California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 1, 2005
Fremont Unified School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 2866-04 · Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard
Fremont Unified may implement a student's IEP, but must first correct the document, which misrecorded agreed reading services.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted. Footnote 10 says the parties may agree on a compensatory remedy or the student may pursue relief in an independent action.
Summary
Fremont Unified School District filed for hearing to implement the June 15, 2004 IEP of a fifth grader with a specific learning disability. Her mother had withdrawn consent in September 2004, and the student had received no special education services since then. Both sides agreed that the offer made at the IEP meeting was a FAPE. The dispute was over what that offer actually was. After hearing testimony and listening to the meeting audiotapes, Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard found that the team agreed to one 90-minute pull-out each day. That pull-out would include the Language! Level 2 reading program for 60 minutes a day, five days a week, plus math and speech within a 450-minute weekly total. The written IEP recorded Language! as three days a week. With new staff in place, the District then offered only three days. The Hearing Officer held that this recording error cut agreed services by two hours a week and denied FAPE. She rejected the mother's other reasons for withdrawing consent. Using Level 1 instead of Level 2 during summer school had been agreed with the parent in writing. Speech and math services were offered on time, and a qualified teacher could provide the math. Assistive technology had only been agreed to be considered. The District was ordered to hold an IEP meeting within five school days to correct the offer and address current needs, and was then authorized to implement it. The mother's request for compensatory services was outside the hearing's scope and was not decided.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO treated an IEP document that did not match what the team actually agreed. The district carried the burden of writing the offer clearly. A recording error that reduced agreed services counted as a denial of FAPE, even though the offer made at the meeting was appropriate.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailed in partDistrict-filed: implement IEP
Issue 1. Did the District offer Student a FAPE at the June 15, 2004 IEP team meeting and may it implement that IEP despite the parent's revocation of consent?
The offer made at the meeting was a FAPE and the District may implement it. But the IEP document misrecorded the offer, which denied FAPE as to Language! services, so the IEP must be corrected first.
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue 1.1. Accuracy of IEP document: whether the services the District attempted to provide in September 2004 matched the offer agreed to on June 15, 2004 (Language! five days a week; speech included in the 450-minute total; single 90-minute pull-out)
The IEP wrongly recorded Language! as three days a week and left out the agreement to count speech within the 450 minutes. Offering three days cut agreed services by two hours a week and denied FAPE, both procedurally and substantively.
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue 1.2. 2004 Extended School Year: whether providing Level 1 rather than Level 2 Language! services during ESY denied FAPE
The deviation from the IEP was mutually agreed with the parent in writing, did not harm Student, and did not deny FAPE.
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue 1.3. 2004-2005 school year: timely implementation of speech-language and RSP math services by qualified personnel in a single coordinated pull-out
The District offered to start speech and math services within two weeks of the school year, which was timely. The IEP did not require Mr. Astafuroff rather than the qualified Ms. Ross to teach math.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1.4. Assistive technology devices and services: whether the District failed to timely provide them
The IEP only agreed to consider the devices. Student received them in October 2004, and part of the delay came from the parent's rejection of all services. FAPE was not denied.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within five school days of the decision, convene an IEP meeting to accurately record the June 15, 2004 offer: speech-language included within the 450 weekly minutes; RSP Language! Level 2 for 60 minutes a day, five days a week; RSP math 30 minutes, three days a week; speech-language 25 minutes, two days a week; all pull-out services in a single 90-minute pull-out each day. The team must also consider and address Student's current needs given that she has had no special education services this school year.
- Order that district's offer may be implemented. Subject to changes agreed at the ordered IEP meeting, the District may implement RSP Language! Level 2, RSP math, and speech-language services as outlined in Order 1. Language! Level 2 must be taught by Mr. Astafuroff or another resource specialist trained in Level 2; math must be taught by a qualified resource specialist teacher. The order refers to the 'June 15, 2005 IEP,' which likely means June 15, 2004.
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District; School Committee of Town of Burlington v. Department of Education; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. State of Missouri
People named in the decision
- Jack Bannon, director of special services; District representative and witness, Fremont Unified School District
- Sylvia Zante, speech pathologist and case manager, Fremont Unified School District
- Janet Ross, resource specialist teacher, Fremont Unified School District
- Charlene Okamoto, assistant director of special services, Fremont Unified School District
- Robert Perry Astafuroff, itinerant resource specialist; Language! and ESY teacher, Fremont Unified School District
- Linda Santillan, former principal, Mattos Elementary School, Fremont Unified School District (former)
- Leslie Miles, former program specialist, Fremont Unified School District (former)
- Marsha Barker, principal, Mattos Elementary School, Fremont Unified School District
- Beth Medberry, program specialist, Fremont Unified School District
- Mr. McLeod, fifth grade general education teacher, Mattos Elementary School
- Burns-Jepson, former director of special services, Fremont Unified School District (former)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter convened for hearing before Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Fremont, California, on January 18, 19, and 20, 2005. On January 21, 2005, the parties presented their oral closing arguments via telephone conference. Petitioner Fremont Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by its director of special services, Jack Bannon. Student (Student) was represented at the hearing by her mother, Student’s Mother. Also present on Student’s behalf on January 18, 2005, was her father, Student’s Father. The District called the following of its employees to testify: speech pathologist Sylvia Zante, resource specialist teacher Janet Ross, and assistant director of special services Charlene Okamoto. Student called as witnesses District itinerant resource specialist Robert Perry Astafuroff and her mother, Student’s Mother. Student also called as witnesses two former District employees: former principal of Mattos Elementary School, Linda Santillan, and former program specialist Leslie Miles. The Hearing Officer called director of special services Jack Bannon as a witness. Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following oral argument, the record remained open for the receipt of District Exhibit 11, official calendars for the 2003-2004 and the 2004-2005 school years requested by the Hearing Officer, and District Exhibit 12, copies of the audio tapes from the individualized education program (IEP) team meetings of May 21, and June 15, 2004, requested by the parties.
