California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 30, 2003

Los Angeles Unified School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 1807-02 · Hearing Officer Van T. Vu

Los Angeles Unified's offer to move a student from a small private school to a large high school was not FAPE.

Split decision: student prevailed on 3 of 4 issuesVanaman German LLP represented the student

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

Footnote 1 states that this Amended Decision corrects a typographical error in Respondent's name on page 2.

Summary

Los Angeles Unified School District filed for due process to show that its May 7, 2002 IEP offered a 14-year-old ninth grader a FAPE. The student was eligible under other health impairment. His eligibility under specific learning disability was disputed. He has superior cognitive ability but significant written-language, anxiety, and behavioral needs linked to a nonverbal learning disability. Under mediation agreements, he had attended Bridges Academy, a private school with 81 students. The District offered general education at El Camino High School, a campus of about 3,500 students. The offer included a one-to-one aide, a resource specialist "hub," counseling, a behavior support plan, and a laptop. The Hearing Officer found Dr. Sandra Kaler and Bridges administrator Sherry Minkowski more persuasive than District staff, who had only briefly observed the student. Their testimony showed he needed a small, protective setting with little visual clutter. El Camino was not that setting, and the offered supports would not reduce his anxiety there. The IEP also had no written plan to move him from Bridges to El Camino. The ESY English class offered later by letter was not discussed at an IEP meeting and would have added to his anxiety. More than half of the goals had illogical or out-of-term dates, which made them unmeasurable. The Hearing Officer rejected the student's claim that he needed occupational therapy. The District's request was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled a district's request for approval of its own IEP when parents refused consent. The Hearing Officer gave more weight to witnesses who knew how the student functioned day to day. The decision also shows that widespread date errors in goals can make an offer inadequate, and that a letter sent after the meeting cannot replace the IEP process.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1A. Was the District's May 7, 2002 IEP an offer of FAPE? — Whether placement at El Camino High School was designed to meet Student's unique needs

    A 3,500-student comprehensive campus, even with an aide, RSP hub and behavior support plan, was not the small, protective environment Student needed and was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.

  2. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue 1B. Whether the District offered an appropriate plan to transition Student from Bridges to El Camino

    Moot given the placement ruling, but the IEP contained no written transition plan; the June 2002 letter offering ESY at El Camino was an amendment made outside the IEP process and would have been inappropriate anyway.

  3. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue 1C. Whether the goals and objectives could be realized in the timeframes specified in the IEP

    Five of nine goals had illogical, missing, or out-of-term start or achievement dates, making the goals unmeasurable and meaningless.

  4. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1D. Whether Student has sensory processing deficits requiring occupational therapy beyond the compensatory OT in the IEP

    The evidence, including the treating occupational therapist's testimony, did not show Student needed OT to benefit from his education.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • The District's request for a determination that its May 7, 2002 offer was appropriate was denied; no implementation order was issued.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Daniel R. v. State Board of Education; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education; Cleveland Heights-University Heights City Sch. Dist. v. Boss

People named in the decision

  • Paula Calvert, assistant principal, Hale Middle School (LAUSD)
  • Margaruite Newman, special education teacher, Hale Middle School (LAUSD)
  • Terri Veasman, school psychologist, LAUSD
  • David Fehte, assistant principal, El Camino High School (LAUSD)
  • David Hussey, assistant principal of secondary counseling services, El Camino High School (LAUSD)
  • Michelle Hatfield, transition resource teacher, LAUSD
  • Jane Cohen, resource specialist teacher, El Camino High School (LAUSD)
  • Dr. Ivor Weiner, assistant professor of special education; witness for District
  • Charlotte Sewell, coordinating specialist for due process, LAUSD
  • Susan Tandberg, coordinator with instructional services, LAUSD
  • Lyne Rednick, assistive technology specialist, LAUSD
  • Ruth Adatto, occupational therapist (treated student 2000-2001, assessed 2002)
  • Dr. Sandra Kaler, licensed clinical psychologist; expert witness for Student
  • Sherry Minkowski, dean of students / administrator; former teacher of student, Bridges Academy
  • Dr. Theresa Rattray, private psychotherapist
  • Bridges Academy, private school placement, Sherman Oaks, California

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Encino, California, on February 13, 14, 17-19, 2003.

Petitioner Los Angeles Unified School District (Petitioner or District) was represented at hearing by attorneys Cynthia Floyd and Katrina Campbell and the District’s coordinating specialist for due process, Charlotte Sewell. Respondent STUDENT (Respondent or STUDENT) was represented at hearing by attorneys George Crook and Valerie Vanaman and paralegal John Chan. STUDENT’s parents, PARENTS, were also present on his behalf. Additionally, Respondent requested that the hearing be open to the public, and the hearing was observed by friends of the STUDENT’s family.

The Petitioner called the following witnesses: Paula Calvert, assistant principal at Hale Middle School (Hale); Margaruite Newman, special education teacher at Hale; Terri Veasman, school psychologist; David Fehte, assistant principal at El Camino High School (El Camino); David Hussey, assistant principal of secondary counseling services at El Camino; Michelle Hatfield, transition resource teacher; Jane Cohen, resource specialist teacher at El Camino; Dr. Ivor Weiner, assistant professor of special education; Charlotte Sewell, coordinating specialist for due process; Susan Tandberg, coordinator with instructional services; Lyne Rednick, assistive technology specialist; and Ruth Adatto, occupational therapist.

