California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 25, 2003

Alhambra City Elementary School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 2116-02 · Hearing Officer Trevor Skarda

Alhambra City Elementary may move a fully included seventh grader to a county special day class, Hearing Officer rules.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

Alhambra City Elementary School District filed for due process to confirm its June 2002 triennial IEP offer for a 13-year-old seventh grader. He has multiple disabilities, including cerebral palsy, a seizure disorder, a neurological vision impairment, and profound intellectual disability. Since kindergarten he had been fully included in general education classes at his home school, Repetto Elementary. He had a full-time one-on-one aide and many related services. The District proposed moving him to a special day class (SDC) run by the Los Angeles County Office of Education at Huntington Middle School. The parent wanted full inclusion to continue. Both sides agreed the IEP goals were appropriate.

The Hearing Officer found that the student had made almost no measurable progress for several years in full inclusion. He needed a simple, uncluttered, low-stimulation setting with few transitions, room to move and explore, and instruction at his developmental level. District witnesses testified that the SDC met those needs. They included psychologist Dr. Bruce Gale, whom the District hired, and vision teacher Lee Robinson. The Hearing Officer applied the four Rachel H. factors. Academic benefit weighed heavily toward the SDC. The student got little nonacademic benefit from nondisabled peers. His behaviors and his seizures, which required evacuating the classroom, affected the class. Cost was not weighed because the District stipulated it was not a factor. The Hearing Officer held that the SDC offered a FAPE in the least restrictive environment. The District was allowed to implement the June 2002 IEP there immediately.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied the Rachel H. least restrictive environment factors when a district asked to move a student out of long-term full inclusion after years of little measurable progress. It also notes that the student's brief did not compare the two placements, a comparison the first factor requires.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1. Is a special day class (SDC) operated by Los Angeles County Office of Education (LACOE) at Huntington Middle School the appropriate placement for Student for the 2002-2003 school year?

    The LACOE SDC was designed to meet the student's unique needs, was reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, comported with the June 2002 IEP, and was the least restrictive environment under the Rachel H. factors; full inclusion was not appropriate.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order that district's offer may be implemented. The District may immediately implement the June 2002 IEP at the SDC operated by LACOE at Huntington Middle School.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education; Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel H. (Holland)

People named in the decision

  • Laurel Bear, director of pupil services; District representative and witness, Alhambra City Elementary School District
  • Judith Wells, school nurse, Alhambra City Elementary School District
  • Lee Robinson, vision teacher/vision specialist and assessor, District
  • Jean Tsunashima-Lau, sixth grade general education teacher, Repetto Elementary School
  • Mary Theresa Jaurequi, director of educational services, District
  • Dr. Bruce M. Gale, private behavioral psychologist hired by District; conducted functional analysis assessment; expert witness for District, Private
  • Mona Neter, inclusion specialist, District
  • Terry Avalos, 1:1 aide, District
  • Blair Roger, independent inclusion consultant; witness for Student, Private
  • Dr. June Downing, professor; parent's inclusion consultant; witness for Student, Private

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Alhambra, California, on January 23, 24, 28, 29, and 30, 2003.

Petitioner Alhambra City Elementary School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Denise Godfrey Helfstein of the law firm Lozano Smith. Also present on the District’s behalf was Laurel Bear, the director of pupil services. Respondent STUDENT (Student or STUDENT) was represented by educational advocate Brigitte Ammons and attorney Anahid Hoonanian, both of Protection and Advocacy, Inc. Also present on the Student’s behalf was his mother, MOTHER. The entire hearing was interpreted by two certified Chinese language interpreters.

The parties called the following witnesses to testify: Judith Wells, school nurse; Lee Robinson, vision teacher; Jean Tsunashima-Lau, sixth grade teacher; Mary Theresa Jaurequi, director of educational services; Dr. Bruce M. Gale, psychologist; Mona Neter, inclusion specialist; Terry Avalos, aide; MOTHER; Blair Roger, independent consultant; Dr. June Downing, professor; Laurel Bear.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open for the submission of written closing arguments, the last of which was received by the Hearing Officer on February 19, 2003. After the parties' written closing arguments were received, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUE

Is a special day class (SDC) operated by Los Angeles County Office of Education (LACOE) at Huntington Middle School the appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 2002-2003 school year?

