California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 5, 2005
San Diego Unified School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 2742-04 · Hearing Officer Judith E. Ganz
San Diego Unified may reassess a nonverbal 12-year-old without parent consent; Hearing Officer rejects sign-language and vision objections.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None stated. The decision notes earlier due process cases: one resolved by an August 8, 2002 settlement agreement, and a later one dismissed on October 30, 2003 after the parent did not appear.
Summary
San Diego Unified School District asked for a due process hearing so it could reassess a 12-year-old student without his mother's consent. The student was eligible for special education based on autism and moderate to severe mental retardation (now called intellectual disability) and is nonverbal. He had not attended a district program since 2002 and lived at home with his mother. After a September 2004 IEP meeting, the district proposed a reassessment plan dated October 28, 2004. Staff would observe him and review his class work in academics, social/emotional/adaptive skills, communication, and motor skills, including occupational therapy (OT) and adapted physical education (APE). He was not enrolled in school, so the testing would happen at the district's Diagnostic Center for Positive Change. The mother objected for three reasons. She said she had no part in writing the plan. She wanted him assessed in American Sign Language (ASL) at the California School for the Deaf. She also wanted his vision tested. Hearing Officer Judith E. Ganz found that reassessment was needed because staff had not seen the student in years and had never assessed his OT or APE needs. She found that the mother had given input and that the assessors were qualified. The evidence showed his language was English paired with gestures, not ASL. Nothing suggested his vision needed testing. The district may assess. It must enroll him at the center within 20 days and provide door-to-door transportation.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled a district request to reassess over a parent's objection. The Hearing Officer asked whether conditions warranted reassessment and whether the plan was developed with parent input. She also asked whether it used the student's actual way of communicating and covered every suspected area of disability. It also applies the rule that parents who want special education must allow testing.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedDistrict-filed: assess without consent
Issue 1. Is the District entitled to reassess STUDENT as set forth in the proposed assessment plan dated October 28, 2004, without the consent of his mother? (Analyzed as: whether conditions warrant reassessment; whether the plan was appropriately developed with parent input; and whether it will be given by qualified assessors in the student's native language in all areas of suspected disability.)
Reassessment was warranted because staff had not observed the student since 2002 and had never assessed his OT or adapted PE needs. The plan was properly developed with the mother's input and will be given by qualified assessors in English paired with gestures, which is his language, not American Sign Language. Vision did not need to be assessed. The District may assess without consent.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order that district may assess without consent. District may conduct the reassessment under the October 28, 2004 reassessment plan and must follow the timelines in Education Code sections 56344(a) and 56043.
- Within 20 calendar days of the decision, District must arrange for the student to be enrolled in or registered at the Diagnostic Center for Positive Change for the assessment.
- Order to provide or change services. District must arrange door-to-door round-trip transportation from the student's home to the Diagnostic Center for Positive Change, at District expense, for each day the student attends.
- District must notify the mother five school days before the date the student is to begin the assessment process.
- If the mother wants the student to receive a publicly funded education program from the District, she must make him reasonably available for the reassessment.
Key authorities
Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307 (9th Cir. 1987); Andress v. Cleveland Independent School District, 64 F.3d 176 (5th Cir. 1995); Vander Malle v. Ambach, 673 F.2d 49 (2d Cir. 1983); 20 U.S.C. § 1414; Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56320, 56381, 56501(a)(3)
People named in the decision
- Dr. Bruce Dake, school psychologist; District witness, San Diego Unified School District
- Patricia Laurick, case manager; credentialed teacher of the visually impaired; District witness, San Diego Unified School District
- Ann Milledge, occupational therapist; District witness, San Diego Unified School District
- Deborah Clemm, speech and language pathologist; District witness (also called Patricia Clemm once in the decision), San Diego Unified School District
- Institute for Effective Education Children's Workshop, nonpublic school (prior placement), Nonpublic school
- California Diagnostic Center-Southern California, state diagnostic center that did the February 2003 comprehensive assessment, State of California
- California School for the Deaf, Riverside, state school that denied admission in 2002, State of California
- San Diego Children's Hospital, private medical provider (early assessment and audiological testing), Private
- Diagnostic Center for Positive Change (DCPC), District assessment and short-term intervention site, San Diego Unified School District
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Judith E. Ganz, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in San Diego, California, on December 7, 2004.
Petitioner San Diego Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by Amy Bozone, assistant general counsel for the District. Also present on behalf of the District was Dr. Bruce Dake, school psychologist. STUDENT (Student or STUDENT) was represented by his mother, MOTHER.