Respondent called the following witnesses: Dr. Sandra Kaler, licensed clinical psychologist; Sherry Minkowski, dean of students at Bridges Academy (Bridges); MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother; and George Crook, STUDENT’s attorney.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Respondent’s written closing brief was received by the Hearing Office by fax on March 11, 2003, and the District’s closing brief was received by mail on March 14, 2003. The record was then closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUE(Footnote 2)

Was the District’s May 7, 2002 IEP an offer of a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for STUDENT?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

As discussed below, the District filed this case seeking a determination that it offered Respondent STUDENT a FAPE. The District contends that its May 7, 2002 offer of placement and services was appropriate and was an offer of FAPE. With regard to the main area of contention between the parties, the District contends that STUDENT does not require a private school placement and could be appropriately placed at El Camino High School. According to the District, STUDENT’s academic and emotional needs can appropriately be addressed at El Camino with support services such as an individual aide and an “RSP hub,” where STUDENT can go when he becomes anxious in his regular education classes or to seek individualized attention from the resource specialist teacher. The District further contends that it offered STUDENT appropriate goals and objectives and opportunity to gradually transition from Bridges to El Camino. The District asserts that STUDENT could have appropriately transitioned from his small private school to El Camino High School prior to the fall of 2002 by attending a writing class during the extended school year of 2002, when he would have been able to familiarize himself with the campus and school staff. Moreover, the District contends that it is not obligated to offer STUDENT occupational therapy services because STUDENT does not have sensory processing issues that require those services.

Respondent STUDENT disagrees that District’s May 7, 2002 offer was an offer of FAPE. Specifically, Respondent contends that the IEP offer of placement at El Camino was not designed to meet his needs because his social/emotional and behavioral problems would impede his ability to function in the environment of a large campus. Additionally, Respondent argues that the District’s goals and objectives cannot be realized in the timeframes indicated, and the IEP lacked a plan to transition him from Bridges to El Camino. Furthermore, Respondent asserts that he has significant sensory processing deficits that require that he be provided occupational therapy services.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

Respondent STUDENT is a fourteen-year-old ninth-grader who is currently qualified for special education and related services as a student with a specific learning disability and an “other health impairment.”(footnote 3) Cognitively, STUDENT is in the superior range, but he has a visual motor integration deficit that translates to difficulty with written language. Additionally, he has been diagnosed with a nonverbal learning disability (NLD) that impacts, among other things, his ability to generate written material and to interpret and comprehend social conventions and nuances.(Footnote 4) He has also been diagnosed with Tourette’s Syndrome, obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD), and attention deficit hyperactive disorder (ADHD), all for which he takes medication. STUDENT lives at home with his parents and siblings and attends school at Bridges Academy (Bridges), a small private school located in Sherman Oaks, California.

STUDENT was initially placed at Bridges in April 1999 during his fifth grade year pursuant to a mediation agreement between his parents and the District. His placement at Bridges continued through the sixth, seventh, and eighth grade as a result of subsequent mediation agreements between the parties, and continues currently in the ninth grade pursuant to stay put. STUDENT’s ninth grade class at Bridges consists of approximately twelve students and he generally has no more than approximately three other students in each of his classes. The most recent mediation agreement that continued STUDENT’s placement at Bridges was entered into between the parties on March 5, 2002. In addition to resolving issues pertaining to STUDENT’s educational placement and services at Bridges through the end of the 2002 extended school year, the mediation agreement required the District to conduct his triennial evaluation and to convene an IEP meeting to discuss those assessments by May 15, 2002. The IEP meeting was actually held on May 7, 2002.

At STUDENT’s May 7, 2002 IEP meeting, the team reviewed the results of STUDENT’s assessments and the District offered to change STUDENT’s placement from Bridges to a general education placement with resource specialist support at his home public school, El Camino High School. According to District witnesses, El Camino is a comprehensive high school with approximately 3500 students and is located on a large campus. Additionally, the District offered STUDENT one class period per day of adapted physical education services, one hour per week of counseling services, one hour per month of mental health services, accommodations for written language and behavior, assistive technology in the form of a laptop computer and software to address STUDENT’s issues with written language and motor functioning, a behavior support plan, extra time during physical education to dress, a temporary support assistant (TSA) for four to six hours per day, and compensatory occupational therapy services to make up for therapy not provided under his prior IEP. The District also indicated that STUDENT’s 2002 extended school year (ESY) services would be governed by the March 5, 2002 mediation agreement that provided for ESY services at Bridges Academy.

At the end of the IEP meeting, MOTHER stated that she believed Bridges was the appropriate placement for STUDENT and not El Camino. She also indicated on the IEP that she did not consent to the District’s offer of placement and services, that she intended to request a due process hearing to resolve issues regarding the District’s offer, and that she was invoking STUDENT’s stay put right to remain at Bridges pending the due process procedures.