STIPULATIONS OF THE PARTIES

On the first day of the hearing, the issue for hearing was discussed at length. The parties stipulated that STUDENT’s numerous designated instructional services (DIS), other than the frequency and duration of the inclusion specialist services, were not at issue in the hearing. It was further stipulated by the parties that the goals and objectives developed by the Individualized Education Program (IEP) team for STUDENT at his June 2002 triennial IEP team meeting were appropriate, and likewise, not at issue in the instant hearing.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is thirteen years old. He lives with his mother, MOTHER, within the boundaries of the Alhambra City Elementary School District. STUDENT, who is by all accounts a happy young man, is also profoundly disabled. He has multiple physical and developmental disabilities, which include, among other things, cerebral palsy; intractable seizure disorder; cortical visual impairment (STUDENT is legally blind); profound mental retardation;(Footnote 1) macrocephaly (large head). (Testimony of Wells, Gale, Robinson and MOTHER, District’s Exhs. 17, 29, 50, 54, 58 and 62.) STUDENT qualifies for special education and related services because of these multiple disabilities.

STUDENT, who is currently in the seventh grade, has attended his home school, Repetto Elementary School, since kindergarten. During this entire period, STUDENT has been fully included in the general education classes with his typically developing, nondisabled, peers. He has received numerous designated instructional services (DIS) to address his extensive special education needs, including a full-time one-on-one instructional aide; vision specialist services; orthopedic handicapped services; speech and language services; augmentative communication/assistive technology services; occupational therapy; physical therapy; adaptive physical education; and inclusion specialist services. (Testimony of Neter, Robinson, District’s Exhs. 6, 26, 36,58, 61, 63.)

As stated above, STUDENT has been attending general education classes at Repetto since kindergarten. On June 12 and 19, 2001, at the end of STUDENT’s fifth grade year, STUDENT’s annual IEP team meeting was held. (District’s Exhs. 26 and 27) The team reviewed STUDENT’s progress, established present levels of performance, and revised STUDENT’s annual goals and short-term objectives in the areas of social/adaptive, self help, social communication skills, adapted physical education (APE), assistive technology, and basic concept development. MOTHER requested, among other things, that the District adopt the written recommendations of inclusion consultant Dr. June Downing. The IEP team generally adopted Dr. Downing’s recommendations, attached them to STUDENT’s June 2001 IEP, and they were implemented throughout the 2001-2002 school year. (Testimony of M. Neter; Exh.26.)

The IEP team agreed, as it had since STUDENT was in kindergarten, that STUDENT should remain in a full inclusion program during the sixth grade, although some District members of the IEP team believed that an SDC should be explored. It was also agreed that STUDENT required the following DIS services to benefit from his education: (1) speech and language services, small group, for thirty minutes each week; (2) assistive technology support, direct and consultation, two hours each week; (3) APE, small group, two sessions each week, thirty minutes each session; (4) occupational therapy (OT) consultation, two hours each month; (5) physical therapy (PT) consultation, “up to six hours per year”; (6) orthopedic specialist consultation, one hour each month; (7) vision specialist services, direct therapy and consultation, thirty minutes each week; (8) a full-time (six and one-half hours each day), one-on-one aid; (9) two hours of full-inclusion specialist consultation after school with the one-on-one aide each month. (District’s Exhs. 26 and 27.) The parties could not agree, however, on the amount and type of inclusion specialist services to be provided in the classroom; MOTHER requested four hours each week of “in class” inclusion specialist services and consultation services from Dr. Downing.

In June 2001, MOTHER filed a request for due process seeking additional in-class inclusion specialist time and funded consultations by Dr. Downing. The case was settled at mediation in the fall of 2001. As part of the settlement, the District agreed to fund two consultations between the parent’s inclusion specialist, Dr. Downing, and the District’s inclusion specialist, Ms. Neter, regarding STUDENT’s inclusion program. The District also agreed to increase the amount of Ms. Neter’s inclusion support time to at least four hours per week (at least two of which had to be spent with STUDENT in his classroom). The settlement agreement was promptly implemented and Ms. Neter subsequently increased her in-class time with STUDENT and consulted with Dr. Downing. (Testimony of Neter.)

