California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 1, 2002

Lawndale Elementary School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 2794-01 · Hearing Officer Glenn A. Fait

Lawndale Elementary may reassess a five-year-old without parent consent; Hearing Officer also orders an autism assessment added to the plan.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

Lawndale Elementary School District asked for this hearing after a five-year-old's mother and grandmother refused to sign its October 16, 2001 reassessment plan. The boy has Down syndrome and developmental delays. He attended a preschool special day class at Cabrillo Elementary in the Wiseburn School District under a stay-put order. The family argued that a reassessment was not yet due. They also said the plan should have been written at an IEP meeting, objected to some tests and to two assessors they did not trust (Cheryl Sikes and Roberta Friedman), and wanted to watch every assessment.

The Hearing Officer ruled for the District on every issue. Reassessment was justified before the three-year deadline. The child had changed a lot between ages three and five, could now communicate more, and might change placements, and the parties disagreed about his current skill levels. The law does not require an IEP meeting to write an assessment plan, and the family gave input through letters. Witnesses said without contradiction that the tests were appropriate. The family admitted that every assessor was qualified, and the law lets the district choose competent assessors. In a footnote, the Hearing Officer suggested using someone other than Ms. Sikes. Parents have no legal right to observe assessments, so each assessor will decide. The grandmother raised possible autistic-like behavior, and the District agreed to test for autism, so the plan must add an autism assessment. The family must cooperate with the assessments.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The case shows how SEHO handled a district's request to reassess a child without parent consent. Reassessment could be justified before three years when conditions warranted it. Districts chose any competent assessors, even ones the family distrusted. There was no automatic parent right to watch testing; the decision left that to each assessor's judgment.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue 1. Is the District justified in proposing a reassessment of Student at this time?

    Conditions warranted reassessment before the three-year mark: rapid development from ages 3 to 5, a dispute over present levels and goals, new communication skills, and an expected change of placement.

  2. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 2. Should the assessment plan have been developed during an IEP meeting?

    No IEP meeting is required to develop a reassessment plan; the District got meaningful input from team members and the family through letters, so the plan was properly developed.

  3. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 3. Were the tests and other assessment materials to be used in the reassessment of Student appropriate?

    Uncontradicted testimony showed the tests were given in English, nondiscriminatory and validated for their purpose; no intelligence tests were proposed.

  4. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 4. Were the District's proposed assessors appropriate?

    Under Ed. Code 56322 the district chooses competent assessors; the family conceded all were qualified, and mistrust of two assessors did not disqualify them.

  5. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 5. Can those assessing Student exclude his mother and grandmother from observing the assessment?

    No law gives parents a right to observe; each assessor decides whether and how the mother and grandmother may observe, based on the accuracy of results.

  6. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 6. Did the assessment plan proposed by the District include assessment in all areas of suspected disabilities?

    Because the grandmother raised possible autistic-like behavior and the District agreed, the plan must be amended to add an autism assessment.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order that district may assess without consent. The District is authorized to perform the assessments set out in its assessment plan dated October 16, 2001.
  • The District shall amend the October 16, 2001 assessment plan to include an assessment to determine the presence of autism.
  • The individual assessors shall decide whether and under what circumstances the mother and/or grandmother may observe the assessments.
  • The mother and grandmother shall cooperate in facilitating the assessments.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

34 C.F.R. § 300.536(b); 34 C.F.R. § 300.533; 34 C.F.R. § 300.505; 34 C.F.R. § 300.532; Cal. Ed. Code § 56381; Cal. Ed. Code § 56321; Cal. Ed. Code § 56320; Cal. Ed. Code § 56322; Cal. Ed. Code § 56501(a)(3)

