California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 4, 2002
Davis Joint Unified School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 2181-02 · Hearing Officer Mark D. Brylski
Davis Joint Unified may assess a private-school student with autism only if his parent seeks services or files for due process.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted. The decision mentions that the student's earlier case, SN02-01605, was withdrawn on September 16, 2002. In that case, a July 23, 2002 amended stay put order had granted stay put for the January 2002 IEP services but denied it for Bridges services at the private school.
Summary
Davis Joint Unified School District filed for due process to assess a six-year-old boy with autism without his mother's consent. The family moved in from Woodland in December 2001. The District had never assessed him. His last formal assessment was a May 2001 triennial by the Yolo County Office of Education. Since June 2002 he had attended Merryhill, a private school, and also received behavior services from Bridges Behavioral Language Systems, a nonpublic agency. His mother refused consent to the District's June 19, 2002 assessment plan and to any observations. The student had already withdrawn his own due process case.
The Hearing Officer found that conditions warranted an assessment. The student was young, his needs were changing, and he had made notable progress. District staff needed their own observations instead of relying only on the agency's progress reports. The plan was properly developed using the information available and parent input. It also met Education Code section 56321 and would be given by qualified staff. However, the student was in private school and was not seeking services or relief from the District, so the Hearing Officer held that the District could not assess him now. If the parent seeks services, files for due process, or seeks any remedy, the District may assess under the June 2002 plan after giving five days' written notice. The parent must then consent in writing to observations at the private school. The District substantially prevailed.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled a district's request to assess a child who moved into the district and was then placed in a private school. The Hearing Officer found that assessment was warranted. However, the Hearing Officer allowed the District to assess only if the parent sought services or relief, relying on Gregory K. and Andress.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedDistrict-filed: assess without consent
Issue 1. Does the Davis Joint Unified School District have the right to conduct an assessment of STUDENT in accordance with its comprehensive assessment plan dated June 19, 2002, and as part of that assessment, observe him in his current private school placement?
The Hearing Officer found that conditions warranted assessment and that the plan was properly developed, legally adequate, and would be given by qualified staff. Because the student was in private school and was not seeking services, the District could not assess him now. The District may assess under the plan, and the parent must consent to observations at the private school, if the parent seeks services, files for due process, or seeks any remedy.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order that district may assess without consent. Conditional order. The District is not entitled to assess the student at present. If the student seeks special education services from the District, files for a due process hearing, or seeks any other remedy for past or prospective services, the District may assess him under its June 19, 2002 assessment plan after giving the parent five days' written notice. The plan remains valid through the end of the 2002-2003 school year and ESY.
- If the District becomes entitled to assess, the parent must give the District written consent for observations of the student at Merryhill or any other private school he attends, and must make the student reasonably available for the assessment.
Key authorities
Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307 (9th Cir. 1987); Andress v. Cleveland Independent School District, 64 F.3d 176 (5th Cir. 1995); Cal. Educ. Code § 56381; Cal. Educ. Code § 56321; Cal. Educ. Code § 56320; Cal. Educ. Code § 56327; 20 U.S.C. § 1414
People named in the decision
- Laurel Clumpner, coordinator of special education, Davis Joint Unified School District
- Michelle King, behavior analyst / behavior specialist; conducted functional analysis assessment and proposed assessor, Yolo County Office of Education
- Barbara Sells, school psychologist; proposed assessor, Davis Joint Unified School District
- Anne Rosecrance, speech-language pathologist; proposed assessor, Davis Joint Unified School District
- Linda Brooks, coordinator for special education inclusion program / inclusion specialist; proposed assessor, Davis Joint Unified School District
- Tara Mills, program director and bachelor's level consultant, nonpublic agency, Bridges Behavioral Language Systems
- Audrey Gifford, director, nonpublic agency; witness for Student, Bridges Behavioral Language Systems
- Mary Runion, private school teacher, Merryhill School
- Jill Ahrens, preschool teacher (First Steps SDC/State Preschool), Greengate State Preschool / First Steps
- Poh Ngau, school psychologist (May 2001 triennial), Yolo County Office of Education
- Shohreh Nouralishahi, private speech-language pathologist (May 2001 assessment)
- Brenda Turner, speech-language pathologist (May 2001 triennial)
- Gayle Hamm, occupational therapist (May 2001 triennial)
- Bridges Behavioral Language Systems, nonpublic agency providing behavioral services
- Merryhill School, private school
- Alta California Regional Center, regional center (diagnosis)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mark D. Brylski, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Davis, California, on October 29, 30, and 31, 2002.
Petitioner Davis Joint Unified School District (Petitioner or District) was represented by attorney Kimberly Schulist of Miller, Brown & Dannis. Also present on behalf of the District was its coordinator of special education, Laurel Clumpner. Respondent STUDENT (Respondent or STUDENT) was represented by attorney Roberta Savage of Varma & Clancy. Attorney Joyce Carrillo, of counsel to Varma & Clancy, observed on the first day of hearing. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was his mother, PARENT.
Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Michelle King, behavior analyst with the Yolo County Office of Education (YCOE); Barbara Sells, a District school psychologist; Anne Rosecrance, a District speech and language pathologist; Linda Brooks, the District’s coordinator for special education inclusion program; Laurel Clumpner, the District’s coordinator of special education; Tara Mills, program director and bachelor’s level consultant with Bridges Behavioral Language Systems (Bridges); and Mary Runion, teacher at Merryhill School.
Respondent called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Audrey Gifford, director of Bridges; and Petitioner’s mother, PARENT.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following oral closing arguments, the case was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUE(Footnote 1)
1. Does the Davis Joint Unified School District (District) have the right to conduct an assessment of STUDENT in accordance with its comprehensive assessment plan dated June 19, 2002, and as part of that assessment, observe him in his current private school placement?
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
Respondent STUDENT is a boy six years and ten months of age with a diagnosis of autism. STUDENT was first diagnosed with autism by the Alta California Regional Center (Regional Center) in July 1999. STUDENT resides with his mother, PARENT, in Davis, California. STUDENT and his mother moved from the adjoining Woodland Unified School District and into the Davis Joint Unified School District (District) in December 2001.(Footnote 2) STUDENT is currently attending a kindergarten/first grade class at Merryhill, a private school in Davis.
STUDENT initially qualified for special needs services following a December 1998 assessment conducted by the Yolo County Superintendent of Schools when STUDENT was two years and ten months of age. (Respondent Exh. 234-239) An occupational therapist (OT) found mild gross motor skill delays, significant fine motor skill delays, moderate self-help skill delays, and significant sensory integration difficulties and recommended motor development services. A speech language assessment conducted by a speech language therapist found significant speech and language delays in receptive and expressive language and recommended speech and language services. A health and development history by a First Steps Preschool Program (First Steps) nurse noted that STUDENT qualified for services due to language delays as well as “the quality of his social interactions with other children and adults.” STUDENT was diagnosed by the Regional Center at age three and one half with pervasive development disorder, not otherwise specified (P.D.D.N.O.S.)
In January 2000, STUDENT, at age four, had transitioned into the First Steps Early Intervention program in Davis and was found in an “educational assessment” to need support in self help/adaptive skills and was found to present some challenging behaviors in the program and at home. In a March 2000, First Steps preschool progress report and a speech and language evaluation, STUDENT was noted to have made significant progress but continued to demonstrate developmental delays. The speech and language assessor noted that STUDENT demonstrated severe delays in expressive language, phonology and oral motor skills. (Respondent Exhs. 226-230) In a March 2000 behavior assessment report, a behavior analyst recommended that STUDENT participate in a preschool setting three times per week and receive intensive supplemental one-on-one services to address identified deficits. (Respondent Exhs. 218-225)
In April 2000, STUDENT first began receiving one-on-one behavioral services at home from Bridges Behavioral Language Systems (Bridges), a nonpublic agency. Bridges has provided services to STUDENT from April 2000 to the present. (Test. of PARENT and Ms. Gifford)
STUDENT attended the Greengate State Preschool during the 2000-2001 school year. On October 13, 2000, a behavior observation report was prepared by YCOE behavior specialist Michelle King. The report followed observations made of STUDENT in his preschool classroom (at Greengate) and after interviews conducted with his preschool teacher (Jill Ahrens) and with the Early Childhood Program coordinator. Ms. King recommended training the preschool teacher and one-on-one aide to generalize STUDENT’s skills learned in preschool, fading out his “edible reinforcements,” and developing a behavior support plan. (Respondent’s Exhs. 195-196 and Test. of Ms. King)
In a May 2001 triennial assessment conducted by YCOE, STUDENT was given an assessment by school psychologist Poh Ngau, speech and language assessments by speech language pathologists Shohreh Nouralishahi (private assessment) and Brenda Turner, and an occupational therapy (OT) evaluation by occupational therapist Gayle Hamm. (Dist. Exhs. 1, 3, 4, and 5) First Steps SDC/State Preschool teacher Jill Ahrens made classroom observations in the areas of self help, readiness skills, communication, and social/behavioral, and Bridges provided an updated behavioral report. (Dist. Exhs. 2 and 6). A May 29, 2001 assessment plan also provided for a functional analysis assessment (FAA). (Dist. Exh. 8) Behavior specialist Michelle King conducted the FAA and prepared a written report on August 20, 2001. (Dist. Exh. 10 and Test. of Ms. King)
STUDENT attended a “full inclusion” kindergarten class in Woodland (Maxwell Elementary School) from August 2001 to October 18, 2001, when his mother removed him from the school. (Test. of Ms. King) Ms. Michelle King observed him in that program until October 2001.
