California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 5, 2002

Ventura Unified School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 1892-01 · Hearing Officer Michael F. Geary

Ventura Unified may move a 16-year-old from Devereaux to a Ventura group home and public school ED class.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

Ventura Unified School District filed for due process after the parents refused consent to a change of placement. The student, almost 17, was eligible for special education because of an emotional disturbance. His stay-put placement was the Devereaux Foundation's residential campus in Santa Barbara. The February 1, 2002 IEP offered a Chapter 26.5 group home placement in Ventura (the Living and Learning Center). It also offered four periods a day in Craig Williams's special day class for emotionally disturbed students at Buena High School, mental health services through Ventura County Behavioral Health, a vocational program, and a behavior support plan. The mother represented her son. The Hearing Officer repeatedly denied her requests to delay the hearing until a lawyer would be free five months later.

Relying mainly on independent evaluator Dr. Fred Norris, the Hearing Officer found the student needed several things. These included a residential setting with similar peers, intensive mental health services including family therapy, classmates at his academic level, a path toward a diploma or GED, vocational training, more normal relationships, and a psychiatric evaluation. The District's offer met those needs and was less restrictive than Devereaux. Devereaux did not meet his needs: most of his classmates had developmental delays, he earned no graduation credits, and his vocational training was minimal. The District was ordered to implement the IEP and arrange a psychiatric evaluation. It also had to hold an IEP meeting if no group home bed opened by June 30, 2002. The parents were ordered to cooperate.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO applied Rowley and least restrictive environment principles to residential placements. A group home combined with a special day class on a public campus was found less restrictive than a residential treatment center. A parent's wish to keep the student farther from home did not justify the more restrictive setting.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue 1. Is the District's offer of placement and a program contained in its February 1, 2002 IEP an offer of FAPE to Student in the least restrictive environment through the end of January 2003?

    The offer of a Chapter 26.5 group home in Ventura, an ED special day class at Buena High School, county mental health services and a vocational program met the student's unique needs, provided educational benefit, and was the least restrictive environment for the one-year IEP term.

  2. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2. Does Student's current placement at Devereaux provide him with a FAPE in the least restrictive environment?

    Devereaux was not designed to meet the student's needs, because his peers were mostly developmentally delayed, he earned no graduation credits and had little vocational training; it was also more restrictive than the District's offer.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order that district's offer may be implemented. District shall promptly implement the February 1, 2002 IEP and immediately take all necessary steps to arrange placement at the Living and Learning Center (LLC) group home in Ventura. Once the student is admitted to LLC (no later than June 30, 2002), the District shall arrange attendance in Mr. Williams's ED special day class at Buena High School, the vocational programs, consistent behavior support plans at home and school, mental health services through VCBH, and the District transition specialist's coordination of rehabilitation and vocational services.
  • Order to assess. District shall work with Ventura County Behavioral Health to arrange a thorough psychiatric evaluation of the student.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. If LLC space is not available by June 30, 2002, District shall immediately convene an IEP meeting to offer an alternative placement consistent with the Hearing Officer's findings on the student's unique needs.
  • Conclusion states the District remains obligated to fund the stay-put Devereaux placement until LLC space is available. If parents keep the student at Devereaux after space opens, they do so at their own expense.
  • Parents ordered to cooperate in implementing the IEP: complete admission and enrollment forms for LLC, the special day class, the vocational programs and VCBH services, including the psychiatric evaluation; fairly consider VCBH psychotherapy recommendations; and reasonably participate in family therapy and parent education.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Hendrick Hudson Central School Dist. v. Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education; Valerie J. v. Derry Cooperative School Dist.

People named in the decision

  • Sheri Schoenwald, school psychologist and program specialist, Ventura Unified School District
  • Amy Balchum, supervisor of school-based programs, LCSW, Ventura County Department of Behavioral Health
  • Craig Williams, ED special day class teacher, Buena High School, Ventura Unified School District
  • Fred Norris, Ph.D., licensed clinical psychologist; independent triennial evaluator, Independent
  • Michael Namm, counselor/therapist, witness for Student, Devereaux Foundation, Santa Barbara
  • Donna Barranco, administrator, Devereaux Foundation, Santa Barbara
  • Chad (Chris) Wright, student's teacher, Devereaux Foundation, Santa Barbara
  • Eugene Coleman, house parent, Del Sol dormitory, Devereaux Foundation, Santa Barbara
  • Gina Phelps, case manager, Devereaux Foundation, Santa Barbara
  • Cheryl Fox, school-based mental health liaison, LCSW, Ventura County Department of Behavioral Health
  • Paula Montgomery, former case worker, Ventura County Department of Behavioral Health
  • Dr. Zachary, psychotherapist, Morningsky residential treatment facility
  • Devereaux Foundation (Santa Barbara), residential treatment center; stay-put placement
  • Living and Learning Center (LLC), licensed residential group home offered by District/VCBH
  • Morningsky, residential treatment facility (prior placement)
  • Anacapa Hospital, prior treatment provider

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Ventura, California, on February 26 and 27, 2002.

Petitioner Ventura Unified School District (District) was represented by Donald F. Austin, general counsel for the District. Sheri Schoenwald, school psychologist and program specialist for the District, was also present. Respondent STUDENT was represented at the hearing by his mother, PARENT. During some of the hearing, STUDENT’s paternal grandfather, Mr. GRANDPARENT, was also present.

The District called the following witnesses: Amy Balchum, a supervisor of school-based programs for Ventura County Department of Behavioral Health (VCBH); Craig Williams, the teacher of the special day class for emotionally disturbed students (ED-SDC) at Buena High School; Sheri Schoenwald; and Fred Norris, Ph.D., a licensed clinical psychologist who conducted a triennial evaluation of STUDENT in November 2001.

The student called the following witnesses: Michael Namm, a counselor employed at the Devereaux Foundation facility in Santa Barbara (Devereaux), STUDENT’s current stay-put placement; FAMILY FRIEND, a friend of STUDENT and his family who is also a special education teacher for the emotionally disturbed classes at Devereaux; and STUDENT’s mother, PARENT.

