California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 16, 2002

Student v. San Luis Coastal Unified School District (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 1908-02, SN02-01908, SN02-02241 · Hearing Officer Joy Redmon

San Luis Coastal Unified loses its bid for a medical assessment, but the student with chemical sensitivity is found not eligible.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 3 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

San Luis Coastal Unified School District filed for due process. The family of a 15-year-old high school sophomore then filed its own case, and the two cases were combined. The student has a diagnosed multiple chemical sensitivity. He had never been found eligible for special education and had missed most of ninth grade. The District wanted an unconditional medical assessment and his past medical records so it could plan changes to his regular classes or write a Section 504 plan. It also asked for a ruling that he was not eligible as other health impaired. His mother asked for three independent medical evaluations at District expense.

The Hearing Officer found the District's 2001 assessment valid. The IEP team had reviewed and accepted reports from two doctors who knew the condition. For that reason, special education law gave the District no right to another assessment or to the records, and any request tied to a 504 plan belonged with the Office of Civil Rights. The student was not eligible. His test scores were average to superior, and he was passing all his classes. His ninth-grade absence was his own choice and was not shown to be medically necessary. Also, the changes his doctors recommended, such as fragrance-free rooms and hard floors, could be made in the regular program. The independent evaluations were denied because the mother did not disagree with any District assessment. Nothing was ordered.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled a health condition that did not hurt the student's grades. A diagnosis alone did not make him eligible as other health impaired. Changes that a regular program could make were treated as 504 matters. Parent-provided medical reports could count as a valid assessment. A publicly funded evaluation required disagreement with a District assessment.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue I. s the District entitled to an unconditional medical assessment of Student by a qualified California physician and a release of Student's prior medical records?

    The District's 2001 assessment was valid because the IEP team considered and accepted reports from physicians knowledgeable about the condition, so the District had no right under the IDEA or state law to another medical assessment or to the records; any request tied to a 504 plan belongs with the Office of Civil Rights.

  2. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue II. Is Student currently eligible for special education as other health impaired?

    Student was not eligible: his condition did not adversely affect his educational performance (average to superior scores, passing all classes, ninth-grade absence self-determined and not shown to be medically necessary), and any needed changes could be made in the regular program.

  3. Issue III. Is Student entitled to independent medical assessments at District expense by Dr. Heuser, neurotoxicologist; Dr. Meggs, toxicologist; and Dr. Gutierez, neuropsychologist?

    Publicly funded independent assessments are available only when a parent disagrees with a District assessment; the mother did not object to any prior District assessment, so the request was denied.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • The District's request for an unconditional medical assessment and access to medical records was denied; Student was found not eligible; Student's request for three independent medical assessments at public expense was denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Cal. Educ. Code § 56026; Cal. Educ. Code § 56320; Cal. Educ. Code § 56329; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(f); 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(8); 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A); Walpole Pub. Schs., 26 IDELR 976 (SEA Mass. 1997); Baltimore County (MD) Public School, 18 IDELR 1041 (OCR 1991); Hunt v. St. Peter School, 26 IDELR 6 (W.D. Mo. 1997)

People named in the decision

  • Linda Somers Smith, attorney for District, San Luis Coastal Unified School District
  • Mary Jo DeSio, director of the special education local plan area, SELPA
  • Ed Valentine, assistant superintendent for educational services, San Luis Coastal Unified School District
  • Katherine Thomas Anderson, director of student services, San Luis Coastal Unified School District
  • Anne Davies, program specialist, San Luis Coastal Unified School District
  • Joseph Holifield, school psychologist (administered WISC-III), San Luis Coastal Unified School District
  • Brad Parker, director of facilities, San Luis Coastal Unified School District
  • Sue White, school psychologist, San Luis Coastal Unified School District
  • Karen Lopez, high school teacher and part-time dean of students, San Luis Obispo High School
  • Kirt Collins, elementary school principal, San Luis Coastal Unified School District
  • Steve Anderson, middle school principal, San Luis Coastal Unified School District
  • Judith Gier, school nurse (reviewed medical reports), San Luis Coastal Unified School District
  • Will Jones, high school principal, San Luis Coastal Unified School District
  • Greg Bettencourt, high school counselor, San Luis Coastal Unified School District
  • Vinetta Negranti, middle school teacher, San Luis Coastal Unified School District
  • Meredith Boyd, home instructor (administered reading assessments), San Luis Coastal Unified School District
  • Elena O'Reilly, special education teacher (administered WJ-R), San Luis Coastal Unified School District
  • Dr. Meggs, toxicologist; diagnosing physician; requested IEE provider, East Carolina University School of Medicine
  • Dr. Allan Lieberman, occupational and environmental medicine physician; diagnosing physician, Center for occupational and environmental medicine, Charleston, South Carolina
  • Dr. Heuser, neurotoxicologist; prior treating physician; requested IEE provider, Agoura Hills, California
  • Dr. Gutierez, neuropsychologist; requested IEE provider, Santa Barbara, California
  • Dr. Anderson, physician who wrote a report recommending modifications

