California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 26, 1999

San Francisco Unified School District et al. v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 1512-98, SN 1645-98 · Hearing Officer Marie Ward

San Francisco Unified and Community Mental Health's offer of Seneca residential placement upheld for 19-year-old; transition plan ordered.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

Follows the prior decision in SN 476-98 (August 17, 1998), which found a denial of FAPE for 1997-1998 and ordered a residential placement offer with specified characteristics. No later history is noted in this document.

Summary

San Francisco Unified School District and San Francisco Community Mental Health filed this case, which was consolidated with SN 1645-98. The student was 19 and eligible for special education as seriously emotionally disturbed with a specific learning disability. In an earlier case, SN 476-98, a Hearing Officer had found that the agencies denied her a FAPE. That decision ordered them to offer a 24-hour residential treatment program with specific features: a high staff-student ratio, intensive therapy, peers at her level of functioning, resources for seclusion and restraint, recreation such as track, and instruction in independent living and vocational skills. Her mother and conservator had placed her at KidsPeace, a residential center in Pennsylvania. The agencies then offered Seneca San Francisco Community Alternatives Program. The family argued that the student needed a single-sex living unit, needed treatment away from San Francisco because of post-traumatic stress disorder, and should not be moved while she was doing well. Hearing Officer Marie Ward found that Seneca had every feature the earlier order required. She also found that the student did not need a single-sex unit or an out-of-area placement. The experts agreed that this condition is usually treated in the patient's own community, family therapy was limited by the distance, and the student would need local adult services later. The Hearing Officer ordered an IEP meeting within two weeks to create a transition plan. The plan had to name a therapist and move the student to Seneca within one month.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO checked a district's offer against the placement features ordered in an earlier hearing. It also shows how SEHO decided that a parent's preferred out-of-state facility was not required under Rowley and Gregory K. The Hearing Officer ordered a structured transition plan so the student could move safely between residential programs.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1. Is the District's placement designed to address Student's unique needs, provide some educational benefit and comport with her IEP (including the placement characteristics ordered in SN 476-98)?

    Seneca's residential program met each characteristic ordered in SN 476-98, including staffing, intensive therapy, peers, seclusion and restraint resources, recreation, and independent living and vocational instruction. It was designed to meet Student's unique needs and provide some educational benefit.

  2. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2. Does Student need to be placed in a facility which is sexually segregated and is located outside San Francisco?

    Student's unique needs did not require a single-sex living unit or a facility away from San Francisco. The experts agreed that PTSD is usually treated in the patient's community, and Student would need local services after residential care.

  3. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 3. Is it appropriate to change Student's placement at this time?

    The change to Seneca was appropriate if made through a carefully designed transition plan. Student had adjusted to a new facility before, and the distance limited the family therapy she needed.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order that district's offer may be implemented. Seneca San Francisco Community Alternatives Program is an appropriate placement for Student.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within two weeks of the decision, the IEP team and a Seneca staff person must meet and develop a transition plan addressing Student's needs during and after the move to Seneca. The team must invite a KidsPeace representative familiar with Student's current condition.
  • The transition plan must name a specific therapist who will visit Student once at KidsPeace, be available to her at Seneca during the transition, and be available to the parent to help with her role in the transition. Student is to be transferred to Seneca no later than one month from the date of the decision.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176; Gregory K. v. Longview School District (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307

People named in the decision

  • Anna Grande, administrator, San Francisco Unified School District
  • Helene Weinstein, licensed clinical social worker, San Francisco Community Mental Health
  • Pamela Mills, school psychologist (District witness), San Francisco Unified School District
  • Christine Stoner, executive director, nonpublic residential program (Mental Health witness), Seneca San Francisco Community Alternatives Program
  • Michael Mertz, program director, nonpublic residential program (Mental Health witness), Seneca San Francisco Community Alternatives Program
  • Albert DeRanieri, M.D., medical director, Child, Youth and Family Services (Mental Health witness), San Francisco Community Mental Health
  • Kurt S. Chaleby, M.D., treating psychiatrist (witness for Student), KidsPeace National Centers for Kids in Crisis
  • Kirsten Lyman, clinical social worker / therapist (witness for Student), KidsPeace National Centers for Kids in Crisis
  • Charles Connor, M.D., psychiatrist, associate medical director of inpatient psychiatry (witness for Student), California Pacific Medical Center
  • Ms. Reiss, educational psychologist (testified in prior hearing SN 476-98)
  • Amanda Metcalf, attorney for Student; testified on a procedural matter, Law Offices of Amanda Metcalf
  • Diane E. Finkelstein, attorney for District, Shupe and Finkelstein
  • Charlotte Siggins, deputy city attorney for Mental Health, San Francisco City Attorney

