California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 5, 2002
Los Altos Elementary School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 1950-02 · Hearing Officer Lawrence E. Mendel
Hearing Officer finds Los Altos Elementary's 2002-2003 inclusion offer for a second-grader with autism provided a FAPE without a home program.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
Los Altos Elementary School District filed for due process to confirm that its 2002-2003 offer for a seven-year-old second-grader with autism provided a FAPE. The student was fully included in a general education class at Loyola Elementary School and had made strong progress. Her triennial testing showed high-average cognitive scores and above-average achievement. Her remaining needs were mainly in behavior, social skills, and speech. The offer included full inclusion with a full-day shadow aide and three 30-minute pull-out speech-language sessions a week. It also included 45 minutes of after-school services three days a week, a behavior plan, and staff training and program consultation by specialist Michelle Garcia Winner. The parents agreed with the assessments and goals. They wanted a home program of 5 to 10 hours a week and 60-minute speech sessions outside class time. They also wanted a Lovaas-trained aide they could approve, and continued case management by the Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE).
The Hearing Officer applied the Rowley "some educational benefit" standard and found the offer was a FAPE. The year before, the student had progressed with less speech therapy and very little home programming. Aides without Lovaas training had worked well with her. Parents have no veto over the district's hiring decisions. The after-school services could address the home-program goals. The LIFE consultant was not fully informed about the student's current skills. All of the parents' requests were denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled a district-filed case to approve an offer that phased out a home discrete trial program for a student with autism who was doing well. It held that parents could not veto staff choices or require a particular provider or teaching method, as long as the offer met the student's needs under Rowley.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedDistrict-filed: implement IEP
Issue 1. Has the District offered a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2002-2003 school year? (Offer in the May 7, 2002 IEP, July 12, 2002 addendum, and September 10, 2002 email: full inclusion with full-day shadow aide; three 30-minute pull-out speech/language sessions weekly; extended day services three days a week for 45 minutes; behavior support plan; staff training and program consultation by Michelle Garcia Winner.)
The offer met the student's unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. The aide did not need Lovaas training, parents had no veto over staff choices, 30-minute pull-out speech sessions and after-school services in place of a home program were adequate, and the District could pick a different case-management provider than LIFE.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order that district's offer may be implemented. The District's 2002-2003 offer, as contained in the May 7, 2002 IEP, the July 12, 2002 IEP addendum, and the September 10, 2002 email from Ms. Luks to the parents, is an offer of FAPE. All of the student's requests for relief are denied.
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8); 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56507(d)
People named in the decision
- Charlene Luks, director of pupil services; District representative and witness, Los Altos Elementary School District
- Mary Allen, program specialist, Los Altos Elementary School District
- Elizabeth Rathbone, school psychologist (triennial assessor), Los Altos Elementary School District
- Janet Taylor, second grade general education teacher, Loyola Elementary School
- Megan Scatena, first grade general education teacher, Loyola Elementary School
- Sheri Sinchek, speech/language pathologist, Los Altos Elementary School District
- Lisa Wiedenfeld, behavior therapist, home program provider and shadow aide, formerly CARD; supervised by LIFE
- Linda Figone, instructional aide (summer 2002 shadow aide), Los Altos Elementary School District
- Linda Eckols, school principal, Loyola Elementary School
- Abbie Sandborn, shadow aide and home program provider, Los Altos Elementary School District
- Norma Quintero, LIFE supervising consultant; witness for Student, Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE)
- Cheryl Provost, autism specialist offered for social skills consultation in July 2002 addendum
- Michelle Garcia Winner, specialist in social cognitive learning and theory of mind; proposed staff trainer and program consultant (nonpublic agency)
- Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), private agency; earlier evaluator and discrete trial training provider
- Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE), private agency; program supervision and consultation, Sacramento
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Lawrence E. Mendel, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Los Altos, California, on September 19, 20, October 8 and 9, 2002.
Petitioner Los Altos Elementary School District (District) was represented at the hearing by Charlene Luks, director of pupil services. Also present on the District’s behalf on September 19 only was Mary Allen, program specialist. Respondent STUDENT was represented at the hearing by FATHER, and MOTHER (on September 19 and 20 only).
Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Elizabeth Rathbone, school psychologist; Janet Taylor, teacher; Sheri Sinchek, speech/language pathologist; Lisa Wiedenfeld, behavior therapist; Megan Scatena, teacher; Linda Figone, instructional aide; Charlene Luks, director of pupil services; and Linda Eckols, school principal. Respondent called the following witnesses to testify: FATHER, and Norma Quintero, LIFE consultant.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Upon the receipt of closing arguments, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUE
Has the District offered a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2002-2003 school year?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a seven-year-old second-grader attending Loyola Elementary School in the Los Altos Elementary School District (District). STUDENT is receiving special education and related services based upon a diagnosis of autism.