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Joy Redmon, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific. The matter proceeded to hearing in Los Osos, California, on October 30 and 31, and November 1, 2002.

Petitioner/Cross-Respondent San Luis Coastal Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Linda Somers Smith. Also present on the District’s behalf at various times throughout the hearing were Mary Jo DeSio, director of the special education local plan area; Ed Valentine, assistant superintendent for educational services; and Katherine Thomas Anderson, director of student services. Respondent/Cross-Petitioner STUDENT (STUDENT or Student) was represented at most times throughout the hearing by either his mother, MOTHER, or his adult brother, BROTHER.

The District called the following witnesses: Anne Davies, program specialist; Joseph Holifield, school psychologist; Brad Parker, director of facilities; Sue White, school psychologist; Karen Lopez, high school teacher and dean; and Katherine Thomas Anderson, director of student services.

STUDENT called the following witnesses: MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother; Kirt Collins, elementary school principal; Steve Anderson, middle school principal; Judith Gier, school nurse; Will Jones, high school principal; Greg Bettencourt, high school counselor; BROTHER, STUDENT’s brother; Vinetta Negranti, middle school teacher; Ed Valentine, assistant superintendent for educational services; Meredith Boyd, teacher; and STUDENT.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The parties submitted written closing briefs. Thereafter, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

I Is the District entitled to an unconditional medical assessment of STUDENT by a qualified California physician and a release of STUDENT’s prior medical records?

II Is STUDENT currently eligible for special education as other health impaired?

III Is STUDENT entitled to independent medical assessments at District expense by Dr. Heuser, neurotoxicologist in Agora Hills; Dr. Meggs, toxicologist in South Carolina; and Dr. Gutierez, neuropsychologist in Santa Barbara?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The District does not dispute STUDENT’s diagnosed medical condition of multiple chemical sensitivity (MCS). Despite STUDENT’s medical condition, the District contends that STUDENT is not a child with a disability requiring special education and related services as defined by the IDEA and corresponding California law because he does not require instruction, services or both, which cannot be provided with modifications to the regular school program. Further, the District contends that STUDENT is not eligible for special education as other health impaired because STUDENT’s diagnosed medical condition does not adversely affect his educational performance. According to the District, despite STUDENT’s periods of absence, he continues to perform at or above grade level academically. Therefore, the District contends STUDENT is not eligible for special education as other health impaired. However, even though the District asserts STUDENT is not eligible for special education, in light of STUDENT’s medical condition, it seeks the right to an independent medical assessment and access to STUDENT’s previous medical records, not for the purpose of determining eligibility, but for guidance in providing appropriate modifications to STUDENT’s regular school program or to create a §504 plan.(Footnote 2)

MOTHER did not take a clear position regarding STUDENT’s current eligibility for special education under IDEA. She explained that in her opinion STUDENT is not currently disabled but expressed concern that if he continues to be exposed to chemicals at school, he will become sick again and even possibly permanently disabled. MOTHER argued vigorously that regardless of the eligibility determination, the District should not be given the right to an unconditional medical assessment of STUDENT. If an assessment is ordered, MOTHER argued that the doctor must have experience diagnosing children with MCS and must prove he or she has never testified for the chemical industry, building product industry, or insurance companies. Additionally, MOTHER requested that Dr. Heuser, a neurotoxicologist that has treated STUDENT in the past, or his representative be allowed to observe the District’s medical testing if it is ordered. Additionally, MOTHER argued that the District’s physician should be ordered to execute a declaration accepting liability for any injury STUDENT may suffer during the assessment and an agreement to take STUDENT as a patient after the assessment is complete. Finally, MOTHER requests medical assessments be conducted by three doctors who have seen STUDENT in the past in order to combat the findings of the District’s medical assessment.

