State law. After numerous continuances, the hearing in Case No. SN00-01316 commenced with receipt of testimony on April 11, 2001.

Case No. SN01-01394 was filed by the Student on June 24, 2001. Generally stated, the issue in that case was whether the District failed to offer a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year. The Student filed Case No. SN01-01634 on July 18, 2001. The issue in that case was reimbursement for the 2000-2001 school year. By order dated August 2, 2001, cases SN00-01316 and SN01-01394 were consolidated. By order dated August 14, 2001, case SN01-01634 was consolidated with cases SN00-01316 and SN01-01394.

On September 25, 2001, the District/WOCCSE filed Case No. SN01-02087. By order dated October 8, 2001, case SN 01-02087 was consolidated with the three previously consolidated cases, SN00-01316, SN01-01394, and SN 01-01634.

ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING(Footnote 5)

(1) Did the District offer a FAPE to the Student in the least restrictive environment for the 2000-2001 school year?

(2) Did the District offer a FAPE to the Student in the least restrictive environment for the 2001-2002 school year?

(3) If the District failed to offer the Student a FAPE in the least restrictive environment for the 2000-2001 and/or 2001-2002 school years, is the Student entitled to reimbursement for private services and/or compensatory education?

(4) Is the District entitled to complete the triennial assessment proposed in the assessment plan dated September 4, 2001, submitted by the District and WOCCSE?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The Student alleges that the District failed to offer him a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year.(Footnote 6) More specifically, the Student alleges that the District committed one or more of the following acts or omissions: failed to offer a full continuum of placement options appropriate to the Student’s needs; failed to supervise and monitor the Student’s placement at SLDC; failed to take appropriate action to reverse the Student’s “de facto expulsion” from SLDC; failed to provide the Student with a full-time, one-on-one classroom aide; failed to allow the Student’s parents the opportunity to participate in IEP meetings; failed to complete IEP meetings; failed to conduct a timely and complete assessment of the Student in all areas of his suspected disabilities, including, but not limited to, a functional analysis assessment and an assistive technology assessment.

The Student also alleges that the District failed to offer him a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year. More specifically, the Student alleges that the District committed one or more of the following acts or omissions: failed to offer the Student a full continuum of placement options appropriate to his needs; failed to offer the Student an appropriately trained and full-time one-on-one classroom instructional aide; failed to provide the Student’s parents the opportunity to participate in the May 7, 2001 IEP meeting, including, but not limited to, providing only 1 ½ hours for that meeting, and failing to allow the Student’s father and his designees to observe proposed District classes prior to that meeting; failed to provide a regular education teacher at the IEP meetings for the school year; failed to propose a timely and complete assessment in all areas of the Student’s suspected disabilities; failed to develop appropriate goals and objectives to address all of the Student’s needs; failed to propose appropriate curriculum modifications; failed to provide an appropriate educational placement; and failed to offer sufficient designated instruction and services (DIS) in the areas of speech and language, reading, assistive technology (i.e. voice output laptop computer), and therapeutic recreational therapy.(Footnote 7)

The Student asserts that for the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years, he was not offered a placement in the least restrictive environment (LRE). The Student asserts that he should have been offered a placement in his neighborhood school (Spring View) in classroom settings other than that of a special day class (SDC), with a trained one-on-one instructional assistant. For both school years, he asserts that the LRE would have consisted of community-based programs and regular education classes, with no portion of the school day being in an SDC.

The District and WOCCSE dispute all of the Student’s contentions. They assert that the program offers, including the combination of SDC and regular education classes at Marine View, constituted an offer for FAPE in the LRE.

Regarding assessment, the District and WOCCSE assert that the District is entitled to assess the Student in accordance with their proposed assessment plan dated September 4, 2001. The Student objects to the type of assessment offered, and he claims that an “ecological assessment,” consisting of assessment in regular education classes and other environments, is required.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT, born [date redacted], is eligible for special education and related services as a child with autism.(Footnote 8) STUDENT’s grade level in public school for the 2001-2002 school year, on the basis of his age, would be eighth grade. STUDENT attended District classes and received special education services from the District in preschool, kindergarten, first grade, and a portion of second grade. In preschool, he was placed in an SDC. From kindergarten through a portion of second grade, he was in regular education classes and received support services. He was home-schooled under the auspices of California Ranch School for the remainder of second grade and all of third, fourth and fifth grade. The only service provided by the District during STUDENT’s home-school years through fifth grade was OT.

Pursuant to a general release and settlement agreement dated April 30, 1999, between STUDENT, the District, and WOCCSE, STUDENT began attending SLDC for the 1999-2000 sixth-grade school year on or about July 6, 1999. (District/WOCCSE [D/W] Ex. A.) Related services at SLDC, as specified in the settlement agreement, included a 6-hour one-on-one aide, 3 hours per week of speech and language therapy, up to 2 hours per week of OT, and transportation.(Footnote 9)

The settlement agreement specified that “STUDENT qualifies for special education and related services. . . . Pursuant to 20 USC Sec. 1400 the parties agree not to conduct a formal triennial re-evaluation to establish STUDENT’s continuing eligibility. STUDENT’s next triennial evaluation would be scheduled for 2/01.” The settlement agreement provided that the District would convene an IEP meeting at SLDC within 45 days to establish present levels of performance and goals and objectives. The settlement agreement also provided that the District would conduct an IEP meeting in April 2000 at SLDC for the purpose of determining placement for the 2000-2001 school year. The parties further agreed that SLDC would be the “stay put” placement if they could not agree upon placement for the 2000-2001 school year.

Although STUDENT received services at SLDC for the entire 1999-2000 school year, the parties never reached an agreement regarding present levels of performance or goals and objectives.(Footnote 10) Ms. O’Conner testified that her plan for STUDENT at SLDC was to continue working with the particular portions of goals and objectives that she felt SLDC and the father had agreed upon.

STUDENT’s speech and language status was summarized in an SLDC annual progress report dated January 15, 2000, written by Ms. Pfeiffer. (D/W Ex. D.) The report states that STUDENT, age 12, had been receiving individual (one-on-one) and small-group (two-on-one) therapy totaling 180 minutes per week. Positive behavioral modifications had been incorporated into the speech and language therapy. The report notes that goals and objectives had not been agreed upon. The report discusses STUDENT’s deficits in receptive language, expressive language, language pragmatics, attention, and behavior. His skills were described in terms of activities such as demonstrating comprehension of simple nouns and verbs during structured activities by pointing to pictures, following novel one-step directions involving 2 critical elements (i.e. “put the glasses in the bag”), saying and gesturing “hi” and “bye,” using a person’s name during greetings, answering yes/no or “wh” questions when given initial phonemic cues. About 90% of his spontaneous utterances at school were 1-2 words in length, but an increase in the frequency of three-or-more-word utterances had been observed in the past several months. Behaviors that interfered with STUDENT’s social interactions and learning experiences included bouncing, hitting his hand on the wall or table, clapping, vocal perseverations, pushing, and fleeing the room. The behaviors were induced by language breakdowns, transitions to new situations, and/or inconsistencies in the environment.

Ms. Pfeiffer submitted a followup report from SLDC dated April 15, 2000. (D/W Ex. F.) Speech and language sessions were being conducted in the classroom, in the speech room, and in conjunction with STUDENT’s OT sessions. The report quantified STUDENT’s current performance in the speech-language target skill areas. Ms. Pfeiffer concluded that STUDENT had made steady gains in all areas. His increased ability to attend and participate, according to Ms. Pfeiffer’s report, had significantly contributed to his success.

An annual OT progress report dated May 19, 2000, was submitted by Ms. Del Rosario from SLDC. (D/W Ex. G.) The report stated that STUDENT exhibited deficits in behavioral organization and ocular motor control. He remained easily distracted by physical or internal stimuli. He had difficulty with change or imposition, but that was decreasing. He required structure in order for him to interact effectively with his environment.

On May 24, 2000, and IEP meeting was held in preparation for the 2000-2001 school year. Several matters became apparent during the course of that meeting. First, STUDENT’s father wanted the program to include an environment with nondisabled peers for at least a portion of the school day.(Footnote 11) Inclusion with nondisabled peers could not be provided at SLDC. The father suggested a split program, with one or two periods at Spring View (STUDENT’s school of residence) and the remaining periods at SLDC. Second, SLDC representatives at that meeting concurred that STUDENT could benefit from association with nondisabled peers. However, they did not believe that a split program involving SLDC and a public school would benefit STUDENT. They stated that the logistics of such a program would be too complex, considering the schedules of each school and the problems STUDENT would face with transitions.(Footnote 12) Third, according to Mr. Hemsley’s testimony, since the District had not anticipated prior to the meeting that STUDENT would be requesting partial inclusion, the District did not have the appropriate personnel at that meeting to discuss such a program. Accordingly, the meeting was adjourned and continued to a later date. Mr. Hemsley testified that because STUDENT’s father clearly wanted SLDC or SLDC-type services for a portion of the day, only slight discussion occurred at that meeting regarding a full-inclusion option.

The IEP document generated from the May 24, 2000 IEP meeting (D/W Ex. H) is generally consistent with Mr. Hemsley’s description of the meeting, but it contains more details regarding the District’s position and shows that the District was already discounting the notion of including Spring View as a component of the placement offer. The IEP states that STUDENT was eligible under the category of multiple disabilities and that his next triennial evaluation was due in February 2001. The program recommendations by the District were for STUDENT to continue at SLDC through the extended school year, and then begin a program at Marine View on September 6, 2000. The Marine View program would consist of a combination of SDC and regular classes, with the frequency to be determined at a transition IEP meeting. The transition IEP meeting would be held by July 2000 to discuss placement at Marine View and to discuss the father’s proposals for goals and objectives. One-on-one support at Marine View would be determined. Twenty pages of proposed goals and objectives prepared on SLDC forms were attached to the IEP.

On May 24, 2000, the Student submitted to the District his own written set of goals and objectives for the areas of reading, academics/prevocational, mathematics, social/emotional, speech and language, linguistics, social/behavioral, self-help/independence, and recreational skills. (D/W Ex. LL.) Prior to the next IEP meeting, Ms. Lundberg blended the 20 pages of goals and objectives prepared on the SLDC forms (D/W Ex. H) with the goals and objectives submitted by the Student (D/W Ex. LL). The result, as described by Ms. Lundberg, was a set of goals and objectives reflecting goals and objectives previously discussed between and submitted by SLDC and the Student, but on WOCCSE forms and in a suitably measurable format. (D/W Ex. I, A-16.)

The next IEP meeting convened on June 22, 2000. (D/W Ex. I.) A notation on the IEP form recounts that the meeting was adjourned after 1½ hours because the father and STEPMOTHER would not allow the other members of the team to present goals and objectives without undue interruption. The time, according to the IEP notation, had been consumed by explanation of one goal and a rotating-block schedule. The blended set of goals and objectives prepared by Ms. Lundberg on behalf of the District were attached to the IEP form.

Following the failed June 22, 2000 IEP meeting, Mr. Hemsley sent a letter to the father dated July 6, 2000. (D/W Ex. J.) The purpose of the letter was to state the District’s offer of placement for the 2000-2001 school year. A similar letter, with modifications to the July 6 offer, was sent by Mr. Hemsley on July 27. Another letter and offer were sent on August 16, 2000, by the attorney for the District and WOCCSE. (D/W Ex. K, P.)(Footnote 13)

The August 16, 2000 offer included the following: SDC at Marine View, a full-time one-on-one instructional assistant, integration periods and activities with typical peers, consultation from the District’s inclusion specialist, weekly community-based instruction, speech and language services, facilitation of STUDENT’s transition to a public school setting, weekly consultation from the District’s assistive technology specialist, OT, adapted physical education, regular physical education, parent training, transportation, a functional behavioral assessment, IEP team meetings to discuss further opportunities for STUDENT to integrate with typical peers, and a triennial evaluation in February 2001 to include a vision assessment.

By letter dated August 18, 2000 (D/W Ex. Q), Ms. Lundberg invited STUDENT’s father to attend an IEP meeting on September 14, 2000, to “address your request for a Full Inclusion placement.”(Footnote 14) A notice of IEP meeting was attached, listing 14 education specialists that had been invited by the District to attend the IEP meeting. Those education specialists included the school principals from Marine View and Spring View.(Footnote 15) The father was asked to contact Ms. Lundberg by September 1 with 2 or 3 alternative dates if necessary. No meeting was held.

A progress report from SLDC dated November 15, 2000, states that STUDENT’s language progress, both receptively and expressively, was amazing the staff daily. He also was improving academically, working up to 30 minutes at a single sitting. During language sessions he was able to sit for 45 minutes, listening intently to questions directed at him and listening sporadically for the remaining time. However, frustrations were occurring more frequently in the past two months, possibly as a result of experiencing the transitions of adolescence. The speech and language progress report from SLDC dated November 15, 2000, lists specific and measured current levels of performance in answering yes/no questions, following two-step instructions, understanding of spacial concepts “top/bottom” (70 % accuracy with trained locations such as the bookshelf, file cabinet, and cupboard in the speech room), answering “who” and “what” questions about a picture stimulus, taking turns during one-on-one game interactions, and responsively using “hi” and “bye” combined with a familiar person’s name. (D/W Ex. T.)

Another IEP meeting was noticed by the District for November 20, 2000, to discuss ways of facilitating a transition for STUDENT from SLDC to public school. The meeting did not occur. According to Mr. Hemsley’s letter to the father dated November 30, 2000, the father had canceled the November 20 IEP meeting. In that letter, Mr. Hemsley submitted a specific proposal for transition services.(Footnote 16) (D/W Ex. S.)

A speech and language progress report by Ms. Pfeiffer from SLDC dated January 15, 2001, (D/W Ex. DD) gives a detailed listing of STUDENT’s progress in behavior, receptive language, expressive language, and pragmatics. In behavior, he was demonstrating an overall increase in self-stimulatory, compulsive, and agitated behaviors over the past few months that were impairing his performance during speech and language sessions.

Ms. Lundberg submitted a detailed draft of a proposed assessment plan dated January 26, 2001, in preparation for the triennial assessment due in February 2001. The proposed plan listed the areas that would be assessed, the specific assessment tests and methods, and the persons who would perform the assessment, listing each involved person’s name and/or area of expertise. The cover letter by Ms. Lundberg requested the father’s input for further development of the assessment plan. (D/W Ex. U.)

A letter from the father to the District dated January 29, 2001, states that the father was “again request[ing] an Individualized Education Program team meeting,” that he could not attend the prior scheduled meeting, and that the District, not the father, had canceled the prior meeting and refused to reschedule it. The father’s letter further stated that the District was the party who had a history of canceling meetings, that the father would not be “antagonized by [the District’s] illegal actions,” and that he had “filed the appropriate federal and state complaints.” The letter does not specify a particular canceled meeting, but it is probably in reference to the November 20, 2000 IEP meeting proposed by the District. (D/W Ex. V.)

On February 1, 2001, the District sent a notice of IEP meeting to the father. The meeting date was scheduled for February 16, 2001, a date that the father had specified as available in his January 29 letter. Eleven education specialists were listed as invited by the District to attend the meeting. The notice form requested that the father confirm whether he would attend. (D/W Ex. W.)

The father did not reply to the IEP meeting notice. On February 12, 2001, the attorney for the District wrote a letter to STUDENT’s attorney, Mr. Wyner, expressing concern about the scheduled IEP meeting. The letter reiterated the importance of the meeting, requested confirmation of whether the father would attend, and mentioned that the father had not yet responded to the proposed assessment plan. (D/W Ex. X.)

Ms. Del Rosario’s OT progress report from SLDC dated February 14, 2001 (D/W Ex. DD), states that STUDENT had made remarkable progress, particularly in ocular motor control, and that clinic-based OT was no longer needed. Instead, a one-hour classroom consult per week was recommended to facilitate successful reintegration into the classroom and playground.

Ms. Olsen, STUDENT’s classroom teacher at SLDC, prepared an annual progress report dated February 15, 2001, listing current levels of performance. (D/W Ex. DD.) The report states that STUDENT was receiving OT and speech and language services in addition to his classroom program, and that he required the services of a one-on-one aide for 5 ½ hours per day for frequent redirection, educational support, and behavioral needs.

A letter from the attorney for the District to Mr. Wyner dated February 21, 2001, summarizes the District’s perspective of what occurred regarding the IEP meeting scheduled for February 16. On February 15, the attorney for the District had contacted Mr. Wyner by phone, and Mr. Wyner confirmed that the father would attend the meeting. Late in the morning of February 16, and prior to the start of the IEP meeting scheduled for noon, the father telephoned Mr. Hemsley and, during a 25-minute conversation, discussed a proposed agenda for the IEP meeting. The father confirmed that he would attend the IEP meeting and that he would be on time. The IEP meeting convened at noon. Neither the father nor STEPMOTHER was in attendance. STEPMOTHER arrived at 12:20 p.m. About 15 minutes after the IEP meeting convened, the father left a telephone message for Mr. Hemsley stating that he had cracked a tooth, that he was going to the dentist, and that he wanted Mr. Hemsley to call him to reschedule the meeting.(Footnote 17) (D/W Ex. Y.)

During the 2000-2001 school year at SLDC, STUDENT was exhibiting increased problems with behavior. Concurrently, STUDENT’s father was increasing his visits to SLDC. The increased visits were, at least in part, precipitated by the father’s concerns about STUDENT’s escalated behavior and about alleged erratic attention/attendance by the one-on-one aide assigned to STUDENT. When the District became aware of the father’s concerns, Mr. Hemsley contacted Ms. O’Conner at SLDC and received her assurance that the one-on-one instructional aide would be assigned exclusively to STUDENT and available to him throughout the school day. Ms. O’Conner was advised that District staff members would monitor the aide situation, and other procedures to address the father’s concerns were discussed. (D/W Ex. Z.)

According to the testimony of SLDC staff, the frequent visits by STUDENT’s father, especially after a Halloween incident in October 2000, were causing disruption to STUDENT and the other students. Specifically as a response to the visits by STUDENT’s father, SLDC instituted a written visitation policy for the first time in its 35-year history. STUDENT’s father felt that STUDENT’s safety and best interests were being put at risk by the new visitation policy because it restricted the frequency of visits. In approximately mid-February 2001, the father removed STUDENT from SLDC and reinstituted the home-teaching program administered through California

Ranch School. From that time through the present, STUDENT’s services have been delivered in his home program by STUDENT’s father, STEPMOTHER, and relatives, in consultation with other experts such as Dr. Sailor and Dr. Gee.(Footnote 18)

After receiving input from STUDENT’s father and/or his attorney regarding the January 26, 2001 proposed assessment plan, the District’s attorney submitted a revised assessment plan dated April 3, 2001. (D/W Ex. AA, BB.) Added to the prior plan were a vision assessment and a functional behavioral assessment. Meanwhile, the District was attempting to schedule an IEP meeting. In a letter to the District from STUDENT’s father dated March 6, 2001, the father proposed March 13 as an IEP meeting date. The District agreed to hold an IEP meeting on that date, but the father subsequently rejected the date. By letter to the father dated March 29, the District solicited a new list of dates from the father. (D/W Ex. EE.) On April 19, 2001, on the basis of a list of dates provided by the father on April 19, the District submitted a notice of IEP meeting scheduled for May 7, 2001. Fourteen persons were listed on the notice as invited to attend the meeting. (D/W Ex. HH.) The cover letter submitted with the notice arranged for classroom observations by the father’s identified observers, Dr. Sailor and Lou Barber. The cover letter asked the father to give further details on the specific areas of clarification that he was requesting for the proposed assessment plan. The April 3 plan had already provided for a complete vision assessment in the areas of “binocularity, objective testings, visual information processing, evaluation, vision health check, accommodative integrity ocular motion” as requested by the father.

An IEP meeting was held on May 7, 2001.(Footnote 19) (D/W Ex. JJ.) The IEP proposed by the District provided for services to commence on May 10, 2001, consisting of SDC at Marine View for 6 of 8 periods; regular classes at Marine View for 2 of 8 periods; speech and language, individual and group; weekly consults in augmentative/assistive technology, inclusion services, and OT; adapted physical education; parent education; computer software; a one-on-one aide; transportation; vocational education; adapted and regular physical education consult; extended school year services; and further integration opportunities with typical peers. All of the above-listed program would be reviewed on or after 30 days following the placement at Marine View. A transition plan was included.

At the May 7, 2001 IEP meeting, 12 pages of goals and objectives from the June 22, 2000 IEP were reviewed by the classroom teacher and speech and language pathologist from SLDC (Ms. Olsen and Ms. Pfeiffer). According to the meeting notes, those goals and objectives were deemed to be appropriate for 30 days upon placement at Marine View.(Footnote 20) The Student presented a 20-page package consisting of a progress report (listing present levels of performance) and goals and objectives prepared by STEPMOTHER, and a report by Dr. Sailor regarding his observations and recommendations.(Footnote 21) (Student Ex. 64.) The IEP meeting was not completed in the allotted time, and was adjourned to a later date. Meanwhile, Ms. Lundberg took the written goals and objectives presented by the Student at the May 7, 2001 IEP meeting and blended then with the previously blended set of goals and objectives that she had presented at the June 22, 2000 IEP meeting. (D/W Ex. A-16.)

On May 17, 2001, Ms. Lundberg left a voice-mail message for STUDENT’s father and sent a certified letter requesting available dates for an IEP meeting. Ms. Lundberg’s certified letter to STUDENT’s father dated June 22, 2001, states that the District was still seeking dates from the father for an IEP meeting in July to discuss the package of information presented by the father at the May 7, 2001 IEP meeting. The June 22 letter also mentions that the due process case SN 462-01, filed by the District and WOCCSE, had been voluntarily dismissed, and that the District wanted to add discussion of an acceptable assessment plan to the IEP meeting agenda.(Footnote 22) (D/W Ex. SS.)

On June 24, 2001, the Hearing Office received a request for due process hearing from the Student (Case Number SN01-01394). The hearing request asserts, in part, that “the district refuses to hold an IEP [meeting] in accordance to Federal and State statutes, making it impossible for the parents to address the IEP team to give informed consent, or function in the manner in which Federal and State laws mandate.”