STUDENT was diagnosed with autism in1998, at the age of three, and began receiving speech/language therapy. In 1999 STUDENT and her family moved to Los Altos. STUDENT was subsequently evaluated by the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), which recommended continued speech/language therapy and a program of intensive individual discrete trial training (DTT). In March 1999, when STUDENT was three and one-half years old, the District performed its own psychoeducaitonal assessment of STUDENT. The assessor used the Scales of Independent Behavior - Revised (SIB-R), the Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scale of Intelligence - Revised (WPPSI-R), and the Childhood Autism Rating Scale. It was concluded that STUDENT had a performance IQ of 77, a verbal IQ of 71, and a full scale IQ of 71. The assessor also found that STUDENT’s adaptive behavior and independent functioning levels were similar to that of a child aged one and a half years old. STUDENT exhibited autistic behaviors including self-stimulation, tantrums, repetitive activity, resistance to change, and withdrawal. STUDENT continued to receive twenty-four hours a week of DTT through CARD and speech/language therapy. Lisa Wiedenfeld was the CARD employee providing the home DTT. In February 2000, oversight of the DTT program was transferred to the Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE). LIFE began providing monthly consultation services, and Ms. Wiedenfeld, now under the supervision of LIFE, continued to provide the home DTT.(Footnote 1)
STUDENT made significant progress in all areas, and in August 2000, she began attending kindergarten. STUDENT attended kindergarten in the morning accompanied by a shadow aide and received four hours a day of DTT at home in the afternoon. Speech/language therapy continued as well. Lisa Wiedenfeld was serving as one of the shadow aides and providing the home DTT. LIFE continued to provide supervision and coordination of the home and school services.
In June 2001, the IEP team met to develop STUDENT’s program for the first grade. STUDENT had continued to show improvement, and the team agreed to place STUDENT in a regular first grade class with a shadow aide and to reduce the home program to one and one-half hours per day. STUDENT would also receive speech therapy, twice a week for thirty minutes each session. One session would be one-on-one and the other session would be in a small group. It was planned that STUDENT would work on social skills during the group session. LIFE would continue to provide monthly consultation services. A behavior plan was developed and it was further agreed that an occupational therapy assessment would be performed in September. The behavior program involved charts that targeted two specific behaviors each day (such as “stopping the first time” and “talking nice to others”), with the day broken down into four time periods. If STUDENT did well during each time period, she would receive a star, and if she received at least six stars in a day, she would receive a reward at the end of the day. If STUDENT did not do well on a behavior, she would receive immediate feedback and counseling from her aide. Lisa Wiedenfeld and Abbie Sandborn shared the shadow aide duties. Ms. Wiedenfeld provided one day a week of the home program, and another aide was hired to provide the other four days of the home program. Sheri Sinchek provided the speech/language therapy. Norma Quintero was the supervising consultant from LIFE.
In September 2001, the occupational therapy evaluation was completed. STUDENT exhibited adequate balance, postural strength, proximal stability, grasp and release and all of the mature hand skills. STUDENT was able to grasp and manipulate small objects appropriately and complete timed dexterity tasks within age-appropriate levels. STUDENT did demonstrate some sensory seeking behaviors - moving around in her chair, swaying, wrapping or kicking her legs, and mouthing her fingers. STUDENT also occasionally bumped into objects and seemed somewhat clumsy. It was concluded that STUDENT had difficulty in several areas: moving about in a controlled manner; sitting in a comfortable, upright posture; coloring in a space. In addition, STUDENT had occasional trouble tolerating the touch of others. To address these needs, the IEP team added occupation therapy consultation services to STUDENT’s program.
Shortly after the start of the first grade, the aide providing four days of the home program left, and her replacement left shortly thereafter. As a result of these staffing problems, for the majority of the first grade, STUDENT only received the one and one-half hours a week of the home program provided by Lisa Wiedenfeld.(Footnote 2)
During the first grade, as part of the home program, STUDENT worked on comprehension, social skills, language and communication skills, and general knowledge. Social stories were later added to STUDENT’s school and home program to help her learn appropriate social interaction. Social stories were used by the aide at school, and by Ms. Sinchek, the speech therapist. Ms. Sinchek also worked with STUDENT on articulation, expressive and receptive language, social language skills, listening, and class participation and turn-taking. RSP support in math was also added to STUDENT’s program for part of the year. STUDENT also had weekly home play dates facilitated by the aide.
Throughout the first grade, STUDENT continued to make progress. Ms. Scatena, STUDENT’s first grade teacher, reported that, except for math, STUDENT was one of her top students academically. STUDENT had good decoding skills and was able to read a third grade text with 90% accuracy by the end of the year. STUDENT also demonstrated good reading comprehension. If problems did occur, the aide was usually able to address them with a little re-teaching. STUDENT’s math skills, though always her weak area, did improve with the extra RSP support. STUDENT’s articulation also improved during the year, though more slowly than some of her other skills. By the end of the year, STUDENT’s speech was understandable most of the time. If STUDENT became excited, her articulation would suffer, but STUDENT always responded well to requests for her to slow down and repeat things.
