California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 22, 2002

Tehachapi Unified School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 2659-01 · Hearing Officer Judy F. Hirano

Tehachapi Unified's reduced speech therapy offer denied FAPE to a third grader with autism; 10 compensatory hours ordered.

Student prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None stated. Before the hearing the parties settled one of the two issues the District had raised.

Summary

Tehachapi Unified School District filed for due process to show that its November 27, 2001 IEP offered an appropriate amount of speech and language therapy. The student was an 8-year-old third grader with autism. He was fully included in a general education class at Tompkins Elementary School with a one-on-one aide. A September 2001 IEP had carried over 135 minutes of weekly speech therapy from an earlier plan. In November, district speech pathologist Paula Beckham-Woodward recommended 30 minutes of group therapy twice a week plus one more 30-minute session every other week. The parent wanted the 135 minutes kept.

The Hearing Officer gave the most weight to Jackie Cooper-Glenn, a Kern County Superintendent of Schools speech pathologist who had assessed the student. Based on her testimony, the Hearing Officer found that the student needed 90 minutes a week, including 30 minutes of individual therapy. She found 135 minutes was more than he needed and would pull him out of class too often. The November offer was all group therapy and fell 30 minutes short every other week. The student had made little progress and still needed a lot of prompting. The Hearing Officer held that the offer denied a FAPE. She rejected the argument that a reassessment was required before services could be reduced. The district was ordered to provide 60 minutes of group and 30 minutes of individual therapy weekly until November 2002. It also had to hold an IEP meeting within 15 days to plan 10 hours of individual compensatory therapy. The student had asked for 19.75 hours.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO judged whether a speech therapy offer was sufficient: by weighing expert testimony and the student's actual progress on goals. The Hearing Officer set her own amount and type of service, which differed from both the district's offer and the parent's request. She also limited compensatory hours based on how much extra service the student could tolerate.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Did the District offer the Student an appropriate amount and frequency of speech and language services in the November 27, 2001 IEP?

    The November 2001 offer of all-group therapy (60 and 90 minutes in alternating weeks) did not meet the student's needs and was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, so it denied FAPE. An appropriate amount was 90 minutes weekly, 30 of them individual. The parent's request for 135 minutes was not supported.

  2. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2. If not, is the Student entitled to compensatory speech and language services?

    Because FAPE was denied from November 27, 2001, the student was awarded 10 hours of individual compensatory speech therapy, less than the 19.75 hours requested, to account for his ability to tolerate added services.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to provide or change services. District shall provide 60 minutes of group speech therapy and 30 minutes of individual speech therapy weekly until November 2002 (the anticipated end date of the November 27, 2001 IEP), unless circumstances change markedly or the parties agree otherwise.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, the District must convene an IEP meeting to develop a compensatory education plan.
  • Compensatory education. 10 hours of individual compensatory speech and language services from a qualified speech pathologist. Services must be provided during the rest of the 2001-2002 school year and the next school year, starting within one week of the IEP meeting. The IEP team sets the per-session amount and frequency based on the student's schedule and tolerance.

Total: 10 hours of compensatory services

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Burlington; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Doe v. Maher

People named in the decision

  • Tara Lemes-Jones, director of special education, Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Paula Beckham-Woodward, speech pathologist, Tompkins Elementary School, Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Jackie Cooper-Glenn, speech-language pathologist, assessor, and District witness, Kern County Superintendent of Schools
  • Rosa Styner, 1:1 aide, Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Anita Nelson, speech and language specialist, assessor, Los Angeles County Office of Education / Westside Union School District
  • Elaine Schneider, Ph.D., CCC-SLP, private speech-language pathologist, Private provider

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Judy Hirano, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Tehachapi, California, on March 19 and 20, 2002. Petitioner Tehachapi Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Stacy Inman. Also present on the District’s behalf was Tara Lemes-Jones (Jones),(Footnote 1) director of special education. Respondent STUDENT (Student or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Donnalee Huffman. Also present on STUDENT’S behalf was his mother, PARENT.

The District called the following witnesses: PARENT, STUDENT’S mother; Paula Beckham-Woodward (Woodward), speech pathologist at Tompkins Elementary School; Jackie Cooper-Glenn (Glenn), speech pathologist, Kern County Superintendent of Schools (KCSOS); and Ms. Jones, District director of special education. The Student called the following witnesses: PARENT, STUDENT’S mother; and Rosa Styner, STUDENT’S one-on-one aide.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the parties to submit Joint Exhibit 1, a tape of the November 27, 2001 IEP meeting, and written closing arguments. Thereafter, the record was closed and the matter submitted for a decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

On the second day of hearing, the Student’s attorney, Ms. Huffman, requested that the issues for hearing be broadened to include whether the pertinent IEPs provided a FAPE, and, specifically, whether the IEP goals and objectives were appropriate. Ms. Huffman asserted that the testimony of the District’s witness, Ms. Glenn, opened the door to this issue being addressed. The District’s attorney, Ms. Inman, argued that the issue for hearing was limited to the appropriateness of the frequency and duration of speech and language services pursuant to the November 27, 2001 IEP, as set forth in the District’s issue statement and clarified on the first day of hearing. The Hearing Officer denied the Student’s request. The Hearing Officer stated that as the petitioner, the District determined the issues for hearing, and its issue statement presented the limited issue of the appropriate amount of speech and language services since November 27. Further, the Student’s issue statement similarly raised only the amount of speech and language services and requested compensatory speech therapy as a remedy if the amount offered by the District was found to be inappropriate. The Student could have cross-filed for due process and raised his own issues related to denial of a FAPE but had failed to do so. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer ruled that the issues would not be expanded to include the denial of a FAPE because of allegedly inappropriate IEP goals and objectives.

