California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 6, 2002

Temecula Valley Unified School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 2310-02 · Hearing Officer Judith E. Ganz

Temecula Valley Unified may assess student without parent consent; assessment plan did not need to list specific tests.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. The decision mentions a related District-filed case seeking to assess the student's sibling, which was handled separately.

Summary

Temecula Valley Unified School District filed for due process to assess a nine-year-old fourth grader without his parents' consent. The boy had a private diagnosis of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). He had just enrolled at Nicholas Elementary School and had never been found eligible for special education. His mother asked for special education testing the day she enrolled him. Two days later, the District gave her an assessment plan. It covered academics, cognitive ability, social-emotional and behavioral development, perceptual-motor skills, speech and language, and health, plus occupational therapy, hearing, and observation. She refused to sign because the plan did not name the specific tests. The parents also argued that testing should wait because the boy was anxious, was avoiding school, and was on home tutoring.

The Hearing Officer ruled for the District. A parent's referral requires a district to assess, and parents who want special education must allow testing. Education Code section 56321(b) requires a plan to explain the types of assessments, not to list the test instruments. The District's assessors credibly explained that they choose instruments only after they review records, interview the parents, and see how the child performs. The assessors were qualified, and the plan covered the mother's concerns. The private psychologist's advice to delay testing was not persuasive, because experienced assessors could adjust to the boy's emotional state. The District must give ten days' notice, and the parents must make him reasonably available.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO handled a district's request to override a parent's refusal to consent. The Hearing Officer held that an assessment plan must explain the types of assessments but need not name specific tests. The student's current emotional distress also did not justify delaying an initial assessment that the parent herself had requested.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue 1A. Is the District entitled to conduct assessments of STUDENT under its August 29, 2002 assessment plan without parental consent — is the assessment necessary?

    Assessment was necessary because the mother referred her son for special education testing, which obligates the District to assess; parents who want special education must permit testing.

  2. Issue 1B. Does the assessment plan conform to legal requirements, including whether Education Code section 56321(b) requires the plan to list the particular test instruments to be used?

    The plan must explain the types of assessments, not name specific instruments; the plan was in plain language, covered the mother's concerns, and would be administered by qualified assessors.

  3. Issue 1C. Is the District entitled to conduct an assessment of STUDENT now, even if he presently suffers from emotional problems and/or is home on medical leave?

    The private psychologist's advice to delay was unpersuasive; experienced assessors could adjust to the student's emotional state, and concerns about validity were premature and could be addressed through an IEE.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order that district may assess without consent. The District is entitled and obligated to assess the student under the August 29, 2002 assessment plan.
  • Before scheduling the assessments, the District must give the parents ten days' notice.
  • The parents must make the student reasonably available for the assessments.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307 (9th Cir. 1987); Andress v. Cleveland Independent School District, 64 F.3d 176 (5th Cir. 1995); Vander Malle v. Ambach, 673 F.2d 49 (2d Cir. 1983); Cal. Education Code section 56321(b); Cal. Education Code section 56320; Title 5 C.C.R. section 3021(a)

People named in the decision

  • Deborah S. Miller, Director of Special Education, Temecula Valley Unified School District
  • Dr. Leslie Ann Taylor, itinerant school psychologist (District witness), Vista Unified School District, serving Temecula Valley Unified School District
  • Beth Jensen, school nurse (District witness), Temecula Valley Unified School District
  • Pam Ann Steffen, resource specialist (District witness), Temecula Valley Unified School District
  • Alisa Marie Carslake, speech and language specialist (District witness), Temecula Valley Unified School District
  • Fred Fox, special education program specialist (District witness), Temecula Valley Unified School District
  • Jodi McClay, school principal, Nicholas Elementary School
  • Dr. Jessica A. Maxwell, private clinical psychologist; expert witness for Student and former parent advocate, Private practice, Del Mar
  • Dr. Joel A. Streng, treating pediatrician (letters submitted; did not testify), Private practice
  • Dr. Donna Hughes, former parent advocate

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Judith E. Ganz, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Temecula, California, on November 12 and 13, and November 21, 2002.

Petitioner Temecula Valley Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Peter A. Sansom of the Law Office of Lozano Smith. Present on behalf of the District on November 12th and 13th was Deborah S. Miller, the District Director of Special Education. Respondent STUDENT (Respondent or STUDENT) was represented by his mother and father, MOTHER and FATHER. On November 12, 2002, FATHER was present for part of the day. On November 13, 2002, only FATHER was present. On November 21, 2002, only MOTHER was present.