FACTUAL BACKGROUND

STUDENT is a fifteen-year-old student who has never been found eligible for special education. STUDENT is currently a sophomore at San Luis Obispo High School. STUDENT was assessed for eligibility for special education services in 1995 and again in 2001. It was determined by both IEP teams that STUDENT was not eligible as a student with a specific learning disability, speech and language impairment, emotional disturbance, or an other health impairment.

STUDENT enrolled in the District in September of 1994 and attended Los Ranchos School during elementary school. MOTHER informed the District that while attending kindergarten in Florida, STUDENT was repeatedly exposed to a pesticide called Dursban.(Footnote 3) MOTHER explained that the exposure to Dursban caused STUDENT to be extremely sensitive to chemicals.(Footnote 4)

STUDENT has been seen periodically by physicians from North Carolina, South Carolina, and California since he was five years old. MOTHER provided medical reports to STUDENT’s IEP team in 2001 that were prepared by Dr. Meggs and Dr. Lieberman. Dr. Meggs diagnosed STUDENT in 2000 with chemical sensitivity. Dr. Allan Lieberman, a consultant in occupational and environmental medicine, diagnosed STUDENT in 2001 as having chemical sensitivity, intermittent chronic fatigue, and classical IgE mediated atopic allergy.(Footnote 5) MOTHER explained that these conditions collectively are called multiple chemical sensitivity (MCS). Dr. Lieberman’s letter indicates that STUDENT requires “as chemically clean an environment as possible.”

All parties described the relationship between the District and MOTHER as contentious during the last eight years. The parties have not reached an agreement regarding a written §504 accommodation plan for STUDENT. District employees testified that despite the lack of a formal plan, the District has provided informal accommodations to STUDENT, such as requesting that his teachers and classmates refrain from wearing fragrances, attempting to place STUDENT in classrooms without carpet, placing STUDENT on a “health watch” list asking his teachers annually to pay close attention to STUDENT’s health, and providing a home instructor when STUDENT is out of school without requiring medical documentation substantiating the reason for or duration of his absence.

STUDENT and MOTHER testified that these informal accommodations have not been implemented consistently and STUDENT has become ill on several occasions requiring his absence from school. According to the PARENTS, when STUDENT is exposed to common chemicals (e.g. fragrances, paints, diesel and car fumes, most pesticides, most fertilizers, some new building products, and some cleaning chemicals), STUDENT can have breathing problems and flu-like symptoms. STUDENT explained that the time it takes to recover from an exposure is not predictable. Sometimes STUDENT feels better immediately after the stimulus is removed, other times it takes longer for the lethargy to abate. Both STUDENT and MOTHER testified that STUDENT alone determines when and if he is well enough to attend school. MOTHER testified that STUDENT does not have a local treating physician and does not take medication for his illness.(Footnote 6) MOTHER explained that the treatment for STUDENT’s illness is chemical avoidance. STUDENT and MOTHER testified that STUDENT is not sick when he is at home, which they described as their “safe house.” The house has high ceilings, a clean ventilation system, hard surface floors, and non-toxic chemicals.

STUDENT attended Laguna Middle School during the seventh and eighth grades. During the first semester of seventh grade, STUDENT performed well academically and completed the semester with a 3.33 grade point average. MOTHER testified that STUDENT became ill toward the end of the semester and decided not to return to school after the winter break. STUDENT remained out of school for most of the remainder of seventh grade. The District offered a home instructor; however, Dr. Thomas-Anderson testified that MOTHER refused the home instructor at that time. As a result of STUDENT’s absence, and lack of current medical documentation substantiating the absence, STUDENT was referred to the School Attendance Review Board (SARB). The result of the proceeding was that STUDENT was to return to Laguna Middle School, which he did.

STUDENT attended school during the eighth grade with sporadic periods of absence until approximately February. STUDENT again determined he was not able to attend school and remained home for a significant portion of the spring semester of eighth grade. The District provided a home instructor, Meridith Boyd, until STUDENT returned at the end of the year to graduate. The District did not receive any medical documentation regarding the absence. The District initiated a referral for a special education assessment to determine STUDENT’s eligibility for special education as a student with a specific learning disability, speech and language impairment, emotional disturbance, or an other health impairment. MOTHER provided copies of medical reports to the District to consider as part of the IEP process. An IEP meeting was held in June of 2001 to determine STUDENT’s eligibility for special education. The IEP team determined STUDENT was not eligible for special education under the IDEA. However, the District requested an independent medical assessment and access to STUDENT’s medical records and diagnosing physicians in order to determine exactly what accommodations STUDENT may require while at school to formalize a §504 plan. The parties could not reach agreement regarding the wording of the medical release.