On January 31, 2005, the Hearing Officer received these exhibits. The record was then closed and the matter submitted for a decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
On the first day of the due process hearing, Student provided her statement of issues and proposed resolutions, documentary evidence, and list of witnesses to the District and to the Hearing Officer. Student’s statement of issues included issues outside the scope of those raised by the Petitioner/District. Specifically, Student sought to add issues relating to whether the District failed to comply with the terms of the June 5, 2003 settlement agreement reached in a previous due process case, whether the District had provided her with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003 extended school year (ESY) and/or the 2003-2004 school year, and whether the District had violated the uniform complaint procedure relating to the parent’s written allegations of discrimination by resource specialist teacher Janet Ross on March 18, 2004. The District objected to the addition of new issues in its case as well as to the timeliness of Student’s issue statement. Student requested that if these issues could not be considered in the District’s case, that the hearing be delayed to allow her an opportunity to file an independent action and to combine these issues for one hearing. The District objected to a continuance of its case to allow the parent an opportunity to file an independent action against it raising these issues.
The Hearing Officer determined that Student’s statement of issues was not timely filed as required by California Education Code section 56505(e)(6), and that there was no good cause to continue the District’s case to accommodate Student’s new issues. The Hearing Officer advised Student’s parents that the party requesting the due process hearing typically identifies the issues for hearing, that Student had a right to file an independent request for due process hearing regarding prior school years, and that enforcement of a previous settlement agreement was outside the scope of the Hearing Officer’s jurisdiction.
Student’s mother then asserted that she had not received notice of the District’s issue for hearing. The Hearing Officer treated this as a motion to continue. In its December 2, 2004 request for hearing, the District explained that it sought a hearing to implement the June 15, 2004 IEP that had been agreed to by the parties. The Hearing Officer asked Student’s Mother what her understanding of the District’s issue for hearing was and, in response, Student’s Mother stated that it was because she had refused to allow the District to implement the June 15, 2004 IEP. The Hearing Officer determined that Student had actual notice of the issue for hearing. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concluded that there was no good cause to continue the hearing on this basis.
ISSUE
Did the District offer Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) at the June 15, 2004 IEP team meeting and may it implement that IEP despite the parent’s revocation of consent?
CONTENTIONS
The District contends that it offered Student a FAPE at the June 15, 2004 IEP team meeting as evidenced by the fact that her mother, MOTHER, signed the IEP on that date and stipulated at the due process hearing that the June 15, 2004 IEP offered her a FAPE. The District asserts that it made every effort to implement this IEP, but that in September 2004, Student’s Mother thwarted its efforts to provide Student with special education services by refusing to allow the District to implement the agreed-upon services. In the District’s view, Student’s Mother revoked her consent to the IEP within one to two weeks of the start of the 2004-2005 school year, at a time when it was actively developing a schedule for providing the agreed-upon services. The District contends that, without these special education services, Student is experiencing difficulty in her general education classroom. In its view, Student requires the services it offered in the June 15, 2004 IEP in order to receive a FAPE. The District requests that the Hearing Officer issue an order authorizing it to implement the June 15, 2004 IEP and to convene an IEP team meeting to make any necessary revisions to that IEP in light of Student’s current needs, given the passage of time since she has received any special education services.
Student contends that while the District offered her a FAPE at the June 15, 2004 IEP team meeting, it subsequently failed to provide her with the services actually offered and agreed to at that IEP meeting. Specifically, Student asserts that the IEP team agreed that, during the 2004-2005 school year, she would be pulled out of her general education class once a day for ninety minutes, five days a week, to receive all offered speech and resource specialist (RSP) services and that the agreed-upon services consisted of sixty minutes of RSP Language! services five days a week, thirty minutes of RSP math services three days a week, and twenty-five minutes of speech and language services two days a week. Student asserts that in September 2004, the District advised her that she would be pulled out for her RSP Language! services three rather than five days a week and that it failed to timely implement other agreed-upon services. In addition, Student asserts that the District provided her with the Level 1 Language! program during the 2004 extended school year rather than the Level 2 Language! program outlined in the IEP, and that it failed to timely provide her with assistive technology devices. Student asserts that, due to these actions by the District, her parents had “probable cause” to refuse to allow the implementation of the IEP on approximately September 17, 2004, because it did not conform to the FAPE offered at the IEP meeting of June 15, 2004.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Student is a ten-year-old, fifth-grade student who is eligible for special education and related services based upon a specific learning disability. Student has been diagnosed with a central auditory processing deficit (CAPD) and with dyslexia. Student is currently attending fifth grade at the District’s Mattos Elementary School (Mattos). Because her mother verbally revoked her written consent to the June 15, 2004 individualized educational program (IEP) in September 2004, Student has not received any special education or related services during the 2004-2005 school year. In October 2004, Student’s Mother received a notice of Student’s potential failure in her general education class for the first trimester from her current teacher, Mr. McLeod.
On June 5, 2003, at the end of Student’s third grade school year, the parties entered into a settlement agreement relating to her educational placement and services for the 2000-2001, 2001-2002, and 2002-2003 school years. Pursuant to this agreement, Student was to receive the Fast ForWord program during the 2003 extended school year, and the Language! program during the 2003-2004 school year. In addition, Student was to be assessed by the District with the Woodcock Johnson III-Test of Achievement (WJ-III), the Test of Written Language (TOWL-III), and the Gray Oral Reading Tests (GORT-III) in June 2003, and reassessed with those same instruments in June 2004.