Another IEP team meeting was convened for STUDENT on February 19, 2002. (District’s Exh. 36.) The IEP team meeting was convened because of concern about STUDENT’s nonresponsiveness and passivity, as he was often falling asleep in class. At the IEP team meeting, STUDENT’s teachers stated that his instructional aide “worked very hard” to stimulate him and keep him awake, to no avail. STUDENT’s occupational therapist opined that STUDENT’s sleepiness was due to an educational environment that was too stimulating for him. The team members also expressed their concerns about STUDENT’s increased seizure activity (STUDENT had three major seizures in the month of January). MOTHER requested, and the team agreed, that a behavior assessment was warranted and that it would be “helpful in providing information to the team regarding the relationship between [STUDENT’s] environment and his behavior.” (Testimony of Wells, Neter, District’s Exh. 36.)

During the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT had eleven major seizures in school, each lasting more than five minutes. (District’s Exh. 39). On each occasion, the paramedics were called pursuant to STUDENT’s special health care emergency plan, which was developed based on the recommendations of STUDENT’s physician. (Testimony of Wells, District’s Exh. 38.) On each occasion STUDENT’s class was forced to evacuate and remain outside while the paramedics attended to STUDENT. (Testimony of Wells, Avalos, Tsunashima-Lau, District’s Exh. 38.)

In June 2002, STUDENT’s triennial IEP was due. (District’s Exhs. 40, 42, 44, 45, 46, 48.) In preparation, the District conducted assessments of STUDENT in the following areas: health and development (District’s Exh 50), adaptive physical education (District’s Exh. 49), occupational therapy (District’s Exh. 56), physical therapy (District’s Exh. 47), speech and language (District’s Exh. 57), augmentative communication/assistive technology (District’s Exh. 51), psycho-educational (District’s Exh. 62), academic (District’s Exh. 54), vision (District’s Exh. 54), and orthopedic. (District’s Exh. 60).

Lee Robinson, STUDENT’s vision specialist, completed her assessment of STUDENT on June 3, 2002, in preparation for STUDENT’s triennial review. Ms. Robinson has provided vision services to STUDENT since June 1999. She explained in her report that STUDENT has neurological vision impairment (NVI), a type of visual impairment due to neurological abnormalities of the visual pathway and /or visual centers of the brain without ocular disease. In the summary section of her report, she concluded:

STUDENT’s vision is adequate for his present level of functioning. In most cases, NVI children will have indication of vision. STUDENT responds to objects in his central and peripheral fields, high contrast, and rotating and moving targets. Often with NVI children’s vision can improve with time. Medical and surgical treatments do not cure NVI. Spectacles and low vision aids do not correct NVI. It is a condition that indicates that the visual systems of the brain do not consistently understand or interpret what the eyes see. STUDENT’s vision appears to be variable: sometimes he seems to see better than others, and this can change minute by minute, day by day. His sensitivity to light is also characteristic of NVI. He likes color, and responds best if things are bright and attractively presented. Moving targets are appealing to STUDENT as well. He tracks by moving his head, not with eyes exclusively.

(District’s Exh. 54.)

Ms. Robinson recommended multiple teaching strategies, which included, in pertinent part, the following:

The simpler, more constant and more predictable the visual information, the better he will do. Keep surroundings simple, uncluttered, and free of unnecessary stimulation and noise.

(Id.)

Finally, Ms. Robinson made the following recommendations to the IEP team:

STUDENT continues to qualify for vision services on a regular basis. Ongoing dialogue between his teacher, aide and the vision teacher will be helpful. STUDENT needs a well-ordered, simple setting where there is minimal confusion, activity and noise. He cannot handle being over-stimulated, certainly not to meaningfully process what is going on. It is in STUDENT’s best interest that his physical needs and delayed responses are foremost in consideration as regards setting.

(Id.)

The District also hired a private behavioral psychologist, Dr. Bruce Gale, to conduct a functional analysis assessment (FAA) of STUDENT to determine whether any interfering behaviors existed that adversely affected STUDENT’s ability to access his curriculum as modified for him by his inclusion and other specialists. (Testimony of Neter, Gale; District’s Exhs. 44, 45, 58.) Dr. Gale’s assessment included multiple interviews, observations, and an extensive record review. Based on his assessment, Dr. Gale concluded, in pertinent part, as follows:

The concept of modifying regular education curriculum appears to have been a successful strategy when STUDENT was in the first and second grade. However, after carefully reviewing reports and IEP data combined with current interviews and assessment, it appears that his cognitive challenges make current adaptation of this regular education curriculum ill-suited to meet his educational needs. In doing so presently, the school district, wholly unintentionally, does not appear to be providing STUDENT with an appropriate educational curriculum designed to meet his individual needs and to provide for the level of interest required for stimulating learning and retention. His “interfering behaviors” appear largely a function of him being exposed to a curriculum that is causing him to make minimal progress over a period of years. In a more specialized setting with more appropriately trained staff with special education background, tasks could be broken down in more manageable steps and addressed multiple times per day, creating a curriculum more uniquely tailored for his specialized needs.