By letter dated June 28, 2001, the District notified STUDENT’s father that an IEP meeting was set for July 9, 2001, and invited the father to submit different dates if he would be unable to attend. (D/W Ex. TT.) Fourteen education specialists were listed on the IEP notice as invited by the District to attend the meeting. (D/W Ex. UU.)

The IEP meeting commenced as noticed on July 9, 2001, at 1:00 p.m. (D/W Ex. A-1.) The meeting notes state that STUDENT’s father was not present, that the District left a voice-mail message for the father at 2:10 p.m., and that at 2:50 p.m. the father’s attorney called the District and informed the District that the father had been in Sacramento.

The July 9, 2001 IEP proposed by the District offered placement at Marine View for the 2000-2001 school year, with SDC for 2 of 8 periods, regular education classes for 4 of 8 periods, other school/vocational classes for 2 of 8 periods, adapted physical education, speech and language, assistive technology consult, inclusion services consult, OT consult, parent education, computer software appropriate to STUDENT’s goals and objectives, a one-on-one aide, transportation, vocational education, adapted and physical education consult, extended school year services, annual progress to be measured using the goals and objectives, further integration opportunities. The program would be reviewed on or after 50 days following the placement at Marine View. A transition plan was included for the movement of STUDENT into public school. An “IEP Statement of Needed Transition Services” was included for development of a long-range plan regarding STUDENT’s eventual movement into the adult world.

On September 4, 2001, the District submitted a new assessment plan to STUDENT’s father. The cover letter by Mr. Hemsley explained that the plan dated April 3, 2001, had not been consented to, and that because new information had been received regarding STUDENT, the new plan contained some slight modifications.

Through the conclusion of the due process hearing testimony on December 6, 2001, STUDENT had remained in his home-based program through California Ranch School. The parties had engaged in some further correspondence regarding the assessment plan, but no consent for assessment had been given by STUDENT’s father. (D/W Ex. A-7, A-10).

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue No. 1: Did the District offer a FAPE to the Student in the least restrictive environment for the 2000-2001 school year?

Under State and federal law, individuals with exceptional needs have the right to a “free appropriate public education.” 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1400(d), Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” (FAPE) means “special education” and “related services” that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401(8).

The term “special education” means specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parent, to meet the unique needs of individuals with exceptional needs, whose educational needs cannot be met with modification of the regular instruction program, and “related services,” at no cost to the parent, that may be needed to assist these individuals to benefit from specially designed instruction. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56031.The parameters for adequacy of a student’s IEP are set forth in Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S.176 (1982). The United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide some educational benefit to the student. Rowley, at 207-208.

The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 201. Federal special education law requires states to establish certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which the student is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1483. Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE. Procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. 960 F.2d at 1484.

Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be satisfactorily achieved. 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1412 (a) (5) (A); Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56031.

In summary, there are two overall categories of inquiry. One category of inquiry is substantive appropriateness. Under the IDEA , State law, and Rowley, the program proposed by the district must have met the following four substantive requirements to have constituted an appropriate educational program for the student: (I) been designed to meet his unique needs, (II) been reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, (III) comported with his IEP, and (IV) provided him an education in the least restrictive environment. The other category of inquiry is procedural appropriateness: Has the district complied with the procedural requirements of the IDEA?

Substantive Appropriateness

I. Did the District offer a program for the 2000-2001 school year that was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs? A. STUDENT’s unique needs.

Before determining whether the District offered a program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, it is necessary to identify STUDENT’s unique needs. The best evidence presented regarding STUDENT’s needs as he approached the 2000-2001 school year was contained in progress reports from SLDC, including Ms. Pfeiffer’s speech and language reports dated January 15 and April

15, 2000, and Ms. Del Rosario’s OT report dated May 19, 2000. The reports show that STUDENT had deficits in behavior, receptive language, expressive language, language pragmatics, behavioral organization, and ocular motor control.

STUDENT’s behavior is addressed in Ms. Pfeiffer’s January 15, 2000 progress report. The report states that positive behavioral modifications had been incorporated into the speech and language therapy. Characteristics such as bouncing, hitting his hand on the wall or table, clapping, vocal perseverations, pushing, and fleeing the room interfered with STUDENT’s social interactions and learning experiences. The behaviors were induced by language breakdowns (inability to effectively send or receive a message), transitions to new situations, and/or inconsistencies in the environment (i.e. where the therapist was sitting) or routines (such as the manner that he exited or entered a room). Recommended teaching strategies to avoid language breakdowns and enhance learning of successful communicative behaviors included focusing attention, direct instruction, modeling, providing vocabulary, minimizing environmental distractions, and allowing time for processing and organization.

Ms. Pfeiffer concluded in her April 15, 2000 report that STUDENT had made steady gains in all areas, and that his increased ability to attend and participate had significantly contributed to his success.(Footnote 23) For receptive language, the report states that STUDENT could follow directions involving 2 critical elements (i.e. shape and color) with 75-80% accuracy given some repetition. For directions involving 3 critical elements, accuracy decreased to 60-65%. He demonstrated 65% accuracy following novel 2-step directions. On the computer, he could identify 9 of 20 pictures depicting action words given an auditory stimulus in a field of 20. He was able to point to flashcard pictures of action words given a verbal stimulus with 65% accuracy in a field of 8 for a total of 15 words. Repetitions were usually required at the beginning of tasks to focus attention. He could match a written word to a picture with 90% accuracy with approximately 20 stimuli. He was beginning to match simple 3-5 word sentences containing familiar vocabulary to pictures (i.e. “The girl is running”) in a field of two. He could construct simple sentences using word cards to match an auditory stimulus with 65-70% accuracy given multiple repetitions.

For expressive language, Ms. Pfeiffer’s April 15, 2000 report states that STUDENT could request an object utilizing 2 descriptor words of shape and color (i.e. blue circle) with about 80% accuracy during structured tasks. Accuracy decreased to about 60% when using 3 words (i.e. small yellow square). Average length of utterance ranged from 4-6 words during structured activities with limited variety of vocabulary and syntax. STUDENT could verbalize a written word with 90% accuracy in a set of 20 words. He demonstrated 80% accuracy verbalizing 4-6 word sentences of familiar vocabulary presented graphically.

For language pragmatics, Ms. Pfeiffer’s April 15, 2000 report states that STUDENT could greet a person (peer or staff) using “hi” and “bye” plus the person’s name responsively with 65% accuracy given an average of 2 repetitions and one verbal/gestural cue. He could verbally protest/refuse an undesired item by saying “no thank you” with 70% consistency given cues during structured activities. He typically utilized gestures in conjunction with saying “no thank you” (i.e. gently pushing away the hand with the undesired item). He could accept a desired item by saying “yes” or “yes please” given initial phonemic cues and/or modeling of the target response during structured tasks. He could participate in simple games such as “memory” with a peer given verbal cues for turn taking and following the rules of the game.

Ms. Del Rosario’s annual OT progress report dated May 19, 2000, states that individual OT services were being provided to emphasize STUDENT’s self-directed engagement in sensory and motor tasks which provide controlled input to his various sensory systems. Purposeful, goal-directed responses were encouraged and were thought to aid in neural and behavioral organization, providing the foundation for academic and social skills. Goals of STUDENT’s OT included improving somatosensory processing, vestibular processing, and organization of behavior.(Footnote 24) The OT report states that STUDENT’s need to seek a lot of proprioceptive input in his activities had decreased since he was first seen. Initially, he had engaged in activities that required large amounts of climbing and jumping. He was now able to engage in other activities. His proprioceptive system appeared to be more modulated.

The OT progress report lists results from the Bruininks-Oseretsky Test of Motor Proficiency (BOTMP) and the Beery Test of Visual Motor Integration Revised (VMI-R). On the BOTMP, STUDENT’s age-equivalent scores in years and months were running speed and agility (6.8), balance (6.11), bilateral coordination (6.5), upper limb coordination (8.2), visual motor control (5.8), upper limb and dexterity (5.11). On the VMI-R, visual motor skills were rated at 4.6, and the motor subtest rated his skills at 6.9. STUDENT’s chronological age at testing was 12 years and 5 months. Writing was compromised. STUDENT had problems making sharp corners and complex designs. His control of writing implements had increased, and he could now write, when reminded, with his wrist in contact with the paper. Behavioral organization was initially an area of marked difficulty but had significantly improved. Attention was better, although still inadequate. He was more able to work on a task without getting disorganized. However, he remained easily distracted by physical or internal stimuli. He had difficulty with change or imposition, but that was decreasing.

Ms. Del Rosario concluded her report by stating that STUDENT exhibited deficits in behavioral organization and ocular motor control. He required structure for him to interact effectively with his environment. Continued OT at one hour per week was recommended in a classroom setting to focus on ocular motor skills for successful classroom reintegration. Adaptive physical education was recommended. Since STUDENT was more organized and more focused, Ms. Del Rosario recommended that he could be involved in age-appropriate activities.

STEPMOTHER testified that STUDENT had good visual, memory, and imitation skills. He enjoyed building things. He had a “winning” smile and wanted to connect with people. He knew when he needed to have his own space. He needed to expand his language, to learn to tolerate movement and activity patterns of other people, and to learn how to access a situation and know what to do. She testified that he needed time to analyze and learn what he was supposed to do in a given situation, but when he knew what to do he would do it quite well. He had difficulties with new or unfamiliar transitions, but he could handle transitions when he knew the routine. He needed to access what his typical peers would do, and he needed friends beyond his siblings. He learned primarily through modeling, imitation, and gentle explanation. She believed that in a classroom, once the expectations of him were clear, he could accept them. She felt that he needed exposure to new situations so that he could grow.(Footnote 25)

In summary, as the 2000-2001 school year approached, STUDENT needed services to address deficits in speech and language, including receptive language, expressive language, and language pragmatics. His speech and language skill levels were measurable by tasks such as matching shapes and colors, identifying action words using pictures, saying “hi” and “bye” in connection with a familiar name, and saying “no thank you” or “yes please.” He needed services to address deficits in attention, behavior, and behavioral organization. He needed structure to interact successfully with his environment, as he was easily distracted by physical or internal stimuli and had a need for sameness, showing difficulty with change or imposition. He needed to know what was expected of him in given situations. He needed appropriate proprioceptive input to assist and/or maintain neural and behavioral organization. He needed services to address deficits in ocular motor control. The mechanics of writing were problematic, as he was just beginning to write with his wrist in contact with the paper.

STUDENT had other needs in addition to those identified in the SLDC reports and by STEPMOTHER. STUDENT would reach the age of 13 years in December 2000. He needed services to address his vocational needs and ability to function with some degree of independence in the community, especially as his teenage years were upon him. He obviously had severe academic deficits, as shown by his present levels of performance. The degree to which his academic deficits were a function of his communication deficits was unknown. Therefore, assessment was needed in intellectual functioning and academic skills.(Footnote 26)

B. The District’s program offer.

In response to STUDENT’s unique needs, the District’s offer on August 16, 2000, included (1) SDC at Marine View, where the District would implement the goals and objectives presented by the District at the June 22, 2000 IEP meeting and mailed to STUDENT’s father on July 6, 2000, (2) a full-time one-to-one instructional assistant to facilitate STUDENT’s integration and support his goals and objectives, (3) integration with typical peers consisting of 15 minutes daily for advisory, 1 period of physical education on a rotating schedule (5 times over a 10-day period), 1 period of elective on a rotating schedule (5 times over a 10-day period), lining up and purchasing and eating snack and lunch daily with typical peers, participation with his class in field trips and other school-wide activities, and interaction with typical peers who enroll in the SDC as an elective, (4) consultation from the District’s inclusion specialist (with STUDENT’s teachers and instructional aide) a minimum of one hour per week for the first trimester, and thereafter a minimum of 2 hours per month, (5) weekly community-based instruction including, among other activities, purchasing items at a grocery store from a shopping list, cooking lessons using groceries purchased by the class, community outings to practice skills such as crossing the street, (6) three hours of speech and language services per week to include 2 hours of individual therapy, 1 hour of in-class services with emphasis on generalization skills and integration with typical peers, and, after the first trimester, a reevaluation by the IEP team of the level of speech and language services, (7) consult from the SLDC speech and language therapist to the District’s speech and language therapist for the first trimester a minimum of 4 hours to facilitate STUDENT’s transition to a public school setting and to assist District personnel in learning and managing STUDENT’s communication style and related behaviors, to be reviewed by the IEP team at the end of the first trimester, (8) one 30-minute consultation per week from the District’s Assistive Technology Specialist, (9) sixty minutes of OT per week, to include collaboration between the OT therapist, STUDENT’s aide, and teacher to implement STUDENT’s OT goals and objectives in the classroom, (10) two 30-minute group sessions of adapted physical education (in addition to regular physical education class) to enable STUDENT to socialize with his peers, (11) one hour per month of parent training regarding the strategies that the school staff are using to work with STUDENT, (12) curb-to-curb home/school transportation daily, (13) if consented to by the father, a functional behavioral assessment of STUDENT for the purpose of developing a positive behavior management plan to address any behaviors that may interfere with STUDENT’s learning in a public school setting, and, thereafter, a minimum of 3 hours of consultation by the school psychologist to STUDENT’s teachers and instructional aide, plus monitoring of the plan by the school psychologist, (14) an IEP team meeting within the first 3 weeks of school to discuss further opportunities for STUDENT to integrate with typical peers, (15) an additional IEP team meeting by the end of the first trimester to discuss STUDENT’s progress, and (16) a triennial evaluation in February 2001 to include a vision assessment. (D/W Ex. P.) The July 6, 2000 offer also provided for continuation of extended school year services at SLDC through the 2000 summer session, with all the support services as specified in the District’s May 24, 2000 IEP offer.

C. Discussion.

With respect to matters concerning meeting the Student’s needs, the Student alleges that the District committed one or more of the following acts or omissions: failed to develop appropriate goals and objectives to address the Student’s needs; failed to offer sufficient designated instructional services (DIS) in the areas of speech and language, reading, occupational therapy, sign language, parent training in sign language, and recreational therapy; and failed to offer a “full continuum of placement options appropriate to the Student’s needs.” The District and WOCCSE dispute each of the Student’s contentions.

The Student’s broadly stated contentions extend to essentially all components of the District’s program offer. For purposes of clarity in analysis, each category of the Student’s unique needs, as identified by the Hearing Officer, is listed below. The Student’s contentions will be examined within a discussion of whether the program offer meets each category of the Student’s unique needs. This approach will allow examination of the Student’s contentions in a practical context and sequence.

Speech and Language. In reviewing the portions of the District’s program offer that were most specific to speech and language, the Hearing Officer observes that the provision for 3 hours of speech and language services per week, including 2 hours of individual therapy, was consistent with the program that had enabled STUDENT to progress at SLDC. The District’s offer contained modifications to the prior speech and language program in recognition of the fact that STUDENT would be attending a public school campus where he would have interaction with typical peers and where he would be receiving services from new providers. Those modifications included consult from the SLDC speech and language therapist and 1 hour per week of in-class services to emphasize generalization skills and integration with typical peers. The proposed consult would have been to the District’s speech and language therapist and District personnel for the purpose of assisting the District in learning and managing STUDENT’s communication style and related behaviors. The further provision for re-evaluation of speech and language services after the first trimester was prudent, given that STUDENT’s learning environment would have differed radically from his prior situations and that current assessment information was limited.(Footnote 27)

The Student’s objections to the speech and language component of the program offer are basically twofold. First, the Student asserts that speech and language services should have been offered for 5 hours per week instead of 3 hours per week. Second, the Student objects to the goals and objectives. (Testimony of STEPMOTHER.)

Speech and Language: hours per week

With respect to the number of hours per week of speech and language services, STEPMOTHER testified that speech and language is the main area of need for STUDENT because the curriculum is language-based. She testified that although STUDENT is otherwise capable of learning quickly, he is greatly limited in learning because of his speech and language deficits. Speech and language deficits also impair his ability to interact with peers and in the community. Because of the importance of speech and language to STUDENT’s success, she believes that 5 hours per week is presently required, and that 5 hours per week was required for the 2000-2001 school year.

Ms. Pfeiffer testified that she believes the speech and language offer of 3 hours per week was appropriate. She added that in the partial inclusion program proposed by the District at Marine View, the speech and language services should be primarily pull-out initially, to enable STUDENT to build a relationship with the speech and language specialist. Ms. Larson testified that she has been a speech and language specialist at the District for 8 years. She reviewed the available materials regarding STUDENT. She testified that she would have been able to implement the goals and objectives on the proposed IEP. She testified about how she works in close collaboration with Ms. Franklin to incorporate speech and language strategy throughout the day for each student. She testified that Ms. Franklin’s classes have some very verbal students who initiate and maintain conversations, in addition to the regular education students who come to the class. She believed that 3 hours per week of speech and language was more appropriate than 5 hours because STUDENT needed to invest the remaining time generalizing his communication skills by working with others.

STEPMOTHER was quite correct in her observation that STUDENT’s speech and language deficits have extensive ramifications in his ability to learn, to function in the community, and to interact with peers. The question is whether 3 hours per week of speech and language services was an appropriate amount of time to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. That question must be answered within the context of STUDENT’s multiple needs and the entire program that the District offered. The program sought to increase STUDENT’s basic speech and language skills and, concurrently, to facilitate his ability to generalize those skills into functional oral communication. Given the limited amount of time in a school day and the many needs that had to be addressed in STUDENT’s overall program, a balance had to be struck between the apportionment of time for direct speech and language therapy and the time devoted to working on generalization of the skills learned in therapy. Providing time in Ms. Franklin’s SDC to generalize STUDENT’s speech and language skills was especially important because, in comparison to other environments, Ms. Franklin’s class would have been more focused toward improving STUDENT’s functional communication skills. Ms. Larsen was particularly well-qualified to give an informed opinion on that matter, as she was familiar with STUDENT’s records and she had extensive experience working with Ms. Franklin and Ms. Franklin’s SDC students. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that 3 hours per week of therapy services was an appropriate amount.

Speech and Language: goals and objectives

The second matter to be resolved is goals and objectives for speech and language. The Student asserts that the proposed goals and objectives for speech and language showed no opportunities for interaction with typical peers, that they were just benchmarks with the focus being too narrow, that the expectations for the annual goals were too limited, and that the goals were too limited in the environmental setting.

Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56345 describes the required content of an IEP. Section 56345(a)(2)(A-B) provides that an IEP shall contain measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, related to (A)“meeting the pupil’s needs that result from the pupil’s disability to enable the pupil to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum,” and (B) “meeting each of the pupil’s other educational needs that result from the pupils’s disability.”

Six pages of goals and objectives specifically for speech and language are contained in the program offer.(Footnote 28) (D/W Ex. J.) The District’s proposed speech and language goals and objectives addressed following 2-step directions in the SDC and speech and language specialist’s room; following novel directions involving spatial concepts in a structured setting; answering simple “wh” questions about familiar people or activities using complete sentences with subject, verb, object; answering concrete yes/no questions about objects/events in STUDENT’s immediate environment with intonation/gestural cues; using “hi” and “bye” responsively in combination with a familiar person’s name in a structured setting; and taking turns with at least 4 different peers or adults during a one-on-one game with minimal assistance. Provisions were made for prompts and fading of prompts. The SDC teacher and/or speech and language specialist would have been responsible for implementation.

With respect to meeting the requirements of Section 56345(a)(2)(A), i.e. “meeting the pupil’s needs that result from the pupil’s disability to enable the pupil to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum,” the annual goals and objectives proposed by the District were in measurable format, with benchmarks and short-term objectives.(Footnote 29) The speech and language goals matched STUDENT’s needs arising from his deficits in receptive language, expressive language, and language pragmatics. The goals and objectives were appropriate to the available baseline data for STUDENT’s present levels of performance as those levels were described by SLDC staff and by STEPMOTHER. Meeting the goals and objectives would have improved STUDENT’s oral communication skills and enabled him to progress in a general curriculum modified to his individual skills and needs. The requirements of Section 56345(a)(2)(A) were satisfied. The Student’s contention that the expectations for the annual goals were too limited is rejected. STUDENT’s levels of performance, given his age, did not indicate that the goals were too limited.

Section 56345(a)(2)(B), i.e. “meeting each of the pupil’s other educational needs that result from the pupils’s disability,” does not necessarily require that every domain of goals and objectives must relate to meeting every domain of a pupil’s unique needs. In STUDENT’s case, however, his communication deficits have such a pervasive effect on his entire set of needs that the speech and language goals should be considered on the basis of whether they appropriately relate to and support the broader spectrum of STUDENT’s educational needs that result from his disability. The Hearing Officer observes that the speech and language goals and objectives were limited with regard to the variety of environments where they would be achieved. The Student correctly states that the proposed goals and objectives for speech and language make no mention of typical peers, that the benchmarks refer exclusively to STUDENT’s performance in a structured setting, and that only the SDC teacher and the speech and language therapist were listed as the persons responsible for their implementation. However, the Hearing Officer finds that those limitations in the environmental scope of the speech and language goals were effectively mitigated by several factors.

The first mitigating factor is that meeting the proposed speech and language goals would have given STUDENT basic tools to capitalize on his interaction opportunities with typical peers at Marine View, both in the SDC with the typical peer classroom aides and elsewhere on the campus. Additionally, the program offer specifically stated that a portion of in-class speech and language services (in the SDC) would emphasize generalization skills and integration with typical peers. Furthermore, the program offer expressly provided for interaction with typical peers in regular education electives and other school activities where STUDENT could use the communication skills learned in the individual and group sessions. Some of the remaining goals and objectives proposed by the District, although not categorized as speech and language, included community-based activities and other activities with typical peers that would have provided additional opportunities for STUDENT to use his language skills learned in the SDC across a variety of environments. Finally, as will be shown below, Ms. Franklin and Marine View have numerous programs in place for promoting interaction between disabled students and their typical peers. Considering all of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives for speech and language, when considered in the context of STUDENT’s overall program, were designed to meet his need for development of speech and language skills across a variety of environments. The speech and language goals and objectives appropriately related to and supported the broader spectrum of STUDENT’s educational needs resulting from his disability. The requirements of Section 56345(a)(2)(B) were satisfied.