After STUDENT moved into the District in early December 2001, an interim placement IEP meeting was held on December 13, 2001. (Dist. Exh. 15 and Test. of Ms. Clumpner) PARENT had signed an authorization for the release to the District of information from Woodland on November 30, 2001. (Dist. Exh. 14) The District offered STUDENT 20 hours of behavioral intervention services through Bridges and OT and speech and language services. However, STUDENT’s mother would not consent to a District assessment in the area of cognitive development. (Test. of Ms. Clumpner)
On January 7, 2002, an additional IEP meeting was held between PARENT and Ms. Clumpner to complete an interim placement form. The form indicates that the parent “does not want assessment done.” (Dist. Exh. 17 and Test. of Ms. Clumpner) On January 25, 2002, PARENT executed a consent to exchange information form to allow the District to obtain Regional Center records. (Dist. Exh. 20)
On January 27, 2002, Bridges issued an update report on STUDENT’s progress. (Dist. Exh. 21) On February 8, 2002, Michelle King issued an “intensive behavior services” update report. (Dist. Exh. 22)
An IEP meeting was held on March 14, 2002. The District determined STUDENT’s present levels of performance primarily based upon the January 27, 2002 update report prepared by Bridges. The IEP notes the following regarding proposed goals: “Objectives were presented by speech and language therapist and inclusion specialist. It was clarified that present level[s] of performance [are] primarily based on information provided by NPA. After district professionals have had an extended opportunity to work with STUDENT, the goals may need to be refined by the IEP team.” The IEP team then prepared agreed-upon goals and objectives based upon the present levels of performance. (Dist. Exh. 23 and Test. of Ms. Clumpner and Ms. Sells)
From approximately March 2002 through mid-May 2002, a District speech and language therapist, Anne Rosecrance, provided speech language services to STUDENT. The services were discontinued because of PARENT’s scheduling or transportation difficulties. (Test. of Ms. Rosecrance) Other than the observations of Ms. King and Ms. Rosecrance, the District has not had the opportunity to observe or assess STUDENT in any setting.
On June 3, 2002, STUDENT began attending Merryhill, a private school. (Dist. Exh. 34 and Test. of PARENT) STUDENT attends Merryhill approximately twenty hours per week with a one-on-one aide and is given discrete trials therapy (DTT) and positive reinforcement through ABA by Bridges for a program totaling forty hours per week.(Footnote 3) (Test. of Ms. Mills)
STUDENT’s annual IEP review was held on June 19, 2002. Bridges had not provided an updated report as of June 19 to reflect STUDENT’s present levels of performance. (Test. of Ms. Clumpner) PARENT only attended for about fifteen minutes due to an illness but instructed the team to develop goals and objectives without her. The District IEP team members decided upon an assessment plan to obtain first-hand information as to STUDENT’s present levels of performance in order to draft current goals and objectives because the most recent information from Bridges was six months old. (Test. of Ms. Clumpner) A copy of the proposed assessment plan and an explanatory cover letter was sent to PARENT with a release for information from the Regional Center.(Footnote 4) (Dist. Exhs. 26 and 27 and Test. of Ms. Clumpner) A follow-up letter was sent by Ms. Clumpner with further explanation. (Dist. Exh. 29 and Test. of Ms. Clumpner)
By letter dated June 24, 2002, the attorney for the District informed the attorney for the Respondent that because STUDENT had been placed unilaterally at Merryhill, a private school, the District would terminate funding the Bridges services. Enclosed with the letter were copies of documents and letters provided to PARENT by letter from Ms. Clumpner, including a copy of the assessment plan and exchange of information.(Footnote 5) (Dist. Exh. 31)
On June 28, 2002, the IEP team reconvened with the presence of Tara Mills of Bridges and PARENT. Ms. Mills provided information regarding present levels of performance and goals and objectives agreed upon by the parties. (Dist. Exh. 32 and Test. of Ms. Clumpner, Ms. Mills and PARENT)
On July 9, 2002, the Hearing Office received a request for a due process hearing from the attorneys for STUDENT. The Hearing Office designated that case as Case No. SN02-01605. The request named the Davis Joint Unified School District as the only respondent and asserted denial of FAPE claims for the 2001-2002 school year and ESY and for the 2002-2003 school year and sought compensatory services and reimbursement for STUDENT’s private school services. (Dist. Exh. 34) Case No. SN02-01605 was subsequently withdrawn(Footnote 6).
On July 11, 2002, the District stopped funding the Bridges program. The District explained that since PARENT had moved STUDENT’s home program to a private school, Merryhill, in June 2002, without IEP team involvement or the District’s involvement, Bridges had breached the master contract it had with the District. (Dist. Exhs. 30 and 31 and Test. of Ms. Clumpner) In July and October 2002, Bridges provided the District with two updates on STUDENT’s objectives. (Respondent Exhs. 257-273 and Exhs. 95-114)
On September 25, 2002, the Hearing Office received a request for a due process hearing from the District. Attached to the request was the District’s proposed assessment plan dated June 19, 2002. The District seeks an order allowing it to conduct its proposed assessment because Respondent’s parent has not consented to the plan. The comprehensive assessment plan seeks assessments of STUDENT in the following areas: academic (by the proposed special education teacher and the school psychologist); social/emotional and adaptive behavior (by the proposed special education teacher and school psychologist); body coordination/psychomotor and adaptive physical education (APE) by the school psychologist; speech and language development by the language speech specialist; intellectual ability by the school psychologist; and in the health area (by a school nurse).
