California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 21, 2001

Rio Elementary School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 2095-01 · Hearing Officer Joseph T. Macaluso

Rio Elementary School District may not reassess a preschooler with autism without parental consent because it failed to show a reassessment was needed.

Student prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The decision notes that it was amended to add the Hearing Officer's signature and that the amendment does not affect the substance. It also refers to a related prior case, SN00-01810, which concerned the 2000-2001 assessment issue; that case had been heard but was still awaiting a decision.

Summary

Rio Elementary School District filed for due process. It asked for permission to reassess a four-year-old boy without his parents' consent. The boy was eligible for special education because of autism. He had received Early Start services through Tri-Counties Regional Center, and the District found him eligible in June 2000. The parents and the District disagreed about his 2000-2001 program. During that year, he received a one-to-one home behavioral program from Behavioral Education for Children with Autism (BECA), plus private speech and occupational therapy. In an earlier hearing, the parents gave the District those providers' records and their own daily logs for August 2000 through June 2001. In August 2001, the assistant superintendent wrote a reassessment plan alone by copying the June 2000 plan. He did not consult District specialists or outside providers, and he did not review the records. The parents never signed the plan.

The Hearing Officer denied the student's motion to dismiss, which relied on the earlier case that was still awaiting a decision. On the merits, the Hearing Officer found the District had not shown that conditions warranted a reassessment. The passage of time alone was not enough. District witnesses had not read the records and gave no evidence of how the child's needs had changed. They also did not all agree a reassessment was needed. The parents were not wrong to withhold consent. The District may not assess under the August 3, 2001 plan.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled a district's request to reassess a child without parental consent. The district had to show that conditions warranted a reassessment. Time passing since the last assessment was not enough when the district already had current records from private providers that it had not reviewed. A plan written by one administrator without input from specialists was weighed against the district.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue 1. May Petitioner, Rio Elementary School District, conduct a reassessment of Respondent STUDENT without his parents' consent?

    The District did not show that conditions warranted a reassessment as of August 3, 2001. One administrator wrote the plan alone by copying the 2000 plan, ignored the providers' records, and offered no evidence that the child's needs had changed. The parents were not wrong to withhold consent, and the appropriateness of the plan was not reached.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order that the District does not have the right to assess the student under the August 3, 2001 assessment plan (the District's request to assess without consent was denied).

Go to full decision

Key authorities

20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(2)(A); 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(1)(C)(i); Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(c); Cal. Educ. Code § 56506(e)

People named in the decision

  • David Lopez, assistant superintendent; wrote the assessment plan (also called 'Daniel Lopez' once in the decision), Rio Elementary School District
  • Erin Sharp, occupational therapist, Rio Elementary School District
  • Shana Shea D'Alton, school psychologist, Rio Elementary School District
  • Kathleen Guerrero, school nurse, Rio Elementary School District
  • Illayne Kiel, speech and language specialist, Rio Elementary School District
  • Marina Ellis, preschool special day class teacher, Rio Elementary School District
  • Dr. Melanie Lennington, psychologist; expert witness for Student
  • Anne Tournay, M.D., pediatric neurologist; made the initial autism diagnosis, U.C.L.A.
  • Nina Hawkins, early intervention specialist; developmental evaluation, Tri-Counties Regional Center
  • E. Cheryl Fletcher, private speech pathologist; evaluator and therapy provider
  • Jan Van Duinwyk, private registered occupational therapist, Saratoga Clinic, Ventura
  • Steven M. Graf, psychologist; psychological evaluation
  • Robert E. Nopar, M.D., physician; psychological evaluation
  • Barry C. Barmann, Ph.D., clinical psychologist; behavior evaluation, Behavior Therapy and Family Counseling clinic
  • Doreen Granpeesheh, Ph.D., clinical psychologist; evaluator, Center for Autism and Related Disorders
  • Lynn Kern Koegel, Ph.D., evaluator, University of California Santa Barbara Research and Training Center
  • Cynthia M. Carter, Ph.D., evaluator, University of California Santa Barbara Research and Training Center
  • Mary Huffman, speech and language specialist; 2000 assessment, Rio Elementary School District
  • Lee Zinter, Ph.D., school psychologist; 2000 psychological evaluation, Rio Elementary School District
  • Janet I. Yi, educational consultant; in-home behavioral program, Behavioral Education for Children with Autism (BECA)
  • Marie-Noelle Poulin, registered occupational therapist; 2000 OT evaluation, Rio Elementary School District
  • Behavioral Education for Children with Autism (BECA), private in-home behavioral provider
  • Tri-Counties Regional Center, regional center providing Early Start services

