California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 3, 2005

Student v. Torrance Unified School District (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 2956-04 · Hearing Officer Van T. Vu

Torrance Unified must reimburse UCLA and BECA services and fund compensatory behavior services for ignoring a preschooler's behavior needs.

Split decision: student prevailed on 8 of 29 issues (6 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. The decision notes the right to appeal within ninety days.

Summary

Torrance Unified School District and the parents of a five-year-old kindergartner with autism each filed for hearing, and the cases were consolidated. The District asked to reassess the student without parental consent. The parents raised child find, assessment, and FAPE claims from March 2003 through 2004-2005. They also sought reimbursement for independent evaluations and private services.

The Hearing Officer found no child find violation. However, the District held the first IEP meeting about eight school days late after the mother's phone request for an assessment, and that delay denied FAPE. The March 2003 assessment was appropriate. But tantrums and transition problems kept interfering with the student's learning, so the District should have started a behavior assessment by May 28, 2003. From early October 2003 to October 7, 2004, his IEPs had no behavior goals and no positive behavioral interventions. That denied FAPE, even though his behavior did not meet the Hughes Bill threshold for a behavior intervention plan. The LAUNCH preschool special day class, the ASSIST services, the goals, and the kindergarten offer were otherwise appropriate. The District won all of the procedural claims for 2004-2005.

The District may reassess. Because the parents refused consent, the student had no right to FAPE after October 7, 2004. The District must reimburse the BECA behavior assessment, the UCLA program, and BECA services from September 18, 2004. It must also provide BECA home, aide, and supervision services through the 2005 extended school year.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO separated the Hughes Bill threshold for a behavior intervention plan from the lower duty to consider positive behavioral interventions when behavior impedes learning. It also shows a Hearing Officer allowing reassessment over the parents' objection and cutting off FAPE claims after they refused consent.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedChild find

    Issue I. Did the District fail to timely locate and identify Student as a child with autism under its child-find obligation from September 2002 through January 11, 2003, when it first started an assessment at his mother's request?

    The District, through its SELPA, did community outreach and had no notice or referral before the mother's December 2002 call, so it met its child-find duty.

  2. Student prevailed in partAssessment

    Issue II. Did the District appropriately assess Student in all areas of suspected disability from March 2003 to the present?

    The March 2003 assessment was appropriate, including pragmatics, articulation, and behavior at that time. But continuing behaviors that impeded learning required a behavior assessment starting May 28, 2003, and none was sought until September 16, 2004.

  3. Student prevailedAssessment

    Issue III.A.1. Failure to provide an assessment plan within 15 days of the parent's oral request and to hold a timely IEP meeting

    Staff did not help the mother put her mid-December 2002 oral request in writing. The initial IEP meeting was due by March 10, 2003, but was held March 20, which denied FAPE for eight school days.

  4. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPERecords

    Issue III.A.2. Failure to provide the parents a revised and signed copy of the March 20, 2003 assessment report

    The parents never received the revised report, which only corrected typos, but they had the original report, so there was no prejudice.

  5. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue III.A.3. Failure to provide the parents with information about the full continuum of services and placement options (2002-2003)

    No law requires a district to describe every possible program, and in any case the IEP record and teacher testimony showed that program options were discussed.

  6. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure

    Issue III.A.4. Amending the IEP in May 2003 outside the IEP process to add ASSIST services

    The ASSIST services were added by an addendum sent home for signature without a meeting. This was a violation, but the mother had been called, ASSIST had been discussed in March, and she consented, so there was no prejudice.

  7. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue III (fn. 11). Whether the District predetermined Student's placement and services

    Staff came with proposals, but the parents fully took part and approved the goals, so there was no predetermination.

  8. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue III.B.a. Whether the March 2003 IEP goals and objectives were measurable and addressed all areas of deficit, including transitions and ASSIST services

    The cuing terms were defined well enough, observation guided by the Carolina Curriculum was a valid way to measure progress, and no transition or ASSIST-specific goals were required in 2002-2003.

  9. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue III.B.b. Whether the March 2003 IEP was deficient for lacking behavioral interventions (behavior support plan)

    Assessment timelines meant the District did not have to finish a behavior assessment and address behavior until early October 2003, so no plan was required in 2002-2003.

  10. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue III.B.c. Whether the LAUNCH SDC placement and ASSIST discrete trial instruction were appropriate in the least restrictive environment, or whether Student needed general education preschool with a 1:1 behavioral aide and an intensive home ABA/DTT program

    The District witnesses who worked with Student at the time were credited over experts who first saw him in 2004. LAUNCH and ASSIST met his needs, and he made progress.

  11. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue IV.A.1. Failure to provide information on the full continuum of placement and service options (2003-2004)

    This was already resolved for the prior year, and the father had independently researched the District's options.

  12. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue IV.A.2. Failure to have a general education teacher participate in the March 2004 IEP meeting

    Student was in an SDC and no regular class was being considered for the rest of that year. Kindergarten placement was deferred to later meetings that a general education teacher attended.

  13. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPERecords

    Issue IV.A.3. Failure to provide all educational records within five days of the parents' June 2, 2004 written request

    Data sheets were not produced until September 27, 2004, and Ms. Reeves's test protocols were never produced. This was a violation, but it caused no prejudice.

  14. Student prevailed in partIEP content

    Issue IV.B.goals. Whether the 2003-2004 IEPs (March 2003 as amended, and March 2004) had measurable goals addressing all areas of deficit

    The goals were measurable, but the IEPs had no goals for behavior related to Student's transition difficulties, which impeded his learning.

  15. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue IV.B.behavior. Whether the 2003-2004 IEPs failed to include positive behavioral interventions such as a behavior support plan

    From early October 2003, Student's behaviors significantly impeded learning. Positive behavioral interventions were required under Ed. Code 56341.1(b)(1) even though the Hughes Bill threshold was not met, and none were provided, which denied FAPE.

  16. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue IV.B.placement. Whether the LAUNCH SDC placement, ASSIST, speech, and OT services were appropriate for 2003-2004 and ESY

    The placement and services were appropriate, and Student met most of his goals.

  17. Issue V. Is the District entitled to assess Student under its September 16, 2004 assessment plan?

    Conditions warranted academic, home-services, and functional analysis assessments after Student's private program and the reports of worsening behavior. The District need not rely only on private evaluations.

  18. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue VI.A.1. Failure to provide information on the full continuum of placement and service options (2004-2005)

    The parents already knew the kindergarten options and services, and the District discussed its BRIDGE in-home program.

  19. Issue VI.A.2. Failure to consider the parents' independent evaluations and input from private providers

    The IEP team reviewed the evaluations with the parents, BECA, and their advocate taking full part. Considering does not require adopting the recommendations.

  20. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue VI.A.3. Failure to identify by name the District staff who would provide aide services under the September 2004 IEP

    Union v. Smith does not require naming the specific aide. The offer clearly stated the placement and services.

  21. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue VI.A.4. Failure to provide prior written notice of refusal to reimburse privately procured services

    Prior written notice is not required for a refusal to reimburse private services.

  22. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue VI (fn. 19). Failure to timely file for due process when the parents refused consent to parts of the September 2004 IEP

    The District filed in December 2004 after informal efforts to resolve the dispute. This was at most a technical issue with no prejudice.

  23. Student prevailed in partIEP content

    Issue VI.B.1.behavior. Whether the 2004-2005 offer, through October 7, 2004, lacked behavior goals and positive behavioral interventions

    From the start of 2004-2005 through October 6/7, 2004, the lack of behavior goals and interventions denied FAPE. The goals were otherwise measurable.

  24. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue VI.B.1.services. Whether the ASSIST services, the Preppy Plus placement, and the September 2004 offer of a 1:1 District paraeducator (rather than a BECA-trained aide plus home program) were appropriate

    Judged on what the District knew as of June 2004, the ASSIST services and a District-trained level-two aide were appropriate. The District could assess before relying on new private information.

  25. District prevailedThreshold and jurisdiction

    Issue VI.B.1.c. Entitlement to FAPE from October 7, 2004, after the parents refused consent to reassessment

    Under Gregory K. and Andress, the parents' refusal to allow a warranted reassessment ended Student's entitlement to FAPE from October 7, 2004, until he is made available for assessment.

  26. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue VI.B.2. Did the District fail to implement the September 2004 IEP by not providing 60 minutes per week of classroom/playground OT?

    The classroom/playground OT was tied to the Preppy Plus class, which Student never attended, so the District had no obligation to provide it.

  27. Issue VII. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for the independent educational evaluations by Dr. Susan Schmidt-Lackner, Dr. Avazeh Chehrazi, and BECA?

    Only the BECA behavior assessment is reimbursable, because behavior was the only area the District failed to assess. The other two evaluations were not behavior assessments. The five-month delay in responding did not by itself require reimbursement.

  28. Issue VIII. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for privately procured services from the UCLA Early Childhood Partial Hospitalization Program and from BECA?

    The UCLA program and BECA services addressed Student's behavior and were reasonably calculated to provide benefit, so both are reimbursed. BECA is reimbursed only from September 18, 2004, because of the overlap with UCLA.

  29. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue IX. Is Student entitled to compensatory education?

    Based on Dr. Paparella's recommendation for a year of intensive behavioral intervention, BECA home, aide, and supervision services were awarded through the 2005 ESY. The requested prospective Preppy Plus placement was not ordered.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Reimburse the parents for the June 2004 BECA behavioral observation assessment (IEE) within ten calendar days of receiving proof of cost.
  • Reimbursement. Reimburse the parents for the UCLA Early Childhood Partial Hospitalization Program (July 1 through September 17, 2004) and for BECA services from September 18, 2004, through the date of the Decision, within ten calendar days of receiving proof of cost.
  • Compensatory education. District to provide, through BECA, 20 hours per week of home-based services and 15 hours per week of BECA aide services in Student's classroom, plus 20 hours per month of BECA supervision, from the date of the Decision through the end of the District's 2005 extended school year.
  • Order that district may assess without consent. The District may assess Student under its September 2004 assessment plan (academic/preacademic achievement, need for home-based services, and functional analysis assessment).
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. The District must hold an IEP meeting to review the assessment results and revise the IEP as needed within fifty calendar days of the Decision, excluding days between regular school sessions, terms, or school vacations of more than five schooldays.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range; Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm.; Gregory K. v. Longview; Clyde K. v. Puyallup; Adams v. State of Oregon; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Bend-Lapine School Dist. v. D.W.; Andress v. Cleveland ISD; Vander Malle v. Ambach; Burlington; Florence County v. Carter; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup; Alamo Heights ISD v. State Bd. of Educ.

People named in the decision

  • Brian Sciacca, attorney for District, Torrance Unified School District
  • Marcy Tiffany, attorney for Student
  • Steven Wyner, attorney for Student
  • Dona Wright, paralegal and educational advocate for Student
  • Jennifer Ralph, advocate for Student
  • Aaron Benton, director of special education, Torrance Unified School District
  • Shelly Chavez, program specialist, Torrance Unified School District
  • Sallie Reeves, school psychologist (initial assessor), Torrance Unified School District
  • Shaana Baluch, LAUNCH special day class teacher (initial assessor), Torrance Unified School District
  • Ann Gurlach, speech-language pathologist (initial assessor), Torrance Unified School District
  • Elaine Semple, school psychologist, Torrance Unified School District
  • Michelle Litton, speech-language pathologist (service provider), Torrance Unified School District
  • Susan Lee, school psychologist, Torrance Unified School District
  • Felicia Shanahan, ASSIST team teacher, Torrance Unified School District
  • Danielle Colin-Wirtz, ASSIST teacher, Torrance Unified School District
  • Stacy Pacheco, resource specialist program teacher, Torrance Unified School District
  • Melissa Matherly, speech-language pathologist (current provider), Torrance Unified School District
  • Victoria Estrada, principal of Sherry Continuation High School; former director of special education, Torrance Unified School District
  • Jessica Schilling, LAUNCH special day class teacher, Torrance Unified School District
  • Bobbie Wynhoff, administrative designee at April 2004 IEP meeting, Torrance Unified School District
  • Anita Winfrey, general education teacher at March 2004 IEP meeting, Torrance Unified School District
  • Avazeh Chehrazi, clinical psychologist, independent evaluator and expert witness for Student
  • Janet Yi, educational consultant, president and co-owner of BECA; behavior assessor and expert witness for Student, Behavior Education for Children with Autism (BECA)
  • Jason Baker, case supervisor, Behavior Education for Children with Autism (BECA)
  • Behavior Education for Children with Autism (BECA), certified nonpublic agency providing home-based ABA/DTT services
  • Tanya Paparella, program director, Early Childhood Partial Hospitalization Program; expert witness for Student, University of California, Los Angeles
  • Susan Schmidt-Lackner, assistant clinical professor, independent evaluator, UCLA School of Medicine
  • Pediatric Therapy Network, nonpublic agency providing occupational therapy
  • Starting Point, private preschool
  • Diana Browning Wright, compiler of behavior plan information (stricken Exhibit C)

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Torrance, California, on January 12-14 and 18-21, 2005.

Petitioner/Cross-Respondent Torrance Unified School District (District) was represented at hearing by attorney Brian Sciacca. Also present on the District’s behalf were Aaron Benton, director of special education, and Shelly Chavez, program specialist. Respondent/Cross-Petitioner STUDENT (STUDENT or Student) was represented by attorneys Marcy Tiffany and Steven Wyner. Also present on his behalf were his parents, PARENTS, paralegal and advocate Dona Wright, and advocate Jennifer Ralph.

The District called the following witnesses to testify: Sallie Reeves, school psychologist; Shaana Baluch, LAUNCH special day class (SDC) teacher; Ann Gurlach, speech and language pathologist; Elaine Semple, school psychologist; Michelle Litton, speech and language pathologist; Susan Lee, school psychologist; Felicia Shanahan, Austism Spectrum Services Inclusion Support Torrance (ASSIST) team teacher; Shelly Chavez, program specialist; Aaron Benton, director of special education; Stacy Pacheco, resource specialist program (RSP) teacher; Melissa Matherly, speech and language pathologist; Victoria Estrada, principal of Sherry Continuation High School; Danielle Colin-Wirtz, ASSIST teacher; and Jessica Schilling, LAUNCH teacher. The Student called the following witnesses: Avazeh Chehrazi, clinical psychologist; Janet Yi, educational consultant, president, and co-owner of Behavior Education for Children with Autism (BECA); Tanya Paparella, program director of the Early Childhood Partial Hospitalization Program at the University of California at Los Angeles; Ms. Schilling; and his parents.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Additionally, written closing arguments were received from the parties, the record was then closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES (Footnote 1)

I. Did the District fail to timely locate and identify STUDENT as a child with autism pursuant to its “child-find” obligation from September 2002 through January 11, 2003, when it first initiated an assessment of STUDENT at his mother’s request?

II. Did the District appropriately assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability from March 2003 to the present?

III. Did the District commit procedural violations and substantive failures that resulted in a denial of a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to STUDENT from March 20, 2003, through the end of the 2002-2003 school year and extended school year?

IV. Did the District commit procedural violations and substantive failures that resulted in a denial of a FAPE to STUDENT during the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year?

V. Is the District entitled to conduct an assessment of STUDENT pursuant to its September 16, 2004 assessment plan?

VI. Did the District commit procedural violations and substantive failures that resulted in a denial of a FAPE to STUDENT during the 2004-2005 school year and extended school year?

VII. Are the PARENTS entitled to reimbursement for the independent educational evaluations conducted by Dr. Susan Schmidt-Lackner, Dr. Avazeh Cherazi, and BECA?

VIII. Are the PARENTS entitled to reimbursement for privately procured services from the UCLA Early Childhood Partial Hospitalization Program and from BECA?

IX. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?

PROCEDURAL MATTER

On the last day of hearing, the parties agreed to a page limit of thirty-five pages for their closing briefs. While both parties limited the body of their briefs to thirty-five pages, the Student’s closing brief included three exhibits that, when the pages are counted with the body of the brief, made the Student’s submission well in excess of the page limit agreed to by the parties.

On February 14, 2005, the District submitted to the Hearing Office a motion to strike the Student’s exhibits as violative of the agreement between the parties to limit the closing briefs to thirty-five pages. The District also contends that the attached exhibits should be stricken as supplemental evidence that was not presented or offered at hearing. On the same date, the Student submitted an opposition to the District’s motion. According to the Student, the Exhibits A and B are demonstrative exhibits that summarize the evidence already contained within the record and are not presented as additional evidence. The Student also contends that if the font size of his brief and Exhibits A and B is reduced to 12 point font, which is the same font size used by the District, the total number of pages of those documents would total no more than 31 pages. The Student submitted a reformatted brief, including Exhibits A and B, to support his position. As for Exhibit C, which is information apparently compiled by Diana Browning Wright that is contained on the State Department of Education’s website, the Student asks that the document not be stricken and that the Hearing Officer take judicial notice of the information in that document.