In her academic assessment summary report dated June 15, 2003, District resource specialist teacher Janet Ross summarized Student’s performance on the WJ-III. Student’s standard scores fell within the average range in basic reading skills, reading comprehension, basic math skills, math reasoning, basic writing skills, written expression and oral expression, and in the low-average range in listening comprehension. In these same areas, Student was below her 3.9 grade equivalent level (GE), except in written expression in which her performance was strongest (GE=4.9). Her relative weakness was in math fluency (GE=2.4). On the TOWL- III, Student scored at the 50th percentile in vocabulary, at the 25th percentile in spelling, and at the 16th percentile in style (mechanics). On the GORT-III, Student was asked to read a timed passage and was checked for reading rate, accuracy, and comprehension. She was functioning within the below-average range in reading rate, and the average range in accuracy and comprehension.
Student attended fourth grade at Mattos during the 2003-2004 school year. RSP teacher Janet Ross, who was also Student’s case manager, was trained in Level 1 of the Language! program, a highly structured and repetitive curriculum that requires students to master multiple strands necessary for literacy (e.g., phonemic concepts and awareness, phoneme-grapheme correspondence, word recognition/spelling, vocabulary). In late October 2003, Ms. Ross began to implement the Language! program to address Student’s needs in the areas of reading, spelling, language arts, and writing. In addition, Student continued to receive the Fast ForWord program she had begun during the 2003 extended school year, and she completed this program in April 2004. Student was frequently pulled out of her general education classes and she also stayed after school for an additional ten minutes a day to complete her Language! program. During this school year, conflict arose between Student’s Mother and Ms. Ross. As a consequence, speech pathologist Sylvia Zante was assigned take over as Student’s case manager.
On May 21, 2004, Student’s IEP team met for her triennial review. At Student’s Mother’ request, standardized testing was not conducted because Student had been formally tested the previous year and the settlement agreement specified that formal testing would be conducted in the summer of 2004. As a consequence, at this meeting the IEP team reviewed Student’s present levels of performance as gleaned from informal assessments and a review of prior testing data. The IEP team noted that Student’s specific learning disability affected her progress in general education activities due to her “weak auditory comprehension skills, weak visual perception, listening weakness, poor memory, and directional confusions” that required “explicit instruction, re-teaching using all modalities when possible, and constant review for concepts to be mastered.” Student was described as having received a “very modified” fourth grade curriculum, with her reading curriculum centered on the Language! program. Ms. Ross advised the IEP team that Student would complete the Level 1 Language! program, unit 18, within three weeks, thereby “reaching the 2.5 grade level according to the program.” (Footnote 1) In addition, the IEP team noted that Student lost her concentration during instruction and required prompts, and that her math curriculum was “greatly modified.” The IEP further team noted that “Student’s exposure to the 4th grade curriculum has been affected by her pull-out program.”
The May 21, 2004 IEP document outlined the following special education services for Student: (1) four hundred and fifty (450) minutes a week of resource specialist services, five days a week, and (2) fifty minutes a week of speech and language services, to be provided in two sessions of twenty-five minutes each. The IEP team offered to provide Student with Level 2 of the Language! program over the summer and for the fall. Specifically, for the fall 2004, the IEP stated that Student would receive “Lang! 90 mins. (60 mins. Language & math 30 minutes 3x/week (sic).” Goals and objectives were provided in communication for mild to moderate receptive and expressive language delays in semantics (vocabulary), auditory processing abilities, and articulation delays; in mathematics problem solving; and in self-management for improving focusing and independent work skills. In addition, the IEP team identified accommodations (teacher strategies) and modifications to the classroom to address Student’s needs.
On June 15, 2004, the IEP team again met to finalize Student’s triennial IEP. At this meeting, the team discussed having District itinerant resource specialist Robert Astafuroff provide both Language! and math RSP services to Student, but it did not specify him as a provider in the IEP. The IEP team reached nine separate agreements that were memorialized on a supplemental information sheet. Of particular note to this case, the IEP team agreed that (1) “for ESY 04 Student will receive Lang! Level 2 for first 2 hours and remainder two hours will receive remedial math,” (2) Student’s reading and writing goals would be prepared “at a later date by the RSP teacher who is providing Language! program Level 2 in the Fall,” (3) “Student will have one pullout for Lang! 90 minutes (60 min. Lang! & math 30 minutes 3x/wk (sic),” with the word “total” written below “90 minutes,” and (4) “consultation will be provided three times a year (1st, 2nd, & 3rd trimester) by a qualified Language! trainer.” The IEP team also agreed that Student would receive an assistive technology assessment, with consideration of the alpha smart, a word prediction program and the homework wiz. At the conclusion of this IEP meeting, Student’s Mother provided her written consent to the placement and services recommended at the IEP meeting.
Following the June 15, 2004 IEP, there was a change in District personnel familiar with Student’s case. Specifically, former director of special services Student Burns-Jepson left the District and was replaced by the District’s current director, Jack Bannon. Mattos Elementary School principal Linda Santillan and program specialist Leslie Miles, each of whom attended the June 15, 2004 IEP team meeting, also left the District and were replaced with new personnel.
