California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 5, 1999

Student v. Hacienda La Puente Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1550-98 · Hearing Officer Glenna Eubank deCamara

Hacienda La Puente Unified's expulsion of student with learning disability set aside; compensatory education ordered for lost semester.

Split decision: student prevailed on 2 of 3 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The decision notes that the student's appeal of the expulsion to the county board was stayed pending this due process decision. No remand, vacatur or correction is noted.

Summary

A 16-year-old student with a specific learning disability (visual and auditory processing deficits) attended a special day class at Workman High School in Hacienda La Puente Unified School District. In July 1998, while working on campus in a summer work program, he was accused of an attempted sexual assault. The District suspended him and mailed his guardians an assessment plan limited to academic and processing areas. When they refused consent, the District relied on a records review to find the conduct was not a manifestation of his disability. It offered one hour a day of home instruction, and the school board expelled him in September 1998. The student filed for due process, and the District's request to assess him was heard at the same time.

The Hearing Officer applied federal discipline law because state law excluded this type of offense from California's special procedures. She found the District never held an IEP meeting to develop a behavior assessment plan. Its records review also did not look at social-emotional areas or at any disability not yet identified. These violations denied a FAPE, so the expulsion was set aside. Any new expulsion process must include a proper behavior assessment, and the guardian must make the student available for it. One hour of daily home instruction also denied a FAPE. The Hearing Officer ordered an IEP meeting within two weeks to plan compensatory education for July 9, 1998 to January 5, 1999.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO read the 1997 IDEA discipline provisions. It required an IEP-developed assessment of the behavior before a manifestation determination, covering all suspected disabilities, not just known ones. It also held that one hour of daily home instruction could not provide a FAPE to a student who received all academics in a special day class.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedDiscipline

    Issue 1. Were appropriate expulsion procedures followed in the removal of Student from Workman High School in July 1998?

    Under 20 U.S.C. §1415(k), the District had to convene an IEP meeting to develop an assessment plan addressing the behavior. It did not, and its records review covered only known processing disabilities, not social-emotional areas or unidentified disabilities. These procedural violations denied a FAPE, and the expulsion was set aside.

  2. Issue 2. May the District conduct an assessment of Student over the objections of his guardians?

    The District may conduct a comprehensive assessment, including emotional and psychological testing by a knowledgeable assessor, but under §1415 as part of any reinstated expulsion proceedings, not under §1414 or state assessment law. The guardian must make Student available.

  3. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. Is Student entitled to compensatory education from the date of his expulsion to the present?

    One hour per day of home instruction, which was never delivered, could not provide a FAPE to a student who received all academics in a special day class, and Student was denied stay put. He is entitled to compensatory education from July 9, 1998 to January 5, 1999, to be set at an IEP meeting.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • The District's expulsion of Student is set aside. Student may return to his original placement if he and his guardian choose. The District may develop a plan to supervise Student and ensure no further misconduct.
  • Any later expulsion proceedings must include (a) an IEP meeting to develop an assessment plan addressing behaviors and conditions related to anger and sexual assault, (b) actually conducting the assessment, (c) considering the results at the manifestation determination review, and (d) compliance with all other federal suspension and expulsion safeguards.
  • Order that district may assess without consent. If the IEP team creates the assessment plan called for in Order 2, Student's guardian must make him available to the District for the assessment.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. The parties must convene an IEP meeting within two weeks of the decision to determine compensatory education for the loss of FAPE from July 9, 1998 to January 5, 1999.
  • Compensatory education. The compensatory education plan must cover (a) how the IEP goals in reading, written language, U.S. history and integrated science will be addressed, (b) criteria for measuring success, (c) a timeline that accounts for Student's learning style and capacity, and (d) the qualifications of the providers. It must be designed so Student earns the credits he would have earned during the lost semester. No hours were specified.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Hacienda La Puente Unified School District v. Honig; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23; Burke County Board of Education v. Denton; Roland M. v. Concord School Committee; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Todd v. Andrews; Moubry v. Independent School District No. 696; 20 U.S.C. §1415(k); Education Code §48915.6

People named in the decision

  • Robert Twitchell, coordinator of special education / pupil services, Hacienda La Puente Unified School District
  • Sam Flame, special education (SDC) teacher, Workman High School
  • Tom (Thomas) Herman, school psychologist, Hacienda La Puente Unified School District
  • Karen Usery, school psychologist, Hacienda La Puente Unified School District
  • Yvette Meneses, assistant principal of student services, Workman High School
  • Mid-Valley, nonpublic school, Nonpublic school placement offered by District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Glenna Eubank deCamara, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Hacienda Heights, California, on January 28 and 29, 1999.

Petitioner Student (hereinafter Petitioner or Student) was represented by attorney Thomas Beltran of the Law Office of Thomas Beltran and attorney Margaret S. Oppel of the Law Office of Margaret Oppel. Student was present throughout the hearing, as was his aunt and legal guardian, Ms. Guardian 1. Parent, Student’s mother, and Ms. Guardian 2, his grandmother, were present during portions of the hearing.

Respondent Hacienda La Puenta Unified School District (hereinafter District or Hacienda) was represented by attorneys Deborah Cesario and Bobbie Albanese of the law firm of Lozano, Smith, Smith, Woliver & Behrens. Also present on Respondent’s behalf was Robert Twitchell, coordinator of special education for the District.

