California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 26, 2004
Student v. Los Altos Elementary School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 2346-03 · Hearing Officer Lawrence E. Mendel
Los Altos Elementary denied FAPE through inconsistent behavior support; Hearing Officer orders added consultation, parent training, and assessments.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The decision follows a prior SEHO decision between the same parties, SN02-01950 (November 5, 2002). It also notes a Superior Court temporary restraining order of November 7, 2003 and a stipulated order of December 2003 keeping the student out of Springer School pending this decision.
Summary
This case followed an earlier SEHO decision (SN02-01950) that upheld Los Altos Elementary School District's 2002-2003 offer for an eight-year-old with autism in general education with a one-on-one aide. The parents challenged the program from November 2002 on. The district sought to assess without parent consent and defended an interim one-on-one placement.
Hearing Officer Lawrence E. Mendel found a denial of FAPE from November 2002 through June 2003. Frequent turnover of aides and consultants, plus constant home-school conflict, left the behavior program without meaningful consistency. The student made no progress on acting-out behaviors or social skills, though reading comprehension improved. The 2003 extended school year offer was appropriate. The district could hold the June 2003 IEP meeting after the parents refused to attend over the choice of behavior consultant.
For fall 2003, the June offer was appropriate. The September "Shooting for the Stars" plan was too complex, gave little immediate reinforcement, and the district did not consistently use the agreed consequence for unsafe behavior. The district could conduct a functional analysis assessment, reinforcement survey, and social/emotional assessment without consent. The functional analysis must occur where the plan will be used. A December 2003 counsel letter adding assessments was not a valid assessment plan. The interim one-on-one placement was upheld, but with a new interim behavior plan and weekly meetings. Compensatory services added consultation and parent training through 2004-2005.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO treated consistency in implementing a behavior plan as an element of FAPE, even where parent conduct contributed to the problem. It also held that a functional analysis assessment must be done where the plan will be used. An assessment plan must state the areas to be assessed, not just who will assess.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Did the District offer and provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year from November 5, 2002 through the end of the regular school year?
FAPE denied: the behavior program lacked any meaningful consistency because of frequent staff turnover and home-school conflict, and the student made no progress on acting-out behaviors or social skills. She did progress in reading comprehension, and no Hughes Bill behavior intervention plan was required.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 2. Did the District offer and provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2003 extended school year?
The ESY offer was a FAPE. The district made extensive efforts to get the parents to attend and could hold the June 4, 2003 IEP meeting without them. The consultant was qualified, and her law degree created no conflict of interest.
- Student prevailed in partIEP content
Issue 3. Did the District offer and provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year through November 4, 2003?
The June 4, 2003 offer was a FAPE. The September 24, 2003 'Shooting for the Stars' plan was too complex and lacked immediate reinforcement, and the district did not consistently apply the agreed consequence for unsafe behavior, so FAPE was denied from September 24 to November 4, 2003. The daily reports gave the parents enough information to participate.
- District prevailedDistrict-filed: assess without consent
Issue 4 (November 4, 2003 plan). Is the District entitled to conduct assessments pursuant to the assessment plan of November 4, 2003 without the consent of the parents?
The district substantially prevailed. It may conduct the functional analysis assessment, reinforcement survey, and social/emotional assessment without consent, but the functional analysis must take place in the setting where the behavior intervention plan will be used. The district did not show a need to repeat the Test of Problem Solving.
- Student prevailedDistrict-filed: assess without consent
Issue 4 (December 11, 2003 amended plan). Is the District entitled to conduct assessments pursuant to the December 11, 2003 amended assessment plan without the consent of the parents?
The counsel letter adding a medical assessment and an autism-specialist reevaluation said who would assess but not what areas would be assessed. It was therefore not a valid assessment plan under Education Code section 56321(b).
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 5. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE from November 4, 2003 continuing through the end of the 2003-2004 school year?
The district substantially prevailed. The written interim offer satisfied Union v. Smith, and the interim one-on-one placement on a general education campus was the LRE under Rachel H. However, a new interim behavior plan based on the LIFE report and weekly home-school meetings were required.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 6. If STUDENT was denied a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year, the 2003 extended school year, or the 2003-2004 school year, is she entitled to compensatory education?
Compensatory education was awarded for behavior management: case management/behavior consultation was raised to 4 hours a week and parent in-home training and support to 1 hour a week, for the rest of 2003-2004 and all of 2004-2005.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to provide or change services. District shall immediately conduct a reinforcement survey and develop an interim behavior plan based on Shawn Regnier's (LIFE) October 31, 2003 report. The plan must be based on a review of the 2003-2004 behavior records and use a token system, with tokens delivered shortly after desired behavior and exchanged later for identified reinforcements.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 10 calendar days, convene an IEP meeting to amend the November 4, 2003 interim placement. The amended IEP must include the interim behavior plan, weekly meetings between district staff and the parents, and the compensatory services.
- Compensatory education. Case management/behavior consultation increased to a total of 4 hours per week (2 hours added to the 2 in the IEP), and parent in-home training and support increased to a total of 1 hour per week. Services run for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year and the entire 2004-2005 school year.
- Order that district may assess without consent. District may conduct a social/emotional assessment and a functional analysis assessment under the November 4, 2003 assessment plan without parent consent. The district must give the parents 5 calendar days' notice of assessment dates, and the parents must make the student reasonably available.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. After the social/emotional assessment, and within 40 calendar days of the decision, convene an IEP meeting to determine placement for the rest of 2003-2004. The IEP must provide for completing the functional analysis assessment and developing a behavior intervention plan under 5 C.C.R. §§ 3001 and 3052.
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H.; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Andress v. Cleveland Independent School Dist.; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Burlington; Hoeft v. Tucson Unified School Dist.; Seattle School Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.; Roland M. v. Concord School Committee; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. Missouri
People named in the decision
- Charlene Luks, director of pupil services, Los Altos Elementary School District
- Shawn Regnier, behavior consultant who reviewed the program and wrote the October 31, 2003 report, Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE)
- Vicki Wells, behavior consultant, expert witness for Student, hired by parents
- Laura McErlane, RSP teacher, Springer Elementary School
- Kathy Panec, general education third grade teacher, Springer Elementary School
- Mary Allen, program specialist and school psychologist, Los Altos Elementary School District
- Robert (Bob) Celeste, principal, Springer Elementary School
- Shelley Davis, behavior consultant/case manager, 2002-2003, contracted by District
- Sinead McDonnell, behavior consultant/case manager, 2003-2004, Bay Area Child Development Agency (BACDA)
- Stacie Solt, 1:1 aide, 2003-2004, Bay Area Child Development Agency (BACDA)
- Lisa Wiedenfeld, 1:1 aide, contracted by District
- Abby Sandborn, 1:1 aide, Los Altos Elementary School District
- Betty Gist, 1:1 aide (briefly), Los Altos Elementary School District
- Eleanor Martindale, speech therapist, Springer Elementary School
- Michelle Garcia Winner, social cognitive learning specialist proposed for staff training, private
- Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE), private behavior consultation agency
- Bay Area Child Development Agency (BACDA), agency providing aide and behavior consultant
- Abracadabra day care, on-campus day care used as agreed removal setting for unsafe behavior
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Lawrence E. Mendel, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Los Altos, California, on January 13, 14, 15, 16, 20, 21, 22, 23, 27, and 28, 2004.
The Los Altos Elementary School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorneys Eliza McArthur and Rod Levin. Also present on the District’s behalf was Charlene Luks, director of pupil services. STUDENT (STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorneys Bob Varma and Roberta Savage. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was her father, PARENT.
The following witnesses were called to testify at the hearing: Charlene Luks, director of pupil services; MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother; Shawn Regnier, behavior consultant; Vicki Wells, behavior consultant; Laura McErlane, RSP teacher; Kathy Panec, teacher; PARENT, STUDENT’s father; Mary Allen, program specialist; Robert Celeste, school principal; Shelley Davis, behavior consultant; and Sinead McDonnell, behavior consultant.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following the submission of written closing arguments the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL HISTORY
On November 5, 2002, a decision was issued in an earlier case involving these same parties, SEHO case number SN02-01950. That case determined that the District had offered STUDENT an appropriate placement for the 2002-2003 school year. There is no dispute that the parties cannot use the present case to re-litigate issues that were or could have been raised in the prior matter. However, the PARENTS are contending that, during the remainder 2002-2003 school year (after November 5, 2002) STUDENT developed new unique needs and that the program the District offered and implemented did not meet the requirements set forth by the hearing officer in his decision in SN02-01950. Because these are issues that could not have been raised or litigated at the prior hearing, the Hearing Officer will be considering STUDENT’s needs, and the program the District offered and implemented during the remainder of the 2002-2003 school. The PARENTS have also raised issues regarding the 2003 extended school year. This time period was not covered by the decision in SN02-01950.
At an IEP meeting on November 4, 2003, the District proposed conducting additional assessments and an interim placement for STUDENT pending the completion of those assessments. (Footnote 1) The PARENTS refused the District’s offer in its entirety. On November 7, 2003, the District obtained a temporary restraining order (TRO) from the Superior Court, removing STUDENT from her placement in a general education class at the Springer School. Pursuant to the TRO, STUDENT’s placement was changed to a tutorial room on the Springer School campus with a one-on-one teacher and an instructional aide. STUDENT never attended the placement set forth in the TRO. She was removed from her District placement by her parents. The TRO remained in effect until December 13, 2003, at which time a stipulated order was entered in Superior Court. That order stated that STUDENT would not return to Springer School until there was either agreement between the parties or an administrative due process hearing decision. It is undisputed that the Hearing Officer has no jurisdiction to review STUDENT’s placement pursuant to the November 7th TRO. However, the Hearing Officer does have jurisdiction to consider the District’s right to assess STUDENT over her parents’ objection. Furthermore, pursuant to the terms of the December 13, 2003 stipulation, the Hearing Officer also has jurisdiction to consider the appropriateness of the District’s offer of prospective placement for STUDENT for the remainder of 2003-2004 school year.
ISSUES
1. Did the District offer and provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education during the 2002-2003 school year from November 5, 2002 through the end of the regular school year?
2. Did the District offer and provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education during the 2003 extended school year?
3. Did the District offer and provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education during the 2003-2004 school year through November 4, 2003? (Footnote 2)
4. Is the District entitled to conduct assessments pursuant to the assessment plans of November 4 and December 11, 2003 without the consent of the parents?
5. Did the District offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education from November 4, 2003 continuing through the end of the 2003-2004 school year?
6. If STUDENT was denied a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year, the 2003 extended school year, or the 2003-2004 school year, is she entitled to compensatory education?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
For the 2002-2003 school year, the PARENTS contend that the District failed to provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) because its offer failed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and because it was not calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit in relation to her reading comprehension or her behavioral needs. Specifically, the PARENTS contend that the District did not provide a consistent program, did not develop an appropriate behavior plan, did not collect adequate data on STUDENT’s behavior, did not facilitate STUDENT’s peer play and peer socialization, did not provide an appropriate shadow aide, and did not provide an appropriate case manager.
The District argues that it did offer and provide STUDENT with a FAPE. Although conceding that there was a relatively high staff turnover, the District contends that that turnover did not affect the appropriateness of STUDENT’s program. Furthermore, the District contends that any deficiencies in the implementation of STUDENT’s behavior program were primarily the result of a lack of cooperation on the part of the PARENTS.
For the 2003 extended school year, the PARENTS contend that the District violated the PARENTS’ procedural rights by holding an IEP team meeting on June 4, 2003 without the PARENTS present. In addition, they argue that the District’s offer did not meet STUDENT’s unique needs because the offered placement was in a special education program, not a general education program. The PARENTS also argue that the case manager the District proposed was not appropriate.
The District contends that it made reasonable efforts to convince the PARENTS to attend an IEP meeting, but that the PARENTS refused. On the basis of this refusal, the District was entitled to hold an IEP meeting without the PARENTS present. In relation to the offer of placement, the District contends that it offered placement in a general education class, and that the proposed case manager was appropriate.
For the 2003-2004 school year through November 4, 2003, the PARENTS repeat their contention that the District violated their procedural rights by holding the June 4, 2003 IEP meeting without the PARENTS present. The PARENTS also contend that their procedural rights were violated because the District failed to accurately inform them of the seriousness of STUDENT’s behavioral problems. In relation to the program offered and provided, the PARENTS raise the same contentions as were raised in relation to the previous school year. The PARENTS also allege that the offer was not in the least restrictive environment.
The District contends that it did offer STUDENT FAPE for this period of time. The District also continues to argue that any deficiencies in the implementation of STUDENT’s behavior program were primarily the result of a lack of cooperation on the part of the PARENTS.
In relation to STUDENT’s placement for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year, the District contends that it needs to perform additional assessments of STUDENT pursuant to its November 4, 2003 assessment plan, and a December 11, 2003 amendment to the November assessment plan. Specifically, the District seeks to conduct a social/emotional assessment, a functional analysis assessment (FAA), a reinforcement inventory, a speech/language assessment, an assessment by a medical doctor familiar with autism, and a reassessment by an autism specialist. In conjunction with the requested assessments, the District offered an interim placement until the assessments could be completed and an IEP meeting convened.
The PARENTS contend that, although an FAA and a reinforcement inventory need to be conducted, the FAA cannot be conducted in an interim placement. The PARENTS argue that the FAA must be conducted in STUDENT’s general education placement. The PARENTS also contend that the social/emotional assessment is not necessary. In relation to the assessment by a medical doctor familiar with autism, and a reassessment by an autism specialist proposed in the December 11 amended assessment plan, the PARENTS contend that the December 11 amendment did not satisfy the legal requirements for an assessment plan. In relation to the interim placement, the PARENTS contend that the placement offered by the District is not a FAPE because it is not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and it is not an offer of placement in the least restrictive environment. The PARENTS contend that STUDENT should continue in her general education placement while the FAA and reinforcement inventory are completed.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT (STUDENT) is an eight-year-old third-grader who had been attending Springer Elementary School in the Los Altos Elementary School District (District). Currently, STUDENT is not in any educational placement. She is currently eligible for special education and related services on the basis of a diagnosis of autism.