The District called the following District employees as witnesses: Dr. Bruce Dake, school psychologist; Patricia Laurick, STUDENT’s case manager; Ann Milledge, occupational therapist; and Deborah Clemm, speech and language pathologist. MOTHER testified on STUDENT’s behalf.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following the parties’ oral closing arguments and the admission of two additional documents submitted by the District, the record was closed on December 13, 2004, and the matter was submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTER
On December 6, 2004, the day before the due process hearing was scheduled to begin, the Hearing Office received from Student a request for postponement. MOTHER checked the box indicating that she wished to pursue mediation and added in a handwritten note that she was ill. A clerk from the Hearing Office telephoned MOTHER and advised her that because her request was too late to permit the District an opportunity to respond, her request would be considered by the presiding hearing officer on the morning of the due process hearing. On December 7, 2004, MOTHER was present at the hearing. Before documents were admitted or testimony taken, the parties were given the opportunity to discuss settlement outside the presence of the Hearing Officer. After the parties informed the Hearing Officer that they were unable to reach agreement, MOTHER stated that she was ready to proceed to hearing and withdrew her request for a continuance.
ISSUE
Is the District entitled to reassess STUDENT as set forth in the proposed assessment plan dated October 28, 2004, without the consent of his mother?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The District contends that conditions warrant reassessment. The District maintains that its assessment of STUDENT in February 2003 provided sufficient information for it to make an offer of placement. However, because STUDENT has not been in an educational setting for some time, the District argues that it needs additional information to establish STUDENT’s current levels of performance to determine whether the goals and objectives described in the September 21, 2004 IEP need to be revised.
MOTHER asserts that she did not participate in the development of the proposed reassessment plan. At the crux of MOTHER’s remaining objections is her disagreement with all the previous assessments that concluded STUDENT was low functioning and that “overused” the label “autism.” MOTHER believes that STUDENT has a hearing impairment. Accordingly, she maintains that because STUDENT has a hearing impairment and is nonverbal, the assessments should be conducted in American Sign Language at the California School for the Deaf. Finally, MOTHER argues that because STUDENT also has poor vision, his vision should be reassessed.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a twelve-year-old student who is eligible for special education and related services as a child diagnosed with autism and moderate to severe mental retardation. STUDENT exhibits significant delays in communication and is nonverbal. (District Exh. 50.) STUDENT last attended a District program in April 2002. Since that time he has been at home with his mother.
STUDENT was first assessed in November 1995 at San Diego Children’s Hospital when he was three years old. Test results revealed that STUDENT had global developmental delays. STUDENT was found eligible for special education and related services. For his kindergarten year, STUDENT was initially placed in special education early childhood program at Grant Elementary, his neighborhood school. STUDENT was then placed in an integrated life skills class at Adams, a different District public school. Sometime thereafter, the District placed STUDENT back at Grant in a full inclusion program. However, Grant’s teaching staff had difficulty implementing STUDENT’s individualized education program (IEP) in that environment. In approximately March 2000, STUDENT was returned to the integrated life skills class at Adams until an opening became available in a nonpublic school placement. In the fall of 2000, STUDENT was placed in the Institute for Effective Education Children’s Workshop, a nonpublic school serving special needs children, at District expense.
According to Hearing Office records, MOTHER requested a due process hearing on April 9, 2001. (Student vs. San Diego Unified School District, Case No. SN01-00725.) In June 2001, the District assessed STUDENT’s cognitive functioning and found he was performing at the one-and-one-half to two-and-one-half-year-old range. (District Exh. 50; Testimony of Dake.) STUDENT remained at the Children’s Workshop until April 2002. According to Patricia Laurick, STUDENT’s case manager, the Children’s Workshop dropped STUDENT from its program when MOTHER declined to be part of their “team.” (Footnote 1) During the time STUDENT was out of school, STUDENT received his first eye examination on August 1, 2002, and eyeglasses were prescribed. (District Exh. pp. 72-73.)
On August 8, 2002, MOTHER and the District entered into a settlement agreement, resolving the matters in dispute in Case No. SN01-00725 and agreeing to further assessments of STUDENT. (District Exh. pp. 1-2.) MOTHER and the District agreed that the California Diagnostic Center-Southern California (Diagnostic Center) would conduct a comprehensive assessment, that psycho-educational, assistive technology, and speech and language assessments would be performed by mutually agreed-upon assessors, and that District personnel would conduct an audiogram. The parties also agreed that after completion of the audiogram, the District would refer STUDENT to the California School for the Deaf in Riverside (CSD). In addition, MOTHER agreed to share the results of any independent evaluations she obtained. The parties further agreed to convene an IEP meeting following completion of the assessments to discuss the results. Pending the development of the IEP, MOTHER also agreed to place STUDENT in a home school program, which the District agreed to fund. (Footnote 2)
Pursuant to the August 8, 2002 settlement agreement, an audiogram was conducted on August 29, 2002. Although STUDENT was difficult to test because he was unable to tolerate the headphones for more than a few seconds, the assessor reported that STUDENT’s hearing was within normal limits. (District Exh. p. 70.) On November 12, 2002, the CSD rejected STUDENT’s application for admission to its school. The admissions committee explained that STUDENT did not have a significant hearing impairment, although it invited MOTHER to inform the school if a follow-up hearing assessment produced a different result. The admissions committee also noted that STUDENT was unable to communicate using American Sign Language (ASL), a primary mode of communication used in all the school’s programs. (District Exh. p.71.)