(District’s Exh. 58.)

STUDENT’s triennial IEP team meeting convened on June 14 and 17, 2002. The team discussed STUDENT’s triennial assessments. (District’s Exhs. 61, 63.) The consensus of the District members of the IEP team was that STUDENT’s current inclusion program was not appropriate. The team concluded that in the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT did not meet any of his classroom goals and generally did not make meaningful progress, with one exception in the area of physical strength. (District’s Exhs. 51, 55, 58, 61 and 63.) The District members of the IEP team then determined, among other things, that STUDENT’s needs required a more functional approach and safer environment where he could: (1) acquire some more independence without being motored though his activities by a one-to-one aide, and (2) develop and otherwise increase his self-help skills. The IEP team offered STUDENT placement in an SDC with DIS services. The specific SDC was later identified as the SDC located at the Huntington Middle School in the San Marion Unified School District, operated by the Los Angeles County Office of Education. (District’s Exhs. 61, 63, 67.)

MOTHER would not consent to the proposed June 2002 IEP, including the goals and objectives. She conceded the goals and objectives were appropriate only after the due process hearing began in January 2003, about six months later. (Testimony of MOTHER; District’s Exhs. 61 and 63.) Moreover, MOTHER was unwilling to visit the SDC proposed for STUDENT, and did so only on the belated advice of her special education advocate shortly before the hearing convened. (Testimony of Bear and MOTHER).

The District requested the instant due process hearing on September 18, 2002. The issue stated by the District was whether the District’s offer of an SDC was appropriate for STUDENT for the current school year.

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The District argues that a full inclusion seventh grade class is inappropriate for STUDENT because it cannot meet his unique needs. It contends further that STUDENT’s needs dictate that he be placed at the SDC located at the Huntington Middle School operated by the LACOE.

The Student’s closing brief is silent regarding the appropriateness of the SDC at Huntington Middle School. Rather, the Student contends that STUDENT’s current full-inclusion program is the “least restrictive environment” for STUDENT.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Is a special day class (SDC) operated by Los Angeles County Office of Education (LACOE) at Huntington Middle School the appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 2002-2003 school year?

Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.) The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).) The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22).) California Education Code § 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. (Id. at 200.) According to Rowley, the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available, or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. (Id. at 198-200.) The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Id. at 201.)

In determining whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE, the proper focus is on the adequacy of the District’s placement. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If the District’s proposed program reflects STUDENT’s needs, provides some benefit, and comports with his IEP, the District has offered a FAPE, even if the parent or guardian prefers another program, and even if the preferred program would have resulted in greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.

Special education law also requires that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that his removal from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and the severity of his disabilities are such that education in regular education classes with use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Ed. Code § 56031.)

To summarize, under the IDEA, State law, and Rowley, a substantively appropriate program for STUDENT must meet the following four requirements to constitute an appropriate placement: (1) be designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, (2) be reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, (3) comport with his IEP, and (4) be provided in the least restrictive environment. Each requirement will be developed below.

1. Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs

The first requirement is that the June 2002 IEP be designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Again, the District proposed that STUDENT be removed from his full-inclusion program, and that he be placed in a special day class at Huntington Middle School operated by LACOE. To make this determination, it is first necessary to have an understanding of STUDENT’s unique needs and his present levels of functioning. The parties stipulated that the goals and objectives developed at the June 2002 IEP meeting were appropriate. The identified areas of unique need and the corresponding present levels of performance derived from those goals and objectives are summarized below:

