California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 28, 2004

Alhambra City Elementary School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 16-04, SN-16-04 · Hearing Officer Claudia J. Wrazel

Hearing Officer finds Alhambra City Elementary's Encinitas special day class offer provided FAPE in the least restrictive environment.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

Footnote 1: parties agreed the issue was not moot even though the 2003-2004 school year and ESY had ended, because the decision would guide placement for 2004-2005. A prior case (SN03-00084) on stay put was resolved by settlement on April 29, 2003.

Summary

Alhambra City Elementary School District filed for a hearing to confirm that its June 2003 IEP offer was appropriate. The student was seven years old and eligible for special education as "severely mentally retarded," the term then used for an intellectual disability. He had profound developmental delays and functioned mostly at a three-to-nine-month level. He attended a full inclusion preschool at Almansor Center, a nonpublic school, with a one-to-one aide. The District offered a special day class (SDC) for students with moderate to severe disabilities at Encinitas School, run by the Los Angeles County Office of Education. It also offered adapted physical education, vision, occupational therapy and orthopedic consultation, and transportation. The parents accepted the services. They wanted general education at Repetto, their neighborhood school, or a split day between a Repetto speech-language SDC and general education. Their expert, Dr. Joanne Singer, called the goals "isolated" and criticized the Encinitas teacher. The Hearing Officer found her critique less credible because it rested on one morning's visit. She credited teacher Ceferina Martinec and the District's witnesses. She held that the program met the student's unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit under Rowley. Applying the four Holland factors, she found that Encinitas offered much greater educational benefit. She also found that inclusion would bring minimal nonacademic benefit at his current stage and that his needs would significantly disrupt a Repetto class. The District prevailed.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied the four Holland factors to a student with severe disabilities whose parents wanted full inclusion. The Hearing Officer weighed the student's developmental level, classroom safety, and the effect on other students. She discounted an expert opinion that rested on one brief classroom observation.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue 1. Is the District's proposed program and placement at Encinitas School designed to meet Student's unique needs?

    The developmental approach, IEP goals, and Encinitas SDC were designed to meet the student's unique needs; the expert's critique of 'isolated' goals and of the teacher was not credible.

  2. Issue 2. Is the District's program reasonably calculated to provide Student with some educational benefit?

    The SDC program, with a high staff ratio, experienced teacher, safe sensory environment, and related services, was reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit under Rowley.

  3. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 3. Would the Encinitas placement provide the least restrictive environment to Student?

    Under the Holland factors, the Encinitas SDC was the LRE; general education or a speech-language SDC at the neighborhood school would give less benefit, minimal nonacademic benefit, and would disrupt the class.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order that district's offer may be implemented. Hearing Officer found the District's proposed placement in the Encinitas SDC was an offer of FAPE in the LRE for the 2003-2004 school year and ESY.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H. (Holland); Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.

People named in the decision

  • Frances Stearns, coordinator of special education, Alhambra City Elementary School District
  • Laurel Bear, director of pupil services, Alhambra City Elementary School District
  • Celeste Young, Mandarin Chinese speaker present for District, Alhambra City Elementary School District
  • Maureen Fong, Mandarin Chinese speaker present for Student
  • Nancy Reynolds, director of early education, nonpublic school preschool, Almansor Center
  • Diane Cullinane, M.D., developmental pediatrician, assessor, Referred by District
  • Meg Tan, principal, Lincoln Principal Administration Unit, Los Angeles County Office of Education
  • Hannah Park, occupational therapist, West San Gabriel Valley SELPA
  • Rachel Falls, school psychologist, Alhambra City Elementary School District
  • Carolyn Pearson, orthopedically handicapped specialist, Alhambra City Elementary School District
  • Mona Neter, inclusion specialist, Alhambra City Elementary School District
  • Tina Lee, speech and language pathologist, Alhambra City Elementary School District
  • Mark Jia, director, regional center (witness for Student), East Los Angeles Regional Center
  • Joanne Singer, Ph.D., educational consultant, expert witness for Student
  • Ceferina (Rina) Martinec, special education teacher, Encinitas SDC, Encinitas School (Los Angeles County Office of Education)
  • Jill Thomas, special education teacher, speech-language SDC, Repetto School

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Claudia J. Wrazel, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Alhambra, California, on June 15-18, June 22, and July 13, 2004.

Petitioner Alhambra City Elementary School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorneys Angela Gordon, Bobbie Albanese, Wes Parsons, and Cyndi Dalton. Also present for the District were Frances Stearns, coordinator of special education; Laurel Bear, director of pupil services; and Celeste Young, a Mandarin Chinese speaker. Respondent STUDENT (STUDENT) was represented by attorneys Matthew Pope and Irma Wagster. Also present for STUDENT were his mother, MOTHER; his father, FATHER; and Maureen Fong, a Mandarin Chinese speaker. The hearing was translated into Mandarin Chinese by a certified Chinese interpreter.

The District called the following witnesses: MOTHER; Nancy Reynolds, director of early education at Almansor Center preschool, where STUDENT currently is placed; Diane Cullinane, M.D., developmental pediatrician; Meg Tan, principal of the Lincoln Principal Administration Unit (PAU), a Los Angeles County program serving severely disabled students; and Hannah Park, occupational therapist for the West San Gabriel Valley Special Education Local Planning Area (SELPA). The District also called the following District employees as witnesses: Frances Stearns; Rachel Falls, school psychologist; Carolyn Pearson, specialist for the orthopedically handicapped; Mona Neter, inclusion specialist; and Tina Lee, speech and language pathologist.

STUDENT called the following witnesses: MOTHER; FATHER; Mark Jia, director of the East Los Angeles Regional Center; and Joanne Singer, Ph.D., educational consultant.

The Hearing Officer called the following witnesses: Ceferina Martinec, special education teacher at Encinitas School, and Jill Thomas, special education teacher at Repetto School. Oral and documentary evidence was received. After the receipt of oral closing arguments, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUE PRESENTED FOR HEARING

Is a special day class (SDC) at Encinitas School the appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year (ESY)? (Footnote 1)

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a seven-year-old boy with a chromosome 15 abnormality resulting in profound developmental delays in all areas. He also has been diagnosed with microcephaly (small head and brain), cerebral dysgenesis (incomplete brain formation), cerebral palsy, and optic nerve lesion (deformed nerve from eyes to brain), and has several food allergies. (Testimony of Dr. Cullinane; see Dist. Exs. 6 [Cullinane report], 15 [November 2003 addendum to IEP].) STUDENT qualifies for special education as severely mentally retarded and currently receives special education services, with the assistance of a one-to-one aide, in a full inclusion preschool class at Almansor Center, a nonpublic school. (Footnote 2)

STUDENT was found eligible for special education services in April of 2000, when he was three years old. He attended a special education preschool at Lincoln School in 2000, but his mother believed he was regressing and withdrew him after several months. (Footnote 3) STUDENT received home school services from April to October 2001, when he was placed in a full inclusion Head Start preschool. (Testimony of MOTHER.)