Oral and documentary evidence was received at the hearing. The parties gave oral closing arguments, the record was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision on February 27, 2002.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

On February 8, 2002, Respondent’s mother requested a continuance of the due process hearing. Her request indicated that Respondent’s attorney was unable to handle the case until the latter part of June and that he would need about one month after that to prepare. Ms. PARENT asked that the matter be continued to dates between late July and mid-August. That motion was denied by minute order issued on February 20, 2002. The minute order stated that the unavailability of an attorney for five months or more was not good cause for a continuance.

At the commencement of the hearing, the Respondent’s mother renewed her motion to continue, relying upon the same ground: that the only attorney who said that he would be willing to help her son was not available for hearing until late July to mid-August. The motion was denied again by the presiding Hearing Officer. Ms. PARENT made the same request repeatedly throughout the two-day hearing. The request was denied each time.

At various times throughout the hearing, witnesses were called to testify out of order by stipulation. Testimony was taken from FAMILY FRIEND by telephone, also by stipulation.

ISSUES

1. Is the District’s offer of placement and a program contained in its February 1, 2002 IEP an offer of a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) to STUDENT in the least restrictive environment through the end of January, 2003?(Footnote 1)

2. Does STUDENT’s current placement at Devereaux provide him with a FAPE in the least restrictive environment?

CONTENTIONS

As to Issue 1:

The Petitioner contends that its offer to STUDENT of placement, program and services contained in the February 1, 2002 IEP was an offer of FAPE in the least restrictive environment. Pursuant to the IEP, STUDENT was to have the following: an out-of-home placement pursuant to Chapter 26.5, Division 7, Title 1 of the California Government Code (Chapter 26.5) at a group home in Ventura; four periods daily in Craig Williams’ ED-SDC at Buena High School (Buena) in Ventura; mental health services from VCBH pursuant to Chapter 26.5; a regular school year vocational program consisting of two periods daily of employment experience at the local mall through the Transition Partnership Program (TPP); an extended school year (ESY) vocational program providing employment experience at the Ventura Holiday Inn, also through TPP; a behavior support plan; and continued services through the California Department of Rehabilitation (CDR).(Footnote 2) Petitioner seeks an order allowing that IEP to be implemented.

The Respondent contends that the District’s offer will not provide a FAPE to him because it will not meet his unique needs for consistency in his therapeutic relationship with his counselor, supervision for his safety and the safety of others, and one-on-one attention to his academic and mental health services.

As to Issue 2:

The Petitioner contends that STUDENT’s current placement at Devereaux is not in the least restrictive environment in that the facility is located in Santa Barbara and is, in its clientele and program offered to STUDENT, more restrictive than the placement offered by the District.

The Respondent contends that Devereaux is the least restrictive placement in which he can receive a FAPE.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a boy of sixteen years and ten months who has a history of problems with depression, anger and aggression. Since February 2000, he has been eligible for and receiving special education solely on the basis of an emotional disturbance (ED). According to assessors, that disturbance is evidenced by inappropriate behaviors or feelings under normal circumstances and a pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.

STUDENT has had difficulties with learning since infancy. He was evaluated at three years and ten months for problems with attention and auditory processing and found eligible for special education. There were concerns about hyperactivity in kindergarten. He went from kindergarten to a transitional first grade. STUDENT was assessed during that year. Intellectual functioning was in the borderline range. Performance testing showed delays of up to two years eight months. It was concluded that there was not a significant discrepancy between ability and performance that would qualify STUDENT for services under the category of specific learning disability. It was also determined by the assessor that emotional factors interfered with his performance.

Several times over the next six years STUDENT was found ineligible for special education. During STUDENT’s sixth grade year, a District psychologist noted concerns about ADHD, lack of motivation, anger defiance, and verbal and physical aggression. She decided against retaining STUDENT in the sixth grade and, instead, recommended as options a 504 plan, monitoring his medications, a shortened school day, or participation in a class for children having difficulties in school for various reasons. At the time, STUDENT was under the care of a psychiatrist and taking medication for depression and aggression.

STUDENT was found eligible for special education and other services (speech and language) under the category of specific learning disability (SLD) in 1998. In October 1998, his program consisted of four academic subject periods in an SDC for communicatively handicapped students, twenty minutes of speech and language twice per week, assistive technology services to help with keyboarding skills, and two regular education periods, including physical education (PE). In April 1999, the program was changed to two academic periods of SDC, an RSP English period, fifteen minutes per day working with a one-on-one aide on keyboarding skills, and three regular education periods, including math with a tutor, PE and a home arts elective.

The parents’ concerns about STUDENT’s social and emotional problems continued. There was significant conflict in the home. In January 1999, the District offered a referral to VCBH. Dissatisfied with the District’s response to their concerns, the parents obtained their own psychoeducational and neuropsychological evaluations. Later that month, they filed a request for a due process hearing seeking, among other relief, reimbursement for the independent evaluations and a determination that the District had failed to provide STUDENT with appropriate programs to address his needs, including his social and emotional needs, during the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years.

On January 12, 2000, a Hearing Officer found that the District’s program for the 1998-1999 and the 1999-2000 school years did not provide a FAPE to STUDENT. Among other things, the Hearing Officer also found that the District had failed to properly assess STUDENT for social and emotional problems.

According to the history reported by Dr. Norris, confirmed in many respects by the testimony of Ms. PARENT, STUDENT continued to have significant emotional problems, particularly with defiance, anger, aggression and violence in the home. Dr. Norris reports that STUDENT’s parents called the police at least ten times to request assistance dealing with STUDENT’s behavior during December 1999 and January 2000. His behaviors included theft, burying things in their backyard, hiding knives in his room, threats of suicide, and putting holes in the walls with knives and hammers. This culminated in an incident on January 28, 2000, when STUDENT threatened his adoptive father with a knife. Ms. PARENT testified that the incident was quickly defused, but she would not let the police leave until they did something to help her with her son. Because it was believed that STUDENT, at age fourteen, posed a threat to himself and others, he was admitted to Anacapa Hospital for psychiatric evaluation and treatment.

