California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 26, 2001

Anaheim City School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 168-01 · Hearing Officer Joseph T. Macaluso

Anaheim City School District may implement its preschool IEP for a child with Down syndrome; district prevails on all four issues.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted in the decision.

Summary

Anaheim City School District filed for due process in January 2001 about a four-year-old preschooler. The child is eligible for special education because of Down syndrome. The family moved from Butte County in June 2000. The parent rejected the district's interim and annual preschool placements and enrolled the child at the Jewish Community Center preschool in Costa Mesa. The district kept providing weekly occupational and speech therapy. The Hearing Officer denied the parent's requests to postpone the hearing. The parent stayed only for the first half hour, so the district presented its case unopposed.

The Hearing Officer found that the district's speech, occupational therapy and psychological assessments met Education Code section 56320. The August 2000 interim placement was timely, even though it was offered during summer break. It was also appropriate because it followed the Butte IEP as closely as available resources allowed. It combined a language-based special day class, a general education preschool, an aide and individual therapy. The district did not review the interim placement within 30 days. However, this procedural violation did not cost the child educational opportunity or seriously limit the parent's participation, so it did not deny FAPE. Finally, the November 8, 2000 IEP offered FAPE in the least restrictive environment. It placed the child in a language-based preschool class at Benito Juarez School with one hour each week of individual speech therapy and one hour of occupational therapy. The district was ordered to implement it immediately.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The case shows how SEHO applied the interim placement rule for students moving in from another SELPA under Education Code section 56325. It treated summer as outside the duty to serve unless the IEP provided extended school year services. It also held that a late 30-day review was a procedural violation that did not deny FAPE.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 1. Did the District conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT?

    The district's speech-language, occupational therapy and psychological assessments met Education Code section 56320. Qualified assessors used multiple instruments and observations, and no single procedure decided the program.

  2. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2. Did the District provide STUDENT with a timely and appropriate interim placement?

    The August 4, 2000 interim placement was timely under Education Code section 56325(a), even though it was offered during summer break. It was also appropriate because it matched the Butte County IEP to the extent resources allowed; the summer rule in 5 CCR 3043(h) excused the general education part until September.

  3. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. Did the District provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education while it developed its placement for the 2000-2001 school year?

    The district did not review the interim placement within 30 days. This caused no loss of educational opportunity and did not seriously infringe on parent participation, because the district kept offering the Butte-conforming placement and therapy and held the IEP meeting three weeks later. The placement offered FAPE in the LRE.

  4. Issue 4. Did the District's offer of placement and services at Benito Juarez preschool on November 8, 2000, provide STUDENT with FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year?

    The November 8, 2000 IEP was timely and had goals based on the assessments. It offered a language-based preschool special day class at Benito Juarez plus one hour per week each of individual speech and occupational therapy, which was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit in the LRE. The parent's request for two hours of each therapy was not required.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order that district's offer may be implemented. The district shall immediately implement the placement and services offered in the IEP dated November 8, 2000 (preschool special day class at Benito Juarez School with individual speech-language and occupational therapy).

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education v. Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H.; Education Code section 56320; Education Code section 56325; Education Code section 56346(a); 5 CCR section 3043; 34 CFR Part 300, Appendix A, Question 17

People named in the decision

  • Dr. Tricia Howell, director of special education services/SELPA, Anaheim City School District
  • Hope Boshoff (also spelled Bosheff), special education preschool teacher, Benito Juarez School, Anaheim City School District
  • Dr. Ann Rytting, school psychologist (assessor), Anaheim City School District
  • Sherry Blakely, special education coordinator, Anaheim City School District
  • Carol Edwards, school psychologist, Benito Juarez School, Anaheim City School District
  • Rebecca Allen (also spelled Allan), speech and language specialist (assessor and therapist), Anaheim City School District
  • Dean Paul, speech and language specialist, Anaheim City School District
  • Jessica Peng, occupational therapist, Anaheim City School District
  • Carol Owens, school occupational therapist (assessor), Anaheim City School District
  • Julie Bissel, school occupational therapist (assessor), Anaheim City School District
  • Dianne E. Van Peter (also spelled Dyanne), private occupational therapist (parent-obtained evaluation), Private
  • Nina J. Welch, private speech-language pathologist (parent-obtained evaluation), Private
  • Sharon Bolden-Schleh, school psychologist (prior assessment), Butte County
  • Kathleen Nissan, speech and language specialist (prior assessment), Butte County
  • Lori Diessen, registered occupational therapist (prior assessment), Butte County
  • Jewish Community Center Preschool (JCC), private preschool, parent's unilateral placement, Costa Mesa
  • Rehabilitative Institute of Southern California (RIO), private preschool where the student was observed, Orange
  • San Andreas Regional Center, early intervention provider, San Jose

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Joseph T. Macaluso, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Anaheim, California, on March 27 and 28, 2001. Appearing on behalf of Petitioner Anaheim Unified School District (District) were attorneys Lauri LaFoe and Deborah R.G. Cesario from Lozano Smith; and Dr. Tricia Howell, director of special education services/special education local plan area (SELPA) Anaheim City School District. As explained more fully under procedural matters below, MOTHER appeared on behalf of STUDENT for the first half hour of the due process hearing only.

The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: Hope Boshoff, special education teacher at Benito Juarez School; Dr. Ann Rytting, school psychologist, Anaheim City School District; Sherry Blakely, special education coordinator, Anaheim City School District; Carol Edwards, school psychologist, Anaheim City School District; Dr. Tricia Howell, District director of special education services/special education local planning area; Rebecca Allen, speech and language specialist; Dean Paul, speech and language specialist, Anaheim City School District; and Jessica Peng, occupational therapist, Anaheim City School District.

STUDENT neither called any witnesses nor presented any written evidence at the hearing.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of oral closing argument on March 28, 2001, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

On March 26, 2001, at 1:06 p.m., STUDENT made a written motion for reconsideration of the Hearing Officer’s order of March 23, 2001, denying STUDENT’S motion to continue the due process hearing on March 27 and 28, 2001. The Hearing Officer declined the initial request for a continuance on three grounds: (1) STUDENT’S request to mediate the case further was not good cause since the mediation process was voluntary and Petitioner did not wish to mediate the case any further, (2) STUDENT’S retention of counsel to mediate the case was not good cause and (3) STUDENT’S request to continue the due process hearing because the due process hearing dates were not convenient was also not good cause.

The Hearing Officer did not rule upon the STUDENT’S motion for reconsideration of the Hearing Officer’s denial of STUDENT’S request for a continuance, in order to allow the District an opportunity to respond, until the hearing convened the following day, on March 27, 2001.

On March 27, 2001, the first day of the hearing in this case, the parties were heard on this matter. STUDENT presented five grounds in support of his motion to reconsider the Hearing Officer’s denial of STUDENT’S initial motion to continue: (1) MOTHER had retained an advocate to represent STUDENT and to mediate the case, (2) the advocate was allegedly in the hospital for an unspecified surgical procedure and would not be available for mediation or the hearing, (3) STUDENT had found an attorney, who would represent STUDENT upon the condition that a continuance was granted, and (4) STUDENT intended to file a request for a due process hearing against the District arising out of the same facts and intended to have it consolidated with this matter.

Counsel for Petitioner objected to STUDENT’S motion to reconsider the Hearing Officer’s order denying the initial motion for a continuance on the following grounds: (1) STUDENT did not give Petitioner ten days written notice of representation by counsel as required by California Education Code § 56507, (2) Petitioner did not receive written notice from any counsel attesting to any representation of STUDENT, (3) Petitioner had the right to a speedy due process hearing pursuant to California Education Code § 56505(f), and (4) Respondent did not present any new facts substantiating good cause for a continuance.

The Hearing Officer denied STUDENT’S motion for reconsideration of the March 23, 2001 order denying STUDENT’S initial motion for a continuance on five grounds: (1) STUDENT provided neither a declaration from a doctor nor documentation from any other individual attesting to the nature of the advocate’s alleged illness and the anticipated period of incapacity, (2) STUDENT never provided either Petitioner or the Hearing Office with notice of representation by either an attorney or an advocate,(Footnote 1) (3) STUDENT presented no facts as to why she failed to diligently seek counsel from January 24, 2001 until March 19, 2001, in order to help her with the case,(Footnote 2) (4) Petitioner had numerous witnesses present at the hearing and ready to testify, and (5) Petitioner had the right to a speedy due process hearing.

