California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 18, 2004

Student v. San Diego County Office of Education (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 2364-02, SN02-02364, SN03-02497 · Hearing Officer Jessica Katz

San Diego County Office of Education and California Children's Services win all claims; March 2003 IEP may be implemented.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

An earlier SEHO decision dated March 3, 2004, after a January 13-14, 2004 hearing, applied the three-year statute of limitations to bar claims arising before October 21, 1999, and dismissed Lakeside Union School District and Cajon Valley Union School District. The cases were consolidated on December 16, 2003.

Summary

The conservators of a 20-year-old student filed for due process against the San Diego County Office of Education (SDCOE) and California Children's Services (CCS). SDCOE then filed its own case to defend its March 24, 2003 IEP offer. The student has profound cognitive disabilities, cerebral palsy with low muscle tone, and orthopedic impairments. He attended Friendship School, an SDCOE school for students with severe disabilities. An earlier ruling limited his claims to October 21, 1999 and later.

The student argued that from 1999 through April 2004 he needed direct occupational, physical and speech therapy rather than consultation. He also argued that he needed a one-on-one aide, better assistive technology, a behavior support plan, and teachers credentialed for orthopedic impairments. He further alleged pre-written IEPs, a poor classroom transfer in 2002, improper personal care, and assessments done without consent.

Hearing Officer Jessica Katz rejected every claim. She credited the CCS therapists and the student's orthopedic surgeon, Dr. Henry Chambers. They testified that his cognitive level and low muscle tone meant direct therapy would not produce change. She gave little weight to the private experts, who relied mainly on the conservators and did not observe him at school. The teachers' credentials were adequate. Draft IEPs offered as recommendations were allowed. Data sheets showed the IEP was carried out. Extra speech therapy given without consent caused no harm because it matched what the student had requested. The Hearing Officer ordered that the March 2003 IEP may be implemented.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO weighed treating providers against private experts who had not observed the student at school or talked with his school staff. It also shows how SEHO treated draft IEPs, teacher credentials for a student with multiple disabilities, and services given without IEP consent that caused no harm, under Rowley.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Did SDCOE and CCS provide a FAPE to Student from October 21, 1999 through the end of the 1999-2000 school year, including ESY?

    Consultative OT, PT and speech services, the teacher's moderate/severe credential, and classroom staffing met Student's needs; draft IEPs and absence of CCS staff caused no loss of educational opportunity.

  2. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2. Did SDCOE and CCS provide a FAPE to Student during the 2000-2001 school year?

    The February 2000 and February 2001 IEPs, based on a triennial assessment, were appropriate and implemented; a CCS therapist and qualified assessors attended the IEP meeting.

  3. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. Did SDCOE and CCS offer and/or provide a FAPE to Student during the 2001-2002 school year?

    The transfer to a new teacher with an emergency credential was properly handled, the IEP was implemented, personal care and community outings were appropriate, and the May 2002 revised goals fit Student's actual abilities.

  4. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 4. Did SDCOE and CCS offer and/or provide a FAPE to Student during the 2002-2003 school year?

    The March 24, 2003 offer of limited direct OT and speech plus consultation, a two-choice voice-output communication system, and the existing gait trainer was appropriate; no behavior support plan was needed and assessments had consent.

  5. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5. Did SDCOE and CCS offer and/or provide a FAPE to Student from the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year through April 2004?

    Communication goals were implemented; extra direct speech therapy given without IEP consent caused no harm; CCS therapy updates needed no consent; private reports were not available to the 2003 IEP team; no continuum of options was owed to the individual student.

  6. Issue SDCOE cross-filing. Whether SDCOE offered Student a FAPE at the March 24, 2003 IEP meeting, with the offer remaining in effect through April 2004.

    The March 24, 2003 IEP was appropriate and may be implemented.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order that district's offer may be implemented. SDCOE's proposed IEP dated March 24, 2003 is appropriate and may be implemented.
  • Student's claims for relief, including extended eligibility and direct OT, PT, speech services and a 1:1 aide, were denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Honig v. Doe; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; W.G. v. Target Range School District; Roland M. v. Concord School Committee; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education

People named in the decision

  • Gene Gallegos, principal, Friendship School (SDCOE)
  • Brenda Button, special education teacher (emergency credential), Friendship School (SDCOE)
  • Dr. Henry Chambers, pediatric orthopedic surgeon, chief of staff; treating physician, witness for SDCOE, San Diego Children's Hospital
  • Sylvia Nielson, physical therapist; conducted 2003 PT assessment, Children's Hospital South Bay Center
  • Eleanor (Elly) Millman, speech-language pathologist, Friendship Home
  • Barbara Tabor, school nurse (registered nurse), Friendship School
  • Steven Oas, speech-language pathologist providing direct services, Friendship Home/Friendship School contractor
  • Jorge Ley, school psychologist, SDCOE
  • Judith Van Brocklin, senior director of special education, SDCOE
  • Jennifer Canaris, occupational therapist; conducted 2003 OT assessment, San Diego County SELPA
  • Judy Gwinnup, itinerant teacher and assistive technology specialist; conducted AT assessment, Cajon Valley Union School District / San Diego State University
  • Anita Macy, speech-language pathologist and program specialist; conducted 2003 speech-language assessment, National School District / San Diego County SELPA
  • Cathy Cortney, physical therapist, California Children's Services
  • Patricia Bernens, occupational therapist, California Children's Services
  • Nancy Lavine-Anderson, supervising therapist, California Children's Services
  • Karen Brown, State therapy consultant, California Children's Services
  • Dr. Ardith Williams-Meyers, expert witness for Student (physical therapy professor; private PT assessment), Azusa Pacific University
  • Susan Berkowitz, expert witness for Student (speech-language pathologist; private speech and augmentative communication assessment), Private consultant
  • Brian Seacord, program director, Not stated
  • Annemarie Pesqualia, regional center representative, San Diego Regional Center
  • Kimberly Spangler, regional center representative, San Diego Regional Center
  • Ronald Lopez, program manager, Sweetwater School District
  • Tracy Cook, speech-language pathologist, Friendship School
  • Lori Mannheimer, occupational therapist, Friendship School
  • Jaime Tate, assistive technology specialist, Friendship School
  • Maria Gless, attorney for SDCOE at IEP meetings, SDCOE counsel
  • Lysa Saltzman, attorney for SDCOE at IEP meetings, SDCOE counsel
  • Jessica Rufo, qualified mental retardation professional (QMRP), Friendship Home
  • Susana W., director of pupil services, Chula Vista Elementary School District
  • Pam Espinosa, coordinator, Chula Vista Elementary School District
  • Elyse Latella, staff of Student's attorney's office, Student's counsel's office
  • Friendship Home, private residential placement, Private

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Jessica Katz, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in San Diego, California, on April 13-16 and 20-22, 2004.

Petitioner and Cross-Respondent Student (Student or Student) was represented at the hearing by attorneys Michael Cochrane and Thomas Nelson. Also present on behalf of the Student were his conservators, Conservator 1 and Conservator 2. Respondent and Cross-Petitioner San Diego County Office of Education (SDCOE) was represented at hearing by attorneys Jack Clarke and Kristina Lupariello. Also present on SDCOE’s behalf was Gene Gallegos, principal of Friendship School, a public school operated by SDCOE. Respondent California Children’s Services (CCS) was represented at hearing by attorney Lynda Williams. Also present on behalf of CCS was Karen Brown, State therapy consultant for CCS.

The Student called the following witnesses: Conservator 2; Dr. Ardith Williams-Meyer, professor of physical therapy at Azusa Pacific University; Susan Berkowitz, speech and language pathologist; and Conservator 1.

SDCOE called as its witnesses: Brenda Button, special education teacher at Friendship School; Dr. Henry Chambers, chief of staff of San Diego Children’s Hospital and pediatric orthopedic surgeon; Sylvia Nielson, physical therapist; Eleanor Millman, speech and language pathologist; Barbara Tabor, registered nurse; Steven Oas, speech and language pathologist; Jorge Ley, school psychologist; Judith Van Brocklin, senior director of special education for SDCOE; Jennifer Canaris, occupational therapist; Judy Gwinnup, itinerant teacher and assistive technology specialist; Anita Macy, program specialist for National School District; and Gene Gallegos.

CCS called as its witnesses: Cathy Cortney, physical therapist; Patricia Bernens, occupational therapist; and Nancy Lavine-Anderson, supervising therapist.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was closed upon receipt of final written arguments and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES (Footnote 1)

1. Did the SDCOE and CCS provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to Student from October 21, 1999 through the end of the 1999-2000 school year, including extended school year (ESY)? (Footnote 2)

2. Did the SDCOE and CCS provide a FAPE to Student during the 2000-2001 school year?

3. Did the SDCOE and CCS offer and/or provide a FAPE to Student during the 2001-2002 school year?

4. Did the SDCOE and CCS offer and/or provide a FAPE to Student during the 2002-2003 school year?

5. Did the SDCOE and CCS offer and/or provide a FAPE to Student from the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year through April 2004?

CONTENTIONS

The Student contends that from October 21, 1999 through February 2002, he was not provided a FAPE because SDCOE and CCS failed to provide direct occupational therapy (OT) and direct physical therapy (PT). The Student also contends that SDCOE failed to provide instruction from a properly credentialed teacher, a one-on-one aide in the classroom, assistive technology, and direct one-on-one speech and language therapy (SP/L). The Student further contends that SDCOE committed procedural violations in that Student’s IEP documents were prepared prior to his IEP meetings and discussions regarding Student’s placement were held outside the presence of his surrogate parent. Further, the Student argues that during the IEP meetings, there were no assessors present and no discussion regarding services from CCS.

The Student contends that from March 2002 through April 2004, in addition to the previous contentions, SDCOE also failed to provide instruction from a properly credentialed teacher and an appropriate transition from Conservator 1’s class to Ms. Button’s class. Further, the Student asserts that the IEP process was inadequate because the IEP team failed to consider a full continuum of services and independent assessments. Additionally, the Student contends that a SP/L assessment and SP/L services were provided without parental consent, that his academic needs were not met because his goals and objectives regarding his communication board were not implemented, and that he was denied a full day of instruction and denied an opportunity to socialize in the community. The Student asserts that his personal care was improper because he did not have a set time to finish lunch, he was placed on the floor without cushions after his surgery, his toileting was inappropriate, and he had improper administration of medication.

The Student proposed in his opening arguments that he should receive eight years of extended eligibility and argued that, due to his regression, it would take longer for him to learn. The Student also requested direct OT, PT, and SP/L services and a one-on-one aide. The Hearing Officer notes that in the Student’s closing brief, he requested services through his twenty-fifth birthday which is a day-for-day award for the alleged FAPE denials, but further argued that due to Student’s alleged regression, it would not provide a full equitable remedy.

The SDCOE contends that from October 1999 through February 2002, Student was placed in Conservator 1’s classroom and that he had appropriate services and made progress. The SDCOE asserts that from March 2002 through April 2004, Student was in Ms. Button’s class and that Student continued to receive appropriate services and continued to make progress. Finally, the SDCOE asserts that it offered and/or provided a FAPE from October 1999 through April 2004.

CCS contends that it provided appropriate OT and PT services during the entire time period at issue. CCS further contends that at no time prior to the due process hearing did the conservators or the SDCOE ever request additional OT or PT services. CCS asserts that OT and PT consultations were provided in the classroom and that the consultants participated in the IEP meetings.

BACKGROUND FACTS

Student is twenty years old. He has been diagnosed with profound mental retardation, cerebral palsy with hypotonia, orthopedic impairment, and a seizure disorder. (Footnote 3) Student was removed from his parents’ home prior to the age of two and placed in foster care. He remained in foster care until 1995 when he was placed in the Friendship Home. Upon placement in the Friendship Home, he began attending the Friendship School, which is operated by SDCOE for students with severe to profound cognitive and/or physical disabilities and where he remains today. (Footnote 4)

Student was placed in Conservator 1’s special education class in 1995. He continued his placement in her class through February 2002, when Conservator 1 and her husband, Conservator 2, became his legal conservators. (Footnote 5) Friendship School is a school for severely physically and mentally disabled students. The school has an integrated approach to educating its students and contracts with occupational, physical, and speech and language therapists to provide ongoing direct services to its students within the classroom setting and to provide additional support to the classroom teachers and aides. There are five classrooms, one class for ages five to eleven, two classes for ages eleven to seventeen, and two classes for ages seventeen to twenty-two. Conservator 1 taught a class in the middle age group from 1995 through the 2002-2003 school year when she left on medical leave. Her class had up to twelve students, with an average of seven students, many of which were wheelchair bound with little or no verbal communication skills. There was one full-time aide and one part-time aide also in the classroom. Conservator 1 also was requested by Friendship School to develop the goals and objectives and write draft individualized education programs (IEP) documents prior to the IEP meetings for all her students, including Student.

On February 25, 1999, Student’s annual IEP meeting was held. In attendance at the IEP team meeting were Dorothy Wellman, Student’s educational surrogate; Conservator 1; Mr. Gallegos, the school principal; Barbara Tabor, the school nurse; Brian Seacord, a program director; and Annemarie Pesqualia from the San Diego Regional Center. Student’s IEP team agreed that for the 1999-2000 school year, Student would continue to be placed in Conservator 1’s class and receive ongoing consultations from the school nurse, the speech and language pathologist, and from CCS for occupational therapy (OT) and physical therapy (PT). The consultations helped Conservator 1 develop appropriate services that the aides and Conservator 1 could implement within the classroom setting. Conservator 1 also developed a series of goals and objectives to work on Student’s functional skills, including skills in the areas of communication, cognition, gross motor, and computer and leisure.

Just prior to the February 1999 IEP meeting, Student had undergone a spinal fusion operation. The physical therapist from CCS provided recommendations to Conservator 1 for exercises that she could implement in the classroom and also provided one month of direct PT. Conservator 1 also determined Student’s present levels of performance and indicated on the IEP that Student could use switches, was learning his sorting skills, understood two-step commands, identified body parts and some of their functions, identified and matched colors and shapes, indicated when he needed to use the toilet and when he was finished with the toilet, collected dishes from the table, assisted with putting on his shirts, and wiped his nose and mouth with a cloth. Additionally, according to Conservator 1’s description in the IEP document, Student could pull himself to a standing position and help with transfers and was able to “cruise furniture” and walk and run in his gait trainer. Conservator 1 also indicated that Student could identify the numbers one to twenty, had a sight vocabulary of twenty words, and could name three shapes.

On March 10, 2000, Friendship School held its annual IEP meeting for Student. Ms. Wellman, Conservator 1, and Mr. Gallegos were in attendance. Consistent with Conservator 1’s standard practice, she prepared the draft IEP document prior to the IEP meeting. Student continued to be offered the same placement and services as listed in his previous IEP. Goals and objectives were continued in the areas of communication, cognition, gross motor, and computer and leisure. Additionally, Conservator 1 indicated Student’s present levels of performance. She continued to describe the same abilities as in the previous IEP. Conservator 1 also noted that Student was continuing to use switches and was making some progress on transfers. She also noted that he enjoyed story telling and could identify thirty large-print vocabulary words.

Student’s March 2000 IEP continued to be implemented through February 2001, when his annual/triennial IEP meeting was held. Jorge Ley, the school psychologist, Ms. Tabor, and Conservator 1 conducted the triennial assessment in February 2001 and submitted the report on February 20, 2001, the same day as the IEP meeting. The triennial review team determined that Student had a cognitive age equivalency of eight months. Conservator 1, Ms. Wellman, Mr. Gallegos, Kimberly Spangler from the San Diego Regional Center, Ms. Tabor, Student’s attendant from the Friendship Home, and occupational therapist Pat Bernens from CCS attended the IEP meeting. Student’s IEP team agreed to continue his placement in Conservator 1’s special day class (SDC). He also continued to reside at the Friendship Home. Conservator 1 again had prepared the draft IEP document prior to the meeting and written the goals and objectives in the same areas as previously mentioned. Conservator 1 also had prepared a transition plan for Student because he was seventeen. Conservator 1 indicated that Student recognized thirty-five nouns and action words and the numbers one through twenty. She also indicated that Student maintained his skills as previously described above.