STUDENT’s mother refuses consent to all or a portion of the proposed assessment plan and also refuses to provide consent to observations of STUDENT in any settings.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Does the District have the right to conduct an assessment of STUDENT in accordance with its assessment plan dated June 19, 2002, and as part of that assessment, observe him in his current private school placement?
Federal and State special education law provides that a reassessment of a Respondent with disabilities must be conducted at least once every three years, more frequently, if conditions warrant a reassessment, and when the Respondent’s parent or teacher requests that a reassessment be conducted and a new IEP be developed. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(a); 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(2)(A). In Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1315 (9th Cir. 1987), the Ninth Circuit stated “if the parents want [their child] to receive special education under the Act, they are obligated to permit such testing.” In Andress v. Cleveland Independent School District, 64 F.3d 176, 178 (5th Cir. 1995), the Fifth Circuit concluded that “a parent who desires for her child to receive special education must allow the school district to evaluate the child...there is no exception to this rule.”
Notwithstanding a school district’s right and obligation to conduct reassessments, parental consent for an evaluation is required before a school district may assess a child. Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(c); 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(1)(C)(i). However, a local educational agency can overcome a lack of parental consent if it establishes a need to conduct an assessment at a due process hearing. Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(c), § 56506(e), and 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(1)(C)(ii).
In this case, the District contends that conditions warrant reassessment of STUDENT. First, the District asserts that it has never assessed STUDENT, who moved into the District in December 2001. Second, the District argues that STUDENT is a young boy with autism and changing needs and that because over one year has passed since his triennial assessment (held in May 2001), a comprehensive assessment is necessary. Finally, the District asserts that it needs to observe STUDENT in a variety of environments (including in his current educational placement at Merryhill) in order to assess him appropriately to determine his current needs.
Respondent contends that STUDENT’s triennial assessment was conducted in May 2001, and that there is no change in STUDENT warranting reassessment at this time. Respondent further contends that the District’s development of goals and objectives at IEP meetings held in 2002 is tantamount to the District’s acknowledgement that an assessment of STUDENT is not warranted. Respondent also contends that private permission is required to allow the District to observe STUDENT in his current private school placement at Merryhill.
Do conditions warrant reassessment of STUDENT by the District?(Footnote 7)
It is undisputed that the District has never conducted any formal assessments of STUDENT since he moved into the District in early December 2001, nearly one year ago.(Footnote 8) It is also undisputed that STUDENT was last formally assessed one and one-half years ago in May 2001, and that Bridges, STUDENT’s nonpublic service provider, has not conducted any standardized or formal testing of STUDENT.(Footnote 9) (Test. of Ms. Clumpner and Ms. Gifford) Moreover, it is also undisputed that no formal or standardized cognitive testing was conducted during the triennial (STUDENT’s last assessment) conducted in May 2001.
It is also undisputed that the District, with the exception of the observations made by Michelle King (at the time, a behavior specialist) in STUDENT’s home environment during the period October 2001 to March 2002, and speech-language pathologist Anne Rosecrance’s involvement with STUDENT during the period February 2002 to May 2002, the District has not had any opportunity to observe STUDENT in any settings. Moreover, the District has not been authorized to observe STUDENT in his current school environment (Merryhill) where he has been a pupil since June 3, 2002.
It is also undisputed that STUDENT is autistic and has changing needs. Moreover, witnesses who have worked with STUDENT recently (Ms. Runion of Merryhill and Ms. Mills and Ms. Gifford of Bridges) testified to the recent progress made by STUDENT on his goals and objectives. Ms. Runion, STUDENT’s teacher at Merryhill, testified that STUDENT has “absolutely without a doubt” made progress at Merryhill over a relatively short period of time (from August 2002, through October 30, 2002 when she testified). Ms. Runion further described STUDENT’s progress there as “astounding,” but Ms. Runion acknowledged that she and the staff members at Merryhill have no experience working with children with autism. Ms. Mills testified that STUDENT has made “tremendous gains” in generalizing language, not just in discrete trials. The overall progress described by the three non-District witnesses, including changes in Bridges goals and objectives, suggest that STUDENT has experienced significant changes since moving into the District and support the conclusion that these changes warrant reassessment by the District.