STUDENT remained in the hospital for almost three months. According to a February 22, 2000 letter from a program director at Anacapa Hospital addressed “To Whom It May Concern,” STUDENT struggled with chronic learning disabilities, depression, ADHD, and limited ability to express feelings, empathize with others, and accept responsibility for his own behavior. There were self-reports of hearing voices and other indications of psychosis. He had responded well to the structured hospital setting and constant supervision, and had been stabilized with medications, Haldol and Vistaril. It was recommended that STUDENT not return home, but be placed in a residential treatment facility.

STUDENT’s eligibility classification was changed from SLD to ED on the March 10, 2000 IEP. SLD was noted only parenthetically. STUDENT was still hospitalized at the time, so no specific offer of placement was made. Pre-academic, academic, organizational, social and communication goals were recommended and agreed upon. An out-of-home placement pursuant to Chapter 26.5 was recommended. VCBH was pursuing residential placement options, including group homes. STUDENT was discharged from the hospital to Morningsky, a residential treatment facility in Mountain Center, California, approximately 200 miles from Ventura.

At an IEP meeting on September 21, 2000, STUDENT’s parents stated that they wanted him closer to home. Visits and participation in family therapy sessions were difficult for the PARENTs. The parents had already determined that they wanted STUDENT to be transferred to Devereaux. The facility was less than an hour drive from their home, and they had already arranged for an interview. Amy Balchum was present at that IEP meeting for VCBH. She believed at the time that STUDENT would be better served by a less restrictive environment. Ms. Balchum, Dr. Zachary, STUDENT’s psychotherapist at Morningsky, and the District representatives agreed that STUDENT’s needs would be best met by a placement in a local group home in Ventura. As a Medi-Cal recipient, he would then qualify for additional therapeutic behavioral services through VCBH. They believed that STUDENT needed to be back on a regular school campus. The school psychologist was concerned that he might be exposed to more inappropriate behaviors at Devereaux or a similar facility. The parents were adamant about Devereaux, so the other members of the team reluctantly agreed to a “six-month trial” at Devereaux. The IEP provided that if, after six months that placement was deemed inappropriate, the parents would reconsider.

The District has been concerned about STUDENT’s placement at Devereaux from the beginning. In the December 8, 2000 IEP documents, District and VCBH members expressed various concerns, among them the lack of medication, the absence of speech and language therapy called for by the previous IEP addendum, the lack of individual and family therapy, and the academic placement and program that did not move STUDENT in the direction of graduation with a diploma.

Some of the similar concerns were expressed at the June12, 2001 IEP meeting, which some of the Devereaux staff attended by telephone. The District members were concerned that STUDENT was not taking appropriate academic classes that would earn him credits toward graduation. The parents also wanted STUDENT to get a diploma. It was confirmed that in his then-current program, STUDENT was not on a diploma track. He was attending classes geared toward students with far less ability, most of whom were developmentally delayed. Devereaux members explained that STUDENT was comfortable where he was and did not want to be moved to the higher functioning classes that could earn him credits toward graduation.

There were also some concerns about vocational training. The IEP document stated that STUDENT, who had been bussing tables at an off-campus dormitory at the local university, was then working for only one to three hours per week at a tire shop. The District’s psychologist was concerned about progress toward STUDENT’s return to Ventura for public school attendance and family reunification.(Footnote 3) He still was not under the regular care of a psychiatrist and was taking no medications. Many of his problem behaviors continued, including threats and physical incidents. There was also a discussion at this IEP meeting of the upcoming triennial review and the District’s desire to conduct an assessment.

On May 23, 2001, the District gave STUDENT’s parents formal written notice of its intent to request a change of placement for STUDENT and requested that the parents allow an independent evaluation.(Footnote 4) That independent evaluation was conducted by Dr. Fred Norris in November 2001.

Dr. Norris’s evaluation took place over three days. In addition to a parent interview and a review of STUDENT’s file, Dr. Norris interviewed Devereaux administrator Donna Barranco, Chad Wright, STUDENT’s teacher, Eugene Coleman, the house parent at the Del Sol dormitory where STUDENT lived, and Gina Phelps, STUDENT’s case manager. He did an interview and behavioral observation of STUDENT and administered a battery of tests consisting of the following: Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children - III (WISC III), Bender Visual-Motor Gestalt Test (BVMT), Sentence Completion Test, Human Figure Drawing, Kinetic Family Drawing, Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory-A (MMPI), Personal Problems Checklist, Reynolds Depression Scale, Rorschach, Test of Variables of Attention (TOVA), Ishihara Color Blind Test, Burk’s Behavior Rating Scale, Wide-Range Achievement Test-Revised (WRAT-R), Peabody Individual Achievement Test-Revised (PIAT-R), and a creative writing sample.

As a result of this assessment, Dr. Norris concluded that STUDENT continued to be eligible for special education due to an emotional disturbance, as evidenced by his inappropriate behaviors or feelings under normal circumstances and his pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. He stated that while STUDENT continues to require out-of-home placement, Devereaux was not the least restrictive placement for him. The doctor recommended a placement that would provide STUDENT with intensive mental health services, academic remediation, and vocational training and experience. The placement should be with other children with emotional problems, and not with those who are developmentally disabled or who are juvenile delinquents. Dr. Norris recommended a complete psychiatric evaluation, including an assessment of STUDENT’s need to take medication in an effort to control his many emotional and behavioral problems. He also expressed a significant concern about STUDENT’s suicidal ideation and recommended that staff be alerted to this risk.

