California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 12, 2001
Mountain Empire Unified School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 1660-00 · Hearing Officer Van T. Vu
Mountain Empire Unified may implement its IEP over a mother's refusal; student eligible with a learning disability, not emotional disturbance.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The decision notes that the mother had earlier filed her own hearing request (SN 399-00) on March 9, 2000, and withdrew it the day before its September 14, 2000 hearing date. No subsequent history appears in the document.
Summary
Mountain Empire Unified School District filed for a hearing after a mother refused all special education services for her nine-year-old son, except speech therapy. He was repeating third grade at Clover Flat Elementary School and had received speech and language therapy since about 1998-1999. The District argued that he qualified as a student with a specific learning disability and an emotional disturbance. His mother and grandmother represented him. They said his problems came from frequent school moves and that a special education label would hurt his self-esteem.
The Hearing Officer found that he qualified as a student with a specific learning disability. Testing showed a 35-point gap between his ability and achievement in reading and a 39-point gap in written language. These gaps came from auditory processing, visual-motor and attention deficits. They continued after a full year of classroom help from teachers Laura Turner, Andra Shelton and Bill Cudog.
The Hearing Officer rejected emotional disturbance for three reasons. Attention and processing deficits explained his learning problems. He got along with his teachers and had friends. There was no evidence of inappropriate behavior outside school.
The August 31, 2000 IEP was found to offer FAPE under Rowley. It included seven goals, speech therapy, and mornings in Erin Fears' special day class with general education in the afternoons. The District did not invite the mother to the August meeting. This was a technical violation that caused no harm because she had refused all services. Under Education Code section 56346, the District may implement the IEP without her consent.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied Education Code section 56346 to let a district override a parent's refusal of special education services. The district first had to prove both eligibility and an appropriate offer. The decision also shows the Hearing Officer separating attention-related classroom behavior from emotional disturbance when deciding eligibility.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue I. s STUDENT eligible for special education and related services?
The student is eligible as a student with a specific learning disability. He showed severe ability-achievement gaps in reading (35 points) and written language (39 points), caused by processing and attention deficits, that regular education interventions could not correct. He does not qualify under emotional disturbance.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue II. If yes, did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) pursuant to the August 31, 2000 IEP?
The IEP offered FAPE under Rowley: seven goals, 45 thirty-minute speech sessions a year, and a half-day special day class with afternoon mainstreaming. The failure to invite the mother to the August meeting was a technical violation that caused no prejudice.
- District prevailedDistrict-filed: implement IEP
Issue III. May the District implement the August 31, 2000 IEP without parental consent to receive services?
Under Education Code section 56346, the District may implement the IEP over the mother's refusal of consent because the program is necessary for the student to receive FAPE.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order that district's offer may be implemented. The District may implement the August 31, 2000 IEP over the mother's refusal of consent.
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education; Cal. Educ. Code § 56346; Cal. Educ. Code § 56337; 5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)
People named in the decision
- Dr. Bronwyn Lee, Director of special education and school psychologist, Mountain Empire Unified School District
- Laura Turner, General education teacher (first grade; language arts instruction), Mountain Empire Unified School District
- Bill Cudog, General education third grade teacher and principal, Mountain Empire Unified School District
- Erin Fears, Special education teacher (special day class), Clover Flat Elementary School
- Andra Shelton, General education second/third grade combination teacher, Mountain Empire Unified School District
- Roberta Burkett, School psychologist intern, Mountain Empire Unified School District
- Diane Yops, Principal, Clover Flat Elementary School
- Greg Ryan, Superintendent, Mountain Empire Unified School District
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Campo, California, on November 28 and 29, 2000.
Petitioner Mountain Empire Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Pamela Dempsey and by law clerk Stephanie Vaudreuil, both from the law firm of Parham and Rajcic. Dr. Bronwyn Lee, director of special education and school psychologist, was also present at the hearing on the District’s behalf. Respondent STUDENT (hereinafter Student or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by his mother, MOTHER, and his grandmother, GRANDMOTHER.
The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Dr. Bronwyn Lee; Laura Turner, regular education teacher; Bill Cudog, regular education teacher and principal; Erin Fears, special education teacher; Andra Shelton, regular education teacher; and Roberta Burkett, previously Dr. Lee’s school psychologist intern. The Student called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: MOTHER and GRANDMOTHER.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of written closing arguments. The Student’s closing brief was received on the last day of hearing, and the District’s closing brief was received on December 12, 2000. The record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES(Footnote 1)
I. Is STUDENT eligible for special education and related services?
II. If yes, did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) pursuant to the August 31, 2000 IEP?
III. May the District implement the August 31, 2000 IEP without parental consent to receive services?
POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES
The District contends that STUDENT is qualified for special education and related services as a child who has a specific learning disability and an emotional disturbance. The District also asserts that the IEP dated August 31, 2000, sets forth an appropriate educational plan for STUDENT. Asserting that MOTHER has generally refused all special education services that STUDENT requires to progress in school (except speech services), the District seeks an order allowing it to implement the August 2000 IEP over MOTHER’s refusal of consent.