The District called the following witnesses to testify: Dr. Leslie Ann Taylor, an itinerant school psychologist; Beth Jensen, the District’s school nurse; Pam Ann Steffen, the District’s resource specialist; Alisa Marie Carslake, the District’s speech and language specialist; and Fred Fox, the District’s program specialist.

Respondent called the following witnesses to testify: Dr. Jessica A. Maxwell, a clinical psychologist in private practice, and MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. On November 21, 2002, after hearing oral closing arguments, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

Respondent’s Request for a Continuance to Obtain the Services of an Attorney.

On the first day of hearing, MOTHER requested that the matter be continued. MOTHER explained that she had recently discharged her advocate and was waiting for a particular attorney to advise her whether she was able to represent Respondent at the hearing. According to MOTHER, the attorney she selected was on a medical leave of unknown duration. MOTHER informed the Hearing Officer that the attorney’s staff “did not have a clue” when the attorney would be available to perform legal services. Accordingly, MOTHER asked that the matter be continued for 30 or 60 days.

The Hearing Officer reviewed the case file and noted that MOTHER already had two advocates, but had discharged both of them. The District filed its request for a due process hearing on October 15, 2002. On October 25, 2002, the Hearing Office received from Dr. Jessica Maxwell a letter identifying herself as the parent advocate. On October 31, 2002, the Hearing Office received a letter from Dr. Maxwell asking for a continuance so that the PARENTS could obtain an attorney to represent them. The matter was originally set for hearing on November 5, 2002. On that date, MOTHER discharged her second advocate, Dr. Jessica Maxwell.(Footnote 1)

On November 8, 2002, the Hearing Office received a letter from MOTHER asking that the case be dismissed. On November 11, 2002, the Hearing Office issued a summary order denying MOTHER’S motion for the case to be dismissed.

While the request for more time to obtain the services of an attorney was reasonable, the request to wait for a particular lawyer who was not available for an unknown period of time, was not. MOTHER indicated that she did not want the services of any other attorney. In light of the history of this case, MOTHER’S uncertainty when her attorney would be available, the District’s right to have its case heard, and the state and federal law requirements that these proceedings occur in a timely fashion, the Hearing Officer found that MOTHER’S request for a continuance did not amount to good cause. See Education Code section 56505 (f).

Respondent’s Request for Dr. Maxwell to Testify by Telephone.

On the second day of hearing on this matter, on November 13, 2002, the Hearing Officer determined that STUDENT would be given the opportunity to call witnesses named on the first day of hearing. Respondent’s parents requested that STUDENT’s treating pediatrician, Dr. Joel A. Streng, and his treating psychologist, Dr. Jessica Maxwell, testify that STUDENT should not be assessed at this time because of his medical and psychological problems. The District objected to the proposed testimony. The Hearing Officer determined that the named witnesses would provide relevant testimony on the issue presented for hearing. See Cal. Education Code section 56501.1(d). The Hearing Officer also found that neither witness came as a complete surprise to the District, since Dr. Maxwell was listed on the District’s list of proposed witnesses, and a letter dated October 7, 2002 from Dr. Streng stating that STUDENT was in a depressive state and has a problem related to an incident at school was submitted by Respondent’s parents on November 5, 2002, as an exhibit to a motion. Nevertheless, since Respondent did not file a list of proposed witnesses, and only orally advised the Hearing Officer of the witnesses on the first day of hearing, the matter was continued. As set out in a Memorandum of Interim Order dated November 15, 2002, the matter was continued to give the District five days’ notice of the witnesses, and to accommodate MOTHER’S previously scheduled medical appointment.

In addition, since FATHER was unable to advise the Hearing Officer whether the witnesses would be available, an interim schedule to provide that information to the Hearing Office and the District was established. On November 19, 2002, the Hearing Office received two letters. The first was from Dr. Maxwell. She stated that she would be available to testify, but only by telephone. The second was from Dr. Streng, indicating that he would defer to Dr. Maxwell as to the proper time for educational testing and would not testify. At the reconvened hearing, on November 21, 2002, the District objected to Dr. Maxwell testifying by telephone and asserted that it was doubly prejudiced by Dr. Streng’s letter. The District maintained that it did not receive Dr. Streng’s letter and that the absence of his testimony only made the proposed testimony of Dr. Maxwell that much more important.

After placing Dr. Maxwell under oath, the Hearing Officer exercised her discretion and determined that there was sufficient justification to permit Dr. Maxwell to testify by telephone. See Title 5 C.C.R. 3082(g). Dr. Maxwell explained that she had several clients who were at high risk of suicide at the present time and that she was unable and unwilling to reschedule her appointments for that day. Moreover, the Hearing Officer noted that Dr. Maxwell’s office in Del Mar is more than a one-hour drive from the hearing location in Temecula. Finally, the Hearing Officer found that the witness had particular knowledge that was relevant to the legal issue to be decided.