On June 27, 2004, pursuant to the signed IEP, Student began attending an extended school year class at Wiebel Elementary School with three other students. The ESY class was taught by Mr. Astafuroff, who had just completed training at the District’s expense in Levels 1 through 3 of the Language! program. Mr. Astafuroff talked to Student’s Mother about providing Student additional Level 1 Language! services during the ESY rather than the Level 2 services specified in the IEP to ensure that she had a good foundation for Level 2 in the fall. With Student’s Mother’ consent, Mr. Astafuroff then provided Level 1 Language! services to Student for the nineteen-day ESY period which ended July 29, 2004. (Footnote 2)
On Wednesday, September 1, 2004, the 2004-2005 school year began. Following the September 6, 2004 Labor Day holiday, efforts were made by Student’s Mother as well as by Ms. Ross and Ms. Zante to contact Mr. Astafuroff to arrange a schedule for providing Language! and remedial math services to Student. Student was still on Ms. Ross’s caseload and Ms. Ross was also available to provide RSP math services to her. On September 8, 2004, Ms. Zante contacted Student’s Mother to inform her she was ready to begin Student’s speech and language services. Student’s Mother told Ms. Zante that she did not want Student pulled out of class for speech services until all services had been arranged to occur in one pull-out from her general education class five days a week as required by the June 15, 2004 IEP.
On September 9, 2004, Student’s Mother had a meeting with District assistant director of special services Charlene Okamoto, Mattos’s new principal Marsha Barker, and new program special Beth Medberry. The purpose of this meeting was to discuss how and when Student would receive the offered services. The evidence is in conflict regarding whether Student’s Mother told the District she was rescinding her consent to the IEP at that meeting. During this meeting, Student’s Mother signed an assessment plan for academic assessment of Student using the WJ-III, the TOWL-III, and the GORT-III, conditioned on the assessments being conducted outside of instructional hours and by resource staff not assigned to Mattos.
Following this meeting, Mr. Astafuroff attempted to arrange a schedule with Student’s Mother to implement Student’s services. He also attempted to secure a physical location for Student’s pull-out services at Mattos. Student’s Mother and Mr. Astafuroff had several conversations about how to schedule Student’s services. Due to his status as an itinerant RSP provider at three different school sites, Mr. Astafuroff discussed various options for providing services to Student in light of his schedule. According to Student’s Mother, Mr. Astafuroff told her he could provide services to Student only three days a week.
On approximately September 17, 2004, at the end of the second full week of school, Student’s Mother informed Mr. Astafuroff that she would not accept services because they were not being offered as agreed upon at the June 15, 2004 IEP team meeting. Following her decision to revoke consent to the implementation of the IEP, Student’s Mother had several telephone conversations with the District’s new director of special services, Jack Bannon. Ultimately, Student’s Mother asked Mr. Bannon to request a due process hearing to resolve the matter.
On December 2, 2004, following unsuccessful mediation, Mr. Bannon requested a due process hearing on the District’s behalf to seek to implement the IEP developed for Student on May 21, 2004 and June 15, 2004.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no cost to the parents, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s written individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8) (1997). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401 (25) (1997). The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). Education Code section 56363 (a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”
Under California law, “informed parental consent shall be obtained before the initial provision of special education and related services.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(a). In addition, “a pupil may not be required to participate in all or part of any special education program, unless the parent is first informed, in writing, of the facts that make participation in the program necessary or desirable, and of the contents of the individualized education program, and after this notice, consents, in writing, to all or part of the individualized education program. If the parent does not consent to all the components of the individualized education program, those components of the program to which the parent has consented shall be implemented so as not to delay providing instruction and services to the pupil.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(b); 34 Code of Fed. Regs. § 300.505(d). The “granting of consent is voluntary on the part of the parent or guardian and may be revoked at any time.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56021.1(c). If a parent revokes consent to an IEP, however, “that revocation is not retroactive” and does not negate an action that has occurred after the consent was given and before the consent was revoked. 34 Code of Fed. Regs. § 300.500 (b)(1)(iii)(B), Cal. Educ. Code § 56021.1(c). (Footnote 3)
A school district has an affirmative duty to offer and to provide a FAPE to all eligible students with disabilities who reside within its jurisdictional boundaries. If a parent does not consent to an IEP or, as in this case revokes consent to an IEP, and a district “determines that the part of the proposed special education program to which the parent does not consent is necessary to provide a free and appropriate public education to the pupil, a due process hearing shall be initiated....” Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(c).
In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S.C. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirement of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. Id. at 198 - 200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instructional and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201. The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 205.
To determine whether the District offered Student a FAPE at the June 15, 2004 IEP team meeting, the hearing officer must determine whether the procedural safeguards of the IDEA have been satisfied and whether the offer was substantively appropriate. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-207. To constitute a FAPE as required by the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s offer must meet the following substantive requirements: (1) have been designed to meet Student’s unique needs; (2) have been reasonably calculated to provide Student with some educational benefit; and (3) have comported with her IEP. (Footnote 4)
Student’s unique needs
In this case, there is no dispute regarding STUDENT's unique needs. Student’s unique needs were described by District RSP teacher Janet Ross, who testified that she worked with Student for three years, from the second through the fourth grades, and that she has assessed Student both formally and informally. Ms. Ross described Student’s deficits arising from her specific learning disability as including a wide range of processing deficits, including visual-motor integration difficulties, auditory processing, auditory memory delays, and language processing weaknesses. Ms. Ross testified that Student has been diagnosed with central auditory processing deficits (CAPD), that Student has difficulty in all areas of reading, writing, and math and requires special instruction in these areas. Further, as indicated in the testimony of District speech pathologist Sylvia Zante and in the May 21, 2004 and June 15, 2004 IEP documents, Student also has unique needs in the area of speech and language. Specifically, Student has mild to moderate receptive and expressive language delays in the area of semantics (vocabulary) and articulation delays for “th” sounds and requires speech and language therapy to address these delays.