During the hearing on Respondent’s motion for reconsideration, the Hearing Officer had difficulty hearing the parties arguments. The reason for this difficulty was because MOTHER had brought her grandmother and three children to the hearing, which included Respondent. All three children were quite loud, making it difficult to both hear the parties and obtain a clear record. When the Hearing Officer requested that two of the children be removed from the room with the grandmother, MOTHER refused to do so. When the Hearing Officer reiterated his request, MOTHER stated that she would not allow her children to leave the room without her. Before the Hearing Officer had an opportunity to explain his ruling fully, MOTHER left the hearing with her grandmother and three children. Thus, MOTHER disagreed with both the Hearing Officer’s ruling on the motion for reconsideration and with his request to have the grandmother remove the three children from the room.

The Hearing Officer was persuaded to go forward with the case for three reasons: (1) Petitioner had the right to a speedy resolution of their case pursuant to California Education Code § 56505(f), (2) Petitioner had all of its witnesses present at the hearing and ready to testify, and (3) Neither the Petitioner nor the Hearing Officer had any notice of a firm representation of Respondent by counsel.

ISSUES

1. Did the District conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT?

2. Did the District provide STUDENT with a timely and appropriate interim placement?

3. Did the District provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education while it developed its placement for the 2000-2001 school year?

4. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2000- 2001 school year?

BACKGROUND FACTS

Respondent is a four-year-old preschool student who is eligible for special education and related services due to Down Syndrome. He has resided within the jurisdictional boundaries of the District since July 2000, and attended a District preschool at Benito Juarez for one week in December 2000. In January 2001, STUDENT did not return to Benito. MOTHER advised the District that she had withdrawn STUDENT from Benito Juarez and enrolled him in a private preschool, The Jewish Community Center (JCC), in Costa Mesa, California. STUDENT remains enroled at JCC to date. From August 2000 to date, STUDENT has continued to receive individual occupational therapy once per week for sixty minutes and individual speech and language therapy one per week for sixty minutes.

On [date redacted], STUDENT was born and was diagnosed with Down Syndrome. Due to this condition, STUDENT’S parents sought early start intervention services and an infant/toddler assessment from the San Andreas Regional Center in San Jose, California. Assessment findings in the first year revealed developmental delays in gross and fine motor skills and receptive and expressive language. Thus, STUDENT was referred for occupational and physical therapy, speech and language therapy, and an infant development program.

In November 1997, STUDENT and his parents moved from Mountain View to Butte, both of which are located in northern California. Butte county assessed STUDENT in January 1998. The assessment revealed developmental delays in gross and fine motor skills, receptive and expressive communication and articulation, social/emotional and self-help skills. An individual family service plan (IFSP) was written and approved by STUDENT’S parents with goals, objectives and benchmarks to meet these developmental delays. Finally, the IFSP team set up a therapy plan which included in-home occupational, physical and speech and language therapy. STUDENT received each type of therapy four times per month. In addition, STUDENT received in-home respite care assistance and a developmental program once per week. These services were scheduled through December 1998.

During 1998, STUDENT received follow-up evaluations in his areas of suspected disability. The respective therapists for occupational and physical therapy observed gains throughout the year. By December 1998, the occupational therapy was reduced to every other week up to three times per month and the physical therapy was reduced to one time per month. However, speech and language continued to be an important area of concern. Thus, the therapy was increased up to five times per month.

In December 1998, an IFSP meeting was held. New goals, objectives and benchmarks were set through December 1999 in STUDENT’S areas of developmental delay. The IFSP team also agreed to continue the various individual therapy services through December 1999. By the end of the year, STUDENT had continued to make gains in his areas of need, but still showed considerable delay in the area of speech and language. Thus, STUDENT was assessed by both a Butte school psychologist and an early start teacher. The psychological assessment instruments revealed that STUDENT’S functioning level was typical of a child who was between one to two years old and confirmed that speech and language was an important weakness. The early start teacher noted that STUDENT had a high activity level and seemed to work best in a structured play environment with clear directions, choices and routine. She noted that “play provides the learning environment and the context for STUDENT to practice communication, social, cognitive and motor skills. A preschool program designed to support and improve STUDENT’S overall development, especially in the areas of communication, social and motor is recommended. Curriculum opportunities should include and integrate all areas of development.”

On the basis of the aforementioned assessments, STUDENT’S last IEP in Butte was developed in December 1999 and remained in effect until October 2000. The goals, objectives and benchmarks were prepared in speech and language, self-help, and social skills. The IEP team chose an innovative pre-school placement in a full inclusion severely handicapped-special day class (SH-SDC) which met 4 to 5 days per week for half a day.(Footnote 3) STUDENT would spend eighty percent of the time in a general education class and twenty percent of the time in designated instructional services (DIS). The designated instructional services included occupational physical therapy and speech and language therapy. In addition, STUDENT was to receive individual occupational therapy 50 minutes one time per week and individual speech therapy one hour per week with the respective therapists. Finally, classroom aides would help STUDENT.

The December 1999 IEP was in effect when STUDENT and his parents moved to Anaheim, California, in June 2000. On June 13, 2000, MOTHER contacted the Anaheim City School District (District) and told them that she and her family had moved into the district.(Footnote 4) She advised them that STUDENT had been diagnosed with Down Syndrome and she hoped that STUDENT would be placed in a District preschool program. After this conversation, MOTHER and her family went on vacation until June 25, 2000. In early July 2000, she contacted the District again. On July 11, 2000, she signed consents for release of confidential information from the Butte County Office of Education and the Northern Regional Center. On July 19, 2000, an educational placement meeting was scheduled for July 25, 2000, to discuss an educational placement and program options for STUDENT. In the interim, the District received STUDENT’S records from his placement in Mountain View and Butte counties.

On August 4, 2000, an IEP meeting was held, in order to provide STUDENT with an interim placement. The interim placement consisted of two classes. The first class was a language-based special day class with fourteen students at Madison Elementary School for students not requiring intensive service (NON-RIS) for two and one-half hours in the morning. The second class, also at Madison Elementary School, was a regular education regional occupation preschool (ROP) class in the afternoon for two and one-half hours.(Footnote 5) The first placement was taught by a speech and language specialist and the second placement was taught by a regular education teacher. Both placements had the assistance of a classroom aide. Furthermore, STUDENT would receive 150 minutes per week of speech and language therapy in school. Finally, STUDENT was offered one hour per week of individual speech and language therapy and one hour per week of individual occupational therapy outside of school. The NON-RIS class and the individual speech therapy were set to begin on August 7, 2000. The occupational therapy was set to begin on August 8, 2000. However, the ROP class did not begin until September 2000 because of summer vacation. The placements and services were to continue until October 1, 2000.

MOTHER agreed with the individual speech and language and occupational therapy and those services began as planned. She did not agree with the interim placement in the NON-RIS class. Thus, MOTHER sought alternative placements for Student. She spoke with school officials at the private Jewish Community Center Preschool in Costa Mesa and at another private preschool named the Rehabilitative Institute of Southern California (RIO) in Orange. MOTHER recommended that the District place STUDENT in one of these programs. The District, however, had reviewed the documentation from STUDENT’S placement in Butte County and believed that the interim placement it offered conformed with the placement Butte provided him. Over the next few weeks, the parties discussed placement options for STUDENT. When the ROP preschool began in September, MOTHER visited the class and also found it insufficient to meet STUDENT’S needs. An IEP scheduled for September 4, 2001, did not occur because of the parties’ disagreements. Because MOTHER rejected these programs, which the District felt met his special educational needs, it decided to assess him. MOTHER, however, would not grant the District permission to assess STUDENT. She felt that prior assessments done in Butte County were sufficient. During this time, MOTHER would not allow STUDENT to attend the District’s proposed preschool placements. However, he continued to receive the individual occupational therapy and individual speech and language therapy.

On September 27, 2000, a second IEP meeting was held. The District offered STUDENT the same placement and services at Madison Elementary school that it had offered at the August 4, 2000 IEP meeting. MOTHER did not agree with the placement at Madison or any other preschool in the Anaheim district. She did agree to continue the individual occupational therapy and individual speech and language therapy.

On September 27, 2000, Mother gave the District permission to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability. On October 11, 2000, STUDENT was assessed by Rebecca Allen, school speech and language specialist, in the areas of speech production, motor speech skills, and attention/communication . On October 20, 2000, Carol Owens, school occupational therapist, conducted an occupational evaluation of STUDENT’S fine and gross motor skills. Ann Rytting, school psychologist, assessed STUDENT’S cognitive functioning, socialization/play skills, self-help skills, and fine and gross motor skills. Furthermore, she observed STUDENT at the RIO preschool in Orange, California.(Footnote 6) On November 7, 2000, Julie Bissel, school occupational therapist, conducted a second occupational therapy evaluation of Student. On November 7, 2000, MOTHER also had a private occupational therapy evaluation conducted by Dianne E. Van Peter. On December 8, 2000, MOTHER had a private speech and language evaluation conducted by Nina J. Welch. During the evaluation period, STUDENT did not attend class but did continue to receive the individual occupational and individual speech and language therapy.

