California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 16, 2002
Three Rivers Union Elementary School District et al. v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 1710-01 · Hearing Officer Michael F. Geary
Three Rivers Union Elementary and Tulare County Office of Education lose bid to move student from home-school inclusion to a distant SDC.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
Three Rivers Union Elementary School District and the Tulare County Office of Education filed for due process. The parents had refused a July 9, 2001 IEP that would place their seven-year-old son in a special day class (SDC) for students with severe disabilities at the F. J. White Learning Center in Woodlake, about an hour away by bus. The student has severe developmental delays, Down syndrome and autism, and does not speak. He was in his third year of inclusion at his home school, Three Rivers School. He had a one-on-one aide, resource specialist and speech services, and spent half his day in a general education class. The districts argued that he was not progressing and was disrupting classmates. The Hearing Officer found the SDC offer did not provide FAPE in the least restrictive environment. It lacked intensive one-on-one instruction, a one-on-one aide, a clear behavior plan and daily contact with typically developing peers. Its schedule also did not fit his needs. Under the four-factor Rachel H. (Holland) test, the student gained academic and social benefit at Three Rivers School. The disruption factor could not count against him because the districts had not properly analyzed or addressed his behaviors. He stays in his current placement. The district must hire an inclusion specialist, complete a functional behavior analysis within 30 days, and hold an IEP meeting within 40 days to build a program at his home school.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied the Rachel H. (Holland) least restrictive environment factors to a student with significant disabilities. Before claiming that a student's disruptive behavior justified removing him from general education, the district first had to use reasonable means to address that behavior, such as a functional behavior analysis and inclusion expertise.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1. Does the District's offer of placement at the F. J. White Learning Center in Woodlake, CA, as proposed in the IEP of July 9, 2001, offer the student a free, appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment?
The Woodlake SDC offer was not designed for the student's unique needs. It lacked intensive one-on-one instruction, a one-on-one aide, an adequate behavior plan, daily peer contact and a suitable schedule. The Rachel H. (Holland) factors favored the home school, so the offer was not FAPE in the LRE.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 2. Does the student require a change of placement in order to receive a free, appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment?
No change of placement is required. The districts had not used all reasonable means, including a functional behavior analysis and inclusion expertise, to make the home-school inclusion placement work, so it could not be changed over the parents' objection.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Student remains in his current placement at Three Rivers School pending further IEP team determinations; districts' requested resolutions denied.
- Order to assess. Within 10 calendar days, District must retain an inclusion specialist to conduct an impartial and balanced evaluation of the student's placement and program at Three Rivers School. Parents may, but need not, be allowed to take part in selecting the specialist. The specialist must finish gathering data within 25 days, write a report within 30 days, take part as an IEP team member within 40 days, and help implement the program as appropriate.
- Order to assess. Within 30 calendar days, Petitioners must use a qualified behavior analyst to complete a functional behavioral analysis of the maladaptive behaviors interfering with the student's and classmates' education, with a written report and draft plan.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 40 calendar days, District must convene an IEP meeting to consider the inclusion specialist's and behavior analyst's reports and develop a program at Three Rivers School. The program must include an appropriate amount of intensive one-on-one instruction, an instructional aide, a behavioral plan, and revised goals and objectives.
- Parents must cooperate with the inclusion specialist and behavior analyst, including interviews, providing information, and reasonable observations at home, at school or in other settings.
Key authorities
Rowley; Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education (5th Cir. 1989); Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H. (Holland) (E.D. Cal. 1992; 9th Cir. 1994)
People named in the decision
- Bryna Siegel, Ph.D., educational consultant and expert witness for District (autism specialist), Langley Porter Institute, University of California, San Francisco
- Larry Gillham, Ph.D., administrator of behavioral services; author of June 2000 behavior plan, Tulare County Office of Education
- Robert May, school psychologist (2000 psychoeducational assessment)
- Terri Hiltel, resource specialist and speech-language therapist, Tulare County Office of Education
- Susan Sherwood, superintendent and principal of Three Rivers School; District representative, Three Rivers Union Elementary School District
- Marilyn Rankin, Ed.D., assistant superintendent and SELPA director; COE representative, Tulare County Office of Education
- Donna Martin, program manager for severely handicapped services, Tulare County Office of Education
- Melinda Simonian, first grade teacher, Three Rivers School
- Mindy Boyer, instructional aide (one-on-one aide in first grade), Three Rivers Union Elementary School District
- Marie Powell, kindergarten teacher, Three Rivers School
- Barbara Merline, instructional aide assisting with RSP and language services, Tulare County Office of Education
- Barbara Clarey, teacher of severely handicapped special day class, F. J. White Learning Center, Woodlake
- Trish Griswold, former special education teacher of Woodlake SDC (1999 assessment), F. J. White Learning Center, Woodlake
- Laurie Cassano, instructional aide (kindergarten), Three Rivers School
- Leslie Farlow, Ph.D., educational consultant and expert witness for Student (inclusion)
- Howard J. Glidden, Ph.D., developmental neuropsychologist (March 2000 evaluation)
- Diagnostic Center for Central California, state diagnostic center assessor (1998 and 2000 assessments), California Department of Education
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was as heard before Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Visalia, California, on November 1, 2, 27, and 28, December 6, 7, 18, and 19, 2001, and on January 14, 15, 22, and 23, 2002.
Petitioners Three Rivers Union Elementary School District (District) and Tulare County Office of Education (COE) were represented by attorney Eliza J. McArthur of the law firm McArthur & Levin, LLP. In addition to its attorney, the District was represented throughout the hearing by Susan Sherwood, superintendent of the District and principal of the Three Rivers School (3R School), and the COE was represented by Marilyn Rankin, Ed.D, assistant superintendent for the COE and director of the special education local plan area (SELPA).
Respondent STUDENT was represented by attorney Michael Kluk, of Protection & Advocacy, Inc. STUDENT’s parents, Mr. Parent and Ms. Parent, were also present during the hearing.(Footnote 1)
The Petitioners called the following witnesses: Bryna Siegel, Ph.D., the District’s retained educational consultant; Larry Gillham, Ph.D, administrator of behavioral services for the COE; Robert May, school psychologist; Terri Hiltel, resource specialist and speech and language therapist for the COE; Susan Sherwood, superintendent of the District and principal of 3R School; Donna Martin, program manager for severely handicapped services for the COE; Melinda Simonian, first grade teacher at the 3R School; Mindy Boyer, instructional aide for the District; Marie Powell, kindergarten teacher at the 3R School; Barbara Merline, instructional aide for the COE; and Barbara Clarey, teacher of the severely handicapped special day class at the F. J. White Learning Center at the District’s school in Woodlake (Woodlake SDC).
The Respondent called the following witnesses: Mr. Parent, his father; Ms. Parent, his mother; Leslie Farlow, Ph.D., the Respondent’s retained educational consultant; and FAMILY FRIEND, an acquaintance of the Respondent’s family who cared for STUDENT for two weeks to provide respite to his parents.
Oral and documentary evidence was presented at the hearing. Written closing arguments were received from the parties, and the record was closed on February 22, 2002.
ISSUES PRESENTED(Footnote 2)
1. Does the District’s offer of placement at the F. J. White Learning Center in Woodlake, CA, as proposed in the individualized education plan of July 9, 2001, offer STUDENT a free, appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment?
2. Does STUDENT require a change of placement in order to receive a free, appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment?(Footnote 3)
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
As to Issue 1:
Petitioners contend that the offer of placement in a special day class (SDC) at the F. J. White Learning Center in Woodlake, California, as proposed in the individualized education plan of July 9, 2001, offers STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment. More specifically, they argue that STUDENT needs the services of a full-time special education teacher and support staff who can administer his individualized education program in a structured, predictable environment in which he will have greater opportunity to learn at less risk to the learning of his general education peers. The Petitioners request a finding that the offer of July 9, 2001, is an offer of a FAPE in the least restrictive environment.
