California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 3, 2003

Temecula Valley Unified School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 1996-03 · Hearing Officer Lawrence E. Mendel

Temecula Valley Unified's 2003-2004 IEP denied FAPE over deficient goals and speech services; middle school placement upheld.

Split decision: student prevailed on 6 of 11 issues (4 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

Temecula Valley Unified School District filed for a hearing to defend its 2003-2004 IEP offer for a 13-year-old with a seizure disorder, ADHD, and mental retardation (now called intellectual disability). Her mother had placed her at a small private school in San Diego. The District offered a special day class (SDC) at Temecula Middle School. The offer included speech-language therapy, occupational therapy, adapted physical education, and a one-on-one aide.

The Hearing Officer found that the notice for the August 2003 IEP meeting was adequate. However, the District's academic testing (the Brigance) was not given according to the publisher's instructions. The District still identified the student's needs correctly, and the present levels were acceptable. Four goals were inappropriate: math, coin values, a three-step household task, and general education PE. Three of these set skills the student could already do. The IEP also had no adequate goals for receptive, expressive, and pragmatic language, self-advocacy, or gross motor skills. Weekly speech-language therapy was too little to meet all of her language needs. The SRA reading program was acceptable only with workbook modifications that the IEP left out.

The Hearing Officer upheld the SDC placement at the large middle school with a full-year aide, including a home economics elective, as appropriate and as the least restrictive environment. The District was ordered to hold an IEP meeting within 30 days and amend its offer to match the findings.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO reviewed an offer goal by goal. Goals setting skills the student had already mastered were found inappropriate, and missing goals for identified needs led to a FAPE denial. The Hearing Officer still upheld a large-campus placement with an aide as the least restrictive environment. Goals were judged on what the team knew at the meeting, including what the parent did or did not tell it.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue 1. Did the District offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year?

    The District's combined June 10/June 18/August 20, 2003 IEP did not offer a FAPE because of deficient goals, too little speech-language service, and missing reading modifications.

  2. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1a. Did the District provide adequate notice for the August 20, 2003 IEP meeting?

    The notice ('plan for student's return to the public placement') and cover letter inviting other concerns were broad enough to cover adding a goal and filling in target dates.

  3. Student prevailedAssessment

    Issue 1b. Did the District conduct appropriate assessments (academic achievement)?

    The Brigance was not given per the publisher's instructions: there were interruptions, and the student did not read the comprehension passages aloud. The academic assessment was therefore improper.

  4. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 1c. Did the District identify STUDENT's unique needs?

    The District correctly identified all nine areas of unique need. No need in anger management or aggression was shown.

  5. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 1d. Did the IEP lack accurate present levels of performance?

    Present levels were adequate because they included the teacher's and private teacher's input, though the math goal ignored the private teacher's information.

  6. Student prevailed in partIEP content

    Issue 1e. Were the goals and objectives appropriate?

    Goals 5 (math), 8 (coins), 10 (three-step task), and 14 (general PE) were inappropriate. There were no or inadequate goals for receptive, expressive, and pragmatic language, self-advocacy, and gross motor skills. The remaining goals were appropriate.

  7. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1f. Did the District's offer contain all of the necessary related services (counseling and social skills)?

    Counseling was not needed, and the SDC curriculum addressed self-advocacy. However, weekly 53-minute speech-language service was not enough to meet all of the student's language needs.

  8. Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1g. Was the District's offer of placement (SDC at Temecula Middle School, elective, PE, aide) appropriate?

    The SDC at Temecula Middle School with a full-year aide, a sensory diet, and a home economics elective was appropriate. The general education PE class was not.

  9. District prevailedCurriculum

    Issue 1h. Did the District's offer provide for the student to be involved and progress in the general curriculum?

    The functional academics (Bridges) program met the student's need for meaningful instruction and gave her access to the general curriculum.

  10. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1i. Was the District's offer calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit (SRA reading program)?

    The SRA method was acceptable. However, it was not calculated to provide benefit without the needed modifications: covering workbook pages, reducing written work, and extra time.

  11. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1j. Was the District's offer of placement in the least restrictive environment?

    An SDC on a general education campus with an aide was the LRE. The student's discomfort with an aide did not justify a small private school.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. District shall convene an IEP meeting within 30 days of the decision and amend its offer of placement to conform to the findings in the decision.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range; Adams v. State of Oregon; Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education; Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Polk v. Central Susquehanna; Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist.; Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm.; Honig v. Doe

People named in the decision

  • Deborah Miller, director of special education, Temecula Valley Unified School District
  • Christine Fonseca, school psychologist, Temecula Valley Unified School District
  • Ruben Castellano, special day class teacher; administered Brigance, Temecula Valley Unified School District
  • Kay Bussell, school nurse, Temecula Valley Unified School District
  • Casey Goad, teacher, Temecula Valley Unified School District
  • Pamela Metzger, speech-language therapist, Temecula Valley Unified School District
  • Carissa Chinn, occupational therapist, Temecula Valley Unified School District
  • Ronald Plotner, adapted physical education specialist, Temecula Valley Unified School District
  • Jeffrey Owen, licensed clinical psychologist and certified school psychologist, District witness
  • Troy Knudsvig, program specialist, Temecula Valley Unified School District
  • Nanci Engle, educational therapist; owner of Banyan Tree Learning Center and former owner of Banyan Tree School, Banyan Tree
  • Kathleen Kasar, private occupational therapist, Banyan Tree School
  • Debra Barnett, private speech-language pathologist, Banyan Tree School
  • Upham, private school teacher, Banyan Tree School
  • Sierra Academy (formerly Banyan Tree School), private school (unilateral placement), San Diego
  • Lindamood Bell, private summer program provider

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Lawrence E. Mendel, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Temecula, California, on October 14, 15, 16, 21, and 22, 2003.

The Temecula Valley Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Diane Willis. Also present on the District’s behalf at times during the hearing were Christopher Keeler, attorney; Peter Sansom, attorney; Lauri Lafoe, attorney; and Deborah Miller, director of special education. STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Eric Freedus. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was her mother, MOTHER.

The following witnesses were called to testify at the hearing: Christine Fonseca, school psychologist; Ruben Castellano, teacher; Kay Bussell, school nurse; Casey Goad, teacher; Pamela Metzger, speech/language therapist; Carissa Chinn, occupational therapist; Ronald Plotner, adapted physical education specialist; MOTHER, mother; Jeffrey Owen, psychologist; Troy Knudsvig, program specialist; Nanci Engle, educational therapist; Kathleen Kasar, occupational therapist; and Debra Barnett, speech/language pathologist.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following the submission of written closing arguments the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUE

Did the District offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The Student contends that the District failed to adhere to all of the procedural safeguards set forth in the IDEA and failed to make an offer that was substantively appropriate.

Procedurally, the Student contends that her parents were not given adequate notice of the August 20, 2003 IEP meeting. As a result, it is alleged that MOTHER was prevented from participation in the IEP process.

