California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 7, 1999

Rim of the World Unified School District et al. v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 1742-98, SN 1561-98 · Hearing Officer Glenna Eubank deCamara

Rim of the World Unified may finish assessing a student placed in Utah by her parents, who must return her to the district.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The case was consolidated with Student v. Rim of the World, SN 1561-98. The procedural section says SN 1561-98 "is without legal foundation and is dismissed." The conclusion says instead that an Order to Show Cause would be issued, in a separate document, on why SN 1561-98 should not be dismissed.

Summary

Rim of the World Unified School District and the East Valley Special Education Plan Area (SELPA) filed this case to finish assessing a 14-year-old girl. Her parents had placed her at Cross Creek Manor, a secure residential facility in Utah. She had never received special education. Her father signed an assessment plan on August 24, 1998, and David Brown, the district's special education director, did some of the testing the next day. At an October 12, 1998 IEP meeting, the team discussed whether she qualified as seriously emotionally disturbed. It decided it needed her full mental health records before deciding. Days later, the parents placed her in Utah. They then filed their own hearing request seeking funding.

The Hearing Officer found that the team had put off the eligibility decision rather than denied eligibility. Summer break and the weeks when no one knew where the student was did not count toward the 50 days allowed to assess and hold an IEP meeting. That meant only 15 of the 50 days had been used. So the district could finish the tests in the August 24 plan without new consent. Relying on federal cases, the Hearing Officer also held that the district did not have to send staff out of state. If the parents want her eligibility decided, they must bring her back within district boundaries for testing. The parents' own case (SN 1561-98) faced an order to show cause why it should not be dismissed.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled a family's out-of-state residential placement made before the district finished its assessment. Days when the child could not be assessed did not count toward the 50-day timeline. The district could finish testing under the original consent, and it did not have to travel out of state to do so.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue 1. Is the District entitled to conduct further testing on Student pursuant to an assessment plan authorized by her parents on August 24, 1998?

    The Hearing Officer found the IEP team had deferred eligibility rather than denied it. Only 15 of the 50 statutory days had run because days the student was unavailable did not count, so the district could finish the tests in the August 24, 1998 plan without new consent.

  2. Issue 2. If the District is entitled to complete its assessment, should it be conducted at the out-of-state residential facility in Utah or within the Rim of the World School District?

    The district has no duty to travel out of state to assess a student whose parents placed her there on their own. The parents must return her to the district for the assessment if they want her eligibility decided.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order that district may assess without consent. The District may conduct the uncompleted tests described in the August 24, 1998 assessment plan at a location within the District's boundaries.
  • The parents must return the student to a location within the District's boundaries for completion of the assessment if they want her special education eligibility determined.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Andress v. Cleveland Independent School District, 64 F.3d 176 (5th Cir. 1995); Gregory K. v. Connecticut State Board of Education, 811 F.2d 1307 (9th Cir. 1987); Lenhoff v. Farmington Public Schools, 680 F.Supp. 921 (E.D. Mich. 1988); Patricia P. v. Board of Education of Oak Park, 8 F.Supp.2d 801 (N.D. Ill. 1998); Doe v. Phillips, 20 IDELR 1150 (N.D. Cal. 1994); Cal. Ed. Code §§ 56043, 56321, 56327, 56341, 56342, 56344

People named in the decision

  • David Brown, director of special education and school psychologist (assessor); District witness, Rim of the World Unified School District
  • Gail Lindberg, SELPA representative present at hearing, East Valley Special Education Plan Area
  • Dr. Gary Warren, school psychologist; District witness, Rim of the World Unified School District
  • Syam Kunam, M.D., attending psychiatrist, Loma Linda Behavioral Medicine Center
  • Gurmeet Multani, M.D., private psychiatrist who evaluated the student, Private
  • Loma Linda Behavioral Medicine Center, hospital treatment provider, Private
  • Vista, residential treatment provider, Private
  • Cross Creek Manor, out-of-state secure residential facility (parents' unilateral placement), LaVerkin, Utah

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Glenna Eubank deCamara, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Lake Arrowhead, California, on February 5 and March 2, 1999.

