California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 27, 2000
Student v. Gateway Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1661-00 · Hearing Officer Deborah M. Cooke
Gateway Unified may reassess a six-year-old without parental consent; Hearing Officer finds a FAPE denial but rejects residential placement.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted. Footnote 5 says the question of using the Diagnostic Center, Northern California for the assessment became moot after the student missed the November 14-15, 2000 appointment.
Summary
A parent filed for hearing against Gateway Unified School District in September 2000 on behalf of her six-year-old son. His IEPs listed four categories as primary disabilities: mental retardation, other health impairment, autism, and multiple disabilities. No IEP team had settled on one, and the parties disagreed about whether he was autistic. He attended a learning handicapped special day class at Buckeye Elementary School. The mother had refused consent to a district reassessment, so the district asked for an order allowing it to assess.
Hearing Officer Deborah M. Cooke ruled that the district could assess without consent. She pointed to the student's lack of progress, his unmet goals, and the need to identify his primary disability. She also found that the district's September 18, 2000 assessment plan met legal requirements. She further held that the district denied a FAPE in 2000-2001. Most district witnesses, including his own teacher, Matthew Diskin, said the class did not fit his needs and was not giving him educational benefit. The district also provided no occupational therapy (OT) that year, even though his last signed IEP still required it. Claims about adapted physical education, speech, toilet training, and a one-on-one aide failed. The IEP either did not include those services or the district had provided them. The request for a residential autism-specific nonpublic school was denied. The order required new assessments and an IEP meeting within 14 days of receiving the reports. No compensatory services were ordered.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO handled a district's request to reassess over a parent's objection. A student's lack of progress and an unclear primary disability supported assessing without consent. Even after finding a FAPE denial, the Hearing Officer left the choice of placement to the IEP team after assessment rather than ordering the parent's preferred residential placement.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedDistrict-filed: assess without consent
Issue 1. Should the District be authorized to conduct a formal evaluation of STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability?
Because the student was not progressing, was not meeting his goals, and had no identified primary disability, a full reassessment was warranted. The district's September 18, 2000 assessment plan met legal requirements, so the district could assess without parental consent.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2000-2001 school year?
The district denied FAPE for 2000-2001. The special day class placement was not designed for his needs or reasonably calculated to give educational benefit, and the district provided no OT required by the November 9, 1999 IEP. Claims that APE, speech, intensive toilet training, and a one-on-one aide were not provided failed.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 3. Should STUDENT be temporarily placed in a residential nonpublic school whose program is autism-specific and which includes an applied behavioral analysis model, intensive toilet training and hygiene, and appropriate academics, and then later be mainstreamed with regular education students?
The requested residential nonpublic school placement was denied. The parent's only witness had not met or observed the student and did not support that placement. The IEP team should decide placement after reviewing the new assessments.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order that district may assess without consent. The District may assess the student under its September 18, 2000 assessment plan (Respondent's Exhibit 9), in compliance with Education Code section 56320 et seq. The mother must make the student available to the District and its assessors.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 14 days of receiving all completed assessment reports, not counting school holidays, the District must hold an IEP meeting. The new IEP must be consistent with the reports and set appropriate goals and objectives, services, and placement.
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District; M.C. v. Central Regional School District; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education; Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16; 20 U.S.C. § 1414(c)(3); Education Code §§ 56320, 56321, 56381
People named in the decision
- Matthew Diskin, special day class teacher, Buckeye Elementary School, Gateway Unified School District
- Suzanne Cresswell, occupational therapist (nonpublic agency provider), Cresswell Clinic
- Wendy Sanders, school psychologist, Shasta County Office of Education
- Joyce Bianchini, principal, Buckeye Elementary School
- Don Gilmer, speech-language pathologist, Gateway Unified School District
- Kandis Lighthall, program specialist, Shasta County Office of Education / Shasta County SELPA
- Patty Mancuso, school nurse, Buckeye Elementary School
- Chris White, adapted physical education instructor, Gateway Unified School District
- Stephanie Gosling, adapted physical education instructor, Gateway Unified School District
- John Cunnion, former special education director, Gateway Unified School District
- Susan Christensen, special education director and District representative, Gateway Unified School District
- Bobbie Groves, program specialist, Shasta County SELPA
- Neal Sternberg, executive director; witness for Student, Victor Youth Services, North Valley School
- Mary Louise Bland, staff psychologist (prior psychological evaluation), Tri-Counties Regional Center
- Danny Morris, regional center service coordinator, Far Northern Regional Center
- Roberta Wallace, completed student needs rubric (role not stated)
- Nola R. Marx, physician (prior pediatric neurodevelopmental evaluations)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Redding, California on October 12, 13, 24, and 25, 2000.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by his mother, Ms. PARENT. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf during portions of the hearing was Mr. Danny Morris, STUDENT’s service coordinator from Far Northern Regional Center. Respondent Gateway Unified School District (District) was represented by Ms. Susan Christensen, director of special education for the District.
The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: Ms. PARENT and Mr. Neal Sternberg, executive director of the Victor Youth Services, North Valley School.
The following witnesses were called by the District to testify: Matthew Diskin, STUDENT’s special day class teacher at Buckeye Elementary School; Suzanne Cresswell, occupational therapist; Wendy Sanders, school psychologist for the Shasta County Office of Education; Joyce Bianchini, principal of Buckeye Elementary School; Don Gilmer, speech pathologist for the District; Kandis Lighthall, program specialist for Shasta County Office of Education and the Shasta County Special Education Local Plan Area (SELPA); Patty Mancuso, school nurse at Buckeye Elementary School; Chris White, adapted physical education instructor for the District; John Cunnion, former special education director for the District; Susan Christensen, current special education director for the District; and Bobbie Groves, program specialist for Shasta County SELPA.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of closing arguments. Written closing arguments were received from both parties, the record was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES(Footnote 1)
1. Should the District be authorized to conduct a formal evaluation of STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability?
2. Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2000-2001 school year?
3. Should STUDENT be temporarily placed in a residential nonpublic school whose program is autism-specific and which includes an applied behavioral analysis model, intensive toilet training and hygiene, and appropriate academics, and then later be mainstreamed with regular education students?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a six-year-old student who lives with his mother, PARENT, and his two siblings. STUDENT’s family moved from Santa Barbara, California, into the jurisdictional boundaries of the District in August 1999. STUDENT currently attends Buckeye Elementary School (Buckeye) and since the fall of 1999 has attended a kindergarten through fifth grade (K-5) learning handicapped, special day class (LH-SDC) taught by Matthew Diskin. He has been found eligible by the District for special education services as a student with mental retardation, other health impairment, autism, and multiple disabilities.
STUDENT has been given several diagnoses over time, including, pervasive development disorder - not otherwise specified (PDD-NOS), which is a form of autistic spectrum disorder, developmental delays, seizure disorder, cerebral palsy, congenital cataracts (which were removed in February 1999), attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), prenatal/congenital encephalopathy with delays in language and motor skills-hypertonicity/dystonic posture, mild mental retardation, and autism.