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

Case Number: SN 1512-98 Case Year: 1998 Petitioner: SAN FRANCISCO UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT and SAN FRANCISCO COMMUNITY MENTAL

HEALTH (CONSOLIDATED WITH SN 1645-98)

Issue: Placement CDS Code: 38-68478 District: San Francisco Unified Disability Type: Seriously Emotionally Disturbed Specific Learning Disability

Case Details This matter was heard before Marie Ward, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in San Francisco, California, on December 1 and 2, 1998. For purposes of this decision, all references to Petitioner are to San Francisco Unified School District (District) or to San Francisco Community Mental Health (Mental Health), and all references to Respondent are to STUDENT.

San Francisco Unified School District was represented by attorney Diane E. Finkelstein from the firm of Shupe and Finkelstein. Also present on the District's behalf was Anna Grande, administrator. San Francisco Community Mental Health was represented by attorney Charlotte Siggins, a deputy city attorney. Also present on Mental Health's behalf for most of the hearing was Helene Weinstein, licensed clinical social worker.

Respondent STUDENT was represented by attorney Amanda Metcalf of the Law Offices of Amanda Metcalf. Also present on STUDENT's behalf for most of the hearing was her mother, PARENT.

The following witness was called by the District: Pamela Mills, San Francisco Unified School District psychologist.

The following witnesses were called by Mental Health to testify: Christine Stoner, executive director of Seneca San Francisco Community Alternatives Program (Seneca); Michael Mertz, program director of Seneca; Albert DeRanieri, M.D., medical director of Child, youth and Family Services for San Francisco Community Mental Health.

The following witnesses were called by Respondent: Kurt S. Chaleby, M.D., a psychiatrist with KidsPeace National Centers for Kids in Crisis (KidsPeace); Kirsten Lyman, clinical social worker for KidsPeace; and Charles Connor, M.D., associate medical director of the Inpatient Psychiatry Unit at California Pacific Medical Center (CPMC). These witnesses all testified by telephone. PARENT, STUDENT's mother, testified in person.

Attorney Amanda Metcalf testified on a procedural matter.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open for the submission of written closing arguments. The parties' closing arguments were received by December 17, 1998, the record was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUE

Has the San Francisco Unified School District and San Francisco Community Mental Health offered STUDENT an appropriate placement consistent with the placement characteristics ordered in SN 476-98?

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

On November 20, 1998, the Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office) received Respondent's motion to admit into evidence, in effect, the entire record of SN-476/98, the prior hearing between the parties. At the instant hearing, the Hearing Officer denied the motion on the grounds that the instant case is a separate case, requiring its own individual record, and that a large amount of the prior evidence was irrelevant to the issue on which a decision would be made.

On December 2, 1998, Mental Health offered as evidence the California Department of Social Services' authorization for Seneca to admit STUDENT. Respondent objected on the ground that the authorization was not obtained according to the Department's own internal procedures. The Hearing Officer stated that the Hearing Office does not have jurisdiction over the Department. Respondent was given five additional days in which to offer any other objection. The Hearing Office received no other objection and the authorization was entered into evidence on December 7, 1998. After the hearing, Respondent attempted to introduce further documentary evidence on another matter. That evidence was not admitted or considered.

FACTS

STUDENT, a 19-year-old girl, is a resident of San Francisco, California, and is currently enrolled at KidsPeace, a 24-hour residential care treatment center in Orefield, Pennsylvania. STUDENT qualifies for special education because she is seriously emotionally disturbed (SED) and has a specific learning disability (SLD). STUDENT was first identified as a special education student in the second grade and have been receiving services from the District since that time. STUDENT's Individualized Education Program (IEP) calls for her to be placed in a 24-hour residential program with a career orientation program, and includes the services of the San Francisco Community Mental Health Department.