STUDENT’s mother and grandmother assert that STUDENT is not a special education student and should not be identified as such. MOTHER and GRANDMOTHER allege that STUDENT would be stigmatized if placed in special education, and that a special education placement would negatively affect his self-esteem. MOTHER also asserts that STUDENT’s difficulties in school are the result of his having had to change schools frequently and her not requiring him to do his homework. For these reasons, they do not want STUDENT to be identified as a special education student or to receive special education services.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a nine-year-old student who is repeating the third grade at Clover Flat Elementary School. STUDENT has received special education and related services in the form of speech and language therapy since approximately the 1998-1999 school year.
During the the 1996-1997 school year, STUDENT attended a regular education kindergarten class within the District. At the beginning of the first grade, STUDENT and his mother moved to El Cajon, California. After attending school in El Cajon for approximately three months, STUDENT and his family returned to the Mountain Empire School District. Shortly thereafter, in March of 1998, STUDENT and his mother moved to Sacramento, California. However, MOTHER kept STUDENT out of school from approximately March 1998 through July 1998. According to MOTHER, STUDENT was enrolled in within Sacramento in July 1998, and attended school the remaining one month of the school year.
STUDENT and his mother remained in Sacramento during the 1998-1999 school year, where STUDENT attended the second grade. MOTHER testified that STUDENT changed schools within the Sacramento school district at least one time during the school year. As part of his educational program while in Sacramento, STUDENT received speech and language services.
During the summer of 1999, STUDENT and his mother moved back to the Mountain Empire School District. At the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT was placed in a District regular education third grade class. Within days of being placed in the third grade class, STUDENT was moved to Ms. Andra Shelton’s second and third grade combination class because of difficulties STUDENT was having with academics. According to Ms. Shelton, STUDENT continued to have difficulty in her class and was unable to progress at the second grade level in the areas of reading and writing. As a result, STUDENT was placed in Ms. Laura Turner’s first grade class during the mornings for language instruction. According to Ms. Shelton, STUDENT lacked basic reading skills and required instruction in language at a lower level than could be taught in her second/third grade class. STUDENT remained in Ms. Turner’s class for language instruction until approximately January 2000, when MOTHER requested that he attend Ms. Shelton’s class full time.
On December 2, 1999, an Individualized Education Program (IEP) meeting was convened to develop a special education “Interim Placement” for STUDENT. At the time of the meeting, the District had not yet assessed STUDENT for special education eligibility. Apparently, because STUDENT had received speech and language services from his previous school district, the District continued the same level of speech and language services pending his assessment by the District.(Footnote 2) During the IEP meeting, MOTHER signed an assessment plan giving the District consent to assess STUDENT in the areas of academic/pre-academic achievement, social/adaptive behavior, psycho-motor development, intellectual development, and health, vision and hearing.
During December 1999 and January 2000, the District conducted its assessments of STUDENT. A subsequent IEP meeting convened on January 24, 2000, in which the IEP team reviewed STUDENT’s assessments and discussed STUDENT’s eligibility for special education and related services(Footnote 3). Present at the meeting were: STUDENT’s mother; Erin Fears, special education teacher; Andra Shelton, STUDENT’s third grade teacher; Laura Turner, STUDENT’s language arts teacher, Dr. Bronwyn Lee, school psychologist and special education director, Diane Yops, principal of Clover Flat; and Roberta Burkett, school psychology intern. The District members of the IEP team recommended that STUDENT be determined eligible for special education services as a student who is learning disabled and emotionally disturbed. The team also explained to MOTHER its “integrated program” at Clover Flat Elementary School and offered her such program as a special education placement for STUDENT.(Footnote 4) However, MOTHER disagreed with the eligibility recommendation, refused any and all special education services for STUDENT, and left the IEP meeting. Following MOTHER’s departure, the District members of the IEP team concluded the IEP meeting. While the IEP from the meeting contained notes regarding what occurred at the meeting, it did not contain any specifics regarding what placement was offered to MOTHER.
On March 9, 2000, MOTHER filed a request for a due process hearing. In her request, MOTHER indicated as an issue for hearing whether the District could require her to place STUDENT in its special education placement. Upon receipt of the request, the Hearing Office opened a case, assigned it case number SN 399-00, and scheduled the matter for hearing.
At the end of the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT’s teachers recommended that he be retained in the third grade. Following a meeting during the summer of 2000 with MOTHER discussing STUDENT’s retention, the District decided to place STUDENT again in the third grade for the oncoming school year. STUDENT was placed in Mr. Cudog’s third grade regular education class for the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT was.
Following a number of extensions requested by the parties, case SN 399-00 was scheduled for hearing on September 14, 2000. On August 31, 2000, the District convened a meeting to discuss STUDENT’s educational placement. At the meeting, the District drafted an IEP document that memorialized its recommendation from the January IEP meeting that STUDENT be placed in the Clover Flat “integrated program.”(Footnote 5) Present at the meeting were Dr. Bronwyn Lee and Erin Fears, who were present at the January IEP meeting. Greg Ryan, school superintendent, and Pamela Dempsey, the District’s attorney, were also present at the meeting. There is no indication from the record that MOTHER was invited to the meeting. (Footnote 6) The day before the scheduled hearing, MOTHER withdrew her case from the hearing calendar.