Substantively, the Student makes several arguments. First, the Student contends that the District failed to appropriately assess her academic achievement because the District’s assessor did not conduct testing in conformity with the instructions provided by the producer of the test. The Student also contends that the District’s offer of placement for the 2003-2004 school year was not designed to meet her unique needs because: 1) the IEP lacked accurate present levels of performance, 2) the goals and objectives were not appropriate to meet all of STUDENT’s unique needs, 3) needed related services were not offered in the areas of counseling and social skills, and 4) the location of the placement, on the Temecula Middle School campus, was inappropriate because the campus was too large, was unsafe, and the instructional aide was only offered for the first thirty days. In addition, the Student contends that the offered general education physical education and home economics classes were not appropriate for STUDENT.

The Student also contends that the program lacked sufficient academics for STUDENT to progress in the general curriculum and that the offered reading program was not calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. Finally, the Student contends that the District’s offer of placement was not in the least restrictive environment.

The District contends that it did give MOTHER adequate notice of the August 20, 2003 IEP meeting. In addition, the District contends that its offer of placement for the 2003-2004 school year was an offer of a free and appropriate public education. The District argues that any deficiencies in its IEP were the result of MOTHER’s failure to provide input during the June 18, 2003 IEP meeting.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a thirteen-year-old student who is eligible for special education and related services as a child with a seizure disorder, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, and mental retardation. STUDENT lives within the boundaries of the Temecula Valley Unified School District (District) but currently attends the Sierra Academy (formerly known as the Banyan Tree School), a small private school located in San Diego.

STUDENT has been eligible for special education since 1992. She and her family moved to Temecula in 1995. STUDENT attended the District’s Vail Elementary School from 1998-2002. For the 2002-2003 school year STUDENT was unilaterally placed at the Banyan Tree School, a private school approximately forty-five miles from Temecula. In April 2003, the parties entered into a settlement agreement that called for the District to conduct new assessments of STUDENT and to convene an IEP meeting for the purpose of making an offer of placement for the 2003-2004 school year.

In May 2003, the District assessed STUDENT in the areas of cognitive functioning, academic achievement, perceptual-motor development, speech/language, occupational therapy, adapted physical education, social/emotional behavior, self-help, and health and development.

The District’s assessment team concluded from the testing that STUDENT’s composite IQ score was 42, placing her in the deficient range. She struggled in the areas of planning and successive processing, and demonstrated problems with distractibility. STUDENT’s non-verbal reasoning skills were in the borderline to low average range. However, STUDENT demonstrated relative strengths in the areas of attention and simultaneous processing, and did significantly better with more meaningful visual information as opposed to abstract information. STUDENT’s general memory was in the deficient range, but her memory for visual information was slightly better than her memory for verbal information. Furthermore, STUDENT’s test scores indicated that she benefited from repeated exposure to information, regardless of the mode of presentation.

Academically, STUDENT’s reading, writing and math skills were all at the pre-primer to first grade level. STUDENT also had difficulty with functional math, including being able to state her date of birth, address, and phone number.

STUDENT’s language scores were, overall, in the very poor to extremely low range across all areas. On the listening comprehension and the oral expression subtests STUDENT’s scores were in the extremely low range. STUDENT also demonstrated poor to very poor expressive and receptive vocabulary and her grammar skills were fair to poor. STUDENT’s receptive language skills were at the simple, concrete conversational level. STUDENT was able to engage in simple, meaningful conversation, utilizing non-verbal communication as well. However, her communication was not consistently appropriate. At times, STUDENT needed to be prompted to initiate conversation, and was inconsistent in answering who, what, when, where, why, and how questions. STUDENT’s conversational skills needed improvement, especially in the areas of turn taking, topic maintenance, and elaboration.

STUDENT’s ability to accurately interpret visual information was in the very low range and she demonstrated low motor coordination skills. However, STUDENT was using an appropriate grasp for writing, and her writing was legible. STUDENT’s letter formation was clear but large, but she required more time to complete handwritten tasks. Her handwriting legibility was impacted when she had to recall letters or numbers from memory.

STUDENT also displayed difficulty with sensory processing in various areas. She had difficulty with auditory processing, multi-sensory processing, and modulation of sensory input. STUDENT’s gross motor performance demonstrated needs in the areas of speed, agility, balance, strength, and bilateral coordination. STUDENT’s gross motor strength was in the area of upper limb coordination.

Testing indicated that STUDENT had significant needs in the areas of communication, home living, community use and functional academics. STUDENT also demonstrated needs in social skills and self-direction. In addition, STUDENT’s adaptive functioning was rated in the low range. STUDENT continued to have seizures approximately every six to eight weeks. Otherwise, STUDENT is in good health.

The first IEP team meeting was held on June 10, 2003. MOTHER attended this meeting accompanied by her educational advocate. District personnel reviewed the results of their assessments. Mrs. Upham, STUDENT’s teacher at Banyan Tree, participated by telephone and reviewed STUDENT’s current levels of performance and the program at Banyan Tree. Draft goals and objectives were presented but not reviewed in detail because the meeting had to be concluded before the IEP was completed. The team agreed to reconvene on June 18th.

On June 18, 2003, the IEP team reconvened to complete the IEP. Goals in the areas of reading, writing, math, transition skills, mobility, money skills, calendar skills, sequencing, occupational therapy, and adapted physical education were reviewed. Several of the goals were modified by the team. The District offered placement at the Temecula Middle School in a special day class (SDC) with speech/language, occupational therapy, and adapted physical education services. The District also offered an instructional aide to assist STUDENT in class and with moving between classes. In addition, the team discussed the need for a transition program to assist STUDENT with the transition from a small private school to the middle school. The District offered a summer session program during the 2003 summer, with the support of an instructional aide, to facilitate STUDENT’s transition. The team also discussed the need for additional assessments in pragmatic language, vision therapy, and assistive technology. An assessment plan was developed in these areas and signed by MOTHER. At the conclusion of the meeting MOTHER signed the IEP indicating that she had attended the meeting, but was not agreeing to the District’s offer. MOTHER testified that she wished to take some additional time to consider the District’s offer.

MOTHER decided not to enroll STUDENT in the summer program at Temecula Middle School because STUDENT was already enrolled in a summer program at Lindamood Bell. On July 31, the District wrote to MOTHER, summarizing the offer of placement and notifying her that it needed to convene another IEP meeting to develop a new plan for transitioning STUDENT into the middle school. The District proposed IEP meeting times on August 8 and August 11. By letter dated August 8, 2003, MOTHER’s attorney informed the District that MOTHER was rejecting the District’s offer of placement and would be placing STUDENT at Banyan Tree for the 2003-2004 school year. The District’s proposed IEP team meeting on August 8 or 11 did not occur. On August 13, the District informed MOTHER, through her attorney, that it intended to hold an IEP team meeting to develop a transition plan for STUDENT and to address any other concerns regarding the June IEPs. On August 15, the District sent MOTHER an invitation to an August 20 IEP team meeting.

The IEP team meeting was held on August 20, 2003. MOTHER did not attend the IEP meeting. The team developed a plan to assist STUDENT with her transition to Temecula Middle School. The plan called for an aide to assist STUDENT in her general education classes, lunch, breaks, and during class-to-class transitions. The IEP team also developed an additional goal in the area of written language and filled in target dates for the objectives in several of the goals (the target dates had been left blank in the June 10 / June 18 IEP). The combined June 10, June 18, August 20 IEP was sent to MOTHER on September 5, 2003.