In 1996, when STUDENT was 16, she reported to her counselors at camp and school that a boy in her neighborhood had been sexually assaulting her after school for several months. After the disclosure, STUDENT began to exhibit suicidal, depressed, and sometimes, violent behavior. She was hospitalized in the McAuley's Behavioral Health Services Unit of St. Mary's Medical Center (McAuley's) because it was felt that she presented a danger to herself. A psychological evaluation was performed at McAuley's which concluded that STUDENT felt frightened to go home and worried constantly that the boy who had raped her would hurt her again. It was recommended that STUDENT receive outpatient psychotherapy at least twice a week and receive family therapy once a week.

In January 1997, STUDENT moved in with a friend of her older sister's because she wanted to get out of the neighborhood in which the alleged rapist (Footnote 1) lived and to be a little more independent. However, even out of the immediate neighborhood, STUDENT was still extremely fearful that the alleged rapist would discover where she was staying, and she was still afraid of encountering him in other neighborhoods. After the suicide attempt, STUDENT was returned to McAuley's; she had a number of other brief hospitalizations at McAuley's thereafter.

In January 1998, STUDENT again attempted suicide by ingesting 14 Tylenol tablets and was hospitalized at California Pacific Medical Center (CPMC). Psychological assessments performed by the CPMC staff found that the recent stressors in STUDENT's life included moving out of her mother's house after an altercation with her mother, a very conflicted and allegedly verbally abusive relationship with her mother, guilt about rejecting her father's offer to move in with him, and stress because her application for food stamps had been turned down.

While at CPMC, STUDENT continued to exhibit suicidal tendencies and also appeared to have hallucinatory experiences. It was determined that three factors contributed to STUDENT's emotional instability: unresolved anger and shame about sexual assaults, difficulty integrating the child and adult parts of herself, and anger and anxiety about the relationship with her mother. It was recommended that residential treatment be considered due to STUDENT's fragile "defensive structure" and that the family have counseling. The staff at CPMC concluded that STUDENT would likely need weeks of structured supportive treatment. The staff also concluded that she would need to continue on medications to progress any further and that it would be good for her to stay in the area for continuity of support and treatment until she finished high school.

In March 1998, STUDENT was transferred from CPMC to Shrader House, a therapeutic unit provided more freedom. Shortly thereafter, she cut herself with broken glass and threatened to jump off the roof at Shrader House. She was readmitted to CPMC. During this second hospitalization at CPMC, STUDENT alleged for the first time that her father had been sexually molesting her from an early age. During this time, the District psychologist concluded that STUDENT met the criteria under the IDEA as a student who is seriously emotionally disturbed. In May 1998, and AB 3632 assessment for residential placement was performed. In April 1998, MOTHER was appointed STUDENT's conservator.

On May 18, 1998, an IEP meeting was held for STUDENT. The team agree that (1) the category of SED should be added to STUDENT's primary eligibility designation and (2) she needed immediate placement in a 24-hour residential treatment program with extended school year services (ESY), and recommended placement at Seneca (Footnote 2). MOTHER agreed with the SED designation but rejected the placement recommendation. Three days later, on May 21, a due process hearing, case number SN 476-98, was reconvened to resolve issues regarding STUDENT's educational placement. MOTHER enrolled

STUDENT at KidsPeace on June 22, 1998, before that hearing was concluded.

At KidsPeace, STUDENT's treatment focuses on her post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), which stems from her history of sexual abuse. While she was also diagnosed with a paranoid schizophrenic disorder at KidsPeace, her treating psychiatrist, Dr. Chaleby, testified that this problem is under control

On August 17, 1998, a decision was issued from the California Special Education hearing Office in case number SN 476-98. It had been determined that the District and Mental Health failed to provide a free appropriate public education for STUDENT during the school year 1997-1998. The District and Mental Health were ordered to convene an IEP meeting and offer STUDENT a 24-hour residential treatment program which had "at minimum, characteristics that are the same as or comparable to the following: a high staff-student ratio; a comprehensive and intensive level of therapeutic care; other patients who are at her level of functioning' the resources to seclude and restrain patients when necessary; recreational opportunities, such as track; and instruction in independent living and prevocational/vocational skills."