With STUDENT’s educational placement still unresolved, the District filed its own request for hearing in the present matter (SN 1660-00) by letter dated September 13, 2000. MOTHER was given the August IEP sometime on or before October 12, 2000. However, MOTHER continued to refuse any and all services for STUDENT on the basis that he does not need special education services.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
I. Is STUDENT eligible for special education and related services?
Under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Act (IDEA) and State law, children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20. U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A “child with a disability” is a child with mental retardation, hearing impairments, speech or language impairments, visual impairments, emotional disturbance, orthopedic impairments, autism, traumatic brain injury, other health impairments, or specific learning disabilities who, by reason thereof, needs instruction, services or both which cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56026(a) and (b).
In this case, the District asserts that STUDENT is eligible for special education and related services under the categories of specific learning disability (SLD) and emotional disturbance (ED). Each category will be addressed below.
A. Specific Learning Disability
The IDEA defines “specific learning disability” as a “disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or using language, spoken or written, which disorder may manifest itself in a imperfect ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell, or do mathematical calculations.” 20 U.S.C. § 1401(26). California Education Code § 56337 states that the following three requirements must be met in order to satisfy eligibility criteria for a specific learning disability:
(a) A severe discrepancy exists between the intellectual ability and achievement in one or more of the following academic areas:
(1) Oral expression;
(2) Listening comprehension;
(3) Written expression;
(4) Basic reading skills;
(5) Reading comprehension;
(6) Mathematics calculation;
(7) Mathematics reasoning.
(b) The discrepancy is due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes and is not the result of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantages. (c) The discrepancy cannot be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program.
The evidence established that STUDENT meets the requirements for special education eligibility as a student with a specific learning disability. With regard to the first criterion, a severe discrepancy can be established either through a formula using standardized tests (5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(4)(A)), by alternative means when standardized tests are considered invalid (5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(4)(B), or through a determination by an IEP team that such a discrepancy exists (5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(4)(C)).
There was no testimony or evidence that the use of standardized tests is invalid in assessing STUDENT’s ability or achievement. While the District members of STUDENT’s IEP team determined that STUDENT has a specific learning disability, MOTHER disputes this determination. Thus, no consensus was reached by the IEP team on this matter. Therefore, to determine if a severe discrepancy exists, STUDENT’s scores on standardized intellectual testing can be compared with his scores on achievement testing. When standardized tests are considered valid, a severe discrepancy is established by the following:
[F]irst, converting into common standard scores, using a mean of 100 and standard deviation of 15, the achievement test score and the ability test score to be compared; second, computing the difference between these common standard scores; and third, comparing this computed difference to the standard criterion which is the product of 1.5 multiplied by the standard deviation of the distribution of computed differences of students taking these achievement and ability tests.
5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(4)(A).
The calculation of this formula has commonly involved interpreting the required difference for a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement standard scores to be at least 22.5 points (1.5 multiplied by the standard deviation of 15), adjusted by 4 points, which is one standard error of measurement(Footnote 7). This computed difference constitutes a severe discrepancy when “such discrepancy is corroborated by other assessment data which may include other tests, scales, instruments and work samples, as appropriate.” Id.
In this case, STUDENT’s cognitive ability was assessed on January 5, 2000, using the Kaufman Assessment Battery for Children (KABC). On the Kaufman, STUDENT’s cognitive ability was scored at a standard score of 78, which is in the below average range of intelligence. Additionally, STUDENT’s academic achievement was assessed on the same date using the Woodcock Johnson-Revised (WJ-R). On the WJ-R, STUDENT received the following standard scores: broad reading-43, broad mathematics-72, broad written language-39, and broad knowledge-79. While STUDENT’s achievement scores on the WJ-R in broad mathematics and broad knowledge is commensurate with his cognitive ability based on the KABC, STUDENT’s scores in broad reading and broad written language indicate that he is achieving significantly below his ability. Specifically, there is a thirty-five point discrepancy between STUDENT’s ability and achievement in the area of reading and a thirty-nine point discrepancy between his ability and achievement in written language.
Other evidence submitted by the District supports that STUDENT’s academic achievement in reading and writing is significantly discrepant from his intellectual ability. When STUDENT started the third grade in September 1999, he was given the Basic Reading Inventory (BRI) to assess his reading performance. The same test was given to STUDENT at the end of the school year in May 2000 to assess his progress during the year. In September 1999, when STUDENT first started the third grade, he could not read many sight words that children his age are expected to know. According to Ms. Laura Turner, who assessed STUDENT, his scores on the BRI indicated that his reading skills fell at the kindergarten/pre-primer level; these scores were consistent with his reading performance in class. Ms. Turner and Ms. Shelton testified that STUDENT could identify some letters of the alphabet and the corresponding sounds, but he could not consistently connect the sounds together to read. By the end of the school year, STUDENT continued to score at the same kindergarten/pre-primer level of reading on the BRI and perform at the same level in class. Despite STUDENT’s cognitive abilities, his reading skills were more than two years below grade level and he made little or no academic progress in reading during the entire academic year.