STUDENT attended Head Start until he “aged out” of the program in June 2002. The parties failed to agree on a new placement, and STUDENT’s parents filed for a due process hearing in January of 2003, seeking an order declaring the full inclusion kindergarten class at Repetto School to be the stay put placement. (Footnote 4)On February 10, 2003, the Hearing Office issued an order indicating that for purposes of stay put, STUDENT would require a placement analogous to the Head Start preschool – that is, another full inclusion preschool. As a result of that order, the District placed STUDENT in the full inclusion preschool at Almansor Center in February 2003. (Testimony of Frances Stearns.)

The parties settled the placement dispute raised in SN03-00084 in an agreement dated April 29, 2003. (Dist. Ex. 3.) The agreement provided that (1) STUDENT would remain at the Almansor preschool through June 20, 2003; (2) the District would perform specified assessments of STUDENT prior to that date; and (3) the parties would convene an IEP meeting on or before June 20 to review the assessments and plan STUDENT’s educational program for the 2003 ESY and the 2003-2004 school year. (Footnote 5)

At an IEP meeting on June 10, 2003, after a discussion of the assessments performed pursuant to the settlement agreement, the District offered to place STUDENT in a full-day SDC for students with moderate to severe disabilities at Encinitas School, a general education campus operated by the Los Angeles County Office of Education (LACOE) and located about five miles from STUDENT’s residence. (Testimony of Ms. Stearns.) The District also offered designated instruction and services (DIS) consisting of adapted physical education (APE) twice a week for 30 minutes, vision consultation once a month for 60 minutes, and transportation. In an addendum to the IEP dated July 2, 2003, the District also offered occupational therapy (OT) consultation once a month for 50 minutes. (Dist. Ex. 12.) In a second addendum dated November 6, 2003, the District offered orthopedic handicap (OH) services once a month for 60 minutes. (Dist. Ex.15.)

STUDENT’s parents agreed with the offered services, but declined to accept the proposed placement at Encinitas. On January 5, 2004, the District filed a request for a due process hearing, seeking a determination that it had offered a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year and ESY. In the meantime, the District has maintained STUDENT in his current placement at the Almansor Center preschool.

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The District contends that the Encinitas SDC will provide STUDENT with a safe and stimulating environment appropriate to his developmental level, and with instruction in the basic functional skills he will need to achieve some measure of independence and to prepare for academic instruction in the future.

STUDENT does not object to the District’s offered services, but disagrees with the proposed educational program on the grounds that it was developed with undue emphasis on STUDENT’s deficits, and that its goals and objectives are presented “in isolation” instead of in the context of a meaningful curriculum. Further, STUDENT asserts that the District’s proposed placement at the Encinitas SDC is inappropriate because its curriculum is inadequate, its teacher does not interact well with nonverbal students, and its approach to educating severely disabled students is to “warehouse” them instead of offering them a stimulating learning environment. Finally, STUDENT asserts that even if the Encinitas SDC were an appropriate educational setting, it would not constitute the least restrictive environment (LRE). STUDENT contends that his needs would best be met at his neighborhood school, Repetto, where he could become established in a supportive neighborhood community as he grows to adulthood. STUDENT asserts that his needs could be met in a program in which he spends part of the day working on functional skills in a Repetto SDC for speech and language-impaired students, and the remainder of the day interacting with typically developing peers in a general education kindergarten or first grade class.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE: Is the SDC at Encinitas School the appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year and ESY?

Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25). The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). (Footnote 6)

The United States Supreme Court has determined that the instruction and services provided to a student with disabilities must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. Board of Ed.of Hudson Cent. School Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200. According to Rowley, school districts are not required to provide special education students with the best education available, or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. Rather, school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201.

Special education law also requires that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE), and that his removal from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and the severity of his disabilities are such that education in regular education classes with use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.

In this case, STUDENT objects to the standards by which the District’s proposed program was developed, the context in which its goals and objectives are set forth, and the adequacy of the curriculum and the teacher at the Encinitas SDC, the District’s proposed placement. (Footnote 7) Further, STUDENT asserts that the proposed placement at Encinitas does not constitute the least restrictive environment.

A determination of the appropriateness of the District’s proposed program first requires an analysis in light of the requirements of Rowley. If the program is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs, and is reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, the District has offered a FAPE, even if his parents prefer another program, and even if the preferred program would have resulted in greater educational benefit. (Footnote 8) See Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If the District has offered a FAPE, its proposed program must then be reviewed to determine if it is the least restrictive environment.

Accordingly, a substantively appropriate program and placement for STUDENT must (1) be designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs; (2) be reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit; and (3) be provided in the least restrictive environment. Each of these requirements is addressed below.

1. Is the District’s proposed program and placement at Encinitas School designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?

To determine whether this first requirement has been met, it is necessary to understand STUDENT’s present levels of functioning and the unique needs resulting from his present abilities.

A. STUDENT’s present levels of functioning

STUDENT’s most recent assessments, performed between May and November of 2003, indicate that he currently functions at the following levels:

Cognition – three-to-nine month level. (Footnote 9) In May of 2003, the District undertook a pre-academic readiness assessment of STUDENT that consisted of observation, record review, interviews with STUDENT’s mother and preschool teacher at Almansor, and administration of the Hawaii Developmental Chart and Developmental Profile II. According to the assessment report, STUDENT’s cognition skills fell within the range of a three-to-four month old infant. The report noted that STUDENT enjoys exploring the facial features of others at close range, learns about objects by putting them in his mouth, and likes to listen to music. (Dist. Ex. 4.)

The District also referred STUDENT for a developmental assessment by Dr. Cullinane, a developmental pediatrician. In May and June of 2003, Dr. Cullinane interacted directly with STUDENT, observed him at school, reviewed his records, and interviewed his mother about his development. According to Dr. Cullinane’s report and testimony, STUDENT’s cognitive development at the time of the assessment was within the three-to-nine month range, based on a comparison of his skills to normally developing children with the same skill level. (Dist. Ex. 6.) Dr. Cullinane testified that individuals with STUDENT’s level of severe mental retardation eventually may obtain the skill level of a child of kindergarten age.

Speech/language – zero-to-twelve month level. A speech assessment was conducted in June of 2003, consisting of observations, interviews, and attempted administration of the Rossetti Infant-Toddler Language Scale. (Dist. Ex. 10.) (Footnote 10) According to the assessment report, STUDENT demonstrates “severe delays” in receptive and expressive language, with most skills falling in the zero-to-three month developmental range, and scattered skills up through the nine-to-twelve month range. STUDENT smiles in response to greetings, and communicates his wants and needs by making “umm” sounds or by tugging on his mother’s clothing. He responds to hearing his own name and family members’ names, and can vocalize to get attention. According to his mother, STUDENT can say “mama” and “papa,” but otherwise is nonverbal. (Footnote 11)Other assessments noted that STUDENT is noncompliant with verbal directions. (Dist. Ex. 7 [Adapted Physical Education Assessment, 6/9/03]; Dist Ex. 13 [Physical Therapy Evaluation, 7/21/03].)