On August 28, 1998, the IEP team met to offer STUDENT placement at Seneca, the 24-hour residential care treatment center. Seneca is located on the grounds of San Francisco General Hospital, in a building separate from the hospital. Neither STUDENT, her mother and conservator, MOTHER, nor her attorney, Ms. Metcalf, was present at that meeting. The IEP team reconvened on September 15, 1998. MOTHER signed the IEP, but indicated on it that she disagreed with the team's recommendation. The instant due process hearing of the consolidated cases, SN 1512-98 and 1645-98, was held to determine whether or not Seneca conforms to the requirements of SN 476-98 and is an otherwise appropriate placement for STUDENT.

LEGAL ANALYSIS

State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), provide that students with disabilities have the right to a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs and prepare them for employment and independent living. 20 U.S.C. §1400(d); California Education Code §5600. A "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that meet the standards of the State educational agency and conform with the student's individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. §1401(8). "Special education" is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability. 20 U.S.C. §1401(25). The term "related services" means transportation and such other supportive services as may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. §1401 (22).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. V. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court determined that the requirement of the Act (IDEA) for a free, appropriate public education is satisfied when the State provides personalized instruction with sufficient support services to permit the student with disabilities to benefit educationally from that instruction. The Court determined that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court concluded that "the µbasic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to proved educational benefit" to the student. Id.,458 U.S. 176 at 207-208.

In determining whether the school district has offered a FAPE, the court must focus primarily on the District's proposed placement, not on the alternative that the family prefers. Gregory K. v. Longview School District (9thCir.. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307. In comparing the program Gregory had with the program the District offered, the court went on to say that even if the program which the parents' preferred was better for the student, it would not necessarily mean that the District's placement was inappropriate.

In the relevant part, therefore, under IDEA and Rowley, an educational program is appropriate when it is designed to meet the student's unique needs, provide the student with some educational benefit and comport with the IEP. The program must also include preparation for employment and independent living.

ISSUE: Has the San Francisco Unified School District and San Francisco Community Mental Health offered STUDENT an appropriate placement consistent with the placement characteristics ordered in SN 476-98?

1. Is the District's placement designed to address STUDENT's unique needs, provide some educational benefit comport with her IEP?

Dr. Connor, the psychiatrist who worked with STUDENT at CPMC, and Ms. Reiss, and educational psychologist, testified to STUDENT's unique needs during case number SN 476-98. In the order from that case, STUDENT's unique needs were identified as characteristics which must be present in the placement which the District offers in order for it to be appropriate. The District and Mental Health were ordered to offer STUDENT a 24-hour residential treatment program which had "at the minimum, characteristics that were the same as or comparable to the following: a high staff-student ratio; a comprehensive and intensive level of therapeutic care; other patients who are at her level of functioning' the resources to seclude and restrain patients when necessary; recreational opportunities, such as track; and instruction in independent living and prevocational/ vocational skills." (Respondent's Exhibit 7.)

In the instant hearing, Ms. Stoner, the executive director of Seneca, Mr. Mertz, Seneca's program director, and Dr. Mills, a District psychologist, testified that the Seneca program offers the following characteristics:

High staff-student ratio: In his testimony during the prior hearing, Dr. Connor stated that STUDENT needs to be constantly supervised. At Seneca, the ratio of supervision is 1 line staff to 2 students. The students have the services of four doctors, a medical director, licensed social workers, child psychiatrists and three residents from the University of California at San Francisco. Available during waking hours are six staff persons, two shift supervisors, the program director, two administrative assistants and three therapists. At night, there are three staff persons who stay awake during their shift from 10:30 p.m. until morning. This level of staff-student ratio is consistent with the order in SN 476-98 and meets STUDENT's unique need for constant supervision.

A comprehensive and intensive level of therapeutic care: Dr. Connor also testified at the prior hearing that STUDENT needs a comprehensive, high level of care which includes a large therapeutic component. Seneca is licensed to provide services for children who have the highest level of need. The program that it has developed offers a "continuum of care" in which services are "wrapped around" the students. This means that a treatment plan can be designed that keeps students in the most appropriate, and least restrictive, placement. Students who live with their families can remain at home, and Seneca will provide them with home-support counseling, respite, family or individual therapy and on-call response for emergencies. As another option, the student may begin in the 24-hour residential and day treatment program, go home with wraparound services in the home, and attend Seneca's school program and day treatment services. A student can also live in the residential facility and attend a public school program.