The Petitioner did not call witnesses to testify.

Respondent called the following witnesses to testify: Ms. Guardian 1, Petitioner’s aunt; Ms. Guardian 2, Petitioner’s grandmother; Sam Flame, special education teacher at Workman High School; Tom Herman, school psychologist for Hacienda; Karen Usery, school psychologist for Hacienda; Yvette Meneses, assistant principal of student services at Workman High School; and Robert Twitchell, Hacienda’s coordinator of pupil services.

Oral and documentary evidence was received and closing arguments were presented at the conclusion of the Hearing. The issues were then submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

At the beginning of the hearing, Respondent objected to the addition of attorney Margaret Oppel as Petitioner’s co-counsel, claiming that it had not received the requisite ten-day notice of intent to be represented by counsel. The Hearing Officer overruled this objection, finding that a party was entitled to notice of the participation of an attorney for the opposing party, although notice of the specific identity of the attorney was not required. Respondent knew that Petitioner was represented by counsel and the addition of co-counsel did not negate that notice. Arguing that the Respondent was attempting to change the status quo, Petitioner brought a motion to shift the burden of going forward to the Respondent. The Hearing Officer granted this motion.

The Petitioner agreed that the District’s request for an assessment could be heard with his case. The facts upon which the District based its request were substantially similar to those supporting the issues identified by the Petitioner. The Hearing Officer concurred with the stipulation of the parties and agreed to address the Respondent’s proposed assessment within this decision.

Following discussion, the parties agreed to modify the issues to be presented at the Hearing to those enumerated below.

ISSUES

1. Were appropriate expulsion procedures followed in the removal of Student from Workman High School in July 1998?

2. May the District conduct an assessment of Student over the objections of his guardians?

3. Is Student entitled to compensatory education from the date of his expulsion to the present?

BACKGROUND FACTS

Student is a sixteen-year-old male who has been enrolled in special education since the third grade. Pursuant to a court order, he and his brothers have resided with their aunt since 1994. During the time frame relevant to this case, legal custody of Student was shared jointly by his aunt, Ms. Guardian1, and his grandmother, Ms. Guardian 2. (By the time of the hearing, Ms. Guardian 1 had exclusive guardianship.) Student’s identified handicapping condition is a specific learning disability caused by visual and auditory processing deficits. Student attended a special day class at Workman High School, within the Hacienda La Puenta School District, for the 1995-96 and 1996-97 school years.

During the summer between his tenth and eleventh grades, Student was accused of attempted sexual assault by his ex-girlfriend. The assault allegedly took place on July 9, 1998, in the boys’ soccer room at Workman High School (hereinafter Workman). Student was not enrolled as a student for the extended school year program. Rather, he was working on campus, assigned to maintenance through a school work program. Upon learning of the alleged incident, school personnel detained the alleged victim, Student, and two of their friends. They notified the police as well as Student’s guardians. The police arrived, questioned Student and later transported him to juvenile hall.

At the time of the occurrence, Student’s Individual Education Program (IEP) was one that had been implemented on May 20, 1998, following a three-year evaluation. His reading and spelling skills were in the mid-second-grade level. His writing ability was a mid-fourth-grade level and his math skills were a mid- fifth-grade level. The IEP team agreed that Student required placement in a special day class, with 39% of his school day in a regular education environment. Student’s goals in his special day class were to improve his reading and English skills ( grammar, comprehension, critical thinking, literary analysis and writing skills). He also was to increase his familiarity with U.S. history and his knowledge of integrated science. Student had a transition plan in place. He did not have a behavioral intervention plan.

Student is reported by everyone involved with him to be a very cooperative student who is hard working and respectful After the incident several of his teachers wrote letters of recommendation for him praising him as conscientious, honest, well-liked, courteous, and helpful. He is involved in sports and has acted as the basketball team manager. According to a letter from a deputy sheriff who has worked with Student for five years in his capacity as the director of the Sheriff Youth Activities Program, Student’s behavior has always been exemplary. He has twice served as a youth counselor for the Sheriff’s summer camps. He often acts as a peer group leader and he supervises younger children in the program. The Deputy reports that Student has always wanted to be a police officer and last summer he began participating in the California Highway Patrol’s Explorer Program. Although he had seen others from Student’s neighborhood and from the Sheriff’s program falter and become involved in substance abuse or criminal activities, Student had always “stayed on the straight and narrow.” Student’s psychologist, appointed through the juvenile dependency court, wrote that “as a professional who has known Student for years therapeutically, I do not believe he would commit the act of attempted rape. It’s not part of his personality.” Student’s prior disciplinary problems involved an incident with a janitor’s cart from which he was cleared of wrongdoing, two warnings to stay away from other students after disagreements with them, and fighting over a watch.