STUDENT was diagnosed with autism in 1998 and has been receiving special education and related services through the District since 1999. When STUDENT first came to the District, she was exhibiting autistic behaviors which included self-stimulation, tantrums, repetitive activity, resistance to change, and withdrawal. STUDENT was receiving twenty-four hours a week of home discrete trial therapy (DTT) and speech/language therapy. In February 2000, oversight of the DTT program was transferred to the Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE), who began providing monthly consultation services.
STUDENT made significant progress in all areas, and in August 2000, she began attending kindergarten in the morning accompanied by a shadow aide along with four hours a day of DTT at home in the afternoon. Speech/language therapy continued as well.
In June 2001, the IEP team met to develop STUDENT’s program for the first grade. Because of STUDENT’s continued progress the team placed STUDENT in a general education first grade class with a shadow aide and reduced the home program to one and one-half hours per day. Speech therapy continued and a behavior plan was developed. LIFE continued to provide monthly consultation services. During the first grade, occupational therapy and resource specialist (RSP) support in math were added to STUDENT’s program. By the end of the first grade, STUDENT’s primary deficits were in the areas of social skills and behavior.
In March 2002, STUDENT was referred for her triennial assessment. On May 7, 2002, the IEP team met to develop STUDENT’s program for the second grade. Using the results of the triennial assessment and the information shared at the IEP meeting, District members of the IEP team recommended that the home program be discontinued but that STUDENT should continue to have the shadow aide at school. The team also recommended that STUDENT’s program should include speech/language therapy, a behavior plan, and RSP support on an as-needed basis. Supervision and oversight of the program was to be done by the school psychologist, rather than through LIFE. The PARENTS disagreed with the team’s recommendation, believing that the home program should continue and be supervised by a LIFE consultant.
As a result of the dispute over STUDENT’s program for the second grade, on August 28, 2002 the District filed a request for a due process hearing (case number SN02-01950). A hearing was held and a decision in SN02-01950 was issued on November 5, 2002. (Footnote 3) That decision found that STUDENT had the following unique needs: 1) a structured and consistent program that utilizes a system of rewards and consequences for improving behavior; 2) visual and verbal prompts for maintaining attention and self-monitoring behavior; 3) monitoring and facilitation of peer play and peer socialization; 4) repetition and re-teaching of academic skills and concepts as needed; 5) speech/language therapy in the areas of articulation, receptive and expressive language, pragmatic language, social rules, and non-verbal communication; 6) a shadow aide with appropriate education and experience, preferably at least a BA in a related field and one year of practical experience, who has been trained in the provision and monitoring of STUDENT’s program; and 7) a case manager to oversee STUDENT’s program. To meet those needs, the District offered full inclusion in a second grade class at Loyola Elementary School, a shadow aide for the entire school day, pull-out speech/language therapy three times a week for 30 minutes each session, extended day services three days a week, a behavior support plan, and staff training and supervision of the program by Michelle Garcia Winner, a specialist in social cognitive learning and theory of mind strategies. The decision in case number SN02-01950 found that the District’s offer met the requirements of the IDEA for a free and appropriate public education.
After the hearing decision the District retained the Bay Area Child Development Agency (BACDA) to provide the aide and case manager/consultant for STUDENT’s program. In addition, the District continued to contract with Lisa Wiedenfeld (Lisa), an aide who had worked with STUDENT for several years, to provide additional training to STUDENT’s new aide and to continue as STUDENT’s aide at school for two and a half days a week. (Footnote 4) The District also began attempting to arrange an IEP meeting to formally implement the hearing decision.
An IEP team meeting was held on December 5, 2002. The IEP drafted essentially memorialized the services the District had previously offered which had been the subject of the prior due process hearing. The only significant change was that, instead of an after-school program, STUDENT was to receive additional RSP support. The IEP called for thirty minutes of RSP services five days a week. As previously offered by the District, STUDENT would continue in a general education second grade class with pull-out speech therapy three days a week for thirty minutes each session. STUDENT would also have a full-time one-on-one aide during the school day and BACDA would provide three hours a month of consultation and case management services. Additional goals and objectives were drafted in the areas of math and reading comprehension. The IEP also incorporated the behavior plan that had been drafted in October 2002. The PARENTS agreed to the December 5th IEP on December 19, 2002.
On December 11, 2002, Mr. PARENT emailed Ms. Luks, the District director of pupil services, and informed her that STUDENT had run away from class, girl scouts, and home on several occasions and that STUDENT had started to bit and kick other students. Mr. PARENT was concerned that STUDENT’s behavior was regressing. The PARENTS and District staff began efforts to schedule another IEP meeting to address the PARENTS’ concerns. The IEP was eventually scheduled for February 12, 2003. While the parties were trying to find a mutually agreeable date for an IEP meeting, there were several events of significance. BACDA notified the District that it would no longer be able to provide an aide or consultation services for STUDENT. In response, the District proposed hiring Shelley Davis, a behavioral consultant, as STUDENT’s new consultant. However, Ms. Davis’s services would not include the provision of an aide, so the District also had to begin the search for a new aide. (Footnote 5) Mrs. PARENT met with Ms. Davis and agreed to the District hiring her as STUDENT’s new consultant. Another significant event involved STUDENT’s home situation. Mrs. PARENT, STUDENT, and STUDENT’s sister moved to a new home as the result of Mr. and Mrs. PARENTS’ separation. (Footnote 6) There was also a serious behavior incident at school. On January 25, 2003, STUDENT became very upset with Lisa during a class activity and began to have a tantrum. In the course of this incident STUDENT was screaming and crying and ran away from Lisa several times. Eventually, Lisa took STUDENT to the principal’s office and Mrs. PARENT was called to pick up STUDENT.
On February 5, 2003, Ms. Davis completed her initial report and recommendations. Ms. Davis identified three types of behavior that she believed needed to be addressed. The first was off task behavior, described as behaviors that interrupt learning such as talking out of turn, blurting out answers, getting out of her seat when other students are seated, walking around the room without permission, and fidgeting at her desk. The second was negative attitude, described as speaking to others in an inappropriate tone, verbally refusing to comply with instructions, grabbing others’ items, and pushing items off her desk. The last was leaving the classroom or other designated building without permission. Ms. Davis noted that the last behavior usually occurred in conjunction with a behavioral outburst. Ms. Davis recommended that STUDENT have an occupational therapy (OT) consultation and a behavior support plan that included a token economy system with response costs for inappropriate behavior.
At the February 12, 2003 IEP meeting, the team reviewed Ms. Davis’ report, agreed to an OT consultation and developed a new behavior plan. The behavior plan targeted impulsive behavior, poor frustration tolerance, testing limits, verbal and physical aggression, difficulty attending to the teacher, running out of the classroom, and going to another area of the classroom or under the table. To address these behaviors the plan included a token economy system with rewards for appropriate behavior, and various strategies for dealing with inappropriate behaviors including “time away” in class, and leaving the class under supervision to allow STUDENT time to calm down. In the case of physical aggression STUDENT was to be removed to a quiet room.
Throughout February, March, and April, 2003 the District continued to have problems finding a new aide for STUDENT. The District used several temporary aides, including a substitute teacher and a District aide from a self-contained special education class. At one point, the District hired Betty Gist, but Ms. Gist resigned after only three to four weeks. The District went back to the use of substitute aides. In May, the District began using Abby Sandborn, an aide who had worked with STUDENT during the previous school year, as STUDENT’s one-on-one aide. Lisa continued to be STUDENT’s aide for two and one-half days a week for the remainder of the school year. STUDENT’s behavior during later half of the 2002-2003 school year was inconsistent. The daily behavior charts indicate that STUDENT had some very good days, but also had several incidents involving tantrums and running away.
An interim planning meeting was held on March 27, 2003. The notes from this meeting indicate that STUDENT was doing well in math and reading comprehension. It was also noted that STUDENT was playing with new peers during lunch, but tended to become upset when she did not get her way. The February behavior plan was modified to allow STUDENT to be kept for the first seven minutes of recess as a consequence for inappropriate behavior in class. (Footnote 7)
On April 13, 2003, Ms. Davis issued her second report. Ms. Davis described STUDENT as highly distractible, fidgety, and extremely impulsive with mild to moderate social cognition difficulties. Ms. Davis stated that STUDENT was exhibiting off task behaviors, noncompliance, tantrumming, elopement, and inappropriate verbalizations. It was also noted that STUDENT had experienced significant changes in her school staff during the year. (Footnote 8) Because of the staffing problems the District had not been able to implement the entire behavior plan; specifically, the token system with response costs had never been fully implemented. Ms. Davis also stated that STUDENT had a pattern of “playing the adults against each other” resulting in a lack of respect for authority on STUDENT’s part. Ms. Davis recommended that an appropriate aide be hired to finish the second grade and continue with STUDENT into the third grade. Ms. Davis stressed the need for consistency in STUDENT’s program, including the need for improved communication and consistency between the home and school environments. Ms. Davis expressed concern that STUDENT’s behavior problems would cause her to fall behind her peers and result in an escalation of her acting-out behaviors.
On April 26, 2003, the OT completed a progress report. The purpose of the OT consultation was to address STUDENT’s fidgeting, getting out of her desk, and moving around the classroom. The OT had recommended that STUDENT be supplied with a wedge cushion and therabands on her chair legs to provide extra sensory input. The OT stated that both items had been provided and that school staff reported that they were effective. The OT recommended continued monitoring and adjustments as needed.
An IEP team meeting was held on April 28, 2003. In preparation for this IEP meeting, STUDENT had been administered the Weschler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT), the Woodcock Johnson Test – Revised (WJ-R), the Test of Language Development – P:3 (TOLD, P:3), the Test of Problem Solving (TOPL), and the Comprehensive Assessment of Spoken Language (CASL). On the WIAT, a test of academic achievement, STUDENT scored above average in all areas. Her lowest score was in the 74th percentile in reading comprehension, which was above average. All other scores were in the 95th to 99th percentile. On the WJ-R, another test of academic achievement, STUDENT scored in the 91st percentile in dictation, the 88th percentile in writing samples, and the 95th percentile in broad written language. STUDENT demonstrated average to above average oral language skills, but the speech therapist noted that STUDENT needed more practice in using those skills in conversational speech. It was noted that difficulty with impulse control resulted in STUDENT’s sentence structure and grammar becoming more disorganized in less structured speaking situations. On the TOPS, a test of STUDENT’s critical thinking abilities, STUDENT scored in the below average range. STUDENT’s answers to why, what, and how questions were limited. STUDENT also had difficulty providing clear definitions of the words presented. STUDENT’s articulation skills had shown improvement. STUDENT had demonstrated the ability to produce the “r” sound in isolation, and was working on carrying that skill over into words, sentences and conversation. The speech therapist concluded that STUDENT had an ongoing need for speech therapy with a focus on social interactions, pragmatic language, expressive language, and articulation.
At the IEP meeting, the team reviewed the results of the testing and the proposed goals and objectives. The team agreed to goals in reading comprehension, math skills and concepts, expressive language, social skills/pragmatic language, classroom participation, articulation, and problems solving/expressive communication. It was also agreed that the behavior plan developed in February and modified in March would be continued. After Ms. Davis discussed her April report, Mr. PARENT objected to Ms. Davis’s continued involvement in STUDENT’s program. Mr. PARENT stated that Ms. Davis was an attorney and accused the District of dishonesty for hiring an attorney to be STUDENT’s behavior consultant. From that point on, the IEP meeting degenerated until Ms. Luks ended the meeting, stating that it would be reconvened after Ms. Davis’s status had been agreed upon by the parties.
Following the IEP meeting, a series of emails was sent between the PARENTS and the District. One subject of the emails was Ms. Davis’s status. The PARENTS accused the District of secretly hiring an attorney and violating the PARENTS’ right to have any attorney present at the IEP meeting. Ms. Luks attempted to reassure the PARENTS that the District had hired Ms. Davis solely as a behavior consultant, not as an attorney. Mr. PARENT was adamant that they would not attend any IEP meeting until Ms. Davis was removed from all involvement with STUDENT’s case. Initially, the District refused to dismiss Ms. Davis and insisted that she would attend the next IEP meeting. However, on May 20, Ms. Luks informed Mr. PARENT that Ms. Davis would not attend the IEP meeting scheduled for May 22. Mr. PARENT continued his refusal to attend any IEP until Ms. Davis was removed. Because of the PARENTS’ continued refusal to attend an IEP, the May 22 meeting was postponed to June 4. On May 28, Ms. Luks informed the PARENTS that the June 4 IEP meeting would go forward whether the parents chose to attend or not. Ms. Luks also stated that the District was willing to discuss, at the IEP meeting, finding a replacement for Ms. Davis. The PARENTS continued to refuse to attend any IEP.
The other subject of emails following the April 28 IEP meeting was extended school year (ESY) services for summer 2003. Mr. PARENT requested that the District provide a one-on-one aide for STUDENT’s summer camp plus one session each week of RSP services to address problem solving. Ms. Luks responded with a written offer of placement in a summer enrichment program with a one-on-one aide for four hours each day. However, Ms. Luks also stated that the District was willing to discuss providing an aide for summer camp for an equivalent number of hours. Mr. PARENT did not respond directly to this offer. On May 22, Ms. Luks emailed Mr. PARENT, expressing the need to make a decision about the ESY services. Ms. Luks stated that the District’s formal offer was the enrichment summer school for four hours a day, five days a week, a one-on-one aide, and two sessions a week of speech therapy. Ms. Luks asked for a response by June 2nd. The PARENTS did not respond to this offer except to continue to object to Ms. Davis’s involvement in STUDENT’s case.