Petitioners Rim of the World Unified School District (hereinafter District or Rim) and East Valley Special Education Plan Area (hereinafter SELPA) were represented by attorney Andrew Arczynski with the law firm of Filarsky & Watt. Also present on behalf of the Petitioners were Gail Lindberg from the SELPA and David Brown, director of special education for Rim.

Respondent Student (hereinafter Respondent or Student) was represented by attorney Steve Hermanson with the Law Office of J.S. Hermanson. Also present on Respondent’s behalf were her parents, Mr. and Mrs. Parent..

The District called the following witnesses to testify: Dr. Gary Warren, school psychologist, and David Brown, special education director for the District.

Respondent called the following witness to testify: Mr. Parent, Respondent’s father, and Mrs. Parent, Respondent’s mother.

Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of written closing arguments. The Hearing Office received the written closing arguments, the record was closed, and the issue was submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

On the first day of the hearing, the parties stipulated that the instant case and that of Student v. Rim of the World (SN 1561-98) would be consolidated and that the current Hearing Officer would retain jurisdiction over the combined cases. The parties further agreed that the District would first present its case (SN 1742-98) regarding the issue of assessment. It was also determined that the only issue that would be presented in the present case was whether the District could conduct the unperformed tests described in its assessment plan of August 24, 1998. The Hearing Officer would not hear evidence that the District should be allowed to conduct additional assessments presented to the parents through an assessment plan dated December 18, 1998, after the Respondent had filed for a due process hearing. The Hearing Officer issued an order incorporating the parties’ stipulation. On the next day of hearing, the parties agreed that the Hearing Officer would first render a decision in case number SN 1742. The results of that decision would determine when the case of Student v. Rim, et.al. (SN 1561-98) would proceed to hearing. However, as discussed below, the Hearing Officer finds that the case of Student v. Rim, et.al. SN 1561-98, is without legal foundation and is dismissed.

ISSUES

l. Is the District entitled to conduct further testing on Student pursuant to an assessment plan authorized by her parents on August 24, 1998?

2. If the District is entitled to complete its assessment, should it be conducted at the out-of-state residential facility in Utah or within the Rim of the World School District?

BACKGROUND FACTS

Student is a fourteen-year-old girl who currently resides in a secure residential facility in Utah pursuant to a unilateral placement effectuated by her parents on October 15, 1998. Prior to her placement in Utah, Student, with periodic absences, had resided with her parents and attended school in the Rim School District. She had not previously been identified or referred for special education services.

Mr. Parent is an English and psychology teacher at a District high school. Mrs. Parent is a school counselor who provides individual and group therapy for students at a District elementary school. On August 20, 1998, Mr. Parent contacted a counselor with whom he works and asked how he would request that his daughter be assessed for special education. On Mr. Parent’s behalf, the counselor notified David Brown, the District’s director of special education, that the FAMILY were requesting special education assistance for their daughter. Although the District remained on summer break, as a courtesy to another District employee, Mr. Brown telephoned Mr. Parent on August 23, 1998, and arranged to meet with him the next day.

At their lengthy meeting on August 24, 1998, Mr. Parent explained that Student had been exhibiting behavioral problems and experiencing emotional difficulties since April 1998. She had been hospitalized in April 1998 at Loma Linda Behavioral Medicine Center (hereinafter Loma Linda) for depression associated with family conflicts and poor academic performance. Her grades had declined and she was defiant. She had a history of running away from home. While in the hospital, Student was started on antidepressants, which she refused to take after she was discharged. Because Student's issues focused primarily on her father, he moved out of the family home when she returned home. On August 19, 1998, Student ran away again and was picked up by the sheriff. When she was returned to her home, she attempted to overdose on the medication prescribed for her depression. This possible suicide attempt resulted in her readmission to Loma Linda Hospital on August 19, 1998. According to the report of Syam Kunam M.D., Student's attending psychiatrist at Loma Linda, since her first hospitalization in April 1998 Student had continued to “have problems with running away, insomnia, irritability, mood swings and failing grades.” Her problems with her father had escalated. Dr. Kunam recommended that Student be transferred to residential treatment because of her family situation and the failure of outpatient treatment rendered it unsafe for her to return home. On the afternoon of August 25, 1998, Student was transferred to residential care at Vista with a diagnosis of bipolar affective disorder and psychological stress caused by “severe conflict with father.” Mr. Parent returned home because he and Mrs. Parent felt that his absence had not reduced their daughter’s problems.