On July 9, 1998, Student was placed on a five-day suspension while the alleged assault was investigated by the District. On July 16, 1998, the District sent Student’s guardians, Ms. Guardian 1 and Ms. Guardian 2, an assessment plan proposing to assess Student in the areas of academic, intellectual and psychological processing abilities. Ms. Guardian 1 returned this document with a notation that stated “all charges was dismissed on 7-16-98 in (unintelligible) court 283. No, permission denied. Student’s therapist states Student don’t need to be tested.” Upon receipt of this refusal, the District’s psychologist, Thomas Herman, performed a record review in preparation for the manifestation determination IEP meeting. He reviewed the psychological report written for the May 1998 three-year evaluation, a health history, teacher reports, information from current teachers, the discipline file, and report cards. Mr. Herman believed that this review provided adequate information to determine any connection between Student’s behavior and his disability. On July 22, 1998, Mr. Herman issued a psychoeducational study concluding that the alleged attempted assault was not connected to Student’s visual and auditory processing disabilities. The District related the alleged act to the issue of anger management. However, it did not purpose to assess in this area. When reviewing the records, the District focused on whether anger was a manifestation of Student’s processing disabilities. Mr. Herman discovered that the psychologist who had conducted Student’s recent three-year evaluation had written that the Sentence Completion Test and a personal interview revealed that Student possessed a great deal of anger and was concerned about controlling it. After completing the record review, Mr. Herman did not find that Student exhibited an ongoing anger problem. He reported that Student’s IEP and placement were appropriate and that his special education services were provided in conformance with his IEP.

The preexpulsion IEP was held on July 23, 1998. The following individuals were in attendance: Mr. Herman, a school psychologist; Sam Flame, Student’s SDC teacher; Yvette Meneses, assistant principal at Workman; Ms. Guardian 1, Student’s aunt and co-guardian; and Ms. Guardian 2, Student’s grandmother and co-guardian. At the request of Ms. Guardian 1 and Ms. Guardian 2, the District also invited the attorney who had represented Student through the dismissal of the sexual assault charge. The attorney did not attend the IEP meeting. The IEP team reviewed Mr. Herman’s conclusion that the alleged conduct was not a manifestation of Student’s disability. The District recommended that Student be placed on home study, with a teacher provided one hour per day, five days per week. Ms. Guardian 1 and Ms. Guardian 2 signed the IEP document under the preprinted statement that they did not agree to the placement and services documented on the IEP. Mr. Herman then wrote that they “refuse placement for home instruction but Guardians agree with IEP findings (except for home instruction placement).” The District maintains that this means that Ms. Guardian 1 and Ms. Guardian 2 agreed that the assault was not related to Student’s disability. Ms. Guardian 1 and Ms. Guardian 2 state that they did not agree with any portion of the IEP. Since they did not believe that the assault occurred, they would not concur, or disagree, that it was connected to Student’s disability. They felt that asking them that question was asking them to admit the Student had committed the crime. Ms. Guardian 1 and Ms. Guardian 2 did agree that Student did not have an anger problem as they interpreted the word anger. They described their definition of anger as physically striking a person or object, which Student did not do.

Following the decision that the alleged conduct was not a manifestation of Student’s disability, the District conducted an expulsion hearing. The expulsion panel determined that Student had committed the attempted rape. On September 10, 1998, the Hacienda Board of Education expelled him from school. In December 1998, Petitioner filed a notice of appeal of the expulsion. The appeal is stayed pending resolution of the due process hearing. A request for “stay put” was not made and the District continued to offer home study placement for one hour per day. This home study was never implemented and there is some dispute as to why it never began. Ms. Guardian 1 felt that Student should be on a school campus, not at home. She looked for other districts that might accept Student and the District supplied his records to requesting districts. Ms. Guardian 1 was unable to arrange an interdistrict transfer for him. Ms. Guardian 1 worked during the day and Student had to stay with either Ms. Guardian 1’s brother or sister for supervision while she was gone. She requested that the home teacher go to the home of either of her siblings. The District could not accommodate this request because both the sister and the brother lived in other school districts. On December 17, 1998, Hacienda offered to place Student at Mid-Valley, a nonpublic school, and provide transportation. Ms. Guardian 1 did not agree with this proposed placement. She felt the school was primarily for severely emotionally disturbed children and not appropriate for her nephew. However, she was advised by the social worker that monitors Student’s dependency placement with her, that she had to return him to school. Fearing she might lose custody, Ms. Guardian 1 enrolled Student at Mid-Valley on January 5, 1999. Student continues to attend the nonpublic school pursuant to a stay-put order.

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner and his family adamantly maintain that he did not commit an attempted sexual assault. They also contend that procedural violations occurred during the expulsion process, particularly in the area of assessment. The Petitioner raises other contentions that are based upon state law. As set forth below, state law does not govern this case. Petitioner argues that his expulsion is invalid and must be set aside as a result of the procedural violations. The Petitioner further contends that he was not offered an appropriate placement following his expulsion and that he is therefore entitled to compensatory education.

Hacienda maintains that all procedures relating to expulsions were followed. It argues that it provided Petitioner’s guardians with their rights and that it was the Petitioner’s duty to file for a due process hearing if they disagreed with the actions of the District. Hacienda asserts that the Petitioner cannot wait until the entire expulsion process is complete and then seek to have it overturned. Hacienda claims that its assessment was properly conducted through a review of records after the Petitioner refused to consent to a new assessment. It further contends that although Petitioner’s guardians disagreed with the preexpulsion IEP placement, they concurred that the alleged attempted rape was not related to Petitioner’s disability. Upon agreement by the IEP team that the conduct was not a manifestation of the disability, Student was properly referred to the District’s expulsion panel. After the panel determined that Petitioner had committed the crime, it was within the authority of the school board to expel him. The District asserts that its offer of home placement with a teacher one hour per school day was appropriate.