Respondent contends that because STUDENT can receive a FAPE in his current educational program at 3R School, an environment far less restrictive than the proposed SDC, and since there is no adequate evidence to support a contrary finding, the presumption in favor of providing an education to the special student in his home school must prevail. He requests a finding that the offer of July 9, 2002, is not an offer of FAPE.
As to Petitioners’ Issue 2:
Petitioners contend that STUDENT has made inadequate progress in his program at 3R School. They contend that he is not receiving a FAPE in the least restrictive environment, as required by the Individuals with Disabilities in Education Act (IDEA). More specifically, they contend that STUDENT’s developmental levels and maladaptive behaviors prevent him from receiving a benefit from his current educational program at 3R School and that his attendance in the regular education class interferes with his classmates’ education. The Petitioners request a finding that STUDENT does require a change of placement in order to receive a FAPE in the least restrictive environment.
Respondent contends that STUDENT is receiving a FAPE in the least restrictive environment in his current educational program at 3R School as evidenced by progress made toward goals and objectives and that his progress could be even further enhanced, and the disruption to his classmates lessened, by changes in the way services are delivered to him. The Respondent requests a finding that STUDENT does not require a change of placement to receive a FAPE in the least restrictive environment. He also requests that the Petitioners be ordered to retain the services of an inclusion specialist, an education professional who is qualified to provide constructive advice and assistance on ways to make the inclusion program work for STUDENT.
BACKGROUND
STUDENT is a boy of seven years and ten months who resides with his parents and two siblings in Three Rivers, a small community in eastern Tulare County. STUDENT has pervasive developmental delays in all domains and has long carried the diagnosis of Down syndrome. More recently, he has been diagnosed with an autistic disorder. His developmental levels are generally in the six- to twenty-four month range. He is nonverbal. STUDENT has been eligible for and receiving special education and related services since he was an infant. His current placement is the regular first grade class at 3R School, where he is in his third year of an inclusion program.(Footnote 4) His program calls for 50 percent integration with a one-on-one instructional aide and intensive, one-on-one resource specialist (RSP) and speech and language services for the remainder of the day.
STUDENT’s first individualized education plan (IEP) developed in September 15, 1997, provided for twenty minutes of speech and language therapy twice per week in a preschool of the parent’s choice with the services of a one-on-one instructional aide. Goals and objectives were in the areas of social skills, receptive language, expressive language and self-help. (Ex. 1:5-7)(Footnote 5) Following the September 1997 IEP meeting, STUDENT’s parents stated some of the goals they had for their son. They wanted him to be able to communicate his basic needs (eat, hurt, cup, up, down, Mom and Dad), point to or otherwise indicate body parts, take turns, share, interact with his peers one-on-one or in a small group by attending to or participating in a story, game or other activity for five minutes, and develop at least some awareness of toileting basics. The parents also felt “quite strongly that an inclusive school setting [was] the first step for STUDENT to feel that he is part of the community.” (Ex.1:10)
STUDENT’s next IEP meeting was on December 12, 1997. (Ex. 1:13) At that time, he was enrolled at a private preschool with the help of an instructional aide and was, by this report, continuing to work toward the goals outlined in the earlier IEP. An increase in speech and language services to three times per week for twenty minutes was recommended and agreed upon.
On April 15, 1998, STUDENT underwent a speech and language assessment by the California Department of Education’s Diagnostic Center for Central California (Diagnostic Center). The report states that STUDENT, while extremely limited in social and communicative initiation, did initiate some interaction with adults and with his little sister. With the elimination of sensory-based repetitive activity, such as spinning an object, STUDENT would engage in cause-effect and exploratory play. He also engaged in reciprocal play with his parents by rolling a ball back and forth. The assessor concluded that a continuing emphasis on the development of receptive and expressive language was appropriate and that the services of Terri Hiltel had been very effective. The report also noted that the efforts to eliminate a sound that STUDENT made frequently were successful and that the same methods could be used, along with other strategies, to control behaviors that were interfering with STUDENT’s learning. It was suggested that once a working vocabulary (speech, signs, symbols or picture communication) was established, opportunities should be created for STUDENT to facilitate his initiation of communication within various contexts or environments, such as lunch or snack time. There also were a number of recommendations for focusing language around a functional vocabulary and facilitating auditory language processing.
The next IEP meeting was on May 29, 1998. The document indicates that STUDENT had met some of his goals. He was able to respond to “stop” and “come” commands, make a choice, attend to small group activity for five minutes, and sit on a toilet. It was reported that he also was able to follow the classroom routine with verbal prompts. His placement and program were continued through the extended school year and into the next year of preschool until a review in January 1999. (Ex. 1:17)
Pursuant to the February 1999 IEP, STUDENT attended an SDC at the F. J. White Learning Center in Woodlake (Woodlake SDC), approximately one hour from Three Rivers from 8:00 a.m to 2:00 p.m., five days a week, with speech and language services continuing twice per week for ten to fifteen minutes in the classroom. In spite of the parents’ objection to the length of the bus ride, they consented to the placement, and STUDENT started attending the Woodlake SDC on February 16, 1999. (Ex. 1:30)
STUDENT was assessed in April 1999 by Trish Griswold, the special education teacher of the Woodlake SDC at the time. She found STUDENT to be able to sit at circle time for fifteen to twenty minutes, but only actually attend to the story or activity for one to two minutes. He was able to imitate hand movements to a song and overcome an obstacle to get a desired object. He could stab food with a fork but needed help scooping with a spoon. He liked to bounce a ball and roll it back and forth, and was learning to throw a ball. He demonstrated little interest in his peers but his interest had been increasing recently. He would sit on the toilet but seemed unaware of its purpose.
STUDENT’s annual review IEP meeting was on May 7, 1999. Ms. Griswold’s assessment results were considered. New goals and objectives were developed in the areas of fine motor skills, self-help, gross motor skills, cognitive skills, and communication skills. It is not clear from the IEP document what discussion there was about the earlier goals and objectives, at least some of which had already been met. The consensus was that STUDENT would continue to attend the Woodlake SDC from 8:30 a.m. to 1:30 p.m., one hour less than previously recommended.
STUDENT attended a private school that summer, funded by Central Valley Regional Center (CVRC), then returned to the Woodlake SDC in August 1999. By late August, STUDENT’s parents were dissatisfied with the SDC and requested an IEP meeting to plan for his placement in the regular kindergarten at the 3R School in their own community. On September 3, 1999, the IEP team agreed to the change of placement. The IEP document provided that the “curriculum, training of staff and services would be coordinated to ensure success. An instructional aide will be added to the classroom as a whole and will assist as needed. A behavioral aide is available for training and an SH credentialed teacher will assist with curriculum modification.” Resource specialist services (RSP) were to be available in the kindergarten class daily. (Ex.1:46-47)
STUDENT started attending the 3R School kindergarten on October 5, 1999. On November 15, 1999, an IEP meeting was held to review the placement and his progress. (Ex. 1:65-68) The IEP called for a limited day ending at 1:00 p.m. STUDENT was to have RSP services twenty minutes per day in the classroom, at lunch, and on the playground. In addition, he was to have twenty minutes of pull-out speech and language therapy three days per week in the speech room. The document indicated that STUDENT needed a behavior management system, but there was no explanation in the document about the behaviors exhibited or how the concern would be addressed.
STUDENT underwent a second assessment by the Diagnostic Center in January 2000 to identify strategies that might help to meet STUDENT’s educational needs at the time. The assessor’s report made recommendations regarding instructional targets for language and learning.(Footnote 6) Those recommendations included the use of a structured work approach, such as the TEACCH methodology(Footnote 7). There were also a number of specific recommendations directed toward the efforts to integrate STUDENT into the regular education class, including the initial introduction of the structured-work approach during direct, individual instruction, staff use of gestures with iconic symbols for core vocabulary, and the creation of communicative spaces built around routines such as snack time, lunch time, play time, cooking or art. The report explained that predictable opportunities for communication in familiar contexts should facilitate the initiation of communication in a variety of contexts.