On May 14, 2003, at the District’s request, Ms. Davis drafted a new behavior support plan. The plan targeted STUDENT’s inappropriate responses to instruction and/or feedback. In her report, Ms. Davis stated that STUDENT’s noncompliance was the result of STUDENT’s strong desire to control situations. Ms. Davis stated that STUDENT had the belief that if her behavior was sufficiently challenging, undesired demands would be changed or removed in favor of STUDENT’s own desires. Ms. Davis recommended visual reinforcements, frequent verbal praise for appropriate behaviors, and the use of a token system with response costs. Specifically, Ms. Davis suggested presenting STUDENT with tokens for appropriate behavior, which could be redeemed for prizes of favored activities. If STUDENT exhibited inappropriate behaviors, tokens would be taken away, with reminders to STUDENT that she could earn the tokens back with appropriate behavior.
On June 4, 2003, the District held an IEP meeting without the PARENTS present. At the meeting the team agreed to the ESY services that Ms. Luks had offered the PARENTS on May 22. The team also agreed to goals and objectives and the continued implementation of the behavior plan developed in February 2003 and revised in March. STUDENT’s placement was to be in a general education third grade class at Covington Elementary School with a full time shadow aide. (Footnote 9) The District also offered RSP, speech therapy, continued consultation from an OT, and behavior consultation by an autism specialist. The IEP team agreed to the continued use of Ms. Davis as the behavior consultant. (Footnote 10) The District added consultation services by a District program specialist for additional monitoring and staff training in relation to the behavior plan. On June 9, the completed IEP was forwarded to the PARENTS. In the cover letter, Ms. Luks summarized the offer, and stated that she took the PARENTS’ lack of response to the ESY offer as refusal of those services.
On July 21, 2003, Ms. Luks emailed Mrs. PARENT to remind her to enroll STUDENT at the Springer School as soon as possible. (Footnote 11) On July 25th, Ms. Luks followed up with an email informing Mrs. PARENT that the District was considering replacing Ms. Davis with an agency to provide a consultant and aide for STUDENT’s program. (Footnote 12) Ms. Luks also stated that the District could not hire a new consultant without a signed IEP, and offered to meet with Mrs. PARENT to review the District’s offer from the June 4 IEP meeting. On July 28th, Mr. PARENT responded to Ms. Luks, stating that he and Mrs. PARENT believed that the District’s inappropriate program had caused STUDENT’s behaviors to regress. Mr. PARENT stated that he wished the District to provide STUDENT with a home program, supervised by LIFE, similar to what had been provided prior to the previous due process decision. Mr. PARENT also requested that the PARENTS be involved in the choice of aides to work with STUDENT. (Footnote 13) However, on August 8, Mr. PARENT informed Ms. Luks that Mrs. PARENT would meet with the District’s proposed consultant. Mr. PARENT’s email included a request for ten references and contained a list of questions that Mrs. PARENT would want answered. On August 12th, Mr. PARENT informed Ms. Luks that Sinead McDonnell, the proposed consultant from BACDA, did not have sufficient experience. Mr. PARENT stated that Ms. McDonnell appeared to have only worked with one child in the past. Mr. PARENT renewed his request that the District rehire LIFE as consultant for STUDENT’s program. On August 20th, Mr. PARENT relented and agreed to the District retaining BACDA to provide a consultant and aide for STUDENT so that these services would be in place for the start of school. However, Mr. PARENT stated that this agreement was only for thirty days to allow the District time to rehire LIFE. As a result, Ms. McDonnell was retained as STUDENT’s behavior consultant and Stacie Solt (Stacie), also from BACDA, as STUDENT’s aide. School began on August 25, 2003. Kathy Panec was STUDENT’s primary teacher; Laura McErlane was STUDENT’s RSP teacher; Eleanor Martindale was STUDENT’s speech therapist; and Bob Celeste was the principal.
During the first week and a half of school, Ms. McDonnell worked with STUDENT and Stacie in class and took data on STUDENT’s behavior. After this initial observation period, Ms. McDonnell drafted a new behavior support plan that was titled “Shooting for the Stars” (Stars).
The Stars program awarded points for appropriate behavior. On the basis of the number of points awarded, a level was determined, with each higher level giving STUDENT greater independence. The Stars program had two targeted behaviors: 1) following directions the first time and 2) using a quiet hand (raising her hand in class and waiting to be called on by the teacher). The program called for charting STUDENT’s behavior in ten-minute intervals. For each interval STUDENT was allowed one reminder for each targeted behavior. If she needed two reminders in a time interval she did not get a star for that behavior in the period and she lost one minute of free reading time. At the end of each week, points would be totaled based upon the number of stars STUDENT received. On the basis of her total points, STUDENT’s level for the next week would be determined. As STUDENT moved up levels (one, two, three, and world champ) she would obtain more privileges and greater freedom from supervision. However, to move up to level three, STUDENT needed to maintain at least level two points for two weeks. Attaining world champ required STUDENT to maintain level three points for two weeks. If STUDENT wanted to move up a level at the end of the week, she would write up a “petition” which set out why she believed she should move up a level. STUDENT’s petition was then circulated among STUDENT’s school staff, who voted on the petition. If the majority of the staff agreed that STUDENT should advance to the next level, then STUDENT would start the next week at the higher level. STUDENT would also earn an allowance based upon her points each week and could use that allowance to buy prizes at her student store. In addition, if STUDENT received a certain number of stars in a row (10, 20, 30, or 34) she was rewarded with a choice activity. The plan also allowed STUDENT three bathroom passes each day that STUDENT could use for “cooling off” time when she was feeling frustrated or upset. Finally, the plan had what was referred to as the “minor leagues.” The minors called for STUDENT to be removed from class and from the level system for a twenty-four hour period as a consequence for unsafe behavior (hitting, hiding, biting, or waving sharp objects). While in the minors, STUDENT was isolated in a “quiet room” under the supervision of a teacher and her aide. During the isolation STUDENT was to be treated respectfully but neutrally (a “cold shoulder”). STUDENT was to work on academics and complete apology letters to the students and adults directly involved in the incident. After the twenty-four hour period STUDENT would return to class but drop one level. Every day, Stacie was to email reports on STUDENT’s day to Mrs. PARENT. The staff began implementing the Stars system on September 8, 2003.
In addition to the Stars system, Ms. Panec had a class token system that STUDENT participated in. In this system, students earned or lost “Chips” based upon behavior. At the end of each month, the students could cash in their chips for prizes at the class store. However, a student had to always have at least ten chips, and the least expensive item at the store cost twenty chips. Therefore, a student needed at least thirty chips to buy anything at the end of the month.
On September 17, 2003, STUDENT had an incident that resulted in her being sent to the minors. According to Stacie’s daily school log, STUDENT became upset during PE and kicked another student. STUDENT then ran away from Stacie and eventually had to be physically restrained. STUDENT was then taken to the “quiet room” for the remainder of the day. School staff testified that the Stars program had been fully explained to STUDENT, including the use of the “quiet room” for unsafe behaviors. However, the Stars program had not been explained in detail to the PARENTS. When Mrs. PARENT arrived at school on the 18th, she was told that STUDENT would be spending the majority of the day in the “quiet room.” Mrs. PARENT became very upset, and STUDENT became increasingly upset as well. Eventually, Mr. Celeste was called. Mr. Celeste was able to convince Mrs. PARENT that STUDENT should remain in the “quiet room,” and Mr. Celeste and Stacie worked with STUDENT for the remainder of the day. After this incident, the PARENT’s instructed the District that it could no longer use the “quiet room” as a consequence for STUDENT’s behavior.
The next IEP team meeting was held on September 24, 2003. At that IEP the goals and objectives from the June 4 IEP were reviewed and agreed to. In addition, the Stars program was reviewed and incorporated into STUDENT’s program. (Footnote 14) The team also agreed that LIFE would be called in to review the District’s program, including the Stars program and make recommendations. The District offered additional services, including thirty minutes a day of extended school day services for pre-teaching, and twenty hours of in home consultation/direct services to promote coordination and generalization of STUDENT’s skills into other environments. The PARENTS declined both of these offers.
For the remainder of September and into October the daily logs indicate that STUDENT had some very good days, and some problem days. STUDENT had recurring problems with winning and losing games, tending to lash out verbally when she lost. STUDENT also had difficulty being unable to maintain focus, talking out of turn, wandering in class, touching others’ belongings, and being defiant. There were several incidents involving physically aggressive actions: throwing things, throwing chairs, hitting and kicking Stacie, and yelling at adults and peers. This pattern continued until October 8th, when there was more severe incident. On the 8th, STUDENT had become upset in the morning because she had not had her backpack with her. She appeared to calm down after her backpack arrived, but she later became very upset in class and started yelling, tantrumming, and kicking. She then ran out of class and was running around the school, climbing a fence and pulling on pipes. Mrs. PARENT was called and eventually STUDENT was able to calm down. After lunch, STUDENT was able to go through the rest of the day without incident. The next day, there was another incident in PE involving yelling, screaming and kicking. On the 10th STUDENT again had problems, yelling and hitting Stacie and hitting another student. STUDENT’s behavior problems continued into the next week with reports of yelling, arguing, hitting, throwing things, and running away. On the 16th there was another major incident. This incident involved screaming, hitting, running away, and running into and across the street. At one point, Stacie picked STUDENT up after she had run into the street and carried her back to school grounds. STUDENT spent the remainder of the day in Mr. Celeste’s office.
As a result of the incident on the 16th, Mr. Celeste held a meeting with Ms. McDonnell, and Mr. and Mrs. PARENT. Mrs. PARENT was very angry and upset and was asking that Stacie be removed at STUDENT’s aide. The PARENTS also requested that the Stars plan be discontinued, but agreed that STUDENT would be sent to the Abracadabra day care in the event of future unsafe behaviors. From the 17th on the District continued to fill out STUDENT’s star chart and to send daily reports to Mrs. PARENT; however, the level system was discontinued and STUDENT no longer received rewards or was allowed to petition to change levels. During the following week, Mr. Celeste tried to convince the PARENTS to allow the District to reinstitute the Stars program. The PARENTS insisted that they would not give permission for any behavior program until the LIFE consultant completed her report. STUDENT’s behavior continued to be problematic. The daily reports contain descriptions of arguing, hitting, throwing a chair, and running around the classroom.
On October 24, 2003, a group calling themselves the “Concerned Parents of Springer’s Room 11” sent a letter to the District expressing concern over STUDENT’s behavior. The letter alleged incidents of kicking, slapping, biting, screaming, and banging on the classroom door. The letter stated that this behavior had created an atmosphere of intimidation and hostility in the class. The letter also alleged that the high levels of stress were driving the teacher out of the classroom. (Footnote 15)
On October 27th the PARENTS informed the District that they were also withdrawing consent for RSP services. The PARENTS alleged that STUDENT would come home frustrated and upset every time she had an RSP session with Ms. McErlane. STUDENT’s behavior on the 27th was very good, but deteriorated as the week progressed. On the 28th there were reports of difficulty following directions and running away. The 29th contains an account of STUDENT arguing and becoming threatening with a pair of scissors. Another major incident occurred on October 30th. Early in the day, STUDENT had had problems following directions and was pushing people and throwing things during PE. STUDENT’s behavior escalated during a series of timed math tests. STUDENT became very upset when she was told to stop at the end of one of the timed tests. She began yelling, screaming, and would not leave the class. After STUDENT was finally convinced to leave the classroom, Ms. Panec locked the classroom door. STUDENT remained out of the class the remainder of the day. One parent wrote the District, alleging that her child had witnessed STUDENT being dragged, screaming, along the floor. STUDENT worked one-on-one with Mr. Celeste in the library for part of the following day. On November 3rd there were more reports of arguing, not following directions, and throwing a chair.
On November 4, 2003, an IEP meeting was held to discuss the LIFE report, which had been completed on October 31st. Shawn Regnier, the LIFE consultant, presented her report. Ms. Regnier had reviewed records, interviewed Mrs. PARENT and school staff, and observed STUDENT on October 16th and 23rd. Ms. Regnier noted that the Stars behavior plan had not been consistently implemented due to disagreements between the District and the PARENTS over the appropriateness of the plan. Ms. Regnier made the following recommendations:
1) A reinforcement survey be conducted by Mrs. PARENT and school staff to determine what items/activities are reinforcing for STUDENT. All reinforcements should then be restricted in all environments. The reinforcements should only be delivered to STUDENT based upon appropriate behaviors as determined by a behavior plan. 2) A new behavior plan should be developed based upon frequency data collected over a one to two week period, and ABC (antecedent-behavior-consequence) data should be taken on all unsafe behaviors. Reinforcement should be delivered based upon the frequency of appropriate behaviors rather than a fixed interval system. 3) The new behavior plan should incorporate a token system, with tokens delivered shortly after a desired behavior is exhibited, rather than an absence of inappropriate behaviors, and exchanged later for identified reinforcements. 4) All demands on STUDENT must be consistently followed through with in all environments. 5) If STUDENT continues to exhibit behaviors that threaten the safety of her peers, a more restrictive placement should be used for a period of two to three weeks to allow STUDENT time to regain control of her behaviors. 6) STUDENT should continue to have a one-on-one aide in the school environment. 7) The PARENTS should receive additional training and support in the home environment. 8) Parents and staff should participate in weekly meetings 9) All decisions regarding STUDENT’s behavior plan should be based on frequency and ABC data.
At the IEP meeting, Ms. Regnier stated that she did not believe a home program was necessary. She also stated that she did not have enough information to determine whether a change to a more restrictive environment was necessary at that time. Following Ms. Regnier’s presentation, members of the District team expressed their concern that, in addition to autism, STUDENT’s unpredictable and unsafe behaviors may have been evidence of a coexisting medical or mental impairment. The District proposed temporarily changing STUDENT’s placement pending further assessments. (Footnote 16) STUDENT’s new placement would be in a tutorial room on the Springer school campus with a teacher and a one-on-one aide. STUDENT would continue to receive speech therapy and RSP services. During the interim placement the District would perform a functional analysis assessment of STUDENT’s behavior, the reinforcement survey recommended by LIFE, an assessment of STUDENT’s social/emotional functioning, and a test of problem solving to be performed by the speech therapist. The PARENTS strongly objected to the District’s proposal. The PARENTS proposed instituting the LIFE recommendations in STUDENT’s current setting in Ms. Panec’s class. Mr. PARENT stated that STUDENT’s behaviors were not unsafe, and any problems were the result of the District’s failure to provide an appropriate program in the past. The meeting ended without agreement. The next day, the District filed for a temporary restraining order in Superior Court, seeking an order to remove STUDENT to the interim placement they had proposed at the IEP meeting.