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Joseph T. Macaluso, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Oxnard, California, on November 29 and 30, 2001. Appearing on behalf of Petitioner Rio Elementary School District (District) were attorney Nancy Stephens from Filarsky & Watt LLP, and David Lopez, assistant superintendent for the District. Appearing on behalf of Respondent (STUDENT) were attorney Ralph Lewis and MR. and MS. PARENT.

The following witnesses were called by the District to testify on its behalf: David Lopez, assistant superintendent for the District; Erin Sharp, occupational therapist; Shana Shea D’Alton, school psychologist; Kathleen Guerrero, school nurse; Illayne Kiel, speech and language specialist; and Marina Ellis, pre-school special education teacher.

The following witnesses were called by the Student to testify on his behalf: Dr. Melanie Lennington, psychologist; and MS. PARENT.

Oral and documentary evidence were received. Following receipt of closing briefs on December 21, 2001, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision. * The decision has been amended to add the signature of the Hearing Officer. The amendment does not affect the substance of the decision.

-1-

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

On November 29, 2001, the first day of hearing, STUDENT moved to dismiss this case. STUDENT contended that the assessment issue in the present case was litigated in prior case number SN00-01810. STUDENT pointed out that while this prior case had gone to hearing and closed, the hearing officer had yet to render a decision. STUDENT argued that because this assessment issue had not been decided yet, this matter should be dismissed.

The District objected to dismissing this cause of action. The District argued that the assessment issue in the prior case was limited to the 2000-2001 school year and did not affect the District’s right to assess STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year. Furthermore, the District argued that the parties specifically agreed that the resolution of the assessment issue in SN00-01810 had no bearing on the present school year. Moreover, the District alleged that it had not assessed STUDENT since June 2000. Finally, the District contended that it had the legal right to reassess STUDENT as often as there was a need to do so.

California Education Code § 56381(a) provides that a reassessment of the pupil shall be conducted at least once every three years or more frequently, if conditions warrant a reassessment, or if the pupil’s parent or teacher requests a reassessment and a new individualized education program to be developed. In this matter, the District alleged that it had not assessed STUDENT in over a year and a half. Thus, the Hearing Officer found that this passage of time raised a question of fact whether conditions had changed enough to necessitate a reassessment and denied STUDENT’s motion to dismiss this matter.

ISSUE

May Petitioner, Rio Elementary School District, conduct a reassessment of Respondent STUDENT without his parents= consent?(Footnote 1)

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner Rio Elementary School District asserts that STUDENT became eligible for Early Start services in 1997 due to developmental delays in motor, communication, and social/emotional domains. In June 2000, STUDENT was referred for an assessment to determine eligibility for special education services. The individualized education program (IEP) team found STUDENT eligible for services because he had been diagnosed with autism. In August 2001, the District sent STUDENT’s parents a reassessment plan. STUDENT’s parents have not signed the plan to date. The District contends that conditions warrant a reassessment because it has neither seen nor assessed STUDENT since June 2000. Finally, the District alleges that until it reassesses -2- STUDENT, the IEP team is unable to formulate an appropriate program and placement for STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year.

STUDENT asserts that conditions do not warrant a reassessment. First, STUDENT alleges that from August 2000 to the present, he has received ongoing speech and language therapy, in-home therapy, and occupational and physical therapy from various service providers. STUDENT contends that up to June 2001, all information from these service providers has been provided to the District and said information is more than sufficient to form current goals and objectives, a placement, and any related services. Finally, STUDENT asserts that the District has failed to follow proper procedures in forming its present assessment plan.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a four-year-old boy who resides in the Rio Elementary School District. He is eligible for special education based upon a diagnosis of autism. Anne Tournay, M.D., a pediatric neurologist at U.C.L.A., made the initial diagnosis of autism when STUDENT was two years old. As a result of his autism, STUDENT has significant developmental delays in his daily living skills, social/emotional skills, and speech and language skills. Although STUDENT also is delayed in gross and fine motor skills, his delays in these areas are not as severe as in the previously noted areas.

