California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 24, 2002
Long Beach Unified School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 2314-01 · Hearing Officer Paul E. Lacy
Long Beach Unified's 2001-2002 offer to a student with autism was not a FAPE; the District's request is denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
Long Beach Unified School District filed for a due process hearing. It asked the Hearing Officer to rule that its 2001-2002 offer gave an 11-year-old student with autism a FAPE. The student was taught at home through discrete trial training (DTT), a program first designed by the Lovaas Clinic at UCLA and partly paid for by the District. The District offered a special day class for students with specific learning disabilities at Twain Elementary School. The offer also included a transition-behavior plan and weekly speech-language therapy: three 15-minute individual sessions and one 30-minute group session. The parents rejected the offer.
The Hearing Officer relied heavily on the District's own expert, Dr. Sandra Kaler. He found the student needed teaching strategies designed for children with autism, a team with autism expertise, a structured classroom, a behavior plan, and substantial speech-language therapy. The offer fell short on each point. It named no teaching strategy, and the teacher had no training in autism methods. It did not clearly promise a one-to-one aide for the full year. The class switched activities often, and the District did not show how it would give the student structure. The behavior plan covered only the move into the classroom. It ignored the aggressive and self-injurious behaviors the District's psychologist had documented. The student's language skills were below a two-year-old's level, so 45 minutes a week of individual therapy was not enough. The District's request was denied.
Why it matters
This case shows how a SEHO Hearing Officer decided a district-filed case by comparing the offer with the student's assessed needs. The district's own expert described what students with autism generally need, and that became the yardstick. Gaps in teaching method, staffing, behavior planning, and speech-language time each counted against the offer.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedDistrict-filed: implement IEP
Issue 1. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year? (District sought a ruling that its July 2001 IEP offer, together with the October 2001 behavior-transition plan, constituted a FAPE.)
The offer did not provide a FAPE. It named no autism-specific teaching strategy, did not provide a qualified multidisciplinary team or clearly offer a full-year 1:1 aide, did not show how the class would provide structure, had a behavior plan that ignored the student's documented behaviors, and offered too little individual speech-language therapy.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- The District's request for a ruling that its 2001-2002 offer was a FAPE was denied. No other relief was ordered.
Key authorities
20 U.S.C. § 1401; Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(3); Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3040(c); Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3042(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56507(d)
People named in the decision
- Susan Melly, SELPA administrator, Long Beach Unified School District
- Nick Davaei, due process liaison, Long Beach Unified School District
- Gail Stoter, speech and language therapist (District assessor), Long Beach Unified School District
- Jane Goodsell, occupational therapist, Long Beach Unified School District
- Shirley Sanders, school psychologist (psychoeducational assessor), Long Beach Unified School District
- Linda Scott, special day class teacher, Twain Elementary School, Long Beach Unified School District
- Laurie Murrin, administrator for teaching and learning, office of special education, Long Beach Unified School District
- Dr. Sandra R. Kaler, expert witness for District (clinical psychologist, autism education), UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute
- Elana Bellino, home-school educational aide (witness for Student), Student's home program
- Nina Lovaas, DTT provider, Lovaas Clinic, UCLA
- Tristan Smith, DTT provider, Lovaas Clinic, UCLA
- Julia Ann Singer, nonpublic school previously attended
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Paul E. Lacy, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, on February 26, 27, and 28, 2002, in Long Beach, California.
The Long Beach Unified School District (hereinafter “District” or “Petitioner”) was represented by attorney Jennifer Mullendore. Susan Melly, the District’s SELPA administrator, and Nick Davaei, the District’s due process liaison, were also present on behalf of the District. STUDENT (hereinafter “STUDENT” or “Respondent”) was represented by attorney Bruce Bothwell. Also present on his behalf were his parents.
The Hearing Officer received oral and documentary evidence during the course of the proceedings. On March 19, 2002, the Hearing Officer received closing briefs from the parties and the matter was submitted for decision.
In support of its case, the District called the following witnesses: Ms. Gail Stoter, a speech and language therapist for the District; Ms. Jane Goodsell, an occupational therapist for the District; Ms. Shirley Sanders, a District psychologist; Ms. Linda Scott, a special day class teacher at Twain Elementary School; Ms. Laurie Murrin, an administrator for teaching and learning in the District’s office of special education; and Dr. Sandra R. Kaler, a clinical psychologist with expertise in the area of educating children with autism. On his behalf, STUDENT called Elana Bellino, his home-school educational aide, and his parents, Mr. and STUDENT’s mother.
ISSUE
Did the District offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2001-2002 school year?