With regard to written language, Ms. Turner testified that STUDENT had difficulty writing and did not write in complete sentences. To assist STUDENT, Ms. Turner would write sentences that STUDENT dictated so that STUDENT could later copy the sentences into his journal. According to Ms. Turner, students STUDENT’s age and grade are expected to be able to write paragraphs of three sentences. Because STUDENT was unable to do this and had significant difficulty composing sentences, Ms. Turner estimated STUDENT’s writing abilities to be below the first grade level. Similarly, Mr. Cudog, STUDENT’s teacher at the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year, testified that STUDENT could not independently compose a sentence. STUDENT required someone to talk him through the composition process by giving him context and support. Additionally, Mr. Cudog testified that STUDENT was only able to copy sentences “a little.” In summary, STUDENT’s difficulties with writing as observed in the classes of Ms. Turner, Ms. Shelton, and Mr. Cudog classes supports the assessment findings that STUDENT is achieving below his abilities in this area. Therefore, it is concluded that STUDENT exhibits a significant discrepancy between his intellectual ability and achievement in the areas of reading and written expression.
With regard to the second criterion, that the discrepancy must be due to basic psychological processing disorder, Dr. Bronwyn Lee, the District’s school psychologist and director of special education, testified that STUDENT’s discrepancy is due to his deficits in auditory processing, visual-motor processing, and attention. According to Dr. Lee, STUDENT has difficulty understanding and following oral directions because of his delays in auditory processing. Additionally, Dr. Lee testified that STUDENT’s visual-motor deficits results in his inability to read and write. Furthermore, Dr. Lee found that STUDENT’s performance on academic tasks is negatively affected by his inability to focus and attend to task.
STUDENT’s teachers also testified that his attention problems interfere with his academic performance. Mr. Cudog testified that STUDENT was easily distracted and had difficulty staying on task, maintaining focus on instruction, and following through with his assignments. According to Mr. Cudog, STUDENT’s attention problems caused “tremendous frustration” for STUDENT and interfered with his ability to read and learn. Ms. Andra Shelton, STUDENT’s third-grade teacher during the 1999-2000 school year, testified that STUDENT was unable to concentrate on a task for more than three minutes at a time. Ms. Shelton testified that STUDENT could not stay on task and required close supervision to help him manage his behaviors and to get him to focus on his academics. Furthermore, Ms. Turner testified that STUDENT could not sit still and would often “fiddle with things” instead of keeping to task. Moreover, Ms. Turner testified that these behaviors impacted STUDENT’s performance in class.
MOTHER argues that STUDENT’s academic difficulties are a result of his frequent school changes and his being out of school for three months during the first grade rather than a result of a processing problem. Her argument is unpersuasive. While such events may have caused STUDENT to fall behind academically, they do not explain why STUDENT failed to progress academically from September 1999 to the present even though he was attending the same school regularly and was receiving numerous interventions to help him progress. As noted above, STUDENT’s teachers testified that STUDENT had significant difficulty learning and could not retain the information he had learned. Given that STUDENT’s cognitive ability is sound, it would be reasonable to expect that he could have progressed educationally if, as MOTHER contends, he did not have any learning disabilities. In light of the consistent and credible testimony of Dr. Lee, Mr. Cudog, Ms. Shelton, and Ms. Turner, the Hearing Officer concludes that the discrepancy between STUDENT’s ability and achievement are a result of his various processing deficits, particularly his attention problems, and not the result of environmental or economic factors.
With regard to the third criterion for a specific learning disability, the evidence established that STUDENT’s discrepancy cannot be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program. From the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year, the District provided STUDENT with many interventions to assist him in his regular education environment. However, STUDENT’s academic difficulties have persisted despite his receiving such interventions. For example, in September 1999, the District placed STUDENT in Ms. Turner’s first/second grade class for language arts to assist STUDENT in reading because Ms. Turner had significant training in teaching reading skills, and she focused her instruction on building foundational reading skills. In Ms. Turner’s class, STUDENT was provided with small-group instruction and individual attention, and he was paired up with a student who would model reading and writing. Ms. Turner testified that none of the interventions worked with STUDENT and he did not progress significantly in these areas.
While STUDENT was in Ms. Shelton’s class during the 1999-2000 school year, Ms. Shelton spent much of her time helping STUDENT manage his behaviors and his time so that he would stay on task. Ms. Shelton also supervised STUDENT closely and instructed him individually and in small groups. In addition, Ms. Shelton provided STUDENT with positive reinforcement to help his self-esteem, and modified his assignments and tests so that STUDENT could experience some academic success. Despite Ms. Shelton’s interventions, STUDENT continued to have difficulty in class. At the end of the school year, because of STUDENT’s academic difficulties, Ms. Shelton recommended that STUDENT attend summer school and that he be retained in the third grade.