FINDINGS OF FACTS AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE ONE

Were appropriate expulsion procedures followed in the removal of STUDENT from Workman High School in July 1998?

A. Applicable procedural law

Before procedural issues can be addressed, the Hearing Officer must first determine the statutory expulsion procedures that apply to the Petitioner’s circumstances. California does not extend its procedural safeguards to students expelled for attempted sexual assault. California Education Code §48915.6 provides:

The restrictions and special procedures provided in Section 48915.5 for the expulsion of a pupil with exceptional needs shall not apply when the pupil possessed a firearm, knife, explosive, or other dangerous object of no reasonable use to the pupil, or the pupil committed or attempted to commit a sexual assault or committed sexual battery, at school or at a school activity off school grounds, unless for these acts the restrictions and special procedures in Section 48915.5 are mandated under federal law, including Section 1415 of Title 20 of the United States Code.

The Petitioner is accused of an attempted sexual assault. The Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), Title 20 U.S.C. §1415(k) therefore controls this case and California’s procedural requirements are not applicable.

B. Requirements for an IEP and an assessment plan when a district suspends a student

Title 20 U.S.C. §1415 (k)(1)(A) enables school personnel to suspend a student with a disability for not more than ten school days for conduct violations or for not more than forty-five days for weapon or drug offenses. Section 1415 (k)(1)(B)(i) addresses the assessment required when a district exercises this authority to suspend, and thereby change the placement of a child with a disability who does not have a behavioral intervention plan.

Either before or not later than 10 days after taking a disciplinary action described in subparagraph (A)- (i) if the local educational agency did not conduct a functional behavioral assessment and implement a behavioral intervention plan for such child before the behavior that resulted in the suspension described in subparagraph (A), the agency shall convene an IEP meeting to develop an assessment plan to address that behavior . . . (Emphasis added).

The Hearing Officer recognizes that the law addressing the suspension of a special education child complicated and that the Department of Education has not issued regulations implementing the IDEA 1997. A review of §1415(k) results in several possible interpretations of the Congressional intent for an “assessment plan to address that behavior” when a child without a prior “functional behavioral assessment” faces suspension. One reading would find that §1415(k)(4) should be viewed in isolation and that the assessment described in §1415(k)(1)(B)(i) has no relationship to the manifestation determination review or any other subsections of §1415(k). Under this interpretation, only the children described in §1415(k)(1)(A)(i) and (ii), those suspended for less than ten days and those removed for less than forty-five days for drugs or weapons, would be entitled to a behavioral assessment. However, those children removed for more than ten days for other disciplinary reasons or those removed for more than forty-five days for weapons or drugs would not receive the protection of an assessment to analyze their misconduct. A second interpretation would be that §1415(k)(1) through (10) is a multistep process with each subsection a necessary building block connected to the other subsections. Under this interpretation, each subpart would be interrelated. An assessment addressing the behavior would be required prior to the manifestation determination IEP. This interpretation would provide assessment results that could assist in determining the connection between the conduct and the disability. It would also assist in developing an appropriate educational placement for the child and enable the provision of services to ensure that the behavior “does not recur.” In a third interpretation, it could be argued that all three categories of students to be removed for misbehavior (suspended for less than ten days, drugs or weapons, and suspended for more than ten days) are entitled to an assessment because §1415(k)(4)(i) grants “all procedural safeguards accorded under this section” to the student and his or her parents. An assessment to address the behavior precipitating the suspension is one of those safeguards contained in §1415.

The Hearing Officer finds it most reasonable that an interrelationship was intended within the statute. It would seem illogical that Congress intended to grant children suspended less than ten days the major procedural protection of an assessment, but not grant the same protection to students who faced expulsion or lengthy suspensions of more than ten days. This would result in a student who committed a relatively minor offense benefitting from a behavioral assessment, while a student who committed a more serious infraction would not be evaluated. The students who have serious behavior problems are those most in need of behavioral assessments and resulting services to address their behavior. Although the statute states only that an assessment plan must be developed, it is reasonable to conclude that an actual assessment is to be conducted. It would be meaningless to create an assessment plan and then not implement it. The assessment plan would not have been included in the statute if it had no purpose. A persuasive rationale is that the assessment plan is intended to result in an assessment that addresses the student’s behavior and provides a portion of the “evaluation and diagnostic results” that must be considered when conducting the review mandated by §1415(k)(4)(C) of any relationship between the student’s action and his or her disability.