Vision – no age range given. The District vision specialist reported that STUDENT has lesions on the pathways between his eyes and his brain that impair his vision and affect how his brain processes what he sees. (Dist. Exs. 9, 15.) STUDENT also is nearsighted, but wears glasses that improve his vision to 20/400. (Footnote 12) STUDENT can make sustained eye contact, and likes to study faces within his close range of vision (three to four feet), but is not yet able to visually “track” a moving object. (Id.; Dist. Ex. 5.) The vision specialist reported that STUDENT’s interest in faces and his inability to track objects correlate with the perceptual development of an infant.

Gross motor skills – five-to-eight month level (with recent improvement). According to assessment reports dated May and November of 2003, STUDENT needed the assistance of a strap to sit up in a chair and to propel his walker, and his gross motor skills were within the five-to-eight month range. Witnesses who have observed him more recently, however, agree that STUDENT has gained back and leg strength since he was last assessed and no longer needs the strap to support him in the chair or the walker. When STUDENT is helped to sit up, he can stay seated by himself without assistance, but he has balance problems when standing and wears a helmet for safety when he is outdoors. He can walk with assistance or with a walker and can propel himself around the playground in his walker for long periods without tiring. However, he cannot control his direction and must be repositioned by an aide when his walker hits a wall or other obstacle. (Dist Exs. 4, 6, 15; testimony of MOTHER.)

Fine motor skills – zero-to-one month level. According to the May 2003 assessment report, STUDENT can grasp and hold some objects for a few seconds, often while putting them in his mouth. (Dist. Ex. 4.) MOTHER testified that he can hold some objects, like a rattle, for several minutes, and can bat with his open hand at the light switch on the wall. STUDENT’s preschool teacher reported that he must be totally “motored” through all activities at school, with an aide guiding his hands through all motions. (Dist. Ex. 15.)

Self-help skills – two-to-three month level. STUDENT eats pureed foods and has difficulty swallowing. He will open his mouth to receive a spoon or a drink from a cup, but does not close his mouth around the spoon or control the drink from the cup. He drools frequently. STUDENT is fed by an aide at school and by his mother at home, who reports that STUDENT can put his hand on the spoon but cannot yet move it to his mouth without assistance. STUDENT can hold his arms out to assist others in dressing him. His mother is training him to use the toilet at home, but he wears diapers at school and on other trips out of the house. (Dist. Exs. 4, 10; testimony of MOTHER.)

Social skills – four-to-seven month level. STUDENT is very pleasant and sociable, and enjoys the attention of adults who directly engage him face-to-face within a close range of vision. He shows little interest in communicating with other children at this time, and often does not appear to notice the other children either in his classroom or on the playground. (Dist. Exs. 9, 10, 14.) MOTHER testified that STUDENT plays with his five-year-old brother by allowing his brother to push him around in a toy car and by watching television with him. STUDENT does not play directly with his brother, but will try to pull a toy back if his brother takes it away from him. (Testimony of MOTHER.)

At the hearing, witnesses for STUDENT testified to somewhat more advanced skills than those described in the assessments. For example, MOTHER testified that STUDENT can follow certain one-word commands, such as “eat” and “stop,” and is learning from her efforts to toilet train him and to teach him to hold a spoon. FATHER testified that STUDENT’s balance and muscle strength have improved and that he needs less support when standing or walking. Mark Jia, director of the East Los Angeles Regional Center, testified that he has visited STUDENT many times over the last six months and that he has noticed recently that STUDENT walks faster in his walker, eats faster and with less difficulty swallowing, and will now turn his head and smile at Mr. Jia when greeted by him.

Aside from these reports of recent improvements, STUDENT does not dispute the accuracy of the above-referenced assessments. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT currently functions at the level of a three-to-nine-month-old infant in most areas of development, with scattered skills falling outside that range, and with observable recent improvements in the areas noted above.

B. STUDENT’s unique needs

Frances Stearns, coordinator of special education for the District, testified that STUDENT’s present levels of functioning indicate that his primary needs are “pre-academic.” She asserted that STUDENT needs to develop basic functional skills to maximize his independence and to give him the tools he will need to learn academic skills in the future. According to Ms. Stearns, children learn best when approached at their level of functioning and STUDENT is still at a level where he needs to “learn how to learn.”

Ms. Stearns stated that children with developmental delays need to be taught consciously what typically developing children learn incidentally. For STUDENT, a functional skills program would focus on improving mobility (through development of muscle strength and balance), communication skills (through learning to point and vocalize), independence (through training in self-feeding and toileting), and understanding of and control over his environment (through learning to visually track and manually control objects). Ms. Stearns and several other witnesses stressed that one of the most important pre-academic concepts STUDENT needs to learn is that of “cause and effect” – the understanding that he can make things happen through his own actions.

An OH assessment conducted in November 2003 noted:

STUDENT has limited opportunities to crawl or roll on the carpet, or to freely explore his environment by moving to objects he could touch, taste, feel, hold, and manipulate. His mobility in the classroom is limited often because of safety factors and lack of a developmentally appropriate area to freely explore without limits to what he can touch and experience.

(Dist. Ex. 14.) The assessment recommended that STUDENT’s school program “encourage free exploration in an environment that is developmentally appropriate and safe inside and outside.” At the hearing, several witnesses emphasized the importance of a broad, safe floor space to allow STUDENT to roll around, crawl, explore, and thereby increase his muscle strength and learn about his environment. (Testimony of Dr. Cullinane, Nancy Reynolds, and Carolyn Pearson.)

STUDENT does not directly dispute the District’s characterizations of his unique needs. However, STUDENT’s expert witness Dr. Joanne Singer criticized the District’s reliance on STUDENT’s developmental level to determine those needs, referring to this approach as outdated and inappropriate. (Footnote 13) According to Dr. Singer, the District’s “developmental” approach focuses on STUDENT’s deficits instead of his potential, thereby lowering expectations for STUDENT and excusing the District from having to try harder to help him learn. In this regard, Dr. Singer asserted that the notion that STUDENT needs to “roll around on the floor” to develop muscle strength and explore his physical environment underestimates STUDENT’s potential to learn more relevant skills now, and instead assumes that floor rolling will translate into functional behavior at some later point.

Dr. Singer stated that the developmental approach no longer is considered the “best practice” for determining a special education student’s needs. (Footnote 14) Rather, the method currently considered the best practice is a “functionally inclusive” approach, which de-emphasizes a student’s developmental level and places more emphasis on including the student in the age-appropriate curriculum and social life of the school. Instead of having STUDENT roll on the floor to improve mobility and coordination, a functionally inclusive approach would directly address the demands of STUDENT’s physical environment by, for example, teaching him to control his walker through engaging in “obstacle course” games with other students. (Testimony of Dr. Singer.)