Moreover, Mr. Cudog implemented many of the same interventions employed in the classes of Ms. Turner and Ms. Shelton. Mr. Cudog gave STUDENT small-group instruction and opportunities to model other students. Mr. Cudog also broke down his instructions so that they were clearly defined, repeated his instructions, and modeled each step of what he expected STUDENT to do. Additionally, to help STUDENT retain what he learned, Mr. Cudog would repeat the same types of assignments. Furthermore, STUDENT was placed in an after-school program where he received extra help on his homework and class assignments. According to Mr. Cudog, even with the interventions, STUDENT was unable to learn and retain information. Given STUDENT’s inability to progress in class despite the numerous interventions provided, it is found that STUDENT’s discrepancy cannot be adequately addressed in a regular education environment.
In summary, STUDENT exhibits a significant discrepancy between his intellectual ability and achievement in the areas of reading and written language. Additionally, STUDENT’s discrepancies are due to his auditory processing, visual/motor processing, and attention deficits. Moreover, STUDENT’s discrepancy cannot be corrected through services in the regular instructional program. Therefore, STUDENT meets the three criteria for special education eligibility as a student who is learning disabled.
B. Emotional Disturbance
Federal and State law provide that a student qualifies for special education services if, because of a serious emotional disturbance, a pupil exhibits one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree, which adversely affect educational performance:
(1) An inability to learn which cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors.
(2) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers.
(3) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances. (4) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. (5) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.
34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4)(i); 5 C.C.R. ' 3030(i). California regulations add that any inappropriate types of behaviors or feelings under normal circumstances must be “exhibited in several situations.” 5 C.C.R. § 3030(i)(3). A student does not meet special education eligibility criteria as SED, if he or she is “socially maladjusted,” unless it is determined that the student has an emotional disturbance. 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4)(ii).
The District asserts that the Student qualifies for special education under only the first three criteria: (1) an inability to learn which cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors, (2) an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers, and (3) the exhibiting of inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances in several situations. The evidence does not support the District’s contentions.
To establish STUDENT’s special education eligibility under the first criterion, the District presented evidence, as discussed above, that STUDENT was unable to progress in class despite many interventions employed by his teachers. The District also presented evidence that STUDENT is disruptive in class, makes noises in class, and is occasionally aggressive with other students. While such evidence establishes that STUDENT has difficulty learning and exhibits certain negative behaviors, it does not establish that his inability to learn is the result of an emotional problem. As found above, STUDENT’s educational difficulties are largely due to his specific learning disability and attention deficits. Specifically, Mr. Cudog, Ms. Turner, and Ms. Shelton all testified that STUDENT’s academic performance was impacted by his inability to attend in class. According to Mr. Cudog, STUDENT’s educational problems were mainly a result of his problems with focusing, attending, and following through with an assignment. Although STUDENT exhibited behaviors such as restlessness, “fiddling” with toys and his fingers, and disruption, there is no evidence that such behaviors are a result of an emotional problem rather than his attention problems. Because STUDENT’s inability to learn can be explained by his attention problems and processing deficits, STUDENT does not qualify for special education and related services under this criterion.To establish STUDENT’s eligibility for special education under the second criterion (i.e., an inability to maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers), Dr. Lee testified that STUDENT has difficulty interacting and communicating with other children appropriately because of his language delays. Additionally, as was noted above, Ms. Shelton testified that STUDENT sometimes becomes aggressive with other students. While the District’s evidence indicates that STUDENT has some social problems, it does not indicate that STUDENT is unable to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers. Rather, when questioned by MOTHER, Ms. Turner testified that STUDENT was able to maintain a satisfactory interpersonal relationship with her. Mr. Cudog and Ms. Shelton also testified that STUDENT was able to get along well with them. Additionally, Ms. Shelton and MOTHER both testified that STUDENT had friends at school. On the basis of this evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT was able to maintain satisfactory relationships with his teachers and peers. Therefore, STUDENT also does not qualify for special education under this criterion.
To establish STUDENT’s special education eligibility under the third criterion regarding inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations, the District offered STUDENT’s behavioral assessment, which indicates very significant interpersonal problems and depression based on the results of the Devereaux Beheavior Scales. The District also presented the testimony of Ms. Turner and Ms. Shelton that STUDENT made noises in class and that he shoved, pinched, and stomped on other children’s feet. Furthermore, Dr. Lee testified as to her conclusion based on STUDENT’s assessments that he was emotionally disturbed. While STUDENT’s assessment scores and classroom behavior are troubling, they alone do not establish that STUDENT exhibits inappropriate behaviors or feelings in several situations. There was no evidence that the behaviors STUDENT exhibited were greatly outside of the norm of behaviors for other children his age. Additionally, there was no evidence that STUDENT exhibited inappropriate behaviors in any other situation outside of the school environment. Therefore, the evidence does not support STUDENT’s eligibility for special education under this criterion.
In summary, STUDENT does not meet any of the asserted criteria for eligibility for special education as a student who is emotionally disturbed.
****
In conclusion, while STUDENT does not satisfy the criteria for special education eligibility as a child who is emotionally disturbed, STUDENT meets the eligibility criteria as a student who is learning disabled. Therefore, STUDENT is eligible to receive special education and related services.