Ms. Hiltel conducted an assessment of STUDENT in February 2000, when he was in his first kindergarten year. Her report showed that there was little progress and possibly some regression. STUDENT would not roll a ball back in reciprocal play and was able to sit for only forty seconds in group without verbal and physical prompts. He could sit for up to ten minutes with such prompts. STUDENT did not demonstrate the ability to imitate sounds or gestures. Nor would he respond to simple commands or successfully choose one of two items more than 20 percent of the time. Ms. Hiltel stated that STUDENT appeared to understand the consequences of his actions and would “frequently hit, kick or pull the hair of nearby students.” He had considerable difficulty using an adapted spoon and bowl, instead using his hands to feed himself most of the time.
School psychologist Robert May conducted a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT over three days in February and March 2000. Mr. May observed STUDENT in three environments: his classroom, the playground, and at home. He recommended that STUDENT’s educational plan should continue to emphasize self-help, socialization and communication skills. He stated that imitation skills should be developed through the use of tangible and functional reinforcers for desired behaviors, which was best accomplished through individual, direct instruction with intensive practice. Mr. May indicated that social skills should be developed through structured opportunities for interaction. He believed that STUDENT’s PECS training should begin with actual object exchange, then gradually move toward more representative pictures and icons. He also recommended the TEACCH methodology.
On March 10, 2000, STUDENT was evaluated by developmental neuropsychologist Howard J. Glidden, Ph.D. Dr. Glidden’s impression was that STUDENT’s diagnosis should include autism spectrum disorder. Some of his recommendations were a referral to CVRC for behavior management interventions from a qualified specialist in both the home and school environments, a picture exchange system of communication, and a “buddy system” program that would allow STUDENT to be introduced gradually to his peers. He also recommended an ESY with continued one-on-one support to avoid regression.
On April 7, 2000, STUDENT’s next IEP meeting was convened. His limited-day placement in the kindergarten class was continued. RSP services were increased to 30 minutes per day in the classroom, play yard and cafeteria. Speech and language services were increased to 30 minutes three days per week. Fifteen new goals were developed in the areas of fine motor skills, gross motor skills, social skills, receptive language, expressive language, and self-help.
A major change in STUDENT’s program was proposed at the June 7, 2000 IEP meeting at the conclusion of his first year of kindergarten. (Ex. 1:151) The IEP team agreed that STUDENT would repeat kindergarten and recommended 50 percent integration, with one hundred fifty minutes per day in the regular class with supports (one-on-one aide and modified curriculum), ninety minutes per day of RSP services in the classroom and pull-out, and sixty minutes per day of speech and language services in the classroom and pull-out.(Footnote 8) STUDENT’s goals and objectives remained essentially unchanged.
There also was substantial discussion at the June 7, 2000 IEP meeting about STUDENT’s increasing maladaptive behaviors. Ms. Powell, the kindergarten teacher, had complained that STUDENT was dropping when he had to walk long distances, and that he was having an increasing number of temper tantrums and other behaviors that were disrupting the class. A behavior plan was prepared by Dr. Gillham and presented and approved at this meeting. The plan stated that STUDENT’s targeted maladaptive behaviors, dropping, temper tantrums, crying and flailing, and biting and grabbing others, were associated with a functional intent to escape when STUDENT experienced frustration. The plan described frequency of the behaviors as follows: temper tantrums, three to five times per day; dropping to the ground, twenty times per day; crying, flailing and dropping to the ground, five times per week; grabbing other persons, twenty-five times per week; and biting other persons, five times per week. It recommended specific interventions and goals for reduced frequency of the behaviors.
At the June 7, 2000 IEP meeting, the District and COE members of the team expressed their frustrations with STUDENT’s lack of progress. Ms. Hiltel testified at the hearing that she was concerned and thought the lack of progress may have been due, in part, to significantly increased services. Team members suggested that an SH-SDC placement be considered, explaining to the parents that more services could be delivered in the SH-SDC classroom, but STUDENT’s parents were adamant that STUDENT did not do well in the Woodlake SDC, and they did not want him to be on the bus for a long ride to and from school. Ultimately, it was agreed by the team that STUDENT would remain at 3R School with support, as outlined above.
The next IEP meeting was on September 13, 2000, shortly after the beginning of STUDENT’s second kindergarten year. STUDENT’s levels of functioning were essentially unchanged, as was his special education program. While the IEP document still provided for the same one hundred fifty minutes of RSP and speech services, and one hundred fifty minutes of regular education integration, it also stated that STUDENT was at school for a full day, which, according to his teacher Ms. Powell, was approximately 8:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m.(Footnote 9)
Progress reports for the 2000-2001 school year showed progress on most of STUDENT’s goals. He did well sitting in a large group, feeding himself with an adapted bowl and spoon, and working on his PECS. He also showed good progress, at least in the early part of the year, on using adapted scissors with physical prompt and some progress on carrying a tray, scooping food, pulling up his pants, grasping a crayon/marker, tolerating earphones, and reduced grabbing, crying and biting. He also showed some progress on his fine motor goals and his response to simple commands. By the end of the third quarter in early April, STUDENT was beginning to recognize familiar staff and to come to them when called 50 percent of the time. This third quarter report noted that the behaviors of dropping, grabbing and biting were not observed unless STUDENT was placed into a excessively challenging group situation.
An annual review IEP meeting occurred on April 4, 2001. (Ex.1:217-240) Ten goals were developed and agreed upon: (1) grasp spoon and feed self with verbal prompt 4 of 5 times; (2) Pull pants up and down during toileting with verbal prompts 4 of 5 times; (3) respond to familiar two-word commands with brief physical assistance 4 of 5 times; (4) use PECS (Phase III) to communicate needs and wants 4 of 5 times; (5) sit at a table and work parallel to another child for five minutes 4 of 5 times; (6) sit in large group for five minutes without prompting 4 of 5 times; (7) indicate recognition of family and staff by responding to question, “STUDENT, Where is ?” with physical and verbal prompts 4 of 5 times; (8) use picture from schedule to transition between activities with verbal prompts 4 of 5 times; (9) carry a meal or work tray up to ten feet without dropping and with verbal prompts 4 of 5 times; and (10) seat himself on the toilet and remain seated for two to three minutes with hands on his legs or at his sides with verbal and physical prompts. The IEP also stated that STUDENT would not be participating in the general education environment for any functional curriculum with RSP and speech therapy because he requires “intensive individualized and small group instruction.” Terri Hiltel noted that almost all problem behaviors had disappeared and tended to reoccur only with more frustrating experiences.
It was at this April 2001 meeting that the District and COE staff indicated that they were adamant that Dr. Bryna Siegel be allowed to complete her evaluation of STUDENT’s placement, services, goals and objectives that had begun in January 2001. STUDENT’s parents had refused consent to the evaluation. They eventually relented and gave consent to the completion of the assessment by Dr. Siegel, who did an observation of STUDENT in his kindergarten classroom and conducted interviews with his parents and school staff on June 4, 2001. Her findings and conclusions are contained in her report dated June 25, 2001. (Ex. 1:252-258)
Dr. Siegel, who holds a Ph.D. in child development from Stanford University, is an adjunct professor and the director of the pervasive developmental disorders clinic at Langley Porter Institute, University of California, San Francisco. She is generally considered to be an expert on autism, which is one of the reasons why she was first retained by the Petitioners to evaluate STUDENT and make placement recommendations.
Dr. Siegel believed that the additional diagnosis of autism added nothing to assist with STUDENT’s educational planning. She stated that in all probability STUDENT would never develop spoken communication or a level of independence that would allow him to live without the assistance of a care-giving adult. In her opinion, STUDENT’s developmental levels, below eighteen months in all domains, made integration into the general education class unworkable.