STUDENT entered the District with an IEP dated June 1, 1999, from Santa Barbara County, where he was previously found eligible to receive special education services. STUDENT’s special education eligibility categories then included mild mental retardation, language/speech impaired, other health impaired and developmental delay. STUDENT’s program in Santa Barbara included placement in a special day class with the related services of adapted physical education (APE), occupational therapy (OT), and speech and language. On August 31, 1999, STUDENT was given an administrative interim placement in the District’s special day class at Buckeye Elementary School.
Between August and September 1999, Petitioner’s mother visited a severely handicapped special day class at Shasta Meadows Elementary School (Shasta Meadows) on three separate occasions. On one of those occasions, she was accompanied by Bobbie Groves, the program specialist for Shasta County special education local plan area. The Shasta Meadows class was a county-run program that comprised kindergarten and first grade students with developmental delays such as autism, and physical disabilities. PARENT testified that she believed the students in that class had “extreme disabilities” and were low functioning and nonverbal.
PARENT also visited a noncategorical special day class at Columbia Elementary School (Columbia) on one occasion, along with Bobbie Groves. Both PARENT and Ms. Groves testified that the student population in that class seemed younger, the atmosphere quieter, and the curriculum more age-appropriate for STUDENT. PARENT testified that she clearly expressed to Bobbie Groves that she wanted STUDENT to attend Columbia, but that the District refused to provide transportation for STUDENT to Columbia, which was a thirty-minute trip each way, to and from home. Not being able to commit to transporting STUDENT to and from school, PARENT did not insist on STUDENT’s attending Columbia.
John Cunnion, who was the special education director at the time of the November 9, 1999 IEP meeting, testified that attendance at Columbia was not offered because the SDC teacher at Columbia observed Mr. Diskin’s program and observed STUDENT in Mr. Diskin’s class and determined that Mr. Diskin’s program was equivalent to her program at Columbia. Therefore, the District did not offer STUDENT the SDC program at Columbia because it had an equivalent program in the District at STUDENT’s home school. According to Mr. Cunnion, the District considered other programs; however, it did not offer STUDENT any other programs.
Bobbie Groves, however, testified that the District offered Columbia as an option for STUDENT, along with transportation - stating that she believed that the District offered to pay PARENT for mileage to transport STUDENT herself, in lieu of the District transporting STUDENT. Ms. Groves testified that she may have left PARENT a message at home regarding transportation, but that the message may have been cryptic, and thus caused some confusion regarding the transportation issue. Ms. Groves also testified that there were other severely handicapped special day classes that PARENT could have been shown; however, she was unsure why those classes were not visited and stated that she may have forgotten to tell PARENT about the other classes.
On September 28, 1999, an initial IEP meeting was held, at which time the IEP team reviewed STUDENT’s 30-day placement and decided that STUDENT would remain in Matthew Diskin’s special day class at Buckeye with designated instructional services (DIS) of speech, APE, and OT. The categories of mental retardation, other health impairment, autism, and multiple disabilities were all marked as STUDENT’s primary disabilities. The September 28, 1999 IEP incorporated past goals and objectives from STUDENT’s then-current IEP dated June 1, 1999, from Santa Barbara. An assessment plan was devised at that meeting recommending speech and language and APE assessments. PARENT signed the September 28, 1999 assessment plan in agreement. In October 1999, assessment observations were conducted and reports generated by Don Gilmer, the District’s speech and language pathologist, and Chris White, the District’s APE specialist. Informal observation assessments were performed by Matthew Diskin, the special day class teacher at Buckeye.
A second IEP meeting was held on November 9, 1999, for the purpose of modifying the annual review date and reviewing STUDENT’s progress from the September 28, 1999 IEP. This was the last signed and implemented IEP for STUDENT. Annual goals and benchmarks were developed in language arts, math, and APE. STUDENT’s placement remained in the Buckeye Elementary special day class. The following DIS services were to be received: thirty minutes of APE, one time a week; twenty minutes of speech, two times a week; and OT. No specific time was specified on the IEP for OT; however, it was noted on the IEP that services would be received in Susan Cresswell’s office and the District would provide STUDENT’s transportation to OT and then to his home. Again, the same four areas of primary disability were marked on the IEP: mental retardation, other health impairment, autism and multiple disabilities. A referral for individual aide support was also made.(Footnote 2)
PARENT testified that at the November 9, 1999 IEP meeting, STUDENT was given the choice of placement in Mr. Diskin’s special day class at Buckeye or the special day class at Shasta Meadows. Mr. Diskin’s special day class contained students from kindergarten through fifth grade, all of whom were learning disabled. Students presently in the class are all learning disabled and are also classified as either seriously emotionally disturbed, speech impaired, or mentally retarded, and some have traumatic brain injury. STUDENT was not classified as learning disabled. However, STUDENT spent the 1999-2000 school year in Mr. Diskin’s class with the related services noted above.
In June 2000, PARENT requested an IEP meeting, at which the IEP team reviewed her concerns as submitted in a document dated June 2, 2000. (Respondent’s Exh. 4.) PARENT requested that STUDENT be given a comprehensive assessment of not less than three days in duration so as to develop educational goals. She also requested that the evaluation be executed by a trained specialist in autism and suggested three different places where this could be done: the Fremont Diagnostic Center(Footnote 3), Oakland Children’s Hospital (Autism Unit), or Stanford University. PARENT also requested that STUDENT receive intensive behavioral treatment of thirty hours or more per week for a limited time as prescribed by the autism assessment and a one-on-one personal aide. She requested that STUDENT be placed in a full inclusion mainstream kindergarten full-day program and asked that all assessments be completed and services ready for implementation on the first day of the 2000-2001 school year.
The IEP team decided at that meeting to refer STUDENT to the Diagnostic Center of Northern California (DCNC) for a complete assessment. A key question to be answered from the assessment was the nature of STUDENT’s primary handicapping condition. The District also offered to provide additional aide time on a temporary basis until the assessment was completed to help implement toilet training. The IEP team felt that it needed additional data in order to review and determine possible adjustments to STUDENT’s curriculum and placement. As a result of that meeting, a referral was made to the DCNC. The IEP team also offered to conduct a curriculum assessment led by the program specialist. A curriculum assessment includes observing a student’s skills and behaviors in a number of different areas, such as their general knowledge and reasoning, language, and fine and gross motor tasks. This assessment tool assists the teacher in developing a more comprehensive program for the student. Additionally, based on a recommendation by STUDENT’s occupational therapist, Susan Cresswell, the IEP team decided to discontinue OT services pending any further assessment data. PARENT declined to sign the June 2, 2000 IEP document.
Subsequently, STUDENT spent the summer in Texas. In a letter dated August 6, 2000, PARENT requested that STUDENT’s OT services resume immediately upon STUDENT’s return to the area, and that Suzanne Cresswell, or another licensed occupational therapist, address STUDENT’s fine motor skills, particularly those that impeded toilet training.
The District responded to PARENT’ request to resume OT by contacting Suzanne Cresswell and requesting that she reconsider her decision to terminate services to STUDENT. Ms. Cresswell arranged another evaluation of STUDENT, which took place on September 15, 2000. Based on that evaluation, Ms. Cresswell agreed to again begin service to STUDENT using a consultative model for OT services by which she would work with STUDENT and school personnel in the school setting. Ms. Cresswell developed OT-related academic goals and suggested an initial OT schedule of two times per month for three months, and then one time a month for the remainder of the school year. At the time of hearing, these new OT services had not yet begun for the 2000-2001 school year, according to the District, because of the District’s inability to convene the IEP team to discuss the change in OT goals and location of program. (Respondent’s closing statement.)