During September, the District sent several letters to MOTHER’s attorney regarding completing the assessments MOTHER had agreed to on June 18. Through the commencement of the hearing in this case, the assessments had not been conducted.

STUDENT is currently enrolled in and attending the Sierra Academy (formerly Banyan Tree). The District filed this case on September 19, 2003.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a child at no charge to his or her parent or guardian, meet the standards of the State educational agency, include appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education, and are provided in conformity with an IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). Such special education and related services must be tailored to meet the unique needs of the child with a disability by means of an IEP. Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16 853 F.2d 171, 173 (1988). The IEP, which is the “centerpiece of the [IDEA’s] education delivery system for disabled children,” consists of a detailed written statement that must be developed, reviewed, and revised for each child with a disability. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343, 56345; Honig v. Doe 484 U.S. 305 (1988). The IEP must include a statement of the student’s present levels of performance, goals and objectives, special education and related services, and program modifications or supports for school personnel that are to be provided to meet the child’s needs resulting from his or her disability to enable the child to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum and be educated and participate with non-disabled children to the maximum extent possible. Id.; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56031, 56345.

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that a child’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the child with some educational benefit to satisfy the IDEA, but that the school district is not required to provide the child with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court held that a school district is required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child. Id. at 201. Consequently, an appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the child. Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S. 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996). De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist. 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2nd Cir. 1997).

In addition to these requirements, special education law also requires that a child with a disability be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A). This statute requires that students with disabilities be educated with children who are not disabled to the maximum extent possible.

The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. 458 U.S. at 205. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he or she is entitled, and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range, 960 F.2d at 1483; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm. 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).

In summary, under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley the proposed educational program must: 1) be designed to meet the student’s unique needs, 2) provide for the student to be involved and progress in the general curriculum and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities, 3) be calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, 4) be provided in a manner that conforms with the student’s IEP, and 5) be in the least restrictive environment. IEP. 20 U.S.C. §1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer must consider whether the necessary procedural requirements were followed. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-207. In this case, the District’s offer was never implemented; therefore, the fourth factor requiring the program to be provided in conformity with the IEP need not be addressed.

The District’s offer is contained in the IEP that was drafted over the team meetings held on June 10, June 18 and August 20, 2003. The District offered placement at the Temecula Middle School in a special day class (SDC) with speech/language, occupational therapy, and adapted physical education services. The District also offered an instructional aide to assist STUDENT in class and with moving between classes.

The student contends that the District failed to make an appropriate offer, both substantively and procedurally. The procedural objection will be addressed first.

Did the District Provide Adequate Notice for the August 20, 2003 IEP Meeting?

The Student alleges that she was denied the opportunity to participate in the August 20, 2003 IEP team meeting because the District’s notice of the IEP meeting only indicated that a transition plan would be developed and did not state that new goals and objectives would be considered. On August 15, 2003, the District wrote to MOTHER that the District was convening an IEP meeting to discuss STUDENT’s transition from Banyan Tree to Temecula Middle School. The letter also stated that the team would discuss any other concerns that MOTHER may have had regarding STUDENT’s program. The IEP notice form, sent with the August 15 cover letter, stated that the purpose of the IEP meeting was to plan for the student’s return to a public school placement. MOTHER did not attend the IEP meeting. At the IEP meeting the team developed a plan for helping STUDENT transition from Banyan Tree to the middle school. The team also drafted one additional goal in the area of written language and filled in target dates for several goals and objectives that had been left blank at the conclusion of the June 18 IEP team meeting. MOTHER testified that she did not attend the August 20 IEP meeting because she understood that the purpose of the meeting was solely the development of a transition plan.

California Education Code section 56341.5 states that the notice of an IEP meeting shall indicate the purpose, time, and location of the meeting. However, there is no requirement that the notice set forth each and every action and discussion that may take place at the meeting. The notice in this case stated, “Plan for student’s return to the public placement.” In addition, the cover letter stated that the IEP team would discuss any other concerns raised about STUDENT’s program. This description, in combination with the cover letter, was sufficiently broad to include drafting one additional goal and filling in the target dates on several other goals. These actions can fairly be interpreted to fall within the District’s notice to MOTHER of the purpose of the IEP meeting. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s notice of the August 20, 2003 IEP was adequate.

Did the District Conduct Appropriate Assessments?

Special education law requires that a district’s assessment of a student meet certain requirements. These requirements include, but are not limited to, the following:

(a) Testing and assessment materials and procedures used for the purposes of assessment and placement of individuals with exceptional needs are selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory.

(b) Tests and other assessment materials meet all the following requirements:

(1) Are provided and administered in the pupil's primary language or other mode of communication, unless the assessment plan indicates reasons why this provision and administration are not clearly feasible.

(2) Have been validated for the specific purpose for which they are used.

(3) Are administered by trained personnel in conformance with the instructions provided by the producer of the tests and other assessment materials, except that individually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning shall be administered by a credentialed school psychologist. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320

In this case, the only dispute is in relation to the District’s assessment of STUDENT’s academic achievement. The Student contends that the District’s assessment of STUDENT’s academic achievement was not appropriate because the test was not administered in conformance with the instructions provided by the producer of the test.

To assess STUDENT’s academic achievement Mr. Castellano, one of the District’s special day class teachers, administered the Brigance to STUDENT. STUDENT had been sick the week the testing was done. In addition, the academic testing was late in the day, and STUDENT had told Mr. Castellano that she was tired and did not want to do any more tests that day. Mr. Castellano also testified that there were numerous interruptions during his testing and he had had to change locations because of the distractions. Mr. Castellano also stated that STUDENT had not been willing to read out loud the reading comprehension passages of the Brigance.

At the hearing, Mr. Castellano testified that the Brigance should be given in a quiet environment without interruptions. Mr. Castellano stated that too many distractions or interruptions could lower a student’s score. In addition, Mr. Castellano testified that the publisher’s instructions for the Brigance require that students read out loud the reading comprehension portion of the Brigance. Mr. Castellano explained that, because STUDENT had not read out loud, he could not judge her fluency, nor could he tell if she was actually reading the passages.

On the basis of Mr. Castellano’s testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not appropriately assess STUDENT in the area of academic achievement. The District’s assessment was not conducted in conformance with the instructions provided by the producer of the test.

Was the District’s Offer Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?

Did the District identify STUDENT’s unique needs?

The next step in determining if the District’s offer was a FAPE, is to determine the Student’s unique needs. Although there is little dispute on this issue, in order to evaluate the District’s offer, it is helpful to review STUDENT’s unique needs.

The results of the District’s testing revealed that STUDENT had impairments in numerous areas of cognitive functioning, especially in the areas of planning and successive reasoning. STUDENT also had significant difficulty learning and retaining information. In addition, STUDENT had impaired visual and auditory processing, although her visual processing was somewhat stronger than her auditory processing. Testing indicated that STUDENT learned best when information was presented in a simple, concise, concrete manner. STUDENT also required multiple repetitions before she was able to learn new information. Furthermore, STUDENT performed significantly better when information was presented in a manner meaningful to her, as opposed to learning more abstract information.