Area of Unique Need Present Level of Performance Daily Living Skills-Feeding 4 to 12 month range. STUDENT is beginning to grasp a spoon, scoop food from a bowl, and bring it to his mouth with some spilling. He can lift a cup, but cannot drink from an open cup without assistance or spilling. He uses assistive technology with assistance to request food items. He carries his own materials for short distances, but does not retrieve them when he drops them. Daily Living Skills-Dressing 4 to 12 month range. STUDENT reaches for his shirt and pulls on it in response to a prompt to remove it. He does not independently assist in putting on or removing his shirt or pulling his pants up or down. Social/Adaptive Skills 5 to 12 month range. STUDENT enjoys social interactions with familiar adults and peers and displays his pleasure by smiling and making eye contact with them. Participates in daily classroom activities, but not independently. STUDENT must be “motored” through activities. Unable to use a simple visual schedule with photos and three dimensional shapes to match. Vocational Skills/Fine Motor Reaches for doorknob with a physical prompt as he approaches a door. He does not close his hand or grasp the knob, nor does he attempt to push or pull the door open when he is given a verbal prompt to open the door. Vocational Skills/Motor STUDENT carries a lightweight bag with his materials as he travels from class to class or cafeteria. During a five minute, fifty foot walk, STUDENT drops his bag four to six times, did not attempt to pick it up, and was not aware he dropped it. STUDENT must be physically prompted to complete tasks such as carrying items, opening doors, removing signs, and feeding himself, and cannot complete any of these tasks independently. Language/Communication STUDENT displays limited use of an assistive technology device called a “tech talk.” He uses it to participate in class activities [with assistance from his aide] and to choose food, as long as the symbol for food on the device is not moved to another location. STUDENT has not used tech talk to interact with others to express preferences. He does not possess the skill of symbolic representation, which is necessary to expand his skills beyond cause and effect. STUDENT’s skill levels in this area remain at the level of cause and effect, with facilitation. His unique need is to address his ability to attend and to respond at the cause and effect level. Social Communication Skills STUDENT participates in a group, non-academic activity called “Circle of Friends.” Nondisabled peers verbally and physically interact with STUDENT, and he smiles and laughs in response. With physical prompting (a touch to his elbow) STUDENT responds in kind to a “high five.” Will not reliably respond with verbal or gestural prompt. Adapted Physical Education STUDENT’s area of strength. STUDENT can do ten pushups with assistance. He has demonstrated some resemblance of a kicking motion in relation to a soccer ball, but he requires assistance keeping his head down. Leg swing has improved. Balance is a concern.

STUDENT needs specialized and individual instruction to address communication, adaptive and daily living skills deficits identified above. In addition, the District also argues that STUDENT requires an environment where he is not forced to make frequent transitions, but instead, is allowed to explore his environment at his own pace. Dr. Gale, who has considerable experience assessing students with multiple disabilities such as STUDENT, testified persuasively that STUDENT’s full inclusion sixth-grade environment likely impeded his ability to learn (and was therefore inappropriate). He testified, based upon his assessment, observations, and multiple interviews, that STUDENT displayed behaviors such as kicking, pounding, squealing and sleeping, in varying amounts, likely because of the constraints of his regular education environment and the required transitions. (Testimony of Gale.) In his assessment report, Dr. Gale explained, in pertinent part, as follows:

STUDENT’s daily schedule includes many transitions and changes from day to day. Given his global difficulties with processing, it is difficult to see how he can benefit from such frequent changes. Especially because his mother has reported that they “go everywhere” together and he has done so well, it would seem that a similar approach at school might have some possible benefit where the environment is more adapted to his needs rather than the other way around. He would be better suited by receiving his education in a setting where he did not have to continually change rooms, have frequent schedule changes, and where the visual distractions in the environment were kept to a minimum. Additionally, by allowing him to be in one more consistent environment, I would think that STUDENT could gain more independent mastery over navigation of that environment.

(District’s Exh. 59.)

According to the District witnesses, STUDENT also has a unique need for an environment where he has the freedom to move around and explore at his own pace. (Testimony of, Gale, Robinson, Neter.) Moreover, the vision specialist, Lee Robinson, explained that because of STUDENT’s neurological vision impairment (NVI), he also requires an environment that is simple, uncluttered and free of unnecessary stimulation and noise, and one that is developmentally appropriate. (Testimony of Robinson). Dr. Gale also testified that STUDENT requires a developmentally appropriate environment.

The Hearing Officer finds, based on the weight of the evidence, that STUDENT has the above-described unique needs. STUDENT’s unique needs dictate that he be placed in an environment where he is not required to make frequent transitions, where he has freedom to move around and explore at his own pace, an environment that is simple, uncluttered and free of unnecessary stimulation and noise, and that is developmentally appropriate.