The student's treatment plans are designed based on information from the student, the program director, individual psychiatrists, the teaching staff, the line staff, the family and the social worker. An individual therapist is assigned to each student. Each therapist has six cases and works with the individual child in groups and with the family. Seneca has a "mileau" program which is extremely structured and during which every minute of the day is planned. If the plan calls for free time for the student, the time is used to address individual needs. Students needing acute therapy can met with a psychotherapist weekly and a therapist daily. The treatment plans are reviewed every three months to evaluate whether the goals are being met. If a student needs to be hospitalized, Seneca can maintain contact with the student, to visit and to continue to work with him or her. These services are inclusive and extensive and can be adjusted to meet each student's acute or transitional needs. Therefore, the services comply with that component of the prior order that reflected STUDENT's previously identified unique need for a facility that offers both comprehensive and intensive care.

Other patients who are at her level of functioning: It was also determined at the prior hearing that one of STUDENT's unique needs is to interact with patients whose levels of functioning are similar to her own. At Seneca, there are eleven resident students, seven of whom are girls. Many of these girls have been abused. Though STUDENT is 19, she functions at a younger academic and social level. The Seneca program is currently serving students 15-16 years old, with academic skills ranging from pre-reading to almost high school graduate level. At Seneca, STUDENT would have the opportunity to be with other students who have some similar problems and who have a broad range of skills and needs. Therefore, the Seneca program satisfies the characteristic of the prior order that STUDENT needs to be with similarly functioning students.

Resources to seclude and/or restrain patients when necessary: From evidence presented at the prior hearing, it was determined that STUDENT does not need a locked facility, but that her placement must have a seclusion room. All of the Seneca staff are trained in a technique called "Professional Assault Response Trained" (PART). They take refresher courses in this restraint method twice a year. If restraint is required, the staff members use "holds" on students that are PART-certified. There are two padded quiet rooms in Seneca that are locked only when someone is actually present and depressing the button. There is a window in the door to this room and, when appropriate, a Seneca staff person goes into the room with the student and holds him or her as long as is needed. In the classroom there are two "time out" chairs. Students use these when they want to remove themselves from a difficulty they are experiencing in the classroom. Students can also leave the classroom with a mental health worker or therapist to work through problems. Quiet rooms are available for students when they feel unsafe. The students are not alone in these quiet rooms, but are with a clinician. Based on the evidence, it is concluded that the procedures used at Seneca meet STUDENT's unique needs and that these procedures are in keeping with the requirements for seclusion and restraint ordered in SN 476-98.

Recreational opportunities, such as track: Ms. Reiss testified at the prior hearing that STUDENT needs a setting with recreational opportunities. The building in which Seneca is housed contains a gymnasium that can be reserved for the exclusive use of the Seneca students. Seneca works with the Park and Recreational Department of San Francisco, and two girls at Seneca are participating in a basketball skills workshop. Opportunities were made available to three prior students who wanted to play football. It is also possible to participate in a local high school team while a resident at Seneca, and one boy did so. It is concluded, then, that STUDENT's unique need for recreation, which was identified in the prior hearing, can be met by the Seneca program and that this program provides the recreational component ordered in SN 476-98.

Instruction in independent living and prevocational/vocational skills: STUDENT's need for education in the are of independent living was identified in the prior hearing by Ms. Reiss. At Seneca, the student is prepared for independent living through the above-mentioned wraparound services. In addition, the students participate in and 18- or a 36-week job skills program organized by the Jewish Vocational Services (JVS). Through this program, students are taught to fill out job applications and prepare for job interviews. JVS has connections to local placement opportunities for volunteer and paid jobs, and recently, eight Seneca students had jobs. In these jobs, the students worked independently if they were able to. If they needed a mental health assistant with them at all times during the job, one was provided. The District also has a transition program that is exclusive to special education students and assists with the transition of students who are in the nonpublic schools (NPS). Through the District program, a student can access the services of the California Department of Rehabilitation.

