California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 7, 1997
Long Beach Unified School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 289-97 · Hearing Officer Carin N. Crain
Long Beach Unified may keep student at Alton nonpublic school for 1997-98 after parent withdrew consent to IEP.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
Long Beach Unified School District requested a due process hearing after a mother withdrew her consent to her son's IEP. She said she did not understand it. The 17-year-old student qualified for special education with a specific learning disability in reading and written expression. Under a May 1996 IEP, he attended Alton School, a nonpublic school. He also received weekly counseling, transportation, and extended school year services, and he took an automotive class with nondisabled peers through the Regional Occupational Program. While the case was pending, he stayed at Alton under a stay put order. Neither the family nor its non-attorney advocate came to the hearing. The Hearing Officer had already denied the advocate's request to postpone, and the mother did not ask for a continuance on the hearing day, so the hearing went ahead without them.
The Hearing Officer split the issue into two school years. For 1996-97, Alton staff and district witnesses testified that the student received the services in his IEP. He met his vocabulary goal and a reading comprehension goal, got better at organizing his work and finishing it, and passed his classes. Under Rowley, that placement was appropriate. For 1997-98, the evidence showed that his needs had not changed and that he still needed small-group and one-to-one instruction. The Hearing Officer ordered the district to provide special education and related services at Alton School for 1997-98. The district also had to hold an annual IEP meeting within 21 days to update the IEP.
Why it matters
This case shows how SEHO handled a district's request to confirm a nonpublic school placement after a parent withdrew consent. The Hearing Officer went ahead when the family did not appear and applied a three-part Rowley review: whether the placement followed the IEP, met the student's needs, and gave him educational benefit. The order also required a prompt IEP meeting to update goals.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedDistrict-filed: implement IEP
Issue 1A. Is STUDENT's 1996-97 placement at the Alton School appropriate? (Sub-issue of: Does STUDENT's current placement at Alton School, a state-certified nonpublic school, continue to be an appropriate placement for the 1997-98 school year?)
The Alton School placement matched the IEP, met the student's unique needs, and gave him educational benefit under Rowley, so it was appropriate for 1996-97.
- District prevailedDistrict-filed: implement IEP
Issue 1B. Is placement at the Alton School during the 1997-98 school year appropriate for STUDENT?
The student's needs were essentially unchanged and he still needed small-group and individual instruction, so Alton School was appropriate for 1997-98 and his IEP goals should be updated.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Placement ordered. District ordered to provide special education, transportation, psychological counseling, extended school year and other necessary related services at Alton School for the 1997-98 school year.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 21 calendar days of receiving the decision, District to convene an annual IEP team meeting to update the student's current IEP.
Key authorities
Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982); 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16), (a)(18); Education Code section 56507(d)
People named in the decision
- Cynthia A. Yount, District attorney, Parker, Covert, & Childester
- Eloise Thompson, Director of special education student support services; District witness, Long Beach Unified School District
- Leslie Ronacher, Special education teacher, Alton School
- Wilbur I. Smith, School counselor (licensed Marriage, Family and Child Counselor), Alton School
- Carolyn McGrew, School director, Alton School
- Nancy Harris, Special education program facilitator, Long Beach Unified School District
- Alice Thompson, Individual small-group instruction (ISGI) itinerant teacher; provided Lindamood-Bell reading instruction, Long Beach Unified School District
- Maria Paco-Cortez, Spanish language interpreter
- R.A. Drew, Non-attorney advocate for Student and Parent
- Reyna Akers, Non-attorney advocate for Student
- Sally Hinton, State Department of Education staff, California Department of Education
- Team Advocates for Special Kids (TASK), Bilingual parent advocacy agency (referral)
- Alton School, Nonpublic school
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
Case Number: SN 289-97 Case Year: 1997 Petitioner: LONG BEACH UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT Issue: Placement CDS Code: 19-64725 District: Long Beach Unified Disability Type: Specific Learning Disability
Case Details This matter was heard on June 5, 1997, in Long Beach, California, before Carin N. Crain, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law.
Petitioner Long Beach Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Cynthia A. Yount of Parker, Covert, & Childester. Eloise Thompson, director of special education student support services, also appeared on behalf of Petitioner.