On the basis of these findings, the District’s assessment team recommended that STUDENT receive instruction in a small group setting where the information was presented in a simple, concise, concrete manner, with multiple repetitions. In addition the team recommended that multi-modal instruction be utilized, and that STUDENT be provided visual reinforcement for all auditory information. Because STUDENT responded better to information that was meaningful to her, the District recommended that she be enrolled in a program that emphasized functional academics. To help STUDENT compensate for her impaired visual and verbal processing, it was recommended that distracting auditory and visual stimuli be reduced.

The results of the District’s testing, the information provided to the IEP team by Ms. Upham, the testimony of STUDENT’s mother, and the testimony of Nanci Engle were all in agreement that STUDENT had significant academic needs in reading, writing, and mathematics. Academically, STUDENT was only performing at the first to second grade level at best. In some areas, such as reading comprehension, she was at a pre-first-grade level.

Both the District’s testing and the testimony of Debra Barnett, the speech pathologist from Banyan Tree, established that STUDENT had significant needs in receptive, expressive, and pragmatic language. STUDENT tested in the very poor to extremely low range across all areas. STUDENT’s needs included listening comprehension, oral expression, expressive and receptive vocabulary, grammar, and conversational skills.

In the area of occupational therapy, STUDENT demonstrated impaired fine motor skills, poor seated posture, and impaired sensory processing. STUDENT needed to improve her writing skills, improve her posture while sitting, and to engage in sensory activities prior to being asked to engage in tabletop or fine motor activities.

STUDENT also demonstrated gross motor needs. On testing, STUDENT scored low in all areas, including speed, agility, balance, strength, and bilateral coordination. Carissa Chinn, the District’s occupational therapist; Ronald Plotner, the District’s adapted physical education specialist; and Kathleen Kasar, STUDENT’s occupational therapist at Banyan Tree all agreed that STUDENT needed services to help her improve her gross motor functioning in these areas.

In the social/emotional area, testimony and testing revealed that STUDENT needed to improve her self-advocacy and self-help skills.

It was also undisputed that, because the District was proposing to transition STUDENT from a small private school to a much larger middle school campus, STUDENT would need specialized services to help her with the transition to the much larger school environment.

STUDENT also had a history of seizures. MOTHER testified that, over the last three years, STUDENT had approximately one seizure at school each year. It was undisputed that STUDENT’s program would need to include an emergency medical plan setting forth the procedure for dealing with a seizure.

The above needs were all undisputed and were all identified by the District. There was also testimony that STUDENT had difficulty with anger management and aggressive behavior when she started at Banyan Tree in 2002. To address this, Banyan Tree had been providing STUDENT with individual and small group counseling. However, testimony established that in June 2003 STUDENT was no longer exhibiting those behaviors. Although there was speculation that those types of behaviors might reemerge if STUDENT was transferred to a large middle school environment, there was no evidence that supported this speculation. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not have a need related to anger management or aggressive behavior.

Based upon the District’s testing, the testimony of the witnesses, and the record as a whole, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT had the following unique needs:

1. STUDENT needed a placement in a small, structured class with information presented in a simple, concise, concrete manner, with multiple repetitions. Instruction should utilize multiple modalities, and emphasize STUDENT’s relative strength in visual processing. Distracting auditory and visual stimuli should be minimized. Academics should be taught utilizing a functional, rather than an abstract, curriculum.

2. STUDENT needed remedial instruction in reading, writing and mathematics.

3. STUDENT needed services to address her deficiencies in receptive, expressive, and pragmatic language.

4. STUDENT needed services to address her impaired fine motor skills and her impaired sensory processing. STUDENT also needed to address her poor seated posture.

5. STUDENT needed services to address her needs in relation to her gross motor deficits. STUDENT had deficits in speed, strength, agility, balance and bilateral coordination.

6. STUDENT needed services to improve her social skills, particularly her communication skills and self-advocacy.

7. STUDENT needed services to address her need to improve her self-help skills.

8. STUDENT needed an emergency medical plan to address the possibility of seizures.

9. STUDENT needed a transition plan to help her transition from a small private school to a much larger public school.

Did the District’s offer meet STUDENT unique needs?

The Student makes several specific arguments regarding how the District’s offer failed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The Student alleges: 1) the IEP lacked accurate present levels of performance, 2) the goals and objectives were not appropriate to meet all of STUDENT’s unique needs, 3) needed related services were not offered in the areas of counseling and social skills, and 4) the placement at Temecula Middle School was inappropriate.

1. Did the IEP lack accurate present levels of performance?

As set forth earlier, one of the requirements of an IEP is that it contains a statement of the student’s present levels of performance. One of the primary purposes of this requirement is to establish a baseline for the development of the student’s goals and objectives.

STUDENT’s IEP contained present levels of performance in the areas of communication, reading, written expression, math, health, behavior, daily living skills, fine and gross motor, and social emotional. The dispute in this case involves the present levels in reading, written expression and math. The present levels in these areas were derived primarily from Mr. Castellano’s administration of the Brigance, but also contained information provided by Ms. Upham, STUDENT’s teacher at Banyan Tree, and by MOTHER.

It has already been established that Mr. Castellano failed to properly administer the Brigance. Despite this failure, the evidence established that Mr. Castellano’s assessment of STUDENT’s academic present levels of performance was accurate except in the area of mathematics.

In reading, Mr. Castellano concluded that STUDENT’s recognition of sight words and functional community words was at an age equivalent of 6.3 to 7 years of age. He also concluded that her reading comprehension was at the preprimer level. Ms. Upham told the IEP team that STUDENT’s overall reading ability was at the 1.3 grade level. Ms. Upham reported that STUDENT’s fluency and comprehension were at the .8 grade equivalent and that STUDENT’s decoding and encoding skills were at the 2.2 grade equivalent. Ms. Engle, the owner of the Banyan Tree Learning Center and former owner of the Banyan Tree School testified that Ms. Upham’s information was basically consistent with the scores from the Brigance. The IEP listed STUDENT’s scores from both Mr. Castellano and Ms. Upham in the present levels of performance section.

In the area of written expression, Mr. Castellano found that STUDENT could write her first and last name and the letters of the alphabet, though the order of some of the letters was incorrect. He also concluded that STUDENT could not capitalize and punctuate a sentence. Ms. Upham informed the IEP team that STUDENT’s spelling was at the 1.3 grade equivalent. Testimony established that Ms. Upham’s information was consistent with Mr. Castellano’s information. Again, the IEP listed the scores provided by both Mr. Castellano and Ms. Upham.

In the area of mathematics, Mr. Castellano concluded that STUDENT could not consistently add or subtract one digit numbers. Ms. Upham informed the IEP team that STUDENT could add and subtract two digit numbers without regrouping using the “touch math” method. (Footnote 1) These two reports are completely inconsistent. As with the reading and written expression sections, both Mr. Castellano’s and Ms. Upham’s information was listed on the IEP.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s IEP met the technical requirement in relation to present levels of performance because it reflected not just the results of the District’s assessment, but also the input from Ms. Upham and from MOTHER. Unfortunately, the goal in mathematics was written based solely on the results of Mr. Castellano’s testing, without considering Ms. Upham’s or MOTHER’s input. This resulted in an inappropriate mathematics goal, which will be discussed in the next section.