As discussed above, upon the District’s request for page limits and the parties’ agreement to a page limit of thirty-five pages, the Hearing Officer ordered that the closing briefs would be limited to thirty-five pages. Despite the page limitation, the Student’s closing brief, when counted with its attached exhibits, exceeds thirty-five pages. Although the font size and formatting of the Student’s brief and attachments could be altered to fit the information within thirty-five pages, the documents submitted by the Student by the deadline set for the submission of closing briefs did not have such formatting. The Student was well aware of the page limits and could have submitted the documents with the proper formatting if he wanted that information considered, but he did not. The Hearing Officer also finds persuasive the District’s argument that exhibits A and B contain comparisons between the evidence in the record and are “argument” that should have been contained in the body of the closing brief. In light of the page limit imposed on the parties, and in the interest of fundamental fairness, the District’s motion to strike the Student’s attached exhibits is granted. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will only consider the Student’s thirty-five page brief.

Finally, the Hearing Officer declines to take judicial notice of the Student’s Exhibit C. There is no provision in special education law that provides for a hearing officer to take judicial notice. Although the formal rules of evidence do not apply in special education due process hearings, the Hearing Officer looks to the Evidence Code for guidance. See Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3082(b). According to California Evidence Code section 452, among the matters which may be judicially noticed are “facts and propositions that are of such common knowledge within the territorial jurisdiction of the court that they cannot reasonably be the subject of dispute” and “facts and propositions that are not reasonably subject to dispute and are capable of immediate and accurate determination by resort to sources of reasonably indisputable accuracy.” (Footnote 2) The Student’s Exhibit C does not contain facts that are appropriate subject matter for judicial notice. Rather, the document contains information regarding behavior plans that the Department of Education considers “best practices” in the school environment. By its very nature, the document contains information regarding opinions that can be disputed. Additionally, because Exhibit C is additional evidence that should have been presented five days prior to the hearing, the presentation of it at this late stage is inappropriate. Therefore, this exhibit is also stricken for these reasons.

In conclusion, the District’s motion to strike the Student’s attached exhibits to the closing brief is granted. The Hearing Officer will only consider the first thirty-five pages of the Student’s submission, namely the body of the closing brief. Additionally, the Student’s request for the Hearing Officer to take judicial notice of his Exhibit C is denied.

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The Student contends that the District failed to timely locate and identify him as a child with autism who is eligible for special education and related services. Specifically, the Student contends that the District should have initiated an assessment of him prior to January 11, 2003, when the District first acted upon his mother’s request for an assessment. The Student also asserts that the District failed to appropriately assess him from March 2003 through the present and that, from March 20, 2003, through the present, the District failed to comply with procedural and substantive requirements of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA).

From March 20, 2003, through the end of the 2002-2003 school year, the Student asserts that the District committed procedural violations by (1) failing to provide his parents with an assessment plan within fifteen days of the parent’s verbal request for assessment and failing to hold a timely individualized education program (IEP) meeting following the request for assessment, (2) failing to provide the PARENTS with a revised and signed copy of the assessment report dated March 20, 2003, (3) failing to provide the PARENTS with information regarding the full continuum of services and placement options, and (4) amending his IEP in May 2003 outside of the IEP process. Moreover, the Student asserts that from March 20, 2003, through the end of the 2003 extended school year, his IEP was not designed to meet his unique needs or reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit because: (1) it included goals and objectives that were not measurable and/or not sufficiently challenging, (2) it did not include goals and objectives to address all of his areas of deficit, (3) it did not include a behavioral intervention program and plan, and (4) it failed to include appropriate services and placement in the least restrictive environment.

For the 2003-2004 school year, the Student contends that the District committed the following procedural violations: (1) failing to provide the PARENTS information regarding the full continuum of placement and service options for him, (2) failing to have a general education teacher participate in the March 2004 IEP meeting, (3) failing to appropriately and timely respond to the PARENTS’ request for independent educational evaluations, and (4) failing to provide all of his educational records to the parents upon their written request. Additionally, the Student reasserts his prior contentions regarding the substantive inappropriateness of the District’s provided program and placement for the 2003-2004 school year.

For the 2004-2005 school year, the Student contends that the District committed the following procedural violations: (1) failing to provide the PARENTS with information regarding the full continuum of placement and services options for him, (2) failing to consider the independent educational evaluations obtained by the PARENTS, (3) failing to consider input from his private service providers, (4) failing to identify the name of the District personnel who would provide aide services to him pursuant to the September 2004 IEP, (5) failing to provide prior written notice of the District’s refusal to reimburse the PARENTS for the cost of privately procured services, and (6) failing to initiate a due process hearing when the PARENTS refused consent for the District’s offered IEP. Again, the Student reasserts his prior contentions regarding the substantive inappropriateness of the District’s provided program and placement for the 2004-2005 school year. Moreover, the Student also contends that the District failed to provide services that comported with his September 2004 IEP because it failed to provide him with direct occupational therapy services for sixty minutes per week.

To remedy all of these alleged denials, the Student requests reimbursement for the independent educational evaluations performed by Dr. Susan Schmidt-Lackner, Dr. Avazeh Cherazi, and BECA. Additionally, the Student requests reimbursement for the privately procured services from the UCLA Early Childhood Partial Hospitalization Program and from BECA. Moreover, the Student requests compensatory direct occupational therapy services at a rate and frequency of sixty minutes per week to remedy the District’s failure to provide any of those services as agreed upon in the September 2004 IEP. Furthermore, the Student requests prospective placement in the District’s “Preppy Plus” regular education kindergarten class with aide services provided by BECA. Additionally, the Student requests home-based discrete trial training services provided by BECA, a certified nonpublic agency, with the associated consultation services. According to the Student, this requested prospective placement and services would meet his needs for the 2004-2005 school year and extended school year, and would incorporate any necessary compensatory education services he would have required from the past denials of FAPE. The Student requests these placement and services through the end of the 2004-2005 school year. Finally, the Student requests that the District be denied permission to assess him.

The District contends that it complied with its child-find obligations as they pertained to STUDENT. Additionally, the District contends that it fully and appropriately assessed STUDENT and that it complied with all procedural requirements. Moreover, the District contends that from March 20, 2003, through the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year, it offered and/or provided STUDENT a free appropriate public education. The District also contends that, due to new information it was provided by STUDENT’s private assessors and service providers, conditions currently warrant additional assessments to determine STUDENT’s present levels of performance and to determine STUDENT’s placement and services for the 2004-2005 school year. Because the District asserts that it complied with all procedural and substantive requirements, it requests that all of the Student’s requests for remedies be denied.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a five-year-old kindergarten student who is eligible for special education and related services as a child with autism. At all times relevant to this proceeding, STUDENT and his family have resided within the District boundaries. STUDENT is currently receiving home-based behavior intervention services from Behavior Education for Children with Autism, a certified nonpublic agency, and the services are funded by his parents. Additionally, STUDENT receives speech and language therapy and occupational therapy through the District.

In September 2002, approximately two months before STUDENT turned three years old, STUDENT’s parents enrolled him at Starting Point, a private preschool that serves typically developing children. According to STUDENT’s parents, STUDENT was not using oral language to communicate during this time and he exhibited behaviors, such as tantrumming and difficulty with transitions. At the recommendation of STUDENT’s pediatrician, the PARENTS took STUDENT to have his hearing tested. When STUDENT’s hearing was found to be normal, his parents were told to go to the local school district once STUDENT turned three years old to have him assessed.

On November 9, 2002, STUDENT turned three years old. Sometime in mid-December 2002, MOTHER called Arlington Elementary School, STUDENT’s home school within the District, to request a speech and language assessment for STUDENT. (Footnote 3) According to MOTHER, the District staff told her that the assessments were conducted by staff from the District’s LAUNCH program and that someone from the District would call her back regarding the assessment. After failing to receive a response from the District, MOTHER called the District on January 11, 2003, to again request a speech and language assessment for STUDENT. At that time, MOTHER spoke with Michelle Litton, a District speech and language pathologist, who scheduled an appointment for MOTHER to come to the District with STUDENT on January 29, 2003, to discuss the assessment.

At the meeting on January 29, Ms. Litton presented MOTHER with an assessment plan requesting permission for the District to assess STUDENT’s language and communication needs. MOTHER signed consent to the assessment plan during the meeting, and Ms. Litton attempted to assess STUDENT that same day. However, according to Ms. Litton, STUDENT was unable to sit for an extended period of time or to “understand contingency,” and she was unable to get information from that assessment. Ms. Litton also testified that she knew within fifteen minutes of beginning the assessment that STUDENT had more extensive educational needs that would require a more comprehensive assessment than just in the area of speech and language.

Apparently, at Ms. Litton’s recommendation, staff from the District contacted MOTHER again in February 2003 to schedule another meeting at the District regarding STUDENT’s assessments. At that meeting, which was held on March 6, 2003, the District presented to MOTHER another assessment plan that included as areas to be assessed academic/preacademic achievement, social and emotional development, motor ability, language/speech/communication, general ability, and health and development. Again, MOTHER signed consent to the assessment plan at the meeting and the District began its assessment later that day. This time, the assessment was conducted by speech and language pathologist Ann Gurlach, school psychologist Sallie Reeves, and special day class (SDC) teacher Shaana Baluch. Ms. Reeves and Ms. Baluch also observed STUDENT during preschool at Starting Point as part of their assessment.

The District’s assessment, which was conducted when STUDENT was thirty-nine months old, indicates that STUDENT exhibited autistic-like behaviors and uneven development and scattered skills ranging from “some more age appropriate” skills to significant and/or moderate delays. STUDENT’s “more age appropriate” skills were in the areas of nonverbal cognitive development, pre-academics, self-help skills, nonverbal cognitive development, fine and gross motor skills, and play and social skills. In contrast, STUDENT “exhibit[ed] an inability to use oral language for appropriate communication, [an] impairment in social interaction, a preoccupation with objects and repetitive play with objects, and limited eye contact.” (Footnote 4)

Following completion of the District’s assessment, STUDENT’s IEP team convened on March 20, 2003, to review the assessments and to determine his eligibility for special education services. At the meeting, the PARENTS learned for the first time that their son was autistic, which greatly upset them. According to the notes of the IEP, the District members of the IEP team “described the ‘autism spectrum’ to the parents and discussed different disorders on the spectrum.” Ultimately, the team agreed that STUDENT was eligible for special education services and agreed on fifteen proposed goals and objectives in the areas of language, preacademics, social/emotional development, and motor abilities. The team also agreed that STUDENT should be placed in the LAUNCH preschool SDC classroom for two hundred minutes per day with forty-five minutes per week of speech and language services. The IEP notes also state that a teacher from the District’s ASSIST program, a program that provides inclusion support for autistic and other disabled children, would consult with STUDENT’s teacher about the possible need for ASSIST services.

At the beginning of April 2003, STUDENT began to attend class in Jessica Schilling’s special day class at LAUNCH. Additionally, Michelle Litton began to provide STUDENT with speech and language services. Also during this time, STUDENT continued to attend his private preschool placement at Starting Point at his parents’ expense. Towards the end of May 2003, Ms. Schilling called MOTHER and discussed the need to add ASSIST services to STUDENT’s IEP. Ms. Schilling then sent home an IEP addendum form that included the addition of ASSIST services to STUDENT’s educational program, including forty minutes per week of discrete trial instruction, forty minutes per week of facilitated play, and fifteen minutes twice per month of small-group instruction. MOTHER signed the IEP addendum and the ASSIST services started shortly thereafter.

During the spring of 2003, STUDENT exhibited at LAUNCH, during speech and language therapy, and at Starting Point behaviors such as tantrumming, difficulty with transitions, and aggression. Specifically, STUDENT would protest to activities by saying “No!”, would climb under the table, and would hit and kick peers and adults. MOTHER testified that STUDENT exhibited the same behaviors at home and that STUDENT also had difficulty getting on the bus to go to and from school.

On May 28, 2003, Ms. Schilling made a referral to the District to assess STUDENT’s sensory processing and fine motor abilities. The District, on June 4, 2003, then sought and received MOTHER’s consent to have a District occupational therapist assess STUDENT. One week later, Ms. Schilling filled out a “Staff Request for Services” form in which she described STUDENT’s behaviors as noted above. Believing that the behaviors were due to sensory deficits, Ms. Schilling indicated that she supported the addition of occupational therapy services.

In the meantime, following the end of the 2002-2003 regular school year, STUDENT attended extended school year services at LAUNCH during the summer of 2003.

In July 2003, the District conducted an occupational therapy (OT) assessment of STUDENT and determined that he was eligible for OT services to address his sensory processing deficit and weaknesses in organization of behavior, fine motor abilities, and visual motor skills. STUDENT’s IEP team convened on September 26, 2003, to discuss the OT assessment. At the meeting, the team agreed that STUDENT required sixty minutes per week of clinic-based OT, one hour per month of individual therapy in a therapy room, one hour per month of group therapy on the playground, and thirty minutes per month of small-group therapy in the classroom. STUDENT’s occupational therapy services began shortly thereafter and were provided by Pediatric Therapy Network, a nonpublic agency.

For the 2003-2004 regular school year, STUDENT remained in Ms. Schilling’s classroom and received all of the services per his March 2003 IEP, as amended by the addendums from May and September 2003. According to MOTHER, STUDENT’s problems getting on the bus continued. By January 2004, the PARENTS discontinued the District’s bus services due to STUDENT’s behaviors and began taking STUDENT to school themselves.

On March 12, 2004, STUDENT’s IEP team convened for his annual review. At that meeting, STUDENT’s teacher and service providers reported on his progress during the prior year and discussed with the team their revised goals and objectives. The District recommended the continuation of STUDENT’s placement and services through the end of the 2004 extended school year, with the placement and services for the 2004-2005 school year to be determined at STUDENT’s kindergarten transition meeting in April 2004. FATHER signed the IEP and consented to the proposed goals and objectives, placement, and services.

Also during March 2004, the PARENTS visited many of the District’s kindergarten classes in preparation for the transition IEP meeting. Among the classes they visited were the District’s kindergarten SDC and the “Preppy Plus Plus” class, which is another SDC located on a preschool campus. Although the PARENTS requested to visit a third class (i.e., the District’s “Preppy Plus” class), they were unable to schedule the visit with the District. The Preppy Plus class, unlike the Preppy Plus Plus class, is a regular education kindergarten class on an elementary school campus that utilizes the regular education curriculum but has the support of a resource specialist program (RSP) teacher.

On April 26, 2004, STUDENT’s IEP team met again to discuss his transition to kindergarten. For the 2004-2005 school year, the District recommended changing STUDENT’s speech and language services to one hour per week of small group therapy, his occupational therapy services to one hour per week of OT in the clinic and one hour per week of OT in the classroom, forty minutes per week each of academic and social instruction by the ASSIST team, and forty-five minutes per week of additional ASSIST services in the “lunch group.” When discussing STUDENT’s placement, FATHER requested that STUDENT be placed in the Preppy Plus Plus SDC because he wanted a placement for STUDENT that had a low student-to-teacher ratio and that could prepare him for placement in the regular education environment. At the time, FATHER also wanted STUDENT to have the support of a special education teacher and he believed that the District’s regular education kindergarten class (i.e., the Preppy Plus class) was not appropriate for STUDENT. However, the District’s administrative designee at the meeting, Bobbie Wynhoff, informed FATHER that the Preppy Plus Plus class was not available. Apparently to address FATHER’s desire for a more restrictive environment, she instead offered STUDENT a placement in the District’s other SDC. Having already visited that SDC, the PARENTS disagreed with the placement offer because the students appeared to them to be lower functioning than STUDENT. To support the PARENTS, Ms. Schilling and STUDENT’s ASSIST teacher, Danielle Colin-Wirtz, both also dissented to the placement offer. To resolve the disagreement over the placement offer, FATHER requested an “administrative review” of the IEP. An administrative review is a process available within the District that allows parents to have the District’s offer reviewed by a different IEP administrator.

The administrative review was held on June 3, 2004, in the context of another IEP meeting. The PARENTS appeared with an educational advocate named Dona Wright. Additionally, the District’s administrator at the IEP meeting was the District’s then special education director, Victoria Estrada. Upon discussing the PARENTS’ goal of preparing STUDENT for a regular education kindergarten placement, the team agreed that STUDENT would be best placed in the Preppy Plus regular education kindergarten class because the regular education curriculum is used in that class and the class has the support of an RSP teacher. Although FATHER was in agreement with the Preppy Plus class placement, he was bothered that the District changed its recommendation so dramatically from the restrictive SDC to the less restrictive regular education Preppy Plus class. Thus, although the PARENTS consented to the placement in the Preppy Plus class with the services outlined in the April 2004 IEP, they did so pending the results of independent educational evaluations (IEE) that the PARENTS intended to obtain. Hearing about the request for IEEs for the first time, the District agreed to respond to the PARENTS after the IEP meeting with a “list of providers and the circumstances for reimbursement.”