Mr. Brown, who is a District psychologist as well as the director of special education, visited Student at Loma Linda on August 25, 1998, pursuant to the assessment plan signed by her father the previous day. This plan authorized a District psychologist to utilize the following assessment tools: Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children III (WISC III); Woodcock Johnson Test of Achievement (WJ); Burks Behavior Rating Scale; Draw a Person; Sentence Completion; an observation of Student: Self Concept Scale; a review of the report from Loma Linda; a handwriting sample; Wepman Auditory Discrimination Test; and an interview with Student, one of her parents and her teachers. The school nurse was to take a developmental history, conduct a vision and hearing screening and write a nurse’s report. During the August 25, 1998-visit, Mr. Brown did not conduct the performance portion of the WISC, the WJ achievement test, the mother’s completed Burks rating scale, the Draw a Person, the self-concept scale, and interviews with Student's teachers. The nurse’s portion of the assessment also was not done on that day.

On September 5, 1998, Student returned home from the residential placement. School had resumed following summer break on September 2, 1998. She briefly attended her regular school placement. No further tests were administered or initiated by the District during the five school days Student was present on the campus. On September 14, 1998, Student ran away from home and was not returned until October 9, 1998. She took a family car and left with three males who are reported to have a history of negative and antisocial behavior. The group traveled around Northern and Southern California panhandling for money. When they were located, Student was charged with burglary, grand theft auto and other crimes. One of the friends she traveled with was placed in jail on charges of kidnaping, robbery and grand theft auto.

The District mailed a notice of an Individual Education Program (IEP) meeting to Mr. and Mrs. Parent on October 2, 1998. This notice specified that the purpose of the meeting was to consider eligibility for special education pursuant to the parents’ request. Those invited to attend, in addition to the parents, were a District administrator, a regular education teacher, a special education teacher and the school psychologist. The notice indicated that all school records would be considered and that the placement options to be discussed were regular classes, resource specialist assistance and designated instructional services. The assessment procedures listed on the notice were observation, testing by the psychologist and a review of records. The meeting was scheduled to take place on October 12, 1998.

The IEP meeting occurred as scheduled on October 12, 1998. Mr. Brown presented the psychological report which was based upon the information he had obtained during the evaluation of Student at Loma Linda. He concluded that she did not appear to qualify as seriously emotionally disturbed (SED) under the education code. The duration of her problems had not existed for a long period of time, nor were her behaviors to such a marked degree that her educational performance was seriously affected. Her achievement was commensurate with her abilities according to her eighth-grade achievement tests. Mr. Brown recommended that the IEP team carefully consider whether Student suffered from a serious emotional disturbance that adversely affected her educational performance. The participants at the IEP meeting agreed that Student would return to school the next day and attend general education, tutor-supported classes. After Mr. and Mrs. Parent provided detailed information about Student's hospitalizations, the team also decided that they required the complete mental health records from Loma Linda and Vista before they made a final determination of her eligibility for special education. They would reconvene the IEP meeting when these records were received.

Mr. and Mrs. Parent had arranged for Student to be seen by Dr. Gurmeet Multani subsequent to the IEP meeting on October 12, 1998. Dr. Multani reported that Student was feeling extremely upset, depressed, helpless and unable to cope. She expressed hatred toward the police and made physical threats toward them. Student stated that she wanted to obtain guns, gather her friends, attack the jail and rescue her imprisoned friend. She did not feel that she belonged at home and she reported a need to get away from it. She also admitted that she experienced intense episodes of happiness interspersed with feelings of devastation. Recently, the “highs” were greatly outnumbered by emotional “lows.” During her “high” periods, she felt as if she could handle anything and she did not have a need for sleep. It had been during one of these “high” episodes that she left home with her male friends. Dr. Multani reported that Student was withdrawn and isolated and that she had poor self-esteem. She did not like to interact with adults. However, she had no difficulties interacting with her friends.

