California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 29, 1996
Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 240-94 · Hearing Officer Kathleen S. Chovan
Los Angeles Unified may reassess an 18-year-old student; interim home instruction ordered, and nonpublic tutoring and vision therapy denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
At the June 28, 1995 hearing the parties reached an interim agreement that was not carried out, so the hearing reconvened. The hearing was later taken off calendar so the parent could seek counsel, then recalendared. No remand, court order, or correction is noted.
Summary
The student's mother filed for due process against Los Angeles Unified School District in March 1994. The case grew to cover the district's right to reassess, the student's placement, and vision therapy. The student was 18. He was eligible for special education under the then-used category of mental retardation ("trainable mentally retarded"), but his mother believed he had a learning disability. He had missed a great deal of school, had received no services since July 1995, and was last assessed in 1992.
Hearing Officer Kathleen Chovan held that the district could do a triennial reassessment, including vision and visual perception. She ordered the mother to make him available. The mother agreed the reassessment was overdue but wanted it delayed until after a year of tutoring. The Hearing Officer said that disagreeing with the expected results is not a reason to block an assessment. On placement, neither side prevailed. The mother asked for tutoring from the Kelter Center, a nonpublic agency, but offered no evidence about it. The district proposed a special day class at a public high school. The Hearing Officer found that setting unsuitable for the short time left in the school year, given the student's emotional distress from his last placement. She ordered five hours per week of home instruction, where he had made progress before, as an interim placement. The vision therapy request was premature until the district's assessment was finished. Requests to add eligibility and compensatory education came too late in the hearing and were not decided.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO handled a parent's objection to an overdue triennial reassessment: disagreeing with the likely results did not justify a delay. It also shows a Hearing Officer rejecting both parties' placement proposals. Instead, she ordered short-term home instruction based on the student's past progress and the time left in the school year.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 1. Is the District entitled to conduct a triennial assessment of STUDENT under California Education Code section 56381?
The District may conduct an overdue triennial assessment, including vision and visual perception and a possible mental health referral; the parent's wish to delay until the student caught up academically did not justify blocking it.
- Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE
Issue 2. What is the appropriate placement for STUDENT at this time?
The District's proposed public school placements were not appropriate as an interim placement for the rest of the school year, and the requested Kelter Center tutoring was unsupported by evidence; the Hearing Officer ordered five hours per week of home instruction until reassessment and an IEP meeting.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. Does STUDENT require perceptual training or vision therapy as a related service?
A decision on vision therapy was premature until the District completed its vision assessment, which must consider the private optometrist's report; the request was denied without prejudice to a later hearing.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order that district may assess without consent. District entitled to conduct triennial assessment under Ed. Code 56381, including vision and visual perception; Mother shall make Student available for assessment.
- Placement ordered. District to provide 5 hours per week of home instruction as interim placement, starting within 15 calendar days of the order, until the triennial review is completed and an IEP meeting is held, ending no later than the conclusion of the 1996 extended school year.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of the order, District to convene an IEP meeting to amend the IEP to provide the interim placement.
Key authorities
Board of Education v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176; Cal. Ed. Code 56381; Cal. Ed. Code 56506(e); Cal. Ed. Code 56329(b); Cal. Ed. Code 56507(d); 20 U.S.C. 1412(5)(B); 34 C.F.R. 300.550
People named in the decision
- Lou-Ann Webber Novak, home instructor; teacher, Pacific Boulevard Special Education Center, LAUSD
- Billie Thomas, school psychologist, LAUSD
- Paul Mueller, coordinator, Special Education Division, South, LAUSD
- Patricia Patterson, program specialist, Special Education Unit - South, LAUSD
- Anita Dave, teacher, Narbonne High School, LAUSD
- Terry Ho, teacher, Narbonne High School, LAUSD
- Ronald Filbin, teacher, Narbonne High School, LAUSD
- Nancy Ingerson, teacher, Narbonne High School, LAUSD
- Leonard Studley, teacher, Narbonne High School, LAUSD
- Alnita Rettig Dunn, school psychologist (1992 psychoeducational evaluation), LAUSD
- Gary Citron, private psychologist for Student
- James E. Saunders, M.D., Student's pediatrician
- Gary Etting, O.D., private optometrist (vision report)
- Kelter Center, nonpublic agency (tutoring requested by Student)
- Shirley H. Brown, District representative, coordinator, Due Process, LAUSD
- Valerie Vanaman, attorney for Student (June 28, 1995 only)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Kathleen Chovan, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Gardena, California, on June 28, 1995, September 26, 1995, January 30, 1996, and February 9, 1996.