Designed to meet her unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit
There also is no dispute that Student’s placement in the general education setting with the DIS services offered to her by the District -- in the form of the intensive Language! Level 2 program, remedial RSP math instruction, and speech and language services -- was designed to meet her unique needs and to provide her with some educational benefit. As previously indicated, MOTHER stipulated at the outset of the due process hearing that the offer made at June 15, 2004 IEP team meeting, as she understood it, was an offer of FAPE for Student at the time she signed the IEP.
Did the services provided comport with services agreed upon at the IEP?
1. Accuracy of IEP document
The central dispute, as discussed below, is whether the services the District actually provided to Student during the 2004 ESY and attempted to provide to her in September 2004 comported, or were consistent with, those it offered and agreed to provide her at the June 15, 2004 IEP team meeting. Student’s Mother testified that she understood the District’s offer to Student for the 2004-2005 school year to be as follows: Student would receive a total of 450 minutes of pull out services each week in a ninety-minute pull-out each day, with sixty (60) minutes of RSP Language! program services provided every day, five days a week, and the remaining thirty minutes a day of services divided between RSP math services three days a week, and speech and language services twice a week. According to Student’s Mother, at the June 15, 2004 IEP meeting, the IEP team agreed with her request that Student’s fifty minutes of weekly speech and language services would be part of, rather than in addition to, the 450 total minutes delineated as RSP services. It was this understanding of the District’s offer that Student’s Mother stipulated to as constituting a FAPE for Student. Student’s Mother also testified that in September 2004, District personnel told her that Student would only receive pull out RSP Language! services three days a week rather than five days a week agreed to by the IEP team, and that this was one of the primary reasons she revoked her consent to the IEP.
Student’s Mother’ testimony regarding her understanding of the offer made at the June 15, 2004 IEP team meeting was corroborated by the testimony of District speech pathologist and Student’s case manager Sylvia Zante, who had attended both IEP team meetings. Further, at Student’s request, the Hearing Officer reviewed the audiocassettes of these IEP team meetings. From that review, the Hearing Officer determined that the revised offer made by the IEP team on June 15, 2004 was consistent with the testimony of Student’s Mother and Ms. Zante and with Student’s Mother’ stipulation. (Footnote 5)
Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer of services actually made to Student by the IEP team on June 15, 2004, was for a total of 450 minutes of pull out services a week to be provided in a single ninety-minute pull out each day as follows: sixty minutes of RSP Language! Level 2 services five days a week, plus thirty minutes of RSP math services three days a week and twenty-five minutes of speech and language services two days a week.
The Hearing Officer finds that the combined fifteen-page May 21, 2004 (Part I) and June 15, 2004 (Part II) IEP document created confusion regarding the offer by failing to clearly and accurately record the special education and DIS services actually offered to Student at the June 15, 2004 IEP team meeting. A review of the combined IEP document reflects an offer that was not consistent with that actually made by the IEP team on June 15, 2004.
First, the Hearing Officer finds that the June 15, 2004 IEP document failed to accurately reflect the IEP team’s agreement to revise its May 21, 2004 offer by including speech and language services as part of, rather than in addition to, the 450 minute service total. The May 21, 2004 Part I IEP, under the section entitled “education programs and related services,” delineated the District’s initial offer to provide Student a total of five hundred (500) minutes of services a week, broken down to four hundred and fifty (450) minutes of RSP services a week, to be provided over five days, and an additional fifty (50) minutes a week of speech and language sessions, to be provided in two twenty-five (25) minute sessions. The IEP team’s agreement on June 15, 2004, to include speech and language as part of a total of 450 minutes of pull out services a week is not documented on the June 15, 2004 IEP supplemental information sheet contained on page 14 of 15 of the combined IEP, nor is this revised offer reflected on the “education programs and related services” section of the original May 21, 2004 IEP document.
Second, the Hearing Officer finds that the June 15, 2004 IEP erroneously documented that Student would be provided RSP Language! services only three days a week instead of the five days a week agreed to by the IEP team at both the May 21, 2004 and the June 15, 2004 IEP team meetings. The June 15, 2004 supplemental information sheet erroneously documented a reduction in Language! services by providing that the IEP “Team is in agreement that Student will have one pullout for Lang! 90 minutes (60 min. Lang! & math 30 minutes 3x/week (sic).” The word “total” is written under “90 minutes.” This error was exacerbated by an internal inconsistency regarding the frequency of RSP Language! services in the May 21, 2004 IEP. While the services section indicated that unspecified “RSP” services would be provided five days a week, elsewhere, the IEP indicated that, in the fall of 2004, Student would receive “Lang! 90 mins. (60 mins. for Language & math 30 minutes 3x week (sic).” Thus, the combined IEP document nowhere reflects that RSP Language! services were to be provided an hour a day, five days a week.