II. If yes, did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) pursuant to the August 31, 2000 IEP?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Education Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).
“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25). The term “related services” includes transportation and other services that may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). California Education Code § 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”
To determine whether the District provided STUDENT a free appropriate public education, one must focus on the adequacy of Respondent’s program. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F. 2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Rowley, 458 at 207-208.
To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program must have met the following four requirements in order to have constituted an appropriate educational program: (1) been designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, (2) been reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, and (3) must comport with his IEP.
A. Designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs
To determine whether the placement offered by the District is designed to meet STUDENT’s needs, it is first necessary to determine what STUDENT’s unique and individual needs are. As was found above, STUDENT qualifies for special education with a learning disability in the areas of reading and writing. Additionally, STUDENT has an auditory processing deficit that affects his ability to understand and follow directions, a visual-motor processing deficit that affects his ability to read and write, and an attention deficit that affects his ability to focus and stay on task. As described by Ms. Shelton and Ms. Turner, STUDENT has difficulty connecting letters to sounds and is only able to read at the kindergarten to pre-primer level, two years below his grade level. Furthermore, STUDENT has great difficulty composing and writing and his writing abilities also fall at the kindergarten to pre-primer level.
As discussed above, STUDENT’s teachers tried a number of interventions to assist him to learn. Such interventions included placing him in a lower-level language arts class, providing him with a model, providing him with small-group and individual instruction, providing him with positive reinforcement and feedback, breaking down and repeating instructions, and presenting instructions multi-modally.
Having tried the interventions with STUDENT in the classroom, STUDENT’s teachers testified as to what he needed in order to learn. Ms. Turner, Mr. Cudog, and Ms. Shelton all agreed that STUDENT requires small-group instruction and individualized attention for most of his academic instruction time. They all also agreed that STUDENT requires close supervision to help him focus on his assignments and to manage his time. According to STUDENT’s teachers, STUDENT exhibited many behaviors such as restlessness, aggression, and disruption when he became frustrated with his assignments and when he became distracted. Thus, the small-group instruction, individualized attention, and close supervision would serve to keep STUDENT on task and to manage his behaviors so that he could learn.
In summary, STUDENT requires special education and related services to address his learning deficits in the areas of reading and writing. Because of STUDENT’s processing problems, STUDENT needs to be taught in a structured environment in small groups and individualized attention and close supervision.
To address STUDENT’s needs, the District proposed seven goals and objectives in the August 2000 IEP: (1) to remain on task, (2) to produce three written sentences, (3) to initiate writing in his daily journal, (4) to orally reproduce consonant sounds for letters S, M, T, D, and F, (5) to add single numbers 1 to 9 correctly 9 out of 10 times, (6) to auditorily discrimate the long and short vowels sounds, and (7) to improve oral vocabulary skills. Additionally, the District proposed to provide STUDENT with forty-five 30-minute sessions of speech therapy per year. Moreover, the District proposed to place STUDENT in Ms. Fears’ special day class at Clover Flat Elementary School. Ms. Fears’ class currently consists of nine students, who are supervised by her and two aides. Of the nine children in Ms. Fears’ class, approximately six are learning disabled, one has Down Syndrome, and two are autistic. According to the IEP, STUDENT is to attend Ms. Fears’ class for the first half of his school day, and he is to attend regular education classes during the afternoons.
In light of STUDENT’s deficits, the evidence established that the District’s offered program is appropriate to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs. First, the goals and objectives written for STUDENT address each of his areas of need. These goals and objectives included one goal to increase STUDENT’s attention and focus to task, two goals to improve his writing, two goals to improve his ability to produce and discriminate between consonant and vowel sounds, and one goal to improve his oral vocabulary. Second, to address STUDENT’s language problems, the District appropriately offered to provide him with additional speech therapy. As acknowledged by MOTHER, STUDENT has benefited from the speech therapy that he received within the District and the therapy has improved his language skills. Third, placement in Ms. Fears’ class is appropriate to provide him with the small-group instruction, individual attention, and freedom from distractibility that STUDENT requires. As noted above, there is one adult to every three children in Ms. Fears’ class, and the physical layout of her class is divided into workstations so as to minimize distractions. Furthermore, similar to STUDENT, many of the other children in Ms. Fears’ class are also learning disabled. Hence, the instruction in Ms. Fears’ class would be tailored to address STUDENT’s learning difficulties. Lastly, the mainstreaming opportunities in the afternoon offered by the District would enable STUDENT to interact with his regular education peers and work on his social skills.
In summary, the District has offered appropriate goals and objectives, speech services, and an educational placement to address STUDENT’s educational deficits. Therefore, the District’s August 2000 IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs.
B. Reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit
To be appropriate under the IDEA, the District’s proposed program must have been reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 200. While this requires a school district to provide a disabled child with meaningful access to education, it does not mean that the school district is required to guarantee totally successful results. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998). De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Id. at 130. Rather, a child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997).