Respondent STUDENT did not appear and was not represented at the hearing. Spanish language interpreter Maria Paco-Cortez was present.
Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify: Leslie Ronacher, special education teacher, Alton School; Nancy Harris, District program facilitator in special education; Alice Thompson, district individual small-group instruction teacher (ISGIT); and Eloise Thompson.
No witnesses testified on behalf of STUDENT.
Oral and documentary evidence was received on June 5, 1997. The District presented its closing argument orally, the matter was submitted for decision, and the record was closed on June 5, 1997.
PROCEDURAL NOTE
By letter dated May 22, 1997, Respondent's nonattorney advocate, R.A. Drew, requested, among other things, a "recess of hearing pending investigation" because "PARENT is considering asking the Hearing Officer, Carin Crain, to step aside on the basis of Prejudice." By letter dated May 27, 1998, the District opposed Ms. Drew's request. On May 29, 1997, the Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office) issued a written order denying Ms. Drew's request because she did not establish good cause for a continuance. No additional requests for continuance of this hearing were made before the dates scheduled for hearing.
On June 5, 1997, the day of the hearing, the Hearing Officer attempted to reach Ms. Drew by telephone at 9:30 a.m., and again at 10:30 a.m.(Footnote 1) Unable to reach Ms. Drew at the number she provided, the Hearing Officer next telephoned the Hearing Office to ascertain whether either Respondent or Ms. Drew had requested another continuance or otherwise communicated with the Hearing Office. A clerk from the Hearing Office stated that neither STUDENT nor his representative had communicated with the Hearing Office.
Additionally, Ms. Thompson asked District staff whether Ms. Drew had communicated with the District regarding her intention to participate in this proceeding. Ms. Thompson said that on the previous day, Reyna Akers, who has also represented STUDENT in due process hearings, stated in a letter to Ms. Thompson that Ms. Drew was not available to participate in this matter. However, neither Ms. Drew nor anyone acting on STUDENT's behalf explained why Ms. Drew was unavailable or indicated that STUDENT planned to request a continuance.
The Hearing Officer the directed a clerk from the Hearing Office to telephone STUDENT's mother, PARENT. With the assistance of the Spanish language interpreter, Ms. PARENT informed the clerk that health reasons prevented her from attending the hearing and advised the clerk to contact Ms. Drew. (Footnote 2) However, Ms. PARENT did not request a continuance.
After waiting over an hour beyond the scheduled starting time, the District indicated that it wished to proceed with its case. The Hearing Officer concluded that the District, as Petitioner in this case, was entitled to prompt resolution of the issue presented, and that the parties were duly notified of the time, date, and place of the hearing on April 23, 1997. The Hearing Officer determined that the hearing would proceed as scheduled in the absence of the Respondent and/or his representative.
ISSUE(Footnote 3)
1. Does STUDENT's current placement at Alton School, a nonpublic certified by the state of California, continue to be an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1997-98 school year?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a seventeen-year-old high school student(Footnote 4) who lives with his parents within District boundaries. STUDENT qualifies for special education because of a severe discrepancy between intellectual ability and academic achievement in the areas of reading and written expression. (Footnote 5)
The PARENT family speaks both English and Spanish at home. Based on testing conducted in February 1994, the District considers STUDENT a student with limited English proficiency (LED) at the mastery level (LED level M). The District identifies Spanish as STUDENT's primary language. (Footnote 6)
STUDENT established his eligibility for special education in 1988 when he was in the second grade. From grades two through seven, STUDENT has been variously enrolled in the resource specialist program (RSP), special day class (SDC), and learning handicapped class (LH). (Footnote 7) Pursuant to parental request, STUDENT was withdrawn from special education and spent his eighth and ninth grade years in regular education programs.
With the consent of his parents and his nonattorney representative, Ms. Drew, STUDENT reentered the District's special education program in the tenth grade. Pursuant to the decision of STUDENT's individualized educational program team (IEP), STUDENT enrolled in the nonpublic Alton School for the 1996-97 school year. (Footnote 8) STUDENT's IEP indicates that he receive transportation to and from the Alton School and psychological counseling for one hour each week. STUDENT also attends daily automotive repair classes with his nondisabled peers. These classes are offered at a local high school through the Regional Occupational Program (ROP).