Petitioner was represented by MOTHER, STUDENT's mother.(Footnote 1) Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD or District) was represented by Shirley H. Brown, coordinator, Due Process, Student Services Special Education. Also present on behalf of the District was Paul Mueller, coordinator, Special Education Division, South, LAUSD.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open until February 26, 1996, to allow Petitioner to submit additional evidence and to allow the District to respond to that evidence. Thereafter, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
MOTHER, STUDENT's mother, testified on behalf of Petitioner. Petitioner also called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Lou-Ann Webber Novak, teacher, Pacific Boulevard Special Education Center, LAUSD; and Billie Thomas, school psychologist, LAUSD. The following witnesses testified on behalf of Respondent: Paul Mueller; Patricia Patterson, program specialist, Special Education Unit - South, LAUSD; and the following teachers from Narbonne High School: Anita Dave, Terry Ho, Ronald Filbin, Nancy Ingerson, and Leonard Studley.
ISSUES
1. Is the District entitled to conduct a triennial assessment of STUDENT under California Education Code section 56381?
2. What is the appropriate placement for STUDENT at this time?
3. Does STUDENT require perceptual training or vision therapy as a related service?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
Issues for hearing
During the course of the hearing, Petitioner requested that the Hearing Officer address the following issues in addition to the issues identified above:
Eligibility
Midway into the hearing, MOTHER stated that an additional issue for hearing was whether "trainable mentally retarded" (TMR) was the appropriate eligibility category for STUDENT. MOTHER contended that STUDENT was not mentally retarded but, instead, was learning disabled. The District argued that STUDENT's eligibility category had not been identified as an issue for hearing, and that it was inappropriate for Petitioner to raise this issue in the middle of the hearing. The Hearing Officer concluded that Petitioner raised this issue too late in the hearing and that he could not therefore add eligibility as an issue.(Footnote 2)
Compensatory education
Petitioner also alleged midway through the course of this proceeding that the District had not provided him with an appropriate education, and requested that the Hearing Officer award compensatory education. The Hearing Officer notes that the issue of compensatory education was not an issue originally identified for hearing, and concludes that the issue of compensatory education was not raised by Petitioner in a timely manner. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will not address the issue of compensatory education in this proceeding. Petitioner is not precluded from filing for a separate hearing on the issue as to whether the District has provided him with an appropriate education in the past, and requesting compensatory education as his relief.(Footnote 3)
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is 18 years old and is eligible for special education by reason of mental retardation.(Footnote 4) STUDENT currently is not attending school and is not receiving services from the District.
STUDENT and his mother moved within the District's jurisdiction in September of 1990. The District assessed STUDENT for special education services in the fall of 1990 in response to his mother's referral, and found him eligible for special education services as "trainable mentally retarded" (TMR). Although the District offered special education placements to STUDENT, MOTHER disagreed with the placements offered. It is not clear whether STUDENT received any schooling during the 1990-91 or 1991-92 school years.(Footnote 5)
In the fall of 1992 (STUDENT's ninth grade year), STUDENT was enrolled in a Special Day Class (SDC) at Carnegie Junior High School. In October of 1992, when STUDENT was age fifteen, the District conducted a psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT at the request of MOTHER. Alnita Rettig Dunn, the District's psychologist, concluded that STUDENT was functioning at the three-to-six-year-old range in academics, language and communication skills, adaptive functioning in the home, school and community, and in most areas of his fine and gross motor development. (Joint P & R Exh. 10). Ms. Dunn noted that STUDENT was cooperative and friendly, but that he was often "viewed with ridicule and derision by his peers," which hurt and concerned him. (Id.)
