California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 15, 2004
Student v. Ocean View Elementary School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 2258-04 · Hearing Officer Michael F. Geary
Ocean View Elementary must hold a new IEP meeting and provide 216 compensatory hours after leaving a regular education teacher off the IEP team.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
A Memorandum Re: Orders at Hearing was issued on October 11, 2004. The decision does not mention any remand, vacatur, or correction.
Summary
Ocean View Elementary School District and the parents of a five-year-old boy with autism both filed for due process, and the cases were consolidated. After a year at St. Wilfrid's, a private preschool, the District offered for 2004-2005 a special day class at Westmont with about 90 minutes of daily inclusion, school and home behavioral intervention, speech therapy, and occupational therapy (OT). The parents wanted the private preschool with a shadow aide and home verbal behavior services.
The Hearing Officer found the District denied a FAPE through February 17, 2005. No regular education teacher attended the June 9, 2004 IEP meeting, even though the boy attended a regular preschool and the offer included regular class time. The preschool director was not his teacher and was not credentialed, so she did not fill that role. The IEP had no goal for oral-motor needs affecting eating and saliva control. The District also failed to prove that two 30-minute weekly speech sessions were enough. A transition plan and goal revisions that one staff member drafted outside an IEP meeting were procedural violations. The Hearing Officer upheld the OT and behavioral services, the measurable goals, the clarity of the offer, and the special day class as the least restrictive environment. Reimbursement and funding for the private preschool were denied. The District must hold a new IEP meeting within 20 school days and provide 216 hours of compensatory services.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO handled a missing regular education teacher when a child attends, or may attend, regular education. A private preschool director who was not the child's teacher did not count. It also treated plan changes drafted by one staff member outside an IEP meeting as procedural violations, even when parents could later request a meeting.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Has the District offered Student a FAPE in the least restrictive environment for the 2004-2005 school year from the beginning of the regular school year through the expiration of the current IEP on February 17, 2005?
Overall, the District denied a FAPE through February 17, 2005. The missing regular education teacher, the missing oral-motor (nutrition and hygiene) goal, too little speech therapy, and the transition plan and goal revisions drafted outside the IEP process together denied FAPE.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 1-A(1). June 9, 2004 IEP, procedural: failure to conduct the preschool-to-kindergarten reassessment required by Education Code section 56445
Section 56445 requires reassessment to decide whether the child still needs special education. Continued eligibility was never in question, and the IEP team had enough current data, so no violation was found.
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1-A(2). June 9, 2004 IEP, procedural: no regular education teacher was present at the IEP meeting
A regular education teacher was required because the student attended a regular preschool and the offer included about a third of the day in regular education. The preschool director was not his teacher and held no credential, so she did not fill the role. This denied an important procedural right.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1-A(3). June 9, 2004 IEP, procedural: offer not adequately specific because placement at two school sites (Westmont and Lake View) was discussed
The written offer clearly named Westmont. Discussing Lake View as an option, and listing Lake View in the form's header, did not make the offer unclear.
- Student prevailed in partIEP content
Issue 1-B(1). June 9, 2004 IEP, substantive: absence of goals for expressive language, gross and fine motor skills, oral-motor skills (nutrition and hygiene), learning readiness/preacademics, play/social skills, sensory integration, self-help, functional skills, and behavior
Goals were adequate in every challenged area except one: the IEP improperly lacked a goal for oral-motor needs related to nutrition and hygiene. No behavior goal was required in June 2004.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 1-B(2). June 9, 2004 IEP, substantive: goals not measurable (inaccurate baselines, mastery thresholds below 70 percent)
The District made a reasonable effort to report present levels accurately. No law requires a 70 percent mastery level, and the goals were measurable.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1-B(3)(a). June 9, 2004 IEP, substantive: insufficient speech and language therapy
The District gave only unsupported opinions that two 30-minute weekly sessions were enough. The IEP also failed to specify the frequent short oral-motor practice the student needed, so the offer did not meet his needs.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1-B(3)(b). June 9, 2004 IEP, substantive: insufficient occupational therapy
One 45-minute clinic session and one 30-minute classroom session each week was reasonably calculated to provide benefit, given his past progress at similar levels.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1-B(3)(c). June 9, 2004 IEP, substantive: insufficient ABA services (including shadow aide) and ABA supervision
The District offered more direct ABA hours than Student requested, plus an aide during inclusion time. Eight hours of supervision a month was reasonable.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPETransition
Issue 1-B(4). June 9, 2004 IEP, substantive: no transition plan
A transition plan from private to public providers was needed and should have been part of the June 9 offer. Because a plan was sent by June 22, well before school started, leaving it out of the June 9 offer did not deny FAPE by itself.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1-B(5). June 9, 2004 IEP, substantive: offered program not in the least restrictive environment
Applying the Rachel H. factors, the SDC with about 90 minutes of daily inclusion was the LRE based on the information then available. The new IEP team, including a general education teacher, must reconsider inclusion time.
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1-C. June 22, 2004 IEP addendum (transition plan) not developed by the IEP team as required by Education Code section 56341(a)
One District employee drafted the transition plan outside the IEP process without input from parents or providers. This was a procedural violation, and a properly composed IEP team must develop the plan. The plan's substantive adequacy was not reached.
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1-D. September 23, 2004 IEP addendum (revised goals, sensory diet, contingent behavior plan) created outside the IEP process
The addendum made substantive changes that the IEP team should have decided. It was procedurally defective and did not cure the June 9 deficiencies.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1-E. October 5, 2004 emergency IEP meeting held without parents; interim behavior plan not based on a functional analysis assessment
Four days' notice was enough, and the parents chose not to attend, so other efforts would have been futile. The meeting had no consequence and did not deny FAPE. The claim that no functional analysis assessment was done was not reached.
- District prevailedDistrict-filed: assess without consent
Issue 2. Is the District entitled to conduct a gross motor/adapted physical education assessment of Student pursuant to an assessment plan dated June 9, 2004?
Based on the parties' stipulation and the parents' written consent given during the hearing, the District may conduct the assessment. The Hearing Officer stated that no one prevailed because the issue was decided by stipulation.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 3. If the District has failed to offer Student a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year, are his parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of educational and related services provided during the 2004-2005 regular school year to the date of the Decision?
The OT offer was appropriate. For speech therapy, Student offered no proof of the amount the parents paid, the provider's qualifications, or whether the services were appropriate, so no reimbursement was ordered.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4. If the District has failed to offer Student a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year through February 17, 2005, is he entitled to an award of compensatory education?
Compensatory education was awarded to roughly match the services the student would have received during the 14 school weeks. It was offset only by three OT sessions, because the District did not prove any other services it provided.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 5. Is Student entitled to an order requiring the District to fund his continued placement at St. Wilfrid's or some other regular education nonpublic preschool, and to provide or fund speech and language therapy, OT, and ABA services (including a shadow aide) through February 17, 2005?
St. Wilfrid's is not a certified nonpublic school, Student offered no other placement, and the evidence did not show the District was unable to provide a FAPE.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to assess. Within ten school days of the decision, the parents must make the student available for the gross-motor assessment they consented to, if they wish to use a public education for him.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within twenty school days of the decision, the District must convene an IEP meeting with all required participants to finish the student's IEP. The IEP must include appropriate goals for oral-motor needs related to nutrition and hygiene, an appropriate level of speech and language therapy, an appropriate transition plan, a sensory diet, and appropriate behavior supports, all in the least restrictive environment.
- Compensatory education. 150 hours of direct home-based ABA services and 28 hours of ABA supervision, provided by or as directed by the District by the end of the 2007 extended school year. The IEP team decides frequency and duration.
- Compensatory education. 21 hours of individual speech and language therapy by the end of the 2007 extended school year.
- Compensatory education. 10 hours of clinic-based OT and 7 hours of classroom-based OT by the end of the 2007 extended school year.
Total: 216 hours of compensatory services
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range School District; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Seattle School District No. 1 v. B.S.; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District; Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel H.; Adams v. State of Oregon; Shapiro v. Paradise Valley Unified School District; M.L. v. Federal Way School District; Burlington; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education; Lester H. v. Gilhool
People named in the decision
- Linda Forsythe, program director / autism program director; drafted IEP addenda, West Orange County Consortium for Special Education (WOCCSE)
- Marilou Lundberg, interim coordinator of special education, Ocean View Elementary School District
- Greg Endelman, coordinator of special education, Ocean View Elementary School District
- Shawna Kemp, occupational therapist, WOCCSE
- Vickie Kincaid, speech and language pathologist, Ocean View Elementary School District
- Patty Mulcahy, occupational therapist, WOCCSE
- Michelle Wall, pre-kindergarten/kindergarten special day class teacher, Westmont campus; IBI supervisor, Ocean View Elementary School District
- Michelle Anderson, autism program specialist / ABA supervisor, WOCCSE
- Kim Doyle, preschool special day class teacher, Pleasant View campus (2002-2003), Ocean View Elementary School District
- Abby Rozenberg, private speech-language pathologist; expert witness for Student, Private practice
- Mary Hiber, private preschool teacher (2003-2004), St. Wilfrid's Preschool
- Phyllis Lembke, private preschool director, St. Wilfrid's Preschool
- Richard Furbush, private occupational therapist, SKY Pediatrics
- Denise Eckman, supervisor of private ABA/verbal behavior analysis program, Private provider
- Jennifer Obholz, private speech and language assessor, Private provider
- Cornerstone Therapy, private speech-language and global therapy provider, Private agency
- Autism Spectrum Consultants, certified nonpublic agency (private report), Nonpublic agency
- Regional Center of Orange County, regional center (early services), Regional center
- St. Wilfrid's Preschool, private Christian preschool (unilateral placement), Private school
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), the University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Huntington Beach, California, on October 6, 12, 13, 14, 15, and 19, 2004. (Footnote 1)
STUDENT (Student or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorneys Ellen Bacon, Paul Roberts, and Mike Jewell. (Footnote 2) STUDENT’s parents, Mr. and Ms. PARENT, were also present.
The Ocean View Elementary School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Caroline Zuk. Marilou Lundberg, the District’s interim coordinator of special education, and Linda Forsythe, a program director of the West Orange County Consortium for Special Education (WOCCSE), were also present. (Footnote 3)
The District, which agreed to present its witnesses first, called the following witnesses: Linda Forsythe; Greg Endelman, the District’s coordinator of special education; Shawna Kemp, a WOCCSE occupational therapist; Vickie Kincaid, the District’s speech and language pathologist; Patty Mulcahy, another WOCCSE occupational therapist; Michelle Wall, teacher of the District’s pre-kindergarten/kindergarten special day class (SDC) at the Westmont campus, part of the District’s proposed placement for STUDENT; Michelle Anderson, a WOCCSE autism program specialist; and Kim Doyle, STUDENT’s teacher in the preschool SDC at the Pleasant View campus during the 2002-2003 school year.
Student called the following witnesses: his mother, Ms. PARENT; Abby Rozenberg, a private speech and language pathologist; Mary Hiber, a teacher at St. Wilfrid’s Preschool (St. Wilfrid’s), the private preschool that he attended during the 2003-2004 school year; Richard Furbush, an occupational therapist with SKY Pediatrics who has been providing private services to him; Phyllis Lembke, the director of St. Wilfrid’s; and Denise Eckman, the supervisor of his private applied behavioral analysis (ABA) program.
Oral and documentary evidence was presented at the hearing. Thereafter, the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
Issue No. 1: Has the District offered Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment for the 2004-2005 school year from the beginning of the regular school year through the expiration of the current individualized education program (IEP) on February 17, 2005? (Footnote 4)
Issue No. 2: Is the District entitled to conduct a gross motor/adapted physical education assessment of Student pursuant to an assessment plan dated June 9, 2004?
Issue No. 3: If the District has failed to offer Student a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year, are his parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of educational and related services provided to Student during the 2004-2005 regular school year to the date of the Decision in this case? (Footnote 5)
Issue No. 4: If the District has failed to offer Student a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year through February 17, 2005, is he entitled to an award of compensatory education?
Issue No. 5: Is Student entitled to an order requiring the District to fund his continued placement at St. Wilfrid’s or some other regular education nonpublic preschool, and to provide or fund the provision of speech and language therapy, occupational therapy, and applied behavioral analysis (ABA) services (including a shadow aide) for the remainder of the term of the current IEP through February 17, 2005? (Footnote 6)
BACKGROUND
STUDENT is a five-year-old child who is eligible for special education and related services on the basis of his diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder. He has extensive developmental delays in various areas, including cognition, communication, social/emotional functioning, and sensory processing. In addition, STUDENT has, at times, displayed maladaptive behaviors including screaming, tantrumming, head banging, and biting.
STUDENT lives with his biological mother and his stepfather within the geographical boundaries of the District. STUDENT was in a District preschool SDC placement with additional services during the 2002-2003 school year. His parents unilaterally placed him at St. Wilfrid’s, a private Christian preschool, for the 2003-2004 school year. (Footnote 7) Additional public and private services, including speech and language therapy, occupational therapy, and verbal behavior analysis (VBA) services, also have been provided to STUDENT. (Footnote 8) Although STUDENT’s parents had planned for him to return to St. Wilfrid’s for the 2004-2005 school year, as of the time of the hearing, he had not yet attended class there this school year.
When he was about eighteen months old and a client of the Regional Center of Orange County (RCOC), the chief concerns were about his speech development, maladaptive behaviors, including biting and temper tantrums, and body awareness/coordination. At that time, it was believed that STUDENT could remain attentive to a tabletop task for fifteen minutes. Eight months later, just after STUDENT’s second birthday, it was reported that he was able to respond to simple two-step commands, understood at least six object labels, used word approximations for “mom,” inconsistently used signs for “more,” “finished,” and “open,” and was able to put away his toys with a verbal cue and to engage in parallel play (a solitary play activity in proximity to another child).
