California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 31, 2004

Student v. Magnolia Elementary School District (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 2454-04 · Hearing Officer Patrick J. Balucan

Magnolia Elementary School District offered FAPE to a preschooler with autism and may reassess him; all reimbursement claims denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 12 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The decision also denied as moot the District's post-hearing motion to observe the in-home ACES program under Education Code section 56329(d). This did not affect the District's right to observe the student at home as part of the reassessment. The decision mentions no remand, vacatur, or correction.

Summary

The parents of a 4-year-old boy with autism filed for due process against Magnolia Elementary School District in Orange County. The district then filed its own case to reassess him without parental consent. The district found him eligible under autistic-like behaviors and significantly below average intellect. It offered a preschool special day class (SDC) at Salk Elementary with speech, occupational therapy (OT), and applied behavior analysis (ABA) built into the class. The parents wanted 35 to 40 hours a week of in-home ABA plus individual clinic-based speech therapy and OT. They paid for private assessments and services. Later, the district offered an autism SDC at Weaver Elementary with added individual speech, OT, and 10 hours a week of in-home ABA. The parents did not attend the October 2004 IEP meeting.

The Hearing Officer found that the district's January 2004 assessment was appropriate. Using the Slossen Intelligence Test informally as a screening tool was acceptable. However, the report should have said the test was given in a non-standard way. No remedy was ordered for that omission. The Hearing Officer gave more weight to district experts Dr. Ronald Leaf and Dr. Betty Jo Freeman than to the family's private assessors. Every IEP offered FAPE. The district's August 2004 letter changing its offer did not violate the parents' rights, and the October meeting was properly held without them. All requests for reimbursement and services were denied. The district may reassess under its August 25, 2004 plan.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO weighed a school-based autism preschool with built-in services against a parent-requested intensive in-home ABA program under the Rowley standard. It also shows that a district must report non-standard test administration. And it shows that conflicting expert opinions can justify reassessing a child over the parents' objection.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailed in partAssessment

    Issue 1. Was the District's January 2004 preschool transdisciplinary assessment conducted appropriately?

    Using the Slossen Intelligence Test as a non-standardized screening tool, the classroom observation at Salk, and reliance on Kaiser speech and OT data were appropriate. However, the report failed to state that the test was given in a non-standard way. No remedy was awarded.

  2. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE at the February 25, 2004, March 19, 2004, and July 6, 2004 IEP meetings?

    The district considered the private assessments and was not required to file for due process sooner. The eligibility finding was correct. The Salk SDC with embedded speech, OT and ABA met the student's needs, and his goals and language needs were properly addressed. FAPE was offered.

  3. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 3. Did the District appropriately make an offer of placement in the August 2, 2004 letter to STUDENT's parents?

    The letter changing the offer reflected discussions at the July 6 IEP meeting and was also a settlement attempt. No IEP meeting was required, and parent participation was not impaired.

  4. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 4. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE at the October 18, 2004 IEP meeting?

    The notice stated the meeting's purpose, and the district made sufficient attempts to schedule with the parents before meeting without them. The Weaver autism SDC with added individual speech, OT and 10 hours of in-home ABA offered FAPE.

  5. Issue 5a. If the District failed to offer a FAPE, is Student entitled to reimbursement for the speech and language assessment and services provided by Abby Rozenberg?

    Denied because FAPE was offered and the district appropriately assessed speech and language.

  6. Issue 5b. If the District failed to offer a FAPE, is Student entitled to reimbursement for the occupational therapy assessment and services provided by Nancy Lin?

    Denied because FAPE was offered and the district appropriately assessed OT needs.

  7. Issue 5c. If the District failed to offer a FAPE, is Student entitled to reimbursement for the psychoeducational assessment by Dr. Christine Davidson?

    Denied. The district's psychoeducational assessment was appropriate despite the minor reporting omission, and the omission did not cause the private assessment.

  8. Issue 5d. If the District failed to offer a FAPE, is Student entitled to reimbursement for the behavioral therapy assessment and services provided by ACES, Inc.?

    Denied. FAPE was offered, and the ACES assessment was only a precursor to privately chosen services that were not needed for FAPE.

  9. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 6a. Does STUDENT require in-home applied behavior analysis (ABA) therapy for thirty-five hours per week in order to receive a FAPE?

    Denied because the district's program met his needs.

  10. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 6b. Does STUDENT require speech and language services at Buena Park Speech and Language Development Center for three hours per week in order to receive a FAPE?

    Denied because the district's program met his needs.

  11. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 6c. Does STUDENT require individual clinic based occupational therapy services for two hours per week in order to receive a FAPE?

    Denied because the district's program met his needs.

  12. Issue 7. Should the District be allowed to assess STUDENT without his parents' consent pursuant to the August 25, 2004 assessment plan?

    Conditions warranted reassessment because expert opinions conflicted and the student's skills varied across settings. The district may assess under the August 25, 2004 plan over the parents' objection.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order that district's offer may be implemented. If the parents want a publicly funded program through the District, they must make the student available for services under the October 18, 2004 IEP. The District must remain ready and able to implement all parts of that IEP if the parents choose to have him attend Weaver Elementary School.
  • Order that district may assess without consent. The District may assess the student under its proposed assessment plan dated August 25, 2004, over the parents' objection. The parents must make him available for this assessment if they want a publicly funded program through the District.
  • No remedy was awarded for the omission of the non-standard administration statement from the assessment report. All of Student's requests for relief were denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range; Clyde K. v. Puyallup; Gregory K. v. Longview; Burlington; Student W. v. Puyallup; Andress v. Cleveland ISD; Vander Malle v. Ambach

People named in the decision

  • Debbie Wegner, school psychologist, Magnolia Elementary School District
  • Cherie Bauer, speech-language pathologist and program specialist, District / GASELPA
  • Annette Cleveland, administrator of special education, Magnolia Elementary School District
  • John Richard Reid, Jr., coordinator of special education, Magnolia Elementary School District
  • Agnes Arneaud, special day class preschool teacher, Salk Elementary School, District
  • Cari Yamafuji, special day class teacher, Weaver Elementary School, District
  • Sarah Morgan, preschool teacher who took part in the assessment, District
  • Candy Miller, regional administrator, GASELPA
  • Patricia Polcyn, coordinator of occupational and physical therapy, GASELPA
  • Glenda McHale, autism program coordinator, GASELPA
  • Dr. Ronald Leaf, director, expert witness for District, Autism Partnership
  • Dr. Mitchell Taubman, director of research, expert witness for District, Autism Partnership
  • Dr. Betty Jo Freeman, psychologist, District consultant and expert witness, UCLA (emeritus)
  • Dr. David Rostetter, special education consultant, District witness
  • Abby Rozenberg, private speech-language pathologist
  • Nancy Lin, private occupational therapist
  • Dr. Christine Davidson, private psychologist, expert witness for Student
  • Ellen Bender, ABA therapist, ACES, Inc.
  • Dr. Sharyn Kerr, senior therapist / clinic director, ACES, Inc.
  • ACES, Inc., private in-home ABA provider (nonpublic agency)
  • Autism Partnership, autism services and training provider consulting with the District
  • Dr. Cindy Evans, diagnosing physician, Kaiser-Permanente Medical Center, Anaheim
  • Buena Park Speech and Language Development Center, private speech-language provider requested by Student

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Patrick J. Balucan, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Anaheim, California, on October 27-29 and November 2-5, 2004.

Petitioner and Cross-Respondent STUDENT (Student or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorneys Ellen Bacon and Mike Jewell from the law office of Roberts, Adams and Jewell. Also present on his behalf was his mother, MOTHER. Respondent and Cross-Petitioner Magnolia Elementary School District (District) was represented at the hearing by Charles Weatherly and Jennifer Fain with The Weatherly Law Office. Also present on the District’s behalf was Annette Cleveland, the District’s administrator of special education. The Greater Anaheim Special Education Local Plan Area (GASELPA) was also present on the first day of hearing and was represented at hearing by Mr. Weatherly and Ms. Fain. Also present on its behalf was Candy Miller, the regional administrator for GASELPA. (Footnote 1)

Student called the following witnesses to testify: Debbie Wegner, a school psychologist with the District; MOTHER; Abby Rozenberg, a private speech and language therapist; Nancy Lin, a private occupational therapist; Ellen Bender, his ACES, Inc. applied behavior analysis (ABA) therapist; Dr. Christine Davidson, a private psychologist; and Dr. Sharyn Kerr, the senior therapist at ACES, Inc. The District called the following witnesses to testify: Dr. Ronald Leaf, the director of Autism Partnership; Patricia Polcyn, the coordinator of occupational therapy and physical therapy with GASELPA; John Richard Reid, Jr., coordinator of special education with the District; Ms. Cleveland; Cherie Bauer, a program specialist with the District; Glenda McHale, autism program coordinator with GASELPA; Agnes Arneaud, the special day class (SDC) teacher at Salk Elementary School; Cari Yamafuji, the SDC teacher at Weaver Elementary School; Dr. Mitchell Taubman, the director of research at Autism Partnership; Dr. David Rostetter, a special education consultant; and Dr. Betty Jo Freeman, a psychologist.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open for the receipt of closing briefs. After receipt of the closing briefs, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING

1. Was the District’s January 2004 preschool transdisciplinary assessment conducted appropriately?

2. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) at the February 25, 2004, March 19, 2004, and July 6, 2004 individualized education program (IEP) meetings?

3. Did the District appropriately make an offer of placement in the August 2, 2004 letter to STUDENT’s parents?

4. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE at the October 18, 2004 IEP meeting?

5. If the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE, is he entitled to reimbursement for the following assessments and services provided at his parents’ expense: a. Speech and language assessment and services provided by Abby Rozenberg; b. Occupational therapy assessment and services provided by Nancy Lin; c. Psychoeducational assessment by Dr. Christine Davidson; and d. Behavioral therapy assessment and services provided by ACES, Inc.?

6. Does STUDENT require the following services in order to receive a FAPE: a. In home applied behavior analysis (ABA) therapy for thirty-five hours per week; b. Speech and language services at Buena Park Speech and Language Development Center for three hours per week; and c. Individual clinic based occupational therapy services for two hours per week?