People named in the decision

  • Dr. Sue Nelson, Director of Pupil Services; District representative, Lawndale Elementary School District
  • Cheryl Sikes, preschool special day class teacher; proposed academic readiness assessor, Lawndale Elementary School District
  • Roberta Friedman, proposed speech and language assessor, Lawndale Elementary School District
  • Marianne Mitchell, school psychologist, Lawndale Elementary School District
  • Deanna Seiler, home instruction teacher/assessor, Lawndale Elementary School District
  • Teresa Matsushima, school nurse (health and development assessment), Lawndale Elementary School District
  • Monica Lizarraga-Papke, adaptive physical education assessor, Lawndale Elementary School District
  • Barbara Seffin, speech and language assessor, Lawndale Elementary School District
  • Roberta Kay, speech and language assessor, Lawndale Elementary School District
  • Rosemond Seligson, occupational therapy assessor
  • Sponderwrks Children's Services, private provider (behavior assessment obtained by family)

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard on Januray 17 and 18, 2002 in Lawndale, California, by Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific.

Petitioner Lawndale Elementary School District (District) was represented by Dr. Sue Nelson, director of Pupil Services for the District.

Respondent STUDENT was represented by his mother, MOTHER, and his grandmother, GRANDMOTHER.

The record in this hearing was closed on January 18, 2002, and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUE

Should the District be allowed to assess STUDENT as provided in its assessment plan dated October 16, 2001?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The District contends that it should be permitted to perform the assessment as set out in its assessment plan of October 16, 2001. It further contends that its assessors should be permitted to assess STUDENT without his mother and grandmother being present.

At the end of the hearing, STUDENT’s mother and grandmother admitted that further assessments were needed, but that they felt the best people to perform the assessments were those who have been providing STUDENT services at his current placement. They also contended that two of the proposed assessors (Cheryl Sikes and Roberta Friedman) were not appropriate to assess STUDENT because their past dealings with them had led STUDENT’s mother and grandmother not to trust them. STUDENT’s mother and grandmother also contended that the assessment plan was not developed by the IEP team as required by law. They also believed that they had the right to be present to observe STUDENT’s assessments. During the hearing, STUDENT’s grandmother also raised a concern about the possibility that STUDENT was demonstrating autistic-like behavior and should be assessed in the area of autism.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a five-year-old boy who has been diagnosed as having Down’s Syndrom with a history of developmental delays. He also suffers from chronic sinus infections, asthma, sleep apnea and a mild hearing loss.

In September 1999, STUDENT enrolled in a District preschool special day class for severely handicapped students taught by Cheryl Sikes. STUDENT’s grandmother accompanied him during his attendance in the class. After only two days, she became upset over the way Ms. Sikes treated STUDENT and removed him from school. The District agreed to provide home instruction for STUDENT for one hour per day while the parties attempted to reach agreement on an appropriate placement.

During the first three months of 2000, the District performed a series of assessments of STUDENT. These included assessments of preacademic achievement, general ability, and social and emotional development by psychologist Marianne Mitchell and home school instructor Deanna Seiler; health and development by school nurse Teresa Matsushima; adaptive physical education by Monica Lizarraga-Papke; speech and language by Barbara Seffin and Roberta Kay; and occupational therapy by Rosemond Seligson.

The parties were still not able to agree on a program for STUDENT and he continued to receive home instruction for the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year.

In August 2000, after engaging in mediation, the parties agreed to place STUDENT in a preschool special day class at Cabrillo Elementary School in the Wiseburn School District during the 2000-2001 school year. STUDENT continues to remain in this class under a stay-put order issued in relation to a hearing requested by STUDENT’s mother and grandmother. He receives related services that include occupational therapy (OT), physical therapy (PT), adaptive physical education (APE), and speech and language (S&L).

In October 2000, an assessment was performed of STUDENT’s gross motor skills at the request of the District.

During May 2001, STUDENT’s IEP team met to develop a plan to transition STUDENT back to a District program for the 2001-2002 school year. The District and STUDENT’s mother and grandmother could not agree on appropriate goals and objectives for STUDENT because they disagreed about his current level of functioning.

In June 2001, STUDENT’s mother and grandmother obtained a Behavior Assessment Report from Sponderwrks Children’s Services. In July 2001, the District obtained an assistive technology assessment and an audiological assessment of STUDENT.