She observed STUDENT in his kindergarten class and found that he was not truly engaged in his class. He worked exclusively with his aide, Laurie Cassano, on a curriculum which was modified to the point that it was unrecognizable as being in any way related to the regular first grade curriculum. There was no participation in class curriculum. In the doctor’s opinion, STUDENT’s developmental level, when compared to the level of the other children, barred any meaningful integration. Dr. Siegel stated that STUDENT needed a full-time special education teacher and that the TEACCH methodology used at the Woodlake SDC was ideal. She suggested that STUDENT begin the placement at the Woodlake SDC with a full-time aide, and that the aide be gradually faded out to provide STUDENT an opportunity for greater independence. The bus ride, in a harness, of forty-five minutes or less was in her opinion appropriate. Dr. Siegel also suggested that STUDENT be evaluated for possible management of his repetitive motor activities through medication.
While Dr. Siegel thought that STUDENT was unlikely to learn imitatively from peers at this point in his life, she recognized a broader value to STUDENT’s exposure to nondisabled peers. She was also aware of the parents’ views about where STUDENT should be educated. She suggested that the parents’ concerns about STUDENT’s exposure to general education peers in his community could be satisfied by having STUDENT participate in an after-school program at 3R School with a one-on-one aide.
The report of Dr. Siegel and a proposed “draft” IEP based substantially on Dr Siegel’s findings were presented at the IEP meeting of July 9, 2001. (Ex.1:259-274) Leslie Farlow, Ph.D., the parents’ retained educational consultant, had conducted her assessment of STUDENT and his current and recommended placements between May 31 and June 28, 2001. However, her report was not available at the time of the July 9, 2001 IEP meeting. The recommendation of the District and COE team members was that STUDENT be placed in the Woodlake SDC, where he would participate in the general education environment for “lunch, recess, field trips, assemblies and other special activities.”(Footnote 10) Speech and language services were to be provided in the SDC daily. There was no offer of intensive one-on-one instruction or the services of an instructional aide.
Dr. Gillham states in his comments to the July 9, 2001 IEP that “STUDENT needs an opportunity to spend time in a mainstream environment in order to develop and maintain acceptable patterns of behavior for public activities.” According to the IEP, however, 98 percent of STUDENT’s time at school was to be spent in a special education environment outside a regular classroom. There was no other provision in the IEP for exposing STUDENT to an environment comparable to a regular classroom setting.
The July 2001 IEP documents also state that the maladaptive behaviors addressed in the June 2000 behavior plan were “essentially non-existent within the normal course of his school day.” Anticipating the possibility that these or other maladaptive behaviors could reoccur, particularly if STUDENT became frustrated as a result of developmentally inappropriate activities or expectations, the IEP indicated that reference should be made to the behavior support plan from June 2000.
The parents agreed to the goals and objectives proposed at the July 9, 2001 IEP meeting, but did not consent to the placement recommended by the District and COE. On July 26, 2001, this due process matter was filed.
The report of Dr. Farlow was not completed until September 7, 2001. (Ex. 1:281-308) It revealed that Dr. Farlow observed STUDENT in his kindergarten placement for most of an entire day on May 31, 2001. She also observed him in his home and at his swimming lesson. She interviewed District and COE staff (Terri Hiltel, Marie Powell and Laurie Cassano) and briefly observed the first grade class at 3R School. She also conducted two observations at the Woodlake SDC, one brief visit when students were not present, and another lasting approximately forty-five minutes when students were present but the regular teacher was not. The report contained many findings, conclusions and recommendations. She did not believe that STUDENT’s needs would be better served at the Woodlake SDC, particularly insofar as his needs for development of communication and social skills were concerned. Dr. Farlow said that STUDENT had made progress in his inclusive setting at 3R School and that he should remain in an inclusive program at his home school where he can receive a free, appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment. She believed that, with certain modifications, the inclusive setting at 3R School could even better meet STUDENT’s needs.
Since the filing of the request for due process by the District and COE, STUDENT has moved on to the first grade. His day at school begins at approximately 8:00 a.m. and ends at 3:10 p.m. (Testimony of Melinda Simonian) Since returning to school this year, STUDENT has continued to be served pursuant to the last agreed-upon IEP, which provided for one hundred fifty minutes of participation in the regular education class, ninety minutes of RSP, and sixty minutes of speech and language.
ANALYSIS
Issue 1: Does the District’s Offer of Placement at the F. J. White Learning Center in Woodlake, Ca, as Proposed in the Individualized Education Plan of July 9, 2001, Offer STUDENT a Free, Appropriate Public Education in the Least Restrictive Environment?
The federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), and State law require that students with disabilities be offered a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment. 20 U.S.C. §§ 1400 (d) and 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56000 and 56031. A “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. Section 1401(8).
The United States Supreme Court has held that “a "free appropriate public education" consists of educational instruction specially designed to meet the unique needs of the disabled child, supported by such services as are necessary to permit the child "to benefit" from the instruction. Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et .al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 188-189. It is not necessary for the child’s program to maximize the educational opportunities or put them on a par with the opportunities provided to typically developing students. What is required is that the disabled student be provided with access to a FAPE which is “sufficient to confer some educational benefit upon the handicapped child.” Id. at 200-201. To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District's proposed placement at the Woodlake SDC must have met the following three requirements in order to constitute an appropriate educational program: It must have (1) been designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs; (2) been reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit; (3) comported with his IEP. There is also the requirement that the FAPE be provided to STUDENT in the least restrictive environment.
Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment and that the removal of the disabled child from the regular education environment should occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in general education classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be satisfactorily achieved. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Calif. Educ. Code § 56031.
A. Was The District’s Proposed Placement Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?
There is no dispute concerning STUDENT’s multiple disabilities. He suffers from severe developmental delays in all domains, and exhibits some autistic characteristics. Evaluations have consistently put STUDENT’s developmental levels in the six- to twenty-four month range, with gross motor and self-help skills being stronger than communication and social skills. He is at a sensory-motor learning stage. There is general agreement that STUDENT’s needs that are the result of his developmental delays, and not his autism, are the primary factors that should guide the development appropriate educational program.(Footnote 11)
The Hearing Officer finds, based upon the agreement among the witnesses or the absence of any significant dispute, that STUDENT needs the following: An educational program that focuses on the development of basic communication (using PECS), social, and self-help skills; a high degree of structure, consistency and predictability in his educational environment; a schedule that will take advantage of his increased vitality and tolerance during the early part of the day; an educational environment that is not too distracting, one that facilitates STUDENT’s focus on the necessary visual elements of his educational program, such as his picture schedule, but does not invite or facilitate stereotypic behavior; reasonable performance expectations and demands that are clearly indicated and within STUDENT’s ability to complete successfully; and a behavior plan that will effectively control his behaviors that interfere with his education and the education of his classmates. There was undisputed evidence that transitions that require STUDENT to move from one room or building to another tend to cause an increase in maladaptive behaviors. There was a dispute regarding whether STUDENT needs a significant amount of intensive one-on-one instruction. Dr. Siegel believed that an adult staff-to-student ratio of approximately one to three was adequate to meet STUDENT’s needs. Her opinions were echoed by some of the Petitioners’ staff at the hearing. Dr. Farlow stated that STUDENT needs intensive one-on-one instruction. She testified that two hours of such instruction or training per day would probably be adequate and that not all of STUDENT’s pull-out services had to be one-on-one. She emphasized that it was necessary to first teach STUDENT the skill through one-on-one instruction, then provide opportunities for him to practice the skill. She said that he would continue to need the services of the one-on-one aide. STUDENT’s parents agreed with Dr. Farlow. They stated that STUDENT needs one-on-one intensive instruction and the services of a one-on-one aide. They said that without this STUDENT would become lost in his own world and would regress in the same way that he did the last time he was placed without an aide and adequate one-on-one instruction.
The Hearing Officer is persuaded that the Respondent’s view is correct and that STUDENT does need at least two hours per day of intensive one-on-one instruction in basic communication, social and self-help skills. Before Dr. Siegel’s involvement, many of the Petitioners’ own staff were of the opinion that intensive one-on-one instruction was needed. Both the Diagnostic Center and Mr. May in their 2000 assessment reports stated that STUDENT needed direct individual instruction. Mr. May referred to the need for intensive practice. Ms. Hiltel, the specialist who has worked with STUDENT for so long, and Ms. Powell, STUDENT’s teacher for the two kindergarten years, both stated that STUDENT made the greatest progress toward his goals as a result of one-on-one instruction delivered in a distraction-free environment. The District’s own program moved steadily toward the delivery of that level of instruction. It was the Hearing Officer’s impression that at least some of these opinions changed only after Dr. Siegel opined that STUDENT would do fine in the Woodlake SDC. This evidence combines to support the opinions of Dr. Farlow regarding STUDENT’s need for intensive one-on-one instruction.