7. Should the District be allowed to assess STUDENT without his parents’ consent pursuant to the August 25, 2004 assessment plan?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a four-year-old student who is eligible for special education with a diagnosis of autism. STUDENT does not currently attend school in the District. In December of 2003, when STUDENT was three, Dr. Cindy Evans at the Kaiser-Permanente Medical Center in Anaheim diagnosed STUDENT with autism. Shortly after Dr. Evans’ diagnosis, MOTHER contacted the Magnolia Elementary School District (District) to have STUDENT assessed to determine his eligibility for special education services.

On January 20, 2004, Debbie Wegner, a District psychologist, and Cherie Bauer, a District speech and language pathologist, conducted a preschool transdisciplinary assessment of STUDENT. As part of this assessment, Ms. Wegner administered the Slossen Intelligence Test (SIT) to determine his academic ability level. Based on the results of the SIT, Ms. Wegner determined that STUDENT was functioning within the severely deficient range with skills comparable to a child twenty-three months of age. In a report dated February 5, 2004, Ms. Wegner determined that STUDENT qualified for special education because of his autistic-like behaviors and below average general intellectual functioning. Ms. Wegner recommended that STUDENT be involved in a language based preschool program, that he use the picture exchange communication system to express his wants and needs, and that sensory integration development be included as part of his educational program.

On February 25, 2004, the District convened a meeting of STUDENT’s individualized education program (IEP) team. At this meeting, Agnes Arneaud, the special day class (SDC) teacher at Salk Elementary School, presented draft versions of STUDENT’s goals and objectives that addressed the areas of fine motor, communication, preacademic skills, pre-vocational skills, social skills, self-help skills, and community based instruction. The District offered to place STUDENT in Ms. Arneaud’s SDC at Salk for his entire school day. The District also offered to provide health services for diapering and toileting, and adapted physical education (APE) services for STUDENT. The IEP noted his parents’ agreement with the results of the assessment and the goals and objectives. However, the document also noted Mr. and MOTHER’s lingering concerns regarding the amount of discrete trial therapy (DTT) that would be provided to STUDENT, and indicated their desire to review the IEP before agreeing to the placement. They did not provide their consent to implement the IEP.

Via letter dated March 8, 2004, MOTHER requested another meeting of STUDENT’s IEP team. His IEP team met again on March 19, 2004. Representatives from the Regional Center of Orange County were present at this meeting. At this meeting, the team discussed many different aspects of STUDENT’s placement in the preschool autism program, including the parents’ concerns regarding the amount of intensive one-to-one services STUDENT was to receive in the District program. The District continued to offer the SDC placement at Salk pursuant to the initial IEP meeting held on February 25, 2004. At this meeting, MOTHER again did not provide her consent to implement the program offered by the District.

After this meeting, MOTHER obtained several independent assessments of STUDENT. On April 15, 2004, Nancy Lin, a private occupational therapist, assessed STUDENT. Ms. Lin determined that STUDENT is severely delayed in his fine motor and visual motor skills. She developed several occupational therapy (OT) goals and objectives, and recommended that he receive individual occupational therapy three times per week for sixty minutes each session. Abby Rozenberg, a private speech and language pathologist, assessed STUDENT on April 21, 2004. Ms. Rozenberg determined that STUDENT had moderate to severe deficits in both receptive and expressive language. Ms. Rozenberg recommended that STUDENT receive individual speech and language therapy three times per week for sixty minutes each session. In May and June of 2004, STUDENT was assessed by Dr. Chris Davidson, a private psychologist. Dr. Davidson determined that STUDENT had a developmental age level of twenty-seven months. She recommended that STUDENT receive thirty-five to forty hours of one-to-one in-home applied behavior analysis (ABA) therapy. Via letter dated June 30, 2004, the parents informed the District that they would seek reimbursement for these privately obtained assessments.

On July 6, 2004, STUDENT’s IEP team met once again. Dr. Davidson, Ms. Rozenberg, and Ms. Lin were present at this meeting and presented the findings made in their assessments. However, the District continued to offer the services and placement outlined at the February 25, 2004 IEP meeting. The District also requested that MOTHER provide consent to conduct further assessments. MOTHER disagreed with the placement and services offered and requested that STUDENT be provided with one-to-one speech and language therapy three times per week for sixty minutes each session, one-to-one occupational therapy three times per week for sixty minutes each session, and thirty-five to forty hours per week of an in-home ABA program. MOTHER indicated her intent to provide these services to STUDENT and to seek reimbursement for these services. She also reiterated her request for reimbursement for the independent assessments, and did not provide consent for the District to conduct further assessments.

On July 22, 2004, the Hearing Office received the parents’ request for a due process hearing.

On August 2, 2004, Ms. Cleveland sent a letter to STUDENT’s parents delineating the District’s position regarding his request for services. Ms. Cleveland stated that the District would not reimburse the parents for the costs of the independent assessments. Via this letter, the District amended its placement offer to include the following services: SDC at Weaver Elementary School, ten hours per week of an in-home ABA program, individual speech and language services three times per week for sixty minutes each session through the month of August, and OT services three times per week for sixty minutes each session through the month of August. The parents did not provide consent to implement this amended offer.

In August of 2004, STUDENT’s parents began providing him with ABA therapy from ACES, Inc. at their expense.

On August 25, 2004, the District presented MOTHER with an assessment plan and requested that she consent to another District assessment of STUDENT. The assessment plan requested that a home observation be conducted and that the following areas, among others, be tested: academic/preacademic achievement, social/adaptive behavior, visual/auditory perception and processing/motor skills, language/ speech/communication development, and intellectual development. MOTHER did not provide her consent to conduct this assessment.

On October 4, 2004, the Hearing Office received the District’s request for a due process hearing. On October 11, 2004, the District sent a letter to Mr. and MOTHER requesting another IEP team meeting and forwarding potential dates for such a meeting. On October 15, 2004, after having not heard from the parents, the District sent a letter to Mr. and MOTHER indicating its intent to hold an IEP meeting on October 18, 2004. Via letter dated that same day, the parents’ attorney requested that the District “identify with specificity what new information has come to light which needs to be discussed at an IEP or the specific reasons why an IEP should be convened…”

On October 18, 2004, the District convened a meeting of STUDENT’s IEP team. PARENTS and their representative did not attend this meeting. At this meeting, the District offered the autism SDC at Weaver Elementary, APE twice per week in a group setting for thirty minutes each session, OT once per week for forty minutes in a group setting, speech and language therapy twice per week for thirty minutes each session in a group setting, and ten hours per week of in-home ABA support.

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Student contends that the District failed to conduct its January 2004 preschool transdisciplinary assessment appropriately. Student alleges that the District’s use of the Slossen Intelligence Test (SIT) was not appropriate because it was an outdated test that used a ratio formula to determine ability. Furthermore, the SIT was not administered appropriately because several questions on the test were left blank, and the test was administered to MOTHER and not to STUDENT. Student also argues that the observation portion of the assessment, which he alleges was conducted in an office at Salk Elementary, should have been conducted in an age-appropriate classroom. Finally, Student argues that the assessment failed to take into account Student’s specific areas of need because it did not include specific speech and language and occupational therapy (OT) tests.

Student further argues that the offer of placement made at the February 25, 2004 IEP meeting, which was re-confirmed at the March 19 and July 6, 2004 IEP meetings, did not offer him FAPE. Student argued that the offer of placement was procedurally deficient because the District failed to consider the input of his private assessors at the July 7, 2004 IEP meeting, and that the District failed to timely initiate a due process hearing in this matter. Student also argues that the District’s offer of placement failed to substantively offer him FAPE. First, Student argues that the District erroneously found him eligible under the category of below average intellectual functioning. Next, Student argues that the placement at Salk was not appropriate because it was for students who were functioning physically and cognitively below him. Furthermore, Student argued that the District did not take into account his limited English proficiency when making its placement offer. Student also contends that the District failed to offer any OT, speech and language therapy, or ABA services. Lastly, Student argues that the goals and objectives were not appropriate because the present levels of performance did not provide adequate baselines, the goals and objectives themselves were not objective or measurable, and they did not address all areas of need. Regarding the last contention, Student alleges that the goals and objectives in the District’s program did not address the following areas of need: speech and language, fine and gross motor skills, sensory integration, behavior, self-help skills, and play skills.

Student argues that the offer of placement made in Ms. Cleveland’s August 2, 2004 letter did not constitute FAPE. Student argues that this letter was an attempt to revise his IEP contrary to the requirements of State and federal special education law, and denied MOTHER the right to participate in the IEP process.

Finally, Student contends that the offer of placement made at the October 18, 2004 IEP meeting did not provide him with a FAPE. Student argues that the IEP was procedurally flawed because the District failed to convene the IEP meeting at a mutually agreeable time and date, and because the IEP notice did not state the purpose of the IEP meeting. Student argues that the IEP is substantively flawed because it does not contain goals and objectives that are objective or measurable. Furthermore, Student argues that the Weaver placement is not appropriate, that the District has not offered appropriate levels of OT, speech and language therapy, and in-home ABA services, and that the program fails to address his limited English proficiency.

As for the issue it presented for hearing, the District argued that it should be allowed to assess STUDENT without his parents’ consent because conditions warrant reassessment. The District argues that, in light of the information provided by STUDENT’s independent assessors, it requires a further assessment to assist it in understanding STUDENT’s unique needs.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue No. 1: Was the District’s January 2004 preschool transdisciplinary assessment conducted appropriately?

Student asserts that the January 2004 preschool transdisciplinary assessment was not conducted appropriately for several reasons. First, Student alleges that the District’s use of the Slossen Intelligence Test (SIT) was not appropriate because it was an outdated test that used a ratio formula to determine ability. Second, Student alleges that the SIT was not administered appropriately because several questions on the test were left blank, and the test was administered to MOTHER and not to him. Third, Student alleges that the observation portion of the assessment, which he alleges was conducted in an office at Salk Elementary, should have been conducted in an age-appropriate classroom. Finally, Student argues that the assessment failed to take into account Student’s specific areas of need because it did not include specific speech and language and occupational therapy (OT) tests. (Footnote 2) The District argues that the assessment was conducted appropriately for a student of STUDENT’s age and disability.

California Education Code section 56320, subsections (a) through (d), state in relevant part that testing and assessment materials and procedures must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; provided and administered in the student’s “primary language” or other mode of communication; be validated for the purposes for which they are used; administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; tailored to assess specific areas of need; and selected and administered to best ensure that, when administered to a pupil with impaired speaking skills, the test produces results that accurately reflect the student’s aptitude, achievement level, or any other factors the test purports to measure and not the student’s impaired speaking skills. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320, subs. (a) - (d) 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(2) and (3).) (Footnote 3)

California Education Code section 56320(e) requires that no single procedure be used as the sole criterion for determining the appropriate educational program for an individual with exceptional needs. California Education Code section 56320(f) requires that the pupil be assessed in all areas of suspected disability. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320, subs. (e) and (f); 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(2) and (3).)