On November 25, 2002, MOTHER, along with STUDENT’s father, requested another due process hearing alleging that the District had failed to comply with the August 8, 2002 settlement agreement and named both the District and CSD as respondents. (Student vs. San Diego Unified School District and California School for the Deaf, Case No. SN02-02632.) (Footnote 3) Although it is unclear from the record who requested the test, on January 24, 2003, the District performed an audiological screening. (Student Exh. A.) The test results, which were reported to be fairly reliable, indicated that STUDENT demonstrated normal ear drum mobility in both ears.
It was not until February 2003 that the additional assessments provided for in the August 8, 2002 settlement agreement were first performed. On February 4, 2003, STUDENT, accompanied by MOTHER, was assessed at the Diagnostic Center. (Footnote 4) STUDENT was assessed in the areas of cognitive development, adaptive behavior, and communication. Dr. Bruce Dake, the District’s school psychologist, Ms. Laurick, and Deborah Clemm, the District’s speech and language therapist, testified that they reviewed the Diagnostic Center’s report and also attended a meeting, along with MOTHER, at the Diagnostic Center to discuss the test results. A variety of measures had been used to assess STUDENT, including informal assessments, observations, parent interview, and a review of recent records. Standardized tests administered were the Southern California Ordinal Scales of Development, Assessment of Sensory Seeking Behavior Inventory, Early Social Communication Scales, Sequenced Inventory of Communication Development, and the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scale: Parent Interview.
The report indicated that in the area of cognitive functioning, STUDENT demonstrated abilities similar to those usually acquired by typically developing peers during the first two years of life, including some imitation, use of objects for their intended purpose, forming associations between objects and actions or spoken words or signs, operating mechanical objects, using trial and error, keeping in mind objects that were not in view, and matching three dimensional objects. STUDENT exhibited some additional abilities with the use of prompts or demonstration.
In the area of adaptive behavior, MOTHER reported to the assessors that she used a combination of oral communication and gesture to communicate with STUDENT. STUDENT was independent in all aspects of toileting, mostly dressed himself, showered with some direction and assistance from his mother, and performed some household chores including laundry, dishwashing, sweeping and vacuuming. In the community, STUDENT selected groceries but did not know the value of coins. He was unable to tell time using a clock, needed assistance to watch for traffic while crossing the street, and did not understand the potential danger strangers might pose. By parent report, STUDENT got along with other children and observed and imitated their play. STUDENT enjoyed playing with particular toys and dressing up in his parents’ clothes.
In the area of communication, the assessors observed that STUDENT used “functional language,” that is, a variety of means to express what was on his mind. STUDENT shook his head “no,” vocalized “o,” and requested continuation of an activity with prolonged and loud vocalization. He also engaged in behaviors or “antics” to avoid tasks, including doing the opposite of what he was asked, vocalizing loudly, leaving the worktable, scratching his arm or head, or flapping his hands. Regarding social interaction, STUDENT was “aloof” but found pleasure in being with others. He played among or beside other children and could be enticed to play with an adult if the activity interested him. STUDENT followed simple directions and responded to his name. The assessors concluded that STUDENT’s deficits in communication represented a “profound problem that impact[ed] all aspects of his life.” The assessors noted that ASL and the Picture Exchange Communication System were beyond STUDENT’s skill level and their use was not recommended.
The report concluded that STUDENT’s educational program should emphasize the acquisition of functional life skills across environments and maximization of his independence. The assessors recommended that STUDENT be placed in a highly structured and intensive full-day program, five days each week, for the full school year. Also recommended were assistive technology (AT) interventions including the use of switch operated toys, paired photographs with objects, an object schedule, and mini-communication boards. Further recommendations included continued speech and language services and family education and support (such as the Regional Center). (District Exh. pp. 5-49.)
STUDENT underwent corrective heart surgery in April 2003. (District Exh. p. 63.) On May 22, 2003, a nurse assessment report was completed and indicated that STUDENT was “otherwise extremely healthy.” The nurse observed that STUDENT wore eyeglasses but reported that his eyesight could not be tested because of his inability to respond verbally or to sign. A test of STUDENT’s hearing required him to drop a block in a bucket when he heard the beep sound. According to the nurse, STUDENT’s hearing appeared to be within normal limits “although [the test was] not entirely reliable.” (District Exh. pp. 67-68.)
On May 30, 2003, the IEP team, including MOTHER, met to discuss the assessment results and educational placement. Present levels of performance were derived from the Diagnostic Center’s report and STUDENT’s April 2002 IEP. District members of the IEP team recommended that STUDENT be placed in an integrated life skills special day class at Taft Middle School (Taft) a District comprehensive school, for the 2003-2004 regular and extended school year. Recommended designated instructional services included speech and language services, occupational therapy, and adapted physical education. A single message communication device was also included in the program. MOTHER did not sign the IEP or agree to the program offer. MOTHER wanted an oral motor goal to be part of STUDENT’s program as it had at the Children’s Workshop. She also wanted academic objectives and peer interaction. Finally, she expressed concerns to District members of the IEP team about STUDENT’s “[unspecified] language of instruction.” (District Exh. p. 53.)