According to Ms. Turner, Mr. Cudog, and Ms. Shelton, STUDENT was unable to make significant progress in the regular education environment because he became frustrated when he could not perform at the level of the other students and he required more individualized attention than they were able to provide him in their classes. Most telling of STUDENT’s educational difficulties was STUDENT’s inability to progress in Ms. Turner’s first/second grade class for language arts despite being instructed with students closer to his skill level. Therefore, an educational placement where he would receive individualized instruction and services tailored to address his level of learning is necessary for STUDENT to benefit from his education.
The goals and objectives offered by the District are designed for STUDENT’s ability level. For example, Ms. Turner and Ms. Shelton testified that STUDENT has difficulty connecting letters to sounds. Included in the IEP are goals and objectives to improve STUDENT’s ability to distinguish and produce consonant and vowel sounds. As another example, Mr. Cudog and Ms. Shelton testified that STUDENT has an attention span of only a few minutes. Included in the District’s offered program are a goal and objective that seek to increase STUDENT’s ability to focus and attend. In light of the fact that the goals and objectives take into account STUDENT’s deficits and seek to build on his skills, such goals and objectives are reasonably calculated to confer STUDENT with educational benefit.
With regard to the individualized attention that STUDENT requires to learn, the District’s placement in Ms. Fears’ class offers STUDENT the opportunity to be instructed in a small-group setting. Because Ms. Fears’ class has a high teacher-to-student ratio, it is reasonable to conclude that STUDENT would also receive more individualized attention regarding his language deficits than he could receive in his regular education environment. Because Ms. Fears’ class offers STUDENT small-group and individual attention, STUDENT could reasonably be expected to be able to learn in such an environment. For the above reasons, the District’s offered educational program is reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit.
C. Comported with his IEP
This standard was designed to determine if the student’s IEP was appropriately implemented. Because STUDENT was not available for the educational placement offered by the District, this standard is irrelevant to determining whether the District offered him a FAPE.
**** In conclusion, the District’s offered program is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs, and is reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. Because STUDENT has not been available for the District’s program, it is irrelevant to the FAPE analysis whether STUDENT’s educational program comported with the IEP. On basis of the findings above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offered program contained in the August 2000 IEP is an offer of FAPE.
III. May the District implement the August 31, 2000 IEP without parental consent to receive services?
The District’s final issue requires the Hearing Office to make a legal finding apart from the facts of this case. Specifically, the District seeks the Hearing Office to determine whether the District may implement its recommended special education program over MOTHER’s refusal of consent for such program. The Hearing Officer finds that the law does in fact allow local educational agencies to use the due process hearing procedures to override a parent’s refusal of consent for special education services.
The IDEA requires that informed parental consent must be obtained before (1) conducting an initial evaluation or reevaluation and (2) initially placing a child with disabilities in a program providing special education and related services. 34 C.F.R. § 300.505(a)(1). While the IDEA specifically limited the parental consent requirement only to these two situations, subsection (d) of the same provision allows states to adopt additional parental consent requirements for “other services and activities” if the state also adopts and implements procedures to “ensure that a parent’s refusal to consent does not result in a failure to provide the child with FAPE.” Therefore, federal law requires states to balance a parent’s right to consent to services for his or her child with the local educational agency’s duty to provide the child with a free appropriate public education.
In California, law was adopted that requires local educational agencies to obtain written parental consent for all or part of an IEP before a child is “required to participate in all or part of any special education program.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(a). Thus, California law broadened the federal consent requirements to require local educational agencies to obtain written parental consent before any placement in all or part of a special education program, not just for initial placements. If a parent consents to only part of a special education placement, the local educational agency must implement the parts of the placement to which the parent has consented. Id.
In situations where a parent refuses consent for all or part of a program, such as in this case, California law requires local educational agencies to take steps to ensure that the child receives a free appropriate public education. Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(b). If the local educational agency determines that the portions of the program to which the parent did not consent, or all of the program, if the parent did not consent to any part of the IEP, is necessary to provide the child with a free appropriate public education, the local educational agency is required to initiate due process hearing procedures to override the parent’s refusal of consent. Id. During the pendency of the hearing, the local educational agency may try to resolve the disagreement informally by convening a parent conference or by participating in mediation. However, if the matter goes to hearing, the parties are bound by the decision resulting from the case. Id. Therefore, if the Hearing Officer determines that all or any part of the IEP to which the parent did not consent is required for the child to receive a free appropriate public education, those portions of the IEP may be implemented over the parent’s refusal of consent.(Footnote 8)
In this case, MOTHER has refused consent to place STUDENT in any special education program, including the program contained in the August 31, 2000 IEP. As was found above, STUDENT is eligible for special education and related services and cannot progress in solely a regular education environment. Additionally, it was found above that the educational program offered by the District in the IEP is designed to meet his unique and individual needs and is reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. Because STUDENT requires this placement in order to receive a free appropriate public education, the District may implement the program over MOTHER’s refusal of consent.
ORDER
The District may implement the August 31, 2000 IEP over MOTHER’s refusal of consent.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code ' 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
I. Is STUDENT eligible for special education and related services? -The District prevailed on this issue.
II. If yes, did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) pursuant to the August 31, 2000 IEP? -The District prevailed on this issue.