In making these findings, the Hearing Officer notes that there was a general agreement among the witnesses at hearing who had attended one or both of the IEP team meetings that the IEP was written in a confusing manner. For example, Ms. Zante testified that the June 15, 2004 IEP supplemental page should have documented the agreement of the IEP team that the Language! program would be provided five times a week, but, instead, it indicated that Language! and math services would be provided three times a week. A similar confusion was acknowledged by both Linda Santillan, Mattos’s former principal who attended both IEP team meetings, and Leslie Miles, Mattos’s former program specialist who attended the June 15, 2004 IEP team meeting. Ms. Santillan testified that the June 15, 2004 IEP document provided that Student would receive Language! for sixty minutes and math for thirty minutes, three times a week. Ms. Santillan further testified, however, that the IEP document was poorly written and that the IEP team had no intention of reducing Student’s Language! services from what they had been the prior school year; i.e., sixty minutes a day five days a week. Ms. Miles also testified that the IEP team had no intention of reducing Student’s RSP Language! service time. In this case, the inaccuracies and conflicts in the description of services to be provided that are contained in the combined May 21, 2004 and June 15, 2004 IEP document created significant confusion when the District attempted to implement the IEP in September 2004. This confusion was heightened due to the change in District personnel familiar with Student’s case and who had attended her June 15, 2004 IEP and their replacement with new staff. Student’s Mother testified that, in September 2004, both itinerant RSP teacher Mr. Astafuroff and director of special services Mr. Bannon told her that Student would only receive pull out RSP Language! services three days a week rather than five days a week agreed to by the IEP team. Student’s Mother later testified that, while she could not state with certainty that Mr. Bannon had told her this, Mr. Astafuroff told her he would only provide Language services three days a week. (Footnote 6) The Hearing Officer notes that, during his testimony, Mr. Astafuroff consistently expressed his inability to recall the rather recent details surrounding his efforts to implement the IEP in September 2004, suggesting his desire not to displease either party. Of significance, however, is Mr. Astafuroff’s testimony that he “may have” suggested that he provide Language! services to Student only three times a week in an effort to negotiate a workable schedule to implement the IEP. Mr. Astafuroff also testified that he would have, and was instructed to, implement the services specified in the IEP document. While this was presumably a reference to the five days a week of RSP services outlined in the services section of the May 21, 2004 IEP, the Hearing Officer has already found that the June 15, 2004 IEP team revised the offer made at the May 21, 2004 IEP team and then inaccurately recorded that Language! services were to be provided only three days a week. As a consequence, because the IEP failed to accurately record the frequency of Language! services as described, the Hearing Officer finds Student’s Mother’ testimony that only three days a week of Language! services were in fact offered to be implemented for Student in September 2004 to be entitled to great weight. For Student’s Mother, this apparent reduction in Language! services for Student not only conflicted with what had been agreed on at the IEP, but also directly conflicted with the Language! program’s three-level pacing system, each of which is designed to be completed in one academic year, as well as its exit criteria, pursuant to which Student could return to her general education language and reading curriculum if she completed Levels 1 and 2 by the end of the fifth grade. (Footnote 7) The Hearing Officer finds that this was an administrative error that nonetheless had the practical effect of reducing Student’s Language! services two-hour-week and causing Student’s Mother to revoke her consent to the implementation of the IEP.
The IEP is a written blueprint for the education of a student with a disability that must be capable of being read and understood by the professionals responsible for implementing agreed-upon services. Federal and State law underscore the need for a clearly written IEP offer. For example, both federal and State law define an IEP as a written document that must contain specific types of information, including “a statement of the special education and related services and supplementary aides and services to be provided to the child, or on behalf of the child,...” as well as “the anticipated frequency, location, and duration of those services and modifications;....” 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(iii) and (vi), Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(6), Cal. Code Regs. tit. v, 3051(a)(2). Moreover, the necessity for an IEP that can stand alone and be clearly understood is apparent from the legislative importance placed on the dissemination of this document. Once the IEP is completed and consent is obtained, the school district must maintain a copy of the IEP “at each schoolsite where the pupil is enrolled,” and provide a copy of the IEP to service providers from other agencies who provide instruction or a related service to the student offsite. In addition, the district “shall ensure that the regular teacher or teachers, the special education teacher or teachers, and other persons who provide special education, related services, or both ... have access to the pupil’s individualized education program, shall be knowledgeable of the content of the individualized education program, and shall be informed of his or her specific responsibilities related to implementing a pupil’s individualized education program and the specific accommodations, modifications and supports that shall be provided....” in accordance with the IEP. Cal. Educ. Code § 56347. In short, different teachers and service providers must be able to read the IEP and come to a similar understanding of what amount and type of services the IEP team has determined the student requires to receive a FAPE.
In this case, the District’s efforts to implement an IEP that did not accurately record the offer of services made and agreed to at the June 15, 2004 IEP team meeting resulted in a factual dispute between the parties about the exact nature of the services to be provided to Student. This dispute was exacerbated by changes in District staff who had participated in and/or were familiar with Student’s June 15, 2004 IEP. In addition, it resulted in a significant reduction in the services actually offered and agreed to by the parent. While the parent has responsibility to read and understand the IEP document to which she gives her consent, the ultimate burden of preparing an IEP document that accurately reflects the offer made and consented to rests with the District.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that, while the District offered Student a FAPE at the June 15, 2004 IEP team meeting, it failed to accurately record the frequency of offered Language! services on the IEP. The Hearing Officer further finds that the District’s failure to accurately record the offer in the June 15, 2004 IEP document denied Student educational opportunity by reducing the amount of her agreed upon Language! services by two hours a week. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District, 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992). As a consequence, the District’s error had both procedural and substantive dimensions and resulted in a denial of a FAPE to Student when it tried to implement those services in September 2004. (Footnote 8)
2. 2004 Extended School Year
In addition to the confusion over the frequency of Language! services, Student’s Mother testified that she revoked her consent to the IEP because the District failed to provide Level 2 Language! services during the 2004 extended school year in conformity with the IEP. The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not deny Student a FAPE by providing her with Level 1 Language! services during the 2004 ESY rather than the Level 2 Language! services written in the June 15, 2004 IEP.