STUDENT started the 2000-2001 school year with the IEP dated November 9, 1999, in place. Despite PARENT’s refusal to sign the IEP dated June 2, 2000, the District proceeded with planning for the 2000-2001 school year, which included completing the referral to the Diagnostic Center in Fremont, completing a curriculum assessment performed by Mr. Diskin and the SELPA program specialist, and increasing aide time to help with STUDENT’s toileting and other issues. The District informed PARENT of its intent to proceed with these matters in a letter dated August 14, 2000, from Susan Christensen, the current director of special education for the District. STUDENT was accepted for a center-based assessment at DCNC; however, DCNC advised PARENT that the evaluation could not be conducted until November 14 and 15, 2000. PARENT expressed concerns regarding the late timing of the assessment and the fact that a written report would not be available until January 2001.
In response to PARENT’s objection to using DCNC for assessment, on September 18, 2000, the District offered to complete its own evaluation in order to better understand STUDENT’s primary handicapping issues and his ability to progress toward curricular goals. The assessment plan called for evaluation in the following areas of concern: intellectual development, academic achievement, speech and language, adaptive behavior, perceptual and perceptual-motor skills, and health and development. It also called for an observation by the Shasta County autism team. PARENT declined to sign the assessment plan.
The Hearing Office received PARENT’s request for hearing on September 19, 2000. Therein, PARENT alleged that STUDENT is not receiving any of the services stated in his current IEP. The hearing request also stated that she had repeatedly told the District in writing that she would not allow STUDENT to be evaluated by DCNC because of its “notoriously bad reputation.” PARENT’s request for hearing requested that STUDENT receive a comprehensive, unbiased assessment at Oakland Children’s Hospital Autism Unit to assist in generating an appropriate curriculum and practicum strategies.(Footnote 4)
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. Should the District be authorized to conduct a formal evaluation of STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability?
School districts must reevaluate a child with a disability if conditions warrant a reevaluation or if the child’s parent or teacher requests a reevaluation, but at least once every three years. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(2)(A).) Parental consent for a reevaluation of a child with a disability is required before a school district can reassess the child, unless the school district establishes the need to conduct such an assessment at a due process hearing. (California Education Code §§ 56321(c), 56381(f); 20 U.S.C. § 1414(c)(3).)
The District contends that it is required to conduct STUDENT’s assessment because more than 20 months have passed since his last full evaluation and because significant new information has come to light which indicates that a reassessment is required. The District seeks an order authorizing it to conduct a formal evaluation of STUDENT and fulfill its legal obligations despite the parents' lack of consent to assess.
Petitioner’s mother disputes the District’s right to assess, contending that STUDENT has been “assessed ad nauseam” and that “more assessment will never help STUDENT meet his annual goals.” (Petitioner’s closing statement.) PARENT testified that the IEP team had access to the March 1999 psychological evaluation at the November 9, 1999 IEP meeting and that the evaluation diagnosed STUDENT with autism.
STUDENT’s March 1999 psychological evaluation was conducted by Mary Louise Bland, Ph.D, a staff psychologist with the Tri-Counties Regional Center. (Respondent’s Exh. 21.) Ms. Bland did not testify at the hearing; therefore, her report is hearsay. Moreover, there was no evidence that Ms. Bland is a credentialed school psychologist who has had consistent experience working with children with developmental delays, cerebral palsy, autistic spectrum disorders, or ADHD, as is required by California Education Code §§ 56320 and 56324(a).
Susan Christensen testified that Ms. Bland’s March 1999 psychological evaluation was questionable in that although Ms. Bland observed STUDENT, she did not administer tests for autism. There were no normative data relative to autism. John Cunnion also noted that Ms. Bland’s administration of the Standford-Binet Intelligence test failed to yield scores on some of the subtests and there were many estimated scores, which led him to question the validity of the tests.
The evidence established that STUDENT’s primary handicapping condition had not been determined by any IEP team either in Santa Barbara or at the District. Rather, four different disability categories are marked on both of STUDENT’s IEPs of November 9, 1999 and June 1, 1999. STUDENT has received numerous diagnoses over the years. The District has not conducted a comprehensive evaluation, only observation assessments in the areas of speech and language and adapted physical education (APE), and a curriculum assessment conducted by STUDENT’s special day class teacher. (Testimony of Susan Christensen.) Moreover, at the June 2, 2000 IEP meeting, concerns were raised both by Petitioner’s mother and the District regarding the appropriateness of STUDENT’s placement in Matthew Diskin’s special day class and STUDENT’s lack of progress and inability to meet stated goals. (Respondent’s Exh. 4.) The District members of the IEP team believed they did not have a good record of STUDENT’s history and questioned whether STUDENT was truly autistic. The IEP team needed additional data in order to review STUDENT’s curriculum and placement and determine the need to possibly make adjustments. (Testimony of John Cunnion; Respondent’s Exh. 4.) Mr. Cunnion testified that given STUDENT’s young age, his recent surgery, and his multiple needs and handicaps, when progress is not seen, it is necessary to determine the status of his development.
Additionally, Don Gilmer, STUDENT’s speech and language instructor during the 1999-2000 school year and the current school year, testified that when the issue of further assessment was raised towards the end of the 1999-2000 school year, he expressed to John Cunnion that although STUDENT was making sufficient progress in most areas, he felt he needed information so that he could determine the appropriate goals and objectives and implement them effectively. He believed that such information would be helpful for the annual review and in determining the correct direction to take. Mr. Gilmer contended that a good diagnostic work-up done by a team of professionals experienced in dealing with children with multiple handicaps would have a much better chance of answering questions regarding STUDENT’s receptive language difficulties. Mr. Gilmer believed he didn’t have a very good “handle on” STUDENT’s condition. He stated that STUDENT has a hard time following instructions. For instance, when given a two-stage command, STUDENT will not respond to the second item. It is difficult to get STUDENT to shift to different tasks and he is uncertain why STUDENT is not progressing in this area. Mr. Gilmer believes that there may be some instructional methods that he may need to handle differently, and believed that since he does not have the capacity to measure why STUDENT is not progressing, a comprehensive assessment would advise him on methods to use in working with STUDENT and his receptive language problems.