Although enrolled, STUDENT did not attend ninth grade at San Luis High School. STUDENT testified that he felt fatigued and decided not to attend school. STUDENT was not treated by a physician for his fatigue during the ninth grade. STUDENT testified that he was bored at home, missed his friends, and wanted to return to school.

STUDENT returned to high school this current school year as a sophomore. Karen Lopez, teacher and part-time dean of students, testified that at the time of the hearing STUDENT was passing all classes. She testified that his lowest, but still passing grade, was in Spanish. She also explained that she observed STUDENT socializing with his friends at school, including eating lunch on the grass. BROTHER, STUDENT’s older brother testified that STUDENT attends the movies approximately twice per month. STUDENT also attended the homecoming dance in October. STUDENT testified that he knew several people would be wearing perfume, scented deodorant, and other chemical-based products but he still wanted to attend. STUDENT testified that the fog machine at the dance made him feel ill; however, he was able to tolerate it and did not miss any school after the incident. STUDENT also testified that this school year he feels much less fatigue and ill than last year.

Despite the foregoing, there has been ongoing contention between the District and MOTHER. The issue of accommodations pursuant to a §504 plan remains unresolved to date. Dr. Thomas-Anderson explained that the District believed it was necessary to file for this due process hearing in order to obtain a determination regarding eligibility for special education and to obtain the right to an unrestricted medical assessment in order to have additional information regarding modifications STUDENT may need to his regular school program. MOTHER also filed for due process requesting three medical assessments at public expense. MOTHER explained that currently STUDENT is not ill; however, she is concerned that if STUDENT remains at school he may become permanently disabled.

DISCUSSION

I Is the District entitled to an unconditional medical assessment of STUDENT by a qualified California physician and a release of STUDENT’s prior medical records?

The District does not dispute STUDENT’s diagnosed medical condition. Further, the District asserts that as part of the IEP process in June of 2001, it adequately assessed STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability, including other health impaired, prior to determining that STUDENT was not eligible for special education. As part of the IEP process, the IEP team considered the independent medical reports prepared by Dr. Meggs and Dr. Lieberman that MOTHER provided to the District. However, the District now seeks the right to an unconditional medical assessment of STUDENT and a release of his complete medical records not to determine eligibility, but for guidance in providing appropriate modifications to the regular school program or to develop a §504 plan. The District did not specifically contend that it sought additional assessments to develop an appropriate IEP if the Hearing Officer finds STUDENT eligible for special education. However, out of an abundance of caution, the Hearing Officer will first determine whether or not the District had adequate medical information about STUDENT’s medical condition in order to render a determination regarding eligibility for special education.

Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations §3021 states that all referrals for special education and related services shall initiate the assessment process. In this case, the District initiated the referral process in 2001, when STUDENT returned to school as the result of a SARB proceeding. The District completed its assessment of STUDENT and held an IEP meeting in June of 2001. California Education Code §56320 sets forth the requirements for a valid assessment and mandates that the pupil be assessed in all areas of suspected disability including health and development where appropriate. Additionally, Education Code §56320(g) requires that the assessment of a pupil be conducted by persons knowledgeable about that disability; in this case MCS. In addition to the requirements for a valid assessment, California Education Code § 56329(b) mandates that an IEP team consider the results of an independent assessment that a parent procures at private expense and provides to the IEP team.

The District did not conduct its own medical assessment of STUDENT. Rather, the District relied upon the medical reports submitted by MOTHER, which were reviewed by Judith Gier, the school nurse. The medical reports reviewed by Ms. Gier, and presented to the IEP team, were prepared by Dr. Lieberman and Dr. Meggs.