At the time of the District’s initial assessment in June 2002, just prior to STUDENT’s third birthday, it was difficult for the assessors to test for skill levels due to STUDENT’s anxiety and nearly constant crying and his difficulty attending to tasks and following directions. His mother explained that STUDENT typically had this kind of difficulty with new people and situations. According to the report of the school psychologist, direct assessment measures could not be used. Based principally on observation and parent input, the psychologist opined that STUDENT’s overall skill level was in the area of five months, with some scattered skills as high as the nine-month level. (Footnote 9)
The psychologist also conducted an in-home observation, which confirmed that STUDENT was calmer and better able to demonstrate his skills in a familiar environment. Other than improved eye contact, there was nothing about the in-home observation that altered the assessor’s opinions about STUDENT’s levels of development. However, the report acknowledged that the estimate might have been low in view of a report issued seven months earlier by STUDENT’s private speech and language therapy and global therapy provider, Cornerstone Therapy (Cornerstone), stating that STUDENT then functioned cognitively in the nine- to eleven-month range. (Footnote 10) The school psychologist also noted moderately serious behavior problems.
Vickie Kincaid, the District’s speech and language pathologist, found, based in part on testing conducted by Cornerstone, that STUDENT had scattered language skills in the twelve- to twenty-one-month range, with the greatest skills in comprehension and the least in social language.
At about the same time that the District was conducting its initial assessment, Cornerstone was conducting a reassessment of STUDENT. The report of that reassessment concludes that STUDENT was then functioning cognitively in the twelve- to twenty-one-month range. His other skills were rated as follows: receptive language skills were scattered from twelve to twenty-one months; expressive language skills were scattered from twelve to eighteen months; social-emotional skills were at thirteen to fourteen months; gross motor skills were at fourteen to twenty-one months; fine motor skills were at sixteen months; visual-motor integration was at seventeen months; and daily living skills were at nine to fifteen months. In addition, Cornerstone found that STUDENT had atypical sensory processing skills that resulted in decreased body awareness (clumsiness) and a need for sensory input. (Footnote 11)
STUDENT’s initial IEP with the District dated July 12, 2002, provided a preschool-level SDC in the morning for three hours and twenty minutes, followed by an extended-day program that consisted of a lunch/play break and intensive behavioral intervention (IBI) in a one-to-one format. (Footnote 12) STUDENT also received one hour of IBI per day in his SDC, two thirty-minute speech and language therapy collaborations weekly, one forty-five-minute individual occupational therapy (OT) session and one thirty-minute small group OT session weekly, and one hour of IBI supervision weekly. In addition, STUDENT participated in the “August Program,” described as a program to help participants maintain or preserve the skills already learned, and the District provided a sensory diet (periodic physical activities to regulate his attention and readiness to learn during his time at school).
In early August 2002, the District conducted an assessment to address STUDENT’s biting behavior. Within a week, Ms. PARENT requested that the extended-day program be limited to the thirty-minute lunch/social break due to her concern that the long days were interfering with STUDENT’s usual nap schedule and probably causing or contributing to the maladaptive behaviors. The IEP was changed as requested by addendum.
On September 20, 2002, there was another IEP meeting. The District recommended that STUDENT resume his full extended-day program and that a home-based IBI component, three times weekly for ninety minutes each, be added. Ms. PARENT agreed to the offer of a home-based program and to extend the school-based program to 1:30 p.m., or for approximately half of the afternoon IBI session, with further adjustments to be determined by the parents and STUDENT’s teacher, Kim Doyle.
After an assessment of STUDENT’s gross motor skills, the District proposed the addition of twice-weekly adapted physical education (APE) sessions of twenty minutes each to work on jumping and throwing skills. With Ms. PARENT’s consent, APE was added to STUDENT’s program on September 26, 2002.
In October 2002, STUDENT began to purposefully bang his head, possibly in place of his biting behavior. At another IEP meeting on October 25, 2002, the parties agreed to reschedule the home program to earlier in the day.
A December 2002 report on progress toward IEP goals states that STUDENT had made “good progress” on the use of his Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS), imitation, matching, and following directions, “some progress” on transitions and behavior (selecting alternative activities to reduce anxiety), and “no progress” on imitating sounds. Biting had decreased but continued to some extent, as did pinching, head banging, and crying.
At Ms. PARENT’s request, STUDENT’s extended-day hours were again reduced to only the lunch/social break pursuant to a December 2, 2002 IEP addendum. (Footnote 13) According to the documents, Ms. PARENT was again concerned about STUDENT’s need for an afternoon nap to improve his behavior and replenish his immune system. However, she wanted to increase the number of hours in the home-based program.
A few days later, Ms. PARENT requested another meeting to discuss the home program. There were no changes made to the program at the IEP meeting on December 12, 2002, but, according to the IEP, the team agreed that STUDENT’s afternoon program would again be extended to 2:00 p.m. and that his home program also would be provided on Wednesdays for ninety minutes beginning in January 2003. Ms. PARENT presented a private report from Autism Spectrum Consultants, a certified nonpublic agency, and the team agreed to review it by December 20, 2002. (Footnote 14)
STUDENT’s first annual IEP review meeting was on February 27, 2003. The District offered a program similar to that which it had been recommending, including placement in an SDC, an extended-day IBI program, home-based IBI, IBI supervision, APE, speech and language therapy, and OT. The District also offered to provide extended school year services from mid-June to mid-July in addition to the August program. The IEP document states that, although apraxia had not been conclusively diagnosed, the goals and objectives would address STUDENT’s needs in the area of speech production. (Footnote 15) Ms. PARENT agreed to the IEP.
There were several addenda to the February 2003 IEP. The first, on March 17, 2003, amended to IEP to offer STUDENT a home program consisting of four ninety-minute sessions weekly. Ms. PARENT requested that the home sessions start at only seventy-five minutes to allow some additional naptime for STUDENT, then gradually increase his time to the ninety minutes offered. The District agreed.
Another IEP addendum meeting on March 24, 2003, addressed Ms. PARENT’s continuing concerns about the adequacy of the speech and language services to address STUDENT’s needs due to apraxia. The IEP team, including Ms. PARENT, agreed that five minutes per school hour would be devoted to oral-motor activities directed by educational staff trained by a speech and language specialist with expertise in apraxia. In addition, the IBI therapist/aide would observe the speech and language therapy sessions to learn strategies to address STUDENT’s oral-motor needs. This part of STUDENT’s program was to be supervised and advanced by the speech and language/apraxia specialist. STUDENT’s formal speech and language therapy sessions were reduced to twenty minutes three times weekly.
STUDENT was exhibiting maladaptive behaviors in early 2003. A functional analysis assessment of STUDENT’s biting behavior was conducted, beginning with observations and data collection from March 3 to April 4, 2003. STUDENT’s mother believed that the home program was interfering with STUDENT’s naptime and causing the maladaptive behaviors. The behaviorist’s observations revealed that the biting behavior occurred approximately seven times every eight instructional hours. There was a high frequency of the behavior during the one-to-one instructional time, but a low frequency during circle time and on Wednesdays. It was the assessor’s opinion that the function of the biting behavior was to avoid new or challenging demands. On April 11, 2003, a plan to address the biting behavior was presented to and approved by the entire IEP team.
The final addendum to the February 2003 IEP was on July 3, 2003. At that time the team again agreed to scale back STUDENT’s home program from ninety to seventy-five minutes to accommodate his nap schedule on the days he was scheduled for late school/service sessions.
STUDENT did not attend the District’s August program in 2003 and did not return to the District during the entire 2003-2004 school year. His parents opted to enroll him at St Wilfrid’s and provide him with private speech and language therapy, OT, and a VBA program supervised by Denise Eckman. He attended a typical preschool class at St. Wilfrid’s for two and one-half hours per day, two days per week throughout the regular school year. In early July 2004, this time was increased to three days per week.
There was a prior due process matter between these same parties. That matter was resolved by a settlement agreement dated January 9, 2004. The settlement agreement purported to settle all issues between the parties through July 31, 2004. It also required the District to convene a new IEP team meeting to incorporate their agreement. That IEP meeting occurred on February 17, 2004. The IEP developed at that meeting identified various needs in the areas of academic/functional skills, communication/language skills, gross and fine motor skills, social/emotional and behavioral skills, self-care skills, and sensory processing skills. The District’s providers proposed goals in the areas of articulation, sensory modulation, and upper body strength. Denise Eckman proposed goals in the areas of circle time, parallel play, schedule board use, visual performance (including visual imitation of relative positions using blocks, puzzle assembly, and picture matching), receptive language, imitation (of various motor movements and sounds), requesting, “tacting” (labeling), “intraverbals” (receptive/expressive language fill-ins), spontaneous vocalizations, play/social skills, fine motor skills, and self-help skills (dressing). (Footnote 16) The IEP states that placement for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year was to be the “private school placement and related services” agreed upon between the parties and set forth in their settlement agreement.
On June 9, 2004, the IEP team met to plan STUDENT’s program for the summer of 2004 and the 2004-2005 regular school year.
The District offered placement for the 2004-2005 regular school year to February 17, 2005, in a morning SDC with thirty minutes spent in a regular classroom with a one-to-one aide. In addition to the thirty minutes daily in a regular classroom. The District also proposed to “mainstream” STUDENT (educate him with typically developing peers) during lunch, recess, and library time. (Footnote 17) The District also offered a school-based IBI program, a home-based IBI program, IBI supervision, one forty-five-minute clinic-based OT session at WOCCSE weekly, one thirty-minute classroom-based OT session, and twice-weekly, thirty-minute individual speech and language therapy sessions. These services were all to begin on the first day of school, September 8, 2004, and be subject to annual review on February 17, 2005. In addition, the District offered its August program from August 2 through August 26, 2004. As with the prior IEP, the District proposed a number of goals in the area of speech and language. The OT goals from the February 17, 2004 IEP were carried forward and Ms. Eckman proposed annual goals (July 2004 to July 2005) in multiple domains, which were accepted by the IEP team. The IEP also indicates that a gross motor/APE assessment plan would be submitted and a plan to transition STUDENT from the private placement and service providers to public ones would be developed within two weeks and sent to the parents for their consideration.
Mr. and Ms. PARENT made it clear at this meeting that they were not interested in the District’s offer. In their dissent, they requested that STUDENT’s IEP provide for the continuation of his current program, including attendance at St. Wilfrid’s with a shadow aide, Ms. Eckman’s home-based VBA program, and speech and language therapy and OT provided by the District at levels greater than offered by the District at the June 9, 2004 IEP meeting. The parents also requested a slightly modified version of the home program during the summer months. The District responded to the parents’ request that STUDENT be allowed to continue with his private program by letter dated June 23, 2004. In essence, the District refused all of the parents’ requests, stating that STUDENT had been offered a FAPE by it on June 9, 2004.
On June 22, 2004, Linda Forsythe sent STUDENT’s parents a “proposed transition plan.” The proposed plan was attached to a form for an IEP addendum and stated that the IEP team was recommending adoption of the plan, but the form also allowed the parents to request an IEP team meeting to further discuss the proposed transition plan.
The District filed its request for a due process hearing on September 9, 2004. Student filed for a hearing on September 13, 2004. The matters were consolidated by minute order on September 17, 2004.
On September 23, 2004, Linda Forsythe prepared another addendum to STUDENT’s June 9, 2004 IEP. According to her testimony, this one purported to clarify the goals and objectives by transferring Ms. Eckman’s onto WOCCSE forms and adjusting the benchmarks to comport with the term of the IEP (September 2004 to February 17, 2005). The addendum also indicated that STUDENT would be given a sensory diet, with breaks required at least every thirty minutes, and that a behavior plan would be developed if his level of maladaptive behaviors warranted. The District attempted to schedule an IEP meeting to discuss this proposed addendum, but was unable to do so. Student’s attorneys responded to the invitation, explaining that the short notice and the upcoming due process hearing in this matter prevented them from attending an IEP meeting until October 14, 2004, or later.
About a week later, the District learned that STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors, including screaming, aggression, tantrumming, biting, and head banging, had increased in frequency and intensity. (Footnote 18) It attempted to schedule an IEP meeting to address behavioral concerns but Student’s attorneys again stated that they would be unable to participate until after the due process hearing.
The District convened an IEP meeting on October 5, 2004, without the parents. According to the meeting documents, the team reviewed a report of a behavioral emergency but no information was provided regarding the content or author. The IEP goes on to state that the team members identified additional unique needs in the area of behavior, developed a draft interim behavior plan, recommended implementation of the plan, and prepared a plan for an FAA of STUDENT. Copies of the draft interim behavior plan and the proposed FAA assessment plan were to be sent to the parents for their review. On the first day of hearing on October 6, 2004, Student’s attorney requested a continuance to review and consider these documents. The continuance request was granted. The Hearing Officer is aware of no other response from Student or his parents.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
In addition to the matters that were addressed on the first day of hearing and identified in the prior Memorandum Re: Orders at Hearing, the following procedural matters were addressed on the second day of hearing.
District’s Motion to Limit Prospective Relief
Pursuant to the Hearing Officer’s order issued on October 6, 2004, the parties provided points and authorities and argument in support of their respective positions regarding the Hearing Officer’s authority to award prospective relief beyond the term of the current IEP that expires on February 17, 2005. The District argued that the Hearing Officer should not substitute his judgment now in place of judgment that the IEP team has not yet had an opportunity to exercise. It argues that issues relating to STUDENT’s program beyond the expiration of the current IEP are not ripe. Student argued that the Hearing Office has ordered prospective relief beyond the term of the current IEP in the past and that to refuse to consider such a remedy at the outset would have a chilling effect on the motivation of parents and students to compel compliance with the IDEA.