By letter dated March 12, 1997, PARENT, STUDENT's mother, withdrew her consent to the IEP that placed him at Alton school because she did not understand the IEP. (Footnote 9) On March 14, 1997, the District requested a due process hearing regarding STUDENT's placement. The District also requested a "stay put" order. STUDENT remains at Alton School pursuant to a stay put order granted on April 1, 1997.
By letter dated May 13(Footnote 10), 1997, Ms Yount informed Ms. Drew that the District was available, on a limited basis, to participate in the "mediated IEP conference" that Ms. Drew requested after canceling the "annual IEP review" that the Alton School scheduled. The parties did not convene an IEP meeting and this matter proceeded to hearing.
SUMMARY OF WITNESS TESTIMONY
Leslie Ronacher
Leslie Ronacher, STUDENT's special education teacher, has taught at Alton School since September 1996. Prior to joining the Alton School staff, Ms. Ronacher worked as a regular education teacher, a speech pathologist, and a RSP teacher.
STUDENT enrolled in Ms. Ronacher's class in September 1996. Two instructional aides assist Ms. Ronacher with STUDENT and the ten other students enrolled in the class.
According to Ms. Ronacher, STUDENT is proficient in English and receives all his instruction in English. Ms. Ronacher observes that STUDENT likes attending school, seems to be "in a good mood," and seldom misses a school day. Neither Ms. PARENT nor Ms. Drew has expressed dissatisfaction with STUDENT's program to Ms. Ronacher or suggested alternative placement for him.
Ms. Ronacher testified that she implements all five of the instructional goals and objectives listed on STUDENT's IEP. Ms. Ronacher stated that, based on the results of informal testing, STUDENT has met the first objective, i.e., "to improve his comprehension to 5.5 reading level in classroom and leisure situations 80% of the time." STUDENT accomplished this goal by reading silently and orally, and responding to reading comprehension questions.
STUDENT has been working to achieve the second objective, to "organize a school notebook by subject and keep track of assignments with 90% accuracy." Ms. Ronacher remarked that organization is "an area of weakness" for STUDENT but that his performance has improved. When STUDENT entered Ms. Ronacher's class, she estimated that he organized his notebook 30% of the time, but he now organizes it 70% of the time. STUDENT's ability to keep track of assignments has improved from 30% to 60%. Ms. Ronacher suggested that STUDENT continue to work toward this goal during the 1997-98 school year.
Ms. Ronacher testified that STUDENT has not met his third goal of improving study skills by completing "classroom and homework assignments and turn in to teacher ±85% of the time." Ms. Ronacher states that STUDENT will turn in classwork if he has the "support" of his teacher or aide. Moreover, STUDENT's rate of classwork completion has improved from approximately 50% to approximately 70%. Ms. Ronacher said that she does not assign homework because her students seldom complete it.
Ms. Ronacher stated that STUDENT has met the fifth goal of vocabulary improvement. Ms. Ronacher observed that each week STUDNT adds five new words that he wishes to learn to his "personal word list." STUDENT relies on the dictionary for the definitions of the words and then uses them in sentences and conversation. STUDENT gleans new vocabulary from such sources s the newspaper or his ROP class. Ms. Ronacher suggested that improvement of vocabulary should remain as one of STUDENT's goals.
Ms. Ronacher also testified that goal six, improvement of reading comprehension, should also remain as one of STUDENT's goals. Informal testing has revealed that STUDENT's reading comprehension has improved since the beginning of the year, but she stated that he can progress further still.
In Ms. Ronacher's view, STUDENT's academic achievement depends on the size of his class. She remarked that STUDENT accomplishes much more when he receives individualized attention or when placed in a setting that minimizes distractions. For example, Ms. Ronacher commented so that he can focus on his class work rather than his classmates.
Ms. Ronacher testified that THE Alton School is an appropriate placement for STUDENT because he ahs progressed academically. Ms. Ronacher offered that the two class periods of instruction that STUDENT receives through rop are academically challenging and nondisabled peers. Ms. Ronacher also stated that STUDENT requires the individualized and small-group instruction that the Alton School provides. Without staff support, Ms. Ronacher doubts that STUDENT would complete his assignments. Finally, Ms. Ronacher advised that STUDENT's IEP should be updated and should contain educational goals and objectives directed toward improvement of his achievement in mathematics.