Student’s February 2001 IEP continued to be implemented through February 27, 2002 and Student continued his placement in Conservator 1’s SDC, Conservator 1 again prepared the draft IEP document prior to the IEP meeting on February 27, 2002. Student’s IEP team remained the same, except that his home attendant had changed. The IEP team agreed to update his goals and objectives in the areas of communication, cognition, gross motor, and computer and leisure. Conservator 1 continued to indicate on his IEP that Student recognized numbers and had a sight vocabulary of approximately thirty-seven words.

Student turned eighteen on February 15, 2002, and was aged out of the dependency system. Conservator 1 and Conservator 2 had developed a strong relationship with Student by this time and requested that the dependency court appoint them as legal conservators for Student. The court granted the request on March 11, 2002. Because Conservator 1 had become Student’s conservator and her class was for ages eleven to seventeen, Student was transferred to Ms. Button’s class on March 11, 2002. Prior to the transfer, Ms. Button observed Conservator 1’s class on a daily basis to familiarize herself with Student’s program. Upon Student’s transfer, Conservator 1 went to Ms. Button’s class, often multiple times a day, to give guidance and assistance.

From March 2002 through May 2002, there was testimony that disputes arose between Conservator 1 and Ms. Button because Conservator 1 was in Ms. Button’s classroom constantly. Conservator 2 intervened and requested a discussion/meeting with Ms. Button and Mr. Gallegos in May 2002, and during that meeting, a shouting match occurred between Conservator 2 and Ms. Button and she requested that he not return to her classroom. From March through May 2002, the staff at Friendship School attempted to implement the IEP as written in February 2002; however, Ms. Button, the speech and language pathologist, and the aides in Ms. Button’s classroom determined that Student could not perform many of the skills that Conservator 1 had previously indicated he could.

On May 24, 2002, an IEP meeting was held and new goals and objectives were offered that were in alignment with Student’s abilities as observed by Ms. Button and the staff who were working with him at the time. Conservator 1 and Conservator 2 refused to accept the new goals and objectives because they wanted the goals and objectives that Conservator 1 had written for Student in February 2002. Therefore, the February 2002 remained in effect.

On October 21, 2002, the conservators filed for a due process hearing on behalf of Student (SN02-02364). A mediation was held in November 2002, and the parties agreed to provide a one-on-one aide for three hours and forty-five minutes a day and that Student would remain in Ms. Button’s classroom; however, no other agreements were reached.

In January and February 2003, prior to Student’s annual IEP meeting, Student underwent a series of assessments in the areas of OT (assessment conducted by Jennifer Canaris of the San Diego SELPA), PT (assessment conducted by Sylvia Nielsen of Children’s Hospital South Bay Center), SP/L (assessment conducted by Anita Macy of the San Diego SELPA), and a multidisciplinary assessment (conducted by Jorge Ley, Ms. Button, Conservator 1, Ms. Nielsen, Ms. Canaris, Ms. Macy, Judy Gwinnup, and the Friendship Home’s nursing staff). The assessment team determined that Student functioned at the 15.7-months behavioral age with communication skills within the six- to sixteen-month range.

On February 18, 2003, Student’s annual/triennial IEP meeting was held at Friendship School. (Footnote 6) The meeting was facilitated and approximately fifteen people were present representing SDCOE, Friendship School, Friendship Home, CCS, and Student’s conservators. Student continued to be offered goals and objectives based on his present levels of performance in the areas of communication, cognitive functioning, fine and gross motor skills, and self-help skills. Student also was offered ten thirty-minute sessions each of direct OT and SP/L, per school year (delivery in fifteen-minute sessions if Student could not tolerate thirty-minute sessions). Conservator 1 and Conservator 2 refused to sign the IEP document and disagreed with both the proposed placement and services and the goals and objectives. However, the parties agreed that Student should continue his placement in Ms. Button’s SDC in spite of his conservators’ disagreement with the IEP.

Because no agreement was reached on February 18, 2003, the IEP meeting was continued and reconvened on February 21 and again on March 4, 2003 with most of the same people present. Much discussion occurred regarding the proposed goals and objectives in communication because the conservators were concerned that Student had been able to utilize symbols and now he only used concrete items or photos. No agreement was reached regarding the goals and objectives and the February 2002 IEP goals and objectives continued to be implemented pending the reconvening of the IEP meeting.

On March 11, 2003, the IEP team meeting again reconvened with most of the same team members present. There was no agreement on the goals and objectives and the meeting was reconvened on March 24, 2003. Disagreement over Student’s abilities continued to be the main focus of the meeting. The conservators requested additional direct OT and SP/L services as well as direct PT services. No agreement was reached on the IEP and the February 2002 goals and objectives continued to be implemented.

In July 2003, the Student added CCS as a party to his case. On November 26, 2003, the SDCOE filed a request for a due process hearing against Student alleging that its proposed program was appropriate (SN03-02497) and the matters were consolidated on December 16, 2003. On January 13 and 14, 2004, a due process hearing convened in this matter regarding the applicability of the three-year statute of limitations because the Student had attempted to raise claims dating as far back as 1987. (Footnote 7) On March 3, 2004, the Hearing Officer issued a Decision finding that the three-year statute of limitations applied to bar claims arising prior to October 21, 1999. Therefore, the relevant time frame in this matter is from October 21, 1999 through April 2004. (Footnote 8)

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

1. Did the SDCOE and CCS provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to Student from October 21, 1999 through the end of the 1999-2000 school year, including ESY?

Under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.) Federal and State law mandates that all children with disabilities have available to them a FAPE that includes special education and related services to meet their unique needs. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000 et seq.) The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a child at no charge to his or her parent or guardian, meet the standards of the State educational agency, include appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education, and are provided in conformity with the child’s individualized education program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401 (8).) Special education law also requires that a child with a disability be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). (20 U.S.C. § 1412 (a)(5)(A).) The IEP, which is the “centerpiece of the [IDEA’s] educational delivery system for disabled children,” consists of a detailed written statement that must be developed, reviewed and revised for each child with a disability. (Honig v. Doe (1988) 484 U.S. 305, 108 S.Ct. 592, 598; 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343, 56345.) The IEP must include a statement of the goals and objectives, special education and related services, and program modifications or supports for the school personnel that are to be provided to meet the child’s needs resulting from his or her disability and to enable the child to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum and be educated and participate with nondisabled children to the maximum extent possible. (Honig v. Doe (1988) 484 U.S. 305; see also 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56031, 56345.)

In Rowley, the Supreme Court determined that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education instruction or services, or that those services maximize a student’s potential. (Board of Hendrick Hudson School District v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176.) The Court stated that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.” (Id. at 200.) Additionally, as long as a school district provides an appropriate education, the question of methodology is left up to the school district’s discretion. (Id. at 208.) In determining whether the school district has offered a FAPE, the focus is on the adequacy of the district’s proposed program. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307 (9th Cir. 1987).) If the district has offered the student a FAPE, the district is not required to place the student in the program preferred by the parents, even if the preferred program is likely to result in greater educational benefit. (Id.)

The standard for determining if the program provided the Student a FAPE involves consideration of the following factors: whether the placement and services were designed to address Student’s unique needs, were reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit, and conformed to his IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, 458 U.S. 176.) (Footnote 9)

The Student contends that from October 21, 1999 through the end of the 1999-2000 school year, the SDCOE and CCS denied him a FAPE because there were no direct OT and PT services. The Student further contends that SDCOE failed to provide him instruction from an appropriately credentialed teacher, a one-on-one aide in the classroom, assistive technology, and direct SP/L services. The Student further asserts that procedural violations were committed because the IEP document was prepared prior to the IEP meeting and discussions regarding his placement occurred outside the presence of the surrogate parent. The Student contends that during the IEP meeting, there were no assessors present and there was no discussion of CCS-related services.

SDCOE and CCS contend that they provided Student with a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year. Further, SDCOE contends that Conservator 1 was Student’s teacher during the entire school year, wrote and prepared the IEP documents, utilized the services of the CCS consultants, and never requested, in her capacity as a teacher and representative of Friendship School, and the provision of related services on a direct basis or a one-on-one classroom aide.

Student’s annual IEP meetings were held every year in February or early March, near the time of his birthday. Therefore, when Student began the 1999-2000 school year, his February 1999 IEP was still in effect through February 2000. In February 2000, Student’s annual IEP meeting was held and his placement and services changed very minimally.

Substantive Requirements--

Was Student’s placement designed to meet his unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

Before it can be determined if Student’s placement was designed to meet his unique needs, it is important to first determine what his unique needs were at the time. There is no dispute that Student has multiple severe disabilities and that his unique needs have changed minimally since 1999. He has cerebral palsy, hypotonia, profound mental retardation, orthopedic impairments, and a seizure disorder. Student is significantly delayed in multiple areas of development and has needs in the areas of communication, gross motor, fine motor, and self-help.

Student’s cerebral palsy with hypotonia causes decreased muscle tone and increased contracting of the muscles. He also is profoundly mentally retarded with a cognitive functioning level between six months and fifteen months old. Due to his cognitive limitations, Student’s ability to learn is minimal. He also is non-verbal and needs to develop a basic communication system so that he can express preferences and make consistent choices. He uses a wheelchair but can maneuver himself around through the use of a gait trainer. He has some ability to assist in transferring himself from his wheelchair to the toilet. There is no dispute that his main areas of need in 1999 were communication, gross and fine motor skills, and self-help.

October 21, 1999 through February 24, 2000

During the 1999-2000 school year, Student was placed in Conservator 1’s SDC class at the Friendship School. He began the school year with his February 1999 IEP in effect. His placement included nursing and speech and language consultations from staff at the Friendship School and OT and PT consultations from CCS. He participated with non-disabled children during outings and special events and had goals in the areas of communication, cognition, fine and gross motor, and computer and leisure.

Conservator 1, on behalf of Student, contends that SDCOE and CCS did not provide him a FAPE from October 21, 1999 through February 24, 2000 because there were no direct OT and PT services. She further contends that SDCOE failed to provide a properly credentialed teacher, a one-on-one classroom aide, assistive technology, and direct SP/L services. Conservator 1 also testified that she had determined in February 2000 that Student had met his goals and objectives from the February 1999 IEP.

Direct OT services

The Student contends that he should have received direct OT services from a credentialed occupational therapist within the classroom. The Student contends if he had received direct OT rather than just consultation services from CCS, he would be able to walk today. In response, SDCOE contends that Student received the appropriate amount of OT service within the school setting. CCS contends that because Student is so low functioning cognitively, he would not have benefited from direct OT services. Further, CCS contends that due to his cognitive functioning and his hypotonia, Student would not be able to walk today even if he had been provided direct OT services.

In February 1999, Conservator 1 wrote Student’s IEP document and indicated on the IEP that CCS would provide OT on a consult basis. She testified that she developed the fine and gross motor goals and objectives based on her experience and there was no objection regarding the appropriateness of those goals and objectives at the IEP meeting. Conservator 1 testified that she took a class in occupational therapy and participated in many OT trainings while in Florida. She testified that her “extensive trainings were helpful in writing the goals.” Conservator 1 also testified that she sought consultation from the CCS occupational therapist when problems arose, which occurred a few times a year and more frequently after Student had surgeries. Conservator 1 also testified that she consulted with CCS regarding feedings.

Conservator 1’s testimony in this regard was supported by the testimony of Student’s occupational therapist from CCS, Patricia Bernens. Ms. Bernens has been working with Student since 1991, before his placement at Friendship School. In September 1999, Ms. Bernens wrote a summary of progress report and developed several goals and objectives for Conservator 1 and the staff at Friendship School and Friendship Home to implement in Student’s classroom and home environment, in addition to the goals and objectives that Conservator 1 developed for his IEP. During the 1999-2000 school year, Ms. Bernens provided at least two consultations in which she gave written instructions to Conservator 1 for treatment within the classroom. Ms. Bernens testified that she worked on functional skills within the classroom environment. Ms. Bernens testified that during the 1999-2000 school year, there were no “real changes” in his abilities; but that, Student became more reliable in toileting after his spinal fusion surgery in December 1998. She testified that Conservator 1 was a proactive teacher and would call her whenever there was a problem. She further testified that at no time during the school year did Conservator 1 request additional direct services from CCS and that had she requested additional services, Student’s doctor would have evaluated him further. Ms. Bernens persuasively testified that Student would not have benefited from direct OT services. She testified that direct services multiple times a week is only beneficial if a child is able to make changes, and that Student’s cognitive levels, alertness, inconsistency, and hypotonia made change unlikely for Student. She added that a therapist cannot make him change if he is unable.

Ms. Bernens’ testimony in this regard was supported by the testimony of Dr. Henry Chambers. Dr. Chambers, chief of staff of San Diego Children’s Hospital and a pediatric orthopedic surgeon, has been working with Student since 1992. Dr. Chambers testified that he is the only orthopedic surgeon in San Diego County and one of forty physicians in the country that works with children and young adults who have cerebral palsy. He is on the board of directors of nine different medical boards including United Cerebral Palsy of San Diego and the American Academy for Cerebral Palsy and Developmental Disorders. Dr. Chambers is also an associate professor at the University of California, San Diego. Dr. Chambers has had thirty-five journal articles published and has given hundreds of presentations around the world at conferences, universities, and San Diego forums on the topics of cerebral palsy and orthopedic surgery. Dr. Chambers is a consulting physician for Friendship School and works with CCS to write the prescription for services required by CCS to provide OT and PT services to children.

Dr. Chambers has evaluated Student one to two times a year and has performed two back surgeries on Student since 1992. Dr. Chambers has participated in Student’s medical therapy unit (MTU) meetings at the Friendship Home one to two times a year since Student’s placement. (Footnote 10) Dr. Chambers testified that Student would not be able to walk today if he had had direct services because his cognitive functioning is too low and his hypotonia is too severe for him to have made progress. He explained in his testimony that it is the role of the occupational therapist to develop functional OT goals for Student that can be implemented in the classroom and on the school campus by all the staff.

The Student offered no contrary evidence regarding the provision of direct OT services. Therefore, based on the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer is persuaded by Ms. Bernens and Dr. Chambers that Student did not need direct OT services and that OT services on a consult basis was designed to meet his unique needs. Further, Conservator 1 acknowledged that she was well trained in developing goals and objectives in the area of OT and felt that the goals and objectives were appropriate when she wrote them. Therefore, Student’s placement with respect to OT was designed to meet his unique OT needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit from October 21, 1999 through February 24, 2000.

Direct PT services

The Student contends that he required direct physical therapy from a credentialed physical therapist in the classroom and that had he received direct PT, he would be able to walk today. In response, SDCOE contends that PT on a consult basis was appropriate to meet Student’s unique needs. CCS contends that because Student is so low functioning cognitively and due to his hypotonia, he would not have benefitted from direct PT services nor would he be able to walk today.

In February 1999, Student’s IEP indicated that he was receiving a month of direct physical therapy due to his spinal fusion surgery. Cathy Cortney, CCS physical therapist, testified that she provided Student with six months of direct services during the spring and summer of 1999 in her office and at the Friendship School and Friendship Home. She testified that the program at the home included two to three months of electro therapy performed five days a week. (Footnote 11) Ms. Cortney indicated that by August 1999, Student had made no functional change after six months of intensive services and she determined that Student needed the consultative model of services. Therefore, during the 1999-2000 school year, Student received PT services from CCS on a consultative basis per his IEP and his prescription from Dr. Chambers for PT.

Additionally, Conservator 1 wrote goals and objectives in the area of PT. Conservator 1 testified that she developed the goals based on her extensive training in the area of PT and that there was no dispute at the February 1999 IEP meeting regarding the appropriateness of the PT goals and objectives. Conservator 1 also testified that she would call the physical therapist from CCS if she had any questions. Ms. Cortney testified that she met with Conservator 1 and Student to work on appropriate activities in the classroom environment but that direct PT services were not medically necessary. Ms. Cortney testified that it was more important to incorporate functional skills into Student’s daily routine and to assist Student through repetition.

Dr. Chambers also testified that Student would not have benefited from direct PT because he was too weak and needed strengthening exercises; however, Student did not have the cognitive ability to cooperate. Dr. Chambers testified that Student could not move an object nor did he have the balance to participate in the strengthening exercises. Dr. Chambers testified that Student has such profound weakness due to his hypotonia and cerebral palsy (CP) that he lacks control over his muscles.