Student did not have a behavioral intervention plan at the time of the alleged incident. Thus an assessment to address his behavior was needed. His initial suspension was for five days. He was then placed on home study and ultimately expelled from his high school. Under the first interpretation of §1415(k), the five-day suspension was a change in placement for less than ten days, which placed him in the category of students entitled to an assessment to address their behavior. The second possible meaning of the suspension statute also encompasses the Petitioner’s situation. If each subsection of §1415(k) is a prerequisite to the next, Student would be entitled to an assessment before his manifestation determination IEP meeting. If the third interpretation is used, the convening of a manifestation determination IEP meeting would trigger an entitlement to all of the procedural safeguards contained in §1415, which includes an assessment. Therefore, any of the above interpretations of §1415(k) required the District to convene an IEP meeting to develop an assessment plan and conduct an evaluation of Student’s alleged behavior. Hacienda did not do this. Rather than hold an IEP meeting to determine the necessary assessments, the District’s psychologist completed the proposed assessment plan and mailed it to Ms. Guardian1. When she did not consent to this assessment, the District proceeded with a records-review assessment. Thus, the District committed a procedural violation by failing to convene an IEP meeting to develop an assessment plan to address Student’s alleged behavior and to conduct the necessary assessment.

C. Assessment requirements

The assessment plan required by 20 U.S.C. §1415(k)(1)(B)(i) is not defined other than to state that it must “address that behavior” that resulted in the suspension. (Footnote 1) Although it is not specifically stated, it is reasonable to infer that the assessment could address the behavior only if it evaluates in all areas of disabilities which are known, suspected, or reasonably suggested by the conduct. The case of Hacienda La Puenta Unified School District v. Honig, 976 F.2d 487 (9th Cir.) applied this principal when holding that a pre-expulsion assessment must investigate all areas of disability. Only through this interpretation of the statute’s required assessment plan would the IEP team possess the requisite information to conduct its next required function, a second IEP meeting to conduct a review “of the relationship between the child’s disability and the behavior subject to the disciplinary action.” 20 U.S.C. §1415(k)(4)(A)(ii). In carrying out this review, the IEP team must consider the following as it relates to the behavior subject to the disciplinary action: (1) all relevant information, including evaluation and diagnostic results; (2) pertinent information supplied by the parents of the child; (3) observations of the child; and (4) the child’s IEP and placement. If, after reviewing the above information, the IEP team determines that the behavior of the child was not a manifestation of the child’s disability, it must next determine whether the IEP, placement and services were appropriate when the incident occurred and whether any behavior intervention strategies were provided in accordance with the child’s IEP. It must also find that the child had the ability to understand the consequences of his or her actions as well as to control them. 20 U.S.C. 1415(k)(1)(4)(C). It is logical, therefore, to conclude that the assessment plan and consequent assessment must provide adequate information for the IEP team to determine whether there was any nexus between the wrongful conduct and the child’s disability, whether the placement and services were appropriate at the time the acts occurred, and whether the child understood that the behavior was wrong and had consequences. The assessment must also generate sufficient information to enable the IEP team to decide upon an interim, alternative placement that is appropriate for the child’s current needs. 20 U.S.C. 1415(k)(1)(3). The above cited provisions of §1415 link the assessment and IEP deliberations to the behavior that resulted in the suspension. Logic dictates that this connection can only be analyzed following a comprehensive assessment that addresses whether the behavior is the result of a disability that is known, has escalated or was previously hidden.

Hacienda proposed reevaluating Student’s academic ability and his visual and auditory processing skills. It also intended to review his previous tests of intellectual and cognitive ability. When Ms. Guardian 1 would not consent to the assessment plan, the District preformed what it referred to as a “limited assessment,” which consisted of a review of Student’s triennial evaluations. Mr. Herman, the school psychologist, testified that his record review focused on Student’s known visual and auditory processing disabilities. The purpose of his records assessment was to determine whether the alleged assault was a manifestation of these identified disabilities. Mr. Herman confirmed that the assessment plan he sent to Ms. Guardian 1 recommended retesting in the areas of disability already identified in Student. It did not include a proposal to evaluate in the areas of social and emotional development or adaptive behavior, although these were the areas of testing that could reveal problems relating to a sexual assault.

According to Mr. Herman, assessment tools such as the Behavior Rating Scale and Draw a Person may have revealed information about the alleged aggressive behavior. He agreed that testing in the areas of social and emotional functioning should have been included in the pre-expulsion assessment plan and that they were inadvertently omitted. Had he actually conducted a new assessment, he would have liked a more extensive interview with Student’s guardians. He stated that “it would have been better to have a new assessment, but it was not necessary to make a manifestation determination finding.” He, and the other IEP members from the District, focused on Student’s visual and auditory processing disabilities and felt they had enough information to determine that these disabilities were not related to the alleged attempted assault.