ISSUE(Footnote 2)

1. Did the District offer the Student an appropriate amount and frequency of speech and language services in the November 27, 2001 IEP?

2. If not, is the Student entitled to compensatory speech and language services?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is an 8-year-old high-functioning autistic child who resides within the District and is eligible for special education because of autism. He previously attended school within the District from 1997 to 2000 and then attended school within the Westside Union School District (WUSD) during the 2000-2001 school year. In July 2001, he returned to the District and is currently attending grade 3 at Tompkins Elementary School (Tompkins). He has a full-inclusion placement in a regular education class with a one-on-one aide and receives speech therapy, adapted physical education (APE), and occupational therapy (OT). Since kindergarten, he has also received private speech and language services. (Testimony of PARENT.)

An August 25, 2000 IEP was developed by the WUSD when STUDENT was in grade 2 at Quartz Hill Elementary School in Quartz Hill. The IEP provides for a regular education placement, with a one-to-one aide. According to the IEP, STUDENT was performing at or above grade level in all subject areas. The IEP provides for speech and language services for 45 minutes twice weekly and also in collaboration with the teacher and aide. The speech and language specialist had also trained the one-to-one aide to provide services for 30 minutes twice weekly. An August 29, 2000 WUSD IEP addendum indicates that speech and language services were to remain as set forth in the August 25 IEP.

A September 22, 2000 Los Angeles County Office of Education (LACOE) assessment of STUDENT was conducted by speech and language specialist Anita Nelson when he was a WUSD student. On the Test of Language Development-Primary, he obtained the following percentile subtest scores: Picture Vocabulary, 9; Grammatical Understanding, 9; Grammatical Completion, 25; Word Articulation, 84; Oral Vocabulary, 16; Sentence Imitation, 25; and Word Discrimination, 9. He achieved the following scores on the following tests: Test of Pragmatic Skills, 10 percentile; Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test, 45 percentile; and Classroom Communication Skills Inventory, below average. On the Illinois Test of Psycholinguistic Abilities, he had the following standard scores: Auditory Receptive, 23; Auditory Association, 25; Verbal Expression, 21; and Grammatical Closure, 38. The report indicates that STUDENT’S voice, fluency, phonology, and morphology skills were age-appropriate but that pragmatics was an area of delay and recommends speech and language services.

An October 1, 2000 speech and language assessment report was prepared by Elaine Schneider, Ph.D., CCC-SLP, who had been providing private individual speech therapy to STUDENT since October 1, 1999. During the testing, the mother worked diligently to keep STUDENT on task. On the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals-3, his receptive, expressive, and total language standard scores were 88, at the 21 percentile; 84, at the 18 percentile; and 85, at the 18 percentile, respectively. He had difficulty in receptive language with sentence structure and in expressive language with word structure and formulating sentences. An informal spontaneous speech sample indicated that STUDENT responded to consistent and constant cues and required assistance in formulating sentences and questions. In pragmatics, he did not use direct eye gaze, and his speech had a halting quality. Dr. Schneider noted that STUDENT needed to work on skills to be able to interact with others and understand information being provided in the classroom. She stated that adaptations may be required to enable him to receive information and express himself orally and in writing and recommended continued individual speech therapy.

At an October 3, 2000 WUSD IEP meeting, speech and language specialist Ms. Nelson reported that the provision of speech therapy for 45 minutes twice weekly, with collaboration with the one-on-one aide and classroom teacher, was working well and that STUDENT was making progress. At a January 11, 2001 IEP meeting, Ms. Nelson wrote additional goals and objectives for expressive language and pragmatics skills, and the January IEP increased the amount of speech therapy to 45 minutes three times weekly to work on these goals and objectives.

Because the family was moving back to the District, the District held a June 5, 2001 IEP meeting to develop an interim IEP for STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year, when he would be in grade 3 at Tompkins. The IEP provides for a regular education placement with a one-on-one aide, speech and language services, APE, OT, physical therapy, and ESY. The IEP indicates that the IEP team was adopting the goals and objectives developed at WUSD. The IEP recommends direct and consultative speech and language services for 135 minutes weekly.

On September 18, 2001, the District convened an IEP meeting. The IEP states that past assessment suggested average to above average nonverbal intelligence and that STUDENT was performing at grade level in reading and spelling. The IEP provides for a regular education placement, with speech therapy in a group of three students, APE, OT, ESY, and adaptations such as a one-on-one aide. The IEP states that STUDENT was doing well in regular education with extra support and that his needs were in socialization. The IEP contains goals and objectives in the areas of self-help and socialization behavior; expressive language skills, pragmatics and voice quality; and gross-motor skills.(Footnote 3) The IEP provides for 135 minutes of direct speech therapy weekly but notes that speech services were being provided for only 60 minutes weekly and that the parents sought reimbursement for services beyond the 60 minutes being provided. According to District special education director Ms. Jones, the matter of make-up hours for the deficient amount of speech services provided was resolved at the November 27, 2001 IEP meeting.