ISSUE PRESENTED FOR HEARING

Is the District entitled to conduct assessments of STUDENT in accordance with its assessment plan dated August 29, 2002, without the consent of his parents?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a nine-year-old boy who is one of a set of triplets. Before the start of the 2002-2003 school year, the family moved within the boundaries of the Temecula Valley Unified School District. On August 27, 2002, MOTHER enrolled STUDENT in Nicholas Elementary School. STUDENT is in a general education fourth grade class.

MOTHER testified that STUDENT was born prematurely. Before he started kindergarten, STUDENT had been diagnosed by a private psychologist and psychiatrist as having attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). When MOTHER first enrolled STUDENT in kindergarten in another school district, she requested that her son be assessed. According to MOTHER, STUDENT was not assessed until May of his kindergarten school year. For the remainder of that school year, as well as for the first and second grades, STUDENT was placed in a general education class and did not receive any special education or related services. When STUDENT was in the third grade, the PARENTS relocated within the boundaries of a different school district. No assessments took place.

Mrs. Pam Steffen, the resource specialist, testified that MOTHER left a note at the school on August 27, 2002, asking to discuss STUDENT with his teachers as soon as possible. MOTHER testified that she was concerned that STUDENT was having trouble with his peers and wanted to talk about implementing an assessment plan. Mrs. Steffen testified that MOTHER requested that STUDENT be given “special education testing.” MOTHER testified that she explained that STUDENT had been diagnosed with ADHD and that she wanted to initiate an assessment as soon as possible.

Upon consideration of the urgency of MOTHER’S request, Mrs. Steffen testified that a meeting was held two days later on August 29, 2002. In attendance were MOTHER; Mrs. Steffen; Dr. Donna Hughes, Respondent’s advocate;(Footnote 2) Mr. Fred Fox, the special education program specialist; and Mr. Jodi McClay, the school principal.

Mrs. Steffen testified that the meeting was both a student study meeting and a meeting to discuss possible assessments. At the meeting, MOTHER reported that STUDENT was distractable, that he needed special tools to learn, and that he should qualify for special education. According to MOTHER, STUDENT was having problems in school beginning on the first day, and she wanted him assessed as soon as possible to help him feel confident in the new school environment. Mr. Fox testified that the meeting soon became an assessment plan meeting when MOTHER stated that STUDENT was in need of special education and that she wanted him tested as soon as possible.

MOTHER testified that she objected to the assessment plan at the meeting because she did not want any area of testing eliminated, and further complained that the meeting took place even though FATHER was not able to attend. The assessment plan dated August 29, 2002, was provided to MOTHER. (District’s Exh. 3.) MOTHER did not approve of the plan; she wrote on the assessment plan form “incomplete please provide complete list of types of tests.”(Footnote 3)

Mr. Fox testified that after the meeting, he requested Dr. Taylor to perform some of the testing. It was decided that Dr. Hughes (Respondent’s then advocate) and Dr. Taylor (the itinerant school psychologist) would meet. It was anticipated that the advocate would share STUDENT’s existing records with Dr. Taylor and the two would explore the details of the actual testing. MOTHER signed an authorization to release STUDENT’s existing educational records to Dr. Hughes. (District’s Exh. 2.) MOTHER testified that Dr. Hughes had all of Respondent’s existing school records, but that these records were not provided to the District.

On October 15, 2002, the District filed its request for a due process hearing seeking authorization to assess STUDENT. On October 29, 2002, the District’s attorney sent a letter to the Student’s new advocate, Dr. Jessica Maxwell, indicating that the Respondent’s parents could contact Dr. Taylor if they had any questions about the assessment plan. (District’s Exh. 5.) A similar letter was sent to Dr. Maxwell on November 5, 2002. (District’s Exh. 4.)

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The District contends that it has an obligation to assess STUDENT in order to carry out MOTHER’s request to assess her son and to determine whether, as Respondent’s parents maintain, STUDENT is eligible for a special education program and related services.

Respondent’s parents acknowledge that they requested the District to assess STUDENT in the hopes that he will be found eligible for special education and related services. However, Respondent’s parents failed to consent to the assessment plan as currently drafted because the plan did not list the particular tests the District would administer. In addition, Respondent’s parents contended that STUDENT should not be assessed now because of his current “school phobia.” Respondent’s parents are concerned that any test results obtained at this time would not provide an accurate evaluation.