STUDENT’s primary problems were in social skills and behavior. At the start of the year, STUDENT had repeated problems with class participation and turn-taking. This improved during the year, but continued to be an area that STUDENT needed to work on. On occasion, STUDENT also would have problems with following directions. STUDENT occasionally had bad days on which she would have tantrums. The aide was usually able to control the tantrums and help STUDENT work through the problems with little class disruption. STUDENT did so well on her behavior plan that the threshold for a reward had to be raised from six stars a day to seven in order to make it challenging for STUDENT. STUDENT’s home program also evolved during the year to reflect her continued progress. By April, 2001, STUDENT was working on community outings, homework, idioms and jokes, impossible tasks, peer play, role playing, social stories, what would you do if..., and vocabulary. Some of these activities were facilitated by Ms. Wiedenfeld, and others, such as some of the play dates and community outings, were facilitated by the PARENTS.
In March 2002, STUDENT was referred for her triennial assessment. As part of this assessment, STUDENT was administered the Weschler Intelligence Scale for Children (WISC-3), the Test of Visual Motor Integration (VMI), the Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills - Revised (TAPS-R), the Behavior Assessment System for Children (BASC), the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT), the Gates-MacGintie Reading Test, the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals (CELF-3), and the Test of Language Development (TOLD-P3). On the WISC-3, STUDENT received a verbal IQ score of 107, and performance IQ score of 121, and a full scale IQ score of 115. These scores suggest that STUDENT was functioning in the high average range. STUDENT’s weakest scores were in the areas of comprehension, which tested her knowledge of social conventions, and in picture arrangement, which tested STUDENT’s ability to identify missing details. STUDENT’s strongest area was in decoding. On the TAPS-R, STUDENT demonstrated average auditory processing in all areas except sentence memory, in which she scored in the low average range. On this subtest, STUDENT made subtle errors that generally did not alter the meaning of the sentence. On the WIAT, STUDENT scored above average in all areas. Her only score below the 90th percentile was in math reasoning, in which she received a standard score of 114, in the 82nd percentile. Her highest scores were in basic reading (a standard score of 152) and in the reading composite (a standard score of 148). On the CELF-3, STUDENT received scores in the average range on all subtests except for recalling sentences. On this subtest STUDENT’s standard score was 5, in the 5th percentile. STUDENT’s scores on the TOLD-P3 were all in the average range. In the area of articulation, STUDENT demonstrated errors in the use of the “r” sound in all positions of words. STUDENT also had occasional difficulty producing the “th” sound.
The interviews, classroom observation and the parent and teacher responses to the BASC established that behavior continued to be STUDENT’s greatest area of need. MOTHER’s responses on the BASC showed a much more negative assessment of STUDENT’s behavior than the responses of STUDENT’s teacher. MOTHER noted problems with acting out, hyperactivity, verbal aggression, depression, crying easily, and changeable moods. Problems were also reported in the areas of atypical behaviors and attention. Finally, MOTHER reported problems with socializing and adaptive skills. Ms. Scatena, STUDENT’s first grade teacher, reported that STUDENT exhibited problems with acting out, verbal aggression, and hyperactivity in class. Ms. Scatena also reported some signs of depression, as well as a tendency to be become upset and frustrated easily. In addition, STUDENT exhibited some atypical behaviors, some difficulty with adaptive skills, and difficulty adjusting to change. Ms. Rathbone, the school psychologist who performed this portion of the evaluation, noted that MOTHER’s excessively negative response pattern needed to be interpreted with caution, but that it was likely that STUDENT misbehaved to a greater extent at home than at school.
On May 7, 2002, the IEP team met to develop STUDENT’s program for the second grade. Using the results of the triennial assessment and the information shared at the IEP meeting, the team agreed that STUDENT had made progress in all areas, despite only receiving one and one-half hours of the home program each week. Norma Quintero, the LIFE consultant, had submitted a report recommending that STUDENT’s home program continue at five to ten hours a week, with ongoing supervision by LIFE. Despite this recommendation, the team concluded that the home program could be eliminated from STUDENT’s program in the second grade; however, the team also recommended that the shadow aide should continue. The team also recommended that the speech/language therapy be increased to three sessions a week, thirty minutes each. Two sessions would be individual and one session would be small group. The group session was to focus on social skills utilizing social stories and “theory of mind,” a program designed to teach STUDENT to understand that a person’s beliefs are often governed by the information available to them. The behavior plan was to continue, and RSP support would be available on an as-needed basis. Supervision and oversight of the program was to be done by the school psychologist, rather than through LIFE. Goals and objectives were developed in math skills and concepts, attention to task, language and communication, auditory comprehension and expressive communication, classroom participation, social skills, and articulation. The PARENTS agreed with the present levels of performance and the goals and objectives, but disagreed with the team’s recommendation to eliminate the home program, believing that the home program should continue and be supervised by a LIFE consultant.
For the summer of 2002, it was agreed that STUDENT would attend a YMCA sport day camp and that the District would provide a shadow aide for STUDENT for the majority of each day. No home program or speech/language services were to be provided during the summer.