Attention, Behavior, and Behavioral Organization. At the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT had needs arising from his attention deficits, behaviors, and behavioral organization deficits. The evidence showed that STUDENT needed structure to interact successfully with his environment, as he was easily distracted by physical or internal stimuli and had a need for sameness, showing difficulty with change or imposition. He needed to know what was expected of him in given situations. He needed appropriate proprioceptive input to assist and/or maintain neural and behavioral organization.

The District’s program offer would have exposed STUDENT to a variety of environmental settings outside of an SDC classroom, including regular education classes, the common areas of the Marine View campus, and the community. Therefore, a program designed to meet STUDENT’s needs would have to address his needs across different environments. The District’s program offer contained numerous components consistent with that requirement. The periods of SDC at Marine View would have provided a “home base” for STUDENT where he would have been in a structured environment conducive to his need for sameness, where he would have had access to people who understood his needs and behaviors, and where he would have been taught skills for successfully interacting with typical peers and adults in other environments. Such skills would have been taught both in the SDC classroom and on various community outings with the SDC. The skills would have served to decrease the situations that caused frustration in STUDENT. Inclusion specialist consultation, a full-time one-on-one assistant, speech and language services including services that emphasized generalization and integration with typical peers, consult with the SLDC speech and language specialists who were familiar with STUDENT’s needs and behaviors, and assistive technology consult would have collectively served to (a) provide STUDENT with the necessary structure, skills, and support to successfully interact with his environment, (b) teach him what was expected of him in given situations, and (c) facilitate the use of his skills. Physical education, adapted physical education, and OT support would have provided him with proprioceptive input to help maintain his behavioral organization. A functional behavioral assessment and monitoring of the resulting positive behavior management plan would have supplemented all of the above.(Footnote 30)

Although the services in the program offer relevant to attention, behavior, and behavioral organization were extensive, the goals and objectives specific to STUDENT’s attention, behavior, and behavioral organization were sparse. Stated goals and objectives included STUDENT’s participating in group instructions and remaining a part of the classroom group, eventually for an entire day at a desk in a typical class configuration. However, by providing for a functional behavior assessment, review of the program after the first 3 weeks, review after the first trimester, and a triennial assessment in February 2001, the offer appropriately envisioned further development of goals and objectives in the areas of attention, behavior, and behavior organization after the functional behavior assessment was completed and after a baseline of data was collected regarding STUDENT’s performance across the different environments encountered within his program.

The Student asserted that horseback riding therapy and swimming pool or aquatic therapy were required to meet his needs. The Student presented testimony from Mr. Busacca and Ms. Appel on that subject. Their testimony showed that STUDENT had derived benefit from those activities, but the overall evidence, especially the testimony from Ms. Del Rosario, STUDENT’s OT therapist at SLDC, showed that STUDENT’s proprioceptive input needs for maintaining behavioral organization could effectively be met through on-campus OT, physical education, and adapted physical education activities.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the program offered by the District was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs in the areas of attention, behavior and behavioral organization for the 2000-2001 school year. Horseback riding therapy and swimming pool or aquatic therapy were not required for meeting the Student’s needs.

Ocular Motor Control. The District’s program offer provided for STUDENT’s ocular motor control deficits to be addressed by 60 minutes of OT per week, to include collaboration between STUDENT’s aide, teacher, and OT therapist to implement STUDENT’s OT goals and objectives in the classroom. Pertinent goals and objectives included developing and refining scissor skills using appropriate hand positioning, and demonstrating functional ocular motor skills by being able to copy complex forms (1-23 on the VMI). The above services were consistent with the testimony and recommendations of Ms. Del Rosario, who stated STUDENT had progressed sufficiently so that further OT should be administered outside of the OT clinic.

Dr. Sailor, an inclusion specialist testifying on behalf of the Student, was critical of the goal and objectives regarding scissor skills, questioning how such skills could be relevant to a sixth- or seventh-grade curriculum. However, Dr. Sailor’s criticism of the goal and objective for scissor skills was not germane to that activity’s purpose of developing ocular motor control.

The Hearing Officer finds that the program offered by the District was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs in the areas of ocular motor control.

Vocational/Community. Portions of the District’s program offer that were pertinent to development of STUDENT’s vocational/community skills included integration with typical peers, weekly community-based instruction, and the activities reflected in the goals and objectives listed below.

Goals and objectives involved STUDENT using specifically-named computer software to develop reading skills, including identification of 7 new common safety signs and a variety of words from a given reading series; identifying all coins by values, telling time to the quarter hour, relating those skills to at least 3 activities such as purchasing lunch or snacks, and utilizing math computer programs to assist with those goals; while using a computer, writing/typing his emergency information from memory, locating all letters of the alphabet, and typing a sentence to describe a picture; increasing community and independent living skills by making purchases with assistance at school and in the community; and exiting the school bus and walking to class, walking from class to class, returning to the bus, and participating in an appropriate elective and regular physical education, all with typical peers and with minimal assistance. The SDC teacher would have been responsible for the above-stated goals.(Footnote 31)

The above-mentioned portions of the District’s program offer provided for development of vocational and community skills by listing goals and objectives applicable to those skills and appropriate to STUDENT’s levels of performance. Activities both in the classroom and in the community would support STUDENT in meeting those goals and objectives. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that, for the 2000-2001 school year the District’s program offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs with respect to development of his vocational and community skills.

Academics/Assessment in Intellectual Functioning and Academic Skills. At the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT had severe academic deficits, as shown by the available progress reports from SLDC and information provided by STEPMOTHER during the failed IEP process in the 1999-2000 school year. Testimony and the reports showed that except for some splinter skills at kindergarten or first-grade level, STUDENT’s academic skills were almost nil. Academics in the program proposed by the District for the 2000-2001 school year would have been received through participation in an SDC, including vocational and community-based activities, and his participation in one or more regular education electives.

The goals and objectives listed above for vocational/community skills address academics in reading, writing, and math. Given STUDENT’s severe academic deficits, additional goals and objectives for academics would have been desirable. However, for the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year, development of more extensive goals and objectives specific to academic skills would have been somewhat speculative without an assessment of STUDENT’s overall intellectual functioning. The extent to which STUDENT’s communication deficits may have been masking his intellectual functioning and potential was unknown. As Dr. Brown testified, parents and teachers are often quite pleasantly surprised by an autistic child’s actual academic potential once the child learns how to communicate more effectively.

With regard to the lack of such assessment information, the Student alleges that the District failed to assess him in all areas of suspected disability. The Hearing Officer agrees that the District made its 2000-2001 program offer with limited information regarding STUDENT’s intellectual functioning and academic potential. The District acknowledges that it did not submit a formal written assessment plan during the 1999-2000 school year (D/W Ex. A-3). A two-fold question therefore arises regarding (a) whether the District offered a program reasonably designed to meet STUDENT’s academic needs and, if not, (b) whether the lack of additional assessment information at the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year prevented the District from offering a program reasonably designed to meet STUDENT’s academic needs.

To resolve this question, the Hearing Officer has considered the following. When the 2000-2001 program offer was completed by the District on August 16, 2000, the parties knew that pursuant to their April 1999 settlement agreement, a triennial assessment would be due by February 2001.(Footnote 32) In the interim, if the 2000-2001 program offer was accepted by the Student, or if the Student was at least enrolled in a program at Marine View, he would be receiving some academics through the SDC-based vocational/community aspects of his program. STUDENT’s attendance at Marine View would also give the District an opportunity to observe STUDENT before the triennial assessment was conducted and suggest adjustments accordingly. The program offer provided for an IEP team meeting within the first 3 weeks of school to discuss further opportunities for STUDENT to integrate with typical peers, and it provided for review of STUDENT’s educational progress by the end of the first trimester. At the 3-week review, additional information would have been available to the parties to enable determination of one or more appropriate electives for STUDENT and additional goals and objectives specific to the chosen elective or electives, including academic goals. The SDC teacher and the inclusion facilitator, being more knowledgeable about STUDENT by that time, would have aided the process. That situation would not have been favorable for a long-term period of time, such as for the entire school year, but it was sufficient to meet STUDENT’s academic needs pending the anticipated receipt of additional information from the triennial assessment due in February 2001. Given those circumstances, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program offer for the 2000-2001 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s academic needs.(Footnote 33)

D. Other contentions by the Student regarding unique needs.

The Student asserts additional objections to the District’s program offer for the 2000-2001 school year, in the areas of sign language and goals and objectives.

Sign Language. The Student asserts the District failed to offer him sufficient designated instructional services in sign language and parent training in sign language. The testimony on this issue was split, and not entirely along “party” lines. Ms. Lundberg testified regarding her understanding that sign language was used on occasion as one of the methodologies for communicating with STUDENT at SLDC, but that the use of sign language in STUDENT’s program at SLDC apparently did not rise to a level that SLDC staff thought it should be included in present levels of performance or goals and objectives. Ms. Atkins thought that STUDENT would benefit from sign language paired with language skills, and that sign language could later be phased out. Ms. Sheetz testified that reliance on sign language would tend to isolate STUDENT from his peers. She might, in some circumstances, support sign language as a visible enhancement to spoken language for an autistic child with auditory processing deficits, but that would depend on factors such as eye contact, usually weak in autistic children. She noted that assessment in sign language pursuant to the current triennial assessment plan proposed by the District would give information on those matters. Ms. Kennard testified that she thought STUDENT would benefit from sign language because it facilitated his ability to communicate.

Ms. Pfeiffer provided extensive speech and language services to STUDENT at SLDC. She testified that sign language was not appropriate for STUDENT because he is a verbal child and formally teaching him sign language would confuse him. In her opinion, sign language did not help him at all with his communication, and seemed more difficult for him than speech.

The Hearing Officer especially valued the opinions and testimony of Ms. Pfeiffer, given her expertise and experience, her familiarity with STUDENT, and the fact that she was not affiliated with a party in this matter. Additionally, the Hearing Officer has considered that teaching sign language could interfere, to STUDENT’s detriment, with other aspects of his speech and language program, such as his motivation to communicate orally. Reliance on sign language could tend to isolate STUDENT from his peers, as STUDENT is not immersed in an environment where sign language is used to communicate. The matter of sign language services should be revisited by STUDENT’s IEP team following the triennial assessment. For the 2000-2001 school year, the Hearing Officer finds that sign language services were not required for meeting STUDENT’s unique needs.

Goals and Objectives. The Student asserts that the District and WOCCSE failed to develop appropriate goals and objectives to address the Student’s needs. The Student’s contentions regarding goals and objectives for speech and language involving typical peers and environmental diversity have been resolved above. The Student’s remaining objections to the proposed goals and objectives, as those objections were described by the testimony of STEPMOTHER, include the following.

The Student alleges that the goal on safety signs underestimated STUDENT’s potential at 10 signs. Also, community signs should have been included as a functional objective. STUDENT could read numbers, but the goal for reading clocks included no discussion of digital clocks. For reading skills, the District goal dealt with site-word recognition. STEPMOTHER proposed literacy development and reading with a phonetic approach so that STUDENT could decode written material. The science objective was considered good, but the Student sought to connect all curriculum areas such as language arts, history, and social studies in the goals and objectives. The Student wanted goals and objectives for developing his vocabulary in the content areas of the curriculum. The Student wanted goals and objectives more specific to the structure of multiple environments. The Student wanted “hi” and “bye” to develop into invitations for typical peers to play with him. No recreation goals and objectives were contained in the District proposal, yet recreation was important to STUDENT because it was one of his strength areas and would have been a good vehicle for his inclusion with typical peers.

The proposals by STEPMOTHER regarding goals and objectives have merit in the sense that incorporation of her specific proposals would improve upon the goals and objectives written by the District. However, the potential for improvement of the goals and objectives proposed by the District does not necessarily render them deficient. For each of STUDENT’s above-stated needs as identified by the Hearing Officer, a finding has already been made that the services and underlying goals and objectives were designed to meet those needs. Accordingly, having considered the content and detail already present in the goals and objectives proposed by the District, and given the statutory description of what is required for goals and objectives in an IEP (Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56345(a)(2)(A-B)), the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives as written in the District’s program offer were reasonably designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.(Footnote 34)

E. Summary.

The Hearing Officer finds that the program offered by the District for the 2000-2001 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

II. Was the District’s program offer reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit?

The Hearing Officer has already found that the program offered by the District was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The goals and objectives were consistent with his needs and his present levels of performance. The services and placement offered were reasonably calculated to meet those goals and objectives. Meeting those goals and objectives would have provided STUDENT with educational benefit. The program contained flexibility to adjust to STUDENT’s needs through provision for monitoring by an inclusion facilitator, a 3-week review, a first trimester review, and a functional behavioral assessment. Further adjustment could have been made, if appropriate, following the triennial assessment due in February 2001. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program offer was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. III. Did the District’s program comport with the IEP?

In STUDENT’s case, there was no agreed-upon IEP. Therefore, no issues exist strictly with regard to whether the District’s program comported with the IEP. However, an analogous issue has arisen from STUDENT’s agreed-upon placement at SLDC.

While STUDENT was attending SLDC through mid-February of the 2000-2001 school year, the parties were not operating under an IEP. His attendance and services at SLDC had been arranged pursuant to the April 1999 settlement agreement. The plan was to keep STUDENT at SLDC for the 1999-2000 school year and then, with an agreed-upon IEP, to transition STUDENT into public school at some point thereafter. However, the parties were never able to agree on an IEP for the 2000-2001 school year. That lack of agreement resulted in the filing of case SN00-01316 on July 19, 2000. The April 1999 settlement agreement provided that SLDC would become the “stay put” placement if the parties could not agree on a program for the 2000-2001 school year. Accordingly, the District and WOCCSE had an obligation to maintain the stay put placement at SLDC as long as that placement remained available to STUDENT.(Footnote 35)

STUDENT’s father removed STUDENT from SLDC in approximately mid-February 2001. The Student has classified this removal as a “de facto expulsion” by SLDC and/or the District. The rationale of the Student is essentially that if the District and WOCCSE had properly supervised and monitored the placement at SLDC, then, according to the Student, his increased behaviors in the fall of 2000 could have been appropriately controlled; the assigned one-on-one aid would have been devoting full attention to the Student; the father would not have feared for the Student’s safety; SLDC would not have been using a “take down” strategy with the Student to control him; the father would not have had to visit SLDC to monitor the Student so frequently; SLDC would not have changed its visitation policy to keep the father from visiting so frequently; and the father would not have had to remove STUDENT in response to all of the above. The Student also alleges that the District and WOCCSE failed to take appropriate action to reverse the Student’s “de facto expulsion” from SLDC, meaning that after the Student’s father removed the Student from SLDC, the District and WOCCSE did not take appropriate action to have the Student placed back into SLDC.

Testimony pertinent to the above matters was received from Mr. Hemsley, STEPMOTHER, Ms. Tipton, the father, Ms. Olsen, Ms. O’Conner, and Ms. Pfeiffer. Their testimony, in combination with SLDC progress reports, showed that STUDENT’s behaviors did escalate upon his return to SLDC for the 2000-2001 school year. Escalations in behavior for one or two months at the beginning of the school year were considered ordinary by the SLDC staff as pupils adjusted to the new school year. In STUDENT’s case, however, the escalation in behaviors did not subside. The SLDC staff testified that they conferred on multiple occasions to discuss reasons why STUDENT’s behaviors had escalated, but the cause was never determined. The onset of adolescence in combination with STUDENT’s need for sameness was considered. Mr. Hemsley testified that he conferred with Ms. O’Conner about the aide, and Ms. O’Conner promised to comply.(Footnote 36) Mr. Hemsley and Ms. O’Conner also had discussions about whether a formal assessment or behavior plan was needed regarding STUDENT’s behaviors, but Ms. O’Conner felt that the SLDC staff was able to handle the situation appropriately.(Footnote 37) The father dramatically increased the frequency of his visits to SLDC, either because of concern about STUDENT, a desire to obtain evidence for a due process hearing, or both.(Footnote 38) His visits were becoming a distraction to the students at SLDC and to STUDENT.(Footnote 39) In response, SLDC decided to institute a new visitation policy, objected to by the father. (Footnote 40) The father was dissatisfied with the visitation policy and its effect on his ability to monitor STUDENT and SLDC, and the father withdrew STUDENT.

STUDENT’s behavioral problems at SLDC in the 2000-2001 school year merited attention by his IEP team. The record shows that the District attempted to have IEP meetings during that period, but the meetings did not occur. The list of scheduled and/or offered IEP meeting dates included September 14, 2000 (father did not respond to the invitation), November 20, 2000 (cancelled by the father), and February 16, 2001 (father did not appear due to a cracked tooth).(Footnote 41) An IEP meeting was eventually held on May 7, 2001.

During the attempts to schedule and/or hold IEP meetings, a number of communications occurred between the parties. Those communications included a detailed draft of the District’s proposed assessment plan dated January 26, 2001, accompanied by Ms. Lundberg’s cover letter requesting the father’s input to the plan; the father’s January 29, 2001 letter to the District that demanded an IEP meeting, stated that he was withholding consent for any and all proposed assessment until he could give “informed consent,” and unduly criticized the District for having a history of cancelling IEP meetings; a February 29 letter from the District’s attorney to the Student’s attorney stating that the father had never responded to the proposed assessment plan; and a letter by the father dated March 1, 2001, stating that he wanted an IEP meeting and that he was “again formally requesting an assessment” and that he had “requested a behavior plan for several months and information of assessments with no response from the district.”(Footnote 42)

Considering all of the above factors, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s departure from SDLC was not precipitated by action and/or inaction on the part of the District or WOCCSE. The father’s own actions in unreasonably disrupting the Students and teachers at SLDC and failing to cooperate in the IEP and assessment process were the overriding factors in the entire matter. Furthermore, the District and WOCCSE had no authority to make SLDC reverse its new visitation policy. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District and WOCCSE did not violate their “stay put” obligations for STUDENT’s placement at SLDC.

IV. Did the District offer to provide STUDENT with an education in the least restrictive environment (LRE)?

A. Contentions.

The Student alleges that the District failed to offer him a program in the least restrictive environment (LRE) for the 2000-2001 school year. The Student alleges that the LRE would have been a program consisting entirely of regular education classes and community-based instruction, with no SDC. The Student also alleges that placement at Spring View, his school of residence, was the LRE for such a program.

For purposes of LRE analysis, the District’s offer can be summarized as placement at Marine View in an SDC for the major portion of the school day. Components of the SDC most applicable to STUDENT’s involvement with typical peers and the community would have included STUDENT’s participation with his class in field trips and other school-wide activities, interaction with typical peers who enrolled in the SDC as an elective, and weekly community-based instruction. The weekly community-based instruction would have included, among other activities, purchasing items at a grocery store from a shopping list, cooking lessons using groceries purchased by the class, and community outings to practice skills such as crossing the street. In addition to the SDC activities, the program offer included integration (or inclusion) with typical peers consisting of 15 minutes daily for an advisory period, 1 period of physical education on a rotating schedule (5 times over a 10-day period), 1 period of elective on a rotating schedule (5 times over a 10-day period), and lining up and purchasing and eating snack and lunch daily with typical peers. The offer also provided for an IEP team meeting within the first 3 weeks of school to discuss further opportunities for STUDENT to integrate with typical peers, and for further review after the first trimester.

B. Applicable law.

The applicable federal statute describes the requirement of LRE in terms of educating the child with typical peers and in the regular education environment to the maximum extent appropriate. The applicable State statute specifies a requirement for providing a full continuum of program options for meeting the child’s needs in the LRE, although the statute itself does not define LRE.(Footnote 43) Accordingly, special education law can be viewed as establishing a preference for inclusion with typical peers to the maximum extent that inclusion is appropriate to the child’s needs. The LRE for any particular child thereby remains a function of that child’s needs.

To assist in determining whether a student is being educated in the least restrictive environment, the courts have indicated factors to be considered as a balancing test. Those factors include (1) the educational benefits available to the child in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared to the educational benefits of a special education classroom, (2) the non-academic benefits to the disabled child of interaction with nondisabled children, (3) the effect of the presence of the disabled child on the teacher and other children in the regular classroom, and (4) the costs of supplementary aids and services necessary to mainstream the disabled child in a regular classroom setting. The above factors have been derived from the case of Sacramento City Unif. School Dist. v. Rachel H., (9th Cir. 1994) 14 F.3d 1398.

Before applying the above-stated law to the present case, testimony pertinent to LRE from District and WOCCSE employees, from the SLDC staff, and from the Student’s experts will be recounted in detail below.(Footnote 44)

C. Witnesses from the District and WOCCSE.

Ms. Franklin. Ms. Franklin testified concerning her SDC and programs at Marine View.(Footnote 45) In the 2000-2001 school year, her class had 7 students from ages 11 to 13 years (9 students and similar support for the 2001-2002 school year). She had 2 instructional aides. The computer in the class was connected to a big screen TV on which the class worked on math, reading, problem solving, print shop, kid works, writing letters, and creating stories. She had 6 regular education students in her SDC as “classroom aides.” Because of the small size of the class, she would try not to have more than 2 classroom aides per period. The classroom aides would assist with dressing, fine motor, gross motor, and academic skills. The class regularly went on community outings during which community skills were learned, such as going to the store and using money. Vocational skills including filing, collating, sorting, classifying, hole punching, and stapling were learned in the classroom in small groups,. For the 30-minute snack time, the class cooked its own meals from a weekly list of groceries that they had designated for purchase on the prior Friday. She supported the regular education components of her student’s programs by consulting with the regular education teachers for each student on behaviors, level of functionality, and goals and objectives. She described the regular education teachers as very supportive, and testified that they would ask her to place her students in their classrooms. After reviewing the available information on STUDENT, she was certain that his goals and objectives could be implemented in her class. She thought that woodshop, computer, art, and music would be good regular education choices for STUDENT. She did not believe that STUDENT could tolerate regular education classes for an entire day. In her SDC, he would receive academic benefit from the goals and objectives that she has seen for him. In regular education classes, her expectations of benefit for STUDENT would be socialization, communication, and peer modeling; any gain in academics would be considered a plus.