Concerned over STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language problems, MOTHER requested additional audiological assessments. (District Exh. pp. 92-93 (6/27/03).) On July 31, 2003, a clinical audiologist at San Diego Children’s Hospital placed STUDENT under general anesthesia and performed an Audiological Brainstem Evoked Response test. No neurological abnormalities were noted. (District Exh. p. 91.)
As noted above, MOTHER had earlier requested a due process hearing. (Case No. SN02-02632) On October 30, 2003, the Hearing Office granted the District’s and CSD’s joint motion to dismiss the case when MOTHER failed to appear on several days set for hearing or to sufficiently explain her absence. (District Exh. pp. 75-78.) Ms. Patricia Laurick, STUDENT’s case manager, testified that she was told by the District’s legal office that after MOTHER failed to pursue the due process hearing, it was assumed that MOTHER and STUDENT had moved out of the District.
The District made no further effort to locate STUDENT until the summer of 2004, when Ms. Laurick was asked by the District’s legal office to check again on STUDENT’s whereabouts. Ms. Laurick testified that she called STUDENT’s father, who told her that STUDENT still resided within the boundaries of the District at the same address. Two letters were sent to MOTHER that requested her presence at an IEP meeting and MOTHER agreed to attend. (District Exh. pp. 96-97.)
The IEP meeting was held on September 21, 2004. Ms. Laurick testified that District members of the IEP team believed they could develop a “meaningful” IEP based upon the data from the Diagnostic Center. District members of the IEP team recommended that STUDENT be placed at Taft in the integrated living skills special day class for the 2004-2005 school year. Goals and objectives were drafted. However, at hearing, Ms. Laurick explained that STUDENT’s present levels of performance were unknown because he had not been observed in a school environment for some time. The program offer included speech and language therapy. Both occupational therapy and adapted physical education services were also included because, according to Ms. Laurick, STUDENT had received these services the last time he attended a District school. (District Exh. pp. 79-99.)
According to the IEP meeting notes, members of the team planned to send an assessment plan to the school site proposing to assess STUDENT in the areas of occupational therapy and adapted physical education. The Diagnostic Center had not assessed STUDENT in either of these areas. Ms. Laurick testified that the District staff believed MOTHER would enroll STUDENT at Taft, and that after informal observations by school personnel, if additional data were needed, the Taft teachers and service providers could add to the proposed assessment plan. The team agreed to meet again after the OT, APE, and any additional assessments had been performed to make any needed revisions to the goals and objectives.
MOTHER did not sign the IEP or enroll STUDENT at Taft. (District Exh. pp. 83, 102.) One month later, on October 28, 2004, the District sent MOTHER a proposed reassessment plan. The plan proposes to assess STUDENT using informal observations and review of his class work in the following areas: social/emotional/adaptive, communication, academic/preacademic achievement, and motor development. (District Exh. pp. 104-106). Along with the proposed assessment plan, the District attached a letter from Ms. Laurick informing MOTHER that because STUDENT was not enrolled in school, the assessment would be conducted at the District’s Diagnostic Center for Positive Change (DCPC). (District Exh. p. 103.) (Footnote 5) As both the letter and District school psychologist Dr. Bruce Dake’s testimony explained, the DCPC is a school site which supports students with difficult to manage behaviors with the goal of returning them to their comprehensive school sites. The DCPC provides short-term intervention and an assessment service and is not considered a school placement. The intensive one-on-one support provided by highly trained special education personnel allows the District to become very familiar with the student and his or her needs. A qualified speech and language pathologist, occupational therapist, and adaptive physical education specialist are assigned to the DCPC to conduct the assessments. Dr. Dake testified at hearing that STUDENT would attend DCPC daily for from three weeks to fifty days.
MOTHER responded in writing on November 5, 2004, to the District’s request to sign the assessment plan, that she preferred the assessment to be conducted at the University of California at San Diego. (District Exh. p. 107.) Pursuant to MOTHER’s request, another audiological screening was performed on November 15, 2004. (District Exh. pp. 108-109.) The results indicated that STUDENT had normal drum mobility in both ears. On November 15, 2004, the District filed its request for a due process hearing seeking authorization to reassess STUDENT. At hearing, MOTHER asserted that the proposed assessment plan was developed without her participation, that STUDENT should be assessed at the CSD in American Sign Language, his native language, and that STUDENT’s vision should be tested. (Footnote 6)
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Is the District entitled to reassess STUDENT as set forth in the proposed assessment plan dated October 28, 2004, without the consent of his mother?
Under special education law, a reassessment of a special education student must be undertaken by the District at least every three years or more frequently, if conditions warrant. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(2); Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(a).) Parental consent is required prior to the District conducting the assessment unless the District “can demonstrate that it had taken reasonable measures to obtain such consent and the child’s parent has failed to respond.” (20 U.S.C. § 1414(c)(3); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56381(f), 56506(e).) If the parent refuses to consent to a proposed assessment, the District may request a special education due process hearing to determine whether it may proceed with the assessment without the consent of the parent. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56501(a)(3).)