Dr. Multani diagnosed Student with Bipolar Disorder, depressed with psychotic features. He found that she had experienced moderate psycho-social stressors and poor functioning during the prior year. He recommended that she be started on medication and placed in a locked facility. He felt that there was great likelihood that she would hurt herself. Dr. Multani also felt that her “paranoia and delusional thinking put her at a high risk to hurt other people.” Student had previously run away from home and continued to express a desire to leave again. Thus, it was very likely that she would not stay with her parents. In Dr. Multani’s opinion, Student required consistent monitoring in a secure facility to prevent her from escaping or hurting herself and/or others. He suggested that Mr. and Mrs. Parent “approach the school for funding for immediate placement.” The treatment goal was to provide consistent medication to alleviate the depression and volatile mood swings, as well as to improve overall functioning and self-esteem.

The next day, October 13, 1998, Student did not return to school as agreed to at the IEP meeting. Instead, Mr. Parent contacted the District and advised it that he was placing Student in Cross Creek Manor, a residential facility in Utah. Mr. Brown advised Mr. Parent that such placement without a ten-day notice to the District could prevent any reimbursement for costs associated with such placement. Student was transported to Utah on October 15, 1998, and she continues to reside there.

The Respondent filed for a due process hearing on November 9, 1998, and the parties engaged in mediation on December 18, 1998. Thereafter, on December 18, 1998, the District filed for the instant due process hearing and mailed a request that Mr. and Mrs. Parent sign a new assessment plan containing extensive testing that was not requested by the District in its original assessment plan. The parents did not sign this proposed plan.

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The District contends that Student was unilaterally placed out of state by her parents before it concluded its assessment and made a finding of eligibility. It claims that Student has not been made reasonably available for evaluations and that it must be allowed to complete its assessment process before the Respondent’s due process request for funding of the out-of-state placement can be considered.

It is the Respondent’s contention that the District had completed all of the testing it intended to do and that it denied eligibility for special education at the IEP meeting of October 12, 1998. In the alternative, the Respondent argues that if the District did intend to conduct further evaluations, it was obligated to seek a time extension from the parents and travel to Utah to complete the tests during its authorized fifty days to complete its assessments.

FINDINGS OF FACTS AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue One Is the District entitled to conduct further testing on Student pursuant to an assessment plan authorized by her parents on August 24, 1998?

A school district must convene an IEP team meeting within fifty days of receiving parental consent to assess the student (excluding school vacations in excess of five days) unless the parent provides a written agreement to an extension. California Education Code §56344(d). It is undisputed that Mr. Parent consented on August 24, 1998, to a proposed assessment plan for his daughter. Mr. Brown, in his capacity as a school psychologist, went to Loma Linda the following day and conducted some of the tests enumerated in the assessment plan while the school district remained on summer break. School resumed for the 1998-99 school year on September 2, 1998. Thus, pursuant to the above statute, the fifty-day time period to assess and convene an IEP meeting actually began on September 2, 1998. Student returned to school following her discharge from Vista on Monday, September 8, 1998. That following Sunday, September 14, 1998, Student ran away from her home. When she left, twelve days of the fifty had elapsed. Student's location was unknown until she was returned to her parents on October 9, 1998. Although being a runaway is not identified as a specific tolling circumstance in the above statute, a child must be reasonably available for the assessment. During the twenty-four days when no one knew where Student was, the District did not have access to her for any further assessments and these days should not be charged against its fifty-day time period. Student was again available to the District from October 9, 1998, through the IEP meeting of October 12, 1998. This would add another three days to the twelve, for a total of fifteen days attributable to the District’s fifty days. When the District convened the IEP meeting, it still had time remaining to conduct further testing pursuant to the assessment plan.

A factual consideration is required to determine whether the District denied eligibility for special education at the IEP meeting of October 12, 1998, or whether it deferred a decision on eligibility and intended to gather additional data pursuant to its assessment plan of August 24, 1998. If the District indicated that it had adequate information to make a determination regarding eligibility and, in effect signaled that it had done so, it cannot, after a due process request, conduct further examinations in an attempt to gather support for its prior determination. However, as discussed below, if the parents removed Student from the District before the assessment process was complete, they cannot deny the District an opportunity to complete its evaluation while at the same time requesting reimbursement for the out-of-state placement.