In her recommendations, Ms. Dunn did not advise a change in STUDENT's eligibility of "TMR." She stressed the importance of STUDENT's maintaining consistent school attendance, and stated that in addition to receiving an education in academic areas, STUDENT needed to learn the survival skills necessary for him to function independently. (Id.)
On November 10, 1992, an IEP team meeting was held to address the nature of STUDENT's special needs and his placement. The District determined that STUDENT was eligible for special education services as TMR and recommended placement in an SDC and adapted physical education (APE). MOTHER did not sign this IEP because she disagreed with the District's assessment and the eligibility category of retardation. MOTHER also disagreed with the transportation offered STUDENT. (Pet./Res. Exh. 7)
STUDENT attended his SDC placement at Carnegie through December 1992, but did not attend school from approximately February to early April 1993 because of a disagreement between MOTHER and the District over transportation. Although STUDENT returned to school in the beginning of April, MOTHER removed him from school at the end of April because she contended that STUDENT's placement was inappropriate and that STUDENT had been harassed by students at school. Although MOTHER and the District attempted to resolve the disagreement over STUDENT's placement, STUDENT did not receive instruction for the remainder of the year.
In STUDENT's tenth grade year, school year 1993-94, STUDENT attended Carson High School. He was initially placed in the resource specialist program (RSP) for four periods per day, with a one-to-one aide and adapted goals. After STUDENT was in that program for approximately one month, the IEP team agreed that an SDC program would be more appropriate for STUDENT than the RSP program, and placed him in four SDC classes, an art class, and APE. The team agreed that STUDENT would continue to have a one-to-one aide, and noted that STUDENT's safety was a priority.
During this IEP team meeting, STUDENT's resource teachers reported that STUDENT was reading and writing at the preschool level. The teachers also reported that students tended to tease STUDENT and that he had a hard time responding appropriately. At MOTHER's request, the team agreed that STUDENT's eligibility category would be reevaluated at the end of the 1993-94 school year. (Pet./Res. Exh. 5)
STUDENT experienced difficulty in his program at Carson and made little progress. On November 12, 1993, STUDENT was suspended for allegedly threatening to shoot another student and himself. The parties attempted to address the problems that STUDENT was experiencing at Carson, but his attendance became spotty. On February 16, 1994, STUDENT's glasses were broken at school during an incident with another student in which STUDENT was hit in the face. MOTHER removed STUDENT from school at that time, and filed for a due process hearing on March 25, 1994, to address the destruction of STUDENT's glasses. She also alleged that STUDENT had been subjected to "continuous physical and mental abuse to STUDENT by students..." (Pet./Res. 30) STUDENT did not return to Carson after the incident with his glasses on February 16th.
On April 14, 1994, the parties met in mediation. The parties reached an agreement in which the District offered six nonpublic schools for STUDENT, and MOTHER agreed to select one of those schools as STUDENT's placement. The parties agreed that STUDENT would receive home teaching "for a maximum of 30 days or until STUDENT is placed." (Pet./Res. Exh. 2). STUDENT began receiving home instruction for five hours per week on May 23, 1994. At the request of MOTHER, he often received this instruction at a local library.
In April 1994, the District offered to assess STUDENT, but MOTHER refused consent for the assessment, indicating that STUDENT needed to "learn something" before he could be accurately assessed. (Pet./Res. Exh. 12).