Do conditions warrant reassessment?
The District established it had sufficient information that STUDENT remained eligible for special education and related services and reassessment was not needed to determine eligibility. (Footnote 7) There also was no persuasive evidence that STUDENT required retesting to determine his cognitive functioning because of the lapse of nearly two years since the previous administration of tests at the Diagnostic Center in February 2003. Dr. Dake and Ms. Laurick testified that the standardized testing of STUDENT completed by the Diagnostic Center in February 2003, when STUDENT was ten years two months old, found that STUDENT’s cognitive functioning fell in the two-year-old range. (Footnote 8) However, as will be set forth below, the fact that STUDENT had not attended a District program since September 2002 established that reassessment in other areas was warranted.
MOTHER testified that except for several weeks when STUDENT was home-schooled in September 2002, he has not been in a District program since he left the Children’s Workshop in April 2002. Dr. Dake and Ms. Laurick testified persuasively that because District personnel have been unable to observe STUDENT since that time, the District lacks sufficient contemporary information about STUDENT’s present levels of performance in the areas of preacademic/academic, social/emotional/adaptive, communication, and motor development. (Footnote 9)
In addition, at both the May 2003 and September 2004 IEP meetings, District members of the IEP team noted that STUDENT had not received adapted physical education (APE) from the time he last attended a District public school. At the September 2004 IEP meeting, District members of the IEP team also noted that the February 2003 Diagnostic Center assessment had failed to assess either STUDENT’s OT or APE needs and determined that STUDENT’s OT and APE skills also needed to be assessed.
Thus, because STUDENT has not been in an educational setting since September 2002 and the District staff has not had the opportunity to observe him or has yet to perform an APE assessment, the Hearing Officer concludes that an assessment is warranted to determine STUDENT’s occupational therapy and adapted physical education needs, and his present levels of performance in the areas of preacademic/academic, social/emotional/adaptive, communication, and motor development. Student presented no evidence refuting the need to reassess STUDENT.
Has the District appropriately developed the proposed assessment plan?
Whenever a school district seeks to reassess a student with a disability, certain procedures must be followed. First, members of the IEP team and other qualified professionals, as appropriate, are required to review existing data, current classroom assessments and observations, and teacher and related service providers’ observations. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(b)(1); 20 U.S.C. § 1414(c)(1)(A).) Second, relying on the information obtained through the review and input from the student’s parent, the IEP team and appropriate qualified professionals identify what, if any, additional data are needed to determine, among other things, the child’s present levels of performance and educational needs, and whether additions or modifications to the child’s program are required to provide a free appropriate public education. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(b)(2); 20 U.S.C. § 1414(c)(1)(B).) Finally, from this review, the IEP team develops an assessment plan that should be focused on producing the data identified by the team as necessary to make determinations regarding the child’s program. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(c).
The Hearing Officer considers first whether District members of the IEP team reviewed existing data before developing the assessment plan. The testimony of Dr. Dake, Ms. Laurick, and Patricia Clemm, the District’s speech and language pathologist, established that in preparing the October 28, 2004 assessment plan the District appropriately reviewed existing data before determining what additional data were needed. All three witnesses attended the meeting at the Diagnostic Center, where the February 2003 comprehensive assessment testing results were reported and then, before developing the proposed assessment plan, reconsidered the results. Dr. Dake and Ms. Laurick explained that from this review and in consultation with an occupational therapist, they concluded that observing STUDENT as he engaged in a variety of tasks and performed class work would enable the District to determine STUDENT’s present levels of performance. In addition, Ann Milledge, the District’s occupational therapist since 1997, reviewed the previous occupational therapy assessment conducted in July 2001 and noted that STUDENT performed between the two- and three-year-old range. Ms. Milledge testified that, given STUDENT’s communication and cognitive deficits, current observations of what STUDENT is able to do would provide more useful data than a standardized OT measure. Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that District members of the IEP team reviewed existing data before developing the proposed assessment plan.
The Hearing Officer next considers whether the District members of the IEP team appropriately determined if additional data were needed. At the September 21, 2004 IEP meeting, District members of the IEP team indicated that an assessment plan would be drafted to assess STUDENT in the areas of OT and APE, because, as set forth above, these areas had not been assessed by the Diagnostic Center. In seeking to determine what additional data, if any, were needed to determine STUDENT’s present levels of educational performance and educational needs in the areas of preacademic/academic achievement, social/behavior/adaptive, and communication, District members of the IEP team expected to receive input from the teachers and related services’ providers at Taft soon after STUDENT started school. However, upon learning that STUDENT had not been enrolled in school, Ms. Laurick consulted with Dr. Dake, a District occupational therapist, and Ms. Clemm to develop an alternative approach to obtaining the additional data. (Testimony of Laurick.) Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the District members of the IEP team consulted with “other qualified professionals” and appropriately determined if additional data were needed.