Matthew Diskin, STUDENT’s special day class teacher during the 1999-2000 school year and the current school year, testified that his class was not the appropriate placement for STUDENT and reported that STUDENT was not meeting the goals and objectives listed on his November 9, 1999 IEP. He believes that STUDENT could meet the goals, but that the modalities presently being used are not helping STUDENT. Mr. Diskin reported that STUDENT was not cheerful anymore and now was angry, aggressive, and very stressed. He believed that something has happened since the November 9, 1999 IEP meeting. Mr. Diskin testified that STUDENT was not ready for his special day class because STUDENT had not made the transition to the academic level of the other children in the class. STUDENT was often not “reachable” and he could not gage where STUDENT was in terms of progress.Petitioner and Respondent originally agreed at the June 2, 2000 IEP meeting that STUDENT would be assessed at the Diagnostic Center, Norther California (DCNC). A referral was made to the DCNC, with Petitioner’s mother concurring. (Petitioner’s and Respondent’s closing statements.) The referral requested assistance in determining: (1) STUDENT’s primary handicapping condition; (2) STUDENT’s strengths in the educational setting and the appropriate curriculum to develop his skills; (3) whether STUDENT’s primary issues were cerebral palsy, autism, ADHD, or developmental delays and the best way to address them; (4) whether there was a physical reason why STUDENT could not be toilet-trained; and (5) whether STUDENT needed continued OT. The referral also requested recommendations of some management/training options. (Respondent’s Exh. 28.)(Footnote 5)
After discovering that the DCNC evaluation would not take place until November 14 and 15, 2000, and being told by a contact at Client’s Rights Advocacy that DCNC was not acceptable and that she may have requested the wrong diagnostic center, Petitioner’s mother refused to allow STUDENT to attend the center-based assessment. (Respondent’s Exh. 2.) In response to PARENT’s concerns about the late timing of the November assessment, the District offered to complete its own assessment in order to better understand STUDENT’s primary handicapping issues and his inability to progress towards curricular goals. (Respondent’s closing statement; Respondent’s Exh. 9.)
The District’s September 18, 2000 assessment plan provided to Petitioner’s mother conformed to the requirements of the law. Pursuant to California Education Code § 56321(b), a proposed assessment plan given to the parents shall: (1) be in language that is easily understood by the general public, (2) be provided in the primary language of the parent, (3) explain the types of assessments to be conducted, and (4) state that no individualized education program will result from the assessment without the consent of the parent. The Hearing Officer finds that the assessment plan of September 18, 2000, meets these requirements on its face.
The District's assessment plan proposes to investigate STUDENT for possible autism and to conduct an updated comprehensive assessment in all areas of Petitioner's suspected disabilities, including the areas of intellectual development, academic achievement, speech and language, adaptive behavior, perceptual and perceptual-motor skills, and health and development. There was no evidence to suggest that the assessments would be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory or that they would be administered in a language other than STUDENT's primary language.
Finally, the Hearing Officer notes that the District has taken a number of steps to address PARENT’s concerns, and, to the extent federal law requires input from the parents, the District has considered it. (See 34 C.F.R. § 300.532(b); see also Respondent’s Exh. 1.) The Hearing Officer finds no evidence to suggest that the District was either ignoring or has not considered the input of the family in designing STUDENT’s comprehensive evaluation plan. In fact, it was apparent from Ms. Christensen's testimony that she is acutely aware of PARENT's concerns and is willing to accommodate them to the extent possible, consistent with her professional obligations.
For example, one month before Petitioner filed his request for this hearing, Ms. Christensen responded to a letter written by PARENT to Buckeye’s principal, after having researched PARENT’ concerns and requests. (Respondent’s Exh. 1.) Subsequently, on September 18, 2000, Ms. Christensen met with PARENT for approximately 1½ hours to work with her to develop an assessment plan. (Testimony of S. Christensen.) Ms. Christensen testified that she told PARENT who the psychologist would be and described to her the tests that would be administered. Ms. Christensen also offered to use individuals outside the District for the evaluation if PARENT had a problem with District people.
Based on STUDENT’s lack of sufficient progress, his inability to meet educational goals, and the need to obtain additional information regarding STUDENT’s primary handicapping condition, the Hearing Officer concludes that a comprehensive evaluation is warranted. The District is entitled to conduct a comprehensive assessment of STUDENT without his parent’s consent and his parent must make STUDENT available for the assessment. The District is reminded that although Petitioner has not disputed the proposed assessment measures or personnel noted in its September 18, 2000 evaluation plan, California Education Code §§ 56320(e) and (f) require that STUDENT be assessed in all areas of suspected disability and that no single procedure be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for him. Additionally, the assessments must be conducted by persons competent to perform the assessments, and any psychological assessment must be performed by a credentialed school psychologist. (California Education Code §§ 56322, 56324(a).)
Lastly, STUDENT’s assessment should include interviews of individuals who have worked closely with STUDENT and/or observed him. In particular, STUDENT’s special day class teacher, speech and language therapist, occupational therapist, and adapted physical education specialist, should all be interviewed, as they offered some valuable opinions and information regarding STUDENT’s progress and unique needs.
2. Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2000-2001 school year?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Education Code § 56000.) The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).)
“Special Education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).) The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22).) California Education Code § 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA (now IDEA ‘97). The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. (Id. at 200.) According to Rowley, the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available, or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. (Id. at 198-200.) The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Id. at 201.)
To determine whether the District provided STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE), one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s program. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).) If the District’s program reflected STUDENT’s needs, provided some benefit, and comported with his IEP, the District provided a FAPE, even if the parent preferred another program and even if the parent’s preferred program would have resulted in greater educational benefit. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.) Special education law also requires that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of his disabilities is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services could not have been achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Education Code § 56031.)
To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program for the 2000-2001 school year must have met the following four requirements in order to have constituted an appropriate educational program: (1) been designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs; (2) been reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit; (3) comported with his IEP; and (4) been provided in the least restrictive environment.
In this case, Petitioner disputes that the District provided him a FAPE from the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year to present on two grounds. First, Petitioner contends that his placement in Mr. Diskin’s special day class at Buckeye Elementary School is not designed to meet his needs and has not provided him with educational benefit. And second, Petitioner alleges that the District’s program failed to comport with his November 9, 1999 IEP by failing to provide certain services listed in his IEP, namely, occupational therapy, adapted physical education, speech, an intensive toilet-training program, and a one-on-one shadow aide.
Designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs
The first step in this analysis is to determine what STUDENT’s unique and individual needs are for the 2000-2001 school year. The parties dispute whether STUDENT is autistic. Moreover, the District has been unable to name a single primary handicapping condition for STUDENT, having marked four different disability categories on STUDENT’s November 9, 1999 IEP, including mental retardation, other health impairment, autism and multiple disabilities. Understandably, the District is in a difficult position, not having the benefit of a current, comprehensive assessment because of PARENT’s denial of consent. However, PARENT’s lack of consent does not terminate the District’s duty to provide STUDENT with a FAPE. The Hearing Officer has determined that a comprehensive assessment of STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability is warranted, and acknowledges that information regarding STUDENT’s unique and individual needs is limited, given that much of this information was derived from the possibly outdated IEP of November 9, 1999. However, some information can be gleaned from witness testimony and documentary evidence introduced at the hearing.
At a June 2, 2000 IEP meeting, the IEP team decided to refer STUDENT to the Diagnostic Center, Northern California, for a complete assessment, because they believed they needed additional data in order to determine whether STUDENT’s curriculum and placement should be adjusted. (Respondent’s Exh. 4.)