The Hearing Officer found that there was inadequate information provided at that time to justify a determination that an award of prospective relief beyond the term of the current IEP would be inappropriate as a matter of law. The Hearing Officer could envision circumstances that might justify such an award if, for example, the evidence demonstrated that the District would be unable to provide a FAPE to STUDENT for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer denied the District’s motion, but advised the parties that both should take care to provide evidence and argument on the issue since it was possible that it would be have to be addressed in the Decision.
By the conclusion of the hearing in this matter, Student had offered no evidence or further argument to support his claim that the Hearing Officer should award prospective relief beyond the term of the current IEP. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that there is no adequate basis for an award of such prospective relief and that the FAPE issues to be addressed here are only ripe through the end of the current IEP on February 17, 2005. Agreement Regarding the District’s Right to Assess
On the second hearing day, Student’s attorney tendered to the District’s attorney a signed assessment plan for the gross motor/APE assessment and stated that the District’s assessment issue, identified as Issue No. 2, above, was thereby resolved and should be dismissed. The District’s counsel was skeptical and stated her concern that the parents would later withdraw their consent or otherwise prevent the assessment from being conducted. The parties stipulated on the record that the assessment plan was appropriate and that STUDENT’s parents had given their written consent to the plan. The Hearing Officer agreed to enter an order based on that stipulation.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue No. 1: Has the District offered Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment for the 2004-2005 school year from the beginning of the regular school year through the expiration of the current individualized education program (IEP) on February 17, 2005?
The Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq., and State special education law provide that a disabled student is entitled to a FAPE. A claim that there has been a denial of a FAPE can present both procedural and substantive questions.
Procedurally, the law requires that the student and parents be allowed to meaningfully participate in the process for the development of the IEP. Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 206-207, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982). Not every procedural flaw is critical, but one that results in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringes on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process may constitute a denial of a FAPE. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483-1484 (9th Cir. 1992).
Substantively, a FAPE is special education and related services that are available to a student at no charge to his or her parent or guardian, that meet the standards of the State educational agency, and that are provided in conformity with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). It includes special education and related services that are designed to meet the child’s unique needs when those needs cannot be met with modification of the regular instructional program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. It must enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347; Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(3).
The term “related services,” which in California also is referred to as “designated instruction and services” (DIS), includes developmental, corrective, and supportive services that may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363. DIS may include language and speech development and remediation services, APE, physical and occupational therapy, and parent counseling and training. Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(b)(1); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3051 et seq. In addition to DIS, the local educational agency (LEA) may be required to employ appropriate behavioral strategies if the pupil exhibits behavior that impedes his or her learning or the learning of others. 34 C.F.R. § 300.346(a)(2)(i); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.1(b)(1).
The United States Supreme Court stated that the local education agency (LEA) is not required to provide the child with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child’s abilities, but must provide at least a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 198-201. In this federal appellate circuit, at least, an appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the child. Seattle School District No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996); Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1524 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 513 U.S. 965 (1994). The Second Circuit has held that mere de minimis benefit or only trivial advancement is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2d Cir. 1997). However, there may be circumstances that justify an expectation of slow progress in small increments. In such instances, a child’s academic progress should be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability. Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997).
In summary, an IEP must be the result of a process that adequately protected the procedural rights of the student and parents. In addition, the student’s educational program must (1) be designed to meet the student’s unique needs; (2) be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit; and (3) conform to the student’s IEP. A disabled child also must be provided an education in the least restrictive environment (LRE). This means that the student must be educated and allowed to participate in school activities with nondisabled students to the maximum extent appropriate. (Footnote 19) 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A). The LEA has the burden of proof on all of these issues. Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994).
Several IEP meetings and documents went into making up the District’s offer of a placement and program to STUDENT for the 2004-2005 school year. Student contends that the June 9, 2004 IEP, and the June 22, September 23, and October 5, 2004 IEP addenda were all the result of a procedurally defective process. (Footnote 20) He also contends that the offered program is not adequately clear and specific, that the goals and objectives are inappropriate, and that the speech and language therapy, OT, ABA services, behavioral assessment and services, and transition assistance offered are insufficient. Each IEP and addendum referred to in Student’s contentions will be addressed separately below.
June 9, 2004 IEP
The June 9, 2004 IEP meeting was the first held to develop STUDENT’s IEP for the 2004-2005 school year.
Procedural Claims
Student alleges that this IEP was the result of a procedurally defective process because (1) the District did not conduct the assessment required by California Education Code section 56445 addressing preschool to kindergarten transitions, (2) there was no regular education teacher present at the IEP meeting, and (3) the District’s offer is not adequately specific because the placement offer refers to two different school sites.
(1) Assessment
California Education Code section 56445(a) states:
Prior to transitioning an individual with exceptional needs from a preschool program to kindergarten, or first grade as the case may be, an appropriate reassessment of the individual shall be conducted pursuant to Article 2 (commencing with section 56320) of Chapter 4 to determine if the individual is still in need of special education and services. (Emphasis added.)
The clear language of the statute itself provides that the assessment of the student prior to a transition from preschool to kindergarten or first grade is required expressly to determine if the student is still in need of special education and services. Thus, the specific language of the statute contemplates a mandatory reassessment only when a cessation, or at least a significant reduction in services, is anticipated. This construction finds further support in the language of later subsections, all of which deal with the cessation or reduction of special education or related services. STUDENT’s continued eligibility for special education was never in question and there was no plan to exit STUDENT from special education. The District instead contends that it wanted a more intensive program for STUDENT, not a less intensive one. This contention is borne out through the fact that a more intensive program was offered to STUDENT at the June 9, 2004 IEP meeting.
Even if the statute could be reasonably construed to require an assessment of all special education children prior to a transition into kindergarten or first grade, California Education Code section 56320 now provides that the IEP team and other qualified professionals are to determine the need for and the scope of any required reassessment. (Footnote 21) At the time of the June 9, 2004 IEP meeting, the IEP team had the benefit of a February 2004 T progress report from STUDENT’s private provider, a June 2004 progress report from his District OT provider, and a detailed progress report from Denise Eckman that discussed STUDENT’s progress in the areas of behavior/emotional development, communication, social skills, self-help skills, and pre-academic skills. Furthermore, the WOCCSE speech and language therapist and OT provider were both present at the meeting, as was Ms. Eckman. The IEP indicates that only a gross-motor skills assessment by its APE specialist was required at the time. There was no evidence to suggest that anyone, including the parents, Ms. Eckman, or Student’s attorney, believed that any additional assessment data was required. See Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(h); 34 C.F.R. § 300.533. The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not fail to conduct a required assessment of STUDENT pursuant to California Education Code section 56445.
(2) Regular Education Teacher at IEP Meeting
An IEP team must include “at least one regular education teacher of the child (if the child is, or may be, participating in the regular education environment).” 34 C.F.R. § 300.344(a)(2); see also Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b)(2). As a member of the IEP team, the regular education teacher must, to the extent appropriate, participate in the development, review, and revision of the child’s IEP, including assisting in the determination of appropriate positive behavioral interventions and strategies for the child, and supplementary aids and services and program modifications or supports for school personnel that will be provided for the child. 34 C.F.R. § 300.346(d).
The June 9, 2004 IEP offers STUDENT thirty minutes per day in a regular education classroom and additional mainstreaming opportunities during lunch, recess, and school assemblies, for a total of approximately ninety minutes per day of mainstreaming. Moreover, STUDENT was attending a private preschool with typically developing peers at the time of the IEP meeting. The statutory language is clear. It states that the IEP team shall include at least one regular education teacher if the child is or may be participating in the regular education environment. 34 C.F.R. § 300.344(a)(2); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b)(2). In this case, STUDENT was participating in a regular education environment at St. Wilfrid’s at the time of the IEP meeting. Additionally, the District offered him a placement that includes a significant amount of time in the regular education environment. As noted in 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, App. A, Q.24, which addresses the role of the regular education teacher in the IEP process, “the regular education teacher who is a member of the IEP team must participate in discussions and decisions about how to modify the general curriculum in the regular classroom to ensure the child’s involvement and progress in the general curriculum and participation in the regular education environment.” 64 Fed. Reg. 48 at 12477. The question of STUDENT’s ability to be successfully included in the regular education environment was one of the primary issues in this case. The parents prefer a general education placement, while the District recommends a predominantly special education placement. Additionally, given the parties’ settlement of a prior due process dispute in early 2004 (which included a dispute over whether the District should fund placement in a preschool with typically developing peers for STUDENT), the District was aware at the time it noticed the June 9 meeting that the parents preferred a general education placement. Therefore, under the facts of this case, a regular teacher was a required member of the IEP team because STUDENT was a child who was, or may be, participating in the regular education environment.
The District did not dispute at hearing that it was required to have a regular education teacher at the June 9 IEP meeting. In fact, Greg Endelman, the District’s coordinator of special education, testified that the District had invited “a representative” of St. Wilfrid’s to the meeting expressly so that person could represent the views of the only regular education teacher STUDENT had during the school year then ending. However, the District’s invitation to St. Wilfrid’s (via the notice of the IEP meeting) indicated only that a “representative” of St. Wilfrid’s should attend the meeting. As a result, Phyllis Lembke, the director of St. Wilfrid’s, attended the IEP meeting, not STUDENT’s teacher at St. Wilfrid’s, Mary Hiber.
Based on the evidence produced at hearing, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Lembke was not qualified to fulfill the required role of “a regular education teacher of the child” at the IEP meeting. 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, App. A, Q.26 provides that the regular education teacher who serves as a member of a child’s IEP team should be a teacher who is, or may be, responsible for implementing a portion of the IEP, so that the teacher can participate in discussions about how best to teach the child. (Footnote 22) Ms. Lembke testified that she has a master’s degree in early childhood development, is currently writing her doctoral thesis, has taught regular classes at St. Wilfrid’s, and is currently a professor at Coastline Community College and the University of California, Los Angeles, where she teaches courses on child development. However, Ms. Lembke testified that she does not hold a teaching credential, regular education or otherwise. Additionally, while she testified that she has personal knowledge regarding STUDENT because she observed him in his classroom daily, there is no dispute that she was not his teacher. The Hearing Officer finds that the attendance of Ms. Lembke at the IEP meeting did not satisfy the requirements of the law. Finally, there is no evidence that the District specifically invited STUDENT’s teacher from St. Wilfrid’s or any other regular education teacher to attend the meeting, or that any of the IEP team members who attended the June 9 meeting were credentialed regular education teachers. The District proceeded with the June 9 meeting, where issues regarding STUDENT’s program for the 2004-2005 school year (including the extent of appropriate mainstreaming) were discussed and decided, without a regular education teacher present. There also is no evidence that the District received input from a regular education teacher by any other means, such as through participation (even in part) in other IEP meetings related to the 2004-2005 school year or through written reports submitted to the IEP team. Thus, the District failed to establish at hearing that a regular education was a member of STUDENT’s IEP team.
Moreover, the District failed to offer any persuasive evidence that not having a regular education teacher in attendance at the June 9 meeting resulted in harmless error to STUDENT. (Footnote 23) The District offered to place STUDENT in the regular education environment during a third of his school day. Yet, there was no regular education teacher present at the June 9, 2004 IEP meeting to discuss how his needs should be addressed while he is in the regular education environment. (Footnote 24) Further, the District failed to offer the testimony of any regular education teacher at hearing to establish that STUDENT’s needs would be appropriately met while in the regular education environment under the District’s proposed program.
Given the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to include a regular education teacher on STUDENT’s IEP team to participate in the development of a program for STUDENT for the 2004-2005 school year and that this resulted in a denial of an important procedural right. The significance of this procedural violation will be examined further below.
(3) Specificity of Placement Offer
Districts are required to give written prior notice to the parents of the child whenever they propose to initiate or change, or refuse to initiate or change, the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child, or the provision of a free appropriate public education to the child. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3). Such notice provides the parents with information that can help them to make informed decisions about their child’s education. The notice is also important in that it helps ensure that there is a clear record of what placement, services, and assistance were offered to the student and when they were offered. Union School Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 513 U.S. 965 (1994).
Student contends that the offer was presented in terms that are misleading regarding the location of the proposed placement because the team discussed placements at Westmont and at Lake View, both public elementary schools within the District, and his parents did not understand which of those placements was actually offered. The District responds that, although it is true that SDCs at both Westmont and Lake View were considered, the offer specifically states that the proposed placement is at Westmont.
There was conflicting testimony regarding the discussion at the IEP meeting concerning possible and recommended placements. Ms. PARENT stated that the District offered an SDC placement at Lake View but stated that Westmont was also available. (Footnote 25) Ms. Eckman testified that the District made two offers, Lake View and Westmont. In contrast, virtually all of the District’s witnesses who attended the meeting testified that both placements were discussed, but only Westmont was recommended and was the specific placement written into the actual offer.
A review of the IEP itself reveals that the District’s written offer of services clearly identifies Westmont as the proposed location. Furthermore, there was no evidence that STUDENT’s parents or attorneys expressed any confusion regarding the placement at the meeting when the offer was made or at any time until the issues for hearing were clarified on the first day of hearing. This is consistent with the credible testimony of the District’s witnesses.