2. Were the goals and objectives appropriate?

An IEP must contain measurable annual goals and objectives that are related to meeting the student’s needs that result from his or her disability. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345. STUDENT’s IEP contained a total of fifteen annual goals. Student is contesting all but three of the goals.

The first two goals were almost identical: goal one requiring STUDENT to orally read forty community functional words with 80% accuracy, and goal two requiring STUDENT to orally read 20 supermarket aisle words with 80% accuracy. Testimony established that these goals addressed STUDENT expressive language, vocabulary, and encoding and decoding skills. Mr. Castellano testified that the baseline for these goals was based upon the results of the Brigance.

At the hearing, MOTHER testified that, as to the supermarket aisle words, STUDENT was already able to accomplish that goal. MOTHER also testified that she did not share that information with the IEP team during the June 18 meeting. The appropriateness of an IEP is judged based upon the information reasonably available to the IEP team at the time of the meeting, not on the basis of new information that comes to light after the IEP has been drafted. Adams v. State of Oregon 195 F. 3d 1141 (9th Cir. 1999). The only way this particular information was available to the IEP team was through the parent. MOTHER was at the IEP meeting and participated in discussions about the goals and objectives. It was reasonable for the other team members to assume that, if STUDENT could already accomplish a goal, MOTHER would have spoken up and said so at the meeting. Therefore, based upon the information reasonably available to the IEP team at the time of the meeting, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals related to vocabulary were appropriate.

Goal number three called for STUDENT to participate in a small group reading program and to increase one level from the baseline. The IEP called for the use of the SRA reading program to accomplish this goal. Mr. Castellano testified that the baseline in the SRA program would be established at the start of school. Mr. Castellano and Mr. Knudsvig, the District’s program specialist, testified that the SRA program addresses phonics, sight words, comprehension and fluency in a sequential manner. It was uncontested that these were areas of need for STUDENT in relation to her reading deficits. The Student’s dispute as to this goal is that the goal covers too many areas and should be broken down into separate goals. The Hearing Officer finds that this goal is appropriate as written. The fact that several areas of need are covered in a single goal does not make the goal inappropriate. A goal need only be drafted to address an area of need, and be measurable. There is no requirement that a goal be broken down to a separate goal for each skill addressed. Furthermore, this goal is measurable. If STUDENT is able to progress as set forth in the benchmarks then both the teacher and the parents will know that she is making progress in this area of need. If STUDENT does not progress, then it will be apparent that the goal needs to be revised.

Goal number four addresses STUDENT’s writing skills and self help skills. It requires STUDENT to correctly write down her full name, phone number, and complete date of birth. It was uncontested that these were appropriate subject matters for STUDENT. The primary contention is that the objectives should break the goal down differently, focusing on name, then phone number, then date of birth. The Hearing Officer finds that this goal is appropriate as written. It addresses an area of unique need and is measurable. The fact that it could have been measured differently does not make the goal inappropriate.

The fifth goal addresses STUDENT’s need in mathematics. The goal calls for STUDENT to add two one-digit numbers. As set forth earlier, STUDENT could already do this. It was discussed at the June 18 IEP meeting that STUDENT could add and subtract two digit numbers using “touch math.” It was undisputed that “touch math” is an appropriate teaching method, and is used in the District. There was no explanation given as to why the IEP team ignored this information and adopted a goal that significantly understated STUDENT’s current abilities. The Hearing Officer finds that this goal is not appropriate to meet STUDENT’s unique needs because it calls for STUDENT to perform tasks that she could already perform.

Goal number six requires STUDENT to recognize class/time changes by the bell or clock for the purpose of making independent transitions. Testimony received at the hearing established that STUDENT could already accomplish this goal. However, when this goal was discussed at the June 18 IEP meeting, MOTHER did not share this information with the IEP team. As with the present levels of performance, there was no way for the IEP team to know that STUDENT could accomplish this goal without input from MOTHER. The Hearing Officer finds that this goal was appropriate based upon the information reasonably available to the IEP team at the time that the goal was drafted.

Goal number seven requires STUDENT to demonstrate the ability to navigate the campus independently. This goal addresses STUDENT’s needs for services to assist her transition to a middle school campus. It was undisputed that this was a need of STUDENT’s. The Hearing Officer finds this goal is appropriate and measurable.

The eighth goal requires STUDENT to identify the value of coins. Testimony at the hearing as well as the District’s triennial assessment report both establish that STUDENT could already perform this task. The District’s assessment report states that, “she can state the value of a penny, nickel, dime, and quarter as well as discriminate between bills of different denomination.” No explanation was offered as to why this information was not considered when this goal was drafted and reviewed by the IEP team. The Hearing Officer finds that this goal is not appropriate to meet STUDENT’s unique needs because it calls for STUDENT to perform tasks that she could already perform.

The ninth goal requires STUDENT to read the days of the week, know the day and date, and know the days and dates for yesterday, tomorrow and days of the weekend. Testimony established that this goal addressed expressive language skills, daily living skills, and understanding concepts such as yesterday and tomorrow. It was undisputed that the skills addressed by this goal were appropriate for STUDENT. It was also undisputed that the goal was measurable. The Hearing Officer finds that this goal is appropriate to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

Goal ten required STUDENT to verbally sequence and carry out a simple three-step household task. The District’s speech therapist stated that the goal addressed sequencing, expressive language, and daily-living skills. It was undisputed that the verbal sequencing aspect of the goal was appropriate for STUDENT; however, testimony and the District assessment report established that STUDENT could already accomplish the physical aspects of this goal. The District assessment report contains detailed descriptions of STUDENT’s ability to perform numerous multi-step household tasks, including picking up her room, meal preparation, simple repairs, and clearing and setting the table. The Hearing Officer finds that this goal is not appropriate because it calls for STUDENT to perform tasks that she could already perform.

Goals eleven, twelve, and thirteen are occupational therapy goals. There is no dispute regarding the appropriateness of these goals.

Goal fourteen is an adapted physical education goal. It calls for STUDENT to participate in a general physical education class five days a week. The objectives call for STUDENT to work toward this goal by beginning with STUDENT primarily in an adapted physical education class and progressively transitioning into the general education class. The Student’s contention regarding this goal is that participation in a general education class was not appropriate for STUDENT. The general education PE class at Temecula Middle School contains approximately sixty students. The District’s offer proposed that STUDENT would be able to participate in that class with the assistance of a one-on-one aide. The only evidence regarding STUDENT’s ability to participate in such a class was a brief observation of STUDENT playing two-on-two basketball. However, the District’s assessment established that STUDENT had significant gross motor impairments in all areas tested. Ms. Kasar, STUDENT’s occupational therapist at Banyan Tree, testified that a large general education PE class would be overwhelming for STUDENT due to STUDENT’s gross-motor and sensory processing impairments. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Kasar’s testimony persuasive based upon her experience working with STUDENT. The ability to participate in two-on-two basketball is not comparable to participation in a large general education PE class, even with the participation of an aide. Given the severity of STUDENT’s gross motor impairments combined with her sensory processing impairments, the Hearing Officer finds that placement of STUDENT in a general education PE class, even on a gradual basis, is not calculated to meet STUDENT’s adapted physical education needs. The Hearing Officer finds that this goal is not appropriate for STUDENT.