In addition, contrary to MOTHER’s contention, the District established at hearing that District members of the IEP team also obtained input from MOTHER. MOTHER attended the meeting at the Diagnostic Center in February 2003 at which the comprehensive assessment results were reviewed. She was also present at the September 21, 2004 IEP meeting when the IEP team discussed the proposed teacher observations at Taft as well as the need for additional observations in the areas of occupational therapy and adapted physical education. (Testimony of Laurick; District Exh. pp. 81, 83.) MOTHER acknowledged at hearing that she attended the IEP meeting and she did not dispute that assessments were discussed. The Hearing Officer notes that after MOTHER received a copy of the proposed October 28, 2004 reassessment plan, she responded with a handwritten note to the District indicating her preference for another assessor, a fact that established she provided her input. (District Exh. p. 107.) (Footnote 10)
Further, the District established that the proposed assessment plan focused on producing the data identified by the team as necessary to make determinations about STUDENT’s program. Dr. Dake participated in developing the social/emotional/adaptive portion of the proposed reassessment plan. Dr. Dake explained that collection of behavioral data and observations were included in the proposed assessment because STUDENT had a behavior intervention plan in a previous IEP and the team needs to know whether these problems have persisted. Ms. Clemm participated in developing the communication development portion of the proposed reassessment plan. According to Ms. Clemm, observation and review of class work would provide the speech pathologist with sufficient information to develop baselines and determine if the September 2004 IEP goals were appropriate. Ms. Clemm testified that the previous testing was comprehensive and that no further testing was necessary. Ms. Milledge testified that it appeared from her review of records that STUDENT might benefit from occupational therapy services. Ms. Milledge also testified that standardized tests would not be useful for STUDENT. She noted that in previous testing, STUDENT scored between the two- and three-year-old range. Ms. Milledge explained that observation of STUDENT’s functional skills, that is, what he could do in the class, would provide a better baseline from which to develop appropriate occupational therapy goals. Thus, the members of the IEP team that developed the proposed assessment plan appropriately focused on what additional data were needed.
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that the District reviewed existing assessment results and available data, included MOTHER in the discussion of the proposed assessment plan, determined what additional data were needed, and thus, appropriately developed the proposed assessment plan.
Will the assessment plan as proposed be administered by qualified assessors in STUDENT’s native language and assess him in all areas of suspected disability?
Special education law requires that if the District conducts further tests as part of a reassessment, it must follow the procedures for initial assessments. (Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56320; 56381(a).) Testing and assessment materials and procedures must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; must be provided and administered in the pupil’s native language; must be administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; and must be validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(a)(b).) The pupil must be assessed in all areas of suspected disability including, where appropriate, health and development; vision; hearing; motor abilities; language function; general ability; academic performance; self-help; orientation and mobility skills; career and vocational abilities and interests; and social and emotional status. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f).) Assessment materials must assess specific areas of educational need and not merely provide a single general intelligence quotient. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(c).) Further, no single procedure shall be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for a child. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(e).)
The Hearing Officer briefly discusses the matters that are not in dispute. There is general agreement that the assessment materials and procedures are not racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. It is also undisputed that the assessments shall be conducted by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions and are validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. Moreover, the proposed assessors are persons knowledgeable of the suspected disability. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(g); Cal. Educ. Code § 56322.) According to Dr. Dake and District Exhibit at pages 104-106, two credentialed special education teachers at the DCPC will first become familiar with STUDENT and then collect data through observations and review of class work in the area of academic and preacademic skills. To assess in the area of social/emotional/adaptive, the special education teacher and school psychologist would observe STUDENT’s behavior. To assess in the area of communication, the speech and language therapist would observe STUDENT and review his classroom work. Ms. Milledge has conducted five to six hundred occupational therapy assessments and, of those, nearly half were of nonverbal students. She reviewed the proposed assessment plan and testified that in the area of motor development, clinical observations by an adapted physical education specialist and occupational therapy specialist would determine STUDENT’s needs.
In addition, the proposed assessors, who include credentialed special education teachers, a speech and language pathologist, and occupational therapy and adapted physical education specialists are trained observers, able to collect data, knowledgeable of STUDENT’s suspected disabilities, and qualified to perform the reassessment. Further, Ms. Milledge testified that in addition to her own clinical observations, she will ask MOTHER to complete a questionnaire regarding STUDENT’s motor skills at home and in the community. Thus the assessment will not rely on a single procedure as the sole criterion for determining STUDENT’s educational program. (Footnote 11)
The Hearing Officer will turn next to Student’s remaining concerns. First, as set forth above, Student contends that the assessment would not be administered in STUDENT’s native language (that is, American Sign Language). Testing and assessment materials and procedures must be provided and administered in the pupil’s native language. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(a)(b).) MOTHER maintains that STUDENT’s native language is not English and that he should be assessed using ASL. Dr. Dake reviewed the Diagnostic Center’s report and testified in assessing STUDENT, the assessors paired gestures with verbal prompts. The report noted that STUDENT responded to simple commands. Dr. Dake agreed with the Diagnostic Center’s conclusion that STUDENT did not possess the cognitive skills necessary to learn ASL. Dr. Dake testified that the assessors at the DCPC would pair gesture with the English language to communicate with STUDENT.