The most recent IEP meeting was held on February 1, 2002. Dr. Norris’s report was presented and considered. The District and VCBH recommended a change of placement from Devereaux to a group home in Ventura, with daily attendance for four periods at an ED-SDC, two daily periods of vocational training and experience, integration for lunch at school, mental health services through VCBH and vocational services through the California Department of Rehabilitation. The parents expressed some concern about the accuracy of Dr. Norris’s report, but, according to the IEP document, they declined to discuss those in greater detail. They definitely did not agree with the change of placement and remained firmly committed to Devereaux as the only appropriate placement for STUDENT. They requested further assessment by a neuropsychologist.

The District filed its request for due process on August 24, 2001. While there is no indication in the request regarding the issue or issues to be addressed, testimony at the hearing indicated that the purpose was to address the District’s right to conduct a triennial assessment of STUDENT. That issue was resolved by the parents’ agreement to the assessment by Dr. Norris. However, the case was not withdrawn. It was taken off the hearing calendar by stipulation. On February 6, 2002, after the parents refused to consent to the change of placement, the matter was placed back on the hearing calendar at the request of the District.

ANALYSIS

1. Is the District’s Offer of Placement and a Program Contained in its February 1, 2002 IEP an Offer of a Free, Appropriate Public Education (FAPE) to STUDENT in the Least Restrictive Environment?

The federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law require that students with disabilities be offered a FAPE in the least restrictive environment . 20 U.S.C. Sections 1400 (d) and 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code Sections 56000 and 56031. A “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. Section 1401(8).

The United States Supreme Court addressed the procedural and substantive requirements of the IDEA in Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et .al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176. The Court held that “a "free appropriate public education" consists of educational instruction specially designed to meet the unique needs of the disabled child, supported by such services as are necessary to permit the child "to benefit" from the instruction.” Id. at 188-189. The IDEA does not require that the states “maximize the potential of each handicapped child commensurate with the opportunity provided non-handicapped children.” What is required is that the student be provided with access to a FAPE which is “sufficient to confer some educational benefit upon the handicapped child.” Id. at 200-201.

"Special education" is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. Section 1401(25). "Related services" includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. Section 1401(22). California Education Code Section 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." Included in the list of possible related services are language-speech development and remediation, physical and occupational therapy and specially designed vocational education and career development. 20 U.S.C. Section 1401(22); California Education Code Section 56363(b).

As stated above, the United States Supreme Court determined in Rowley that school districts are required to provide only a "basic floor of opportunity" that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Rowley, supra, at 207-208. To comply with the IDEA as interpreted by the court in Rowley, the program offered to STUDENT by the District must meet the following three requirements: (1) It must have been designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs; (2) It must have been designed to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit; and (3) It must have conformed to STUDENT's IEP. If the program offered by the District meets the above three requirements, the Hearing Officer must determine that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE, even if the parents preferred another placement and even if the parents' preferred placement could have resulted in greater educational benefit to STUDENT. Gregory K. v. Longview School District (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307, 1314.

Is the Offered Placement and Program Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?

What Were STUDENT’s Unique Needs?

The parties agreed regarding some of STUDENT’s needs. They agreed that STUDENT requires some kind of out-of-home placement that will not expose him to negative influences from peers and will provide adequate supervision to guard against harm to himself and others. They agreed regarding his need for an educational component commensurate with his cognitive and academic levels. They agreed that STUDENT required intensive mental health services to address anger management and other social and emotional needs. Finally, they agreed that STUDENT needed to participate in a vocational program that would prepare him for future employment. There was some disagreement, however, regarding other needs.

The evidence showed that the District and the parents believed that STUDENT needed to be on a diploma track. Sheri Schowenwald, the District’s psychologist, agreed, as did Dr. Norris. It was only after it became clear to the parents that STUDENT would not be earning credits toward graduation at Devereaux that they decided that a diploma was not necessary. The Hearing Officer viewed that change of heart as merely a concession by the PARENTs to keep STUDENT at Devereaux and not as a reliable indication that they believed STUDENT did not need to be able to at least work toward a diploma.

Doctor Norris stated that STUDENT needed to be in a residential treatment center or group home living situation where other residents of the facility have similar needs, rather than developmental disabilities. He believed that STUDENT needed a complete psychiatric evaluation to consider, among other things, psychotropic interventions (medications) to assist with the management of his emotional and behavioral problems. The doctor believed that STUDENT needed to be in an academic placement that puts him in a class with other students who function at a cognitive and academic level comparable to his own, and that offered STUDENT the opportunity to earn credits toward graduation.(Footnote 5)

Amy Balchum, who has been involved with STUDENT in her capacity as a mental health supervisor for VCBH, essentially agrees with Dr. Norris’s opinions about STUDENT’s needs. According to VCBH goals and objectives, STUDENT’s program has also included family therapy sessions as a necessary component. Ms. Balchum testified that, in her opinion, STUDENT needs to live and attend school in an environment that will offer him the opportunity for more normalized relationships and behavior.

Mr. Namm testified that STUDENT has a hard time making a connection with people and that, for this reason, he needs a lot of consistency, particularly in his therapeutic relationships. He said that STUDENT has developed relationships with the staff at Devereaux, including him, and that it would not be good for STUDENT to interrupt those relationships. He also believes that STUDENT should not be closer to his family home because he will attempt to escape to there when things are not going as he would like at his residence. Mr. Namm agrees that a thorough medical assessment to look at the possible use of antidepressants would be appropriate.(Footnote 6)

While Ms. PARENT agreed that STUDENT needs intensive mental health services, she believes that it would be detrimental to him to interrupt the therapeutic relationship that he has established with his current therapist, Michael Namm. She does not believe that STUDENT needs medication. Ms. PARENT recognizes that her son is difficult to control and testified that no one has ever been able to control him. While she tried on him various medications in the past, she never saw any results, so she took him off all of them eventually, usually against medical advice. Ms. PARENT does not believe that STUDENT needs to be closer to home or in a public school. She explained that she did not want STUDENT to be released from the hospital. She agreed to allow his discharge from the hospital to Morningsky only under duress. She stated that did not want him to be as far away from her as he was at Morningsky, but she did not want him to be close enough to her that there was a risk that he would simply walk out of his residential placement and come home. She thinks STUDENT needs to be far enough away from the family home to discourage escape to that destination. Finally, Ms. PARENT believes that STUDENT needs a significant but unspecified amount of one-on-one academic attention.