The Hearing Officer is not persuaded that the District’s developmental approach focuses inappropriately on STUDENT’s deficits or lowers expectations for his development. Rather, it would appear that the District views STUDENT’s current level of development as a baseline for determining what he needs to learn to advance beyond that level and how best to help him do so. STUDENT has provided no evidence to counter the District’s position that engaging with STUDENT at his level of development is an appropriate and effective way to educate him.

Further, the Hearing Officer finds that a functionally inclusive approach to determining STUDENT’s needs (at least as described by Dr. Singer) makes unfounded assumptions about STUDENT’s current abilities that are contradicted by his developmental history. The idea that STUDENT can learn to control his walker through engaging in “obstacle course” games with fellow students, for example, assumes that STUDENT currently is able to interact with his peers, to realize that a game is occurring, to pay attention to what is going on, to understand what is expected of him, and to respond accordingly. STUDENT’s assessors, however, have testified persuasively that STUDENT does not yet respond to overtures from his peers, does not attend to any activity for more than a few seconds (other than listening to music), and does not yet know how to play. (Testimony of Ms. Reynolds, Rachel Fall, and Mona Neter; see Dist. Exs. 9 [comments of learning specialist], 15 [comments of OH specialist and of STUDENT’s teacher at Almansor Center].)

In contrast to STUDENT’s evidence, the District has provided persuasive testimony from several witnesses, each with many years of experience in child development, indicating that a child learns best when the learning environment is geared to the child’s developmental level. Dr. Cullinane testified that severely mentally retarded children learn in the same manner as other children at their cognitive level, and that STUDENT, whose cognitive level is still at an infant stage, needs the kind of highly sensory environment suited to typically developing infants. Ms. Fall, school psychologist, and Ms. Pearson, OH specialist, testified that STUDENT needs to physically explore his environment through touch, taste and sight before he can interact with others on a more advanced level. Tina Lee, speech and language pathologist, testified that STUDENT needs to learn “communicative intent” – the ability to distinguish between what he wants and doesn’t want, and to make that distinction known – before he can communicate effectively with others. The combined testimony of these witnesses supports the assertion by Ms. Stearns that, before STUDENT can learn more advanced tasks and skills, he needs to “learn how to learn.”

Based on STUDENT’s assessment reports and the testimony of the District witnesses, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s unique needs are those identified by the District and described above. The Hearing Officer further finds that the evidence and testimony has established that STUDENT’s needs will require (1) placement in a safe environment where he has room to physically explore his surroundings and increase his mobility and coordination; (2) a program that helps him to understand his environment through better visual tracking and through learning cause and effect, and that helps him act upon his environment through increased communication and fine motor skills; and (3) training in self-help skills, such as feeding, dressing, and toileting.

C. The District’s proposed program and placement

In the June 10, 2003 IEP and its addenda, the District proposed to place STUDENT in a LACOE-operated SDC for moderately and severely disabled students of early elementary school age at Encinitas School. (Dist. Exs. 9, 12, 15.) The proposed program would consist of five full days of classroom instruction per week; APE twice weekly for 30 minutes per session; vision consultation once a month for 60 minutes; OT consultation once a month for 50 minutes; OH consultation once a month for 60 minutes; and transportation. The program also would include the following goals and objectives:

Safe mobility – STUDENT will wear his helmet at all times.

Communication – STUDENT will imitate five new gestures (waving for “hi” and “bye,” hand out with open palm for “give me,” yes and no, pointing), and two verbal approximations (“bye” and “no”), with a decreasing number of prompts until he can perform without prompts.

Adapted Physical Education – STUDENT will be able to grasp and hold a two-inch rubber ball for up to seven seconds.

Self-help – STUDENT will finger-feed himself with foods either provided or approved by his parents. With OT assistance, he will actively close his lips around a spoon when being fed. STUDENT will follow a classroom toileting routine including sitting on the appropriate toilet, voiding as necessary, and washing and drying hands with adult support.

Social skills – STUDENT will play peek-a-boo with an adult and/or a child for three exchanges, and will explore a hand-held toy for up to one minute.

Pre-academic skills – STUDENT will activate a variety of cause and effect toys to produce desired sounds (music).

Vision – With the assistance of the vision specialist, STUDENT will sustain focus on various objects (lighted, colored, and black and white) presented to him for 15 seconds or more, and will visually track the object for 15 seconds or more, in four consecutive trials.

The program would take place in a classroom equipped with access ramps for STUDENT’s walker, with wide floor areas for STUDENT to explore, sensory toys, a three-to-one student-teacher ratio, and a one-to-one aide for at least several months’ transition period. (Footnote 15)

STUDENT, through Dr. Singer, objects to the goals and objectives in the IEP as having been created “in isolation,” instead of being worked naturally into activities that would allow him to interact with his classmates. For example, Dr. Singer criticized the District’s plan to have an instructor teach cause and effect to STUDENT through the use of sound and light-producing toys. Instead, Dr. Singer recommended that STUDENT be provided with a communicative device like a “vocorder,” which allows a nonverbal student to press a button to play prerecorded messages (such as “hello” or “will you play with me?”). Dr. Singer said that even if STUDENT has to be helped to press the button, doesn’t understand the recorded message, and doesn’t comprehend the connection between that message and any response he may receive from other students, his learning environment would be enriched by the activities themselves and by the interest they would generate among his classmates.

The Hearing Officer is not persuaded that the goals and objectives in STUDENT’s IEP are inappropriately “isolated.” This critique, like Dr. Singer’s earlier comments about the District’s assessment of STUDENT’s needs, makes the unfounded assumption that strategies and devices currently beyond STUDENT’s skills and comprehension, such as interactive playground games or a vocorder, nevertheless will enrich his learning experience. Further, Dr. Singer’s critique appears internally inconsistent: Although she criticizes the IEP goals as “isolated,” she stresses the importance of teaching skills through “task analysis” (breaking tasks down into discrete, achievable steps) – which implies that learning how to press a button to activate a noisemaking toy might be a useful prerequisite to learning how to use a vocorder.

Based on the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives in STUDENT’s IEP are designed to meet his unique needs. As the District’s offered services are not in dispute, the final element of the District’s program requiring review is its proposed placement of STUDENT in the Encinitas SDC for moderately and severely disabled students.

The Encinitas SDC is taught by Ceferina Martinec, an experienced, credentialed special education teacher, with the assistance of two instructional aides. (Dist. Ex. 9; see Dist. Ex. 27 [Martinec curriculum vitae].) The class currently has eight students of ages six through nine, four of whom are non-verbal, and six of whom use walkers or wheelchairs for at least part of the day. Their disabilities include severe developmental delays, moderate mental retardation, orthopedic handicaps, and blindness. The class follows a general education curriculum for kindergarten through third grade, adapted to the functioning level of the students in accordance with California content standards for special education. (Testimony of Ms. Martinec; see Dist. Ex. 25 [content standards].)