On or about May 31, 2002, the District sent the PARENTS a letter to “supplement and clarify the Los Angeles Unified School District’s… offer of placement and services for STUDENT for the 2002-2003 school year.” (Dist. Exh. 36, emphasis added.) Specifically, the District reiterated its educational offer and further clarified the type of classes STUDENT would be enrolled in, the expected class size of each of his courses, the type of curriculum to be implemented, the types of modifications or accommodations that would be provided to assist him with written language and behavior, and the role of the TSA. On June 20, 2002, the District again wrote the PARENTS regarding its educational offer for the “2002-2003 school year.” In that letter, the District offered STUDENT six weeks of services in a general education English class with aide support at El Camino High School for the 2002 extended school year.(Footnote 5)

What complicates the facts of this case is the confusion surrounding the implementation date of the May 7, 2002 IEP. As noted above, the March 5, 2002 mediation agreement had already resolved issues pertaining to STUDENT’s educational placement and services through the end of the 2002 ESY in August 2002. However, the Hearing Officer notes that the IEP and Charlotte Sewell’s testimony indicate that the District was offering STUDENT an educational program for the time period from May 7, 2002 (i.e., the date of the IEP meeting), through May 7, 2003. If the IEP term was to begin on May 7, 2002, as the District asserts, the IEP offer would overlap by approximately four months with the placement and program agreed to by the parties in mediation, and the PARENTS’ agreement to the IEP would have resulted in their losing the rights and obligations pertaining to STUDENT’s education that they negotiated and obtained through mediation.(Footnote 6) There is no evidence that the PARENTS intended for the IEP offer to supercede the mediation agreement. Moreover, a review of the tapes of the IEP meeting and subsequent letters from the District to “clarify” its offer indicates that the District’s offer was to be implemented in the fall of 2002 rather than from the May 7, 2002 date specified on the IEP.(footnote 7) Ultimately, because the PARENTS refused consent to the IEP, the existing mediation agreement governed STUDENT’s placement through the end of the 2002 ESY. Therefore, in light of all of the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the effective start date of the District’s IEP offer could not have been any sooner than the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year.(Footnote 8)

Despite the District’s letters clarifying and supplementing the District’s May 7, 2002 IEP offer, the PARENTS continued to refuse consent to implement the IEP. On August 2, 2002, before the PARENTS had filed a request for due process, the District requested of the Hearing Office a hearing to determine whether its May 7, 2002 IEP offer was an offer of FAPE.(Footnote 9)

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Was the District’s May 7, 2002 IEP an offer of a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for STUDENT?

Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Education Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(8). An IEP is a written statement that must be developed, reviewed, and revised for each student with a disability. The IEP must include a statement of the goals and objectives, of the special education and related services, and of the program modifications or supports for school personnel that are to be provided to enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum, and to be educated and participate with disabled and nondisabled peers in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347; Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343 and 56345. “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student, including instruction conducted in the classroom, in the home, in hospitals and institutions, and in other settings. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16). The term “related services,” which is also referred to in California as “designated instruction and services” (DIS), includes developmental, corrective, and supportive services that may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363.

To determine whether the District provided STUDENT a free appropriate public education, one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s offered and proposed programs. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F. 2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services, which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Rowley, 458 at 207-208. De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d at 130 (2d Cir. 1998). A child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997).

Additionally, special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A) specifically provides:

To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.

The requirement that disabled children be educated to the maximum extent appropriate with nondisabled children is often referred to as “mainstreaming,” or education in the “least restrictive environment” (LRE). The law demonstrates a “strong preference for ‘mainstreaming’ which rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption.” Daniel R. v. State Board of Education, 874 F.2d 1036, 1044-45 (5th Cir. 1989).

To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program must have met the following four substantive requirements in order to have constituted an appropriate educational program: (1) been designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, (2) been reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, (3) comported with his IEP, and (4) been provided in the least restrictive environment.

I. STUDENT’s Unique and Individual Needs

To determine if the District’s offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs, it is first necessary to determine what his educational needs are. The parties are in general agreement as to STUDENT’s deficits and areas of need. As was discussed above, STUDENT is cognitively in the superior range but he has a visual motor integration deficit. STUDENT has also been diagnosed with a nonverbal learning disability, obsessive-compulsive disorder, Tourette’s Syndrome, and attention deficit hyperactive disorder.(Footnote 10) The parties also agree that, as a result of his deficits, STUDENT has difficulty with the mechanical act of handwriting and with organizing and integrating thoughts and ideas to compose paragraphs. Hence, to address STUDENT’s handwriting and written language deficits, it is undisputed that he needs a laptop for word processing and adult assistance to learn to develop a “structure for writing” to enable him to organize his thoughts into written paragraphs.

The parties also agree that STUDENT currently has social/emotional and behavior difficulties. At hearing, clinical psychologist Dr. Sandra Kaler, who has assessed STUDENT three times since 1997, explained how many of STUDENT’s behavioral and social difficulties were related to his nonverbal learning disability. According to Dr. Kaler, persons with a nonverbal learning disability have difficulty integrating and assigning meaning to what they see, and this causes them anxiety that further affects the integration of information. This often results in their misperceiving what they see or their seeing the whole and not the parts or vice versa. To compensate for their deficit, they tend to talk things through aloud as an avoidance technique to calm themselves down and to organize their thoughts to give meaning to what they see. If the situation is something that they know well, they are less anxious, they pick up more information from the environment, and they can sort the visual information better. For STUDENT, his NLD is exhibited in school by his asking questions constantly about what is required of him and calling out frequently to talk things through. At hearing, Dr. Kaler described STUDENT as “hyperverbal” and as having an unmodulated loud voice. STUDENT’s talking aloud serves to increase the speed in which he processes information. Sometimes, STUDENT will over-focus on one aspect of a task and not see the “tree for the forest” or vice versa. Additionally, Dr. Kaler testified that STUDENT continues to be anxious and has a “profound lack of understanding of social conventions,” despite being in the small, safe environment of Bridges. Dr. Kaler testified that in new settings, even when he is provided individualized attention, STUDENT becomes very anxious. Moreover, STUDENT’s ability to complete written tasks is hindered by the significant stress he experiences when asked to complete written assignments.