A November 27, 2001 IEP, unsigned by the parent, recommends a change in the amount of direct speech therapy to 30 minutes twice weekly and an additional 30-minute session every other week. The IEP does not indicate a change in the type of therapy (that is, group therapy) previously offered. The IEP states that STUDENT participated in all general education subjects and required specialized services to meet his goals and objectives. The IEP contains a speech and language goal and objectives to improve and increase social interaction in the classroom setting. On December 3, 2001, the Hearing Office received a due process hearing request from the District related to the provision of speech and language services.

On March 12, 2002, KCSOS speech and language pathologist Jackie Cooper-Glenn conducted an assessment of STUDENT. The assessment included diagnostic therapy techniques, observations, and parent, aide, and teacher interviews. Ms. Glenn administered the Functional Communication Profile, a criterion-referenced checklist of skills related to sensory-motor skills, attentiveness, receptive and expressive language, pragmatics, social speech, voice, and fluency. In the sensory-motor area, STUDENT tended not to turn toward the source of a sound, although his hearing appears adequate. His attention span and response rate were inconsistent, depending upon his interest, physical state, task difficulty, and the perseverance of his communication partner. He did not demonstrate much interest in other people or the environment.

As for receptive language, STUDENT’S basic concepts appeared to be relatively well-developed. He responded to his name, sometimes requiring repetitions and prompts, and responded to attention commands with prompting. Meaningful smiles and laughter were still emerging. Regarding expressive language, STUDENT spoke English effectively and communicated with facial expressions, eye gaze, head nod, actions, and writing. His grammar was adequate, and his vocabulary relatively well-developed. He was beginning to express emotions verbally and to express humor, but social exchange was poorly developed. He occasionally engaged in self-stimulatory vocal behavior but stopped when reminded.

As for pragmatics and social language, STUDENT communicated to make requests and gain attention and answered questions with prompting, but was less likely to provide information, greet or take leave, or show interest in others. His conversational topics were self-centered, and his ability to initiate or maintain a conversational topic was poor. He required extensive prompting to recall events and might have some memory difficulties. In the area of speech, his intelligibility was good. During an interview, the aide revealed pragmatic lesson plans that she worked on daily with STUDENT. She had recently been trying to decrease the number of prompts.

Ms. Glenn concluded that STUDENT’S situation appeared to contain the ingredients for a highly successful inclusion program. She stated that his communication needs must be addressed within the natural environment. According to her, behavior related to communication development must be “engineered” in situations within the natural environment, and as behavior is established, prompts should be systematically eliminated. She stated that the communicative behavior addressed should be capable of implementation daily or throughout the day. She stated that a descriptive plan for the gradual elimination of prompts should be in place to assist STUDENT to produce the behavior independently. Ms. Glenn recommended continued speech therapy for communication development. She also recommended that the aide manage and record daily practice of target behaviors and that the speech pathologist observe his behavior, review his progress weekly, and ensure that prompts are being eliminated. Ms. Glenn stated that coaching or modeling behavior may be required to ensure that the aide is eliciting the desired behavior and encouraging independence. She stated that specific goals may include establishing an independent social greeting, establishing ritualized communication behavior for a common situation, replacing repetitive verbal cueing with discreet gestures, replacing an inappropriate behavior with a verbal message, developing appropriate game-playing behavior, and developing a method of staying on track when carrying out an environmental command.

LEGAL ANALYSIS

ISSUE 1: Did the District offer the Student an appropriate amount and frequency of speech and language services in the November 27, 2001 IEP?

Under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), as amended in 1997, and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. §1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A free appropriate public education is special education and related services, at no cost to the parents, that are designed to meet the student’s unique needs and are provided in conformity with the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8)(D), (25). Related services are transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services that are required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); see Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(a) (“designated instruction and services” (DIS) shall be available when necessary for a student to benefit from his or her special education program). Speech and language services are related services. 34 C.F.R. § 300.24(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(b)(1).

Under State law, speech and language services include the following:

(1) Referral and assessment of individuals suspected of having a disorder of language, speech, or hearing. . . . (2) Specialized instruction and services for individuals with disorders of language, speech, and hearing, including monitoring of pupil progress on a regular basis, providing information for the review, and when necessary participating in the review and revision of [IEPs] of pupils. (3) Consultative services to pupils, parents, teachers, or other school personnel. (4) Coordination of speech and language services with an individual’s regular and special education program.

Cal. Code Regs. tit 5, § 3051.1(a).

In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central School Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that the IDEA provides such a student with a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of “access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit.” Id. at 200-01. The Court stated that the specialized educational services furnished need not maximize each child’s potential. Id. at 198-99. To determine whether the District offered STUDENTan appropriate amount and frequency of speech and language services in the November 27, 2001 IEP, it is necessary to address whether the amount and frequency were designed to meet his needs, were reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit, and conformed to his IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Rowley, 458 U.S. at 188-89, 202.