A March 18, 1999 psychological evaluation had been performed by staff psychologist Mary Louise Bland at the Tri-Counties Regional Center. Ms. Bland did not testify at the hearing; however, her report states that she diagnosed STUDENT with autism, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), and mild mental retardation. (Respondent’s Exh. 21.) There was no testimony regarding STUDENT’s current level of cognitive development. However, the November 9, 1999 IEP states that STUDENT exhibits delays in cognition (mild mental retardation), academics, adaptive behavior, and receptive and expressive behavior. He also showed fine and gross motor delays and demonstrated skills at a pre-kindergarten level. (Respondent’s Exh. 5.)
Mr. Diskin, STUDENT’s special day class teacher, testified that a good starting point in describing STUDENT was as mentally retarded. He believes that there are some impediments to STUDENT’s cognitive abilities. Mr. Diskin’s special day class consists of fourteen students who are in kindergarten through fifth grade, and who all are classified as learning disabled. The students in his class are also either seriously emotionally disturbed, speech impaired, mentally retarded, or have traumatic brain injury. STUDENT, on the other hand, has not been labeled as learning disabled, which is one of the reasons Mr. Diskin believes his class is not appropriate for STUDENT. Mr. Diskin’s class activities include swimming twice a month, bowling once a month, and other activities that allow the students to be out of the classroom as much as possible. Mr. Diskin testified that in teaching his class, he constantly makes exceptions for STUDENT. All of the academics are modified for STUDENT, and Mr. Diskin makes adaptations in other areas at least seven times a day. (Respondent’s Exh. 43.) According to Mr. Diskin, STUDENT is not meeting his November 9, 1999 goals and objectives. He believes STUDENT can meet these goals, but the present modalities are not helping him. Mr. Diskin also testified that STUDENT is not cheerful anymore, but, instead, is angry and aggressive.
In the area of speech and language, STUDENT’s speech and language therapist, Don Gilmer, testified that when observing STUDENT in the kindergarten class during inclusion time, he noted that STUDENT is more intent on communicating. STUDENT is asking for items and asking for attention, and he also knows the other children’s names in the class. STUDENT’s sentence length is now longer than it was one year ago, and STUDENT is trying to involve himself with people and things in a meaningful way. Additionally, STUDENT’s language structures are increasing and becoming more sophisticated. However, Mr. Gilmer also noted that STUDENT is currently less verbal in his special day class, which may be related to all of the stimulation going on in class. There are many variations in STUDENT’s language, depending on the situation he is in. When in large groups, STUDENT does not use much language. Conversely, when in small groups, where STUDENT is participating in an activity that he really enjoys and the environment is highly structured, STUDENT uses much more language.
Adaptively, STUDENT is currently not toilet-trained and wears a diaper. Mr. Diskin testified that the classroom aide checks STUDENT’s diaper every hour, and every two hours places STUDENT on the toilet. STUDENT’s diaper is also checked and changed, if necessary, at recess time. Chris White, STUDENT’s adapted physical education (APE) instructor for the 1999-2000 school year, testified that STUDENT has not met the goals and objectives from the November 9, 1999 IEP. Although STUDENT is jumping with both feet, he cannot jump a distance of two feet.
Ms. Bland’s March 1999 psychological report recommends that STUDENT’s school placement focus on teaching STUDENT appropriate speech, daily living skills, such as dressing and toileting; socialization skills, such as toy play and interaction with other children; and gross and fine motor skills. Mr. Diskin testified that his class does not reflect the recommendations for placement made in the March 18, 1999 psychological report. Mr. Diskin’s class is curriculum-based and not designed for living skills. He does do some life skills activities; however, those activities are not the hallmark of his class. Because of STUDENT’s low cognitive development, Mr. Diskin believed that he was not properly equipped to serve STUDENT.
Bobbie Groves, program specialist for the special education local plan area (SELPA), observed STUDENT in October 1999, and October 2000, and also participated in the November 9, 1999 IEP meeting. Ms. Groves testified that although STUDENT has made some progress in the area of communication, he has not progressed in the area of functional academics - learning to learn. She believes STUDENT needs structure, a small-group setting, and the support from an adult. STUDENT also needs to be with age-appropriate students and students who have good language skills so that he can model their behaviors. STUDENT also needs speech and language services, and since the way he walks and plants his feet appears to be related to his cerebral palsy, APE would benefit him. Ms. Groves testified that some of the county-run programs would be able to address STUDENT’s self-help, behavioral, communication, and functional academic needs. Ms. Groves testified that she was surprised that STUDENT stayed in Mr. Diskin’s class because she did not believe this placement was appropriate for STUDENT. But it was her understanding that PARENT wanted STUDENT to be in Mr. Diskin’s class and that Mr. Diskin believed he could serve STUDENT.
Susan Christensen, the District’s special education director, testified that in her previous experience as a program specialist, a learning handicapped classroom was not the usual setting for a student, like STUDENT, with multiple handicaps She believes that Mr. Diskin’s class is not an appropriate placement for STUDENT. After visiting Mr. Diskin’s classroom, she was persuaded that STUDENT needs more behavioral structures in place and fewer distractions. She believes that a severely handicapped special day class that offers life skills training would be appropriate for STUDENT.
Finally, Mr. Diskin, Mr. Gilmer, and Roberta Wallace each completed a student needs rubric for STUDENT in October 1999. (Respondent’s Exh. 54.) The student needs rubric is a form used to analyze and measure (from one person’s perspective) a student’s needs in the areas of health, personal care, behavior, instruction, and inclusion. A score of “4" indicates the highest level of need for a particular area. Each evaluator gave STUDENT a “4" in the area of instruction, which indicates the following:
Cannot participate in a group without constant 1:1 support. Requires constant verbal and physical prompting to stay on task and follow directions. Regularly requires specific 1:1 instructional strategies to benefit from the individualized educational program. Cognitive abilities and skills require significant accommodation and modification not typical for the class group.
What has been evidenced through testimony and documents is that STUDENT requires a more structured environment with one-on-one instruction and little distractions. Additionally, STUDENT may benefit from a placement where he can have his own separate area and possibly a toilet in the room. In any event, Petitioner and a majority of Respondent’s witnesses question the appropriateness of STUDENT’s placement in Mr. Diskin’s special day class. Although the District did not have an updated comprehensive evaluation to assist them in placing STUDENT, STUDENT’s mother expressed her concern to the District about STUDENT’s placement. Moreover, STUDENT’s teacher and many of the IEP team members believed that this placement was not appropriate.
In summary, STUDENT’s educational needs cannot be provided in Mr. Diskin’s classroom. Based on the above, the District’s placement for STUDENT for the 2000-2001 school year was not designed to meet his unique and individual needs.
Reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit
To be appropriate under the IDEA, the District’s proposed program must have been reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 200.) While this requires a school district to provide a disabled child with meaningful access to education, it does not mean that the school district is required to guarantee totally successful results. (Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998).) De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. (Id., 142 F.3d at 130; M.C. v. Central Regional School District, 81 F.3d 389, 393 (3d Cir. 1996).) Of course, a child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his/her disability and must be gaged in relation to the child’s potential. (Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997); Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16, 853 F.2d 171, 185 (3d Cir. 1988).)
The evidence establishes that the placement offered by the District for the 2000-2001 school year is not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. As indicated above, both Petitioner and Respondent acknowledge that STUDENT is not making progress toward mastering educational goals. (Respondent’s closing brief; Petitioner’s closing brief.) In fact, based on STUDENT’s lack of progress, the IEP team noted at the June 2, 2000 IEP meeting that it needed more data from an evaluation in order to help the team make decisions regarding STUDENT’s curriculum and placement.