Pursuant to subsection (g), the assessment must be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the student’s disability. California Education Code section 56322 also requires that the assessments be conducted by persons competent to perform the assessments. Additionally, California Education Code section 56324 requires that a credentialed school psychologist perform any psychological assessment. (Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56320(g), 56322, 56324.)

Student first argues that the District’s assessment was not appropriate because it used the SIT to determine his cognitive ability. Debbie Wegner, the District’s psychologist, used the SIT as part of the January transdisciplinary assessment. According to that assessment, STUDENT’s intellectual functioning was in the below average range. Student disagrees with that finding. Dr. Davidson, Student’s private psychologist, testified that the SIT was developed over forty years ago, and its use of the ratio formula to determine ability has been discredited. (Footnote 4) Student argues that because this test is of questionable validity in determining cognitive ability, the District did not appropriately test his intellectual functioning. Student argues that this test, therefore, was not designed to test his needs in the area of intellectual functioning pursuant to California Education Code section 56320(c).

The District readily admits that the psychological community has abandoned the SIT’s use of the ratio formula to obtain an intelligence quotient (I.Q.) and it is no longer best practice to use the SIT to determine cognitive ability. Ms. Wegner, however, testified that the District used the SIT as a screening device to obtain developmental information regarding STUDENT. Ms. Wegner testified that because of STUDENT’s presentation as a preschool child with autism, using a standardized test would have yielded little useful information. Therefore, she testified, she used the SIT in a non-standardized way as an alternative measure to determine what specific skills STUDENT had. Moreover, while she did note in her assessment report an I.Q. score of 43 and a finding that STUDENT was functioning within the severely deficient range in his skills, her report stressed that the performance measure should only be considered a “snapshot” of his intellectual functioning. Dr. Freeman, the District’s consultant, persuasively testified that it was consistent with the professional standards to use the SIT in a non-standardized way to assess children with autism. (Footnote 5) Ms. Wegner further testified that the results of the screening using the SIT were just one measure that was used to determine STUDENT’s intellectual functioning. Ms. Wegner also used the results of two other tests, the Developmental Profile-II and the Gilliam Autism Rating Scale, as well as the results of the Kaiser assessments and her observations of STUDENT, to conclude that his intellectual functioning was in the severely deficient range. (Footnote 6) Thus, the SIT was just one of several sources from which the District gathered information about STUDENT’s intellectual functioning. The Hearing Officer determines that the use of the SIT as a non-standardized screening tool was appropriate to test STUDENT’s needs related to intellectual functioning.

Student also argues that the SIT was not administered appropriately because several questions on the test were left blank, and because the test was administered to MOTHER and not to him. Student argues that the District failed to administer the test in conformance with the test instructions provided by the producer of the tests pursuant to California Education Code section 56320(b). However, as noted above, Ms. Wegner used the test as a screening device in order to determine whether STUDENT had acquired certain skills. Dr. Freeman credibly testified that it was appropriate testing procedure, especially for autistic children, to use the SIT in the non-standardized way to gauge STUDENT’s intellectual functioning. Thus, the Hearing Officer determines that it was appropriate for the District to use the SIT in a non-standardized way in this case.

Student further argues that federal regulations require that if a test is not conducted under standard conditions, the extent to which it varied from non-standard conditions must be included in the evaluation report. (34 C.F.R. § 300.532(c)(2).) Ms. Wegner testified that she did not use the SIT to arrive at an intelligence score, but merely used it as a screening device to obtain developmental information regarding STUDENT. Dr. Freeman testified that this was acceptable practice. However, a review of the District’s evaluation shows that Ms. Wegner failed to include in her report a statement that the SIT was administered in non-standard conditions, and failed to state the extent to which her administration of the SIT varied from non-standard conditions. Furthermore, the District presented no evidence that it explained to PARENTS that the SIT was administered in a non-standard way. Instead, the District’s assessment report includes both a mental age (23 months) and an IQ score (43), appearing for all intents and purposes that the District derived a standardized test score from the administration of the SIT. Moreover, not providing this information deprived PARENTS of all the necessary information required to evaluate the appropriateness of the District’s assessment. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s administration of and reliance on the SIT were appropriate, but that the District’s evaluation was not reported appropriately because it did not include a statement in the evaluation report that the SIT was administered in a non-standard way and a description of the extent to which the administration varied from non-standard conditions.

Next, Student argues that the assessment was not appropriate because the observation portion of the assessment should have been conducted in an age-appropriate classroom. Student alleges that the District’s assessment included observations in an office setting at Salk Elementary School. However, Student had attended the Prince of Peace Preschool approximately six months prior to the District’s assessment. Student argues that the assessment should have included observation information from Prince of Peace. Student argues that 34 C.F.R. § 300.533 requires the IEP team, when considering a child’s eligibility for special education, to review classroom based assessment and observations, as well as observations by teachers and related service providers. However, the Hearing Officer finds Student’s argument unpersuasive. 34 C.F.R. § 300.533 states, in relevant part:

(a) Review of existing evaluation data. As part of an initial evaluation (if appropriate) and as part of any reevaluation under Part B of the Act, a group that includes the individuals described in § 300.344, and other qualified professionals, as appropriate, shall-- (1) Review existing evaluation data on the child, including-- (i) Evaluations and information provided by the parents of the child; (ii) Current classroom-based assessments and observations; and (iii) Observations by teachers and related services providers.

Ms. Wegner, Ms. Cleveland, and Ms. Bauer, a program specialist with GASELPA, all testified that the District’s assessment occurred over the course of two and a half hours in a preschool classroom at Salk. Included in that assessment was a preschool teacher, Sarah Morgan. The assessment also included another student so that the team could observe STUDENT’s social skills. Thus, the evidence presented at hearing shows that the District conducted observations in conformity with 34 C.F.R. § 300.533. Moreover, the regulation requires current classroom-based observations. MOTHER testified that STUDENT had stopped attending Prince of Peace in May of 2003, approximately seven months prior to Kaiser’s diagnosis of autism and eight months prior to the District’s assessment. Therefore, the classroom-based observation conducted by the District was the most current classroom-based observation available. Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer determines that the District’s assessment appropriately relied upon the observations at Salk as part of STUDENT’s evaluation.

Finally, Student argues that the District’s assessment was not appropriate because it failed to test him in the areas of speech and language and occupational therapy (OT). Student contends that pursuant to California Education Code section 56320(f), the District was required to assess him in all areas of suspected disability. Student asserts that the Kaiser assessment conducted in December of 2003 outlined specific deficits related to occupational therapy and speech and language. The District, he argues, failed to conduct its own tests in these areas, and therefore failed to assess him in all areas of suspected disability. The District, however, presented credible evidence that those areas of disability were assessed. In terms of speech and language, Ms. Bauer, a program specialist and a speech and language pathologist from GASELPA, testified that she was present at the assessments and assisted in the evaluation of STUDENT’s communication skills. Moreover, Student’s argument assumes that the District was required to conduct another speech and language assessment and occupational therapy assessment because the Kaiser assessment identified these areas of need. However, as Student’s argument acknowledges, the Kaiser assessment was available to the District when it conducted its assessment. The Kaiser report included recent speech and language and occupational therapy assessments, and Student did not allege that the Kaiser assessments were not appropriate. The District determined, based on these reports, that STUDENT’s motor skills and communication skills were developmentally at about the thirty-month age level. Thus, it was clear that the District’s assessment did gather information regarding STUDENT’s communication and gross and fine motor deficits. Thus, the evidence reflects that these areas were assessed, even if the District did not conduct its own standardized tests for speech and language and occupational therapy. The Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s assessment was not inappropriate because it did not include its own standardized tests in speech and language and occupational therapy.

In sum, the Hearing Officer determines that the District’s use of the SIT was appropriate and that it was appropriate to administer the test in a non-standardized way. Further, the District conducted an appropriate observation as part of its assessment, and assessed STUDENT’s speech and language and occupational therapy needs. However, the District did not include in its evaluation report a statement that the SIT was administered in a non-standardized way. Therefore, while the Hearing Officer concludes that the District generally conducted the January 2004 preschool transdisciplinary assessment appropriately, the District failed to include in the assessment report a statement that the SIT was administered in a non-standardized way. The remedy, if any, for such a failure will be discussed below.

Issue No. 2: Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) at the February 25, 2004, March 19, 2004, and July 6, 2004 IEP meetings?

Pursuant to the IDEA and State special education law, children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE) that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs and prepare them for employment and independent living. (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.) A “free appropriate public education” consists of special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, meet the State educational standards, and conform to the child’s individualized education program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).)

“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, provided at no cost to parents, that meets the unique needs of the child. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.) “Related services” means transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22).) State law refers to related services as “designated instruction and services” (DIS) and, like federal law, provides that DIS services shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” (Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(a).)

In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. (Id. at 198-200.) The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Id. at 201.)

The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. (Id. at 205.) Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. (W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992).) Procedural flaws, however, do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE. (Id. at 1484.) Procedural violations may constitute a denial of FAPE if they result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process. (Id.)

Therefore, the inquiry in IDEA cases is twofold. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206.) The first question is whether the school district has complied with the procedures set forth in the IDEA. (Id.) The second is whether the IEP developed through the IDEA’s procedures is reasonably calculated to enable the student to receive an educational benefit. (Id. at 207.) The school district has the burden of proving at an administrative hearing that it has complied with the IDEA, including that it offered an appropriate educational placement to the student. (Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist. No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994).) Student alleges that the District failed to provide him with a FAPE both procedurally and substantively.

1. Compliance with procedural requirements

Student argues that the District did not comply with the procedural requirements of State and federal law because it failed to consider the input of his private assessors at the July 6, 2004 IEP meeting, and because it failed to timely initiate a due process hearing in this matter. Each of these contentions will be addressed in turn.