STUDENT did well in home instruction, and the District agreed that STUDENT could remain in home instruction until MOTHER selected one of the nonpublic schools as STUDENT's placement. On October 3, 1994, the parties held an IEP team meeting to discuss STUDENT's placement, eligibility and assessment. At that time, STUDENT was still on home instruction because MOTHER had not agreed to any of the nonpublic school placements available to STUDENT. MOTHER disagreed with the placements offered because they were all for severely developmentally delayed students, and she felt that STUDENT was primarily learning handicapped and delayed because of lack of schooling. The team agreed, however, that STUDENT should be placed in an SDC in a small, nonpublic school setting because of STUDENT's difficulty in dealing with a large campus and his difficulty in dealing with peers. MOTHER also asked for a screening for APE, and for assessments to determine if STUDENT required vision therapy and speech and language services. (Pet./Res. Exh. 4)
On November 2, 1994, the parties met again in an IEP team meeting to discuss the results of the language and APE assessments. The team agreed that STUDENT was eligible for both of these services, but MOTHER disagreed with the assessments themselves because she felt they contained negative comments about STUDENT. The parties continued to discuss placement, and MOTHER reiterated that she would not agree to place STUDENT with low-functioning students. The IEP team continued to recommend a nonpublic school placement for STUDENT. (Pet./Res. Exh. 3)
In December 1994, STUDENT began receiving speech and language services and APE at Narbonne High School, but the parties could not agree to a specific nonpublic school placement. On January 13, 1995, the parties met in mediation and agreed that STUDENT would attend an SDC for learning disabled students at Narbonne High School, a public school within the District. STUDENT's schedule included special day classes in math, life science, English, and driver's education, and regular education classes in physical education (Footnote 6) and art. The parties agreed that STUDENT would have the assistance of a one-to-one aide throughout the day. The parties also agreed that STUDENT would receive home instruction for five hours per week through April 1995.
STUDENT began attending Narbonne at the end of January 1995. STUDENT's attendance was sporadic throughout the semester, in part because of various disputes between the parties regarding STUDENT's transportation. On April 4, 1995, the parties held an IEP team meeting to evaluate whether STUDENT's placement at Narbonne was appropriate. Although STUDENT's teachers noted concerns about STUDENT's absences, social skills, and ability to achieve in that setting, the parties agreed that STUDENT should stay at Narbonne through June 29, 1995. The parties agreed that the IEP team would reconvene after STUDENT's reevaluation to determine his appropriate placement for the 1995-96 school year. (Pet./Res. Exh. 62)
Although the parties agreed that STUDENT would stay at Narbonne for the remainder of the school year, STUDENT still experienced problems with attendance because of the parties' continuing disputes. STUDENT missed approximately two weeks of school because of an alleged racial slur by his bus driver and the inability of the parties to reach agreement on alternative transportation. On May 16, 1995, STUDENT was suspended for three days for bringing a cap gun to school. STUDENT did not return to school after this suspension because of several alleged incidents between STUDENT and school personnel.(Footnote 7)
On May 22, 1995, MOTHER requested home instruction because of the various disputes between STUDENT and the school. STUDENT's psychologist, Gary Citron, also recommended that STUDENT be placed on home instruction because of "unresolved issues at Narbonne High School." (Pet. Exh. A) The District refused to place STUDENT on home instruction, indicating that this was an issue for hearing. (Res. Exh. 96)
On June 28, 1995, the hearing in this matter commenced. At the hearing the parties reached an agreement that STUDENT would attend the extended school year program at Narbonne High School and that MOTHER would visit three designated nonpublic schools as potential placements for STUDENT. MOTHER agreed to notify the District by August 10, 1995, as to whether she wanted STUDENT to attend one of the three proposed nonpublic schools or to return to Narbonne in the fall of 1995. The parties also agreed that if MOTHER complied with the terms of the agreement, Petitioner would dismiss the case. However, if the agreement was not implemented, the parties agreed that the hearing would reconvene in September.
On July 10, 1995, STUDENT began attending the extended school year program at Narbonne. Although STUDENT had the assistance of a one-to-one aide, he continued to have difficulties with school personnel. After letters and phone calls were exchanged, MOTHER withdrew STUDENT from the extended school year program on July 20, 1995, because of these difficulties.
By mid-September 1995, STUDENT had not returned to Narbonne and MOTHER had not selected a nonpublic school for STUDENT. Since the terms of the agreement reached in June had not been met, a second day of hearing was held on September 26, 1995. At the hearing, MOTHER stated that she and STUDENT had observed the nonpublic schools suggested by the District, but that they had rejected those schools because the programs were for severely delayed students and they did not consider STUDENT to be severely delayed. MOTHER requested a continuance of the hearing to enable her to retain counsel. The parties agreed to take the hearing offcalendar for two months to enable MOTHER to obtain counsel. The parties also agreed that if neither party called the Hearing Office before November 26, 1995, to recalendar the hearing, the case would be dismissed without prejudice.
