California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 10, 2001

South Pasadena Unified School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 1414-01 · Hearing Officer Paul E. Lacy

South Pasadena Unified cannot move student with autism to Gridley School before conducting a functional analysis assessment and behavior plan.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 2 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

South Pasadena Unified School District filed for due process. It asked to move a nine-year-old fourth grader with autism from his special day class at Monterey Hills Elementary School, in his home district, to an autism class at Gridley School in the El Monte School District. The boy had severe communication delays. The IEP team found that his loud vocalizations and aggression were attempts to communicate. Starting in December 1999, the district used a behavior plan, a visual schedule, and picture-based communication systems (PECS and TEACCH strategies). His aggression toward others mostly stopped. But he still vocalized 30 to 35 times a day and pounded on tables and on himself. The district admitted it had never done a functional analysis assessment or written a behavior intervention plan under California's Hughes Bill regulations. The Hearing Officer found the remaining behaviors severe, pervasive, maladaptive, and potentially self-injurious, and found the IEP's approaches ineffective. Under the regulations, those findings require an assessment and a plan. Whether there was an "emergency" was not the test. The assessment and plan had to happen at Monterey Hills first for three reasons: it was the less restrictive setting, it was his home school, and it was where his behaviors happened. The Hearing Officer denied the district's request. The district had to start the assessment within ten days and then use a plan at Monterey Hills for a reasonable period before the IEP team could reconsider placement.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO applied California's Hughes Bill regulations. Serious, pervasive behaviors that the IEP's approaches had not fixed called for a functional analysis assessment and a behavior intervention plan. That process had to be completed and tried in the current, less restrictive home-school placement before the district could move the student to a more restrictive program.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedAssessment

    Issue 1. Is the District required to conduct a functional assessment analysis and implement a behavior intervention plan under 5 C.C.R. §3001(f) and §3052 prior to changing Student's placement?

    Student's vocalizations and pounding were severe, pervasive, maladaptive and potentially self-injurious, and the IEP approaches were ineffective, so the Hughes Bill regulations required a functional analysis assessment and behavior intervention plan, carried out at Monterey Hills for a reasonable period, before any change of placement.

  2. Issue 2. If the District is not required to conduct a functional assessment analysis under C.C.R. §3052 prior to changing Student's placement, is Gidley School the appropriate placement for Student for the 2001-2002 school year?

    The Hearing Officer said Issue 1 decided this issue; the conditional question was not separately reached, and all of the District's claims for relief, including the request to move Student to Gridley, were denied.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to assess. Within ten days of the decision, the District must undertake a functional analysis assessment as required under 5 C.C.R. §3052.
  • Order to provide or change services. The District must then immediately develop and implement any behavior intervention plan the assessment indicates, in Student's current placement at Monterey Hills.
  • The District's request to change placement to Gridley School was denied. The IEP team may revisit whether Monterey Hills is appropriate only after the behavior intervention plan has been implemented for a reasonable period of time.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

5 C.C.R. §3001 (Hughes Bill regulations); 5 C.C.R. §3052; Cal. Educ. Code §56520 et seq. (Hughes Bill); Cal. Educ. Code §56345; 34 C.F.R. §300.550; 34 C.F.R. §300.552

People named in the decision

  • Mike Hendricks, Assistant superintendent; District representative, South Pasadena Unified School District
  • Kathleen Bautista, Special education coordinator, South Pasadena Unified School District
  • Matthew Pope, Special education advocate for Student
  • Beatriz Gomez, Regional center representative present for Student, East Los Angeles Regional Center
  • Janet Miller, School psychologist (1996 psychoeducational assessment), South Pasadena Unified School District
  • Patricia Drake, Speech and language pathologist/therapist, South Pasadena Unified School District
  • Priya Agrawal, Autism consultant, West San Gabriel Valley SELPA
  • Ms. Alegria, Special day class teacher, Monterey Hills Elementary School
  • Dr. Bill Frea, Autism consultant retained by District; Director of autism program, California State University, Los Angeles
  • Terry Kappe, Speech and language consultant specializing in autism, retained by District
  • Sean Surfas, Licensed educational psychologist specializing in autism, retained by District
  • Janejit Potikom, Occupational therapist consultant retained by District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Paul E. Lacy, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, on October 23 and 24, 2001, in South Pasadena, California.