Dr. Kaler’s descriptions of STUDENT’s anxiety and difficulty with transitions, staying on task, and understanding social cues and nuances were corroborated by the testimony and reports of STUDENT’s assessors and service providers. Sherri Minkowski, the administrator at Bridges who monitors STUDENT’s progress, testified that STUDENT exhibits anxiety and tearful frustration called “melt downs.”(Footnote 11) For example, Ms. Minkowski explained that when STUDENT was placed in a history class with a teacher with whom he was unfamiliar, STUDENT became paralyzed with anxiety, he was resistant to tasks, he demanded a great amount of attention, and he often disrupted the class. Additionally, his showed his stress by shaking, crying, and expressing feelings of frustration at being a failure. According to Ms. Minkowski, STUDENT was sometimes unable to overcome his stress in time to make it to his next class. School psychologist Terri Veasman described in her September 2001 class observation report that STUDENT demonstrated disruptive behaviors by shouting out when needing assistance or by randomly talking or changing the topic of conversation with peers. Additionally, special education teacher Margaruite Newman wrote in her May 2002 report that, although STUDENT had made significant gains in social/emotional area, he continues to need support in this area. Similarly, Dr. Theresa Rattray, STUDENT’s psychotherapist since September 1997, wrote in her May 2002 letter that STUDENT continues to struggle to control his anxiety and is inconsistent with his social skills goal. Dr. Rattray concluded that STUDENT requires continued therapy and behavior support to teach him new methods to reduce his anxiety regarding new tasks and to improve his ability to understand social cues. In light of STUDENT’s social/emotional and behavioral deficits, it is undisputed that he needs intensive adult attention, feedback, and reassurance.

Although the witnesses of both parties generally agree and testified consistently about the nature and extent of STUDENT’s social/emotional and behavioral deficits, their opinions and testimony diverge regarding what type of educational environment STUDENT requires to meet those deficits. The District, focusing on STUDENT’s difficulties with peer relations, contends that STUDENT requires placement at El Camino’s large school campus so that he would have opportunities to improve his social skills. It is the District’s position that STUDENT has the cognitive ability to function at a large comprehensive high school campus. In support of the District’s position, school psychologist Terri Veasman testified that she recommends a larger school environment for STUDENT because he is cognitively strong but has weak peer-relations skills. Ms. Veasman stated that at El Camino STUDENT could improve his social skills in a setting with many opportunities for peer relations. Similarly, special education teacher Margaruite Newman testified that STUDENT requires a more “normalized” setting with more students for him to learn social skills.(Footntoe 12)

The Respondent, on the other hand, focuses on his anxiety and behavioral difficulties as the basis for his assertion that he requires a small, structured educational environment. Specifically, Respondent contends that STUDENT requires a small, supportive environment like the one he has at Bridges where he will not be overwhelmed by his environment and where he can progress academically. In support of Respondent’s contention, Dr. Kaler recommends that STUDENT be placed in a small, protected environment where the teachers are flexible with dealing with atypical behaviors and who do not mind being constantly interrupted. According to Dr. Kaler, because of STUDENT’s difficulty with anxiety and with integrating and assigning meaning to what he sees, STUDENT’s environment must have minimal visual clutter and must be manipulated so as to reduce stressors. As discussed above, when STUDENT’s environment is familiar, controlled, and uncluttered, he is better able to pick up and sort information from his surroundings. Ms. Minkowski agreed with Dr. Kaler’s recommendation for a small, protected environment for STUDENT. At hearing, Ms. Minkowski testified that STUDENT would be “emotionally lost” in a large environment and his behaviors would interfere with his ability to function there. Hence, Ms. Minkowski also testified that STUDENT needs a small, nurturing environment where his frustrations and anxiety are reduced.

The Hearing Officer finds the testimony and recommendations of Dr. Kaler and Ms. Minkowski more persuasive than the testimony of Ms. Newman and Ms. Veasman regarding what type of educational environment STUDENT requires. First, Ms. Newman’s and Ms. Veasman’s recommendation for the large high school environment to improve his social skills disregards STUDENT’s significant difficulties with anxiety, transitions, and attention. Rather, in making their recommendation, they appear to assume that STUDENT’s high intellect would enable him to compensate for any anxiety and behavioral difficulties that he would experience in the larger educational environment. However, there is no significant evidence or support that STUDENT’s cognitive ability would enable him to overcome or control his emotional and behavioral problems. While no one disputes that STUDENT requires improvement of his social skills, those difficulties do not significantly impact his ability to function academically, as do his anxiety and related emotional and behavioral problems. Hence, STUDENT’s emotional and behavioral difficulties must be considered in determining his educational placement.

Additionally, Ms. Newman and Ms. Veasman made their recommendation for placement at El Camino with only limited current and first-hand knowledge of how he performs in the classroom with other students. Ms. Newman observed STUDENT at Bridges in the spring of 2002 for only approximately one hour. Ms. Veasman’s only observation of STUDENT in the classroom with other students was in 2001. In comparison, Ms. Minkowski was STUDENT’s teacher for an entire school year and she continues to closely monitor his progress as an administrator at Bridges. Thus, she has worked with STUDENT directly for an extensive period of time and has a better understanding than Ms. Veasman and Ms. Newman of how he actually functions at school. Because the Hearing Officer finds Dr. Kaler and Ms. Minkowski more persuasive, she also found that STUDENT’s needs require that he be placed in a small, protective school environment with teachers accepting of his need to talk aloud to process information and with minimal visual clutter so that he is better able to accord meaning to what he sees.