All District members of the IEP team, as well as both of the school psychologists, testified that to their knowledge, Student had no prior difficulties with anger control. Ms. Usery, a District psychologist who wrote Student’s triennial psycho educational report, testified that this question was important to them because rape is an expression of anger. Mr. Herman acknowledged that he was concerned by a portion of Student’s May 1997 psychoeducational report which stated: “Student’s responses to a sentence completion suggested that he has a lot of anger and struggles to control his temper. He also mentioned difficulties with his girlfriend and experiences with racial tension.” Feeling that he should address these statements, Mr. Herman spoke with Student’s teachers and his guardians. They told him that Student did not exhibit anger management problems. He accepted their representations and determined that additional evaluation in this area was unnecessary. Ms. Usery testified that she did not believe that her findings the previous year were significant because Student was “working on his anger and he had resources to help him.” She had not recommended any services for Student in this area. The District did not conduct an adequate assessment to address the behavior that was the subject of the suspension as required by Federal law. Even had Student’s guardians consented to the District’s assessment plan as proposed, it did not include any evaluations to address behaviors that could be related to attempted sexual assault. Although Mr. Herman testified that it was an oversight to omit social and emotional testing, the assessment plan actually presented to Ms. Guardian 1 and Ms. Guardian 2 offered to test only in the areas of Student’s known disability. It is clear from the testimony of the District’s witnesses that they focused solely on whether the alleged crime was connected to a visual or auditory processing disability. They did not consider assessing to determine if a previously unidentified disability was related to the alleged attempted rape. Student’s disabilities may involve factors more complex than the processing disorders previously identified. The significant discrepancy between Student’s chronological age and his academic achievement may evidence decreased cognitive abilities which include a diminished ability to accurately interpret situations and social cues. This could have affected his behavior with his ex-girlfriend. Because the District’s “limited assessment” was merely a review of the previous three-year evaluation, it was not designed to specifically investigate whether the behavior of attempted assault was related to a disability. Consequently, it did not contribute to a meaningful review of “the relationship between the child’s disability and the behavior subject to the disciplinary action.” The District’s failure to explore all of Student’s possible areas of disability as they relate to sexual assault, resulted in another procedural violation.

D. The Petitioner’s obligation to institute due process proceedings prior to the conclusion of the expulsion proceeding.

The District asserts that the Petitioner cannot wait until the entire expulsion procedure is complete to contest it. It claims that the expulsion was accomplished through legitimate proceedings to which the Petitioner did not object. Hacienda argues that it was incumbent upon the guardians to institute a timely due process hearing if they did not agree with the District’s actions during the expulsion process. By failing to do so, their conduct was a tacit agreement with the decisions of the District. Hacienda points out that Student’s guardians were provided with their procedural rights, yet they did not use the “self-help measures” available to them. The District contends that the Petitioner’s inaction evidences an informed decision to forego their right to contest the expulsion process and that it cannot be held responsible for the Petitioner’s delay.

Hacienda makes what appears to be a “waiver” and a “latches” argument. The Hearing Officer is unaware of any authority to support the proposition that equitable principles apply to the timing of the filing of a due process claim. California Education Code §56505(p) specifically applies a three-year statute of limitations to requests for due process. The Hearing Officer does not agree that the Petitioner waived his right to file for a due process hearing by waiting until the expulsion had occurred. Conceivably, Student could have been exonerated in the expulsion hearing and returned to his high school program, thereby negating his need to request a due process hearing. Section 1415(k)(6)(A)(i)(ii) states that “if the child’s [guardian] disagrees with a determination that the child’s behavior was not a manifestation of the child’s disability or with any decision regarding placement, the [guardian] may request a hearing.” This section further states that an expedited hearing must be arranged “when requested by the parent.”(Emphasis added) The parent is not mandated to request an expedited hearing. No time limit is specifically imposed by §1415(k)(6) upon the Petitioner’s right to appeal a school district’s decision that the child’s behavior is not related to the disability or to disagree with the placement offered. The Hearing Officer disagrees with the Respondent’s contention that the Petitioner’s case is untimely because he “slept on his rights.” The Petitioner did not lose his entitlement to file for a due process hearing by waiting until after the expulsion occurred to institute his claim.

The Petitioner claims that it was the District’s duty to file for due process when he would not agree to the proposed assessment plan and that the District could not proceed to assess without his consent or an order from the hearing office. The parties are confusing state procedural requirements with the procedures applicable under §1415. U.S.C.§1415(k)(1)(B)(i) requires an IEP meeting to develop an assessment plan. However, it does not state that the parent or guardian must consent to the assessment before it can be conducted. The District did not need the consent of Ms. Guardian 1 or Ms. Guardian 2 to assess Student. Their failure to do so constitutes another procedural violation.

The procedural rights of disabled children and their parents are closely guarded by Congress and the courts. The IDEA mandates the establishment, by educational agencies, of procedural safeguards “to ensure that children with disabilities and their parents are guaranteed procedural safeguards with respect to the provision of free appropriate public education by such agencies.” 20 U.S.C. §1415(a) The landmark United States Supreme Court decision in Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175 (1982) addressed the importance of compliance with the procedures contained in the IDEA. The court held “that Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation at every stage of the administrative process, as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP against a substantive standard.” However, not every procedural flaw results in the denial of a free and appropriate education (FAPE). Such violations must cost the child educational opportunity or prevent his or her parents from meaningful participation in the IEP process. Burke County Board of Education v. Denton, 895 F.2d 973 (4th Cir. 1990); Roland M. v. Concord School Commission, 910 F.2d 982 (lst Cir. 1990); W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No.23, 960 F.2d 1479 (9th Cir. 1992).