Goal number fifteen is a written language goal. It called for STUDENT to construct a three to four-sentence writing sample using correct spelling and punctuation. This goal addressed STUDENT fine motor, punctuation, and spelling skills. It was undisputed that these were all areas of need for STUDENT. The only dispute regarding this goal was that it was drafted at the August 20 IEP meeting without the parent present. The Hearing Officer has already found that the District’s notice for the August 20 IEP meeting was adequate. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that this goal is an appropriate goal.

On the basis of the foregoing analysis, the Hearing Officer finds that goals five, eight, ten, and fourteen were not calculated to meet STUDENT’s needs in the areas addressed. In addition, there were several areas of need that were not addressed, or inadequately addressed, by the District’s goals and objectives. These areas are speech/language, social/emotional, and gross motor.

Ms. Barnett, STUDENT speech pathologist at Banyan Tree, testified that the District’s goals only addressed expressive language directly in goals nine and ten, and indirectly in goals one and two. However, none of these goals addressed organizing and sequencing a narrative. Furthermore, she stated that there were no receptive language goals. There were no goals addressing oral comprehension, memory, recalling information, or semantics. It was undisputed that all of these were areas of need within the broad category of receptive language. On the basis of Ms. Barnett’s experience working with STUDENT, and the results of the District’s assessment, the Hearing Officer finds Ms. Barnett’s testimony persuasive. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to draft goals in the areas of receptive and expressive language. In addition, there were no goals in the area of pragmatic language. The District argued that it did not draft a pragmatic language goal because it intended to perform an additional assessment in this area during the first 30 days of school. This may have been reasonable in June; however, by August 20, the date of the final IEP meeting, the District was aware that STUDENT would not be attending Temecula Middle School. The District’s own assessment identified pragmatic language as an area of need. Upon review of this assessment and considering Ms. Barnett’s testimony on this issue, the Hearing Officer finds that there was sufficient information available for the District to have drafted a goal in this area. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to draft a goal to address STUDENT’s need in the area of pragmatic language.

In relation to social/emotional, it was undisputed that STUDENT had a need to improve her self-advocacy. No goal was drafted to address this need. There was also no goal to address STUDENT’s gross motor needs. Mr. Plotner, the District adapted physical education specialist, testified that STUDENT had significant needs in relation to her gross motor skills. He also stated that the one goal he drafted was not a gross motor goal. Although STUDENT’s gross motor skills may have been addressed by her participation in adapted physical education and regular physical education classes, the District was still required to draft a goal in this area. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to draft any goals to address STUDENT’s needs in the areas of self-advocacy and gross motor functioning.

In summary, the District failed to draft appropriate goals in the areas of mathematics, money skills, daily living skills (carrying out a three-step household task), and adapted physical education. In addition, the District failed to draft goals to adequately address STUDENT’s expressive, receptive and pragmatic needs. Finally, the District failed to draft any goals to address STUDENT’s needs to improve her self-advocacy and gross-motor functioning.

3. Did the District’s offer contain all of the necessary related services?

The Student contends that the District’s offer failed to contain necessary related services in counseling and social skills. Education Code section 56363(a) provides that designated instruction and services (California’s term for related services) shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” The District offered speech/language services once a week for fifty-three minutes, occupational therapy services twice a week for thirty minutes each session, and one period of adapted physical education three times a week.

The Hearing Officer has already found that STUDENT did not have any unique needs in the area of anger management and aggressive behavior. However, it has been established that STUDENT had a unique need to improve her self-advocacy and social communication skills. Mr. Castellano testified that his SDC class incorporates social skills training as part of the regular curriculum. Mr. Castellano’s testimony was corroborated by other District witnesses, including the testimony of Ms. Metzger, the District’s speech therapist. On the basis of this testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s need to improve her self-advocacy skills would have been adequately address by the SDC curriculum. Therefore, STUDENT did not need additional related services to address self-advocacy in order to benefit from her instructional program.

It has also been established that STUDENT had a unique need to improve her social communication through improvement of her pragmatic language skills. The District failed to draft goals and objectives to address this need. Furthermore, the District failed to draft goals and objectives that were appropriate to meet STUDENT’s needs in receptive and expressive language. All three of these areas would have been addressed, in part, by the provision of speech/language services. Ms. Metzger testified that the speech/language services offered were sufficient to implement the goals and objectives that had been drafted. The Hearing Officer finds that, had the District drafted appropriate goals to address all of STUDENT’s speech/language needs, the speech/language services offered would not have been sufficient to implement all of those goals. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to offer a sufficient amount of related services in the area of speech and language.

4. Was the District’s offer of placement appropriate?

The District offered placement in an SDC class on the Temecula Middle School campus with mainstreaming in one elective and general education physical education twice a week, gradually increasing to five days a week. To assist in STUDENT’s transition, the District offered a one-on-one aide. It was undisputed that the offered SDC class would provide a small structured setting, with information presented in a simple, concise, concrete manner, with multiple repetitions. It was also undisputed that the proposed SDC class would have a curriculum that focused on functional academics. There was also no dispute regarding the appropriateness of the proposed emergency medical plan.

The Student’s primary contention was that the location of the SDC class, on the Temecula Middle School campus (a campus with over thirteen hundred students enrolled), was inappropriate because it was too large, with too many students and would be overwhelming and dangerous for STUDENT. Specifically, the Student argues that: 1) STUDENT would be overwhelmed because of her sensory processing deficits, 2) STUDENT would be vulnerable to being taken advantage of by other students, in particular male students, because of her low cognitive functioning and poor pragmatic language skills, 3) STUDENT would suffer lowered self esteem because she would tend to compare her performance to that of other non-disabled peers, 4) STUDENT would be in danger of suffering an increased number of seizures at a large middle school. In addition to these contentions regarding the campus, the Student also contended that the elective and the general education physical education classes were not appropriate and that the District only offered an aide for the first thirty days.

The Hearing Officer finds that the Temecula Middle School, with the use of an aide is an appropriate placement for STUDENT. Ms. Kasar, STUDENT’s current OT, testified that the visual and auditory input that STUDENT would experience at a large middle school would be overwhelming for STUDENT, resulting in irritation and frustration. She also stated, in that environment, STUDENT would become disoriented, and have difficulty attending. Ms. Kasar went so far as to suggest that STUDENT might not ever be able to handle this level of stimulation. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Kasar’s testimony is not supported by the evidence. The SDC class the District proposed for STUDENT contains only six to ten students. All of STUDENT’s academics were to be addressed in this small, structured setting. The only times STUDENT would be exposed to larger groups would be during breaks, at lunch, and in electives. There was no evidence that relatively limited exposure to large numbers of students would be overwhelming for STUDENT. MOTHER testified at length to STUDENT’s ability to function outside of school. MOTHER stated that STUDENT is able to assist her with shopping, although she does have a tendency to wander off. Furthermore, MOTHER testified that STUDENT generally does well in the community and with crowds, and enjoys going to amusement parks such as Disneyland and Sea World. The Hearing Officer finds that, given STUDENT’s ability to function in grocery stores and amusement parks, she would be able to function in a middle school environment. Ms. Chinn, the District’s occupational therapist, Mr. Plotner, the District’s adapted physical education specialist, and Mr. Owen and Ms. Fonseca, both school psychologists, all testified that, based on the results of their assessments and observations, STUDENT would be able to function at Temecula Middle School with the use of an aide. The Hearing Officer finds the District’s witnesses to be persuasive and their testimony supported by the evidence as a whole.