In May 1999, STUDENT’s parents referred him for Early Start services to Tri-Counties Regional Center in Oxnard, California. He was almost two years old. In June 1999, Ms. Nina Hawkins, an early intervention specialist, conducted a developmental evaluation of STUDENT. Employing the Bayley Scales of Infant Development II, Ms. Hawkins determined that STUDENT exhibited significant speech, mental, and motor delays. His functioning in these domains ranged from a low of six months to a high of fifteen months.

In July 1999, E. Cheryl Fletcher, speech pathologist, also evaluated STUDENT. Employing the Rossetti Infant Toddler Language Scale, Communication Temptations from the Communication Symbolic Behavior Scale, a Communication Interview and play observation, Ms. Fletcher learned that STUDENT exhibited profound delays in his receptive, expressive, and related communication skills. His play skills were also significantly restricted.

In July 1999, STUDENT’s first Individualized Family Service Plan (IFSP) meeting was held. Through the IFSP, STUDENT began to receive Early Start Services through Tri-Counties Regional Center. The services consisted of speech therapy two times per week, physical therapy one time per week, an in-home infant development program fifteen hours per month, and behavioral interventions.

In August 1999, Jan Van Duinwyk, a registered occupational therapist at Saratoga Clinic in Ventura, California, evaluated STUDENT. Employing the Early Developmental Profile test, Ms. -3-

Van Duinwyk determined that STUDENT performed fine and gross motor skills close to age expectancy. However, he demonstrated poor motor control and had poor muscle tone. Finally, Ms. Van Duinwyk noted that STUDENT’s motor patterns demonstrated compensatory patterns that affected his overall motor skills.

In August 1999, Steven M. Graf, psychologist, and Robert. E. Nopar, M.D. conducted a psychological evaluation of STUDENT. Administering the Clancy Scale of Autism, they learned that the results were positive for autistic symptoms in the communication, social/emotional and motor domains. During this same month, Barry C. Barmann, Ph.D., a clinical psychologist at the Behavior Therapy and Family Counseling clinic, evaluated STUDENT’s behavior due to inappropriate biting, tantrums, and mealtime misbehavior. Dr. Barmann suggested numerous behavior strategies to improve STUDENT’s behavior during play time, meals, and other structured/unstructured times.

In September 1999, STUDENT was evaluated by Doreen Granpeesheh, Ph.D., a clinical psycholigist from the Center for Autism and Related Disorders. Dr. Granpeesheh observed and evaluated STUDENT’s maladaptive and self-stimulatory behavior, social development, and receptive and expressive development. Dr. Granpeesheh noted that STUDENT’s social interactions were marked by a failure to develop appropriate peer relations and that he lacked basic symbolic and imaginative play. He exhibited impairment in the use of nonverbal behaviors, such as eye contact and gesture use. STUDENT’s communication skills also were delayed in both receptive and expressive language. Furthermore, STUDENT displayed a variety of self-stimulatory behaviors, including toe walking, repetitive vocalizations, and repetitive motor mannerisms. Finally, STUDENT exhibited tantrums, non-compliance, and aggressive behavior. Thus, Dr. Granpeesheh concluded that these various symptoms were characteristic of a child with autism.

In October 1999, STUDENT was evaluated at the University of California Santa Barbara Research and Training Center by Lynn Kern Koegel, Ph.D. Administering the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales to STUDENT’s parents, Dr. Koegel learned that STUDENT exhibited significant delays in communication, while socialization and daily living skills were less affected. STUDENT’s motors skills were very close to his chronological age. Dr. Koegel recommended that the primary focus of the interventions be in developing STUDENT’s expressive language.