Lastly, the parties disagree whether STUDENT has sensory processing deficits that require him to receive occupational therapy services to benefit from his education. In support of Respondent’s position that he has significant sensory issues that must be addressed in his educational program, MOTHER testified that STUDENT does not wear pants because he does not like the feel of the pants on his legs and he is particular about the food that he eats. MOTHER also testified that STUDENT is sensitive to heat and he will not wear certain clothes that he thinks will make him feel hot. Ms. Minkowski agrees that STUDENT does not like the heat and added that STUDENT is also aversive to being wet. Even assuming that STUDENT has the sensory issues related to heat and wetness that MOTHER and Ms. Minkowski testified about, there is no evidence that those issues interfere with his ability to function at school or that he needs OT services at school for him to benefit from his education. On the contrary, Ruth Adatto, STUDENT’s OT therapist during the 2000-2001 school year and the therapist who assessed him in 2002, testified that STUDENT previously received OT services to address his fine motor needs and issues pertaining to his self-regulation, but he made “wonderful gains” and does not need continued occupational therapy in the school environment. Furthermore, Ms. Addatto testified that she had not noticed during any time that she worked with STUDENT that he had any issues with temperature regulation, texture, or food. In light of Ms. Adatto’s professional recommendation as an OT therapist that STUDENT does not require continued OT services, and the lack of any information as to how his tactile and sensory issues adversely impact his education, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT no longer requires OT therapy to benefit from his education.

In summary, STUDENT has deficits in the areas of fine motor functioning, written language, and social/emotional behavior. STUDENT has difficulty with handwriting and with organizing and integrating thoughts to compose paragraphs. Hence, he requires individualized attention to walk him through the composition process and to reduce his anxiety related to writing. STUDENT’s main difficulties are in the area of social/emotional and behavioral functioning. STUDENT becomes easily distracted, has difficulty with transitions and novel situations, has difficulty understanding social cues and nuances, is disruptive in class, talks aloud to process information, and tends to be easily frustrated. He also experiences periods of tearful frustration called “melt-downs” a few times a week. Thus, to reduce his anxiety and to enable him to progress academically, he requires a small, structured educational environment where he can talk aloud to process information and that has minimal visual clutter. He also needs continued therapy and behavior support to teach him methods to reduce his anxiety and to improve his ability to understand social cues. Additionally, he requires prompting and redirection to stay on task, and adult support, encouragement, feedback, and guidance to reduce his anxiety. Although Respondent contends that he has sensory issues that require him to receive occupational therapy, the evidence does not support this contention.

II. Whether the District’s Offer is Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Needs

To address STUDENT’s needs, the District offered to change STUDENT’s placement from Bridges to a general education placement with resource specialist support at his home public school, El Camino High School. Additionally, the District offered STUDENT one class period per day of adapted physical education services, one hour per week of counseling services, one hour per month of mental health services, accommodations for written language and behavior, assistive technology in the form of a laptop computer and software to address STUDENT’s issues with written language and motor functioning, a behavior support plan, extra time during physical education to dress, a one-to-one aide for four to six hours per day, and compensatory occupational therapy services to make up for therapy not provided under his prior IEP. Pursuant to the District’s June 2002 letter to the PARENTS, it also offered to place STUDENT in an English class at El Camino during the 2002 ESY to work on his written language goals.

As discussed above, the parties’ dispute centers on whether the District’s offer of placement at El Camino is appropriate to meet Respondent’s needs. The Respondent also challenges the District’s goals and objectives and lack of a transition plan. Because a determination regarding the appropriateness of the District’s offer of placement would affect the determination of the appropriateness of other parts of the District’s program (such as whether the District offered Respondent an appropriate transition plan from Bridges to El Camino), the Hearing Officer turns first to whether the offer of El Camino was designed to meet Respondent’s needs.

A. Placement at El Camino

El Camino is a comprehensive high school of 3500 students that is located on a large campus. At El Camino, STUDENT would be placed in all regular education classes with a student to teacher ratio of up to 39 to 1. The classrooms at El Camino are housed in multiple buildings separated by distances of up to a couple hundred yards. STUDENT would also have the assistance of a one-to-one aide to keep him on task and to assist him with social skills, the support of a behavior support plan, and access to the RSP hub for emotional or academic support. In comparison, STUDENT’s current school, Bridges Academy, is housed in one building of approximately 5000 square feet. There are 81 students at Bridges and the classrooms are no more than approximately 50 feet apart. When Ms. Newman observed STUDENT at Bridges, she noted that he attended class with approximately two to three other students.