South Pasadena Unified School District (hereinafter “District” or “Petitioner”) was represented by the District’s assistant superintendent, Mike Hendricks. Also present on the District’s behalf was Kathleem Baustista, the District’s coordinator for special education. STUDENT (hereinafter “Respondent”) was represented by Matthew Pope, a special education advocate. STUDENT’s mother, and Beatriz Gomez from the East Los Angeles Regional Center were also present on behalf of STUDENT.

The Hearing Officer received oral and documentary evidence during the course of the proceedings. The parties submitted written closing arguments. The briefs, postmarked November 5, 2001, were received by the Hearing Officer on November 8, 2001, and the record was closed.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

At the beginning of the hearing, the District sought to introduce an audiotape that contained recordings of STUDENT’s vocalizations in his classroom. STUDENT objected to the admission of the tapes because his mother had not given permission for the recordings to be made. At the time of the hearing, witnesses were called to lay a foundation for the recordings, and the Hearing Officer took the matter under submission. Since the recordings are not available to anyone who is not privileged to hear them–STUDENT’S mother and representative, authorized District personnel, and the Hearing Officer–admission of the tapes will not violate STUDENT’S right to have his educational records remain confidential. Therefore, because the evidence is relevant to the matters in dispute, the Hearing Officer rules that the tapes are admissible

ISSUES(Footnote 1)

1. Is the District required to conduct an functional assessment analysis and implement a behavior intervention plan under 5 C.C.R. §3001(f) and §3052 prior to changing STUDENT’S placement?

2. If the District is not required to conduct a functional assessment analysis under C.C.R. §3052 prior to changing STUDENT’S placement, is Gidley School the appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a boy who was born on [date redacted], and was nine years old at the time of this hearing. He currently lives with his mother in South Pasadena and attends Ms. Alegria’s special day class at Monterey Hills Elementary School, also in South Pasadena. When STUDENT was two years old he was referred to the East Los Angeles Regional Center due to severe speech delays and behavioral difficulties. STUDENT began his formal education at the Orangegrove Headstart program during the 1995-1996 school year. While attending Orangegrove in December 1995, STUDENT was diagnosed with autism and mental retardation. He was three years and eight months at that time.

In March 1996, a psychoeducational assessment was administered to STUDENT by Janet Miller, the District’s psychologist. Ms. Miller noted problematic adjustments in the areas of interpersonal relations, activity levels, compliance, and work and studies skills. She reported that STUDENT’S difficulties in these areas adversely affected his academic performance and social functioning. The assessment tests revealed that STUDENT met the criteria for autism and developmental disability, and that his impairments significantly affected his verbal and nonverbal communication skills and his ability to socially interact with others. The assessment report also disclosed that STUDENT exhibited an inability to use oral language for appropriate communication, that he was extremely resistant to controls, and that he had a history of relating to people inappropriately from early childhood. Ms. Miller concluded that STUDENT needed a highly structured classroom for intensive-needs students. Additionally, a speech and language assessment was administered to STUDENT by Patricia Drake, the District’s speech and language pathologist. Her evaluation indicated STUDENT had a severe receptive and expressive language disorder secondary to his diagnosis of autism and mental retardation. Ms. Drake’s report also revealed that STUDENT’S language sample documented a markedly restricted repertoire of spontaneous expressive language.

After completing the 1995-1996 school year at the Orangegrove Headstart, STUDENT was placed in three different Los Angeles County Office of Education special day class preschools during the 1996-1997 and 1997-1998 school years. In September 1998, STUDENT was placed in a special day class at Monterey Hills Elementary School within the South Pasadena District. At Monterey Hills, STUDENT was designated a first-grader for the 1998-1999 school year, a second-grader for the 1999-2000 school year, a third-grader for the 2000-2001 school year, and is currently listed as a fourth-grader for the 2001-2002 school year. Each year at Monterey Hills, the IEP team placed STUDENT in a special day class and provided him with speech and language therapy, adaptive physical education, and occupational therapy services.