On November 8, 2000, an IEP meeting was held. The IEP included goals, objectives, and benchmarks in readiness, social adaptation, pre-vocational, gross and fine motor skills, self help and care, stability, tool use, receptive and expressive language, speech and attention. The District offered a full inclusion language-based preschool special day class at Benito Juarez School for three hours and thirty-two minutes per day for four days per week. The class was taught by a special education teacher and also had four classroom aides. Furthermore, STUDENT would receive an additional one hour per week of individual speech and language therapy at Benito Juarez and an additional one hour per week of individual occupational therapy at an outside clinic. Finally, the speech and language therapist would come into class once a week and the occupational therapist would come into class every other week to observe the special day class students and provide therapy in small groups. Mr. and Mrs. PARENT agreed with the designated instruction and services offered and with all the goals and objectives except for those in speech and language. At an IEP meeting on December 13, 2000, MOTHER requested two hours per week of occupational therapy and two hours per week of speech and language therapy. STUDENT continues to receive one hour per week of individual occupational therapy and individual speech and language therapy.

The class at Benito Juarez did not start until early December, since it went off track at the end of October 2000 and was out of session during November 2000. In the interim period, STUDENT did not attend class. In December, MOTHER agreed to try the placement at Benito Juarez for 30 days. Both MOTHER and STUDENT attended the school for five days in early December and never returned. On or about January 10, 2001, MOTHER informed the District that STUDENT was attending JCC. On January 24, 2001, the District filed for a due process hearing.

LEGAL ANALYSIS

ISSUE 1: Did the District conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT?

On September 27, 2000, MOTHER provided the District with the authority to conduct an assessment of STUDENT. Between October 10, 2000, and November 7, 2000, the District conducted its evaluations of STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability. However, MOTHER disagreed with the occupational therapy and speech and language evaluations. Thus, on November 7, 2000, and on December 8, 2000 respectively, MOTHER obtained a private occupational therapy evaluation and a private speech and language evaluation. While the District considered MOTHER’S private evaluations in forming the goals and objectives for STUDENT’S November IEP, pursuant to Dr. Tricia Howell’s testimony, the District concluded that its own evaluations of STUDENT properly assessed him in all areas of suspected disability.

For the District’s assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements California Education Code § 56320, which states in relevant part that testing and assessment materials and procedures must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; provided and administered in the student’s primary language or other mode of communication; administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; and validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. Additionally, individually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning must be administered by a credentialed school psychologist. Assessments must include tests and other test materials that assess specific areas of educational need and that do not just provide a single general intelligence quotient. Assessment and testing materials also must not measure the student’s impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills unless that is what the test purports to measure.

Subsection 56302(e) states that no single procedure shall be used as the “sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for an individual with exceptional needs.” Subsection 56320(f) requires that the student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional status. Pursuant to subsection(g), the assessment must be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the student’s disability. Psychological assessments must be conducted by credentialed school psychologists, and health assessments must be conducted by a credentialed school nurse or physician. These assessors must be trained and prepared to assess cultural and ethnic factors appropriate to the pupil being assessed. Education Code § 56324(a) and (b). Education Code § 56322 additionally states that assessments shall be conducted by “persons competent to perform the assessment, as determined by the school district, county office, or special education local plan area.”

Rebecca Allan, school speech and language specialist, testified that she conducted the speech and language evaluations. Furthermore, the assessment plan noted that Ms. Allan also conducted the pre-academic/academic evaluations. She reviewed the developmental, medical, and educational histories, spoke to relevant individuals from STUDENT’S prior school district, conducted observations of STUDENT in his home and at the RIO preschool, interviewed MOTHER, and administered test instruments to assess the suspected areas of disability. To assess STUDENT’S speech production, Ms. Allan administered the Goldman Fristoe Test of Articulation. To assess motor speech skills, she observed him speak at home. To assess attention/communication, she observed STUDENT at home and in Key Elementary School. To assess receptive language skills, Ms. Allan administered both the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test Form III B and the Rosetti Infant-Toddler Language Scale.

Carol Owens and Julie Bissel, school occupation therapists, conducted occupational therapy evaluations in October and November 2000 respectively. Jessica Peng, school occupational therapist, also assisted in the evaluations. Ms. Owens and Ms. Bissel reviewed the medical, developmental and educational histories, conducted observations of STUDENT in the occupational therapy room, interviewed MOTHER, and administered test instruments to assess fine and gross motor skills. To assess STUDENT’S fine motor skills, Ms. Owens and Ms. Bissel administered the Peabody Developmental Motor Scales. To assess STUDENT’S gross motor skills, both therapists observed STUDENT in the occupational therapy room.

Ann Rytting, school psychologist, conducted the cognitive functioning, socialization/play skills, self-help skills, and additional fine and gross motor evaluations. Ms. Rytting reviewed the educational, developmental and medical histories alone and with MOTHER, conducted observations of STUDENT at home and at the RIO pre-school in Orange, California, and administered test instruments to assess the aforementioned areas. To assess intellectual development, Ms. Rytting administered the Bayley II Scales of Infant Development. To assess social/adaptive behavior, she administered the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales and the Brigance. To assess self-help skills, Ms. Rytting obtained reports from MOTHER and applied the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales. To assess readiness skills, she administered the Brigance. To assess STUDENT’S fine and gross motor skills, she administered the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales by a combination of parent input, observations, occupational therapy input, and information from reports.

There was no evidence that the District’s assessment of STUDENT was racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. Thus, the requirements of Education Code § 56302(a) were satisfied. As to whether the District’s assessment of STUDENT satisfied the requirements of Education Code § 56302(b)(1), the native language of STUDENT and his family is English. The assessment was administered to STUDENT in English and, therefore, was administered in his primary language.

Education Code §§ 56302(b)(3) and (g), 56322 and 56324(a) and (b) state that the assessors must be “trained, competent, and knowledgeable” of the student’s disability, and that psychological assessments must be conducted by a credentialed school psychologist. The credentials of the assessors was as follows: (1) Ms. Rebecca Allan testified that she received her Master of Arts degree in communicative disorders, has her California state license from the Medical Quality Assurance board, certification of clinical competence from the ASHA Speech and Hearing Association, and certification for clinical rehabilitation services for work in California schools. Ms. Allan taught a special day class for six years for mentally handicapped children and has worked with children with down syndrome to provide speech and language services in the classroom. (2) While neither Carol Owens nor Julie Bissell testified, the District supplied a curriculum vitae on behalf of Ms. Bissel. ( Petitioner’s Exhibit 82.) Jessica Peng testified and the District provided a curriculum vitae on her behalf. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 86.) Julie Bissel’s curriculum vitae revealed that she received her Master of Arts degree in occupational therapy. She has been a registered occupational therapist since 1978 and is certified in sensory integration and praxis tests. Jessica Peng’s curriculum vitae revealed that she received her Master of Arts in occupational therapy and has conducted occupational therapy assessment, treatment planning, and goal development for students with special needs. (3) Ann Rytting testified that she received her Master of Arts degree in school psychology and has a pupil personnel credential from the state of California as a school psychologist. She has worked for the Anaheim School District for 14 years as a school psychologist and has assessed pre-school children with developmental delays and Down Syndrome. The oral and documentary evidence established that Ms. Alan, Ms. Owens, Ms. Bissel, Ms. Peng, and Ms. Rytting have the appropriate training and credentials and are knowledgeable of students with learning disabilities. Therefore, the requirements described above related to the qualifications of the assessors was satisfied.

As to the instruments used to assess STUDENT, the evidence established that the assessments included test instruments that are frequently employed by speech and language specialists, occupational therapists and psychologists to assess students with learning disabilities and are relied upon to make decisions regarding special education eligibility, services, and placements. Moreover, the list of test instruments administered to STUDENT is extensive. The District administered instruments to assess STUDENT’S speech and language, fine and gross motor skills, self-help skills, social/adaptive behavior, pre-academic/academic skills, and intellectual development. Therefore, the District’s assessment satisfied the requirements of Education Code § 56320(b)(2) and (3), (c) and (d). The evidence established that the assessment also included observations of STUDENT in several environments. Additionally, STUDENT’S mother was interviewed and she helped complete Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales. The evidence established that no single procedure was used to make decisions regarding STUDENT and, therefore, the District’s assessment satisfied the requirement of Education Code § 56320(e) that no single procedure be used for determining an appropriate educational program.