POSITION OF THE PARTIES
The District contends that the program it offered STUDENT was designed to meet his unique needs as a child with autism. The District also agrees that STUDENT has significant needs in the area of expressive and receptive language as well as articulation. To address STUDENT’s needs, the District offered to place him in Ms. Scott’s special day class for students with special learning disabilities at the District’s Twain Elementary School. The District also asserts that it appropriately offered STUDENT three 15-minute sessions of one-to-one speech and language therapy as well as 30 minutes of group speech and language therapy. Additionally, the District believes that it offered STUDENT sufficient support services to allow him to transition into the class from his home program, where he presently receives home instruction, and to address his behavioral needs.
STUDENT argues that the program offered by the District is fatally flawed because Ms. Scott, who was assigned to teach STUDENT’s special day class, does not have adequate knowledge of the strategies required to teach children with autism; the District did not offer STUDENT a one-to-one classroom aide for the entire school year; the proposed program did not include an appropriate behavior plan; and the District did not offer adequate speech and language services in light of STUDENT’s unique needs. Thus, he contends, the District’s offered program did not address his needs and provide him with a FAPE.
RELEVANT BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT, born on [date redacted], was 11 years 8 months old at the time the hearing closed. STUDENT presently lives with his parents and sister in Long Beach, California. He is eligible for special education as a child with autism. At the time of this decision, STUDENT was the age of most sixth-graders. STUDENT is presently home-schooled by his parents and four tutors, who provide him with discreet trial training services (DTT) that were originally designed for him by the Lovaas Clinic at UCLA. The District pays STUDENT’s parents $13.00 an hour for 41 hours a week toward the tutoring services.
STUDENT was first diagnosed with autism in October 1992, when he was two years old. The District found STUDENT eligible for special education in November 1993. He initially attended a day care center, and thereafter he was enrolled in the Lovaas Clinic at the University of California, Los Angeles. Ms. Nina Lovaas and Tristan Smith, both of the Lovaas clinic, provided STUDENT with DTT services. In addition, Lovaas and Smith also trained STUDENT’s parents how to administer DTT services to STUDENT. First Lovaas, and then STUDENT’s parents, trained aides to assist in the DTT services. Once they were trained, STUDENT’s parents and their aides directly administered the DTT services to STUDENT.
When STUDENT reached kindergarten age, he was placed in a special day class at the District’s Burroughs Elementary School. In April 1997, STUDENT was enrolled at Julia Ann Singer, a nonpublic school. STUDENT was enrolled three days a week in a special day class at the District’s Gant Elementary School for the 1999-2000 school year. In that setting, STUDENT manifested significant behavior problems, including physical violence, property damage, and self-stimulating behaviors. At the conclusion of the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT’s parents removed STUDENT from Gant and placed him exclusively in the home-school program referenced above. Throughout these years, STUDENT continued to receive DTT training at home in addition to his formal schooling.
Initially, the Lovaas Clinic supervised STUDENT’s program, and the District contracted directly with the Lovaas Clinic for the DTT services. Within a few years, the Lovaas clinic discontinued its involvement with STUDENT’s program. Thereafter, the District funded–at least in part– the costs of STUDENT’s aides. STUDENT’s parents themselves managed STUDENT’s DTT training. They directly hired, trained, and supervised STUDENT’s aides, most of whom were college students with studies in fields related to education. Since the time STUDENT’s parents took direct control of STUDENT’s educational services, they have continued to provide and oversee his in-home education and DTT services. During those periods of time when STUDENT attended Singer and Gant schools, he continued to receive in-home DTT services.
In February 2001, STUDENT received a psychoeducational assessment from the District’s school psychologist, Ms. Shirley Sanders. The assessment included observations of STUDENT, a review of his school records, interviews with his teachers, the Scales of Independent Behavior-Revised (SIB-R)–filled out by STUDENT’s mother, and interviews with STUDENT’s parents. No standardized tests were administered. In June 2001, STUDENT was administered a speech and language assessment by Ms. Gail Stoter, the District’s speech and language therapist. Tests administered to STUDENT by Ms. Stoter included an oral mechanism examination, the Arizona Articulation Proficiency Scale, the receptive One word Picture Vocabulary test, the Preschool Language Scale-3, a language sample, and a the General Speech Behavior Rating. STUDENT also received an occupational therapy assessment from the District in June of 2001.
The District held IEP team meetings for STUDENT in November 2000, March 2001, July 2001, and October 2001. The parties agreed that the program proposed by the District in July 2001, along with the behavior-transition program proposed at the October 2001 IEP meeting, constituted the District’s offered program for the 2001-2002 school year -- the year that is at issue in this case.