On November 7, 2003, the Superior Court issued a temporary restraining order, removing STUDENT to the placement in the tutorial room with a teacher and one-on-one aide and services as proposed in the November IEP. The order also permitted the use of physical restraint if necessary. The PARENTS chose not to send STUDENT to this placement. As a result, STUDENT has not attended school since November 5th. On December 7th, the District offered to provide a one-on-one home teacher or, in the alternative, to place STUDENT on temporary independent study at home. In response, Mrs. PARENT stated that STUDENT would not attend school until all of the legal proceedings had been concluded.
On December 11, 2003, counsel for the District sent a letter to counsel for the PARENTS that stated that the District was amending the November 4 assessment plan. The letter amended the plan to include a medical assessment by a doctor knowledgeable in autism. The District also suggested adding a reevaluation by an autism specialist. The letter went on to state that the personnel the District had proposed using for the functional analysis were not available. The District proposed having that assessment done by a team, which would include BACDA, LIFE, and the school psychologist.
On December 15, 2003, the parties entered into a stipulation in Superior Court. The stipulation stated that STUDENT would not return to Springer school pending a due process decision or agreement of the parties. In exchange, the District would take no action against STUDENT. This stipulation has remained in effect throughout the due process hearing.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. Did the District offer and provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education during the 2002-2003 school year from November 5, 2002 through the end of the regular school year?
Under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a child at no charge to his or her parent or guardian, meet the standards of the State educational agency, include appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education, and are provided in conformity with an IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). Special education law also requires that a child with a disability be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court determined that a child’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the child with some educational benefit to satisfy the IDEA, but that the school district is not required to provide the child with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court held that a school district is required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child. Id. at 201. Consequently, an appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the child. Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S. (9th Cir. 1996) 82 F.3d 1493, 1500. De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist. (2nd Cir. 1997) 142 F.3d 119, 130.
The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. 458 U.S. at 205. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he or she is entitled, and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1483. Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range, 960 F.2d at 1483; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm. (1st Cir. 1990) 910 F.2d 983, 994.
In summary, under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley the proposed educational program must: 1) be designed to meet the student’s unique needs; 2) provide for the student to be involved and progress in the general curriculum and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities; 3) be calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit; 4) the program must conform with the student’s IEP; and 5) the placement must be in the least restrictive environment. IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer must consider whether the necessary procedural requirements were adhered to. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-207.
As stated earlier in this Decision, the decision in the prior case (SN02-01950) found that the District had offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year. For the portion of the 2002-2003 school year following the decision in SN02-01950 (November 5, 2003 through the end of the regular school year), the PARENTS are contending that STUDENT developed new unique needs that were unmet and that the program the District offered and implemented did not meet the requirements set forth by the hearing officer in SN02-01950. Therefore, this Decision will consider only those contentions for this period of time.
Did STUDENT’s unique needs change during the 2002-2003 school year?
In the decision in the prior case, SN02-01950, it was found that STUDENT’s primary impairments resulting from her autism were in the areas of behavior and social skills. Her behavior problems were typified by impulsive behaviors, poor frustration tolerance, verbal and physical defiance, difficulty attending, occasional tantrums, and leaving the classroom without permission. (Footnote 17) Socially, STUDENT had difficulty with expressive, receptive and pragmatic language, non-verbal communication, and social rules. STUDENT also had a great deal of difficulty in appropriately dealing with any competitive situation. (Footnote 18) In addition to these deficits, STUDENT had deficits in articulation, math skills and reading comprehension. To appropriately address these deficits, the decision in case number SN02-01950 found that STUDENT needed a program that contained the following elements: 1) a structured and consistent program that utilizes a system of rewards and consequences for improving behavior; 2) visual and verbal prompts for maintaining attention and self-monitoring behavior; 3) monitoring and facilitation of peer play and peer socialization; 4) repetition and re-teaching of academic skills and concepts as needed; 5) speech/language therapy in the areas of articulation, receptive and expressive language, pragmatic language, social rules, and non-verbal communication; 6) a shadow aide with appropriate education and experience, preferably at least a BA in a related field and one year of practical experience, who has been trained in the provision and monitoring of STUDENT’s program; and 7) a case manager to oversee STUDENT’s program. It is undisputed that STUDENT continued to have these needs throughout the 2002-2003 school year. However, the PARENTS contend that, by February 2003, STUDENT had developed the additional need for a “behavior intervention plan” (BIP) developed and implemented pursuant to the strict requirements of California Education Code section 56520 et seq., which is commonly known as the Hughes Bill.
California law generally requires that every pupil whose behavior impedes his or her learning must have an IEP that includes appropriate positive behavioral interventions, strategies, and supports to address those behaviors. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.1. The Hughes Bill and its stringent requirements only applies when a student exhibits a serious behavior problem that significantly interferes with the implementation of the goals and objectives of the individual’s IEP. 5 C.C.R. § 3001 (f). The regulations define a “serious behavior problem” as “behaviors which are self-injurious, assaultive, or cause serious property damage and other severe behavior problems that are pervasive and maladaptive for which instruction/behavioral approaches specified in the student’s IEP are found to be ineffective.” 5 C.C.R. § 3001 (aa). Under the Hughes Bill, a “behavior intervention plan” (BIP) must meet the detailed requirements set forth in tile 5, California Code of Regulations, section 3001(d), (e), (f), and (aa). A BIP can only be formulated on the basis of a particular type of assessment known as a “functional analysis assessment” (FAA). The elements and application of FAA’s are described in title 5, California Code of Regulations, section 3052.
Based upon the testimony and documentary evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not have a “serious behavior problem” during the 2002-2003 school year. The only potentially dangerous behavior that STUDENT exhibited at that time was her tendency to run away. However, none of the documentary evidence described STUDENT’s behavior as either dangerous or pervasive. In fact, Mrs. Luks, Ms. Davis, Mr. PARENT, and Mrs. PARENT all testified that STUDENT was not exhibiting any dangerous behaviors during the 2002-2003. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that, during the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT did not have the need for a BIP as described in title 5, California Code of Regulations, section 3001.
On the basis of the foregoing analysis and the evidence as a whole, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT continued to have those needs identified in the decision in SN02-01950 during the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year.
Did the District’s program meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
To create a program to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, two IEPs were developed and agreed to by the parties. The first, developed on December 5, 2002, and agreed to by the parents on December 19, 2002, was, with a few exceptions, the program the District had previously offered which had been found to be appropriate by the decision in SN02-01950. The primary difference was that, instead of the after-school program previously offered, the December IEP called for pull-out RSP services five days a week for thirty minutes each session. The IEP also contained additional goals in math skills and reading comprehension. The only other variation was that, instead of utilizing Michelle Garcia Winner as the consultant, the District proposed using a behavior consultant provided by BACDA. (Footnote 19) On February 12, 2003, the parties met at an IEP meeting and agreed to two modifications to STUDENT’s program. A new behavior plan was developed, and OT consultative services were added.
The PARENTS made numerous arguments in relation to how the program the District provided during the later portion of the 2002-2003 school year did not meet STUDENT’s unique needs. These included: a lack of facilitation of peer play and peer socialization, a failure to provide an appropriately trained and qualified shadow aide, a failure to provide an appropriate case manager, and a lack of data collection. However, the PARENTS’ central contention is that the program, as provided, lacked consistency. As this is the PARENTS’ primary complaint regarding this time period, this need will be addressed first.
In the previous decision, it was found that STUDENT needed to have behavioral expectations clearly set out, with limits on her behavior firmly enforced, and that her program needed to be consistent throughout all environments: in class, at recess, during speech/language therapy, and at home. The various behavior consultants who testified in this case, Ms. Davis, Ms. Regnier, Ms. McDonnell, and Ms. Wells, all agreed that the need for consistency was a central requirement for STUDENT’s program. Unfortunately, STUDENT’s program during the 2002-2003 school year, was almost entirely lacking in consistency. Between November 5, 2002 and the end of the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT had two teachers, two behavior consultants, and at least six aides. Many of the aides had little or no training. In her April 13, 2003 report, Ms. Davis noted that the staffing difficulties had resulted in STUDENT developing an entrenched pattern of “playing the adults against each other.” STUDENT would oppose the directions of one adult, while playing up to another adult in an effort to avoid an undesired task or consequence. Furthermore, the frequent staff changes prevented the District from implementing the token system and response cost portion of STUDENT’s behavior plan. Although many of these staffing changes were the result of District staff quitting abruptly, the result for STUDENT was a veritable revolving door of staff. Not only were these staff changes damaging to STUDENT’s program, but they were very frustrating for STUDENT as well. Mrs. PARENT testified that STUDENT would come home crying because she didn’t know whom she would be working with the next day. In addition to the frequent staff changes, there was constant disagreement between the PARENTS and District staff as to the proper design and implementation of STUDENT’s program. (Footnote 20) This disagreement often played out in STUDENT’s presence in the form of verbal altercations between Mrs. PARENT and District staff, and at least one note from Mrs. PARENT to District staff countermanding behavioral rules the staff had been attempting to enforce. (Footnote 21) In addition, Mrs. PARENT testified that she did not believe she needed to be as strict regarding STUDENT’s behavior at home as the staff needed to be at school. (Footnote 22) The end result was that STUDENT had no respect for authority.
On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s program during the 2002-2003 school year lacked any meaningful consistency. However, it must be noted that responsibility for the lack of consistency cannot be entirely attributed to the District. STUDENT’s need was for a consistent program across all environments. It was incumbent upon both the District and the PARENTS to provide that consistency. The Hearing Officer is not implying that school districts and parents must always agree; however, once a program is decided upon, either through the IEP process or as the result of due process decision, both the school district and the parents must work together to ensure proper implementation of that program. In this case, the constant and open conflict between the parties, combined with the frequent staff changes, led to the lack of consistency in STUDENT’s behavior program.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s program failed to meet STUDENT’s need for a consistent behavior program. Due to the nature and extent of the parties’ joint failure to meet STUDENT’s need for consistency, the Hearing Officer finds that it is unnecessary to address the PARENTS’ contentions regarding the District’s other alleged failures to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
Did the District’s program provide for STUDENT to be involved and progress in the general curriculum and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities?
There is no dispute regarding this requirement.
Did the District’s program provide STUDENT with some educational benefit?
The PARENTS contend that STUDENT did not receive benefit in the areas of social skills, behavior, and reading comprehension. In fact, the PARENTS argue that STUDENT regressed in these areas.
The April 28, 2003 IEP indicated that, although STUDENT was seeking friends on the playground, many peers had lost interest in playing with her because she got upset if things did not go her way. In addition, STUDENT tended to cheat at games, which resulted in peers not wanting to play with her. In her April 13, 2003 report, Ms. Davis stated that many of STUDENT’s behaviors were “learned behaviors” (i.e.: playing adults against each other, using outrageous behavior to intimidate others) and that these behaviors had not improved. On the basis of this evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s acting-out behaviors and social skills did not improve during the 2002-2003 school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s program did not provide her with benefit in these areas.
There is no evidence that STUDENT’s reading comprehension regressed. Testing done in April 2003 indicated that STUDENT’s reading comprehension was in the 74th percentile. Testing done in April 2002 indicated STUDENT was in the 98th percentile in reading comprehension, which the PARENT’s point to as proof of regression. However, Mary Allen, District program specialist and school psychologist, explained that STUDENT’s raw score in 2003 was higher than the raw score in 2002, indicating that STUDENT was able to answer more questions correctly, and was an indication that STUDENT had made progress in the area of reading comprehension. Furthermore, Ms. Allen stated that the drop in STUDENT’s standard score, 117 points from 131 points, was not a full standard deviation and therefore not statistically significant. On the basis of Ms. Allen’s testimony, and the fact that STUDENT’s raw score increased, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did receive educational benefit in the area of reading comprehension.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not receive educational benefit in relation to reducing her acting-out behaviors or improving her social skills. STUDENT did receive educational benefit in the area of reading comprehension.
Did the District’s program conform to STUDENT’s IEP?
There is no dispute regarding this requirement.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not receive a FAPE during the portion of the 2002-2003 school year at issue in this hearing. STUDENT’s program did not meet her need for a structured and consistent behavior program because her behavior program lacked any meaningful consistency. As a result, STUDENT did not receive educational benefit in relation to reducing her acting-out behaviors or improving her social skills and peer interactions.
2. Did the District offer and provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education during the 2003 extended school year?
Extended school year (ESY) programming is educational programming that extends instruction beyond the normal school year to prevent serious regression over the summer months. (Hoeft v. Tucson Unified Sch. Dist., 967 F.3d 1298, 1301 (9th Cir. 1992); 5 CCR § 3043; see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(b).) It is undisputed that STUDENT requires ESY services.
The District made its first offer for the 2003 ESY via email on May 2, 2003. The District offered placement in the summer enrichment program for four hours each day with the support of a one-on-one aide for the school day. The PARENTS never directly responded to this offer. (Footnote 23) On May 22, via email, the District expanded its offer of ESY services to included two sessions each week of speech/language therapy. This offer was repeated at the June 4, 2003 IEP meeting. The PARENTS, because of their continued objections to Ms. Davis, did not attend that IEP meeting. On June 9, 2003, Ms. Luks emailed Mr. PARENT that she was taking his silence on the offer of ESY services as refusal of that offer. As a result, the District did not provide STUDENT with any ESY services during the 2003 summer.
The PARENTS contend that the June 4, 2003 IEP meeting constituted a violation of their procedural rights because it was held without the PARENTS in attendance. A school district is required to take steps to ensure that one or both of the parents of the individual with exceptional needs are present at each IEP meeting or are afforded the opportunity to participate in the IEP process. 34 C.F.R. § 300.345(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(a). However, if the district is unable to convince the parent that he or she should attend the IEP meeting, the meeting may be conducted without a parent in attendance. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(g).