Dr. Meggs is a physician, professor, and chief of medicine for the division of toxicology at East Carolina University School of Medicine. Dr. Meggs saw STUDENT in August of 2000. Dr. Meggs diagnosed STUDENT’s medical condition as MCS and indicated that he requires modifications that will minimize his exposure to respiratory irritants that exacerbate his condition. Dr. Lieberman is a physician who practices medicine at the center for occupational and environmental medicine in Charleston, South Carolina. He is a Diplomate with the American Board of Environmental Medicine and a member of the American College of Occupational and Environmental Medicine. Dr. Lieberman diagnosed STUDENT in 2001 with chemical sensitivity, chronic fatigue and Classical IgE mediated atopic allergy. STUDENT’s IEP team accepted the findings of Dr. Meggs and Dr. Lieberman.

In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s health was an area of suspected disability that required assessment pursuant to California Education code §56320. Additionally, the Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Meggs and Dr. Lieberman were knowledgeable about STUDENT’s medical condition as required by Education Code §56320(g). Further, the Hearing Officer finds that the uncontested medical reports prepared by Dr. Meggs and Dr. Lieberman were valid assessments pursuant to the applicable portions of Education Code

§56320. Additionally, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP team considered the valid assessments of Dr. Meggs and Dr. Lieberman, and accepted their diagnosis of STUDENT’s medical condition.

In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District completed an appropriate assessment of STUDENT as part of the IEP process. The District generally seeks an additional medical assessment for three reasons: to determine what modifications STUDENT requires to his regular school program; to develop an appropriate §504 plan; or if eligible for special education, to determine how to best serve STUDENT. Since the Hearing Officer found that the District completed a valid assessment of STUDENT, it has no right to an additional assessment under the IDEA or corresponding State law. Further, additional medical information is not necessary in light of the discussion below wherein the Hearing Officer determines that STUDENT is not eligible for special education on alternate grounds. Finally, if the District continues to seek additional assessments in order to develop a §504 plan, such a request must be directed to the Office of Civil Rights which has jurisdiction over §504 issues.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District does not have the right to obtain an independent medical assessment of STUDENT and access to his prior medical records.

II Is STUDENT currently eligible for special education as other health impaired?

Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. §1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A “child with a disability” is defined as a child with mental retardation, hearing impairments, speech or language impairments, visual impairments, emotional disturbance, orthopedic impairments, autism, traumatic brain injury, other health impairments, or specific learning disabilities who, by reason thereof, needs instruction, services or both which cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program. 20 U.S.C. §1401(3)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §56026(a) and (b) (Emphasis added). In this case, the only eligibility category at issue is other health impaired resulting generally from STUDENT’s multiple chemical sensitivity (MCS).

Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations section 3030(f) states that eligibility for special education as other health impaired is established when “a pupil has limited strength, vitality, or alertness, due to chronic or acute health problems...which adversely affects a pupil’s educational performance.” See also 34 C.F.R. §300.7(b)(8).

STUDENT argues that when exposed to most chemicals, his MCS affects his ability to attend in class, which adversely affects his educational performance. The District accepts that, at times, STUDENT’s medical condition can impact his strength, vitality, and alertness; however, it argues that STUDENT is still not eligible for special education because his medical condition does not adversely affect his educational performance. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will assume that STUDENT’s medical condition results in limited strength, vitality, or alertness. The Hearing Officer must determine whether or not STUDENT’s medical condition adversely affects his educational performance.

STUDENT’s most recent standardized assessments were conducted in the spring of 2001, as part of the IEP process. The District contends that STUDENT’s cognitive ability and achievement testing reveal that his educational performance was solidly within the average range and not adversely affected by MCS.

Dr. Holifield assessed STUDENT’s cognitive ability using the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Third Edition (WISC-III). At that time, STUDENT had a verbal intelligence quotient (IQ) of 111, a performance IQ of 115, and a full scale IQ of 113. STUDENT’s full scale IQ is within the high average range of cognitive ability. STUDENT’s academic achievement was assessed by special education teacher Elena O’Reilly using the Woodcock-Johnson psycho-educational battery - revised (WJ-R). At that time, STUDENT’s broad reading score of 118 was in the superior range. His broad math score of 110 was in the high average range and his broad written language score of 100 was solidly in the average range. Ms. O’Reilly’s notes indicate that STUDENT’s developmental level in reading was comparable to that of an average eighteen-year-old, and his math level was comparable to that of an average seventeen-year-old.