STUDENT’s parents did not accept the District’s offer, and the District filed for a due process hearing on October 24, 2001.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue Number 1: Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year?
APPLICABLE LAW
Under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), as amended in 1997, and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. §1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.) A free appropriate public education is special education and related services, at no cost to the parents, that are designed to meet the student’s unique needs and are provided in conformity with the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8)(D), (25). Related services are transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services that are required to assist a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); see Cal. Educ. Code § 56303(a) (“designated instruction and services” shall be available when necessary for a student to benefit from his or her special education program).)
California law states that the specific special education instruction and related services are to be provided in order to assist the student in advancing appropriately toward attaining his learning goals and objectives. (Cal. Ed. Code § 56345(a)(3).) Additionally, California regulations require that the individualized education program show a direct relationship between the present levels of performance, the goals and objectives, and the specific educational services to be provided. (C.C.R. § 3040(c).) State regulations also state that specific educational placement means that unique combination of facilities, personnel, location or equipment necessary to provide instructional services to an individual with exceptional needs, as specified in the individualized education program, in any one or a combination of public, private, home and hospital, or residential settings. (C.C.R. § 3042(a).)
EVIDENTIARY ANALYSIS
The sole question in this case is whether the program offered by the District constitutes a FAPE. For the Hearing Officer to make such a determination, it is necessary to ascertain STUDENT’s unique needs and then evaluate whether the program proposed by the District is calculated to meet those needs. To that end, the Hearing Officer will review evidence presented by the District regarding appropriate approaches to educating autistic children who are less than high functioning as well as evidence relating to STUDENT’s unique needs. Thereafter, the Hearing Officer will review STUDENT’s individual needs to ascertain what educational approaches he requires to receive a FAPE. Finally, the Hearing Officer will evaluate the District’s offered program to determine whether the District’s program meets STUDENT’s unique needs.
General Approaches to Educating Autistic Children Who are Not High-Functioning
As supported by documentation submitted by the District, autism is a developmental diagnosis of a behaviorally defined syndrome in which symptoms occur on a continuum or spectrum ranging from mild to severe. (Dist. Ex. 36.) The District also presented evidence that suggests that persons with autism experience difficulty relating to other people and situations; they present with a variety of speech, language, and communication impairments; many have an obsessive insistence on environmental sameness; and it is common for persons with autism to manifest aberrant responses to sensory stimuli. (Dist. Ex. 31.) The District’s evidence also indicated that children with autism have a wide range of abilities and disabilities. (Ibid.) Dr. Sandra R. Kaler, a child, developmental, and clinical psychologist who is also an associate professor at the UCLA neuropsychological institute, was called to testify by the District to offer her views generally on how to educate autistic children appropriately. Dr. Kaler revealed that seventy-five percent of her work involves evaluating children for special education services and consulting with districts on the appropriate educational strategies for eligible students. She related that she did not assess STUDENT herself, and therefore, she did not offer specific opinions regarding STUDENT’s educational placement. But she did offer expert opinions and commented on professional articles relating generally to the education of children with autism. Based on her professional training and experience as well as her knowledge of the subject of educating autistic children, the Hearing Officer found Dr. Kaler to be a credible and persuasive witness.
Dr. Kaler explained that autism is a social-communication learning disability. She described autism as a neurological disorder that predominately affects how impaired children in-put information and how such children have difficulty understanding the meaning of many of the things that they do. Dr. Kaler pointed out that she and other experts in the field believe that a wide variety of educational interventions are effective to address the needs of autistic students. She reviewed and summarized a number of approaches to educating autistic children that are accepted by professionals in the field, including Lovaas-DTT, TEACH, Greenspan-floor time, and the naturalistic approach.(Footnote 1) Dr. Kaler opined that it was a mistake to debate whether one approach was good or bad per se; rather, a program or combinations of components from several programs should be considered for a given child depending on that child’s particular needs. She explained that children with autism present differently and manifest their disorder in different degrees. Dr. Kaler also testified that strategies or teaching methodologies designed to address autistic learning disabilities are necessary, in fact essential, for autistic children to learn. Dr. Kaler, however, also made it clear that in her opinion, as well as in the opinions of other experts in the field, although autistic children share some traits in common, they are more different than alike. As a result, she said, it is important to evaluate each individual child to determine that child’s unique needs. According to Dr. Kaler, the IEP team needs to have a clear picture of how a particular child presents his autism in order to select an appropriate teaching strategy and establish an educational placement for him.(Footnote 2) Dr. Kaler explained that from an educational evaluation, including standardized tests, observations, and information from the parents, the IEP team can determine the educational approach or combination of approaches required to meet the child’s unique needs. In other words, once the IEP team understands the child’s needs, how he learns, and, perhaps most importantly, what impedes his learning, the team can select those strategies and interventions that will assist the student to progress in his educational program.