The Encinitas classroom has access ramps for walkers and wheelchairs, and a broad central floor area where the students can crawl, roll, and explore. Learning stations are set up around the perimeter of the class, and sensory toys are provided for play. The toys are screened for safety, and none of them (not even the puzzle pieces) are small enough to be placed in a child’s mouth. Ms. Martinec testified that a typical lesson plan in her class includes functional skills (learning to self-feed and use the toilet); group activities (singing songs and listening to stories); individual activities (looking at books or playing with toys or games); community activities (neighborhood walks and field trips); art projects; and pre-academic skills. Pre-academics typically include teaching the students each other’s names, the days of the week, and the seasons, and teaching them to recognize and name pictures of animals, objects, letters and numbers. (See Dist. Ex. 24 [sample lesson plan].) Ms. Martinec and her aides keep charts on each student’s progress in meeting his or her goals and objectives, and make regular progress reports to the students’ parents. (Testimony of Ms. Martinec.)

STUDENT, through Dr. Singer, objects to the proposed placement at Encinitas SDC on the grounds that there are minimal opportunities for interaction with nondisabled peers; that the teacher, Ms. Martinec, does not interact well with nonverbal students; and that her educational approach consists of “warehousing” the students instead of providing them with a stimulating learning environment. Dr. Singer testified that she watched Ms. Martinec teach her class for about three hours one morning in April of 2004, and made the following observations:

No systematic curriculum building meaningful skills is present in this class. Extremely minimal interactions with nondisabled peers are possible during the week. Most days there are none. The class schedule is only minimally integrated with the school schedule, and there is no individualized instruction, no expressive communication systems or assistive technology set up for any of the nonverbal students, no peer tutors or cooperative play activities, no systematic social skills instruction, and no opportunities for partial participation in the typical routines of school life. There is a terrible underestimation on the part of the staff of what the students are capable of learning. None of the teaching technology developed over the last twenty-five years to teach students with severe disabilities is being implemented in this class, including shaping, minimal assistance prompting, task analysis, motivational techniques, applied behavior analysis, expressive language expansion techniques for nonverbal students, receptive vocabulary building, behavioral momentum, social skills training, etc. In addition to all of these deficits in the program provided in this class, most serious for STUDENT is the fact that the teacher, Rina Martinec, appears to, perhaps unconsciously, be quite biased against students who are nonverbal with severe disabilities.

(Resp. Ex. 12.) Dr. Singer stated that during her observations, Ms. Martinec repeatedly singled out two verbal students for praise (calling them her “best” students), rewarded only those two students with extra turns at activities, and “totally ignored” the four nonverbal students. Finally, Dr. Singer criticized the amount of time Ms. Martinec spent singing to the students, stating “this might be a teaching method [used] in a preschool program, not an elementary class.” (Id.)

At the hearing, Ms. Martinec strongly disputed Dr. Singer’s conclusions. She noted that Dr. Singer visited her class for only three hours on one day (arriving after the pre-academics lesson had concluded), and could not fairly assess an entire teaching program from one isolated observation. Ms. Martinec also noted that Dr. Singer never asked to see her lesson plan or the students’ IEPs, and did not ask her how her teaching methods were intended to meet her students’ goals and objectives. She testified that many of the teaching tools Dr. Singer cited as absent are used regularly in her class, such as expressive communication systems for nonverbal students (the Language Master and the Picture Exchange Communication System [PECS]); peer tutors (by general education elementary students); receptive vocabulary building (through identification of pictures, numbers and letters); task analysis; minimal assistance prompting; expressive communication training; and individualized instruction.

Ms. Martinec noted that her students have regular opportunities for interactions with nondisabled peers at Encinitas, which is a general education campus. The SDC students take their daily recess periods on the playground with the other students, and usually eat lunch with them in the school cafeteria. (Footnote 16) Twice a week, nondisabled peers come to the class to read to the students or assist them with art projects. Further, the SDC students attend assemblies and school-wide programs with their nondisabled peers in the school auditorium. (Testimony of Ms. Martinec.)

Ms. Martinec also disputed the allegation that she favors her verbal students. She testified that Dr. Singer probably observed a lesson directed to particular goals in the verbal students’ IEPs, and that if she had been present at another day or time, other students’ goals would have been addressed and those students would have appeared to be favored. Ms. Martinec stated that she regularly gives positive reinforcement to all of her students and that her praise often takes the form of telling a student “you are the best!”

Finally, Ms. Martinec strongly defended her extensive use of singing as a teaching device. She noted that many special education students “don’t learn from lectures” because they cannot readily process or retain information, or they are easily distracted. For these students, singing is a powerful teaching tool, because the melodies and rhythms hold their interest and help them remember the words and lessons in the songs. Ms. Martinec noted with pride that after 17 years of special education teaching, she often is visited by students from many years past who still can remember the words and hand motions to her teaching songs.

Ms. Martinec’s statements were supported by the testimony of other District witnesses. Meg Tan, principal of the administrative unit that operates the LACOE special education classes, testified that she has visited Ms. Martinec’s class on several occasions and has never observed her discriminate against nonverbal students. She further stated that Ms. Martinec is highly trained in, and regularly implements, many of the teaching techniques cited as absent in Dr. Singer’s report, and that her class follows an appropriate curriculum that teaches meaningful skills. Ms. Stearns testified that when she visited Ms. Martinec’s class, she observed the students engaged in picture identification and matching of shapes, and noted that Ms. Martinec engaged with each of the students in turn and did not appear to favor any student over the others. Finally, both Ms. Stearns and Dr. Cullinane noted the importance of music and singing as teaching tools.

The Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Singer’s critique of the Encinitas SDC lacks credibility because it is based on a single morning’s visit to the class, and because it makes highly critical assumptions and conclusions about Ms. Martinec’s teaching methods and attitudes without any reference to Ms. Martinec’s lesson plan or to the students’ IEPs, which might have provided some context for Dr. Singer’s observations. Further, Dr. Singer’s criticisms have been effectively rebutted by Ms. Martinec, a credentialed special education instructor with over 17 years’ experience in teaching moderately to severely disabled students. Ms. Martinec testified credibly that her class will provide STUDENT with a safe and stimulating environment and education in accordance with his IEP goals and objectives, and her testimony was supported by other District witnesses.

Based upon the above-referenced evidence and testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives in STUDENT’s IEP, as well as the proposed placement at the Encinitas SDC, are designed to provide STUDENT with a safe and stimulating physical environment, increased mobility, increased communication skills, cause and effect training, and self-help training. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed program and placement are designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

2. Is the District’s program reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit?

To be appropriate under the IDEA, the District’s proposed program must be reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 200. While requiring meaningful access to education, the law does not require the District to guarantee success. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2d Cir. 1998); 34 C.F.R. § 300.350(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(c).