The Hearing Officer concludes that the District adequately assessed STUDENT in speech and language, fine and gross motor skills, self-help skills, social/adaptive behavior, pre-academic/academic skills, and intellectual development. In sum, the District conducted an appropriate assessment of Student pursuant to California Education Code § 56320.

ISSUE 2: Did the District provide STUDENT with a timely and appropriate interim placement? STUDENT and his parents moved into the Anaheim school district during the summer in June 2000. Immediately thereafter, STUDENT and his family went on vacation. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 47.) Dr. Tricia Howell and Ann Rytting testified that Student returned to the District from vacation in early July 2000. An IEP meeting was held on August 4, 2000, and the interim placement was offered to STUDENT and his parents. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 52.) The Hearing Officer shall analyze whether the District’s interim placement was both timely and appropriate.

(1) Timely interim placement

For the District’s interim placement to be timely, it must meet the requirements of California Education Code § 56325(a). This section requires that “(w)henever a pupil transfers into a school district from a school district not operating programs under the same local plan in which he or she was last enrolled in a special education program, the administrator of a local program under this part shall ensure that the pupil is immediately provided an interim placement for a period not to exceed 30 days.” However, services shall be provided during the summer months only if they are provided for in the student’s IEP. California Code Regulations § 3043.

In this case, the District provided STUDENT with a timely interim placement and services. Dr. Tricia Howell, director of special education services/special education local plan area (SELPA) Anaheim School District, and Ann Rytting, school psychologist, testified that MOTHER first contacted the District on June 13, 2000, during summer break. Shortly thereafter, MOTHER and her family left on vacation and did not return until early July 2000. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 47.) The District, per Dr. Howell’s testimony, was still on summer break in July. Dr. Tricia Howell and Ann Rytting testified that MOTHER brought no information from either Butte or Mountain View counties regarding STUDENT’S prior placements and services. After MOTHER signed releases for STUDENT’S prior educational and medical documents on July 11, 2000 (Petitioner’s Exhibits 48 and 49), the District obtained the information and had a meeting set with her 14 days later on July 25, 2000. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 50.) The District learned that STUDENT’S prior IEP did not provide for extended school year services. Nonetheless, on August 4, 2000, an IEP meeting was held during the summer and the proposed interim placement and services were offered to MOTHER. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 52.)

Although the evidence established that the District did not have an obligation to offer STUDENT an interim placement until the District’s school year began in September 2000, it nonetheless offered him an interim placement during the summer. Thus, the District immediately provided STUDENT with an interim placement pursuant to California Education Code § 56325(a).

(2) Appropriate Interim Placement

California Education Code § 56325(a) provides in pertinent part that “the placement must be in conformity with an individualized education program, unless the parent or guardian agrees otherwise. The individualized education program implemented during the interim placement may be either the pupil’s existing individualized education program, implemented to the extent possible within existing resources, which may be implemented without complying with subdivision (a) of § 56321, or a new individualized education program, developed pursuant to § 56321.”

In order to establish that the District’s proposed interim placement and services conformed with STUDENT’S placement and services in Butte County, the District presented the December 14, 1999 Butte IEP for comparison. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 44). Dr. Tricia Howell testified that the December 14, 1999 IEP found STUDENT eligible for special education services due to his Down Syndrome. The District concurred with this finding. STUDENT’S identified areas of need were communication, self-help, and social skills. STUDENT was placed in a severely handicapped special day class (SH-SDC) 4 to 5 days per week for one-half day. The class was “innovative” due to both the teaching approach and the class make-up. First, the class was taught jointly by a special day class preschool teacher and a regular education teacher.(Footnote 7) Second, the special day class was made up of severely handicapped children who participated in regular preschool activities in a full inclusion setting.(Footnote 8) Student spent 80% of the time in general education and 20% of the time outside of it.(Footnote 9) STUDENT also received designated instructional services (DIS) which included one hour per week of individual speech therapy and 50 minutes per week of individual occupational therapy. Finally, he had an instructional aide to help him.

After obtaining STUDENT’S medical and education records from both Mountain View and Butte counties (Petitioner’s Exhibits 1 to 44) and reviewing them with the IEP team, the District offered the following interim placement at Madison Elementary School at the August 4, 2000 IEP meeting. Beginning in August, STUDENT would take part in a two and one half hour morning language-based preschool class not requiring intensive service (NON-RIS). Dr. Tricia Howell testified that the class was taught by a speech and language specialist with the assistance of a classroom aide. The class was composed of 14 children, all of whom had learning disabilities, but none had learning disabilities as severe as Student’s. Beginning in September, STUDENT would take part in a two and one half- hour afternoon regular education regional occupation program (ROP) preschool class. Dr. Howell testified that the District could not offer this afternoon ROP class in August because it was on summer vacation. This class was taught by a regular education preschool teacher and a classroom aide. The class was also assisted by high school students who received credit toward becoming preschool teachers and day care workers. Thus, the District used the name Regional Occupation Program (ROP). The class consisted of typically developing preschool children with a few special needs children. Ann Rytting testified that the preschool class developed both communication and social skills all day through activities and interaction with typically developing peers. The District also offered designated instruction and services. They included individual speech and language therapy two times per week for 60 minutes and individual occupational therapy two times per week for 60 minutes. STUDENT began to receive these services in August. Finally, the District offered to provide STUDENT with an aide in both the NON-RIS and ROP classes.

When one compares the District’s interim placement with the Butte placement, the elements reveal that the District’s placement was in conformity with the Butte placement. First, both of the District’s placements offered STUDENT a speech and language component for a half day, which was one of STUDENT’S key areas of need. The placements used numerous language-based activities such as greetings, singing, circle time with other children, and small-group activities. The District’s speech and language class and the Butte placement were taught by teachers who were specialists. Both of the District’s placements, like the Butte placement, used aides to help STUDENT. Second, the District’s placements included gross and fine motor activities like those in the Butte placement. STUDENT would draw, learn how to cut objects, and would take part in recess activities. Third, the placements in the NON-RIS and ROP preschool classes offered STUDENT with socialization opportunities such as those he had in the SH-SDC class in Butte. During circle time, small groups, and at recess, he would have the opportunity to interact with his typically developing peers. Fourth, STUDENT’S interaction with the District’s teachers and aides would provide him with the requisite interaction, as in Butte to learn how to take things out and put them away, which would meet his self-help needs. Finally, STUDENT would receive the same individual occupational therapy and speech therapy in the District’s interim placement as he received in the Butte placement. Jessica Peng testified that her occupational therapy, twice a week for sixty minutes, would focus on both his gross and fine motor skills. With regard to his gross motor skills, she would work on his shoulder strength and ability to throw objects. With regard to his fine motor skills, she would use various types of scissors, pencils and small bags which STUDENT would pick up and use. Rebecca Allen, speech and language specialist, testified that her speech and language therapy, twice per week for sixty minutes, would concentrate on the pronunciation of sounds, articulation, and simple words. Thus, the totality of all these components establishes that the Districts placement was in conformity with the Butte IEP.

Dr. Tricia Howell testified that when the District’s duty to implement STUDENT’s interim placement began in August, its regular education ROP preschool class at Madison Elementary School was on summer vacation and did not resume instruction until September. California Code of Regulations § 3043(h) provides that “if during the regular academic year an individual’s individualized education program specifies integration in the regular classroom, a public education agency is not required to meet that component of the individualized education program if no regular summer school programs are being offered by that agency.” Thus, while the Butte placement offered STUDENT integration with regular education preschool children, the District was not required to provide the regular education component in its interim placement, since the ROP class was on summer vacation.

In conclusion, the interim placement offered by the District implemented STUDENT’S existing IEP from Butte because it included all the requisite components to address his individualized needs and provided them to the extent possible based upon the resources which were available during the summer. Therefore, the interim placement was in conformity with the Butte IEP.

ISSUE 3: Did the District provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education while it developed his placement for the 2000-2001 school year?

Before the expiration of the interim placement, the District had the obligation to make a final recommendation regarding a placement and services for STUDENT. California Education Code § 56325(b). The District offered STUDENT a placement and services for approximately two months while it assessed STUDENT and developed an IEP for the 2000-2001 school year. Thus, the Hearing Officer now determines whether the District’s placement provided STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education. Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free and appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. §1400; California Education Code § 56000). Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(18), “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that conform with the student’s individualized educational program. “Special education” is defined as “Specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child...” 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(16).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. vs. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the students’ abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Rowley, 458 at 201-208.)

The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parents’ participation in the IEP process may result in the denial of a free appropriate public education to the student. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479.

In summary, under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley, the analysis of whether a student has been provided a FAPE is twofold. It must be determined whether the District has followed procedural requirements and whether it has offered a placement that is substantively appropriate.