The Hearing Officer found the opinions expressed by Dr. Norris to be impartial, well-reasoned, and based upon a sound foundation of data collected from various sources. Based principally upon his testimony, but also upon the testimony of Amy Balchum and Ms. PARENT, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s unique needs are as follows: (1) He needs to be in a residential placement with similarly challenged children and with adequate supervision to protect against the risk of self-harm or harm to others, including his family; (2) he needs intensive mental health services, including family therapy; (3) he needs to be in an academic setting that contains children of similar cognitive and academic levels and that will provide him with both academic remediation and behavior control through a properly devised and implemented class-wide system or individual plan; (4) he needs to be given the opportunity, encouragement and assistance toward a goal of graduation or a GED; (5) he needs an intensive vocational program to prepare him for employment;(6) he needs to be in an environment or environments which will provide greater opportunities for normalized relationships and behaviors; and (7) he needs to be evaluated by a psychiatrist for possible management of his emotional and behavioral problems with medication.(Footnote 7)

Is the District’s Program Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Needs?

The District’s offer of placement contained in the February 1, 2002 IEP contains several elements, including STUDENT’s present levels of functioning, annual goals and interim short-term objectives, and a description of the program and services to be provided. Those elements that are disputed by the parties will be examined to determine whether the offered placement was appropriate.

There are few significant disputes regarding STUDENT’s present levels of functioning. His cognitive development and intellectual functioning described in the IEP are essentially those measured and documented by Dr. Norris in his report. WISC-III scores indicated that he functioned cognitively in the borderline to low average range, with a full scale I.Q. of 77 and relative strengths in abstract reasoning and puzzle assembly. Academic functioning was measured by the WRAT-R and the PIAT-R at the fourth- to sixth-grade level. This was consistent with testing done by Devereaux, with the exception of letter-word identification, which was measured at fourth-grade level. Devereaux staff reported that STUDENT was reading and doing pre-algebra at the eighth-grade level. These reported levels were used for setting goals and objectives.

There were no specific disputes concerning the goals and objectives identified by the parties. There were eight goals: There were four academic goals: one in mathematical calculations and word problems, one in reading and reading comprehension, one in spelling and vocabulary, and one in language arts and writing. There was one vocational goal requiring five to eight hours work per week at an integrated off-campus job site. There were two social and emotional goals identified with the educational environment: one requiring that STUDENT accept criticism of academic or behavioral performance and the other requiring that he perform assigned tasks without complaint. In addition, there were mental health goals established by VCBH. These required that STUDENT (1) participate in all services outlined in his IEP, (2) make progress toward a less restrictive placement by attending school daily, making academic progress (grade “C” or better), and appropriate behavior, and (3) participate in the formulation of a treatment plan, cooperate with recommendations of his doctor, and successfully participate in his residential program as measured by staff and therapist reports. There was also a fourth goal that was directed more to STUDENT’s family. It stated that the family was to provide regular health and dental care, participate in family therapy, and continue to learn new ways to encourage STUDENT toward positive behavior. The Hearing Officer finds that these goals were reasonably calculated to address STUDENT’s needs. The real focus of the dispute is the placement. The one offered by the District has several distinct elements: the educational component, the VCBH component, and the residential component.(Footnote 8) Each will be examined.

The educational component of the program includes placement in Craig William’s ED-SDC for four periods per day, integration for lunch/nutrition for fifty-five minutes per day, and participation in a vocational program, Transition Partnership Program, for two periods per day.(Footnonte 9)

Craig Williams is the teacher of the ED-SDC at Buena in Ventura. He testified about his class. Mr. Williams has a master’s degree in pupil personnel services and a severely handicapped credential. He has been teaching ED-SDCs for over sixteen years, the last eleven at Buena. According to his testimony, close to ninety percent of the ED students he has taught during his career have carried the diagnosis of depression and greater than fifty percent of them have been diagnosed with oppositional defiant disorder (ODD).

The class currently has seven students assigned, but one of them had not been to class in months and one was mainstreamed daily for three periods. The room is approximately nine hundred square feet. There are rows of desks, computers, a television and a VCR.(Footnote 10) The class is staffed by three adults. In addition to Mr. Williams, there is an aide in the class for an hour in the morning and another who takes over for five and one-half hours after the first aide leaves . The third adult is Cheryl Fox, the VCBH mental health liaison whose office adjoins the classroom. Excluding Ms. Fox, the staff-to-student ratio is one-to-four or better.

The core academic curriculum covers all areas required for graduation: mathematics, English, physical and life sciences, and modified physical education. Mr. Williams explained that there is a high turnover, but all students who have remained with him have eventually graduated. STUDENT would have the opportunity to graduate if he does the work.

Mr. Williams has worked with all academic performance levels from second through twelfth grades. The current students are doing reading and mathematics from the fifth-grade to the eighth-grade level. Most are in the sixth- to seventh-grade level. One is working on algebra. On the basis of STUDENT’s performance levels he should be able to perform in the middle to upper range in the class. All students work at their own pace. One-on-one remedial assistance is available. The written class description explains that each student works at his or her own pace, receiving credit based on the quantity and quality of work done. There is usually no homework assigned, but the students are required to do missed work, usually in the classroom while other students may be enjoying some social reward. STUDENT should be able to work at his own pace, with assistance, resulting in less risk of the frustration that led to so many of his behavioral problems in the classroom setting.