The parties also disagreed regarding STUDENT’s need for exposure to typically developing peers. Everyone agreed that there were benefits to STUDENT from such exposure. However, there were dramatically different views on whether STUDENT needs that exposure as part of a FAPE and, if so, how much and in what environment it should occur.
Dr. Siegel’s opinion was that STUDENT does not need exposure to general education peers to benefit from his educational program. She explained her view that participation by a disabled student in regular education classes can be beneficial if the student has age-appropriate skills or skills for which the regular curriculum can be meaningfully adapted. But if the developmental level of the disabled student is more than two years behind that of the general education students, the curriculum can no longer be truly adapted, but becomes, instead, an entirely different curriculum, unrecognizable in its relationship to the regular curriculum. Dr. Siegel said that STUDENT is so far behind his chronological peers that his participation in a regular classroom would offer him no real benefit. She also explained that disabled children who have adequate imitative skills can learn from other children. However, in her opinion, STUDENT has inadequate imitative skills to benefit in this way from exposure to typically developing peers. While Dr. Siegel testified that STUDENT did not need an integrated educational experience, she acknowledged that there is a broader value to these experiences and suggested that the parents’ concerns about STUDENT’s exposure to general education peers in his own community could be satisfied by having STUDENT participate in an after-school program.(Footnote 12)
Dr. Farlow essentially agreed with Dr. Siegel that STUDENT may not be ready for imitation of peers or modeling and that he probably will not learn incidentally at this time. However, she believed that STUDENT’s lack of imitative skills was not a reason to avoid integration. In her opinion, it simply indicated that there is a need for direct instruction in this area. Dr. Farlow believed that STUDENT would benefit from inclusion as a result of the greater generalization and transference of skills that comes from the increased opportunities for communication and socialization. In her opinion, STUDENT needs to be in the classroom with his general education peers for at least part of the day to practice his skills. Dr. Farlow testified that STUDENT’s training should be linked to what is happening in a regular education setting in the classroom and that he should then be brought into the instruction in the classroom by holding him accountable for some participation, however small. She also explained that opportunities for STUDENT to practice his communication, social and self-help skills would also need to be created for him in other environments, such as the cafeteria and playground.
Dr. Siegel has strong opinions about the benefits of inclusion to disabled children who have severe developmental delays that place them far behind their chronological peers. Dr. Farlow has equally strong but vastly different opinions about inclusion of those children. Both witnesses have unwavering confidence in their respective positions. The Hearing Officer found Dr. Farlow’s testimony most persuasive on this question. Her education and employment experience has focused more on the development and facilitation of appropriate inclusion programs or related issues than those of any of the Petitioners’ witnesses. While Dr. Siegel also has impressive credentials and work experience, she was retained by the Petitioners because of her expertise in the area of autism. She testified that this diagnosis is not significant to educational planning for STUDENT. Furthermore, her views on integration failed to adequately take into account the law’s mandate to educate disabled children with their nondisabled peers whenever reasonably possible. Dr. Siegel was asked only to evaluate the current program as implemented and the Woodlake SDC. She never considered her role to include making recommendations to the Petitioners to assist them in meeting STUDENT’s needs in his current integrated placement. She testified that she would have made recommendations regarding the 3R School placement if the Woodlake SDC had not been available.(Footnote 14) As a result of this narrow focus of Dr. Siegel’s evaluation, the parties and the Hearing Officer were denied the benefit of Dr. Siegel’s opinions regarding whether the law’s mandate might be met.
Some of Dr. Farlow’s opinions were made more persuasive by their concurrence with the opinions of others, including some of Petitioners’ own staff. Dr Farlow stated that STUDENT needed to have opportunities for communication and socialization created and facilitated for him by teacher and staff, with the cooperation of his general education peers, and that these opportunities should be in the context of an integrated placement. Similar conclusions had been reached by the evaluators from the Diagnostic Center in 1998 and 2000 and by Mr. May in 2000. In addition, the notes to the July 2001 IEP stated that STUDENT needed an opportunity to spend time with typically developing peers so that he could learn and maintain acceptable social behaviors and that it was “important” that STUDENT have consistent peer interaction.
The weight of the evidence convinced the Hearing Officer that STUDENT does need to be exposed to general education peers for at least some part of every school day in the classroom, in the cafeteria, and on the playground.
A related issue is whether STUDENT needs the services of a one-on-one instructional assistant. The testimony showed that STUDENT’s need for this service is primarily a function of his placement. Dr. Siegel testified that STUDENT might need a one-on-one aide at the Woodlake SDC only for a period of time while he became familiar with the class and routine. According to her recommendations, the aide would then be gradually faded out. Dr. Siegel did not address STUDENT’s need for an instructional aide in a general education environment. Dr. Farlow addressed STUDENT’s need for an aide in a general education class. She stated that he needs the services of a one-on-one aide to facilitate the practice of skills in the classroom and during nutrition and play activities. It is the finding of the Hearing Officer that STUDENT does require the services of a one-on-one instructional aide during those times when he is integrated with his general education peers.
To summarize, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs a high degree of structure and predictability and a physical environment that will not distract him from prescribed tasks. Sources of frustration, such as difficult transitions between service locations should be minimized. STUDENT’s program should be designed to take optimum advantage of his higher levels of energy and tolerance in the early part of the school day. He needs a behavior plan to control the behaviors that are interfering with the education of STUDENT and his classmates and a program that will provide intensive one-on-one instruction at least two hours per day in basic communication skills, using PECS, as well as social and self-help skills. STUDENT requires time with his general education peers every school day. He requires time in the classroom, as well as time in the cafeteria, playground and other areas where the other children spend parts of their school day. Finally, he needs the assistance of a one-on-one aide during the times that he is integrated with the general education students to create and facilitate opportunities for STUDENT to practice his skills.
It is now necessary to determine whether the July 9, 2001 IEP was reasonably designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. That IEP (Ex. 1:259-274) recommended that STUDENT be placed in the Woodlake SDC for a full-day program. According to Ms. Clarey and other witnesses, the day would begin with a bus ride of fifty to seventy minutes.(Footnote 15) The bus would arrive at approximately 8:05 a.m. The schedule for the SDC is consistent and structured. It begins with toileting and breakfast, then moves through the first group meeting, centers (where the children work on various sorting, letter, word, and reading skills), toileting and physical goals, recess, math group, gross motor activity, second group meeting and lunch recess. The afternoons would consist of a group meeting, report time (when reports are prepared for parents), free time for an optional activity chosen by the child, toileting, snack and preparation to go home. The bus would return STUDENT to Three Rivers at approximately 2:45 in the afternoon.
The Hearing Officer is persuaded that this schedule was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. It begins with a bus ride that the parents have described as difficult for STUDENT. He is likely to be frustrated or tired from the experience. While the schedule is consistent, it provides little if any flexibility for intense one-on-one instruction during the early part of the day when STUDENT is more receptive to instruction and challenges. The school day is busy and would be followed by another lengthy bus ride home. This schedule is not reasonably designed to meet STUDENT’s need for a program that will take maximum advantage of his vitality and tolerance during the early part of the day.
The ten goals agreed to by the team, including the parents, covered basic communication, social and self-help skills. These were basically the same as those adopted by agreement at an April 2001 IEP meeting. The IEP team, including STUDENT’s parents, agreed to these goals and objectives at both IEP meetings. The parties agreed the goals should be updated to the extent that they have been met. Respondent, however, argued in his brief for the development of new goals and objectives in all areas of need. While this argument may find support in the report and testimony of Dr. Farlow, it appears that at the time these goals and objectives were adopted by the IEP team, they were agreed upon as reasonably designed to address STUDENT’s needs.(Footnote 16) The Hearing Officer sees no reason to find otherwise now. However, the goals are now a year old and they should be updated. The Hearing Officer declines to craft new goals and objectives based solely on the opinions of Dr. Farlow. That is the province of a properly convened IEP team.