The evidence does establish that STUDENT’s sensory processing difficulties might make it difficult for her to attend to academic activities after exposure to a large degree of visual or auditory stimulation. However, the District’s offer included the use of a sensory diet to help STUDENT transition to academic activities. The testimony of both Ms. Kasar and Ms. Chinn established that use of a sensory diet would help STUDENT adjust her level of stimulation and allow her to better attend to academic activities. The Hearing Officer finds that the use of a sensory diet as offered by the District would compensate for any over-stimulation caused by STUDENT’s exposure to a regular middle school campus.

The Hearing Officer also finds that concerns that STUDENT would tend to wonder off or be vulnerable to suggestions of other students, in particular male students, would be adequately addressed by the use of an aide. It was undisputed that an aide would insure that STUDENT would be able to physically navigate the campus, and would not be subject to inappropriate social interactions.

The argument that STUDENT’s self-esteem would be negatively impacted is also unsupported by the evidence. STUDENT classes, except for one elective, would all be in a small environment with other special education students. (Footnote 2) Therefore, STUDENT would not be put in a position of comparing her performance to that of non-disabled peers. There was no evidence that simply being around non-disabled peers has a negative impact on STUDENT’s self esteem. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of placement would not have negatively impacted STUDENT’s self esteem.

MOTHER testimony that STUDENT might suffer an increased number of seizures is unsupported by any medical or historical evidence. MOTHER testified that STUDENT had had, on the average, one seizure a year at school over the last three years. STUDENT had been in a small private school for only the last year. There was no evidence that STUDENT has suffered seizures in crowded environments outside of school. As stated earlier, STUDENT would only be exposed to the general school population for a relatively limited portion of the school day. The Hearing Officer finds that there was no support for the allegation that such limited exposure to larger numbers of students would increase STUDENT’s seizure activity.

The Hearing Officer has already determined that the general education physical education class would not be appropriate for STUDENT. Testimony established that the home economics class would have had approximately thirty students. The District’s offer called for STUDENT to be accompanied by a one-on-one aide in that class. MOTHER testified that STUDENT already participates in home economics type activities at home. STUDENT helps in meal preparation and does needlepoint and embroidery. MOTHER believed that STUDENT would enjoy a home economics class. The Hearing Officer finds that any safety concerns relating to the home economics class would be adequately addressed by the use of the aide. In addition, the aide would be able to give STUDENT one-on-one assistance to ensure that she understood assignments and instructions. The Hearing Officer finds that the elective home economics class would be appropriate for STUDENT with the support of a one-on-one aide.

Finally, the Student argues that the one-on-one aide was only offered for the first thirty days. This misstates the District’s offer. The IEP, states, “The aide will be used to facilitate inclusion in elective, pe, as well as lunch and breaks.” This is also the offer that was stated in the District’s September 5, 2003 letter to MOTHER. Elsewhere in the IEP there is the statement that the aide would be used at the start of the school year. There is a separate provision in the IEP calling for the team to meet after the first thirty days to review the placement. Nowhere does the IEP specifically limit the use of the aide to the first thirty days. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer is for the use of the aide to facilitate inclusion in electives, PE, lunch and breaks. Absent a specific change to the IEP, the use of the aide would continue for the entire school year.

After considering all of the Student’s arguments regarding the offered placement at Temecula Middle School, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of placement in an SDC class with inclusion in one elective, during class breaks, and lunch is an appropriate placement.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District, having correctly identified all of STUDENT’s unique needs, drafted an IEP that contained accurate present levels of performance in all areas. However, the District’s offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs for several reasons. The District failed to draft appropriate goals in the areas of mathematics, money skills, daily living skills, and adapted physical education. The District also failed to draft goals to adequately address STUDENT’s expressive, receptive and pragmatic needs and failed to draft any goals to address STUDENT’s needs to improve her self-advocacy and gross-motor functioning. Furthermore, the District failed to offer a sufficient amount of related services in the area of speech and language.

The Hearing Officer also finds that the offer of placement in an SDC class on the Temecula Middle School campus, with the use of an aide, is an appropriate placement for STUDENT. In addition, the offered elective home economics class would be appropriate for STUDENT with the support of a one-on-one aide. Finally, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer for the use of the aide to facilitate inclusion in electives, PE, lunch and breaks was not limited to the first thirty days of the school year.

Did the District’s offer provide for the student to be involved and progress in the general curriculum?

The Student contends that the District’s offer did not provide for STUDENT to be involved and progress in the general curriculum. Specifically, the Student contends that the offer lacked adequate academics.

The District’s offer called for STUDENT to be placed in an SDC class that utilized the Bridges program. This is a program that focuses on teaching functional academics. Within this program, STUDENT would receive instruction in math, reading, writing, science, and social studies. The District’s assessment report found that STUDENT learned best when information was presented in a format that was meaningful to her, as opposed to an abstract format. MOTHER stated that STUDENT tends to learn practical things relatively. On the basis of this information, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposal to teach STUDENT academics through a functional format is designed to meet STUDENT’s need to have information presented in a meaningful manner. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of placement would provide for STUDENT to be involved in and progress in all aspects of the general curriculum. Was the District’s offer calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit?

The Student’s only contention in relation to this prong of the standard is that the District’s proposed use of the SRA reading program was not calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit because STUDENT would not be able to make progress using that teaching methodology. Ms. Engle, who is trained in the SRA program, testified that the SRA is not a true multi-sensory program because it only uses auditory and visual input. She stated that the Wilson Reading Program, which she uses, utilizes auditory, visual, and tactile input. Ms. Engle also testified that the SRA would require STUDENT to respond orally on cue, which STUDENT would have trouble with, and that the SRA workbooks have to much visual stimuli on each page, which would be confusing for STUDENT. Mr. Knudsvig, the District’s program specialist, testified that the SRA is a sequential reading program that teaches basic reading skills and progressively builds on those skills. He also testified that the program utilizes repetition, visual reinforcement, visual cues, and oral responses on cue.

The District’s assessment found that STUDENT required information to be presented in a simple, concise, concrete manner, with multiple repetitions. It was recommended that instruction utilize multiple modalities, and emphasize STUDENT’s relative strength in visual processing. In addition, districting auditory and visual stimuli should have been minimized. Ms. Engle’s testimony that the SRA is not a true multi-sensory program does not, in itself, establish that STUDENT would not be able to benefit from the program. Based upon Ms. Engle’s and Mr. Knudsvig’s testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that the SRA does present information in a simple, concise, concrete manner with multiple repetitions. In addition the program uses visual reinforcement for information presented orally. The assessment results emphasized the use of the visual modality to reinforce auditory information combined with repetition. The SRA satisfies these requirements. An appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the child. Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S. 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996). The District is required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of a program designed to provide educational benefit to the child. Rowley at 201. The Hearing Officer finds that the basic format of the SRA reading program satisfies this standard.