To help the students obtain the educational foundation (Footnote 3) needed for their vocational training, Seneca offers a comprehensive educational program. The classroom at Seneca has eleven students, one teacher and one teacher's assistant. The District reviews the high school instruction and the student's transcripts to ensure that the curriculum in the NPS meets high school instruction and college requirements. Seneca's program for preparing students for independent living and for teaching prevocational and vocational skills is consistent with the order in SN 476-98 and meets STUDENT's unique needs for this type of preparation and training.

Based on the evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District's proposed placement is designed to address STUDENT's unique needs, as identified in SN 476-98, will likely provide some educational benefit, comports with her IEP, and can prepare her for employment and independent living. The placement also offers those characteristics specifically ordered in the prior decision.

2. Does STUDENT need to be placed in a facility, which is sexually segregated and is located outside San Francisco?

Respondent contends that STUDENT's unique needs also include that she be placed in a facility which has a sexually segregated "living unit" and that her placement must be in a facility outside San Francisco. These matters were not discussed in the prior decision. The phrase "living unit" was not specifically defined, but Respondent contends that this type of unit is not available at Seneca. She offers the conditions at KidsPeace as evidence of an appropriate sexually segregated living unit.

According to Ms. Lyman, STUDENT's therapist at KidsPeace, STUDENT's interaction with males at KidsPeace is limited to the following: while there are both male and female students being treated, the girls sleep and have some other activities in a separate building from the boys. The sexes do not eat together, and STUDENT receives her group therapy with girls only. It is not, however, a philosophy of KidsPeace to separate the sexes. The males and females attend school together and are together for recreational and other activities. Of the ten staff on her living unit, three are male. STUDENT's immediate supervisors include one male and one female, and the counselor who answers her daily living questions is male. At KidsPeace, there are 75 students, of whom 30 are males. STUDENT's treatment plan does not specify that she needs to be segregated from males or that the staff who attend her must be only female. (Respondent's Exhibit 1.)

Mr. Mertz testified that, at Seneca, the girls' sleeping quarters are on the same floor as the boys', because the main facility is on one floor. However, the students are supervised 24 hours a day. As at KidsPeace, the male and female students are together for school and other activities, and there are male and female staff members. At Seneca, STUDENT would be in a placement, which has only a few students, a maximum of twelve residents, of whom currently only four are male students.

In the opinion of Dr. Chaleby, STUDENT's psychiatrist at KidsPeace, STUDENT should be on a female unit because she is not ready to adjust to a mixed group. He also testified that STUDENT is able to decide whether or not she wants to interact with males and that she is now communicating more comfortable with male staff and students. On this issue, Dr. Connor testified that while he could speculate that STUDENT might be less stimulated in an all female unit, he could not support the contention because he is so accustomed to his unit in which the sexes are not segregated.

Mr. Mertz testified that it is not unusual for young people who have been abused by men to be afraid of them, that STUDENT's needs in this regard would be built into her treatment plan. He stated that most of the female students at Seneca have been sexually abused. At Seneca, a girl is always able to talk to a female staff member because there is never a single-sex shift, even during the overnight shift.

At KidsPeace, STUDENT currently interacts with both male staff and students, and it is not part of her treatment plan that she be sexually segregated at any time other than is the general practice for all female students. Given those facts and the ability of the Seneca program to address any fear she may have of being in a facility with four male students, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's unique needs do not include placement in a sexually segregated living unit.

Respondent also objects to the District's placement because it is located in San Francisco. She argues that she should be treated in a facility which is away from where her traumas occurred. The experts who testified at the hearing agreed that it is usual to treat PTSD in the community in which the patient lives, even if this is the community where the trauma occurred; however, there was also testimony that, in specific cases, it is appropriate to treat the patient away from the location where the trauma occurred.

Dr. Connor was STUDENT's psychiatrist when she was CPMC and was a witness during the prior hearing. At the instant hearing, he acknowledged that he was not familiar with her current symptoms or treatment. He testified that when STUDENT's placement was being discussed at the prior hearing, the level of care, not the location of the facility, was the main issue. He speculated that treating STUDENT near her home would be beneficial because she could be near her mother, but that it might also be helpful for her to be away from her father.