(1) Procedural compliance

California Education Code § 56325(b) provides that “before the expiration of the 30-day period, the interim placement shall be reviewed by the individualized educational program (IEP) team and a final recommendation shall be made by the team in accordance with the requirements of this chapter. The team may utilize information, records, and reports from the school district or county program from which the pupil transferred.” However, if the parties are unable to agree on a placement, the federal law provides further guidance. In Appendix A to Part 300 of the Code of Federal Regulations, under the heading “Individualized Education Programs (IEPS) and Other Selected Implementation Issues, Part IV, “Other Questions regarding the Development and Content of IEPs,” question 17 provides in pertinent part: “Before the child’s IEP is finalized, the new public agency may provide interim services agreed to by both the parties and the new public agency. If the parents and the new public agency are unable to agree on an interim IEP and placement, the new public agency must implement the old IEP to the extent possible until a new IEP is developed and implemented.” Finally, California Education Code § 56346(a) provides that “if the parent does not consent to all the components of the individualized program, then those components of the program to which the parent has consented shall be implemented so as not to delay providing instruction and services to the pupil.”(Footnote 10)

In this case, Dr. Howell testified that the interim placement was not timely reviewed before the expiration of the 30-day period. The first issue raised by this fact is whether this procedural violation resulted in the loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT, thus denying him a FAPE. Dr. Tricia Howell testified that the IEP scheduled on September 4, 2000, did not occur because the parties disagreed about the appropriate placement for STUDENT. In the three weeks immediately following the failed IEP, the District offered to begin STUDENT’S placement in the ROP preschool class pursuant to the August IEP. MOTHER rejected it. The District also renewed its offer to place STUDENT in the NON-RIS class, which it offered to him in August. MOTHER rejected this preschool class again.(Footnote 11) (Petitioner’s Exhibit 52.) As discussed in the interim placement above, the Hearing Officer found both of these placements in conformity with the Butte IEP. Furthermore, the District continued to provide STUDENT with occupational and speech therapy during this time. The District, then, attempted to implement STUDENT’S old IEP to the extent possible after the September IEP did not timely occur. Thus, the District’s failure to timely review the interim placement before the expiration of the 30-day period did not result in the loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT and did not deny him a FAPE.

The second issue raised by the District’s failure to timely review the interim placement before the expiration of the 30-day period was whether it seriously infringed on the parent’s participation in the IEP process, thus denying STUDENT a FAPE. Dr. Howell testified that in the three weeks following the failed IEP meeting on September 4, 2000, the parties discussed both an appropriate placement for STUDENT and assessing him. However, MOTHER would not allow the District to assess him and confirmed this fact in writing.(Footnote 12) (Petitioner’s Exhibits 53 and 54.) On September 27, 2000, MOTHER agreed to allow the District to assess STUDENT and the second IEP occurred on the same day. (Petitioner’s Exhibits 57 and 58.) While the IEP did not timely occur on September 4, 2000, the parties continued talking with each other and the IEP occurred only three weeks later. The three-week delay in holding the IEP, then, did not seriously infringe on the parent’s participation in the IEP process. Thus, STUDENT was not denied a FAPE.

At the September 4, 2000 IEP, (Petitioner’s Exhibit 57), the District offered STUDENT the same placement and services it offered him at the August 4,2000 IEP. The placement was effective to October 27, 2000. MOTHER rejected the offer of placement. However, STUDENT continued to receive the individual occupational therapy and the individual speech and language therapy up to the November 8, 2000 IEP. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 57.) Thus, the District timely provided STUDENT with designated services in compliance with California Education Code § 56346(a).

The Hearing Officer now determines whether the District’s September 27, 2000 placement and services provided STUDENT with a FAPE.

(2) STUDENT’S unique needs

In order to analyze the appropriateness of the educational program offered by the District, one must first determine the nature of STUDENT’S needs as of September 2000. As noted above, the records provided from Mountain View and Butte Counties (Petitioner’s Exhibits 1 to 44) established that STUDENT suffered from Down Syndrome and had developmental delays in communication, gross and fine motor skills, and self-help skills.

Since MOTHER would not initially allow the District to assess STUDENT, the District had to rely upon the prior assessments from Butte County for guidance. Sharon Bolden-Schleh, school psychologist, conducted the psychological evaluation on December 9, 1999. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 42.) Employing the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales, Ms. Bolden-Schleh found delays in STUDENT’S communication, daily living skills, and motor skills. Socialization was STUDENT’S strength. She established STUDENT’S functioning level between one to two years old. While Dr. Bolden-Schleh found STUDENT eligible for special education services as a child with an established disability, she did not make any specific recommendations for therapy.

Kathleen Nissan, speech and language specialist, conducted the speech and language evaluation on November 1, 1999. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 35.) Employing the Preschool Language Scale 3, Ms. Nissan found delays in auditory comprehension and expressive communication. STUDENT’S functioning level was from sixteen to twenty months. Employing the Bzoch-League Receptive-Expressive Emergent Language Scale Second Edition, she found delays in receptive and expressive language. The age equivalent was from 14 to 22 months. Employment of the Early Language Milestone Scale two revealed delays in auditory expressive and auditory receptive language skills. The age equivalent was 18 months. Ms. Nissan also employed the Articulation Test, Identifying Early Phonological Needs, which revealed delays in STUDENT’S articulation. Thus, Kathlen Nissan recommended oral motor therapy and speech and language therapy.

Lori Diessen, registered occupational therapist, conducted the occupational therapy evaluation on November 8, 1999. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 36.) Ms. Diessen evaluated STUDENT’S gross and fine motor skills and self-help skills. The gross motor evaluation revealed decreased muscle tone and weakness. The fine motor evaluation revealed problems with gripping and eye and hand coordination. STUDENT also exhibited delays with using food utensils and dressing. Lori Diessen recommended occupational therapy to develop STUDENT’S gross and fine motor skills and his self-help skills.

In sum, the Butte county assessment revealed that STUDENT’S needs were in communication skills, gross and fine motor skills, and self-help skills. The next step in determining whether the proposed program was designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs is to examine the December 1999 IEP.

(3) Program designed to meet STUDENT’S needs

The District’s placement and services for September and October 2000 were based upon the December 1999 Butte IEP. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 44.) The Butte IEP contained goals, objectives, and benchmarks for STUDENT’S needs through October 1, 2000. The District did not present any evidence that the parties disputed the Butte IEP goals and objectives and whether the IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’S needs. As discussed above, the goals and objectives in the IEP addressed STUDENT’S needs in communication, self-help and socialization.

The District presented oral and documentary evidence to establish that its placement and services from September 4, 2000, to October 27, 2000, were designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs.(Footnote 13) The District first established that the NON-RIS and ROP classes were taught by qualified staff. Dr. Particia Howell and Ann Rytting testified that the NON-RIS class was taught by a speech and language specialist and that the ROP preschool class was taught by a regular education preschool teacher. The Butte program also had a special education teacher and a regular education preschool teacher. Second, both classes included a classroom aide for STUDENT. The Butte IEP also had this component. Furthermore, there were high school students in the ROP class who were learning to become preschool teachers and helped the teacher. This component went beyond the Butte IEP. Finally, the speech and language specialist had experience in teaching children both with Down Syndrome and other developmental delays. While there was no specific indication in the Butte IEP that the SH-SDC teacher was qualified to teach children with Down Syndrome and other developmental delays, the Hearing Officer assumes that this was the case due to the fact that STUDENT was in a class for severely handicapped children.

Dr. Tricia Howell and Ann Rytting testified how the placement in both the NON-RIS and ROP classes would have fostered STUDENT’S speech and language needs, social/adaptation needs, and self-help needs. First, they testified that the morning NON-RIS class was available to specifically help children with communication needs. The children would take part in circle time, small groups and other activities, all of which had the goal of fostering and improving language. Although the ROP program was not taught by a speech and language specialist, Dr. Howell pointed out that it provided STUDENT with typically developing peers who would serve as good role models for his communication and socialization needs. Furthermore, both classes had recess during which STUDENT would have additional opportunities to develop his language and socialization skills. During the day, STUDENT also had an opportunity at lunch time to foster these skills. Dr. Tricia Howell testified that the classroom aides would help STUDENT to use the restroom and take part in classroom projects, which fostered his self-help skills. Finally, STUDENT received individual occupational therapy once per week for one hour, and individual speech and language therapy also once per week for one hour. This component was exactly like the DIS component in the Butte IEP. Thus, the District established that the combination of both the NON-RIS class in the morning and the ROP class in the afternoon, along with the designated instruction and services in the afternoon, provided STUDENT with opportunities throughout the entire day to work on all of his unique needs.

The NON-RIS and the ROP placements, together with the ongoing individual occupational therapy and individual speech and language therapy, were designed to meet STUDENT’S needs in the December 1999 Butte IEP.