In addition to the academic portion of the class, there is a clearly structured behavior management system that is based on a system of social rewards. Mr. Williams explained that students earn “reinforcement time” for adherence to classroom rules and expectations. Each fifty-five-minute work period is broken into forty-five-minutes of work time and ten minutes of reinforcement time that the student earns by appropriate behavior. The students, who are monitored every fifteen minutes, can also accumulate points for appropriate behavior that allow them to move up through five levels of performance and reward. According to Mr. Williams and the documents that described the behavior management system, the overall goal is to gradually increase the student’s privileges and freedom as a reward for the student’s demonstration of increased ability to exercise good judgement and self-control.

Counseling services provided by VCBH are an integral part of the ED-SDC. These were described by Mr. Williams and by Amy Balchum, a mental health supervisor for VCBH and currently the supervisor of school-based programs. She holds a master’s degree in social work and is a licensed clinical social worker (LCSW). She has been with VCBH for fifteen years, as a case manager, school liaison, and a supervisor providing administrative and clinical supervision. Ms. Balchum has significant experience working with school districts in connection with the funding and monitoring services provided to students under Chapter 26.5. She has dealt with a variety of placements available under the law. She supervised Paula Montgomery, STUDENT’s former case worker, and attended four of STUDENT’s IEP meetings as a representative of VCBH. Ms. Balchum also has knowledge concerning the other counseling services also available to STUDENT as a Medi-Cal recipient.

Both Mr. Williams and Ms. Balchum testified that Ms. Fox, also an LCSW, is the school-based clinician assigned to the ED-SDC at Buena. She meets with the students twice per week in group sessions and once per week in individual therapy as needed. Ms. Fox also works with the students and their families in their homes. She will monitor and facilitate the therapeutic relationships and communications between and among the ED-SDC teacher, a prescribing psychiatrist, the parents, group home staff, and other VCBH staff relating to the student’s mental health. She will also administer and monitor medication with proper consent.

In addition to the services that would be available to STUDENT directly through his attendance at the ED-SDC, Ms. Balchum explained that STUDENT and his family would be entitled to non-educationally-related mental health services through VCBH, if STUDENT resided within the County. As stated in the notes to the February 1, 2002 IEP meeting, these are not IEP services but are available to Medi-Cal recipients residing within the County of Ventura. Such services could include referral to and the coordination of services from a psychiatrist.

The IEP provides vocational training and work experience. According to the evidence, STUDENT should be eligible to participate in that program for eight to ten hours per week during the regular school year, and for a greater percentage of his time during the summer. The District has a transition specialist who will help STUDENT with transition, including the coordination of vocational services available to him through LLC and CDR.

The out-of-home placement recommended by the District in the February 1, 2002 IEP was one to be determined by VCBH. Ms. Balchum testified that the only group home in Ventura used by VCBH was the Living and Learning Center (LLC). No one from LLC testified at the hearing. The LLC was described in documentary evidence as a licensed residential group home for emotionally or behaviorally disturbed adolescent males, aged twelve to eighteen years. In addition to room and board, the facility would deliver a minimum of one hour per week of individual psychotherapy and one hour per week of group psychotherapy. Educational tutoring and vocational training would also be given as required. Family therapy and parent training would be available “as clinically indicated.” Medication evaluation and management also would be provided. Ms. Balchum described the director as an experienced clinical psychologist.

LLC was described in the documents as a twenty-four-hour structured environment based on the behavioral model. According to Ms. Balchum and the documents, the facility uses a behavioral management system that allows residents to accumulate points on an hourly basis, including the time spent at school, based on reports from teachers and staff. The student’s demonstration of good judgement and appropriate behavior is rewarded by points earned and increasing levels of freedom and privilege.

Ms. Balchum also described the residents. At the time of hearing, there were six residents. Four boys who were placed pursuant to Chapter 26.5. One was placed as a court dependent. One was there by probation placement. Those residents carried various diagnoses, including ADHD, ODD, and bi-polar disorder. Some of the residents attended public school. Some were in day treatment. One was at an nonpublic school during the day.

LCC is not a locked placement. Behavior is controlled by the behavior plan. There are alarms that alert staff to unauthorized departures of residents. If a resident goes absent without leave (AWOL), the facility staff notify the director, the parents, the police and the case manager.

The Hearing Officer finds that the placement proposed by the District in the February 1, 2002 IEP meeting was appropriate for STUDENT and constituted an offer of a FAPE to him. The group home placement will provide STUDENT with an opportunity to live with and relate to boys more like him. It was also apparent from the evidence that STUDENT would receive intensive mental health services in the proposed placement through Ms. Fox at the ED-SDC, through the therapist at the group home, and otherwise through VCBH’s noneducational counseling services. STUDENT will be in the class with other students of comparable cognitive and academic abilities. He will be able to work at his own pace, with remediation in the classroom and with the further assistance, if necessary, of educational tutoring through the group home. Both the academic and the residential components of the proposed placement include behavioral plans that are reasonably well-designed to address STUDENT’s need to learn and adopt socially appropriate behaviors. The proposed school program will provide him with necessary vocational training and experience through TPP, in additional to the services available through LLC and CDR. Finally, a psychiatric assessment for evaluation of medications available to treat STUDENT can be provided through VCBH. If that assessor recommends that STUDENT take medication to help him with his social or emotional problems, those can be managed by the mental health liaison, Ms. Fox, at school and by the staff of the LLC, all subject to the parent’s consent.

Is the Offered Placement and Program Designed to Provide an Educational Benefit?

There is no dispute concerning whether the District’s offered program is designed to provide an educational benefit to STUDENT. He will have the opportunity to learn core academics, vocational skills and appropriate behavior and social skills in the real world environment in which he will probably be living as an adult. He will have the chance to graduate with a diploma. The placement and program is designed to provide an educational benefit to STUDENT.

Does the Offered Placement and Program Comport with STUDENT’s IEP?

The conformance of the actual placement and program to STUDENT’s February 1, 2002 IEP is not an issue. There was no suggestion in the evidence or arguments that the placement and program contemplated would not be as described. The District was able to show through its evidence that the residential placement at LLC and the educational component through Buena would comport with the IEP.