The District seeks an order authorizing it to assess STUDENT as outlined in its August 29, 2002 assessment plan to override the PARENTS’ lack of consent. The District maintains that nothing in the law requires the District to name the particular assessment tools it will administer under the assessment plan. It asserts that its assessment plan meets federal and State law requirements. The District further maintains that the qualified professionals who will administer the assessment will take STUDENT’s needs into account, but that his emotional status should not prohibit implementation of its assessment plan.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

I. Is the District entitled to conduct an assessment of STUDENT?

School districts are required by statute to “systematically seek out” all persons under the age of 22 who reside within their boundaries and have exceptional educational needs. (Cal. Education Code section 56300; 20 U.S.C. section 1412(a)(10).) To implement this “child find” obligation, “[e]ach district, special education local plan area, or county office shall provide for the identification and assessment of an individual’s exceptional needs, and the planning of an instructional program to meet the assessed needs.” (Cal. Education Code section 56302.)

Before any action is taken with respect to the initial special education placement of a student, the student must be assessed in all areas of suspected disability. (Cal. Education Code section 56320.) The process for assessment begins with a written referral for assessment by the parent, teacher, school personnel, or other appropriate agency or person. (Cal. Education Code sections 56302, 56321(a); Title 5 C.C.R. section 3021.) Within 15 days of referral (with exceptions not applicable here), the parent must be given a written assessment plan which explains the types of assessments to be conducted and meets certain other requirements. (Cal. Education Code section 56321.) The parent then has 15 days to consent in writing to the proposed assessment. (Cal. Education Code section 56321(c).)

Generally, a local education agency must have parental consent prior to conducting an assessment. (20 U.S.C. section 1414(a)(1)(C)(i); Cal. Education Code section 56321 (c).) However, a local education agency can overcome a lack of parental consent for an evaluation by utilizing due process hearing procedures. (Cal. Education Code sections 56321 (c) and 56506(e), and 20 U.S.C. 1414(a)(1)(A)(ii).) The local education agency may obtain a due process decision that overrides a lack of parental consent if it establishes an assessment is necessary. (Cal. Education Code sections 56321(c), 56501(a)(3), 56506(e), and 20 U.S.C. 1414(a)(1)(C)(ii).)

In the present case, MOTHER requested an assessment on August 27, 2002, when she left her note at the school. The undisputed evidence shows that the District has attempted to gain consent and that MOTHER has withheld such consent. (District Exhs. 3, 4, and 5.)

A. Is the assessment necessary?

First it must be determined whether an assessment of STUDENT is necessary. (20 U.S.C. section 1414(a)(2)(A); Cal. Education Code sections 56303 and 56381(a).) MOTHER left a note at the school on the day of enrollment on August 27, 2002, asking to discuss STUDENT with his teachers as soon as possible. MOTHER testified that she alerted the school to her son’s diagnosis of ADHD and wanted him “tested for special education.”

The Hearing Officer finds that the assessment of STUDENT is necessary because of MOTHER’s request that he be provided with special education and related services. A referral for special education and related services obligates the District to perform an assessment. (Title 5 C.C.R. section 3021(a).(Footnote 4)) Decisional law is in accord. In Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F. 2d 1307, 1315 (9th Cir. 1987), the Ninth Circuit stated “if the parents want [their child] to receive special education under the Act, they are obligated to permit such testing.” In Andress v. Cleveland Independent School District, 64 F. 3d 176, 178 (5th Cir. 1995), the Fifth Circuit concluded that “a parent who desires for her child to receive special education must allow the school district to evaluate the child...there is no exception to this rule.” See also Vander Malle v. Ambach, 673 F. 2d 49, 53 (2nd Cir. 1983). Moreover, the District is obligated to assess STUDENT based upon its “child find” responsibilities. See Cal. Education Code section 56302.

The Hearing Officer also takes note that according to the undisputed testimony of MOTHER and Mr. Fox, MOTHER requested that STUDENT be tested as soon as possible. Mr. Fox testified that at the August 29, 2002 assessment plan meeting, MOTHER expressed concerns that STUDENT was anxious, that he had emotional problems, that he was not working to his potential, that he had difficulty completing his school and homework assignments, and that he had difficulty achieving academically. Mr. Fox testified, based upon MOTHER’s concerns, he suspected STUDENT was a child with a disability, and consequently, the team developed its assessment plan that day. (District’s Exh. 3.)

B. Does the assessment plan conform to legal requirements?

The Assessment Plan

The assessment plan lists the areas to be assessed and names the job titles of the individuals who will test STUDENT. The plan proposes to conduct assessments in the areas of academic/preacademic achievement by the resource specialist, cognitive development/learning ability, social/emotional/behavioral development, and perceptual-motor development by the school psychologist, language/speech development by the speech and language pathologist, and health/developmental/medical by the school nurse. In addition to these areas, the plan proposes that independent assessments will be conducted by an occupational therapist, and that an audiological evaluation will be performed. Finally, the plan proposes that the resource specialist will conduct observation and interviews in the school and/or natural setting. (District’s Exh. 3.)