As noted above, to reduce his anxiety and to enable him to progress academically, STUDENT needs to be educated in a small, protective environment that is accepting of his need to talk aloud and that has minimal visual clutter. The Hearing Officer finds that El Camino’s size and student population cannot be considered to be a small, protective environment. Rather, the sheer expansiveness of El Camino and the size of its student body indicate that it is an environment filled with activity and visual stimuli. Such an environment would, according to Dr. Kaler and Ms. Minkowski, overwhelm STUDENT and cause him great anxiety and frustration, which would result in his shutting down emotionally and would inhibit his ability to function academically. The Hearing Officer finds it striking that even small changes to a very familiar and controlled environment like Bridges, as Ms. Minkowski described, has caused STUDENT enormous and prolonged distress. By all accounts, although he has matured and made progress towards controlling his anxiety, he currently does not have sufficient coping strategies to deal with limited changes even in his familiar environment and routine.

The District claims that it offered STUDENT services that would address his social/emotional and behavioral difficulties and that would support his attendance at El Camino. To explain, the District offered STUDENT the assistance of a one-to-one aide to help with his social skills and anxiety control, an RSP hub where he could go to decompress from stresses in his classrooms, and a behavior support plan. Regarding the aide, the evidence establishes that STUDENT does benefit from individualized attention and instruction and that he needs this individualized attention to assist him in part with his social skills and behavior. However, the evidence does not support the District’s contention that the assistance of the aide would enable STUDENT to tolerate attendance at El Camino. By all accounts, STUDENT receives a great amount of individualized attention at Bridges Academy. STUDENT attends each of his classes with only approximately two or three other students. Despite the individualized attention that he receives at Bridges, STUDENT continues to have behavioral difficulties and “melt downs” that impact his ability to progress at school. Hence, there is no significant evidence how the one-to-one aide would enable to STUDENT to attend school in a considerably larger campus with many more students and more visual clutter in his environment. While the aide may assist STUDENT to navigate around El Camino and to keep organized, there is no significant evidence to explain how the aide would assist STUDENT to filter the increased amount of visual stimuli he would encounter at El Camino or to meaningfully reduce the anxiety he would experience from the unpredictability of the larger school environment.(footnote 13)

Moreover, the RSP hub that the District offered is intended to provide STUDENT a place to go if he becomes overwhelmed in his regular education classes or if he requires additional academic support. The RSP hub does not provide STUDENT proactive support to learn to deal with his behaviors before they become an issue. Additionally, to benefit from the RSP hub, STUDENT would need to remove himself from his regular education classes where his classmates are receiving instruction. Finally, the behavior support plan developed by the District does not meaningfully address STUDENT’s meltdowns or anxiety. Instead, the behavior support plan solely targets STUDENT’s verbal outbursts, picking scabs, and biting fingernails. To address these target behaviors, the plan calls for his teacher to redirect him when he picks at his scabs or bites his fingernails, and it calls for STUDENT to use appropriate language to express his needs, wait patiently for teacher assistance, and use appropriate words to express frustration or displeasure. Except for providing STUDENT the option of taking small-group breaks from class, the plan is devoid of any strategy to deal with STUDENT’s stress. Therefore, the RSP hub and the behavior support plan would not significantly address STUDENT’s behavioral and academic needs and are insufficient to enable STUDENT to attend and progress at El Camino.

In summary, the District’s offer of placement at El Camino is not the small, protective environment that STUDENT requires. Even with the supports the District proposes, El Camino is not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs or reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. While STUDENT may someday be ready to attend El Camino, it is not appropriate to so dramatically change his placement from a small private school to such a large campus and busy environment, without more graduated steps and additional behavioral supports.

B. Plan to Transition from Bridges to El Camino

Because it is found above that El Camino is not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs, it is not necessary to determine whether the District offered an appropriate plan to transition STUDENT from Bridges to El Camino. However, assuming that El Camino was appropriate for STUDENT, the evidence establishes that the District failed to offer STUDENT a transition plan to meet STUDENT’s needs.

The District asserts that it offered Respondent (as stated in its June 2002 letter to the PARENTS) the opportunity to transition to El Camino during the 2002 extended school year, when he could familiarize himself with the campus layout and schedule. According to the District, the 2002 ESY would have provided STUDENT with an appropriate transition from Bridges to El Camino. The Respondent argues that the District’s offer fails to address his behavioral needs related to handling transitions and novel situations because it lacks a plan to transition him from Bridges to El Camino.

The evidence supports Respondent’s contention. First, STUDENT could not have transitioned during the 2002 ESY because, as determined above, the District’s offered placement could not have been implemented prior to the fall of 2002 since the parties’ mediation agreement governed STUDENT’s placement and services at Bridges through the end of the 2002 ESY. Second, assuming out of an abundance of caution that the offer could have been implemented in May 2002 as the District asserts, the May 2002 IEP lacks any reference to how STUDENT would transition from Bridges to El Camino. Third, although the District claims its June 2002 letter offered STUDENT 2002 extended school year services at El Camino, that offer was never discussed at any IEP meeting by STUDENT’s IEP team. Accordingly, the District’s June 2002 letter administratively amended the May IEP offer rather than clarified an offer that was made as part of the IEP process. Regardless, the June 2002 offer of ESY services at El Camino also did not elaborate on how STUDENT would be transitioned if he attended the ESY services at El Camino. Thus, because an offer of ESY services is not the same as an offer of transitional services, the District’s June 2002 letter cannot be determined to be a written offer of transitional services.