District witnesses testified consistently that formal assessments are needed each year prior to the annual review, particularly given STUDENT’s age and profile as a child on the autistic spectrum. (Test. of Ms. King, Ms. Rosecrance, Ms. Sells, Ms. Brooks and Ms. Clumpner) The Hearing Officer notes that Ms. King and Ms. Rosecrance have already had some experience working with STUDENT (although not recently) and demonstrated a knowledge of STUDENT’s disability. The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Sells and Ms. Brooks particularly persuasive on the need for direct observations by District staff members. Ms. Sells stated that it was especially important to observe a child new to the District and that it was “extremely important” for her to assess STUDENT herself and not to rely on the independent written progress reports (of Bridges) that may be subjective and not realistic about the school setting.(Footnote 10) Ms. Sells stated that proceeding without a District assessment, was like “being asked to adopt a child and serve that child based on paperwork and then to place the child not in your home but in a home down the street.” Ms. Brooks also stressed the importance of observation and raised the following questions she contends are not answered by the Bridges updates and that require observations by District staff members for answers: If he has so many sight words, how does he (use the words) during the whole day and in another context? Does he use the information or the skills that he has (acquired) throughout his environment, and is it functional for him? How does he do when other students are around? Ms. Brooks observed that the latter question is the part “so critical in observation.”
Ms. Clumpner testified that the District has had little contact with STUDENT and that District employees didn’t have their own perception of current performance levels and did not have their own informal assessments that would normally be done in the course of serving him.
The Hearing Officer notes that a district has the right to conduct its own assessment of a student and cannot be required to rely upon the observations and data provided by a nonpublic agency. For example, California Education Code obligates a District to make its own observations to determine present levels of performance. Education Code Section 56327 (d) provides that the written assessment report shall include the relevant behavior noted during the observation of the pupil in an appropriate setting. (emphasis added) The need for an assessment and observations by the District is particularly relevant for a young (approaching age seven) autistic child like STUDENT whose needs change from year to year and who, over the past year, has gone from a State preschool to no school (October 2001 to June 2002) to a private school (in June 2002). Moreover, it is commonly understood that for young autistic children like STUDENT, there is a window of opportunity for learning. The District not only has the right but the obligation to ensure that it understands how STUDENT is currently progressing through periodic assessments in order to ascertain his needs and to identify an appropriate placement and services.
The Hearing Officer finds that all of the above considerations are factors in the determination that changing conditions warrant reassessment of STUDENT by the District. Observations of STUDENT by District staff members are particularly important on the issue of generalization and inclusion, to determine the effectiveness of the behavioral techniques used by Bridges and whether skills learned by STUDENT are functional across all settings. Observations conducted at Merryhill will also help the District to determine firsthand how well STUDENT is interacting with his peers and how he is behaving in a classroom. The Hearing Officer also finds particularly persuasive the testimony of inclusion specialist Linda Brooks, who stated that observations are a crucial part of the assessment process and that to rely simply on reports from an NPA would be akin to having a doctor prescribe medicine over the phone for a patient never seen by the doctor.
The Hearing Officer does not find persuasive the testimony of Ms. Gifford that an “audience effect” (the effect on behavior when people are watching) resulting from observations of STUDENT by District staff members would invalidate the observations. The Hearing Officer finds the assertion self-serving and also contradicted by the testimony of Ms. Runion, who stated that STUDENT has made “astounding” progress in the short time he has been at Merryhill. Presumably the new staff and peers at Merryhill can also create an audience effect for STUDENT. Moreover, District employees are experienced and can minimize the impact of audience effect by making observations of STUDENT over different settings and on different days and times. The Hearing Officer is also not persuaded that the District’s agreement to goals and objectives at IEP meetings indicates that the District has acquiesced on statements regarding present levels of performance, thereby suggesting that assessments are unwarranted at this time. District staff members testified that they developed goals and objectives based upon the information then available to them, but Ms. Brooks described the effort as a “shot in the dark” because the District did not have an adequate opportunity to work with STUDENT (never having been a pupil in a District school). The Hearing Officer notes that one year had not yet passed from the time of STUDENT’s triennial in May 2001 when goals and objectives were formulated in March 2002, and that STUDENT’s mother would not consent in January 2002 to cognitive testing or to an “assessment.” The District’s proposed assessment plan was developed in June 2002, over one year after the triennial.
PARENT’s testimony that she doesn’t “trust” the District is perplexing, given the District’s limited involvement with STUDENT. Notes recorded on the initial interim IEP held on December 13, 2001, indicate that, even then, within a few weeks of STUDENT’s move into the District, PARENT indicated a “lack of trust” in the District. PARENT provided no credible evidence to support her lack of trust in the District. The Hearing Officer also does not find persuasive Respondent’s contention an assessment is unwarranted because the same YCOE staff members who conducted the triennial will be conducting this assessment. Ms. King is the only individual employed by the YCOE who will be participating in this assessment, and Ms. King persuasively testified to the need for the District’s assessment after a significant lapse of time since the triennial (one and one-half years). Moreover, it has been over one year since Ms. King prepared the FAA (August 2001) and when she made her last observations of STUDENT in a classroom setting (October 2001).