In this case, the record contains numerous emails sent by the District to the PARENTS attempting to persuade the PARENTS to attend an IEP meeting in order to develop a program for the 2003 ESY and for the 2003-2004 school years. Mr. PARENT continually insisted that neither he nor Mrs. PARENT would attend an IEP unless Ms. Davis was removed from STUDENT’s program. In its efforts to secure the PARENTS’ attendance, the District offered to not have Ms. Davis attend the IEP meeting. Mr. PARENT continued in his refusal to attend any IEP meeting. The Hearing Officer finds that the District had made extensive efforts to convince the PARENTS to attend the June 4 IEP meeting. Therefore, the District was entitled to hold the June 4 IEP meeting without the parents in attendance.
The PARENTS also argue that the fact that Ms. Davis was a lawyer constituted a conflict of interest. The evidence established that Ms. Davis was hired by the District only in her capacity as a behavior consultant, was not engaged in the practice of law, was never consulted by the District as an attorney or representative, and never acted as the District’s attorney or representative. The PARENTS were repeatedly informed of these facts prior to the June 4 IEP meeting. The mere fact that Ms. Davis graduated from law school and was a member of the Bar Association did not create a conflict of interest. Furthermore, the evidence established that Ms. Davis was well qualified as a behavioral consultant. Ms. Davis had a bachelor’s and master’s degree in psychology. Ms. Davis had been working with autistic children for over twenty years and had attended over seventy-five workshops related to children with autism, having been a presenter at many such workshops. Ms. Davis had worked with approximately four hundred autistic children, one hundred and fifty to two hundred of whom were high functioning. On the basis of the foregoing analysis, the Hearing Officer finds that the PARENTS’ contention that they were justified in their refusal to attend the June 4 IEP meeting because the District would not dismiss Ms. Davis is without basis.
The PARENTS also argue that the ESY offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in two respects: it involved continued supervision by Ms. Davis, and it continued to utilize the February 2003 behavior plan.
It has already been determined that Ms. Davis was qualified to be STUDENT’s behavioral consultant, and that the fact that she was a lawyer did not create a conflict of interest. The only other objection raised by the PARENTS in relation to Ms. Davis is that she was not a certified non-public agency. California law states that a hearing officer may not render a decision that results in a service for an individual with exceptional needs being provided by a nonpublic, nonsectarian agency, if the agency has not been certified pursuant to Section 56366.1 (Cal. Educ. Code § 56505.2). However, nothing in the law prevents a school district from contracting with a non-certified non-public agency as long as that agency is otherwise qualified to provide the services. As stated earlier, Ms. Davis was qualified to serve as STUDENT’s behavioral consultant. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that her status as a non-certified non-public agency did not make it improper for the District to retain her as a behavioral consultant for STUDENT.
In relation to the February 2003 behavior plan, the PARENTS’ objections are based upon the contention that the plan did not meet the criteria required for a (BIP) set forth in Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001. The Hearing Officer has already determined that, during the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT’s behavior did not rise to a level that required the District to conduct an FAA and develop a BIP pursuant to the Hughes Bill. Therefore, the February 2003 behavior plan did not need to meet the requirements of Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001. Furthermore, the February 2003 behavior plan correctly identified STUDENT’s undesired behaviors: impulsive behavior, poor frustration tolerance, testing limits, verbal and physical defiance, difficulty attending, and running out of the classroom. The plan also identified appropriate replacement behaviors, teaching strategies, environmental and structure supports, and reinforcement procedures. The plan included a token system for rewarding appropriate behaviors and clear consequences for inappropriate behaviors. The Hearing Officer finds that the February 2003 behavior plan met STUDENT’s need for a structured behavior program that utilized a system of rewards and consequences.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was justified in holding the June 4, 2003 IEP meeting without the PARENTS present. The Hearing Officer also finds that Ms. Davis was qualified to serve as STUDENT’s behavioral consultant/case manager, and that the February 2003 behavior plan met STUDENT’s unique need for a structured behavior program that utilized a system of rewards and consequences. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of ESY services for the 2003 summer was an offer of FAPE.
3. Did the District offer and provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education during the 2003-2004 school year through November 4, 2003?
The District made two offers during the time period at issue. The first offer, completed at the June 4, 2003 IEP meeting, was never agreed to by the PARENTS and never implemented. (Footnote 24) The second offer, made at the September 24, 2003 IEP meeting, was agreed to in part, and the agreed upon portion was implemented by the District. Each offer will be examined separately.
The June 4, 2003 IEP
The PARENTS raise two contentions in relation to this offer: 1) that the June 2003 IEP meeting was held without the PARENTS present in violation of their procedural rights, and 2) that the offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
Procedural violations
It has already been found that the District was entitled to hold this IEP meeting without the PARENTS in attendance. No other procedural violations were raised in relation to this offer.
Was the District’s offer designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
It has already been found that STUDENT’s needs as of the June 4, 2003 IEP meeting were the same as those identified by the decision in SN02-01950. To meet those needs, the District had offered essentially the same program as it had been providing during the 2002-2003 school year. The offer contained goals and objectives in problem solving, expressive language, reading comprehension, social skills, pragmatic language, classroom participation, and articulation. The offer also called for the continued use of the February 2003 behavior plan. Offered services included a one-on-one aide, a behavioral consultant/case manager, OT consultation services, RSP services, and speech/language services. The IEP and behavior plan called for the use of visual and verbal prompts for maintaining STUDENT’s attention in class and helping her to self-monitor her behavior. One of the aide’s duties was to facilitate STUDENT’s peer play and peer socialization on a daily basis. The daily RSP sessions were to provide STUDENT with repetition and re-teaching of academic skills and concepts. The offered speech/language therapy was to address articulation, receptive and expressive language, pragmatic language, social rules, and non-verbal communication. The Hearing Officer finds that the offer completed at the June 4, 2003 IEP meeting was designed to meet all of STUDENT’s unique needs.
The PARENTS raised no other objections to the June 4 offer. Therefore, on the basis of the foregoing analysis, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer for the 2003-2004 school year, completed at the June 4, 2003 IEP meeting, was an offer of FAPE.
The September 24, 2003 IEP
In relation to this offer, the PARENTS contend that the District violated their procedural rights. The PARENTS also contend that the District’s offer did not meet STUDENT’s unique needs, was not calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit, and was not in the least restrictive environment.
Procedural violations
Procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process can result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range, 960 F.2d at 1483. The PARENTS contend that they were denied the right to meaningfully participate in the IEP process because they were not provided with accurate information regarding STUDENT’s behavior during the 2003-2004 school year. According to California Education Code Section 56345(a)(10), a student’s parents must be regularly informed of the pupil’s progress toward the annual goals and short-term objectives or benchmarks. In this case, the District was providing Mrs. PARENT with daily reports on STUDENT’s behavior. The PARENTS are not contesting the frequency, but the content of those reports. Specifically, the PARENTS argue that the reports misrepresented the serious nature of STUDENT’s acting-out behaviors. The PARENTS point to at least four instances when the school logs (documentation kept by Ms. McDonnell and Stacie at school, but not regularly provided to Mrs. PARENT) indicated that STUDENT had been physically restrained (September 17, October, 8, 9, and 16); however, the email reports to Mrs. PARENT for those same days failed to use the term “restrained” in their descriptions of the incidents. Although the email reports for these days do not contain the word “restrained,” they do contain descriptions of the behavior and the responses by District staff. In addition, there were numerous phone conversations and meetings between the PARENTS and Mr. Celeste and Ms. McDonnell at which STUDENT’s behavior during those incidents, as well as other incidents, were fully discussed. Overall, the daily reports present a detailed and accurate description of STUDENT’s behavior during the 2003-2004 school year, and were sufficient to inform the PARENTS of the serious nature of STUDENT’s acting-out behaviors. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds the District did provide the PARENTS with information about STUDENT’s behavior that allowed them to meaningfully participate in the IEP process.
Did the District’s program meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
Although STUDENT’s needs at the start of the 2003-2004 school year were the same as they had been during the prior school year, by September 24th it was evident that those needs had changed. It is undisputed that STUDENT continued to have the needs identified in the decision in SN02-01950. However, documentation taken during the first month of school showed that STUDENT had begun to demonstrate recurring aggressive behaviors. During the first two weeks of class, records show that STUDENT had at least five separate incidents that involved tantrums, hitting, kicking, screaming, or running away. (Footnote 25) On the basis of this data, the hearing officer finds that STUDENT had the additional need for a behavior plan designed to reduce her aggressive behaviors. (Footnote 26) The PARENTS contend that, not only did STUDENT need a behavior plan to address her aggressive behaviors, but that she required a BIP which met the criteria set forth in Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001. As stated earlier in this Decision, a BIP pursuant to section 3001 is only required when a student displays behaviors which are “self-injurious, assaultive, or cause serious property damage and other severe behavior problems that are pervasive and maladaptive for which instruction/behavioral approaches specified in the student’s IEP are found to be ineffective.” 5 C.C.R. § 3001 (aa). Although STUDENT’s aggressive behaviors were potentially assaultive, those behaviors had only recently emerged as a recurring problem. The IEP of September 24th was the District’s first attempt to control those behaviors through other instructional and behavioral approaches. Therefore, as of September 24th did not require a BIP pursuant to section 3001.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT had the following needs: 1) a structured and consistent program that utilized a system of rewards and consequences for improving behavior; 2) a behavior plan designed to reduce aggressive behaviors; 3) visual and verbal prompts for maintaining attention and self-monitoring behavior; 4) monitoring and facilitation of peer play and peer socialization; 5) repetition and re-teaching of academic skills and concepts as needed; 6) speech/language therapy in the areas of articulation, receptive and expressive language, pragmatic language, social rules, and non-verbal communication; 7) a shadow aide with appropriate education and experience; and 8) a case manager to oversee STUDENT’s program.
To meet STUDENT’s need for a structured and consistent program that utilized a system of rewards and consequences for improving behavior, the District had designed and implemented the “Shooting for the Stars” (Stars) program. (Footnote 27) The Stars program identified two specific replacement behaviors: 1) using a quiet hand, and 2) following directions the first time. To reinforce these behaviors, the Stars program used a complex system of points and levels. This system is described more fully in the Background Facts portion of this Decision. The Hearing Officer finds that the Stars program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs because the program was not understood by STUDENT and it lacked sufficient reinforcements for appropriate behavior. Ms. McDonnell, Ms. Regnier, the LIFE consultant, and Ms. Wells, a behavior consultant hired by the PARENTS, all agreed that an appropriate behavior plan for STUDENT would be one which provided STUDENT with clear behavioral expectations, and rewarded appropriate behavior with reinforcements that were sufficiently motivating for STUDENT. It was established that the most powerful reinforcement for STUDENT was the increased independence she could receive under the level system. Instead of providing clear behavior expectations, the Stars program was so complex that it was not clearly understood by District staff, much less by STUDENT. Every District witness who testified about the program had a different explanation for how it was supposed to work. (Footnote 28) Furthermore, the Stars program failed to offer STUDENT sufficient immediate reinforcement for appropriate behavior. In particular, the delivery of the most powerful reinforcement, greater independence, was so far delayed from STUDENT’s appropriate behavior that the program ended up frustrating STUDENT instead of motivating her. For example, after a particularly good week of behavior, STUDENT was not allowed to move up to the next level (as in the example described in footnote 28). Instead of any tangible reinforcement, STUDENT was simply encouraged to “keep up the good work.” The program did provide for STUDENT to receive an allowance that could be exchanged for certain prizes, but this only occurred at the end of the week. The only daily tangible reinforcement for appropriate behavior provided in the Stars program involved the award of free reading time for earning a certain number of stars in a row. Unfortunately, there was no evidence as to how or when this exchange actually took place. The end result was that the only reinforcement that STUDENT would receive for appropriate behavior during any given day was the awarding of the stars on her stars chart. On the basis of the foregoing analysis, the Hearing Officer finds that the Stars program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs because it did not provide STUDENT with clear behavioral expectations, and failed to provide tangible reinforcement for appropriate behavior.
To address STUDENT’s aggressive behaviors, the Stars program included a “minor leagues.” The minor leagues involved STUDENT’s removal to a “quiet room” under the supervision of a teacher and her aide for twenty-four hours as a consequence for any unsafe behaviors. Unsafe behaviors were defined as hitting, hiding, biting, or waving sharp objects. (Footnote 29) Ms. McDonnell, Ms. Luks, and Ms. Allen all testified that this level of consequence was necessary to impress upon STUDENT the seriousness of unsafe behavior. Ms. Regnier did not offer an opinion on this part of the Stars program because she had not been able to observe its use. Only Ms. Wells believed that the use of the minor leagues as a consequence for unsafe behavior was inappropriate. Although the District staff all agreed that the minor leagues was an appropriate methodology for addressing STUDENT’s aggressive behaviors, the plan was only implemented on one occasion, on September 18th. After this incident, the PARENTS prohibited the District from using the minor leagues or the quiet room. The compromise agreed to by the District and the PARENTS was that STUDENT would be removed to the Abracadabra day care in the event of unsafe behaviors. However, the Hearing Officer has no way of determining if this alternative was appropriate because the evidence established that the District failed to utilize it with any consistency. The school logs contain many instances of STUDENT exhibiting unsafe behavior without her being removed to Abracadabra. (Footnote 30) In fact, the only apparent consequence on most of these occasions was the loss of stars on her stars chart. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer, as implemented, was not appropriate to meet STUDENT’s need to reduce her aggressive behaviors. Although the PARENTS prevented the District from using its preferred methodology, the use of the minor leagues, the District failed to implement the agreed upon alternative.