Although Dr. Kaler, for the reasons noted above, did not give an opinion as to what STUDENT’s educational program should look like, she did expound on the components of a program that generally should be in place for autistic students who were not high-functioning and required special teaching stratedgies and methodologies in order to learn.(Footnote 3) She delineated that generally the program should be relatively intense, be set in a structured environment, actively engage the student for five to six hours each day, provide social skills training, afford the child opportunities for social engagement, address his functional and academic needs, involve the parents, and include a component for continuing parental involvement to ensure structure and consistency at home. Dr. Kaler also furnished general guidelines for the personnel involved in the education of autistic children.
Dr. Kaler testified that generally autistic children require a multi-disciplinary team to provide them with educational services. She believed that it was not necessary for the autistic child’s teacher to be an expert in autism as long as other members of the multi-disciplinary support team, including an aide, the aide’s supervisor, and the speech and language therapist have appropriate expertise in teaching or working with autistic children. However, the classroom teacher herself must learn basic skills for teaching autistic children, employ a hands-on approach to teaching, be open to the use of picture schedules, and organize a structured class in which the child knows where he will be “moment to moment.” The teacher also must have the ability to break down tasks, have a good understanding of how to engage the child, and be willing to work in a multi-modal way, i.e., work with the child’s aide, the aide’s supervisor, the speech and language therapist, the child’s parents, and any other experts such as inclusion and behavior specialists.
Dr. Kaler maintained that in most cases an autistic child requires a one-to-one aide to assist him with learning and class participation. She asserted that the aide needs to have a working knowledge of the particular strategy or strategies employed to teach the autistic student. Additionally, the aide should work under the guidance and direction of a consultant or supervisor who is in fact an expert in the educational strategies selected to educate the student. The aide’s supervisor, she said, would also help educate the classroom teacher. The aide, the aide’s supervisor, and the teacher should work as a team with the speech and language therapist, the parents, and any other professionals involved in the autistic student’s educational program. The crux of Dr. Kaler’s testimony on this point was that autistic children require specialized teaching strategies delivered by a multi-disciplinary team that have sufficient experience and expertise to meaningfully educate them.
Although Dr. Kaler discussed various strategies for educating autistic children in general, the question arises as to whether STUDENT requires the type of educational interventions that Dr. Kaler outlined.
STUDENT’s Unique Needs
To determine whether STUDENT requires the educational approaches discussed by Dr Kaler, it is necessary to review the evidence relating to STUDENT’s unique needs. (In this way, the Hearing Officer can determine whether STUDENT requires the educational approach outlined by Dr. Kaler.)
A. STUDENT’s Language Needs
The parties agreed that STUDENT has severe impairments in the areas of expressive and receptive language. A speech and language assessment conducted by the District in June of 2001 by Ms. Stoter, the District’s speech and language therapist, indicated that STUDENT’s expressive vocabulary was age-equivalent to one year seven months. In that assessment, STUDENT did not demonstrate a self-initiated expressive vocabulary of even ten words, nor could he name objects upon request without previous stimulation such as familiar pictures. Test scores in the area of receptive language placed STUDENT’s age equivalency at one year eight months. His language comprehension age-equivalency was estimated at one year and seven to ten months. STUDENT’s oral mechanism showed some difficulties in the area of occlusion and teeth positioning. His articulation was estimated to be age-equivalent with that of a two and a half year old.
In her assessment report, Ms. Stoter, recommended that STUDENT receive individual speech and language services as well as small-group language therapy in the area of social thinking to increase his pragmatic skills. Ms. Stoter also recommended that a picture exchange system in combination with verbalized speech be continued.
STUDENT’s mother testified that STUDENT’s biggest problem is in the area of receptive oral language. She related that STUDENT can learn visually but not auditorily. In that regard, she said he is able to read better than he is able to understand oral language. She noted that although over the years STUDENT has increased his ability in the area of receptive oral language, he still has great difficulty understanding abstract concepts such as the word “patience.” As to his functional language abilities, STUDENT’s mother explained that STUDENT likely would not understand a person who just began talking with him, i.e. someone who initiated a conversation with him out of the blue. She also noted that STUDENT processes written language more quickly than he does spoken words. Additionally, STUDENT’s mother said that STUDENT’s abilities for expressive language were limited to objects or situations in his own environment. For example, he can say “more swing” or “I want shower.” However, STUDENT’s mother pointed out that STUDENT has to be taught expressive language, as he will not imitate sounds on his own. Moreover, STUDENT’s mother concurred that STUDENT had serious difficulties articulating words.