An IEP addendum was drafted on July 12, 2002. In the addendum, the District offered to contract with Cheryl Provost, an autism specialist, for three hours a month to facilitate STUDENT’s social skills training and to consult with the parents and staff. The PARENTS continued to disagree with the District’s offer, believing that a home program supervised by a consultant from LIFE was necessary for STUDENT to continue to make progress on her social skills and communication goals.
Linda Figone served as STUDENT’s shadow aide for the summer of 2002. Ms. Figone was with STUDENT from nine to four daily, though the camp ran from seven to six. Ms. Figone stated that, on occasion, if STUDENT was having a bad day, she would stay until six. Ms. Figone used a behavior chart and rewards similar to those on the behavior plan utilized during the school year. If STUDENT had behavior problems, she received immediate feedback and counseling. Ms. Figone stated that at first a lot of time was spent getting to know STUDENT and establishing limits and expectations. Overall, Ms. Figone stated that STUDENT did very well. STUDENT would learn the rules to games, such as soccer, in a one-to-one or small-group setting, and then work on generalizing those rules to a real game situation. This approach worked well, and STUDENT made progress throughout the summer. At times, STUDENT would become overwhelmed or frustrated and act out. In general, Ms. Figone was able to work through these problems with STUDENT.
STUDENT began the second grade in August 2002. The District filed this due process case on August 28, 2002. Because of the disagreement over the program for 2002-2003, the previous year’s program was continued. Lisa Wiedenfeld continued to reduce her hours because of her return to school. Although she continued to provide one day a week of the home program, she was only able to serve as the shadow aide for the first two weeks of the school year. At the start of the year, Abbie Sandborn, the other shadow aide from the previous year, was providing the other four days a week of the home program. In September, the PARENTS requested that Ms. Sandborn no longer provide the home program, stating that she was not properly trained. In addition, the PARENTS objected to the shadow aide who had replaced Ms. Wiedenfeld. After the PARENTS refused Ms. Sandborn’s services, the home program continued at only one day a week. In addition, there were repeated problems finding a new shadow aide. The District and the PARENTS have been unable to agree on an appropriate replacement for Ms. Wiedenfeld. The result was a series of temporary aides during the school day.
On September 10, 2002, the District supplemented its offer for the 2002-2003 school year. The District offered extended school day services of forty-five minutes a day for three days a week. This additional time would be used by the RSP teacher to provide additional academic instruction as needed, and by the shadow aide to provide additional social skills work and to deal with any behavior problems that had arisen during the regular school day. The District had arranged for Lisa Wiedenfeld to serve as STUDENT’s aide from noon through the end of the extended school day (3:10 p.m.) three days a week. In addition, the District offered to contract with Michelle Garcia Winner, a specialist in social cognitive learning and theory of mind strategies, to provide staff training at Loyola Elementary School as well as consulting on STUDENT’s individual program. The PARENTS continued to decline the District’s offer, including the extended day services, pending the outcome of the due process matter.
Janet Taylor, STUDENT’s second grade teacher, stated that the 2002-2003 school year started out very well. Initially, STUDENT needed only minimal prompting from her aide, and there were no major behavior problems. Ms. Sinchek stated that STUDENT had not regressed during the summer, despite that lack of speech/language therapy, and was already progressing on her current goals and objectives. Ms. Wiedenfeld agreed that she had not seen any regression in behavior from the end of the first grade. Unfortunately, when Ms. Wiedenfeld stopped acting as STUDENT’s shadow aide, STUDENT’s behavior at school became more of a problem. STUDENT began acting out, has needed more “time outs,” and her behavior has, at times, interfered with her academics. The new aides have not been able to work with STUDENT as effectively as Ms. Wiedenfeld. Despite the problems with the shadow aides, STUDENT has responded well to Ms. Taylor. If STUDENT’s attention starts to wander, Mr. Taylor is usually able to prompt her to refocus on the class work. In addition, if STUDENT is having trouble with a subject or concept, Ms. Taylor is able to do re-teaching during the silent reading time.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The District’s offer of placement for the 2002-2003 school year is contained in the May 7, 2002 IEP, the July 12, 2002 IEP addendum, and the September 10, 2002 email from Ms. Luks to the PARENTS.(Footnote 3) The offer is as follows:
1. Full inclusion in a second grade class at Loyola Elementary School. 2. A shadow aide for the entire school day.
3. Pull-out speech/language therapy three times a week for 30 minutes each session. One session will be a small group and the other two will be individual sessions. 4. Extended day services three days a week from 2:25 to 3:10 p.m. at which one-on-one academic instruction and work on behavior and social skills will be conducted. 5. A behavior support plan.
6. Staff training and supervision of the program by Michelle Garcia Winner, a specialist in social cognitive learning and theory of mind strategies, to provide staff training at Loyola Elementary School as well as consulting on STUDENT’s individual program.
Goals and objectives were drafted in the areas of social skills, class behavior, speech and language, and math. The District contends that this offer is an offer of FAPE.