On June 10, the District sent the PARENTS a letter requesting information regarding the request for IEEs, including (1) what areas the PARENTS believed the District failed to assess STUDENT, (2) which results of the District’s assessment PARENTS disagreed, and (3) what areas already assessed by the District required further assessment. On June 21, the PARENTS’ attorney, Steven Wyner, wrote the District a letter stating that the PARENTS wanted the IEEs because they “did not trust or agree with the District’s prior assessments.” Mr. Wyner also stated that the District may not impose conditions or time lines on the parents’ request for IEEs, and he declined to provide any of the information requested by the District. (Footnote 5) Additionally, Mr. Wyner notified the District that the PARENTS had consulted with Dr. Susan Schmidt-Lackner, an assistant clinical professor at the UCLA School of Medicine, who recommended that STUDENT be placed at the UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute Early Childhood Partial Hospitalization Program. Moreover, he informed the District that the PARENTS intended to obtain independent evaluations from BECA and clinical psychologist Dr. Avazeh Chehrazi during the latter part of June.

In the meantime, following the end of the 2003-2004 regular school year, STUDENT began attending the District’s extended school year program. After STUDENT attended the ESY program for approximately one week, the PARENTS were informed by the UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute that a spot had opened up for STUDENT and he could be immediately placed there. In response, the PARENTS withdrew STUDENT from school at the end of June and placed him at UCLA, where he attended six hours per day for six weeks at his parents’ expense.

By letter dated August 17, 2004, Mr. Wyner informed the District that STUDENT was attending the UCLA program, that the assessments by BECA and Dr. Chehrazi had been conducted as scheduled, and that the PARENTS would be seeking reimbursement for those assessments. Mr. Wyner also informed the District that the PARENTS intended to follow the recommendations of the private assessors and UCLA to transition STUDENT to a discrete trial training (DTT) program provided by BECA and that the PARENTS would also be seeking reimbursement for that program. Additionally, Mr. Wyner invited the District to attend a conference held by UCLA at the end of STUDENT’s placement in the Early Childhood Partial Hospitalization Program. Shortly thereafter, BECA began providing home-based DTT services to STUDENT at his parents’ expense.

Among those in attendance at the UCLA meeting on September 8 were the District’s new director of special education, Aaron Benton; the District’s program specialist, Shelly Chavez; and a District school psychologist, Elaine Semple. At that meeting, all of the persons who had worked with STUDENT at UCLA reviewed his or her portion of the assessment and they discussed the progress STUDENT had made in that program. Among the recommendations made by the UCLA team was a recommendation that a “functional assessment” be conducted to evaluate STUDENT’s behaviors.

The following week, on September 16, STUDENT’s IEP team convened to discuss the independent evaluations and to review STUDENT’s placement and program for the 2004-2005 school year. Relying on the recommendations of the private assessors and providers, the PARENTS requested at the meeting that the District provide STUDENT with a home-based applied behavioral analysis program. Toward the end of the meeting, and in light of the reports of STUDENT’s progress during the summer from the independent assessors and UCLA representative, FATHER questioned the appropriateness of the goals and objectives developed at the March 2004 IEP meeting. At that time, the District was provided with new draft goals and objectives developed by BECA. After taking a break to review the goals and objectives, the District members of the IEP team returned to the meeting and reviewed the District’s offer to STUDENT for the 2004-2005 school year. The District members added to the services identified in the March and June 2004 IEPs the services of a one-to-one paraeducator to assist STUDENT in class. Additionally, to address FATHER’s request for home-based services and his concerns over the validity of the goals and objectives, the District requested that the District be provided consent to assess STUDENT to determine his present levels of performance and the need for home-based services. The PARENTS disagreed with the District’s offer, and the IEP meeting ended without resolution of STUDENT’s placement and program for the 2004-2005 school year.

During the weeks that followed, the District and the PARENTS communicated regarding the District’s request for permission to assess STUDENT, and the PARENTS’ request for reimbursement for the IEEs and private services and for the provision of a home-based program for STUDENT. By letter dated October 7, 2004, Mr. Wyner notified the District that he was advising his clients not to consent to the assessments. By letter dated November 8, 2004, the District notified the PARENTS that it declined to reimburse them for the independent educational evaluations and for any of the private services obtained from BECA and UCLA.

The parties were unable to resolve their disputes over the District’s requested assessments and the PARENTS’ request for reimbursement of the IEEs and privately-obtained services. The District requested a due process hearing on December 14, 2004, seeking a determination that its March 2003 assessment was appropriate and that conditions currently warrant further assessments. Three days later, the PARENTS also requested a due process hearing to resolve additional issues related to child-find violations and to the appropriateness of the District’s offers and provision of special education services. Both cases were consolidated by the Hearing Office on December 30, 2004.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

I. Did the District fail to timely locate and identify STUDENT as a child with autism pursuant to its “child-find” obligation from September 2002 through January 11, 2003, when it first initiated an assessment of STUDENT at his mother’s request?

The Student asserts that the District failed to conduct any outreach into the community regarding the availability of special education services within the District. Additionally, the Student asserts that the District should have initiated an assessment of him for special education services prior to January 11, 2003, when the District first acted upon MOTHER’s request for assessment. The District counters that it conducted outreach into the community and that it complied with all legal requirements for child-find as it pertains to STUDENT.

Pursuant to State and federal law, school districts are required to “systematically seek out” all persons under the age of twenty-two who reside within their boundaries and have exceptional educational needs. Cal. Educ. Code § 56300; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10). To implement this “child find” obligation, “[e]ach district, special education local plan area, or county office shall provide for the identification and assessment of an individual’s exceptional needs, and the planning of an instructional program to meet the assessed needs.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56302. Districts must conduct child find for all children residing in their jurisdiction, including those attending public and private schools. 34 C.F.R. § 300.451. The purpose of child find is to ensure that a free appropriate public education can be made available to all eligible children. 34 C.F.R. §§ 300.125, 300.300(a). To ensure access, school districts are responsible for disseminating information to the local community to create awareness that public services exist for disabled students. In carrying out child find for children who are not enrolled in the school district, school districts undertake activities such as widely distributing informational brochures, providing regular public service announcements, staffing exhibits at health fairs and other community activities, and creating direct liaisons with private schools. Once children are identified who are suspected of having disabilities under Part B of the IDEA, school districts must have procedures for conducting, at no cost to parents, assessments of these children residing in their jurisdiction within a reasonable period of time and without undue delay. 34 C.F.R. § 300.127. These assessments are the first step towards finding a child eligible for special education and related services and formulating an offer of a FAPE. Therefore, this step provides for the direct access to FAPE that the IDEA guarantees. 34 C.F.R. § 300.531. Hence, a school district’s child-find obligations are a precursor to the district’s responsibility to offer and provide a disabled student with a FAPE. In this case, the evidence establishes that the District complied with its child find responsibilities as they pertained to STUDENT. Victoria Estrada, who was the director of special education for the District at the time at issue here, testified that the District through its special education local plan area (SELPA) conducted numerous child find activities to notify the public of special education services. Ms. Estrada testified that, every year including the 2002 and 2003 calendar years, the SELPA sent letters to pediatricians and to all licensed preschools within the SELPA area notifying them to contact the local school district for assessment if they had concerns about a child’s abilities, disbursed “search and serve” flyers to all schools, placed an advertisement in the local newspaper inviting the public to an infant/toddler fair presented by the SELPA, presented information at the local Mommy and Me classes, provided enrollment packages for District and SELPA programs that included information on special education rights and responsibilities, and provided speakers to talk at local groups regarding special education. Although the Student claims that the District failed to conduct such outreach activities, he did not present any persuasive evidence to dispute Ms. Estrada’s testimony.

Additionally, although the Student asserts that the District should have initiated an assessment of him prior to January 11, 2003, when the District first acted upon his mother’s request for an assessment, it is undisputed that the District did not receive a referral to assess him for special education services prior to that time. Prior to STUDENT’s turning three years old on November 9, 2003, he did not receive any services from the District and there is no indication that the District had access to any specific facts to put it on notice that STUDENT was a child with special education needs. Moreover, there is no evidence that anyone, such as STUDENT’s pediatrician or his educators at Starting Point, the preschool he had attended since September 2002, referred STUDENT to the District for assessment prior to his turning three years old. Furthermore, as is discussed above, MOTHER testified that she first asked the District to assess STUDENT in December 2002, a few weeks after STUDENT turned three years old. Because the District was not on notice that STUDENT was a child with a disability and it did not receive a referral for assessment for STUDENT until December 2002, its responsibility to assess STUDENT was not yet triggered. Accordingly, the evidence does not support the Student’s contention that the District had an obligation to assess him from September 2002 through January 11, 2003, except insofar as determined below. (Footnote 6)

In summary, the District complied with its child-find responsibilities by conducting outreach activities to notify the public of the availability of special education services. Without notice that STUDENT was a child with a disability or a referral for a special education assessment, the District was not obligated to initiate an assessment of STUDENT prior to January 11, 2003, except insofar as determined in Issue No. 3. Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District complied with its child-find obligations as they pertained to STUDENT.

II. Did the District appropriately assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability from March 2003 to the present?

The Student contends that the District inappropriately assessed him because it failed to assess him in the areas of articulation, pragmatics, and behavior. The District contends that it appropriately assessed STUDENT. As was discussed above, the District conducted a transdisciplinary assessment of STUDENT in March 2003.

For the District=s assessment to be appropriate, it must have met the requirements of California Education Code sections 56320, 56322, and 56324. California Education Code section 56320, subsections (a) through (d), states in relevant part that testing and assessment materials and procedures must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; provided and administered in the student’s primary language or other mode of communication; be validated for the purposes for which they are used; administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; tailored to assess specific areas of need; and selected and administered to best ensure that, when administered to a pupil with impaired speaking skills, the test produces results that accurately reflect the student’s aptitude, achievement level, or any other factors the test purports to measure and not the student’s impaired speaking skills. California Education Code section 56320(e) requires that no single procedure is used as the sole criterion for determining the appropriate educational program for an individual with exceptional needs. Finally, California Education Code section 56320 (g) states that the assessments must be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the student’s disability. California Education Code section 56322 also requires that the assessments be conducted by persons competent to perform the assessments. California Education Code section 56324 requires that a credentialed school psychologist perform any psychological assessment.

The Student disputes the appropriateness of the District’s assessment based on the contention that the assessment must have contained insufficient information because the assessment resulted in inappropriate placements and services for the 2003-2004 school year through the 2004-2005 school year and extended school year. However, at the beginning of the hearing, the Student notified the Hearing Officer that he made no contention regarding whether the District’s March 2003 assessment was conducted appropriately pursuant to the provisions referenced above. Additionally, the Student does not dispute the validity of the information contained in the assessment report. Thus, the Student takes issue with the placements and services that resulted from the assessment and not with the way the assessment was administered or with anything contained in the assessment.

The Student also contends that the District’s assessment was inappropriate because the District failed to adequately assess him in the area of speech and language and behavior. Regarding the area of speech and language, the Student contends that the District failed to assess his pragmatics and articulation. Regarding the area of behavior, the Student contends that he exhibited behaviors such as tantrumming, physical aggression, self-injury, screaming, biting, and acting out in frustration. The District contends that it assessed STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability.

California Education Code section 56320(e) requires that a student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability. In the areas of pragmatics and articulation, the Student provided no specific information as to what deficits he exhibited that should have put the District on notice that these areas needed to be assessed or assessed beyond that which was already done by the District in the March 2003 assessment. As was noted in the District’s assessment report and affirmed by the testimony of speech and language pathologist Ann Gurlach, the District assessed STUDENT’s pragmatics using the Autism Diagnostic Observation Schedule (ADOS) and observation. The ADOS is a standardized observation of social behavior and communication that allows the assessment team to see a child in a variety of different communicative situations. (Footnote 7) Ms. Gurlach found that STUDENT exhibited fleeting eye contact, was able to respond in response to a social smile, and had difficulty responding to his name. Additionally, she found that STUDENT responded to and interacted more readily with his mother than to the examiners, with whom he rarely initiated joint attention. The Student did not challenge the appropriateness of Ms. Gurlach’s administration of the ADOS or her use of the ADOS to assess pragmatics.

Additionally, Ms. Gurlach testified that she informally assessed STUDENT’s articulation skills by obtaining a speech sample, and she noted that STUDENT was able to produce all age appropriate consonants, vowels, and syllable combinations. Similarly, Michelle Litton, the speech and language pathologist who provided services to STUDENT from March 2003 through October 2003 and from May 2004 through June 2004, testified that STUDENT did not exhibit any articulation problems that warranted further assessment in this area. From the evidence above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District appropriately assessed STUDENT’s language pragmatics and articulation.

In the area of behavior, the evidence establishes that the District adequately assessed STUDENT’s behaviors at the time of the March 2003 assessment. According to the March 2003 assessment report, STUDENT’s behaviors were assessed through observation and by using the Childhood Autism Rating Scale (CARS) in which MOTHER was the informant, the Autism Diagnostic Observation Schedule (ADOS), and an informal behavior screening developed by school psychologist Sallie Reeves. Ms. Reeves has been a school psychologist for eight years and she holds four credentials, including a school psychologist credential and a pupil personnel services credential in counseling. Additionally, Ms. Reeves was a part of the team that assessed STUDENT. Although Dr. Chehrazi testified that the ADOS and the CARS are not technically behavior assessments, Ms. Reeves testified credibly and persuasively, and the District’s assessment report indicates, that those assessment tools are helpful to obtain useful information regarding STUDENT’s ability to adapt to change and to attend to task, and regarding his emotional responses, among many other things. Additionally, as part of the assessment, STUDENT was observed during the assessment for approximately one and a half hours and for an hour at his preschool, Starting Point, by Ms. Reeves and by special day class teacher Shaana Baluch. During the team’s observation of STUDENT at the District’s LAUNCH speech and therapy room, they noted behaviors such as some tantrumming and protesting. In comparison, these behaviors were not noted during the preschool observation.

It is clear from the assessment report and the testimony of Ms. Reeves and Ms. Baluch that STUDENT’s behaviors were assessed by the District. Although the Student contends that the behaviors should have been assessed further in order to develop a behavior intervention plan for him, the evidence indicates that the District’s assessment at that time was adequate. First, Ms. Baluch testified without dispute that additional testing in the area of behavior was not necessary at that time because STUDENT’s behaviors varied across settings. Thus, it would have been more appropriate to wait until STUDENT was placed at school and provided his special education services and supports to see whether his behaviors required further assessment to develop a behavior intervention plan. Similarly, Janet Yi, the co-owner of BECA, who is certified as a behavior intervention case manager (BICM), testified that the District’s assessment of STUDENT’s behaviors in its initial assessment was appropriate, although the subsequent persistence of his behaviors may have required additional assessment at a later time. In light of the undisputed evidence above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District appropriately assessed STUDENT’s behaviors at the time of its initial assessment.

Following STUDENT’s placement within the District, STUDENT continued to tantrum and exhibit transition problems. Ms. Litton, the speech and language pathologist who provided STUDENT services during the 2002-2003 and the 2003-2004 school years, testified that she observed approximately three instances in which STUDENT tantrummed in the classroom and that his tantrumming interfered with his speech and language therapy. (Footnote 8) Ms. Litton described that the tantrumming included STUDENT’s refusing to go to therapy, throwing himself on the floor, and going under a table and refusing to come out. Although Ms. Litton testified that she only recalled three instances when STUDENT’s behaviors interfered with his education during the entire time she worked with him, she did not dispute that there could have been other instances that she did not readily recall.

Similarly, Ms. Schilling, STUDENT’s special day class teacher, testified that she observed behaviors such as STUDENT’s getting out of his seat or moving around in his seat, jumping, touching peers, going under the table if he did not want to do something, protesting and yelling. Ms. Schilling also recalled that STUDENT sometimes refused to get on the bus after school and had difficulty when being dropped off at school by his mother. For example, when MOTHER dropped him off, STUDENT would cry, refuse to sit down, and refuse to participate in circle time. Ms. Schilling also testified that STUDENT’s behaviors occurred sometimes two to three times per week and sometimes not at all. However, Ms. Schilling testified that the behaviors exhibited did not appear to be related to transitioning difficulty only, but appeared to be driven also by other factors; she believed that STUDENT’s behaviors were primarily related to sensory integration problems. Accordingly, Ms. Schilling referred STUDENT for an occupational therapy assessment on May 28, 2003. In her assessment referral form for an OT assessment, Ms. Schilling noted that her “concerns” related to STUDENT’s behaviors, which included his “stomping his feet, pounding on the table with his fists, tensing his muscles, hitting his peers, speaking loudly, and tantrumming (with difficulty calming down).” Aside from the referral for an OT assessment, no one within the District referred STUDENT for any other assessment to address his behaviors.