STUDENT had a continuing need for consistency in her behavior program across all environments. To address the conflicts that had occurred between home and school during the prior year, the District offered twenty hours of in home consultation/direct services. The Hearing Officer finds that this offer was appropriate to improve communication between home and school, and help insure that STUDENT received consistent responses to her behavior in both environments. Unfortunately, the PARENTS declined this service. (Footnote 31) During the 2003-2004 school year, the conflicts between the PARENTS and the District continued virtually unabated. Testimony established that Mrs. PARENT had numerous verbal confrontations with school staff in STUDENT’s presence. In addition, as the year progressed and STUDENT’s behavior began to escalate, the PARENTS reacted by withdrawing permission for the District to utilize the programs in place. On October 17th the PARENTS withdrew permission for the District to utilize any aspect of the Stars program. On October 27th the PARENTS withdrew permission for the RSP services. Furthermore, despite their dissatisfaction with the program, the PARENTS refused to discuss any alternative until the LIFE report was completed. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not receive a consistent program during the 2003-2004 school year. However, the Hearing Officer also finds that the lack of consistency was primarily due to the PARENTS’ refusal of the home services, Mrs. PARENT’s pattern of verbal confrontations with District staff in front of STUDENT, and the PARENTS piecemeal withdrawal of permission for the District to implement STUDENT’s IEP while refusing to meet and discuss alternatives.
The District’s offer did provide for visual and verbal prompts to help STUDENT maintain attention and self-monitor her behavior. The Stars program used a star chart to remind STUDENT of her behavioral goals and visually track her performance during the day. In addition, Ms. Panec testified that her class incorporated various visual and verbal prompts including schedules, charts, and hand signals. Ms. McDonnell testified that all staff utilized verbal and visual prompts to help STUDENT remain focused and to redirect her when necessary. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer did contain appropriate visual and verbal prompts to help STUDENT maintain attention and self-monitor her behavior.
The PARENTS also contend that the District failed to meet STUDENT’s need for monitoring and facilitation of peer play and peer socialization. The IEP contained various goals related to peer play and socialization. One goal addressed STUDENT’s need demonstrate the use of appropriate tone of voice, physical proximity and personal space in class and on the playground. Another goal addressed turn taking and tolerance for rules and acceptance of losing. A third goal addressed appropriate classroom behaviors, including working with peers in groups. To meet these goals, Ms. Panec and Stacie provided STUDENT with direction, feedback, and prompting on social skills within the classroom. The daily reports document ongoing monitoring and facilitation of peer play by Stacie during breaks and recess. In addition, the speech therapist addressed social skills through various strategies, including social stories and role playing. The Hearing Officer finds that the District did offer appropriate goals and objectives to address STUDENT’s needs in this area, and provided services appropriate to implement those goals.
It is undisputed that Ms. McErlane, the RSP teacher at Springer, used repetition and re-teaching in academics in the course of her RSP sessions with STUDENT. Although the PARENTS eventually withdrew their permission for Ms. McErlane to work with STUDENT, their stated reasons were related to STUDENT’s behavior rather than concerns about academics.
It is also undisputed that STUDENT’s IEP provided for speech/language therapy in the areas of articulation, receptive and expressive language, pragmatic language, social rules, and non-verbal communication.
The PARENTS contend that the District did not provide STUDENT with a shadow aide with appropriate education and experience. Specifically, the PARENTS argue that Stacie was not properly trained to work with a physically aggressive child such as STUDENT. The evidence established that Stacie had a Bachelor’s degree in human development, had taken courses in autism, and had over thirty hours of training from BACDA in autism and applied behavioral analysis. Ms McDonnell testified that, as part of the training from BACDA, Stacie had received instruction in strategies for dealing with aggressive children. However, Stacie had not received specific training in restraint procedures. (Footnote 32) Although the school logs indicate that Stacie had used some form of restraint on STUDENT on at least four occasions, testimony established that the restraint used was the minimum necessary to control the situation and to ensure STUDENT’s safety. For example, on October 8th Stacie lifted STUDENT off a fence she was climbing, and on October 16th Stacie picked STUDENT up to carry her out of a busy street. The Hearing Officer finds that, although Stacie did not receive restraint training until mid October, she did have training in strategies for dealing with aggressive children, and she used appropriate measures to ensure STUDENT’s safety and the safety of others. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Stacie was appropriately trained and qualified to serve as STUDENT’s aide.
Sinead McDonnell served as STUDENT’s behavioral consultant/case manager during the 2003-2004 school year. Ms. McDonnell had a Bachelor’s degree and Master’s degree in psychology, and had worked with autistic children in Great Britain. After coming to the United States, Ms. McDonnell had been a resource specialist for a class that contained a high percentage of autistic children. She had later served as treatment coordinator for three classes and was responsible for writing behavior programs for the students in those classes. She had also served as lead coordinator for a weekly program in autism for over four years. Ms. McDonnell had worked as a behavior specialist for home programs for autistic children and clinical director at a day treatment program. Her position at BACDA involved writing and coordinating home and school based programs for autistic children. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. McDonnell was appropriately qualified to serve as STUDENT’s behavior consultant/case manager during the 2003-2004 school year.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer presented at the September 24, 2003 IEP meeting was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs because the Stars behavior program did not provide STUDENT with clear behavioral expectations, and failed to provide immediate tangible reinforcement for appropriate behavior. In addition, the District failed to implement any plan for addressing STUDENT’s aggressive behaviors. The PARENTS prevented the District from using the minor leagues portion of the Stars program, and the District failed to utilize the agreed upon alternative of removing STUDENT to the Abracadabra day care.
Did the District’s offer provide for STUDENT to be involved and progress in the general curriculum and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities?
There is no dispute that the District’s offer did provide for STUDENT to be involved and progress in the general curriculum and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. Was the District’s offer calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit?
The PARENTS contend that the lack of an appropriate behavior plan prevented STUDENT from receiving educational benefit during the time period at issue. The November 4, 2003 IEP indicates that STUDENT made progress on her academic goals, and in her speech/language goals. However, STUDENT’s progress on her speech/language goals was primarily in the structured setting of the therapy sessions. STUDENT was not generalizing new skills to unstructured situations. Furthermore, STUDENT did not make progress on her aggressive behaviors. The daily reports show that, from October 7 through November 4, STUDENT was displaying serious acting-out behaviors on a frequent basis. The Hearing Officer finds that the escalation in STUDENT’s acting-out behaviors can, at least in part, be attributed to a lack of an appropriate behavior plan and the District’s failure to implement any consistent consequence for STUDENT’s unsafe behaviors. The Hearing Officer also finds that the lack of cooperation and consistency between home and school contributed as well. It is also highly likely that the changes that had occurred in STUDENT’s home life also contributed to the changes in her behavior seen during the 2003-2004 school year. However, the Hearing Officer has no way of quantifying the effects of these various factors. Therefore, the Hearing Officer must conclude that the lack of an appropriate behavior plan and the District’s failure to implement any consistent consequence for STUDENT’s unsafe behaviors were substantial causes of STUDENT’s lack of progress in relation to her aggressive behaviors. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer, as implemented, was not calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.
Did the District’s program conform to STUDENT’s IEP?
There is no contention regarding this prong of the standard.
Was the District’s offer placement in the least restrictive environment?
The PARENTS contend that the September offer was not an offer of placement in the least restrictive environment. Specifically, the PARENTS argue that STUDENT’s program provided for the use of bathroom passes to allow STUDENT to “cool off” when she became frustrated, and that Ms. Panec utilized “fake mail” for the same purpose. (Footnote 33) The PARENTS contend that these strategies amounted to removal from the general education environment. The PARENTS also contend that the “minor leagues” was a further unnecessary removal from the general education environment.
Special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A) specifically provides:
To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.
In this case, STUDENT’s program in both the 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 school year provided for the use of “cooling-off” periods to allow STUDENT to calm down in the event she became frustrated during class. The “fake mail” and bathroom passes were the means by which STUDENT was allowed to take these “cooling-off” periods. Ms. Davis, Ms. McDonnell, and Ms. Panec all agreed that these were appropriate and necessary accommodations. The Hearing Officer finds that these strategies were appropriate to address STUDENT’s behavioral needs and allow her to be placed in a general education environment.
As to the use of the minor leagues, the PARENTS prohibited the District from utilitizing this consequence after only one use, on September 18. Therefore, the minor leagues was not part of STUDENT’s placement at any time thereafter. The Hearing Officer finds that the single use of the minor leagues did not result in the District failing to offer a placement in the least restrictive environment.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of September 24, 2003 was not an offer of FAPE because the Stars behavior program did not provide STUDENT with clear behavioral expectations, and failed to provide immediate tangible reinforcement for appropriate behavior. In addition, the District failed to implement the agreed upon strategies for addressing STUDENT’s aggressive behaviors. The lack of an appropriate behavior plan also resulted in the offer not being calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. Finally, the placement offered was not in the least restrictive environment because the “minor leagues” constituted an unnecessary removal of STUDENT from the general education environment.
4. Is the District entitled to conduct assessments pursuant to the assessment plans of November 4 and December 11, 2003 without the consent of the parents?
At the IEP meeting on November 4, 2003, the District presented the PARENTS with an assessment plan. The plan called for the completion of a social/emotional assessment, a speech/language assessment, a functional analysis assessment (FAA), and a reinforcement inventory. The District amended the assessment plan by letter dated December 11, 2003. The amended plan called for an additional assessment by a medical doctor familiar with autism, and an evaluation by an autism specialist. The PARENTS rejected both assessment plans.
Reassessment of a student with disabilities must be conducted at least once every three years, or more frequently, if conditions warrant a reassessment or if an assessment is requested by the student’s teacher or parent. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381; 20 U.S.C. § 1414 (a)(2)(A). In Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1315 (9th Cir. 1987), the Ninth Circuit stated “if the parents want [their child] to receive special education under the Act, they are obligated to permit such testing.” In Andress v. Cleveland Independent School District, 64 F.3d 176, 178 (5th Cir. 1995), the Fifth Circuit concluded that “a parent who desires for her child to receive special education must allow the school district to evaluate the child…there is no exception to this rule.” See also Vander Malle v. Ambach, 673 F.2d 49, 53 (2nd Cir. 1983).
While the law provides that a school district has the right and obligation to conduct these reassessments, parental consent for an evaluation is required before a school district can assess the child. Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(c); 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(1)(C)(i). To obtain consent, the school district must first develop an assessment plan to present to the student’s parents that complies with California Education Code section 56321(b). Section 56321(b) requires that the assessment plan (1) be in language that is easily understood by the general public; (2) be provided in the primary language of the parent; (3) explain the types of assessments to be conducted; and (4) state that no individualized education program from the assessment without the consent of the parents. Once the assessment is provided to the student’s parents, the parents must be allowed at least fifteen days to respond to the assessment plan. Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(a).
If the parents do not consent to the assessment plan, a local education agency can override a lack of parental consent if it establishes at a due process hearing the need to conduct such an assessment. Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(c), § 56501(a)(3), § 56506(e), and 20 U.S.C. § 1414 (a)(1)(C)(ii).
The November 4, 2003 Assessment Plan
The PARENTS do not contest the need for an FAA or a reinforcement inventory. The PARENTS do object to the environment in which the District proposed conducting the FAA. At the November 4, 2003 IEP meeting, the District proposed removing STUDENT to an interim one-on-one instructional placement while all of the assessments were conducted. The PARENTS contend that the FAA must be conducted while STUDENT is in a general education environment. The PARENTS also object to the speech language and social/emotional assessments as unnecessary.
The FAA
The purpose of an FAA is the development of a positive behavior intervention plan (BIP). State law sets forth specific procedures for conducting an FAA. The FAA must include the gathering of information from three sources: direct observation, interviews with significant others, and review of available data. 5 C.C.R. § 3052(b). The observation portion must include the systematic observation of the occurrences of the targeted behaviors, the immediate antecedent events associated with each instance of the targeted behavior, and the analysis of the consequences following each display of the behavior. Id. An additional requirement of an FAA is the analysis of the settings in which the target behavior occurs most frequently. Id. In STUDENT’s case, the primary targeted behaviors are her acting-out and aggressive behaviors during class and in less structured settings such as PE. It is undisputed that STUDENT performs very well in one-on-one instructional settings. Therefore, an FAA conducted entirely in a one-on-one instructional setting would be of little use in developing a BIP to address behaviors that primarily occur in the general education setting. The person or persons conducting the FAA would not be able to analyze the relevant ecological setting, nor would they be able to observe relevant antecedents or consequences, assuming the targeted behaviors occurred at all. The Hearing Officer finds that the FAA must be conducted in the environment in which the BIP is to be implemented.
The Social/Emotional Assessment
The District contends that it needs to conduct a social/emotional assessment to determine if, in addition to autism, STUDENT is suffering from depression, a mood disorder, or some other mental impairment. The PARENTS contend that a social/emotional assessment is unnecessary. They argue that all of STUDENT’s behaviors are consistent with autism.
State and federal law require a school district to assess in all areas related to a student’s suspected disability including, if appropriate, health and development, vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general intelligence, academic performance, communication, self-help skills, orientation and mobility, career and vocational interests and abilities, and social/emotional status. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(3)(C); 34 C.F.R. § 300.532(g); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f).) In this case, Ms. Panec, STUDENT’s teacher; Ms. McDonnell, STUDENT’s behavioral consultant; Ms. McErlane, STUDENT’s RSP teacher; and Ms. Allen, a District program specialist and school psychologist, all expressed concerns regarding STUDENT’s mood changes, and the frequency and intensity of her acting-out behaviors. They also agreed that STUDENT did not appear to have consistent antecedents to her acting out. One day, a given circumstance may have produced no reaction, while the next day the same antecedent may have produced an extreme reaction. All of the witnesses agreed that STUDENT’s behavior might be attributable to autism, but believed that the significant escalation over a two-month period warranted further investigation of other possible causes. No evidence was offered to contradict this testimony. The Hearing Officer finds that it is appropriate for the District to conduct a social/emotional assessment pursuant to the November 4, 2003 assessment plan.
The Speech/Language Assessment
No evidence was presented in support of, or against administering the Test of Problem Solving (TOPS). The Hearing Officer notes the TOPS had been administered in April 2003. On the basis of the recent use of this test, and the lack of evidence to establish the need to re-administer this test, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has failed to establish the need for this assessment.