Although the IEP stated that STUDENT’s behaviors impede learning, it addressed this need simply by reference to Dr. Gillham’s behavior support plan from June 2000. The evidence established that Dr. Gillham’s behavior support plan had been effective during the 2000-2001 school year. The IEP notes state that the behaviors described in that plan had been “greatly reduced” and were “essentially non-existent within the normal course of [STUDENT’s] school day.” The IEP also stated that because STUDENT’s behaviors were impeding learning, there would be a need for a functional behavioral analysis if STUDENT was moved to a new setting.(Footnote 17) However, there was no clear statement in the IEP regarding how maladaptive behaviors would be addressed over the term of that IEP. In addition, the Hearing Officer could not determine from the evidence what was being done to control STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors since the July 9, 2001 IEP. Mindy Boyer testified that she was implementing Dr. Gillham’s plan without success. Terri Hiltel stated that the plan was no longer being implemented. The absence of a consensus among staff regarding how to address the behaviors is a good indication that there is inadequate clarity in STUDENT’s plan. The Hearing Officer finds that the reference in the IEP to the behavior plan from June 2000 did not adequately address STUDENT’s need for a positive behavior support plan.
The IEP does not state that STUDENT will receive any intensive one-on-one instruction. That evidence also showed that there are already eight children in the class, two with Down syndrome, two who are autistic, two who have cerebral palsy, and two who are developmentally delayed. Two of these need one-on-one assistance for certain tasks, including eating. STUDENT would be the lowest functioning student in the class. Mr. PARENT testified that when he visited the class in November 2001, one of the students required almost the full-time attention of one of an adult staff. Ms. Clarey testified that some of the children have needs and goals similar to STUDENT’s. The Hearing Officer concludes that the recommended placement will not provide the intensive one-on-one training that STUDENT needs.
According to the subject IEP, STUDENT was to be integrated for lunch, recess, field trips, assemblies and other special activities. But ninety-eight percent of STUDENT’s time was to be spent within the special education environment. There was a reference to a “structured buddy system” and to an after-school program, but there was no clear description of the former, either in the IEP documents or in the evidence, and there was no indication of an offer to provide the latter.(Footnote 18) According to Ms. Clarey, there is no “reverse mainstreaming,” which is contrary to what Dr. Siegel believed would occur in the class. Ms. Clarey testified that her class does not eat with their general education peers. They eat at their own table. She also stated that there have been no field trips with the regular classes. The Hearing Officer finds that this class will not provide STUDENT with the opportunities for interaction with general education peers that he needs.
While Dr. Siegel testified that a one-on-one aide should be provided to STUDENT for a period of time to allow him to get used to the class and the schedule, there is no offer of a one-on-one aide in the IEP document.(Footnote 19) The Hearing Officer believes that it is unlikely that STUDENT will make progress without the assistance of an aide and finds that the recommended placement does not meet STUDENT’s needs in this respect.
In summary, the Hearing officer finds that the offer of placement at the Woodlake SDC as set forth in the July 9, 2001 IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the following respects: (1) it was not designed to take advantage of STUDENT’s greater vitality and tolerance during the early part of the day; (2) it did not adequately address STUDENT’s behavioral needs;(3) it did not provide intensive one-on-one instruction; (4) it did not meet STUDENT’s need for daily exposure to general education peers; and (5) it did not provide a one-on-one aide to assist with integrated activities.
B. Was the District’s Proposed Placement Designed to Provide STUDENT with Educational Benefit?
It is undisputed that STUDENT’s disabilities are severe. Dr. Gillham testified that, regardless of where STUDENT is placed, his progress will be slow. The measurement of benefit to STUDENT from an educational program in any environment will be in small increments. The Petitioners’ witnesses have testified that STUDENT has not made meaningful progress in his current placement. But the factors already determined to be those most likely to lead to progress, significant one-on-one instruction with opportunities to practice social and communication skills with typically developing peers, are present to at least some degree in the current placement and all but absent in the placement proposed in the July 9, 2001, IEP. The Hearing Officer finds that this proposed placement is not designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT.
C. Would the District’s Proposed Placement Comport with STUDENT’s IEP?
Conformity of the actual placement is usually not an issue when the placement has not yet been implemented. In this case, however, the evidence showed that the Woodlake SDC placement would not have comported with the IEP. The IEP states that STUDENT requires intensive instruction and training. The offered program is not likely to provide that. The IEP states that STUDENT needs interaction with his general education peers and would participate with nondisabled children at lunch, recess, field trips, assemblies and other special activities, but the testimony demonstrated that such participation and interaction is not likely to occur. Finally, the Hearing Officer was not convinced that the stated need for behavioral interventions would be met at Woodlake. The Hearing Officer concludes that the offered program would not comport with STUDENT’s IEP
D. Would the District’s Proposed Placement Be the Least Restrictive Environment for STUDENT’s Education?
The preference in the law for educating disabled students with those who are not disabled is so strong that it rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption. Daniel R. v. State Board of Education, (5th Cir. 1989) 874 F.2d 1036, 1044-45. Furthermore, it is not an all-or-nothing proposition. Even when it is determined that some of the student’s needs cannot be satisfactorily met in regular education classes, removal to a special education environment should occur only as necessary to meet those needs. Id at 1050.
The determination of whether a particular placement is in the least restrictive environment involves an analysis of four factors: (1) the educational benefits available to the child in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared to the educational benefits of a special education classroom; (2) the nonacademic benefits to the disabled child of interaction with nondisabled children; (3) the effect of the presence of the disabled child on the teacher and other children in the regular classroom; and (4) the costs of supplemental aids and services necessary to mainstream the disabled child in a regular classroom setting. Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel Holland (1992) 786 F. Supp. 879 (1992); Adopted by the Ninth Circuit in Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel Holland, (9th Cir. 1994)14 F.3d 1398; cert. denied 512 U. S. 1207, 114 S. Ct. 2679 (1994).
(1) Comparative Educational Benefit
STUDENT’s current placement is in the general education first grade class at 3R School with modifications and support services. The District provides him with a full-time aide, ninety minutes per day of RSP services, sixty minutes per day of speech and language services and one hundred fifty minutes of integration with general education peers. The evidence shows that STUDENT has made demonstrable progress in his program at 3R School. Dr. Farlow testified that the program could be further modified to better meet STUDENT’s needs. Dr. Siegel testified that she also would have recommended changes to STUDENT’s current program if the Woodlake SDC was not available. When Donna Martin, a strong proponent of the Woodlake SDC, was asked how STUDENT’s current placement might be improved, she declined to clearly state. But she did say that if Dr. Siegel had recommended that STUDENT remain in his current placement, her opinion may have been different. The weight of the evidence supports the conclusion that STUDENT’s current program provides him with an educational benefit, and that it could be modified to provide an even greater benefit to STUDENT in the future.
It has already been determined that the District’s proposed program is not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. While that is not to say that the Woodlake SDC would provide no educational benefit to STUDENT, its potential to equal the benefit available through the current program is suspect. Furthermore, there was sufficient evidence offered through the testimony of STUDENT’s parents and confirmed in documents offered by the District that STUDENT did not make progress and, in fact, probably regressed during his earlier placement in that SDC.
The Hearing Officer finds that, on balance, STUDENT receives a greater educational benefit from his current program than that which he is likely to receive in the Woodlake SDC in the following respects: He receives more of the intensive one-on-one instruction that has been found to be most effective in teaching him the basic communication, social and self-help skills; he is provided with a one-on-one aide who can assist him with the practice required for generalization of those skills across various environments and contexts; and he has far more opportunity to interact with his general education peers, which is likely to lead to higher rates of progress and increased social and communication skills. The Hearing Officer finds that this factor weighs in favor of allowing STUDENT to remain in his current placement at 3R School.