Dr. Maxwell, a Board-certified and licensed clinical psychologist in private practice for nearly four years, met with STUDENT twice for one hour each time. About 60-65% of her practice involves children from eight to ten years old. Part of her practice involves performing assessments as well as providing treatment. Dr. Maxwell belongs to several organizations, including the Learning Disabilities Association and has been found to be an expert in individualized education programs.(Footnote 5)

In Dr. Maxwell’s opinion, the District’s assessment plan falls below the standard of practice in the field because the plan does not indicate the particular tests that will be used. According to Dr. Maxwell, the plan is not written in a manner that the parents can understand, and, consequently, the parents are not able to make a decision whether to accept or reject the plan.

Does the Law Require the Assessment Plan Required to List the Particular Test Instruments Which Might Be Used?

Pursuant to Cal. Education Code section 56321(b), a proposed assessment plan given to a parent shall: (1) be in language that is easily understood by the general public; (2) be provided in the primary language of the parent; (3) explain the types of assessments to be conducted; and (4) state that no individualized education program will result from the assessment without the consent of the parent. The Hearing Officer finds that the assessment plan is in plain English which is the parents’ language, and is easily understood. The plan states that no individualized education program (IEP) will be implemented without the parents’ consent.

The focus of the dispute in this case is whether the assessment plan, which listed the areas to be tested but omitted the names of the particular instruments to be employed, conformed to the requirement that the plan “explain the types of assessments to be conducted.” (Cal. Education Code section 56321(b)(3).) The Hearing Officer is unaware of and has not been cited to any authority that interprets this provision to require school districts to further detail the precise assessment tools which that will be used. Nor has the Hearing Officer found nor been provided with any authority that limits the assessors’ discretion to select testing instruments based upon their professional evaluation of the student’s test-taking abilities and performance on initial screening instruments.

The District’s witnesses were the individuals who would conduct the assessment in the areas outlined on the proposed assessment plan. As stated, the District is not required to identify the specific tests its assessors might use to assess STUDENT. Nevertheless, it is worth noting that the assessors named specific tests they might use to conduct their assessment.

Dr. Taylor is a credentialed school psychologist, with a doctorate in clinical psychology. Dr. Taylor has assessed children for all handicapping conditions for eight years and has conducted approximately 150-200 assessments per year. Dr. Taylor has been employed by the Vista Unified School District as a school psychologist for six years and serves the Temecula Valley Unified School District as an itinerant psychologist.(Footnote 6) Dr. Taylor testified that the choice of testing instruments depended in part on the child’s age, whether he demonstrated language issues, whether there were any cultural concerns, and the results of a parent interview to learn more about the student’s developmental history.

Dr. Taylor testified that she might select from the Weschler Intelligence Scale for Children, the Peabody-Picture Test, the Comprehensive Test of Non-Verbal Intelligence, the Kaufman Assessment Battery for Children to assess STUDENT’s intellectual functioning. Dr. Taylor testified that to assess STUDENT’s perceptual motor development, she might select from the Visual Motor Integration test, the Bender-Gestalt test, and/or the Test of Visual Perceptual Skills. To assess STUDENT in the area of auditory perceptual skills, she might employ the Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills. In addition, Dr. Taylor testified that she might use certain subtests to determine if the test results were valid. Dr. Taylor also testified that she would assess STUDENT’s social and emotional behaviors by selecting from the Kinetic Family Drawing instrument, the Behavior Assessment System for Children, the Roberts Apperception Test, and the Beck’s Behavioral Rating Scale.

Mrs. Jensen has been a nurse for twenty-five years and a school nurse for eight years. Mrs. Jensen has a California health services credential and has considerable training in special education. She has conducted a couple of hundred or more special education assessments. Mrs. Jensen would assess STUDENT in the area of health/developmental/medical. She testified that she would test STUDENT’s hearing, vision, and perform a quick neurological clinical screening. Mrs. Jensen might use the Pure Tone Audiomotor-Calibrated to determine if STUDENT had a hearing loss, the Snellin eye chart to assess his vision, and the Ishiara Color Vision Testing Book to assess STUDENT’s ability to recognize color.