The PARENTS state that they believe that the triennial assessments were appropriate and gave an accurate picture of STUDENT’s present levels of performance. In addition, the PARENTS agree with the goals and objectives. The PARENTS argue that the services offered are not adequate to help STUDENT progress on her goals and objectives and not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Specifically, the PARENTS contend that the program offered by the District fails to offer a FAPE for the following reasons:
1. The program is merely a collection of services, not a cohesive plan designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. 2. The speech/language therapy sessions need to be 60 minutes each, and they should be provided after school or at home so that STUDENT does not miss general education instruction when she is pulled out of class. 3. The aide must have the proper qualifications, must have training in the Lovaas method of DTT, and must be subject to approval by the PARENTS. 4. There must continue to be a case manager from LIFE who oversees the design and implementation of the program. 5. A home program of five to ten hours a week is still necessary to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Has the District offered a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2002-2003 school year?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE) that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs and prepare them for employment and independent living. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 (d). The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). The student’s IEP must provide, among other things, for the student to be involved and progress in the general curriculum and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. 20 U.S.C. §1414(d).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201.
In summary, under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley the proposed educational program must, 1) be designed to meet the student’s unique needs, 2) provide for the student to be involved and progress in the general curriculum and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities, 3) be calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, and 4) the program must conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176. If these requirements are met, then the District has offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer a different program or services and even if the parents’ preferred program or services would result in greater educational benefit. (Rowley at 207-208; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist. (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307, 1314.)
1. STUDENT’s Unique Needs.
The first step in determining if the District’s offer is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs is to identify those needs. The testimony of all of the witnesses establishes that STUDENT does best when she clearly understands what is expected of her, and is given firm and consistent feedback on her behavior. Therefore, STUDENT needs a consistent and structured program. STUDENT needs to have behavioral expectations clearly set out, with limits on her behavior firmly enforced. In addition, the program needs to be consistent throughout the day, in class, at recess, during speech/language therapy, and at home. There also was agreement among all of the witnesses that STUDENT responds well to a system of rewards and consequences for improving her behavior.
Although STUDENT has made great progress, she continues to need prompts, both visual and verbal, to help her maintain attention and self-monitor her behavior. STUDENT still has difficulty with peer play, peer socialization, and learning the rules for, and participating in, more complex games (such as basketball and soccer). Therefore, STUDENT still needs these activities monitored and, at times, facilitated by a qualified person.
Academically, STUDENT has become one of the top students in her class and continues to perform well in the general education curriculum. However, STUDENT will occasionally need additional repetition and re-teaching to learn certain skills and concepts, particularly in math. In the past, STUDENT has required pre-teaching, but her first grade and second grade teachers and her shadow aide all agreed that STUDENT no longer requires pre-teaching of academics.
Testing and the testimony of the speech/language pathologist revealed that STUDENT has articulation problems, primarily with the “r” sound and occasionally with the “th” sound. Despite these problems, witnesses testified that STUDENT is generally understandable, except when she gets excited. However, articulation continues to be a problem area, requiring ongoing services. STUDENT also has language deficiencies in the use of tenses, irregular verbs and other aspects of expressive language. Testimony established that STUDENT requires additional instruction in social rules, pragmatic language and nonverbal communication. STUDENT also needs to continue to work on higher order thinking, such as understanding the abstract meaning behind stories, and grasping the overall meaning of pictures and stories rather than focusing on the details.
Finally, it is apparent from teacher and parent testimony that it is vital to the success of any program for STUDENT that the shadow aide be properly qualified and trained. The aides that have been particularly successful have had a combination of formal education and practical experience. Lisa Wiedenfeld, who all agree has been an excellent aide, has a BA in psychology and had one year of practical experience working with autistic children prior to working with STUDENT. Linda Figone, who achieved very good results as STUDENT’s aide at the summer sports camp, had no prior experience with autistic children, but has an MA specializing in adolescent behavior and had practical experience as part of her master’s program. In addition to having the necessary education and experience, the aide must receive appropriate training and orientation as to STUDENT’s individual program. Furthermore, all of the witnesses agreed that consistency is a very important part of STUDENT’s needs. To ensure that STUDENT’s program is executed consistently, and problems are addressed in an appropriate manner, the program must be overseen by a case manager who has experience in designing and supervising programs for autistic children. This has been done by LIFE in the past and has ensured that all of the people involved in the program are giving STUDENT consistent feedback and that problems and changing needs are addressed promptly and in an appropriate manner.
In summary, STUDENT’s unique needs are as follows:
1. A structured and consistent program that utilizes a system of rewards and consequences for improving behavior. 2. Visual and verbal prompts for maintaining attention and self-monitoring behavior. 3. Monitoring and facilitation of peer play and peer socialization. 4. Repetition and re-teaching of academic skills and concepts as needed. 5. Speech/language therapy in the areas of articulation, receptive and expressive language, pragmatic language, social rules, and non-verbal communication. 6. A shadow aide with appropriate education and experience, preferably at least a BA in a related field and one year of practical experience, who has been trained in the provision and monitoring of STUDENT’s program. 7. A case manager to oversee STUDENT’s program.