Home instructor Meredith Boyd also assessed STUDENT’s academic achievement in 2001. Ms. Boyd administered the Sucher-Aured Placement test to evaluate STUDENT’s vocabulary and reading comprehension. STUDENT’s grade equivalent was 9/10, which is between the ninth and tenth grade. Ms. Boyd also administered the Stanford Diagnostic Reading Comprehension assessment. STUDENT’s score was at the 95th percentile, or “past high school.”

Even though these standardized tests were administered last year, the evidence presented during the hearing indicates that STUDENT is currently performing academically at or above grade level. As of the time of the hearing, STUDENT had missed only one afternoon of school since the beginning of this current school year. Karen Lopez, teacher and dean, testified that report cards had not yet been prepared for the current school year. She testified, however, that she had spoken with STUDENT’s teachers prior to the hearing to get information regarding his current educational performance. Ms. Lopez reported that STUDENT is passing all of his classes with predominantly B’s, with the exception of Spanish. Ms. Lopez reported that STUDENT’s current Spanish grade is 69.3%. According to STUDENT’s Spanish teacher, his grade is a result of inconsistent scores on vocabulary tests and socializing too much with his classmates rather than a result of illness or fatigue. STUDENT testified that Spanish is not his favorite subject and he confirmed that he socializes in that class. In light of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is currently performing at or above grade level.

MOTHER argued that despite STUDENT’s current educational performance, the Hearing Officer should consider STUDENT’s absence from school for the ninth grade as a basis for eligibility. The District argues that STUDENT’s absence from school for the ninth grade was self- imposed and should not be considered as the basis for eligibility for special education. Additionally, the District argues that STUDENT’s absence did not adversely affect his education as evidenced by his current academic performance.

The Hearing Officer found above that STUDENT is currently performing at or above grade level despite his prolonged absence during the ninth grade. Additionally, no medical evidence was presented establishing that STUDENT’s absence was a result of his MCS. Both MOTHER and STUDENT testified that he, as a fifteen-year-old boy, was solely responsible for determining if and when he was able to attend school. MOTHER confirmed that STUDENT had health insurance, but he did not see any physician for his MCS while he was absent during the ninth grade. Despite his illness, STUDENT was able to attend the movies regularly, take guitar lessons, and even travel to Southern California to attend an amusement park on a family vacation. STUDENT testified that he was bored at home and missed his friends, which is why he wanted to return to school for tenth grade.

The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT made the determination to stay out of school. However, in light of the fact that STUDENT participated in activities while he was not going to school, such as attending the movies regularly in a closed-in and carpeted room, the Hearing Officer does not find that STUDENT’s absence from school during the ninth grade was medically necessary. The fact that he could attend the movies regularly suggests that his medical condition during that time period was not so significant that it prevented him from attending school with appropriate modifications. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s absence, even if partially attributed to his MCS, was not significant enough to establish that his MCS adversely affected his education.

In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s medical condition does not adversely affect his educational performance. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that he is not eligible for special education and related services as other health impaired.

Even assuming, arguendo, that STUDENT’s medical condition did adversely affect his educational performance, he is still not a child with a disability under the IDEA and State law because academic instruction, services or both can be provided with modification of the regular school program.

MOTHER testified that if the school employs the modifications recommended by “her doctors,” STUDENT will not suffer symptoms from MCS and can attend school. A review of the medical documentation submitted by STUDENT reveals that diagnosing physicians have suggested modifications that can be made to the regular school program without requiring special education instruction or services. These modifications are avoidance of pesticides, a fragrance-free classroom, hard surface floors, doors and windows that open to the outside, non-toxic cleaning products (Bon Ami, white vinegar), notification and availability of an alternate site when a classroom is being renovated (painted), and a box to be used as needed to hold new textbooks that cause irritations due to out-gassing of chemicals from ink and paper. (Extracted from reports by Dr. Anderson, Dr. Heuser, and Dr. Lieberman prepared from 1995 to 2001; testimony of MOTHER and STUDENT). The type of modifications to the regular school program that STUDENT’s diagnosing physicians have identified have been provided in other cases to students pursuant to §504 plans. (See e.g., Walpole Pub.Schs., 26 IDELR 976 (SEA Mass. 1997); Baltimore County (MD) Public School, 18 IDELR 1041 (OCR 1991); Hunt v. St. Peter School, 26 IDELR 6 (W.D. Mo. 1997). The Hearing Officer declines to make a determination as to whether or not these modifications should be included in a §504 plan for STUDENT because §504 claims are beyond the scope of this hearing. However, the Hearing Officer finds that even if STUDENT requires the above modifications, they can be made to the regular school program without requiring special education instruction or services. Therefore, STUDENT is not a child with a disability requiring special education under the IDEA and State law.(FOOTNOTE 7)

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is not currently eligible for special education as other health impaired, and he is not a child with a disability requiring special education under the IDEA and State law.