B. STUDENT’s Behavioral Needs
The District’s psychologist, Ms. Shirley Sanders, conducted a psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT in February 2001. In her evaluation, Ms. Sanders noted that STUDENT “demonstrates marginally serious problem behaviors.” She noted that he also exhibits serious internalized maladaptive behaviors, withdrawal or inattentive behaviors, unusual or repetitive habits, and occasionally hurts himself. She added that he demonstrates moderately serious externalized maladaptive behaviors, including disruptive behaviors, destructiveness to property, and hurting others. Specifically, her report indicated that STUDENT will engage in biting or scratching once a month. Other behavior problems that Ms. Sanders described as moderately serious were hitting, head-butting, and kicking. STUDENT, she noted, will also cry and pace.
STUDENT’s home instructional aide, Ms. Elana Bellino, testified that STUDENT’s behavior has improved in his home-schooling environment over the past year, but that he still becomes frustrated when tasks become too difficult for him. She explained that on such occasions STUDENT becomes uncooperative and verbally oppositional, but that over the past year he has not exhibited physical violence at home.
STUDENT’s mother explained that STUDENT had serious behavior problems when he attended school at Gant during the 1999-2000 school year. She recalled that he exhibited violent behavior, including hitting and kicking, and vandalism of property, and that the police had to be called at one point. Additionally, she described how STUDENT became more oppositional at home during the time he was attending Gant and, on one occasion, kicked out her car windshield. STUDENT’s mother conceded that STUDENT’s behavior had improved significantly since returning full-time to home schooling.
C. STUDENT’s Social Needs
Ms. Sanders assessment of February 2001 included an evaluation of STUDENT’s ability to interact, communicate, and socialize with others. Ms. Sanders concluded in her assessment report that STUDENT’s social skills were comparable to that of a two– to four-year-old child. Ms. Bellino testified that STUDENT is well-behaved when he shops, goes to the movies, or plays in the park. She noted that in the park he generally stays to himself and does not initiate play with other children. She described him as polite in his contacts with other children and adults. STUDENT’s father described STUDENT as gregarious and outgoing–even liking to kiss girls on occasion. He testified that STUDENT accompanies him to Boy Scout events and interacts with the other boys on those occasions. STUDENT’s father observed that when STUDENT attends scouting events he is responsive to the other children when they initiate contact with him, and although he initially stood at the periphery of group activities, he eventually took to following other Scouts that were engaged in various group activities.
D. STUDENT’s Academic Needs
Ms. Bellino stated that STUDENT can spell words familiar to him and can match pictures to words. Both STUDENT’s mother and Ms. Bellino noted that STUDENT can comprehend written words better then oral language, and that he is able to read books that have pictures and a few words. STUDENT is able to identify most of the activities or objects in the stories by means of pointing. All of the parties agreed that STUDENT is unable and cannot be expected at this point to compute arithmetic or write grammatically correct sentences with punctuation.
E. STUDENT’s Ability to Learning
STUDENT does not learn the same way as his normally developing peers. Both Mr. and STUDENT’s mother, as well as Ms. Bellino, testified that STUDENT does not model or imitate the behavior of others. Additionally, they explained that STUDENT is not an auditory learner–he is primarily a visual learner. In other words, STUDENT does not learn from people merely verbally explaining information to him. It is necessary for him to associate visual images–objects or symbols–to conceptual ideas, for example, a picture of a shower or a person stepping into a shower to comprehend or communicate the idea of taking a shower. In short, STUDENT is a visual and concrete learner. He has difficulty understanding abstract concepts, and he cannot generalize very well specific events or particular pieces of information. Thus, STUDENT requires special teaching strategies for him to learn and acquire knowledge and skills. F. Summary of STUDENT’s Needs
To recap, the evidence establishes that STUDENT presents with significant language delays, behavior problems, and to a lessor extent, with social skills impairments. Therefore, he requires a program to address each of these needs. Moreover, as a direct result of his autism, STUDENT does not learn the same way as his typically developing peers. Unlike most children, STUDENT’s primary mode of learning is visual and not auditory. The assessments and observations of witnesses most familiar with STUDENT establish that to meet his needs, STUDENT requires a program that includes components as described by Dr. Kaler for children with STUDENT’s characteristics. For example, he requires teaching strategies specially designed for autistic children, a multi-disciplinary team of professionals with the requisite knowledge and skills to implement his program, a small structured classroom, a behavior plan, and speech and language services sufficient to address his severe language deficits.