Ms. Larson. Ms. Larson has been a speech and language specialist at the District for 8 years. She reviewed the available materials regarding STUDENT. She testified that she would have been able to implement the goals and objectives on the proposed IEP at Marine View. She testified about how she works in close collaboration with Ms. Franklin to incorporate speech and language strategy throughout the day for each student. She testified that Ms. Franklin’s classes have some very verbal students who initiate and maintain conversations, in addition to the regular education students who come to the class. She questioned whether the speech and language goals and objectives could have been successfully incorporated into STUDENT’s classes at Spring View. The children in SDC at Spring View had higher cognitive and academic skills. She further testified that programs for generalization of skills and community-based training for children at STUDENT’s level were already in place at Marine View, but not at Spring View. Also to STUDENT’s advantage at Marine View were Ms. Franklin’s considerable skills and the methods for successfully collaborating with the regular education teachers when serving children with STUDENT’s level of disability.

Ms. Carr. The District’s inclusion facilitator, Ms. Carr, testified that she is very familiar with Marine View. The staff at Marine View are very accommodating. She testified that Ms. Franklin, the SDC teacher for severely disabled students, has built an “incredible program” to have her children out and about. Ms. Franklin is very proactive, taking her students into the community to learn functional activities and life skills. Ms. Franklin’s students prepare their own lunches before going into the community. She has regular education students in her SDC class almost constantly. Ms. Carr stated that she would be very concerned about sending STUDENT onto a large campus without SDC as a base. If he was doing his own program in a regular education class, he would be isolated from the rest of the class, and the assistant would be obligated to teach STUDENT, making him dependent on adult assistance. She was not surprised by the different descriptions of STUDENT by Dr. Gee, Dr. Sailor, and SLDC staff, because they were observing STUDENT’s functional level in different environments, i.e. outdoors versus in school, and in high interest activities. Accordingly, he could understandably present as high functioning to Dr. Gee and Dr. Sailor, but low functioning in the SLDC setting. Ms. Carr thought that functioning in a school setting was important if STUDENT was going to someday be employed. He needed to learn to adjust to different environments even a particular environment did not include high-interest activities for STUDENT, such as sports. She agreed that STUDENT needed community exposure, and she thought that Ms. Franklin’s program was good for community exposure. In her opinion, building on success for STUDENT was more important than taking a risk where he might fail and not recover.

Ms. Williams. Ms. Williams, the principal at Marine View, testified concerning her knowledge of the school. Marine View is a California “distinguished school,” meaning that it is in the top 5 percent of California schools academically. Marine View has a “tolerance grant” that funds programs for tolerance of diversity, including children with disabilities. To apply for the grant, a school must show that students with disabilities have access to activities that include all students. She feels that a strength of the school is its programs for social and emotional aspects of children with disabilities. Ten percent of the 800 students in attendance have disabilities. Marine View has 4 special education teachers, 5 special education aides, 2 instructional aides that are bilingual, and 4 special education classes (SDCs), including one for severely handicapped students, one for non-severely handicapped students, and 2 resource classes. All class periods are 72 minutes. The seventh- and eighth-grade curriculum is academically rigorous. All of the material on the high school exit exam is taught at Marine View. Each year, the staff undergoes training for students with disabilities by Linda Franklin and Ann Carr. The staff at Marine View have the highest level of knowledge in the District for the needs of students with disabilities and the need to include them. Ms. Williams described with highest praise the regular education teachers in classes that STUDENT would likely be taking. All were described as veteran teachers experienced in teaching children with disabilities who would need to know about STUDENT as an individual and then could “take it from there.” She believed that an SDC was important for STUDENT because he needed to ease his transition. Instead of setting him up for failure, it would be better to set him up for early success. Regular education students go into Ms. Franklin’s class as tutors and also to socialize, including during the lunch hour. Ms. Franklin and/or Ms. Carr speak to student groups and strongly advocate the integration of children with disabilities into the regular education classroom. Spring View, in her opinion, would not meet STUDENT’s needs, because there is no SDC for severely disabled students at Spring View. Marine View has an SDC for children with severe disabilities because Ms. Franklin wanted it, and Ms. Lundberg set it up with her. In Ms. Williams’ opinion, few schools are as well-qualified as Marine View to meet the needs of children with disabilities.

Mr. Malotee. Mr. Malotee is the principal at Spring View. He testified that Spring View has an SDC for learning handicapped students and 2 resource specialist classes for language arts, social studies, math, and science. Spring View’s special education services does not provide for community-based instruction such as going to stores or restaurants. Spring View provides full-inclusion supports such as one-on-one aides, a preferred schedule, careful selection of classes, and modified curriculum. STUDENT’s proposed goals and objectives, reviewed by Mr. Malotee, were significantly lower than the goals and objectives for students in SDCs and resource specialist classes at Spring View. All of the special needs students at Spring View have access, with modification, to the sixth- seventh- and eighth-grade curriculum content standards.

Ms. Caruso. Ms. Caruso is an adaptive physical education specialist at the District. She testified that she could have provided STUDENT’s adaptive physical education and sensory integration services at Spring View, although she believed the typical peers were very understanding at Marine View and the peer-builders program worked well at Marine View.

Ms. Mulcahy. Ms. Mulcahy, an OT with WOCCSE, testified concerning the array of sensory integration activities that could have been provided either at Marine View or at Spring View to keep STUDENT organized. The sensory “diet” could have been provided inside or outside of the classroom, depending upon the activity needed under the circumstances. The specific OT services or consultation she provided would have been determined by the outcome of her proposed assessment.

Ms. Dryden. Ms. Dryden testified that she could have provided assistive technology support at either Spring View or Marine View.

D. Witnesses from SLDC.

Witnesses from SLDC were called by both the Student and the District. The Speech and Language Development Center in Buena Park, otherwise referred to as SLDC, is certified as a non-public agency by the State of California Department of Education to provide services to children with disabilities. SLDC has provided services to children with disabilities since 1965, and Ms. O’Conner has been its program director since 1977. SLDC has a master contract with the District and with other school districts to provide services to individuals with exceptional needs when no appropriate public education program is available. Approximately 300 children with disabilities attend SLDC, where they are provided an array of resource services by SLDC staff in addition to their daily classroom activities. The Hearing Officer valued the testimony of the SLDC staff because they demonstrated excellent knowledge and ability in their respective specialties. They had good knowledge of STUDENT (having worked with him from approximately April 1999 to mid-February 2001). They had observed him in group classroom settings and individual instruction, where his attention to task and ability to adapt were challenged. SLDC was not a party to the due process hearing, and its staff appeared to be neutral with regard to the outcome of the hearing.

Ms. Del Rosario. The Student was assessed by Ms. Del Rosario when he arrived at SLDC, and she was his OT therapist throughout his stay at SLDC. Her reports were summarized above. Ms. Del Rosario testified about STUDENT’s problems with behavior organization. STUDENT had trouble determining “where his body was in space.” This could be manifested by him bumping into things. More pertinent to his behaviors, this condition would cause him to do things such as jumping so that hitting the ground would give him feedback on where his body was. Because his body behavior was compromised, his classroom participation was compromised. She testified that if STUDENT was enrolled in a regular education class, he would need proprioceptive input from intermittent activities such as running, relay games carrying things, pushups, or trampoline as needed. A target would be to have STUDENT alert his aide or teacher when he needed such activity. The periodic proprioceptive input would serve to help keep his sensory integration and behavior organized, resulting in better performance at school.

Ms. Del Rosario had observed STUDENT in classrooms at SLDC. She testified that STUDENT required a structured environment. Subtle changes in his environment could be very difficult for STUDENT to tolerate. STUDENT was often unable to generalize or adapt his responses to changed situations. For example, he had been used to going from speech to OT. When they attempted to take him to OT from a different class, he would insist on going to the speech room first, and then he would proceed to OT. Several months were required to resolve the speech-to-OT situation. If his cubby was taken, he would become agitated and run out of the room, but later he learned to put his shoes wherever there was space. In one situation where a flat swing was suspended on two robes that had twisted, he became agitated when the rope was untwisted. He fled the room, was sweating, would listen to nobody, would push all the therapists, and insisted on recreating the scene to restore the twisted rope and put everyone back where they had been.

Ms. Del Rosario did not believe that a regular middle school classroom had sufficient structure for STUDENT. She stated that STUDENT had trouble enough with distractions in the structured environment at SLDC, and that generalizing would be very hard for him in a regular school environment. She cautioned against placing STUDENT in a situation in which he would become so agitated that one could not restore his composure. She would be concerned about distractions from a regular school setting, including noise level, class switching, having to move his things to the next room, and the host of other situations that could not be predicted or identified. He could react to such situations by moving objects, moving people, fleeing, becoming agitated, or worse.(Footnote 46)

Ms. Olsen. Ms. Olsen was STUDENT’s classroom teacher at SLDC from approximately July 1999 to the end of his stay at SLDC in February 2001. STUDENT was in her class 2 ½ to 3 hours per day. She testified that during his first year at SLDC, STUDENT’s behaviors included self-stimulatory behaviors, echolalia, fleeing the classroom on occasion when frustrated, hitting things on the table when angry, and trying to physically move her to maintain sameness in structure or routine. These behaviors worsened in his second year. STUDENT seemed to enjoy social activities, and toward the end of the first year he could participate in group activities. In cognitive ability, he was at the bottom of his class of 11 to 13 students. He was lacking in social skills and language, but had some splinter skills; his gross motor skills were good, and he could read a few words. STUDENT would become upset from matters such as his aide varying in the way STUDENT was asked to write a letter (STUDENT would run or press his head onto the aide’s shoulder in a nonviolent way); by changes in the number or pattern of lights that were on compared to the previous day; and by a student sitting in a different seat from his or her normal seat. One day (during the second year), he came into the room upset and started putting the backpacks on the other students so that they would go out of the room and come in again. On some days he would insist on eating every grain of his rice before he would move to other activities.

By the end of the first year, STUDENT knew about 5 names from his class. He could follow some directions. He did well in a classroom discussion with a speech teacher but not in other groups. He was highly distractible and needed to be redirected. He had difficulty transitioning from one activity to another. He had no trouble if the situation was constantly changing, but he had trouble changing an established routine. During the IEP process in May 2000, Ms. Olsen believed that STUDENT should stay at SLDC and try perhaps a 2-period transition to a public school. She did not think he would be successful full-time in a public school because of excessive fluctuation in the environment and in his behavior. She felt that as of June 2000, he would have had a hard time in regular education classes. He would have been bothered by people changing desks. He would have had difficulty making friends. He would have had trouble in group/team physical education. Academically, he was not at seventh-grade level. He would not listen to a discussion at seventh-grade level. He would receptively derive little or nothing from the teacher speaking to the class, except that he would hear his assistant whispering as his assistant paraphrased the teacher’s oral communications. She believed STUDENT could not have made a transition from SLDC to full inclusion in September 2000, but SDC with some integration would have been reasonable. For such a program, consultation with SLDC would have been imperative, initially, so that his behaviors would be recognized as frustration, not as aggression. When he was upset, he would bolt out of the class as though with blinders on. Although no malice was intended by STUDENT, other people in the class might get hit by STUDENT as he ran from the room.

Ms. Olsen testified about STUDENT’s escalated behaviors in the fall of 2000. A tantrum event involving a mask occurred at Halloween. STUDENT was getting “hyped up”; then he bolted out to a field, where he ate grass and rolled on the ground screaming and crying for 20 to 30 minutes. He was pulling and grabbing at assistants to show how he felt. This was the first of more frequent incidents in which he would run farther into the field. The behaviors in the fall of 2000, according to Ms. Olsen, basically got extreme, and recovery, instead of being quick, could take hours or an entire afternoon. He was not imitating other students’ behaviors, except for what they would say. His behaviors were unique to him. Although he would not model his behaviors after other students, he would very often model his behaviors after adults, such as standing with his hand on his hip. After 1½ years, he would smile a lot more, had better eye contact, and his peers liked him and would hug him. He was able to work in the classroom group but very minimally. He worked best with a one-on-one aide in a quiet environment. She believes that in February 2001, when she last saw him, he could not have been successful in a rotating block schedule due to his behaviors. She testified that mainstreaming with STUDENT needed to be a slow process. Putting him in a big school would not be fair to him. Supports for mainstreaming would include an assistant, flexibility, and placing him in the same first period everyday. Starting with a rotating schedule would not be something he could do at first. In February 2001, he probably could have tolerated 1 or 2 periods in something he liked, such as band, but throwing him in all at once would have been too much for him to handle.

Ms. Olsen testified that she did not think STUDENT would benefit from being in a class with typical peers. He was on too much of an individualized plan, i.e. following 2-step directions and working on turn-taking skills vs. working on science. SLDC had a modified eighth-grade curriculum, but she did not think that curriculum would help STUDENT. He needed to develop social skills and get friendships with peers, but she was uncertain that a regular education peer would befriend him. She added that a new aide would require months and extensive discussion to understand STUDENT.

Ms. O’Conner. Ms. O’Conner, the director at SLDC, was also familiar with STUDENT. Her testimony was consistent with the testimony of Ms. Del Rosario and Ms. Olsen. She testified that when STUDENT arrived at SLDC, his needs for sameness, in her opinion, were extreme, and that the need for sameness continued. She mentioned that in language group, if the teacher used any pen other than a black pen on the board, it was difficult for STUDENT to stay in session. He would take the pen out of her hand and replace it with a black pen. He would sometimes hit or kick in an attempt to move people, but not with an intent to hurt them. The children in his class were accustomed to STUDENT, and they would allow him to move them. In June 2000, he required a high level of consistency in his environment. He could establish some basic parallel play, such as reciprocal poking. His relationships were more with the adults in his environment than the children. He could read some words and simple phrases, tell time to the ½ hour, understand concepts such as tall/short, big/little, over/under. She acknowledged that a boy had hit him once on the bus.

Ms. O’Conner thought the block schedule would have been extremely difficult for STUDENT to adapt to in June 2000. She thought he could feasibly be placed on a regular campus in an SDC, but that he could not handle a full-day rotating schedule in which almost every day would bring change. He needed structure and sameness in matters such as the location of the room and where the teacher and students would sit. If placed totally in regular education classes, he would need extreme supports, and she was not sure what he would gain from such a program academically. For example, he would gain nothing receptively in a seventh-grade English class. He would not follow the vocabulary or the speed of presentation, and he would need visual presentation rather than oral. She believed that at least in the classes at SLDC, STUDENT could access the state content standards in the general curriculum at grade level in certain courses, such as science, but only then with modification. He could stay with a group for about 45 minutes only if he was up and down and not in the same seat, but not for a 72-minute block.

Ms. O’Conner testified that the District’s program offer for the 2000-2001 school year would have been the LRE for STUDENT. Regarding why STUDENT would need some SDC in his schedule, Ms. O’Conner testified that teachers in an SDC were trained to deal with students who have STUDENT’s needs. The main advantage of an SDC is accommodation. An SDC teacher can assist the regular education teacher in needed accommodations. SDCs are smaller and provide more opportunities for individual or small-group instruction. The SDC would provide a home base where STUDENT could go if he needed sensory input, such as curling up in a bean bag chair. He needed a safe spot where he could go and people would understand him. In seventh or eighth grade, he would still be isolated because of the need for one-on-one individualized instruction and, in Ms. O’Conner’s opinon, he would not benefit socially by being in regular education classes. His probability of success in the program proposed by the District would be hard to predict. His success would depend on the type of classes, the skill of the people involved, and the support given to the aide. His running out and rolling on the ground was a result of too much sensory input and his need to seek further sensory input. In regular education, sensory integration training would be necessary. The aide and staff would have to understand STUDENT’s needs and how those needs were related to his behaviors. They would have to be taught how to use certain equipment to provide appropriate sensory input as required. Physical education, with its focus on gross motor, would not necessarily provide the needed sensory input.

Ms. Pfeiffer. Ms. Pfeiffer testified that she would have concerns about STUDENT in public school regular education classes because of his likely reactions to peers in large numbers, the rotating block schedule, and his needs for consistency in the environment, including consistency by the peers and staff, and in the physical surroundings. When he flees a room he is “in his own zone.” Fleeing would be disruptive to the other students. Other disruptions would occur from STUDENT doing the things that he needed to do to “reset himself,” such as bouncing, hitting, shaking his head, and vocalizing. She testified that STUDENT was distractible, but his distractions were not from other children speaking. Instead, distractions to STUDENT were environmental, like a new box of toys, a water bottle in a filing cabinet instead of on a desk, a chair in the wrong place, windows opened instead of closed, or the board eraser not always being in the same place. In response to those environmental distractions, STUDENT would insist on restoring his environment to the way he thought it should be. Typical peers would not understand his behavior and that might isolate him. He would need the SDC for part of the day for environmental consistency with respect to the classroom and who and what were in it. She thought he could be successful in a public school with a one-on-one aide only if he had SDC.

Patricia Tipton. Ms. Tipton is the supervisor of SLDC’s speech and language pathology department. She testified about STUDENT’s need for sameness and structure. She described how STUDENT insisted on sameness such as the therapist having her hands on the table instead of on her lap and always going out the same door. He would often try to recreate the setting to correct the environmental disturbance that he perceived.

E. The Student’s expert witnesses.

The Student’s chief expert witnesses regarding least restrictive environment were Dr. Sailor and Dr. Gee. Both witnesses testified and presented narrative reports. Dr. Sailor is a professor in the department of special education at the University of Kansas, where he is also co-coordinator for the severe disabilities program. He holds a Ph.D. in psychology. Most of his research activities are related to evaluating ways of improving the education of children with disabilities in settings where the disabled children are integrated with nondisabled (typical) peers. Dr. Gee is an associate professor in the special education program, School of Education, at St. Mary’s college in California. She holds Ph.D. in special education. He has numerous publications, including some co-authored with Dr. Sailor. Both witnesses had impressive experience and accomplishments in their field.

Dr. Sailor. Dr. Sailor’s March 20, 2001 report (Student Ex. 61) and testimony show that he was retained by STUDENT’s father to conduct an observational assessment of STUDENT to address the question of his educational placement and instructional needs. His initial observations of STUDENT were in March 2001. The observations were made at STUDENT’s home and during community outings with STUDENT’s family for several hours over a period of 2 or 3 days. Dr. Sailor also reviewed the available documentary materials pertinent to STUDENT’s educational program.

Dr. Sailor’s impressions of STUDENT were that he exhibited a variety of characteristics consistent of a child on the spectrum of autism disorders. He had significant impairments in speech and language development and delays in cognitive development associated with that disability. He had some stereotypic behavior. He had exaggerated responses to stressful events in his family and to frustration from his communication deficits. STUDENT’s responses did not appear to be violent, and they seemed to be easily remediated through redirection and negotiation. Dr. Sailor believed that the responses should not be difficult to manage in a general education setting with appropriate supports. Regarding STUDENT’s strengths, Dr. Sailor found him to be at the positive end of the spectrum for persons his age with autism on a number of characteristics, including a remarkably well-developed sense of humor and friendliness to a stranger in the family context (presumably Dr. Sailor); more willingness to tolerate disruptions in his daily routines than others with autism; an ability to communicate with a physical prompting procedure to signal his intents and desires; a strong motivation to acquire and use speech in a functional manner relative to his peers with autism; a strong social orientation and comfort in complex social situations such as restaurants. Dr. Sailor thought STUDENT was “very attentive” and appeared quite bright and alert in certain areas, with a potential to develop some skills to a very high level above others his age. In short, STUDENT was non-threatening, social, and motivated to learn and acquire new skills.

Dr. Sailor’s extensive recommendations included, in summary form: (1) immediate placement in an age-appropriate general education school, with a trained instructional aide; (2) an inclusive educational placement and program that would not segregate him from contact with his general education peers, further consisting of placement in those general education classes where his assessment information would suggest that he can benefit within the parameters of his disability; (3) exemption from standardized testing; (4) curricular adaptations and accommodations as needed, by peer supports, a speech and language therapist on the instructional team, a classroom aide whose role would be defined as classroom support rather than a one-on-one, thereby facilitating inclusion with STUDENT and creating circumstances favorable to all the students in the classroom; (5) immersion in a community-based instruction in a variety of off-campus environments during the portions of the school day where STUDENT was not in a general education classroom or in physical education or recreational activity with typical peers; (6) planning for STUDENT’s first “transitional” year beginning at age 14 for post-secondary education support; (7) placement in STUDENT’s local school so he could develop relationships in his immediate community; (8) further assessment primarily in the form of situational assessment of STUDENT in a variety of community and school-based instructional environments including the general education classroom, and a minimum of standardized assessment, as standardized testing would contribute little useful information relevant to STUDENT’s immediate educational needs.

Regarding the District’s program offer for the 2000-2001 school year, Dr. Sailor had several criticisms. Nearly all of his criticism, however, was derived from his firm belief that STUDENT should have no involvement in an SDC. Dr. Sailor believed that SDC would not benefit STUDENT. Consequently, placing him at Marine View because of the categorical description of the SDC would serve no purpose. Dr. Sailor testified that STUDENT would not be best served by an SDC for children with severe disabilities because he was too highly motivated to pursue new knowledge and be a social person. In Dr. Sailor’s opinion, STUDENT was more like a typical seventh grader than he was like children with severe disabilities. Dr. Sailor also stated that speech and language services should not be provided in “pull-out” sessions, but should be integrated into the regular classroom. He believed that although STUDENT would not benefit from listening to lectures in a general education class, in most general education settings the lecture approach is not used as much as interactive teaching in groups, an area where STUDENT is at his best. Dr. Sailor also believed the goals and objectives for STUDENT were not aligned to his performance and deficits, would not lead to meaningful educational progress, and were drafted from the position that he is a special student without referencing the general curriculum. For example, he thought the entire page of goals and objectives for scissor skills was not going to be useful for a seventh grader. He thought the District’s proposal took the position that special education in general was considered to be a place instead of a support. He thought that STUDENT could access the seventh-grade core curriculum with modifications, and that standardized assessment might be needed to know his levels in core subjects such as math. Dr. Sailor also thought the District’s approach to transitions was misplaced. He thought STUDENT needed order and structure as quickly as possible, not a mixed and matched set of transitions in small steps.