The Student bases his contention that he would have been able to walk with the provision of direct PT services on a privately obtained assessment by Dr. Ardith Williams-Meyers in September 2003. Dr. Meyers is a physical therapy professor at Azusa Pacific University (APU). Dr. Williams-Meyers indicated in her assessment and testimony that had Student been receiving ongoing direct PT throughout his educational career, he would be able to walk today. She based her conclusion on two evaluations of Student during which she spent a total of ten hours reviewing documents (an old psychological evaluation from “when Student was young,” PT and OT reports from CCS, and the February 2003 IEP), interviewing the conservators, and observing Student in her physical therapy center at APU. Dr. Williams-Meyers did not review Student’s medical records or talk with his doctor or Ms. Bernens. Dr. Williams-Meyers relied heavily on Conservator 1’s reports of Student’s abilities and Conservator 1’s assistance during the observation.

Dr. Williams-Meyers relied on several studies in reaching her conclusion; however, from both her testimony and Dr. Chamber’s testimony, the Hearing Officer was informed that Dr. Williams-Meyers misquoted the studies. Dr. Williams-Meyers relied on a study conducted by doctors Mulnar and Gordon. Dr. Williams-Meyers stated in her assessment that, “other studies by Molnar and Gordon and Shapiro et al, found that decreased mental ability does not prevent a child from learning to walk.” In their study, Doctors Mulnar and Gordon evaluated the probability of ambulation of children with cerebral palsy. They observed 233 children over many years. Only two of the children observed had hypotonia and neither child was ever able to walk. The doctors also concluded “observations also suggest that the presence of mental retardation adversely affects ambulation.” (SDCOE Exh. 66.) Dr. Williams-Meyers also relied on a study by Dr. Shapiro, et al. (SDCOE Exh. 67.) This study charted 152 profoundly mentally retarded children and its effect on walking. The study divided the children into six different categories. In Student’s category, profound retardation with cerebral palsy, only eleven percent of the population ever walked after receiving years of PT.

The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the testimony of Ms. Cortney, Dr. Chambers, and Conservator 1 that Student’s placement and services regarding PT were designed to meet his unique needs from October 21, 1999 through February 24, 2000. Conservator 1 developed appropriate PT goals and objectives and utilized the consultative-based services from CCS. Further, Student had received direct PT services for the six months prior to the 1999-2000 school year and made no progress in his functional skills during that time. The Hearing Officer was not persuaded by Dr. Williams-Meyers. Her recommendations were based on an inaccurate reading of a study, minimal observations, and a lack of information from those working with Student. She relied almost exclusively on the history and statements provided by Conservator 1. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s PT program was designed to meet his unique PT needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit from October 21, 1999 through February 24, 2000.

Qualifications of teacher

The Student contends that Conservator 1 lacked the necessary training and education to provide him services because she was not properly credentialed to work with students who were orthopedically impaired. The Student contends that Conservator 1 required a physical and health impairments (PHI) credential in accordance with California Education Code section 44265.5.

Conservator 1 testified that she has a master’s degree in special education, a multiple subject credential, and a moderate to severe specialist credential. She received her bachelor’s of science degree in special education and regular education in 1978 from the City University of New York, Brooklyn Teacher’s College. She has worked with the severely handicapped, autistic, and blind. In New York, she worked with speech and language therapists, occupational therapists, and physical therapists. She helped students develop communication systems and designed communication boards. In 1982, she moved to Florida and worked as a developmental specialist. Conservator 1 conducted assessments in conjunction with speech and language therapists, occupational therapists, and physical therapists. In 1987, Conservator 1 began working at Friendship School. In 1992, she received her master’s degree in special education in the areas of severely, visually, and physically handicapped and mental retardation.

Conservator 1 also testified regarding her qualifications to teach Student. She testified that in addition to her master’s degree in special education for the severely handicapped and her teaching credentials, she has worked with various populations who had OT, PT, and SP/L needs. She also worked closely with occupational therapists, physical therapists, and speech and language therapists to provide services to students when she lived in Florida. She testified that she took many classes and workshops in OT, PT, and SP/L and that she had “extensive” training that helped her write goals. Conservator 1 testified that when she did not know “enough about muscles,” she would consult CCS providers.

California Education Code section 44265.5 requires that pupils who are orthopedically impaired be taught by teachers whose professional preparation and credential authorization are specific to “that impairment.” According to California Commission on Teaching Credentialing, Leaflet Number CL-808C, a moderate/severe credential enables a teacher to work with students with autism, deafness and blindness, moderate to severe mental retardation, multiple disabilities, and serious emotional disturbance. The credential also authorizes services in grades kindergarten through twelve and in classes primarily for adults through age twenty-two. Leaflet Number CL-808C provides that a PHI credential enables a teacher to work with students with orthopedic impairments, other health impairments, multiple disabilities, and traumatic brain injury and authorizes services to individuals ages birth through twenty-two.

Although Conservator 1 does not have a credential specific to teach orthopedically impaired students, she does have a moderate to severe credential that enables her to teach mentally retarded and multiply handicapped students such as Student. Additionally, Conservator 1 testified that she has “extensive training” in the area of OT and PT. California Education Code section 44265.5 does not specifically state that a teacher must possess a PHI credential; rather, a teacher must have professional preparation and a credential authorization specific to the child’s impairment. Student suffers from many impairments, including mental retardation, multiple handicaps, and orthopedic impairments. Student’s teacher must be qualified by both professional experience and have a credential specific to his impairments. Conservator 1 testified that she has extensive professional experience and she possesses a credential to teach mentally retarded and multiply handicapped students. She considered herself highly qualified to teach Student. The Hearing Officer finds that Conservator 1 was appropriately qualified to teach Student because she had a master’s degree in education in the area of severely handicapped and possessed a teaching credential to work with multiply handicapped and mentally retarded students. The Hearing Officer finds that Conservator 1’s qualifications were designed to meet Student’s unique needs and were reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit from October 21, 1999 through February 24, 2000.

One-on-one classroom aide

Student was placed in Conservator 1’s SDC. There was one full-time classroom aide and one part-time classroom aide, in addition to Conservator 1. There were approximately eight students in the class. Conservator 1 testified that she spent much time with Student because she felt he was higher functioning than the other students. She testified that when Student was in her class, he never went home with a dirty diaper, he was able to finish his lunch, and he interacted appropriately in her classroom. Conservator 1 testified that Student had tasks and chores in the classroom. According to Conservator 1, when he finished toileting, he would get a treat and he knew how to propel his wheelchair to the cabinet where the treats were; he was able to get assistance to help him take out the treats; and he was responsible for collecting the dishtowels and putting them in the cupboard.

Additionally, the February 1999 IEP indicated and Conservator 1 testified that Student had one-on-one activities within the classroom during which she or the aides would work with Student. PARENT testified that she worked with Student on sorting, matching, and vocabulary and that she developed a list of vocabulary words and numbers that Student was able to learn. Conservator 1 indicated on the IEP documents that she wrote in both February 1999 and 2000, “Student’s disability requires one-on-one teaching which is best met in a structured special day class setting.”

No evidence was presented that Student lacked appropriate attention or needed additional help during the 1999-2000 school year. To the contrary, Student was placed in a classroom with a low teacher-student ratio and was provided frequent individual attention by Conservator 1. Conservator 1 gave ample evidence that she provided for Student’s need for individual attention within the classroom. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Student did not need a one-on-one aide in the classroom and that his placement was designed to meet his unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit from October 21, 1999 through February 24, 2000.

Assistive Technology

The Student argued that he needed additional communication systems to access his education from October 21, 1999 through February 24, 2000. “Assistive technology service” means any service that directly assists an individual with exceptional needs in the selection or use of an assistive technology device that is educationally necessary. (Cal. Code of Regs. Title 5 § 3065(b)(1); see also, 34 Code of Fed. Reg. § 300.5) Code of Federal Regulations section 300.346(a)(2) requires that the IEP team consider whether the child requires assistive technology devices and services.

Student’s February 1999 IEP document indicates that Student utilized switches to operate computers, radios, tapes, and toys. He had a “big red switch” that operated the equipment either by turning it on and off or by switching screens on the computer programs. Conservator 1 testified that Student utilized the communication board that she developed for him to indicate choices, when he needed to use the restroom, or when he wanted to sit in his beanbag or go outside. He had goals and objectives to work on the computer with the switch and to utilize the communication board. In fact, she testified that she felt Student had met his February 1999 goals and objectives regarding the use of a switch and the use of his communication board by February 2000.

On the basis of the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that Student utilized assistive technology in the classroom, that he did not need additional assistive technology to access his education, and that his program was designed to meet his unique assistive technology needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit from October 21, 1999 through February 24, 2000.

Direct SP/L services

The Student contends that he should have received direct speech and language services from a credentialed speech and language therapist in the classroom. SDCOE contends that Student did not need additional direct SP/L therapy and that it provided Student with ongoing speech and language consultations.

In February 1999, Student’s IEP indicated that Student received on-going speech and language services at Friendship School. Student utilized a communication board that Conservator 1 created for him; he was producing some vocalizations and was beginning to use some expressive language. Conservator 1 also worked with Student on identifying large-print vocabulary words (approximately twenty words) and responding to directions. Conservator 1 developed several goals that were designed to maintain and increase Student’s communication skills.

The Student presented Susan Berkowitz as his expert in SP/L pathology. Ms. Berkowitz is a licensed speech and language pathologist and an educational consultant. She is a consultant for families and some school districts and also consults with the Cerebral Palsy Foundation in San Diego. At the request of the Student and his attorneys, she conducted a speech and language and augmentative communication assessment and prepared a report dated May 23, 2003. Ms. Berkowitz stated in her testimony that she believes that Student had a communication system when he was in Conservator 1’s classroom. She indicated that Student developed the ability to scan and differentiate symbols. Ms. Berkowitz testified that Student would slap at his communication board and that even though his open hand would hit several symbols, she understood which symbol he actually chose. She indicated that Student should receive direct SP/L services three times a week for thirty to forty-five minutes to address the regression he suffered when he was no longer in Conservator 1’s classroom. Also, Ms. Berkowitz testified that the speech and language pathologist should train all of Student’s educational providers so that his services can be implemented throughout the day.

In short, Ms. Berkowitz did not give any contradictory or negative testimony regarding Student’s communication program while he was in Conservator 1’s classroom. Anita Macy, who conducted a speech and language assessment of Student in 2003 and was a consultant at Friendship School in 1995-1996 school year, testified that the consultants regularly trained the classroom staff to implement a student’s communication program and that she had worked with Conservator 1 to assist in developing Student’s communication program during the 1995-1996 school year. Conservator 1 also testified regarding her extensive training in the area of speech and language and that she developed Student’s communication system based on her training.

No evidence was presented that Student’s communication system was inappropriate from October 21, 1999 through February 24, 2000. Conservator 1 convincingly testified that she carefully designed his communication board and worked extensively with him on a one-on-one basis. Ms. Berkowitz also testified that Student had an appropriate communication program while he was placed in Conservator 1 classroom. Therefore, based on all the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s speech and language program was designed to meet his unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit from October 21, 1999 through February 24, 2000.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s placement from October 21, 1999 through February 24, 2000 was designed to meet his unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit.

February 24, 2000 through the extended school year 2000

On February 24, 2000, Student’s annual IEP meeting was held. Most of the same IEP team members were present. Conservator 1 again prepared Student’s IEP draft document prior to the IEP meeting. The IEP document was virtually identical to Student’s February 1999 IEP with the exception that his sight vocabulary was listed as thirty words instead of twenty words. His placement and services did not change and all members of the IEP team agreed upon his IEP.

The Student continued to contend that SDCOE and CCS failed to provide him with direct OT and PT and that SDCOE failed to provide a qualified teacher, a one-on-one aide, appropriate assistive technology, and direct speech and language services. Because Student’s placement and services did not change from the previous IEP and the Hearing Officer has previously found that the February 1999 IEP was designed to meet his unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, the Hearing Officer finds that the February 24, 2000 IEP also was designed to meet Student’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provided educational benefit.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s placement during the 1999-2000 school year was designed to meet his unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.

Did Student’s placement conform to his IEP?

There is no dispute that the IEPs were implemented during the 1999-2000 school year as agreed upon by all parties in February 1999 and February 2000.

Procedural Safeguards--

The Student contends that SDCOE and CCS committed procedural violations because the surrogate parent was unable to fully participate in the IEP process. The Student asserts that there were discussions regarding Student’s placement and services outside the presence of the surrogate parent and that the IEP was pre-written prior to the IEP meeting. Additionally, during the IEP meeting, the Student contends that there was a failure to discuss services by CCS and there were no assessors present. SDCOE and CCS contend that no procedural violations that denied Student a FAPE were committed during the 1999-2000 school year.

The Supreme Court in Rowley recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. (458 U.S. at 205.) States are required to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each child with a disability receives the FAPE to which he or she is entitled and that the parents are involved in the formulation of the child’s educational placement. (W.G. v. Bd. Of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992).) Not every procedural flaw constitutes a denial of FAPE, but procedural violations that result in loss of educational opportunity to the child or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process may constitute a denial of FAPE. (W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).)

Accordingly, the analysis of whether a student has been provided a FAPE in the LRE is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to decide whether the proposed placement is substantively appropriate and whether procedural steps have been followed. (Rowley, at 206-207.)

In regards to the procedural violations allegedly committed prior to the IEP meeting, Conservator 1 wrote the draft IEP documents for Student prior to the IEP meetings, per school regulations. Conservator 1 testified that the school principal, Mr. Gallegos, directed her to prepare the draft IEP prior to all IEP meetings for all of her students. She testified that she started preparing the IEP documents about three weeks prior to the IEP meetings and worked very hard, but she also testified that she copied the previous IEP documents.

The law imposes on school districts an obligation to ensure that parents of a child with a disability are members of any group that makes decisions about the educational placement of their child (34 C.F.R. § 300.501(c)(1)), but allows school district personnel to engage in preparatory activities to develop a proposal that will be discussed at a later IEP meeting. (34 C.F.R. § 300.501(b)(2).) Additionally, school district personnel may come to an IEP meeting prepared with evaluation findings and proposed recommendations regarding IEP content as long as they make it clear to the parents at the outset of the meeting that the services proposed by the District are only recommendations for review and discussion with the parents. (34 C.F.R. Part 300 Appendix A, Q.32.) The evidence demonstrated that SDCOE acted within these guidelines when it made its proposal for the Student’s educational placement for the 1999-2000 school year. Mr. Gallegos and Conservator 1 persuasively testified that the IEPs were routinely prepared prior to the IEP meetings as recommendations but that the placement and services could be altered during the IEP meetings. Additionally, there was no evidence that SDCOE and CCS personnel engaged in impermissible discussions outside the presence of the surrogate parent.

Regarding procedural violations allegedly committed during the IEP meetings in February 1999 and February 2000, Conservator 1 contends that there were no discussions regarding CCS services even though CCS consultation was listed on all IEP documents. California Education Code section 60310(c)(4) requires the county to provide ten-day notice of all IEP meetings to the CCS agency providing medically necessary services. Further, under Government Code section 7572(e), if a CCS provider cannot be present, at an IEP meeting then written reports must be provided and CCS should participate by way of a conference call. If CCS was not able to participate in the IEP meeting, then the SDCOE was to ensure that a qualified substitute was available to explain and interpret the evaluation. Mr. Gallegos testified that CCS was sent proper notification of the IEP meetings ten days in advance and that the IEP team had access to all CCS reports that had been received throughout the school year and MTU meeting reports from Friendship Home at the time of the IEP meetings. No evidence was presented that members of the IEP team did not understand the CCS guidelines and in fact, Conservator 1 took advantage of the consultations and contacted Ms. Cortney and Ms. Bernens.

Further, Ms. Bernens testified that she presented her OT progress report and Student’s OT goals and objectives on August 30, 1999 for the 1999-2000 school year. Ms. Cortney testified that she presented Conservator 1 with notes on Student’s PT program the day before his February 1999 IEP and did a follow-up progress report six months later that was presented to Conservator 1 and the school staff in August 1999. The next PT progress report occurred in August 2000, so the February 2000 IEP team did not have access to that information. Although no CCS provider was present at either the February 1999 or 2000 IEP meetings, the Hearing Officer finds that no formal evaluations were conducted that required interpretation by a CCS representative during the 1999-2000 school year. However, even if a CCS representative was required at the IEP meetings, this procedural flaw did not equate to a loss in educational opportunity. (See, W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).) The IEP team had full access to all of Student’s CCS documents at the time of the IEP team meetings. As previously found above, he did not require direct OT and PT services from CCS to substantively receive a FAPE.