The credible evidence with regard to the several factors set forth above establishes that conditions warrant an assessment of STUDENT by the District that has never previously assessed him. However, at present, STUDENT is enrolled in a private school and is not requesting special education services from the District at this time and is not requesting relief for past or prospective services (Case No. SN02-01605 has been withdrawn). Moreover, the District has taken the position that the method by which STUDENT’s parent placed him unilaterally at Merryhill makes him a private school student. The District’s position is that it is not obligated to fund STUDENT’s placement at Merryhill. The District has provided no authority, and the Hearing Officer is not aware of any, establishing the proposition that a District may assess a student in private school who is making no special education claims against the District. At present, STUDENT’s parent will not consent to the District’s assessment plan. Therefore, the District is not entitled to assess STUDENT and the Hearing Office has no authority to order an assessment.
However, if STUDENT’s parent seeks services from the District in the future or files for a special education due process hearing seeking past and/or prospective relief for alleged violations of FAPE, the District will become entitled to assess STUDENT immediately. See Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307 (9th Cir.); See also Andress v. Cleveland Independent School District, 64 F.3d 176 (5th Cir.). The order of this Decision sets forth the circumstances under which the District would become entitled to assess STUDENT immediately in accordance with its June 19, 2002 assessment plan.
Regarding the District’s request to make observations of STUDENT at Merryhill, a private school, the Hearing Officer finds that there is no persuasive authority precluding the Hearing Officer from ordering Respondent’s parent to provide consent for the observations. Accordingly, Respondent’s parent is directed to provide written consent for observations of STUDENT at Merryhill by District staff members and by Michelle King if and when the District’s right to assess STUDENT is activated by the terms of the order of this Decision.(Footnote 11)
Has the District developed its proposed assessment plan appropriately?
When a school district seeks to evaluate or reevaluate a Respondent with a disability, certain procedures must be followed. Members of the IEP team and other qualified professionals, as appropriate, are required to review the existing assessment data, current classroom assessments and observations, and teacher and observations of related service providers. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(b)(1); 20 U.S.C. §1414(c)(1)(A). Following the review of information and input from the pupil’s parent, the IEP team and appropriate qualified professionals must then identify what, if any, additional data are needed to determine, among other things, the child’s present levels of performance and educational needs, and whether additions or modifications to the child’s program are required to provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE). Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(b)(2); 20 U.S.C. § 1414(c)(1)(B). From this review, the IEP team develops an assessment plan that should be focused on producing the data identified by the team as necessary for making decisions regarding the child’s program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(c).
District witnesses credibly testified that information was obtained from PARENT as early as during the first IEP meeting held on December 13, 2001, the second IEP meeting held in January (at the December meeting PARENT indicated that she would not consent to a cognitive assessment, and at the January meeting, to any assessments), as well as at the IEP meeting held on March 14, 2002. For the interim IEP meeting, the District also obtained Respondent’s file from Woodland. (Test. of Ms. Clumpner) Information was sought from Respondent’s mother during the IEP meetings. Ms. Gifford (Bridges director) appeared at the March 14 meeting and participated in the discussions, and the January 27, 2002 Bridges update report was provided to the IEP team. (Test. of Ms. Gifford) At the time the proposed assessment plan was developed at the June 19 IEP meeting, the District had the only available Bridges update report (January 27) as well as records from the triennial assessment conducted in May 2001. The District also had update reports from Ms. King and Ms. Rosecrance. Moreover, at the reconvened IEP meeting held on June 28, the Respondent, through his parent and Ms. Mills, provided information on the Bridges’ version of STUDENT’s present levels of performance. Because the District was not directly providing any services to STUDENT as of June 2002, the District IEP members had obtained all of the available information it could obtain in order to develop an appropriate assessment plan.(Footnote 12) The contention by Respondent’s mother that her input wasn’t sought or questions weren’t solicited from her is unpersuasive. The letters sent by the District to PARENT in June 2002 indicated that if she had any questions about the plan, she could call the District. It is undisputed that PARENT did not call the District with questions nor did not she ask the District questions about the plan at the reconvened IEP meeting held on June 28, 2002.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District complied with federal and State law regarding development of its proposed assessment plan.
Does the District’s proposed assessment plan comport with legal requirements
California Education Code section 56321 provides that the proposed assessment plan given to a parent shall: (1) be in a language that is easily understood by the general public; (2) be provided in the primary language of the parent; (3) explain the types of assessments to be conducted; and (4) state that no individualized education program will result from the assessment without the consent of the parents. There is no dispute that the assessment plan conformed with paragraphs 1, 2, and 4 of section 56321. However, Respondent contended that the plan failed to explain the types of assessments to be conducted. The Hearing Officer is satisfied that the District’s assessment plan meets the requirements of section 56321 and was sufficiently detailed in its description of the types or areas of assessments to be conducted. Special education law requires that if a district assesses a Respondent, the procedures for initial assessments commencing with California Education Code Section 56320 must be followed. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(a). The following relevant requirements apply. Testing and assessment materials and procedures must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; the materials must be provided and administered in the pupil’s primary language; the testing must be administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; and the test instruments must be validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(a), (b). Assessment materials must assess specific areas of educational need and not merely provide a single general intelligence quotient. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(c). Further, no single procedure shall be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for a child. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(e)
The assessment shall be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the disability. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(g). Health assessments must be conducted by a credentialed school nurse or physician who is trained and prepared to assess cultural and ethnic factors appropriate to the pupil being assessed. Cal. Educ. Code § 56324(b). Additionally, assessments must be conducted by persons competent to perform the assessments, as determined by the school district, county office, or special education local plan area. Cal. Educ. Code § 56322.