In April 2000, a semi-annual IFSP meeting was held.(Footnote 2) The team agreed to continue the services that STUDENT and his parents had begun to receive in July 1999. Finally, the team discussed transitioning STUDENT to a District preschool program and sending the District appropriate information about STUDENT. During the same month, STUDENT’s parents agreed to refer STUDENT for assessment for special education preschool services and filled out a health history questionnaire about STUDENT for the District. -4- In June 2000, STUDENT’s parents signed the District’s assessment plan for STUDENT. The plan included assessments in the areas of pre-academic/achievement, social/emotional behavior, self-help/adaptive skills, psycho-motor development, language/speech/communication development, and intellectual development. During the same month, Mary Huffman, District speech and language specialist, evaluated STUDENT. Employing the Preschool Language Scale Three and parent report, Ms. Huffman determined that STUDENT continued to exhibit significant delays in expressive and receptive language, articulation/phonology, semantics, syntax/morphology, auditory processing and comprehension, and pragmatics. Lee Zinter Ph.D., school psychologist, conducted the psychological evaluation the same month. Employing the Developmental Observation Checklist and reviewing Ms. Huffman’s results, Dr. Zinter determined that STUDENT’s cognitive skills ranged from age 18-24 months; his pre-conceptual thought ranged from age 2-4 years; and his motor imitation and expressive language were limited. Finally, Dr. Zinter determined that STUDENT’s play was relatively stereotypical for a child his age.

During the month of June and July 2000, Dr. Koegel and Cynthia M. Carter, Ph.D. reevaluated STUDENT. Again employing the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales and Bayley Scales of Infant Development, Dr. Koegel and Dr. Carter determined that STUDENT had made progress in the areas of communication, daily living skills, and motor skills. However, both doctors noted that STUDENT’s communication was still significantly delayed. STUDENT’s socialization was most delayed in play, leisure time, and coping, and less so in interpersonal relationships. Furthermore, his living skills showed a consistent delay across domains, including the need to begin toilet training. Finally, STUDENT’s motor skills were very close to his chronological age, with less delay evidenced in gross motor skills than in fine motor skills.

In June 2000, STUDENT’s first IEP meeting was held. Although STUDENT’s parents were unable to attend the meeting, the IEP team members found STUDENT eligible for special education and services. The IEP team did not recommend a placement. However, it developed proposed goals and objectives in attention span and speech and language. The IEP team noted that it would continue the IEP meeting to September 2000.

In August 2000, STUDENT began to receive one-to-one behavioral education twenty-four hours per week at home through Behavioral Education for Children with Autism (BECA). Janet I. Yi, educational consultant from BECA, recommended that STUDENT not attend school until he acquired generalized imitation and observational learning skills, could follow basic instructions and tolerate increased amounts of instruction, use basic expressive language, had acquired basic toy play skills and generalized these skills to several different settings, was toilet trained, and could transition between activities. Thus, she recommended that STUDENT continue his home program and focus on receptive and expressive communication, language, pre-academics, motor development, self-help, play, socialization and behavior. MS. PARENT testified that from August 2000 to the present, STUDENT has received an in home program from BECA. MS. PARENT pointed out that during this time, BECA and MS. PARENT have kept daily logs on STUDENT’s progress. She stated that this information has been made available to the District through June 2001.

-5- In September 2000, Ms. Fletcher reevaluated STUDENT. She employed the same tests as used in her 1999 evaluations. In receptive language, STUDENT showed some improvement in recognizing family names, responding to family names and his own name, some commands such as “come” or “stop,” interest in toys, imitating some simple play, gestural skills, and was able to sort 6 colors. In expressive language, STUDENT showed some improvement in words such as “juice,” letters of the alphabet, singing songs, and the use of the Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS). Nonetheless, Ms. Fletcher still noted significant delays in these areas. She recommended continued intensive intervention, including speech and language therapy.

During September 2000, STUDENT’s parents filled out a second health questionnaire for STUDENT. Furthermore, Marie-Noelle Poulin, registered occupational therapist for the District, evaluated STUDENT. Employing the Peabody Developmental Motor Scales, Analysis of Sensory Behavior Inventory, clinical observations, and interviews of STUDENT’s parents and psychologist, Ms. Poulin determined that STUDENT’s gross motor skills were “pretty good.” With regard to his fine motor skills, STUDENT could hold a pen, work with pegs and rings, and stack blocks. With regard to his daily living skills, STUDENT could pull his pants up and down, and take off his socks, but he was unable to dress himself. He was able to hold eating utensils on a limited basis. Finally, Ms. Poulin reported behavioral issues such as biting, banging his head, pinching, fear of electric objects, strong dislikes toward certain foods, and poor eye contact.(Footnote 3)

On September 19, 2000, the IEP team met. The IEP team developed goals and objectives in speech and language, daily living skills, fine motor skills, academics, and play skills. Furthermore, the IEP team recommended speech and language services three times per week for thirty minutes, occupational therapy one time per week for sixty minutes and a preschool special day class (SDC) placement four times per week for two hours. MS. PARENT testified that STUDENT’s various service providers appeared at this IEP meeting. STUDENT’s parents disagreed with the goals and objectives, services, and the placement proposed by the IEP team. Instead, they proposed a “Lovaas type program,” forty hours of direct therapy from BECA, a home program fifty-two weeks per year, and speech therapy three times per week for fifty minutes. They did agree to the District’s proposed occupational therapy one time per week for sixty minutes.