Mrs. Steffen has been a resource specialist who teaches children who have been identified as disabled for twenty-four years. During that time, she has conducted over 1000 assessments of children with suspected disabilities. Mrs. Steffen has a master’s degree in learning handicaps and possesses California credentials as a resource specialist and teacher. She would assess STUDENT in the area of academic achievement. Mrs. Steffen testified that she might start with the Woodcock-Johnson battery to identify STUDENT’s strengths and weaknesses, and depending on the results, select the next tests. She explained that she could not identify particular test instruments until she worked with STUDENT, spoke to his classroom teachers and parents, observed STUDENT in the classroom, and reviewed any outside available information.

Mrs. Carslake has been a speech and language specialist for ten months and assesses students with suspected speech and language disorders to determine whether to provide speech and language services. She has both a bachelor’s and master’s degree in communication disorders, and possesses a clinical rehabilitation services credential. She would conduct the language and speech development portion of the assessment plan and would test for voice, language, articulation and expressive and receptive disorders. Mrs. Carslake would begin by administering general tools and then select different testing instruments depending on STUDENT’s performance. She might administer the Test of Language Development and talk to STUDENT’s teachers to determine whether communication is affecting his academic achievement. She would talk to the PARENTS to obtain a developmental history.

The Hearing Officer finds persuasive the testimony of the District’s witnesses that they were unable to identify the particular test instruments they would use to assess STUDENT in advance because they did not know him. The Hearing Officer finds credible Mr. Fox’s concerns that because the PARENTS failed to release STUDENT’s existing records and because the District did not know if STUDENT had been recently assessed, the assessors could not identify particular testing instruments until they obtained that information. Mr. Fox testified that to avoid skewed results, the protocols of certain tests require that they not be readministered until a specified time has passed.

Moreover, the Hearing Officer finds convincing the testimony of the District’s assessors that they can only determine STUDENT’s need for accommodations after initial screening instruments are used. The credible testimony of Dr. Taylor established that before she could determine the actual tests she would administer, she would first observe STUDENT in a classroom setting, interview STUDENT’s parents to obtain a developmental history and learn about STUDENT’s educational background. In addition, STUDENT’s actual performance on particular subtests might lead to the administration of additional tests to confirm or refute his scores. Dr. Taylor also explained that if she observed that STUDENT was unable to attend to a particular task, she might select an instrument that allowed for the administration of the test over a period of several testing sessions. Dr. Taylor provided assurances that she would not “over-test” STUDENT, but, on the other hand, testified that she would administer an appropriate battery of tests to validate the measures. Mrs. Steffen testified credibly that she would first administer the Woodcock-Johnson battery to identify STUDENT’s strengths and weaknesses, and from that information select further tests she might administer in order to determine STUDENT’s deficits. Likewise, Mrs. Carslake testified that she would begin by administering general testing tools, and then select other tests depending on STUDENT’s areas of need.(Footnote 7)

In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that the failure to identify particular test instruments did not render the assessment plan inadequate and that the District’s proposed assessment plan is designed to meet the legal requirements set forth in Cal. Education Code section 56321(b).

Does the Assessment Plan Conform to All Other Legal Requirements?

According to the testimony of the District’s evaluators, the testing instruments they would select conform to the statutory requirements set forth in Cal. Education Code sections 56320 et seq. Section 56320 provides in relevant part:

(a) Testing and assessment materials and procedures used for the purposes of assessment and placement of individuals with exceptional needs are selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory.

(b) Tests and other assessment materials meet all the following requirements:

(1) Are provided and administered in the pupil’s primary language or other mode of communication, unless the assessment plan indicates reasons why this provision and administration are not clearly feasible.

(2) Have been validated for the specific purpose for which they are used.

(3) Are administrated by trained personnel in conformance with the instructions provided by the producer of the tests and other assessment materials, except that individually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning shall be administered by a credentialed school psychologist.

In addition, the statute requires that the tests and other assessment materials “include those tailored to assess specific areas of educational need ... and accurately reflect the pupil’s aptitude, achievement level, or any other factors the test purports to measure and not the pupil’s impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills unless those skills are the factors the test purports to measure.” No single procedure is to be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program, and the student must be assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability. (Cal. Education Code section 56320, subdivisions (c) through (f).) The assessments must be performed by persons who are competent to perform them, as determined by the district. (Cal. Education Code section 56322.) Psychological assessment of a student must be conducted by a credentialed school psychologist. (Cal. Education Code section 56324.)

According to the testimony of the District’s witnesses, the tests from which they will choose have been selected because they are administered in a manner that is not racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. The tests have been validated for the specific purpose for which they will be used. The Hearing Officer further finds that the assessors are all trained personnel who are qualified and competent to perform the assessment. All have the education and experience to enable them to properly assess STUDENT. According to the testimony of the District’s witnesses, the proposed assessment conforms to these legal requirements. A credentialed school psychologist and appropriate district staff will administer the District’s proposed testing.