As set forth above, the District’s program has been designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and thereby is likely to provide him with some educational benefit. It will provide him with an extensive array of services, including placement in a structured SDC with a high teacher-student ratio, consistent instruction in functional and pre-academic skills by a trained and experienced teacher, a safe and stimulating physical environment, frequent positive reassurances, opportunities for interaction with nondisabled students, and additional OH and vision services and OT consultation. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offered program will provide STUDENT with meaningful access to education and has been reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit.

As the District’s offer has met the educational requirements set forth in Rowley, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has provided STUDENT with a FAPE. Accordingly, the final issue for resolution is whether placement in the Encinitas SDC constitutes the least restrictive environment for STUDENT’s education.

3. Would the Encinitas placement provide the least restrictive environment to STUDENT?

To ensure that disabled children are educated in the “least restrictive environment” (LRE), the IDEA requires them to be educated with nondisabled children “to the maximum extent appropriate.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b)(1). Under these regulations, disabled children may be separated from the regular educational environment “only if the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.” 34 C.F.R. § 550(b)(2). A disabled student should be educated in his or her neighborhood school, unless the IEP requires otherwise, and in any case should be educated in a setting as close as possible to the child’s home. 34 C.F.R. § 300.552.

A. STUDENT asserts that he should be educated at Repetto, his neighborhood school.

STUDENT contends that the District has failed to comply with LRE requirements because it has failed to show that he cannot be educated satisfactorily in a regular education setting with his nondisabled peers, or at least in an SDC in his neighborhood school. STUDENT’s mother noted that he has been educated in a full inclusion setting for the last few years, both at Head Start and at Almansor Center, and asserted that he has shown improvement in those placements. Further, STUDENT was happy at Head Start and at Almansor. In contrast, STUDENT’s ability to crawl regressed when he attended Lincoln, the special education preschool, and he was unhappy there, often crying when placed on the school bus in the morning. (Testimony of MOTHER.)

Dr. Singer asserted that STUDENT can be educated satisfactorily in a general education class or SDC in his neighborhood school, Repetto. According to Dr. Singer, the most important priority for a child with STUDENT’s significant disabilities is that he be “safely embedded in his family and community.” Placement at Repetto would mean that STUDENT would be educated with neighborhood children and would grow up in a community of friends and acquaintances who would surround him in his later life. When she visited Repetto, Dr. Singer observed a number of students and teachers who appeared to be of Chinese heritage. She surmised that the likely presence of Mandarin speakers on campus would make it easier for STUDENT’s parents to be involved in his education. (Testimony of Dr. Singer.)

Dr. Singer acknowledged that STUDENT is severely disabled, but asserted that the nature and severity of a student’s disability should not interfere with the student’s right to be educated with nondisabled peers. She stressed the importance of an age-appropriate curriculum in maintaining the dignity of disabled individuals, and opined that any general education curriculum could be modified to suit a severely disabled child’s needs without disrupting the class, as long as the child is taught primarily by a one-to-one aide. In Dr. Singer’s opinion, the only time a severely disabled child might not be satisfactorily educated in a general education class would be if the child had extreme behavior problems, or needed resources that could not practically be provided in a classroom. She noted that all of STUDENT’s teachers and assessors have observed that he is a good-natured child with no behavior problems and that he needs no special resources that cannot be provided in class. (Id.)

STUDENT’s parents primarily seek a general education placement for STUDENT at Repetto. (Testimony of MOTHER; see Dist. Ex. 9.) Dr. Singer advocated a general education placement as well, but made an alternative suggestion in accordance with her assertion that placing STUDENT in his neighborhood school should be the primary goal. Specifically, Dr. Singer suggested that STUDENT spend half of the school day in the Repetto SDC for kindergarten and first grade students with speech and language disabilities, and the remainder of the day engaged in nonacademic activities in one of Repetto’s general education kindergarten or first grade classes. Dr. Singer spent part of a day observing the Repetto SDC, and praised the academically focused curriculum and the teaching methods of its instructor, Jill Thomas. (Id.; see Resp. Ex. 12.)

B. The District asserts that STUDENT cannot be educated satisfactorily in Repetto’s general education classes or in its SDC for speech and language disabilities.

The District contends that placement at Repetto in any environment would be inappropriate and unsafe for STUDENT. First, it notes that the physical environs of its kindergarten and first grade classes are unsafe, since they contain small toys, pencils, puzzle pieces, scissors, and other items that would be dangerous to a child like STUDENT, who is still learning about objects primarily by mouthing them. (Footnote 17) In addition, the kindergarten and first grade classes are filled with rows of student desks lined up to face the teacher, and do not have safe, wide open areas for STUDENT to explore by crawling. Further, even though STUDENT has the strength to sit up at a desk, this typical classroom arrangement is inappropriate for him because the teacher stands too far from the class for STUDENT to see or to be engaged by the teacher’s instruction. (Testimony of Dr. Cullinane.) At STUDENT’s current level of development, “teachable moments” occur only when his instructor makes direct, face-to-face contact with him. (Id.; testimony of Ms. Stearns.)

The District asserted that its kindergarten and first grade curricula are primarily academic, involving reading, simple math, and other concepts beyond STUDENT’s comprehension. It disagreed with Dr. Singer’s theory that any curriculum can be modified for STUDENT as long as he receives primary instruction from a one-to-one aide, noting that LACOE’s instructional aides are not teachers themselves, but are trained to reinforce instruction from the primary teacher. (Testimony of Ms. Stearns.) When Mona Neter, the District’s inclusion specialist, was asked how she would modify the curriculum in a general education class to meet STUDENT’s needs, she said she wouldn’t, because the curriculum would not address STUDENT’s pre-academic needs on any level.

The District stated that STUDENT needs a teacher trained and experienced in working with disabled students who can engage with STUDENT at his developmental level, and that general education teachers are not trained to do so. It disputed the claim that STUDENT had benefited in his full inclusion placements, noting that the inclusion specialist at Almansor described STUDENT’s progress as “minimal.” (Dist. Ex. 9.) STUDENT’s teacher at Almansor said that STUDENT had made almost no noticeable improvement there, and that he did not believe Almansor was an appropriate placement for STUDENT. (Footnote 18) (Id.)

Finally, the District disagreed with Dr. Singer’s opinion that the Repetto SDC would be a suitable educational environment for STUDENT. The Repetto class is designed for students who have speech and language disabilities but normal or near normal cognitive levels. (Testimony of Ms. Stearns and Ms. Fall.) Ms. Thomas, who teaches the class, testified that most of her 12 students have delayed communication skills, and although some are autistic, most are on the “high-functioning” end of the spectrum. None is mentally retarded. The class follows a modified kindergarten and first grade curriculum that includes reading, writing, spelling, phonics, and the teaching of concepts like “beginning-middle-end.”