MS. PARENT testified that because the IEP team was unable to reach a consensus regarding STUDENT’s placement and services for the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT continued to receive his in home program from BECA, his occupational therapy at Saratoga Clinic from Ms. Van Duinwyk, and his speech and language therapy from Ms. Fletcher. Because of the IEP team’s failure to reach an agreement for the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT’s parents filed a request for a due process hearing. MS. PARENT testified that as a result of the hearing, she supplied the District with all of STUDENT’s daily speech and language, occupational therapy, BECA, and personal records and logs from August 2000 to June 2001.

-6- In preparation for the 2001-2002 school year, Daniel Lopez, assistant superintendent for the District, testified that on August 3, 2001, he wrote an assessment plan for STUDENT. The District’s witnesses testified that they did not participate in the development of STUDENT’s assessment plan. Mr. Lopez pointed out that he used STUDENT’s June 2000 assessment plan as a model for STUDENT’s present assessment plan. The present plan proposed assessing STUDENT in the areas of pre-academic/academic achievement, social/emotional behavior, self help/adaptive skills, psycho-motor development, language/speech/communication development, intellectual development, and health. Finally, Mr. Lopez testified that he did not review any of STUDENT’s speech and language, occupational therapy, or BECA records from August 2000 to June 2001, nor did he send STUDENT’s parents releases for the aforementioned information prior to writing STUDENT’s assessment plan.

On August 3, 2001, Mr. Lopez mailed STUDENT’s assessment plan to STUDENT’s parents. Mr. Lopez believed that his secretary included the parents’ rights and procedural safeguards with the plan. Mr. Lopez emphasized in his letter that the District needed to assess STUDENT to determine his present levels of performance. Although Mr. Lopez requested that STUDENT’s parents return STUDENT’s assessment plan by August 20, 2001, they did not do so. Mr. Lopez testified that he mailed STUDENT’s parents the assessment plan a second time on September 5, 2001, and requested that they return it no later than September 14, 2001. Mr. Lopez believed that his secretary included the parents’ rights and procedural safeguards with the plan. Again, STUDENT’s parents did not return the assessment plan. Mr. Lopez testified that the District noticed an IEP meeting on September 18, 2001, to review the assessment data, update STUDENT’s goals and objectives, and determine the most appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year.

Mr. Lopez and the other Districts’ witnesses testified that on September 18, 2001, STUDENT’s IEP meeting occurred. However, STUDENT’s parents did not appear for the meeting. Mr. Lopez testified that the remaining IEP team members were unable to update STUDENT’s goals and objectives and offer a placement because the IEP team did not have STUDENT’s present levels of performance. Ms. Shana Shea D’Alton, District psychologist, testified that on the same day as the IEP meeting, she mailed STUDENT’s parents a copy of the parents’ rights and procedural safeguards, a copy of the IEP, a health history questionnaire, and a consent for release of information. Unable to obtain the consent of STUDENT’s parents for STUDENT’s re-assessment, the District requested a special education due process hearing by letter dated September 27, 2001.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Federal and State special education law provide that a reassessment of a STUDENT shall be conducted at least every three years or more frequently if conditions warrant a reassessment. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(2)(A); California Education Code ' 56381(a). Parental consent for an assessment of a child is required before a school district can assess the child. 20 U.S.C. ' 1414(a)(1)(C)(i); California Education Code ' 56321(c). However, a local educational agency can overcome a lack of parental consent if it establishes at a due process hearing the need to conduct -7- such an assessment. 20 U.S.C. ' 1414(a)(1)(A)(ii); California Education Code ' 56506(e). In this case, the District contends that conditions warrant a reassessment of STUDENT because more than a year has passed since the District last assessed STUDENT in June and July 2000. Furthermore, the District asserts that STUDENT’s present levels of performance are unknown to it because he has been educated at home. To properly place STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year, the District contends that it first needs to reassess STUDENT. The District asserts that it is entitled to reassess STUDENT to fulfill its legal obligations, despite lack of consent by STUDENT’s parents to do so. STUDENT contends that the District failed to properly determine whether conditions warranted a reassessment of STUDENT and failed to develop a proper assessment plan.