In November 1995, MOTHER contacted the Hearing Office to recalendar the hearing for January, 1996. Two additional days of hearing were held on January 30 and February 9, 1996. The record was held open until February 26, 1996, to allow the parties to submit additional documents. Thereafter, the record was closed and the case submitted. STUDENT is now 18 years old and has not attended school or received services since July 1995.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Petitioner contends that tutoring from the Kelter Center, a nonpublic agency, is the appropriate placement for him for one year. Petitioner contends that his academic needs are more important at this point than any socialization benefits that he could receive from attending a regular school. Petitioner contends he is too far behind academically to attend a regular high school at this time and that he will suffer mental and emotional harm if he returns to a public school setting.
Petitioner notes that home instruction or tutoring has been successful in the past and that he needs to succeed in a placement because of his age and the extent of his academic needs. Petitioner also alleges that the District should not be allowed to assess him at this time because this assessment will reflect the fact that he has missed an extensive amount of schooling rather than reflecting his actual abilities. Petitioner contends that he should receive a year of tutoring before he is assessed. Petitioner also contends that he should receive vision therapy as a related service, based on the assessment conducted by Gary Etting, O.D. F.C.O V.D., in July 1995.
Respondent contends that STUDENT's IEP of April 4, 1995, should be implemented in a special day class setting at a public high school with related services of transportation, speech and language, and APE.(Footnote 8) Respondent also notes that the assistance of a one-to-one aide is available to STUDENT throughout the day.
Respondent asserts that home instruction or tutoring from a nonpublic agency, such as the Kelter Center, is not an appropriate placement for STUDENT because it is not the least restrictive environment for him. Respondent further asserts that an important component of STUDENT's education is socialization with age-appropriate peers because he has missed so much school. Respondent contends that it is entitled to conduct an assessment of STUDENT, including a vision assessment, because his three-year reevaluation became due in November 1995, and because STUDENT has not received services since July 1995. Respondent asserts that Petitioner should be compelled to cooperate with its assessment of STUDENT, and that the Hearing Officer should order an IEP meeting to be held after Respondent's assessment.
DISCUSSION
Under the Individuals with Disabilities Act (IDEA) and state law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. (20 U.S.C. Section 1400(c); Education Code Section 56000) The term "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian and that conform with the student's individualized educational program. (20 U.S.C. Section 1401(a)(18)) "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child, including classroom instruction, instruction in physical education, home instruction, and instruction in hospitals and institutions." (20 U.S.C. Section 1401(a)(16))
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court further defined the term "free appropriate public education" as "educational instruction specially designed to meet the unique needs of the handicapped child, supported by such services as are necessary to permit the child 'to benefit' from the instruction. . . . [T]he definition also requires that such instruction and services . . . comport with the child's IEP." (458 U.S. 176, 188-89).
In Rowley, the Court also addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the student. (458 U.S. 176, 200-201)
California Education Code Section 56381 addresses when a District shall assess a special education student. Section 56381 provides that:
A reassessment of the pupil...shall be conducted at least every three years or more frequently, if conditions warrant, or if the pupil's parent or teacher requests a new assessment and a new individualized education program to be developed.
Prior written consent of the student's parent must be obtained before the District may conduct an assessment of the student unless the District prevails in a special education due process hearing regarding the right to assess the student over the objection of the parent. California Education Code section 56506(e).
1. Is the District entitled to conduct a triennial assessment of STUDENT under California Education Code section 56381?
The District contends that under California Education Code section 56381, it has the right and obligation to conduct a reassessment of STUDENT because his last assessment took place in the fall of 1992. In addition, the District argues that STUDENT has been out of school a considerable amount of time, which should be considered a condition warranting an assessment at this time.
MOTHER stipulated to the fact that STUDENT has not been assessed for over three years and that the District has a right to assess STUDENT by law. However, she contended that an assessment of STUDENT at this time would reflect STUDENT's absence from school rather than his actual abilities. Therefore, she requested that STUDENT's assessment be delayed until he had the opportunity to "catch up" academically in a tutoring program.