To support its contention that it had not completed its evaluations, the District offered the testimony of David Brown, who is the District’s director of special education as well as one of its school psychologists. Mr. Brown drafted the assessment plan, conducted the tests that were given to Student, and wrote a report of his findings. Mr. Brown testified that he spent one to one-and- a-half hours with Student at Loma Linda. He knew that he would need additional time and he intended to complete his testing when she returned to school. He stated that he still needed to conduct an observation of Student in her school setting and to have a resource specialist (RSP) provide an assessment plan for an educational assessment. Mr. Brown said that the District needed a multi-disciplinary team assessment. However, he did not identify any specialist required other than the RSP teacher. Mr. Brown also wanted to interview Student's teachers. As evidence that it had not yet determined eligibility, the District points out that the IEP document is blank under “does” or “does not” qualify for special education and that it references a future IEP meeting after receipt of additional mental health records. As further corroboration of its position, the District relies upon Dr. Brown’s report, which concludes that the “IEP team should carefully consider whether they feel that there is a serious emotional disturbance . . . and whether services under an IEP goals and objectives need to be in place for student to benefit from the educational program.” The District maintains that these facts support its position that eligibility had not been determined prior to the IEP.

Mr. and Mrs. Parent both testified that they assumed the District had conducted all the tests it wanted to perform because the District had never asked to do further testing on Student. They believed that the purpose of the IEP meeting of October 12, 1998, was to discuss Mr. Brown’s findings and determine what assistance was available. The parents testified that Mr. Brown reviewed his report and explained why each test he had conducted resulted in a finding that Student was ineligible as a seriously emotionally disturbed (SED) student. Mr. Brown’s report summarized that “it does not appear that residential placement is necessary for this student in order for this student to benefit from education and progress in the public educational program.” Mr. and Mrs. Parent each testified that they interpreted this statement in the report to be a finding by the District’s director of special education that Student did not qualify as a SED student. Mrs. Parent testified that Mr. Brown reported that Student “was not that bad and that she needed to come back to school and give it a try.” Both parents also testified that they believed that the District’s IEP team members had decided that Student did not qualify for special education before the meeting began. However, as the meeting progressed and the parents provided more detailed information, the District became unsure of its decision. It ultimately determined that it needed additional records from Loma Linda and Vista before a final eligibility decision could be made. After determining that the hospitals had not provided all of Student's medical records in response to the District’s prior records request, the parents signed another medical records release. This authorized the District to again request Student's medical record. The parties then agreed to convene another IEP meeting when the records arrived. The IEP team concurred that Student would return to school the next day and be placed in an aide-supported general education class. She would attend the school where her father taught so that he could personally transport her to and from school and help monitor her during her school day. The parents testified that they signed the IEP agreeing to this placement only because they thought that nothing else was available for their daughter.

Later on the same day as the IEP meeting was held, Mr. and Mrs. Parent had Student evaluated by Gurmeet Multani, M.D. Per his written report, Dr. Multani found that Student was in a state of acute paranoia with delusional thinking and that she was at a high risk for causing harm to herself or others. In his opinion, Student required immediate placement in a locked facility. Mr. Parent testified that the next day, October 13, 1998, he contacted Mr. Brown and advised him that they were placing Student in a residential program in Utah. On October 15, 1998, Student was taken to Cross Creek Manor, a secure residential facility in LaVerkin, Utah.