On October 16, 200l, the District prepared an assessment plan in order to perform a comprehensive assessment of STUDENT. The assessment plan called for assessment of STUDENT in the following areas: academic/preacademic achievement, social and emotional development, motor ability, language/speech/communication, general ability, health and development, physical therapy, occupational therapy, and a functional analysis of behavior.

On October 18, 2001, STUDENT’s mother and grandmother wrote a letter to the District requesting additional information about the proposed assessment, including the names, credentials, and experience of the proposed assessors, the length of the assessments and the number of times he would be seen by assessors. They also requested that the District use only assessments to which they agreed and that they be permitted to be present during all assessments.

On November 6, 2001, the District wrote a letter to STUDENT’s mother and grandmother setting out the persons who would assess STUDENT and the specific tests that would be administered. Included among those who would assess STUDENT were Cheryl Sikes, who would assess academic readiness, and Roberta Friedman, who would assess in the area of speech and language. On November 26, 2001, STUDENT’s mother and grandmother wrote to the District objecting to STUDENT’s being assessed by Cheryl Sikes and Roberta Friedman. They also requested that they be provided with more information concerning the qualifications of the other proposed assessors. On December 11, 2001, the District sent resumes of the proposed assessors to STUDENT’s mother and grandmother, and further information about the physical therapy and health assessments. STUDENT’s mother and grandmother continued to refuse to sign the assessment plan. On December 27, 2001, the District requested a hearing to obtain authorization to conduct the assessment set out in its October 16, 2001 assessment plan.

LEGAL ANALYSIS

Both federal and State law provide that a child with a disability be reassessed if conditions warrant such a reassessment or if the child’s parent or teacher requests a reassessment, but that there be a reassessment of the child at least once every three years. 34 C.F.R § 300.536(b) and Cal. Ed. Code § 56381(a).

In developing a plan for reassessment, the members of the IEP team and other qualified professionals, as appropriate, must review current assessment data, including observations by service providers, and receive input from the child’s parents. 34 C.F.R. § 300.533(a) and Cal. Ed. Code § 56381(b). This review can be conducted without a formal meeting of the IEP team. 34 C.F.R. § 300.533(b). The educational agency must prepare a written assessment plan which, among other things, must explain the types of assessment to be conducted. Cal. Ed. Code § 56321(a)&(b).

Before an educational agency can reassess a child with a disability, it must obtain informed parental consent. 34 C.F.R. § 300.505(a)(1)(i) and Cal. Ed. Code § 56321(c). If a parent refuses to consent to the reassessment, the educational agency may request a hearing in order to receive authorization to conduct the reassessment. 34 C.F.R. § 300.505(b) and Cal. Ed. Code § 56501(a)(3).

A reassessment must be based upon the same procedures specified for initial assessments. 34 C.F.R. § 300.536(b) and Cal. Ed. Code § 56381(a). Initial assessments and reassessments must use a variety of evaluation materials that do not discriminate on a racial, cultural, or sexual basis; are provided in the child’s native language; are validated for the specific purpose for which they are used; are administered by trained personnel; and are tailored to assess all areas related to the suspected disability. 34 C.F.R. § 300.532 and Cal. Ed. Code § 56320. California Education Code § 56322 provides that “the assessment shall be conducted by persons competent to perform the assessment, as determined by the school district....”

In this case, the District developed an assessment plan on October 16, 2001, and asked STUDENT’s mother and grandmother to consent to the assessment. After a number of communications back and forth between the parties that resulted in further clarification of the assessment plan--the persons who would perform the assessment, their qualifications, and the tests that would be used-- STUDENT’s mother and grandmother continued to refuse to consent to the assessment plan. As provided in federal and State law, the District then requested this hearing to determine whether it could proceed with the assessment.

The only objections to the assessment raised by STUDENT’s mother and grandmother were that they were not sure additional assessments were necessary at this time, that the assessment plan should have been developed during an IEP meeting, that some of the tests proposed were inappropriate, that two of the proposed assessors were not appropriate to assess STUDENT, and that the assessments should not be performed without one or both of them present.