Ms. PARENT also testified that the identifying information at the top of the first page of the IEP identifies the “school” as Lake View and based upon her past experience with the form, she understood this to mean a placement at Lake View was also being offered. Although a review of prior IEP documents reveals that the District was inconsistent in its identification of “school” at the top of the first page of the IEP form, the Hearing Officer does not believe that this inconsistency misled the parents or Student’s attorneys. Although it is not clear to the Hearing Officer what school is supposed to be identified in the upper section of page one of the IEP form, an examination of the three IEPs dated July 12, 2002, February 27, 2003, and February 17, 2004, reveals that none used this information to specify an alternative placement. On the other hand, all of them identified the placement actually offered in the “program recommendation” section, as was done on June 9, 2004. The prior IEPs also reveal that there were two instances where the District identified a placement in its offer different than the one identified in the top section of the form, but there was no suggestion in the testimony that this past practice by the District ever led to any confusion on the part of the parents regarding placements offered in prior IEPs, even when the same identification of Lake View appeared at the top of the February 17, 2004 IEP form.
The Hearing Officer finds that the team’s consideration of Lake View as a possible placement was not confusing. On the contrary, IEP teams should be discussing, and parents should be considering, options. He also finds that there was nothing confusing about the reference to Lake View on the June 9, 2004 IEP, particularly in light of the District’s past practice, including the clear identification of the offered placement in this and prior IEPs. Ms. PARENT, and even more so Ms. Bacon, had no reason to believe that a reference in the identifying information at the top of the IEP form also identified an alternative offer.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s June 9, 2004 offer to STUDENT was adequately clear and specific to allow his parents an opportunity to fairly consider the offer and give or withhold informed consent.
In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not violate the procedural safeguards of the IDEA by not performing an assessment immediately prior to the 2004-2005 regular school year or by not having a specific written offer of placement. However, the District violated the procedural safeguards by failing to ensure the presence of a regular education teacher on STUDENT’s IEP team in developing an IEP for the 2004-2005 regular school year through February 17, 2005. The significance of this violation will be explored below.
Substantive Claims
Student alleges that the June 9, 2004 IEP is not designed to meet his unique needs and is not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit in the following respects:
(1) There are no goals and objectives to address Student’s needs in the areas of expressive language (including oral-motor/articulation), gross and fine motor skills, oral-motor skills (nutrition and hygiene), learning readiness/preacademic skills, play/social skills, sensory integration, self-help, functional skills, and behavior; (2) The goals and objectives are not measurable;
(3) Insufficient speech and language therapy, OT, and applied behavioral analysis (ABA) services (including the provision of a shadow aide) are offered; (4) There is no transition plan; and, (5) The offered program is not in the least restrictive environment.
Designed To Meet Needs and Provide Benefit
There was no real dispute between the parties regarding most of STUDENT’s needs. When Cornerstone assessed him in July 2002 when he was thirty-six months old, STUDENT was functioning in the twelve- to twenty-one-month range with atypical sensory processing skills. (Footnote 26) He was delayed in most domains, including cognition, communication, social/emotional functioning, motor skills, and sensory processing. To the extent that reliable assessment data could be obtained by anyone, District and private assessments had generally identified needs in the areas of speech and language (receptive language and expressive language, including oral motor functioning as it relates to articulation), upper body/hand strength and endurance, gross- and fine-motor skills (including motor planning and fine-motor dexterity), oral-motor functioning (as it relates to nutrition and hygiene skills), sensory processing, self-help skills (such as eating and dressing), functional skills (such as toileting and safety awareness), learning readiness/pre-academics, and social/emotional skills.
Although it appears likely from the evidence that STUDENT has apraxia and that this condition impairs his ability to pronounce the sounds and syllables that are the building blocks of speech, the Hearing Officer need not make a particular finding regarding the diagnosis because the parties agree that STUDENT has impaired ability to pronounce sounds and syllables and that best practices require the District to address those needs regardless of whether or not they are the result of apraxia. It is the need, and not a particular diagnosis, that must be addressed. According to the evidence, STUDENT’s oral-motor deficits also impact his saliva control and his ability to chew and swallow food. According to a report by the private occupational therapist, Richard Furbush, these latter oral-motor deficits are more related to OT needs than to speech and language needs.
The parties also agree that when his program is changed significantly, such as a change from a private placement to a public school, STUDENT needs a plan to facilitate that transition. The Hearing Officer finds that all of these were areas of need for STUDENT on June 9, 2004.
The extent to which STUDENT was engaging in maladaptive behaviors during the months preceding the June 9, 2004 meeting is not clear. According to the testimony of Ms. PARENT and others, STUDENT’s behaviors were under good control during the 2003-2004 school year at St. Wilfrid’s and at home. Ms. PARENT and Ms. Eckman testified that STUDENT’s behavior did not become a problem again until approximately two months later in August 2004. On the other hand, there are references in the documents, including Ms. Eckman’s June progress report, to a continuing need for behavior support. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not have a need for a specific behavioral support plan at the time of the June 9, 2004 IEP meeting, but that he did have a need for vigilance by parents and service providers to better ensure that behavior issues would be promptly addressed.
There are references in the evidence to STUDENT’s ability to use PECS to communicate his wants and needs, but because there was no evidence or argument concerning STUDENT’s need to develop this skill, the Hearing Officer cannot determine whether or not this is an area of need. The Hearing Officer notes, however, that Student did not specifically challenge the District’s offered program with respect to PECS.
(1) Goals & Objectives to Address Needs
To meet a special education student’s unique needs, an IEP must contain measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, that relate to meeting those needs. 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a)(2); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(2). The purpose of IEP goals is to set clear performance goals for the student that will enable him to make progress toward greater participation in the general curriculum. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a)(1).
Numerous sets of goals and objectives are part of the June 9, 2004 IEP. The OT goals addressing sensory modulation and upper body strength are continued from the February 17, 2004 IEP. There are three speech and language goals in the areas of articulation (1) and receptive language (2). All of the other goals were developed and proposed by Denise Eckman, Student’s preferred VBA provider. Ms. Eckman proposed goals in the areas of visual performance, receptive language, intraverbals, vocal imitation, motor imitation, requesting, labeling, spontaneous vocalization, play and social skills, fine motor, and self-help. Ms. Forsythe testified that the IEP team accepted all of Ms. Eckman’s goals.
Much of the hearing was devoted to the adequacy of the goals and objectives to meet STUDENT’s needs. Both private and District/WOCCSE providers testified about the adequacy of the goals and objectives.
(a) Speech and Language
Student contends that the speech and language goals did not address his needs in the areas of expressive language and oral-motor functioning. (Footnote 27) In support of this contention, he called Abby Rozenberg, who holds a master’s degree in communicative disorders and a rehabilitative services credential. Ms. Rozenberg is board certified and holds a certificate of clinical competence issued by the American Speech and Hearing Association. She has been in practice since 1991, during which time she has provided assessment/diagnostic and treatment services to many clients, including school districts. She estimates that she has assessed or treated 150 students with diagnoses on the autism spectrum and has treated a number of children who carried the diagnosis of apraxia.
Ms. Rozenberg has never seen or assessed STUDENT. Her involvement with this case began just the week before her testimony. She reviewed several documents, including the report of the District’s initial speech and language assessment by Vickie Kincaid, a report of a private speech and language assessment conducted by Jennifer Obholz on August 1, 2003, Cornerstone’s January 2004 progress report, the June 9, 2004 IEP, and the September 23, 2004 addendum. On the basis of her document review, Ms. Rozenberg testified that she concurs with Ms. Obholz’s diagnosis of apraxia. She also testified that the goals and objectives are inadequate to address STUDENT’s speech and language needs, particularly those in the areas of oral-motor functioning and pragmatics (social speech). She did not describe what different or additional goals she believes are required to adequately meet STUDENT’s needs.
Several of the District’s witnesses testified regarding the adequacy of the speech and language goals. Vickie Kincaid is a District speech and language pathologist who assessed STUDENT in 2002 and has provided services to him since February 2004, in conjunction with private services provided by Cornerstone. She holds a master’s degree in speech pathology and audiology, a certificate of clinical competence, and a credential in speech pathology and audiology. Ms. Kincaid has been a licensed speech and language pathologist working with preschool to eighth-grade students for over twenty-nine years, during which time she has assessed and provided services to approximately thirty-five to forty children on the autistic spectrum. Her current caseload includes five children on the autism spectrum.
Ms. Kincaid testified that she is qualified and trained to diagnose and treat apraxia, but has inadequate information to diagnose apraxia in STUDENT because she found insufficient evidence of communicative intent. On the other hand, she does not disagree with Ms. Obholz’s diagnosis and admits that it is best practice to treat STUDENT’s symptoms of apraxia under such circumstances. Ms. Kincaid prepared the speech and language goals for the June 9, 2004 IEP and believes that they would adequately address STUDENT’s speech and language needs, including his apparent difficulty with the oral-motor control required to pronounce sounds and syllables. She explained that her work with STUDENT also would cover receptive and expressive language skills and social skills, even though there were no specific expressive or pragmatic language goals identified in the IEP.
Linda Forsythe has a master’s degree in communicative disorders. She is also a licensed speech and language pathologist and worked primarily in that capacity for eighteen years before becoming the District’s autism program director. Ms. Forsythe has been involved with STUDENT’s educational planning since at least March 2003, when she attended an IEP meeting to assist with speech and language and autism issues and strategies. She testified that the three speech and language goals proposed by Ms. Kincaid are adequate to meet STUDENT’s speech and language needs when viewed in the context of all of the other services he would receive throughout the day. She explained that STUDENT, like other children in the District’s IBI program, would work on many basic skills, including speech and language skills, throughout the day. Ms. Forsythe testified that communication skills are a big part of IBI, but it includes practice on other skills, including joint attention, imitation, matching, sorting, categorizing, and receptive and expressive language. Ms. Forsythe stated that one should look at the entire program, including all goals and objectives and services, to evaluate the District’s plan to meet the needs of the child.
District staff proposed one articulation goal and two receptive language goals in the IEP. However, Ms. Eckman proposed many goals that have a speech and language content, including one for receptive labeling, one for following directions, one for filling in phrases for the blanks in songs, three for vocal imitation of sounds and syllables, three for requesting (two of these allowing the use of signs, gestures or verbalizations), one for expressive labeling, one for spontaneous vocalizations, and one for returning a social greeting. Ms. Eckman’s goals became a part of the District’s offer for STUDENT when the IEP team accepted the goals during the June 9, 2004 IEP meeting.
STUDENT has extensive expressive language needs. Other than a few word approximations, he does not speak. Ms. Kincaid is not certain of the extent of STUDENT’s communicative intent, but others describe STUDENT’s use of word approximations to communicate a few of his wants. According to the testimony of all of the speech and language professionals, one of STUDENT’s most basic deficits is his inability to pronounce sounds and syllables. Beyond that, he needs to learn a basic vocabulary and how to use words functionally to get someone’s attention, to engage in social activities, and to make his wants known.
The IEP contains an articulation goal that requires STUDENT to initiate sounds and syllables. That goal relates to his most basic expressive language need. The Hearing Officer finds that this goal relates to STUDENT’s need for development of his oral-motor/articulation skills. Additionally, the goals drafted by Ms. Eckman also are designed to meet STUDENT’s expressive language needs. Ms. Eckman’s goals generally emphasize verbal behavior and many focus on expressive verbal behavior.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the speech and language goals and objectives contained in the June 9, 2004 IEP are adequate to meet STUDENT’s needs in the area of expressive language.
(b) Gross- and Fine-motor Skills
Student called Richard Furbush, who holds a master’s degree in OT and has been licensed as such since 1996. He is certified to administer the Sensory Integration and Praxis Test and has been STUDENT’s private OT provider since July 2003. In his February 2004 progress report, Mr. Furbush recommended: (1) ten goals for oral-motor skills at mealtime, (2) four goals for tool (spoon and fork) use at mealtime, (3) thirteen goals for upper body strength and endurance and bilateral hand use, strength, and dexterity during playtime, (4) nine goals for self-care and dressing, (5) four goals for balance, motor planning, visual tracking, timing and sequencing, behavioral regulation, and safety awareness of people and objects in his vicinity during playground time, (6) four goals to reduce maladaptive oral-sensory, biting, and tantrumming behaviors while increasing his ability to follow directions and attend to a task, and (7) seven goals for play skills. He recommended fifty-one goals in all. Some of those would be considered gross- and fine-motor goals.
At hearing, Mr. Furbush did not testify that the IEP failed to include gross and fine motor goals as alleged by Student. However, he was generally critical of the scope of the District’s OT goals and stated that the IEP should have contained goals for upper body and hand strength and play skills that would require gross- and fine-motor skills, including motor planning.
Shawna Kemp, who testified for the District, is the WOCCSE occupational therapist who drafted the OT goals contained in the February 17, 2004 IEP that were carried forward into the June 9, 2004 IEP. (Footnote 28) She holds a bachelor’s degree in OT and is certified to administer the Sensory Integration and Praxis Test, an instrument used to evaluate sensory integration needs. Ms. Kemp has been a school-based occupational therapist during her entire five and one-half years of practice.
The IEP contains only one gross-motor goal, but the parents did not give their consent to a requested gross-motor/APE assessment until the second day of hearing. Additionally, Ms. Kemp testified that the second OT goal relates to STUDENT’s gross motor needs in the areas of upper body strength/proximal stability. A review of the goal itself shows that it requires STUDENT to engage in fine motor tasks, such as bead lacing or coloring, while maintaining a prone position. Depending on the activity that STUDENT engages in while maintaining a prone position, this goal would relate not only to those areas specifically identified by Ms. Kemp, but also to grasp, bilateral hand use, and fine motor skills, including motor planning and finger dexterity.
The Hearing Officer finds that, given the information reasonably available to the District at the time, the goals contained in the IEP adequately relate to STUDENT’s needs in the area of gross and fine motor skills.