Dr. Wilbur I. Smith
The Alton School has employed Dr. Wilbur I. Smith as a school counselor fro the past four years. Dr. Smith is a licensed Marriage, Family and Child Counselor who holds college teaching credentials in psychology and counseling, and community college teaching credentials in philosophy and religion.
STUDENT has attended weekly one-hour psychological counseling sessions with Dr. Smith since September 1996. Dr. Smith has also spoken with STUDENT's Alton School teachers, and observed STUDENT in class and on campus. However, Dr. Smith has not conducted a formal assessment of
STUDENT.
Over the course of the 1996-97 school year, Dr. Smith observed that STUDENT's "awareness of the need to mature" has increased. Dr. Smith stated that STUDENT now recognizes that as an adult he will need to earn an living, develop responsible relationships, and engage in appropriate behavior when conflicts arise. For example, Dr. Smith described events in which STUDENT avoided a conflict with gang members, protected weaker children, and defended his younger brother.
Dr. Smith characterized STUDENT as sociable, "astute, «wise compared to his peers" and possessing leadership skills. At the same time, Dr. smith noted that STUDENT sometimes lacks initiative and focus. For these reasons, Dr. Smith advised that STUDENT's 1997-98 IEP goals should include increasing his self-motivation, self-esteem, discipline, and decreasing his passivity and tendency to "sabotage" his own efforts. Dr. Smith also suggested that STUDENT's updated IEP contain goals and objectives that will "address concentration."
Dr. Smith stated that Alton School is an appropriate placement for STUDENT because it provides him with the one-to-one support that he requires. Dr. Smith predicted that STUDENT would "get lost" on a public school campus. Dr. Smith's opinion, STUDENT IS HAPPY AT Alton School and has developed appropriate relationships with staff and peers.
Dr. Smith also noted that STUDENT's attendance at counseling has been nearly 100% and recommended that STUDENT continue to receive one weekly counseling session per week during the 1997-98 school year.
Carolyn McGrew
Carolyn McGrew has been the director the Alton School since 1990. Before that, Ms. McGrew worked as a special education teacher. Ms. McGrew hold a both a learning handicapped and a clear teaching credential as well as a master's degree in educational administration.
Ms. McGrew descrbed the Alton School as a nonpublic school for students who need special education services provided in a small setting. The students who attend the Alton School are generally either learning handicapped or seriously emotionally disturbed. According to Ms. McGrew, to enroll at the Alton School, a student, his parent, and the schoolmust agree that it is an appropriate placement. Ms. McGrew recalled that STUDENT, Mrs. PARENT, and Alton School agreed that the Alton School would be an appropriate placement for STUDENT.
Ms. McGrew testified that neither STUDENT nor Mrs. PARENT complained to her about the STUDENT's placement at the Alton School. Ms. McGrew stated that she did not learn that Mrs. PARENT requested STUDENT be removed from the Alton School until April 24, 1997, (Footnote 11) when Sally Hinton from the State Department of Education telephoned her. During that conversation, Ms. McGrew responded to Ms. Hinton;s request for information about STUDENT's academic progress. Ms. McGrew also arranged a telephone conference that included Mrs. PARENT, STUDENT, STUDENT's nonattorney advocate Reyna Akers, a school secretary, and Ms. McGrew, during which the participants discussed Mrs. PARENT's satisfaction with STUDENT's placement at the Alton School. According to Ms. McGrew, Mrs. PARENT stated that she was pleased with STUDENT's placement and wished that he remain at the Alton School. Ms. Hinton then explained to Ms. PARENT how she might rescind her request to withdraw her consent to STUDENT's IEP. Ms. McGrew reported that Ms. PARENT has not rescinded her withdrawal of consent to STUDENT's IEP, but that STUDENT still attends school and participates in his classes.
In Ms. McGrew's opinion, STUDENT's current placement is appropriate. Ms. McGrew testified that STUDENT passed all of his fall 1996 classes and she expects him to pass all classes in which he is currently enrolled. STUDENT's highest grade is an "A" in physical education and his lowest is a "D" in his R.O.P. class. Ms. McGrew commented that STUDENT "needs to improve his work habits," but noted that his citizenship grades are good.