Throughout his placement at Monterey Hills, STUDENT engaged in disruptive and aggressive behavior. STUDENT’S behaviors included loud and frequent vocalizations as well as hitting, kicking, spitting, and biting. There is no dispute that STUDENT’S behaviors were a direct manifestation of his disability. In December 1999, the IEP team met and developed a behavior plan, although the District concedes that it was not an actual “behavior intervention plan” as the term is used in C.C.R. §3052.(Footnote 2) The IEP team found that the purpose or function of STUDENT’S behavior was an effort on his part to communicate. Specifically, the team noted that STUDENT’S physical aggression was a form of communication, a show of frustration, and a method of seeking attention and independence. The team also found that his loud vocalizations were attempts at communication during transitions and a form of self-stimulation. To address his inappropriate behaviors, the IEP team proposed to substitute alternative behaviors for STUDENT. The alternatives selected by the team included the use of visual prompts and instruction on the appropriate use of touch to gain attention.

In March of 2000, Priya Agrawal, an autism consultant for the West San Gabriel Valley SELPA, was retained to evaluate and implement STUDENT’S behavior plan. Ms. Agrawal also collected data regarding STUDENT’S behaviors in the classroom. From her observations, Ms. Agrawal determined that STUDENT was “desperately trying to communicate,” and his efforts were manifested in his behavior. She opined that as a result of his behaviors, STUDENT’S teachers could not effectively communicate with him and he could not be taught. Ms. Agrawal, who also relied on input from other consultants retained by the District, developed an individualized program for STUDENT that utilized a visual communication system. The system was based on strategies derived from the Training and Education of Autistic and Communicatively Handicapped Children (TEACH) and the Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS).(Footnote 3) The purpose of the visual communication system was to help STUDENT develop an alternative and appropriate mode of communication to replace his inappropriate behavior. Ms. Agrawal trained STUDENT’S classroom teacher and one-to-one classroom aide on the use of these systems. Additionally, specific verbal techniques were developed and put into place to calm STUDENT when he did act out inappropriately.

In an IEP meeting held May 30, 2000, the IEP team observed that STUDENT had made “good progress in following verbal directions in the classroom.” The team noted that “progress toward verbal expression was evident, but inconsistent.” Ms. Alegria, STUDENT’S special day class teacher, commented that STUDENT worked better at tasks he selected than those selected by others that presented increasing challenges. Ms. Alegria also disclosed that STUDENT’S behavior intervention plan appeared to be successful and that the frequency of his aggressive behaviors had ben reduced “dramatically” since the program had been put into effect. She added, however, that STUDENT’S vocalizations had increased during work sessions. Additionally, the IEP team reported that STUDENT had made progress in his academic goals, he was more tolerant of other children in his space, he was beginning to initiate interaction with another student, and he had a friend in the neighborhood with whom he was initiating reciprocal play. The team further commented that transitions were still difficult for STUDENT, but that a picture schedule that had been put in place for him was helping to smooth the process. At that point, the team agreed to continue his behavior plan. The only concern specifically referenced in STUDENT’S IEP at that time was the sufficiency of his physical exercise program. Notwithstanding the team’s report, the District members of the IEP team recommended that STUDENT be placed in an autism class. Ms. PARENT agreed to look at the sites suggested by the District, but she did not agree to a change of placement for STUDENT.

In March 2001, Kathleen Bautista, the District’s special education coordinator prepared a SELPA referral form recommending that STUDENT be transferred from Monterey Hills to a program geared for students with autism. She indicated on the form that the reason for the referral was that STUDENT is mildly autistic and would benefit from a program geared toward students with autism. She also noted that the District had utilized a visual schedule for STUDENT with good results; that the PECS system had been implemented for him with fair results; sensory strategies had been applied, also with good results; and that a behavior plan had been implemented for STUDENT, again, with good results. Ms. PARENT did not sign the form or approve the recommended change in placement.