Ms. Lyman testified that STUDENT is afraid to return to California. Dr. Chaleby opposed placing her in a facility near her home environment at this time because that could provoke post-traumatic stress disorder anxiety symptoms which are beyond her tolerance. He does not propose that STUDENT be isolated from her community, just not return there before she is ready. He also testified that if it were necessary to change her placement, he could work with the receiving staff to minimize the problems which might occur.

Dr. DeRanieri is the Medical Director for the Child, Adolescent and Family Mental Health Services for San Francisco, and acts in an advisory capacity for students at Seneca. He asked to assess STUDENT in May 1998, but was denied permission to do so. He has reviewed STUDENT's KidsPeace records and several years of her hospital records from San Francisco. He testified that treating STUDENT in San Francisco would have beneficial effects. His opnion is that this method of treatment allows patients to integrate the traumatic experiences in a way which helps them to work through those experiences to develop the necessary coping means to feel safe and protected in their environment. He believes that an important aspect of the PTSD treatment is the desensitization process. A patient's painful recall needs to be dealt with slowly, in an incremental manner, so that the individual's recall is not fixed at the time of the event and he or she can learn to handle the experience. His opinion is that being such a long way from her support system in the Bay Area is not good for STUDENT. He questions Dr. Chaleby's opinion, because the vast majority of PTSD patients are treated in their community. He believes STUDENT is being denied the opportunity to integrate into the community in a gradual way, that it is a disservice not to give her a community- based program which provides her a more integrated approach to improving her self esteem, and that keeping her far from home places her in an artificial environment. This opinion was supported by Dr. Mills, the psychologist who determined that STUDENT qualified as SED. Dr. Mills testified that persons who have PTSD should be returned to their environment as quickly as possible. Her opinion is that it is important for STUDENT to be treated in her community to begin feeling safe in her environment and that she cannot begin to get over her fear of being home when she is far away.

While Dr. Connor did not recall it, he testified at the prior hearing that he would have preferred to have STUDENT placed in a facility closer to her mother. Dr. Mills also testified that MOTHER is a critical part of STUDENT's treatment and family therapy is part of STUDENT's treatment plan at KidsPeace (Footnote 4). However, while her mother speaks to her on the phone frequently, she and STUDENT have had joint therapy on only three occasions since STUDENT's admission to KidsPeace in June.

Finally, the evidence established that STUDENT's need for mental health services will continue beyond her need for 24-hour residential care. Dr. DeRanieri suggested that a step-down program through a half-way or three-quarter-way house with a day treatment program may be appropriate for STUDENT when she no longer needs full-time residential care. While Dr. Chaleby stated that STUDENT should be ready to return home in June 1999, he did not discuss how she was being prepared for her eventual move to San Francisco or what preparations were being made for her transition to adult services.

The experts who testified at the hearing agreed that the usual location for treating PTSD is in the patient's community. The record indicates that even when she was at her most fragile, STUDENT did not require a placement in a location away from San Francisco and that the one aspect which Dr. Connor considered a disadvantage to the KidsPeace placement was that it was not closer to her mother. In addition, STUDENT will need services in San Francisco after she no longer needs residential care. The Hearing Officer finds that the record, looked at as a whole, does not indicate that STUDENT needs to be in a facility located away from San Francisco.

In summary, STUDENT does not have additional unique needs which must be characteristics of her placement, and the District's proposal meets the standards of IDEA and Rowley. Therefore, Seneca is determined to be a fully appropriate placement.

3. Is it appropriate to change STUDENT's placement at this time?

Respondent's final contention is that, even if Seneca is appropriate, STUDENT should not be required to make a change in placement at this time (Footnote 5). Dr. Chaleby's opinion is that STUDENT is progressing at an encouraging rate and that she should not be transferred suddenly to another facility.

The record shows, however, that STUDENT has the ability when placed in a new facility, not only to survive, but to thrice. When Dr. Chaleby was asked whether it was possible that the move to KidsPeace, in itself, contributed to STUDENT's fragile condition in June, he said it was very unlikely. He believes the kind of anxiety and behavior she was exhibiting could not be directly related to the stress of moving. Ms. Lyman testified that when STUDENT arrived at KidsPeace, she was shy, self-injurious, reserved, terrified, slow moving and childlike. Now she is a completely different person: she jokes around, her self-abuse has decreased dramatically and she is one of the most popular girls in her unit. The evidence shows that, in STUDENT's case, the ability of the receiving facility to meet her needs is a critical factor in how she will progress in a new placement.