Dr. Gee. Dr. Gee’s opinions were consistent with those of Dr. Sailor. Her report and testimony show that on June 5, 2001, she spent about seven hours with STUDENT at his home and in the community. She considered STUDENT, in her words, to have a delightful personality and to be curious, a quick learner through modeling and imitation, able to handle variation quite well, and to have tremendous educational possibilities. She believed that his educational needs would best be met by educating him in several settings, including general education classes, other parts of the general education school building (such as cafeteria, office, halls, locker room), and in the community. She believed that such settings would provide natural and functional contexts for instruction of a wide range of important skills.

Dr. Gee saw no benefit whatsoever to STUDENT’s attending an SDC. Dr. Gee was aware of STUDENT’s behavioral issues, but she thought they could be well-managed in a general education setting with proper supports and a positive behavior plan, as determined by observing his behaviors in different situations. She felt that his behavioral issues were primarily a result of his frustrations in trying to communicate. She felt that his need for sameness that she had observed (closing car doors in a certain order, shutting down the computer in a certain order, setting the table in a certain order) could be easily managed. She thought his ability to read, even if mainly by word recognition instead of decoding, was a tremendous advantage in educating him. She acknowledged that, despite his many strengths, he had splinter skills at about first-grade level. She felt he could access the seventh- grade curriculum with modification. For example, his teacher could determine what aspects of a particular instructional unit in a given class would be feasible for him to learn. If given a book, such as Tom Sawyer, that the class was reading, he would not be able to read the book, but he could still participate by looking for certain words in the book or remembering key characters. She noted that unless children are exposed to a general education curriculum, they are not exposed to as much important vocabulary expansion, such as the concepts of oceans, mountains, and gases. His computer skills would allow him to work on a laptop computer in class when he could not benefit from the particular class activity. Dr. Gee believed that success for STUDENT would be mainly a function of how committed the District would be toward accommodating his needs in a coordinated plan. She thought an “ecological” assessment was essential to permit the informed drafting of goals and objectives, meaning that STUDENT would be observed in a variety of settings, and she thought that standardized testing would provide little or no functional information. Regarding SDC and goals and objectives offered by the District, she thought they were related almost exclusively to communication, and she would be concerned that other children in the SDC might not have the skills to be a communication partner with STUDENT. She thought the goals and objectives should be aligned to what other children were doing in the regular education class, with appropriate modifications. She classified the District’s goals as “deficit based,” meaning that one determines what STUDENT cannot do and then tries to develop the next step in the chain. The better model, according to Dr. Gee, would be one that considers that he is now 14 years old and asks what can be done with goals and objectives for a job, for accessing and living in the community, and for functioning in a work setting. She thought the District goal and objective for using scissors was pointless for a child his age.(Footnote 47)

When called on rebuttal by the Student, Dr. Gee testified that it was “ridiculous” to say that because the Student has behaviors, he cannot be fully included. When asked whether Marine View would be acceptable over STUDENT’s home school at Spring View if the program at Marine View was better, she answered yes, as long as Marine View had a fantastic program and teachers for STUDENT.

Ms. Roger. Ms. Roger is an independent consultant. She is acquainted with Dr. Gee. She reviewed STUDENT’s file in about 3 hours, and concluded that an SDC would provide no benefit to STUDENT and that his program should contain no SDC. She thought there was no danger of regression if STUDENT was promptly place in full inclusion with proper supports. None of the children she supports have an SDC in their program. Her transition strategy for STUDENT would be to immediately place STUDENT in the environment where one ultimately wanted him to be (not SDC) and assess him there.

STEPMOTHER. STEPMOTHER testified that she observed Spring View, and she thought that STUDENT could successfully attend Spring View. Spring View had small-group interaction and also students learning individually. STEPMOTHER disputed the notion that regular education classes have less structure than an SDC. STUDENT learns by modeling and imitation. She thought that STUDENT would learn better in a quiet environment with typical peers that he could model. She thought that a laptop computer would enable STUDENT to access the general curriculum in a modified way. By using headphones, he could do his work in the regular education classes quietly with a laptop. He would need an instructional aide at the beginning to make meaning of the social structure and curriculum. She testified that to construct a successful program for STUDENT, one would have to consider the entire campus as part of the setting for STUDENT and “make changes as you go.” Accordingly, the eventual structure of a program at Spring View for STUDENT could not presently be described.

F. Discussion.

The matter to be resolved is whether the District’s program offer satisfied the requirement for educating STUDENT in the least restrictive environment (LRE). The 4-prong balancing test from Rachel H., supra, is applicable. The first factor is:

(1) the educational benefits available to the child in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared to the educational benefits of a special education classroom;

The Student’s experts testified that placement in seventh-grade regular education classrooms, with supports and curriculum modifications, would have provided educational benefit to STUDENT. Dr. Sailor testified that he observed STUDENT to be “very attentive” and quite bright and alert in certain areas, with a potential to develop some skills to a very high level above others his age. Dr. Sailor testified that STUDENT’s responses did not appear to be violent and seemed to be easily remediated through redirection and negotiation. He testified that one of STUDENT’s strengths was his willingness to tolerate disruptions in his daily routines compared to others with autism. Dr. Sailor testified that in group teaching, such as the small groups that Dr. Sailor would envision in regular education classes, STUDENT was at his best. He stated that he thought STUDENT could access the seventh-grade core curriculum with modifications. Dr. Gee described STUDENT as a quick learner through modeling and imitation, able to handle variation quite well, and having tremendous educational possibilities. She thought that STUDENT’s need for sameness, as observed by her, could be easily managed. She characterized as “ridiculous” the notion that STUDENT’s behaviors should preclude him from being fully included. She acknowledged that, despite his many strengths, STUDENT had splinter skills at about first-grade level, but she felt that he could access a modified seventh-grade curriculum.

The Student’s experts testified that one or more periods of an SDC would have provided no benefit to STUDENT. Dr. Sailor testified that STUDENT was more like a typical seventh grader than he was like children with severe disabilities. He stated that STUDENT would not be best served by an SDC for children with severe disabilities because STUDENT was too highly motivated to pursue new knowledge and be a social person. Dr. Gee testified that if STUDENT was placed in an SDC, the other children in the SDC might not have the skills to be a communication partner with him.

The description of STUDENT’s needs and abilities by the SLDC staff differed sharply from the portrayal of STUDENT given by Dr. Sailor and Dr. Gee. The SLDC staff testified that STUDENT would have had great difficulty in regular education classes. They testified that STUDENT was not attentive, and he was quite susceptible to environmental distractions. They described STUDENT’s need for sameness as frequently being extreme. The list of instances in which he required sameness was extensive, with each witness adding new examples to the list. His responses often were not easily remediated. The SLDC staff gave examples of how the students in STUDENT’s class would comply with his demands for the purpose of allowing STUDENT to maintain control of his behavior. Some of those examples involved STUDENT’s classmates changing seats, going out of the room and coming back, and allowing him to put their backpacks on them, all as a result of STUDENT needing to recreate a preferred routine or environmental setting. A higher level of behavior or need for sameness, not easily remediated under any circumstances, was shown by the incidents in the fall of 2000 when STUDENT would run into a field, eat grass, roll in the grass, and try to physically keep people away who were trying to assist him. Regarding academics, Ms. Olsen taught STUDENT for nearly 2 years at SLDC. She considered STUDENT to be at the bottom her class in cognitive ability. The goals and objectives derived from SLDC, from STEPMOTHER, and subsequently blended together by the District, do not indicate that STUDENT is a quick learner.

The SLDC staff members testified that for STUDENT to receive educational benefit, he needed to be in an SDC setting for a substantial portion of his school day. In support of that opinion, they referred to STUDENT’s extensive needs arising from severe deficits in receptive language, expressive language, and language pragmatics; from severe academic deficits with splinter skills at kindergarten or first grade level; from his ease in being severely distracted by subtle changes in his environment; from his deficits in maintaining behavioral organization; from his limitations in coping with changes in his environment; and from his behaviors related to and arising from the foregoing. They generally considered STUDENT’s needs in the above-stated areas to be severe in terms of affecting STUDENT in his ability to learn. They considered those needs to be so severe and so far removed from the regular seventh-grade curriculum and classroom environment that STUDENT’s participation in regular education classes would provide him with little or no educational benefit.

The services that the SLDC staff considered as necessary for STUDENT were consistent with the type of services offered by the District in Ms. Franklin’s SDC. The District employees testified that Ms. Franklin’s SDC would have emphasized oral language and other forms of communication activities in a variety of settings where STUDENT could both learn and build upon skills and make progress toward his goals and objectives, including academic and speech and language goals and objectives. They described the supports in the SDC at Marine View that included a highly skilled SDC teacher, classroom assistants, typical peer classroom aides that would have been interested in STUDENT’s progress, and a flexible environment and pace conducive to meeting STUDENT’s needs. They also testified that STUDENT would have had access in the SDC to an educational program at a level meaningful to him for most of his time with his SDC group, either in the classroom or in the community.

With regard to STUDENT’s skills and deficits, especially as applicable to the matter of LRE, the Hearing Officer considers the testimony of the SLDC staff to be more persuasive than the testimony of the Student’s experts. The SLDC staff possessed a superior level of experience with STUDENT, having provided services to him from 1999 through mid-February 2001. The SLDC staff had seen STUDENT perform in a classroom environment. By contrast, Dr. Sailor and Dr. Gee had seen STUDENT for only a few hours, and they had not seen him perform in a classroom environment. The SLDC reports provided important information about STUDENT’s performance in classroom settings, and those reports were available to Dr. Sailor and Dr. Gee. However, the Student’s experts consistently minimized or disregarded the information in the SLDC progress reports in favor of their own limited observations of STUDENT in his home environment or with family members on community outings. On the basis of their limited observations of STUDENT, the Student’s experts formed conclusions about STUDENT that were contrary to the weight of the evidence.

For example, Dr. Sailor, who had never observed STUDENT in a classroom or small-group setting, testified that in the small-group teaching that he expected STUDENT would encounter in a regular education class, STUDENT would be at his best. Dr. Sailor’s assertion about STUDENT being at his best in small-group teaching was effectively invalidated by the testimony of STUDENT’s classroom teacher, Ms. Olsen, who stated that in her class at SLDC, STUDENT was able to work in the classroom group, but very minimally, and that he worked best with a one-on-one aide in a quiet environment. Dr. Gee emphasized her opinion that STUDENT, as observed by her, was able to handle variation quite well, and that his need for sameness could be easily managed in a regular education classroom. Dr. Gee’s opinion was refuted by testimony from SLDC staff members who had actually observed STUDENT in classroom settings, who characterized his need for sameness as frequently being extreme, and who supported that characterization with numerous examples derived from their personal observations.

Dr. Gee, Dr. Sailor, and even STEPMOTHER seemed to be presuming that their observations of how STUDENT acted at home or in community settings with his family members would be the same, both qualitatively and quantitatively, in classroom settings at a school. This approach was curious. One would expect that after stressing the importance of an ecological assessment, i.e. knowing how STUDENT performs in different environments, Dr. Sailor and Dr. Gee would have placed significant value on the information available from the SLDC reports and staff. The approach by the Student’s experts reinforced an impression that they were selectively considering information supportive of their own predisposition for avoiding SDCs, and that they were discounting any information about STUDENT that would cause one to seriously question STUDENT’s ability to benefit in a regular education classroom.

With regard to recommendations for placement, the Hearing Officer considers the testimony of the SLDC staff and the District employees to be more persuasive than the testimony of the Student’s experts. Dr. Sailor and Dr. Gee showed an intense preference for regular education classes in all but the rarest of situations. They showed a correspondingly low regard for the usefulness of SDCs. They refrained from seriously considering whether the particular SDC offered by the District had special attributes that could benefit STUDENT. The testimony of the District’s witnesses showed that the attributes of a placement in Ms. Franklin’s SDC at Marine View had far more to offer students than the preconceived notions held by Dr. Sailor and Dr. Gee regarding SDCs in general would suggest. For example, Dr. Gee expressed her concern that if STUDENT was placed in an SDC, the other children in the SDC might not have the skills to be a communication partner with him. That matter was put to rest by the testimony of Ms. Larsen, who is knowledgeable about the SDC proposed for STUDENT. She testified that in addition to the regular education students who came to Ms. Franklin’s SDC, the class also had some very verbal students who would initiate and maintain conversations. Dr. Sailor offered his opinion that STUDENT would not be best served by an SDC for children with severe disabilities because STUDENT was too highly motivated to pursue new knowledge and be a social person. Aside from the Hearing Officer disagreeing with the general implication that children with severe disabilities are not motivated to pursue new knowledge and be social, Dr. Sailor’s concept of an SDC was contrary to the role that the District had designed for Ms. Franklin’s SDC. Ms. Franklin’s class was designed to be a setting where children would learn academics appropriate to their level of ability, where they would learn to communicate, where they would learn social skills, where they would learn functional vocational and community skills, and where they would learn to generalize those skills for interaction with typical peers. In addition to their failure to seriously consider whether the particular SDC offered by the District had special attributes that could benefit STUDENT, the Student’s experts, as mentioned above, largely ignored important information about STUDENT that was available from various SLDC reports.

The above-stated factors have led the Hearing Officer to conclude that instead of Dr. Sailor and Dr. Gee focusing on STUDENT’s individual needs and the particular characteristics of the SDC offered by the District, their strong predispositions regarding regular education classes and SDCs constituted the primary basis for their placement recommendations. Moreover, to whatever extent the Student’s experts may have considered the Student as an individual with unique needs, the evidence showed that their description of STUDENT’s needs and deficits was not indicative of how STUDENT performed in classroom settings at SLDC, nor should it be considered indicative of how STUDENT would have performed in a regular education classroom.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s deficits would have been highly problematic in regular education classes for purposes of educational benefit. Even with supports, STUDENT’s deficits in communication, behavioral organization, attention, and academics would have strongly tended to isolate him from meaningful interaction with his typical peers and with the classroom teacher. Without a major amount of support by an appropriate SDC program, the pursuit of educational benefit for the Student would have been largely relegated to the type of program that the Student’s witnesses described as advantageous to him. Specifically, STUDENT would have spent a major percentage of his time seated in regular education classes, attempting to learn either through his one-on-one aide, through his laptop computer programs, or through a combination of both. If the District had proposed that STUDENT, with his severe deficits, be given the bulk of his academic curriculum through computer programs and the services of a one-on-one aide, the proposal would have been quickly labeled as irresponsible. The fact that a similar proposal was advanced by the Student and his experts did not transform it into a reasonable idea. Such a proposal was equivalent to inclusion for the sake of inclusion, with distant regard for appropriately meeting STUDENT’s needs.

Even if STUDENT had been able to attend, participate, and learn in a regular seventh-grade class to the extent asserted by the Student’s experts, the Hearing Officer did not find the educational benefits of a modified seventh-grade curriculum, as described by Dr. Gee, to be particularly impressive. Dr. Gee testified that STUDENT could have been asked to pick out certain words or characters in a book that the entire class might be reading, such as Tom Sawyer. That modification to the curriculum would have been made in consideration of the fact that STUDENT could not actually read the book. Dr. Gee also noted that unless children are exposed to a general education curriculum, they are not exposed to as much important vocabulary expansion, such as the concepts of oceans, mountains, and gases. These examples by Dr. Gee actually illustrated some of the points made by the SLDC director, Ms. O’Conner, who testified that in regular education classes STUDENT would need extreme supports, and she was not sure what he would gain from such a program academically. For example, he would gain nothing receptively in a seventh-grade English class. He would not follow the vocabulary or the speed of presentation, and he would need visual presentation as opposed to oral. In any event, the Hearing Officer finds that although such activities and results as described by Dr. Gee might be considered as beneficial, that level of educational benefit would not have justified elimination or major reduction of the program elements that STUDENT could have received in Ms. Franklin’s SDC at Marine View.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the educational benefits that would have been available to STUDENT in the SDC proposed by the District far outweigh the educational benefits that would have been available to STUDENT in a regular seventh-grade classroom supplemented with aids and services. Furthermore, foregoing the array and quality of services that would have been available in Ms. Franklin’s SDC for the purpose of allowing STUDENT to sit predominantly in isolation through regular education classes cannot be justified. Therefore, this “first prong” of the Holland factors shows that the majority of each of STUDENT’s school days at the commencement of the 2000-2001 school year should have been in the SDC and in community and other activities associated with the SDC.

(2) the non-academic benefits to the disabled child of interaction with nondisabled children;

With respect to the non-academic benefits that STUDENT would have derived from interaction with typical peers, i.e. socialization, the parties do not dispute that STUDENT needed social interaction with typical peers, and he needed exposure to typical peers that he could imitate and model. However, the evidence showed that STUDENT would have faced significant isolation in regular education classes. His severe deficits in speech and language would have rendered meaningful oral communication with his typical peers and with the teacher almost nil in a regular classroom setting. STUDENT’s highly individualized program, involving activities such as following 2-step directions and working on turn-taking skills, would have further impaired his already minimal ability to interactively share in the regular academic curriculum with his typical peers. STUDENT would also have required a full-time aide in regular education classes, both to teach him and to monitor his proprioceptive needs. The presence of an aide would not be conducive to direct social interaction between STUDENT and his typical peers. STUDENT’s need for sameness and his associated behaviors would also have tended to isolate him from his typical peers.

Accordingly, meaningful social interaction in regular education classes would have been the exception rather than the rule. By comparison, the typical peers working in STUDENT’s SDC would have been readily accessible in a situation deisgned for STUDENT to interact with them. Furthermore, with the components of inclusion in the District’s offer, STUDENT would have received a good balance of learning basic skills in Ms. Franklin’s SDC, learning to generalize those skills in the SDC, and applying what he learned to selective inclusion opportunities with typical peers outside of the SDC.

In summary, after comparing the program proposed by the Student to the program proposed by the District, the Hearing Officer finds that the non-academic benefits to STUDENT from interaction with nondisabled children would have been better received through the program proposed by the District. In the Student’s proposal, STUDENT would have faced isolation for major portions of his school day. In the District’s proposal, STUDENT could have learned skills in the SDC, interacted with typical peers in the SDC, and had a portion of his day in regular education settings where he could apply the communication and socialization skills learned in the SDC.

3) the effect of the presence of the disabled child on the teacher and other children in the regular classroom;

Regarding the effect of STUDENT’s presence on the teacher and other children in the regular classroom, the evidence showed that STUDENT had distracting effects on his classmates at SLDC. In a regular education setting, the distractions to his classmates would have been partially mitigated by a well-trained aide and by carefully monitoring STUDENT’s needs for proprioceptive input to maintain his behavioral organization. STUDENT could have received some of his needed proprioceptive input within the classroom, and other activities could have been done for brief periods outside of the classroom. Disruption to the class for STUDENT to receive those OT services would have been insignificant. However, as shown by Ms. Pfeiffer’s testimony and other testimony from the SLDC staff, a significant degree of unavoidable disruption to other students would have occurred from STUDENT doing the more subtle things that he needed to do to “reset himself,” such as bouncing, hitting, shaking his head, and vocalizing. STUDENT’s need for sameness would have had additional disruptive effects on the class, especially if STUDENT insisted on recreating a certain environmental setting that no one could identify. One should also expect, on the basis of testimony from Ms. Del Rosario and other SLDC staff, that incidents of STUDENT suddenly fleeing the room would have occurred from unpredictable environmental changes that were intolerable for STUDENT.

The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s presence in a regular education classroom would have had some adverse effects on the teacher and other children in that classroom. Those adverse effects could, on occasion, have been severely disruptive to the class.

(4) the costs of supplementary aids and services necessary to mainstream the disabled child in a regular classroom setting.

No evidence was presented in STUDENT’s case regarding cost, and that factor is not considered by the Hearing Officer.

Conclusions. The Hearing Officer finds that the three applicable factors from Rachel H., considered in the context of STUDENT’s needs, all weigh heavily in favor of the program offered by the District, including the apportionment of time for SDC compared to other activities. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program offer for the 2000-2001 school year satisfied the requirements of LRE.

With regard to the Student’s contention that his attendance at his home school, Spring View, would have been the LRE, the Hearing Officer acknowledges that, if all other factors were equal, placement at STUDENT’s home school may have been the least restrictive environment for the 2000-2001 school year. However, all other factors were not equal. STUDENT needed an effective SDC program. The effectiveness of an SDC program was vital to STUDENT’s ability to benefit academically from his education and his ability to successfully interact with typical peers and in the community. The SDC program at Marine View was designed for that purpose. The District’s witnesses did not believe that the SDC program at Spring View would have met STUDENT’s needs, and no one was more knowledgeable than the District to compare its own SDCs. The evidence also showed that the difference in distance between STUDENT’s home to Spring View and STUDENT’s home to Marine View was not a significant factor.

Procedural Appropriateness

I. IEP meetings.

The Student alleges that the District failed to allow the Student’s parents the opportunity to participate in IEP meetings and failed to complete IEP meetings. The evidence conclusively shows the contrary. Moreover, the evidence shows that the District expended extraordinary effort to protect the Student’s procedural rights. The record demonstrated that cancelled and/or failed IEP meetings were almost entirely the result of the Student’s father electing not appear at meetings, canceling meetings, not managing his mail and answering machine, and unreasonably refusing to defer to Mr. Hemsley in matters related to the procedural course of the IEP meetings that the father chose to attend.

II. Assessment.

The Student alleges that the District failed to conduct a timely and complete assessment of the Student in all areas of his suspected disabilities, including, but not limited to, a functional analysis assessment and an assistive technology assessment.

Section 56320 of the Cal. Educ. Code provides, in pertinent part, that before any action is taken with respect to the initial placement of a child with exceptional needs in special education instruction, the child shall be assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability. For purposes of Sec. 56320, the District’s placement offer for the 2000-2001 school year is not considered by the Hearing Officer to be an initial placement that would have required an assessment prior to the placement offer.

Section 56381 provides that a district shall conduct a reassessment of the pupil at least once every 3 years or more frequently, if conditions warrant a reassessment, or if the pupil’s parent or teacher requests an assessment and a new individualized education program to be developed. No reassessment shall be conducted unless the written consent of the parent is obtained prior to reassessment, or the assessment is approved and/or ordered through due process.