Not having an updated comprehensive evaluation, the Hearing Officer cannot make a finding as to the type of placement that would provide STUDENT with an educational benefit. However, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s current placement is not reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit.
Comported with STUDENT’s November 9, 1999 IEP
This standard was designed to determine if the student’s IEP was properly implemented. Petitioner contends that the District failed to provide the services listed in his November 9, 1999 IEP, specifically, occupational therapy, adapted physical education, speech, an intensive toilet training program, and a one-on-one shadow aide. As discussed in detail below, the District’s response varied with regard to its provision of each service noted above.
Occupational Therapy (OT)
Regarding the District’s alleged failure to provide occupational therapy (OT) as specified in the November 9, 1999 IEP, the IEP document states that STUDENT was to begin receiving OT services as of November 1999; however an end date was not specified, nor was the time and frequency listed. It is noted therein, however, that services would be received at the doctor’s office and that “Cresswell” would be the person responsible for providing the service. John Cunnion, the District’s special education director at that time, testified that he believes no time or frequency was listed because he didn’t know what Ms. Cresswell’s recommendation would be. According to the IEP document, a referral was pending with California Childrens’ Services for possible OT. Occupational therapist Suzanne Cresswell testified that she did not attend any of the IEP meetings, but that she provided OT services to STUDENT in her office on 25 different occasions during the 1999-2000 school year. OT services were initiated on November 5, 1999, and her last session with STUDENT was on May 31, 2000. (Respondent’s Exhs. 15 & 16.)
In a report dated May 27, 2000, Ms. Cresswell recommended that OT services cease because she felt she was no longer having a positive impact on STUDENT, and established goals had been met and/or a plateau in goals had been realized. (Respondent’s Exh. 15.) During the June 2, 2000 IEP meeting, based on Ms. Cresswell’s recommendation, the IEP team decided to discontinue OT services pending further assessment data. PARENT did not sign the June 2, 2000 IEP. Susan Christiansen, the District’s current special education director, testified that Ms. Cresswell’s contract with the District expired on June 30, 2000, and that she believed Ms. Cresswell thought she was not authorized to provide services to STUDENT.
In September 2000, Ms. Christiansen asked Ms. Cresswell to reevaluate STUDENT’s situation and suggested that Ms. Cresswell look for ways to change the OT services to be more educational in nature instead of medical in nature. (Testimony of S. Christensen.) Regarding the provision of OT for the 2000-2001 school year, Ms. Christiansen testified she felt that if she reinstated OT services it would look as though she were trying to do this in response to Petitioner’s filing for a due process hearing. The District’s October 30, 2000 closing statement contended that the District made a good faith attempt to renegotiate a nonpublic agency service agreement with the Cresswell Clinic, but that services have not yet begun for the 2000-2001 school year because of an inability to convene an IEP team to discuss the change in OT goals and location of program.
The record is not clear as to when OT services were to end because the IEP dated November 9, 1999, omitted an end date, and there was no testimony explaining the intended schedule for and the duration of OT services as of the November 9, 1999 IEP meeting. However, PARENT indicated in her testimony and in her closing statement that OT services have not been received during the 2000-2001 school year. Moreover, in a letter to PARENT dated August 14, 2000, in addressing OT services, Ms. Christensen stated that she agreed with PARENT that services as stated in the November 9, 1999 IEP are still in effect and stated she would arrange for services to continue when school was again in session. (Respondent’s Exh. 1.) The evidence supports the finding that no OT services were received during the 2000-2001 school year.
Based on the testimony and documentary evidence received, it appears that at the time of the November 9, 1999 IEP meeting, the District was uncertain as to the duration and schedule for OT services. However, the evidence supports a finding that the OT services offered in that IEP were intended to at least continue until a new IEP was signed and implemented. Given that no new IEP has been signed and implemented since the November 9, 1999 IEP, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT should have received this service during the 2000-20001 school year. Accordingly, the District’s failure to provide the OT services for the 2000-2001 school year constituted failure to comport with the IEP. Adapted Physical Education (APE)
The November 9, 1999 IEP stated that STUDENT was to receive APE from November 1999 to November 2000, at the rate of one day a week for thirty minutes. Chris White was listed as the person responsible for providing the service. Petitioner alleges that STUDENT has not received any of the APE services listed in his November 9, 1999 IEP for the 2000-20001 school year. The District’s APE specialist, Chris White, testified that students do not receive services the first week or two of the school year. Rather, during that time, the APE department meets, does office work, trains, and gets the office together to administer services. The department then decides when to start seeing students. According to Mr. White, STUDENT began receiving services this year on September 12, 2000, from a new District employee, Stephanie Gosling. Ms. Gosling did not testify at the hearing; however, a progress report she completed was included as Respondent’s Exhibit 34. The progress report noted that STUDENT was seen this year by Ms. Gosling on September 12, 19 and 26, and on October 3 for thirty-minute sessions. The progress report is signed by Ms. Gosling on page 2, certifying that to the best of her knowledge and belief the State School Register page had been kept as required by law and in accordance with the instructions of the Superintendent of Public Instruction. (Respondent’s Exh. 34.) Mr. White testified that Ms. Gosling completed the progress report and provided the services to STUDENT as noted therein.
PARENT argued that she had a telephone conversation with Mr. White on September 19, 2000, during which she contended Mr. White stated that Ms. Gosling had not yet started working with the District and that he did not know when she would start because she was in the process of relocating from the Los Angeles area. In responding to this contention, Mr. White testified that he did not remember making this statement regarding Ms. Gosling’s start date and did not remember exactly when Ms. Gosling was hired. To his knowledge, STUDENT had been receiving APE services at thirty minutes a week during the 2000-2001 school year from Ms. Gosling.
The evidence regarding STUDENT’s receipt of APE for the 2000-2001 school year is, at best, sparse. Ms. Gosling’s progress report (Respondent’s Exh. 34.) is hearsay in that she did not testify at the hearing.(Footnote 6) However, Mr. White testified that STUDENT had been receiving APE services from Ms. Gosling as of September 12, 2000, at the rate of once a week for 30 minutes each session. PARENT’s only evidence regarding STUDENT’s alleged lack of receipt of APE services was her testimony that she did not believe he ever received such services in the 2000-2001 school year based on the telephone conversation that she had with Mr. White on September 19, 2000. Mr. White, however, testified that he did not remember making those statements regarding Ms. Gosling’s start date.
In light of Mr. White’s testimony and the progress report noting the occasions on which STUDENT received APE services, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District provided APE services in conformity with STUDENT’s November 9, 1999 IEP.
Speech
STUDENT’s November 9, 1999 IEP states that he was to receive speech services from November 1999 to November 2000, at the rate of two times per week for twenty minutes each session. Services were to be provided in the office at Buckeye, and Don Gilmer was the individual responsible for providing the service. Although Petitioner’s request for hearing stated that he was not receiving any of the services listed on his IEP, at hearing, PARENT testified that for the 2000-2001 school year, the only service that she knew STUDENT was receiving was speech. Additionally, Don Gilmer, the District’s speech and language pathologist, testified that STUDENT definitely received his scheduled speech and language services for the 2000-2001 school year.