Ms. Thomas testified that she had read STUDENT’s IEP, and was certain that her class would not meet his needs. The curriculum would be beyond his comprehension, and the toys and craft objects used by her students – Legos, jigsaw puzzles, Popsicle sticks, glue, and scissors – would be dangerous to him. Further, the sort of sensory toys STUDENT would need for his own development, with their noises and flashing lights, would be highly distracting to her autistic students, who have difficulty focusing on their tasks. Ms. Thomas noted that she had no experience teaching severely retarded children and that she would not have enough time to devote to teaching STUDENT functional skills while still teaching academics to the rest of her class.

C. Discussion.

In determining whether a placement satisfies LRE requirements, the following factors are considered: (1) the educational benefits available to the child in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared to the educational benefits of a special education classroom; (2) the nonacademic benefits to the child of interaction with nondisabled children; (3) the effect of the presence of the disabled child on the teacher and other children in the regular classroom; and (4) the costs of supplemental aids and services necessary to mainstream the disabled child in a regular classroom setting. Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel Holland, 786 F. Supp. 879 (1992); adopted by the Ninth Circuit in Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel Holland, 14 F.3d 1398 (9th Cir. 1994) cert. denied, 114 S. Ct. 2679 (1993). (Footnote 19)

(1) Comparison of educational benefits. The Hearing Officer has determined that STUDENT would receive educational benefits through the District’s proposed program at the Encinitas SDC. STUDENT argues that he also would receive educational benefits in a regular education classroom at Repetto, or in its SDC for students with speech and language disabilities, so long as he receives the full-time assistance of a one-to-one aide. STUDENT acknowledges that the difference between Repetto’s general or SDC curriculum and a program modified for his needs would be so great that his instruction would have to come primarily from his aide. (Testimony of Dr. Singer.)

To meet or exceed the benefits offered by the District, a Repetto program would need to provide STUDENT with instruction at least equivalent to what he would receive at Encinitas. The District has pointed out, however, that its instructional aides, who would be primarily responsible for STUDENT’s education under this scenario, are not trained or credentialed teachers. (Footnote 20) Moreover, neither Ms. Thomas, the teacher of the Repetto SDC, nor the general education kindergarten and first grade teachers at Repetto are trained or experienced in teaching severely disabled students. (Footnote 21)

Further, the District witnesses have testified persuasively that neither the Repetto general education classes nor the SDC for speech and language disabilities would provide a safe physical environment or appropriate sensory stimuli for STUDENT’s development. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the educational benefits of the District’s proposed program and placement in the Encinitas SDC would significantly exceed those available to STUDENT at Repetto.

(2) Nonacademic benefits of interaction with nondisabled children. In her report and in testimony, Dr. Singer asserted that the nonacademic benefits to disabled children of interacting with their nondisabled peers is of paramount importance to their development and their later life in the community. In closing argument, STUDENT contended that even if Repetto offered fewer educational benefits than the Encinitas SDC, the Rowley standard requiring the District to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” indicates that his educational program should be a secondary consideration to the nonacademic benefits he would receive from being educated with his peers.

The Hearing Officer notes that the nonacademic benefits generally associated with full inclusion include interactions with nondisabled students, relationship building, and opportunities for modeling behavior. In this case, however, the Hearing Officer finds little indication that full inclusion would provide those benefits to STUDENT. In the setting envisioned by Dr. Singer, STUDENT would be taught a highly modified curriculum by an aide while his classmates received academic instruction from the teacher. This model suggests a sort of “parallel teaching,” where STUDENT would learn alongside, but not “with,” his classmates. Nothing about this model suggests that any interaction or other nonacademic benefits from full inclusion would occur to benefit STUDENT.

Further, even when nonacademic group activities would allow for interaction, STUDENT’s developmental history indicates that he would receive little benefit from it at this time. The opportunity to model the behavior of nondisabled peers would provide no current benefit, because STUDENT does not yet understand or engage in modeling. [Testimony of Ms. Fall and Ms. Neter.] STUDENT’s assessors have reported that he is at a cognitive level at which he responds primarily to consistent, close-range engagement from adults, and does not yet take into account the larger environment that includes his peers. These assessments have been confirmed by STUDENT’s teacher at Almansor and by the District’s inclusion specialists, who have observed that STUDENT does not respond to his classmates’ overtures or even notice their presence. Even STUDENT’s mother described his playing with his younger brother largely in terms of “parallel play” as opposed to interactive play.

STUDENT argues that one nonacademic benefit to placing him at Repetto, his neighborhood school, would be to educate him in his cultural milieu and among neighborhood children who might provide him with an established community in later life. Even this argument, however, makes many assumptions about the character, cultural makeup, and stability of the neighborhood for which no reliable evidence has been provided.

Further, the Hearing Officer is unpersuaded that the Rowley requirements imply that the nonacademic benefits of educating a child with his nondisabled peers or in his neighborhood school should receive greater weight than the other factors necessary to determining the least restrictive environment for a disabled child’s education. Federal regulations require full inclusion “to the maximum extent appropriate,” and Holland provides the factors by which appropriateness is determined, without assigning more weight to one factor than to another. 34 C.F.R. § 300.5509b)(1); Holland, supra, 786 F. Supp. 879. In addition, federal regulations require placement in a child’s neighborhood school “unless the IEP requires otherwise,” in which case the child should be educated “as close as possible” to the child’s home. 34 C.F.R. § 300.552. (Footnote 22)

For the reasons stated above, the Hearing Officer finds that, at this point in STUDENT’s development, the nonacademic benefits of being educated with nondisabled peers would be minimal.

(3) Effect of the presence of the disabled child on the teacher or other children in the regular classroom. STUDENT argues that including him in a general education setting would not inconvenience the teacher or disrupt the class. Dr. Singer noted that STUDENT’s assessors all commented on his pleasant disposition, and that STUDENT’s teacher at Almansor indicated that he was “fully accepted” by his peers and was not a problem to have in class. She also noted that STUDENT needs no unusual services or supports that could not be provided in a general education setting.

The District argues that the sensory stimuli STUDENT needs for his development, such as toys that light up or make noise, would be unduly distracting to other students focused on academics (particularly to the autistic students in the Repetto SDC). Further, the District argues that the functional, self-help, and other instruction required by STUDENT’s IEP would have to be provided primarily by the classroom teacher, to the detriment of all of the other students in the class.

The Hearing Officer notes that, although STUDENT’s presence in a full inclusion setting at Almansor has not been disruptive, STUDENT is in a preschool class where the children are engaged with toys, games, and other activities, and do not receive academic instruction requiring order, quiet time, staying in one’s seat, and concentrating on a task or on the teacher. Further, STUDENT’s teacher has observed that, although STUDENT is “no trouble” to have in class, his needs are not being met at Almansor because the teacher is responsible for the class as a whole, and does not have the time to engage in the intensive, one-on-one teaching necessary to engage STUDENT at his level of development.