In June 2001, another IEP team meeting was held. At this meeting, the team noted that STUDENT’S performance was inconsistent–some days he was “on target” and on other days “his performance was limited.” According to the team’s notes, STUDENT’S “communication was a major concern.” The team reported that he preferred nonverbal language, but that he had not yet learned to exchange the PECS cards. Additionally, the team noted that STUDENT had some scripted language, which he used in situations in which he was highly motivated. The team also discussed utilizing the TEACH program in a more structured special day class. According to the IEP notes, the “staff” had attempted to implement this strategy at Monterey Hills, but they expressed a belief that STUDENT required an environment where all of the students were utilizing the PECS system. The District members of the team recommended that STUDENT be placed in the special day class for autistic children at Gridley School. Ms. PARENT did not agree with the recommendation, but she did agree to look into it further.

On July 9, 2001, Ms. Bautista again prepared a SELPA referral form recommending that STUDENT be transferred to a special day class that utilized the TEACH program. She stated on the form that the reason for the referral was that STUDENT responds to visual presentation, and that the special day class at Monterey Hills presents “too much auditory stimulation” for him. She noted that STUDENT’S visual schedule met with good results, the PECS system was implemented with fair results, and that both the sensory strategies and the behavior plan that had been put in place for STUDENT had met with good results. Again, Ms. PARENT did not sign the referral form or approve the recommended change in placement.

On June 8, 2001, the District filed for a due process hearing and requested the Hearing Officer order STUDENT’S placement changed from Monterey Hills to Gridley.

POSITION OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner contends that the appropriate placement for STUDENT is in a special day class at the Gridley School in the El Monte School District, which is in the same SELPA as South Pasadena. In support of its contention, the District asserts that STUDENT has engaged in aggressive and disruptive behavior since being placed at Monterey Hills. According to the IEP team, STUDENT’S behaviors were the result of his communication disabilities, and he engaged in loud vocalizations and aggressive conduct as a means of expressing himself. The District points out that the IEP team designed and implemented a behavior plan in December 1999 that dealt with STUDENT’S inappropriate behaviors by addressing his underlying communication impairments. Specifically, the PECS and TEACH approach to instruction were implemented to increase appropriate communication and reduce inappropriate behavior. The District alleges that while STUDENT’S use of the alternative communication systems has improved over time, and his inappropriate behaviors have diminished, he has not adequately progressed in his educational program. Moreover, STUDENT’S behaviors are disruptive to other children at Monterey Hills

School. Therefore, the District takes the position that placement in the Gridley autism program is more appropriate to meet STUDENT’S needs because that program is specially designed to implement the PECS and TEACH system on a class wide basis.

Respondent maintains that the District is “jumping the gun.” While STUDENT agrees that he has not made as much progress under the behavior plan as the IEP team had hoped, he insists that the District is required to undertake a functional assessment analysis (FAA) and implement a behavior intervention plan (BIP) as set forth under Title V C.C.R. §3052 before changing his placement. STUDENT contends that an FAA is required when the IEP team finds that the instructional and behavioral approaches specified in his IEP are ineffective. In short, STUDENT’S position is that the District must undertake an FAA and implement any appropriate behavior intervention plans indicated by the assessment before placing him outside his home school district and in a more restricted environment.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue Number 1: Is the District required to conduct an functional assessment analysis and implement a behavior intervention plan under 5 C.C.R. §3001(f) and §3052 prior to changing STUDENT’S placement?

Applicable Law

Federal regulation requires that a student with exceptional needs be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). (34 CFR §300.550.) Moreover, the child’s placement must be as close as possible to the child's home, and unless the child’s IEP requires some other arrangement, he must be educated in the school that he would attend if he were not disabled. (34 CFR §300.552.) The federal regulation also states that in selecting the LRE, consideration is given to any potential harmful effect on the child or on the quality of services that he or she needs. (34 CFR §300.552(d).)