California statutes precisely set forth the procedures that must be followed when a student is referred for a special education evaluation. Upon the referral of a student for special education, the District must provide the parents with a proposed assessment plan within fifteen calendar days (excluding school vacations or a parental time waiver) of the referral. The parents are then entitled to at least fifteen days to agree or disagree with the assessment plan as proposed. CA Ed. Code §56043(a) and (c), (formerly §56321) The assessment plan must be written in an easily understood language, provided in the parents’ primary language, explain the types of tests to be conducted, and state that the assessments will not result in an IEP without parental consent. CA Ed. Code §56321(b). An IEP must be developed “within a total time not to exceed 50 days . . . from the date of receipt of the parent’s written consent for assessment” (excluding vacations or parental consent to an extension). CA Ed. Code §56043(d), (formerly §56344). The IEP team charged with drafting the IEP is to consist of an administrator, the child’s current or most recent teacher, the parent(s), and when appropriate, the student, other individuals with the knowledge necessary to develop the IEP, and any assessors. CA Ed. Code §56341(b)(1-3) and (c)(1-2d). The individual who conducts an assessment must prepare a written report that includes (1) whether the student needs special education and the basis for making that determination, (2) relevant behavior observed in an appropriate setting, (3) the relationship between the behavior and the student’s functional abilities, (4) educationally relevant health and medical findings, and (5) a determination of the effects of environmental, economic or cultural conditions on the student. CA Ed. Code §56327. The IEP team is then mandated to “review the assessment results, determine eligibility” and develop an IEP. CA Ed. Code §56342.

The IEP notice sent by the District specifically stated that the purpose of the meeting was a “parent request” to “consider eligibility for special education.” This notice also listed the placement options that would be considered, the participants, the records that were considered and the assessment procedures used. The assessment procedures were recorded as “observation, testing by psychologist, and a review of records.”

At the October 12, 1998 IEP meeting, Mr. Brown presented his written assessment report in compliance with California Education Code §56327. Mr. Brown’s report suggested a preliminary finding that Student did not qualify for special education as an SED student. In his report, he set forth Student's mental history, described the results of the tests he administered, and listed the criteria under the Education Code for finding that a student is SED. He then concluded by cautioning the IEP team to carefully consider whether Student was eligible for special education. Mr. Brown’s testimony at the hearing paralleled his written opinion. His impression was that Student probably suffered from a conduct disorder, rather than a severe emotional disturbance as defined by the Education Code, but that the information he presently possessed was insufficient for him to render a final determination of eligibility.

Mr. and Mrs. Parent both testified that although they believed the District had initially determined that Student was not eligible as a SED student, by the end of the meeting it appeared that the District was no longer certain that it should deny eligibility. Mr. Parent testified that he believed that “at the beginning of the meeting, the District had determined that Student was not eligible, but as he expressed more information and he learned how little information the District had received from the hospitals, he felt Mr. Brown became more hesitant in his decision.” Mrs. Parent offered similar testimony when she stated that the District “was reluctant to deny eligibility without obtaining and reviewing the complete medical records.” She also testified that “every member of the team indicated that they needed more records to determine eligibility.”

The facts support a finding that the District was prepared to deny eligibility at the commencement of the IEP meeting of October 12, 1998. However, following a discussion of eligibility, in which the parents provided information about Student's condition in greater detail, the District’s team members were no longer confident that a denial of eligibility was appropriate. Rather, the team decided that it required additional information and deferred a final decision on eligibility. The statements by Mr. and Mrs. Parent reinforce the Respondent’s contention that the District did not formally deny special education eligibility to Student at the October 12, 1998 IEP meeting. (That the eligibility portion of the IEP document was not completed also contributes to the argument that eligibility was not decided, as does the agreement to reconvene the IEP meeting at a later date.) If eligibility had already been denied, there would be no need for a subsequent IEP meeting. Mr. and Mrs. Parent apparently concluded that the District would still find that Student did not qualify for special education even after they reviewed her hospital records. Despite this opinion, the parents concurred with the remainder of the team regarding Student's placement and agreed to convene another IEP meeting upon the team’s receipt of the mental health records. On November 3, 1998, the District mailed a notice of the second IEP meeting to Student's parents. The IEP meeting, which the District had scheduled for November 12, 1998, did not occur. Based upon a consideration of this evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not make an eligibility determination at the October 12, 1998 IEP meeting.

The Hearing Officer further concludes that prior to the IEP meeting of October 12, 1998, the District did not intend to conduct further testing and was satisfied with its evaluation of Student. However, during the course of this meeting, it determined that it required additional information to adequately assess eligibility. On the date of the IEP meeting, the District had thirty five days remaining of its authorized fifty days to complete its assessment of Student. Since eligibility was not decided, the convening of an IEP meeting did not end the assessment period. At the meeting, the District decided that it needed a complete copy of Student's mental health records. In reviewing this documentation, the District may have discovered facts that would have suggested the need for further assessments. Moreover, without obtaining additional consent from Mr. and Mrs. Parent, the District was entitled to conduct the remainder of the tests included in the previously agreed-upon assessment plan had Student been available. The Hearing Officer therefore determines that the District is entitled to complete the testing enumerated in the assessment plan dated August 24, 1998.