Having determined that the placement and program offered to STUDENT by the District met the three Rowley requirements, the Hearing Officer concludes that the offered placement and program was an offer of FAPE. It is now necessary to decide whether the offer is of a FAPE in the least restrictive environment.

Is the Offered FAPE in the Least Restrictive Environment?

The law provides that the placement and program offered to STUDENT must have been designed to provide him with a FAPE in the least restrictive environment. The IDEA at 20 U.S.C. §§ 1412(a)(5)(A) specifically provides: “To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.“ The requirement that disabled children be educated to the maximum extent appropriate with nondisabled children is often referred to as mainstreaming. The law demonstrates a strong preference for mainstreaming which rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption. Daniel R. v. State Board of Education, (5th Cir. 1989) 874 F.2d 1036, 1044-45.

In this case, the focus of the least restrictive environment analysis is not on whether STUDENT can receive a FAPE in a regular education class. The subject IEP does not call for such a placement. The focus is on the residential component. The restrictions on the student should be no greater than circumstances require. A residential treatment center (RTC) placement where the student lives and attends school at the same location or campus, like Devereaux, is more restrictive that a group home placement where the student attends school on a comprehensive public school campus.

In this case, the parties agree that STUDENT needs a out-of-home placement. They disagree on where that placement should be. The parents want STUDENT to stay at Devereaux in Santa Barbara, some thirty-five miles from their home in Ventura. Ms. PARENT frankly admits that she is afraid to have STUDENT so close that he could bolt from the group home and return to her home. The District and VCBH believe that STUDENT does not require placement at a residential treatment center like Devereaux, where the clients receive their educational and residential services in a single location. They believe that STUDENT’s needs can be met by living in the less restrictive group home and attending the ED-SDC with nondisabled peers on the comprehensive campus at Buena.

There is no doubt that Devereaux is a more restrictive environment than that offered by the District. The real question, however, is whether the offered placement is the least restrictive environment for the provision of a FAPE. The Hearing Officer finds that it is. While he is mindful of the parent’s concerns about the possibility that STUDENT will come home when he is not supposed to be there, there was no testimony from which the Hearing Officer could conclude that STUDENT needs greater restriction than that provided by the offered group home. Only Mr. Namm and Ms. PARENT said that STUDENT should not be closer to home than he is at Devereaux because he will go AWOL to get home. Realistically, if STUDENT wanted to run home from Santa Barbara, he could do it. While the greater proximity may make the prospect more inviting to him, there would be behavior plans in effect and interventions available at the District’s proposed placement to discourage that behavior; there would be protections available, including police response, if escape occurred; and there would be consequences to deter repeated escape attempts, including the possibility that a higher level of restrictive placement would be agreed upon or ordered.

The testimony showed that STUDENT can learn how to take responsibility for his actions. The professionals involved in the assessment and treatment of his social and behavioral needs agree that he has made and should be able to continue to make progress in this area. The Hearing Officer does not agree that he can only continue with that progress in an environment separated from his home and family by a distance too great to walk with relative ease. STUDENT will be an adult soon and will be able to decide where he lives. The evidence suggests that it is likely he will return to Ventura. The Hearing Officer is persuaded that the efforts to provide STUDENT with the skills he will need to become independent should occur in Ventura. The Hearing Officer finds that the placement and program offered by the District is the least restrictive environment in which STUDENT can receive a FAPE.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of placement and a program contained in its February 1, 2002, IEP was an offer of a FAPE in the least restrictive environment. This finding applies only for the one-year term of the February 1, 2002 IEP. However, the determination is also subject to the bi-annual reviews required by Cal. Govt. Code § 7572.5(c).

Issue 2: Does STUDENT’s Current Placement at Devereaux Provide him with a FAPE in the Least Restrictive Environment?

The District requested that the Hearing Officer address the question of whether STUDENT’s current placement at Devereaux is providing him with a FAPE in the least restrictive environment.

Is the Current Placement and Program Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?

It is unnecessary to repeat the analysis of STUDENT’s unique needs. It is necessary to determine whether the placement and program at Devereaux is designed to met those needs.

The evidence showed that STUDENT is currently placed on a Devereaux campus in Santa Barbara. The facility houses approximately one hundred residents, most of whom suffer from some developmental delay. According to most of the witnesses who have observed STUDENT in his class, he is probably one of the highest functioning students in the class. Mr. Namm described STUDENT as being at the high end physically and verbally and at about the seventy-fifth percentile developmentally. As early as November 5, 2000, a Devereaux assessment stated that STUDENT outperforms his classmates in many areas of achievement and is easily bored. There was discussion of moving STUDENT to a class closer to his academic level, but nothing came of that discussion.

It was not clear from the evidence what level of mental health services STUDENT is actually receiving at Devereaux. Mr. Namm, who has been his therapist almost since STUDENT arrived at Devereaux, originally saw him once per week individually and once per week in group session. In addition, he held family therapy sessions weekly. He testified that he sees STUDENT less often now, in part because STUDENT chooses to be “out of program.” Sometimes, the therapy session will consist of a talk while walking around the campus because of what Mr. Namm describes as STUDENT’s hyperactivity.

STUDENT is clearly not earning credits toward graduation. Mr. Namm confirmed this and testified that he does not believe that STUDENT is capable of earning a diploma. He said that STUDENT’s teacher at Devereaux doesn’t even think that he can earn a G.E.D.(Footnote 11) In Mr. Namm’s opinion, STUDENT is just not motivated to graduate.

According to Dr. Norris, STUDENT does not like being at Devereaux. He testified that STUDENT looks down on himself for being at that placement with so many developmentally delayed residents.

It was also unclear whether STUDENT was receiving any significant vocational training or experience. Some of the Devereaux documents indicate that he worked for a time bussing tables a few hours per week and more recently was working one to three hours per week in a tire shop. Dr. Norris stated that his interview with STUDENT’s case worker, Gina Phelps, revealed her understanding that there was no off-site job training. The most recent Progress Report dated February 1, 2002, states only that one of STUDENT’s goals is to participate in an integrated off-campus job site for five to eight hours per week. There was no evidence that this was being accomplished.