It is undisputed that Mr. Astafuroff provided Student Level 1 Language! services during the 2004 ESY contrary to the IEP’s specification that she would receive Level 2 services. Nonetheless, the evidence persuasively established that the decision to provide Level 1 services during the ESY was based upon a mutual agreement between Mr. Astafuroff and Student’s Mother. Specifically, Mr. Astafuroff testified that he took this course of action only after discussing Student’s needs and progress in Level 1 with PARENT and reaching consensus to continue Level 1 services during the nineteen-day extended school year to ensure Student had a good foundation to begin Level 2 in the fall. Student’s Mother testified that she was just making the best of a difficult situation; however, her June 28, 2004 letter to Mr. Astafuroff objectively communicated her full consent to this change, when she wrote “I agree with you that reviewing areas not mastered makes sense to ensure program starts in fall with strong foundation.” (Resp. Ex. 16). Thus, while the services actually provided did not comport with the IEP, the Hearing Officer finds that Student was not prejudiced by this deviation from the IEP and that the District did not deny her a FAPE during the 2004 ESY on either procedural or substantive grounds.
3. 2004-2005 School Year: timely implementation by qualified personnel
Student’s Mother testified that another reason she revoked her consent to the implementation of the IEP was that the District failed to provide services in a timely manner with a single coordinated pull out and failed to provide Mr. Astafuroff for RSP math rather than Ms. Ross. While the parties disputed the date on which Student’s Mother initially refused to allowthe District to implement services, her own testimony established that she rescinded her consent to the implementation of all IEP services by September 17, 2004, only eleven school days after the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year.
The Hearing Officer finds this that the District did offer to timely implement both Student’s speech and language and her RSP math services in September 2004. Under both federal and State law, a local educational agency must have an IEP “in effect” at the beginning of each school year for each child with a disability in its jurisdiction. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(2)(A), Cal. Educ. Code § 56344(b). Federal regulations implementing this requirement specify that a public agency shall ensure that an IEP is “in effect before special education and related services are provided to an eligible child” and that the IEP “is implemented as soon as possible” following the IEP meeting. 34 Code of Fed. Regs. § 300.342(b).
Insight into the interpretation of the “in effect” requirement can be gleaned from the comments and discussion to the 1999 federal regulations implementing the IDEA. In response to the use of the term “as soon as possible” in section 300.342(b), some commenters “recommended that an outside timeline (e.g., 15 days following the IEP meetings...) be established for implementing IEPs.” In discussing these comments and the reasons for the language used in the regulations, the authors stated that it “would not be appropriate to add an outside timeline under § 300.342(b) for implementing IEPs, especially when there is not a specific statutory basis to do so.” They also acknowledged that there may be exceptions in certain situations where it “may be appropriate to have a short delay (e.g., (1) when the IEP meetings occur at the end of the school year or during the summer, and the IEP team determines that the child does not need special education and related services until the next school year begins; or (2) when there are circumstances that require a short delay in the provision of services (e.g., finding a qualified service provider, or making transportation arrangements for the child).” Vol. 64 Federal Register No. 48, p. 12579. (Footnote 9)
In this case, the weight of the evidence firmly established that the District promptly attempted to implement services for Student within two weeks of the start of the school year. Ms. Ross, Ms. Okamoto, Ms. Zante, Ms. Santillan each testified that it is unusual to provide services on the first day of the academic year and that it is more typical for services to begin one to two weeks after the start of the school year. Their testimony established the necessity for a short delay in implementing services to allow teachers, librarians, and computer staff to establish their schedules and for both the student and the teacher to have an opportunity to familiarize themselves with the classroom. RSP and other pull out services, such as speech therapy, would then be coordinated with the overarching schedule of the general education curriculum to avoid pull outs from core academic classes. Ms. Zante’s testimony that she offered to begin implementing Student’s speech and language services on September 8, 2004, was uncontradicted and clearly established that the District attempted to implement speech services in a timely manner. Similarly, Ms. Ross testified that Student remained on her caseload and that she was prepared to implement Student’s remedial math services. The Hearing Officer finds that the District was not in any way precluded from assigning Ms. Ross to provide Student the agreed- upon RSP math services. While the IEP team discussed the provision of both Language! and math RSP services by Mr. Astafuroff, nothing in the IEP limited the District to providing services by other qualified personnel. Moreover, it is undisputed that Ms. Ross is a highly qualified RSP teacher with years of familiarity with Student’s unique needs.
From the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was prepared to and did offer to implement Student’s speech and language and remedial math services in a timely manner by qualified personnel in September 2004. In addition, while the IEP team acknowledged Student’s need for a single pull-out, there is no reason to believe that this could not have been accomplished during regular school hours or as otherwise agreed upon by the IEP team. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not fail to offer or provide Student with speech and language and remedial math in September 2004.
4. Assistive Technology devices and services
Finally, Student’s Mother also testified that she revoked her consent because the District failed to timely provide Student with assistive technology devices and services. The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not deny Student a FAPE by failing to timely provide assistive technology services.
The June 15, 2004 IEP provided that an “augmentative communication form will be submitted to the district assistive technology specialist in order to determine what types of assistive technology devices will be needed to meet Student’s disabling needs. The team is in agreement based on reports from the Diagnostic assessment report dated 5/6 & 5/6/02 that assistive technology needs to be considered in order to facilitate both reading and writing. An alpha smart & word prediction program is suggested to meet her needs. The Homework Wiz plus is also suggested to help with her spelling, comprehension, and vocabulary.” While Student’s Mother testified that an agreement had been reached to provide Student with the Alpha Smart and word prediction program at an informal meeting, this was an agreement reached outside of the IEP team meeting. Moreover, the Hearing Officer finds Ms. Santillon’s testimony persuasive that an agreement to “consider” these devices and services was different from agreeing to provide them to her. Finally, the evidence established that Student received the devices in October 2004, and that the delay in providing them to Student was in part attributable to the parent’s rejection of all IEP services on September 17, 2004.