STUDENT contends that the amount of group speech and language services offered in the November 27, 2001 IEP (30 minutes of speech therapy twice weekly and an additional 30 minutes every other week) was not appropriate and that the amount in the September 18, 2001 IEP (135 minutes weekly) should have been continued. The District asserts that the amount and frequency offered in the November 27 IEP were appropriate.

(1) Designed to Meet STUDENT’S Unique Needs

To determine whether the District offered STUDENT an appropriate amount and frequency of speech and language services, it is necessary to first identify his needs. Except for the amount and type (whether individual or group) of speech therapy, there was little disagreement about the nature of his needs, established by the assessments, IEPs, and testimony of the mother and speech pathologists Ms. Woodward and Ms. Glenn. In August 2000, he was performing at or above grade level in all subject areas but required, among other things, collaborative, monitoring, and consultative RSP services; a one-to-one aide; and speech therapy. Beginning in fall 2000, pragmatics was identified as an area of need. STUDENT also had difficulty with sentence structure in receptive language and with word structure and formulating sentences in expressive language. Similarly to the present, he responded to consistent and constant cues. He was beginning to understand meaningful smiles but, as in the present, had difficulty expressing emotions in words. He required continued individual speech therapy to further develop his receptive and expressive language. During the 2001-2002 school year, the following deficits were identified. STUDENT does not display much interest in others, such as asking questions or requesting things. He does not greet others appropriately or take leave easily and has a poor ability to maintain a conversational topic. Fairly high-functioning communicative and cognitive abilities can be elicited by continually asking him questions, but, overall, he requires a great deal of prompting with even fairly basic skills. He sometimes speaks in a loud voice in an inappropriate situation and at times engages in self-stimulatory vocalization.

The evidence established that because of the above deficits, STUDENT has the following instructional needs. He requires repetitive situations to establish certain skills that can eventually become ritualized or more automatic. He requires the fading of prompts and the use of signals other than questions, which isolate him from what is going on in his environment. He requires daily practice of targeted behaviors in his natural environment and people in his natural environment who can reinforce communication opportunities through modeling and coaching. In class, he needs to learn to sit appropriately and focus more on the teacher than the aide.

A difference of opinion existed as to whether STUDENT required individual speech therapy. According to his mother, he requires small-group speech therapy because he needs to learn to socialize.(Footnote 4) Ms. Woodward testified that the mother had requested, and Ms. Woodward provided, small-group speech therapy to STUDENT.(Footnote 5) According to Ms. Woodward, she reviewed his former IEP and thought that a group setting would be good because he needed more social interactions. STUDENT also received small-group speech and language services from a tutor. (Testimony of PARENT.) However, Ms. Glenn testified that she did not think that group therapy was an appropriate way to teach pragmatics. She testified that because STUDENT requires a great deal of prompting and, thus, intensive work, one-to-one therapy would be preferable. She further testified that if he received group therapy, he would require more therapy time because he would be sharing time with the other students in the group. At WUSD, his former school district, STUDENT received individual speech therapy from the speech pathologist. (Testimony of Ms. Woodward.) His private speech therapist during the past school year also provided individual therapy and recommended continued individual speech therapy. (Pet. Exh. E.) Thus, the evidence is that in the recent past and the present, speech pathologists, including current assessor Ms. Glenn, have identified individual speech therapy as one of STUDENT’S needs. The Hearing Officer finds that there was not a significant disagreement about the appropriateness of group therapy, but that the evidence established that, in addition to group therapy, at least some individual therapy is one of STUDENT’S unique needs.

To determine whether the amount and frequency of group speech therapy offered by the District in the November 27 IEP were designed to address STUDENT’S needs, it is necessary to examine the IEP. The IEP is a written statement of the goals and objectives developed to meet the student’s unique needs and the special education and related services and supplementary aids and services that will be provided to assist the student to advance toward attaining these goals. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(ii), (iii).

Ms. Woodward testified that the September 18 IEP goals and objectives were the only ones she worked on in therapy. The November 27 IEP essentially supplemented, or amended, the September IEP. (Dist. Exh. 9, Testimony of Ms. Jones.) The September 18 IEP contains goals and objectives to improve expressive language skills, pragmatics, and voice quality. The pragmatics objectives are designed to assist STUDENT to respond to and initiate greetings and to engage in social interactions through game playing. The expressive language objective addresses responding to “wh” questions with a mean utterance of at least 5 to 7 words. The voice quality objective addresses ascertaining when a voice is too loud or soft for a given situation. The November 27 IEP contains only one goal, to improve and increase social interactions in the classroom. According to Ms. Woodward, this goal was intended to be carried out in the classroom, and the IEP has a box checked indicating that the aide, rather than the speech pathologist, would be working on this goal.(Footnote 6) All of these goals and objectives were designed to meet STUDENT’S identified needs in these areas.(Footnote 7)

The September 18 IEP provided for 135 minutes of group speech and language services weekly. (Dist. Exh. 8.) The November 27 IEP provides for group speech and language services for 30 minutes twice weekly and an additional 30 minutes of group services every other week. (Dist. Exh. 9.) Speech pathologist Ms. Woodward testified that she provided the twice-weekly therapy in the therapy room and the additional 30-minute therapy every other week in the classroom. The Student argues that he required more group speech therapy weekly (specifically, 135 minutes, as called for in the September 18, 2001 IEP) than the amount offered in the November IEP.