2. The District’s offer.
Having identified each of STUDENT’s unique needs, the District’s offer must be analyzed to determine if it (1) meets STUDENT’s unique needs, (2) will provide for STUDENT to be involved and progress in the general curriculum and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities, (3) is calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit, and (4) conforms with STUDENT’s IEP. In this case the dispute involves a proposed program, not one that is currently being provided. Therefore, there is no issue as to whether the program is being provided in conformity with STUDENT’s IEP, so that prong of the test will not be addressed.
It is undisputed that STUDENT’s placement in a second grade class with the assistance of a shadow aide will provide STUDENT with the opportunity to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. The only issue with relation to this prong of the test involves the provision of pull-out speech/language services. That issue will be discussed later in this decision.
Placement in a second grade general education class with a shadow aide throughout the school day.
It is undisputed that placement in a general education class with the support of a shadow aide is appropriate to meet STUDENT’s academic and socialization needs as well as providing her with the opportunity to be involved with and progress in the general curriculum. The central dispute in relation to this portion of the District’s offer involves the choice of and training of the shadow aide. Both parties agree that the aide should have at least a BA and one or more years of experience in working with autistic students. Both parties also agree, however, that these are guidelines only and need not be strictly applied. The evidence established that an appropriate aide might have less formal education or less previous experience. For example, Ms. Figone had significant formal education, a master’s degree specializing in adolescent behavior, but had no prior experience working with autistic children. There was also testimony that an appropriate aide need not have a BA if she had more experience working with autistic children. The Hearing Officer finds that the ideal aide should, as agreed, have a BA in a related field and at least one year of experience working with autistic children. However, the Hearing Officer also finds that an appropriate aide may have more formal education (such as a master’s in a related field) and less experience working with autistic children, or less formal education, and more practical experience working with autistic children.
Both parties agree that the aide should receive orientation training in STUDENT’s program, meeting with STUDENT’s teachers to establish responsibilities, observing STUDENT at school, a transition period during which the new aide would work in conjunction with Ms. Wiedenfeld, and finally a period during which the new aide would be observed while working with STUDENT. In addition to this training, the PARENTS argue that the aide must also receive training in the Lovaas method of DTT from LIFE.
The District contends that STUDENT no longer requires Lovaas DTT and, therefore, that the aide does not need to be trained in this specific methodology. Lisa Wiedenfeld, who has provided STUDENT’s home program since 1999 and was one of STUDENT’s shadow aides during the first grade, testified that last year STUDENT’s home program had become much less structured than in the past. She stated that the home program was utilizing various teaching methods, including aspects of DTT, “social stories,” role playing, and “theory of mind” activities. Because the program was no longer the highly structured Lovaas DTT, Ms. Wiedenfeld believed that the shadow aide no longer needed formal training in that methodology. Furthermore, Abbie Sandborn, one of STUDENT’s aides last year, had never received training in the Lovaas method from LIFE. The PARENTS contended that Ms. Sandborn had not been an appropriate shadow aide. However, Norma Quintero, the LIFE consultant responsible for supervising Ms. Sandborn last year, stated that she had reviewed Ms. Sandborn’s performance, observed her at school, and received feedback regarding her from various sources. She concluded that Ms. Sandborn had performed appropriately as one of STUDENT’s shadow aides during the first grade.
Linda Figone, the aide during the summer sports camp, also had never received training in Lovaas DTT. Testimony establish that there was a period of transition while STUDENT became accustomed to Ms. Figone and Ms. Figone had to learn the most effective ways of dealing with STUDENT. However, after this relatively brief period, Ms. Figone was able to act very effectively as STUDENT’s aide throughout the summer. In fact, Ms. Figone has been asked by the PARENTS to continue as STUDENT’s aide during the regular school year.(Footnote 4) Ms. Wiedenfeld has had extensive experience in working with STUDENT, both at school and at home, and the Hearing Officer gives her testimony great weight. On the basis of this testimony as well as the past examples of Abbie Sandborn’s and Linda Figone’s work with STUDENT, the Hearing Officer concludes that it is not necessary for the shadow aide to receive training in the Lovaas method.
In addition to the training issue, the PARENTS have insisted on having veto authority over the choice of the aide. Although the District must provide qualified personnel to implement a student’s special education program, there is no support, either in the statutes or in case law, for the proposition that a parent has the right to dictate individual hiring decisions. In this case, FATHER testified that he agreed with the basic qualifications the District is using to hire a shadow aide for STUDENT’s program. Furthermore, there is no evidence that the PARENTS have such unique expertise in hiring an aide that they should be allowed to have veto authority over the District’s hiring decision. In fact, the situation with Ms. Sandborn indicates that the PARENTS may disagree with the choice of a particular aide (Ms. Sandborn) who the evidence established was performing her duties appropriately. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District need not allow the PARENTS to exercise veto authority over the choice of the shadow aide, or any other personnel involved in STUDENT’s program.
Three thirty-minute pull-out speech/language therapy sessions each week, provided during the regular school day.