* * * In summary, the Hearing Officer has determined that while the District offered Student a FAPE at the June 15, 2004 IEP team meeting, it failed to accurately and clearly record crucial details on the IEP document, including the frequency of offered Language! program services. This error, while unintentional, resulted in widespread confusion regarding the exact nature of the services agreed upon at the June 15, 2004 IEP and was a primary factor in the parent’s decision to withdraw her consent to the implementation of the June 15, 2004 IEP in September 2004. The Hearing Officer has determined that, as a consequence, the District erroneously offered to implement the Language! program only three days a week, rather than the five days a week agreed upon by the parties at the June 15, 2004 IEP team meeting, and that it thereby denied Student a FAPE in respect to the provision of RSP Language! services. The Hearing Officer has further determined that the District did not fail to offer or provide Student a FAPE in either the 2004 extended school year regarding the provision of Language! services, or in September 2004 when it timely offered to begin providing her speech and language and RSP math services, or when it provided her assistive technology devices and services. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer will order the District to convene an IEP team meeting to correctly record its offer at the June 15, 2004 IEP team meeting, and to consider Student’s current educational needs and to amend the IEP accordingly. The Hearing Officer will also issue an order authorizing the District to implement the agreed upon Language! Level 2, speech and language, and remedial math services. (Footnote 10)
ORDER
1. Within five school days of the date of this Decision, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting to do the following:
a. accurately record its June 15, 2004 IEP offer of services to Student as follows:
(1) speech/language services are included within the 450 minutes weekly service total, (2) RSP Language! Level 2 services sixty minutes a day, five days a week, (3) RSP math services three days a week, thirty minutes a session, (4) speech/language services two days a week, twenty-five minutes a session, and (5) all pull out services to be provided in a single pull-out of ninety minutes a day.
b. consider and address Student’s current educational needs in light of her lack of special education and related services during the current school year;
2. Subject to any changes agreed to by the parties at the IEP team meeting convened in accordance with Order 1, the District is authorized to implement Student’s resource specialist program (RSP) Language! Level 2 services, RSP math services, and speech and language services in accordance with the offer made at the June 15, 2005 IEP as specifically outlined in Order 1. Language! Level 2 services are to be provided by Mr. Astafuroff or by another qualified resource specialist who has been trained in Language! Level 2 program. RSP math services shall be provided to Student by a qualified resource specialist teacher.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed in part and the Student prevailed in part on the issue heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety days of receipt of this Decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: March 1, 2005 ________________________________ Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. According to the June 2003 WJ-3, Student’s basic reading skills (word identification and word attack) were at the 3.1 grade equivalent, and her reading comprehension skills (passage comprehension and reading vocabulary) were at the 3.6 grade equivalent. Passage comprehension was her weakest area (GE=2.6).
2. The District arranged for Mr. Astafuroff and another resource teacher to be trained in the Language! program after Ms. Ross declined to be trained in Level 2. Student’s Mother asked that Ms. Ross not participate in the June 15, 2004 IEP team meeting.
3. AB 152 conformed state law to federal requirements in various areas and became effective July 16, 2004. Pursuant to that Act, Cal. Educ. Code section 56346 was amended by adding subsection (a). As a consequence, former subsection (a) is now subsection (b), and former subsection (b) is now subsection (c).
4. Another requirement, that the placement must be in the least restrictive environment, is not at issue.
5. District’s Exhibits 8 and 9 are transcripts of the May 21, and June 15, 2004 IEP team meetings that were prepared by Ms. Zante. As she acknowledged and the Hearing Officer confirmed on review, they are not verbatim transcripts.
6. After reviewing a personal calendar on which she kept notes of conversations with the District, Student’s Mother testified that she did not see specific reference to Mr. Bannon stating that Language! services would only be for three days a week. She further testified that, in her opinion, Mr. Bannon never understood the specifics of the offer made at the June 15, 2004 IEP team meeting. Mr. Bannon testified that he did not recall telling Student’s Mother that the Language! services would be for three days only and believed that she misunderstood his reference to RSP math services three days a week.
7. The Language! program provides that a student who has not completed Level 2 by the end of the fifth grade is not ready to return to the regular curriculum until she has completed Level 3, a delay of approximately one year.
8. In light of this conclusion, it is not necessary to address Student’s contention that the District did not timely secure a consultant for the Language! program. The Hearing Officer notes, however, that the IEP only required one consultation each trimester and that the District was actively seeking a consultant from another school district at the time Student rescinded her consent to all services.
9. The authors also noted that a question regarding a State’s compliance with the law could be raised where there is a “pattern or practice within a given State of not making services available within a reasonable period of time (e.g., within a week or two following the [IEP] meetings....” Id.
10. In her closing argument, Student’s Mother requested that the Hearing Officer order that Student be prospectively placed in a private school that provides the Language! program for the following school year (sixth grade) and that she be provided compensatory tutoring services to bring her back to grade level. Because this request was outside the scope of the issue raised by the District for hearing and no evidence was provided regarding compensatory education services, the Hearing Officer will not consider this request. It is well-established, however, that when a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. Of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997). Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have also extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See, e.g. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3rd Cir. 1990) 916 F. 2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.) In this case, the parties can agree upon an appropriate compensatory remedy or Student may pursue her right to relief in an independent action.