Under California law, an eligible pupil’s individualized education program must provide those supports and services that allow the pupil to advance in his or her educational program in the least restrictive environment. (Cal. Ed. Code §56345.) Additionally, in 1990, California passed Education Code Section 56520 et seq., which is commonly known as the Hughes Bill. Regulations implementing the Hughes Bill are contained in Title 5, California Code of Regulations §3001 and §3052. According to the Hughes Bill, a functional analysis assessment (FAA) forms the basis of a behavior intervention plan. (C.C.R. §3052 (a)(3).) Subsection (h) of Code §3001 states that the "behavior intervention plan is a written document which is developed when the individual exhibits a serious behavior problem that significantly interferes with the implementation of the goals and objectives of the individual's IEP." The regulations define serious behavior problems as "behaviors which are self-injurious, assaultive, or cause serious property damage and other severe behavior problems that are pervasive and maladaptive for which instructional/behavioral approaches specified in the student's IEP are found to be ineffective." (Emphasis added.) (5 C.C.R. §3001(ah); 5 C.C.R. §3052(b).) When members of an IEP team find that the instructional or behavioral approaches specified in the student's IEP have been ineffective, an FAA must be conducted. (5 C.C.R. §3052 (a)(6)(b).)

California regulations also require that the behavior intervention plan be based on a functional assessment analysis and be specified in the pupil’s IEP. (5 C.C.R. §3052(a)(3).) Additionally, the plan shall be used only in a systematic manner in accordance with the provisions of the regulation. (Ibid.) A functional assessment analysis shall occur after the individualized education program team finds that instructional or behavioral approaches specified in the student's IEP have been ineffective. (5 C.C.R. §3052(b).) The functional assessment analysis must also be carried out in the manner set forth in the regulation, and it must systematically follow the described procedures. (5 C.C.R. §§3052(b), 3052(b)(1), and 3052(b)(2).) Thereafter, the IEP team shall:

...review results and, if necessary, ... develop a behavioral intervention plan, as defined in Article 1, Section 3001(f) of these regulations. The IEP team shall include the behavioral intervention case manager. The behavioral intervention plan shall become a part of the IEP and shall be written with sufficient detail so as to direct the implementation of the plan. (5 C.C.R. §3052(c).)

Thereafter, positive programming for behavioral interventions must be based on the functional assessment analysis. (C.C.R. §3052(d).) Following the implementation of the plan, the regulation provides specific procedures that must be followed in evaluating the effectiveness of the plan. (5 C.C.R. §3052(f).)

Evidentiary Analysis

There are few disagreements as to the underlying material facts in this case. STUDENT has engaged in disruptive behavior throughout his placement at Monterey Hills. Those behaviors include loud and frequent vocalizations and, until the 2000-2001 school year, physical aggression. The District’s consultants and the IEP team determined that STUDENT’S difficulty with communication was the principal source of his behavioral problems and that his misbehavior was primarily communicative and an expression of frustration at his inability to communicate. An alternative system of visual communication was developed and implemented for STUDENT to replace his inappropriate behavior. Additionally, specific verbal techniques were employed to calm his inappropriate behavior when it did occur.

All of the witnesses agreed that the interventions implemented for STUDENT were successful to a degree, but not to the extent that the IEP team had hoped for. STUDENT was able to progress in his use of the visual communication systems at a basic level. Ms. Patricia Drake, STUDENT’S speech and language therapist, explained that STUDENT recognized words that corresponded to a picture, and that he was beginning to understand the meanings of pictures when they were arranged into sentences. He had also learned pronouns, which he had not previously understood, and he was less reliant on short phrases such as “I want.” However, STUDENT had demonstrated only minimal success in initiating requests without external prompting. In short, his use of spontaneous and higher language skills was largely undeveloped. STUDENT’S progress in acquiring communication techniques corresponded to changes in his behavior–in which he was partially successful. STUDENT’S physical aggression was virtually eliminated, but his loud and frequent vocalizations continued. Additionally, he replaced kicking, hitting, and biting with pounding on tables and desks, particularly when he was frustrated.