All of Ms. Schilling’s and Ms. Litton’s accounts of STUDENT’s behaviors are consistent with the testimony of Mr. and MOTHER regarding behaviors that they observed at home during that time. Mr. and MOTHER also testified that STUDENT had difficulty preparing for school in the morning and he resisted being placed on the school bus. After a few months of struggling with STUDENT to get him on the school bus, the PARENTS discontinued bus services and drove him to school themselves. They testified that they shared information about STUDENT’s home behaviors with Ms. Schilling and Ms. Litton.

In light of the behaviors STUDENT exhibited, the Hearing Officer concludes that behavior was an area of suspected disability for STUDENT and the District should have initiated an assessment of STUDENT’s behaviors by May 28, 2003, when the District initiated an OT assessment to address his behaviors. Although Ms. Schilling and Ms. Litton testified that the behaviors did not seem severe enough to require additional assessment or a behavior plan, the evidence establishes that STUDENT’s behaviors impeded his learning. First, the behaviors Ms. Litton observed were significant enough that she sought advice from STUDENT’s teacher, Ms. Jessica Schilling, on how to deal with STUDENT’s behaviors. Ms. Litton also testified that it took her ten to fifteen minutes to coax STUDENT out from under the table or to go to therapy. In light of the fact that Ms. Litton was providing STUDENT twenty minutes per week of individual services in the therapy room, the amount of time that it took Ms. Litton to get STUDENT to comply represented a significant portion of STUDENT’s therapy time.

Ms. Schilling also noted that it took a similar amount of time to calm STUDENT or to coax him to participate in his education. Also, as was discussed above, Ms. Schilling testified that STUDENT exhibited his behaviors sometimes two to three times per week. Given the fact that STUDENT was in school a total of two hundred minutes per day, the time that it took to calm him down when being dropped off, to coax him to comply when he tantrummed, or to encourage him to get on the school bus represented a significant amount of his educational program. Additionally, the Hearing Officer finds unpersuasive the District’s contention that STUDENT’s behavior was addressed appropriately because the District sought to address those same behaviors through an OT assessment. Because STUDENT’s deficits were manifesting as disruptive and aggressive behaviors, it was unreasonable for Ms. Schilling to refer STUDENT only for an OT assessment, particularly since she is not a licensed occupational therapist. Further, according to Ms. Schilling, the occupational therapy services provided to STUDENT following the referral for assessment did not significantly improve his behaviors over time. This fact supports the conclusion that the behaviors were impeding STUDENT’s education and other alternatives needed to be explored to control STUDENT’s behaviors. In conclusion, because the District was on notice that STUDENT’s behaviors were interfering with his education, it should have initiated an assessment of STUDENT’s behaviors at that time.

In summary, the District appropriately assessed STUDENT’s behaviors at the time of the initial assessment in March 2003. However, once STUDENT was placed within the District and he continued to exhibit the same problematic behaviors noted during the initial assessment, the District was on notice that behavior was an area of suspected disability and it should have initiated another, more thorough behavior assessment to gather information to address the behavior difficulties exhibited in the school setting.

****

In conclusion, the Student did not dispute that the District appropriately conducted its March 2003 assessment, or the accuracy or validity of the information contained in the District’s assessment. Additionally, it was found above that the District appropriately assessed STUDENT’s articulation and pragmatics. However, it was determined above that the District improperly failed to initiate an assessment of STUDENT in the area of behavior by May 28, 2003. It was not until the IEP meeting on September 16, 2004, that the District sought to assess STUDENT’s behaviors. Therefore, the District’s failure to assess STUDENT’s behaviors continued from May 28, 2003, through September 16, 2004.

III. Did the District commit procedural and substantive violations that resulted in a denial of a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to STUDENT from March 20 2003, through the end of the 2002-2003 school year and extended school year?

Under both the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student=s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(16). The term “related services” includes transportation and other services that may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(17); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(2).

In guaranteeing disabled children a right to a FAPE, Congress set forth a system of procedural and substantive requirements. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992); Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 205 (1982). Accordingly, the right to a FAPE includes the important entitlement to certain procedural protections during the process of developing an individualized education program for a disabled child. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1483. In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, the Supreme Court recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA as part of the provision of FAPE. 458 U.S. at 205. However, procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process may result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).

To determine whether the District substantively offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education, one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). In Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s IEP must be designed to meet his needs and be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. While this requires a school district to provide a disabled child with meaningful access to education, it does not mean that the school district is required to guarantee successful results. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998). Federal and State law also require that districts educate disabled children in the least restrictive environment, with removal from the regular education environment occurring only when the nature and severity of the children’s disabilities is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56301. To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program must be designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs, be reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, comport with his IEP, and provide an education in the least restrictive environment. (Footnote 9)

Accordingly, the analysis of whether a student has been offered a FAPE is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to consider both whether procedural steps have been followed and whether the proposed program is substantively appropriate. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206﷓208. At the administrative hearing, the burden of persuasion is on the school district to establish that it complied with the IDEA and Rowley. Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist. No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994).

In this case, the Student contends that the District committed procedural violations by: (1) failing to provide his parents with an assessment plan within fifteen days of the parent’s verbal request for assessment and failing to hold a timely IEP meeting following the request for assessment, (2) failing to provide the PARENTS with a revised and signed copy of the assessment report dated March 20, 2003, (3) failing to provide the PARENTs with information regarding the full continuum of services and placement options, and (4) amending his IEP in May 2003 outside of the IEP process. (Footnote 10) Additionally, the Student asserts that, from March 20, 2003, through the end of the 2003 extended school year, his IEP was not designed to meet his unique needs or reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit because: (1) it included goals and objectives that were not measurable, (2) it did not include goals and objectives to address all of his areas of deficit, (3) it did not include behavioral interventions, and (4) it failed to include appropriate services and placement in the least restrictive environment. (Footnote 11)

A. Procedural Appropriateness

1. Failure to assess and hold an IEP meeting in a timely manner

The Student contends that MOTHER made an oral request for assessment in December 2002, but the District failed to assist her in reducing her request to writing or to develop an assessment plan within fifteen days of the request for assessment. He asserts that the District did not provide MOTHER with an assessment plan until January 29, 2003. Additionally, the Student contends that, because of this delay, the District also failed to timely assess him and hold an IEP meeting. The District contends that it complied with all procedural time lines.

All referrals for special education and related services must initiate the assessment process and must be documented. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3021(a). When an oral referral is made by a parent, the staff of the school district must offer assistance in reducing the request to writing. Id. Within fifteen days of a referral for a special education assessment, the parents shall be given a proposed assessment plan in writing, not counting days of school vacation in excess of five schooldays from the date of receipt of the referral. Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(a). The parents have “at least fifteen days” from receipt of the proposed assessment plan to decide whether or not to consent to the plan. Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(c). Unless the parents consent in writing to an extension, the district must develop an IEP in accordance with the results of an assessment within fifty days of receipt of the parents’ written consent to assess, not counting days between the pupil’s regular school sessions, terms, or days of school vacations in excess of five schooldays. Cal. Educ. Code § 56344. If the referral for assessment is made twenty days or less prior to the end of the regular school year, an IEP required as a result of an assessment must be developed within thirty days after the commencement of the subsequent regular school year. Id.

In support of the Student’s case, MOTHER testified that she telephoned Arlington Elementary School, STUDENT’s home school within the District, in mid-December 2002 and requested a speech and language assessment. (Footnote 12) MOTHER also testified that the District failed to respond to her request for assessment, so she waited “at least a week” before she telephoned the District again on January 11, 2003, to again request an assessment of STUDENT. At that time, the District scheduled her for an appointment on January 29, 2003. On that date, MOTHER met with District personnel. She was presented with an assessment plan for the District to assess STUDENT in the area of speech and language, she signed the assessment plan, and the District attempted to assess STUDENT.

MOTHER also testified that the District contacted her in February to schedule another appointment to assess STUDENT on March 6, 2003. On March 6, MOTHER was again presented an assessment plan, but this time the District also sought to assess STUDENT in the areas of academic/preacademic achievement, social and emotional development, motor ability, general ability, and health and development. Again, the District assessed STUDENT on the same day. Then STUDENT’s IEP team met on March 20, 2003, to discuss the results of the assessments.

Although the District witnesses testified that they did not recall MOTHER’s initial call to the District in mid-December 2002, no evidence was presented to dispute MOTHER’s credible testimony that she made that call. Additionally, the parties do not dispute the remaining portions of the time line described by MOTHER above.

Accepting the time line established by MOTHER’s testimony, as was discussed above, the District was required to assist MOTHER in reducing her oral request to writing or to initiate the assessment process and provide her with an assessment plan within fifteen days of the request for assessment, not counting school vacations in excess of five schooldays. MOTHER’s undisputed testimony establishes that no District personnel assisted her in reducing her request to writing. Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District should have provided MOTHER with an assessment plan within fifteen days of her oral request for assessment in mid-December 2002.

However, the difficulty in this case is that MOTHER could not recall at hearing the exact date of her initial request. She testified only that her call was sometime in “mid December” of 2002. In light of MOTHER’s testimony, the Hearing Officer concludes that MOTHER called the District on or about December 16, 2002. Fifteen days from December 16, 2002, would have been December 31, 2002. Testimony from District witnesses establish that STUDENT’s school was on a traditional school year calendar. Thus, the fifteen-day time period described above ending in December 31 would have included the winter holiday, which traditionally begins no later than December 24 and ends no sooner than January 1. (Footnote 13) The District offered no evidence to support extending this time line further. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer estimates that the District should have provided MOTHER with an assessment plan no later than Saturday, January 4, 2003.

Following the provision of the assessment plan, MOTHER had at least fifteen days to consider the assessment plan, which was no earlier than January 19, 2003. Following the receipt of the parent’s consent for assessment, the District had fifty days to assess STUDENT’s speech and language needs and to convene an IEP meeting to discuss the assessment. Hence, the District was required to convene that IEP meeting by March 10, 2003.

There is no dispute that the District did not provide MOTHER the assessment plan pertaining to the speech and language assessment until January 29, 2003, and that STUDENT’s initial IEP meeting was held on March 20, 2003. There was no dispute that Ms. Litton was unable to complete her speech and language assessment of STUDENT in January 2003 and that no IEP meeting occurred prior to March 20, 2003, to discuss that assessment or to develop an educational program for STUDENT. Because the District was required to convene the IEP meeting to discuss the speech and language assessment by March 10, the District committed a procedural error when it convened the IEP meeting approximately ten days (or eight school days) later. Because this delay resulted in a delay in STUDENT’s receiving special education services, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the eight school days.

2. Failing to provide the PARENTS with a revised and signed copy of the assessment report dated March 20, 2003

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56349(a), a copy of the assessment report must be given to the parent or guardian. The Student contends that the District failed to provide his parents with a signed copy of the revised March 2003 assessment report as was agreed to in the March 20, 2003 IEP. There is no dispute that the parents obtained a copy of the original March 2003 assessment report. There is also no dispute that the changes to the original report were to correct typos, misspellings, and to delete a reference to another student. FATHER testified without dispute that he and his wife never received the revised report until they received it in the District’s evidence packet.

While the evidence established that the PARENTS did not receive the revised report in the mail as promised by the District, there was no prejudice to them because they received the original report with all of the substantive findings and conclusions from the assessment, and the revisions to the report did not affect this information. Additionally, the Student must have received the revised report at some point prior to the hearing, as a copy of the revised report was contained in his evidence binder at Exhibit 7. Hence, the Student claims a technical violation that did not affect in any way his parents’ ability to participate in the IEP process or the due process hearing. (Footnote 14)

3. Failing to provide the PARENTS with information regarding the full continuum of services and placement options

California Education Code section 56360 states that each special education local plan area shall ensure that a continuum of program options is available to meet the needs of individuals with exceptional needs for special education and related services. The Student asserts that the District was required to provide his parents with information regarding all services within the continuum of program options available to autistic children within the District, but that it failed to do so. Student’s argument fails.

First, there is nothing in the law that requires districts to provide parents with information about every conceivable program available, even those that are not appropriate to meet the student’s needs. Although the Student’s parents might have preferred to be informed of all conceivable program options, the District’s responsibility was to make an offer of FAPE and to consider options that would be appropriate to meet his needs. Second, even if the District was required to provide the PARENTS with information regarding a continuum of program options, the evidence establishes that this was done. Although the PARENTS testified that they were never told about placement and program options other than that which they were offered at the March 2003 IEP meeting, FATHER acknowledged during cross-examination that he and his wife were very upset during that meeting and that they could have forgotten whether additional service options were discussed. In fact, according to the March 2003 IEP, the team discussed as options resource specialist program services, general education services, special day class services, and designated instruction and services. Additionally, the IEP indicates that the team discussed other parent supports and opportunities such as the “community advisory committee,” the “family resource center,” the regional center, and parent education through the “LEGS” program. Moreover, Ms. Schilling testified that she telephoned MOTHER in May 2003 and talked to her about autism generally and about behavior intervention, the ASSIST program, the SMILE program, and methodologies used in each of the programs offered by the District.

In light of the uncertainty of the PARENT’s testimony regarding whether they were informed of the continuum of program options, the Hearing Officer finds more persuasive the evidence that the PARENTS were in fact informed of the services available within the District. In summary, although there is no legal requirement that school districts must inform parents of the continuum of program options, the District in fact provided this information to the PARENTS.

4. Amending his IEP in May 2003 outside of the IEP process

California Education Code section 56341(a) requires that a child=s IEP team conduct meetings during which the child=s IEP will be developed, reviewed, or revised. In convening an IEP meeting, a school district is required to take steps to ensure that one or both of the parents of the individual with exceptional needs are present at each IEP meeting or are afforded the opportunity to participate in the IEP process. 34 C.F.R. § 300.345(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(a). Similarly, California Education Code section 56341(f) states that parents of disabled children have the right to present information to the IEP team in person or through a representative and the right to participate in meetings relating to eligibility for special education and related services, recommendations, and program planning.

The Student contends that his IEP was amended without an IEP meeting in May 2003 to add ASSIST services. The undisputed evidence supports this contention. No one testified that an IEP meeting was convened for the purpose of amending STUDENT’s IEP. Rather, the undisputed testimony of MOTHER establishes that the IEP addendum form was sent home to her with a request for her signature. MOTHER signed the IEP addendum and returned it to Ms. Schilling. According to the undisputed testimony of Ms. Schilling, she called MOTHER prior to sending the addendum home to explain the ASSIST services. The PARENTS acknowledged at hearing that they and Ms. Schilling had open communication about STUDENT and that they were comfortable asking, and did ask, Ms. Schilling questions about concerns they had regarding STUDENT. Additionally, STUDENT’s possible need for ASSIST services was discussed during his initial IEP meeting on March 20, 2003. Furthermore, MOTHER consented to the additional services. In conclusion, the District inappropriately revised STUDENT’s IEP outside of an IEP meeting. However, the Hearing Officer concludes that the PARENTS were not prejudiced by this violation.

B. Substantive Appropriateness

1. What are STUDENT’s needs?

To determine whether the District provided STUDENT with a placement and program that was designed to meet his unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit, it is first necessary to determine what his unique educational needs were from March 20, 2003, through the end of the 2002-2003 school year. There is no dispute that STUDENT is a high functioning autistic student who has needs in the areas of preacademic achievement, language and communication, social skills, and motor abilities. There is also general agreement about the scope and severity of STUDENT’s needs in these areas.

For specifics regarding STUDENT’s needs in these areas during this time period, the Hearing Officer looks to the District’s initial assessment of March 2003 and the testimony of STUDENT’s assessors, teachers, service providers, and parents. As discussed above, STUDENT exhibited uneven development and scattered skills ranging from some age appropriate skills to skills with moderate to significant delays. STUDENT’s “more age appropriate” skills were in some areas of nonverbal cognitive development, pre-academics, self-help skills, nonverbal cognitive development, fine and gross motor skills, and play and social skills. In contrast, STUDENT “exhibit[ed] an inability to use oral language for appropriate communication, [an] impairment in social interaction, a preoccupation with objects and repetitive play with objects, and limited eye contact.” In summary, STUDENT’s overall cognitive development was uneven and delayed at the 30-36 month range. His pre-academic skills were also delayed and uneven at the 18-24 month range, with scattering through the thirty-six month level. Additionally, STUDENT’s language development was significantly delayed, with his auditory comprehension ranked in the 1st percentile and his expressive language ranked in the 3rd percentile. Moreover, STUDENT’s fine motor skills were delayed at the 24-30 month range, and his gross motor skills in the 25-30 month range.

Thus, STUDENT had low average cognitive abilities, and he had difficulty attending to task and accomplishing tasks related to preacademic skills involving number concepts, shape concepts, reading readiness skills, and color concept skills. In the area of language and communication, according to speech and language pathologist Shaana Baluch, STUDENT had problems following directions related to prepositions and pronouns, identifying vocabulary, combining words and using grammatical language to express himself, and answering “wh” questions. Socially, STUDENT did not know how to initiate play or maintain reciprocal relationships. Furthermore, STUDENT had some difficulty with gross motor tasks.