What Was the Basis for the Offer of 135 Minutes of Speech Therapy in the September IEP?

Before the appropriateness of the amount and frequency offered in the November 27 IEP is addressed, the basis for the District’s offer of 135 minutes of speech therapy in the September 18 IEP will be examined. To do so, it is necessary to look at the WUSD IEPs developed for the 2000-2001 school year and the District’s June, September, and November 2001 IEPs developed for the 2001-2002 school year because they are interrelated.

A review of the WUSD IEPs in the record for the 2000-2001 school year reveals that initially, WUSD had been providing 45 minutes of individual speech therapy twice weekly pursuant to its August 25, 2000 IEP. (Dist. Exh. 3; Testimony of Ms. Woodward.) According to the January 11, 2001 IEP, the speech pathologist increased the therapy amount by 45 minutes weekly to work on additional goals and objectives that she wrote for expressive language and pragmatics skills. (Dist. Exh. 6.) Thus, the most recent WUSD IEP provided for a total of 135 minutes of individual speech therapy weekly.

When STUDENT returned to the District for the 2001-2002 school year, the District needed to provide an interim placement in conformity with an IEP, unless the parent agreed otherwise. Cal. Educ. Code § 56325(a).(Footnote 8) The interim IEP could have been the existing WUSD IEP, implemented to the extent possible within existing resources, or a new IEP developed pursuant to California Education Code Section 56321. Id. Instead of implementing WUSD’s IEP, on June 5, 2001, the District developed a new IEP for the interim placement.(Footnotes 9) (Dist. Exh. 7.)

The June 5 IEP provides for 135 minutes weekly of group and consultative speech and language services. Ms. Woodward, who attended the June IEP meeting, testified that she believed that the mother stated at that meeting the amount of speech and language services that STUDENT had received in his former school district. The June IEP indicates that the IEP team adopted the goals and objectives from WUSD, the prior district. At the September IEP meeting, District special education director Ms. Jones was the scribe and copied in the September 18 IEP the amount of speech and language services from the most recent IEP, the District’s June 5 interim IEP.(Footnote 10) After the September IEP meeting, Ms. Woodward told her that she did not think that STUDENT needed 135 minutes of speech therapy to meet his goals. Ms. Jones realized that Ms. Woodward should have the opportunity to recommend the amount of services at an IEP meeting, and placed this matter as an item for the November 27 IEP meeting. (Testimony of Ms. Jones.) At the November 27 IEP meeting, Ms. Woodward recommended group speech therapy for 30 minutes twice weekly and an additional 30 minutes every other week.(Footnote 11)

Did the November 2001 IEP Offer An Appropriate Amount and Frequency of Speech Therapy?

Ms. Woodward testified that in September 2001, she thought that because STUDENT had so many strengths, 30 minutes twice weekly of group speech therapy (the amount she was actually providing) was sufficient.(Footnote 12) Ms. Jones testified that after the September IEP meeting, Ms. Woodward told her that the 135 minutes provided for in the September IEP was more time than necessary for STUDENT to meet his goals given his present level of performance. Ms. Woodward testified that STUDENT did not like going to speech therapy, and in October 2001, she observed him in his after school daycare, with the parent’s consent, to see how she could better serve him. She then started providing 30 minutes of group speech therapy to him in the classroom every other Tuesday, in addition to the 30-minute group therapy in the therapy room twice weekly. This amount and frequency of speech therapy were offered in the November 27 IEP.

STUDENT’S mother testified that he should receive 135 minutes, as provided in the September IEP, because he would learn faster with more therapy time. She also testified that the amount of time he required depended on the speech therapist’s qualifications.(Footnote 13) She felt that Ms. Woodward did not have much knowledge of, and experience with, autistic children and that STUDENT would make better progress on his objectives with a more experienced therapist. She further testified that because Ms. Glenn had much knowledge and experience with autistic children, she would accept Ms. Glenn’s speech therapy recommendations.(Footnote 14)

Ms. Glenn was asked the amount of time that she thought would be appropriate to work on the September IEP goals and objectives (the only goals and objectives that Ms. Woodward was implementing). Ms. Glenn’s testimony was that if STUDENT was receiving individual therapy, 30 minutes twice weekly and, if he was receiving group therapy, at least three times weekly because he would share the time with other students. Ms. Glenn was also asked whether she thought that group therapy for 30 minutes twice weekly and an additional 30 minutes every other week (the amount and frequency offered in the November 27 IEP) would be an appropriate amount of time for these goals and objectives. She replied that she was not sure, but it would be helpful. Ms. Glenn also testified that 135 minutes weekly of speech therapy was not appropriate because being taken out of class for that amount of time would result in missed opportunities for STUDENT to learn how to sit appropriately, focus on the teacher rather than the aide, and, generally, behave in, and be a part of, his class.(Footnote 15)