(c) Oral-motor Skills (Nutrition and Hygiene)
STUDENT’s oral-motor deficits impact his chewing, drinking, and swallowing, as well as his saliva control. Although it is difficult to determine the extent to which these deficits still existed at the time of the IEP in June 2004, they were sufficient enough impairments four months earlier in February to cause Mr. Furbush to include several OT goals relating to oral-motor skills at mealtime. There is sufficient evidence to cause the Hearing Officer to find that STUDENT did have these needs at the time of the IEP meeting and that they should have been appropriately addressed through a goal or goals.
The Hearing Officer finds that the goals contained in the IEP do not adequately relate to STUDENT’s needs in the area of oral-motor skills relating to nutrition and hygiene.
(d) Learning Readiness/Pre-academics
According to Ms. Forsythe’s testimony, the District IBI program would be used to establish the learning readiness/pre-academic skills, including joint attention, imitation, sorting, matching, and categorizing. While District staff proposed no IEP goals in these areas, the District adopted as part of its offer goals drafted by Ms. Eckman that adequately relate to this area of need. The goals Ms. Eckman refers to as visual performance goals include goals to match block designs to a design card for up to five blocks, to match a given picture to an array of three others, and to sort three dimensional objects and pictures into three categories. Ms. Eckman also drafted goals to develop STUDENT’s ability to imitate actions and to maintain joint attention to tasks. The Hearing Officer finds that the June 9, 2004 IEP contains goals that adequately relate to STUDENT’s learning readiness/pre-academic needs.
(e) Play/Social Skills
The District concedes that STUDENT needs to develop play/social skills and suggested that Ms. Eckman’s goals would serve the purpose. A review of Ms. Eckman’s proposed goals reveal that they include several that relate to play/social skills. There is one for returning a greeting. There is a goal that requires STUDENT to demonstrate joint attention and to take turns during play. Another requires STUDENT to engage in symbolic play under the supervision of an adult. There is a goal for interactive play with one or two peers that requires STUDENT to use his turn taking and sharing skills and a goal that requires him to generalize those skills to a small group setting at school. These goals appropriately relate to STUDENT’s needs in the area of play/social skills.
The Hearing Officer finds that the IEP contains adequate goals relating to STUDENT’s play/social skills needs.
(f) Sensory Integration
Ms. Kemp testified that the first OT goal contained in the IEP relates to STUDENT’s sensory integration needs. Reference to the IEP reveals that this goal is called a sensory modulation goal. It requires STUDENT to initiate and sustain sensory activities to increase his arousal level. Mr. Furbush testified that this goal was broad. He did not state, however, that it inadequately related to STUDENT’s sensory processing needs. As several of the witnesses explained, STUDENT would receive a sensory diet. He would be required to engage in some sensory activity regularly throughout the day to maintain adequate arousal and organization of behavior. The District’s proposed goal addresses a foundational element of a sensory diet, engaging in sustained sensory activity such as those described in this goal.
The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the IEP does contain a goal that relates to STUDENT’s sensory processing needs.
(g) Self-help and Functional Skills
Mr. Furbush testified that STUDENT should have goals to address his deficits in the area of self-help and functional skills. In his opinion, STUDENT needs assistance with dressing and eating with utensils. He is not potty trained. Mr. Furbush also believes that STUDENT has an insufficient safety awareness of people and things in his environment. The District did not dispute these needs but it proposes no goals related to them.
Ms. Kemp testified that goals in many of the areas identified by Mr. Furbush are not educationally necessary. She explained, for example, that STUDENT would be expected to work at school on areas such as the use of eating utensils in any event and that specific goals were not required for those skills. The Hearing Officer disagrees and found the testimony of Mr. Furbush more persuasive on this point. OT services are properly focused on developing, improving, or restoring functional daily living skills, compensating for and preventing dysfunction, or minimizing disability. Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code § 2570.2(k). It involves the therapeutic use of purposeful and meaningful goal-directed activities (occupations), which engage the individual's body and mind in meaningful, organized, and self-directed actions that maximize independence, prevent or minimize disability, and maintain health. Id. Goals for self-help and functional skills, such as dressing, the use of utensils at mealtime, toileting, and safety awareness, are educationally necessary when the child has needs in these areas and requires these skills to become independent. Ms. Eckman included goals for dressing and toileting, which were adopted by the District as part of its offer for STUDENT. However, there was no information presented that STUDENT has specific needs in the areas of mealtime utensil use and safety awareness far beyond those seen in typically developing five-year-old children, and that such needs necessitated the creation of goals in the areas of utensil use and safety awareness. Additionally, his deficits underlying any needs in these areas, such as fine motor deficits, are addressed through goals in other areas.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the June 9, 2004 IEP contains goals that adequately relate to STUDENT’s self-help and functional skill needs.
(h) Behavior
Student generally took the position at hearing that he did not require specific behavioral support in June 2004 when this IEP was developed or at any time since except for a short period of time between the middle of August and October 1, 2004. Although the evidence was somewhat contradictory, the IEP did not identify behavior as an area of need and the Hearing Officer has already found that STUDENT did not need specific behavioral supports at that time. Therefore, no specific behavioral goal was required.
The Hearing Officer finds that the IEP was not required to include goals relating to behavioral needs.
In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that the June 9, 2004 IEP includes goals that adequately relate to STUDENTs’s needs in the areas of speech and language functioning, gross and fine motor skills, learning readiness/preacademics, play/social skills, sensory integration, and self-help and functional skills and that no goals were necessary to address behavior. However, the Hearing Officer finds that the District improperly failed to include a goal to address STUDENT’s oral motor needs with regard to nutrition and hygiene.
(2) Measurable Goals
Student also complains that the goals included in the June 9, 2004 IEP are not measurable, primarily because of inaccurate present levels of performance or baselines and inappropriate thresholds for mastery of a skill.
The IEP must contain a statement of the student’s present levels of educational performance, including a statement of how the disability affects the student’s involvement and progress in the general curriculum or, in the case of preschool-aged children, a statement of how the disability affects the student’s participation in appropriate activities. 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a)(1); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(1). In addition, the IEP must contain a statement of measurable goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, that are related to meeting the student’s needs. 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a)(2); Cal Educ. Code § 56345(2). It must state how the student’s progress toward annual goals will be measured. 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a)(7)(i); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(9). Finally, the IEP must contain appropriate objective criteria, evaluation procedures, and schedules for determining whether or not the annual goals are being met. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(7).
Student's representatives spent a significant amount of time and effort attempting to show that the present levels of performance relied upon by the District were inaccurate in that they were, in most cases, too low when compared to the reports of how he was functioning in his home program. However, it was apparent from the District’s own observations that STUDENT’s ability to demonstrate his skills at home around familiar people was far greater than his ability to do so in less familiar settings with less familiar people. The testimony of those present showed that the IEP team obtained information from the persons who had knowledge concerning STUDENT's levels of performance. Those who gave input included STUDENT's mother, Ms. Eckman, Ms. Kincaid, and Phyllis Lembke. The testimony and the IEP document show that the District made a reasonable effort to obtain current information about STUDENT's present levels and to accurately report those levels in the IEP. Although there was testimony from Ms. Eckman indicating that STUDENT’s skills were more developed than the District noted in the three speech and language goals and two OT goals that are part of the IEP, the District had other information from its own service providers indicating that Ms. Eckman’s estimates were not reliable across all environments.
Student also claims that the goals drafted by the District are not sufficiently challenging because they require less than seventy percent accuracy. Ms. Rozenberg was vaguely critical of using a proficiency goal that at least implied mastery of a skill with less than at least seventy percent accuracy. However, the Hearing Officer is aware of no such legal requirement for an IEP goal. The law simply requires that the IEP identify appropriate objective criteria for determining whether the goals are being achieved. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(7).
Only one of the goals was the subject of the dispute regarding degree of mastery. The speech and language goal for articulation required that STUDENT be able to initiate specified vowel-consonant (VC) and vowel-consonant-vowel (VCV) sequences with an average of fifty percent accuracy in five out of ten trials. The short-term objective for this goal requires an average of thirty percent accuracy in three out of ten trials. The present levels of performance indicate that STUDENT had no demonstrated ability to articulate some of the sequences. His ability to demonstrate others was inconsistent or not specified. There is adequate information in the goal to show that achievement of the objectives would constitute meaningful progress and evidence of educational benefit. The Hearing Officer finds that the use of these performance indicators will not deny a FAPE to STUDENT.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer determines that the goals included as part of the District’s offer for STUDENT are measurable.
(3) Services
The services offered by the District and those requested by Student at the IEP meeting and at hearing are as follows:
ITEM DISTRICT OFFER PARENT REQUEST ON 6/9 PARENT REQUEST AT HEARING
School Placement 170 min. SDC + 90 min. inclusion in regular ed. per day 150 min. per day at St. Wilfrid's (reg. ed.) Private School Placement Shadow Aide During inclusion (90 min./day) During school time (150 min./day) During school time (150 min./day) School-based ABA Four 150 min. weekly (IBI) Provided by aide during class Provided by aide during class Home-based ABA Four 120 min. weekly (IBI) Five 300 min. weekly (VBA) Five 150 min. weekly (VBA) ABA Supervision 8 hrs. monthly (Includes one 90 min. team meeting) 24 hrs. monthly 15-16 hrs. monthly (Includes two 90-120 min. meetings) SL Two 30 min. weekly Three 45 min. weekly Four 60 min. weekly OT One 45 min. clinic + one 30 min. class weekly One 60 min. clinic + one 30 min. class weekly Three 60 min. weekly Total Minutes 2327 min. weekly 2838 min. weekly 2136 min. weekly
Student argues that the amounts of speech and language therapy, OT, and ABA services offered by the District are inadequate to meet his needs. (Footnote 32) The District’s position is that the Hearing Officer cannot look at the DIS alone. It claims that STUDENT’s significant delays require an intensive, transdisciplinary program implemented by special education professionals who are qualified and properly credentialed to deliver the special education and related services to him. The District’s position is that it has offered an appropriate amount of speech and language therapy and OT services considering the program as a whole and an appropriate level of IBI service that will meet STUDENT’s need for intensive behavioral training.
An IEP must identify the specific instruction, aids, services, and program modifications or supports to be provided to the student to advance him toward attaining the annual goals and to allow him to be involved and progress in the general curriculum and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities with other disabled and nondisabled students. 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a)(3); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(3). To support a finding in favor of the District, the Hearing Officer must find that the services offered are appropriate in light of the information that the District knew or should have known at the time the IEP was drafted. Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999).
(a) Speech and Language Therapy
The District offered two thirty-minute individual speech and language therapy sessions weekly in the June 9, 2004 IEP. Vickie Kincaid and Linda Forsythe both recommended that level of speech and language therapy and testified that it is adequate to meet STUDENT’s needs. In addition, Ms. Kincaid stated STUDENT requires frequent, short exercises to address his oral-motor needs, which can be appropriately and more frequently done by educational staff in the SDC. Abby Rozenberg testified that STUDENT should have been offered at least four sessions per week with a qualified speech and language pathologist to address his apraxia-related needs, but she admitted that she had inadequate familiarity with STUDENT to state an opinion regarding the appropriate length of each session. Ms. Rozenberg did not state whether or not fewer sessions would still be likely to confer some meaningful educational benefit on STUDENT, but she was clear in her opinion that these services should be provided by a licensed speech and language pathologist.
The Hearing Officer was persuaded by the testimony of Ms. Rozenberg and Ms. Kincaid that STUDENT requires frequent services. However, in spite of Ms. Rozenberg’s protestations to the contrary, he sees no reason why some of those services (particularly those meant to ensure frequent repetition and practice) cannot be delivered to STUDENT frequently throughout his school day by trained educational staff. Because these frequent, short exercises are an important part of STUDENT’s speech and language services, the IEP should specifically provide for them.
Student argued that he should receive four sixty-minute speech and language therapy sessions per week, but no one testified that one-hour sessions are required to meet his needs. The District offered two thirty-minute speech and language therapy sessions but it also failed to present any convincing evidence that this amount meets STUDENT’s needs. While Ms. Kincaid and Ms. Forsythe testified that the level of speech and language therapy offered by the District is adequate to meet STUDENT’s needs, neither offered any explanation or basis for their opinions. They offered only conclusory statements that, unsupported by a factual basis, fail to establish that the proposed reduction in speech and language therapy adequately addresses STUDENT’s speech and language needs. Further, the evidence offered by the parties only showed that STUDENT made progress in his speech and language needs with a higher frequency of services. There was no evidence of progress resulting from the twice weekly thirty-minute speech and language collaborations that STUDENT received during the first six months of the 2002-2003 school year. In February 2003, the services were increased to fifty minutes three times weekly supplemented by oral-motor exercises for thirty minutes twice daily directed by STUDENT’s aide. On March 24, 2003, the service levels were changed again to twenty minutes three times weekly supplemented by five minutes per hour of short exercises (fifteen minutes per day) directed by STUDENT’s aide. It was reported in a June 2003 progress report that STUDENT was making progress with that level of service. Several witnesses testified at hearing that STUDENT is able to attend for as long as forty minutes or more in familiar surroundings and with familiar people.
The Hearing Officer therefore finds that there is inadequate evidence to show that an offer of two thirty-minute speech and language sessions weekly, without any supplemental services being specified in the IEP, will meet STUDENT’s needs and provide educational benefit. Considering STUDENT’s difficulty adjusting to new environments and people, it may be that twenty- to thirty-minute sessions may be appropriate during the transition into a public school setting. The length of the sessions may have to vary, starting at that level, and then increasing as STUDENT’s comfort level and tolerance improves. The Hearing Officer can offer no further guidance based upon the evidence presented.