Although MOTHER's desire to have STUDENT do his best is understandable, the purpose of assessment in this context is to determine the student's needs, based on his present levels of performance, so that an appropriate placement may be provided. MOTHER's arguments reflect a disagreement with the anticipated results of the assessment rather than with the right of the District to conduct the assessment. Once the District has conducted the required assessments, MOTHER has the right to challenge the assessments themselves and the results obtained.In fact, the evidence showed that MOTHER has repeatedly requested that the District perform an assessment of STUDENT, because of her disagreement with its characterization of STUDENT as trainable mentally retarded. The evidence also showed, however, that MOTHER has never actually consented to assessment of STUDENT since 1992 because, in part, she wanted him to "learn something" before he was assessed.
STUDENT has missed a substantial amount of school since he was last assessed in 1992. The evidence showed that STUDENT has struggled with emotional issues over the past several years which have affected his ability to benefit from his education. Based on these facts, along with the requirement that a student be reevaluated every three years, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District is entitled to conduct a triennial assessment of STUDENT. That assessment may include a referral to mental health for an assessment as to whether STUDENT qualifies for AB 3632 Mental Health services.
In addition, MOTHER contended that STUDENT has a visual perception problem which affects his ability to learn. The District stipulated at the hearing that they would conduct a vision assessment of STUDENT. Therefore, as part of its assessment, the District shall assess STUDENT for potential disabilities in the area of vision and visual perception.
2. What is the appropriate placement for STUDENT at this time?:
As noted above, the Supreme Court in Rowley stated that an appropriate educational placement must include educational instruction and services that are individually designed to meet the unique needs of the student and provide educational benefit to the student. In this case, the evidence does not allow the Hearing Officer to make a determination regarding an extended placement for STUDENT (i.e, a placement for one year), because STUDENT's overall needs must be determined through an assessment, as discussed above. Therefore, the Hearing Officer is limited in this case to ordering an interim placement for STUDENT pending completion of his assessment, based on his most recent experience with schooling.
In this case, the evidence shows that STUDENT's primary need in the interim period while he is being assessed is a safe environment in which his significant academic deficiencies(Footnote 9) can be addressed, so that he can eventually transition back into a school setting.
MOTHER testified that STUDENT suffered emotional trauma from his experiences at Narbonne, and that he is on the verge of a nervous breakdown from the stress associated with going back to a public school. Lou-Ann Novak, STUDENT's home instructor, testified that STUDENT was anxious and upset after he visited various District programs as possible placements. She testified that STUDENT was anxious with her when he first started home instruction but that, over time, he relaxed and was able to learn.
In a letter dated February 15, 1996, Dr. James E. Saunders, M.D., STUDENT's pediatrician, stated that STUDENT may be suffering from emotional problems due to post traumatic stress syndrome, and noted that STUDENT had been referred to a psychiatrist for evaluation and treatment, including possible medication. Dr. Saunders recommended that STUDENT receive home teaching for the duration of the school year because of these problems. (Pet. Exh. GG)
The District argued that Dr. Saunders' letter only made reference to potential problems, and that Petitioner had not submitted sufficient evidence indicating that he was physically or emotionally unable to attend school. While Dr. Saunders' letter by itself is not conclusive on the extent of STUDENT's emotional distress, it is consistent with a letter written by Gary Citron, STUDENT's psychologist, in May 1995. In that letter, Dr. Citron states that STUDENT had been "increasingly emotionally stressed and upset due to unresolved issues at Narbonne High School." (Pet. Exh. A) Dr. Citron recommended home instruction as an interim measure until the issues were resolved.
The District also argued that its programs represent the least restrictive environment(Footnote 10) for STUDENT, and that home instruction or tutoring is too restrictive a placement for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer acknowledges that, except for MOTHER, all of the witnesses indicated that one of STUDENT's most significant needs was to be back in school to interact with young people his own age and to learn life functioning skills. Based on this evidence, there is no question that STUDENT's socialization needs must be a primary component of any extended placement for STUDENT.
However, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded that STUDENT's socialization needs outweigh concerns regarding his mental and emotional health for purposes of this interim placement. STUDENT has been out of school for a significant amount of time, and the evidence showed that STUDENT experienced difficulty in his last school placement. These factors, in addition to the testimony of Ms. Novak, support a conclusion that STUDENT will need time to become adjusted to an academic environment. Since any placement at this point would occur in late spring, it is unlikely that STUDENT would have sufficient time to become acclimated to the school setting and establish relationships with his peers before the end of the year.