According to one District witness, Ms. Woodward, an appropriate amount and frequency of speech therapy were 60 and 90 minutes of group therapy in alternate weeks. The testimony of another District witness, Ms. Glenn, taken as a whole, established that the appropriate amount and frequency of therapy weekly were 60 minutes if individual and at least 90 minutes of a combination of group and individual. Because of Ms. Glenn’s substantial experience as a speech pathologist, including working with autistic children, and her expertise in PECS, a communication system widely used with autistic children, the Hearing Officer places greater weight on her testimony in this matter. The Hearing Officer concludes, based upon a preponderance of the evidence, that a total of 90 minutes of speech therapy weekly is an appropriate amount to meet STUDENT’S unique needs. As found above, he requires some individual speech therapy in addition to group therapy. Given his minimal progress with solely group therapy during the approximately first seven months of the school year (as discussed below), the Hearing Officer finds that an appropriate amount of individual speech therapy is 30 minutes weekly. Thus, 30 minutes of the total 90 minutes of speech therapy weekly should be individual therapy and 60 minutes should be group therapy. STUDENT shall be entitled to this amount and type of speech therapy for the duration of the November 27, 2001 IEP (that is, until November 2002, unless circumstances change markedly) or until the parties agree otherwise. The evidence does not support the conclusion that STUDENT requires 135 minutes weekly of speech therapy at this time. Moreover, the evidence is that the November 27 IEP offered group speech therapy for 60 minutes one week and 90 minutes the next week on an alternating basis. No evidence was presented that this IEP offered individual therapy. During the weeks that therapy was offered for only 60 minutes, the amount was deficient by 30 minutes. Moreover, although an additional group therapy session was offered every other week, the offer was deficient in not providing 30 minutes of individual therapy weekly. To the extent set forth above, the amount and frequency of speech therapy offered in the November IEP were inappropriate.

(2) Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit

Determining whether an educational program and related services are reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit requires a review of various measures, such as standardized test scores, teacher and staff observations, and progress on annual goals and short-term objectives.

Ms. Woodward testified that on the first objective in the September IEP (by December 2001, to respond to greetings such as “hello” within the therapy setting with 90 percent accuracy), STUDENT was almost at the 90 percent level in responding to the other students or to her when he entered the therapy room. She testified that this objective was met in therapy without prompts or gesturing in approximately January 2002. STUDENT’S aide testified that until about mid-February 2002, she accompanied STUDENT and remained in the therapy room with him during his speech therapy from Ms. Woodward.(Footnote 16) She testified that on the first objective, STUDENT sometimes needs to be prompted, on some days several times, and that this objective had not been met without prompting. Ms. Woodward testified that the one-on-one aide was working with STUDENT on this objective in the classroom, and he could respond to greetings less than 50 percent of the time in the classroom.

Regarding the second objective (by September 2002, to initiate greetings within the therapy room with 90 percent accuracy), Ms. Woodward testified that STUDENT could initiate greetings very inconsistently and required quite a bit of prompting. According to her, this objective had not yet been met in the small group. The aide testified that most of the time, STUDENT needed to be prompted. The third objective is, by September 2002, to engage in social interaction (play games) with his speech group members for at least a 30-minute session weekly, with 5 initiations, 5 responses, and 5 eye contacts. Ms. Woodward testified that this was an ongoing objective that she worked on in the therapy session in the classroom. She testified that she had seen a lot of growth with turntaking and being responsive to the other children and that STUDENT was coming along in these areas. The aide testified that STUDENT does not initiate playing games, except for the Wednesday therapy session, which he knows is for game playing, so that the prompt is already set up, and he is prepared to play a game.

The fourth objective is, by March 2002, to use 5 to 7 words to respond to “wh” questions presented by the therapist with 90 percent accuracy. Ms. Woodward testified that in therapy, STUDENT can respond to “wh” questions most of the time with at least 5 words but that she was trying to increase his mean length of utterance. The aide testified that STUDENT was responding better to “wh” questions, but she did not know the percent accuracy. She testified that for the most part, he responded to her own questions with 5 to 7 words, although sometimes she had to ask the question more than once. The fifth objective is, by March 2002, to be able to tell when a spoken voice is too loud or soft for a given situation with 90 percent accuracy. Ms. Woodward testified that with prompting, STUDENT can notice when another person’s voice is too loud or too soft. She testified that in therapy or the classroom, he sometimes speaks loudly inappropriately but can adjust his voice when reminded. The aide testified that STUDENT needed to be reminded to speak up to be heard and that he used a loud voice only when upset.

As for the November IEP goal and objectives to improve and increase social interaction in the classroom, Ms. Woodward testified that these were being implemented in the classroom by the aide and that she herself did not work on them. From the aide’s reports, Ms. Woodward testified as to STUDENT’S progress on the goals and objectives, all with a September 2002 target date. With regard to the first objective to greet three peers daily with minimal prompting and 90 percent accuracy, Ms. Woodward testified that STUDENT was able to do that with prompting, which she believed was minimal, and with an unknown percent of accuracy. According to her, he was in the process of meeting this objective. However, Ms. Glenn testified that she spent “a good hour” in STUDENT’S classroom and observed that he required a great deal of prompting, even with a goal like greeting others. As for the second objective (to demonstrate social control by inviting another child to play with him for at least 10 minutes of a recess each day in 8 out of 10 presentations), Ms. Woodward testified that this was an ongoing objective which had not yet been met. Regarding the third objective (to read a story or from his science book daily to another child for 10 minutes in 8 out of 10 presentations), Ms. Woodward testified that the aide reads with STUDENT daily or has him read with another child. With respect to the fourth objective (3 times during the week to run errands that require him to request an object or information from another person in 8 out of 10 situations), Ms. Woodward testified that she believed that he did 3 errands consistently with his aide. The aide testified that STUDENT was doing at least 3 errands weekly but needed verbal prompts for delivery.