The evidence presented at the hearing established that the District failed to develop a new assessment plan for STUDENT and to consider all available current information from STUDENT’s service providers before concluding that conditions warranted a reassessment of him. First, the District did not use any people familiar with STUDENT’s needs to develop its assessment plan for STUDENT. Mr. Lopez testified that he had no formal meeting with the District’s psychologist, speech and language specialist, occupational therapist, school nurse or any of STUDENT’s outside service providers to determine what areas of need merited reassessment.(Footnote 4) Mr. Lopez testified that he alone prepared STUDENT’s assessment plan. The District’s respective witnesses all confirmed this point. Dr. Melanie Lennington, STUDENT’s psychologist, testified that the District’s procedure in writing STUDENT’s assessment plan was defective. She noted that the District should have had the people familiar with STUDENT’s needs determine to what extent his needs still existed and thereafter write the assessment plan.(Footnote 5) Ms. Shana Shea D’Alton, District psychologist, testified that she follows a similar procedure when developing assessment plans for the District and normally drafts the assessment plans herself. However, Mr. Lopez did not follow this normal course of procedure. Instead, he testified that he used the District’s June 2000 assessment plan as a model for STUDENT’s present plan and checked off the same domains on STUDENT’s present assessment plan. Finally, Mr. Lopez admitted that he had neither education nor training in the specialized areas he felt were ongoing areas of need for STUDENT. Therefore, the evidence established the District failed to use any people familiar with STUDENT’s needs to determine whether in fact conditions warranted a reassessment of STUDENT.

In addition to the District’s failure to employ people familiar with STUDENT’s needs in developing STUDENT’s assessment plan, the evidence also established that the District did not consider all relevant information about STUDENT’s needs before concluding that conditions warranted a reassessment of him. Mr. Lopez initially testified that after the District assessed STUDENT in June and July 2000 and had no new information about his present levels of -8- performance. The District’s other witnesses testified to the same fact.(Footnote 6) However, Mr. Lopez later admitted that the District possessed information from BECA, STUDENT’s in-home service provider, Saratoga Clinic, STUDENT’s occupational therapy provider, and Ms. Fletcher, STUDENT’s speech and language therapist, all of whom provided STUDENT with services after the District’s assessment in June and July 2000. MS. PARENT testified that in the prior due process hearing, case number SN00-01810, she provided the District with information from all of the aforementioned service providers, including her own daily logs on STUDENT’s respective needs, from August 2000 to June 2001. Mr. Lopez admitted that he did not use any of this information in determining whether conditions warranted a reassessment of STUDENT. Ms. Shea D’Alton and Erin Sharp, District occupational therapist, admitted that they would like to review this type of information before writing an assessment plan and assessing STUDENT. Mr. Lopez also stated that he neither called STUDENT’s service providers nor sent his parents releases for any updated information on STUDENT before concluding that STUDENT required the reassessment. Furthermore, Ms. Shea D’Alton testified that she mailed STUDENT’s parents’ releases for information only after the September 18, 2001 IEP meeting. Finally, the District did not invite any of STUDENT’s present service providers to the September 18, 2001 IEP meeting, when it concluded that it did not have any recent information about his present levels of performance in his areas of need. Therefore, the District did not consider all available and relevant information before concluding that conditions warranted a reassessment of him.