Failing to consider the input of STUDENT’s private assessors at the July 6, 2004 IEP meeting

Student argues that the District did not take into account the recommendations made by Student’s private assessors at the July 6, 2004 IEP meeting. However, the evidence clearly shows that those assessments were considered at that meeting. California Education Code section 56329(c) provides that “if the parent or guardian obtains an independent educational assessment at private expense, the results of the assessment shall be considered by the public education agency with respect to the provision of free, appropriate public education to the child…” (See also 34 C.F.R. § 300.502.)In this case, the evidence is undisputed that Ms. Lin, Ms. Rozenberg, and Dr. Davidson attended the July 6, 2004 IEP meeting, and presented the conclusions of their assessments to the IEP team. Student argues that because the team did not adopt the placement and service recommendations made by the Student’s assessors, and did not alter the goals and objectives according to those recommendations, that the results of the independent educational assessments were not considered. However, the statute only requires the District to consider the results of those assessments. Student’s argument clearly acknowledges that Ms. Lin, Ms. Rozenberg, and Dr. Davidson were allowed to present their findings for the IEP team’s consideration. This fact was confirmed by the IEP notes of that meeting. Moreover, Ms. Cleveland wrote a letter dated August 2, 2004, to Student’s parents offering a placement at Weaver Elementary School, as well as speech and language and OT services. (See below.) Ms. Cleveland credibly testified that these changes to the District’s offer of educational programming were made because of the input of STUDENT’s assessors at the July 6, 2004 IEP meeting. Thus, the Hearing Officer determines that the District discharged its obligation pursuant to California Education Code section 56329(c) to consider the results of STUDENT’s private assessments at the July 6, 2004 IEP meeting.

Failing to timely initiate a due process hearing in this matter

Student argues that the District failed to timely request a due process hearing in this matter, and that this failure violated the procedural protections of State and federal law. (Footnote 7) Pursuant to California Education section 56346, the District is required to obtain parental consent before it is allowed to provide special education services to a student. California Education Code section 56346(c) further provides, in relevant part:

If the local educational agency determines that the part of the proposed special education program to which the parent does not consent is necessary to provide a free and appropriate public education to the pupil, a due process hearing shall be initiated pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 56500), unless a prehearing mediation conference is held. During the pendency of the due process hearing, the local educational agency may reconsider the proposed individualized education program, may choose to meet informally with the parent pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 56502, or may hold a mediation conference pursuant to Section 56503. As an alternative to holding a due process hearing, the parties may hold a prehearing mediation conference pursuant to Section 56500.3 to resolve any issue or dispute.

Thus, the District was required to request a due process hearing if STUDENT’s parents did not provide consent to implement the offered educational program. However, the evidence indicated that the District was diligently working with the parents to develop a program for STUDENT that was agreeable to STUDENT’s parents and the District. The parties met for IEP meetings on February 25, 2004, and March 19, 2004. At each of those meetings, the IEP notes reflect that MOTHER wished to take home the IEPs to review them before providing her consent to implement the offered placement. However, MOTHER did not indicate any disagreement with the programs being offered. In fact, the IEP notes indicate that the parents agreed with the assessment results and the IEP goals and objectives as written. Thus, it would have been inappropriate for the District to file for a due process hearing after the March 19, 2004 IEP meeting because it was not apparent that MOTHER would not provide her consent to implement the proposed IEP.

Moreover, California Education Code section 56346(c) specifically contemplates that the parties may attempt to resolve these issues either through mediation or an informal meeting between the parties. The evidence showed that the District attempted to schedule mediations to resolve the disagreements between the parties. (Footnote 8) Additionally, a further IEP meeting was held on July 6, 2004 to consider the findings and recommendations of STUDENT’s private assessors. At this time, MOTHER stated her disagreement with the program being offered. However, shortly after this meeting, via letter dated July 22, 2004, Student filed his request for a due process hearing. Thus, the evidence presented indicated that, by the time MOTHER’s disagreement with the proposed IEP had crystallized, Student had already filed for a due process hearing. The District did not commit a procedural violation by failing to initiate its own due process hearing.

2. Substantive Appropriateness of Proposed Programs

To determine whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE at the February 25, 2004 IEP meeting, which offer was re-confirmed at the March 19 and July 6, 2004 IEP meetings, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of the District’s proposed program. (Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).) If the District’s program was designed to address STUDENT’s unique educational needs, was reasonably calculated to provide him some educational benefit, and comported with his IEP, the District provided a FAPE, even if STUDENT’s parents preferred another program and even if his parents’ preferred program would have resulted in greater educational benefit. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.) The District was also required to provide STUDENT with a program which educated him in the least restrictive environment, with removal from the regular education environment occurring only when the nature or severity of his disabilities was such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services could not be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.) Therefore, under the IDEA and Rowley, the program the District offered must have met the following four requirements to have constituted an appropriate educational program for STUDENT: 1) be designed to meet his educational needs; 2) be reasonably calculated to provide him some educational benefit; 3) comported with his IEP; and (4) provided him an education in the least restrictive environment. (Footnote 9)

In this case, Student’s argument at hearing was that the District failed to offer him an educational program that met his unique needs and that was reasonably calculated to provide him some educational benefit. First, Student argues that the District erroneously found him eligible under the category of below average intellectual functioning. Next, Student argues that the placement at Salk was not appropriate because the class was for students who were functioning physically and cognitively below him. Student also argues that the District did not take into account his limited English proficiency when making its placement offer. Student also contends that the program the District offered was not appropriate because it failed to offer any OT, speech and language therapy, or ABA services. Finally, Student argues that the goals and objectives offered were not appropriate because the present levels of performance did not adequately state his baselines, because the goals and objectives were not objective or measurable, and because they did not address all areas of need.

In order to determine whether the program the District offered STUDENT met his unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him some educational benefit, it is first necessary to determine what STUDENT’s unique needs were. According to the evidence presented at hearing, STUDENT’s needs were essentially not in dispute. The Kaiser report, the District’s assessment, and the Student’s independent evaluations generally agreed that he displayed deficits in the areas of receptive language, expressive language, communication, gross motor skills, fine motor skills, sensory integration skills, behavior, socialization, and attention. Student’s unique educational needs, therefore, relate to theses areas. However, the District and Student disagree on the appropriate educational program that would have met these unique educational needs. Each of Student’s contentions will be addressed below.

Eligibility for special education as below average intellectual functioning

Student first argues that the District failed to appropriately designate his eligibility category for special education. At the February 25, 2004 IEP meeting, the District determined that STUDENT is eligible for special education under the categories of autistic-like behaviors and significantly below average intellect. Student disagrees with the finding that he is eligible for special education as a student with significantly below average intellect. Student argues that the District relied on the SIT to inappropriately obtain a cognitive functioning score, and therefore could not have come to a proper determination of eligibility as significantly below average intellect.

At the outset, the Hearing Officer notes that under both State and federal law, the relevant inquiry is whether the program offered to STUDENT met his unique educational needs, regardless of his designated eligibility category. (34 C.F.R. § 300.300(a)(3).) Additionally, the Hearing Officer has previously determined that the District appropriately used the SIT as an alternative assessment measure to obtain developmental information regarding STUDENT. Ms. Wegner testified credibly that the determination of STUDENT’s eligibility categories was made after consideration of a host of factors, including the Kaiser assessment, observations, and parent reports, and not just on the results of the SIT. Moreover, Student’s own assessor, Dr. Davidson, found that Student’s cognitive developmental age level, based on her administration of the Bayley Scales of Infant Development-Second Edition, was twenty-seven months at a time when Student was chronologically forty-eight months old. Based on her administration of the SIT, Ms. Wegner determined that STUDENT’s cognitive functioning was at the twenty-three month level at a time when he was chronologically forty months old. Thus, there appears to be some consistency between the intellectual functioning results of Dr. Davidson’s assessment and Ms. Wegner’s assessment.

As for whether STUDENT qualifies for special education because he has significantly below average intellectual functioning, Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations, section 3030(h) states that a student is eligible for special education if “a pupil has significantly below average general intellectual functioning existing concurrently with deficits in adaptive behavior and manifested during the developmental period, which adversely affect a pupil's educational performance.” Student’s sole argument on this issue was that the District’s determination of his intellectual functioning was not correct because it relied upon the SIT to determine intellectual functioning. However, the Hearing Officer has already determined that the use of the SIT as an alternative measure was appropriate, and, as previously noted, Ms. Wegner’s and Dr. Davidson’s determination of his cognitive functioning was fairly consistent. Thus, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded by Student’s argument that the District’s determination of his intellectual functioning was not correct. Based on the foregoing evidence, the Hearing Officer determines that the District correctly determined that STUDENT qualifies for special education as a student with significantly below average intellect.

Salk placement

Student argues that the Salk preschool classroom placement that was offered at the February 25, 2004 IEP meeting was not appropriate for him. However, it is difficult to determine why Student takes this position because he presented two different, seemingly contradictory arguments regarding the appropriateness of that placement. On the one hand, Student argues that he was functioning at a higher level than those students already in the classroom. On the other hand, Student argues that his deficits were so severe that he required one-to-one ABA therapy in order to learn skills so that he could be ready for preschool, and therefore the Salk classroom was inappropriate. Regardless of Student’s position, the District presented credible evidence that the Salk placement would have met his unique educational needs.

Ms. Arneaud, the preschool teacher at Salk, testified that her classroom was a language-based classroom. She testified that STUDENT would have worked on his receptive and expressive language deficits in the classroom by being required to respond to and follow directions as a means of compliance. Ms. Arneaud and Ms. Polcyn, GASELPA’s director of occupational and physical therapy, testified credibly that the classroom also had OT components imbedded in the daily curriculum. For instance, STUDENT would have worked on fine motor skills by being taught how to hold scissors correctly. He would also have been encouraged to use functional skills by being taught to open his lunch container or backpack. Moreover, Ms. Arneaud testified that STUDENT would have been provided, in addition to the ABA services imbedded in the school program, with one-to-one ABA therapy as needed to address behavioral issues, and he would have interacted with other peers, including typically developing peers, to address his socialization and play skills deficits. Ms. Arneaud and Glenda McHale, the autism coordinator for GASELPA, testified persuasively based on their personal knowledge of the students in the Salk preschool classroom that STUDENT was within the range of ability levels found in that classroom.