With regard to whether STUDENT will be assessed in all areas of suspected disability, as noted, the District was somewhat hampered in its ability to identify these areas because the PARENTS failed to release STUDENT’s existing educational records. Nevertheless, the assessment plan was developed based upon the information that was provided by MOTHER at the August 29, 2002 meeting, where she detailed her concerns that STUDENT failed to “live up to his potential,” that he was distractable, and that he needed “special tools” in order to learn. The Hearing Officer finds that the areas to be assessed which are checked off on the assessment plan adequately address MOTHER stated concerns. According to the credible testimony of the District’s witnesses a variety of tools and strategies are to be used, and there is no suggestion that any one test will be relied upon as the sole determining factor in designing an individualized education plan for STUDENT if he is determined to be eligible for special education as a student with a disability. The assessment, according to the assessment plan, is designed to assess STUDENT in the areas of academic achievement, cognitive development/learning ability, perceptual-motor development, language/speech development, social/emotional/behavioral development, health/developmental/medical, as well as observation/interviews and independent assessments by an occupational therapist and audiological evaluation. See 34 C.F.R. section 300.532(h); Cal. Education Code section 56320(f).

The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s assessment plan, along with the proposed assessments as testified to by the District’s witnesses, is designed to conform to all state and federal law requirements. (Cal. Education Code sections 56320, 56322, and 56324.)

Is the District Entitled to Conduct an Assessment of STUDENT Now, Even If He Presently Suffers from Emotional Problems and/or Is Home on Medical Leave?

MOTHER testified that STUDENT was kept home from school “on and off” through the month of September because he was “depressed and sick.” By the end of September, MOTHER kept STUDENT home on the advice of his pediatrician, Dr. Joel A. Streng. After six weeks, the District provided STUDENT with home tutoring. On November 11, 2002, Dr. Streng wrote that STUDENT had ongoing medical and psychological problems that “compromised his overall health.” (Respondent’s Exhs. A and B.) According to MOTHER, STUDENT has not been back to school.

Dr. Maxwell saw STUDENT for two clinical visits, for one hour each time. Dr. Maxwell performed a ‘mental status’ examination. Dr. Maxwell assessed STUDENT’s mood, affect, facial expressions, and relationship with his parents. Using play therapy, Dr. Maxwell concluded that STUDENT suffers from school phobia due to an incident which occurred at school at the beginning of the school term, and that he exhibits difficulty with concentration and focus.(Footnote 8) In Dr. Maxwell’s opinion, STUDENT should not be assessed at this time, because his anxiety would interfere with the test scores and the results would not adequately reflect his performance. Dr. Maxwell is also concerned that testing at this time could exacerbate STUDENT’s symptoms. According to Dr. Maxwell, STUDENT might be ready to be assessed when his psycho-motor agitation decreases and when he feels safe about returning to school. Dr. Maxwell was unable to predict when, in her opinion, STUDENT would be ready to be assessed and testified that she first would have to see STUDENT for additional visits.

Mr. Fox explained that even if STUDENT were depressed, the assessment could still go forward. Mr. Fox testified that the assessors would respect STUDENT’s condition, would develop a rapport with him, and would work at STUDENT’s pace. In Mr. Fox’s opinion, if STUDENT is having emotional issues that interfere with his school performance, testing should not be delayed.

Dr. Taylor testified that, in her opinion, she would assess STUDENT even if he was diagnosed with depression. According to Dr. Taylor if the depression was adversely affecting STUDENT’s educational performance, it was all the more reason to assess STUDENT at this time. Dr. Taylor stated that assessing STUDENT at this time could still yield useful information, but it would depend on the child. Dr. Taylor noted that she has assessed children even when they are psychiatrically hospitalized and that she would take account of STUDENT’s condition. Thus, for example, she might administer the test over the course of several days to accommodate STUDENT and to make him comfortable.

Mrs. Steffen testified that she would still assess STUDENT even if he was depressed and/or uncooperative. She was uncertain, however, whether she would pursue testing at this time, if STUDENT had medical or psychological reasons not to be tested. As an experienced assessor, Mrs. Steffen explained that she uses methods to help the student re-focus on a task, develops a rapport with the student, and is flexible in every assessment. Although she has not performed testing at home, she testified that she would consider that option.

In Mrs. Jensen’s opinion, if STUDENT was clinically depressed, she would still be able to conduct her assessment by making him comfortable and not forcing him to perform. Mrs. Jensen added, that if STUDENT was on home tutoring, she would evaluate the circumstances and would consider testing him at home.