The Hearing Officer finds that the two thirty-minute speech and language therapy sessions offered by the District are not designed to meet STUDENT’s speech and language needs and provide an educational benefit.
(b) OT
The District offered STUDENT one forty-five-minute clinic-based OT session at WOCCSE weekly and one thirty-minute classroom-based OT session weekly.
Richard Furbush testified that he originally recommended in September 2003 that STUDENT receive three one-hour clinic sessions weekly for three months, then two one-hour clinic sessions weekly for nine months. He actually provided only one one-hour session per week until December 2003, when he started providing two one-hour sessions per week. In February 2004, after only two months on the increased schedule, Mr. Furbush noted in his report that STUDENT had shown consistent improvement.
Patty Mulcahy has provided OT services to STUDENT at the WOCCSE clinic since September 30, 2004. She had only seen STUDENT on two occasions prior to her testimony, but she was also familiar with him from having assessed and provided services to him during the 2002-2003 school year. Ms. Mulcahy testified that STUDENT made progress that year with services delivered at a level similar to that offered in the June 2004 IEP.
The testimony and reports of Mr. Furbush show that STUDENT made consistent progress receiving one and then two hours of weekly clinic sessions as recently as last school year. According to Ms. Mulcahy, STUDENT made progress during the 2002-2003 school year when he was receiving a one-hour clinic session and a thirty-minute sensory group session per week. (Footnote 33)
The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s June 2004 offer of OT services is designed to meet STUDENT’s needs at the time and reasonably calculated to provide an educational benefit. (Footnote 34)
(c) ABA
Student contends that the District has offered an inadequate amount of ABA services and supervision. He now wants twenty-five hours per week of ABA services, half of those hours to be provided in a home program of intensive one-to-one services and half to be provided in the form of a shadow aide for STUDENT in his regular education class. The District has offered to provide STUDENT with intensive one-to-one ABA services for two and one-half hours per day, four days per week, during an extended school session and for two hours per day, four days per week, in a home-based program, for a total of eighteen hours weekly--five and one-half hours more per week than the amount requested by Student. The District also has offered to provide a one-to-one aide to STUDENT during his ninety minutes of daily inclusion time. If this aide is to be ABA trained and supervised, the District’s offer actually exceeds the level of ABA services requested by Student.
The parties agree that the intensive ABA component is a teaching approach that is typically and most effectively carried on in a distraction-free environment with one therapist/aide and one student. It is in this environment that the therapist conducts the drills to teach specific skills. The services provided by the shadow aide at school are different. According to the testimony of Ms. Hiber, STUDENT’s teacher at St. Wilfrid’s during the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT’s aide acted as his “prompter, guide, and facilitator” while attempting to include STUDENT in the curriculum that was being presented by the teacher. One would expect that the District’s proposed aide would do just that, while also working on STUDENT’s ability to generalize the skills learned in the intensive training sessions. Student did not dispute that the District-provided shadow aide would do that.
Ms. PARENT testified that STUDENT required his shadow aide at St. Wilfrid’s for only two days per week, two and one-half hours per day, or a total of five hours per week, throughout the 2003-2004 school year. She also testified that his home program during that time consisted of sixteen to eighteen hours per week. The only other evidence offered concerning the level of ABA service delivered to STUDENT during the 2003-2004 school year is contained in invoices for services rendered by Ms. Eckman and the therapists. Those show that for the four full weeks of August, STUDENT actually received an average of approximately thirteen and one-quarter hours per week of direct ABA services. Ms. PARENT testified that the level of services was basically the same in August 2004 as it was for the rest of that year. Student asserts that he made good progress with this level of service. It is unclear why so much time and effort has been expended on this dispute over direct ABA services when the District has offered more direct services than Student is now requesting and more than his parents and witnesses deemed adequate during the last school year. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s June 9, 2004 offer of direct ABA services at school and in the home is sufficient to meet STUDENT’s ABA needs and to provide an educational benefit.
With regard to Student’s contention regarding ABA supervision time, the District has offered eight hours of monthly ABA supervision, which includes the supervisor’s participation at one ninety-minute team meeting per month. Student wants fifteen to sixteen hours per month of supervision, including the supervisor’s participation at two team meetings per month.
Michelle Anderson is the District’s autism program specialist who supervises ABA programs. Ms. Anderson holds a master’s degree in special education and California regular, special education, and administrative credentials. She has had regular and special education teaching experience and substantial training relating specifically to meeting the needs of students who are diagnosed with an autism spectrum disorder. Her education and training, including time spent with the Center for Autism and Related Disorders, Inc. (CARD) and Autism Partnership, have included all aspects of ABA. She is familiar with the IBI used by the District, which she generally describes as the educational piece of ABA that includes a number of programs that specifically target communication skills, and is generally familiar with VBA. She also has experience with sensory diets.
Ms. Anderson testified that she would have been, and would be, the supervisor of STUDENT’s school-based and home-based IBI programs. In that capacity, she would oversee the behavioral aide(s), personally observe the program, review and analyze data, collaborate with the teacher(s), determine progress, and recommend changes to the program. She testified that she has seen the June 9, 2004 IEP and believes she would supervise STUDENT’s program, but she did not specifically state that the amount of supervision time required would be adequate.
Denise Eckman supervises STUDENT’s current program. She has a master’s degree in clinical psychology and is awaiting review of her doctoral dissertation for a Psy.D. degree. She testified that she performs the same kinds of tasks that Ms. Anderson performs, but, like Ms. Anderson, Ms. Eckman did not specifically testify regarding the adequacy of the ABA supervision time.
In the absence of direct testimony regarding the amount of time that is required to supervise STUDENT’s program, the Hearing Officer looked to the testimony of Ms. PARENT and the service invoices referred to above. According to STUDENT’s mother, the ABA services rendered in August 2004 were basically at the same level as they were throughout the rest of that prior year. Ms. Eckman’s invoice for August shows only three hours of supervision that month. Although Ms. Eckman testified that she did not charge for all of the supervision actually provided, the Hearing Officer gave greater weight to the invoiced amounts. However, the record showed that Ms. Eckman provided sixty-six percent of the direct services during the four full weeks in August 2004, and it is reasonable to conclude that more supervision would be required when the supervisor is not personally providing any of the direct services. If Ms. Eckman spent three hours supervising therapists who were providing only approximately one-third of the direct services, it was not unreasonable for the District to offer eight hours of ABA supervision.
The Hearing Officer finds that the ABA program offered by the District provides ABA direct services and supervision at levels that are designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.
(4) Transition Plan
The Hearing Officer has already found that STUDENT needs a transition plan to facilitate his move from the private school and providers to the public school setting and providers. One should have been included in the District’s program offered on June 9, 2004. One was not offered, but the team discussed the need for one. It appears from the face of the document that one was to be drafted and sent home to the parents for their review. As discussed in more detail below, this was done by June 22, 2004, long before the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to include a transition plan in its offer on June 9, 2004, did not deny a FAPE to STUDENT for the 2004-2005 school year.
(5) LRE
Student’s final substantive claim concerning the June 9, 2004 IEP is that the offered program is not in the LRE.
Federal and State special education law requires that a special education student be educated in the LRE and that removal of a student from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of the student's disability is such that education in regular education classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.
There is no doubt that placement in an SDC for a majority of the school day is more restrictive than a regular education placement. However, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded that the placement offered by the District on June 9, 2004, is significantly more restrictive than the placement proposed by Student.
The District’s offer includes seven and one-half hours per week of inclusion as part of over twenty-eight hours of services at the school site per week. Student’s proposal includes twelve and one-half hours of inclusion per week, one hour per day more than offered by the District, but that is the only time that STUDENT would be at a school site. (Footnote 35) This analysis focuses on the District’s offered SDC placement with proposed inclusion time as compared with Student’s proposed general education placement.
LRE essentially requires a balancing of needs. The determination of whether a particular placement is in the least restrictive environment for a child involves a balancing of four factors: (1) the educational benefits available to the child in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared to the educational benefits of a special education classroom; (2) the nonacademic benefits to the disabled child of interaction with nondisabled children; (3) the effect of the presence of the disabled child on the teacher and other children in the regular classroom; and (4) the costs of supplemental aids and services necessary to mainstream the disabled child in a regular classroom setting. Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel H., 786 F.Supp. 879 (E.D. Cal. 1992) (adopted by the Ninth Circuit in Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel H., 14 F.3d 1398 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 512 U. S. 1207, 114 S. Ct. 2679 (1994)). Because there is no evidence to consider on the fourth LRE factor and because neither party argued that cost is relevant to determining the LRE for STUDENT in this case, only the first three factors will be discussed.
(a) Comparative Educational Benefit
After his year at St. Wilfrid’s, with supplemental services provided by public and private providers, STUDENT remained significantly behind his chronological peers academically and socially by June 2004. According to Ms. Eckman’s June 7, 2004 progress report, STUDENT’s communication skills were poor. He had difficulty communicating his wants and needs. He could attend to an activity for fifteen minutes, but required frequent sensory breaks. He did not play with other children without prompting and was only able to tolerate parallel play for about four minutes without prompting. He was not potty trained, could not effectively use eating utensils, and was not independent at dressing or undressing. STUDENT’s fine motor skills were impeding his progress and, at least according to Ms. Eckman, he required a “behavior prevention plan to address maladaptive behaviors.” The Hearing Officer believes, and both parties agree, that STUDENT’s many substantial needs require significant services and support.
Michelle Wall, the teacher of the District’s proposed SDC placement, described that class in detail. Ms. Wall holds a master’s degree in special education and a special education credential. Her master’s thesis was on behavioral intervention strategies for autistic children. She has attended multiple training seminars related to meeting the educational needs of autistic children including discrete trial training, TEACCH, and Links to Language. Ms. Wall is an IBI supervisor for the District and was STUDENT’s ABA supervisor during part of his August program in 2003.
Ms. Wall testified that STUDENT would benefit from placement in her class, which she teaches with the assistance of two trained aides. Together they implement the IEPs of her nine students, ages three and one-half to five years old. Most of those students have speech and language impairments, but all are expressly verbal using full sentences of at least two to three words. Most engage in conversation and joint play. STUDENT would be near the lower end of functioning in comparison. Ms. Wall uses three stations to teach skills, so the student-to-teacher ratio at each is approximately three-to-one. She and her staff work on all skills, including communication (verbal and PECS), pre-academic, academic, fine motor, social skills, self-help, and functional skills. They also work with sensory diets and behavior plans. For those students who spend part of their day in regular education classrooms, Ms. Wall works with those regular education teachers to make the integration successful. One of her goals for her students is to provide the maximum reasonable opportunity for them to be educated with typically developing peers. She recommends increasing those opportunities as warranted by their needs and skills. The Hearing Officer finds that the program and environment described by Ms. Wall would provide significant educational benefit to STUDENT.
According to Mary Hiber, STUDENT’s teacher at St. Wilfrid’s during the 2003-2004 school year and the only typical classroom teacher to testify in this case, STUDENT is an observational learner, but she could not recall any instance where he actually demonstrated that ability. She indicated that STUDENT appeared able to adapt to his class schedule with time and that his listening and task-completion skills improved over time. According to Ms. Hiber, STUDENT’s aide was essentially his prompter, guide, and facilitator in her class. In Ms. Hiber’s March 2004 progress report, she indicates that STUDENT had made “great strides” but there is nothing in the report itself that would tend to support that opinion. There is no indication that any meaningful progress had been made.
Phyllis Lembke also testified about how STUDENT did in the typical preschool class at St. Wilfrid’s. She also stated that STUDENT is an observational learner and that she had seen him play with building blocks imitating others, but she did not explain why or how she concluded that STUDENT’s actions were imitative. Other than this reference to building blocks, Ms. Lembke did not provide any information to suggest that there was any academic benefit to STUDENT from his participation in the typical preschool. She seemed to focus more on how much STUDENT seemed to enjoy his time at St. Wilfrid’s and on how important it was to provide him the opportunity and freedom to explore and make choices. Other than stating that STUDENT made good choices, she did not provide any information from which the Hearing Officer could evaluate her conclusion. Like Ms. Hiber, Ms. Lembke tended to testify in generalities when describing STUDENT’s abilities and progress. There is no credible evidence that STUDENT learned anything of substance from anyone other than his aide during his time in the class or even that he is capable of actually learning from observing his peers.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is likely to receive greater educational benefit from a special education placement than from a general education placement.
(b) Nonacademic Benefit of Inclusion Time
The District did not argue that there was no nonacademic benefit available to STUDENT from inclusion time. In fact, the District’s offered program includes approximately ninety minutes per day of time with typically developing peers. Regardless, the extent to which STUDENT is likely to receive nonacademic benefit from his exposure to typically developing peers is not clear. Denise Eckman testified that STUDENT is able to benefit from time with nondisabled children if he is not engaging in maladaptive behaviors, but she did not explain or support that opinion. She reported just days before the June 9, 2004 IEP that STUDENT had progressed to parallel play for “at least four minutes,” which reflected some progress but still a limited ability to receive nonacademic benefit from his exposure to typically developing peers. Ms. Hiber and Ms. Lembke made only conclusory statements about STUDENT’s ability to benefit from exposure to typical peers. Nevertheless, STUDENT’s increased ability to engage in parallel play and his apparent enjoyment of the mainstreaming experience indicate some benefit.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT derives some nonacademic benefit from his inclusion time.