The Student also contends that no assessors were present at the IEP meetings in February 1999 and February 2000; however, there were no assessments conducted prior to either IEP meeting. Additionally, Conservator 1 testified that she wrote the goals and objectives based on her own in-class assessments and she was present at each IEP meeting. California Education Code section 56341(b)(5) requires an individual who conducted the assessment or is knowledgeable about the assessment be present at the IEP team meeting. However, in this case no assessors were required at either IEP team meeting because no assessments occurred during the relevant time periods,

The Student presented no evidence that procedural violations were committed that resulted in loss of educational opportunity or severely infringed on the surrogate parent’s right to meaningful participation in the IEP process at either the February 1999 or February 2000 IEP meetings. Based on all the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that no procedural violations occurred from October 21, 1999 through the 1999-2000 school year that denied Student a FAPE.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered and provided Student a FAPE from October 21, 1999 through the 1999-2000 school year.

2. Did the SDCOE and CCS offer and/or provide a FAPE to Student during the 2000-2001 school year?

As set forth above, the standard for determining whether the program provided the Student a FAPE involves consideration of the following factors: whether the placement and services were designed to address Student’s unique needs, were reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit, and conformed to his IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, 458 U.S. 176.)

The Student contends that during the 2000-2001 school year, SDCOE and CCS failed to provide direct OT and PT services and SDCOE failed to provide a properly credentialed teacher, a one-on-one aide in the classroom, appropriate assistive technology, and direct SP/L services. The Student further asserts that procedural violations were committed because the IEP documents were prepared prior to the IEP meetings and discussions regarding his placement occurred outside the presence of the surrogate parent. The Student contends that during the IEP meeting, there were no assessors present and there was no discussion of CCS-related services.

SDCOE and CCS contend that they provided Student with a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year. Further, SDCOE contends that Conservator 1 was Student’s teacher during the entire school year, she wrote and prepared the IEP documents, utilized the services of CCS consultations, and never asked for direct services or a one-on-one aide.

Substantive Requirements—

Was Student’s placement designed to meet his unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

September 2000 through February 20, 2001

Student continued to be placed in Conservator 1’s special day class during the 2000-2001 school year. His IEP from February 2000 continued to be in effect through February 2001 when his annual/triennial IEP meeting was held. As previously found above, Student’s IEP dated February 24, 2000 was designed to meet his unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit in the areas of communication, gross motor, fine motor, and self-help. Student’s needs did not change as he entered the 2000-2001 school year; therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s February 2000 IEP continued to be designed to meet his unique needs and to be reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit from September through February 20, 2001.

February 20, 2001 through the ESY 2001

The Student continued to contend that SDCOE and CCS failed to provide him with direct OT and PT and that SDCOE failed to provide a qualified teacher, a one-on-one aide, appropriate assistive technology, and direct speech and language services. SDCOE and CCS continued to contend that Student was provided a FAPE that was designed to meet his unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.

In January and February 2001, SDCOE conducted a multidisciplinary assessment for Student. Conservator 1, school psychologist Jorge Ley, and Ms. Tabor participated in the assessment. The team determined that Student continued to be profoundly mentally retarded and required intensive assistance in all areas of daily living. Test results indicated that he functioned at a behavioral age of eight months. The assessment team determined that Student continued to require an SDC; he continued to need a variety of auditory stimuli (including spoken language and music) and high contrast visual stimuli (including bright light in a darkened room, high contrast color, and reflective materials). The team determined that he was continuing to develop awareness of cause and effect relationships. The team determined that Student needed to expand his fine and gross motor skills, increase his mobility by utilizing the gait trainer, maintain and increase his cognitive skills, and improve his ability to activate switches. Student’s needs continued to be in the areas of communication, gross motor, fine motor, and self-help.

On February 20, 2001, Student’s IEP team convened and developed his IEP based on the results of his multidisciplinary assessment. Present at the meeting were Conservator 1, Mr. Gallegos, Ms. Tabor, CCS occupational therapist Ms. Bernens, San Diego Regional Center representative Kimberly Spangler, Student’s qualified mental retardation specialist (QMRP)/care provider from Friendship Homes, and Ms. Wellman, Student’s surrogate parent. Conservator 1 again prepared the draft IEP document prior to the IEP meeting and indicated that Student’s present levels of performance were identical to those noted in his previous IEP, with the exception that Student could recognize thirty-five sight words. Conservator 1 wrote out the goals and objectives based on the multidisciplinary assessment, Student’s present levels of performance, and his progress on previous goals and objectives.

As found above, Conservator 1 was properly credentialed to meet Student’s needs. Furthermore, there was no dispute or disagreement by any member of Student’s IEP team that his program was inappropriate or that he required additional services in assistive technology, OT, PT, or SP/L, or that he needed a one-on-one aide. The consensus of the meeting was that Student needed to work on his functional skills in communication, fine and gross motor, and cognition. Student continued to work on his goals and objectives and continued to make minimal progress in all areas due to his low cognition and muscle control. (Footnote 12) Student increased his vocabulary recognition by two words over the time frame. Although the Student contends that he needed the additional services to meet his unique needs, he presented no additional evidence beyond what was argued for the previous school year. Additionally, Student underwent a comprehensive multidisciplinary assessment and the assessment found no significant changes in his unique needs. The Hearing Officer finds that based on the previous findings and the evidence from February 20, 2001 through the ESY 2001, Student’s placement was designed to meet his unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.

Did Student’s placement and services conform to his IEP?

There is no dispute that Student’s IEPs were implemented during the 2000-2001 school year as agreed upon by all parties in February 2000 and February 2001.

Procedural Safeguards –

The Student contends that SDCOE and CCS committed procedural violations that denied him a FAPE because the surrogate parent was unable to fully participate in the IEP process. The Student asserts that there were discussions regarding Student’s placement and services without the surrogate parent and the IEPs were written prior to the IEP meetings. Additionally, during the IEP meeting, the Student contends that there was a failure to discuss services by CCS and there were no assessors present.

SDCOE and CCS contend that no procedural violations were committed during the 2000-2001 school year that denied Student a FAPE.

As set forth above, states are required to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each child with a disability receives the FAPE to which he or she is entitled and that the parents are involved in the formulation of the child’s educational placement. (W.G. v. Bd. Of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992).) In regards to the procedural violations allegedly committed prior to the IEP meeting, Conservator 1 testified that she wrote the draft IEP documents for Student prior to the IEP meetings, per school regulations. Conservator 1 testified that the school principal, Mr. Gallegos, directed her to prepare the draft IEP prior to all IEP meetings for all of her students. In January 2001, Student underwent a multidisciplinary assessment prior to his IEP meeting and his placement and services were discussed in preparation for his triennial/annual review in February 2001. As set forth above, the law allows school district personnel to engage in preparatory activities prior to the IEP meeting. (See 34 C.F.R. § 501.) Mr. Gallegos and Conservator 1 persuasively testified that the IEPs were routinely prepared prior to the IEP meetings as recommendations but that the placement and services could be altered during the IEP meetings. Additionally, there was no evidence that SDCOE and CCS personnel engaged in impermissible discussions outside the presence of the surrogate parent.

In regards to the Student’s contentions that procedural violations were committed during the IEP meeting, the Student alleges that there was no discussion regarding OT and PT services provided by CCS. However, Ms. Bernens, Student’s occupational therapist from CCS testified that she was present and participated in the February 2001 IEP meeting as a representative of CCS.

The Student also contends that no assessors were present at the IEP meeting to answer any questions or concerns. In regards to Student’s February 2001 IEP meeting, a multidisciplinary assessment had been conducted prior to the IEP meeting. Conservator 1, Ms. Tabor, and Mr. Ley conducted the assessment. Conservator 1 and Ms. Tabor were present at the IEP meeting in February 2001 to review the assessment with the team. California Education Code section 56341(b)(5) requires that the person who conducted the assessment or a person who is knowledgeable about the assessment results and is able to interpret the instructional implications of the assessment be present at the meeting. The individual can be the teacher or administrator if that person is able to interpret the results. Conservator 1 and Ms. Tabor both conducted the assessment being reviewed and were present and knowledgeable about the assessment. Conservator 1 testified that when she was in Florida, she was hired as a developmental specialist to conduct assessments of children. She testified that she conducted approximately 150 assessments of severely handicapped children who required OT, PT, and SP/L services. Conservator 1 also was part of the assessment team for all her students at Friendship School where she has been employed since 1987. Conservator 1 testified that when new children were placed in her classroom, she would observe the child and then conduct assessments in the classroom. She utilized those assessments to develop the student’s goals and objectives. The Hearing Officer finds that Conservator 1 both conducted the assessment in conjunction with Mr. Ley and was qualified to interpret the results based on over twenty years of experience in assessments.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that no procedural violations were committed during the 2000-2001 school year.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that Student was provided a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year.

3. Did the SDCOE and CCS offer and/or provide a FAPE to Student during the 2001-2002 school year?

As set forth above, the standard for determining whether the program provided the Student a FAPE involves consideration of the following factors: whether the placement and services were designed to address Student’s unique needs, were reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit, and conformed to his IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, 458 U.S. 176.)

The Student contends that during the 2001-2002 school year, the SDCOE and CCS denied him a FAPE because there were no direct OT and PT services and that the SDCOE failed to provide properly qualified teachers, a one-on-one aide in the classroom, appropriate assistive technology, and direct SP/L services. The Student further asserts that procedural violations were committed because the IEPs documents were prepared prior to the IEP meetings and discussions regarding his placement occurred outside the presence of the surrogate parent. The Student contends that during the IEP meetings, there were no assessors present and there was no discussion of CCS-related services.

In March 2002, Student was transferred to Ms. Button’s SDC classroom. The Student contends that the transition from Conservator 1’s class to Ms. Button’s was inappropriate. The Student further contends that he was denied a full day of instruction, an opportunity to socialize with nondisabled peers, and the use of his communication board in accordance with his IEP goals and objectives. The Student also contends that he received improper personal care because there was no set time to finish lunch, he was placed on the floor without cushions following his surgery, he had improper toileting, and his medication was delivered inappropriately. The Student also contends that the goals and objectives introduced on May 24, 2002, were inappropriate and that the IEP team failed to consider independent assessments.

SDCOE and CCS contend that they provided Student with a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year. Further, SDCOE contends that Conservator 1 was Student’s teacher from the start of the school year through February 2002, and that she wrote and prepared the IEP document, utilized the services of CCS consultations, and never asked for direct services or a one-on-one aide. SDCOE contends that when Student was placed in Ms. Button’s class in March 2002, Student continued to receive a FAPE. SDCOE also contends that it offered an appropriate placement and goals and objectives at the May 24, 2002 IEP meeting. CCS contends that it provided the appropriate level of medically necessary OT and PT within the classroom environment during the 2001-2002 school year.

Student began his school year with his February 2001 IEP still in effect. He continued his placement in Conservator 1’s SDC class through February 2002. In February 2002, SDCOE held Student’s annual IEP meeting. Shortly after the IEP meeting, Student was transferred out of Conservator 1’s class into Ms. Button’s class because he had aged out of Conservator 1’s class and because the court had appointed her and her husband as Student’s conservators when he turned eighteen years old.

Prior to Student’s transfer, Ms. Button observed Student on several occasions in Conservator 1’s class. She had just been hired on an emergency credential, per Conservator 1’s encouragement and recommendation. Ms. Button had been a staff member at the Friendship Home. Ms. Button had eight students in her class, plus a full-time classroom aide and a part-time classroom aide. After Student was transferred into her class, Ms. Button and Mr. Gallegos testified that Conservator 1 went into Ms. Button’s classroom at any opportunity she had. After about two months of her constant presence, Ms. Button complained to Mr. Gallegos about the frequency of Conservator 1’s visits. A new policy was developed whereby Conservator 1 was required to make an appointment to visit and sign in whenever she visited. However, based on testimony and documentary evidence, Conservator 1 thereafter continued to enter Ms. Button’s classroom without an appointment and without signing in.

Additionally, Ms. Button testified that she and her aides attempted to implement Student’s IEP as it was written; however, after about a month it became obvious to the staff that Student was not as verbal as Conservator 1 had previously indicated. Ms. Button testified that he could not recognize his vocabulary words and was unable to consistently use his communication board. Therefore, SDCOE determined it was necessary to convene an IEP team meeting, which was held on May 24 and 30, 2002. Student was offered the same placement but his goals and objectives were modified based on his present levels of performance.

Because there are three distinct time frames at issue--September 2001 through February 2002, March 2002 through May 30, 2002, and May 30, 2002 through the extended school year--the Hearing Officer will analyze Student’s school year accordingly.

Substantive Requirements—

Was Student’s placement designed to meet his unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

The Student continued to contend that during the 2001-2002 school year, the SDCOE and CCS denied him a FAPE because there were no direct OT and PT services and that the SDCOE failed to provide properly qualified teachers, a one-on-one aide in the classroom, appropriate assistive technology, and direct SP/L services. Student’s unique needs continued to be in the areas of communication, cognition, fine and gross motor, and self-help.

September 2001 through February 2002

Student continued to be placed in Conservator 1’s special day class from September 2001 through February 2002. His IEP from February 2001 continued to be in effect through February 2002 when his annual IEP meeting was held. As previously found above, Student’s IEP dated February 20, 2001 was designed to meet his unique needs. Additionally, the Hearing Officer previously found Conservator 1 to be properly credentialed to teach Student. No evidence was presented that any of his needs changed significantly prior to February 2002; therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s placement and services were designed to meet his unique needs and were reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit from September 2001 through February 2002.

March 2002 through May 30, 2002

The Student contends that when Student was transferred to Ms. Button’s classroom in March 2002, he continued to be denied direct OT and PT from SDCOE and CCS and that SDCOE failed to provide him a properly credentialed teacher, an appropriate transition from Conservator 1’s classroom to Ms. Button’s classroom, a full day of instruction, a one-on-one aide in the classroom, appropriate assistive technology, and direct SP/L services from March 2002 through May 30, 2002.

SDCOE and CCS contend that Student was provided an appropriate placement and services that were designed to meet his unique needs and that were reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit from March 2002 through May 30, 2002.

In March 2002, Student was transferred to Ms. Button’s SDC, which consisted of six other multiply handicapped students, one full-time classroom aide, and one part-time classroom aide. He continued his placement and services as set forth in his February 27, 2002 IEP. His goals and objectives were in the areas of communication, cognition, fine and gross motor, and self-help.

Direct OT services

The Student contends that he required direct OT services from a credentialed occupational therapist. Student was provided OT services on a consultative basis through CCS. Ms. Bernens, Student’s occupational therapist since 1991, testified that she developed an OT plan in March 2002 and gave that to the staff working with Student in Ms. Button’s classroom. She worked with the staff to help Student with functional skills such as putting his arm through his sleeve, feeding, positioning on the toilet, grooming, hygiene, and positioning within the wheelchair. Ms. Bernens testified that all of these skills were best practiced throughout his day, rather than through direct services. Ms. Bernens testified that even if Student had received direct services multiple times a week, his low cognitive levels, inconsistency, lack of alertness, and hypotonia would not have allowed him to “make change” and that direct services are only useful when a child is able to “make change.” His services were designed to assist him with daily functional skills.

Dr. Chambers’ testimony was consistent with that of Ms. Bernens. He also testified that Student did not have the ability to make progress with direct services and that direct services have been a waste of time and money. According to Dr. Chambers, Student was able to benefit more from constantly having his OT services reinforced throughout his day.

The Student did not submit any contrary evidence regarding the level of necessary OT services; therefore, on the basis of the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer is persuaded by the testimony of Dr. Chambers, Ms. Bernens, and Ms. Button that Student did not require direct OT from a credentialed occupational therapist. The Hearing Officer finds that Student’s level of OT services was designed to meet his unique OT needs and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.

Direct PT services

The Student contends that he required direct PT services from a credentialed physical therapist. The Student based his contention on the testimony of Dr. Williams-Meyers whose testimony and assessment indicated that Student would have been able to walk had he received direct PT services throughout his educational career.