(2) Nonacademic Benefits
There is general agreement among the parties that there are nonacademic benefits to STUDENT from his exposure to typically developing peers. Terri Hiltel testified that STUDENT has become more aware of his world, more responsive to the important people in his life and less involved in sensory-driven behaviors. These changes in STUDENT should better enable him to benefit from such exposure. Dr. Gillham indicated that such exposure was necessary and beneficial. Even Dr. Siegel agreed that it would be good for him to have interaction with other children, though she thought that an after-school program would be sufficient.
Dr. Farlow and STUDENT’s parents were adamant that STUDENT’s inclusion experience was critical to the development of his communication and social skills. STUDENT’s parents testified regarding his increasing interest in other children, including two girls from his class who have taken a “motherly” interest in STUDENT. They have seen what they believe to have been an initiation of social contact by STUDENT on the playground. They have seen STUDENT imitate the use of a drinking fountain. They have witnessed what they describe as the general acceptance of their son by his classmates, and they have seen STUDENT respond to the social initiations by those children. The Hearing Officer believes that those benefits may be even greater for a boy like STUDENT who lives in a small community where there are frequent opportunities to see and socialize with classmates in the community.
The Hearing officer finds that there is a nonacademic benefit to STUDENT from his current placement and that this factor weighs in favor of allowing him to continue at 3R School.
(3) The Effect of STUDENT’s Presence on the Teacher and Other Children
STUDENT has exhibited maladaptive behaviors which have interfered with his learning and that of his classmates. According to some witnesses, he engages in those behaviors even more now than he did near the end of the last school year. This is a difficult issue. It requires consideration of the interests of the other students in STUDENT’s class and a balancing of those interests against STUDENT’s own. Special education law is not blind to the needs of nondisabled students. It is perhaps in this context most evident. A closer look at the law is instructive.
In the Holland case, the court stated that the law requires a district to consider and employ all reasonable means to relieve the teacher of excessive burdens which may result from the presence of the disabled student. Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel Holland, supra., at 879. Rachel Holland was not a disruptive student, so the Holland court discussed this burden only in the context of a student who may require too much of the teacher’s attention. However, the Holland analysis of this factor does not suggest to the Hearing Officer that a district does not also have the burden to employ all reasonable means to minimize the disruptive impact of the disabled child’s behavior. The Hearing Officer concludes that the school district must do that. This obligation is consistent with the requirement that the IEP team consider positive behavior interventions, strategies and supports to address behaviors that impede the disabled child’s learning or that of others. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(3)(B)(1); 34 C.F.R. § 300.346(a)(2)(i); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.1(b)(1).
According to Ms. Powell, she had significant problems with STUDENT’s behavior during his kindergarten years. He would have tantrums and drop to the ground when walking, usually during longer walks to the bathroom. He could not be sat next to other children because he would touch them, kick the table, bite the table, take their food, swipe objects off the table, throw himself backward, and engage in other disruptive behavior. Dr. Farlow agreed that there were frequent instances during her observation of STUDENT in the kindergarten class in which he would vocalize or engage in stereotypic behaviors, but she questioned whether these behaviors were truly disruptive of the class. However, regardless of whether STUDENT’s behaviors during his kindergarten years were disruptive, the evidence clearly established that those behaviors were effectively eliminated during the 2000-2001 school year with the implementation of the behavior plan developed by Dr. Gillham.
The evidence established that STUDENT’s disruptive behaviors increased this year. Mindy Boyer has been STUDENT’s aide since he began the first grade this year.(Footnote 20) She testified that STUDENT is never engaged and requires constant prompting and redirection. His maladaptive behaviors have included dropping, hitting himself, flailing, constantly trying to “escape” by engaging in stereotypic behaviors, by licking, chewing on, and grabbing things, and by vocalizing. Other witnesses reported instances of biting other people. Ms. Boyer has heard the other children complain and has seen them turn around, distracted from their task, toward STUDENT’s disruption. Melinda Simonian, STUDENT’s current teacher, said that there can be up to twenty disruptive events per day, though only one or two may be reported by the other children. Ms. Simonian also testified that she is concerned about STUDENT’s safety. One day he bit a large piece out of a plastic funnel. She describes the situation as hard on the other children and hard on her. Barbara Merline, who assists Ms. Hiltel in the delivery of RSP and language services, also states that STUDENT’s behaviors and the interventions that she uses with him are disruptive of the class at least thirty percent of the time.
The testimony of the Petitioners’ witnesses establishes that STUDENT does frequently engage in potentially disruptive or other maladaptive behaviors. He is not convinced, however, that the behaviors are sufficiently disruptive of the education of the other students to cause this factor to weigh against STUDENT’s current program. Dr. Farlow testified about the steps that she took to attempt to determine the disruptive effect of STUDENT’s behavior. She measured the level of disruption and made an effort to analyze the events to determine whether there might be effective strategies to deal with them. She testified that she never observed another child being distracted by STUDENT’s behavior when he was working with his instructional assistant. She did observe some distraction as a result of STUDENT’s one-on-one instruction in the class from Ms. Hiltel or her assistant. She never observed or heard anything about the teachers or staff attempting any quantitative measure of the behaviors which, in her opinion, would be a necessary step in an analysis of the problem and the development of effective strategies.
There is conflicting evidence regarding efforts being employed this year to address STUDENT’s disruptive behavior. Ms. Boyer testified that she has continued to implement Dr. Gillham’s behavior plan, along with other techniques. However, Ms. Hiltel testified that the behavior plan was no longer being implemented because there were fewer maladaptive behaviors. In Ms. Hiltel’s opinion, the plan was effective, but she believed that it was the reduction of STUDENT’s participation in the kindergarten activities that played the more significant role in reducing disruptive behaviors. It was also clear that the Petitioner’s employees have been concerned about the behaviors and have discussed them in at least general terms. Ms. Boyer testified, for example, that she and other staff have speculated that the increase in behaviors this year could be due to increased demands for physical movement, particularly for toileting, the longer school day and its tiring effect on STUDENT, and the stimulating effects of the first grade classroom environment and/or curriculum. The staff was able to deal effectively with a significant increase in dropping that accompanied an acceleration of STUDENT’s toileting schedule.(Footnote 21)
Dr. Farlow also looked at the interventions that were used by teachers and staff with STUDENT. She observed that 80 percent the interventions used to control maladaptive behaviors consisted of a command to stop the behavior, then a prompt, then a reward. Dr. Farlow believed that this intervention was, in effect, rewarding STUDENT for the maladaptive behavior and thus counterproductive. She explained her opinion that the approach should be to reward appropriate behavior on a schedule.
The Hearing Officer finds that there has not yet been an appropriate analysis of the problem behaviors and of the impact they are having on the education of the other students in the class.(Footnote 22) As a result, there has been no coordinated and consistently implemented plan to deal with STUDENT’s current behaviors. On this basis, the Hearing Officer finds that the Petitioners have thus far failed to employ all reasonable means to analyze and address STUDENT’s disruptive behaviors. Therefore, while it is clear that STUDENT’s presence in the class does have some negative effect on the teacher and the class, the extent of that effect cannot be fairly judged. On that basis, this factor cannot be weighed against STUDENT’s current placement at 3R School.
(4) The Cost of Supplemental Aids and Services Necessary to Serve STUDENT at 3R School
The Petitioners’ witnesses stated that cost of the two placements is comparable. This is not a factor that requires further consideration.
For the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offer of placement at the Woodlake SDC, as proposed in the July 9, 2001 IEP, does not offer STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment.
Issue 2: Does STUDENT Require a Change of Placement in Order to Receive a Free, Appropriate Public Education in the Least Restrictive Environment?