In summary, STUDENT needs specialized and individual instruction to address communication, adaptive and daily living skills deficits, plus DIS. He also needs opportunities to interact with nondisabled peers to implement Circle of Friends. Finally, STUDENT’s needs require that he be placed in an environment where he is not forced to make frequent transitions, where he has the freedom to move around and explore at his own pace, an environment that is simple, uncluttered and free of unnecessary stimulation and noise, and that is developmentally appropriate.

The weight of the evidence established the District’s offer of the SDC at Huntington Middle School was designed to meet the above unique needs. It was not disputed that STUDENT’s agreed-upon goals and objectives can be implemented in the SDC, nor was it disputed that if STUDENT were placed in the SDC at Huntington Middle School, he would not be required to make frequent transitions throughout the day at a set time, as he currently does. Moreover, the SDC is designed to meet STUDENT’s remaining unique needs. Lee Robinson, who was familiar with the proposed SDC, testified that the room is not cluttered, has few students, and presents STUDENT with space to move around safely. STUDENT would receive individual attention, and information would be presented at a developmentally appropriate level. Dr. Gale, who also observed the SDC at Huntington Middle School, found that it was generally designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Mona Neter, who was STUDENT’s inclusion specialist during the 2001-2002 school year, and currently oversees the inclusion specialists who are responsible for STUDENT’s current program, was also familiar with the proposed SDC. She explained that the class is very bright, cheerful, and there is ample room for STUDENT to move around and explore. All District witnesses testified that the SDC teacher is experienced, and qualified to teach students like STUDENT. Moreover, the SDC would provide STUDENT with ample opportunities to implement Circle of Friends and for STUDENT to interact with typically developing peers, as the SDC is located on a regular education campus. The Student provided no persuasive evidence that the SDC was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

2. Reasonably Calculated to Provide STUDENT With Some Educational Benefit

It was not disputed that the District’s offer of placement, the SDC at the Huntington Middle School, operated by LACOE, is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. In the past, STUDENT has been placed in a general education environment where he made little, if any, measurable progress in his most basic need areas of communication, adaptive and daily living skills. In the SDC, STUDENT will have the opportunity to make real progress in his basic need areas, according to all District witnesses. In the SDC, STUDENT will receive the individual attention of an experienced special day class teacher and other qualified individuals, in a safe, child-oriented, developmentally appropriate environment. He will not make frequent transitions from class to class. STUDENT will be able to participate in “Circle of Friends,” and he will have other opportunities to interact with typically developing peers, because the SDC is located on a general education campus. Finally, STUDENT will have the opportunity to move around and explore his environment. The Student provided neither argument nor evidence to the contrary. For all of the above reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of placement at the SDC is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.

3. Comport With STUDENT’s June 2002 IEP

STUDENT’s IEP can be implemented in the proposed SDC at Huntington Middle School. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer also comports with his IEP.

4. Least Restrictive Environment

The last FAPE requirement is that STUDENT be placed in the “least restrictive environment.” As discussed above, special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C.§ 1412(a)(5)(A); Ed. Code § 56031.) The Court in Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education (1989) 874 F.2d 1036, concluded that the law sets forth “a strong preference for ‘mainstreaming’ which rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption.” United States Code §1412(a)(5) sets forth the preference that students with disabilities are provided with an appropriate education within the regular education setting. It provides that, to the “maximum extent appropriate,” children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, be educated with children who are not disabled, and that special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of the child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplemental aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.

In determining whether the placement proposed for the student satisfies LRE requirements, federal appellate courts have considered the following factors: (1) the educational benefits available to the child in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared to the educational benefits of a special education classroom; (2) the nonacademic benefits to the disabled child of interaction with nondisabled children; (3) the effect of the presence of the disabled child on the teacher and other children in the regular classroom; and (4) the costs of supplemental aids and services necessary to mainstream the disabled child in a regular classroom setting. Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel Holland (1992) 786 F. Supp. 879 (1992); Adopted by the Ninth Circuit in Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel Holland, (9th Cir. 1994)14 F.3d 1398; cert. denied.

As discussed above, Student’s primary argument is that STUDENT should be fully included in the general education seventh grade setting with appropriate support and DIS services, as he has been since kindergarten, because this setting is appropriate and is also the “least restrictive environment” for STUDENT.