(4) Educational benefit

On September 15, 2000, MOTHER sent the District a letter (Petitioner’s Exhibit 53) and noted: “We are not simply looking for a regular preschool with all typically developing children and regular preschool teachers. We are looking for an extremely unique, and apparently hard to find, combination of typically developing children, differently abled children, regular preschool teachers, and specially trained teachers and related service providers... .” While it is understandable that MOTHER wishes to maximize STUDENT’S potential with an “extremely unique” and “hard to fine” placement, the law does not place such a burden on the District. In Rowley, 458 U.S. at 198, 200 and 201, the court stated that “the requirement that a state provide specialized educational services to handicapped children generates no additional requirements that the services so provided be sufficient to maximize each child’s potential “commensurate with the opportunity provided other children.” The court went on to note that “implicit in the congressional purpose of providing access to a free appropriate public education is the requirement that the education to which access is provided be sufficient to confer some educational benefit upon the handicapped child.... We therefore conclude that the basic floor of opportunity provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide benefit to the handicapped child.”

The District presented evidence that the placements in the NON-RIS and ROP programs and the designated services would have provided STUDENT with educational benefit and a basic floor of opportunity. Dr. Tricia Howell and Ann Rytting testified that the NON-RIS class was specifically geared toward STUDENT’S speech and language needs. The speech and language specialist would help STUDENT to improve his pronunciation, language comprehension, and vocabulary. Furthermore, STUDENT would have the benefit of this class for two and one-half hours per day in additional to one hour per week of individual speech and language therapy. The ROP program also would have provided STUDENT with circle, group and recess time in which to develop his language skills. Both preschool classes also would have helped STUDENT with his gross and fine motor needs. At recess time, STUDENT would have had the opportunity to play with various toys outside. In the classroom, he would have had the opportunity to draw and work with other objects to develop his fine motor skills. Moreover, all the District witnesses testified that the two classes would have provided STUDENT opportunities all day to improve his socialization skills. Dr. Howell pointed out that if STUDENT needed help with his personal needs, such as toileting, a classroom aide was present to help him. Jessica Peng also testified that in her individual occupational therapy, STUDENT would have learned how to take things out put them away. Finally, Jessica Peng, Dean Paul, and Sherry Blakely testified that the individual occupational and speech and language therapy provided STUDENT with the opportunity to further improve his motor and speech skills. Thus, the combined placements in the NON-RIS and ROP programs and the designated services would have provided STUDENT with the educational benefit and a basic floor of opportunity to meet his individual needs.

(5) Implementation of IEP

The District properly implemented the designated instruction and services. As outlined above in the interim placement discussion, this aspect of the analysis is not applicable to the NON-RIS and ROP placements since STUDENT did not attend these classes.

(6) Least restrictive environment

The federal law requires that, to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities are educated with children who are not disabled and that removal from the regular educational environment occur only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. §1412(a)(5)(A). Furthermore, California Education Code § 56031 requires that special education provide a full continuum of program options, including instruction conducted in the classroom to meet the educational and service needs of individuals with exceptional needs in the least restrictive environment. In Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel H., 14 F.3d 1938, 1404 (9th Cir. 1994), the Ninth Circuit provided the factors which one must consider when determining the amount to which a local education agency must integrate a disabled student into the regular education program: (1) the educational benefits of placement full-time in a regular education class; (2) the non-academic benefits of such a placement; (3) the effect the disabled child will have on the teacher and children in the regular education class; and (4) the costs of mainstreaming the disabled child.

In this case, the placement in both the NON-RIS and ROP programs was the least restrictive environment. First, the District’s witnesses testified that by placing STUDENT in both preschool classes, STUDENT would have had the benefit of learning from typically developing peers in the ROP class while at the same time having his educational needs met in the more specialized NON-RIS class. Both Dr. Tricia Howell and Ann Rytting testified that if STUDENT were placed solely in a regular preschool class, he would not receive the proper education to satisfy his unique needs. The final two elements were not addressed by the District. Nonetheless, the totality of the evidence presented by the District established that its placement was the least restrictive environment to maximize STUDENT’S interaction with typically developing peers and still receive educational benefit.

(7) Conclusion

The oral and documentary presented by the District established that the placement and services it offered STUDENT upon expiration of the interim placement provided STUDENT with a FAPE.

ISSUE 4: Did the District’s offer of placement and services at Benito Juarez preschool on November 8, 2000, provide STUDENT with FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year?

Between September 27, 2000, and November 7, 2000, the District assessed student. On November 8, 2000, the IEP meeting took place. At the meeting, the District made its offer of placement and services for STUDENT for the 2000-2001 school year through November 8, 2001.

(1) Procedural compliance

California Education Code § 56344 provides that an individualized education program required as a result of an assessment of a pupil shall be developed within a total time not to exceed fifty days. On September 27, 2000, MOTHER signed an assessment plan to allow the District to assess STUDENT. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 58.) The speech and language and occupational therapy assessments were timely completed in October 2000 and the IEP meeting was held on November 8, 2000, with the entire IEP team. Thus, the District complied with the time guidelines pursuant to California Education Code § 56344.

(2) STUDENT’S unique needs

In order to analyze the appropriateness of the educational program offered by the District, one must first determine the nature of STUDENT’S unique and individual needs as of November 2000. As outlined above, the records provided from Mountain View and Butte Counties to the District (Petitioner’s Exhibits 1 to 44) established that as a result of his Down Syndrome, he had developmental delays in communications, gross and fine motor skills, and self-help skills. His last IEP in Butte County (Petitioner’s Exhibit 44) specifically dealt with those delays.

Using these records as a guideline to understand STUDENT’S past, the District assessed STUDENT’S communication skills, gross and fine motor skills, self-help skills, cognitive development, and pre-academic/academic skills. Rececca Allen conducted the communication evaluation on October 10, 2000. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 59.) Employing the Goldman Fristoe Test of Articulation, she found multiple delays in speech production. Using the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test Form IIIB and the Rossetti Infant-Toddler Scale, she found receptive and expressive language delays, which placed STUDENT at a developmental level of 15 to 21 months. He was in fact over three years of age. Finally, Rebecca Allen noted attention/concentration delays in the testing. Thus, she recommended individual speech and language therapy twice per week for 30 minutes and a placement in a preschool classroom with a focus on language skills.

Mother obtained an independent speech and language evaluation on December 8, 2000, one month after the IEP on November 8, 2000, from Nina Welch. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 70.) Rebecca Allen and Dean Paul, also a school speech and language specialist, reviewed Ms. Welch’s report. They both testified that they found Ms. Welch’s findings consistent with those of Ms. Allen’s. The only disagreement they had with her report was that it recommended two hours of individual speech and language therapy per week, whereas Ms. Allen and Ms. Paul, along with the Butte IEP, recommended one hour per week of individual speech and language therapy. Both Ms. Allen and Ms. Paul testified that more than one hour of individual speech and language instruction per week was not productive because the individual therapy needed to be reinforced with typically developing peers in the classroom.(Footnote 14) The Hearing Officer found both Ms. Allen’s and Ms. Paul’s testimony sufficient to establish that one hour per week of individual speech and language therapy met STUDENT’S individual and unique needs.

Jessica Peng testified that she took part in the occupational therapy evaluations of STUDENT. (Petitioner’s Exhibits 61 and 62.) The gross motor assessment revealed that STUDENT needed to increase his upper body and shoulder strength. His developmental level was 18 months to 3 years. Employing the Peabody Developmental Motor Scales, the testing revealed that STUDENT’S fine motor skills were in the 18 to 22 month range. He needed to increase his ability to manipulate small objects such scissors or a writing utensil. MOTHER had an independent occupational therapy evaluation of STUDENT done on November 7, 2000, by Dyanne E. Van Peter (Petitioner’s Exhibit 67), which Ms. Peng reviewed.(Footnote 15) She testified that the findings and recommendations were the same as those of the two occupational therapy evaluations performed by the District except for the amount of individual occupational therapy. While Ms. Van Peter felt that STUDENT required 2 hours of individual therapy per week, Ms. Peng testified that this amount of individual occupational therapy per week was too much and ultimately counterproductive for STUDENT. He would receive adequate time in school to develop his gross and fine motor skills along with the one hour per week of individual occupational therapy the District offered.