Based on this evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT's primary need during this interim placement is to receive instruction in an environment in which he feels safe, and which will enable him to learn. Placement in a school setting at the end of the school year will not afford STUDENT the time he requires to feel secure in order to benefit from his education. The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that the District's proposed placements are not appropriate for STUDENT at this time.
Petitioner has requested that he receive one year of tutoring from the Kelter Center, a nonpublic agency, at the level of 2-4 hours per week. However, Petitioner provided no information regarding the Kelter Center. Therefore, the Hearing Officer has no basis to conclude that tutoring from the Kelter Center would be an appropriate placement for STUDENT.
However, the evidence shows that STUDENT has had some success in home instruction. MOTHER testified that home instruction has been the only placement in which STUDENT has felt safe, and that he learned as a result of his comfort in that setting. Lou-Ann Novak, STUDENT's home instructor, also testified that STUDENT made progress while on home instruction. STUDENT's progress reports from that period show that STUDENT received marks of "good" or "outstanding" in all of his subjects and that he made an excellent effort in all areas. The progress report also notes that STUDENT had excellent work habits and that he had no absences or marks for tardiness.(Footnote 11) The report notes that STUDENT improved one grade level between the period of September 12 and November 4, 1994. (Pet. Exh. M) Based on this evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has had a positive experience in home instruction.
In this case, neither party has proposed an appropriate placement for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer has no information regarding the Kelter Center, as proposed by Petitioner, and has determined that a public school setting, as proposed by Respondent, is not an appropriate interim placement. However, STUDENT is entitled to receive a free appropriate public education under federal and state law. Based on the limited evidence presented in this case, home instruction is the only placement demonstrated to be successful for STUDENT. Although home instruction may not ultimately be an appropriate long-term placement for STUDENT, the Hearing Officer concludes that home instruction is the most appropriate placement for STUDENT for the interim period prior to the completion of his assessment.(Footnote 12)
During his home instruction, STUDENT received five hours per week of home instruction, and made educational progress at that level. Based on the limited duration of this placement, and the fact that STUDENT made progress previously, the Hearing Officer finds that five hours per week of home instruction is an appropriate level of services for STUDENT for this interim placement. The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT should receive five hours per week of home instruction for the interim period while STUDENT is assessed.
3. Does STUDENT require perceptual training or vision therapy as a related service?
Petitioner contends that he requires vision therapy as a related service in order to benefit from his education. Petitioner bases his claim on a optometric vision report by Gary Etting, O.D.F.C.O.V.D., dated July 5, 1995, which recommends that STUDENT receive vision therapy. (Pet. Exh. C) Respondent contends that it is entitled to assess STUDENT with regard to any visual problems.
The Hearing Officer concluded above that the District is entitled to conduct a triennial assessment of STUDENT. The District agreed that they would assess STUDENT in the area of vision and visual perception problems. In addition, under California Education Code section 56329(b), the District must consider Dr. Etting's report in determining an appropriate placement for STUDENT. Since the District is entitled to assess STUDENT regarding his potential visual problems, the Hearing Officer concludes that a determination regarding vision therapy is premature at this time. Petitioner is not precluded from requesting a hearing regarding the issue of vision therapy following completion of the District's assessment.
ORDER
1. The District is entitled to conduct a triennial assessment of STUDENT pursuant to California Education Code section 56381, including an assessment of STUDENT's needs in the areas of vision and visual perception.
2. MOTHER shall make STUDENT available for assessment by the District.
3. The District shall provide STUDENT with five (5) hours per week of home instruction as a interim placement for STUDENT, to be commenced no later than fifteen (15) calendar days from the date of this Order. This interim placement shall remain in effect until the District completes its triennial review of STUDENT and an IEP team meeting is held. However, this interim placement shall end no later than the conclusion of the 1996 extended school year.
4. Within fifteen (15) calendar days of the date of this Order, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting to amend STUDENT's individualized education program (IEP) to provide an interim placement in accordance with this Order.