Each District witness who testified at the hearing expected to perform part of the assessment (Ms. King, Ms. Rosecrance, Ms. Sells, and Ms. Brooks) stated that each of the above statutory requirements would be met during their portion of the assessment.(Footnote 13) Nor did the Respondent provide persuasive authority that the District was obligated to identify within the assessment plan the specific test instruments to be used during the assessment.
Behavior analyst Michelle King testified that she will conduct observations of STUDENT in his current educational setting and at home and will administer the Assessment of Basic Language and Learning Skills (ABLLS). The ABLLS is a criterion-based test completed by “people who know STUDENT best,” parents, teachers and direct service providers. (Test. of Ms. King) Ms. King stated that the ABLLS is appropriate for STUDENT because it is designed for children on the autistic spectrum. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. King is qualified to conduct observations of STUDENT and is competent to administer the ABLLS.(Footnote 14)
Speech and language pathologist Anne Rosecrance testified that she will be administering the following standardized test instruments: the Preschool Language Scale 3 (PLS-3), the Arizona Articulation Scale, the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test, the Expressive Vocabulary Test, the Stuttering Severity Index (SSI) test, the Boehm, and clinician devised tasks (for which she received training during her master’s degree program). Ms. Rosecrance stated that the testing would be conducted in English (the primary language of STUDENT and his parent), and that each test instrument is valid for the purpose for which they are used. Ms. Rosecrance stated that the PLS-3 is normed for Respondents up to age six years and eleven months, and that if STUDENT at the time of the actual testing is over that age, a different test instrument, the Clinical Evaluation Language Fundamental (CELF) test will be used instead. Ms. Rosecrance persuasively testified that she is a qualified speech language pathologist and is competent to administer the testing as described in her testimony.(Footnote 15)
School psychologist Barbara Sells testified that she will perform that part of the integrated team assessment that tests intellectual ability, body coordination and psycho-motor, socio-emotional, and adaptive behavior. Ms. Sells stated that she will conduct observations in the home, school and community and will administer the Adaptive Behavior Assessment Scale (ABAS) and the NEPSY [a developmental neuropsychological assessment]. Depending on the outcome of these tests, Ms. Sells also may administer the Wechsler III performance scale, the Draw a Person, the Visual Motor Integration Test (VMI) and the CTONI [Comprehensive Test of Nonverbal Intelligence]. Ms. Sells stated that the ABAS and NEPSY are normed for autistic students and that she is experienced in administering these test instruments. Ms. Sells testified that she has twelve years of experience as a credentialed school psychologist and has experience assessing students on the autistic spectrum, including autistic children in the age range of six to seven. Ms. Sells persuasively testified to her unrebutted qualifications as a credentialed school psychologist competent to administer the test instruments described in her testimony.
Inclusion specialist Linda Brooks testified that she will be performing part of the assessment in the following areas: classroom observations in different settings and at different times of day and will target self-help, readiness, academic skills, communication (both verbal and nonverbal), social and behavior (especially peer interactions) and gross motor skills. Ms. Brooks persuasively testified to her unrebutted qualifications as an inclusion specialist with fourteen years of experience overseeing the inclusion program for Davis. Ms. Brooks has experience as a full inclusion teacher for Davis 1989 to the present) and as a special day class (SDC) teacher for the severely handicapped (from 1983 to 1989). Ms. Brooks has severely handicapped and general elementary credentials and is a graduate of the University of California at Berkeley with a B.A. degree in child development. Ms. Sells testified credibly to her qualifications and experience, unrebutted, necessary for the observations and informal assessments she described in her testimony. The District coordinator of special education Ms. Clumpner testified that a school nurse would complete the health portion of the assessment by using a “fairly comprehensive health and development form” and would interview PARENT to complete the form.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed assessment plan comports with the legal requirements under State and federal special education law. If and when the District becomes entitled to assess STUDENT in accordance with the June 19, 2002 assessment plan, the District may use the test instruments specified in the testimony of the District’s witnesses or other test instruments as the District determines appropriate. Education Code Sections 56381(a) and 56320; 20 U.S.C. Ch. 33 §1414 et seq. The current assessment plan is valid for the remainder of the 2003-2003 school year and ESY.(Footnote 16)
ORDER
1. At present, the District is not entitled to conduct an assessment of STUDENT, who is a private school student.
2. If STUDENT seeks special education services from the District or files for a special education due process hearing or seeks any other remedy for past and/or prospective services from the District, the District is entitled to conduct its assessment of STUDENT in accordance with its June 19, 2002 assessment plan.