Hacienda committed multiple procedural violations in the expulsion proceedings that deprived Student of educational benefit. It did not convene an IEP meeting to create an assessment plan. It did not propose an assessment plan to address the behavior that resulted in the suspension and expulsion as mandated by §1415(k)(B)(i). The records review it did conduct was inadequate because it concentrated on the results of prior evaluations and did not consider the newly alleged behavior. As a result, the District lacked sufficient information to preform its obligation to determine the relationship, if any, between the conduct and the disability. The evidence in this case supports a finding that the District committed multiple procedural violations in the expulsion process that rise to the level of denying Student a FAPE. Thus, the expulsion must be set aside. Voiding the expulsion entitles Student to return to his original placement if Student and his guardian so desire. Although Student is legally entitled to return to Workman, the Hearing Officer recognizes that the school district found that he committed a sexual assault. It has expressed concerns about his ability to be safely returned to his prior campus. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District is entitled to develop a plan that effectively supervises Student and ensures that no further misconduct occurs.

ISSUE TWO

MAY THE DISTRICT CONDUCT AN ASSESSMENT OF STUDENT

OVER THE OBJECTIONS OF HIS GUARDIANS?

Hacienda states that the gravity of Student’s behavior necessitates a thorough assessment to determine whether it is safe to allow him to again attend Workman High School. In articulating its need to perform an assessment of Student, the District made a persuasive argument which contained the reasons that it should have conducted an appropriate assessment before the manifestation determination IEP meeting. Ms. Usery testified that such an assessment was obligatory to ensure that he had learned ways to handle his anger and that he was safe to be on the campus again. (Footnote 2) Mr. Herman testified that the seriousness of Student’s action required a complete assessment before he could return to school. He stated that this evaluation should consist of an extensive interview with Student, a psychiatric examination and psychological testing. Student would also need to be in counseling and have a support system in place.

The District did not specify the statutory basis for its request to assess Student. It appears to be requesting a “post expulsion” evaluation to determine if it is safe to return Student to his high school campus. Arguably this would be authorized by Title 20 U.S.C. §1414(a)(2)(A) which states that an educational agency may assess “if conditions warrant a reevaluation.” The Hearing Officer agrees that the District should conduct a comprehensive assessment that addresses all reasonably suspected conditions that may have contributed to Student’s alleged behavior. However, the evaluation should not be conducted pursuant to §1414 or California’s assessment statutes. Instead the District may conduct an assessment in accordance with §1415 to address the behavior that led to Student’s expulsion when it reinstates its expulsion proceedings. This assessment must include emotional and psychological testing as well as any other examinations suggested by the alleged act of attempted rape. The assessment should be conducted by someone knowledgeable in these areas. Both Ms. Usery and Mr. Herman, the school psychologists, testified that they have had very little experience with this type of assessment.

ISSUE THREE

IS THE STUDENT ENTITLED TO COMPENSATORY EDUCATION

FROM THE DATE OF HIS EXPULSION TO THE PRESENT?

Courts have consistently held that the authority to award compensatory education is derived from 20 U.S.C. §1415(i)(2)(B)(iii), which authorizes the court to grant such “relief as it determines is appropriate.” Equitable considerations are appropriate when fashioning remedies. An application of equitable principles requires that the actions of the parties themselves must be considered when evaluating the circumstances surrounding the child’s lost educational opportunity and in creating an adequate remedy. Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489 (9th Cir.1994). Compensatory education may be an appropriate equitable remedy when the responsible educational authority has failed to provide a disabled child with an appropriate education as required by the IDEA. Todd v. Andrews, 933 F.2d 1576 (11th Cir, 1991). “The purpose of compensatory education is to replace lost educational services.” Moubry v. Independent School District Number 696, 951 F. Supp. 867 (8th Cir.1996) There is, however, no obligation to compensate the child by providing a day of education for each educational day lost. “Compensatory education in not a contractual remedy, but an equitable remedy, part of the Court’s resources in crafting appropriate relief . . . [A]ppropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Student W. V. Puyallup, (supra). Thus, when considering a request for compensatory education, it is first necessary to determine whether a school district failed to provide a FAPE. If that issue is answered in the affirmative, the subsequent question is not what precise services were missed, but rather, what compensatory services are necessary to provide an appropriate education under the law.

At the time Student was suspended, his IEP required that he receive the majority of his education in a self-contained special day class (SDC). All of his academics, consisting of reading, writing, U.S. history and science, were provided by his SDC teacher. As Student’s reading and writing skills are at a second- to fourth-grade level, his eleventh-grade curriculum required modifications. Thirty-nine percent of his school day was spent in regular education. Mainstreaming occurred primarily at lunch and during physical education. Student was very involved in high school sports. He did not have a behavior modification plan and there were no social-emotional goals in his IEP.

When Student was initially suspended, the District placed him on home study over his guardian’s objections. Following the determination that Student’s conduct was not related to his disability, a new IEP was drafted which actually changed his placement to home study with a teacher one hour per day. Ms. Guardian 1 and Ms. Guardian 2 continued to disagree with this placement. At that point, there was no agreed-upon change in placement and Student was entitled to, but did not receive, “stay-put.” Title 20 U.S.C. §1415 (j). Instead, the District continued to offer the one hour per day of home instruction and refused to allow Student to return to his prior placement at Workman High School. This remained the District’s position throughout Student’s suspension and subsequent expulsion until December 1998, when it offered a nonpublic school placement.