Ms. Alegria recounted that STUDENT’S vocalizations were very loud and included sudden screaming, laughing, and high-pitch squeals. She noted that STUDENT’S outbursts occurred 30 to 35 times a day. Additionally, Ms. Alegria testified that STUDENT frequently pounded his fists on tables and walls in the classroom as well as on himself. She was particularly concerned because STUDENT was becoming larger and his conduct was potentially more harmful. Ms. Alegria also told how STUDENT’S outbursts frightened the other children in the class. She added that she was often unable to locate the antecedents that triggered STUDENT’S conduct. Furthermore, the audio-tape of STUDENT’S vocalizations submitted by the District demonstrated to the Hearing Officer the severity of his vocalizations. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that while STUDENT’S physical aggression toward others–kicking, hitting, and biting–has substantially been eliminated, his frequent and loud vocalizations and his routine of pounding on furniture and himself constitutes “other severe behavior problems that are pervasive and maladaptive.” Moreover, STUDENT’S practice of pounding on himself, particularly as he increases in stature, is at lest potentially, if not actually, “self injurious.”

According to the District’s witnesses, although STUDENT’S physical aggression towards others subsided over the past year, his vocalizations and pounding continued even after the visual communication systems and verbal techniques had been implemented for him. In other words, the instructional and behavioral approaches specified in STUDENT’S IEP have been ineffective. For that reason, the District contends that STUDENT needs to be placed at Gridley School in the El Monte School District. Witnesses for the District described how the special day class for autistic children at Gridley would benefit STUDENT since that program was based exclusively on the TEACH and PECS systems and all of the children in the class utilized those communication modes. While the District’s rationale for recommending that STUDENT be placed at Gridley is not unreasonable per se, California regulations require that specific processes be undertaken. The C.C.R. §3052 specifically states that when instructional or behavioral approaches in a student’s IEP are determined to be ineffective, a functional assessment analysis must be undertaken. The functional assessment analysis then serves as the basis for designing an appropriate behavior intervention plan for STUDENT. (See C.C.R. §§3052(a)(3) and 3052(c).) Moreover, the behavior intervention plan may only be used in accordance with the very specific provisions set forth in the regulations. (C.C.R. §3052(a)(3).)

While the District expressly concedes in its closing brief that it did not conduct a functional assessment analysis and develop a behavior intervention plan–within the meaning of 5 C.C.R. §3001(f) and §3052–it argues that such measures were not necessary because STUDENT’S behaviors were never perceived as an emergency. But an “emergency” is not the test or determinative factor for conducting a functional assessment analysis and developing a behavior intervention plan. Rather, the test is whether the pupil exhibits behaviors that are self-injurious, assaultive, or cause serious property damage and other severe behavior problems that are pervasive and maladaptive for which instructional and behavioral approaches specified in the student's IEP are found to be ineffective. Under these circumstances a functional assessment analysis must be conducted and a behavior intervention plan developed. Therefore, because STUDENT exhibits severe behavior problems that are pervasive and maladaptive, and to some degree self-injurious, and because the instructional and behavior approaches specified in his IEP have been ineffective in reducing those behaviors to an acceptable level, a functional assessment analysis followed by a behavior intervention plan is required.

Furthermore, for three reasons, the District must conduct the functional assessment analysis at Monterey Hills and implement the behavior intervention plan for a reasonable period of time before a change in placement can be considered. First, STUDENT’S present special day class at Monterey Hills constitutes the least restrictive environment. His current class is predominately made up of children with learning disabilities who do not have significant communication disorders. As Ms. Alegria pointed out, the other students in her class learn and communicate at a higher level than STUDENT and, thus, the Hearing Officer finds they represent more appropriate behavior and communicative role models. According to the District’s witnesses, the children in the special day class at Gridley function in STUDENT’S range–some higher and some lower. Thus, while his current classmates may also be special education students, their level of functioning–particularly in the area of communication–more closely resembles normally developing peers than the students at Gridley. At Monterey Hills, STUDENT is exposed daily to these peers. Thus, in light of the clear State and federal mandate for educating special education children in the least restrictive environment, STUDENT’S placement at Monterey Hills more closely advances those legislative policy preferences.