Student received PT on a consult basis from CCS. Student had gross motor equipment and a gait trainer to scoot around the room. Cathy Cortney, Student’s physical therapist from CCS, worked with the staff in Ms. Button’s room to help Student work on his range of motion, strengthening, transferring, and sitting. Ms. Cortney explained that she worked on his equipment needs and on physical activities that the staff could do with Student. Ms. Cortney testified that she wrote out a program of services and gave that to Ms. Button to work with Student. Further, Ms. Cortney explained that CCS works very closely with Friendship School and that they monitor all the students one time per month.

Ms. Cortney testified that her role was to monitor Student’s supports and services one time per month, support class programming, and to be available on request from his teacher. She testified that she believes that Student received the appropriate level of PT supports and services and that she would not have recommended increasing the level of PT services because Student did not have the potential to reach new milestones such as walking independently. Dr. Chambers’ testimony was also consistent with Ms. Cortney. Dr. Chambers testified that he wrote Student’s prescription for the level of services and would have prescribed direct services, if he had believed Student needed that level.

The Hearing Officer finds that SDCOE provided Student the appropriate level of PT services between March and May 2002. As previously found above, Dr. Williams-Meyers testimony was both unconvincing and not based on a complete understanding of Student’s needs. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by Ms. Cortney and Dr. Chambers that Student did not need direct PT services, and that the level of PT services he received was designed to meet his unique PT needs and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.

Qualifications of teacher

The Student contends that Ms. Button only had an emergency teaching credential and was not properly credentialed to teach a severely mentally and physically disabled student. SDCOE contends that Ms. Button was appropriately qualified to teach Student.

Ms. Button was hired to work at Friendship School in February 2002. Conservator 1 encouraged her to apply and sat on her interview panel. Prior to her work at Friendship School, Ms. Button worked for eight years with severely disabled children and adults in various care-taking capacities, including three years as a qualified mental retardation professional (QMRP) for Friendship Home. Ms. Button obtained her emergency teaching credential in February 2002 to teach moderately to severely disabled children. She does not hold a clear California teaching credential. The California Code of Regulations section 3001 defines a teaching credential as a valid credential to teach issued by the State Board of Education. The Code does not specifically define emergency credential. Ms. Button was issued the emergency credential by the State of California under the supervision of Gene Gallegos and her professors at National University where she was seeking a master’s in special education. (Footnote 13) The Student’s attorneys argue in their closing brief that Ms. Button requires an additional specialty to teach orthopedically impaired students under California Education Code section 44265.5. However, Ms. Button did have a credential to work with multiply handicapped students such as Student. Further, Ms. Button testified that she had worked for approximately eight years prior to her employment with Friendship School with severely disabled children and adults. She worked for approximately three years at the Friendship Home as a QMRP, coordinating services for 25-50 multiply handicapped residents and working with the service providers. She also oversaw the training and development of the certified nursing assistants who worked directly with the residents. Ms. Button also coordinated a weekly wheelchair clinic and participated in wheelchair assessments. Prior to her work at Friendship Home, Ms. Button worked for approximately one year each at four different facilities that provided services for day and residential treatment programs for adults with multiple disabilities. Ms. Button also provided services under the instruction of certified occupational and physical therapists from CCS.

Based on the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Button’s professional experience and her emergency credential that enabled her to work with mentally retarded and multiply handicapped students rendered her appropriate to educate Student.

Transition

The Student asserts that Ms. Button refused to accept assistance from Conservator 1 or meet with her both before and after Student was transferred into Ms. Button’s classroom. Although Conservator 1 testified that Ms. Button did not meet with her prior to Student’s transfer, both Ms. Button and Mr. Gallegos testified otherwise. Ms. Button credibly testified that she spent approximately ten hours observing Conservator 1’s classroom. Mr. Gallegos confirmed that Ms. Button worked with Conservator 1 on Student’s transition. Student was placed in Ms. Button’s class on March 11, 2002 and was in her class for one week before spring break. During spring break, Student underwent back surgery.

Conservator 1 testified that she did not meet with Ms. Button after spring break. However, both Ms. Button and Mr. Gallegos testified that Conservator 1 entered Ms. Button’s classroom on a daily basis. Ms. Button testified that she spent about fifteen to twenty hours meeting with Conservator 1 following Student’s placement in her classroom. She further testified that Conservator 1 repeatedly said that Student could do work if it were presented in a certain way. Ms. Button explained that Conservator 1 would come into the classroom so often that her presence disrupted the other students. Conservator 1’s presence became so intrusive that Mr. Gallegos implemented a system that required Conservator 1 to make an appointment and sign in prior to visiting Student in Ms. Button’s classroom. Conservator 1 acknowledged that she entered Ms. Button’s classroom for various reasons and offered detailed descriptions during the hearing of what Student did during the day, such as lying on the floor, toileting, eating, using his communication board, and she wrote a log of all of her observations. Mr. Gallegos explained the floor plan at Friendship School would not have enabled Conservator 1 to observe Student from her classroom, in spite of Conservator 1’s testimony otherwise.

The Hearing Officer finds Conservator 1’s testimony not credible. Friendship School’s policy changed because of Conservator 1’s intrusiveness into Ms. Button’s classroom. Ms. Button and Mr. Gallegos convincingly testified that there was much preparation regarding Student’s transfer to Ms. Button’s classroom. Conservator 1 even testified that she wrote the goals and objectives for the February 27, 2002 IEP knowing that they would be implemented “in a new young teacher’s class.” Further, following Student’s transfer, Conservator 1 was in Ms. Button’s class on a daily basis, and often several times a day. The Hearing Officer finds that Student was properly transitioned into Ms. Button’s classroom.

Full-day instruction

The Student further contends that he was denied a full day of instruction because Ms. Button let him sleep several hours a day in the classroom. Ms. Button testified that Student had a designated rest time on his mat, just as he had when in Conservator 1’s classroom, due to his changing energy levels. Ms. Button testified that following Student’s back surgery during spring break in March 2002, Student lacked the energy to stay awake the entire class day and would sleep on his mat during the rest time. Although Conservator 1 testified that she observed Student sleeping on several occasions, the Hearing Officer finds Ms. Button’s explanations credible and finds that Student received a full day of instruction, insofar as his post-surgery condition allowed.

One-on-one classroom aide

The Student contends that he required a one-on-one aide in the classroom. Conservator 1 testified that Student needed so much help with his everyday activities that he required the additional assistance of a one-on-one aide. Ms. Button had a total of seven students in her class, including Student, all of whom were in wheelchairs. She had the assistance of one full-time classroom aide and one part-time classroom aide, which provided a one-to-two staff to student ratio for half of the day. Ms. Button testified that Student needed two people to assist him with transfers. Ms. Button testified that Student was not good at waiting his turn and tended to rely too much on one person if given the opportunity; therefore, Ms. Button attempted to have all the staff work with Student.

Further, Conservator 1 developed Student’s IEP in February 2002 and never suggested that Student needed additional help within the classroom. Anita Macy, a speech and language pathologist, testified that Student did not need a one-on-one aide because he would benefitted from working with a variety of people in the classroom. This statement was corroborated by Ms. Button’s testimony that when Student was provided a one-on-one classroom aide from January 2003 through the present due to a mediated agreement in early 2003, Student became very prompt dependent and attached to his aide. Consequently, Student preferred only working with his one-on-one aide and became unable to wait his turn. Other staff also noted concern about Student’s dependence on his one-on-one classroom aide in his March 24, 2003 IEP document. The Hearing Officer finds that there was no evidence to suggest that Student needed the assistance of a one-on-one aide. For the majority of the day, there was a ratio of two students to one adult in Ms. Button’s classroom. During the entire time that Student was in Conservator 1’s class (seven years) there was never a need for a one-on-one aide and he did not require one upon transferring. The Hearing Officer finds that the SDCOE provided the appropriate level of adult supervision and supports that were designed to meet his unique needs and were reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit from March through May 30, 2002.

Assistive technology

The Student contends that he required additional assistive technology for his communication skills. Student utilized a “big red switch” to turn on an off the radio and other electrical equipment. Student was provided an adaptive switch for the computer so that he could switch the pages on the software that was designed for his skills. Additionally, he had a communication board that Conservator 1 had made for him prior to 1998. It was a large laminated mat with twenty-one, two-inch symbols. The Student contends that he should have had an updated communication board that scanned pictures and that SDCOE was not required to continue using the communication board that Conservator 1 had made for him.

Conservator 1 wrote the goals and objectives in February 2002. She specifically wrote, “by February 2003, Student will use his communication board at least 4x’s per day to indicate a need or choice with 100% accuracy for 4 consecutive school weeks.” Student’s second objective was that “by February 2003, Student will review the color communication symbols and their placement on his communication board at least 1x per day, 4 days per week during the school year.” Conservator 1 testified that these objectives could be used with any communication board and that he needed to have an updated board.

Ms. Button testified that she understood that she could use only the communication board that Conservator 1 created to implement the above objectives. She testified that Conservator 1 tried to show her several times how to utilize the communication board with Student and if, they could not determine which symbol Student was swatting at, Conservator 1 would say “he’s trying,” “he’s too tired,” or make other excuses for Student. However, Ms. Button testified that she continued to utilize the communication board because that is what was requested by Conservator 1 who was by now Student’s conservator.

Much evidence was presented both from Friendship School staff and Conservator 1 that Conservator 1 was adamant about the use of the communication board that she created for Student. She never argued at any point during the relevant time frame that Student needed a communication board with upgraded technology. Further, Student’s needs had not changed since she had created the communication board and the Hearing Officer previously found that the use of switches and the communication board were designed appropriately to meet Student’s unique needs and were reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. Although Ms. Button and her classroom aides had difficulty implementing Student’s goals and objectives with respect to his communication board, it does not negate the appropriateness of the communication board at the time it was developed. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that SDCOE provided appropriate assistive technology based on Student’s present levels of performance at the time and that the assistive technology was designed to meet Student’s unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit from March 2002 through May 30, 2002.

Direct SP/L services

The Student contends that he required direct SP/L services from a credentialed speech and language pathologist. The Student based his assertion on Ms. Berkowitz’s assessment and testimony. Ms. Berkowitz testified that Student required direct SP/L services three times a week in thirty-to-forty-five minute sessions in order to develop a communication system.

Ms. Berkowitz stated in her testimony that she believes that Student regressed and had a communication system but lost that when he was no longer in Conservator 1’s classroom. Ms. Berkowitz has been a licensed speech and language pathologist since 1979 and received her master’s degree in speech and language and audiology in 1983. She is also an educational consultant for school districts, families, and United Cerebral Palsy and conducts augmentative communication assessments. She assessed Student for two hours in the spring of 2003 at the Friendship Home. Conservator 1 was present during the entire assessment. Ms. Berkowitz reviewed IEPs from 1995 through 2000 and a communication assessment conducted by Anita Macy in February 2003. She did not interview any of the school staff who worked with Student nor did she talk with Ms. Macy about her assessment. She utilized Student’s communication board that Conservator 1 had made for him while he was a student in her class. She indicated that Student has the ability to scan and differentiate symbols. Ms. Berkowitz testified that Student would slap at his communication board and that even though his open hand would hit several symbols, she understood which symbol he actually chose.

Student had several goals and objectives in the area of speech and language. Additionally, Friendship School had a speech and language therapist on staff that would go into the classroom and provide direct services to students when necessary. Conservator 1 wrote the goals and objectives and indicated that the teacher was supposed to implement the SP/L goals and objectives. Anita Macy, a licensed speech and language pathologist, testified that Student would not have benefited from direct SP/L services. Ms. Macy has been working in school districts since 1989 providing direct services and assessments in the areas of speech and language and communication. Ms. Macy worked with Student during the 1995-1996 school year at Friendship School and conducted a speech and language assessment of Student in December 2002 and January 2003. Ms. Macy testified that based on Student’s 2001 and 2003 assessments, his communication level was between six months and one year old. Ms. Macy testified that it would not have been appropriate for Student to have received SP/L services three times a week because his rate of learning was so slow. She explained that SP/L services should have been delivered throughout Student’s day in his classroom.

Furthermore, in May 2002, when the IEP team reconvened and wrote new goals and objectives, the conservators stated that they wanted to maintain the level of supports and services and the same goals and objectives from February 2002 because they believed that those goals were designed to meet his unique needs. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Berkowitz’s testimony unpersuasive. She failed to interview anyone beyond Conservator 1 who had personal knowledge of Student. She did not have a copy of all the relevant IEPs and although she conducted her assessment at Friendship Home, but she failed to walk to across the grounds to Friendship School to observe Student in his educational setting, or interview any of the educational staff that worked with him. Therefore, the Hearing Officer is persuaded by Ms. Macy and finds that SDCOE provided Student with SP/L services that were designed to meet his unique needs and were reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit from March through May 30, 2002.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that SDCOE and CCS provided Student with appropriate services that were designed to meet his unique needs and were reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit between March 2002 and May 30, 2002.

May 30, 2002 through the extended school year 2002

The Student contends that the goals and objectives developed on May 30, 2002 were not designed to meet his unique needs and were not reasonably calculated to provide education benefit because he asserts that he was more than capable of completing the goals and objectives because the goals and objectives were not challenging.

Conservator 2 testified that he refused to agree to the goals and objectives proposed on May 30, 2002 because he believed Student had more capabilities than the goals indicated. Conservator 2 stated that he had seen Student recognize more words than Ms. Button indicated on the IEP. Conservator 2 testified that he believed Student was capable of completing all his goals and objectives from the February 2002 IEP and that if he could no longer achieve those goals upon placement in Ms. Button’s classroom, than he must have regressed. (Footnote 14)

Ms. Button testified that once Student was transferred to her classroom, she attempted to implement the goals and objectives written by Conservator 1, particularly the ones pertaining to Student’s communication board and vocabulary word recognition, and that Student was unable to perform as Conservator 1 had previously indicated. Ms. Button testified that Student just swatted at the communication board and waited for positive facial reinforcement. She testified that she tried to work on Student’s vocabulary words and that Student would just touch the one closer to him or the one that the person was looking at.

Upon Student’s transfer to Ms. Button’s classroom, she and her staff took data to determine Student’s frequency of meeting his goals and objectives. Student was rarely able to point to a symbol without hand-over-hand assistance. Student was often able to find the symbol for “dance” independently, but needed prompts for most other symbols. Based on the accumulated data, Ms. Button worked with the staff at Friendship School to develop more realistic goals and objectives for Student.

The Hearing Officer finds that SDCOE developed goals and objectives that were designed to meet his unique needs and were reasonably calculated to provide Student with educational benefit. The staff carefully charted Student’s progress and designed the goals based on his levels of performance at the time. Even upon persistent questioning by the Hearing Officer, Conservator 2 was unable to offer any concrete reason to support his position that the goals were inappropriate. Conservator 2 simply testified that he liked the goals and objectives that his wife had created and wanted those to remain because he felt that Student could do more. The Hearing Officer does not find his testimony persuasive. The Hearing Officer finds that the conservators had unrealistic expectations of Student’s abilities and their objectivity was clouded by the seven years during which Conservator 1 worked with Student in her classroom. However, once Student was out of her classroom, it became apparent to the staff at Friendship School that Student could not perform at the level Conservator 1 previously had indicated. The Hearing Officer finds that the SDCOE offered appropriate goals and objectives that were designed to meet Student’s unique needs and that were reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit at the May 30, 2002 IEP meeting.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that SDCOE and CCS offered and/or provided Student with an appropriate placement and services that were designed to meet his unique needs and were reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit during the 2001-2002 school year.

Did Student’s placement and services conform to his IEP?

September 2001 through February 2002

There is no dispute that Student’s IEP was implemented from September 2001 through February 2002 as agreed upon by all parties in February 2001.

March 2002 through May 30, 2002

The Student contends that Student’s IEP was not properly implemented from March 2002 through May 30, 2002, because Ms. Button failed to implement his communication board goals and objectives and failed to provide proper personal care because there was no set time to finish lunch, he was placed on the floor without cushions following his surgery, he had improper toileting, and his medication was delivered inappropriately. The SDCOE contends that it properly implemented Student’s goals and objectives and provided proper personal care.

The Student contends that Ms. Button did not properly implement his goals and objectives regarding the use of his communication board. Conservator 1 contends that Ms. Button did not utilize Student’s communication board in the classroom in accordance with his goals and objectives.