In light of these deficit areas, the parties also generally agree that STUDENT required a low student-to-teacher ratio and a highly structured educational program to address his attention and preacademic difficulties, speech and language therapy and an intensive language-based program to facilitate STUDENT’s oral language and communication, social skills instruction to address his difficulties with peer interaction, and exposure to typical peers for modeling purposes and to enable him to practice his social skills.

Although the parties generally agree about STUDENT’s needs in the above areas, they disagree over whether STUDENT had behavioral needs. The Student asserts that he exhibited behaviors such as aggression, tantrumming, transition difficulties, and noncompliance that required special education services. The District acknowledges that STUDENT exhibited these behaviors but disputes that the behaviors constituted an educational need. As discussed in the section immediately above, it was found that STUDENT had behavioral difficulties that were adversely interfering with his education and that required additional assessment by May 28, 2003, to determine the interventions and supports necessary to address these behavioral difficulties.

However, as was discussed above, once the District was on notice that an assessment was necessary, it was obligated to develop an assessment plan within fifteen days, not counting school holidays in excess of five days, and allow the parents a minimum of fifteen days to consider the assessment plan. Then, the District was required to assess STUDENT and convene an IEP meeting to discuss that assessment within fifty days of receipt of the parents’ written consent to the assessment plan, not counting days between the pupil’s regular school sessions, terms, or days of school vacations in excess of five schooldays. Cal. Educ. Code § 56344(a). For referrals for assessments made within twenty days prior to the end of the regular school year, the school district is required to assess and convene an IEP meeting to discuss the results of the assessment within thirty days after commencement of the subsequent regular school year. Id. Given that the District was on notice of the need for assessment by May 28, 2003, the District would not have been required to convene the IEP meeting to discuss the assessment until early October 2003. Thus, the District was not required to identify and address any additional behavior services that were necessary to address STUDENT’s behaviors until then. Accordingly, although the District was on notice that STUDENT’s behaviors were impeding his education by May 28, 2003, it had until October of the following school year to assess STUDENT and collect information to determine how to address STUDENT’s behavior needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that for the 2002-2003 school year and extended school year, the District was not yet required to convene an IEP meeting to identify and address STUDENT’s behavioral needs.

In conclusion, STUDENT had educational needs in the areas of preacademic achievement, language and communication, social skills, and motor abilities. Additionally, STUDENT required a low student-to-teacher ratio and a highly structured educational program, social skills instruction, exposure to typical peers, speech and language therapy, and exposure to an intensive language-based curriculum. Although the District was on notice by May 28, 2003, that STUDENT’s behaviors were impeding his education, this notice would not have triggered the District’s responsibility to assess him to determine his behavioral needs until early October 2003. Thus, from March 20, 2003, through the end of the 2002-2003 school year and extended school year, STUDENT had no identified behavioral needs that the District was required to address.

2. Was the March 2003 IEP designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit?

To address STUDENT’s needs, the District provided him goals and objectives and special education services pursuant to his March 20, 2003 IEP. The IEP included fifteen annual goals, each broken down into three short-term objectives. The goals and objectives covered the areas of speech and language, preacademics, gross and fine motor abilities, and social/emotional functioning. That IEP also provided that STUDENT would be placed in the District’s LAUNCH SDC preschool class for two hundred minutes per day. Ms. Schilling’s class had a maximum of fifteen students (i.e., eleven special education students and four general education students) and a minimum of four adults. Additionally, embedded within the LAUNCH program were specially designed physical education instruction twice weekly for thirty minutes each session, occupational therapy alert group twice monthly for thirty minutes, OT fine motor group instruction twice monthly for fifteen minute sessions, and ASSIST social skills group twice monthly for fifteen minutes each.

Additionally, STUDENT was provided with ten minutes per week of speech and language consultation services, fifteen minutes per week of small-group speech and language services in the classroom, twenty minutes per week of large-group speech and language services in the classroom, and twenty minutes per week of individual speech and language therapy in the therapy room. In May 2003, STUDENT’s IEP was amended to also include twenty minutes twice per week of “discrete trial instruction” (DTI) through the District’s ASSIST program in a therapy room, twenty minutes twice per week of ASSIST facilitated play services in the classroom, and fifteen minutes per month of ASSIST small-group services in the classroom.

As noted above, the Student asserts that his IEP was not designed to meet his unique needs or reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit because (1) it included goals and objectives that were unmeasurable, (2) it failed to include goals and objectives to address all of his areas of deficit, (3) it did not include behavioral interventions (such as a behavior support plan), and (4) it failed to include appropriate services and placement.

a. Goals and objectives

State and federal law requires that an IEP include measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, related to meeting the student’s needs to enable him to be involved in and progress in the general education curriculum. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(ii); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a). First, the Student contends that some of his goals are not measurable because they state that the goals would be achieved with the assistance of various levels of cuing, but that “cues” is not clearly defined. Specifically, goals numbered one through five call for STUDENT to satisfy the goal or objective “given minimal cues” or “maximum cues.” The District contends that the goals and objective as written are sufficiently clear.

While goals one through four do not specify what “minimal” cuing means, goal number five provides a useful definition. Specifically, goal number five states that the term “minimal cues” is defined as “no more than [one] verbal or visual cue and [one] repetition.” Additionally, goal number five gives examples of verbal and visual cues that could be used for STUDENT to achieve his goal. Ms. Litton also credibly testified that there is a general understanding among the teachers and service providers in the District as to the definitions of minimum and maximum cuing. Although Melissa Matherly, STUDENT’s current speech and language therapist, testified that the therapists implementing STUDENT’s goals and objectives would subjectively determine the definitions of “minimal” and “moderate” cues, she defined the terms similarly to Ms. Litton.

There is no dispute that the goals and objectives were reviewed at the IEP meeting with the PARENTS present and that the PARENTS had the opportunity to discuss each goal and objective and determine whether they accepted each one by signing their initial at the bottom of each page. Thus, they had the opportunity to ask the IEP team any questions they had regarding the definition of cuing in the goals and objectives. Although there is no dispute that the PARENTS were not given a separate definition of these terms, except as set forth earlier with regard to “minimal” cuing, the Hearing Officer finds that there is sufficient information in the IEP to define the level of cuing required for the goals and objectives. Additionally, the teacher and service providers had a uniform understanding of the definitions of cuing to implement the goals and objectives. Therefore, the evidence establishes that the goals are sufficiently measurable on these grounds.

The Student also contends that all of the goals and objectives are unmeasurable because they state that the goals would be evaluated by “observation,” which the Student contends is an inappropriately subjective method. According to the Student’s contention, the subjective method of observation would need to be paired with an objective evaluation method, such as data collection, to be valid. The District asserts that observation is an appropriate means of measuring a child’s progress on goals and objectives. The Hearing Officer finds the Student’s contention unpersuasive.

Although the Student contends that observation should be paired with data collection to appropriately measure goals and objectives, he failed to provide any legal support for his contention that this is required by the law. In contrast, STUDENT’s teacher and service providers testified that they were able to track his progress through observation and, as will be discussed below, they testified in detail how STUDENT progressed educationally through the next annual IEP in March 2004. Moreover, Elaine Semple, a District school psychologist, testified that STUDENT’s goals and objectives were developed based on the Carolina Curriculum, a preschool curriculum, and that his progress was tracked based on his advancement through the curriculum. Thus, the observations of STUDENT’s teachers and service providers were guided by the Carolina Curriculum. Further, although the law does not require the progress on goals and objectives to be measured by data collection, Ms. Schilling testified that STUDENT’s educational team collected data on data sheets regarding STUDENT’s progress towards his goals and objectives. Additionally, ASSIST teachers Felicia Shanahan and Danielle Colin-Wirtz testified the ASSIST team routinely collects data to measure a child’s progress towards his annual goals and objectives. From the undisputed testimony that observation is an appropriate means of measuring a student’s progress, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives were not unmeasurable on this basis.

Second, the Student contends that the goals and objectives offered in the March 2003 IEP were inappropriate because they failed to include goals and objectives to address his transition difficulties and to correspond with the ASSIST services in the areas of socialization and peer interaction that were added in May 2003. Regarding the need for a transition goal, it was found above that STUDENT did not have any identified behavior needs that the District was required to address until as early as October 2003. According to Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999), a review of the appropriateness of a district’s program must focus on the adequacy of the proposed program at the time it was drafted. Hence, to determine whether the District's proposed program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs, it is necessary to have some understanding of what unique educational needs the District knew or should have known about at the time it made its placement offer. The District cannot be held responsible for information it had no basis for knowing at the time it developed the IEP. Id. However, “[i]n striving for ‘appropriateness,’ an IEP must take into account what was, and was not, objectively reasonable…at the time the IEP was drafted.” Id. (quoting Fuhrmann v. East Hanover Bd. Of Educ., 993 F.2d 1031, 1041 (3d Cir. 1993). Districts are also required to review and revise the IEP when necessary to address any lack of expected progress towards goals and objectives. 34 C.F.R. § 300.343(c). Accordingly, although there is no dispute that the March 2003 IEP did not include a goal to increase his tolerance to transitions (e.g., transitions between activities and to and from school), the IEP was not deficient on this basis during the 2002-2003 school year and extended school year.

Additionally, the evidence establishes that there was no need for additional goals to be added with respect to the ASSIST services. According to the undisputed testimony of Ms. Colin-Wirtz, ASSIST services are intended to support the classroom teacher in implementing a student’s existing goals and objectives. Thus, no goals and objectives needed to be added in conjunction with these services because they were not targeting areas of need other than those already identified in the IEP and addressed through the previously developed goals and objectives. Although the Student asserts that goals and objectives were necessary, he did not provide any specifics as to why they were necessary or any factual or legal support for his contention. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that no additional goals and objectives needed to be added with the ASSIST services.

In summary, it was found above that the March 2003 goals and objectives were measurable as written and that the IEP was not required to have goals to address STUDENT’s difficulty with transitions or with regard to the ASSIST services.

b. Behavior intervention plan

One of the factors that must be considered by the IEP team when developing an IEP for a student is whether the student engages in behaviors that impede his or her learning or the learning of others. If there are such behaviors, the team must consider appropriate strategies, including positive behavioral interventions, strategies, and supports to address the behavior. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.1(b)(1); 34 C.F.R. § 300.346(a)(2). A parent can request a functional analysis assessment in the same manner that any assessment can be requested. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3052(b).

The Hearing Officer notes that the requirement to consider “positive behavioral intervention, strategies, and supports” is different than the legal requirement to develop a “behavior intervention plan” (BIP), which arises under the Hughes Bill in California. See Cal. Educ. Code § 56520 et seq. According to the Hughes Bill, a “behavior intervention plan” is a written document that is developed when the individual exhibits a serious behavior problem that significantly interferes with the implementation of the goals and objectives of the individual=s IEP. The regulations define serious behavior problems as “behaviors which are self-injurious, assaultive, or cause serious property damage and other severe behavior problems that are pervasive and maladaptive for which instructional/behavioral approaches specified in the student=s IEP are found to be ineffective.” Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(ah). When members of an IEP team find that the instructional/behavioral approaches specified in the student=s IEP are ineffective, a functional analysis assessment must be conducted to develop a behavior intervention plan. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3052 (a)(6)(b). In comparison, positive behavioral interventions are required when a child’s behavior impedes his or her learning. Accordingly, much more serious behaviors are necessary to trigger the need for a BIP than are needed for an IEP team to include positive behavioral interventions, which may include a behavior support plan, in a student’s IEP.

The Student asserts that the District should have developed a behavior support plan to address his difficult behaviors, including tantrumming, aggression, noncompliance, and problems with transitions. The District contends that no behavior support plan was required during this time because STUDENT’s behaviors were not severe and they were controllable in the school environment. There is no dispute that no behavior support plan was ever developed for STUDENT in any of his IEPs.

As was determined above, the District was on notice by May 28, 2003, that behavior was a suspected area of need for STUDENT but, given the time lines for assessment, the District was not required to complete its assessment of STUDENT’s behaviors and to determine the need for behavior interventions until October 2003. Accordingly, the District was not required to develop a behavior support plan from March 20, 2003, through the end of the 2002-2003 school year and extended school year.

c. Placement and services

As was described above, from March 20, 2003, through the end of the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT was placed in Ms. Schilling’s LAUNCH SDC classroom and was provided speech and language services from Ms. Litton. Additionally, at the end of May 2003, the District added ASSIST services to STUDENT’s program. The Student disputes the appropriateness of the District’s placement of him in the LAUNCH program and the sufficiency of the discrete trial training services provided through the ASSIST program. The Student did not dispute the appropriateness of the District-provided speech and language services.

The crux of the Student’s contention that the LAUNCH placement and the ASSIST DTI services were inappropriate is that he required, and continues to require, a placement and services that include an intensive applied behavioral analysis/discrete trial training program to meet his needs and to benefit from his education. Specifically, the Student contends that he required placement in a regular education preschool classroom with a one-to-one behavioral aide, and an intensive home-based DTT program with consultation services. In support of his contention, he offered the testimony of Dr. Chehrazi, who assessed him in June 2004, and Janet Yi, who has been supervising his BECA program since August 2004. Both witnesses testified that research literature regarding autistic children, including the 1987 study by Dr. Ivar Lovaas and the 1993 follow-up to the study, establishes the efficacy of teaching autistic children utilizing ABA/DTT strategies and some research indicates that autistic children require a minimum of twenty-five hours per week of intensive ABA services to benefit from their education.

Regarding the District’s offered program, there is no dispute that Ms. Schilling utilizes an “eclectic approach to teaching methodologies” in her SDC classroom and, although she utilizes ABA strategies, she also applies other teaching methodologies in her class throughout the day. Additionally, as noted above, beginning in late May 2003, STUDENT was provided twenty minutes per week of discrete trial instruction, which is the District’s term for discrete trial training, through the ASSIST program. Noting that STUDENT did not receive a minimum of twenty-five hours per week of ABA or DTT services in the LAUNCH classroom and through the ASSIST services, both Dr. Chehrazi (a psychologist who assessed STUDENT in June 2004) and Ms. Yi testified that the District’s provided placement and services were inappropriate for STUDENT. Similarly, Dr. Paparella, who is the program director for the Early Childhood Partial Hospitalization Program at UCLA and was part of the team that assessed STUDENT at UCLA during the summer of 2004, testified that a highly structured ABA/DTT teaching format is “most successful” for STUDENT and that it is “unlikely” that he would benefit from an educational program without an aide and a home program.

In contrast, District school psychologist Sallie Reeves testified that, based on her assessment of STUDENT in March 2003 and her observation of him at Starting Point, the District’s offer of the LAUNCH program was an appropriate placement for STUDENT. Specifically, Ms. Reeves testified that STUDENT was high functioning and he exhibited many age appropriate skills. Thus, according to Ms. Reeves, STUDENT was able to benefit from a classroom placement and he did not require an intensive ABA program. Additionally, Ms. Reeves testified that the LAUNCH placement was appropriate for STUDENT because it offered a high adult-to-student ratio (approximately 1:4) and the class provided “excellent support” and structure to meet STUDENT’s needs. For example, it was determined that STUDENT’s difficulties with social interaction could be addressed through facilitated play with the general education students who attended the class.

Along the same lines, District speech and language pathologist Ann Gurlach, who assessed STUDENT’s speech and language needs in March 2003, testified that STUDENT required a placement in an intensive language-based preschool class. Ms. Gurlach testified that the LAUNCH class met her recommendation because it included instruction in a developmental curriculum and the teacher communicated with the speech and language pathologist to ensure continuity of services. Additionally, she testified that the LAUNCH program implemented a vocabulary program that focused on teaching vocabulary words in which all adults connected to the program use the vocabulary words throughout the school day or week to reinforce the students’ use of the words taught.

Additionally, Ms. Schilling, who taught the class where STUDENT was ultimately placed, persuasively testified that STUDENT in fact benefitted from his educational placement and program. For instance, from March 2003 through the end of the first reporting period on the IEP, STUDENT made appropriate progress on seven of his ten academic goals. In her progress report, Ms. Schilling indicated that STUDENT improved upon his ability to follow directions, sit during instructional time, and comply with classroom rules and procedures. To the extent that STUDENT had difficulty with his remaining three goals (i.e., sorting big/little objects, selecting “just one” object, and initiating and maintaining appropriate play), Ms. Schilling testified that the addition of ASSIST services helped STUDENT gain the skills that he needed and progress in his educational program and to learn and practice his social interaction skills with his peers. Similarly, Ms. Litton, who provided STUDENT his speech and language services during this time, indicated in her progress report that STUDENT in fact made appropriate progress towards all five of his speech and language goals and objectives and that the progress was sufficient to meet his annual goals. Ms. Litton also commented that STUDENT’s attention improved, his understanding of basic concepts and grammar improved, and he was using words to communicate most of the time.