Second, as previously noted, federal regulations set forth a clear preference for allowing eligible pupils to be educated in their “home school.” In fact, the preference toward the home school is stated twice in the regulation–and in two different ways. The regulation states that a district shall ensure that a child is placed in the school closest to his home and, unless his disability requires some other arrangement, he must be educated in the school he would attend if he were not disabled. (34 CFR §300.552.) In this case, Monterey Hills is the school closest to STUDENT’S home that has a special day class to serve his disability. It is also located in his home district and in his home town. While the District’s position is that STUDENT’S disability requires that he be educated in a placement other than his home school, such a determination cannot be made without the completion of a functional assessment analysis and an opportunity to evaluate the results of the corresponding behavior intervention plan.

Finally, the functional assessment analysis should be conducted at Monterey Hills for practical reasons. STUDENT has attended that school since September 1998. His behaviors arise in the context of that particular placement, which includes the physical site, certain teachers and aides, and at least some of his classmates. The functional assessment analysis does not operate in a vacuum; rather, it seeks to accumulate useful information from various sources including historical data from his present placement. If STUDENT were transferred to a new school, which necessarily means a new physical environment, new teachers, and entirely new classmates, his behaviors, including their antecedent triggers, may be entirely different. Thus, the functional assessment analysis would require significantly more time in order to observe STUDENT in a new setting and determine both his behaviors and their underlying causes. Thus, Monterey Hills is the appropriate placement for the implementation of STUDENT’S functional assessment analysis and his behavior intervention plan.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District cannot change STUDENT’S placement from Monterey Hills School to Gidley School without conducting a functional assessment analysis and implementing–at least for a reasonable period of time–a behavior intervention plan.

Issue Number 2: If the District is not required to conduct a functional assessment analysis under C.C.R. §3052 prior to changing STUDENT’S placement, is Gidley School the appropriate placement for STUDENTfor the 2001-2002 school year?

The outcome of this issue was determined by the Hearing Officer’s findings in issue number one above.

ORDER

All of the District’s claims for relief are denied. Within ten days of the date of this decision, the District is required to undertake a functional analysis assessment as required under Title V of C.C.R. §3052. Thereafter, the District is required to immediately develop and implement any behavior intervention plan indicated by the assessment in STUDENT’S current placement. After the behavior intervention plan has been implemented for a reasonable perid of time, the IEP team may revisit the issue of whether Monterey Hills is an appropriate placement for STUDENT.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to Education Code §56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statue:

The Student prevailed on the issue that was heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties in this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (Cal. Educ. Code §56505(i).)

Date: December 10, 2001 ___________________________________ Paul E. Lacy, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnote 1: The parties agreed that the sole issue in this case was what is the appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year. However, during the clarification of the issues, the Respondent asserted that the District had not exhausted all reasonable efforts of educating STUDENT in his home school in the least restrictive environment. During the presentation of his case, STUDENT asserted that under C.C.R. §3052, the District is not permitted to change his placement without first conducting a functional assessment analysis and implementing any behavior intervention plan indicated by the assessment. Therefore, for the purpose of analysis, it is more logical to separatae the issues as the Hearing Officer has done above.

Footnote 2: The form utilized by the IEP team to set forth STUDENT’S behavior plan included check-boxes to denote the seriousness of the behavior. The boxes were labeled “mild,” “moderate,” “serious,” and “extreme (need functional analysis.” The box marked “serious” was checked, and the box marked “extreme (need functional analysis)” was not checked

Footnote 3: The other consultants that Ms. Agrawal relied on had been retained by the District over a two-year period between 1999 and 2001, and included Dr. Bill Frea, Director of the autism program at California State University, Los Angeles; Terry Kappe, speech and language consultant specializing in autism; Sean Surfas, licensed educational psychologist with a specialty in autism; and Janejit Potikom, an occupational therapist.