Thus, there is no evidence to support Petitioner’s initial allegation that STUDENT did not receive speech therapy. The Hearing Officer concludes that speech services were in substantial conformity with the November 9, 1999 IEP.
Intensive Toilet Training Program
Regarding toilet training, STUDENT’s November 9, 1999 IEP merely states that the IEP team was to “obtain a medical release for toilet-training.” PARENT contends that she was told repeatedly by STUDENT’s teacher, Mr. Diskin, that he would implement intensive toilet training for STUDENT. She testified that she did not get this commitment in writing because she was not used to such procedures. PARENT also testified that John Cunnion told her the school needed a complete urinary evaluation by a urologist in order to initiate toilet training for STUDENT and that the District would not pay for this. PARENT stated that she was referred to the Regional Center to request funding for the evaluation; however, when she told Mr. Cunnion that Regional Center would not pay for it, Mr. Cunnion referred her to her personal insurance company.
Mr. Cunnion testified that he recalled there being a question at the November 9, 1999 IEP meeting as to whether there was any medical reason why STUDENT could not receive toilet training. He stated that when STUDENT came to the District he was beyond the normal age for toilet training and that Mr. Diskin did not normally change diapers of students STUDENT’s age. According to Mr. Cunnion, the District did not want to get into any behavioral program in this regard if STUDENT could not control his toileting, thus the need for a medical release. He also stated that Mr. Diskin had done some toilet training with STUDENT and had heard Mr. Diskin commenting that sometimes toilet training was successful and sometimes it was not. Mr. Cunnion testified that toileting was put on the referral to the Diagnostic Center as an issue to review, and it was discussed at the June 2, 2000 IEP meeting. Mr. Cunnion testified that he did not recall being contacted about a toilet-training program and did not recall having a conversation with PARENT about her pediatrician’s comment that a toilet-training evaluation would be too invasive.
Bobbie Groves, program specialist for the special education local plan area (SELPA), testified that she believed toilet training was discussed at the November 9, 1999 IEP meeting. She stated that the IEP team wanted STUDENT’s mother to get information from STUDENT’s pediatrician regarding his ability to be toilet-trained. The IEP team wanted to make sure there was no physical reason why STUDENT could not be trained to use the toilet.
Finally, Mr. Diskin testified that he did not know whether a goal had been written for STUDENT for toilet training, but he had decided himself to change STUDENT’s diapers. He also testified that he has STUDENT on a schedule by which the classroom aide checks him every hour and puts him on the toilet every two hours, but that sometimes they forget to do it. Additionally, STUDENT is checked prior to recess and, if he is dry, he gets ready for recess. If STUDENT needs changing and that changing is lengthy, STUDENT joins the class at recess after changing. A review of the IEP dated November 9, 1999, does not reveal any goal regarding toilet training, only the notation on page 9 that states as follows:
“We will continue to implement his current IEP and continue this meeting until we ... obtain a medical release for toilet training.”
To gain a clear understanding of the statement above regarding continued implementation of the current IEP, the Hearing Officer looks to the prior September 28, 1999 IEP addendum, which states that “school personnel will check STUDENT’s diaper at recess and change as needed.” (Respondent’s Exh. 6.) This suggests that there was no specific intensive toilet-training program in place at the September 28, 1999 IEP meeting or as a result of the November 9, 1999 IEP meeting, only a commitment by school personnel that they would change STUDENT’s diapers at recess. The evidence also suggests that toilet training was discussed at District IEP meetings, but was not made a final part of the November 9, 1999 IEP. It appears that Mr. Diskin took it upon himself to put STUDENT on a schedule to check STUDENT’s diaper every hour, and put him on the toilet every two hours - but not because it was a part of an IEP.
As such, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not formally offer the service of an intensive toilet-training program as part of STUDENT’s current IEP, and thus, it had no duty to provide such service. Rather, the only service required by the District was to check STUDENT’s diaper at recess and change him as needed. Mr. Diskin confirmed that STUDENT’s diaper was checked and changed, if necessary, at recess. Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that the toileting services provided were in conformity with STUDENT’s IEP.
One-on-one Shadow Aide
Petitioner contends that former District special education director, John Cunnion, represented to her at the November 9, 1999 IEP meeting that the referral form for individual aide support that was attached to the November 9, 1999 IEP document would ensure that STUDENT would get a one-on-one aide. (Respondent’s Exh. 5.) PARENT testified that District personnel routinely referred to the classroom aide as “STUDENT’s aide.” PARENT also testified, however, that when discussing the aide’s duties with Mr. Diskin, Mr. Diskin informed her that STUDENT’s aide was being shared with another student. PARENT also referred to page 9 of the November 9, 1999 IEP, wherein it states that STUDENT has needs which require small-group and individual supervision.
The District contends that at no time did STUDENT have a one-on-one shadow aide. A decision was made not to give STUDENT a one-on-one shadow aide because it was believed that STUDENT did not need it. (Testimony of John Cunnion.) Mr. Cunnion reasoned that sometimes a one-on-one aide makes a child too dependent. Moreover, there was adequate supervision in Mr. Diskin’s class with aide support; therefore, there was no need for a one-on-one aide. Mr. Cunnion stated that the referral form for independent aide support was a document that was submitted to the SELPA program specialist to get a determination as to whether or not STUDENT needed one-on-one support. The notation of a need for individual supervision on the November 9, 1999 IEP indicated that STUDENT should be placed in a small group where his individual needs could be met. Mr. Cunnion also stated that individualized does not mean one-on-one; rather, it means instruction geared to an individual’s strength and weaknesses.
The IEP team determined at the November 9, 1999 IEP meeting that Mr. Diskin’s class would have extra classroom support, and since inclusion was a part of STUDENT’s IEP, STUDENT would not have a one-on-one aide. (Testimony of Bobbie Groves.) A one-on-one aide is used when a student is medically fragile or if his/her behavior is out of control and there are safety issues, such as a student being a danger to himself or others. (Testimony of B. Groves and Susan Christensen.) Otherwise, a student’s needs should be able to be met through the program. (Testimony of B. Groves.) Ms. Christensen testified that STUDENT does not have a one-on-one aide; rather, the aide is a paraprofessional assigned to Mr. Diskin’s special day class and under Mr. Diskin’s direction. Additionally, the aide may have introduced herself as STUDENT’s aide because she goes to the classroom with STUDENT and she is the only one doing the toileting. Ms. Christensen also testified that they have tried to have one person designated to change STUDENT’s diaper, out of respect for STUDENT. All of these activities may be why some people may have referred to the aide as “STUDENT’s aide.”
The District introduced a job announcement for a paraprofessional II position at Buckeye Elementary School, contending that this was the job announcement for an aide for Mr. Diskin’s class. (Respondent’s Exh. 52.) The job announcement defines paraprofessional II as “one-on-one for special needs student.” Ms. Christensen testified that this position was advertised as one-on-one because the District was requesting aide support in a classroom because of a special needs student.