Dr. Davidson testified that the classroom at Salk was not appropriate. However, the Hearing Officer finds Dr. Davidson’s testimony not credible. Dr. Davidson testified that, when she observed the placement at Salk, she noticed that there were students in the classroom who were functioning lower than STUDENT. But at the same time, Dr. Davidson testified that STUDENT did not have the skills to attend a preschool program and that he required a thirty-five to forty hour per week individual ABA program to learn the readiness skills that would allow him to attend preschool. The Hearing Officer determines that Dr. Davidson’s testimony was inconsistent and contradictory regarding an appropriate program for STUDENT. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds the District’s witnesses more persuasive regarding this issue. The Hearing Officer determines that the Salk classroom placement was appropriate to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

OT, speech and language therapy, and ABA services

Student argues that he required three sessions each per week of one-to-one clinic-based OT and speech and language therapy to meet his unique educational needs. Furthermore, Student argues that he required a thirty-five to forty hour per week in-home ABA therapy program to meet his needs. At the February 25, 2004 IEP meeting, the District offered a program that included speech and language and OT services imbedded in his classroom program, and individual ABA as needed to work on behavioral issues and his goals and objectives. The District contends that the individual OT, speech and language therapy, and ABA services that were recommended by Student’s private assessors were not appropriate to meet his unique needs. The District contends that, because STUDENT is autistic, he required a preschool program in a school setting.

Ms. Rozenberg testified that STUDENT required individual speech and language therapy because he is a language disordered child who has unique needs that are likely different than the ten or eleven other students who attended Salk’s preschool program. Ms. Rozenberg testified that STUDENT could not have received sufficient individualization for his program if he had only received speech and language services as part of a classroom setting. She also testified that because of STUDENT’s distractibility, he needed to be in a setting where he could concentrate on the task at hand. STUDENT, she stated, could not have received this kind of setting in the Salk classroom. Ms. Lin testified that STUDENT required individual OT in a clinic setting primarily for safety reasons, as STUDENT has a tendency to elope. Ms. Lin also stated that STUDENT required individual OT because it would have allowed the therapist to control stimuli and thus be better able to address STUDENT’s responsiveness to sensory integration interventions. Ms. Lin also testified that the clinic setting has many more sensory tools, and thus would have allowed the therapist more variability in targeting sensory areas. With regard to the one-to-one ABA therapy, Dr. Davidson and Dr. Sharyn Kerr, the clinic director at ACES, Inc., testified that STUDENT did not have the requisite skills to benefit from the Salk preschool classroom. Therefore, he required intensive one-to-one ABA therapy to help him learn these skills. Once he learned these skills, they testified, he would have been ready to attend school in a District classroom.

The District, however, presented convincing evidence that STUDENT did not require individual OT, speech and language therapy, and ABA therapy to meet his unique educational needs. As was noted above, if the parents had accepted the District’s offer of placement, STUDENT would have received these services imbedded into his preschool classroom at Salk. Dr. Ronald Leaf, the director of Autism Partnership, and Dr. Betty Jo Freeman, the District’s psychological consultant, testified persuasively that STUDENT should have received his services and education in the school setting to promote functional development of skills and so that he could generalize learned tasks. Dr. Freeman testified that STUDENT has difficulty with observational learning skills, in that he did not watch what other peers were doing and copy that behavior. Receiving intensive services in a one-to-one setting, without the benefit of peers to relate to, would not have addressed his observational learning deficit. Dr. Freeman also testified that one hallmark of autism is a deficit in social communication skills. Dr. Freeman testified that STUDENT displayed a deficit in this area. Receiving his services in a preschool setting, with other peers in the classroom, would have helped address this area of need as well. Dr. Leaf testified that the thirty-five to forty hour per week in-home, individual ABA program recommended by Dr. Davidson would not have been appropriate for STUDENT. Dr. Leaf testified that the program recommended by Dr. Davidson would not have allowed STUDENT to generalize his skills. He testified that ABA therapy was developed in order to move autistic students into the school setting as quickly as possible. As for Ms. Rozenberg’s and Ms. Lin’s concern that STUDENT would have faced multiple distractions, Dr. Leaf testified that ABA therapy was meant to have students learn skills in as natural an environment as possible, which in this case was the school setting, where STUDENT will face distractions his entire school career. Dr. Davidson indicated in her report that she based her recommendation of thirty-five to forty hours of ABA therapy on the findings from the “National Research Council and Dr. Lovaas.” However, Dr. Freeman and Dr. Leaf both testified that neither the National Research Council nor Dr. Lovaas recommend that an autistic student like STUDENT be placed in a thirty-five to forty hour individual ABA program. Dr. Leaf described this recommendation as arbitrary and not based on facts.

The Hearing Officer determines the testimony of Dr. Leaf and Dr. Freeman persuasive regarding this issue. Student argues that Dr. Leaf and Dr. Freeman never met him and based their opinions on a record review. Therefore, their opinions at hearing should not be given any credibility. However, Dr. Leaf and Dr. Freeman possess far greater experience and expertise in treating children with autism than Ms. Rozenberg, Ms. Lin, or Dr. Davidson. Dr. Leaf was the clinic director of the Young Autism Project, a federally funded program directed by Dr. Ivar Lovaas that studied the use of ABA interventions on children with autism. Dr. Leaf’s recommendations regarding the viability of the ABA services imbedded in the Salk placement were based on his research into and development of ABA therapy with autistic children through the Young Autism Project. Dr. Leaf was involved in this program from the early 1970’s. He left the program in 1985, when he was the interim director of that program. In 1994, Dr. Leaf started Autism Partnership to provide a variety of services to children with autism, including providing training and support to District personnel, as well as the personnel of other school districts. His curriculum vita indicates that he has published extensively in this area and acts as a consultant with school districts and public agencies both in the United States and in other countries. Dr. Leaf has over thirty years of experience related to research and the treatment of children with autism. As noted previously, Dr. Freeman is an emeritus professor at UCLA, has assessed a minimum of twenty thousand children with autism, and has over thirty years of experience related to the treatment and assessment of autistic children. Both Dr. Leaf and Dr. Freeman testified that, because of their extensive experience with the treatment of children with autism, they are able to make appropriate placement recommendations based on their review of records. Both Dr. Leaf and Dr. Freeman testified that they had reviewed all of STUDENT’s assessment data, including those obtained by STUDENT’s private assessors, and other information.

In contrast, Dr. Davidson, notwithstanding that her recommendations were erroneously attributed to the National Research Council and Dr. Lovaas, simply does not have the expertise with the ABA therapy she recommends for STUDENT. Her training and experience regarding the treatment of children with autism is limited to assessing children with autism and attending training programs, including those presented by Dr. Leaf and Autism Partnership. Dr. Davidson and Ms. Rozenberg both based their expertise on treating children with autism on the fact that they have assessed numerous children with autism over the years. Dr. Lin, to her credit, acknowledged that she did not have any particular expertise in treating children with autism. In sum, the Hearing Officer determines that the testimony of Dr. Davidson, Ms. Rozenberg, and Ms. Lin regarding STUDENT’s needs for individual one-to-one services in the areas of speech and language, OT, and ABA therapy, was not credible.

Based on the testimony of Dr. Freeman and Dr. Leaf, the Hearing Officer determines that STUDENT did not require one-to-one clinic-based OT and speech and language therapy to meet his unique educational needs. According to the testimony of Dr. Leaf and Dr. Freeman, the individual OT and speech and language services would not have provided STUDENT with the setting necessary to working specifically on his observational learning and social communication deficits, which are typical of children with autism. Moreover, both Dr. Leaf and Dr. Freeman testified that STUDENT needed to work on generalizing his skills and using them in functional settings. Ms. Polcyn, GASELPA’s director of OT, and Ms. Bauer, a speech and language therapist and GASELPA’s program specialist, testified that STUDENT would have been working on functional OT and speech and language skills as part of the imbedded program in Ms. Arneaud’s classroom. Additionally, the Hearing Officer determines that STUDENT did not require a thirty-five to forty hour, in-home ABA program to meet his unique needs. Dr. Leaf testified convincingly that STUDENT required a school-based program, again to promote generalization and the acquisition of functional skills. The Hearing Officer finds that the offer of placement in the District’s Salk classroom was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide him benefit.

Limited English proficiency

Student argues that the District failed to take into account his limited English proficiency when developing his program. Student argues that his primary language is Mandarin Chinese, but his IEP included no recommendations or accommodations regarding how his primary language would affect his placement or services. The District argues that those accommodations were considered as part of the development of STUDENT’s IEP.

Pursuant to State and federal law, the individualized education program team shall, in the case of a pupil with limited English proficiency, consider the language needs of the pupil as those needs relate to the pupil's individualized education program. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.1(b)(2); 34 C.F.R. § 300.346(a)(2)(ii).) MOTHER testified that the primary language spoken in the home is Mandarin Chinese. First, the Hearing Officer notes that the District was aware that the primary language spoken at home is Mandarin Chinese. This was noted in the District’s January 2004 transdisciplinary assessment. However, Student presented no evidence that he was a student with limited English proficiency. At the time of the February 25, 2004 IEP meeting, STUDENT used very little language, and it was noted by the Kaiser assessment that STUDENT had delays in his receptive, expressive, and pragmatic language use. These results were consistent with the findings made in Ms. Rozenberg’s assessment. Thus, the evidence establishes that STUDENT had delays in communication and language generally, and that those delays were not due to a lack of proficiency in the English language. Ms. Arneaud testified credibly that the Salk placement was designed to elicit communication in a general sense. For instance, she stated that language would have been used in her classroom to force STUDENT to communicate his wants and needs. STUDENT would also have been required to respond to and follow directions, which would have addressed his receptive language deficits. Moreover, the Kaiser assessment recommended that STUDENT be exposed to only one language, and warned that exposure to two languages would be detrimental to STUDENT. MOTHER testified she wanted that language to be English. The Hearing Officer further notes that STUDENT is receiving his speech and language therapy, OT, and ABA therapy in English. Thus, because STUDENT had delays in language generally, the District offered him a program that would have elicited language in English as the parents requested. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered STUDENT an appropriate program to meet his limited proficiency in language in general.

Goals and Objectives

State and federal law require an IEP to include a statement of the pupil’s present levels of educational performance, including how the pupil’s disability affects the pupil’s involvement and progress in the general education curriculum. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(i); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a)(1)(i); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.) Additionally, State and federal law require that an IEP document include measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, related to meeting the pupil’s needs to enable him to be involved in and progress in the general education curriculum. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(ii); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a).)

Student contends that the goals and objectives in Student’s IEP did not contain an adequate measure of his present levels of performance and, because they did not, the goals and objectives were not objective or measurable. Additionally, Student contends that his goals and objectives did not address the following areas of need: speech and language, fine and gross motor skills, sensory integration, behavior, self-help skills, and play skills.