Ms. McGrew also further testified that the Alton School will be an appropriate placement for STUDENT during the 1997-98 school year because he continues to require the same level of individualized educational services. Ms. McGrew added that STUDENT should attend summer school in order to remedy his graduation credit deficiency.
Nancy Harris
The District has employed Nancy Harris as a special education program facilitator for the past ten years. Ms. Harris spent the previous twenty-three years as a teacher,
Ms. Harris worked with STUDENT when he was a student at Lakewood and Jordan High Schools but has had no contact with him since May 1996. Ms Harris recalled that she participated in the creation of STUDENT's IEP of May 16, 1996, which was later faxed to and approved by Ms. Drew.
According to Ms. Harris, STUDENT's IEP team relied upon his semester and quarter grades and reports from his teachers to determine his classroom performance. Ms. Harris also stated that STUDENT's IEP team did not conduct a formal educational assessment of STUDENT, but rather relied upon the academic data contained in his triennial assessment of October 1995. The IEP's goals and objectives were designed to address the issues raised in reports from STUDENT's teachers.
Ms. Harris explained that before STUDENT's IEP team created the IEP of May 16. 1996, he was not receiving special education services. After the creation of the IEP, STUDENT began receiving special education services in the form of individual and small-group instruction (ISGI) and Lindamood-Bell instruction for phonics. Referring to pages 8-11 of STUDENT's IEP, Ms. Harris also described the placement options that his IEP team discussed. Ms. Harris remembered that the team considered an SDC placement appropriate, but rejected it because STUDENT did not succeed in a previous placement.
STUDENT's latest English proficiency testing scores identify him as LEP, mastery level. Ms. Harris stated that STUDENT declined academic instruction in Spanish, and his IEP team agreed that it was not appropriate.
Alice Thompson
District ISGI itinerant teacher Alice Thompson has earned a master's degree in special education and holds an RSP certificate. Curing the 1995-96 school-year, Ms. Thompson provides STUDENT with reading instruction using Lindamood-Bell techniques. Ms. Thompson also checked with STUDENT's other teachers regarding his assignments and worked to improve his skills in mathematics.
By Ms. Thompson's estimation, STUDENT's reading comprehension was usually at the fourth grade level but sometimes rose to the sixth grade level. STUDENT did not improve to the degree that Ms. Thompson expected, and she suggested that his failure to read outside the classroom impeded his improvement. Moreover, Ms. Thompson attributed STUDENT's poor academic performance during the 1995- 96 school year to his failure to turn in his assignments.(Footnote 12) Ms. Thompson noted that STUDENT did not complete his assignments unless he received one-to-one support from his teacher. Ms. Thompson further testified that STUDENT requires small-group instruction to benefit from his educational program.
Eloise Thompson
The District's director of special education, Eloise Thompson, holds a bachelor's and master's degrees in communicative disorders and has worked as a speech and language specialist.
Ms. Thompson testified that STUDENT's current placement at the Alton School is appropriate for him. Ms. Thompson observed that the special education and related services (i.e., transportation, psychological counseling, and extended school year) provided pursuant to STUDENT's IEP have enabled him to complete his current course of study and earn passing grades. Ms. Thompson remarked that STUDENT's most recent report card indicates that he continues to need one-to-one and small-group instruction to benefit from his educational program. Ms. Thompson also stated that the District remains willing to fund STUDENT's nonpublic placement during the 1997-98 school year.
Ms. Thompson noted that Petitioner has neither expresed concerns about nor proposed alternatives to his current placement. Instead, Ms. Thompson understood that Mrs. PARENT withdrew her consent to STUDENT's IEP because she did not understand its contents. It was also Ms. Thompson's understanding that Ms. Drew, who represents Mrs. PARENT, received and approved of the May 16, 1996 IEP that authorized STUDENT's placement at the Alton School.(Footnote 13) Ms. Thompson added that the District translated STUDENT's IEP into Spanish so that Mrs. PARENT might better understand its contents.
DISCUSSION
1. Does STUDENT's current placement at Alton School, a nonpublic school certified by the state of California, continue to be an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1997-98 school year?
Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401 (a)(18), "free appropriate public education" (FAPE) means special education and related services that conform with sstudent' IEP. "Special education" is defined as guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child«20U.S.C. § 1401 (a)(16).
In Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982) the United states Supreme court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. Instead, the Court stated that "the µbasic floor of opportunity' provided by the [IDEA] consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the student. Rowley, supra, at p. 200. Although the Court declined to set any one standard for determining the adequacy of substantive educational benefit conferred upon a child, it noted that one important factor is whether the child advances from grade to grade. Rowley, supra, at pp. 203-204.
To determine whether the District has provided a FAPE, the Hearing Officer will consider the following questions: (1) does the special education and related services comply with those stated in STUDENT's IEP? (2) does the special education and related services meet STUDENT's unique educational needs? and (3) did STUDENT derive educational benefit from placement? With these standards in mind, the Hearing Officer will examine whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE during the 1996-97 school year and will then determine whether this same placement would be appropriate for the 1997-98 school year.
The Hearing Officer cannot determine whether STUDENT's placement at the Alton School "continues" to be appropriate without first determining whether it is currently appropriate. Therefore, for the sake of clarity, the Hearing Officer has divided the District's issue into sub-issues. The first addresses the 1996-97 school year and the second addresses the 1997-98 school year.
A. Is STUDENT's 1996-97 placement at the Alton School appropriate?
The first component of an appropriate placement is that it must conform to the student's IEP. STUDENT's IEP calls for him to receive special education in a nonpublic school. STUDENT's IEP also identifies his principal educational objectives as improvement of his reading comprehension and study skills, and calls for him to receive the related services of psychological counseling, transportation, and extended school year. Ms. Ronacher credibly testified that at the Alton school, she provides STUDENT with individual and small-group instruction to address his deficits in reading comprehension, vocabulary acquisition, and study skills. Ms. Ronacher added that STUDENT's participation in ROP enables him, to interact with his peers on a daily basis. Moreover, Dr. Smith testified that he provides the weekly psychological counseling sessions that STUDENT needs to improve his behavior and social skills. Ms. Thompson's undisputed testimony establishes that STUDENT currently receives transportation to the Alton School and receive extended school year services. The credible testimony of Ms. Ronacher, Dr. Smith and Ms. Thompson establishes that STUDENT receives the special education and related services stated on his IEP; therefore, because STUDENT's placement conforms to his IEP, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has satisfied the first requirement of an appropriate placement for the 1996-97 school year.
The Hearing Officer now turns to the second question: Have STUDENT's special education and related services been designed to meet his unique and individual education needs during the 1996-97 school year? The undisputed evidence establishes that STUDNET requires a structured educational program that addresses his educational deficiencies and his need to improve his study and social skills. Witness testimony also establishes that STUDENT requires the type of individual and small-group instruction that he receives in Ms. Ronacher's class.
To address STUDENT's need to improve his social skills, his IEP includes psychological counseling services. As noted above, STUDENT attends weekly psychological counseling sessions with Dr. Smith during which STUDENT works toward improving his behavior. The undisputed testimony regarding STUDENT's current placement establishes that placement in Ms. Ronacher's class and counseling from Dr. Smith address STUDENT's IEP goals and objectives and his need for psychological counseling. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT's current placement was designed to meet his unique and individual need during the 1996-97 school year.
The final requirement of an appropriate placement is that it must provide the student with educational benefit. Before STUDENT enrolled in the Alton School, STUDENT was earning failing grades in most of his academic classes. (Footnote 14) ISGI teacher Alice Thompson attributed STUDENT's poor academic performance during the 1995-96 school year to the lack of individual and small-group instruction that STUDENT received in public school.
In contrast, STUDENT derived educational benefit from his 1996-97 educational placement. Ms. Ronacher's testimony establishes that STUDENT has achieved his vocabulary improvement goal and one of his reading comprehension goals and made substantial progress toward achieving the other three educational objectives. Furthermore, Dr. Smith testified that STUDENT consistently attends his weekly psychological counseling appointments. Dr. Smith observed that over the school year, STUDENT has developed appropriate relationships with peers and teachers. He has also demonstrated increased maturity and willingness to accept responsibility for his actions. Moreover, Ms. McGrew testified that STUDENT passed all fall 1996 classes, is expected to pass all his spring 1997 classes, and has the opportunity to make up the graduation credits that he failed to earn when he was enrolled in public school. Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT derived educational benefit from his placement at the Alton School during the 1996-97 school year. Therefoe, because STUDENT's 1996-97 educational placement satisfied the three standards set forth in Rowley and the IDEA, the Hearing Officer finds that he was appropriately placed during that year.