The Hearing Officer finds credible Ms. Christensen’s explanation regarding the job announcement for a paraprofessional. Moreover, testimony of two other District witnesses who attended the November 9, 1999 IEP meeting corroborates the District’s contention that STUDENT was not offered a one-on-one shadow aide, he did not have a one-on-one shadow aide, and the IEP team did not believe STUDENT needed one. In light of this evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that services provided in this regard were in conformity with STUDENT’s IEP.
In the Least Restrictive Environment
There is no dispute that the proposed program provided STUDENT with education in the least restrictive environment. Since this issue was not raised, it is unnecessary to determine whether the District’s program represented the least restrictive environment possible given STUDENT’s unique needs.
****
In conclusion, the placement provided to STUDENT by the District was not designed to meet his unique and individual needs and was not reasonably calculated to provide him with an educational benefit. Additionally, the District failed to provide STUDENT with OT services, and thus in that regard, the program failed to comport with STUDENT’s IEP. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE from the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year to the present.
3. Should STUDENT be temporarily placed in a residential nonpublic school whose program is autism specific and which includes an applied behavioral analysis model, intensive toilet training and hygiene, and appropriate academics, and then later be mainstreamed with regular education students?
Petitioner’s initial hearing request sought a remedy wherein STUDENT would be temporarily placed in a residential nonpublic school whose program is autism specific and which includes an applied behavioral analysis model, intensive toilet training and hygiene, and appropriate academics, and then later be mainstreamed with regular education students. Petitioner called Neal Sternberg, executive director of Victor Youth Services North Valley School (Victor Youth Services) in Redding, California, to testify regarding an appropriate placement for STUDENT. Mr. Sternberg did not interview STUDENT; nor did he observe STUDENT in any classroom setting or review STUDENT’s November 9, 1999 IEP. Mr. Sternberg testified that he reviewed Ms. Bland’s March 1999 psychological evaluation, and the December 4, 1997, February 10, 1998, and February 12, 1998 pediatric neurodevelopmental evaluations prepared by Dr. Nola R. Marx. Mr. Sternberg also reviewed PARENT’s September 12, 2000 and October 1, 2000 letters to the District, which included the due process hearing request and issues for hearing. He also reviewed the September 28, 2000 letter from the District to PARENT, which also included issues for hearing. Mr. Sternberg briefly described the Victor Youth Service’s Echo program, which offers a one-on-one teacher or aide environment. Mr. Sternberg testified that the Echo program is not a residential placement and cautioned that the District should only place a student in the Echo program as a last resort, if the District does not have resources available to assist a student. Teachers in the Echo program receive the same type of training as the District’s teachers. Mr. Sternberg could not confirm whether the Echo program would be appropriate for STUDENT. He did state, however, that the youngest student in the program was either 12 or 13 years old. Additionally, he did not provide testimony regarding the specific type of placement that Petitioner seeks. The Hearing Officer finds that Mr. Sternberg’s testimony does not support Petitioner’s request for placement at a residential nonpublic school.
Petitioner did not identify any other specific program that might be an appropriate placement for STUDENT. Mr. Sternberg’s testimony is insufficient to make a finding regarding a particular prospective placement for STUDENT. Additionally, given that the Hearing Officer has found that a comprehensive assessment is warranted, a decision regarding STUDENT’s placement should be decided by an IEP team after receipt and review of the assessment reports. Petitioner’s request for a temporary placement in a residential nonpublic school is therefore denied.
ORDER
1. The Gateway Unified School District is entitled to conduct assessments of Petitioner pursuant to the proposed assessment plan dated September 18, 2000 contained in Respondent’s Exhibit 9 and in compliance with California Education Code §§ 56320 et seq.
2. STUDENT’s mother, PARENT, shall make STUDENT available for the District and its assessors to conduct the assessments.
3. Excluding school holidays, within 14 days of receipt of all completed assessment reports, the District shall convene an IEP meeting for the purpose of developing an IEP that is consistent with the findings in said assessment reports and which identifies appropriate goals and objectives, services, and placement for STUDENT.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
1. Should the District be authorized to conduct a formal evaluation of STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability?
The District prevailed on this issue.
2. Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2000-2001 school year?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
3. Should STUDENT be temporarily placed in a residential nonpublic school whose program is autism specific and which includes an applied behavioral analysis model, intensive toilet training and hygiene, and appropriate academics, and then later be mainstreamed with regular education students?
The District prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (California Education Code § 56505(i).)
Dated: November 27, 2000 __________________________________ Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnote 1: Petitioner did not file a formal statement of issues and proposed resolutions; therefore, on the first day of hearing, the Hearing Officer addressed the issues for hearing, pursuant to Petitioner’s letter to the Hearing Office dated October 1, 2000, and Respondent’s Statement of Issues and Proposed Resolutions as noted in its letter to PARENT dated September 28, 2000. The Hearing Officer has since condensed several issues into a more general issue (number 2) of whether the District provided STUDENT with a free appropriate public education. Petitioner’s specific concerns regarding placement and services during the 2000-2001 school year will be addressed within issue number 2. Additionally, Petitioner’s proposed remedy has been added as issue number 3.
Footnote 2: There was considerable discussion during the hearing as to whether the District offered to provide a one-on-one aide only for STUDENT or an aide for STUDENT’s special day class. The District contended that STUDENT did not have a one-on-one aide; rather, the aide was assigned to Mr. Diskin’s SDC. Petitioner’s mother contended that District personnel always referred to the aide as “STUDENT’s aide.” Testimonial and documentary evidence shows that an aide was assigned to Mr. Diskin’s class and had specific duties relative to STUDENT’s needs, but also had responsibilities to other students.
Footnote 3: PARENT testified that she requested that STUDENT be assessed at the Fremont Diagnostic Center based on what she thought was suggested to her by the Office of Client’s Rights Advocacy. During the hearing, and in a letter dated August 6, 2000, directed to the principal at Buckeye, PARENT stated that there was some confusion on the part of the client’s rights advocate (who had advised her) as to whether the center requested should have been the Fremont Diagnostic Center or another center also located in Fremont, California. There was also testimony that the “Fremont Diagnostic Center” is also frequently referred to as the “Diagnostic Center, Northern California.”
Footnote 4: The Hearing Officer notes that although Petitioner’s request for hearing sought a remedy wherein STUDENT would be assessed at the Oakland Children’s Hospital Autism Unit, during the hearing and within the closing statement, Petitioner’s mother indicated that STUDENT needs no further assessment.
Footnote 5: The Hearing Officer notes that at the beginning of the hearing, the parties agreed that an issue to be resolved was whether the District should be entitled to use the DCNC for STUDENT’s assessment. The DCNC had scheduled STUDENT for an assessment on November 14-15, 2000. STUDENT has since missed the scheduled assessment dates at the DCNC and the District indicated in its closing statement that the question of an evaluation at the DCNC is now a moot point. As such, the Hearing Officer will not address the issue of whether the District should be entitled to use the DCNC for STUDENT’s assessment.
Footnote 6: Although hearsay evidence may be used to supplement or explain other evidence, unless admissible over objection in a civil action, hearsay evidence is not sufficient in itself to support a finding. (5 California Code of Regulations, § 3082(b).)