Assuming STUDENT’s unique needs can be met in a general education, full inclusion setting, the Hearing Officer will discuss the above-described factors to determine if the District’s proposed SDC meets the LRE mandate.

A. The academic benefits to STUDENT of placement in a seventh grade, regular education setting, as compared to the academic benefits to STUDENT in the special day class.

The District argues that STUDENT has received no educational benefit in the past because of his placement in the regular education setting and that the setting itself has likely stymied STUDENT’s academic progress. The Student’s arguments in this regard are unclear as the Student’s closing brief fails to discuss the academic benefit to STUDENT in the general education setting as compared to the academic benefit to STUDENT if he were to be placed in the District-proposed special day class.(Footnote 2)

The Hearing Officer finds that this factor weighs heavily in favor of the District’s proposed SDC at Huntington Middle School. There was no evidence of any discernable educational benefit STUDENT has received in the past several years in his full inclusion placement, and there is similarly a lack of any evidence that STUDENT will receive educational benefit in the regular education setting in the future if he remains with his typically developing peers.(Footnote 3) Moreover, it is beyond dispute that STUDENT functions at a level so far below his same-aged peers that the seventh grade curriculum has absolutely no meaning to STUDENT, even as adapted by his appropriately qualified inclusion specialists. STUDENT’s classmates are able to learn about geography; meanwhile, STUDENT has not yet demonstrated an understanding of cause and effect without prompting. STUDENT’s classmates learn to spell words and mathematics; STUDENT has little understanding of symbols, much less letters. STUDENT’s classmates interact verbally with one another; STUDENT shows little, if any, communicative intent, and very little understanding of verbal communication.

In comparison to the lack of evidence of any past or (for the immediate future) potential educational benefit to STUDENT from being placed with his same-aged, nondisabled peers, there was persuasive evidence that a special day class, taught by an appropriately qualified and credentialed special education teacher, with a small teacher-to-student ratio, in a developmentally appropriate environment, will provide STUDENT with meaningful educational opportunities. In that regard, Dr. Gale testified that STUDENT has not meaningfully progressed in nearly all areas since the second grade. STUDENT has been fully included that entire time. Dr. Gale explained that STUDENT’s second grade year was the last time information was presented to STUDENT at a developmentally appropriate level. He surmised that if STUDENT is once again placed in an appropriate environment such as the proposed SDC, he is likely to progress.

In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that the first factor weighs heavily in favor of placement in the SDC as the least restrictive environment.

B. The nonacademic benefits to STUDENT of interaction with children who are not disabled.

There is some evidence that STUDENT benefits from interaction with other children. Several of the witnesses testified that STUDENT “appears” to be happy and that he seems to enjoy interaction. STUDENT’s mother testified that likes school and that he enjoys being around his peers. Additionally, STUDENT has learned to “high five” peers and adults with physical prompting. Blair Roger, who is a friend of the family and also an independent consultant who focuses on inclusion, testified that STUDENT benefits from being a part of a community and that at STUDENT’s age, his school is his community. The Hearing Officer notes that Repetto is also STUDENT’s home school.

However, there was also persuasive evidence that any such benefit is minimal, at best. STUDENT’s full inclusion aide for the past two school years (last year and this year), who works with STUDENT more than six hours every school day, testified that she is unsure whether STUDENT recognizes other children and that he demonstrates no interest in classroom activities, only in people, and even then, only briefly. She also testified that STUDENT seems to be happy at school because he frequently smiles, but that she was uncertain if STUDENT is actually happy because of a particular school activity or peer interaction. He cannot distinguish the difference between a fork and pencil (he places both items in his mouth). Ms. Avalos “motors” STUDENT through nearly every activity because other types of prompting are ineffective.(Footnote 4) (Testimony of Avalos.) Ms. Avalos’ testimony was not disputed.

The Hearing Officer finds, based on the weight of the evidence, that STUDENT can be expected to receive minimal nonacademic benefit from placement with same-aged, nondisabled peers. Accordingly, this factor also weighs in favor of placement in an SDC as the least restrictive environment for STUDENT.