1. Is the District justified in proposing a reassessment of STUDENT at this time?

STUDENT’s mother and grandmother contended at the beginning of the hearing that it was not necessary to reassess him at this time because he had been fully assessed two years previously and the law only requires reassessment every three years. At the end of the hearing, they conceded that there probably was a need to reassess STUDENT.

The law does provide that a reassessment be performed at least every three years, but it also provides that reassessment is appropriate whenever “conditions warrant a reassessment.” Cal. Ed. Code § 56381(a). In this case, it is concluded that the District is justified in reassessing STUDENT for the following reasons.

All the witnesses called by the District testified that the two years between his first comprehensive assessment in 2000 and the present are two of the most crucial years in the development of a child. Much can change between ages three and five, and for a child with STUDENT’s disability it is important to have current assessment data to use in developing an IEP. The evidence was uncontradicted that STUDENT’s mother and grandmother disagreed with the District about the appropriate goals and objectives. An important reason for this disagreement was lack of agreement concerning STUDENT’s current levels of functioning. The best way to resolve such a disagreement is to perform further assessments of STUDENT. The evidence also established that STUDENT was first assessed prior to having any significant experience in an educational setting. It is important to determine how he has changed after being placed in a special day class for over a year and a half. The witnesses for the District also testified that they had trouble assessing him in early 2000 because of his inability to communicate. Now, at age five, STUDENT has developed some communication skills and therefore would be able to be evaluated using tests that could not be used during his initial assessment. Another justification for reassessment was an anticipated move to another placement. STUDENT has been in a preschool class for the last year and a half. Neither of the parties believes that this class is currently appropriate for STUDENT. The District wants to consider moving him back to a District program. Such a change from his current preschool placement to an alternative setting and the possible change of districts provide further support for the need for reassessment. The evidence overwhelmingly supports the need for a reassessment of STUDENT at this time.

2. Should the assessment plan have been developed during an IEP meeting?

The law specifically provides that no meeting of the IEP team is required to develop an assessment plan. 34 C.F.R. § 300.533(b). However, the law does require input from all of the members of the IEP team and other qualified professionals in the development of the assessment plan. 34 C.F.R. § 300.533(a). In this case, the assessment plan was not developed during a meeting of the IEP team. It was developed by the District after consulting with other members of the IEP team and those who would be conducting the assessment. This initial plan was sent to STUDENT’s mother and grandmother. They provided considerable input through a number of letters they wrote to the District. The District responded to this input by providing detailed information about the assessors, their qualifications, and the specific tests that would be used in evaluating STUDENT. The District also agreed to change some of the tests it had originally proposed to use. While there was no formal meeting of the IEP team, there was meaningful input from its members, including STUDENT’s mother and grandmother. Therefore, it is concluded that the assessment plan was developed in the manner required by law.

3. Were the tests and other assessment materials to be used in the reassessment of STUDENT appropriate?

The law requires that in assessing a child with a disability, a district must use evaluation materials that do not discriminate on a racial, cultural, or sexual basis; are provided in the child’s native language; and are validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. 34 C.F.R. § 300.532 and Cal. Ed. Code § 56320.

In this case, the District provided STUDENT’s mother and grandmother a comprehensive list of the tests that would be used in assessing STUDENT. All tests that were to be administered to STUDENT were in English, his native language. The uncontradicted testimony of all of the District’s witnesses, including all of those who would be assessing him, was that the tests to be used would not discriminate on a racial, cultural, or sexual basis and that they were validated for the specific purpose for which they would be used. Since STUDENT is African-American, no intelligence tests were proposed to be used in the assessment.

It is concluded that the tests to be used by the District in assessing STUDENT were appropriate and complied with all of the provisions of special education law relating to assessment and testing materials.

4. Were the District’s proposed assessors appropriate?

California Education Code § 56322 provides that “the assessment shall be conducted by persons competent to perform the assessment, as determined by the school district....” At the beginning of the hearing, STUDENT’s mother and grandmother objected to two of the proposed assessors, Cheryl Sikes and Roberta Friedman. At the conclusion of the hearing, they were more willing to allow Roberta Friedman to assess STUDENT, but were still adamantly opposed to Cheryl Sikes. Their objection to Ms. Sikes and Ms. Friedman was not based upon the assessors’ lack competency to perform the assessments, but rather on past experiences that had led to the mother and grandmother’s feelings of mistrust and hostility. At the conclusion of the hearing, STUDENT’s mother and grandmother conceded that all of the proposed assessors, including Ms. Friedman and Ms. Sikes, were qualified to conduct the assessments.