The December 11, 2003 Amended Assessment Plan
The District’s amended assessment plan is contained in a letter from the District’s attorney. The PARENTS argue that this amended assessment plan does not meet the statutory requirements for a valid assessment plan. Pursuant to California Education Code section 56321(b), a proposed assessment plan given to parents shall: (1) be in language that is easily understood by the general public; (2) be provided in the primary language of the parent; (3) explain the types of assessments to be conducted; and (4) state that no individualized education program from the assessment without the consent of the parents. Although it is unusual for an assessment plan to be in letter format, the Hearing Officer notes that the law does not place any specific requirement on the form of an assessment plan, only the content.
In amending the November 4th assessment plan the District sought to add a “medical assessment by a doctor knowledgeable in autism” and a “reevaluation by an autism specialist regarding STUDENT’s needs stemming from her autism and any other disabilities.” (Footnote 34) These descriptions do not explain the types of assessments to be conducted, only who is to conduct them. (Footnote 35) There is no indication in the District’s letter of what areas are to be assessed. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s December 11 letter was not a valid assessment plan. The Hearing Officer finds that the District is not entitled to conduct the assessments requested in that letter.
In summary the Hearing Officer finds that the District is entitled to conduct an FAA and reinforcement survey. However, the FAA must be conducted in the environment in which the resulting BIP will be implemented. The Hearing Officer also finds that the District is entitled to conduct a social/emotional assessment pursuant to the November 4, 2003 assessment plan. The District is not entitled to conduct any assessments pursuant to the December 11, 2003 amended assessment plan.
5. Did the District offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education from November 4, 2003 continuing through the end of the 2003-2004 school year?
At the November 4, 2003 IEP meeting, the District offered an interim placement pending the completion of the assessments requested in the November 4th assessment plan. The offer consisted of placement in a tutorial room on a general education campus with one-on-one instruction. (Footnote 36) Services would include a full time one-on-one aide, RSP, and speech therapy as offered in the September IEP. The PARENTS rejected this offer. The PARENTS argue that the offer is vague, not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, and not in the least restrictive environment. The PARENTS seek placement in a general education class and the development of an appropriate behavior plan by an organization such as LIFE.
Procedural Violations
The law explicitly requires the District to make a formal written offer of placement when it proposes, or refuses, to initiate or change the educational placement of a disabled child. Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 513 U.S. 965, 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994). The Court in Union stated, “We find that this formal requirement has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe it should be enforced rigorously. The requirement of a formal, written offer creates a clear record that will do much to eliminate troublesome factual disputes many years later about when placements were offered, what placements were offered, and what additional educational assistance was offered to supplement a placement, if any.” Id. The PARENTS contend that the District’s offer does not meet the Union standard because it failed to set forth the specific criteria for the termination of the interim placement. The IEP states that, “the interim placement will be for thirty days or until the IEP team agrees that the interim placement is no longer necessary based on assessment and demonstration of safe behavior.” The Hearing Officer finds that this description is as specific as any IEP can be. The interim placement was to last for thirty days unless the IEP team later agreed otherwise. Under the IDEA, any placement can be changed at any time by agreement of the IEP team. Therefore, the uncertainty the PARENTS complain of is simply the same uncertainty that exists with any IEP. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did make a formal written offer of placement as required by Union.
Having determined that the District’s offer did not violate the PARENTS’ procedural rights, the substance of the offer must be examined. Such an analysis would normally start with an examination of STUDENT’s unique needs. However, because of the need for additional assessments, and because STUDENT has not been in any educational setting for over four months, it is impossible for the Hearing Officer to determine all of STUDENT’s current unique needs. Under these circumstances, the District’s offer must be examined on the basis of the best information available.
Did the District’s offer meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
It is undisputed that STUDENT continues to need visual and verbal prompts, monitoring and facilitation of peer play and peer socialization, repetition and re-teaching of academic skills and concepts, speech/language therapy in the areas of articulation, receptive and expressive language, pragmatic language, social rules, and non-verbal communication, a one-on-one aide, and a case manager/behavioral consultant. It has also been found that STUDENT needs to have a reinforcement survey, an FAA, and a social/emotional assessment conducted in order to develop an appropriate behavior intervention plan and identify any other needs.
In evaluating STUDENT’s behavioral needs, the Hearing Officer notes that both the District and the PARENTS cite Ms. Regnier’s report as an accurate statement of STUDENT’s current needs and the services necessary to meet those needs. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Regnier’s report very persuasive and places great weight on her conclusions. The Hearing Officer has already found that an appropriate FAA cannot be conducted in an isolated setting for the formulation of a behavior intervention plan, which is to be implemented in a different setting. Therefore, the proposed FAA cannot be completed until after the interim setting has ended. However, STUDENT’s behavior during the first two months of the 2003-2004 school year leave no doubt that she requires a behavior plan for whatever setting she will be in while the FAA is completed and the BIP developed. Therefore, STUDENT will require an interim behavior plan. Ms. Regnier testified that an interim behavior plan could be developed on the basis of a review of the behavioral records from the 2003-2004 school year. She stated that the interim plan would be in place while the FAA was begun, and adapted as necessary according to data taken on STUDENT’s behavior in whatever setting she was in. Ms. Regnier also made specific recommendations in relation to STUDENT’s current behavioral needs. She stated that a reinforcement survey be conducted by Mrs. PARENT and school staff to determine what items/activities are reinforcing for STUDENT. All reinforcements should then be restricted in all environments. The reinforcements should only be delivered to STUDENT based upon appropriate behaviors as determined by her behavior plan. Reinforcement should be delivered based upon the frequency of appropriate behaviors rather than a fixed interval system. The new behavior plan should incorporate a token system, with tokens delivered shortly after a desired behavior is exhibited, and exchanged later for identified reinforcements. Ms. Regnier also recommended that all demands on STUDENT must be consistently followed through with in all environments, that the PARENTS should receive additional training and support in the home environment, and that parents and staff should participate in weekly meetings. (Footnote 37) The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Regnier’s recommendations are appropriate to meet STUDENT’s behavior needs pending completion of the assessments.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs visual and verbal prompts, monitoring and facilitation of peer play and peer socialization, repetition and re-teaching of academic skills and concepts, speech/language therapy in the areas of articulation, receptive and expressive language, pragmatic language, social rules, and non-verbal communication, a one-on-one aide, and a case manager/behavioral consultant. STUDENT also needs an interim behavior plan developed on the basis of a reinforcement survey and a review of the behavior records from the first part of the 2003-2004 school year. The interim behavior plan should incorporate a token system, with tokens delivered shortly after a desired behavior is exhibited, and exchanged later for identified reinforcements. The behavior plan must be consistently followed through with in all environments. To ensure consistency, the PARENTS should receive additional training and support in the home environment and parents and staff should participate in weekly meetings.
Testimony established that STUDENT would receive visual and verbal prompts in the tutorial placement from both the teacher and from the aide. Peer play and peer socialization would be facilitated during speech therapy and by the aide at lunch and recess. (Footnote 38) STUDENT would continue to receive repetition and re-teaching during the daily RSP sessions. Speech therapy would continue to address STUDENT’s articulation, receptive and expressive language, pragmatic language, social rules, and non-verbal communication needs.
In relation to STUDENT’s need for an aide and case manager, the IEP called for the continued use of Stacie and Ms. McDonnell as the aide and behavior consultant/case manager. The Hearing Officer has already found that both Stacie and Ms. McDonnell are appropriately trained and qualified to serve as STUDENT’s aide and case manager.
To address STUDENT’s need for an interim behavior plan, the IEP provided for the continued use of the Stars program. (Footnote 39) The Hearing Officer has already found that the Stars program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The Hearing Officer finds that the plan’s deficiencies: its complexity, lack of clear expectations, and lack of appropriate reinforcements, would continue to make it inappropriate as an interim behavior plan. The Hearing Officer finds that a new interim behavior plan must be developed and implemented pending completion of the assessments and the development of a BIP. As stated earlier, the interim behavior plan must be developed on the basis of a review of the 2003-2004 behavior records, and include a token system, with tokens delivered shortly after a desired behavior is exhibited and exchanged later for identified reinforcements. The behavior plan must also be consistently followed through with in all environments. To provide consistency, the District offered 20 hours of home consultation/direct services and monthly meetings of STUDENT’s IEP team. The Hearing Officer finds that 20 hours of home consultation/direct services is appropriate to meet STUDENT’s need for parental training and support in the home. However, the Hearing Officer finds that monthly meetings are not adequate. On the basis of the ongoing problems with coordination between home and school that have plagued STUDENT’s program during the 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 school years, the Hearing Officer finds that weekly meetings, as recommended by Ms. Regnier, are necessary to provide consistency in STUDENT’s program.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer was appropriate to meet STUDENT’s unique needs with two exceptions: a new interim behavior plan must be developed pursuant to Ms. Regnier’s recommendations; and District staff must meet with Mrs. PARENT on a weekly basis to ensure consistency in the implementation of STUDENT’s program across all environments.
There is no dispute that the District’s offer would provide for the student to be involved and progress in the general curriculum and was calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The remaining contention regarding this offer is that it was not in the least restrictive environment. The PARENTS argue that STUDENT should continue to be placed in a general education classroom.
Was the District’s offer in the least restrictive environment?
As discussed above, special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C.§ 1412(a)(5)(A); Ed. Code § 56031.) In determining whether the placement proposed for the student satisfies LRE requirements, federal appellate courts have considered the following factors: (1) the educational benefits available to the child in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared to the educational benefits of a special education classroom; (2) the nonacademic benefits to the disabled child of interaction with nondisabled children; (3) the effect of the presence of the disabled child on the teacher and other children in the regular classroom; and (4) the costs of supplemental aids and services necessary to mainstream the disabled child in a regular classroom setting. Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel Holland (1992) 786 F. Supp. 879 (1992); Adopted by the Ninth Circuit in Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel Holland, (9th Cir. 1994)14 F.3d 1398; cert. denied.
Educational benefits
The District’s offer called for STUDENT to receive the same curriculum in the interim setting as she had received in the general education setting. In addition, the same, or similar, instructional activities would be used in the interim setting. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that there is no difference in the educational benefit STUDENT would receive in the interim setting as compared to a general education classroom.
Nonacademic benefits
In the interim setting offered, STUDENT would receive substantially less opportunities for socialization and interaction with her peers. STUDENT’s only socialization opportunities would occur in speech therapy and during lunch and recess. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the interim placement offered by the District would not provide STUDENT with the nonacademic benefits that she would have in a general education setting.
The effect of the presence of the disabled child on the teacher and other children in the regular classroom
During the first two months of the 2003-2004 school, STUDENT had a significant impact on the teacher and other children in her general education classroom. In October alone, STUDENT had at least fourteen separate instances of unsafe behavior. On October 24th, a group calling themselves the “Parents of Springer’s Room 11” wrote to the District concerned about the environment in the classroom. The letter described incidents of physical and verbal abuse, and stated that STUDENT’s unpredictable behavior had created an atmosphere of constant tension. On October 30th another parent emailed the District with the report that her daughter had witnessed STUDENT being dragged from the classroom, and the remaining students in the class being locked into the class and eventually exiting by a back door. On the basis of this evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s presence in a general education classroom resulted in a significant disruption to the teacher and the entire class.
Cost
Cost was not raised as an issue by either party.
In balancing the four factors set forth above, the Hearing Officer finds that, although STUDENT would not receive the same non-educational benefits in the proposed interim setting as she would in a general education classroom, her unpredictable behavior had created such a significant disturbance to the other students, that it is no longer appropriate for her to be placed in a general education environment. Furthermore, STUDENT has been out of any educational setting for over four months. There is no way to predict whether STUDENT’s behavior will be better or worse once she returns to school. On the basis of the testimony of Ms. Regnier and Ms. McDonnell, the Hearing Officer finds that a one-on-one placement, for a relatively brief period of time, would provide a safe setting in which STUDENT would have the opportunity to bring her behavior back under control so that she can return to a less restrictive setting. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of an interim placement in a one-on-one setting on a general education campus is an offer of placement in the least restrictive environment.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did make a formal written offer of placement as required by Union. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer was appropriate to meet STUDENT’s unique needs with the exception that a new, interim behavior plan must be developed pursuant to Ms. Regnier’s recommendations, and weekly team meetings are required to ensure consistency in the implementation of STUDENT’s program across all environments. Finally, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of an interim placement in a one-on-one setting is an offer of placement in the least restrictive environment.
6. If STUDENT was denied a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year, the 2003 extended school year, and the 2003-2004 school year, is she entitled to compensatory education?
The PARENTS request compensatory education in the form of a block of hours of additional behavioral and one-on-one support. When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997). Court decisions subsequent to Burlington also have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See, e.g. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.) In this case, it has been found that the District failed to offer and provide STUDENT with a FAPE from November 5, 2002 through the end of the 2002-2003 school year, and for the 2003-2004 school year through November 4, 2003. The remaining issue is what relief is appropriate under the IDEA. Compensatory education is not a contractual remedy, and the courts have stated that there is no obligation to provide a day-for-day compensation for time missed. Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(1997).) Appropriate compensatory education is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA. Id. Therefore, the question is not what was missed, but rather what was required to provide the student with a FAPE. In this case, STUDENT did not receive a FAPE because the District failed to provide her with an appropriate behavior support during each of the time periods involved. As a result, STUDENT’s behavior regressed to the point the she was eventually removed from her general education setting by an order of the Superior Court. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is entitled to compensatory education in relation to behavior management. (Footnote 40)
The remaining issue is what services are needed to provide STUDENT with appropriate compensatory education. No evidence was presented on this issue; however, the Hearing Officer finds that the most constant and damaging deficiency to STUDENT’s past programs had been the lack of consistency in implementation in school and across all environments. To meet this need in the future, it has already been found that STUDENT’s program will require the ongoing support of a case manager/behavioral consultant, and training and support for the PARENTS in the home environment. To compensate STUDENT for the past denials of FAPE, the Hearing Officer finds that her program shall include additional hours each week of case management/behavioral consultation services, and training and support for the PARENT’s in the home environment. Considering the amount of time that STUDENT was denied a FAPE (approximately ten months), and the importance in having consistency in her future program, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT will require an additional two hours each week of case management/behavioral consultation services. (Footnote 41) STUDENT will also require one hour a week total of home training and support. (Footnote 42) These addition hours should be provided for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year and for the entire 2004-2005 school year.