B. Is placement at the Alton School during the 1997-98 school year appropriate for STUDENT?
In the foregoing section, the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT's placement during the 1996-97 school year was appropriate pursuant to the standards announced in federal statutory and decisional law. Moreover, the undisputed testimony of Ms. Ronacher, Dr. Smith, Ms. McGrew, and Ms. Thompson established that placement at the Alton School would be appropriate for STUDENT during the coming school year. The evidence establishes that STUDENT's unique and individual educational needs as identified in May 1996 remain essentially unchanged. In fact, Ms. Ronacher recommends that STUDENT continue to pursue the same type of instructional goals and objectives currently stated in his IEP. However, Ms. Ronacher advised that the goal and objectives should be updated to reflect the academic progress he ahs made.
Furthermore Dr. Smith, Ms. McGrew, and Ms. Thompson stated that STUDENT continues to require the small class size and individualized and small-group instruction that the Alton School provides. In fact, Dr. Smith recommended that STUDENT continue to receive psychological counseling and speculated that STUDENT would "get lost" at a public high school campus.
The evidence establishes that Alton School has provided STUDENT with educational benefit and will continue to meet STUDENT's educational needs. Therefore, in the absence of evidence to the contrary, the Hearing Officer fins that the Alton School will be appropriate for STUDENT during the 1997-98 school year.
ORDER
1. The District is ordered to provide STUDENT with special education, transportation, psychological counseling, extended school year and toher necessary related services, at Alton School for the 1997- 98 school year.
2. Within 21 calendar days of receiving this decision, the District is ordered to convene and annual IEP team meeting to update STUDENT's current IEP.
3. All other request for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding made in accordance with this requirement: Petitioner prevailed on the issue heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code section 56505(I).
DATED: July 7, 1997 ______________________________ Carin N. Crain Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnotes Footnote 1: Ms. Drew also represented STUDENT and his brother STUDENT2 in two other cases currently before the Hearing Office. Rather than representing her clients in person, Ms. Drew opted to appear by conference telephone. In this case, as in the others, Ms. Drew arranged her telephone appearance in advance. Footnote 2: At a previously scheduled hearing, Ms. Drew requested a continuance, citing, among other things, Ms. PARENT's elevated blood pressure. The Hearing Officer denied this request for a continuance because, despite repeated requests from the Hearing Officer, Ms. Drew produced no credible evidence establishing that Ms. PARENT has a medical condition that prevents her from participating in a due process hearing. Footnote 3: By letter dated May 29, 1997, the District withdrew one of its previously stated issues. Footnote 4: STUDENT should be an eleventh grader, but lacks sufficient course credits. Footnote 5: Petitioner's Exhibit (Pet. Ex.) 1, at p. 1. Footnote 6: Pet. Ex. 14, at p. 1. Footnote 7: Pet. Ex. 14, at p. 1. Footnote 8: Pet. Ex. 1, at p. 1. Footnote 9: Pet. Ex. 5. At this hearing, the interpreter orally translated Mrs. PARENT's letter dated March 12, 1997, from Spanish to English. Footnote 10: Pet. Ex. 10. Footnote 11: On May 2, 1997, Mrs. PARENT's nonattorney advocate, R.A. Drew, telephoned Ms. McGrew to inform her that Mrs. PARENT had given her copies of all documents addressed to Mrs. PARENT. Ms. McGrew also declared that Ms. PARENT was primarily Spanish speaking, learning disabled, and functionally illiterate. Footnote 12: Pet. Ex. 1, at p. 2. Footnote 13: Ms. Drew requested that the District provide legal representation for Mrs. PARENT. By letter dated November 25, 1996, Ms. Thompson referred her to the Team Advocates for Special Kids (TASK), which provides bilingual advocates who assist parents of children with disabilities. Footnote 14: Pet. Ex. 1, at p. 2.