The uncontradicted testimony of all of the witnesses called by the District firmly established that each of the proposed assessors was competent to perform the assessments that they were designated to perform. STUDENT’s mother and grandmother stated that they believed that those who have been providing services to STUDENT at the Cabrillo Elementary School would be better qualified to assess STUDENT. However, the law clearly leaves it to the discretion of the District as to whom they use in conducting the assessments, as long as the persons are competent to perform the assessment.

The District may use the persons it proposed to perform the assessments of STUDENT, including Ms. Friedman and Ms. Sikes.(Footnote 1)

5. Can those assessing STUDENT exclude his mother and grandmother from observing the assessment?

There is no express provision of the law which provides the parent or other relative the right to be present during the assessment of a disabled child. The guiding principle in determining whether they should be allowed to observe is the need to obtain accurate assessment results. If the presence of the parent or other relative would negatively affect the accuracy of the test results, the parent or other relative should not be allowed to observe the assessment.

In this case, STUDENT’s mother and grandmother have insisted on being present to observe all assessments of STUDENT. It was apparent during the hearing that the reason they wanted to be present was their deep love for STUDENT and their desire to protect him. Those proposed assessors who testified during the hearing had a variety of opinions concerning such observations. The school psychologist, Ms. Marianne Mitchell, did not object to the presence of STUDENT’s mother and grandmother during the assessment, unless his behavior were to change because of their presence. Ms. Sikes, on the other hand, was fairly certain that the presence of STUDENT’s mother and grandmother would negatively affect the outcome of the assessment.

It does not appear that a complete ban on having STUDENT’s mother and grandmother present during the assessment is warranted. It also would not be appropriate to say that they have the right to be present during all assessments, even if their presence would negatively impact the accuracy of the assessment results. It would be better to leave it to the judgement of each assessor to determine whether and under what conditions STUDENT’s mother and grandmother could observe the assessment.

6. Did the assessment plan proposed by the District include assessment in all areas of suspected disabilities?

Assessments and reassessments must be tailored to assess all areas related to the suspected disability. 34 C.F.R.§ 300.532 and Cal. Ed. Code § 56320.

During the hearing, STUDENT’s grandmother testified that she believed STUDENT was engaging in autistic-like behavior. She suggested that he should be assessed for autism. The District agreed to add an assessment of autism to its assessments of STUDENT. Therefore, to ensure that STUDENT is assessed in all areas of disability, an assessment of whether STUDENT has autism should be included in the assessment plan.

In summary, it is concluded that there is a need to assess STUDENT at this time in all of the areas set forth in the District’s assessment plan of October 16, 2001. The assessment plan was developed in the manner provided by law, the tests and other assessment instruments the District proposed to use were appropriate, and the proposed assessors were competent to conduct the assessment. It should be up to the individual assessors to determine whether STUDENT’s mother and grandmother will be allowed to observe the assessment, and the assessment plan should be amended to include an assessment to determine the presence of autism.

ORDER

1. The District is authorized to perform the assessments set out in their assessment plan dated October 16, 2001.

2. The District shall amend the assessment plan of October 16, 2001, to include an assessment to determine the presence of autism.

3. The individual assessors shall determine whether and under what circumstance STUDENT’s mother and/or grandmother may observe the assessments.

4. STUDENT’s mother and grandmother shall cooperate in facilitating these assessments.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: The District prevailed on all of the issues heard and decided. .

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of the receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

Dated February 1, 2002 Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnote 1: While the Hearing Officer has concluded that the District may use Ms. Sikes to perform the assessment of STUDENT, he would recommend that, because of the significant hostility towards Ms. Sikes by STUDENT’s mother and grandmother, it might be better to have that portion of the assessment performed by someone else.