Ms. Clemm observed STUDENT at his nonpublic school placement and testified that STUDENT used gesture, touch, and facial expression to show emotion and to express himself. Ms. Clemm testified that STUDENT understood simple commands in English but did not spontaneously use ASL. Ms. Clemm believed that STUDENT would have demonstrated little change in his communication skills since her last observations because STUDENT had not been in school or received speech therapy since April 2002. In Ms. Clemm’s opinion, ASL is not STUDENT’s language. Although STUDENT is nonverbal, English is his language of instruction. The Hearing Officer accorded Ms. Clemm’s opinion significant weight. Ms. Clemm has a bachelor’s and master’s degree in communicative disorders, is certified in clinical competence by the American Speech and Hearing Association, and has been a speech pathologist with the District for nearly thirteen years. Moreover, Ms. Clemm observed STUDENT’s means of communication firsthand. Her observations were consistent with those in the Diagnostic Center’s report. In addition, MOTHER conceded that STUDENT is not fluent in ASL and testified that she pairs the English language with natural gestures and some simple signs to communicate with STUDENT at home. Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that the proposed assessment plan will be conducted and administered in STUDENT’s native language.
In a related claim, MOTHER asserts that STUDENT should be assessed at the California School for the Deaf instead of at the District. In MOTHER’s opinion, staff at CSD who communicate using ASL, are better able to assess STUDENT because ASL is STUDENT’s means of communication. Based upon the finding above that ASL is not STUDENT’s native language or his means of communication, the Hearing Officer further finds that it is not appropriate for STUDENT to be assessed at the California School for the Deaf. In addition, the District established that the DCPC is an appropriate place to assess STUDENT. As found above, the DCPC assessors will assess STUDENT pairing gestures with language, that is, in the same manner both the Diagnostic Center successfully assessed STUDENT previously and MOTHER communicates with STUDENT at home.
Turning to MOTHER’s final objection to the proposed assessment, MOTHER contends that STUDENT’s vision should also be assessed. As set forth above, the pupil must be assessed in all areas of suspected disability including, where appropriate, vision. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f).) MOTHER observed that STUDENT was a tactile learner and attributed his reliance on touch to poor vision acuity. Ms. Laurick, who was a credentialed teacher of the visually impaired and who had taught blind children in the past, testified that a vision reassessment was not necessary at this time. Ms. Laurick noted that STUDENT had his eyes examined in August 2002 and that although the doctor noted an eye muscle imbalance and prescribed eyeglasses for farsightedness, the doctor did not report that STUDENT was partially sighted or legally blind. Ms. Laurick further observed that although the nurse had been unable to test STUDENT’s vision using flashcards, a review of records revealed that STUDENT was able to see small objects, reach over and under, maintain a steady gait even when there were changes in the amount of light or elevation, and unwrap a small candy. The Hearing Officer concludes that from all the data that were already available to the IEP team, there were no additional areas of suspected disability, including vision, that needed to be reassessed.
The Hearing Officer concludes that reassessment of STUDENT is warranted, that the District followed correct procedures in developing the assessment plan and included MOTHER in the assessment process, and that the District has proposed a legally appropriate reassessment of STUDENT in his native language and in all areas of suspected disability. Accordingly, the District is entitled to conduct the assessment pursuant to the October 28, 2004 reassessment plan and shall adhere to timelines set forth in California Education Code section 56344(a) and 56043. The District shall arrange for door-to-door round-trip transportation from STUDENT’s residence to the DCPC for each day that STUDENT is in attendance, at District expense. MOTHER shall make STUDENT reasonably available for the reassessment. MOTHER’s questioning of the previous assessment results may be answered by the current observations the District seeks to perform. In Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1315 (9th Cir. 1987), the Ninth Circuit stated “if the parents want [their child] to receive special education under the Act, they are obligated to permit such testing.” In Andress v. Cleveland Independent School District, 64 F. 3d 176, 178 (5th Cir. 1995), the Fifth Circuit concluded that “a parent who desires for her child to receive special education must allow the school district to evaluate the child...there is no exception to this rule.” (See also Vander Malle v. Ambach, 673 F.2d 49, 53 (2d Cir. 1983).)
ORDER
1. The District is entitled to conduct the reassessment pursuant to the October 28, 2004 reassessment plan and shall adhere to the timelines set forth in California Education Code sections 56344(a) and 56043;
2. Within 20 calendar days after the date of this Decision, the District shall arrange for STUDENT to be enrolled in or registered at the Diagnostic Center for Positive Change;
3. The District shall arrange for door-to-door round-trip transportation from STUDENT’s residence to the Diagnostic Center for Positive Change for each day that STUDENT is in attendance, at District expense;
4. The District shall notify MOTHER five school days in advance of the date STUDENT is to begin the assessment process;
5. If MOTHER wants STUDENT to receive a publicly-funded education program from the District, she shall make STUDENT reasonably available for the reassessment.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement: The District prevailed on the only issue heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety days of receipt of this Decision. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).)