The PARENTS contend that thirty-minute sessions are too short and that pulling STUDENT out of her general education class is too disruptive. During the 2001-2002, school year STUDENT received only two thirty-minute sessions each week. Her therapist that year was Ms. Sinchek, who is STUDENT’s speech/language therapist this year as well. Ms. Sinchek testified that STUDENT made progress on all of her speech/language goals during the 2001-2002 school year, and met 13 of the 18 objectives. In addition, she stated that STUDENT is already progressing toward her current goals. Ms. Sinchek stated that typically there is a very short transition period at the start of each session and that she is usually able to get STUDENT settled and ready to work in three to five minutes. Ms. Sinchek also stated that she worked with STUDENT’s first grade teacher last year, and her second grade teacher this year, to agree on times for the pull-out services in order to disrupt STUDENT’s general education class as little as possible. Currently, they have the therapy sessions scheduled during silent reading time. Although there was testimony that STUDENT had some problems coming back to class after her RSP sessions last year, there was no evidence that STUDENT had any problems going to or coming back from speech therapy.
In the speech/language therapy sessions, STUDENT is receiving instruction in articulation, expressive and receptive language, pragmatics, nonverbal communication and social skills. Although STUDENT would probably make more progress in speech and language with three sixty-minute sessions, she made significant progress toward all of her goals in only two thirty-minute sessions during the previous school year. The District is proposing to increase the number of sessions each week from two to three. On the basis of the progress that STUDENT made with less services, and the testimony of Ms. Sinchek, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of speech and language. In addition, this level of services is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. Although any student who receives pull-out services is going to miss some of her general education class, in STUDENT’s case Ms. Sinchek has consulted with the general education teacher to ensure that the scheduling of the pull-out sessions has a minimum impact on STUDENT’s class work. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s pull-out speech/language services are not significantly impacting her access to the general curriculum or her opportunity to participate in her general education class.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of three thirty-minute pull-out speech/language therapy sessions each week, provided during the regular school day, meets STUDENT’s needs in this area, will not interfere with STUDENT’s access to the general curriculum, and is calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.
Extended school day services.
The District’s offer of extended school day services is intended to provide STUDENT with additional time to work on behavior and academic issues. The District has proposed three 45-minute sessions each week. It is proposed that this time be used for any RSP support necessary for STUDENT’s academics, and to work on those issues that had previously been addressed by the home program. The PARENTS object to this plan for several reasons:
1. STUDENT will not want to stay after school, and will feel she is being punished because all of the other children will be going home. 2. STUDENT will be unable to address behaviors that primarily occur at home in a school setting. 3. The amount of time is not sufficient to work on all of the goals that had previously been worked on during the home program.
Lisa Wiedenfeld, who has worked with STUDENT at school and at home since 1999, testified that she believed that STUDENT would adapt well to an after-school program. She stated that there are a number of after-school programs at Loyola, so STUDENT would not be the only child remaining on campus and, therefore, would not feel singled out.
FATHER stated that at home STUDENT is more verbally aggressive then she has been in the past. She argues with her sister more, is more competitive, and talks back to her parents more. However, FATHER admits that these new behaviors may just be a sign of STUDENT’s growing independence. STUDENT has also recently started to urinate on the couch. FATHER believes that unusual home behaviors, such as the urinating, could not be addressed in an after-school setting. FATHER is also concerned that the amount of time that the District is offering - two hours and fifteen minutes - is not enough to address all of the issues that the home program would address. Norma Quintero, the LIFE consultant, testified as to the ongoing need for the home program. Ms. Quintero has been the consultant on STUDENT’s program since October 2000. Ms. Quintero testified that the home program for the 2002-2003 school year should be working on comprehension, theory of mind, language pragmatics, social rules, and pre-teaching. In general, Ms. Quintero stated that she recommended ongoing use of a home program, as opposed to an after-school program, because she believes that it is best to teach new concepts at home first and then to work on generalizing the concepts into other environments, and that any behavioral outbursts are more containable in the home environment. Ms. Quintero stated that it is easier to teach new concepts at home because it is a more familiar environment. However, Ms. Quintero went on to state that STUDENT is generalizing her knowledge very well at this time, so the primary reason to continue the home program is the behavior issue. She also stated that it would be more difficult to address home-specific behaviors, such as the urination problem, in an after-school program, but that it could be done.
Lisa Wiedenfeld testified that she has reviewed Ms. Quintero’s recommendations for the 2002-2003 home program and believes that all of those needs could be addressed in an after-school setting. Ms. Wiedenfeld went on to state that, in her opinion, it would be preferable to address these issues at school rather than at home for a number of reasons. First, there are more resources available at school. Textbooks and other school resources, including the RSP teacher, are more easily utilized at school. STUDENT’s first-grade teacher, her second-grade teacher, and Ms. Sinchek, the speech pathologist, all agreed that it would be better for STUDENT to work on academic issues in an after-school setting rather than at home. In addition, Ms. Wiedenfeld testified that it would be easier to do role playing and peer activities at school because of the availability of other students, even after school. Ms. Wiedenfeld also believed it would be easier for STUDENT to maintain her focus at school because of fewer distractions than at home. In relation to the time necessary to work on the goals, Ms. Wiedenfeld noted that most of the programs Ms. Quintero recommends - comprehension, theory of mind, language pragmatics and social rules - are also being worked on during the school day in class, at recess, and in the speech/language therapy sessions. In addition, both Ms. Wiedenfeld and Ms. Quintero noted that STUDENT had made significant progress on all of her areas of need during the first grade despite only receiving one and one-half hours a week of home instruction. Because of Ms. Wiedenfeld’s extensive experience with STUDENT, her testimony is given great weight.