For a variety of reasons, the one hour of tutoring never occurred. However, even had it been provided, it would have been inadequate. A child whose needs are so great that he receives all of his academics in a self-contained special day class cannot receive an appropriate education in conformance with his IEP through one hour per day of home instruction. This would require him to teach, motivate and focus himself for the remainder of his school day. Student has serious deficiencies in auditory and visual processing. He cannot simply be provided work assignments and then left to decipher them himself. His disabilities require specific learning strategies to assist him in circumventing his processing difficulties. This must be provided by a trained educator who is available throughout his school day for him to benefit from his education. In addition, Student’s IEP provided for integration with the general education population 39% of his school day. The home study proposed by the District rendered him completely isolated from all peers during the school day. It was noted on the expulsion IEP that “the team agreed that they have not observed any anger control problems with Student.” In contrast, Hacienda requests an evaluation, in part, to assure itself that Student has his anger under control. If, in fact, the District believed that Student had committed the serious offense alleged and that anger contributed to its occurrence, psychological services were indicated. For the above reasons, Hacienda did not provide Student with a FAPE, either when he was initially suspended or following his expulsion.

On December 17, 1998, the District offered to place Student in a nonpublic school and he enrolled there on January 5, 1999. There was little evidence presented that would allow the Hearing Officer to determine whether the nonpublic school was an appropriate placement. Mr. Twitchell, the District’s special education coordinator, did testify that the nonpublic school was appropriate for Student’s disability and that the District had placed other students in the school. Because this limited evidence was not contested by the Petitioner, it is determined that Student is appropriately placed in his current nonpublic school during “stay-put.” The Hearing Officer finds that Student is entitled to compensatory education from the date of his removal from Workman High School on July 9, 1998 through his first attendance day at the nonpublic school on January 5, 1999.

Although the Petitioner is seeking compensatory education, he did not specify the type or duration of educational services he requests. Thus, the Hearing Officer has no specific evidence of the compensatory relief sought. Therefore the parties must convene an IEP meeting to specifically detail the additional educational services that will compensate Student for the semester of education he lost. The compensatory education plan must specifically enumerate the ways in which Student’s IEP goals to improve his reading and language skills and enhance his knowledge of U.S. history and science will be accomplished. It must provide methods of measuring Student’s compliance with his goals, as well as identify the qualifications of the individual(s) who will provide the compensatory education. It must also be calculated to ensure that Student will acquire all of the high school course credits that he would have obtained had he not been placed on home study for a semester. He can be compensated for the semester he lost through a longer extended school year program, after-school tutoring or any other times that take Student’s learning methods and pace into consideration. Student’s capacity to benefit from compensatory services while he is also performing his regular school requirements may mean that it will take longer than one semester to provide him with the compensatory education. Therefore, the compensatory education plan must also include a time line for provision of the services.

CONCLUSION

Procedural rights are as important as substantive ones when their omission results in the denial of a FAPE. As identified herein, Student was not granted the procedural protections to which he was entitled under federal law. Specifically, an effective assessment to investigate the source of the alleged misconduct was not conducted. Consequently, he was expelled without adequate information. These procedural violations were significant and resulted in a denial of a FAPE. For that reason, the expulsion is set aside and Student is entitled to return to Workman. The District’s expulsion procedure must be conducted again in accordance with this decision. If the District reinstates the expulsion proceedings, it must conduct an assessment to address the behavior that led to the expulsion and the guardian must make Student available for that testing. The District must also provide appropriate compensatory education to remedy the loss of the one semester during which a FAPE was not provided.

ORDER

1. The District’s expulsion of Student is set aside. Student is entitled to return to his original placement if he and his guardian so choose.

2. Any subsequent expulsion proceedings must include: (a) an IEP to develop an assessment plan to address the behaviors and conditions related to anger and sexual assault; (b) actually conducting the assessment; (c) the consideration of assessment results at the manifestation determination review; and (d) the compliance by the District with all other federal procedural safeguards pertaining to suspensions and/or expulsions.

3. If the IEP team creates the assessment plan called for in order two, Student’s guardian must make him available to the District for that assessment.

4. The parties shall convene an IEP within two weeks of the date of this decision to determine the appropriate compensatory education to offset the loss of a FAPE from July 9, 1998 to January 5, 1999.

5. The compensatory education plan shall focus on: (a) the specific manner in which Student’s IEP goals to improve his reading and written language skills and increase his knowledge of U.S. history and integrated science will be addressed; (b) the criteria for determining Student’s success in achieving his compensatory education goals; (c) a time-line setting forth the schedule for providing the compensatory education which takes into account Student’s learning style and capacity; and (d) a description of the qualifications of the person(s) who will provide the compensatory education.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code §56507(d), this decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement: The Petitioner prevailed on the issues of procedural violations and compensatory education.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code §56505(i).

Dated:_________________________ _________________________________________ GLENNA EUBANK deCAMARA, Hearing Officer, Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law

Footnotes: 1. Although the IDEA does define the term "evaluation" in 1414, a definition for the term "assessment" is not provided. California's definition for "assessment" is not relevant because California procedures do not apply to this case. 2. The District acknowledged Student's problem with anger during its three-year evaluation, but determined that it was not a problem that required services. When considering the relationship between the alleged behavior and Student's disabilities, it again found that anger was not an issue. It now maintains that it must be assured that he has learned to manage his anger before he can return to Workman High School.