ISSUE TWO

SHOULD THE DISTRICT’S ASSESSMENT BE

CONDUCTED AT THE RESIDENTIAL FACILITY

IN UTAH OR AT THE RIM SCHOOL DISTRICT?

Because the Hearing Officer has determined that the District may conclude its assessment, it is necessary to address the issue of the location for such an assessment. The District argues that Student must be returned to the District and made reasonably available for the assessment. The Respondent claims that Student cannot be removed from her secure facility (footnote 1) and that the District must travel to Utah to conduct its assessment. Although both parties were asked to provide legal support for their positions on this issue, none was forthcoming. The Hearing Officer has therefore conducted independent research for legal authority and made an independent determination that the assessment of Student must occur within the District’s boundaries.

It is an established principal that “if a student’s parents want him to receive special education under IDEA, they must allow the school itself to evaluate the student.” Andress v. Cleveland Independent School District, 64 F.3d 176 (5th Cir. 1995). Gregory K. v. Conn State Board of Education, 811 F.2d 1307 (9th Cir. 1987) The issue of the assessment’s location was addressed in Lenhoff v. Farmington Public Schools, 680 F.Supp. 921 (Mich. 1988). The court held that a district was under no duty to leave the state to conduct an evaluation of a student unilaterally removed from the school district without the prior knowledge or acquiescence of school officials. Otherwise, parents could effectively impede the evaluation process by removing students to areas where it would be economically infeasible for a district to conduct an evaluation. To hold otherwise would violate a school district’s right to conduct an evaluation.

Recently, this principle was reiterated in the case of Patricia P. v. Board of Education of Oak Park, 8 F.Supp2d 801 (Ill 1998). The parent in this case unilaterally placed her child in a residential out-of-state facility and sought tuition reimbursement. She then claimed that the school district must either conduct its assessment through a review of the outside evaluations she provided or travel to the out-of-state facility to conduct the assessment:

There is no question on the record that [mother] did not offer to tender [student] back to Illinois for such an evaluation. Instead she suggested that District either (1) convene a staffing based solely on outside evaluations that she would procure or (2) send its personnel to Maine to conduct an out-of-state evaluation of [child]. As to the later suggestion, IDEA clearly does not contemplate a school district having to incur such an expense. And as to the former, it is entirely without merit.

Because the District is entitled to complete its assessment and is not obligated to travel out-of-state to do so, Mr. and Mrs. Parent must return Student to the Rim of the World Unified School District for the conclusion of its assessment if they want the District to make a determination of Student's eligibility for special education.

CONCLUSION

The Hearing Officer has determined that Mr. and Mrs. Parent removed Student from the District before the District had an opportunity to complete its assessment and determine eligibility. Consequently, under separate document, the Hearing Officer is issuing an Order to Show Cause why the case of Student v. Rim of the World, et.al., SN 1561-98 should not be dismissed.

ORDER

1. The District is entitled to conduct the uncompleted tests of Student described in the assessment plan of August 24, 1998 at a location within the District’s boundaries.

2. Mr. and Mrs. Parent must return Student to a location within the District’s boundaries for the completion of the assessment if they want her eligibility for special education determined.

Date: April 7, 1999 ____________________________________ GLENNA EUBANK deCAMARA,Hearing Officer, Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law

Footnote: 1. The Hearing Officer acknowledges the Respondent's position that Student's program requires that she remain in the residential facility until she attains a "level" that allows time away from the facility. However, there is no exception to the rule that a school district is allowed to conduct its own evaluation. This has been specifically upheld against claims that such evaluations would cause medical or psychological harm. Andress v. Cleveland Independent School District, 64 F.3d 176 (5th Cir. 1995), Doe v. Phillips, 20 IDELR 1150 (N.D. Cal. 1994)