Student’s first contention regarding the goals and objectives is that they did not contain measured baselines. However, nothing in the law requires the goals and objectives to include measured baselines. Student seemed to argue that the present levels must have included a measurement of how many incidences of a behavior were observed in a certain setting, such as what his level of eye contact was or how long he was able to hold someone’s hand. However, Ms. Arneaud testified credibly that the present levels of performance should include a statement of what a student is able to do. A review of the present levels of performance contained in the February 25, 2004 IEP reveals that the present levels of performance were taken from the District’s own assessment, as well as the Kaiser assessments. The Hearing Officer notes that the present levels of performance on the February 25, 2004 IEP were derived from the results of those assessments. Thus, the Hearing Officer determines that the present levels of performance accurately stated STUDENT’s current functioning levels as they related to his areas of need. The law requires no more.

Student argues that it was impossible to develop measurable annual goals and objectives if the present levels of performance did not contain measured baselines. However, Ms. Arneaud testified that she developed the goals and objectives from the present levels of performance. The Hearing Officer has previously noted that the present levels of performance were appropriate. Consequently, because the present levels of performance were appropriate and the goals and objectives required the demonstration of higher skills for achievement of the goals, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives were measurable and objective.

Finally, Student argues that the goals and objectives should have addressed the following areas: speech and language, fine and gross motor skills, sensory integration, behavior, self-help skills, and play skills. A review of the goals and objectives developed at the February 25, 2004 IEP meeting shows that the District developed goals in the areas of communication, gross and fine motor, preacademics, pre-vocational (two goals), socialization, self-help, and community based instruction. First, the Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT’s goals and objectives did contain goals titled self-help skills, gross motor, and fine motor. Thus, it is obvious from a review of the IEP that those areas of need were addressed in the goals. Moreover, Dr. Freeman credibly testified that the goals, as written in this IEP, addressed different skills within each goal. For instance, the community based instruction goal was written as follows: “Given community based outing or while on campus, STUDENT will hold a peer’s hand for 10 minutes with 80% accuracy by 2/25/04.” Dr. Freeman testified that this goal would have addressed STUDENT’s behavior issues as it would have taught him safety awareness, and would also have addressed his socialization and communication needs. The Hearing Officer notes that there were nine goals that would have addressed multiple areas of need. More importantly, Ms. Arneaud and Dr. Freeman testified credibly that the goals and objectives, taken as a whole, addressed all of STUDENT’s unique educational needs as identified in the Kaiser assessment and the District’s own assessment. Ms. Arneaud testified that the communication goal would have worked on expressive and receptive language skills. She testified that STUDENT’s community based instruction goal, fine motor goal, and toilet training goal would have addressed his compliance and behavior deficits. Finally, Ms. Polcyn testified that sensory issues are part of the imbedded OT program in Ms. Arneaud’s classroom. Thus, those needs would have been met without the need for specific goals and objectives to address them. Therefore, the Hearing Officer determines that the goals and objectives, as written, addressed all of STUDENT’s unique needs.

In sum, the Hearing Officer determines that the goals and objectives contained appropriate present levels of performance and measurable annual goals. Additionally, the Hearing Officer determines that the goals and objectives addressed all of STUDENT’s areas of need. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District developed appropriate goals and objectives in the February 25, 2004 IEP.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed program was designed to address STUDENT’s unique educational needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him some educational benefit. Student did not raise any contention that the District could not have provided a program that comported with his IEP, or that the offered program did not educate him in the least restrictive environment. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE in the February 25, March 19, and July 6, 2004 IEPs.

Issue No. 3: Did the District appropriately make an offer of placement in the August 2, 2004 letter to STUDENT’s parents?

Student argues that the offer of placement made in Ms. Cleveland’s August 2, 2004 letter did not constitute FAPE. Student argues that this letter was an attempt to revise his IEP contrary to the requirements of State and federal special education law, and denied PARENTS the right to participate in the IEP process.

Ms. Cleveland testified that the August 2, 2004 letter to Mr. and MOTHER was written pursuant to 34 C.F.R. § 300.503. That regulation states that written notice must be given to the parents of a child with a disability a reasonable time before the public agency proposes or refuses to initiate or change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child or the provision of FAPE to the child. (34. C.F.R. § 300.503(a).) In her August 2, 2004 letter, Ms. Cleveland stated that the District would not provide reimbursement for the parents’ independent educational evaluations, and that it would not fund the requested thirty-five to forty hour in-home ABA program. Ms. Cleveland also set forth an offer of services that differed in several respects from the offer made at the February 25, 2004 IEP meeting. For one, STUDENT’s proposed placement was changed from Salk Elementary School to Weaver Elementary School. She also offered him a ten-hour in-home ABA program and three sixty-minute sessions each of speech and language therapy and OT per week through the end of August. The letter then stated that the speech and language therapy and OT services would be transitioned over to a school-based program. Student argues that this was an inappropriate attempt to change his IEP outside of the formal IEP process required under State and federal law. (Footnote 10)

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56343, an individualized education program team shall meet whenever any of the following occurs:

(a) A pupil has received an initial formal assessment. The team may meet when a pupil receives any subsequent formal assessment. (b) The pupil demonstrates a lack of anticipated progress.

(c) The parent or teacher requests a meeting to develop, review, or revise the individualized education program. (d) At least annually, to review the pupil's progress, the individualized education program, including whether the annual goals for the pupil are being achieved, and the appropriateness of placement, and to make any necessary revisions. The individualized education program team conducting the annual review shall consist of those persons specified in subdivision (b) of Section 56341. Other individuals may participate in the annual review if they possess expertise or knowledge essential for the review.

Additionally, a school district is required to invite the parents to any meeting held to determine issues regarding the identification, evaluation, and educational placement for a child with a disability. (34 C.F.R. § 300.501.) Therefore, the inquiry under this statute is whether the District was required to convene a meeting of the IEP team to make the proposed changes set forth in the August 2, 2004 letter based on any of the above conditions. Based on the evidence, the Hearing Officer determines that it was not.

First, the Hearing Officer notes that the District had already convened a meeting on July 6, 2004, to discuss the evaluations conducted by Petitioner’s private assessors. No subsequent assessments were conducted that warranted another meeting of the IEP team. Furthermore, there is no dispute that STUDENT was not in a District-provided educational program at the time and thus could not demonstrate a lack of anticipated progress in a District program, and that there had been no request from STUDENT’s parent or teacher to convene another meeting of the IEP team. Finally, the Hearing Officer determines that an IEP team was not required to meet to make “necessary revisions” pursuant to subsection (d). While the District does not dispute that the August 2, 2004 letter made material changes to the offer of educational programming, the changes were made pursuant to the discussions that occurred among all IEP team members at the July 6, 2004 IEP meeting. As noted above, STUDENT’s private assessors presented their recommendations at this IEP meeting, and those recommendations were discussed and considered by the IEP team. That IEP meeting was also the first meeting in which MOTHER specifically dissented to the IEP. Ms. Cleveland testified that the purpose of the changes made in the August 2, 2004 letter was to incorporate some of the suggested changes made by STUDENT’s private assessors in an attempt to obtain consent for STUDENT to begin attending school. Ms. Cleveland testified that the changes made in STUDENT’s educational programming were based upon what was discussed by STUDENT’s private assessors at that July 6, 2004 IEP meeting, when the IEP team, including the parents, had an opportunity to fully discuss matters related to STUDENT’s educational program. Moreover, after the July 6, 2004 IEP meeting, Student filed for a due process hearing in this matter. State law contemplates that parties to a due process hearing may attempt to informally resolve issues related to the due process hearing. (See Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56346(c), 56502(e).) Thus, the August 2, 2004 letter was also an attempt to informally settle this matter prior to proceeding to a due process hearing.

Based on the foregoing, and under the unique facts of this case, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s August 2, 2004 letter did not deny the parents an opportunity to participate meaningfully in the IEP process and therefore did not violate the procedural safeguards of the IDEA.

Issue No. 4: Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE at the October 18, 2004 IEP meeting?

STUDENT’s parents and their representatives did not attend the October 18, 2004 IEP meeting. Student argues that the District committed a procedural violation of State and federal law because it failed to convene the IEP meeting at a mutually agreeable time and date, and because the IEP notice did not state the purpose of the IEP meeting. Student also argues that the program offered by the District was substantively flawed. Student argues that the Weaver Elementary School placement is not appropriate, and that the District did not offer appropriate levels of OT, speech and language therapy, and in-home ABA services. Furthermore, Student argues that the goals and objectives that were developed at this IEP meeting are not objective or measurable, and that the program fails to consider his limited English proficiency.

1. Compliance with procedural requirements

Student argues that the District committed a procedural violation of State and federal law because it failed to convene the IEP meeting at a mutually agreeable time and date, and because the IEP notice did not state the purpose of the IEP meeting.

When convening an IEP meeting, the District is required to take steps to insure that one or both of the parents of the individual with exceptional needs are present at each individualized education program meeting or are afforded the opportunity to participate. (34 C.F.R. § 300.345(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(a).) Additionally, the parents must be notified of the IEP meeting early enough to ensure an opportunity to attend. (34 C.F.R. § 300.345(a)(1); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b).) If no parent or guardian can attend the meeting, the district, special education local plan area, or county office shall use other methods to ensure parent or guardian participation, including individual or conference telephone calls. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(f).) California Education Code § 56241, subsection (g), further states as follows:

A meeting may be conducted without a parent or guardian in attendance if the district, special education local plan area, or county office is unable to convince the parent or guardian that he or she should attend. In this event, the district, special education local plan area, or county office shall maintain a record of its attempts to arrange a mutually agreed-upon time and place, as follows: (1) Detailed records of telephone calls made or attempted and the results of those calls. (2) Copies of correspondence sent to the parents or guardians and any responses received. (3) Detailed records of visits made to the home or place of employment of the parent or guardian and the results of those visits.

Furthermore, notice of an IEP meeting must indicate the purpose, time, and location of the meeting and who will be in attendance. (34 C.F.R. § 300.345(b)(1)(i).)