Dated: January 5, 2005 _______________________________ Judith E. Ganz, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. No further explanation concerning STUDENT’s failure to attend the Children’s Workshop or any other public or nonpublic school placement since April 2002 was provided by either party.
2. Meeting notes from the May 30, 2003 IEP meeting indicate that in September 2002, STUDENT was enrolled in a home school program for thirty days. (District Exh. p. 63.) Pursuant to the April 2002 settlement agreement, the District also agreed to reimburse MOTHER for certain educational expenses as well as for the costs of independent evaluations she had previously obtained.
3. Apparently, STUDENT’s parents do not live together. It was MOTHER alone who signed the August 8, 2002 settlement agreement on STUDENT’s behalf. Although the due process request was submitted by both parents on behalf of STUDENT in Case No. SN02-02632, it was MOTHER’s failure to appear and pursue the matter that ultimately resulted in a dismissal of that case.
4. The District provided no explanation for the lengthy delay.
5. The District’s letter gave MOTHER only eight days to respond to the assessment plan it proposed. (District Exh. 103.) The evidence showed that MOTHER provided her response to the District’s request and that she received a copy of her procedural safeguards. Thus, although MOTHER was entitled to at least fifteen days to consider the plan, there was no harm from the District’s advancing the timeline. (See Cal. Educ. Code § 56043(b).)
6. MOTHER’s position regarding the place for the assessment had changed. On the day of hearing, she stated that she preferred the assessment to be conducted at the California School for the Deaf.
7. The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT’s eligibility category for special education and related services was not identified by either party as an issue for this due process hearing. The Hearing Officer observes that according to the testimony of Dr. Dake and Ms. Laurick, each formal assessment of STUDENT beginning in 1995 when he was three years old and concluding with the comprehensive assessment conducted by the Diagnostic Center in February 2003, concluded that STUDENT is a child diagnosed with autism and mental retardation. The Hearing Officer makes no findings regarding STUDENT’s eligibility category.
8. The Hearing Officer observes that both Dr. Dake and Ms. Laurick referred to the February 2003 Diagnostic Center assessment as “recent.” Nevertheless, even though the District is somewhat misplaced in referring to these nearly two-year-old test results as contemporary, the issue in this case is not whether additional standardized assessments should be performed at this time. Rather, Student objects to the proposed assessment plan for three reasons: (1) MOTHER was foreclosed from participating in developing the proposed assessment plan; (2) the assessment will not be administered in STUDENT’s native language, namely American Sign Language, at the California School for the Deaf; and, (3) STUDENT’s vision is a suspected area of disability that should be assessed.
9. Dr. Dake has a bachelor’s degree in applied psychology, a master’s degree in counseling, and a doctorate in education. Dr. Dake has a pupil personnel services credential and is a Professor of psychology at Chapman College. Dr. Dake supervises other District school psychologists and oversees several District special education programs, including the Integrated Life Skills program and the Program with an Alternative Curriculum that serves children with borderline cognitive functioning. Dr. Dake attended the meeting at the Diagnostic Center in February 2003 to discuss STUDENT’s assessment test results and observed STUDENT when he attended elementary school and while STUDENT was at an IEP meeting at the nonpublic school placement.
Ms. Laurick has a bachelor’s degree in secondary education, a master’s degree in special education, and possesses an administrative credential. She taught a special day class for children with mild to severe handicapping conditions, including those who were deaf and blind. Ms. Laurick was a diagnostic teacher providing classroom support in integrated life skills classes and has attended numerous additional training in autism and behavioral problems. In addition, Ms. Laurick knew STUDENT since the second grade, observed him many times in his District and nonpublic school placements, and reviewed all STUDENT’s formal assessments.
The question of whether the September 21, 2004 IEP offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education was not an issue identified for this due process hearing. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer made no findings regarding the appropriateness of the IEP.
10. MOTHER’s note to the District indicated that she had not received a copy of her procedural rights. At the hearing, however, MOTHER testified that a copy of parental rights was on the back of the assessment plan and that she had received a copy.
11. It was also undisputed that the proposed assessment plan comported with the requirements of California Education Code sections 56321(b) and 56329(a) and (b). According to the testimony of Ms. Laurick and District Exhibit pages 103-106, a proposed reassessment plan was mailed to MOTHER. The cover letter explained that STUDENT would be placed at DCPC for a short term in order to be assessed since he was not attending school. The proposed assessment plan was written in easily understood language, was provided to MOTHER in her native language, explained the types of assessments to be conducted, and included a statement that no educational placement would result from the assessment without parental consent. As set forth above, MOTHER testified that she received a copy of her procedural rights.