A. The District may conduct an assessment after giving five (5) days written notice to STUDENT’s parent before conducting the assessment.
B. The June 19, 2002 assessment plan remains valid and may be administered at any time prior to the conclusion of the 2002-2003 school year and ESY.
3. If the District is entitled to conduct an assessment of STUDENT in accordance with paragraph one of this Order, PARENT is directed to give to the District her written consent for observations of STUDENT at Merryhill or at any other private school that STUDENT may be attending. PARENT shall make STUDENT reasonably available for the assessment.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
In accordance with Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: The District substantially prevailed on the only issue heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
DATED: December 4, 2002 ____________________________________ Mark D. Brylski, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The issue was clarified during an October 16 prehearing telephone conference, as reflected within the prehearing conference order issued on October 17, 2002. The issue has been reworded slightly to facilitate analysis. 2. Davis and Woodland are within the same County (Yolo) and the same SELPA. 3. According to Ms. Runion, STUDENT attends class from 9:00 a.m. until 12:30 p.m., five days per week. 4. According to Ms. Clumpner, a copy of the proposed assessment plan and cover letter was also sent by attorneys for the District to the attorneys who represent STUDENT. 5. In a July 8, 2002 reply letter from the Respondent’s attorney, the Respondent stated that a “full reevaluation” of STUDENT was not appropriate considering his triennial review [in May 2001], and Respondent also disagreed with the contention made by the District concerning the placement change. (Dist. Exh. 33) 6. On July 23, 2002, The Hearing Office issued an Amended Summary Order that granted STUDENT’s motion for a stay put order regarding the services specified in the January 2002 IEP, but denied his motion for a stay put order for services to be provided by Bridges at the private school placement (Merryhill). (Dist. Exh. 37) On September 16, 2002, the Hearing Office received a request from the attorneys for STUDENT for a withdrawal of Case No. SN02-01605, and the matter was withdrawn. 7. The term reassessment refers to an assessment after the initial assessment and where conditions warrant it. Strictly speaking, the District in this case is seeking to assess the transferee Respondent for the first time. 8. Respondent suggested that the District’s speech and language pathologist administered a formal assessment during spring 2002, but no credible evidence supports that contention. 9. Ms. Gifford acknowledged that Bridges does not have a speech-language pathologist or school psychologist on staff to conduct assessments or to provide services. Moreover, Ms. Mills testified that Bridges did not have a formal behavioral plan for STUDENT and has no copy of a “handwritten” behavioral plan. 10. Ms. Sells also asserted that a “conflict of interest” exists when the same people are testing and serving a Respondent. Although the same assertion might be made about District staff members, the Hearing Officer notes that at present a dispute exists among the Respondent’s parent, the District, and Bridges over the District’s responsibilities regarding its decision not to continue funding Bridges. Under the circumstances, without an assessment, the District would be forced to rely upon progress reports from Bridges (without formal standardized testing and without current observations of STUDENT) to determine his present levels of performance. 11. The Hearing Office recognizes that it has no authority over a private school in this matter and that the extent of the Hearing Office’s authority in this case is limited to ordering the parent to execute a written consent for observations to be conducted at a private school. 12. Respondent’s contention that the District did not obtain a Regional Center update is unavailing, since Respondent’s parent did not respond to the District’s request for execution of a new consent form for release of information from the Regional Center. Ms. Clumpner credibly testified that since Respondent was now represented by counsel, the District felt that it would be prudent to obtain another release. In any event, the attorney for Respondent subsequently revoked Respondent’s consent for the exchange of information. (Respondent Exhs. 245-246) 13. The Hearing Officer does not find that the testing will be conducted in accordance with the statutory requirements because such a finding would be premature. 14. Ms. King has administered the ABLLS twice and was trained in May 2001 by the company that devised the instrument, Behavioral Analysis Inc. and received a workshop certificate. Ms. King has a B.S. degree in psychology and business administration with sixteen units in applied behavior analysis course work and is currently enrolled in a master’s degree program for school counseling. Ms. King worked for one year as a behavior specialist with Yolo County and is now a county Behavior Analyst (since 2001). (Test. of Ms. King) 15. Ms. Rosecrance has a master’s degree in speech-language pathology and has been a licensed speech-language pathologist with the District for six years. Ms. Rosecrance testified that she has previously administered each of the test instruments referred to above to Respondents on the autistic spectrum except for the SSI. However, Ms. Rosecrance stated that the SSI is “very easy to administer.” 16. Thereafter, given the possibility of changes in STUDENT’s needs, the proposed assessment plan may not then be appropriate.