III. May the District implement the August 31, 2000 IEP without parental consent to receive services? -The District prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code ' 56505(i).
DATED: January 12, 2001 ____________________________________ Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnote 1: The issues listed here differ in numbering and content than those noticed by Petitioner at the hearing. Changes were made for the purposes of clarification and appropriate analysis. Footnote 2: The only information regarding the District’s provision of speech and language services in the December 2, 1999 IEP came from the testimony of Dr. Bronwyn Lee, who speculated that such services must have been continued from STUDENT’s previous Sacramento IEP. Footnote 3: STUDENT’s January 24, 2000 IEP is contained in the case file, and not in the evidence packets of either parties. Footnote 4: Ms. Fears testified that her special day class at Clover Flat Elementary School is an “integrated program,” where special education services are provided during the morning session and the children are mainstreamed for the remaining portions of the day. Footnote 5: The Ninth Circuit court in Union School District v. Smith, requires that school districts make a formal, written offer of placement in compliance with the IDEA=s procedural requirements. Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert denied, 513 U.S. 965, 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994); see also 20 U.S.C. ' 1415(b)(3) (1997). In Union, the Ninth Circuit stated, AWe find that this formal requirement has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe it should be enforced rigorously.@ Union, 15 F.3d at 1526. The Court went on to discuss the reasons for imposing the requirement: (1) to alert the parents of the need to consider seriously whether the school district=s proposed placement is appropriate under the IDEA; (2) to help the parents determine whether to oppose or accept the placement with supplemental services; and (3) so that the school district is more prepared to introduce sufficient relevant evidence of the appropriateness of the placement at a due process hearing. Id. Footnote 6: While section 300.345 of the federal regulations required the District to take steps to ensure that STUDENT’s parent was a part of the team that developed his educational program, the Hearing Officer concludes that MOTHER’s absence from the August 31 meeting did not result in a substantive violation of STUDENT’s educational rights. The record indicates that MOTHER has continually refused any special education placement for STUDENT. At the January 2000 IEP meeting, MOTHER disagreed with the District’s conclusion that STUDENT was eligible for special education, and she refused all special education services. Rather than staying at the IEP meeting to further discuss STUDENT’s educational needs, MOTHER left the IEP meeting before the meeting concluded. Additionally, MOTHER requested a due process hearing to seek a determination that STUDENT is not required to be placed in special education. Even after MOTHER was provided with the August IEP, she continued to dispute special education eligibility and to refuse special education services and placement. While MOTHER could have used the due process hearing to express her objections to the August IEP, she withdrew the case before the hearing convened. Furthermore, she never made any attempts to communicate with the District to discuss any part of the August IEP. Therefore, MOTHER has had ample opportunity to take part in the development of STUDENT’s IEP, but she has chosen not to. Although the District does not appear to have invited MOTHER to the August meeting, no prejudice resulted from the procedural violation. Hence, the District’s procedural violation is merely technical, and is not a substantive violation of STUDENT’s rights. Footnote 7: An article in the California School Psychologist calls into question this practice. Helm and Johnson, “Updated Tables Needed to Determine a Severe Discrepancy Under California's Title 5 Regulations,” 8 Cal. Sch. Psychologist 19 (1998). According to this article, the formula must take into account the correlation between the specific ability and achievement tests used (by computing the correlation coefficient, r) rather than merely calculating simple differences between scores. The authors set forth tables showing standard criterion values for specific cognitive and achievement tests, based upon the correlation between the tests, and give the standard error of measurement to be applied. However, there is no known corroboration of the data, and the utility of the data provided is seriously limited. For example, no information is provided for the WJ-R Broad Written Language score in comparison with a WISC-III IQ, no data are presented for the Stanford-Binet, and the WRAT-3 data are based upon "combined" standard scores which require administration of both Blue and Tan forms. At the hearing, no evidence was presented which applied the method presented in this article to the specific tests given to STUDENT. Moreover, the federal statute and regulations do not require a specified numerical difference in scores for a severe discrepancy. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(26); 34 C.F.R. § 300.541. Therefore, the methods set forth in California Code of Regulations, Title 5, Section 3030(j), including use of the 22.5 point discrepancy, will be applied here. Footnote 8: The Hearing Officer notes that California Education Code § 48200 provides that all children between the ages of 6 and 18, not otherwise exempt, are subject to compulsory education. The IDEA acknowledges parents’ right to place their child in a private schools as a matter of educational preference rather than placing the child at the public school. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10). In such a situation, the parents could avoid the placement of their child in the public school special education program by taking the responsibility for the child’s education out of the hands of the local educational agency. In light of California law requiring local educational agencies to override parents’ refusal of consent for special education services and the duty of local educational agencies to provide its disabled students with a free appropriate public education, parents are left with the choice to either allow their child to be placed in the public special education program determined by a Hearing Officer to be necessary for the child to receive a FAPE, or to remove the child from the responsibility of the local educational agency by placing the child in a private school or otherwise.