Ann Rytting testified that she conducted readiness (pre-academic/academic) skills, motor skills, social/adaptive skills, self-help skills, and cognitive (intellectual development) functioning assessments. (Petitioner’s Exhibits 58 and 62.) Ms. Rytting employed the Brigance test to assess STUDENT’S readiness skills and determined that he needed to improve his categorization skills. She observed STUDENT at the RIO preschool in Orange, California and employed the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales (VABS) to assess his gross and fine motor skills. Ms. Rytting determined that STUDENT’S level of development was from 22 to 26 months, which was below his three years and 10 months of age. Thus, he needed help in this area also. While observing STUDENT at RIO, Ms. Rytting also used the Brigance to assess his social/adaptive skills. She found that STUDENT needed to learn how to interact better with other children and take an interest in them. To assess STUDENT’S self-help skills, she used the VABS. Ann Rytting found that STUDENT needed help with toileting and dressing. In assessing his cognitive skills, she employed the Bayley II Scales of Infant Development. Ms. Rytting determined that STUDENT needed help in all areas of cognitive development such as language, pointing to pictures, fine motor skills etc. STUDENT’S cognitive developmental level was 20 to 22 months.

The District’s assessments, then, revealed that STUDENT’S areas of need were in communication skills, gross and fine motor skills, self-help skills, cognitive development, and pre-academic/academic skills.The next step in determining whether the proposed program was designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs is to examine the November 8, 2000 IEP. The IEP is a written statement of measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives. It is developed to meet the student’s unique needs and to provide the special education and related services that will assist the student to advance toward attaining these goals. 20 U.S.C. Section 1414(d)(1)(A) (ii), (iii).

(3) Program designed to meet STUDENT’S needs

The November 8, 2000 IEP (Petitioner’s Exhibit 68), sets forth the goals with specific objectives to address STUDENT’S unique needs in readiness, social adaptation, pre-vocational skills, gross and fine motor skills, stability, tool use, self-help, receptive and expressive language, speech and attention.(Footnote 16) The readiness goals focus on learning colors and shapes. The social adaptation goals focus on greeting and playing with other children. The pre-vocational goals focus on imitating in large groups. The gross and stability goals focus on arm strength, joint stability, catching, riding a tricycle and throwing a ball. The fine motor and tool use goals focus on using scissors and crayons. The self-help goals focus on toileting and drinking from a sippy cup and straw, washing and drying the face, and dressing. The receptive language goals focus on following two-step verbal commands. The expressive language goals focus on accurately stating basic needs and desires using verbal gestures. The speech goals focus on pronouncing words properly. Finally, the attention goals focus on staying on task for 5 to 15 minutes. Thus, these goals with specific objectives in the November 8, 2000 IEP are in conformity with the findings in the assessments and are designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs.

The District next presented oral and documentary evidence to establish that its placement and services at Benito Juarez preschool are designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs. The District first established that the Benito Juarez class is taught by a qualified staff. Hope Bosheff, the special education teacher for the class, described her credentials. She testified that she has her Bachelor of Science degree and a teaching credential in early childhood development, and a Master of Arts degree in education with an emphasis in special education. Ms. Bosheff pointed out that she has experience in teaching Down Syndrome children in the past.

Hope Bosheff then described the support she receives in teaching the students. Two aides assist her in the morning and two additional aides help in the afternoon. Dean Paul, school speech and language therapist, comes into the class once per week to teach in small groups and provide Ms. Bosheff with materials to use in her class. Ms. Paul testified to the same facts. The occupational physical therapist, Jessica Peng, comes into the class every other week for 30 minutes to provide therapy in small groups and give Ms. Bosheff input on teaching methods and particular students. Ms. Peng testified to the same facts. Carol Edwards, the Benito Juarez school psychologist, comes into the class one to three times per week to observe the students and provide feedback to Ms. Bosheff. Ms. Edwards testified to the same facts. Ms. Bosheff sends home a daily log to the parents to let them know how their child is doing and to receive input back from them. Finally, the staff at Benito Juarez holds weekly meetings to discuss the program and the progress and needs of the individual children.

Hope Bosheff, Dean Paul and Sherry Blakely, school special education coordinator, testified about how the placement would foster STUDENT’S speech and language needs and social/adaptation needs. First, they testified that the class is heavily language-based. In the morning, STUDENT would be greeted and in the afternoon, he would say good bye to the teacher and other children. In circle time, language and socialization among typically developing peers, the special needs children, and the teacher are pursued. These goals are accomplished by drawing, reading, singing, passing objects and making things. The students then break into small groups, where language is further fostered. During recess, Ms. Bosheff and the special circumstances aides go outside with the children to promote the use of language also. At lunch, the children also have the opportunity to use language in a family setting. Even when the children toilet train, Ms. Bosheff explained that it is done socially to foster language. Finally, the rest of the afternoon is spent in circle time and small groups to further develop language. Thus, STUDENT would have opportunities the entire day to improve his speech and language and social needs.

Hope Bosheff, and Dean Paul then described the specific teaching methods they use to promote language development. First, Ms. Bosheff testified that she is certified in and employs the Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS). This system uses pictures for children like STUDENT to point to when they have difficulty communicating. This system ensures that they are heard and will not become frustrated. Dean Paul testified that she too is certified in this system and uses it in her speech and language therapy both in and outside the classroom. Second, Ms. Bosheff described how she is trained in and uses the Good Language/Good Speech (GL/GS) method in class. Instead of telling a child like STUDENT that he is not speaking correctly, she tells him that he speaks well but can improve if he uses her example. In this way, speech is positively reinforced. Dean Paul testified that she also uses this method. Third, Ms. Bosheff explained that she breaks down language into two distinct steps with words, pictures and objects so the special needs children like STUDENT can learn. Furthermore, language objectives are broken down into concepts like the color green or blue to accomplish language objectives. Finally, Dean Paul testified that she also uses the Links to Language method which requires children to match pictures. Thus, the totality of these methods are aimed at improving STUDENT’S language needs.

Hope Bosheff and all the other Distict’s witnesses testified that the class employs projects to further foster language. To improve receptive language, the children pass around and discuss objects in circle time. To improve expressive language, the students select or draw pictures and then pronounce them. Ms. Bosheff also employs singing, books and story telling to promote language use. Moreover, Dean Paul comes into the class once per week to work with the children in small groups. Ms. Paul testified that she also gives Ms. Bosheff special oral motor packets every week to use in class. Finally, the classroom aides work with the children either in small groups or individually for 10 minutes per day to work on oral motor skills. In conclusion, the District established that language is promoted in a natural environment the entire day using an integrated approach of teaching methods, typically developing peers and the special needs children. Thus, this placement satisfies STUDENT’S speech and language needs.

The District next presented evidence on how the program at Benito Juarez would meet STUDENT’S gross and fine motor, stability, and tool use needs. Hope Bosheff testified that there are two recesses per day. During recess, the children have the opportunity to ride tricycles, pull wagons, throw and catch balls and bean bags, and pull on ropes. If STUDENT had a problem, for example, in using the tricycle, Ms. Bosheff or the classroom aide would teach him how to pedal. Inside the classroom during circle time, the children use crayons, markers, pens, and stencils to develop their fine motor, stability and tool use needs. These activities are broken down into simple steps so children like STUDENT can learn. The classroom aides further work on these skills in small groups. Finally, Jessica Peng testified how she comes into the class every other week to provide occupational therapy instruction in jumping, walking, rolling, body movement etc. Ms. Peng also gives Hope Bosheff further ideas for use in her class. Ms. Peng noted that the typically developing peers serve as good role models for these motor skills and would help STUDENT develop self-confidence. Thus, the program is designed to meet STUDENT’S gross and fine motor, stability and tool use needs.

Hope Bosheff, Ann Rytting, Carol Edwards and Sherry Blakely testified how the placement at Benito Juarez would meet STUDENT’S readiness and pre-vocational needs. With regard to STUDENT’S readiness needs, Ms. Bosheff would require him to name colors and shapes. She works on this skill daily in circle time and in small groups. With regard to his pre-vocational needs, STUDENT would sing and clap his hands in circle time and in small groups, and learn to imitate at recess, at lunch and even during toileting. Activities are specifically planned and supervised for these needs. Finally, a classroom aide is present to assist STUDENT with these needs.

The District next presented evidence on how the placement would meet his self-help needs. Hope Bosheff, Ann Rytting, Carol Edwards, and Jessica Peng testified that in the morning, STUDENT would learn how to take off his jacket, shoes and socks and then put them on at the end of the day. Every day, STUDENT would learn how to drink from a sippy cup and use a straw. After lunch, STUDENT would learn how to wash and dry his hands and face. Toileting is also a group activity everyday. Ms. Rytting and Ms. Bosheff noted how the typically developing peers are good role models for these self-help skills. Finally, Ms. Bosheff explained how she uses the PECS system so children like STUDENT can communicate their needs.