The Program Offered by the District
While the IEP process began in November 2000, the District’s offered program was set forth in writing in the July 2001 IEP. Additionally, a single transition-behavior plan was proposed by the District in October 2001.
The parties did not dispute the goals and objectives developed for STUDENT by the IEP team.(Footnote 4) In July 2001, the team drafted nine annual goals with measurable objectives for STUDENT to accomplish. The first seven goals for STUDENT related to language. These goals were designed to address his needs in the areas of expressive and receptive language, reading, and writing. STUDENT’s first annual goal called for him to give final k, n, b, and g phonemes in words with 80% accuracy. The second goal anticipated that STUDENT would expand his core vocabulary to include 50 to 70 new words with a range of basic object-categories to include a combination of nouns, verbs, and adjectives. Goal number three called for STUDENT to write or type a two-word sentence with 90% accuracy when prompted with pictures. Language goal number four asked STUDENT to accurately spell 50 to 70 new words that corresponded with the picture exchange program utilized in his classroom. The fifth goal called for STUDENT to utilize a picture exchange system to aid in the verbalization of a sentence in eight of ten trials. The sixth goal for STUDENT required him to read books up to 12 pages that included easy-to-read repetitive words where one word changed on each successive page. STUDENT’s seventh and final language goal anticipated that STUDENT would be able to follow three-step instructions 90% of the time. STUDENT’s eighth goal was in the area of mathematics and called for him to associate concrete objects and pictorial symbols with number symbols for zero to ten with 90% accuracy in four of five trials. Goal number nine related to STUDENT’s behavior and social-emotional needs. This goal anticipated that STUDENT would play cooperatively in a group of two to four students 90% of the time.
To assist STUDENT in advancing toward his goals and objectives, the IEP stated that STUDENT required specialized and individualized instruction to meet his individual goals. The District proposed to place STUDENT in a special day class. The IEP indicated that STUDENT would attend lunch and recess with regular education students. The District also offered to provide STUDENT with one-to-one speech and language services three times each week for 15 minutes each session. Additionally, the IEP called for him to receive one 30-minute speech and language session in a group setting each week. The IEP also called for STUDENT to participate in an extended school year and receive transportation services. The IEP meeting notes stated that the team agreed to a trial placement in Ms. Scott’s special day class at the District’s Twain School. The meeting notes also stated that “a classroom aide that is primarily responsible for STUDENT would be provided.”
The October 2001 IEP proposed a behavior-transition plan that included four interventions. The first intervention proposed that STUDENT’s parents would bring him to visit his classroom four times for 30 minutes each visit. The intervention stated that during this time a detailed behavior plan would be written. The second intervention called for STUDENT’s teacher to visit him at his home from one to four times for 15 minutes each visit. The third intervention required STUDENT’s teacher to develop and provide him with a daily schedule before he started school. The fourth intervention called for STUDENT’s teacher to prepare a special section of the classroom with STUDENT’s name and individual schedule. The document also noted that the behavior plan would be measured by completion of the tasks listed in the intervention section of the plan with the frequency of the measurements to be determined when the behavior plan was finalized. The meeting notes attached to the October IEP state that the District would “provide a one-to-one assistant for STUDENT as he transitions into the school program.” The notes added, “The District will consider employment of one of his current assistants.”
Did the District’s Offered Program Appropriately Address STUDENT’s Needs?
To address the question of whether the program offered by the District would provide STUDENT with a FAPE, the Hearing Officer will evaluate the District’s offered program–placement, behavior pan, and speech and language services–in light of STUDENT’s unique needs discussed above.
A. Discussion of the District’s Offered Placement
The District’s offered placement–Ms. Scott’s special day class for specific learning disabled students–did not include any of the approaches or specific teaching strategies that Dr. Kaler discussed and are appropriate for STUDENT. For example, although Dr. Kaler explained that autistic children who require special teaching strategies to learn may utilize programs such as the Lovass, Greenspan, natural, or TEACH systems–or some combination of those programs–the District’s proposal failed to discuss a special teaching strategy at all. The District merely proposed to place STUDENT in a special day class designed for children with specific learning disabilities without any explanation as to how STUDENT would be taught. Thus, although STUDENT requires special teaching strategies in order for him to learn, the District did not include or even discuss such strategies in the program it offered.