However, after reviewing a sample SRA workbook, the Hearing Officer finds persuasive Ms. Engle’s testimony that the presentation of information in the workbook would be confusing and distracting for STUDENT. The District’s assessment team recommended minimizing distracting visual stimuli. The assessment suggested covering all of the page in a workbook except for the portion STUDENT was working on, reducing the amount of written work, and allowing extra time for paper and pencil tasks. Of these recommendations, only allowing extra time was incorporated into STUDENT’s IEP. The Hearing Officer finds that the modifications listed above, minimizing distracting visual stimuli by covering all of the page in a workbook except for the portion STUDENT was working on, reducing the amount of written work, and allowing extra time for paper and pencil tasks, are necessary for the SRA reading program to be appropriate for STUDENT. To this extent, the Hearing Officer finds that the SRA reading program is not appropriate for STUDENT.

The Student also argued that the SRA was not appropriate because STUDENT had used the SRA in the past, most recently in the 2001-2002 school year, and had not made progress. In contrast, the Student alleged that STUDENT had made progress at Banyan Tree using other reading programs. Assuming STUDENT had not made progress using the SRA in the past, Jeffrey Owen, a licensed clinical psychologist and certified school psychologist, testified that there are multiple reasons why a student who had not made progress in one setting might make progress in a different setting. These reasons included the student’s developmental level, teachers, peers, assistive technology, materials, stress levels, and medical complications. The Hearing Officer finds Mr. Owen’s testimony persuasive. In this case there was no evidence that the reason STUDENT might not have made progress in the past was related solely to the use of the SRA program. The Hearing Officer finds that there was no credible evidence to support the Student’s argument that the SRA is not appropriate at this time solely because STUDENT had not made progress using it in the past.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the SRA reading program is not calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit because the District failed to incorporate all of the necessary program modifications into STUDENT’s IEP. STUDENT’s IEP should have contained modifications that called for minimizing distracting visual stimuli by covering all of the page in a workbook except for the portion STUDENT was working on, reducing the amount of written work, and allowing extra time for paper and pencil tasks.

Was the District’s offer of placement in the least restrictive environment?

Special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). The IDEA states that, to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities must be educated with children who are not disabled, and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment should occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that the education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C.§ 1412(a)(5)(A); Ed. Code § 56031.) With this provision, Congress created such a strong preference in favor of educating children with disabilities with their non-disabled peers (mainstreaming) that it rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption. Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education 874 F.2d 1036 (1989).

In this case, there is no disagreement that STUDENT needs to be receiving her academic instruction in a small, structured special day class setting. The Student’s contention is that the placement at Temecula Middle School would require, at least, the use of a one-on-one aide. The Student argues that the aide would make STUDENT feel different and uncomfortable and, as a result, would be a more restrictive environment than a placement that would not require an aide, such as placement at a very small private school similar to Banyan Tree.

The District’s offer provided for STUDENT to be in an SDC on a general education campus. STUDENT would have been with the general education population during lunch, breaks, and electives. Additional opportunities for mainstreaming would exist in relation to extracurricular activities. Because of STUDENT’s disability, these opportunities would only be available to her with the assistance of a one-on-one aide. It was undisputed that STUDENT would have to be in a very small, restricted environment, such as Banyan Tree, to be able to function without the assistance of an aide. Therefore, without an aide, STUDENT would be restricted to an educational environment that would provide little or no contact with non-disabled peers. Mr. Knudsvig testified that the IEP team recommended placement at the Temecula Middle School because it would afford STUDENT greater educational opportunities because of the greater resources available at a regular middle school campus. In addition, it would provide STUDENT with the socialization benefits of being able to be educated with non-disabled peers.

As set forth above, it is a rebuttable presumption that placement in the least restrictive environment is a placement that includes, to the maximum extent possible, education with non-disabled students. Id. The Student presented no credible evidence to rebut this presumption. The argument that STUDENT might feel uncomfortable with an aide is not sufficient to justify removing all or almost all contact with non-disabled students. The Hearing Officer finds that whatever incidental impact an aide might have on STUDENT would be more than offset by the increased educational and social benefits STUDENT would experience by being educated on a general education campus with her non-disabled peers. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of placement in an SDC class on the Temecula Middle School campus with the assistance on an aide was an offer of placement in the least restrictive environment.

CONCLUSION

The District did give MOTHER adequate notice of the August 20, 2003 IEP meeting. However, the District failed to properly assess STUDENT’s academic achievement because the Brigance was not conducted in conformity with the instructions provided by the producer of that test.

In spite of the deficiencies in the conduct of the academic achievement assessment, the District accurately identified all of STUDENT’s unique needs. Furthermore, the District’s IEP contained accurate present levels of performance in all areas.

However, the District failed to draft appropriate goals and objectives in several areas and failed to draft any goals and objectives in other areas. The District failed to draft appropriate goals in the areas of mathematics, money skills, daily living skills (carrying out a three-step household task), and adapted physical education. In addition, the District failed to draft goals to adequately address STUDENT’s expressive, receptive and pragmatic language needs. Finally, the District failed to draft any goals to address STUDENT’s needs to improve her self-advocacy and gross-motor functioning. The District’s offer also did not contain a sufficient amount of related services in speech/language to meet all of STUDENT’s unique needs in that area.

It has also been found that the District’s offer of placement in a special day class at Temecula Middle School, with the use of an aide was an appropriate placement for STUDENT. In addition, the offered home economics class, with the use of an aide, was an appropriate class for STUDENT.

Furthermore, the District’s offer of placement would have provided for STUDENT to be involved in and progress in all aspects of the general curriculum. However, the District’s offer of the SRA reading program as the methodology for teaching STUDENT to read was not calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit because the District failed to incorporate all of the necessary program modifications into STUDENT’s IEP. STUDENT’s IEP should have contained modifications that called for minimizing distracting visual stimuli by covering all of the page in the SRA workbook except for the portion STUDENT was working on, reducing the amount of written work, and allowing extra time for paper and pencil tasks.

Finally, the Hearing Officer found that the District’s offer of placement in an SDC class on the Temecula Middle School campus with the assistance on a one-on-one aide was an offer of placement in the least restrictive environment.

ORDER

The District failed to offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education for the 2003-2004 school year. The District shall convene an IEP within thirty (30) days of the date of this Decision and amend its offer of placement such that it conforms to the findings contained in this Decision.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year?

The Student prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

Dated: December 3, 2003 ____________________________________ Lawrence E. Mendel, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Touch math is a method of teaching that uses tactile and visual cues to help a student understand and remember basic math concepts.

2 The Hearing Officer has already found that participation in a general education PE class would not be appropriate for STUDENT. Therefore, STUDENT would be in an adapted physical education class, containing only six to eight students.