The District witnesses all testified how the placement would meet STUDENT’S attention needs. Hope Bosheff, Ann Rytting and Carol Edwards testified that they use projects, singing, toys, etc. to make learning fun. In this way, the activities are designed to improve the child’s attention span. Second, Hope Bosheff testified that she uses a theme approach throughout the day. For example, everything they do one day will deal with the color blue or green. This theme approach, though fun, has improving attention as its final goal. Third, Ms. Bosheff uses a slow building process on all themes. This slow incremental approach is also structured to hold the child’s attention. Finally, Hope Bosheff testified how she uses reinforcers such as songs about the color blue to hammer home certain themes and concepts. Thus, all of these factors together would improve STUDENT’S attention span.

The Districts’ witnesses also testified that the designated instruction and services are designed to meet STUDENT’S occupational therapy and speech needs. Jennifer Peng testified that she has provided STUDENT with one hour of individual occupational therapy from August 2000 to the present. She has worked on his gross and fine motor skills and stability needs. Dean Paul testified about the individual speech and language therapy she has provided to STUDENT. Ms. Paul testified that she is professionally trained in PECs, Links to Language, GL/GS, American sign language and C-sign language. She also has extensive experience in working with children with mental retardation. Ms. Paul noted that she has provided individual speech and language therapy to STUDENT one hour per week from November 2000 to the present. Furthermore, Ms. Rebecca Allen testified that she has provided the same services to STUDENT from August 2000 to November 2000. Finally, if these services were provided in class, STUDENT would have a special circumstances aide to help him. Thus, the designated instruction services are designed to meet STUDENT’S individual needs.

Based upon the oral and documentary evidence presented at the hearing by the District, the Hearing Officer concludes that the placement at Benito Juarez is designed to meet STUDENT’S individual and unique needs.

(4) Designed to provide educational benefit

The District presented evidence that the placement at Benito Juarez preschool would provide educational benefit to STUDENT. In communication, Dean Paul testified that the placement would help STUDENT to improve his pronunciation, language comprehension, and vocabulary. In social adaptation, Hope Bosheff testified that STUDENT would learn how to interact and work with his fellow peers. In gross and fine motor skills, stability and tool skills, Jessica Peng testified that STUDENT would improve his stability, strength, and use of toys, pens, scissors and similar objects. Ms. Peng also pointed out that from August 2000 to the present, STUDENT has greatly improved his endurance and ability to play with toys and manipulate smaller objects in individual occupational therapy. As to his readiness and pre-vocational needs, Ann Rytting and Carol Edwards testified that STUDENT would improve his understanding of colors, shapes and his ability to imitate the actions of his typically developing peers. Furthermore, the daily building-block approach of the program would help to both maintain and increase his attention span over time. Rebecca Allen and Dean Paul testified that STUDENT had made improvements in both receptive and expressive language in speech language from August 2000 to the present. Finally, STUDENT took part in the Benito Juarez placement for one week in the first week of December 2000 with MOTHER. Hope Bosheff, Sherry Blakely, Carol Edwards, and Dr. Tricia Howell all had an opportunity to observe STUDENT in the placement. The witnesses testified that in the morning STUDENT sat with the other children in circle time and partook in activities. During recess, he went outside and played on the swings, with the wagons and with other children. During lunch, he socialized with the other children. They did not have an opportunity to observe him in toileting since MOTHER took him to the bathroom. They testified that while it is not possible to note progress in communication in only one week in the class, his interaction with his typically developing peers led them to conclude that the environment is very conducive to promoting language development. Thus, the evidence provided by the District establishes that the placement and services at Benito Juarez would provide STUDENT with educational benefit.

(5) Placement conformity with IEP

Jennifer Peng, school occupational therapist, and Dean Paul, school speech and language therapist, testified that from November 2000 to the present, they have continued to provide STUDENT with one hour per week of occupational therapy and speech and language therapy. Thus, the designated instruction and services have been employed in conformity with the November 8, 2000 IEP.

As outlined in the discussion of the interim placement, the Hearing Officer is not able to evaluate whether the remainder of the placement is in conformity with the IEP since MOTHER withdrew STUDENT from the program after only one week. Thus, the Hearing Officer is unable to rule on this aspect of the case.

(6) Least restrictive environment

In this case, the District’s placement of STUDENT in the preschool class at Benito Juarez is the least restrictive environment. First, Dr. Tricia Howell and Ann Rytting testified that placement full-time in a regular education class does not meet STUDENT’S needs. STUDENT needs intensive language, cognitive, gross and fine motor, self-help, and socialization education which he would not receive in a regular education class. Furthermore, they pointed out that a regular education teacher alone is not qualified to meet the needs of a child like STUDENT with Down Syndrome. Second, Dr. Tricia Howell testified that STUDENT would receive non-academic benefits such as socialization with typically developing peers in a regular education class. However, Dr Howell pointed out that the regular education preschool class does not meet his speech and language needs, which is a critical component to his education. Third, the class at Benito Juarez provides STUDENT with the structure and attention he would not receive in the regular education class. While the cost of mainstreaming STUDENT was not discussed by the District, the evidence presented established that it is more costly to place STUDENT in a class at Benito Juarez than is a regular education class. Finally, the District’s witnesses all testified that the Benito Juarez preschool class provides STUDENT with both the educational and socialization benefits he needs to progress and grow as a child. Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that the evidence presented by the District establishes that the placement offered at Benito Juarez provides STUDENT with the least restrictive environment.

(7) Conclusion

Based upon the totality of the evidence presented by the District at the hearing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the placement and designated services offered by the District are designed to meet his unique needs, provide him with educational benefit and is the least restrictive environment. Thus, the District offered STUDENT a free and appropriate public education for the 2000-2001 school year.

ORDER

Petitioner shall immediately implement the placement and services offered to Respondent pursuant to the IEP dated November 8, 2000.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), this decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement: Petitioner prevailed on each issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decisions. California Education Code § 56505(i).

Dated: April 26, 2001 _____________________________________ Joseph T. Macaluso, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES

1. The Hearing Officer advised MOTHER that if she returned with a letter from an attorney attesting to actual representation of STUDENT or returned with an attorney, the Hearing Officer would entertain the motion to continue again at that time. 2.The first date represents the date that Petitioner filed its case and the second date represents the date that MOTHER allegedly contacted an advocate to help her with the mediation. Finally, the testimony revealed during the hearing that MOTHER had previously retained the services of an advocate to represent her while the parties were formulating the goals and objectives of Student’s November 8, 2000 IEP. 3.The IEP team decided to place STUDENT in a new “innovative” preschool class in Butte County. First, STUDENT’S special day class would participate with regular preschool children in different activities. Second, the special day class would be team taught by both a regular education teacher and a special education teacher. Finally, STUDENT would receive individual services separate from the regular education students. Thus, Butte county arrived at the phrase “full inclusion severely handicapped-special day class.” 4.The District was on summer vacation at this time. The summer vacation continued until September 2000. 5.The regional occupation preschool (ROP) was a regular preschool class. It consisted of a regular education teacher, special circumstance aides, typically developing peers, and a few special education students. The class was also assisted by high school students who received credit toward becoming preschool teachers and day care workers. Thus, the District used the name Regional Occupation Program (ROP). 6.MOTHER and the District agreed to have STUDENT visit the RIO preschool in order to assess his social/adaptive and gross and fine motor skills 7.Dr. Tricia Howell testified that she obtained this information about how the SH-SDC class was taught in a telephone conversation she had with the program specialist in Butte County. 8.Dr. Howell noted in her testimony that in her conversation with the Butte County program specialist, she learned that the preschool facility was actually a separate pre-school that had a variety of preschool classes and one general education class merged with a special day class. 9.Dr. Howell testified that the Butte County program specialist did not give her the ratio of special education preschool students to general education pre-school students. 10.The same provision in the federal law is found at 34 C.F.R. 300.505(e) 11.The August IEP, which included the NON-RIS and ROP preschool classes, was in effect from August 7, 2000 to October 1, 2000. 12.Pursuant to this impasse in assessing STUDENT, California Education Code § 56321(c) did not permit the District to assess STUDENT 13.The placement and services which the District offered during this time period were the same if offered STUDENT at the August 4, 2000 IEP. 14.Dr. Tricia Howell testified that the District reconvened an IEP meeting on December 13, 2000, in order to discuss its results with MOTHER. (Petitioners Exhibit 71.) After reviewing the report with MOTHER and the IEP team, the District stood by its offer of one hour per week of individual speech and language therapy. 15.Dr. Tricia Howell testified that the occupation therapy report from Dianne E. Van Peter was used at the November 8, 2000 IEP in forming STUDENT’S gross and fine motor goals and objectives. 16. STUDENT’S parents signed the November 8, 2000 IEP but noted that they disagreed with both the placement at Benito Juarez and the goals and objective for speech and language.