With respect to the requirements of Sec. 56381, the record showed that the Student and the District have been embroiled in assessment disputes since 1990. As nearly as can be discerned from the record, the District’s last assessment of STUDENT was performed, at least to some extent, in 1995 and/or 1996 following due process and federal court intervention. Disputes over assessment and placement were intended by the parties to be set aside by the April 1999 settlement agreement. The April 1999 agreement provided that a triennial assessment would not be due until February 2001. The District submitted a triennial assessment plan in January 2001. In determining whether circumstances warranted reassessment prior to February 2001, the Hearing Officer has considered the long history of assessment disputes and other disputes between the parties, STUDENT’s documented progress at SLDC, and STUDENT’s interest in avoiding new controversies that would have unduly jeopardized the relative status quo that was enabling him to progress at SLDC. On the basis of those factors, the Hearing Officer concludes that conditions did not warrant an attempt at reassessment, a specific assessment for assistive technology, or a functional analysis assessment prior to February 2001. Furthermore, no persuasive evidence was presented to show that an assessment was definitively requested by the father or by a teacher between the execution of the April 1999 settlement agreement and District’s submission of a triennial assessment plan in January 2001. Accordingly, for purposes of determining whether procedural violations regarding assessment may have denied STUDENT a FAPE by causing a loss of educational opportunity or seriously infringing on the father’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process, the Hearing Officer finds that through February 2001, the District did not fail to conduct a timely and complete assessment of the Student in all areas of his suspected disabilities.

With respect to the period from the end of February 2001 through the remainder of the 2000-2001 school year, the Hearing Officer finds there was no denial of FAPE to the Student arising from lack of assessment. The record showed that the District acted with diligence throughout the remainder of the school year in its attempts to have the father consent to an assessment plan. Actions by the District included revision of the plan on April 3, 2001, to include provisions that were eventually requested by the father. The District also filed for due process in the spring of 2001 to obtain an order allowing it to conduct the triennial assessment. That case was subsequently withdrawn by the District when it became apparent the hearing would be so long and protracted that the plan would need to be revised before the hearing could be completed.

III. Other alleged procedural violations.

Throughout the course of the due process hearing, the Student alleged a variety of other procedural violations by the District and WOCCSE. As stated above, procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to a student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G., supra, at 1484. However, none of the other procedural violations alleged by the Student, even if proven, would have resulted in a loss of educational opportunity to the Student or denied the father opportunity to participate in the IEP process to such a degree as to constitute a denial of FAPE. Accordingly, consideration of those alleged procedural violations would not affect the outcome of this Decision, and they are not addressed.

Findings

The Hearing Officer finds that the District offered the Student a FAPE in the least restrictive environment for the 2000-2001 school year.

Issue No. 2: Did the District offer a FAPE to the Student in the least restrictive environment for the 2001-2002 school year?

Substantive Appropriateness

I. Did the District offer a program for the 2001-2002 school year that was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs? A. STUDENT’s unique needs.

New information regarding STUDENT’s needs as he approached the 2001-2002 school year was limited. STUDENT’s father had not consented to the District’s triennial assessment plans and, consequently, assessment by the District had not been performed. Available sources of information included SLDC progress reports completed prior to STUDENT’s departure from SLDC, observations of Dr. Sailor and Dr. Gee, and reporting from STEPMOTHER and STUDENT’s father. A speech and language progress report by Ms. Pfeiffer from SLDC dated January 15, 2001 (D/W Ex. DD), gives a detailed summary of STUDENT’s status in behavior, receptive language, expressive language, and pragmatics. In behavior, he was demonstrating an overall increase in self-stimulatory, compulsive, and agitated behaviors over the past few months that were affecting his performance during speech and language sessions. Although STUDENT’s progress in skills had plateaued, he had made significant overall progress during the past year. He was answering concrete, personally relevant and factual yes/no questions given a visual referant with 80% accuracy and increased self-correction. He was able to follow familiar, 2-step related directions with occasional repetition. Accuracy for following novel, 2-step unrelated directions involving tabletop manipulatives was 75% without repetition. Accuracy decreased to 65% for classroom-related directions and 35% for pencil and paper tasks given multiple repetitions. Similar specificity was listed in the report for understanding of the spatial concepts “top/bottom,” and “under” contrasted with “next to” (70%); answering “who” and “what” questions (70-75%, under 50% when mixed); taking turns during one-one-one game interactions (70% when given verbal/gestural cues and a written script); using “hi” and “bye” responsively in combination with a familiar person’s name (at least 80%).

For receptive language, Ms. Pfeiffer’s report states that semantic skills were limited but increasing. STUDENT was demonstrating increased comprehension of school-related nouns (such as eraser, stapler, paper clips, marker, shelf, drawer), verbs (34 familiar actions), and prepositions (6 basic spatial concepts). Comprehension of word forms and grammar structures required for basic survival was significantly limited. “Wh” question comprehension was emerging. He could not yet discern between singular versus plural, reversible subject-verb-object, and present and past tense. Comprehension of auditory stimuli continued to be impeded by his difficulties in attending to task. Comprehension of abstract language was problematic but aided by focusing attention and using familiar vocabulary within short, succinct messages.

For expressive language, Ms. Pfeiffer’s report states that STUDENT could independently combine noun, verbs, and some adjectives to describe pictures, objects, or actions. He was able to request a specific color and shape, such as “blue circle.” He required cues for size (big/small). He had started using 4- to 5-word sentences. STUDENT had echolalic speech that would increase with his level of discomfort, demonstrated more often in novel settings, transitioning between activities/places, or when anxious about his current situation. He also had perseverative speech behaviors that coincided with his level of anxiety. He had recently begun to overwhelmingly end the majority of his utterances with “yes please.”

For language pragmatics, Ms. Pfeiffer’s report states that STUDENT’s independent functioning in the areas of social language continued to be significantly impaired. A brief attending time hampered his topic maintenance, elaboration and diversity, and overall conversational competence. Behavioral characteristics such as bouncing, hitting his hand on the table/wall, clapping, vocal perseverations, pushing, scratching, and manual manipulation of another’s body (usually hands, feet, arms, legs, head position, and proximity) were interfering with social relationships and learning. Language breakdowns, transitions to new situations, or inconsistencies in environment (where the therapist is sitting) and changes in routines (manner in which he enters/exits a room, method of transportation to school, parent observations) could induce the onset of behaviors. Ms. Del Rosario’s OT progress report from SLDC dated February 14, 2001 (D/W Ex. DD), states that STUDENT was now able to engage in activities other than those that had a proprioceptive element in them. He was more capable of doing desk-type activities without getting disorganized. These improvements demonstrated a more organized proprioceptive system. In the classroom, he was more able to focus after engaging in proprioceptive activities, suggesting that such activities should be incorporated at regular intervals during regular school hours. STUDENT was showing significant improvement in vestibular processing, with improved balance and postural control. He could now try novel movement experiences without getting disorganized. Ocular motor skills had also improved. He had increased control with writing and cutting implements. Behavioral organization was significantly improved. Attention span had improved. He could tolerate more challenging tasks without getting disorganized, and he did not need as much verbal and physical prompts to follow through with novel experiences. Once STUDENT would set his mind on how things were done, it was sometimes difficult to reason with him, and he might not allow the staff to show him other ways of dealing with situations. In such instances, he would get disorganized and “fall apart.” He would perseverate, and the whole scenario would have to be reenacted to his thinking in order for him to be organized again. This posed difficulties in cases where going back to the situation was not possible, or as Ms. Del Rosario added in her testimony, when the situation that caused the disorganization (i.e. something out of place in a room) could not be identified. STUDENT displayed difficulty interacting with other children in the clinic; he would take turns but displayed limited contact with them. He needed social prompts to interact effectively with other children, and he was observed to do parallel play rather than interactive play.

Ms. Del Rosario concluded in her report that STUDENT had made remarkable progress, particularly in ocular motor control, and that clinic-based OT was no longer needed. Instead, a one-hour classroom consult per week was recommended to facilitate successful reintegration into the classroom and playground. An adequate sensory “diet” would have to be maintained. Evaluation for individual adaptive physical education was recommended, as STUDENT exhibited good skills but had difficulty integrating those skills to play effectively with peers.

Ms. Olsen, STUDENT’s classroom teacher at SLDC, prepared an annual progress report dated February 15, 2001. (D/W Ex. DD.) The report states that STUDENT was receiving OT and speech and language services in addition to his classroom program, and that he required the services of a one-on-one aide for 5 ½ hours per day for frequent redirection, educational support, and behavioral needs. Current levels of performance in language, academics, fine-motor/self-help skills, social/emotional, and student strengths were listed. As examples of his levels of performance, he could orally request a desired item using a stereotypic sentence, but he required prompting not to answer his own sentence. He was able to greet 5 of 17 class members by using “hi” and “bye” and their own name’s with 70% accuracy given verbal/gestural cue from the receiver. He could identify 17 body parts. He had made progress in the “Language!” reading program, and could match initial consonant sounds to printed words (b, d, p, j, t, s, m, f, and d), and he had begun to use phonetics in sounding out CVC words. He could identify coins and paper money by name and value with 70% accuracy. He could tell time to the half hour on the classroom clock. With direct adult supervision, he could enter the classroom, “bid good morning,” and hang up his jacket and backpack. He could perform unspecified classroom jobs with minimal assistance. He could sit and work on a task for up to 20 minutes at a time with assistance. He could cut and color within the lines with monitoring. He could go to his therapies independently, but needed to be monitored to walk instead of run. He had developed friendships with peers in and out of his current classroom. He could play structured games, like memory, with peers, given verbal cues for turn taking and following the rules of the game. He had difficulty with transitions, experiencing heightened frustration when routines were broken. He would manipulate a person’s body to correct an unwanted change or flee from the situation, depending on his level of frustration. He worked best in a quiet environment with a one- on-one aide. STUDENT’s strengths included understanding of initial consonants with great accuracy. His presence was enjoyed by his peers, who would express concern when he was absent. He could perform routine tasks with ease. The observations of Dr. Sailor and Dr. Gee have been recounted above. Dr. Brown testified that he did not find STUDENT to be at all distractible when he observed him for about 3 hours in May 2001 in a hotel, restaurant, and drive to the airport. Ms. Appel observed STUDENT on October 15, 2001. She testified that he could easily become overstimulated. His attention span was brief. He needed increased time to understand what was being said. His speech was mostly echolalic.

STUDENT’s father testified that STUDENT had improved greatly over the past year. His activities included skating and bungy jumping. STUDENT wanted to do whatever his sisters were doing. His reading and memory skills were improved. He was using speech to direct their dog. He had his own drum set and liked music. His best tool for learning was the computer. He could hear a word and type it. He would go from activity to activity and place to place. He was excited about typing and could type for 2 to 3 hours. After receiving deep pressure, i.e. from a treadmill, STUDENT could attend to a desk for 2 to 3 hours easily. If he forgot a word he would sign it, and then he could say it.

In summary, as the 2001-2002 school year approached, STUDENT’s needs were almost the same as for the prior school year. He still needed services to address deficits in receptive language, expressive language, and language pragmatics. He needed services to address his attention, behaviors, and behavior organization, and ocular motor control. He needed an inclusion program. He needed services to address his vocational needs and ability to function with some degree of independence in the community. He needed services to address his severe academic deficits, and he needed assessment in intellectual functioning and academic skills.

STUDENT’s needs varied from the prior school year to the degree that he had shown improvement in some skills, most notably in oral communication skills. However, all of his deficits, including oral communication, remained severe. Since STUDENT, at age 14, was now a year closer to adulthood, his needs for vocational/community skills and the importance of availing himself of opportunities for inclusion with typical peers had increased. Consequently, his need for academic progress had also increased.

B. The District’s program offer.

The July 9, 2001 IEP proposed by the District offered a 50-day program commencing September 6, 2001, to be reviewed thereafter for the purpose of considering STUDENT’s further integration opportunities with typical peers. The program offer included placement at Marine View, SDC for 2 of 8 periods, regular education classes for 4 of 8 periods, other school/vocational classes for 2 of 8 periods, two sessions of adapted physical education totaling 60 minutes per week, speech and language 180 minutes per week (60-minute individual sessions twice per week in the speech and language room, 1 session for 60 minutes in the classroom), augmentative/assistive technology consult for 30 minutes per week, inclusion services consult for 60 minutes per week, OT consult for 60 minutes per week, parent education for 1 hour per week, computer software appropriate to STUDENT’s goals and objectives, a trained one-on-one aide to support STUDENT when participating in general education classes, door-to-door transportation, vocational education in the special education classroom, adapted and regular physical education consult, extended school year services, annual progress to be measured using the goals and objectives, and integration opportunities. Additional integration opportunities included daily nutrition break, lunch, grade-level assemblies, field trips, other scheduled activities, regular education students participating in SDC a minimum of 2 of 8 periods per day, and SDC participation in community-based instruction 1 to ½ hours for 2 to 4 times per month with several typical peers. A one-on-one instructional assistant would be assigned. All of the program described above would be reviewed on or after 50 days following the placement at Marine View.(Footnote 50) A transition plan was included for STUDENT’s movement into public school. An “IEP Statement of Needed Transition Services” was included for development of a long-range plan regarding STUDENT’s eventual movement into the adult world.

Extensive goals and objectives were attached to the July 9, 2001 IEP, consisting primarily of the blended set of written goals and objectives assembled by Ms. Lundberg, who used the written goals and objectives presented by the Student at the May 7, 2001 IEP meeting and the previously blended set of goals and objectives that Ms. Lundberg had prepared for the June 22, 2000 IEP meeting. (D/W Ex. A-16.) Present levels of performance were derived from the detailed packet of information, including present levels of performance, submitted by the Student at the May 7, 2001 IEP meeting. The District also had the SLDC reports written in January and February 2001 available for reference.

C. Discussion.

Because of the similarity between STUDENT’s needs for both the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years, and the similarity between the District’s proposed programs for those school years, much of the facts and analysis of the 2000-2001 school year are applicable to the 2001-2002 school year. The variations both in STUDENT’s needs and the District’s new program offer for the 2001-2002 school year will be discussed to the extent warranted. Dr. Sailor, Dr. Gee, and other witnesses who testified concerning the elements of a program that would be required to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year also testified that their opinions were fundamentally the same for the 2001-2002 school year.(Footnote 51)

The District’s program offer for the 2001-2002 school year includes services that match each of STUDENT’s areas of need as identified by the Hearing Officer. Speech and language was addressed through a combination of individual and group therapy for 3 hours per week. Attention, behaviors, behavioral organization, and ocular motor control were addressed by OT consult and adapted and regular physical education. Vocational and community needs were addressed as in the prior year, but with some modification. Since STUDENT’s time in SDC would be reduced, his SDC-based community outings also would be reduced. However, a specific number of hours for such activities were designated to ensure his participation in community-based activities. In recognition of STUDENT reaching age 14, the District’s offer included an “IEP Statement of Needed Transition Services” for development of a long-range plan regarding STUDENT’s eventual movement into the adult world.(Footnote 52) The offer also designated 2 periods for other school/vocational classes. With respect to STUDENT’s severe academic deficits, goals and objectives were enhanced in core subjects of reading, writing, and math. Further academic goals would have to be devised after STUDENT had selected his elective courses in regular education classes. Assessment in intellectual functioning and academic skills would have been provided by the multiple triennial assessment plans offered by the District commencing in January 2001.

Regarding behavior, the July 9, 2001 proposed IEP does not contain a behavior plan, nor does it have goals and objectives specifically for behavior. The District’s proposed assessment plan dated April 3, 2001, had included a functional behavior assessment. However, the father had not consented to assessment by the District. The IEP meeting notes reference the need for consultation among STUDENT’s regular education teacher, SDC teacher, and instructional aide during the implementation of any behavior plan. The IEP meeting notes appropriately state, in contemplation of the IEP team receiving more assessment information, that in addition to the “proposed assessment plan” and “proposed behavioral goals and objectives,” Marine View staff would develop a behavioral hierarchy to identify activities and tangible reinforcers that motivate STUDENT, the activities and situations that are stressful for STUDENT, and strategies to work with STUDENT in bringing him back to task. (D/W Ex. A-1, p. 19, 21.)

The Student’s general contentions with respect to whether the program offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs for the 2001-2002 school year are that the District failed to develop appropriate goals and objectives to address all of the Student’s needs; failed to propose appropriate curriculum modifications; failed to offer sufficient DIS in the areas of speech and language, reading, assistive technology (i.e. voice output laptop computer), and therapeutic recreational therapy; and failed to offer the Student an appropriately trained full-time one-on-one classroom instructional aide.

For the analysis of the 2000-2001 school year, the Hearing Officer listed each category of the Student’s unique needs and then addressed the Student’s contentions within the discussion of whether the program offer meet each category of the Student’s unique needs. For the reasons stated above, that same level of analytical detail for the 2001-2002 school year would be redundant. Accordingly, the Student’s contentions will be directly examined below.

Goals and Objectives. The Student has generally asserted that the goals and objectives were not designed to address all of STUDENT’s needs.

The goals and objectives offered by the District include (1) Reading: developing word analysis strategies, expanding vocabulary; (2) Math: telling time to the quarter hour, answering questions related to “how many” and “how much” by verbally responding with the correct numbers, using money in the community, understanding basic math language concepts; (3) Written language: using written language fluently for a variety of purposes including emergency information and typing three word sentences describing a picture; (4) Communication: answering concrete yes/no questions in an intelligible manner when asked by typical peers about objects/events in his immediate environment, answering “wh” questions asked by familiar peers and staff about familiar people and activities using 3-word responses; (5) school/community vocation: using his student ID card to check out a book, browse and read in the school library with peers for up to 30 minutes weekly, learn the locations of specified work activity centers around the school and perform appropriate work jobs in those locations, purchasing items from stores, pedestrian safety; (6) socialization: learning the names of friends and calling then to participate in activities, taking turns during small-group games in class or physical education or adapted physical education with adult assistance; (7) science: demonstrating knowledge of vocabulary concepts from science topics introduced to the eighth-grade curriculum; (8) transitions: transitioning from one activity to another, including the ability to leave an activity incomplete, without visible agitation or discomfort.

Dr. Gee presented her own set of proposed goals and objectives for STUDENT. She stated, in pertinent part, that STUDENT needed to learn to initiate speech and not just repeat it. He needed to initiate requests and protests in a more acceptable way. He needed to know how to answer a question or express things in class. He needed to learn left-to-right reading so that he could understand what was meant by reading a book. He needed to increase discriminating and sorting concepts, such as gases, liquids, and solids in science. He needed functional math skills such as counting money. He needed turn-taking skills.

The suggestions of Dr. Gee are substantially present in the goals and objectives offered by the District. The goals and objectives address each area of STUDENT’s needs, with the qualification that further goals and objectives for academics would have to be written after STUDENT had selected his electives. Additionally, goals and objectives regarding behavior would best be written after an assessment had been performed. The District’s efforts to start a triennial assessment were ongoing. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives proposed by the District were appropriate and were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

Curriculum Modifications. The Student alleges that the District failed to propose appropriate curriculum modifications. However, the Student did not specify the regular education elective classes that he would want to attend. Accordingly, the District would have been engaging in speculation if it attempted to detail how the curriculum for specific classes would be modified. The District did list some general strategies on the basis of its available information. The July 9, 2001 IEP notes contain a list of factors to be considered in facilitating STUDENT’s success in regular education classes. The factors were stated by Presta Perez, the District’s regular education teacher in attendance at the IEP meeting. The factors included assessing present levels of performance; using “hands on” activities that were personally relevant to STUDENT; using individual and small-group instruction; using instructional materials such as manipulatives, picture schedules, books on tape, and software programs to facilitate vocabulary and comprehension; consultation among regular education teachers, the SDC teacher, and the instructional aide to discuss implementation of the IEP goals and objectives and modification of the general education curriculum to STUDENT’s developmental level and needs and implementation of any behavior plan. In addition to the above recommendations, several of the goals and objectives proposed by the District refer to their alignment with various goal stems from the California state standards.

The Hearing Officer finds that on the basis of the information available to the District, the curriculum modifications proposed by the District were appropriate.

Designated Instruction and Services. The Student alleges that the District failed to offer sufficient DIS in the areas of speech and language, reading, assistive technology (i.e. voice output laptop computer), and therapeutic recreational therapy. On the basis of the testimony by SLDC staff and the District’s witnesses, including the testimony summarized and discussed above in this Decision during analysis of the 2000-2001 school year, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered sufficient speech and language services for the 2001-2002 school year.

With respect to reading instruction and services, the District has proposed appropriate goals and objectives as found above. Neither those goals and objectives nor most of the other goals and objectives proposed by the District in the July 9, 2001 IEP specify the person or persons responsible for their implementation. The IEP notes state that the SDC periods would provide for academics with the support of typical peers, including individual or group instruction related to goals and objectives, under the supervision of the SDC teacher or aide. The inference is that STUDENT’s SDC teacher will be ultimately responsible for implementation of the academic goals and objectives listed in the proposed IEP, including the goals and objectives for reading, using the assistance available in her class. Other aspects of STUDENT’s program, such as his regular education electives and community/vocational activities, would inherently involve a degree of reading. STUDENT would have a one-on-one assistant available for those situations. The Hearing Officer finds these services and supports for reading to be sufficient, given the amount of time that STUDENT will have available in his busy program schedule to devote to each specific skill targeted in the program offer. Regarding assistive technology, the Student asserts that a laptop computer equipped with voice output and speech to text capability was required. On such a computer and software program, when a letter is typed, a computerized voice states the letter. When the spacebar is pressed, the computer states the spelled word. This feature would allow STUDENT to type what he wanted to say and to hear auditory feedback. STEPMOTHER recommended FM auditory training as a device to help STUDENT focus on the person who was speaking to him so that all other auditory input would not be so salient. A laptop computer would allow STUDENT to work on various assignments in his general education classes, using a headset so that he could hear what he was doing. The District’s response to the recommendations of STEPMOTHER was that STUDENT could have his needs met on a classroom computer, and that a laptop was not necessary. The District further stated in the July 9, 2001 IEP notes that if special devices were needed for communication, that would be determined through the assessment process.