Moreover, even if the District had offered to utilize a special teaching strategy in STUDENT’s program, it did not offer to provide him with a multi-disciplinary team of professionals to implement his program. As discussed above, Dr. Kaler stated that generally the team should include at least the classroom teacher, the parents, a classroom aide, a consultant with expertise in autism and the particular teaching strategy selected, and additional service providers such as a speech and language therapist. Dr. Kaler pointed out that team members needed to have varying degrees of knowledge on how to implement the chosen teaching strategy. For example, she said that while an autistic student’s classroom teacher doesn’t necessarily need to be an expert in the particular teaching strategy employed, she must have a basic working knowledge of the strategy and be willing to work with and learn from professionals who were in fact experts in those methods. In this case, however, the District did not offer to assemble a multidisciplianry team to implement STUDENT’s program. The District’s failure to assemble such a team is particularly problematic in this case inasmuch as Ms. Scott testified that she had no experience and had not been trained in the special teaching strategies discussed by the District’s expert, Dr. Kaler. Furthermore, although the parties all agreed that STUDENT needed a personal one-to-one classroom aide over the course of the entire year, the District did not make it clear that it was unequivocally offering to provide STUDENT with such assistance. Therefore, although STUDENT required a multidisciplianry team to implement his program, the District failed to account for this need in its program.
Additionally, Ms. Sanders testified that STUDENT, like many other autistic children, needed a structured class with consistency in his schedule. The District did not offer any evidence that Ms. Scott’s special day class would address STUDENT’s need for structure and consistency. To the contrary, Ms. Scott testified that her special day class engaged in different learning activities day-to-day and hour-to-hour. Ms. Scott testified at length regarding the various lessons and educational exercises that her specific learning disabled students participated in throughout the week. These activities, which are designed for specific learning disabled children, most always vary day-to-day and week-to-week, and frequently, children would be engaged in different activities in various parts of the classroom at the same time. For example, Ms. Scott stated that children who are not able to participate in a particular group activity may work on a computer-based lesson in another part of the classroom. Although Ms. Scott testified that a picture-schedule would be provided for STUDENT, she did not explain how, notwithstanding the picture-schedule, her special day class would in fact provide STUDENT with sufficient structure and consistency to meet his needs. Therefore, the District did not adequately address how STUDENT’s need for structure and consistency would be addressed in Ms. Scott’s special day class.(Footnote 5)
Finally, Dr. Kaler testified that the classroom is but one component in the educational program for an autistic child. She noted that in addition to speech and language services, other program components may include assigning a person to work with the student on social or play skills, and designating a person to provide the parents with ongoing consultation services relating to home behaviors that may carry over into the classroom. All of the parties agreed that STUDENT had progressed and benefitted from his home-based DTT program, but the IEP team did not address what role, if any, that program should play in a future school-based placement. However, the IEP team did not discuss whether any of these components were appropriate to support STUDENT’s program.
B. Discussion of the District’s Proposed Behavior Plan
Dr. Kaler pointed out that autistic children commonly present behavior problems as a result of their communication impairments, and her opinion was supported by the professional articles submitted by the District. Additionally, Ms. Sanders’ behavior assessment concluded that STUDENT “demonstrates marginally serious problem behaviors.” The behaviors Ms. Sanders described in her report included physical assaults, property damage, and self-injurious behavior. But the behavior plan proposed by the District did not address any of STUDENT’s behaviors that Ms. Sanders discussed in her report. Although her report described STUDENT’s behaviors with significant specificity, the interventions proposed by the District failed to mention any of them. The interventions suggested by the District merely related to his transition back into the public school system, and simply did not correlate its plan to the behaviors specified in Ms. Sanders’ report.
The District took the position that it did not have enough information to design an appropriate behavior plan for STUDENT, and that after he was placed in the classroom, it would assess his behaviors and prepare a plan. Dr. Kaler, however, believed that a behavior assessment designed to determine what behaviors may impede STUDENT’s learning was appropriate.(Footnote 6) She explained that the assessment should identify the problem behaviors, determine their antecedents, ascertain their purpose, and then interventions should be designed that are effective in changing the behavior. Dr. Kaler testified that the person conducting the behavior assessment should obtain and consider information from STUDENT’s prior placement at Gant as well as his current home-placement. Thereafter, she explained, the information derived from the assessment should constitute the foundation for an initial behavior plan. Once STUDENT reenters the public school, the behavior plan should be implemented and modified or updated as circumstances dictate.