The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Reeves, Ms. Schilling, Ms. Gurlach, and Ms. Litton credible evidence that the placement in the LAUNCH class and the ASSIST services were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and were reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. Moreover, the Hearing Officer finds their testimony more persuasive than that of Dr. Chehrazi, Ms. Yi, and Dr. Paparella regarding the appropriateness of the District’s offered placement and services. First, unlike Ms. Reeves and Ms. Schilling, none of the Student’s witnesses hold teaching credentials. Second, each of the District’s witnesses either assessed STUDENT contemporaneously to the time period at issue or provided direct services and instruction to STUDENT during that time. In contrast, none of the Student’s witnesses knew STUDENT between March 2003 and the end of the 2002-2003 school year or had any direct knowledge of his needs at that time. Rather, the first exposure to STUDENT of the Student’s witnesses was in the summer of 2004, over one year later.

Third, the District’s witnesses provided specific testimony about how the District’s offered placement and services was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and how STUDENT received educational benefit as a result. In comparison, the testimony of Dr. Cherazi and Ms. Yi relied heavily on general findings regarding autistic children in the cited research studies rather than on STUDENT’s unique and individual needs. Additionally, neither Ms. Yi nor Dr. Paparella observed the LAUNCH classroom or had any detailed knowledge of the program provided to STUDENT by the District. Moreover, although Dr. Paparella testified that it is “unlikely” that STUDENT would benefit from an educational program without an aide and a home program, the evidence established that he in fact benefitted from his program.

Therefore, the credible and persuasive testimony of the District’s witnesses established that the LAUNCH class was a highly structured class with a low student-to-teacher ratio, which STUDENT required to address his attention and preacademic deficits. Additionally, the LAUNCH class included an intensive language-based curriculum that STUDENT required to improve his oral language and communication skills. The LAUNCH class also included at least four general education peers with whom STUDENT could model to improve his social skills, and interact when his social skills were worked on by the ASSIST teachers. Finally, the ASSIST services, which included DTI services, provided STUDENT with the additional individualized attention that he required to progress towards meeting his goals and objectives.

In conclusion, the preponderance of the evidence establishes that the District’s LAUNCH SDC placement and ASSIST DTI services were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit, and did, in fact, provide him with educational benefit.

***

In summary, it was found above that the District committed procedural violations when it failed to assess STUDENT and to hold an IEP meeting in a timely manner. Specifically, the District convened STUDENT’s initial IEP meeting approximately eight school days late. Due to this procedural violation, the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for those eight days.

Additionally, it was also found above that the District should have initiated a behavior assessment of STUDENT by the end of May 2003, but failed to do so. However, because the District would not have been required to complete the assessment until October 2003 during the following school year, this failure did not result in a denial of educational services to STUDENT and, therefore, did not result in a denial of FAPE. Although the District failed to provide the PARENTS the revised copy of the March 2003 assessment report and failed to convene an IEP to add ASSIST services, these violations did not result in any prejudice to the PARENTS or a denial of FAPE. Moreover, contrary to the Student’s allegation, the District provided the PARENTS with information regarding the continuum of program options in the District.

It also was determined above that the March 2003 IEP and the May 2003 addendum were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and provide him with educational benefit. To explain, it was found above that the March 2003 goals and objectives were measurable and appropriate, and that the placement in the LAUNCH SDC class with ASSIST DTI was appropriate for STUDENT. The Student did not challenge any other aspect of the District’s provided program.

In conclusion, from March 20, 2003, through the end of the 2002-2003 school year and extended school year, the District only denied STUDENT a FAPE for the eight school days that it failed to timely convene his initial IEP meeting.

IV. Did the District commit procedural and substantive violations that resulted in a denial of a FAPE to STUDENT during the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year?

For the 2003-2004 school year, the Student contends that the District committed the following procedural violations: (1) failing to provide the PARENTS information regarding the full continuum of placement and service options for him, (2) failing to have a general education teacher participate in the March 2004 IEP meeting, and (3) failing to provide all of Student’s educational records to the parents upon their written request.

Additionally, the Student reasserts his prior contentions regarding the substantive inappropriateness of the District’s provided program and placement for the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year. Specifically, he contends that his IEPs were not designed to meet his unique needs or reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit because: (1) they included goals and objectives that were not measurable, (2) they did not include goals and objectives to address all of his areas of deficit, (3) they did not include necessary behavioral interventions, and (4) they failed to include appropriate services and placement in the least restrictive environment.

A. Procedural Appropriateness

1. Failing to provide the PARENTS information regarding the full continuum of placement and service options for STUDENT

The Student reasserts his same contention from the prior school year: specifically, he asserts that the District failed to notify him of the continuum of placement and service options available within the District. Because it was found above that the PARENTS were provided information regarding the continuum of program options in the District, it is unnecessary to reevaluate this issue again here. However, is should be noted that FATHER testified that in March 2004 he independently researched information regarding autism and the program options available, including those within the District, to serve autistic children. Thus, he had the information he claimed the District had not provided him.

2. Failing to have a general education teacher participate in the March 2004 IEP meeting

An IEP team must include “at least one regular education teacher of the child (if the child is, or may be, participating in the regular education environment).” 34 C.F.R. § 300.344(a)(2); see also Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b)(2). As a member of the IEP team, the regular education teacher must, to the extent appropriate, participate in the development, review, and revision of the child’s IEP, including assisting in the determination of appropriate positive behavioral interventions and strategies for the child, and supplementary aids and services and program modifications or supports for school personnel that will be provided for the child. 34 C.F.R. § 300.346(d). As noted in 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, App. A, Q.24, which addresses the role of the regular education teacher in the IEP process, “the regular education teacher who is a member of the IEP team must participate in discussions and decisions about how to modify the general curriculum in the regular classroom to ensure the child’s involvement and progress in the general curriculum and participation in the regular education environment.” 64 Fed. Reg. 48 at 12477. “Thus, while a regular education teacher must be a member of the IEP team if the child is, or may be, participating in the regular education environment, the teacher need not (depending upon the child’s needs and the purpose of the specific IEP team meeting) be required to participate in all decisions made as part of the meeting or to be present throughout the entire meeting or attend every meeting. … The extent to which it would be appropriate for the regular education teacher member of the IEP team to participate in IEP meetings must be decided on a case-by-case basis.” Id.

The Student contends that the District failed to ensure the attendance of a regular education teacher at the March 2004 IEP meeting. During the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT was placed in the LAUNCH preschool SDC and receiving ASSIST services, as well as the related services of speech and language therapy and OT. During March 2004, STUDENT was nearing the completion of preschool, and the District and his parents were preparing for his transition to kindergarten. Among the placements that his parents were considering for the next school year was a regular education kindergarten class called Preppy Plus, which is located on an elementary school campus where STUDENT could have had opportunities to integrate with the general education population. The purpose of the IEP meeting in March 2004 was to review and revise STUDENT’s goals and objectives, which were to carry into his kindergarten year. At the March 2004 meeting, the District recommended continuation of STUDENT’s placement in the LAUNCH preschool SDC and related services through the end of the 2004 extended school year, but deferred discussion regarding the placement and services for the 2004-2005 school year to STUDENT’s kindergarten transition meeting in April 2004. According to the March 2004 IEP, Anita Winfrey was present at the meeting as a general education teacher. However, FATHER testified without dispute that Ms. Winfrey left the meeting five minutes after the meeting began and did not participate in any discussions regarding the goals and objectives or placement and services. No one else who was present at the meeting was a regular education teacher.

However, as noted above, at the time of the March 2004 meeting, STUDENT was not a child who was participating in the general education program. Further, while the parents were considering a general education placement for his kindergarten year, there is no evidence that either the parents or school staff were considering changing his SDC placement to a placement in the regular education environment for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year. In fact, at the time of the March 2004 IEP meeting, the PARENTS were happy with the LAUNCH SDC placement, and they consented to the continuation of that SDC placement for the remaining three months of the 2003-2004 school year. Moreover, limited discussion occurred during the March 2004 about the school year for which participation in the regular education environment was being considered (i.e., the 2004-2005 school year); discussion about the 2004-2005 school was essentially deferred to the kindergarten transition meeting in April 2004. Finally, there is no dispute that a general education teacher was present at each of the subsequent three IEP meetings held to discuss STUDENT’s placement and services for the 2004-2005 school year, which took place on April 26, June 3, and September 16, 2004. (Footnote 15) STUDENT’s goals and objectives were discussed in depth during at least the September meeting, which included a regular education teacher. Additionally, STUDENT’s placement and services were reviewed at each of the three subsequent meetings. Hence, the Student had at least three other opportunities to obtain the input of a regular education teacher regarding his educational placement.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not violate STUDENT’s procedural rights by not ensuring the participation of a general education teacher at the March 2004 IEP meeting.

3. Failing to provide all of Student’s educational records to parents within five days of their written request

Parents have a right to obtain their child’s school records within five days of making a request under California Education Code section 56504. School records are defined as “any item of information directly related to an identifiable pupil, other than directory information, which is maintained by a school district or required to be maintained by an employee in the performance of his duties.” Cal. Educ. Code § 49061. The Student contends that the District failed to timely provide him with approximately four hundred pages of his educational records, including data sheets collected by STUDENT’s teachers and service providers and assessment protocols. The District contends that it provided the PARENTS with all of STUDENT’s educational records.

The evidence supports the Student’s contention. According to the Student’s Exhibit 51, FATHER submitted a written request to the District on June 2, 2004. On June 4, 2004, the District copied 125 pages of documents from STUDENT’s records and provided those documents to FATHER. According to FATHER, the documents did not include any data sheets that were compiled by the SMILE and ASSIST programs or any testing protocols from the March 2003 assessment. There is no dispute that these documents exist or that they existed at the time of FATHER’s request for documents. The uncontested evidence also establishes that, after a second request from FATHER for STUDENT’s educational records on September 16, 2004, the data sheets were ultimately provided to him on September 27. However, he never received any copies of the testing protocols used by Ms. Reeves.

In light of the facts above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to timely provide the PARENTS with STUDENT’s records within five days of his original request for records on June 2, 2004.

B. Substantive Appropriateness

For the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year, STUDENT’s placement and program were governed by two separate IEPs. From the beginning of the school year through the date of his annual IEP meeting on March 12, 2004, STUDENT’s placement and services was governed by his March 20, 2003 IEP, as amended by the May 2004 addendum adding ASSIST services and the September 2003 IEP addendum adding OT services and goals and objectives. From March 13, 2004, through the end of the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year, STUDENT’s placement and program was provided for through his March 12, 2004 IEP.

As was discussed above, the Student reasserts his prior contentions regarding the substantive inappropriateness of the District’s provided placement and services for the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year. Specifically, he contends that his IEPs were not designed to meet his unique needs or reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit because: (1) they included goals and objectives that were not measurable, (2) they did not include goals and objectives to address all of his areas of deficit, (3) they did not include a behavior support plan, and (4) they failed to include appropriate placement and services.

1. What are STUDENT’s needs?

For the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year, the nature of STUDENT’s needs did not significantly change from the prior school year as was discussed above. STUDENT continued to have deficits in the areas of preacademic achievement, language and communication, social skills, and motor abilities. He also continued to require a low student-to-teacher ratio and a highly structured educational program, social skills instruction, exposure to typical peers, speech and language therapy, and exposure to an intensive language-based curriculum. Additionally, by September 26, 2003, STUDENT’s IEP team also identified deficit areas in sensory processing, organization of behavior, fine motor, and visual skills. There is no dispute that STUDENT required occupational therapy services to improve his fine motor skills and his ability to attend to task and control his behaviors.

Moreover, it was found above that STUDENT exhibited behaviors that adversely affected his education during the 2002-2003 school year that required assessment, and that the District was required to complete the assessment and convene an IEP meeting by early October 2003. The evidence also establishes that STUDENT’s behaviors continued, and even increased in frequency and severity, during the 2003-2004 school year.

At hearing, Ms. Schilling testified that STUDENT’s behaviors came in waves. He would cry, not sit down, or refuse to participate in circle time during some mornings when MOTHER dropped him off at school. Ms. Schilling also testified that these behaviors exhibited when he was dropped off at school lasted from five to twenty minutes each time and escalated “beyond what you would see in a child.” She also described that STUDENT had difficulty getting on the bus after school and he would sit on the ground to avoid being placed on the bus and/or would yell, “No bus!” Similarly, Ms. Schilling stated at the September 2004 IEP meeting that there were times during the prior school year when STUDENT resisted transitions and tantrummed, have “melt downs,” just sit and scream, get under the table, and lay under a table like a ball. Ms. Schilling was aware of Ms. Litton’s difficulties getting STUDENT to go to speech and language therapy and the PARENTS’ difficulty getting STUDENT to get on the bus to go to school. In fact, she spoke to the PARENTS on “several occasions” regarding STUDENT’s behaviors. (Footnote 16) Ms. Schilling was also quoted in Dr. Paparella’s report as stating that, toward the end of the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT experienced a period of five to six weeks in which he demonstrated frequent transition problems, resulting in tantrums lasting one to twenty minutes, followed by a period of two weeks with no behavior problems.

FATHER and MOTHER also testified that STUDENT’s difficulties getting on the bus to go to school continued during the 2003-2004 school year and occurred every morning until they discontinued STUDENT’s bus transportation to school in January 2004 because it was too difficult and emotionally draining on the family to get STUDENT to ride the bus in the morning. MOTHER also confirmed that STUDENT had difficulty getting on the bus after school, which resulted in the PARENTS discontinuing his bus transportation home in May 2004. FATHER testified he spoke with Michelle Litton on several occasions regarding STUDENT’s behavior problems and she told him that, during the spring of 2004, she had to begin providing STUDENT’s speech and language services in the classroom rather than the therapy room because of STUDENT’s difficulties transitioning to his speech and language therapy. Additionally, MOTHER testified that STUDENT was asked to leave Starting Point, the private preschool where STUDENT was dually enrolled with the District’s LAUNCH program, because of his behaviors. Some of STUDENT’s behaviors at Starting Point included hiding in the playground and refusing to transition back to class after recess, hiding under the table, refusing to do classroom activities, refusing to sit at circle time, tantrumming and crying, screaming and defying authority, and being physically aggressive to the owner of the preschool.

In summary, the District was required to complete its assessment of STUDENT’s behaviors by October 2003, but failed to do so. Because there was no contemporaneous assessment of STUDENT’s behaviors while he attended the LAUNCH program, the Hearing Officer looks to the evidence of his behaviors to determine whether STUDENT had unique needs in the area of behavior that needed to be addressed with special education services. There is no dispute that the behaviors described above occurred during the 2003-2004 school year. In light of the undisputed testimony that STUDENT’s behaviors were more severe than those exhibited by typical children, that they occurred in waves of up to five-week periods when the behaviors were exhibited “frequently,” and that the behaviors occurred throughout the school day and would last up to twenty minutes each time, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s behaviors impeded his education. Additionally, the Hearing Officer concludes the behaviors described above occurred primarily when STUDENT was transitioning between activities or locations. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer also concludes that, from October 2003 through the end of the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year, STUDENT required a special education program to address his transition difficulties.

In conclusion, for the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year, STUDENT continued to have deficits in the areas of preacademic achievement, language and communication, social skills, and motor abilities, which required that he be instructed in an environment with a low student-to-teacher ratio and a highly structured educational program, social skills instruction, exposure to typical peers, speech and language therapy, and exposure to an intensive language-based curriculum. Additionally, from September 26, 2003, STUDENT also required occupational therapy services to improve his fine motor skills and his ability to attend to task and control his behaviors. Finally, STUDENT required a special education program that addressed his behaviors related to his transition difficulties starting in early October 2003.

2. Was the District’s provided placement and services designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit?

a. Beginning of 2003-2004 school year through March 12, 2004 i. Goals and objectives

Because the goals and objectives in effect from the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year through March 12, 2004, were the same goals and objectives from the March 2003 IEP that were analyzed above, the same findings apply to the Student’s reasserted contentions regarding the measurability of the goals and objectives. The same findings made above also apply here with regard to the Student’s contention that that the IEP was inappropriate because if failed to include goals and objectives to accompany the ASSIST services that were added in May 2003.

However, the Hearing Officer finds persuasive the Student’s contention that the District’s provided program was inappropriate because it lacked any behavior goals to address his transition difficulties. As was described above, STUDENT continued to exhibit behavior issues that were primarily related to his transitions between activities and locations and that these behaviors impeded STUDENT’s learning. Because STUDENT had behaviors that were significant and that impacted his ability to access his education, the Hearing Officer finds goals and objectives were necessary to address his behaviors and to enable STUDENT to progress in his educational program.

Hence, although the March 2003 IEP contained goals and objectives that were measurable and did not require ASSIST-specific goals, the IEP was inappropriate because it failed to include goals and objectives to address STUDENT’s behavior related to his transition problems.

ii. Behavior plan

As was discussed above, when a student engages in behaviors that impede his or her learning or the learning of others, the student’s IEP team must, when appropriate, consider appropriate strategies, including positive behavioral interventions, strategies and supports to address the behavior. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.1(b)(1). In contrast, a Hughes Bill “behavior intervention plan@ is developed when the individual exhibits “behaviors which are self-injurious, assaultive, or cause serious property damage and other severe behavior problems that are pervasive and maladaptive for which instructional/behavioral approaches specified in the student=s IEP are found to be ineffective.” Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(ah) (emphasis added).