Ms. Button and her staff developed data sheets to track Student’s progress on his goals and objectives. The staff charted the frequency of work on a goal and objective and the level of prompts needed for Student to respond. The data sheets show that Ms. Button and her staff worked on Student’s goals and objectives in accordance with his February 2002 IEP. Further, Ms. Button testified that she worked consistently with Student on his communication board even though she did not believe that he understood what symbol he was swatting.

Based on the evidence, the Hearing Officer is convinced that Ms. Button worked on Student’s goals and objectives between March 2002 and May 30, 2002. The Hearing Officer finds that although Conservator 1 did not personally observe Ms. Button or her staff working on Student’s communication goals and objectives, the data sheets and Ms. Button’s testimony establish otherwise. The Hearing Officer finds that SDCOE properly implemented Student’s communication goals in conformity with his IEP dated February 27, 2002.

The Student also contends that he had improper personal care because there was no set time to finish lunch, he was placed on the floor without cushions following his surgery, he had improper toileting, and his medication was delivered inappropriately. Conservator 1 testified that she observed Student having two and a half hour lunches in Ms. Button’s classroom. The Student contends that this length of time is inappropriate because he was denied educational opportunity during such a lengthy time period. Ms. Button testified that when Student first transferred to her class, Student took up to two and a half hours to finish his food during lunch. Therefore, she began to use a timer during lunch that provided him forty-five minutes to eat. Ms. Button credibly testified that within one month’s time frame, Student was able to consume all his food within his forty-five-minute limit. The Hearing Officer finds that in spite of Conservator 1’s expectations of a seamless transition, Ms. Button appropriately and quickly addressed Student’s needs during lunch but that it took a month to get Student back on a regular eating schedule.

Conservator 1 also testified that Student was placed on the floor without cushions after his surgery. Conservator 1 explained that Student often used a beanbag in her class, but that he never used the beanbag in Ms. Button’s class. Ms. Button testified that Student was placed on a two-and-a-half to three-inch thick egg crate with a clean sheet, body pillow, and regular pillow. Ms Button convincingly testified that she tried utilizing the beanbag but that he would just roll off it. The Hearing Officer finds that Student was placed appropriately on a mat with pillows and cushions following his surgery.

Conservator 1 also testified that Student would sit on the toilet for a lengthy time and say “ah duh” indicating he was done with the toilet, but that Ms. Button would just leave him on the toilet. Conservator 1 testified that she peaked in the window on May 2, 2002 and saw that Student was positioned inappropriately on the toilet. Conservator 1 also testified that she had heard from the staff at Friendship Home that Student returned home with a wet diaper. Ms. Button testified that she learned from the physical therapist correct toilet positioning and that Student never stayed on the toilet longer than necessary. Ms. Button also testified that she never sent Student home with a wet diaper and checked him periodically throughout the day. Additionally, no one from Friendship Home ever informed her of Student’s wet diaper. Furthermore, Mr. Gallegos testified about the Friendship School and explained that there is no way that Conservator 1 could peak into the bathroom in Ms. Button’s classroom because all the windows are frosted and have vertical blinds. The Hearing Officer finds Conservator 1’s testimony unreliable and finds both Mr. Gallegos and Ms. Button’s testimony credible. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s toileting needs were appropriately addressed from March 2002 through May 30, 2002.

The Student also asserted that he did not receive his medications during the proper time frame; however, no evidence was submitted to support this allegation. The school nurse, Ms. Tabor, was actively involved in Student’s program and testified that she monitored him at least three times a week. Medication was to be delivered at lunchtime. Ms. Button testified that Student received his medication at lunchtime. The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Tabor and Ms. Button credible and finds that Student received his medications appropriately.

Based on all the evidence, the Hearing Officer is persuaded by Ms. Button, Mr. Gallegos, and Ms. Tabor that Student’s personal health car needs were appropriately met from March 2002 through May 30, 2002. Additionally, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s communication goals and objectives were implemented in conformity with his IEP.

May 30, 2002 through the extended school year 2002

The Student continued to contend that Student’s IEP was not properly implemented because Ms. Button failed to implement his communication board goals and objectives, and failed to provide proper personal care because there was no set time to finish lunch, he was placed on the floor without cushions following his surgery, he had improper toileting, and his medication was delivered inappropriately. Because there was no agreement on May 24 or 30, 2002, on Student’s revised IEP, SDCOE continued to implement Student’s February 27, 2002 IEP. The staff continued to track Student’s progress on data sheets. Further, no additional evidence was presented that SDCOE did not properly implement Student’s February 27, 2002 IEP during the remainder of the year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that SDCOE and CCS implemented Student’s placement and services in conformity with his last agreed upon IEP dated February 27, 2002, from May 30, 2002 through the 2002 ESY. In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that SDCOE and CCS implemented Student’s placement and services in conformity with his February 2001 and February 2002 IEPs during the 2001-2002 school year.

Was Student educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE)?

The Student contends that he was denied an opportunity to socialize with non-disabled members of the community from March 2002 through ESY 2002.

Special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a student from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in regular education classes cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.)

Student’s IEP indicated that he would participate with non-disabled peers during walks and planned events. Conservator 1 testified that she took each of her students out on Fridays on an individual basis, sometimes to fast-food restaurants. Each student was taken out about once every two months. Conservator 1 testified that Student did not get that opportunity upon transferring into Ms. Button’s classroom. However, Conservator 1 also testified that Student had a lot of health problems and could not be taken out if he is sick. Ms. Button testified that she implemented the same rotating system of taking her students out as Conservator 1, but on days that Student was supposed to go out into the community, he was often suffering from allergies or sinus infections and Conservator 1 would not allow him to be taken out into the community and provided letters to the school stating this concern. Conservator 2 also testified that Student’s sinus infections were a significant concern and that he should not be taken out in the community when he has an infection. However, in spite of Student’s medical needs, Mr. Gallegos convincingly testified that Student did not spend any more time in the community when he was a student in Conservator 1’s class than he has as a student in Ms. Button’s classroom. The Hearing Officer finds that Student had the appropriate amount of community involvement considering his health limitations.

Procedural Safeguards—

The Student continued to argue that the IEPs were prewritten, that discussions were held outside the presence of the surrogate parent and/or conservators, and that there was no discussion regarding OT and PT services provided by CCS at the IEP meetings.

SDCOE contends that no procedural violations were committed in preparation for Student’s annual IEP meeting. Additionally, SDCOE and CCS contend that there was discussion of OT and PT services at the February 2001, February 2002, and May 2002 IEP meetings because a representative from CCS was present at all IEP meetings during the 2001-2002 school year.

As previously found above, SDCOE did not commit any procedural violations in preparing the draft IEP prior to the February 27, 2002 IEP meeting. Additionally, no evidence was submitted that discussions regarding Student’s placement were held outside the presence of Student’s surrogate parent or his conservators during the 2001-2002 school year.

Additionally, the IEP documents indicate and Student’s occupational therapist from CCS, Ms. Bernens, testified that she attended Student’s IEP meetings in February 2001 and February 2002. It is unclear from the IEP document whether Ms. Bernens attended the May IEPs but the goals and objectives in the areas of OT and PT specifically refer to approval by CCS. Ms. Bernens testified that her role in the IEP meetings was to listen to the goals and objectives to ensure that none of Student’s goals contradicted the goals that she had written for Student as well as to represent CCS. Ms. Bernens testified that nothing indicated a need for change in the level of services or the recommendations for either OT or PT for the 2001-2002 school year.

Based on the testimony of Ms. Bernens and the documentary evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Bernens from CCS did participate in the IEP meetings and there was discussion of CCS related services at the IEP meetings.

The Hearing Officer finds that SDCOE and CCS complied with the IDEA’s procedural safeguards during the 2001-2002 school year.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that SDCOE and CCS offered and/or provided Student a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year.

4. Did the SDCOE and CCS offer and/or provide a FAPE to Student during the 2002-2003 school year?

As set forth above, the standard for determining whether the program provided the Student a FAPE involves consideration of the following factors: whether the placement and services were designed to address Student’s unique needs, were reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit, and conformed to his IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, 458 U.S. 176.)

The Student contends that during the 2002-2003 school year, SDCOE and CCS failed to offer and/or provide him a FAPE because he had no direct OT and PT services and SDCOE failed to offer and/or provide a properly credentialed teacher, a one-on-one aide in the classroom, additional assistive technology, direct SP/L services, and a behavior support plan. The Student further asserts that procedural violations were committed because the IEP document was prepared prior to the IEP meeting, discussions regarding his placement occurred outside the presence of the conservators, and SDCOE failed to offer a full continuum of placement options. The Student contends that during the IEP meeting, there were no assessors present and there was no discussion of CCS related services. The Student also contends that the SDCOE failed to create appropriate goals and objectives and implement the goals and objectives from the February 2002 IEP meeting. The Student continued to assert that Student was denied a full day of instruction and that his personal care was improper. The Student also asserted that OT, PT, and SP/L assessments were conducted without consent from the conservators.

SDCOE contends that it offered and/or provided Student a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year. SDCOE contends that Student underwent a comprehensive assessment that was reviewed and agreed upon by all parties during several IEP meetings and that his placement and services were designed to meet his unique needs and were reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. CCS contends that it provided Student with the appropriate level of medically necessary OT and PT services.

Were Student’s placement and services designed to meet his unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

September 2002 through February 2003

Student entered the 2002-2003 school year with his February 27, 2002 IEP still in effect. The Student did not make any additional contentions beyond those addressed prior. The Hearing Officer previously found that Student’s placement and services were designed to meet his unique needs and were reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s program from September 2002 through February 2003 was designed to meet his unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.

February 2003 through ESY 2003

The Student contends that SDCOE and CCS failed to offer him a placement that was designed to meet his unique needs and that was reasonably calculated to offer educational benefit at the series of IEP meetings that began on February 18, 2003, and concluded on March 24, 2003.

On November 4, 2002, SDCOE submitted a three-year triennial evaluation assessment plan to Student’s conservators that was signed and agreed upon. A multidisciplinary assessment was conducted in January 2003 by Jorge Ley, school psychologist; Brenda Button; Conservator 1; Sylvia Nielson, physical therapist at Children’s Hospital; Jennifer Canaris, occupational therapist for San Diego County SELPA; Anita Macy, speech and language pathologist for San Diego County SELPA; Judy Gwinnup, assistive technology specialist; and staff at Friendship Home. The team determined that Student had an overall behavioral age of 15.7 months and functional communication skills within the six-to sixteen-month range. The team determined that Student did not require a higher level of OT or PT services. The team also determined that Student would benefit from computer software that assisted him in making choices between two items.

On February 18, 2003, Student’s IEP team convened to discuss the results of the triennial assessment and to conduct Student’s annual IEP team meeting. Ronald Lopez, program manager for Sweetwater School District; Gene Gallegos; Barbara Tabor; Tracy Cook, speech and language pathologist at Friendship School; Lori Mannheimer, occupational therapist at Friendship School; Jaime Tate, assistive technology specialist at Friendship School; Jorge Ley, school psychologist; Sylvia Nielson, physical therapist; Judy Gwinnup, assistive technology specialist; Jennifer Canaris, speech and language pathologist; Ms. Bernens; Maria Gless and Lysa Saltzman, attorneys for SDCOE; Anita Macy, speech and language pathologist for San Diego County SELPA; Thomas Nelson, Student’s attorney; Conservator 2; Conservator 1; Kimberly Spangler from the San Diego Regional Center; Elyse Latella from the Student’s attorney’s office; Jessica Rufo, Student’s QMRP from Friendship Home; Ms. Button; Susana W., director of pupil services for Chula Vista Elementary School District; Pam Espinosa, coordinator at Chula Vista Elementary School District; and a facilitator attended all or some of Student’s IEP team meetings that began on February 18 and continued over a series of meetings on February 21 and March 11, 21, and 24, 2003. (Footnote 15)

The IEP team meeting concluded on March 24, 2003, and Student was offered continued placement in an SDC taught by Ms. Button and there had been a discussion regarding a placement option in the Sweetwater School District within the local SELPA. Student was offered ten thirty-minute sessions each of direct SP/L and OT per school year. Additionally, goals and objectives were developed in all areas of need, including cognition, communication, fine and gross motor skills, and toileting. Student also was offered specialized health care services, school OT consultation, school SP/L services consultation, and school assistive technology specialist consultation. Each of the consultative services were offered one time for every four-week period of school in fifteen-to thirty-minute sessions. Student also continued to be offered OT and PT services on a consult basis through CCS.

The Student continued to contend that on March 24, 2003, the SDCOE and CCS failed to offer and/or provide him a FAPE because there was not an adequate offer of direct OT services and no direct PT services were offered and the SDCOE failed to offer and/or provide a properly credentialed teacher, a one-on-one aide in the classroom, additional assistive technology, and an adequate level of direct SP/L services. The Student also contends that he needed a behavior support plan.

Direct OT services

The Student contends that he needed direct OT services from a credentialed occupational therapist and that the level of services offered was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. SDCOE and CCS contend that he was offered and/or provided the appropriate level of OT services.

Student was offered ten thirty-minute direct OT sessions during the school year. Additionally, he was offered several goals and objectives in the area of OT and consult-based services from CCS. SDCOE based its proposed OT goals and objectives on Student’s needs as set forth in his multidisciplinary assessment.

Jennifer Canaris, an occupational therapist from San Diego County SELPA, conducted an OT assessment of Student in January and February 2003. Ms. Canaris is a licensed occupational therapist and is certified to administer sensory integration interventions. She conducted her assessment through clinical and classroom observations, a record review, and interviews of Conservator 1 and Ms. Button. She observed Student in his educational environment and determined that it was an appropriate set up to benefit and challenge. She indicated that his OT needs were met in the areas of feeding and fine motor skills. She explained that the purpose of OT in education is to assist a student with fine motor skills and to develop visual perception and visual motor integration skills.

Ms. Canaries explained in her testimony that when she conducts an assessment she looks at sensory integration and considers the student’s environment and the context in which his activities take place, such as the physical structure, equipment, and tools (pencils and pens). Ms. Canaris testified that sensory processing is what one takes from the environment – we take information in, process that information, and then use the information. Ms. Canaris testified that there are three areas to determine if a student has a sensory processing disorder: tactile (by using lotion on his hands or massaging his hands, sitting in a beanbag, or holding textured balls); vestibular processing (e.g. head movement sensation activated by a rocking chair or other movement activities); and proprioceptive processing (i.e. sensory processing in the joint and muscles activated by propelling his wheelchair or gait trainer, lying on the mat, being in a rocking chair, or pushing with his feet in the rocking chair). She testified that she does not believe Student exhibits indicators of a sensory processing dysfunction and that therefore there is no need for direct services in those areas because Student is getting his sensory stimulation from his environment.

Ms. Canaris testified that she does not believe Student would have gained benefit from additional direct OT services because he would have obtained limited benefit due to his significant disabilities. She also testified that she attended the IEP meetings in February and March 2003 and agreed with the goals and objectives and the recommended level of OT services.

The Student did not submit any contradictory evidence that would indicate that Ms. Canaris’s recommendations were inaccurate or inadequate as to the amount of necessary OT services. The Student requested direct OT and SDCOE offered direct OT approximately one time a month, in addition to the consult-based OT. The Hearing Officer finds that the SDCOE and CCS offered the appropriate levels of OT that were reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.

Direct PT services

The Student contends that he required direct PT from a credentialed physical therapist. The Student bases his contention that he requires direct PT services on a privately retained assessment conducted by professor of physical therapy Dr. Ardith Williams-Meyers in September 2003 and prepared in December 2003. Dr. Williams-Meyers strongly disagreed with the “benefits of therapy” as stated in Student’s most recent PT evaluation. She indicated in her report that Student could receive more benefit from a physical therapist on transfers, ambulation, and trunk control needed for reaching his “optimum potential” than he could receive from a classroom teacher who is not skilled in PT. She went on to explain that she believed that with a minimum of three two-to three-hour sessions a week with someone skilled at assisting Student with weight-bearing exercises and functional training to improve head, trunk and upper extremity control, he would be able to work towards ambulation without assistive devices.