Finally, even if the June 2002 offer of ESY services at El Camino can be determined to be a written offer of transitional services, that offer would not have been appropriate to meet STUDENT’s needs. As described above, Ms. Minkowski testified as to the nature and extent of STUDENT’s anxiety surrounding transitions and novel situations. She described that during the fall of 2002, STUDENT experienced paralyzing anxiety and exhibited melt-downs when he was enrolled in a history class with a teacher that he was not familiar with, even though his class was at Bridges where he had attended school for three years. According to Ms. Minkowski, STUDENT’s difficulties were compounded by the fact that the history class required him to do extensive writing, which also causes him significant stress. The District’s proposed transition plan involves placing him at a new school with an unfamiliar teacher in an English class where he would be working on written language. While the District also offered STUDENT the assistance of an individual aide to assist him at school, that aide would not have been known to STUDENT if he had started school during the 2002 ESY. Thus, although STUDENT becomes anxious when faced with novel situations, the District proposed a transition at El Camino where everything would be new to him. Additionally, although written language tasks are known to cause STUDENT significant anxiety, the District proposed to place STUDENT in an English class where his written language goals would be worked on. Because the District’s transition plan involves a combination of situations and factors that are known to cause STUDENT’s anxiety, STUDENT is likely going to be overwhelmed by the very placement that is meant to be his transition.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds the determination above that El Camino was not designed to meet STUDENT’s social/emotional needs renders this issue regarding the existence of an appropriate transition from Bridges to El Camino moot. Regardless, even if a transition were needed, the District failed to offer STUDENT in writing a plan to assist with his transition from Bridges to El Camino. Even if, by some stretch of the imagination, the District’s June 2002 offer of ESY services can be determined to be a written offer of services, that placement would not have been appropriate to assist STUDENT with his transition to El Camino.

C. Projected Achievement Dates for Goals and Objectives

The Respondent contends also that the goals and objectives proposed by the District cannot be realized in the timeframes specified in the IEP. Specifically, Respondent does not dispute the substantive content of the goals and objectives, but contends that the dates by which the goals and objectives should be accomplished are inconsistent and incomprehensible. The District acknowledges that some of the dates of the goals and objectives are inconsistent, but contends that the inappropriate dates are typos and can be easily corrected on the IEP.

California Education Code section 56345(a)(2) and Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations section 300.347(a)(2) require that IEPs include annual goals and objectives. Annual goals are “statements that describe what a child with a disability can reasonably be expected to accomplish within a twelve month period in the child’s special education program. Short-term instructional objectives (i.e., IEP objectives) are measurable, intermediate steps between the child’s present levels of educational performance and the annual goals that are established for the child.” 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, App. C, Q. 39 (1996). The objectives should be developed based on a logical breakdown of the major components of the annual goals and should be projected to be accomplished over an extended period of time, such as a school quarter or semester. Id. IEP objectives are necessary in order to provide general benchmarks for measuring the student’s progress toward meeting the annual goals and otherwise gauging the efficacy of the services provided. Id.; see also Cleveland Heights-University Heights City Sch. Dist. v. Boss, 44 F.3d 391, 399 (6th Cir. 1998) (holding that omission of appropriate objective criteria in IEP was significant violation that “went to the heart of the substance of the plan”).

In the May 2002 IEP, the District proposed nine annual goals, each broken down into two incremental objectives. The nine annual goals address STUDENT’s gross motor, vocational, social/emotional, counseling, occupational therapy, and written language needs. The face of the IEP indicates that its term is to commence on May 7, 2002, and to end on May 7, 2003. According to District witnesses, annual goals covering a twelve-month period are typically broken down into two incremental objectives that are projected to be accomplished four months apart. Thus, in this case, STUDENT’s annual goals are to commence on May 7, 2002, the first incremental objectives are to be achieved in September 2002, the second incremental objectives are to be achieved in January 2003, and the annual goals are expected to be met by May 7, 2003.

As described above, the record is filled with inconsistencies regarding the intended implementation date of the May 2002 IEP. Additionally, the Hearing Officer found above that the May 2002 IEP could not have been implemented earlier than the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year. Even though District members of the IEP team assured MOTHER at the May IEP meeting that the IEP would not be implemented until the fall of 2002, the implementation date for all but one of the annual goals was May 2002. Although the one gross motor goal did have an appropriate September 2002 implementation date, that goal also lists a termination date of July 2003, two months after the expiration of the IEP. Similarly, one of the two vocational education goals includes a second incremental objective achievement date of July 2003, a date also falling two months after the expiration of the IEP. The second vocational education goal does not include projected achievement dates for either of the two incremental objectives. Thus, there is no benchmark date for that annual goal for which Respondent can gauge the efficacy of the IEP services.

The same type of problem can also be found with the counseling goals. The first counseling goal states that the first incremental objective is to be accomplished by “0/02.” Additionally, the projected achievement date for the second incremental objective of the second counseling goal is September 2003, which is a date four months after the expiration of the IEP. In summary, five of the nine annual goals and objectives set forth projected commencement or achievement dates that were either illogical or outside of the term period of the IEP. Although minor discrepancies regarding projected achievement dates for IEP goal and objectives may be harmless errors that are easily corrected, more than half of the District’s offered goals and objectives contained errors. Hence, the number and nature of the discrepancies in this case render the goals and objectives unmeasureable and meaningless. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s May 2002 offer did not include appropriate goals and objectives.

D. Occupational Therapy Services

Respondent contends that he has sensory processing deficits which require him to receive occupational therapy services beyond the compensatory education OT services provided for in the May 2002 IEP. As was discussed above, the evidence does not establish that Respondent has a need for OT services to benefit from his education. Therefore, the District’s offer cannot be inappropriate because it does not include such services.