It was determined above that the District was on notice that behavior was an area of suspected disability for STUDENT and that the District should have assessed his behavior and convened an IEP meeting to discuss that assessment and determine how to address STUDENT’s behavior needs by the early part of October 2003. For example, STUDENT exhibited behaviors that concerned Ms. Litton and Ms. Schilling. Additionally, it was determined above that STUDENT’s behaviors interfered with his ability to access his education. Moreover, it was determined above that the occupational therapy services initiated at the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year did little to resolve STUDENT’s behaviors and that an assessment in the area of behavior was required to address his behavior difficulties.

As was described above, during the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT’s behaviors persisted and, in some ways, increased in severity and frequency. He continued to have difficulty with getting on the bus in the morning, being dropped off at school, transitioning between activities in the LAUNCH program, and getting on the bus in the afternoon. Additionally, STUDENT’s behaviors at his private preschool led him to be asked to leave the school and discontinue enrollment there. In light of the increasing behaviors that STUDENT exhibited, the Hearing Officer concludes that by early October 2003, STUDENT’s behaviors rose to the level that they significantly impeded his learning and the learning of others. Hence, STUDENT required positive behavioral interventions and strategies, such as a behavior support plan, from early October 2003 through the end of the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year, but none were provided.

Although Ms. Schilling testified that she did not believe that a behavior support plan was needed at any time STUDENT attended her LAUNCH SDC from April 2003 through the first week of the 2004 ESY, her testimony was based on her understanding of the requirements of a “behavior intervention plan” pursuant to the Hughes Bill and not on the legal standard for when “positive behavioral interventions, strategies and supports” are required. Specifically, she testified that a behavior plan is only required if the child’s behavior resulted in physical damage to her classroom or injury to the student or his/her peers, or was so severe that the child was not engaged in the academic setting at all. Contrary to Ms. Schilling’s testimony, a child’s behaviors need not rise to the level of severity she referenced before positive behavioral interventions and strategies are included in the student’s IEP. Rather, as is discussed above, the law requires that an IEP include positive behavioral interventions and strategies when a student engages in behavior that impedes his or her learning or the learning of others.

Accordingly, because STUDENT exhibited significant behaviors that impeded his learning, he required a behavior support plan or other positive behavioral interventions and strategies to address his behaviors, but none was developed or provided. Therefore, the District’s program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s behavior needs or was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit in the area to the extent that it did not include a behavior support plan.

iii. Placement and services

During the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year, STUDENT was provided the same placement at the LAUNCH program in Ms. Schilling’s class, the same level and type of ASSIST services, and the same duration and frequency of speech and language services. Because STUDENT’s needs in the areas of preacademic, language and communication, social skills, behavior, and motor abilities did not significantly change during this time, that placement and services are also deemed to have been appropriate for the same reasons stated above.

STUDENT was also determined in September 2003 to require OT services to address his sensory processing and organization of behavior, fine motor deficits, and visual skills. Pursuant to the September 26, 2003 IEP, the District offered STUDENT sixty minutes per week of clinic-based OT, one hour per month of individual therapy in a therapy room, one hour per month of group therapy on the playground, and thirty minutes per month of small group therapy in the classroom. The Student does not dispute that these services were appropriate to meet his unique needs in these areas or were reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit.

The District also provided persuasive testimony that STUDENT in fact benefitted from his educational placement and program from the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year through March 12, 2004. According to STUDENT’s progress reports and the testimony of Ms. Schilling, by the first reporting period, STUDENT made adequate progress towards meeting his annual goals on three of his five academic goals, both of his fine motor goals, and two of his three social skills goals. By the second reporting period, STUDENT was making appropriate progress on all of his goals and objectives. Then, by the third reporting period immediately preceding his annual IEP meeting in March 2004, STUDENT had met all of his annual goals except the one related to identification of colors. Similarly, Ms. Litton credibly testified that STUDENT made adequate and appropriate progress throughout the year and, by March 2004, STUDENT had achieved three of his five speech and language goals and had nearly met the remaining two goals. Moreover, the progress report pertaining to STUDENT’s occupational therapy services indicates that STUDENT made significant progress in his fine motor abilities and organization of behavior/sensory processing, and that he met his goals and objectives by March 2004. From the undisputed testimony and progress reports, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s placement and services were reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit, and he in fact benefitted from his educational placement and services.

In conclusion, the preponderance of the evidence establishes that the District’s LAUNCH SDC placement and ASSIST DTI services were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit, and did, in fact, provide him with educational benefit. It was found above that the District’s placement and services satisfied STUDENT’s need for a highly structured class with a low student-to-teacher ratio, an intensive language-based curriculum to address STUDENT’s oral language and communication skills, exposure to general education peers with whom STUDENT could model to improve his social skills, and additional individualized attention that he required to progress towards meeting his goals and objectives. Additionally, the evidence established that STUDENT was able to meet most of his goals and objectives and in fact benefitted from his education.

b. March 13, 2004, through the end of the 2004 ESY

At the March 12, 2004 annual IEP meeting, STUDENT’s teachers and service providers reported on his progress towards his goals and objectives and revised his goals and objectives to reflect his then-current educational needs. In the area of language and communication, STUDENT had not been able to reach his goal regarding the use of pronouns and his goal of understanding simple prepositional phrases. Thus, two new goals were written in these areas that extended the difficulty of the annual goal and began the short-term objectives at the level where STUDENT left off in March 2004. Because STUDENT met his goals of producing various sentence structures to respond to “What doing?” questions, using twenty descriptive terms to describe objects or pictures, and responding to his name and increasing eye contact, Ms. Litton discontinued those goals and developed a new goal and objectives in the area of receptive language where STUDENT still required remediation. Similarly, Ms. Schilling revised STUDENT’s academic, motor, and social skills goals to reflect his progress from the previous year. The same was done for the OT goals. In all other respects, the IEP continued the same placement and services that had been provided up to that point for the 2003-2004 school year.

i. Goals and objectives

Again, the Student asserts that his March 2004 IEP was inappropriate because it included goals and objectives that were not measurable, and did not include goals and objectives to address all of his areas of deficit. Like the goals from the March 2003 IEP, the March 2004 IEP also contained goals and objectives that used terms such as “minimal cues” and “moderate cues.” However, unlike the 2003 goals and objectives, many of the 2004 goals and objectives defined specifically the level of cuing that would be provided to STUDENT. For example, goals ten, eleven, and fifteen through twenty, all indicate the number and type of prompt that would be used (e.g., one verbal prompt). Because the 2004 goals and objectives provides detailed information regarding the level of prompting needed, and for the same reasons stated for the prior school year, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives are measurable as written.

Also for the same reasons identified above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to develop any goals to address STUDENT’s behavior difficulties. To explain, STUDENT continued to exhibit problems with transitions throughout the school year, but the District failed to develop any goals and objectives for him to address this area of need. (Footnote 17)

ii. Behavior plan

Similarly, to the extent that the Student reasserts that the District failed to develop positive behavioral interventions and strategies for him, the undisputed evidence establishes that STUDENT’s behaviors continued and at times increased during this time but the District continued to fail to develop those interventions. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer also finds that the District’s program was deficient for the reasons stated above.

iii. Placement and services

Finally, with regard to STUDENT’s placement and services, the District offered the same placement and services as provided in the March 2003 IEP, and that placement and services are also determined to be appropriate for the same reasons stated above.

****

In conclusion, it was found above that the District failed to provide the PARENTS with STUDENT’s educational records in a timely manner, but that this violation did not result in any prejudice to the PARENTS. Moreover, it was found above that the District informed the PARENTS of the continuum of placement options available within the District and satisfied its obligation to have a regular education teacher present during the IEP process.

Furthermore, it was determined above that the March 2003 and March 2004 IEPs were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and provided him with educational benefit except in the area of behavior. To explain, it was found above that the goals and objectives were measurable and the placement in the LAUNCH SDC classroom with ASSIST DTI was appropriate for STUDENT. However, the IEP lacked any goals to address STUDENT’s behaviors pertaining to his difficulty with transitions and failed to include necessary behavioral interventions. STUDENT’s behaviors significantly affected his educational program because they occurred throughout the school day, involved transitions from activities and locations, and were often frequent and long lasting. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that behavior goals and objectives and behavioral interventions were necessary components of STUDENT’s educational program. Because no behavior goals or behavioral interventions were provided, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE.

In summary, the District denied STUDENT a FAPE from early October 2003 through the end of the 2003-2004 school year by failing to address his behavioral needs. The Hearing Officer concluded that the District provided STUDENT a FAPE in all other regards.

V. Is the District entitled to conduct an assessment of STUDENT pursuant to its September 16, 2004 assessment plan?

Reassessment of a student with disabilities must be conducted at least once every three years, or more frequently, if conditions warrant a reassessment or if an assessment is requested by the student’s teacher or parent. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381; 20 U.S.C. § 1414 (a)(2)(A). In Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1315 (9th Cir. 1987), the Ninth Circuit stated “if the parents want [their child] to receive special education under the Act, they are obligated to permit such testing.” In Andress v. Cleveland Independent School District, 64 F.3d 176, 178 (5th Cir. 1995), the Fifth Circuit concluded that “a parent who desires for her child to receive special education must allow the school district to evaluate the child…there is no exception to this rule.” See also Vander Malle v. Ambach, 673 F.2d 49, 53 (2nd Cir. 1983).

While the law provides that a school district has the right and obligation to conduct these reassessments, parental consent for an evaluation is required before a school district can assess the child. Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(c); 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(1)(C)(i). To obtain consent, the school district must first develop an assessment plan to present to the student’s parents that complies with California Education Code section 56321(b). Section 56321(b) requires that the assessment plan (1) be in language that is easily understood by the general public; (2) be provided in the primary language of the parent; (3) explain the types of assessments to be conducted; and (4) state that no individualized education program will result from the assessment without the consent of the parents. Once the assessment is provided to the student’s parents, the parents must be allowed at least fifteen days to respond to the assessment plan. Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(a).

If the parents do not consent to the assessment plan, a local education agency can override a lack of parental consent if it establishes at a due process hearing the need to conduct such an assessment. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56321(c), 56501(a)(3), 56506(e); 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(1)(C)(ii). Thus, for a district to be allowed to conduct its assessment, it must establish that consent for the assessment has been withheld and that, pursuant to California Education Code section 56381, it is time for the student’s triennial assessment, conditions warrant reassessment, or that the student’s parent or teacher requests a reassessment.

As discussed above, the District developed its assessment plan and presented it to the PARENTS at the September 2004 IEP meeting. Pursuant to the assessment plan, the District seeks to assess STUDENT in the area of preacademic/academic achievement and to determine the need for home-based services. Additionally, the District requests permission to conduct a functional analysis assessment of STUDENT. It is not disputed that the assessment plan presented to the PARENTS complied with the provisions of California Education Code section 56321(b), that they were afforded at least fifteen days to consider the assessment plan, and that they have withheld their consent to the assessments. The District contends that it should be entitled to assess STUDENT despite the PARENTS’ withholding consent because conditions warrant his reassessment. Specifically, the District contends that an academic assessment is required to determine STUDENT’s current levels of performance and to revise STUDENT’s goals and objectives in light of FATHER’s concerns that the goals and objectives are no longer appropriate. Additionally, the District contends that an assessment is required to determine the need for home-based services because FATHER requested those services at the September 2004 IEP meeting. Finally, the District contends that it must conduct a functional analysis assessment to evaluate STUDENT’s behavioral difficulties that were reported by his parents and private providers.

The Student opposes the assessments, contending primarily that its independent evaluations from Dr. Schmidt-Lackner, Dr. Chehrazi, and BECA contain sufficient information for the District to revise its goals and objectives and to develop its program and services.

The preponderance of the evidence establishes that conditions warrant reassessment at this time in all areas requested by the District. First, the Student provided no legal support, and the Hearing Officer does not know of any, that establishes that Districts must rely on the information provided by outside assessors. Because school districts are ultimately responsible for the educational programs that they offer or provide to their special education students, it is illogical to compel school districts to rely on assessments in which they did not participate and over which they had no control. Although a district may have no reason to doubt the validity of the private assessments, such as in this case, a school district often would have no information to appraise the validity of those assessments without conducting its own evaluation. (Footnote 18) By denying school districts the opportunity to conduct their own assessments, the school districts are also denied the opportunity to verify the information in those assessments. Thus, a school district would be restrained from taking the responsible step of obtaining its own reliable information and would be forced to open itself up to significant liability. While school districts may decide to accept the assessment and findings of outside assessors, they do so at their own risk.

Second, the District in this case has established a necessity for the assessments requested. Initially, the Hearing Officer notes that at the time consent for the assessments was requested, STUDENT had been removed from the District for over two months and had received intensive educational and medical services from the UCLA Early Childhood Partial Hospitalization Program. Additionally, STUDENT had been receiving intensive home-based ABA/DTT services from BECA for over one month. At the IEP meeting, the District was informed by FATHER and representatives from BECA that STUDENT had made substantial academic gains from the private services and that the March 2004 goals and objectives were no longer valid. Because this information conflicted with the District’s last understanding of STUDENT’s needs, and because STUDENT had not attended a District program where the District could have monitored his progress, conditions warranted further assessment to determine STUDENT’s present levels of performance so that the District could evaluate the appropriateness of its goals and objectives.

Moreover, the District was also notified that STUDENT’s behaviors had significantly deteriorated. For example, Ms. Yi testified that STUDENT’s tantrumming, noncompliance, and aggression had increased in frequency and severity, to the point where the BECA staff was unable to implement many of STUDENT’s academic and social skills due to his behaviors. Although the behaviors STUDENT exhibited at school mainly consisted of tantrumming and noncompliance, Ms. Yi testified that STUDENT also now is assaultive and will hit and bite people, and he strips his clothes off and will urinate on the floor. The District, therefore, requests permission to conduct an FAA to develop a behavior plan for STUDENT.

As was outlined above, a Hughes Bill “behavior intervention plan” is developed when the individual exhibits “behaviors which are self-injurious, assaultive, or cause serious property damage and other severe behavior problems that are pervasive and maladaptive for which instructional/behavioral approaches specified in the student=s IEP are found to be ineffective.” Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(ah). When members of an IEP team find that the instructional/behavioral approaches specified in the student=s IEP are ineffective, a functional analysis assessment (FAA) must be conducted. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3052(a)(6)(b). An FAA forms the basis for a behavior intervention plan. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3052(a)(3).

As determined above, the Student has behavioral needs that have not been assessed by the District for some time. Thus, the need for some form of a behavior assessment has existed for the past year and continues to exist today. Additionally, the undisputed and credible information provided by BECA establishes that STUDENT’s behaviors are assaultive, and are pervasive and maladaptive. Specifically, STUDENT frequently hits and kicks people, he strips his clothes, and he urinates on the floor. Additionally, his increased tantrumming and noncompliance has made it difficult to implement many of his goals and objectives. Because STUDENT’s current IEP does not provide for any behavior goals or behavioral interventions, and because this renders his IEP ineffective, the Hearing Officer concludes that conditions warrant an FAA at this time.

Finally, FATHER requested home-based services for STUDENT at the September 2004 IEP meeting. According to ASSIST teacher Felicia Shanahan, an assessment is needed to determine whether a student requires the services requested and, if he or she does, how much services should be provided to meet the child’s needs. Additionally, the District’s special education director, Aaron Benton, testified that Elaine Semple and Shelly Chavez had questions as to whether STUDENT would benefit from a home-based program. To consider FATHER’s request, and for the same reasons stated above regarding the District’s need for current information, the Hearing Officer also finds that conditions warrant an assessment to determine STUDENT’s need for intensive home-based DTT services.

In summary, it was determined above that conditions warrant assessments of STUDENT in the area of academic/preacademic achievement and to determine the need for home-based services. Additionally, conditions warrant a functional analysis assessment of STUDENT’s behaviors. Therefore, the District may conduct its assessments pursuant to the September 2004 assessment plan over the PARENTS’ refusal of consent.

VI. Did the District commit procedural and substantive violations that resulted in a denial of a FAPE to STUDENT during the 2004-2005 school year and extended school year?

For the 2004-2005 school year, the Student contends that the District committed the following procedural violations: (1) failing to provide the PARENTS with information regarding the full continuum of placement and service options for him, (2) failing to consider the independent educational evaluations obtained by the PARENTS and failing to consider input from his private service providers, (3) failing to identify the name of the District personnel who would provide aide services to him pursuant to the September 2004 IEP, and (4) failing to provide prior written notice of the District’s refusal to reimburse the PARENTS for the cost of privately procured services. (Footnote 19)

Again, the Student reasserts his prior contentions regarding the substantive inappropriateness of the District’s provided program and placement for the 2004-2005 school year and extended school year. Specifically, he contends that his IEPs were not designed to meet his unique needs or reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit because: (1) they included goals and objectives that were not measurable and/or not sufficiently challenging, (2) they did not include goals and objectives to address all of his areas of deficit, (3) they did not include positive behavioral interventions and strategies, and (4) they failed to include appropriate services and placement in the least restrictive environment. Moreover, unlike for prior school years, the Student also contends that the District failed to provide services that comported with his September 2004 IEP because it failed to provide him with direct occupational therapy services for sixty minutes per week.