Furthermore, the District failed to establish that the circumstances regarding STUDENT’s unique needs had changed and warranted a reassessment. At the hearing, the District contended that it had not assessed STUDENT in over a year and that the passage of time alone established the need to reassess him. However, Mr. Lopez admitted that the District possessed records from August 2000 to June 2001 from BECA, Saratoga Clinic, Ms. Fletcher, and STUDENT’s mother. Both MS. PARENT and Dr. Lennington testified that these records had current information regarding STUDENT’s present levels of functioning in all his areas of need. Even though the District’s witnesses did not review these records before drawing up the assessment plan or conducting the September 18, 2001 IEP, they still had the opportunity to do so prior to the hearing. At the hearing itself, the District’s witnesses could have established what STUDENT’s current levels of functioning were and argued that a reassessment was needed. However, the District’s witnesses failed to do so. Instead, they testified that they either had not read those records or didn’t even know that they existed. Ms. Ellis, District SDC teacher, testified that she had “no records to go by” regarding STUDENT’s present levels of functioning. Ms. Sharp, District occupational therapist, testified that she did not read the records from Saratoga clinic and that she would like to read the occupational therapist’s records from Saratoga to determine if STUDENT made progress on his goals and objectives. Ms. Shea D’Alton, District pschologist, testified that she was not aware that the aforementioned records had been provided to the District and thus she did not “know exactly” what programs STUDENT had participated in. Ms. Guerrero, District nurse, testified that she did not review STUDENT’s prior health questionnaires and didn’t know that they were available to her. Ms. Kiel did not testify that she was aware of them. Thus, the District’s witnesses presented no evidence regarding what specific unique needs -9- of STUDENT had remained the same, worsened, or improved since its last evaluations in June and July 2000. Finally, the District’s witnesses did not unequivocally concur that a reassessment of STUDENT was needed. Ms. Shea D’ Alton, Ms. Sharp, and Ms. Ellis testified that the need for an IEP meeting did not automatically necessitate the need for a reassessment of a STUDENT. Ms. Guerrero admitted that there were no medical concerns regarding STUDENT that would necessitate an evaluation by her. Moreover, Ms. Kiel admitted that if Ms. Fletcher and individuals from BECA had attended the September 18, 2001 IEP meeting, the District could get current levels of STUDENT’s functioning and would not need a formal reassessment of STUDENT. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to present any evidence at the hearing about how STUDENT’s unique needs had changed and thus warranted a reassessment of him.

In conclusion, the totality of the evidence presented at the hearing established that the District failed to use any people familiar with STUDENT’s needs to develop STUDENT’s present assessment plan, failed to consider all available current information from STUDENT’s service providers regarding his needs, and failed to present any evidence as to STUDENT’s needs. On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to establish, as of August 3, 2001, that conditions warranted a reassessment of STUDENT. The Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT’s parents were not wrong in withholding their consent for STUDENT’s reassessment. Finally, the parties presented oral and documentary evidence regarding the appropriateness of the District’s proposed assessment plan. However, the Hearing Officer does not reach this issue because the District failed to initially establish that the conditions warranted a reassessment of STUDENT on August 3, 2001.

ORDER

The District does not have the right to assess STUDENT pursuant to the August 3, 2001 assessment plan.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code ' 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

The STUDENT prevailed on the only issue heard and decided.

-10-

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code ' 56505(i).

DATED:_____________________ ________________________________

Joseph T. Macaluso, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. The issue listed here differs slightly in wording from the issue noticed by the District before the hearing. Changes were made for the purposes of clarification and analysis. 2. Prior to this semi-annual IFSP, Ms. Fletcher reported in August 1999 that STUDENT began to babble and to say an occasional word, which she characterized as “significant gains.” In November 1999, Ms. Van Duinwyk reported that STUDENT began to demonstrate improved motor control efficiency. Nonetheless, both providers reported that STUDENT still had significant work to do on his language and motor skills. 3. In September 2000, Ms. Van Duiwyk also conducted an occupational therapy evaluation. She recommended continuing STUDENT’s occupational therapy two times per week with particular attention paid to his fine motor skills. 4. Ms. Marina Ellis, the District’s and STUDENT’s proposed preschool special day class (SDC) teacher, testified that an informal meeting occurred after Mr. Lopez wrote the assessment plan to discuss STUDENT’s reevaluation. The members at the meeting did not discuss any particular areas of need. Furthermore, the District sent STUDENT’s parents letters on August 3, 2001 and September 5, 2001, indicating that the District determined that STUDENT needed a reevaluation, and more than one individual developed the assessment plan. However, only Mr. Lopez made the decision to reassess STUDENT and developed his assessment plan. Only after the September 18, 2001 IEP meeting did more than one individual from the District concur that STUDENT needed a reassessment. 5. Dr. Lennigton noted that it was not proper for Mr. Lopez, who had neither training nor experience in STUDENT’s specific areas of needs, to develop his assessment plan. 6. Dr. Shana Shea D’Alton testified that she was unaware that the information from STUDENT’s outside providers existed.