The Hearing Officer finds that the after-school program offered by the District, in combination with the speech/language therapy and the continued use of a shadow aide, is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of behavior modification, peer socialization, re-teaching of academics, social rules, and non-verbal communication. It may be more difficult to work on some home-specific behaviors at school, but those behaviors can be adequately addressed in an after-school program. Furthermore, the availability of school resources, including the RSP teacher, will allow STUDENT a better opportunity to work on academic issues. Finally, the amount of time recommended, combined with the increased speech/language therapy time, is sufficient to allow STUDENT to receive educational benefit in the areas being addressed. In relation to Ms. Quintero’s concern that it would be easier to contain STUDENT’s behavior at home, there was testimony that containing STUDENT’s occasional outbursts at school had not been a problem in the past. There is no evidence that STUDENT’s behavior will be any less controllable in the future.
The Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offer of extended school day services is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and is reasonably calculated to provide her with educational benefit. The behavior plan.
The District’s proposed behavior plan involves charting targeted behaviors throughout the school day and allowing STUDENT to earn rewards for good behavior during the day. This is the same type of behavior plan that was used during the first grade. It is undisputed that the proposed behavior plan is designed to meet STUDENT’s needs in these areas and is calculated to help STUDENT receive educational benefit from her program.
Case management by an NPA.
It is undisputed that case management services are necessary to ensure that STUDENT’s program is properly implemented and that problems are appropriately addressed. In addition, these services will ensure that STUDENT’s program is not, as the PARENTS contend, a random collection of services. To fulfill these needs, the District proposes to contract with an NPA (specifically Michelle Garcia Winner) for staff in-service training on autism and supervision and consultation on STUDENT’s program. The PARENTS wish the supervision and consultation to continue to be provided by LIFE.
In order to ensure consistency in STUDENT’s program, there needs to be a case manager who is experienced in the design and implementation of educational programs for autistic children. In the past, these services have been provided by LIFE, based in Sacramento.(Footnote 5) The District proposes to now contract with Ms. Winner for these services. There is no dispute over Ms. Winner’s qualifications. However, the PARENTS argue that LIFE is more familiar with STUDENT’s program and that LIFE has been largely responsible for the success STUDENT has achieved. As was the case with the shadow aide, the District has the right to make its own personnel decisions. LIFE and Ms. Quintero have been involved with STUDENT for several years, and STUDENT has made excellent progress over that time. However, Ms. Quintero’s testimony regarding STUDENT’s current abilities conflicted significantly with that of STUDENT’s teachers, speech/language therapist, aide, and the results of the triennial assessments. For example, Ms. Quintero stated that she believed that STUDENT needed pre-teaching to comprehend any reading assignment. Testing and testimony established that STUDENT’s comprehension skills are far above Ms. Quintero’s estimation. In addition, Ms. Quintero was unclear as to the activities that occur in STUDENT’s general education class. Ms. Quintero believed that STUDENT was still involved in carpet time in class, which is not correct. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Quintero is not fully informed as to the nature of STUDENT’s current program or STUDENT’s present levels of performance. Therefore, the District is justified in its decision to contract for case management services with a different agency. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed case management services are designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and are calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.
CONCLUSION
The Hearing Officer finds that the combination of services offered by the District is reasonably designed to meet all of STUDENT’s unique needs, to allow her to be involved with and progress in the general curriculum, and is calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. Testimony established that STUDENT no longer needs the highly structured program such as she received through LIFE. STUDENT’s program has, over the past year, become less structured and more flexible so that it could better react to STUDENT’s changing needs. The current program offered by the District is reasonably designed to continue this evolution. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed program for the 2002-2003 school year is an offer of FAPE.
ORDER
1. The District’s offer of a program for the 2002-2003 school year, as contained in the May 7, 2002 IEP, the July 12, 2002 IEP addendum, and the September 10, 2002 email from Ms. Luks to the PARENTS is an offer of FAPE.
2. All of Respondent’s requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
Has the District offered a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2002-2003 school year?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: November 5, 2002 ____________________________________ Lawrence E. Mendel, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. Lisa Wiedenfeld has been STUDENT’s home program provider since 1999, and continues to provide the home program during the 2002-2003 school year. In addition, Ms. Wiedenfeld shared the shadow aide duties with Abbie Sandborn during the 2001-2002 school year.
2. Ms. Wiedenfeld had returned to school and was no longer available to do the other four days of the home program.
3. The parties agreed that the District’s offer was the combination of these three documents. 4. Ms. Figone is not available to fill this position.
5. Sacramento is over 100 miles from Los Altos.