MOTHER testified that she wanted to give STUDENT some idea that she might need to return to San Francisco, and she asked her how she would fee about coming home. She said STUDENT reacted "horribly" to this question, and threatened to hurt herself. However, MOTHER acknowledged that STUDENT is aware that students do leave KidsPeace, that she reacted well to her best friend's transition from KidsPeace, and that she understands that transition will be a part of her own future. Mr. Mertz testified that he has worked in the past with students who were not ready for a transfer. To prepare STUDENT for a transition, he would want to speak with her, with her mother, and with whomever she was working to get information on her current placement. He would want to learn what have been effective in her treatment and would want STUDENT and her mother to tell him what they want out of the placement. Mr. Mertz stated that the move to Seneca is a big change for STUDENT and that the Seneca staff would need to take into account her concerns; they are not feelings to be minimized.

Under the District's proposal, STUDENT will not be moved suddenly, but will be made ready for the change through a carefully executed transition. Dr. DeRanieri testified that it is not unusual for patients to be moved from a particular treatment center for clinical, legal or financial reasons.

The District and Mental Health do not dispute that she will need to adjust to the placement change. STUDENT is not being moved into the community at large, but to a highly protected environment in which she will find support for her needs. When STUDENT no longer needs 24-hour residential treatment, Seneca can offer her gradually diminishing "wraparound" services to assist her to function, not solely in the artificial environment of a residential facility, but in an environment which prepares her for employment and independence in the city in which she lives.

The evidence shows that, in general, it is not unusual to change patients from one facility to another and that STUDENT can adjust to change, provided the receiving facility is appropriate for her needs. In addition, STUDENT has continuing needs which will require, in the near future, her integration into the adult mental health services of San Francisco, and her critical need for family therapy is severely limited due to the distance of her current placement from her family.

It is clear that STUDENT's move will be more successful if it is made through a carefully designed transition plan. The plan should be developed through the participation of those familiar with her current and future placement and should consider MOTHER's recommendations on how to help STUDENT view this change as a reflection of her success at KidsPeace. Based on concerns over STUDENT's tendency to overreact, as part of this plan, a psychotherapist must be designated to visit STUDENT once at KidsPeace and be available to her at Seneca during the transitional period. This will provide STUDENT someone with whom she can relate during the transition period. The therapist shall also be available to MOTHER to assist her with her role in the transition. The record also indicates that, with an effective transition plan, STUDENT's transfer to Seneca can take place within a month.

ORDER

1. Seneca San Francisco Community Alternatives program is an appropriate placement for STUDENT.

2. Within two weeks of the date of this decision, the IEP team, along with a Seneca staff person, shall meet and develop a transition plan which will address STUDENT's needs during and after her move to Seneca. The team will invite the participation of a representative of KidsPeace who is familiar with STUDENT's current condition. The plan will designate a specific therapist who will visit STUDENT once at KidsPeace and be available to her at Seneca during the transitional period. This designated therapist shall also be available to MOTHER to assist her with her role in the transition plan. The plan will provide that STUDENT be transferred to Seneca no later than one month from the date of this decision.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code §56505(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

Issue: Has the San Francisco Unified School District and San Francisco Community Mental Health offered STUDENT an appropriate placement consistent with the placement characteristics ordered in SN 476-98?

Petitioners prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code §56505(i).

Date: February 26, 1999 Marie Ward, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnotes 1) The alleged perpetrator was tried in juvenile court and found not guilty. 2) The Hearing Officer in SN 476-98 did not reach the issue of whether Seneca was a substantively appropriate placement because neither the District nor Mental Health had offered the placement in writing. 3) Respondent is not contesting the adequacy of the "educational part" of the Seneca program. 4) While the treatment plan at KidsPeace identifies that STUDENT will receive recreation, group and individual therapy on a weekly or twice weekly basis, the part of the treatment plan which should have indicated how often she should receive family therapy was not completed. (Respondent's Exhibit 1.) 5) The Hearing Officer determined that the Hearing Office does not have jurisdiction over Respondent's contention that Seneca is not licenced to admit STUDENT.