(c) The Effect of STUDENT’s Presence on a Regular Education Classroom
STUDENT has significant delays in all areas of development that require substantial amounts of individualized and intensive instruction to address. Because of the extent of his delays, STUDENT would require a substantial amount of teacher attention to make progress in a regular education setting, both in terms of direct teacher instruction and teacher consultation with his aide. This would take a disproportionate amount of time away from the teacher’s ability to attend to the needs of the other children in a regular education classroom.
Additionally, STUDENT has a long history of maladaptive behaviors, including some that even his mother found potentially dangerous to himself and others. The extent to which these behaviors were actually present in June 2004 is unclear. Mary Hiber testified that there were no behavior problems in her class, but Denise Eckman stated in her June 7, 2004 report that STUDENT continued to need a formal behavior plan to address his maladaptive behaviors. (Footnote 36)
Although the information would not have been known in June 2004, it is clear from the testimony of Ms. PARENT, Ms. Eckman, and others that STUDENT’s maladaptive and dangerous behaviors increased significantly in August 2004 and, as of the time of the hearing, they had not yet returned to a level that made it safe for him to return to school at St. Wilfrid’s. This information underscores the potential for such behaviors. If they occur in the classroom, they are disruptive in several respects. They distract the teacher and other students. They can at times require the attention of the teacher, even when a one-to-one aide is present, which deprives other students of the teacher’s time. Perhaps most importantly, STUDENT’s particular behaviors could cause injury to himself or others.
Because of his need for individualized attention and his history of maladaptive behaviors that could disrupt the class routine and put other students at risk, the Hearing Officer finds that this factor favors the District’s offered program.
Balancing these three LRE factors, and based upon the information currently available, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s June 9, 2004 IEP, offering a combination of special education and inclusion time, is in the least restrictive environment for STUDENT at this time. (Footnote 37)
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District denied STUDENT and his parents an important procedural right by not including on the IEP team a regular education teacher during the IEP meeting held on June 9, 2004, to develop STUDENT’s IEP for the 2004-2005 school year. In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that the June 9, 2004 IEP fails to include necessary goals to address his oral motor needs related to nutrition and hygiene. Finally, the District failed to offer STUDENT a sufficient amount of speech and language therapy in the June 9, 2004 IEP. The significance of these violations will be determined below.
June 22, 2004 IEP
This IEP is actually an addendum containing a draft of a transition plan prepared by Linda Forsythe, which was mailed to STUDENT’s parents and attorneys for consideration. Student contends that the IEP is procedurally and substantively defective.
Student contends that the June 22, 2004 IEP addendum was procedurally defective because it was not developed by the IEP team in compliance with California Education Code section 56341(a).
The June 9, 2004 IEP states as follows: “A transition plan will be developed within two weeks and sent home for consideration.” However, there is no evidence that the parents or their attorney agreed with the proposal to have the transition plan prepared outside the IEP process by the District and sent to them later. Within two weeks of the June 9, 2004 IEP meeting, Ms. Forsythe sent a proposed transition plan to the parents and to Ms. Bacon, along with a copy of the entire June 9, 2004 IEP. The cover letter refers to the transition plan as a “proposed” transition plan and invites the parents to request an IEP meeting to discuss the plan further.
This may seem a practical approach to some. In the past, Ms. PARENT had sanctioned this addendum procedure, but that was when she requested a reduction of the school-based IBI program in December 2002 and that request, which was agreed to by the District, was handled by the preparation of an addendum form by two District teachers, who sent the form to Ms. PARENT for later approval. In this instance, Ms. Forsythe alone drafted the transition plan. There was no evidence that she sought input from the parents, any representative of St. Wilfrid’s, or Ms. Eckman, all of whom would be expected to have valuable knowledge or opinions regarding STUDENT’s transition that were worthy of consideration by the IEP team. An inappropriate exclusion of the parents, and possibly others, from the process of creating the transition plan, which should be part of the normal IEP process, is not made appropriate by after-the-fact parental involvement. Shapiro by Shapiro v. Paradise Valley Unified Sch. Dist. No. 69, 317 F.3d 1072, 1078 (9th Cir. 2003). STUDENT’s transition needs should have been discussed and considered by a properly composed IEP team.
The Hearing Officer finds that the IEP team did not develop the June 22, 2004 transition plan in compliance with California Education Code section 56341(a) and that this was a violation of Student’s procedural rights. This violation requires that the properly composed IEP team discuss and develop a transition plan.
In view of the need for the IEP team to consider the transition plan, it is not necessary for the Hearing Officer to reach Student’s substantive allegation regarding the adequacy of the transition plan. (Footnote 38)
The Hearing Officer finds that the June 22, 2004 IEP addendum was procedurally defective.
September 23, 2004 IEP
The September 23, 2004 IEP was another attempt by Ms. Forsythe to alter the terms of the District’s offer. According to this IEP addendum, it was to recommend a revision of the goals set forth in the June 9, 2004 IEP, to indicate that a sensory diet would be provided to STUDENT, and to indicate that a behavior intervention plan would be developed within thirty days if STUDENT exhibited maladaptive behaviors. (Footnote 39)
Student alleges that this addendum was improperly created outside the IEP process and that the revised goals retained the same defects already discussed in connection with the June 9, 2004 IEP.
The analysis of Student’s procedural allegation is the same as that of the June 22, 2004 IEP. In spite of the parties’ agreement that STUDENT needs a sensory diet, these were all substantive changes to STUDENT’s IEP that should have been considered and decided by the IEP team. If a meeting had been convened, the District might have learned that STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors had dramatically increased and needed to be addressed and Ms. Forsythe’s proposed revisions of the goals could have been considered. Because Ms. Forsythe’s recommended goal revisions will have to be considered by the IEP team and because the original goals have already been addressed elsewhere in this Decision, the Hearing Officer need not address them here.
The Hearing Officer finds that the June 22, 2004 IEP addendum was procedurally defective and did nothing to cure any of the deficiencies in the June 9, 2004 IEP.
October 5, 2004 IEP
According to witnesses, the District learned on or about September 30, 2004, that STUDENT was exhibiting maladaptive and dangerous behaviors, including biting and head banging. In a telephone conference between the parties’ attorneys, the District asserted that an IEP meeting should be convened immediately to address the behaviors. Student’s attorney requested that an FAA be conducted. On Friday, October 1, 2004, Ms. Forsythe confirmed the telephone conversation and Mr. and Ms. PARENT and their attorney were urged to attend a meeting on October 5, 2004. STUDENT’s parents did not respond to the invitation at all. Instead, Ms. Bacon responded, indicating that because of the short notice and the pending due process hearing that was to begin on October 6, 2004, STUDENT’s parents were “unable” to attend. The letter states that the meeting should take place on any of three dates in mid-October. Aside from the claim that they had inadequate notice and that the due process hearing was approaching, no explanation was given regarding why the parents could not attend.
On October 5, 2004, the District convened what it referred to as an emergency IEP to address a reported increase in STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors. The District convened a meeting on October 5, 2004, with Linda Forsythe, Michelle Wall, Vickie Kincaid, Patty Mulcahy, and Greg Endelman in attendance. STUDENT’s parents and attorney did not attend. As a result of the meeting, another proposed IEP addendum was drafted. It recommended the completion of an FAA, the implementation of an interim behavior plan, and the adoption of the September 23, 2004 addendum. The documents were to be sent home to STUDENT’s parents for review.
Student contends that the IEP meeting was convened without the required notice to his parents and the opportunity for them to attend. He also alleges that the October 5, 2004 proposed IEP addendum was unnecessary and that the District’s actions were based on incorrect or outdated information concerning his behaviors, which had already abated by October 1, 2004. Finally, he claims that the proposed interim behavior plan was not the result of a required FAA.
Parents are entitled to be notified about an upcoming IEP meeting “early enough to ensure an opportunity to attend.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(b). The District gave STUDENT’s parents four days notice of the IEP meeting. The documents show that one or more of STUDENT’s parents have been able to attend other IEP meetings on similar notice. There was no evidence that Mr. or Ms. PARENT was unavailable. On the contrary, the evidence suggests, and the Hearing Officer believes, that STUDENT’s parents simply chose not to attend the meeting.
A school district can convene and proceed with an IEP meeting without a parent present, but steps must be taken to document the efforts to convince the parent to attend and it must use other means, if practical, to ensure the parent’s participation by telephone or otherwise. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(f), (g). In this case the District sent to STUDENT’s parents and attorneys a notice of the meeting and a letter explaining its concern about the importance of promptly dealing with STUDENT’s reported behaviors. Although there was no evidence that the District offered to allow STUDENT’s parents or attorneys an opportunity to participate in the meeting by telephone or other means, the evidence convinces the Hearing Officer that such efforts would have been futile. For whatever reason, STUDENT’s parents and attorneys had decided that they would not participate in the IEP process until the due process hearing was concluded. Under the circumstances, the Hearing Officer finds that the October 5, 2004 IEP meeting was not convened in violation of the rights of STUDENT or his parents.
Student’s position at hearing was that his maladaptive behaviors were an aberration due to a number of transient factors. Ms. Eckman referred in her testimony to the end of STUDENT’s summer session and a change of therapists in his home program, but she admitted that she was unsure what was causing the sudden and dramatic increase in maladaptive behaviors. Ms. PARENT testified that STUDENT’s doctor recommended that he be taken off nutritional supplements and that when this was done, STUDENT’s behavior began to immediately improve. Both Ms. Eckman and Ms. PARENT testified that the dramatic improvement began by October 4, 2004. Student argued that there was no behavior emergency and that no action needed to be taken by the IEP team because the maladaptive behaviors were due to the toxic effects of nutritional supplements and STUDENT’s parents had already taken the necessary corrective action.
Ms. PARENT testified that she remains concerned about STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors. She stated that there have been dramatic improvements since the cessation of the nutritional supplements but that some behaviors still are exhibited when he is tired or agitated. According to Ms. Lembke, STUDENT has not yet attended St. Wilfrid’s at least in part because of those behaviors. However, the parents have declined to consent to an FAA and the District has not requested an order compelling the parents to make STUDENT available for one. In any event, Student has taken the position that he did not and does not require an FAA or a BIP. Therefore, the Hearing Officer need not address Student’s claim that the proposed interim behavior plan was inappropriate because it was not based on an FAA.
In effect, the October 5, 2004 IEP meeting was of no consequence. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not deny a FAPE to STUDENT in connection with the October 5, 2004 IEP.
In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s failure to include a regular education teacher on the IEP team tainted the entire process and as a result denied STUDENT a substantial procedural right. That defect persists even to the present. In addition, the Hearing Officer concludes that the June 22 and September 23, 2004 IEPs were procedurally defective because they were prepared by one District employee outside of the IEP process and that the several IEPs that purport to constitute the District’s offer to STUDENT do not contain goals to address his oral motor needs with regard to nutrition and hygiene, sufficient speech and language therapy services, and an appropriate transition plan. These defects combine to result in a denial of a FAPE. Until a properly comprised IEP team meets to appropriately consider and develop an educational program for STUDENT for the remainder of the term of his current IEP, the District has not offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year through February 17, 2005. The District will be required to convene an IEP meeting that includes all necessary participants. That team should take into consideration the Hearing Officer’s findings herein as well as other matters that the IEP team deems appropriate.
Issue No. 2: Is the District entitled to conduct a gross motor/adapted physical education assessment of Student pursuant to an assessment plan dated June 9, 2004?
On the basis of the parties’ stipulation that the District’s June 9, 2004 plan to assess STUDENT in the area of gross motor/APE needs is appropriate, and in light of the parents’ express written consent to that assessment plan delivered to the District on October 12, 2004, the Hearing Officer finds that the District is entitled to conduct a gross motor/adapted physical education assessment of STUDENT pursuant to the assessment plan dated June 9, 2004.
Issue No. 3: If the District has failed to offer Student a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year, are his parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of educational and related services provided to Student during the 2004-2005 regular school year to the date of the Decision in this case?
Student contends that his parents are entitled to reimbursement for the amounts paid by them for health insurance co-payments for speech and language and OT services rendered after July 21, 2004.
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under the IDEA and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Educ., 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994).
The Hearing Officer found that the OT services offered to STUDENT are appropriate. The Hearing Officer found that the District did not prove that the amount of speech and language services offered is appropriate, but Student did not offer evidence to show that his parents are entitled to reimbursement for any part of the cost of the speech and language services obtained for him by them. However, Student offered no evidence to prove the amount of speech and language therapy that was privately funded, at least in part, by them during the 2004-2005 school year or the qualifications of the provider or the appropriateness of the services. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Student has failed to meet his burden of establishing entitlement to reimbursement for speech and language services and will not order reimbursement. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that Student is not entitled to any reimbursement.
Issue No. 4: If the District denied Student a FAPE, is he entitled to an award of compensatory education?
Student contends he is entitled to an award of compensatory education that should consist of speech and language therapy, occupational therapy, and ABA services.
Court decisions have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District, 916 F.2d 865 (3d Cir. 1990); Miener v. State of Missouri, 800 F.2d 749 (8th Cir. 1986). Compensatory education is an equitable remedy. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for-hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Puyallup, supra, 31 F.3d at 1497.
The Hearing Officer has concluded that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE. Under the circumstances, some award of compensatory education is appropriate. The absence of expert testimony to establish the type and amount of an appropriate compensatory education award makes the determination difficult. The matter is further complicated by the undisputed fact that STUDENT began having behavioral difficulties shortly before commencement of the regular school year, and that this has prevented him from attending school at St. Wilfrid’s. However, had a FAPE been offered to STUDENT, it is reasonable to believe that his maladaptive behaviors would have been effectively addressed and that his school attendance would not have been delayed.