Via letter dated October 5, 2004, the District, through counsel, first communicated its desire to hold another IEP meeting for STUDENT. On October 6, 2004, the District again inquired of the parents as to an agreeable time to schedule an IEP meeting. On October 8, 2004, the District once again inquired of the parents if they would be available for an IEP meeting. The Student replied on that same day, requesting the reason why the District wished to conduct another IEP meeting. On October 11, 2004, the District sent to Student an invitation to attend another IEP meeting, and gave several dates and times that a meeting could be held. The invitation further stated that if there was no response received to the letter, an IEP meeting would be held on October 18, 2004. The invitation to the IEP meeting stated that its purpose was to “discuss private assessments; review and revise the IEP.” On October 15, 2004, the District sent a letter to Student, indicating that it had not heard back from him regarding a date for the IEP meeting, and would therefore hold the meeting on October 18, 2004. Student responded via letter that same day, which was faxed to the District after business hours, again requesting clarification for the reason for holding an IEP meeting. The District held a meeting on October 18, 2004. Student did not attend the meeting.

Student argues that the notice of the IEP meeting was not appropriate because it did not state the purpose of the IEP meeting. However, the invitation sent to Student’s parents on October 11, 2004, clearly stated that the purpose of the IEP meeting was to “discuss private assessments; review and revise the IEP.” Moreover, the evidence as outlined above reflects that the District met its obligation to attempt to have PARENTS and their representatives attend the IEP meeting. The record reflects that the District inquired through correspondence with Student’s counsel on three occasions as to whether the parents and their representatives would be available for a further IEP meeting. Student’s counsel responded with a request “to identify the purpose(s) why the District wishes to convene an IEP meeting,” without indicating if STUDENT’s parents could or would attend an IEP meeting. (District’s Exh. 58.) On October 11 and 13, 2004, the District sent invitations via mail for Student and his representatives to attend the IEP meeting, and sent another letter on October 15, 2004, attempting to secure parental attendance at the IEP meeting. Student did not respond to these invitations until after business hours on October 15, 2004. (Footnote 11) The Hearing Officer determines that the District made a sufficient attempt to secure the participation of the parents and their representatives at the IEP meeting. (Footnote 12) Based on the correspondence between the parties, there was no indication that the parents and their representatives could not attend the meeting; rather, the letters between the parties indicated the unwillingness of the parents and their representatives to attend the meeting because of the District’s prior “uncooperative stance” and Student’s insistence that the District had not stated the purpose of the meeting. Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District attempted to secure the participation of PARENTS and their representatives at the IEP meeting, and that it was appropriate for the District to proceed with the IEP meeting when it did not receive a response to its repeated invitations.

2. Substantive Appropriateness of Proposed Program

As noted above, under the IDEA and Rowley, the program the District offered must meet the following four requirements to constitute an appropriate educational program for STUDENT: 1) be designed to meet his educational needs; 2) be reasonably calculated to provide him some educational benefit; 3) comport with his IEP; and (4) provide him education in the least restrictive environment.

At the outset, the Hearing Officer notes that, as with the prior IEPs, no challenges were raised with regard to whether the District’s proposed program comports with the IEP or provides STUDENT an education in the least restrictive environment. Therefore, these elements of FAPE need not be considered here. Additionally, the Hearing Officer notes that there was still no dispute about STUDENT’s educational needs at the time of the October 18, 2004 IEP meeting. As identified at the February 25, 2004 IEP meeting, STUDENT still displays deficits in the areas of receptive language, expressive language, communication, gross motor skills, fine motor skills, sensory integration skills, behavior, socialization, and attention. However, the District’s program offer changed at the October 18, 2004 IEP meeting. First, the District’s classroom offer changed to the SDC at Weaver Elementary School. The team also added four new goals: two in the area of socialization, and one each in the areas of communication and behavior. Additionally, the District offered two thirty-minute sessions per week of individual speech and language therapy, one forty-minute session per week of OT, and ten hours of in-home ABA therapy per week. Student argues that the Weaver Elementary School placement is not appropriate, and that the District has not offered appropriate levels of OT, speech and language therapy, and in-home ABA services. Furthermore, Student argues that the goals and objectives developed at this IEP meeting are not objective or measurable, and that the program fails to consider his limited English proficiency.

Student argues that placement at Weaver is not appropriate for him because he requires an in-home ABA therapy program, and not a preschool class, to meet his unique educational needs. However, as noted above, the Hearing Officer has determined that STUDENT requires a preschool placement to promote generalization of skills and acquisition of functional skills. Furthermore, Dr. Leaf testified credibly that an in-home ABA therapy program is contrary to accepted practice for treatment of children with autism, and that STUDENT needs to be in as natural an environment as possible, complete with distractions, in which to learn skills. Ms. Yamafuji testified that her class, like the SDC placement at Salk, contains imbedded speech and language therapy and OT. Ms. Yamafuji and Dr. Leaf testified that the class was designed in conjunction with Autism Partnership, and uses ABA principles in different settings to work on students’ goals, as well as through the daily classroom activities. Moreover, Ms. Yamafuji and Dr. Leaf testified that the classroom contains a higher number of adult aides, so that the ratio of students to adults is very nearly one-to-one. Ms. Cleveland testified that the offer of educational placement was changed to Weaver to address STUDENT’s parents’ concerns regarding the need for a more restrictive placement for STUDENT. Ms. Yamafuji has been teaching this class for the past seven years, and has extensive experience with ABA behavioral strategies through Autism Partnership. Thus, the Hearing Officer determines that the Weaver Elementary School placement meets STUDENT’s unique educational needs.

As noted above, the Hearing Officer determined that the District’s offer of imbedded OT, speech and language therapy, and ABA services in the February 25, 2004 IEP meeting would have met STUDENT’s unique educational needs. In this case, Ms. Yamafuji testified that her preschool SDC also contained imbedded OT, speech and language therapy, and ABA services. Additionally, the District is now offering to supplement those services with individual speech and language therapy, OT, and ABA therapy. Therefore, the Hearing Officer determines that the supplemented program also is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

Additionally, the Hearing Officer has determined that the goals and objectives contained in the February 25, 2004 IEP meeting were appropriate. Those same goals and objectives are carried over to the October 18, 2004 IEP, and are supplemented by additional goals and objectives in the areas of behavior, socialization, and communication. Student argues again that the goals and objectives contained in this IEP are not measurable or objective because they do not contain present levels of performance with measurable baselines. For the same reasons articulated previously, the Hearing Officer determines that the goals and objectives contained in the October 18, 2004 IEP also meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs. Finally, the Hearing Officer determined previously that the District appropriately considered STUDENT’s limited English proficiency when forming his educational program. There was no evidence presented that STUDENT’s general communication difficulties changed since that prior IEP. Therefore, the Hearing Officer determines that the District appropriately addresses those needs in this IEP as well.

Thus, based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer determines that the District did not violate any of the IDEA’s procedural safeguards in convening the IEP meeting on October 18, 2004, and that the October 18, 2004 IEP is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs and is reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit. Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds that the October 18, 2004 IEP offers STUDENT a FAPE.

Issue No. 5: If the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE, is he entitled to reimbursement for the following assessments and services provided at his parents’ expense: a. Speech and language assessment and services provided by Abby Rozenberg; b. Occupational therapy assessment and services provided by Nancy Lin; c. Psychoeducational assessment by Dr. Christine Davidson; and d. Behavioral therapy assessment and services provided by ACES, Inc.?

Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services were appropriate under the IDEA and replaced services that the District should have provided. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education, 471 U.S. 359, 369-370 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994); 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C).) Furthermore, a parent has the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the student. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b); 34 C.F.R. 300.502(b)(1).) However, if an educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment was appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent evaluation. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(c); 34 C.F.R. 300.502(b)(3).)

As noted above, the Hearing Officer has found that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE at the February 25, March 19, July 6, and October 18, 2004 IEP meetings. Therefore, STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for any educational services they unilaterally procured for STUDENT.

With regard to the independent educational evaluations at issue, the Hearing Officer concluded above that the District appropriately assessed STUDENT in the areas of speech and language and OT as part of its January 2004 assessment of STUDENT. Therefore, the parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the private speech and language and OT assessments they obtained. Next, turning to the question of whether the parents are entitled to reimbursement for the private psychoeducational assessment obtained from Dr. Davidson, the Hearing Officer found above that the District should have but failed to include in its psychoeducational assessment report a statement that the SIT was administered in a non-standardized way. However, as noted above, the psychoeducational assessment itself was conducted appropriately and the minor omission in the assessment report did not render the assessment’s findings invalid. In fact, the District’s conclusions about STUDENT’s scores were not based solely on the SIT results but were determined after consideration of a wealth of other assessment data, including the results of two other tests, the Developmental Profile-II and the Gilliam Autism Rating Scale, as well as the results of the Kaiser assessments and observations of STUDENT. Further, as mentioned previously, the District’s ultimate determinations regarding STUDENT’s intellectual functioning were strikingly similar to those obtained later by the parents’ private assessor, Dr. Davidson. Consequently, the District established at hearing that its psychoeducational assessment was appropriate. Moreover, there was neither evidence nor argument that the minor omission in reporting the non-standardized administration of the SIT in any way caused the parent to seek the private psychoeducational assessment from Dr. Davidson. For all these reasons, Student’s request for reimbursement of Dr. Davidson’s assessment is denied.

Finally, with regard to the Student’s request for reimbursement for the behavioral therapy assessment by ACES, Inc., the Hearing Officer notes that there was no allegation that the District should have conducted a behavioral therapy assessment and did not. Additionally, the evidence established that ACES, Inc. conducted the assessment simply as a necessary precursor to providing the behavioral therapy privately obtained and funded by the parents. Therefore, because the District offered FAPE and the privately obtained behavioral therapy was not necessary to provide STUDENT a FAPE, the request for reimbursement of the behavioral therapy assessment is likewise denied.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for any of the assessments or services privately obtained by them.

Issue No. 6: Does STUDENT require the following services in order to receive a FAPE: a. In home applied behavior analysis (ABA) therapy for thirty-five hours per week; b. Speech and language services at Buena Park Speech and Language Development Center for three hours per week; and c. Individual clinic based occupational therapy services for two hours per week?

As noted above, the District has offered STUDENT a program that meets his unique educational needs and is reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. Student’s request that these services be incorporated into his educational program is denied.

Issue No. 7: Should the District be allowed to assess STUDENT without his parents’ consent pursuant to the August 25, 2004 assessment plan?