Mrs. Carslake testified that even if STUDENT was not cooperative with her assessment, or was diagnosed with ADHD, or was on medical leave, she would still assess him. She explained that she would break up the tests into smaller timed segments, re-focus STUDENT and re-direct him. Mrs. Carslake would select from those test instruments whose protocols allow the subtests to be administered over a flexible period of time, instead of using an instrument which requires timed testing.

The Hearing Officer finds persuasive the District assessors’ testimony that an assessment of STUDENT should not be postponed. The Hearing Officer did not find Dr. Maxwell’s testimony persuasive that STUDENT’s current emotional state makes it impossible to assess STUDENT at this time. While the Hearing Officer finds STUDENT’s emotional state concerning, the testimony of Mr. Fox and Dr. Taylor that STUDENT’s emotional problems are all the more reason to assess STUDENT is convincing. The Hearing Officer notes that schools often assess students who may be depressed or emotionally disturbed. See Title 5 C.C.R. section 3030(i). Dr. Taylor testified that testing may take place in a psychiatric facility. The Hearing Officer is persuaded that the qualified assessors possess sufficient experience and expertise to adjust their assessments to accommodate STUDENT’s depression and to avoid aggravating it.(Footnote 9)

Finally, Dr. Maxwell’s concern that the assessment results may not be valid because of STUDENT’s current condition is premature. The actual tests that will be used must be validated for the purpose for which they are used. (Cal. Education Code section 56320.) Whether an otherwise appropriate test is valid as administered cannot be determined beforehand. If STUDENT’s parents disagree with the results of the District’s assessment, they have the right to obtain an independent educational assessment from a qualified specialist at public expense. However, if it is established at a due process hearing that the District’s assessment was proper, the independent assessment would be at private expense. (Cal. Education Code section 56329(b).)

In sum, the District is not only entitled but obligated to assess STUDENT to determine if he is a child eligible for special education and related services in the areas identified on the assessment plan presented to MOTHER by the District on August 29, 2002. (District Exh. 3.)

ORDER

1. The District is not only entitled but obligated to assess STUDENT pursuant to the August 29, 2002 assessment plan.

2. Prior to scheduling the assessments, the District shall give STUDENT’s parents ten days notice.

3. STUDENT’s parents shall make him reasonably available for the assessments.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Cal. Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: Petitioner Temecula Valley Unified School District prevailed on the single issue heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Education Code section 56505(i).

Date: December 6, 2002 ____________________________ Judith E. Ganz, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. The District also filed a request for a due process hearing asserting that it has the right to assess STUDENT’s sister, SISTER. (Case No. SN02-02311.) In that case, on November 5, 2002, the Hearing Office received a request from Respondent’s mother to take the matter off calendar. Respondent’s unilateral request to take that matter off calendar was denied. However, the Hearing Office granted Respondent’s mother a brief continuance, since she had just discharged her advocate and stated that she was “in the process of meeting with [her] attorney.” 2. According to MOTHER and the case file records, at some time before October 25, 2002, Dr. Hughes was discharged as the Respondent’s advocate. On October 25, 2002, the Hearing Office received a notice that Dr. Maxwell was representing the Respondent as the advocate. On November 5, 2002, the Hearing Office received a letter from Respondent’s parents stating that Dr. Maxwell had been “released as our Educational Advocate effective immediately.” 3. Later it became clear that MOTHER wanted the names of the particular tests themselves. 4. Title 5 C.C.R. section 3021(a) provides in pertinent part: “All referrals for special education and related services shall initiate the assessment process and be documented.” 5. In this case, Dr. Maxwell also acted as the parents’ advocate. On November 5, 2002, MOTHER decided that Dr. Maxwell should no longer work in that capacity, since she was also seeing STUDENT clinically. According to the case file, MOTHER discharged Dr. Maxwell because the doctor had a “conflict of interest.” 6. Mr. Fox testified that he selected Dr. Taylor to conduct STUDENT’s assessment instead of the staff psychologist who had scheduling conflicts, in order to accommodate the urgent nature of MOTHER’s request that STUDENT be tested as soon as possible. 7. It would appear that a meeting originally contemplated between Dr. Taylor and the PARENTS’ advocate to review STUDENT’s existing records and to explore the details of the actual testing, might have resolved this matter and made the necessity for a due process hearing unnecessary. 8. According to an October 7, 2002 letter from STUDENT’s pediatrician, STUDENT was “attacked by other students.” (Respondent’s Exh. A.) According to an October 14, 2002 letter from Dr. Maxwell , STUDENT and his siblings received “a number of reported verbal threats and physical assaults” while on school premises. According to Dr. Maxwell all three children have developed “extreme anxiety and school phobia.” (Petitioner’s Exh. 1.) 9. The District may find it appropriate to administer its tests outside the school setting.