The Hearing Officer finds that although STUDENT had not been in a classroom setting since June 2000, his behaviors were serious and recent enough to warrant a behavior plan as described by Dr. Kaler before he enters school. There is sufficient information available to the District to undertake an initial evaluation of the behaviors that impede STUDENT’s learning and prepare a plan. Once STUDENT is placed, additional evaluations of his behaviors can lead to appropriate modifications to his behavior plan.(Footnote 7)
C. Discussion of the District’s Offered Speech and Language Services
The parties agree that STUDENT’s primary needs are language based. As discussed above, the District’s assessments indicated that STUDENT–at age eleven–had expressive and receptive language abilities–as quantified by age-equivalency–below that of a two-year-old. Additionally, the District’s assessments revealed that STUDENT’s speech articulation abilities were below that of a three-year-old. The District offered STUDENT three 15-minute individual speech and language sessions and one 30-minute group-session. Ms. Stoter testified that the District offered STUDENT three 15-minute one-to-one speech and language therapy sessions because she believed that severely impaired children generally do not maintain their attention for longer periods of time. However, both Ms. Bellino and STUDENT’s mother testified that STUDENT routinely remained focused on his home-school DTT lessons for at least 45 minutes at a time most everyday. Additionally, Ms. Bellino observed that STUDENT maintained his attention for at least 45 minutes during speech and language therapy sessions he presently receives. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that there is no evidence to support a finding that STUDENT cannot maintain his attention during speech and language services for more than 15 minutes at a time. Moreover, even if STUDENT requires a break during therapy, such a requirement does not itself support a 15-minute time limit on a service as critical for STUDENT as speech and language.
Other than its mistaken belief that STUDENT could not attend to more than 15 minutes of services at a time, the District did not offer any evidence that STUDENT only needed three 15-minute sessions of individual speech and language therapy each week. This in spite of the fact that he is nearly 12 years old and most of his language skills are below that of a two-year-old. Dr. Kaler, however, testified that while she did not assess STUDENT, and she could not testify as to his particular needs, she was of the opinion that three hours of individual speech and language therapy per week was the standard in the field for autistic children with low-functioning language skills. Thus, because the District failed to present any evidence that STUDENT only needed three 15-minute sessions of individual speech and language therapy each week to address his severe language deficits, and because he falls in the category of an autistic child with low-functioning language skills, the Hearing Officer finds that three 15-minute sessions of individual speech and language therapy each week do not meet his needs.
Conclusion
Thus, the program the District offered STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year was not designed to meet his unique needs, and therefore, it did not offer him a FAPE.
ORDER
The District’s request that the Hearing Officer rule that the program it offered STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year constitutes a FAPE is denied.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statue:
1. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties in this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).)
Date: April 24, 2002 Paul E. Lacy, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES
1. For reasons that will become more clear in the discussion to follow, it is not necessary to specifically define and explain these various approaches. 2. Dr. Kaler used the terms “interventions,” “approaches,” “strategies,” and “methodologies” somewhat interchangeably. The gist of her point was that many autistic children do not learn in the same way or process information in the same way as their typically developing peers. Dr. Kaler further explained that in order for these autistic children to learn, they must be taught differently from their typically developing peers to account for the differences in how they learn. Dr. Kaler utilized the adjectives mentioned above to explain or capture the essence of the concept that different teaching approaches were required to teach autistic children who learned or processed information differently. The Hearing Officer will use the term “teaching strategy” when referring to this concept. It is important to understand the term “teaching strategy” as used in this context and distinguish it from the idea of how a teacher implements a particular strategy, i.e., the individual manner or method that a classroom teacher employs to present information to a student so long as it is done in a way that the child, in light of his impairments, can actually learn it. 3. Dr. Kaler emphasized that each autistic child manifested his or her autism differently and presents individual needs. She did, however, generally distinguished between students who are high-functioning and those who are not. For example, she pointed out that there are students with autism whose disorders are moderate enough that they are educated in general education and many of their peers and teachers may not even realize that they are autistic. The approaches to educating autistic children Dr. Kaler discussed at the hearing generally applied to students whose impairments are more severe and require special educational strategies in order to learn. 4. Initially, Respondent took the position that the goals and objectives were another reason for the Hearing Officer to find that the program offered by the District was not a FAPE. However, prior to the hearing concluding, Respondent dropped this contention and expressly stated that he did not challenge the District’s offer on the basis of the goals and objectives developed for STUDENT. 5. The Hearing Officer notes that while the District failed to adequately explain how STUDENT’s need for structure and consistency could be met in Ms. Scott’s special day class, it doesn’t mean that Ms. Scott’s special day class could not ultimately meet his needs if the appropriate degree of consistency and structure were provided. 6. In Dr. Kaler’s opinion, a full functional analysis assessment (FAA) as set forth in the Hughs Bill (Cal. Ed. Code § 56523; C.C.R. § 3052.) was not necessary at this point. 7. In fact, Dr. Kaler testified that behavior evaluations and behavior plan modifications should be an on-going process in the case of an autistic child who demonstrates behaviors that impede learning.