In view of the sensory stimuli, physical exploration opportunities, and feeding and toilet training included in the goals and objectives for STUDENT’s education, the Hearing Officer finds that educating STUDENT in a general education classroom, or at the Repetto SDC, would present a significant distraction to the teacher and the other children in the class. The Hearing Officer further finds that STUDENT’s educational needs are so distinct from those of general education or Repetto SDC students that the classroom teacher could not devote sufficient time and attention to teaching him his program without significant disadvantage to the education of the other students in the class.

(4) Costs of supplementary aids and services. Although the cost of a full time aide as a “supplemental service” would be a factor to consider under Holland, the District has indicated that its position is not based on cost and that it would be prepared to offer a full-time aide if a general education class were otherwise appropriate for STUDENT. Accordingly, the cost of a full-time aide will not be considered to be a factor in this decision.

In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that the educational benefits available to STUDENT at the Encinitas SDC significantly exceed those he would receive at Repetto; that the nonacademic benefits of being educated among his nondisabled peers are minimal, at least at this stage of his development; and that STUDENT’s presence in the Repetto SDC or in a general education classroom would significantly affect the teacher and students in those classes. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed placement at the Encinitas SDC offers STUDENT a free and appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment.

ORDER

The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed placement at the Encinitas SDC constitutes an offer of a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment to STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year and ESY.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on the sole issue heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal. Educ. Code ' 56505(i).

Date: July 28, 2004 _________________________________________ Claudia J. Wrazel, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

The parties acknowledge that by the time this decision is issued, the 2003-2004 school year and ESY will have ended. Nevertheless, the parties jointly assert that the issue to be decided is not moot, because its resolution will guide them in their efforts to agree on the appropriate placement for STUDENT in the 2004-2005 school year and ESY.

2 A “full inclusion” class serves both disabled and nondisabled students.

3 MOTHER testified that STUDENT had learned to crawl before attending the Lincoln preschool, but “was always kept in a chair” at the school and could not crawl as well afterward.

4 Case No. SN03-00084.

5 The agreement stated that STUDENT would be assessed in the areas of academic/preacademic achievement; social/adaptive behavior; psycho-motor development; language/speech/communication development; intellectual development; vision; orthopedic handicap; and medical condition. It also stipulated that STUDENT’s placement at Almansor through June 20, 2003, constituted a FAPE.

6 California law similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(a).

7 A proposed special education program includes the proposed placement, which is defined as “that unique combination of facilities, personnel, location or equipment necessary to provide instructional services to an individual with exceptional needs, as specified in the IEP[ ].” 5 C.C.R. § 3042(ab).

8 When a dispute exists over a current placement, the Rowley analysis also includes consideration of whether the program, as implemented, comports with the student’s IEP. Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 207-208. As the dispute in this case is over a prospective placement, no implementation issues arise.

9 The developmental levels set forth in the italicized subheadings encompass all ranges reported by the cited assessments and testimony.

10 The testing and the interview with STUDENT’s mother were conducted in Mandarin. Due to STUDENT’s developmental delays, much of the Rossetti Scale data were unobtainable through direct testing and instead were obtained through observation and parent interview.

11 The language spoken in STUDENT’s home is Chiu Chow, a Mandarin dialect. STUDENT’s mother testified that she tries to teach him with simple verbal commands in dialect, such as “eat,” “up,” or “stop.” STUDENT does not speak any recognizable words in Chiu Chow.

12 A vision score of 20/400 means that STUDENT’s perception of an object 20 feet away is equivalent to a normally sighted person’s perception of an object 400 feet away. (Dist. Ex. 9.) STUDENT is considered legally blind, but can negotiate his environment within a visual range of three to five feet, and will reach out to a face placed within 12-15 inches of his face. Id.

13 Dr. Singer is an educational consultant and inclusion specialist with many years’ experience teaching moderate to severely disabled students in Oregon. She also supervises the special education teacher training program at the University of California at Santa Barbara. Her critiques of the District’s proposed program and placement are based on a review of STUDENT’s IEP and some of his medical records; a visit to Almansor Center, where she observed STUDENT; a visit to the Encinitas SDC; and a visit to a class at Repetto, STUDENT’s neighborhood school. (Testimony of Dr. Singer; see Resp. Exs. 12 [Singer report], 13 [Singer curriculum vitae].)

14 The “best practice” is the set of strategies and teaching technologies that has been accepted in the special education field as most effective in increasing disabled students’ ability to learn and participate with their peers. (Testimony of Dr. Singer.)

15 The June 2003 IEP provides that upon his placement at Encinitas, STUDENT would continue to be assisted by a one-to-one aide for a transition period of several months, after which the IEP team would review the appropriateness of continuing one-to-one assistance. (Dist. Ex. 9.)

16 When Dr. Singer visited the class, Ms. Martinec had the students’ lunches brought over from the cafeteria so the class could eat lunch with Dr. Singer present. (Testimony of Ms. Martinec.)

17 The presence of such items within STUDENT’s reach at Almansor Center has raised safety concerns among STUDENT’sassessors. (Testimony of Nancy Reynolds, Carolyn Pearson.)

18 The inclusion specialist said she observed some improvement in STUDENT’s ability to grasp objects. STUDENT’s teacher said the only improvement he had observed was STUDENT’s ability to recognize and respond to the teacher’s voice. STUDENT did not appear to recognize other voices, was unresponsive when other students approached him, had to be fully motored through all class activities by his aide, and did not pay attention to the activities as he was being motored through them. (Dist. Ex. 9.)

19 Under Holland, determination of the least restrictive environment requires a case-specific comparison of the benefits of full inclusion to the benefits of a special education placement. Here, STUDENT primarily seeks full inclusion, but also suggests a placement consisting of half of a school day in the Repetto SDC for speech and language disabilities and the remainder of the day in a Repetto general education class. As the Repetto SDC arguably is a “less restrictive” environment than the Encinitas SDC (since it serves students with less severe disabilities), and as this proposal would provide for half of a day in a full inclusion setting, STUDENT’s proposed alternative placement also is analyzed in accordance with the principles set forth in Holland.

20 Conceivably, this problem could be resolved if the District were to hire a trained and credentialed special education instructor to be STUDENT’s one-to-one aide. However, this would be tantamount to establishing a separate special education classroom inside the general education classroom, and would appear to go far beyond the Holland requirement that a District supplement a general education classroom with “appropriate aids and services.” 786 F. Supp. 879.

21 Ms. Thomas’s experience is with students with speech and language disabilities but with normal or near-normal cognitive abilities. (Testimony of Ms. Thomas 22 The Hearing Officer notes that the Encinitas SDC is only five miles from STUDENT’s residence, and that at least one special education teacher at Encinitas, as well as the principal of the Lincoln PAU that administers the school, are Mandarin speakers. (Testimony of Ms. Martinec and Ms. Tan.)