The aide testified that Ms. Woodward discussed with her what needed to be done on the November IEP objectives and checked with her on STUDENT’S progress, and the aide tried to keep track of his progress. According to her, he requires much repetition, and she still uses prompts, although she is attempting to reduce verbal prompts and use touch instead to elicit a response.

The evidence establishes that for the most part, STUDENT still requires prompting, in some instances extensive prompting, in working on the goals and objectives and is unable to initiate or respond to communications independently. The only objective which he appears to be able to accomplish with little, if any, prompting is to respond to others’ greetings in the therapy room. Thus, his progress has been minimal. The amount of speech therapy that the District has provided STUDENT is less than the total amount the Hearing Officer found to be appropriate. Moreover, the November IEP provided for exclusively group therapy and no individual therapy weekly. The Hearing Officer finds that the amount of solely group speech therapy the District offered in the November 27 IEP, which provides for 30 minutes less therapy every other week than the total amount the Hearing Officer found to be appropriate, was not reasonably calculated to bestow educational benefit.

In sum, the amount and frequency of speech and language therapy offered in the November 27 IEP were not designed to meet STUDENT’S unique and individual needs and were not reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit.(Footnote 17) The result is denial of a FAPE.

ISSUE 2: If not, is the Student entitled to compensatory speech and language services?

Because the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year starting from November 27, 2001, he is entitled to appropriate relief. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i); Burlington, 471 U.S. at 369. Compensatory education is a form of equitable relief that may be awarded to help overcome lost educational opportunity. See, e.g., Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist., 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). Compensatory education does not require day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity lost or time missed. Its purpose is to “ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of IDEA.” Id. at 1497. Equitable considerations are relevant in fashioning relief. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 374; Student W., 31 F.3d at 1496.

The Student requests compensatory speech and language services from November 27, 2001, to the date of this decision in the amount of 75 minutes for 11 weeks (13 hours, 45 minutes total) and 45 minutes for 8 weeks (6 hours total), for a total of 19 hours and 45 minutes.(Footnote 18) Because of the denial of a FAPE, the Student has serious pragmatic and social language problems and requires extensive prompting with even basic skills such as greeting others. The Hearing Officer finds that he is entitled to compensatory speech therapy for lost educational services. Because of the denial of a FAPE from November 27, 2001, over a period of approximately 6 months, or 24 weeks, the amount of weekly speech therapy STUDENT received was 30 minutes less every other week than the total amount the Hearing Officer found to be appropriate, and he failed to receive 30 minutes of individual speech therapy weekly. Because there is a limit to the time and amount of services he can tolerate above his regular educational schedule, the Hearing Officer finds that appropriate relief would be 10 hours of individual compensatory speech and language services. The services shall be provided during the remainder of this school year and the next school year, commencing within one week of the date of the IEP meeting called for in the Order below. The services shall be provided by a qualified speech pathologist. The specific per-session amount and frequency of these services shall be determined by the IEP team, considering STUDENT’S schedule and ability to tolerate additional services.(Footnote 19)

ORDER

1. The District shall provide the Student, weekly, with 60 minutes of group speech therapy and 30 minutes of individual speech therapy until November 2002 (the anticipated termination date of the November 27, 2001 IEP), unless circumstances change markedly, or the parties agree otherwise.

2. Within fifteen calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to develop an appropriate compensatory education plan for STUDENT. He shall be entitled to 10 hours of individual compensatory speech and language services. The services shall be provided during the remainder of this school year and the next school year, commencing within a week of the date of the IEP meeting called for by this Order. The services shall be provided by a qualified speech pathologist. The specific per-session amount and frequency of these services shall be determined by the IEP team, considering STUDENT’S schedule and tolerance for additional services.

3. All of Petitioner’s claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: The Student prevailed on all issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

Dated: May 22, 2002 ____________________________________ Judy Hirano, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES

1. For the sake of brevity, all hyphenated last names have been shortened. 2. The District’s issue statement raised two separate issues. Following settlement discussions outside the presence of the Hearing Officer, the parties settled one of the issues and informed the Hearing Officer that they wished to proceed to hearing on the sole remaining issue. Because the Student seeks compensatory speech and language services as a remedy, for purposes of analysis, the Hearing Officer will treat the remedy as a separate issue. The issues have been clarified to facilitate the analysis. 3. The IEP indicates that medications STUDENTwas taking at home were Valtrex (antibiotic), Paxil (antidepressant), Zyrtac (allergies), and Feosol (iron). 4. The mother testified that she is self-educated regarding autism, communicates daily with STUDENT’Saide, and is directly and actively involved in his skill development, but that she does not have a special education or speech and language degree or credential. 5. Ms. Woodward has a bachelor’s degree in speech pathology and audiology and a master’s degree and a California credential and license in speech pathology. She worked as a speech pathologist with another school district from 1985 to 1994 and during this time helped to diagnose some autistic children. After five years of time off, she started working for the District as a part-time speech pathologist in August 2000. Since 2000, she has attended a few classes that may have been on autism. She has worked with approximately 10 autistic children, most of whom were nonverbal and one or two of whom were able to communicate. (Testimony of Ms. Woodward.) 6. Ms. Woodward testified that because the parents had not signed the November 27 IEP, she could not work on the goal set forth in the IEP. 7. It is noted that KCSOS speech pathologist Ms. Glenn testified regarding perceived deficiencies in the goals and objectives. However, as discussed above, this matter is not an issue in this hearing, and the Hearing Officer makes no determination about the overall appropriateness of the goals and objectives. 8. The WUSD is within the Antelope Valley, Los Angeles County, special education local plan area (SELPA). (Dist. Exhs. 3-6.) The evidence is that the District is located within Kern County. (See Dist. Exh. 12.) No evidence was presented that the two districts operate under the same local plan. 9. There is no evidence that the District’s June 5 IEP was developed pursuant to Section 56321 (i.e., pursuant to an assessment conducted in conformance with Section 56321’s requirements). However, the appropriateness of the June 5 IEP was not raised as an issue in this hearing, and, according to Ms. Jones, the matter of a deficiency in the amount of speech therapy provided pursuant to the June 2001 and September 2001 IEPs was resolved at the November 2001 IEP meeting. 10. According to Ms. Jones, she did not become the District’s special education director until July 2001 and did not attend the June 2001 IEP meeting. 11. The Student’s argument that a reduction in the speech therapy amount required a prior reassessment is without merit. The authority cited relies upon regulations implementing Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, 29 U.S.C. § 794. However, the IDEA, rather than Section 504 and its implementing regulations, governs claims alleging the denial of a FAPE. Doe v. Maher, 793 F.2d 1470, 1479 (9th Cir. 1986), aff’d as modified sub nom. Honig v. Doe, 484 U.S. 305 (1988). Under the IDEA and State law, a reassessment shall be conducted at least every three years or more often if conditions warrant or the parent or teacher makes a request. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(2); Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(a). The Student has not established that any of these criteria was met. Even assuming, arguendo, that conditions warranted a reassessment, the District substantially complied with the reassessment requirements. The evidence is that IEP team members, including the mother, Ms. Woodward, and the regular education teacher, reviewed the existing assessment data and current classroom and service provider’s observations, and no IEP team member or other qualified staff identified any additional data that necessitated further testing. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(b), (c). Federal and State law do not require that a reassessment contain the components of an initial assessment. 12. As noted above, the deficiency in the speech therapy amount actually provided (in contrast to that called for by the June and September 2001 IEPs) was resolved at the November IEP meeting. (Testimony of Ms. Jones.) 13. Ms. Jones testified that Ms. Woodward worked as a speech pathologist for the District two days a week and an additional day every other week and had a caseload of approximately 30 students. The caseload of a full-time equivalent speech and language specialist providing services within a school district shall not exceed a district-wide average of 55 individuals unless prior written approval has been granted by the State Superintendent of Public Instruction. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3051.1(b). Ms. Woodward had a half-time equivalent position, and no evidence was presented that prior written approval had been obtained for her to exceed the statutory caseload limit. 14. Ms. Glenn, a KCSOS speech pathologist for 24 years, has a bachelor’s degree and California credential and license in speech pathology. She is a trainer of trainers in PECS (Picture Exchange Communication System), used primarily with nonverbal children or verbal children who do not communicate. She has worked for a number of years with children with autistic tendencies or diagnoses and has provided speech therapy to autistic children who are verbal. (Testimony of Ms. Glenn.) 15. The amount of speech therapy that was appropriate in November 2001 is based upon the goals and objectives that had been developed for STUDENTat that time. The Hearing Officer notes that Ms. Glenn’s testimony at the hearing indicated that she would take a different approach to speech services for STUDENTthan that utilized by the District; however, the approach used is not an issue in this hearing 16. STUDENT’Sone-on-one aide, Ms. Styner, had also been his aide when he attended kindergarten and grade 1 in the District. Her knowledge about autism stems from reading, several conferences on autism, and two early childhood education classes on special needs children. She worked previously with 3 other autistic children in a combined special day class setting. (Testimony of Ms. Styner.) 17. Conformity to the November 27 IEP is not disputed.

18. The reason for the different amounts requested for the 11 weeks and 8 weeks, respectively, is not clear. The evidence was that the additional 30-minute therapy session every other week started from at least November 2001, prior to the November 27 IEP meeting, if not earlier. (Testimony of Ms. Woodward, PARENT, Ms. Styner.) 19. Though not within the scope of this hearing, the Hearing Officer notes that KCSOS speech pathologist Ms. Glenn had specific suggestions and recommendations for a speech and language program for STUDENT. Thus, the Hearing Officer recommends that the District convene an IEP meeting with Ms. Glenn present to discuss the results of her assessment and her recommendations.