Dr. Chambers testified in complete disagreement to Dr. Williams-Meyers. Dr. Chambers has been Student’s treating orthopedic surgeon since 1989. He has performed two back surgeries on Student since 1998. He also wrote all the prescriptions for the medical therapy unit for CCS to provide OT and PT. Dr. Chambers testified that Student lacks control over his muscles. He has severe hypotonia, and even after his back surgeries, continues to hold his head at a tilt because he cannot hold his trunk up without strength. Further, Dr. Chambers testified that Student has more difficulty now than he did when he was in Conservator 1’s classroom because he has gained weight and has more weight to transfer than before. Dr. Chambers also testified that the studies that Dr. Williams-Meyers relied upon were misquoted. Dr. Chambers testified that from his experience, “two-to three-hour sessions three times a week is not worth the time spent to get a significant improvement.” He explained that Student needed to incorporate PT functions into his daily activities. Dr. Chambers also was concerned that Dr. Williams-Meyers made her determination based solely on the reports that were provided by Conservator 1 and her observations of Student, with Conservator 1 present during the entire observation. Dr. Chambers was concerned that Dr. Ardith Williams was a professor of physical therapy and did not consult with Student’s medical doctors regarding neurological, cognitive, speech, and physical abilities. Dr. Chambers testified that to do an appropriate PT assessment, one must talk to a multidisciplinary team.

The Hearing Officer finds that the program offered in February and March 2003 was designed to meet his unique PT needs and was reasonably calculated to provide Student with educational benefit in the area of PT. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by Dr. Chambers’ testimony and his years of work with Student. The Hearing Officer finds that the PT offered on March 24, 2003, was designed to meet Student’s unique PT needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit.

Qualification of teacher and a one-on-one classroom aide

As previously found above, Ms. Button was properly credentialed to teach Student. Furthermore, the Student presented no additional evidence regarding his need for a one-on-one classroom aide beyond his previous argument. Since the Hearing Officer was presented no additional evidence, she finds that SDCOE continued to offer Student the appropriate level of instructional supports during the 2002-2003 school year.

Assistive technology—communication

The Student contends that he needed more assistive technology than was offered in the March 24, 2003 IEP. SDCOE offered assistive technology consultations one time per every four-week period for fifteen to thirty minutes. Additionally, Student was offered adaptive switches and feeding and mobility equipment. The Student contends that he needed a communication board that offered scanning capabilities.

The Student presented Ms. Susan Berkowitz’s testimony as evidence regarding the use of a communication device that enables scanning. Ms. Berkowitz, a licensed speech and language pathologist, conducted an augmentative communication assessment. Ms. Berkowitz testified that she believes Student would benefit from a device that offers voice activation. Ms. Berkowitz testified that Student has the ability to discriminate between pictures and make choices but his communication board did not allow him to develop a communication system. She indicated that he needed something mounted to his wheelchair so that he could initiate communication and make his wants and needs understood.

Anita Macy conducted a SP/L assessment of Student in December 2002 and January and February 2003. Anita Macy is a licensed speech and language pathologist and has been working in school districts since 1989 providing direct services and assessments in the area of speech and language and communication. Her assessment consisted of a review of Student’s files including a letter from Conservator 1 and the most recent assessments, interviews of Brenda Button, a speech and language pathologist from Friendship Homes, Elly Millman, and Student’s QMRP from Friendship Homes, Jessica Rufo, and several observations of Student. Additionally, Ms. Macy worked with Student during the 1995-1996 school year when she consulted at Friendship School. Ms. Macy recommended the use of an object/photo communication board at Student’s February and March 2003 IEP meetings. Ms. Macy also recommended the use of a switch with verbal output because Student is responsive to sound. Ms. Macy testified that a scanning device would be difficult for Student because he would have to wait for the items to scan and Student lacked the attentional skills required for the wait. Additionally, Ms. Macy testified that the scanning device would be difficult for Student to learn and it would be very frustrating to him.

Judy Gwinnup conducted an assistive technology assessment of Student in January and February 2003. Ms. Gwinnup has been a lecturer of applications for technology for individuals with disabilities at San Diego State University for fifteen years and an itinerant teacher for students with orthopedic impairments for Cajon Valley Union School District since 1978. Ms. Gwinnup holds a master’s degree in special education and received a teaching credential in 1971 and in 1978 she obtained specialist credentials in physically handicapped and learning handicapped. Ms. Gwinnup observed Student on two occasions, reviewed Conservator 1’s report, and spoke with Conservator 1, Ms. Macy, and Ms. Button. Ms. Gwinnup recommended that Student have access to two switches on his tray for choice-making activities and that the switches be voice activated. Ms. Gwinnup testified that Student needed to have his switches attached to his tray because otherwise he would pick them up and toss them. Ms. Gwinnup also recommended that Student use a switch to work with the computer because he likes to use switches to “turn the pages” on the computer program. Ms. Gwinnup also testified that scanning devices require higher cognitive abilities than Student possesses and the devices are too slow for Student’s attention span.

Based on the evidence presented the Hearing Officer finds that SDCOE offered Student appropriate assistive technology that was designed to meet his communication needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by Ms. Macy and Ms. Gwinnup that it offered Student an appropriate communication board and access to switches with voice output during the March 24, 2003 IEP meeting. Further, Ms. Macy and Ms. Gwinnup both testified that it would be too difficult for Student to use a scanning device because he does not have the necessary patience and cognitive ability. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Berkowitz’s assessment unpersuasive. She failed to interview anyone beyond Conservator 1 who had personal knowledge of Student. She did not have a copy of all the relevant IEPs and although she conducted the assessment at Friendship Home, she failed to walk across the grounds to Friendship School to observe Student in his educational setting or interview the staff in Ms. Button’s SDC. Furthermore, Conservator 1 assisted in the assessment and Conservator 1 has clouded judgment regarding Student and his ability to recognize symbols on his communication board. The Hearing Officer finds that SDCOE’s offer of assistive technology on March 24, 2003, was designed to meet Student’s unique communication needs and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.

Assistive technology –gross motor

The Student also contends that he needed a new gait trainer and a motorized wheelchair. Student has been utilizing a gait trainer for several years and his IEP team recommended continued use of the gait trainer. The gait trainer is an assistive walking device that straps Student in with a harness-type strap and allows him to have trunk support while he simulates walking. Student also has a standard wheelchair with which he is able to propel himself around the room.

The Student’s expert, Dr. Ardith Williams-Meyers, a professor of physical therapy at Azusa Pacific University, testified that Student needed a different type of gait trainer that would require him to have true weight bearing on his legs. She testified that Student has the ability to gain strength in his muscles and his current gait trainer does not allow him true weight-bearing capacity. She also testified that Student should be trained to safely use a motorized chair. Dr. Williams-Meyers testified that she believes he will need a motorized wheelchair in the future so he should be trained to use one now. (Footnote 16)

Sylvia Neilson, physical therapist, conducted a physical therapy evaluation of Student in January 2003 as part of his multidisciplinary assessment. Ms. Nielson is a physical therapist for San Diego Children’s Hospital and has worked in the field of pediatric physical therapy for twenty-three years. Her assessment involved clinical observations of Student and interviews of Conservator 1 and Ms. Button. Ms. Nielson indicated in her assessment that Student’s class was modified to meet his needs with mat tables, Student’s personal gait trainer, an adapted toilet seat, and his manual wheelchair with a tray that he could use to propel himself around the classroom. She determined that Student’s gait trainer was appropriate and helped him experience the dynamics of weight bearing. She also testified that the gait trainer that Dr. Williams-Meyers recommended was just a newer model but that it was basically the same trainer with the same weight bearing allowance and a slightly different type of body harness.

Ms. Nielson testified that she conducted an educational evaluation of Student to determine his needs within the classroom. Ms. Nielson explained that the purpose of conducting a physical therapy assessment for educational purposes is to ensure that the student can access his classroom, playground, and transportation. Further, the educational assessment addresses seating positioning that is necessary in the classroom and on the toilet. She testified that a power wheelchair would not have been appropriate for Student because he did not have the cognitive abilities to utilize it within his environment.

Dr. Chambers also testified that Dr. Williams-Meyers’ assessment and recommendations would not improve Student’s ability to access his education. Dr. Chambers testified that he has never seen Student do standing activities and has been his treating orthopedic surgeon since 1989. He further testified that Student’s gait trainer allows him the maximum amount of trunk support and that it is not necessary for Student to have a new gait trainer. Dr. Chambers also testified that Student does not have the ability to cooperate and move an object and, therefore, would have difficulty understanding the concept of a motorized wheelchair.

The Hearing Officer is persuaded by Ms. Nielson and Dr. Chambers that Student did not need additional assistive technology to access his education during the 2002-2003 school year. Both witnesses testified that Student’s wheelchair and gait trainer were appropriate and provided appropriate support for his mobility needs. Further, both indicated that the recommendations of Dr. Williams-Meyers were not necessary and not appropriate because Student would receive the same level of weight-bearing opportunities as he received from his current gait trainer and Student would not be able to learn to operate a motorized wheelchair. The Hearing Officer finds Dr. Williams-Meyers assessment inadequate. She failed to speak with any of Student’s treating physical therapists or doctors even though she could have obtained permission from the conservators. She also did not speak with anyone who provided services to Student. Furthermore, Dr. Williams-Meyers did not conduct her assessment in Student’s educational setting. She testified that her first attempt at assessment was unsuccessful because Student was so tired from the long drive. The Hearing Officer finds that the SDCOE and CCS offered Student an appropriate gait trainer and wheelchair that was designed to meet his unique mobility needs and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.

Direct SP/L services

The Student further contends that he was not offered the appropriate level of direct SP/L services and that the communication goals and objectives that were offered were at a lower level than he had previously mastered. Student was offered ten thirty-minute direct speech and language sessions during the school year. Additionally, he was offered several goals and objectives in the area of communication. The SDCOE recommended that Student utilize a yes/no voice output communication system with which he could communicate his wants and needs by activating the switches. Conservator 1 testified that Student could consistently recognize all twenty-one symbols on his communication board and that the proposed communication system that consisted of only two choices represented regression. She testified that she worked very hard to develop that board and that Student could consistently use it and did not need a different system; however, she also argued that Student needed a communication board that would enable him to scan through several choices.

Ms. Berkowitz stated in her testimony that she believes that Student regressed and had a communication system but lost that when he was no longer in Conservator 1’s classroom. She indicated that Student has the ability to scan and differentiate symbols. Ms. Berkowitz testified that Student slapped at his communication board and that even though his open hand hit several symbols at a time, she understood which symbol he actually chose. She indicated that Student should receive direct SP/L services three times a week for thirty to forty-five minutes, and that the speech and language pathologist should train all of Student’s educational providers so that his services can be implemented throughout the day.

The SDCOE developed goals and objectives based on its triennial assessment conducted in January 2003. Ms. Button, school psychologist Jorge Ley, and Ms. Tabor participated in the assessment, in conjunction with the multidisciplinary team including Ms. Macy, speech and language pathologist, and Judy Gwinnup, assistive technology specialist. The team determined that Student needed a communication system with fewer choices. They developed goals and objectives for Student to use a voice-activated switch and choose from a field of two choices rather than twenty-one, as Conservator 1 had previously developed. Further, the team determined that Student needed color photographs rather than symbols. In addition to the goals to help Student develop a communication system, the IEP team also recommended a vocalization goal to help Student with vocal imitations, a receptive vocabulary/vocabulary comprehension goal to help Student correctly identify objects and activities, and an additional communication goal to help Student choose a leisure activity from a field of two photographs with symbols.

Elly Millman, Friendship Home’s speech and language pathologist, testified that Student needed a different communication board. Ms. Millman has seen Student one to two times every two months since January 2001. She testified that there were too many symbols on Student’s communication board and his palm grasp was not consistent. Ms. Millman explained in her testimony that Student was unable to indicate definite choices using the board with twenty-one choices and that Student just hit the board and Conservator 1 interpreted it for whatever she wanted. Ms. Millman testified that Student has never been consistent in hitting the symbols and she does not believe that Student recognizes the symbols or knows what he is hitting. Ms. Millman also testified that it would be “ludicrous” to give a student like Student services once a week or five times a week because Student does not have the cognitive skills to benefit. She testified that it would be more beneficial to train the staff to work on Student’s communication device throughout the school day.

Ms. Macy testified that Student’s communication level is between six months and one year old. Ms. Macy testified that it would not have been appropriate for Student to have had direct SP/L services three times a week because his rate of learning was so slow that little progress would have been achieved in speech and language. Ms. Macy testified that direct services one time per month was appropriate to monitor Student’s progress and provide feedback to the classroom staff and make appropriate changes as necessary. She explained that SP/L services should be delivered throughout Student’s day in his classroom. Ms. Macy determined that Student continued to require auditory stimuli, including spoken language, with varied intonation, music, and other non-speech sounds. She also suggested reinforcing the meaning of objects, using an object/photo communication board and schedule, using a switch with verbal output, using inflected pitch, and providing wait-time for Student to respond to simple commands. Ms. Macy testified that she believed all the goals and objectives in the area of speech and language were very appropriate for Student.

Based on the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that the speech and language program offered on March 24, 2003, was designed to meet Student’s unique needs in speech and language and was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. The Hearing Officer is not persuaded by Ms. Berkowitz’s testimony that Student required direct speech and language three times a week because she did not have the relevant IEPs, she did not interview any staff that worked directly with Student, and she relied heavily on uncorroborated information provided by Conservator 1.

Behavior support plan (BSP)

The Student contends that SDCOE should have offered him a behavior support plan in March 2003. The Student contends that he was screaming in class and throwing objects and that his level of classroom disruption required a behavior support plan. SDCOE contends that it offered Student a behavioral goal and that his behaviors did not disrupt the classroom environment.

In the case of a child whose behavior impedes his or her learning or that of others, the IDEA requires the IEP team to consider, when appropriate, strategies, including positive behavioral interventions, and supports to address that behavior. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(3)(B)(i); see also Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.1(b)(1).) California Education Code section 56520 refers specifically to the use of behavior interventions for children who receive special education services. The regulations implementing this section state that a behavioral intervention plan is to be developed when the student exhibits a “serious behavior problem that significantly interferes with the implementation of the goals and objectives of the individual’s IEP.” (Cal. Code of Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(f).) In March 2003, SDCOE offered Student a behavioral goal because he was exhibiting task-avoidance behaviors such as yelling and pushing away objects. Ms. Button testified that Student’s behaviors were not disruptive enough to warrant a behavior support plan.

Ms. Button testified that she was concerned about Student’s behaviors and developed an aggressive behavior-tracking sheet to see if his behaviors were increasing in severity. Ms. Button testified that Student occasionally hit, bit, kicked, and screamed. Ms. Button testified that she tracked his behaviors over a two-year period and determined that his behaviors were not very severe or very frequent. Ms. Button also testified that Student’s behaviors have greatly improved over the two years.

The Student did not present any contrary evidence or support for his argument that he required a behavior support plan. Based on the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s behaviors did not rise to the level of requiring a behavior support plan. Further, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s goal in the area of behavior intervention was designed to meet his unique behavioral needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement offered on March 24, 2003, by SDCOE and CCS was designed to meet Student’s unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit.

Did Student’s placement conform to his IEP?

The SDCOE did not have an opportunity to implement the March 24, 2003 IEP because the conservators refused to provide consent for its implementation. Regarding the implementation of the last agreed-upon IEP from February 2002, the Student continued to make the same contentions as previously ruled upon. The Student did not make any additional arguments for the 2002-2003 school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer continues to find that Student’s placement conformed to his IEP.

Procedural Safeguards—

The Student continued to argue that the IEPs were prewritten, discussions were held outside the presence of the surrogate parent and/or conservators, and there was no discussion regarding OT and PT services provided by CCS at the IEP meetings.

SDCOE contends that no procedural violations were committed in preparation for Student’s annual IEP meeting. Additionally, SDCOE and CCS contend that there was discussion of OT and PT services at the February 2002, May 2002 IEP meetings and all the IEP meetings in February and March 2003 because a representative from CCS was present at all IEP meetings during the 2002-2003 school year.

As previously found above, SDCOE did not commit any procedural violations in preparing the draft February 2002 and May 2002 IEPs prior to the IEP meetings. Further, based on the IEP documents, and that six IEP meetings took place, it was very clear that each IEP meeting was a collaborative effort between the entire IEP team including the conservators. Additionally, no evidence was further submitted that discussions regarding Student’s placement were held outside the presence of Student’s surrogate parent or his conservators. Furthermore, in reviewing each IEP, and based on testimony from CCS providers, there was a CCS representative present and there was discussion of CCS involvement and the level of services to be provided at each of the relevant IEP meetings.