III Is STUDENT entitled to independent medical evaluations at District expense by Dr. Heuser, neurotoxicologist in Agora Hills, California; Dr. Meggs, toxicologist in South Carolina; and Dr. Gutierez, neuropsychologist in Santa Barbara, California?

California Education Code section 56329(b) and (c) provides that a parent has the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil from qualified specialists, if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency. However, the District may initiate a due process hearing in order to show that its assessment was appropriate. If it is determined that the District’s assessment was appropriate, then the parent still has the right for an independent assessment, but not at public expense.

In this case, MOTHER requested three medical assessments at public expense in order to dispute the findings of the District’s physician’s assessment if the Hearing Officer granted the District’s request for additional assessments. STUDENT has the right to obtain medical evaluations by the doctors listed above. However, California law only provides for assessments at public expense if a parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency. In this case, MOTHER does not object to any assessments previously conducted by the District. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is not entitled to the independent medical evaluations requested at public expense.

In summary, STUDENT’s request for independent assessments at public expense is denied.

ORDER

1. The District is not entitled to conduct an unconditional medical assessment of STUDENT, nor obtain access to his medical records.

2. STUDENT is not currently eligible for special education as other health impaired.

3. STUDENT is not entitled to the independent medical assessments he requested at public expense.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

I. Is the District entitled to an unconditional medical assessment of STUDENT by a qualified California physician and a release of STUDENT’s prior medical records? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.

II. Is STUDENT currently eligible for special education as other health impaired? The District prevailed on this issue.

III. Is STUDENT entitled to independent medical evaluations at District expense by Dr. Heuser, neurotoxicologist in Agora Hills; Dr. Meggs, toxicologist in South Carolina; and Dr. Gutierez, neuropsychologist in Santa Barbara, California? The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Education Code section 56505(i).

DATED: December 16, 2002 ______________________________ Joy Redmon, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. The District filed a request for a due process hearing. Thereafter, STUDENT filed a request for a due process hearing. Prior to the District’s filed case convening for hearing, the District made a written motion to consolidate its case with STUDENT’s case. At that point it was unclear to the Hearing Officer what issues STUDENT intended to litigate. Accordingly, this Hearing Officer issued an order deferring ruling on the request for consolidation until the first day of hearing in the District’s filed case. On the first day of hearing, MOTHER clarified that STUDENT’s sole issue for hearing was a request for three independent assessments. After clarifying the issues for hearing, the District renewed its request to have the cases consolidated. MOTHER agreed, and made an independent request to have the matters consolidated. In light of the requests of the parties, this Hearing Officer consolidated cases SN02-01908 and SN02-02241 because they involved the same parties and presented similar issues of law and fact. 2. Although the District did not explicitly contend that it sought additional assessments for the purpose of creating an IEP if STUDENT was found eligible, there was general discussion in this area. Therefore, out of an abundance of caution, the Hearing Officer will first determine whether or not the District had adequate information regarding STUDENT’s medical condition to make a determination regarding eligibility. 3. MOTHER explained that Dursban was eventually banned by the Environmental Protection Agency because it was determined to cause chemical injury. 4. MOTHER and STUDENT’s older brother BROTHER have also been diagnosed as having multiple chemical sensitivity. 5. Classical IgE mediated atopic allergy is defined as hypersensitivity to an allergen which can trigger a release of mediators (eg histamine). The triggers for IgE related hypersensitivity vary by region depending upon the predominant allergens in the environment. 6. At one point STUDENT received a prescription for the allergy medicine Zyrtec. He had an adverse reaction to the medicine and it was discontinued. 7. While this Hearing Officer makes no determination regarding STUDENT’s eligibility for services pursuant to a §504 plan, she strongly encourages the parties to attempt to resolve this issue as well. According to testimony during this due process hearing, the District now has more medical documentation listing specific recommended modifications than it had access to previously. Therefore, the Hearing Officer suggests that it is in STUDENT’s best interest for the parties to explore this additional information further.