C. STUDENT’s effect upon the teachers and children in the regular education classes.

There was also persuasive evidence that STUDENT’s presence in the classroom creates a distraction on a consistent basis. According to STUDENT’s general education sixth grade teacher, who observed him the most, Jean Tsunashima-Lau, STUDENT’s disruptive behaviors include pounding on the table, kicking the leg of the table, making “screeching” noises, drooling, sneezing without covering his nose or mouth. She also explained that STUDENT, who is incontinent in both urine and stool, would sometimes smell, but that his aide would usher him out of the room very quickly after an accident. Ms. Tsunashima-Lau’s testimony was mirrored by that of STUDENT’s full time one-to-one aide, Terry Avalos, as well as that of his inclusion specialist, Mona Neter, who provided direct services for two hours a week during the 2001-2002 school year. The Student provided no contrary testimony.

Also as discussed previously, STUDENT has severe seizures that require the classroom to be evacuated until STUDENT is attended to by the paramedics, which can take up to one hour. STUDENT had eleven seizures during the sixth grade, and a total of three during the current school year (up to the first day of the hearing, January 23, 2003).

The Hearing Officer finds that this factor also weighs in favor of placement in the proposed SDC as the least restrictive environment.

D. The costs of mainstreaming STUDENT in the seventh grade regular education environment.

The District stipulated that cost is not a factor, as it has shown it is both willing and able to shoulder the additional costs associated with full inclusion.(Footnote 5) The Hearing Officer will not consider it as a relevant factor in this case.

The above discussion leads the Hearing Officer to conclude that the SDC at Huntington Middle School is the least restrictive environment for STUDENT. Three of the four factors weigh in favor of placement in the SDC; one factor weighs heavily so (the lack of academic benefit). Moreover, as discussed above, STUDENT has made almost no progress in any area of need for several years, and that entire time he has been fully included and he has received an abundance of DIS and other supports and services. Therefore, the proposed SDC is the LRE for STUDENT at this time.

Additionally, the Hearing Officer finds that, based on the weight of the evidence, that the full inclusion, general education environment preferred by the Respondent is not appropriate for STUDENT at this time. It is not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. STUDENT’s unique needs, as found above, require that he be placed in an environment where he is not forced to make frequent transitions; in STUDENT’s current full inclusion environment, he is required to transition with his one-to-one aide to three different classes. Moreover, STUDENT’s current full inclusion environment affords him no opportunity to independently explore his environment. His current classes have at least thirty-two students, and there is no space for STUDENT to move around or explore. (Testimony of Avalos, Gale, Neter, Bear.) Additionally, STUDENT’s current placement is not developmentally appropriately for STUDENT, nor is it relatively free from distractions. (Testimony of Gale, Robinson, Neter, Bear, Avalos, Tsunashima-Lau.) Furthermore, STUDENT did not make appropriate progress towards achievement of his goals and objectives in almost all areas in his general education placement. There was no persuasive evidence that by increasing the level of services or supports, over and above the already substantial services and supports he currently receives, STUDENT would have made appropriate progress on his goals and objectives. Because the general education placement requested by the Respondent is not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, it is not appropriate.

In sum, it has been found above that the District’s proposed placement, an SDC at Huntington Middle School, offers STUDENT a free and appropriate public education. It is also the least restrictive environment.

ORDER

The District may immediately implement STUDENT’s June 2002 IEP at the SDC operated by LACOE at Huntington Middle School.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on the sole issue heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Date: March 25, 2003 Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. One recent assessor, Dr. Gale, explained that the diagnosis of mental retardation comprises approximately two and one-half percent of all students, and that less than four percent of students with that diagnosis function at a level as low as STUDENT. 2. It appears that Student’s attorney and advocate misinterpreted the applicable law. Application of the first factor, educational benefit, requires a comparison of the educational benefits to the student in the different environments. In the Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel Holland, (9th Cir. 1994)14 F.3d 1398, 1401, cert. denied, the Court reasoned that “the district’s evidence did not establish that the educational opportunities available through special education were better or equal to those available in a regular classroom.” The Student’s brief fails to compare, in any way, the two proposed placements. In fact, the Student’s brief is silent about the District’s proposed placement. 3. The Student asserted at the beginning of the hearing that STUDENT’s full inclusion placement could be “fixed” with two additional hours of inclusion support services each week (for a total of six hours). There was no persuasive testimony, even from the Student’s own witnesses, in support of this assertion. 4. She, for example, physically places STUDENT’s hand on an object, closes STUDENT’s hand, directs his hand to move, assists him with an action, and when the action is complete, she removes the object from his hand. 5. Again, the Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT has been fully included at the same school his entire academic career.