The Hearing Officer believes that with the exception of FM auditory training, STEPMOTHER’s recommendations for assistive technology and for a laptop computer appear well-founded. The FM auditory training device would have to be considered in the context of what disruptions it might cause to the general education teacher and class. However, the Hearing Officer also concurs with the opinion of the District’s speech and language assistive technology specialist, Ms. Dryden. She testified that the assistive technology provided to STUDENT should be determined by the IEP team following assessment. She testified that to make informed choices for technology, the team would have to look at STUDENT’s needs and his cognitive level before determining which devices would work best for STUDENT as an individual. She also testified that her function in the proposed program would include ensuring that Ms. Franklin had all the software needed for STUDENT’s curriculum, and training the aide in using the equipment. The Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s proposal for assistive technology, stated in the proposed IEP as augmentative/assistive technology consult for 30 minutes per week and computer software appropriate to STUDENT’s goals and objectives is appropriate, given the intent of the District to conduct an assistive technology assessment as part of its proposed triennial assessment plan.

The Student alleges that the District failed to offer therapeutic recreational therapy. The Student asserts that horseback riding and aquatics or water therapy are required to meet his needs. The District offered OT consult and adapted and regular physical education. The Hearing Officer has previously found that for the 2000-2001 to school year, the District’s proposal was appropriate. The reasoning for that finding has equal application to the 2001-2002 school year. As Ms. Del Rosario testified, aquatic therapy or horseback riding would not serve the purposes of OT for STUDENT. Proprioceptive input must be available to STUDENT throughout the day. The Hearing Officer agrees with Ms. Del Rosario’s statement that if the proprioceptive input activities were provided at some location other than at the school, that would defeat the purpose of quickly providing proprioceptive input to STUDENT whenever he appeared edgy so that he could reorganize himself and return to class. One-on-one Aide. The Student asserts that the District failed to offer him an appropriately trained one-on-one classroom instructional aide. The Hearing Officer notes that references to an aide in the District’s offer include mention of a one-on-one aide to support STUDENT when participating in general education classes and a one-on-one instructional assistant to work with STUDENT to support his program. The proposed IEP does not expressly state that the aide would be full-time, but the parties have not disputed that a full-time aide is intended by the proposed IEP. The proposed IEP states that the aide would be included in consultation with the SDC teacher and the regular education teacher on matters pertaining to the implementation of STUDENT’s program. The proposed IEP states that STUDENT would be assisted by his aide during physical education, including during locker room activities. Witnesses from the District testified regarding training for the aide. The Student’s assertion that the District has not offered a properly trained aide is premature. The District has no obligation to train an aide for the Student before a program has been agreed upon. If the District’s proposed program is eventually executed, the District will be obligated to properly train any aide that it provides to STUDENT.

D. Summary.

STUDENT’s needs for the 2000-2001 school year in the areas of receptive language, expressive language, language pragmatics, attention, behaviors, behavioral organization, ocular motor control, academics, and vocational and community skills were all discussed in detail above. The program offered by the District to meet those needs for the 2000-2001 school year was also discussed and found to be appropriate. STUDENT had shown improvement during the 2000-2001 school year. The District’s program offer for the 2001-2002 school year was revised to account for STUDENT’s improvement in skills and his closer proximity to adult life; however, the offer also gave appropriate recognition to the continuing severity of STUDENT’s deficits. Furthermore, the District envisioned in the program offer that when it received additional information about STUDENT from the pending triennial assessment, from observing him in school, and from knowing his choice of regular education electives, the IEP team could then meet and adjust STUDENT’s program as appropriate. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the program offered by the District for the 2001-2002 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

II. Was the District’s program offer reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit?

The District offered goals and objectives to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and provide him with educational benefit. The District offered appropriate placement and services to meet those needs and support the goals and objectives. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program offer for the 2001-2002 school year was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.

III. Did the District’s program comport with the IEP?

STUDENT’s father withdrew him from the stay put placement at SLDC in February 2001. STUDENT has received no subsequent services from the District. Therefore, the question of whether the District’s program offer comported with the IEP is not applicable.

IV. Did the District offer to provide STUDENT with an education in the least restrictive environment?

The Student asserts that the LRE for the 2001-2002 school year would consist of placement at Spring View with no SDC. For the 2001-2002 school year, Dr. Sailor reiterated that STUDENT was reasonably high functioning, that placing him in regular education classes would have no negative effects on STUDENT or the other students, and that placing STUDENT in an SDC would have no value. Dr. Brown testified that the correct approach would be to place STUDENT in a regular education program, see what happens, and adjust accordingly. His suggestion for handling STUDENT’s tendency to run away was to put some identification on him. Dr. Gee stated that STUDENT should gradually be placed back into school, starting him with one or two blocks of periods per week. She believed that he did not need SDC for any subject. The District’s offer for placement at Marine View, compared to the offer for the prior year, would decrease SDC and increases the regular education electives. SDC would comprise 2 of 8 periods and regular education would comprise 4 of 8 periods.(Footnote 53)

The Hearing Officer’s findings regarding LRE for the 2000-2001 school year are applicable to the 2001-2002 school year. In STUDENT’s particular case, the opinions of Dr. Sailor, Dr. Brown, and Dr. Gee are not persuasive. Their view of STUDENT’s deficits and skills is not consistent with the weight of the evidence. Their generally negative view of SDCs fails to account for the positive and integral role that the SDC at Marine View would serve in STUDENT’s overall program, especially with respect to teaching him basic academics in reading, writing, and math; teaching him community and vocational skills; teaching him tools for generalizing his skills in the community and the regular education environment; and giving him a platform for success that he could build upon.

The District states that it increased the regular education periods and decreased the SDC periods in deference to the opinions of Dr. Sailor and Dr. Gee as presented during the latter part of the 2000-2001 school year. The Hearing Officer believes that justification for expanding regular education classes and decreasing SDC in STUDENT’s program can be found in a combination of 2 factors. First, STUDENT’s skills improved during the 2000-2001 school year, as demonstrated by measured progress in speech and language (D/W Ex. DD), improvement in proprioceptive organization and attention span (D/W Ex. DD), and the substantial overall improvement testified to by STEPMOTHER and STUDENT’s father. Second, the Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT will be in high school next year, and he is also one year closer to reaching post-high-school status. Consequently, the window of opportunity for STUDENT to learn to interact successfully with typical peers is narrowing. The need to prepare STUDENT for his future transitions into high school and beyond, considered in combination with his overall improvement over the past year, justifies increasing his regular education schedule and decreasing his SDC, at least pending the 50-day review as offered by the District.(Footnote 54) Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer for the 2001-2002 school year satisfies the requirement of LRE.

Procedural Appropriateness

The Student alleges that the District failed to provide the father and STEPMOTHER the opportunity to participate in the May 7, 2001 IEP meeting by providing only 1½ hours for that meeting, and by failing to allow the Student’s father and his designees to observe the proposed District classes prior to the IEP meeting. The Student also alleges that the District failed to have a regular education teacher at the IEP meetings for the school year and failed to provide a timely and complete assessment in all areas of suspected disabilities.

The evidence showed that the May 7, 2001 IEP meeting was acknowledged on that date, by the District, to have not been completed. The meeting was adjourned to a later date. The meeting was duly continued to July 9, 2001, with proper notice to the Student. The Student’s father, through no fault of the District, failed to attend the meeting. The District acknowledges that, by oversight, a regular education teacher was not present at the May 7, 2001 IEP meeting. A regular education teacher did attend the July 9, 2001 IEP meeting. There was no procedural violation in either instance that would arise to the level of a denial of FAPE.

With respect to the allegation that the District failed to allow the Student’s designees to observe the proposed District classes prior to the May 7, 2001 IEP meeting, there is no reason to believe that the District’s actions resulted in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringed on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process to the level of a denial of FAPE. ( W.G., supra.) The District submitted a declaration by Ms. Lundberg that recounted her many attempts to arrange a time when STUDENT’s father and his designees could view classrooms. (D/W Ex. A-5.) The District also submitted a letter to STUDENT’s father dated

April 23, 2001, wherein the District offered to have the father and his experts view both Marine View and Spring View. (D/W Ex. II.) Ms. Lundberg’s declaration shows that the father failed to avail himself of those opportunities.(Footnote 55)

The Student’s assertions regarding assessment will be addressed in Issue No. 4.

Findings

The Hearing Officer finds that the District offered the Student a FAPE in the least restrictive environment for the 2001-2002 school year.

Issue No. 3: If the District failed to offer the Student a FAPE in the least restrictive environment for the 2000-2001 and/or 2001-2002 school years, is the Student entitled to reimbursement for private services and/or compensatory education?

This issue is rendered moot by the findings in Issue No. 1 and Issue No. 2.

Issue No. 4 Is the District entitled to complete the triennial assessment proposed in the assessment plan dated September 4, 2001, submitted by the District and WOCCSE?

The District asserts that it is entitled to assess the Student in accordance with its proposed assessment plan dated September 4, 2001. The Student objects to the form of the assessment plan and the persons who would conduct the assessment. The Student states that he is not opposed to assessment so long as the assessments are “ecological assessments” that provide direction for educational programming from valid and reliable sources. The Student asserts that the District’s proposed plan is not an ecological assessment, and it would therefore have produced results that underestimate the Student’s learning potential and have no meaning for the Student’s educational program.

Both State and federal special education law provide that a reassessment of a child with a disability shall be conducted at least every three years. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56381, 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1414(a)(2)(A), 34 C.F.R Sec. 300.536(b). In Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1315 (9th Cir. 1987), the court stated that, “if the parents want Gregory to receive special education under the act, they are obligated to permit such testing.” In Andress v. Cleveland Independent School Dist., 64 F.3d 176 (5th Cir. 1995), the court concluded that, “a parent who desires for her child to receive special education must allow the school district to reevaluate the child . . . there is no exception to this rule.”

Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56321 describes the procedure a district must follow in submitting a proposed assessment plan to a parent. Section 56321(c) provides that a parent shall have at least fifteen days from receipt of the proposed assessment plan to arrive at a decision regarding whether to consent to the proposed assessment. Section 56321(c) states that except pursuant to Sec. 56506(e), informed parental consent for an assessment of a child is required before a school district can assess the child. Section 56506(e) states that informed parental consent is not required if the public education agency prevails in a due process hearing relating to the assessment. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56501(a)(3) extends due process hearing procedures to the public education agency when the parent refuses to consent to the assessment of the child.

By letter dated September 20, 2001 (D/W Ex. 7), STUDENT’s father acknowledged receipt of the proposed assessment plan dated September 4, 2001. The letter stated that the father required more information before he felt that he could give informed consent. Further exchanges of information occurred between the District and the father, and consent has not been provided. Since the father has refused to consent to the proposed assessment, the District is entitled to conduct the proposed assessment if the District establishes: (a) the need to conduct such an assessment, and (b) the assessment plan sent to the father conformed to the requirements of the law. The parties do not dispute the need to conduct an assessment the Student. Accordingly, the overall question for determination is whether the proposed plan conformed to the requirements of the law.

Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56321(b), a proposed assessment plan shall: (1) be in language easily understood by the general public, (2) be provided in the primary language of the parent or other mode of communication used by the parent, (3) explain the types of assessments to be conducted, (4) state that no individualized education program will result without the consent of the parent. There is no dispute that the assessment plan satisfied the requirements of subsections (1), (2), and (4).

With respect to the requirement of subsection (3) of Section 56321(b) that the plan explain the type of assessments to be conducted, the father asked for more details after receiving the plan. The September 4, 2001 assessment plan was submitted with a cover letter by Mr. Hemsley that provided notices pursuant to 34 C.F.R. Section 300.503. The standard 10-page WOCCSE notice of procedural safeguards was also attached. The generic first page of the plan provided for assessment in the general areas of health, motor ability, language/communication function, general ability, academic performance, social and emotional status, and augmentative/assistive communication and assistive technology. Under each of the above-stated categories was a general statement of the purpose of that particular portion of the assessment. For health, the purpose was to assess physical status and evaluate educationally significant medical information. For motor ability, the purpose was to assess coordination in large and small muscles and/or visual perception. For language and communication function, the purpose was to assess STUDENT’s ability to understand, relate to, and use language and speech clearly and appropriately. For general ability, the purpose was to assess intellectual functioning, probable learning rate, and problem-solving ability. For academic performance, the purpose was to assess current basic reading, reading comprehension, mathematics calculation, mathematics reasoning, written expression, and pre-readiness skills. For social and emotional status, the purpose was to assess STUDENT’s level of social maturity, ability to function independently, and interpersonal skills.

Attached as part of the plan were 2 pages of information more specifically tailored to STUDENT’s assessment needs. For each category of assessment, the District listed the specific assessment tools that would be used and the persons responsible for administering those assessment tools. Assessment tools and strategies for health included the student health appraisal form WOC-11A, vision screening (Snellen Visual Acuity), and hearing screening (pure tone audiometry or informal hearing acuity screening), all to be administered by Judy Acocello, R.N., a District school nurse. Other assessment tools and strategies for health included, for vision, binocularity, objective testings, visual information processing, vision health check, accommodative integrity, and ocular motor, all by the College of Optometry in Fullerton. Assessment tools and strategies for motor ability included, for gross motor, Brigance and Adaptive Physical Education Ability Scales (APEAS), observation, and interview by adapted physical education specialist Ms. Caruso. Assessment tools and strategies for fine motor included Test of Visual Motor Integration, Bender Gestalt, and observation of functional academic fine-motor skills, all by school psychologist Ms. Trittipo; and observation of functional academic fine-motor skills and observation of self-care skills as they apply to the classroom/education setting by occupational therapist Patty Mulcahy in consultation with Ms. Del Rosario. Assessment tools and strategies for language/communication included observation, interview, Brigance-Receptive/Expressive language, and language sample by speech and language specialists Ms. Larsen and Ms. Pfeiffer. Assessment tools and strategies for augmentative and assistive communication and assistive technology included observation, interview, and informal assessment of the Student by AAC/AT specialist Ms. Dryden in consultation with Ms. Pfeiffer; and sign language assessment by Ms. Sheetz, WOCCSE itinerant teacher of the deaf and hard of hearing. Assessment tools and strategies for general ability included observation, interview, review of specialists’ assessments, work portfolio, and Wide Range Assessment of Memory and Learning (WRAMAL), to be administered by school psychologists Ms. Trittipo and Ms. Cataldo. Assessment tools and strategies for social and emotional status included observation, interview, Scales of Independent Behavior, Gilliam Autism Rating Scale, and functional behavior assessment, further described as an analysis of behavior that impedes learning, to be administered by school psychologists Ms. Trittipo and Ms. Cataldo in consultation with SLDC staff and Ms. Carr, inclusion facilitator. Assessment tools and strategies for academic performance included observation, Brigance, and sampling of functional activities in the domains of personal, domestic, community, functional academics, mobility, recreation and leisure, vocational, and communication, to be administered by SDC teacher Ms. Franklin in consultation with classroom teacher Ms. Olsen and Ms. Carr, inclusion facilitator.

In his September 20, 2001 letter to the District, STUDENT’s father stated that his experts had all informed him that the Brigance and the WRAMAL tests were not appropriate for STUDENT. He requested more information about those tests and the District’s rationale for using them. He wanted details on where the tests would occur, the timeline that would be required for STUDENT to take the standardized tests, whether the tests would occur all in one day, and whether STUDENT’s parents would be allowed to observe. He wanted to know what was meant by a functional behavioral assessment and how that differed from a functional analysis assessment. He wanted to know why a physical therapy assessment was not included. He also repeated his request to allow his experts to view certain classrooms. He requested a meeting to discuss his questions. By letter dated October 1, 2001, Ms. Lundberg proposed meeting dates for October 4, 10, and 12, but the father did not respond. By letter to the father dated October 10 (D/W Ex. A-14), Ms. Lundberg addressed each of the father’s questions, except that she gave a nonresponsive answer to the timeline question, probably as a result of the ambiguity of the question. By letter dated October 29, Ms. Lundberg also attempted to schedule an IEP meeting in November to discuss goals and objectives and assessment. (D/W Ex. A-15.)

After considering the above-recited level of detail in the District’s assessment plan, in combination with the further details provided to the Student by Ms. Lundberg, the Hearing Officer finds that the plan meet the requirement of subsection (3) of Sec. 56321(b) that the plan explain the type of assessments to be conducted.

An assessment must also meet the requirements of Cal. Educ. Code Secs. 56320, 56322, and 56324. Since the assessment has not yet been performed, the Hearing Officer cannot make a determination regarding whether the assessment will actually be appropriate and in conformity with the above-cited sections. However, for purposes of determining whether the District is entitled to conduct the proposed assessment, the Hearing Officer must determine whether there is credible evidence that the District’s proposed assessment would, when administered, meet the requirements of Secs. 56320, 56322, and 56324.

Section 56320(a) through (d) states in relevant part that testing and assessment materials and procedures must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; provided and administered in the student’s primary language or other mode of communication; validated for the purpose for which they are used; administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; tailored to assess specific areas of need; selected and administered to best ensure that, when administered to a pupil with impaired speaking skills, the test produces results that accurately reflect the student’s aptitude, achievement level, or any other factors the test purports to measure and not the student’s impaired speaking skills.

Each of the persons listed on the assessment plan as responsible for its administration testified at the hearing. Their testimony demonstrated that the plan, if administered, would likely meet each of the above-stated requirements of Sec. 56320(a) through (d).

Section 56320(e) requires that no single procedure be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for an individual with exceptional needs. The assessment plan lists multiple test instruments or procedures. Therefore, as required by Sec. 56320(e), no single procedure would be used to determine an appropriate educational program.

Section 56320(f) requires that a student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability. The Student’s deficits and needs arising from those deficits have all been discussed in detail in this Decision. The Hearing Officer finds there is credible evidence that the proposed assessment plan, if administered, would likely meet the requirements of Sec. 56320(f).

Section 56320(g) requires that the assessment be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the student’s disability. Section 56322 requires that the assessments be conducted by persons competent to perform the assessments. Section 56324 requires that any psychological assessment be performed by a credentialed school psychologist. Each of the persons to be involved in the assessment testified at the hearing regarding their credentials and areas of expertise. The review of testimony and written progress reports throughout this Decision demonstrates that each person involved would be knowledgeable of STUDENT’s disability. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds there is credible evidence that the proposed assessment, if performed, would meet the requirements of Sections 56320(g), 56322, and 56324.

The Student asserts that a proper assessment of STUDENT must be an “ecological assessment” in accordance with the recommendations of his experts. Dr. Browder, Dr. Gee, and Dr. Sailor all testified that STUDENT needs an ecological assessment, meaning, as described by Dr. Brower, a “person-centered planning method to identify instructional priorities based on the student’s current and future environments and the student’s and families preferences.” As further described by the Student’s experts, an ecological assessment means that STUDENT would be assessed in the environments where he currently receives his educational program and where it is preferred by the family and the Student that he will receive his program in the future. In STUDENT’s case, since all his experts were opposed to SDC, STUDENT would be assessed in his home, in his community, and in regular education classrooms with typical peers or other environments with typical peers. The Student’s experts also expressed a highly disfavoring view of standardized testing, and his experts generally thought that standardized testing would provide little or no useful information about STUDENT.

The District’s witnesses testified that the assessment plan proposed by the District was in fact an ecological assessment because STUDENT would be assessed in the various environments where he had been receiving his educational program, including his home and the community. They acknowledged that some testing, such as parts of the speech and language and psychological assessments, would occur in the speech and language therapy room at Marine View, and the adapted physical education specialist would see STUDENT on the playground at Marine View. Their testimony was consistent with the assessment details stated in Ms. Lundberg’s letter to the Student’s father dated October 10, 2001. They testified that ecological assessment was appropriate, but not as the sole method of assessment. They testified why they believed the proposed components of standardized and/criterion reference tests would provide useful information about STUDENT. Ms. Trittipo testified that it would be unfair to STUDENT to test him in an environment that he was not used to, such as a regular education classroom, as had been suggested by the Student’s experts.

The Hearing Officer concludes that given STUDENT’s disabilities and history, a combination of standardized testing and ecological assessment is appropriate. However, the type of ecological assessment proposed by the Student’s experts, to the extent that substantial portions of the overall observations and assessment would occur in regular education classes, would be inappropriate. Useful information about STUDENT’s academic and cognitive skills would not, for example, be gleaned simply by observing STUDENT, and especially not by observing him in an unfamiliar regular education classroom environment. The District’s plan is a well-balanced and sensible approach to assessing STUDENT in all areas of his suspected disabilities. Evaluation of STUDENT in regular education classes will eventually be necessary, but that information is more suitably obtained after STUDENT has selected his electives and is in the process of attending those classes.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District is entitled to complete the triennial assessment proposed in the assessment plan dated September 4, 2001.

CONCLUSIONS

The District offered the Student a FAPE in the least restrictive environment for the 2000-2001 school year. The District offered the Student a FAPE in the least restrictive environment for the 2001-2002 school year. The District is entitled to conduct a triennial assessment of the Student pursuant to the proposed assessment plan dated September 4, 2001.(Footnote 56)

ORDERS

1. The District is entitled to conduct a triennial assessment of the Student pursuant to the proposed assessment plan dated September 4, 2001, as specifically set forth in D/W Ex. A-2 and further explained in D/W Ex. A-14.

2. The Student’s father shall make the Student available for the triennial assessment within 30 days from the date of this decision.

3. All of the Student’s requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided.

(1) Did the District offer a FAPE to the Student in the least restrictive environment for the 2000-2001 school year? The District/WOCCSE prevailed on this issue.

(2) Did the District offer a FAPE to the Student in the least restrictive environment for the 2001-2002 school year? The District/WOCCSE prevailed on this issue.

(3) If the District failed to offer the Student a FAPE in the least restrictive environment for the 2000-2001 and/or 2001-2002 school years, is the Student entitled to reimbursement for private services and/or compensatory education? This issue was rendered moot by the findings in issues 1 and 2.

(4) Is the District entitled to complete the triennial assessment proposed in the assessment plan dated September 4, 2001, submitted by the District and WOCCSE? The District/WOCCSE prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56505(i).