STUDENT is entitled to an award of compensatory education that will, to the extent practicable, provide him with the education he was entitled to under the IDEA. This should include something to reasonably compensate him for his loss of special education and related services, including ABA, speech and language therapy and OT, for the period of time that he would have been receiving those during the 2004-2005 school year to the date of this Decision. (Footnote 40)
School began on September 8, 2004. There have been fourteen weeks of school. During that time, STUDENT should have been receiving at least the amount of special and regular education, ABA, and OT offered by the District. The Hearing Officer found that the District’s offer of speech and language services was insufficient. STUDENT should have been receiving more than what was offered. Additionally, while there was some vague testimony that STUDENT received from the District some speech and language therapy and OT during the 2004-2005 school year through a stay put agreement, no evidence was produced to establish the terms of the parties’ agreement or the exact amount of services STUDENT received under this agreement. The only specific evidence presented was that STUDENT has received three OT sessions from the District since the commencement of the 2004-2005 school year. It was the District’s obligation to establish in the record the provision of any services that might serve to offset a compensatory education award. Because the District failed to meet its burden in this regard, the Hearing Officer cannot and will not reduce the compensatory education award by any amount of services already provided during the 2004-2005 school year, except to the limited extent that the record establishes that the District has provided STUDENT with three OT sessions since the beginning of the school year.
To compensate STUDENT for the loss of special and regular education class time and ABA time, the Hearing Officer awards STUDENT 150 hours of direct home-based ABA services and twenty-eight hours of ABA supervision. The Hearing Officer awards twenty-one hours of individual speech and language services, ten hours of clinic-based OT and seven hours of classroom-based OT to compensate STUDENT for the loss of similar services. All instruction and services are to be provided through District providers or as directed by the District and shall be completed by the end of the 2007 extended school year. This award approximates the amount of the various instruction and services that the Hearing Officer believes STUDENT would have received from the District during those fourteen weeks had a FAPE been offered.
Issue No. 5: Is Student entitled to an order requiring the District to fund his continued placement at St. Wilfrid’s Preschool or comparable NPS and speech and language therapy, occupational therapy, and ABA services (including a shadow aide) for the remainder of the term of the current IEP through February 17, 2005?
The parties agreed that St. Wilfrid’s is not a nonpublic school that has been certified by the State of California under California Education Code section 56366.1, so that the Hearing Officer cannot order a prospective placement there. See Cal. Educ. Code § 56502.2(a). Student did not propose, identify or offer evidence about any other prospective placement to enable the Hearing Officer to find that such a placement would be appropriate. In addition, the evidence did not show that the District is unable to develop and implement a program that will meet STUDENT’s needs and provide educational benefit. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is not entitled to an order requiring the District to fund his continued placement at St. Wilfrid’s Preschool or comparable NPS with speech and language therapy, occupational therapy, and ABA services (including a shadow aide) for the remainder of the term of the current IEP through February 17, 2005.
ORDER
1. Within ten school days of the date of this Decision, STUDENT’s parents shall make him available for the gross-motor assessment to which they consented if they wish to avail themselves of a public education for him.
2. Within twenty school days of the date of this Decision, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting with all required participants in attendance to complete the planning of STUDENT’s IEP consistent with this Decision, to include appropriate goals in the area of oral motor needs related to nutrition and hygiene, an appropriate level of speech and language therapy, an appropriate transition plan, a sensory diet, appropriate behavior supports, all to be provided in the least restrictive environment, as well as other elements that the IEP team deems appropriate.
3. By the end of the 2007 extended school year, the District shall provide, and the IEP team shall determine the frequency and duration of, the delivery of compensatory education to STUDENT consisting of:
(a) 150 hours of direct home-based ABA services and twenty-eight hours of ABA supervision; (b) twenty-one hours of individual speech and language therapy; and (c) ten hours of clinic-based OT and seven hours of classroom-based OT.
4. All other claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
Issue No. 1: Has the District offered Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment for the 2004-2005 school year from the beginning of the regular school year through the expiration of the current individualized education program (IEP) on February 17, 2005?
Student prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 2: Is the District entitled to conduct a gross motor/adapted physical education assessment of Student pursuant to an assessment plan dated June 9, 2004?
No one prevailed on this issue because it was determined by stipulation.
Issue No. 3: If the District has failed to offer Student a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year, are his parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of educational and related services provided to Student during the 2004-2005 regular school year to the date of the Decision in this case?
The District prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 4: If the District has failed to offer Student a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year from August 1, 2004, through February 17, 2005, is he entitled to an award of compensatory education?
Student prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 5: Is Student entitled to an order requiring the District to fund his continued placement at St. Wilfrid’s or some other regular education nonpublic preschool, and to provide or fund the provision of speech and language therapy, occupational therapy, and applied behavioral analysis (ABA) services (including a shadow aide) for the remainder of the term of the current IEP through February 17, 2005?
The District prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Dated: December 15, 2004 _________________________________ Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
On the first day of hearing on October 6, 2004, the Hearing Officer clarified the issues and addressed several motions. Those proceedings are described in a Memorandum Re: Orders at Hearing issued in this matter on October 11, 2004.
2 Mr. Jewell was present on October 13, 2004, only and in place of Mr. Roberts.
3 Pursuant to the Hearing Officer’s order on a motion by Student, Ms. Forsythe was excluded from the hearing room early on October 6, 2004, and was not allowed to attend the hearing again until her testimony on October 12, 2004. She was present for most of the remainder of the hearing.
4 Student argued that the entire 2004-2005 regular school year and the 2005 extended school year should be deemed at issue. However, as discussed further below, there was no evidence or argument offered to justify the adjudication of FAPE beyond the term of the current IEP. Under the facts proved, FAPE issues beyond February 17, 2005, are not ripe.
5 In his statement of issues and proposed resolutions filed in this case on September 27, 2004, Student requested adjudication of his parents’ right to reimbursement for “educational services and programs provided to Student at parents’ expense during the 2004/2005 school year and extended school year.” At the hearing, Student limited his reimbursement claim to the insurance co-payments made by his parents after July 31, 2004, to cover necessary educational or related services. The 2004-2005 regular school year was to have begun for STUDENT on September 8, 2004.
6 The scope of this issue has been narrowed to address only issues deemed ripe by the Hearing Officer.
7 St. Wilfrid’s Preschool is not a certified nonpublic school (NPS).
8 Denise Eckman described VBA as an ABA program that focuses on verbal behavior.
9 STUDENT’s mother rated some of his skills higher. For example, she believed that his ability to dress himself was near the one year and ten month level.
10 It is not clear from the evidence what “global therapy” is, but according to Cornerstone’s letterhead, it offers occupational therapy, physical therapy, and speech and language therapy.
11 According to the District’s July 2002 OT assessment report, the District’s occupational therapist also recognized the need for services to address STUDENT’s sensory processing deficits.
12 WOCCSE autism program specialist Michelle Anderson described IBI as the “educational piece” of ABA.
13 The addendum was drafted by STUDENT’s teacher and sent to the parent for approval.
14 The report of Autism Spectrum Consultants was not offered into evidence.
15 According to Ms. Rozenberg, apraxia is a motor disorder and STUDENT has a form of apraxia that limits his ability to speak. According to the American Speech Language Hearing Association website, “childhood apraxia of speech is a disorder of the nervous system that affects the ability to sequence and say sounds, syllables, and words. It is not due to muscular weakness or paralysis. The problem is in the brain's planning to move the body parts needed for speech (e.g., lips, jaw, tongue). The child knows what he or she wants to say, but the brain is not sending the correct instructions to move the body parts of speech the way they need to be moved.”
16 Some of these terms, including “tacting” and “intraverbals,” are used in the particular ABA methodology utilized by Ms. Eckman, VBA, a methodology that is said to emphasize verbal behavior.
17 According to the teacher, Ms. Wall, the morning recess and lunchtime recess are each thirty minutes.
18 According to STUDENT’s mother, the increase in maladaptive behaviors started in early September 2004. Although STUDENT was enrolled in St. Wilfrid’s by the beginning of the current 2004-2005 school year, he had not yet attended by the time the record in this matter closed due, at least in significant part, to the increase in maladaptive behaviors.
19 A FAPE also should enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347; Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(3). This element is not at issue in this case.
20 In his September 27, 2004 statement of issues and proposed resolutions and initially at hearing, Student also contended that the February 17, 2004 IEP was procedurally defective and that the alleged defects resulted in a denial of a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year. At the hearing, Student acknowledged that his issues relate to his right to a FAPE during the 2004-2005 school year only and he specifically withdrew claims relating to the February 17, 2004 IEP.
21 California Education Code section 56320 now incorporates the federal standard found in 34 C.F.R. § 300.533.
22 In its analysis of public comments received in response to a notice of proposed rule making issued in 1997, 62 Fed. Reg. 55026, the United States Department of Education, Office of Special Education Programs (OSEP), specifically rejected suggestions that other individuals could participate in lieu of the child’s regular education teacher as a member of the child’s IEP team. 64 Fed. Reg. 48 at 12583. Those suggested individuals included a special education teacher who is knowledgeable about the general curriculum, a school counselor (particularly for high school students), and an individual certified as a regular education teacher, regardless of whether that individual is currently working with the child. Id.
23 The Hearing Officer notes that the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals recently issued a decision on the legal ramifications of not having a required regular education teacher present at an IEP meeting. See M.L. v. Federal Way Sch. Dist., 387 F.3d 1101, 2004 Daily Journal D.A.R. 13,572 (9th Cir.(Wash.) Nov. 05, 2004). In this plurality decision, the justices came to very different conclusions, legally and factually, about the effect of not having a regular education teacher present at an IEP meeting. However, under the particular circumstances of STUDENT’s case, the Hearing Officer need not determine the precedential value of the plurality decision in M.L. because STUDENT was denied a FAPE under any of the analyses utilized by the three justices. Unlike the student in M.L., who was offered placement in a self-contained classroom, STUDENT is offered a school placement in which he would be in the regular education environment for a third of his school day.
24 There also was no evidence that a regular education teacher was included later on STUDENT’s IEP team to discuss or provide input regarding this issue.
25 Ms. PARENT visited Lake View shortly before the IEP meeting and Westmont shortly after the meeting.
26 The lack of parental and District concern about a global reassessment prior to the June 9, 2004 planning meeting is further indication of the parties’ agreement regarding the areas of need.
27 Since it was unclear whether Student’s contention regarding oral-motor goals related to articulation or nutrition and hygiene, both will be discussed.
28 WOCCSE occupational therapist Patty Mulcahy also testified, but her testimony addressed the level of services only and is discussed below.
29 The proposed inclusion time consists of thirty minutes in a regular classroom, a thirty-minute morning recess, and a thirty-minute lunch recess. The IEP states that library time was also to be inclusion time, but no specifics were provided regarding library time.
30 It appears from the June 9, 2004 IEP documents, including the parents’ dissent and request for services, that the parents were asking for a twenty-five hour per week home-based ABA (VBA) program and a VBA-trained aide for an additional one hundred fifty minutes per day. However, at hearing, Student requested a twenty-five hour weekly VBA program with half of the hours provided by the school-based aide and half provided in the home.
31 This is a monthly estimate based upon the parents’ request for six hours of supervision per week.
32 Although it appeared from the way evidence was presented that Student might argue that he requires VBA to receive a FAPE, that was not put in contention.
33 Ms. Mulcahy testified that, based upon her two forty-five minute sessions with STUDENT in September and October 2004, he should receive two thirty-minute sessions weekly. However, these sessions occurred when STUDENT was engaging in increased maladaptive behaviors and it is likely that her opinion is based, at least in significant part, on those difficulties. The evidence suggests that those behaviors were not occurring at the time of the June 9, 2004 IEP meeting.
34 In light of STUDENT’s many areas of need and the District’s favored transdisciplinary approach, the Hearing Officer assumes that classroom time will include training for educational and IBI staff to address some of the areas of need identified by Mr. Furbush. Furthermore, because the current status of STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors is not certain, the IEP team may need to consider adjustments to the length or frequency of the OT sessions.
35 If, as the parties agree, the ultimate goal is to increase the time that STUDENT is educated with his typically developing peers, it does seem that time successfully spent on the school site ultimately serves to facilitate increased inclusion more so than time spent at home or elsewhere. The Hearing Officer does not suggest that time spent in one-to-one services on a school campus or at home is tantamount to inclusion time, but there may be a logical basis for treating time spent at school differently than time spent at home.
36 Neither STUDENT’s parents nor Ms. Eckman expressed any concern about STUDENT’s behavioral needs at the June 9, 2004 IEP meeting.
37 Because of the importance of the involvement of a general education teacher in considering the LRE issue, it will be necessary for the properly constituted IEP team to consider LRE with the input of a general education teacher, and take into account the status of STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors, in its determination of the appropriate amount of inclusion time.
38 Substantively, Student only generally alleged that the transition plan was deficient. The only evidence offered in support of this claim was testimony by Ms. Eckman, whose opinion that the plan is not adequate is premised on the assumption that more time is required to familiarize the District providers with her VBA program. However, as previously stated, Student did not claim that VBA is required for a FAPE.
39 According to Ms. Forsythe’s testimony, she intended only to transfer the goals and objectives proposed at the June 9, 2004 IEP meeting to appropriate WOCCSE forms and to adjust the goals to reflect their application to the proposed IEP’s term, September 8, 2004, to February 17, 2005, rather than the one-year term assumed by Ms. Eckman.
40 The failure of Student to prove his parents’ entitlement to reimbursement for the uninsured cost of speech and language therapy and OT renders an award of compensatory speech and language therapy and OT appropriate, because there is no evidence that he received appropriate speech and language therapy and OT during the period when he was denied a FAPE.