CONCLUSION
The 2002-2003 school year from November 5, 2002 through the end of the regular school year.
The District failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year because her program lacked any meaningful consistency. However, the lack of constancy was the result of the combination of frequent changes in District staff and the PARENTS’ failure to work cooperatively with the District in the implementation of the program. As a result of the inconsistency in the implementation of her program, STUDENT failed to make progress in relation to reducing her acting-out behaviors and improving her social skills.
The 2003 extended school year.
The District did offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003 extended school year.
The 2003-2004 school year through November 4, 2003.
Although the District did offer STUDENT a FAPE for this time period at the June 4, 2003 IEP, that offer was amended at the September 24, 2003 IEP meeting. The District’s offer contained in that IEP was not appropriate because it’s offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Specifically, the Stars behavior program did not provide STUDENT with clear behavioral expectations and failed to provide immediate tangible reinforcement for appropriate behavior. In addition, the District failed to implement any strategies to STUDENT’s aggressive behaviors. As a result of these deficiencies, STUDENT did not make progress in relation to reducing her aggressive behaviors. However, the lack of cooperation and consistency between home and school continued to contribute to STUDENT’s lack of progress during this period of time.
The District’s November 4, 2003 assessment plan.
The District is entitled to conduct an FAA and reinforcement survey under this assessment plan. However, the FAA must be conducted in the environment in which the resulting BIP will be implemented, therefore, it cannot be completed while STUDENT is in an interim placement. In addition, STUDENT’s recent unpredictable behavior and changes in mood established that STUDENT’s social/emotional status is an area of suspected disability. Therefore, the District is entitled to conduct a social/emotional assessment pursuant to the November 4, 2003 assessment plan.
The District’s December 11, 2003 amended assessment plan
The District is not entitled to conduct any assessments pursuant to the December 11, 2003 amended assessment plan. That plan did not meet the statutory requirements for a valid assessment plan because it was too vague as to what areas it proposed to assess.
The November 4, 2003 offer of placement.
At the November 4, 2003 IEP meeting, the District did make a formal written offer of placement as required by Union. Furthermore, that offer was appropriate to meet all of STUDENT’s unique needs with two exceptions. First, an interim behavior plan must be developed on the basis of a review of the 2003-2004 behavior records, and include a token system, with tokens delivered shortly after a desired behavior is exhibited and exchanged later for identified reinforcements. The behavior plan must also be consistently implemented in all environments. Second, the District staff must have weekly meetings with Mrs. PARENT to help ensure consistency in the implementation of STUDENT’s program across all environments. In addition, on the basis of the frequency and intensity of STUDENT’s acting out behaviors, and considering her absence from any educational setting for over four months, it was found that the District’s offer was an offer of placement in the least restrictive environment.
Compensatory education
The District failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE from November 5, 2002 through the end of the 2002-2003 school year, and from September 24, 2003 through November 4, 2003. As a result, STUDENT failed to make progress on her need to reduce her acting-out behaviors. Therefore, STUDENT is entitled to compensatory education in relation to behavior management. In order to address the lack of consistency between the home and school environments in STUDENT’s past behavior programs, the compensatory services shall be in the form of additional case management/behavior consultation services, and increased training and support for the PARENTS in the home environment. The amount of case management services shall be increased to a total of fours hours each week, and the in-home training and support shall be increased to a total of one hour each week. The compensatory services shall continue for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year, and for the entire 2004-2005 school year.
ORDER
1. The Los Altos Elementary School District shall immediately conduct a reinforcement survey and develop an interim behavior plan on the basis of the recommendations contained in Shawn Regnier’s report dated October 31, 2003. The interim behavior plan must be based upon a review basis of a review of the 2003-2004 behavior records, and include a token system, with tokens delivered shortly after a desired behavior is exhibited and exchanged later for identified reinforcements.
2. Within ten (10) calendar days from the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to amend the interim placement proposed at the November 4, 2003 IEP meeting. The amended IEP shall include the interim behavior plan described above, and shall provide for weekly meetings between District Staff and the PARENTS. The amended IEP shall also provide for compensatory education services in the form of increased case management/behavior consultation services totaling fours hours each week, and increased parental in-home training and support totaling one hour each week.
3. The District shall continue to provide the compensatory services for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year and for the entire 2004-2005 school year.
4. The District is entitled to conduct a social/emotional assessment and functional analysis assessment of STUDENT in accordance with the November 4, 2003 assessment plan without the consent of STUDENT’s parents.
5. The District shall give the PARENTS five (5) calendar days notice in advance of the scheduled dates for the assessment. The PARENTS shall make STUDENT reasonably available for the District to conduct the assessments.
6. Pursuant to the offer contained in the November 4, 2003 IEP, upon completion of the social emotional assessment the District shall convene an IEP meeting to determine STUDENT’s placement for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year. That IEP shall be convened within forty (40) calendar days from the date of this decision. The IEP will also provide for the completion of a functional analysis assessment and the development of a behavior intervention plan pursuant to Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001 and § 3052.
7. All of the parties’ other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement:
1. Did the District offer and provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education during the 2002-2003 school year from November 5, 2002 through the end of the regular school year?
The PARENTS prevailed on this issue.
2. Did the District offer and provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education during the 2003 extended school year?
The District prevailed on this issue.
3. Did the District offer and provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education during the 2003-2004 school year through November 4, 2003?
The PARENTS prevailed on this issue.
4. Is the District entitled to conduct assessments pursuant to the assessment plans of November 4 and December 11, 2003 without the consent of the parents?
The District substantially prevailed on this issue as to the November 4, 2003 assessment plan. The PARENTS prevailed on this issue as to the December 11, 2003 assessment plan.
5. Did the District offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education from November 4, 2003 continuing through the end of the 2003-2004 school year?
The District substantially prevailed on this issue.
6. If STUDENT was denied a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year, the 2003 extended school year, or the 2003-2004 school year, is she entitled to compensatory education?
The PARENTS prevailed on this issue..
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. (California Education Code § 56505(i).)
Dated: March 26, 2004 ____________________________________ Lawrence E. Mendel, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
On December 11, 2003, the District amended the November 4, 2003 assessment plan.
2 Although the TRO was not issued until November 7, 2003, the District’s offer for prospective placement was made at the November 4, 2003 IEP meeting.
3 For a more detailed summary of the facts leading up to November 2002, see the Background Facts contained in the prior decision.
4 The District attempted to retain Michele Garcia Winner to provide staff training specific to STUDENT’s program and needs, but the PARENTS did not sign the authorization for the District to release information to Ms. Garcia Winner.
5 Lisa would continue to work as STUDENT’s aide two and one-half days a week.
6 Mr. PARENT moved to Southern California. The PARENTS would eventually be divorced, which became final in June 2003. Mr. PARENT continues to live in Southern California.
7 Testimony established that there had been an incident at school during which Lisa’s aide and speech therapist had kept STUDENT in for part of recess due to unsafe behavior. The next day STUDENT had brought a note from Mrs. PARENT instructing the staff not to keep STUDENT in from recess at all.
8 STUDENT’s primary class was team taught, and one of the teachers had been absent for an extended period due to pregnancy. Ms. Davis also noted the problems the District had had hiring a permanent aide.
9 STUDENT had attended Loyola Elementary during the 2002-2003 school year. Loyola had closed at the end of the 2002-2003 school year and STUDENT’s new school of residence was Covington.
10 Ms. Davis did not attend this IEP meeting.
11 At some time during late June, early July 2003, Mrs. PARENT, STUDENT, and her sister moved to a new home. Their new address was served by the Springer school, rather than Covington.
12 Lisa Wiedenfeld would no longer be available to serve as an aide for STUDENT during the 2003-2004 school year.
13 This issue had also been in the previous due process hearing
14 There is no statement in the IEP that the minors portion of the “Stars” program was not to be used. However, all witnesses agreed that that was understood.
15 Ms. Panec had missed approximately ten days due to illness and the illness of her husband.
16 The IEP states that the interim placement would be for thirty days or until the team agreed that the interim placement was no longer necessary.
17 These behaviors were also identified in the behavior plan developed by the IEP team on February 12, 2003. In her testimony, Mrs. PARENT agreed that these were STUDENT’s problem behaviors throughout the 2002-2003 school year.
18 STUDENT had a strong desire to control any game and tended to become upset if she did not win.
19 Ms. Luks testified that the District had never proposed using Ms. Garcia Winner as the consultant, only for in-service training; however, evidence presented at the hearing supported the conclusion reached by the hearing officer in SN02-01950, that the District had made a written offer of Ms. Garcia Winner as the new consultant to replace LIFE.
20 The voluminous record of emails between the PARENTS and the District reveals an almost constant disagreement. On November 13, 2002, just eight days after the decision in SN02-01950 was issued, Mr. PARENT was threatening to file a compliance complaint with the State. On December 11, 2002, six days after the parties had met at an IEP meeting, Mr. PARENT emailed that he believed STUDENT was regressing due to inadequate program implementation at school. Although there were areas of cooperation, as the year progressed the tone of the emails became increasingly hostile.
21 Testimony established that STUDENT would make statements to District staff that her mother was going to have people fired, and that “you’re not the boss of me.”
22 Mrs. PARENT testified that she believed, as STUDENT’s mother, it was acceptable for her to “give in” to STUDENT at home.
23 After the April 28, 2003 IEP meeting that ended prematurely, Mr. PARENT refused to discuss any issues with the District until the District removed Ms. Davis from any involvement in STUDENT’s program.
24 This IEP meeting was a completion of the meeting started on April 28, 2003.
25 The cause of STUDENT’s aggressive behavior was the subject of much debate at the hearing. The PARENTS argued that STUDENT’s aggressive behavior was the result of the District’s failure to provide an appropriate program during the prior year. The District pointed to numerous potentially stressful events that had occurred in STUDENT’s life over the prior twelve months. STUDENT’s parents had separated and divorced. STUDENT had moved twice and was starting a new school. In addition, STUDENT had not received any ESY services during the prior summer. For the purposes of this Decision, it is unnecessary for the Hearing Officer to determine the source of STUDENT’s new behaviors, only to recognize their existence.
26 STUDENT’s needs had always included a need for a behavior plan. However, recurring aggressive behaviors had never been a focus of the prior behavior plan.
27 The Stars program had actually been implemented on September 8, 2003, following discussions between Ms. McDonnell and Mrs. PARENT that the sticker system in use the prior year was no longer motivating for STUDENT.
28 According to Ms. McDonnell, STUDENT’s advancement through the levels was to be strictly based upon her points total for each week. However, if STUDENT wished to advance to the next level she was required to prepare a “petition,” which would then be voted on by District staff members who had worked with STUDENT that week. The purpose of this petition process was not understood by all of the District staff. In voting on a petition, District personnel all agreed that STUDENT’s point total was the primary factor to consider; however, some staff members believed that if STUDENT had a very high point total, or wrote a very good petition, she might be allowed to move to the next level even though the rules of the Stars program dictated that she could not yet advance. For example, on the week ending October 3rd, STUDENT had scored 597 points and asked to petition to move to level three. Because STUDENT had only been at level two for one week, and the rules required her to maintain level two status for two weeks before she could move to level three, the Stars program dictated that STUDENT could not move up a level. Nevertheless, STUDENT was allowed to petition to move to level three. The petition was denied, but by a five to four vote. This example illustrates both STUDENT’s and staff member’s confusion about what conditions would allow advancement.
29 The minor league was used only once, on September 18th. After this incident, Mrs. PARENT prohibited the District from using the minor leagues as a consequence for unsafe behaviors.
30 Examples include September 24, 30, October 7, 8, 9, 10, 14, 15, 22, 24, 29, November 1, 3, and 4. 31 Mr. PARENT offered no real explanation for why he refused this service other than to say that it seemed arbitrary.
32 Stacie did receive this training through the District, but not until the last two weeks of October 2003.
33 “Fake mail” was the practice of asking a student to deliver a “message” to the office. The “message” was an excuse to allow a student to leave class for a brief period of time.
34 The December 11 letter also notified the PARENTS that the assessors that the District had proposed using in the November 4, 2003 assessment plan were not available. This change of proposed assessors was not raised as an issue in this hearing.
35 In reading the District’s December 11 letter, it is possible to interpret it as a clarification of who will perform the assessments identified in the November 4 assessment plan. However, in clarifying the issues at the start of the Hearing, counsel for the District stated that the December 11 letter was intended to add two additional assessments to the November 4 assessment plan.
36 The original offer provided for placement on the Springer School campus. By letter dated December 22, 2003, that offer was changed to a placement at the District offices on the Covington School campus.
37 In recommending additional training and support for the PARENTS in the home, Ms. Regnier stated that she was not recommending a return to a discrete trail training “home program” such as STUDENT had been receiving in the first grade.
38 The IEP calls for the aide to interact with STUDENT during lunch and recess.
39 The November 4 IEP incorporates the C1, C2, and C3 pages from the September 24 IEP. On those pages, the District offer calls for use of the Stars behavior plan. The District was not proposing the long term use of the Stars program, only its continued use pending completion of the FAA and development of the BIP.
40 If the PARENTS were seeking reimbursement in this case, the Hearing Officer may have found it appropriate to reduce any award on the basis of the PARENTS’ conduct during the time period at issue. However, under the facts of this case, such a reduction in compensatory services is not appropriate. The PARENTS’ conduct might be an appropriate consideration in relation to any award of attorney’s fees.
41 The IEP provided for two hours a week of these services. The compensatory services would add two hours of case management each week for a total of four hours a week.
42 The IEP offered twenty hours total of this service spread over eight months. This amounts to only two and one half hours a month. The compensatory services bring the total to one hour each week.