A reassessment of a student with disabilities must be conducted at least once every three years or more frequently if conditions warrant a reassessment, or if the pupil’s parent or teacher requests a reassessment and that a new individualized education program be developed. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56381; 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(2)(A).) In Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1315 (9th Cir. 1987), the Ninth Circuit stated that “if the parents want [their child] to receive special education under the Act, they are obligated to permit such testing.” In Andress v. Cleveland Independent School District, 64 F.3d 176, 178 (5th Cir. 1995), the Fifth Circuit concluded that “a parent who desires for her child to receive special education must allow the school district to evaluate the child…there is no exception to this rule.” (See also Vander Malle v. Ambach, 673 F.2d 49, 53 (2d Cir. 1983).)

While the law provides that a school district has the right and obligation to conduct these reassessments, parental consent for an evaluation is required before a school district can assess the child. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(c); 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(1)(C)(i).) However, a local education agency can override a lack of parental consent if it establishes the need to conduct such an assessment at a due process hearing. (Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56321(c), 56501(a)(3), 56506(e); 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(1)(C)(ii).) Thus, for a district to be allowed to conduct its assessment, it must establish that consent for the assessment has been withheld and, pursuant to California Education Code section 56381, that it is time for the student’s triennial assessment, conditions warrant reassessment, or that the student’s parent or teacher has requested a reassessment. The District contends that it is entitled to assess STUDENT despite his parents’ lack of consent because conditions warrant a reassessment. Student argues that the request for further assessment is procedurally deficient because the IEP team did not determine that additional assessments are warranted pursuant to 34 C.F.R. § 300.533.

The Hearing Officer is not persuaded by Student’s argument. It was clear from the evidence presented at hearing that at least the District members of the IEP team believe that further assessments are warranted. The fact that MOTHER disagreed with the conclusion does not make the request for reassessment procedurally defective. Moreover, the District has presented credible evidence that further assessment is warranted at this time. The District presented MOTHER with an assessment plan dated August 25, 2004, and requested that she consent to another District assessment of STUDENT. (Footnote 13) The District requested consent to conduct a home observation and assess him in the following areas: academic/preacademic achievement; social/adaptive behavior; visual/auditory perception and processing/motor skills; language/ speech/communication development; and intellectual development. The District argued that conditions warrant reassessment because, while the Student’s areas of educational need are not generally in dispute, there is a wide discrepancy between the opinions of the District’s representatives and those of the Student’s representatives regarding an appropriate educational program that would meet his unique needs. Dr. Freeman credibly testified that further assessments in this area are necessary to resolve the inconsistencies regarding the recommendations made for STUDENT’s program.

Furthermore, Dr. Freeman testified that there is some variability as to the skills STUDENT displays in different settings. For example, Dr. Freeman testified that, in terms of STUDENT’s communication deficits, ACES, Inc. has been working on STUDENT’s ability to imitate sounds. Dr. Freeman testified that earlier reports showed that STUDENT could already imitate sounds. Dr. Mitchell Taubman, who would conduct the behavioral portions of STUDENT’s assessment, testified that there are some questions that remain regarding the amount of progress STUDENT has been making in his home ABA therapy sessions. Dr. Taubman testified that ACES reported STUDENT had mastered skills when there was no evidence he had generalized these skills. In fact, Dr. Taubman testified that that he did not believe that STUDENT was acquiring skills in the home setting. The Hearing Officer finds Dr. Taubman’s testimony persuasive in this regard. (Footnote 14) Thus, further assessment is warranted to fully resolve the inconsistencies regarding STUDENT’s specific skills. The District has presented credible evidence that further assessment is warranted at the present time in the following areas set forth in its assessment plan: academic/preacademic achievement; social/adaptive behavior; visual/auditory perception and processing/motor skills; language/speech/communication development; and intellectual development. Accordingly, the District’s request to conduct further assessments in these areas pursuant to the proposed assessment plan dated August 25, 2004, over the parents’ objection is granted.

POST-HEARING MOTION

On November 4, 2004, one day prior to the last day of testimony, the District requested that it be allowed to observe the in-home program provided to Student by ACES, Inc. pursuant to California Education Code section 56329(d). (Footnote 15) The Hearing Officer heard oral arguments regarding the motion, then requested that the parties submit written briefs to address the issues raised. On November 8, 2004, the Hearing Office received the parties’ written briefs regarding this motion.

Student’s parents have been unilaterally providing him with an in-home applied behavioral analysis (ABA) program through ACES for approximately twenty hours per week. Student’s parents, through this due process hearing, had sought reimbursement from the District for the ACES program, as well as public funding for continued placement in that program. The District argues that pursuant to California Education Code section 56329(d), it should be allowed to observe Student’s in-home ABA program. Student contends that section 56329(d) allows for observations of students parentally placed in nonpublic schools, and not for services provided by nonpublic agencies. Student alleges that ACES is a nonpublic agency.

The Hearing Officer determines that this motion is now moot. As noted above, the Hearing Officer has already found that STUDENT is not entitled to the ACES, Inc. program as part of his publicly funded education, either for purposes of reimbursement or as prospective services. Since this issue has been resolved in the District’s favor, there is no longer any issue over reimbursement for the ACES, Inc. home program or the proposed public funding of the pupil in the nonpublic school during the remainder of the term of the October 18, 2004 IEP. The District’s motion to observe STUDENT’s in-home program pursuant to California Education section 56329(d) is therefore denied. This finding does not, however, affect the District’s right to observe STUDENT in the home program as part of its reassessment pursuant to the assessment plan dated August 25, 2004.

ORDERS

1. If STUDENT’s parents want him to be provided with a publicly funded educational program through the Magnolia Elementary School District, they must make him available for special education services pursuant to the October 18, 2004 IEP.

2. The District shall remain ready and able to implement all portions of the October 18, 2004 IEP should STUDENT’s parents elect to have him attend Weaver Elementary School.

3. The District is entitled to assess STUDENT pursuant to its proposed assessment plan dated August 25, 2004, over the parents’ objection. If STUDENT’s parents want him to be provided with a publicly funded educational program through the District, they must make him available for an assessment pursuant to that plan.

4. All of Student’s requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on all issues heard and decided, except to the limited extent that the Hearing Officer found that it failed to include a statement in its psychoeducational assessment report that the SIT was administered in a non-standardized way. However, no remedy was awarded for the District’s omission in this regard.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety days of receipt of this Decision. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).)

Date: December 31, 2004 Patrick J. Balucan, Hearing OfficerCalifornia Special Education Hearing Office

GASELPA was dismissed as a party on the first day of the hearing.

2 Petitioner did not contend that the assessment should have been conducted in Mandarin Chinese.

3 The Hearing Officer notes that California Education Code section 56320, subsection (b)(1), was amended by AB 152, effective July 16, 2004. Subsection (b)(1) now requires that test and assessment materials be “provided and administered in the pupil's native language, pursuant to Section 300.19 of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations, or other mode of communication, unless the assessment plan indicates reasons why this provision and administration are not clearly feasible.” (Emphasis added.) However, the District assessment at issue was administered in January of 2004, prior to the amendment being put into effect. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will analyze this issue under the statute in effect in January of 2004. At that time, Section 56320(b)(1) still stated that tests and assessment materials had to be administered in the pupils “primary” language.

4 The ratio formula derives an intelligence quotient (I.Q.) according to the following equation: MA/CA x 100, where MA is mental age and CA is chronological age.

5 Dr. Freeman testified that she is an emeritus professor at the UCLA School of Medicine in the Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, where she has been in residence for over thirty years. She is the clinic director of the UCLA Autism Evaluation Clinic, where she trains other professionals, including psychologists, speech and language therapists, and OT therapists, how to evaluate children with autism. Her curriculum vita indicates that she has lectured on the diagnosis, assessment, treatment, and nature of autism numerous times throughout the United States and abroad, and has published extensively on these subjects in both books and in numerous refereed journals. She has consulted with numerous school districts in California and throughout the country. Dr. Freeman testified that she has assessed a minimum of twenty thousand children with autism in her over thirty yeas of experience in this field. Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Office finds Dr. Freeman’s testimony persuasive.

6 Student also argues in his closing brief that it was inappropriate for the District to use the Developmental Profile-II because it was normed in only two states. Student argues that this made it inappropriate to use for determining his intellectual functioning, and the fact that it was normed in only two states made it culturally discriminatory and inappropriate to use on a minority child. Notwithstanding the fact that there was little, if any, evidence presented to support these contentions, they were not raised on the first day of hearing when the Hearing Officer clarified in detail the issues the parties wished to present at hearing. Therefore, they are not addressed in this Decision because insufficient notice was provided to the District that these contentions were at issue.

7 The Hearing Officer notes that Student did not present any evidence on this issue, and did not argue it his closing brief.

8 Ms. Cleveland’s June 7, 2004 letter indicated that a scheduled mediation had been cancelled. (District’s Exh. 27.)

9 The 1997 Amendments to the IDEA also require that students be provided with a program that “prepare[s] them for employment and independent living.” (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A).) Due to Student’s young age, this provision was not at issue in this matter.

10 Student did not argue that the offer of placement made through the August 2, 2004 letter was not appropriate to meet his needs. It appeared that Student reserved those objections for the offer made at the October 18, 2004 IEP meeting.

11 The facsimile from Student’s attorney sent to the District’s attorney indicated that it was not sent until 6:03 p.m. PST. The District’s attorney did not receive the correspondence until 9:03 p.m. EST. (District’s Exhs. 66 and 67.)

12 There is no indication in the record that the District attempted telephone calls or visited STUDENT’s parents’ home or place of employment. However, the record reflects that correspondence was an acceptable method of communication between Student’s and District’s counsel. Moreover, it was apparent that Student’s counsel did respond to correspondence by District’s counsel, obviating the need to call the parents personally or visit their home or place of employment.

13 Although there were several junctures at which the District requested further assessment of STUDENT, the District contends that the August 25, 2004 assessment plan is the most recent one provided to the parents, and is the assessment plan it would like to proceed with.

14 Dr. Taubman is the director of research for Autism Partnership and was also involved with the Young Autism Project at UCLA. He has presented numerous professional papers and has been published extensively in the area of data collection and research with respect to ABA therapy as it relates to children with autism.

15 California Education Code section 56329(d) states, in pertinent part: “If a parent or guardian proposes a publicly financed placement of the pupil in a nonpublic school, the public education agency shall have an opportunity to observe the proposed placement and the pupil in the proposed placement, if the pupil has already been unilaterally placed in the nonpublic school by the parent or guardian.”