The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s current stay put placement at Devereaux is not designed to meet his needs. Having so found, it is unnecessary to determine whether the current placement offers STUDENT an educational benefit or comports with his IEP.

The issue as framed requires some discussion regarding whether the Devereaux placement is the least restrictive. The Hearing Officer finds that even if the Devereaux program and placement had been found to provide a FAPE to STUDENT, it would not have been provided in the least restrictive environment. As mentioned above, Devereaux is an RTC. It is, in essence, a restricted facility where the residents live, attend school, and engage in other community work and recreational activities on the same campus. While it is not a locked facility, the residents are not allowed to leave the campus without permission. According to Ms. PARENT, if someone goes AWOL, staff will go after and retrieve them. As explained earlier, that is more restrictive than the District’s proposed placement, which has been found to offer a FAPE.

CONCLUSION

The Hearing Officer has determined that the District offered a FAPE. Implementation of the February 1, 2002 IEP will be ordered. The testimony of Ms. Balchum and Ms. Schoenwald indicated that there would be space available for STUDENT by the end of the current school year in June 2002 and that STUDENT would be accepted, subject to parental consent. Until space is available for STUDENT at LLC, the District remains obligated to fund his current stay put placement at Devereaux. If space is not available for STUDENT at LLC by June 30, 2002, the District must immediately convene an IEP team meeting to find an alternative placement, taking guidance from the findings of the Hearing Officer in this Decision.

If STUDENT’s parents want their son to receive the benefits available to him under the IDEA and State special education law, they must cooperate with the implementation of the IEP and with the efforts to have STUDENT evaluated by a psychiatrist, as ordered by the Hearing Officer. If they choose to continue STUDENT’s placement at Devereaux after space becomes available for him at LLC, they do so at their own expense. If they fail to cooperate in other respects, they risk the loss of special education benefits and services for their son.

ORDER

1. The District shall promptly implement the February 1, 2002 IEP. In this regard, the District shall immediately a. take all necessary steps to arrange for STUDENT’s placement at LLC in Ventura; and b. work with VCBH to arrange for a thorough psychiatric evaluation of STUDENT.

2. Upon STUDENT’s admission to LLC no later than June 30, 2002, the District shall immediately arrange for a. STUDENT’s attendance at the ED-SDC taught by Mr. Williams at Buena; b. STUDENT’s participation in the vocational programs described in the February 1, 2002 IEP; c. the implementation of appropriately consistent behavior support plans in both the residential and educational environments; d. the delivery of required mental health services through VCBH; and e. the services of the District’s transition specialist to coordinate rehabilitation and vocational services to be delivered through the District and other participating agencies.

3. If space at LLC is not available for STUDENT by June 30, 2002, the District shall immediately convene an IEP meeting to offer an alternative placement consistent with the Hearing Officer’s findings regarding STUDENT’s unique needs.

4. STUDENT’s parents shall cooperate with the District to implement the February 1, 2002 IEP. Their cooperation shall include a. the prompt and proper completion of all forms necessary for STUDENT’s admission to LCC, his enrollment and participation in the ED-SDC and the vocational programs recommended in the February 1, 2002 IEP, and the continuing services to him through VCBH, including the psychiatric evaluation; and b. the fair consideration of and cooperation with the recommendations of VCBH regarding psychotherapy to address STUDENT’s social and emotional needs, including but not limited to their reasonable participation in family therapy and parent education.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

1. Is the District’s offer of placement and a program contained in its February 1, 2002 IEP an offer of a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) to STUDENT in the least restrictive environment?

The District prevailed on this issue.

2. Does STUDENT’s current placement at Devereaux provide him with a FAPE in the least restrictive environment?

The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code Section 56505(i).

Dated: April 5, 2002 Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES

1. Neither party indicated the period of time to be adjudicated at the hearing. The subject IEP has one-year goals. That will be the period of time adjudicated. The parties are reminded, however, that Cal. Govt. Code § 7572.5(c) requires full review of out-of-home placements at least every six months. 2. References to Chapter 2.5, which governs interagency responsibility for related services, shall include AB (Assembly Bill) 3632 and AB 2726. 3. This was a concern expressed by Sheri Schoenwald to Donna Barranco, administrator at Devereaux, in an April 27, 2001 letter. 4. By that time, the parents had already stated that they would not allow a District psychologist to assess STUDENT. 5. Dr. Norris stated that, in light of STUDENT’s cognitive levels and behavioral difficulties, it is unclear whether STUDENT will be actually able to graduate. 6. The parties did not ask the Hearing Officer to address the question of whether the student’s parents can be compelled to allow their child to be medicated. There is some authority suggesting that a district can not condition special education eligibility on parental consent to medication or other health service. Valerie J. v. Derry Cooperative School District (D.C N.H. 1991) 771 F. Supp. 483,490. The failure of parents to provide for the physical and emotional health of their child is more likely a matter within the jurisdiction of the juvenile courts. 7. The Hearing Officer considers that psychiatric evaluation to be one of the appropriate services pursuant to the original referral to VCBH. 8. There is also a California Department of Rehabilitation component, but the evidence indicated that it was being pursued by STUDENT, through his parents, and that the availability of that service was not dependent on a particular placement. 9. The IEP also provides for participation in a summer Holiday Inn vocational program through TPP. 10. The Positive Behavior Support Plan that is part of the February 1, 2002 IEP also states that a study cubicle can be provided for STUDENT to reduce distractions. 11. A November 15, 2001 Progress Report from STUDENT’s teacher, Chris Wright, stated that he was working to prepare for the G.E.D. According to Dr. Norris’s testimony concerning his interviews with Devereaux staff, Mr. Wrigh was STUDENT’s third teacher in six months and had only an emergency teaching credential, not a special education credential.