Dated: February 25, 2002 ____________________________________ Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES

1. This decision has been amended to correct typographical errors in the original Decision. Amendments include correcting the designation of the school years in the headings for issue number 3 on pages 3, 64, and 69; correcting the use of the words “District” and “Student” and in the designation of a school year in the first full paragraph on page 15; changing the word “him” to “hit” in the last sentence of the first partial paragraph on page 38; and striking the word “would” from the second sentence the summary of Ms. Pfeiffer’s testimony on page 40. These changes do not affect the substance of the decision. 2. Mr. Wyner was the Student’s only attorney of record present at the hearing in Case No. SN00-01316 from April 11 through June 29, 2001. Ms. Hickman Graham initially became involved in this matter as the Student’s attorney of record in Case No. SN01-01394, filed by the Student on June 24, 2001. On October 16, 2001, neither Mr. Wyner nor Ms. Graham appeared at the hearing, and no testimony was received. Mr. Wyner was absent on October 16, citing illness, and he subsequently withdrew without making a further appearance. Ms. Graham was absent on October 16, citing a calendar conflict. Mr. Teitel was present as attorney for the Student only on October 16, 18, and 19, and then he withdrew. Ms. Hickman Graham was also present as the attorney for the Student on October 18, and she was his attorney of record at all subsequent hearing dates. 3. STEPMOTHER is considered by herself and STUDENT’s father to be STUDENT’s stepmother. 4. Ms. Flanagan was present on every hearing date. Mr. Kim made only occasional appearances. 5. The issues listed here differ in wording from the issues as stated by the parties. Changes were made for purposes of clarification and analysis. The Student’s various issue statements set forth the issues in greater detail, but that detail is presented herein under the subheading “Contentions of the Parties.” Issues 1, 2, and 3 were presented by the Student. Issue 4 was presented by the District and WOCCSE. 6. References in this Decision to “the District” are meant to include both the District and WOCCSE where the context so indicates. 7. The Student’s contention that he was denied vision therapy was withdrawn during the hearing. 8. The various IEPs proposed by the District list STUDENT’s eligibility criteria as “MD,” presumably meaning multiple disabilities. There is no dispute, however, that STUDENT has a disability consistent with autism. 9. SLDC, otherwise known as the Speech and Language Development Center in Buena Park, is a non-public agency certified by the State of California Department of Education to provide educational services to children with disabilities. Approximately 300 students attend SLDC, and all or nearly all of them are children with disabilities. SLDC provides a wide range of services. Services provided to STUDENT by SLDC included academics, speech and language therapy, occupational therapy, and transportation. 10. While the parties were preparing for a particular IEP meeting during the 1999-2000 school year, goals and objectives were discussed through a collaborative effort by SLDC, the father, and STEPMOTHER. Twenty pages of individualized goals and objectives were written on SLDC’s standard forms. (D/W Ex. C.) Goals and objectives were also written by STEPMOTHER in a separate document. At the ensuing IEP meeting, an impasse arose regarding which set of goals and objectives should be read first. Mr. Hemsley, who chaired the meeting, wanted the goals and objectives prepared by SLDC read first, but the father would not allow that to occur. Instead, the father began talking over the other IEP team members by reading from the goals and objectives prepared by STEPMOTHER. The father was not willing to stop reading, and Mr. Hemsley was not willing to allow the father to continue. The meeting was then terminated by Mr. Hemsley. (Testimony of Ms. Olson, Ms. O’Conner, STEPMOTHER, Ms. Lundberg.) Mr. Hemsley and STEPMOTHER testified that these events occurred at the May 24, 2000 IEP meeting. Mr. Hemsley also testifed that these or similar events occurred at the June 22, 2000 IEP meeting. Ms. Lundberg initially testified that these events occurred on May 24, 2000, and later she testified that they occurred on November 30, 1999. Ms. O’Conner testified that they occurred at the November 30 meeting. The November 30 IEP meeting notes mention an occurrence of similar nature. Ms. Kennard from SLDC testified that the father interfered with the District’s ability to complete the November 30 IEP meeting by being uncooperative and refusing to allow Mr. Hemsley to maintain order. An expanse of testimony regarding these events was finally terminated by the Hearing Officer. Whether these events occurred on November 30, 1999, May 24, 2000, June 22, 2000, or on all three dates has no effect on the outcome of this decision. These events are recounted in this footnote to illustrate the longstanding inability of the District and WOCCSE and STUDENT’s father to work in a cooperative manner. 11. The Student’s demands regarding the extent of inclusion sought with typical peers fluctuated with regard to the 2000-2001 school year. On May 25, 2000, the day after the IEP meeting, the Student’s father filed a request for due process hearing. (D/W Ex. A-13.) The due process hearing request in that matter stated that STUDENT should remain at SLDC for the majority of his program and be transported to his local school for a small portion of the day to interact with typical peers. The case filed on May 25, 2000, was subsequently dismissed, and was essentially re-filed on July 19, 2000, as case SN00-01316. The notice of issues filed by the Student on July 31, 2000, in case SN00-01316 asserts that “a full-day placement in a regular education classroom, with appropriate supports, is the least restrictive environment for STUDENT.” In a subsequent issue statement filed in case SN00-01316, the Student asserts that “STUDENT should be offered placement in his neighborhood school in classroom settings other than special day class, with a one-to-one full time aide.” The latter issue statement does not necessarily state that an SDC should be completely absent from STUDENT’s program for the 2000-2001 school year. During the hearing, the Student asserted that even a single SDC period would be inappropriate. 12. Spring View and Marine View both had “rotating block” schedules with a “wheel,” resulting in frequent variations of when each class would commence. 13. The modifications of each offer were primarily for enhancement of STUDENT’s inclusion with typical peers. Given the difficulties encountered by the parties in completing IEP meetings, these additional offers were considered by the Hearing Officer to be equivalent to part of the IEP process, as opposed to settlement offers. This evidentiary matter was ruled upon in the Summary Order Regarding Motion to Exclude Respondent’s Exhibits (J, K, P, S, and Z) dated May 21, 2001. A ruling that program offers under the circumstances of this case could only be completed at IEP meetings would have granted a license to STUDENT’s father to disrupt IEP meetings and thereby render impossible the District’s ability to complete a program offer. The disruptions at IEP meetings, according to witnesses for both sides, never took the form of STUDENT’s father being loud or using foul language. Instead, witnesses testified that the father would refuse to defer to Mr. Hemsley on procedural matters, he would talk over the other team members, and he would “badger” other team members by asking such a multitude of redundant questions on one subject that other subjects could not be addressed. 14. The letter implies that STUDENT’s father had by that time expanded his initial request of a split program between Spring View and SLDC to a full inclusion program at Spring View. When this demand was first made is not clear from the record, and the parties were unable at the due process hearing to specify a date. 15. . Lundberg testified about the extraordinary difficulties that she encountered in scheduling IEP meetings for STUDENT, including last-minute cancellations by the father and no-shows by the father. Meanwhile, the District was arranging commitments from a multitude of education specialists, including non-District employees, to attend the meetings on specific dates. The father testified that the District was the party that always cancelled the IEP meetings. 16. Ms. Lundberg also testified that STUDENT’s father canceled the November 20, 2000 IEP meeting. 17. The letter continues by listing the travel time of the persons who attended the meeting, the persons who required arrangement of substitute teachers to attend the meeting, the teachers at SLDC who would have to provide “make up” speech and language services to 5 or 6 students, the person who had canceled a four-day weekend trip to attend the meeting, and another therapist from SLDC who attended the meeting on her day off. This event was consistent with the testimony of Ms. Lundberg, who appeared to be on the verge of tears when she described the meticulous efforts she has made over a period of years to arrange IEP meetings for STUDENT and to give appropriate notices to STUDENT’s father. Those efforts included sending documents by certified mail, hand-delivering items to the father’s post office box to counter his frequent excuse that he did not receive an item, scripting the messages that she left on the father’s answering machine so that there could be no dispute about what she said, and persuading persons to commit to attending scheduled IEP meetings when they knew the probability was high that the meeting would not ensue. 18. STEPMOTHER is also an expert in special education. She specializes in programs for children with severe disabilities who need assistive technology. 19. The father and STEPMOTHER were present, but neither signed the proposed IEP, and they refused signing to confirm their attendance or to confirm receipt of documents. Ms. Lundberg testified that the father never signs documents related to the IEP process, not even to confirm his appearance at IEP meetings. 20. That opinion was presumably not shared by the Student, since he was opposed to any form of SDC for the 2001-2002 school year, and he has always been opposed to placement at Marine View. 21. Dr. Sailor’s March 20, 2001 report (Student Ex. 64-16) states that STUDENT’s behavior patterns did not appear to be violent, seemed to be easily remediated through redirection and negotiation, and should not be difficult to manage in a general education setting with appropriate supports and properly trained personnel. Dr. Sailor recommended “an inclusive educational placement and a program that does not segregate him [STUDENT] from contact with his general education peers.” 22. Case SN 462-01, filed by the District and WOCCSE, sought a decision with respect to the District and WOCCSE’s right to assess and the appropriateness of the assessment plan proposed by the District and WOCCSE earlier in the year. 23. Ms. Pfeiffer’s April 15, 2000 report does not address behaviors. 24. The report provides some definitions of terms. According to the report, the somatosensory system mediates touch (tactile system) and muscle and joint position and movement (proprioception). Adequate functioning of those sensory symptoms contributes to motor coordination, motor planning, the development of good body image, and the ability to attend in class and relate to others. The vestibular system mediates one’s perception of movement through space, balance and posture, and perception of gravity. Its adequate functioning contributes to muscle tone, motor coordination, balance, equilibrium reactions, postural responses, ocular control, reflex development, bilateral coordination, and speech and language abilities. Organization of behavior refers to the child’s activity level, performance of goal-directed behaviors, attention to tasks, purposefulness, and reactions to changes in the child’s environment. 25. The Hearing Officer understood this portion of STEPMOTHER’s testimony regarding STUDENT’s strengths and weaknesses to be generally applicable to both the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years. 26. Inclusion with typical peers will be addressed within the discussion of least restrictive environment (LRE), elsewhere in this Decision. 27. Earlier re-evaluation would have been necessary if student had failed to demonstrate anticipated progress, or if requested by the parent or teacher. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56343 28. The “blended” set of goals and objectives prepared by Ms. Lundberg consisted of at least 12 pages, but 6 pages pertained specifically to speech and language. 29. The full text of the goals and objectives showing benchmarks and short-term objectives is not inserted into this Decision. 30. SLDC staff testified that STUDENT’s behaviors were escalating after his return for the 2000-2001 school year. STUDENT showed an increased need for sameness, increased repetitive behaviors, and a shorter attention span. 31. Dr. Sailor was critical of the concept of STUDENT’s being on community outings with his SDC peers. He believed that such displays, where groups of disabled students travel into the community, were counterproductive to the goals of community acceptance of disabled persons and trying to teach disabled persons to function with a greater degree of independence. However, Dr. Sailor’s criticism was somewhat restrained, and may best be described as reflecting his own preference and philosophy as opposed to an assertion that group outings of disabled persons could not be considered beneficial. The District’s inclusion facilitator, Ms. Carr, offered her viewpoint that she does not prefer sending children into the community with just an aide. She noted that if something happens to the aide, an autistic child is left alone. 32. This provision is in paragraph 7 of the settlement agreement (D/W Ex. 1, quoted above in the Background Facts). The paragraph is vague with respect to how it is intended to effect the District’s rights and obligations to assess STUDENT. The paragraph states that “...the parties agree not to conduct a triennial re-evaluation to establish STUDENT’s continuing eligibility. STUDENT’s next triennial evaluation would be scheduled for 2/01.” This language could be interpreted as meaning that except for determination of continuing eligibility, no restrictions were imposed on assessments by the settlement agreement, triennial or otherwise. Use of the term “would” in the second sentence is curious, implying that a contingency must be met before the triennial evaluation could be scheduled. The District’s witnesses, including Mr. Hemsley, conveyed the impression that this paragraph prevented them from assessing STUDENT until February 2001, and that the paragraph did provide for an assessment in February 2001. Mr. Hemsley testified that the purpose of the paragraph was to avoid further disputes regarding assessment until at least February 2001. Ms. Lundberg and Mr. Hemsley acknowledged that, with agreement by the parent, STUDENT could have been assessed prior to February 2001, but no such plan was submitted by the District. In any event, the language of the agreement infers that a triennial evaluation would neither be demanded, allowed, nor anticipated to occur, by either party, until at least February 2001. 33. Attempts by the District to arrange a comprehensive assessment earlier than February 2001 would likely have been futile. Ms. Lundberg submitted an extensive declaration regarding the attempts to assess STUDENT dating from September 1990 to the present. Some attempts were eventually successful and others failed, but the entire history was replete with disagreement and delay. Ms. O’Conner testified that she was instructed by the father to notify him and pull STUDENT out of his class at SLDC if anyone from the District was in a position on campus to observe STUDENT. The purpose that the father intended to achieve by that request is unknown, but a clear result was exacerbation of the distrust between the parties and the ongoing inability of the parties to work cooperatively for STUDENT’s benefit. 34. The matter of goals and objectives that could be improved through input from all members of an IEP team is a prime example of how lack of cooperation between a parent and school district can work to the detriment of the pupil with special needs. 35. Section 56505(d) of the Cal. Ed. Code provides that during the pendency of due process proceedings, including the actual state level hearing, the pupil shall remain in his or her present placement unless the public agency and the parent agree otherwise. 36. Ms. O’Conner testified that she believed STUDENT received appropriate attention from his aides, although there were times at break or on lunch when no aide was present. She stated that during the incident in which the father alleged he was the only adult in the classroom, the aide was at the door. Keeping an aide was not easy, according to Ms. O’Conner, as the aide was always being scrutinized by the father. 37. Title 5, C.C.R. Sec. 3052(b), provides that a “functional analysis assessment” shall occur after the IEP team finds that instructional/behavioral approaches specified in the student’s IEP have been ineffective. A functional analysis assessment may lead to a “behavioral intervention plan” as defined in Title 5, C.C.R. Sec. 3001(d)(e)(f)(aa). A behavioral intervention plan is a written document that is developed when the student exhibits a serious behavior problem that significantly interferes with the implementation of the goals and objectives of the student’s IEP. The plan is based on results of a functional analysis assessment, and it includes a systematic implementation of procedures designed to result in lasting positive changes in the student’s behavior. 38. SLDC witnesses testified that the father would be outside of classrooms with a clipboard in his hands. When asked by SLDC what he was doing, his response was that he was taking notes for a due process matter. 39. Ms. Pfeiffer said the father’s presence was disruptive to STUDENT, as he would look to his father and attend to him instead of attending to the task, even if the father was not speaking. Ms. Tipton testified that her students were frequently turning around in class to see STUDENT’s father in the back of the room. Ms. Oslen testified that the father would observe in the class, through the window, outside the doorway. She testified that visits were disruptive in the sense that the other students felt tension from it. The visits would vary from a couple of days per month to everyday for an entire week, and from a couple of minutes to nearly a full day. The observations eventually became disruptive by their frequency, and they were unannounced. The father would simply appear and not get a visitor badge. The staff would make comments such as “who is this person standing outside, and why is he looking into my room?” Students were also commenting. Since STUDENT was being affected by the visits, the father began to position himself in places where he was not visible to STUDENT, such as around corners, but he would still be visible to staff and other students. 40. Ms. O’Conner discussed the matter with the father and he reportedly told her that his visits should not be considered as a problem by anyone. In response, SLDC was compelled to initiate a new visitation policy whereby visitors had to give 24-hour advance notice, sign in and obtain a badge, and visit no more than 3 times per month in the classroom and 2 hours per month in related services. The policy would have allowed up to 7 hours per month of visits by a parent, plus time for other occasions not classified as visits. The father was the only parent, among a school of 300 students, who complained about the new policy. 41. The father claimed in a letter that the District cancelled the November 20, 2000 IEP meeting, but the evidence showed that the father was more likely responsible for the failure of that IEP meeting to proceed as scheduled. 42. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56381(a) provides that a reassessment shall be conducted at least once every 3 years, or more frequently if conditions warrant, or if the pupil’s parent or teacher requests a reassessment and the development of a new IEP. A functional analysis assessment had been proposed by the District’s August 16, 2000 program offer and was available to the Student if requested, but the program offer referred to conducting the functional analysis assessment for the purpose of facilitating STUDENT’s transition to public school. Although the proposed triennial assessment plan did not, in January 2001, specifically include a behavior assessment, no meaningful input on the District’s proposed assessment plan was provided by the father until after he withdrew STUDENT from SLDC. 43. 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1412 (a) (5) (A) provides “To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities. . . are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular educational environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be satisfactorily achieved.” Section 56031 of the Cal. Educ. Code, in pertinent part, defines the term special education as providing “a full continuum of program options, including instruction conducted in the classroom, in the home, in hospitals and institutions, and in other settings; and instruction in physical education, to meet the educational and service needs of individuals with exceptional needs in the least restrictive environment.” 44. The matter of LRE was the primary issue addressed by the Student at this lengthy due process hearing. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer will describe the testimony most relevant to LRE in some detail. 45. Ms. Franklin has 27 years of experience working with severely handicapped children in SDCs. She has taught many children with autism. She considered STUDENT to be about in the middle of the autism spectrum compared to other children in her classes, and she thought that STUDENT had approximately kindergarten-level skills. 46. SLDC staff testified about instances in which STUDENT had fled the room to a field and was rolling in the dirt. The father testified that many instances had been reported to him in STUDENT’s last few months at SLDC where STUDENT had to be physically restrained at SLDC for alleged safety reasons. 47. Ms. Del Rosario testified that she chose the scissor goals to address STUDENT’s ocular motor deficits. She wanted STUDENT to “slow down and use his eyes.” 48. See 34 C.F.R. Sec. 300.552.

49. Ms. Lundberg testified that nobody asked for an assessment. Other evidence suggested that the Student’s father may have raised assessment concerns with the District and/or Mr. Hemsley in the fall of 2000. However, even if some form of an assessment had been requested at that time, the lack of either an assessment or the earlier submission of an assessment plan by the District would not have resulted in such a degree of procedural violation as to constitute a denial of FAPE. The District did submit a comprehensive assessment plan in January 2001, and through the end of February 2001the father had neither consented to the plan nor offered a constructive response to the plan. The District also scheduled IEP meetings during that period, but the father did not attend. Accordingly, there is no reason to believe that earlier submission of a written assessment plan by the District would have resulted in an actual assessment prior to January 2001or altered STUDENT’s performance at SLDC or had any positive effect on his program for the 2000-2001 school year. 50. The above-stated provisions were similar to those of the May 7, 2001 IEP proposal. The main differences were an increase of 2 periods in regular education classes, a corresponding decrease of 2 periods in SDC, and no mention of the 15-minute per day advisory period or parent education. 51. The FAPE issue for the 2001-2002 school year was consolidated into the case after many of the witnesses had already completed their testimony regarding the 2000-2001 school year. Those witnesses were then recalled to confirm whether their prior-stated opinions were also applicable to the 2001-2002 school year. 52. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56345.1 provides that when a pupil reaches age 14, a statement of the transition service needs of the pupil shall be included in the pupil’s IEP and updated annually. The term “transition services” refers, in part, to the process of moving from school to post-school activities with an emphasis on vocational education. 53. On a rotating block schedule, this means that on any given day, STUDENT would have 2 regular education periods and 1 SDC period. 54. The program offer for the 2000-2001 school year provided for an IEP meeting within the first 3 weeks of school to discuss further opportunities for STUDENT to integrate with typical peers, an additional IEP team meeting by the end of the first trimester to discuss STUDENT’s progress, and a triennial evaluation in February 2001. The District thereby anticipated by its program offer for the 2000-2001 school year that additional inclusion would occur throughout the year as STUDENT’s skills improved and/or further observation and assessment showed that additional inclusion was appropriate. Therefore, the numbers of SDC and regular education periods offered for the 2001-2002 school year may be similar to what STUDENT’s schedule would have progressed to by the conclusion of the 2000-2001 school year. 55. On July 10, 2001 the Hearing Officer issued a written order regarding the Student’s motion to compel the District to allow observation of the Marine View SDC by the Student’s experts. In that written order, the Hearing Officer noted that under Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56506(d), the pupil and the parent have the right to participate in the development of the pupil’s individualized education program. If a district offered a placement for a pupil but did not allow the parent and the parent’s educational expert to view the proposed placement, this could violate the parent’s right to participate in the development of the program by not allowing the parent to make an informed decision. In the July 10, 2001 order, however, the Hearing Officer found no indication that the Student’s motion arose from concern about making an informed choice regarding the District’s placement offer. For reasons stated in the order, the Hearing Officer concluded that the sole purpose of the demand for observations was to gain an evidentiary advantage in the due process hearing. After the presentation of voluminous oral and documentary evidence by the parties since that order, the Hearing Officer’s conclusion regarding the Student’s limited purpose in wanting his experts to view the SDC and other classrooms has not changed. 56. The Hearing Officer has noted that perhaps STUDENT’s greatest educational need is a reasonable level of cooperation and trust between the father and the District and WOCCSE. STUDENT’s levels of performance and his needs are dynamic. Within the bounds of STUDENT’s eventual program, as described now or in the future either by an agreed-upon IEP, by a Hearing Officer, or by court order, frequent adjustment will be required for meeting STUDENT’s needs as they change in response to changes in his campus environment, daily routines, and STUDENT himself. Proper adjustments will be dependent upon a team process that is not wrecked by distrust and hostility. To date, STUDENT has essentially been receiving educational services throughout his life without the benefit of an IEP team. The IEP meetings recounted in this case served to do little more than promote discord between the father and the District. Future attempts by the District to administer a sufficiently dynamic program to STUDENT on a District campus will likely be fraught with ongoing questioning and criticism by the father. Attempts by the father to offer input to the process will predictably be greeted with skepticism by the District, especially since the father professes to be blameless for every shortcoming in the IEP and assessment process from 1990 to date. If the parties again resort to due process, where they apparently feel compelled to magnify every claim and defense, STUDENT could be subject to a lengthy stay put situation that may not be endurable for him.