STUDENT is currently attending the same school he would be attending of he were not disabled. That is what the law requires, unless it cannot be reasonably accomplished under the guidelines announced in the Holland case. It is, at least initially, less a question of whether STUDENT requires a change of placement in order to receive a FAPE and more a question of whether the District has done everything the law requires of it before a forced move can be accomplished. The only Holland factor that had the potential of weighing against STUDENT’s current placement was the third factor that focuses on the effect of STUDENT’s presence in the general education class on the teacher and other students in that class. That factor was not actually weighed against the current placement because the Hearing Officer determined that the District had not employed all reasonable means to fulfill the law’s mandate that disabled children be educated with their nondisabled peers. This is the same reason why the Hearing Officer cannot consider a forced change of STUDENT’s placement now. The law simply does not allow a change of placement where the preferred, integrated placement at a student’s home school is either working or has a reasonable likelihood of working. Absent an agreement otherwise by
STUDENT’s parents, his placement cannot be changed until it has been determined that he cannot receive a FAPE in his current placement.
The Hearing Officer agrees with the Respondent that there must first be a renewed effort to evaluate the current placement with the assistance of an inclusion specialist. The Hearing Officer believes, based principally on the testimony of Dr. Farlow, that more can and should be done both to determine the effect of STUDENT’s participation on the teacher and other students and to minimize that effect to try to make STUDENT’s inclusion program work for him.(Footnote 23) The inclusion specialist should focus on whether STUDENT can be provided a FAPE at 3R School, gathering data and making recommendations as appropriate to insure compliance with the law’s mandate on least restrictive environment. Next, an appropriate functional behavior analysis (FBA) must be done as a preliminary step in the development of a behavior plan. When the inclusion specialist has completed the program evaluation and the FBA is done, the District should convene an IEP team meeting to discuss the recommendations of the inclusion specialist and to develop and agree upon a program for STUDENT at 3R School, including implementation of a behavioral plan, revised goals and objectives as necessary, and any other matter appropriate for consideration at that meeting. Finally, the IEP and behavior plan should be implemented. Only after the District has done what the law requires and there has been an adequate opportunity to determine the outcome of its efforts can fair consideration be give to the question of whether a change of placement is required in order for STUDENT to receive a FAPE in the least restrictive environment.
Based upon the evidence currently available, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not require a change of placement in order to receive a FAPE in the least restrictive environment.
CONCLUSION
The District’s offer of placement at the Woodlake SDC was not an offer of FAPE in the least restrictive environment. Consistent with this Decision, the District cannot remove STUDENT from his current placement until it has been determined that the nature and severity of his disabilities are such that his education in general education classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be satisfactorily achieved. The resolutions proposed by the Petitioners are denied. The Respondent’s request that STUDENT be allowed to remain in his current placement is granted, pending further determinations by the IEP team regarding STUDENT’s placement and program. Respondent’s request that the Petitioners’ be required to hire an inclusion specialist to assist with this determination is granted.
ORDER
1. Within ten calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall retain the services of an inclusion specialist to conduct an impartial and balanced evaluation of STUDENT’s placement and program at 3R School. The Petitioners may, but are not required to, allow STUDENT’s parents to participate in the selection of that inclusion specialist.
2. The inclusion specialist retained by the District shall do the following:
a. Within twenty-five calendar days of the date of this decision, complete the gathering of all data required by the specialist to state findings, opinions and recommendations regarding the provision of a FAPE to STUDENT in his placement at 3R School; b. Within thirty calendar days of the date of this decision, complete a written report of the evaluation, including the findings, conclusions and recommendations regarding the provision of a FAPE to STUDENT in his placement at 3R School; c. Within forty days of the date of this Decision, participate as an IEP team member in the development of a program for STUDENT at 3R School, including a behavioral plan, revised goals and objectives as necessary, and any other matter appropriate for consideration by the IEP team; d. Participate as appropriate in the implementation of STUDENT’s program at 3R School.
3. Within thirty calendar days of the date of this Decision, the Petitioners shall use the services of a qualified behavior analyst to undertake and complete a functional behavioral analysis of STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors that are interfering with his and his classmates’ education and to prepare a written report and draft plan for consideration.
4. Within forty calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall convene an IEP meting to consider the reports of the inclusion specialist and the behavioral analyst and to develop a program for STUDENT at 3R School. The program shall be consistent with this Decision and shall include an appropriate amount of intensive one-on-one instruction, the services of an instructional aide, a behavioral plan, and revised goals and objectives.
5. The parents of STUDENT shall cooperate with the inclusion specialist and behavior analyst by participating in interviews, gathering, recording and providing information, allowing reasonable observations of STUDENT at home, in school or in other environments and in any other reasonable way facilitating compliance with this order.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
1. Does the District’s offer of placement at the F. J. White Learning Center in Woodlake, CA, as proposed in the individualized education plan of July 9, 2001, offer STUDENT a free, appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment?
The Respondent prevailed on this issue.
2. Does STUDENT require a change of placement in order to receive a free, appropriate public education (FAPE)in the least restrictive environment?
The Respondent prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code Section 56505(i).
Dated: April 16, 2002 Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES
1. There were times during the hearing when one or more representatives of a party were absent and the hearing went forward with their consent. Counsel were always present. 2. In his statement of issues and proposed resolutions, Respondent raised an issue regarding the need to update goals that have been achieved. Because the goals and objectives are part of an analysis of FAPE, they will be addressed in that context below. 3. The order of the issues presented by the Petitioners has been changed to facilitate analysis. 4. The terms “integration” and “inclusion” are used in this Decision to describe the inclusion of the disabled student with peers who are not disabled for classes, recess, lunch, assemblies and other school activities. 5. Petitioners’ exhibits are designated by number:page. Respondents’ exhibits are designated by letter:page. 6. The report offered as an exhibit by Petitioners is six pages long, excluding a six-page “draft” copy and twenty-eight pages of attachments . No signature page is included, so the Hearing Officer is not sure that the report in evidence is the entire report. 7. The acronym TEACCH stands for Treatment and Education of Autistic and related Communication-handicapped Children. It was described in the testimony as an instruction method that emphasizes structure in a visually enhanced and language reduced environment. 8. Prior to this, only a maximum of sixty minutes was spent by STUDENT outside of the regular class. 9. Testimony suggested that additional time was spent in transitions, particularly for toileting. 10. The IEP itself calls for placement in an unspecified SDC, but the attached notes make specific reference to the Woodlake SDC. 11. Dr Siegel believed that STUDENT’s autistic characteristics were also explainable on the basis of the developmental delays. 12. Dr. Siegel thought that this could work if STUDENT had a one-to-one aide to assist him. 13. The District and COE staff were adamant that STUDENT could not be trained or “primed” to participate in class. 14. Dr. Siegel did not state that STUDENT’s current placement could have been modified to provide him with a FAPE. 15. The testimony regarding the length of the bus ride from Three Rivers to Woodlake varied. 16. The absence of goals to address maladaptive behavior will be discussed in the context of a behavioral plan, below. 17. The District’s recognition of this need was further evidenced by correspondence between it and STUDENT’s parents at the beginning of the current school year in August and October 2001 requesting the parents’ consent to a functional behavior assessment. 18. Dr Gillham states in his letter of July 12, 2001, to STUDENT’s parents that he believed a school-based buddy system could be implemented. Dr. Siegel said STUDENT would benefit from an after-school program with a one-on-one aide, but no such aide is offered. 19. While several of the witnesses, including Dr. Siegel, stated that the services of an aide should probably be provided initially, then faded, no witness testified that one would be provided . 20. Ms. Boyer was also STUDENT’s aide during his time at the Woodlake SDC in 1999. 21. The evidence showed that there was a significant increase in STUDENT’s dropping behavior when the toileting schedule was changed from three times per day to hourly. The dropping behavior, which usually occurred while on the way back to the classroom after a bathroom break, improved significantly when STUDENT’s toileting schedule was reduced to four times per day. 22. There was correspondence between the District and the parents in the beginning of the current school year about the District’s desire to do a functional analysis of STUDENT’s behavior. 23. This might have been accomplished had the Petitioners requested that Dr. Siegel look at STUDENT’s current program and tell them what they could do to better meet his needs and the needs of his classmates. It would more likely have been accomplished by consultation with an inclusion specialist whose role it was to conduct a balanced evaluation of STUDENT’s current program.