5. Petitioner's request for tutoring from the Kelter Center is denied.
6. Petitioner's request for vision therapy as a related service is denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
1. Is the District entitled to conduct a triennial assessment of STUDENT under California Education Code section 56381?
Respondent prevailed on this issue.
2. What is the appropriate placement for STUDENT at this time?
Neither party prevailed on this issue.
3. Does STUDENT require perceptual training or vision therapy as a related service?
Respondent prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
DATED: March 29, 1996 ________________________________ Kathleen Chovan, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES
1. In addition to his mother, Petitioner was represented by Valerie Vanaman, attorney, at the hearing on June 28, 1995. Ms. Vanaman notified the Hearing Office in July 1995 that MOTHER had withdrawn her consent for her to represent STUDENT in this matter. Petitioner was represented by his mother on the hearing dates subsequent to June 28, 1995.
2.In addition, the Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT's three-year reevaluation was due in November 1995, and that STUDENT has been out of school since July of 1995. Therefore, even if Petitioner had raised this issue in a timely manner, any determination made in this hearing regarding STUDENT's eligibility would have been based on dated evidence and would have had to be revised after STUDENT's next assessment.
3. The Hearing Officer notes that although both parties submitted evidence regarding their ongoing dispute over the last few years, the main issue addressed at the hearing was the determination of the appropriate placement for STUDENT at this time, in light of his age and the amount of time he has been out of school. As such, the evidence presented centered on STUDENT's current needs, based on his most recent experiences in school, and his need for assessment.
4. STUDENT's IEPs between the period of November 10, 1992, through November 2, 1994, all listed STUDENT's eligibility criteria as "TMR" (trainable mentally retarded). STUDENT's most recent IEP, dated April 4, 1995, lists the following under STUDENT's eligibility criteria: "Undeclared until next assessment as per mediation agreement 1-13-95." (Joint P & R Exh. 62) As discussed below, STUDENT has not been assessed since his April 4, 1995 IEP, and, therefore, the parties have been unable to resolve their disagreement over the appropriate eligibility designation for STUDENT.
5. The evidence showed that the District offered several special education placements for STUDENT in January 1991, but no evidence was provided indicating that STUDENT attended public school during either the 1990-91 or the 1991-92 school year. MOTHER testified that STUDENT did not go to a public school in 1990-91 but that she sent him to private school for several months of that year. MOTHER had no recollection of whether STUDENT attended school during the 1991-92 school year, but stated that he may have attempted to attend private school during that time as well.
6. Although STUDENT remained eligible for APE, MOTHER declined those services, stating that STUDENT's APE class was inappropriate because it contained too many orthopedically handicapped students.
7. STUDENT alleged that he had been made to pick up paper from the ground as a "punishment" and that the assistant principal had pulled him out of class by his ear.
8. Respondent noted that the IEP team found STUDENT eligible for APE, but that STUDENT may decline APE as a related service and attend regular physical education classes.
9. Both parties agreed that STUDENT has significant needs in all academic areas. At the time of STUDENT's last IEP, in April 1995, STUDENT was 17 years old and in the eleventh grade. In the progress report for this IEP, all of STUDENT's teachers reported that he was approximately at the kindergarten to first grade level of academic achievement. (Pet./Res. Exh. 62)
10. The "least restrictive environment" mandate of IDEA requires that "to the maximum extent appropriate" children with disabilities are educated with children who are not disabled. In addition, the IDEA requires that special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily . . . .
(20 U.S.C. Section 1412(5)(B), 34 C.F.R. Section 300.550)
11. As noted above, STUDENT often received his "home instruction" at a local library, at the request of MOTHER.
12. As noted above, the Hearing Officer's decision on placement in this case is based primarily on the factors that STUDENT has been out of school for an extended period of time, that he needs to be assessed, and that the placement resulting from this decision will be implemented at the end of the regular school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer makes no determination in this case as to whether the placements proposed by the District would be appropriate for STUDENT at some point, given the appropriate level of support and transitional services. The Hearing Officer encourages the parties to develop a plan for STUDENT to facilitate his transition back into a school setting once his assessments are complete.