The Student also asserted that OT, PT, and SP/L assessments were conducted without consent from the conservators. However, the conservators signed and agreed to the assessments and specifically requested that additional assessments be conducted in OT, PT, assistive technology, and SP/L prior to the annual IEP meeting in February 2003. The Hearing Officer finds that all the assessments were conducted with explicit consent from the conservators.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that SDCOE and CCS offered and/or provided Student a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year.

5. Did the SDCOE and CCS offer and/or provide a FAPE to Student from the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year to April 2004?

As set forth above, the standard for determining whether the program provided the Student a FAPE involves consideration of the following factors: whether the placement and services were designed to address Student’s unique needs, were reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit, and conformed to his IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, 458 U.S. 176.)

The Student continued to make the same contentions with regard to the 2003-2004 school year. Student continued to be provided the same program as set forth in the February 2002 IEP and continued to be offered the same program as set forth in the series of IEPs in February through March 2003. The parties held Student’s annual IEP meeting in March 2004; however, the parties did not conclude the IEP and therefore did not raise it as an issue for hearing. Further, the parties agreed to extend the March 24, 2003 offer through the date of this Decision. Therefore, the March 2003 offer is what the Hearing Officer will analyze to determine whether Student was offered and/or provided a FAPE from the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year to April 2004.

Regarding the provision of services during the 2003-2004 school year, SDCOE continued to provide Student placement and services per the February 2002 IEP. In addition to the Student’s ongoing contentions that SDCOE and CCS failed to offer and/or provide him a FAPE because he had no direct OT and PT services and the SDCOE failed to offer and/or provide a properly credentialed teacher, a one-on-one aide in the classroom, additional assistive technology, direct SP/L services, and a behavior support plan, the Student also contends that the SDCOE failed to provide Student a FAPE because his goals and objectives regarding his communication board were not implemented properly, he was denied an opportunity to socialize in the community, and his personal hygiene needs were not appropriately maintained. The Student further asserts that procedural violations were committed because OT and PT assessments were conducted without the conservators’ consent, a speech and language assessment and services were conducted and provided without the conservators’ consent, and SDCOE failed to consider the Student’s independent assessments.

SDCOE contends that it offered and/or provided Student a FAPE and that it properly implemented the IEP and conducted all assessments and provided services with proper conservator consent. CCS contends that it conducted its OT and PT assessments properly.

Was the placement designed to meet Student’s unique needs and was it reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

Student continued to require the same levels of supports and services during the 2003-2004 school year as he had during the previous year. SDCOE conducted its triennial/annual IEP in February and March 2003. Because there was no agreement on his placement and services, Student continued to be provided his program as designated in his February 2002 IEP that Conservator 1 had written and developed. No argument was presented that this IEP failed to meet his unique needs in the areas of communication, cognition, toileting, and fine and gross motor development during the 2003-2004 school year.

Further, the Hearing Officer previously found that the placement and services offered in February and March 2003 were designed to meet Student’s unique needs and that IEP continued to be in effect through April 2004 pursuant to the parties’ agreement. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the SDCOE offered Student a placement that was designed to meet his unique needs and that was reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit through April 2004.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that SDCOE and CCS offered and/or provided Student a placement and services that were designed to meet his unique needs and were reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit from the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year to April 2004.

Did Student’s placement conform to his IEP?

The Student contends that SDCOE failed to implement his goals and objectives regarding his communication board. The Student contends that Ms. Button did not work with him on his communication board as Conservator 1 had intended. Conservator 1 testified that when she went into Ms. Button’s classroom in the past, Student did not have his communication board to use and he was only using a communication board with yes and no choices. (Footnote 17)

Student’s goal regarding his communication board was that he would become familiar with twenty-one symbols by using his communication board at least four times a day to indicate a need or choice with 100% accuracy for four consecutive school weeks and by reviewing color communication symbols and their placement on his communication board at least one time per day for four days per week during the school year.

Ms. Button testified that she has used the communication board, but did not feel that it was effective. Ms. Button explained that when Student slapped at a symbol on the board, he hit several symbols at a time and it was unclear if he was slapping the correct symbol. Also, Steven Oas, a speech and language pathologist who contracted with Friendship Home to provide all students with SP/L services, provided Student with direct speech and language services up to three times a week for as much as thirty minutes a session from November 2003 through the due process hearing. Mr. Oas has a master’s degree in speech pathology and was licensed as a speech-language pathologist in 2000 by the American Speech, Language, and Hearing Association and the State of California. Mr. Oas also has consulted with Ms. Button on a regular basis and assisted the aides in Student’s classroom since November 2003. He testified that he worked with Student on his communication board and used a picture board similar to the one that had been developed by Conservator 1; however, Student could not identify the symbols or pictures because he did not understand their meaning. He testified that Student has visual deficits and his motoric skills are impaired. Mr. Oas explained that Student just swats at the board but is not able to use his motor skills well enough to point to the pictures or specific items. Mr. Oas testified that Student made little to no progress during the six months when he provided Student with thrice weekly direct SP/L services.

Based on the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer is convinced that Ms. Button and Mr. Oas implemented Student’s communication goals and objectives. The Hearing Officer does not find Conservator 1’s testimony reliable as she has been out on medical leave and has not worked at Friendship School during the entire 2003-2004 school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that SDCOE properly implemented Student’s goals and objectives pertaining to his communication board.

The Student also contends that he received direct SP/L services from November 2003 through the due process hearing without conservator permission. Testimony from Mr. Oas indicated that Student received direct SP/L services up to three times a week for thirty minutes or less. Student’s February 2002 IEP does not specifically address the provision of SP/L services, though Friendship School routinely had a speech and language pathologist work directly with all of the students in the classroom. Conservator 1 testified that she had several speech and language pathologists work with her in her classroom, including Ms. Macy who helped her develop Student’s communication board, Tracy Cook, who worked with Ms. Button and Student after his transfer to Ms. Button’s class, and Steven Oas.

The Student contends that although he requested direct SP/L services, it was never agreed upon in his IEP and therefore, he should not have received the services. The SDCOE offered direct SP/L services at an IEP meeting in February 2003, but the conservators failed to agree to the proposed services, even though it was exactly what they contend the SDCOE should have been providing. The Student is accurate that the conservators never agreed to the services that they requested. The Student argued vehemently that Student needed additional services. His expert, Susan Berkowitz, stated in her report and reiterated in her testimony that Student should be receiving direct SP/L services three times a week in thirty- to forty-five-minute sessions. Student received exactly what the Student requested.

Mr. Oas testified that he was hired to provide speech and language services to all the students as part of an integrated program meant to address the needs of all the students at Friendship School. Mr. Oas testified that he provides direct services in the classrooms to approximately thirty-four students three days a week and also worked with the staff and observed how the staff implemented goals and objectives for students to give assistance when necessary. Mr. Oas also testified that prior to his employment, Tracy Cook, another speech and language pathologist, provided services to all students in the Friendship School, including Student. The Hearing Officer also understood that Friendship School employed occupational and physical therapist consultants to provide an integrated program for the students at Friendship School. The Hearing Officer does not find any harm in SDCOE’s provision of additional services, as it was part of the Friendship School’s integrated program. Further, during the entire time that Mr. Oas worked with Student, the Student had made his request for additional SP/L services very clear in all of his due process pleadings and the Student specifically requested the amount of services that were provided by SDCOE. The Hearing Officer finds that SDCOE’s provision of speech and language services, as part of its integrated comprehensive educational program at Friendship School was not a violation of the IDEA. Furthermore, even if it was a technical violation, the Student suffered no harm from the provision of services since thrice weekly direct SP/L services is exactly what his conservators insist he should have been receiving. Moreover, the Hearing Officer notes that Student’s conservator, Conservator 1, has taught at the Friendship School since 1995 and is well aware of the integrated nature of the program at the Friendship School. Conservator 1 never opposed the provision of direct services as part of the program at the Friendship School at any of the IEP meetings she has attended on Student’s behalf.

The Student also continued to contend that he was given improper personal care. The Student failed to present any new or additional evidence regarding the 2003-2004 school year and maintained the same arguments as mentioned above. Further, Conservator 1 no longer worked at Friendship School on a daily basis and based her arguments on a continued perception from the previous school year. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds no evidence that Student received improper personal care during the 2003-2004 school year.

Was Student’s placement in the least restrictive environment?

The Student contends that he was denied an opportunity to socialize with non-disabled members of the community.

As previously stated, special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a student from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in regular education classes cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.)

Student’s IEP indicated that Student would participate with non-disabled peers during walks and planned events. Conservator 1 testified that Student did not get an opportunity to go out into the community. However, Conservator 1 also testified that Student has a lot of health problems and cannot be taken out if he is sick. Ms. Button testified that she took Student out about twice a year only because the conservators gave her explicit instructions not to take him out when he was sick or had sinus problems. No evidence was submitted to suggest that Student was treated differently from the other students in Ms. Button’s classroom. The Hearing Officer finds that Student had the appropriate amount of community involvement considering his health limitations.

Procedural Safeguards—

The Student contends that the SDCOE and CCS violated his procedural rights because CCS conducted OT and PT assessments without the conservators’ consent. Further, the Student contends that SDCOE failed to consider the Student’s independent assessments and offer him a continuum of placement options. The Student also continued to argue that the IEP was written prior to the IEP meetings.

SDCOE and CCS contend that they conducted proper assessments and considered all information that they had available during the IEP meetings held in February and March 2003. SDCOE also contends that it discussed possible placement within the Sweetwater School District, but that Conservator 2 observed the placement and was not interested in placing Student there.

Regarding the conducting of assessments, CCS conducted OT testing in September and November 2003 to update Student’s present levels of performance in conjunction with its medical therapy unit’s (MTU) conference held on November 21, 2003. Title 2 of the California Code of Regulations sets forth the guidelines and authority for CCS to provide medically necessary OT and PT to students with Student’s educational needs. Section 60323 requires that the medical therapy unit conduct assessments to determine a child’s OT and PT needs. If a child is eligible, the MTU must develop a plan of services and ensure that the goals and objectives are included in the child’s IEP and is responsible for ensuring that the student’s OT and PT services are delivered in accordance with the student’s therapy plan. Further, section 60325 requires that CCS provide a copy of its assessment and therapy plan to the IEP team and inform the IEP team and the parent within five days if there is a decision to increase, decrease, or change the type of intervention. The Code does not require that parental consent be obtained prior to an annual progress report that is conducted in conjunction with the MTU. Further, the Code indicates that parents need only be informed if there is a change in services provided. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that CCS did not violate any guidelines in conducting its testing to update Student’s OT and PT needs.

In regards to the consideration of privately obtained assessments, the Student obtained two assessments that it made the District aware of: a SP/L assessment by Susan Berkowitz and a PT assessment by Dr. Ardith Williams-Meyers. Ms. Berkowitz completed her assessment on May 23, 2003 and Dr. Williams-Meyers completed her assessment on December 5, 2003. Neither report was considered by the IEP teams in February and March 2003 because neither assessment had been completed by that time. However, there is evidence that Ms. Berkowitz’s assessment was considered by SDCOE because Mr. Oas began working with Student on a more frequent basis per Ms. Berkowitz’s recommendations. Further, Dr. Williams-Meyers’ assessment was only given to SDCOE and CCS in preparation for the due process hearing in March 2004. The Hearing Officer finds the Student’s contention disingenuous, as he did not give SDCOE or CCS an opportunity to review and consider the reports prior to the February and March 2003 IEP meetings. The SDCOE and CCS did not have access to the assessments and therefore committed no procedural violations. (Footnote 18)

Finally, the Student contends that SDCOE failed to offer a continuum of placement options. Again, the Student’s contention is without merit. California Education Code sections 56360 and 56361 require that the special education local plan area ensure that a continuum of program options be available to meet the needs of individuals with exceptional needs. However, a continuum of placement options does not need to be offered to an individual student. As previously found above, SDCOE appropriately used educational and professional expertise to offer a program from the available continuum that was appropriate for Student. The Hearing Officer finds that the SDCOE did not deny Student a FAPE by not offering him a continuum of placement options.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that SDCOE and CCS offered and/or provided Student a FAPE from the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year through April 2004.

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that SDCOE and CCS offered and/or provided Student with a FAPE from October 1999 through April 2004.

ORDERS

1. The Hearing Officer hereby determines that the District’s proposed IEP dated March 24, 2003 is appropriate and may be implemented.

2. Student’s claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507 (d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with the statute: San Diego County Office of Education and California Children’s Services prevailed on all issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56505 (i).)

Date June 18, 2004 ______________________________________Jessica Katz, Hearing OfficerCalifornia Special Education Hearing Office

This matter was consolidated by the Hearing Office and by mutual agreement of the parties on December 16, 2003. The Student proposed the issues as stated above. On cross-filing, SDCOE set forth as its issues that it offered Student a FAPE at the March 24, 2003 IEP meeting and indicated that its March 24, 2003 offer remained in effect through April 2004.

2 There is no dispute that Student qualified for and required ESY during the school years at issue; therefore, when the Hearing Officer refers to a particular school year throughout this Decision, it will always include ESY, unless specified otherwise.

3 Hypotonia is defined as a condition of diminished tone of the skeletal muscles. (Cal. Code of Regs., title 17 § 52000(b)(23).)

4 Friendship Home and Friendship School are situated on the same property but are not affiliated. The Friendship Home is a private residential placement. The Friendship School is operated by SDCOE and is located within the boundaries of National City School District and utilizes many resources that the District offered and provided.

5 Although Student’s placement in Conservator 1’s class began in 1995, the Hearing Officer will only address his placement and services from October 1999, three years from the date of the due process filing.

6 The parties agreed to hold his triennial review a year early in order to conduct thorough assessments of Student.

7 The Student also had filed claims against Student’s prior school districts, Lakeside Union School District and Cajon Valley Union School District. Both parties were dismissed by Decision dated March 3, 2004.

8 The parties convened Student’s annual IEP meeting in March 2004; however, due to the present due process matter, no agreement was reached and the parties did not submit evidence on the March 2004 IEP. Further, the parties agreed at hearing that the March 24, 2003 IEP offer through April 2004.

9 Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a student from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in regular education classes cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.) In this case, LRE was not raised as an issue from October 1999 through February 2002, and therefore, it will not be addressed during the analysis of these school years.

10The MTU met one to two times a year at Student’s home placement, Friendship Home. OT and PT providers from CCS, Student’s doctors, staff from Friendship School, and his care staff were present at the MTU meetings. The occupational and physical therapists presented progress reports at Student’s MTU meetings and forwarded all reports to Conservator 1. Additionally, Student’s qualified mental retardation professional (QMRP) from Friendship Home participated in the MTU meetings, attended most IEP meetings, and worked in conjunction with Conservator 1 and the staff at Friendship School.

11 Ms. Cortney explained that electrodes are placed on the surface of the muscles sending electrical currents to the muscles as a passive muscle strengthening exercise.

12 The Hearing Officer notes that although a placement must be designed to meet his unique needs and be “reasonably calculated” to provide a child with educational benefit, there is no guarantee of progress and a failure to make progress does not in and of itself constitute a denial of FAPE. 34 C.F.R. § 300.350; Cal Educ. Code § 56345(c). A child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. (Mrs. B v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997).)

13 Ms. Button passed away approximately one week after the conclusion of the due process hearing.

14 Conservator 2 is a sixth-grade general education teacher in the Chula Vista School District. He also holds a special education clear credential to work with learning disabled students. He has never worked as a teacher of severely handicapped students.

15 Mr. Lopez and Ms. Espinosa participated in the IEP team meeting as representatives of local school districts within the SELPA that could potentially provide services to Student. Sweetwater was discussed as an alternative placement for Student.

16 Dr. Williams-Meyers also recommended in her assessment and testimony that Student needs an upright stander to allow him to stand during the day and on weekends and a Ranger tricycle with removable trunk

17 Conservator 1 went on medical leave in October 2002 and has remained on medical leave continuously since that time.

18 As stated previously, neither party put at issue the IEP held most recently in March 2004.