****

In conclusion, the District’s offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs or reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit and, therefore, was not an offer of FAPE. Specifically, STUDENT’s social and behavioral deficits related to his nonverbal learning disability render the District’s offer of placement at El Camino inappropriate. Additionally, the District’s offer ignored STUDENT’s significant difficulty with transitions and novel situations when it failed to include a transition plan to transition him from Bridges to El Camino. Moreover, the District’s goals and objectives were unmeasureable and the projected dates to accomplish the goals and objectives were incomprehensible.

ORDER

The District’s request for a determination that its May 7, 2002 offer was appropriate is denied.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: Respondent STUDENT prevailed on the issue decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: May 30, 2003 ___________________________________ Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. This Amended Decision reflects a typographical correction to Respondent’s name as it appears on page 2. 2. issue here differs in wording and number from that noticed by the Petitioner before hearing. The issue was restated to reflect the issue clarification by the parties on the first day of hearing. 3. he May 7, 2003 IEP meeting, the District determined that STUDENT was no longer eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability, but acknowledged that he continues to be eligible as a student with an other health impairment. As discussed below, MOTHER did not consent to that IEP and it is now the subject of this due process hearing. 4. Sandra Kaler testified that a nonverbal learning disorder is a disorder where a person has difficulty integrating material and simultaneously processing information. Persons with NLD tend to use language as a compensatory strategy wherein they attempt to talk through their thinking process. 5. Hearing Officer notes that the letter actually states that the District was offering summer school services for the “2002-2003 school year” (i.e., the 2003 ESY). Hence, the District’s offer of services for the 2002-2003 extended school year appears to reach beyond the expiration of the IEP on May 7, 2003. To explain the discrepancy, Ms. Sewell testified that the District was in fact offering ESY services for the summer of 2002 and not the summer of 2003, and that the timeframe referenced in the letter was a result of a clerical error. 6. Hearing Officer makes no judgment about whether the District’s making an offer of placement and services through the IEP process after already resolving issues regarding the same time period through mediation was appropriate. 7. While the District’s position at hearing was that the effective start date for the IEP was May 7, 2002, the record in this case is clearly riddled with inconsistencies that show the District’s confusion regarding the term of its offer. For example, the IEP goals and objectives contain some goals that begin in May 2002 and one goal that begins in September 2002. Additionally, although the District’s June letter indicates that the District’s offer was for the 2002-2003 school year, it also clarified that the offer included extended school year services for the 2002 ESY, which would occur prior to the start of the 2002-2003 school year. And to add to the confusion, if in fact the offer was to be implemented in May 2002, STUDENT would have been placed in the ninth grade for the remainder of the 2001-2002 school year, although he was in the eighth grade at the time. 8. Furthermore, any disagreement pertaining to the May 2002 IEP regarding the time period from May 7, 2002, through the end of August 2002 was resolved by the parties through the mediation agreement and is outside the jurisdiction of the Hearing Office. 9. In California, local educational agencies must obtain written parental consent for all or part of an IEP before a child is “required to participate in all or part of any special education program.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(a). In situations where a parent refuses consent for all or part of a program, such as in this case, California law requires local educational agencies to take steps to ensure that the child receives a free appropriate public education. Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(b). If the local educational agency determines that the portions of the program to which the parent did not consent, or all of the program, if the parent did not consent to any part of the IEP, is necessary to provide the child with a free appropriate public education, the local educational agency is required to initiate due process hearing procedures to override the parent’s refusal of consent. Id. This is what the District did in this case. 10. The parties do not dispute that Respondent qualifies for special education and related services as a student who is “other health impaired” and is entitled to receive educational services to address his unique and individual needs. The Respondent contends that he is also eligible under the category of “specific learning disability,” that he was determined in the past to have a specific learning disability, and that the District inappropriately dropped “specific learning disability” as an eligibility category during the May 7, 2003 IEP meeting. The Hearing Officer notes that the District’s decision to remove “specific learning disability” as an eligibility category for Respondent, who is otherwise eligible under another category, in and of itself does not result in a substantive denial of FAPE. The Code of Federal Regulations at Title 34 Section 300.300 states that “services and placement needed by each child with a disability to receive FAPE must be based on the child’s unique needs and not on the child’s disability.” Therefore, once a child is found eligible for special education and related services, the child’s needs must be addressed regardless of the eligibility category. Here, the parties disagree whether STUDENT qualifies for special education under a particular eligibility category and not whether STUDENT is in fact eligible for special education. Although the parties do not agree whether STUDENT’s deficits in written language are a result of a specific learning disability or his other diagnoses, they do not dispute the nature and severity of his deficits in written language. Moreover, Respondent has not alleged that the District has inappropriately determined his present levels of performance or failed to specifically address his written language deficits. Thus, the Respondent raised a technical challenge to the IEP that has no substantive effect on the appropriateness of the IEP. 11. Ms. Minkowski estimated that during his eighth grade year, STUDENT had about two meltdowns per week, each lasting from five minutes to a half hour. 12. Although the District’s other witnesses testified that they agreed with the recommendation for placement at El Camino, none testified specifically regarding what educational environment STUDENT requires in light of his needs. 13. As noted above, the District also offered STUDENT one hour per week each of counseling services and one hour per month of mental health services. There was also no significant evidence presented regarding whether the nature or intensity of these services was modified or increased to address his ability to tolerate the larger El Camino school environment.