A. Procedural Appropriateness

1. Failing to provide the PARENTS with information regarding the full continuum of placement and service options for STUDENT

The Student reasserts his same contentions from the 2002-2003 school year, specifically that during the September 2004 IEP meeting, the District failed to provide his parents with information regarding the District’s various autism services such as the ASSIST program, the SMILE program, and the various placement options for autistic students. However, as noted above, the PARENTS were already aware of the continuum of program options available for STUDENT when those program options were considered at STUDENT’s kindergarten transition IEP meetings of April and June 2004. It is undisputed that, at both of those meetings, the IEP teams discussed the various classroom placements offered for kindergarten children within the District and that the PARENTS visited two of the three placements (i.e., the District’s SDC and Preppy Plus Plus class) and received information regarding the third (i.e., the District’s Preppy Plus class). Additionally, by that time, the PARENTS had been informed of the District’s service options, such as the ASSIST program and the SMILE program, and that STUDENT was already receiving those services. Moreover, at the September 2004 IEP meeting, when FATHER requested in-home services for STUDENT, the District discussed its BRIDGE program, which is a program that provides in-home services to students within the District. Furthermore, as was discussed above, FATHER also testified at hearing that during the prior school year, he became very involved in decisions regarding STUDENT’s special education placement and services and he researched on his own information regarding options available to STUDENT. From the above evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the District complied with any obligation it had to provide the PARENTS information regarding the continuum of program options available for STUDENT and the PARENTS in fact had already known about the program options prior to the September IEP meeting.

2. Failing to consider the independent educational evaluations obtained by the PARENTS, and failing to consider input from STUDENT’s private service providers

The Student alleges that the District failed to consider the independent evaluations presented to the IEP team at the September 2004 IEP meeting. The evaluations were those of Dr. Schmidt-Lackner and Dr. Chehrazi, and from BECA. Additionally, the Student also argues that the District failed to consider the information provided by his parents because the District refused to accept the findings of the private assessors and to adopt the proposed goals and objectives from BECA. The evidence did not support these claims.

One of the underpinnings of the IDEA was the intent of the Congress to strengthen the role of parents by providing them with a meaningful opportunity to participate in the education of their children. See 20 U.S.C. § 1400(c)(5)(B). As stated above, California Education Code section 56341.5(a) states that each district convening an IEP meeting for a disabled child shall take steps to ensure that the child’s parents are present at the meeting “or are afforded the opportunity to participate.” Similarly, California Education Code section 56341(f) states that parents of disabled children have the right to present information to the IEP team in person or through a representative and the right to participate in meetings relating to eligibility for special education and related services, recommendations, and program planning. Regarding independent educational evaluations, if the parents disagree with the district’s assessment, they have the right to obtain their own independent assessment at public expense and to have the results of that assessment considered by the district. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(c)(1)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(c)(1); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b).

The undisputed evidence establishes that Mr. Benton and Ms. Chavez attended the UCLA meeting in September and participated in the discussions regarding the UCLA assessment and program findings. Additionally, there is no dispute that STUDENT’s IEP team reviewed the assessments from UCLA, Dr. Chehrazi, and from BECA at the September 2004 IEP meeting. That meeting was attended by the PARENTS, two representatives from BECA, and the PARENTS’ educational advocate. The tape and transcript of the IEP meeting establish that the PARENTS and their representative and service providers fully participated in the IEP discussions and provided input throughout the meeting. (Footnote 20) Despite the Student’s allegations, he failed to allege any specific instances when his parents’ information was not considered by the IEP team or to describe how he was prejudiced by any failure in this regard. Although there is no dispute that the District has not implemented the recommendations from the assessments and service providers at BECA, there is no requirement in the law that the District do so. As was determined above, the District is entitled to an opportunity to assess STUDENT to determine his present levels of performance, and that information obtained by the District may be used as the basis for developing its own goals and objectives. Additionally, no information was offered to establish that the PARENTS or their representatives were denied the right to present information to the IEP team or that any of them were denied the opportunity to participate during the IEP meeting. Rather, as was discussed above, his parents were present and were represented by an advocate experienced in special education law during the September IEP meeting.

In conclusion, from the above, there is no indication that the District failed to consider any of the information provided by the PARENTS.

3. Failing to identify the name of the District personnel who would provide aide services to STUDENT pursuant to the September 2004 IEP

The Student contends that the District committed a procedural violation by failing to identify on the September 2004 IEP the name of the person the District intends to use to provide aide services to STUDENT. In support of his contention, the Student relies on the Ninth Circuit holding in Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 513 U.S. 965, 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3). The District disputes that it is required to state the name of the specific aide on the IEP. The Hearing Officer finds that the Student reads the holding of Union too broadly and finds that the law supports the District’s position.

Districts are required to give written prior notice to the parents of a disabled child whenever they propose to initiate or change, or refuse to initiate or change, the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child, or the provision of a free appropriate public education to the child. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3). According to the Ninth Circuit, among the procedural violations that may constitute a denial of FAPE is the failure of a school district to make a formal, written offer of placement in compliance with the IDEA’s procedural requirements. Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d at 1526. In this case, there is no question that the September IEP clearly identifies the District’s offered placement as the Preppy Plus class and sets forth the type and frequency of the services offered. The Student’s main concern for obtaining the identity of the aide is to determine the appropriateness of the training of the aide. However, nothing in the Union opinion requires the District to define its offer with that level of specificity. To require otherwise would be to limit the District’s flexibility in making personnel decisions and to determine the qualifications of its employees. The Union Court simply did not intend school districts to be bound this way. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was not obligated to identify on the IEP the name of the aide it offered to STUDENT. (Footnote 21)

4. Failing to provide prior written notice of the District’s refusal to reimburse the PARENTS for the cost of privately procured services

The Student alleges that the District failed to give prior written notice of its refusal to reimburse his parents for the cost of privately procured services, namely the UCLA placement and the BECA services. The law does not support the Student’s contention.

As discussed above, districts are required to give written prior notice to the parents of the child whenever they propose to initiate or change, or refuse to initiate or change, the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child, or the provision of a free appropriate public education to the child. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3). That notice generally must include a description of the proposed or refused action, an explanation of the reasons, a description of any other options considered, a description of each evaluation procedure, test, record, or report relied upon, a description of any other factors that are relevant, and information regarding procedural safeguards and sources for assistance in understanding the provisions of this part. 34 C.F.R. § 300.503. Such notice provides the parents with information that can help them to make informed decisions about their child’s education. The notice is also important in that it helps ensure that there is a clear record of what placement, services and assistance were offered to the student and when they were offered. Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d at 1526. School districts are not required to provide written notice in response to informal inquiries by parents. Bend-Lapine School District v. DW, 152 F.3d 923 (9th Cir. 1998).

In this case, the Student assumes that the District must provide prior written notice of its refusal to reimburse his parents for the cost of the privately procured services. The law does not require this. Rather, as is stated above, the law only requires prior written notice be provided when the school district seeks to propose to initiate or change, or refuse to initiate or change, the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child, or the provision of a free appropriate public education to the child. Because the law does not require the District to provide this notice to the PARENTS for their request for reimbursement, the Hearing Officer concludes that there was no procedural violation here. (Footnote 22)

B. Substantive Appropriateness

STUDENT’s placement and services for the 2004-2005 school year and extended school year is governed by the March 2004, April 2004, June 2004, and September 2004 IEPs. At his annual review in March 2004, STUDENT’s IEP team proposed goals and objectives to be implemented from March 2004 through March 2005. Additionally, at the April 2004 IEP meeting, the IEP team agreed that STUDENT’s services for his kindergarten year should be changed to (1) speech and language therapy one hour per week in a small group, (2) occupational therapy services one hour per week in the clinic and one hour per week in the classroom, (3) academic and social instruction by the ASSIST team for forty minutes per week each, and (4) additional ASSIST services in the lunch group for forty-five minutes per week.

Because the team disagreed regarding STUDENT’s placement, his placement decision was not made until the administrative review in June 2004. At that meeting, the team agreed that STUDENT would be placed in the District’s Preppy Plus regular education kindergarten class for three hundred minutes per day. Then, on September 16, 2004, the District offered (1) to increase STUDENT’s speech and language services by sixty minutes per week of individual therapy and (2) to provide STUDENT with a one-to-one paraeducator for five hours per day for five days per week.

At the September 2004 IEP meeting, the PARENTS consented to the District’s offer of placement in the Preppy Plus class and speech and language services and occupational therapy services. However, the PARENTS disputed the appropriateness of the ASSIST services and the paraeducator services. As discussed above, although the PARENTS consented to the placement in the Preppy Plus class, they never made STUDENT available for that placement. Instead, they privately procured intensive home-based ABA/DTT services from BECA in August 2004 and continued to obtain those services following the September 2004 IEP meeting.

For the 2004-2005 school year and extended school year, the Student reasserts his prior contentions regarding the substantive inappropriateness of the District’s provided program and placement. Specifically, he contends that his IEPs were not designed to meet his unique needs or reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit because (1) they included goals and objectives that were not measurable and/or not sufficiently challenging, (2) they did not include goals and objectives to address all of his areas of deficit, (3) they did not include a behavior support plan, and (4) they failed to include appropriate services and placement in the least restrictive environment. Moreover, unlike for prior school years, the Student also contends that the District failed to provide services that comported with his September 2004 IEP because it failed to provide him with direct occupational therapy services for sixty minutes per week.

1. Was the District’s offer for the 2004-2005 school year and extended school year designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit?

a. Time period from the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year until the September 16, 2004 IEP meeting i. What were STUDENT’s unique needs?

In determining whether FAPE was offered for the time period from the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year through the date of the September 16, 2004 IEP meeting, the Hearing Officer will look only to the information the IEP had at the time of the District’s offer. As was discussed above, according to Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d at 1149, a review of the appropriateness of a district’s program must focus on adequacy of proposed program at the time it was drafted and it is necessary to have some understanding of what unique educational needs the District knew or should have known about at the time it made its placement offer.

In light of the Adams standard, the Hearing Officer concludes that, as of June 2004 when the District made its placement offer for the 2004-2005 school year at the administrative review, the information that it had regarding STUDENT’s needs was substantially similar to the information that was shared at the March 2004 IEP meeting. No events occurred between March 2004 and June 2004 that would have significantly changed the District’s understanding of STUDENT’s needs. Thus, as of June 2004, STUDENT’s needs were as determined above for the end of the 2003-2004 school year. Specifically, STUDENT required instruction in an environment with a low student-to-teacher ratio and a highly structured educational program, social skills instruction, exposure to typical peers, speech and language therapy, exposure to an intensive language-based curriculum, occupational therapy services to improve his fine motor skills and his ability to attend to task and control his behaviors, and a special education program that addressed his behaviors related to his transition difficulties.

ii. Was the District’s offer designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit?

AA. Goals and objectives

The goals the District offered to STUDENT for the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year were the goals and objectives contained in the March 2004 IEP that were analyzed above. Therefore, for the same reasons set forth above, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives were measurable and the IEP did not require ASSIST-specific goals and objectives. Additionally, for the same reasons set forth above, the District’s IEP inappropriately failed to include goals and objectives in the area of behavior.

BB. Behavior intervention plan

For the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year, the District continued to fail to develop a positive behavioral interventions and strategies for STUDENT. Because STUDENT’s behavioral needs in June 2004 had not significantly changed since March 2004, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District inappropriately failed to develop positive behavioral interventions and strategies, such as a behavior support plan, for STUDENT for the same reasons described above.

CC. Placement and services

For this time period, the Student does not dispute the appropriateness of the Preppy Plus class or the level and frequency of the OT or speech and language services. Rather, the Student disputes only the appropriateness of the ASSIST services. In comparison to the ASSIST services provided in the March 2004 IEP, the District increased the ASSIST services to include forty-five minutes per week of lunch group services. Because the ASSIST services had not changed significantly between March 2004 and June 2004, and because the Student’s needs had not changed significantly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offer of ASSIST services was appropriate for the same reasons described above.

b. Time period from the September 16, 2004 IEP meeting until the PARENTS refused consent to the District’s assessments on October 7, 2004 i. What are STUDENT’s unique needs?

During the three months following the June 2004 IEP but before the 2004-2005 school year began, STUDENT was placed by his parents in the UCLA Neuropsychiatric Childhood Partial Hospitalization Program. Then, in August 2004, the PARENTS began privately providing STUDENT home-based ABA/DTT services from BECA. Following the end of STUDENT’s participation in the UCLA program in September 2004, the District was notified by the PARENTS and UCLA that STUDENT had made significant academic progress and that his goals and objectives from March 2004 may no longer be appropriate for him. Additionally, as was discussed above, BECA informed the District at the September IEP meeting that STUDENT’s behaviors were increasing in frequency and severity. Thus, only three months after the District made its offer for the kindergarten year, it was provided additional information that it did not have when it made its offer.

Because the additional information provided in September 2004 challenged the appropriateness of the District’s goals and objectives and offer of ASSIST services, the District was required to review and revise the June 2004 IEP offer, if necessary. However, as was noted above, the District questioned the validity of the information provided by the Student’s private assessors and providers. It was also found above that the District has a right to assess STUDENT in light of the privately provided information before it reviews and revises STUDENT’s IEP. Thus, the District was not required to rely on this new information and to change its understanding of STUDENT’s needs based only on this information.

In summary, the appropriateness of the District’s offer must be gauged according to the information it had of STUDENT’s needs as of June 2004. The District had no obligation to amend its offer based on the information from the Student’s providers without first assessing STUDENT.

ii. Was the District’s offer designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit?

The only changes to the District’s offered program at the September 2004 IEP meeting were the addition of more speech and language services (which the Student does not dispute) and the offer of a one-to-one aide. Both parties agree that STUDENT requires a one-to-one aide trained in ABA to address his behaviors while in class. However, the Student contends that the aide must be involved with his home program and trained by BECA, so that he or she would be able to provide continuity of services throughout the classroom and home environments. The Student’s argument fails.

Based on the information the District had of STUDENT’s needs as of June 2004, it was found above that the District’s offer of ASSIST services, in combination with the other undisputed placement and services, were designed to meet his unique needs and were reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. Therefore, based on the information available to the District, STUDENT did not require additional intensive home-based ABA/DTT services. Additionally, the District witnesses testified persuasively that the level-two aide that would have provided STUDENT services and would have been trained by the District on ABA/DTT methodologies, as well has have attended a three-day training on autism. Additionally, according to Aaron Benton, STUDENT’s aide would have had experience and training working with autistic children through the ASSIST program. Mr. Benton also persuasively testified that STUDENT had worked with two level-two ASSIST aides in the past at LAUNCH and that they were successful at helping STUDENT with his education. Although the Student’s witnesses testified that the aide must have more training in ABA/DTT training than is provided to the District staff, there was no evidence provided that his unique needs required an aide with more extensive training. Based on the credible and persuasive evidence provided by the District that its level-two aide was trained to work with STUDENT and could have met his behavioral needs, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of aide services was appropriate.

c. October 7, 2004, through the end of the IEP term on March 12, 2005 (Footnote 23)

It was found above that conditions warrant the District’s reassessment of STUDENT but that the PARENTS inappropriately denied consent for the District’s assessment. To explain, the District has a right to assess STUDENT and to determine his present levels of performance and need for home-based services and behavioral interventions. Because the District has a right to assess STUDENT, by refusing to consent to the District’s assessment plan by letter dated October 7, 2004, the PARENTS in effect waived STUDENT’s right to FAPE services from that point forward. In Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1315 (9th Cir. 1987), the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals held that “if the parents want Gregory to receive special education under the Act, they are obligated to permit such testing.” Similarly, in Andress v. Cleveland Independent School District, 64 F.3d 176, 178 (5th Cir. 1995), the Fifth Circuit concluded that “a parent who desires for her child to receive special education must allow the school district to evaluate the child...there is no exception to this rule.” See also Vander Malle v. Ambach, 673 F.2d 49, 53 (2d Cir. 1983).

Because the PARENTS refused to make STUDENT reasonably available for an assessment and to permit the District to assess STUDENT when conditions warranted a reassessment, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was no longer entitled to special education services after October 7, 2004, when his parents refused consent. Accordingly, from October 7, 2004, through the end of the IEP term on March 12, 2005, STUDENT was not entitled to an offer of FAPE. Additionally, STUDENT will not be entitled to a FAPE until his parents make him available for the District’s assessment.

2. Did the District’s provided program comport with STUDENT’s IEP?

As was discussed above, written parental consent is necessary before a child is “required to participate in all or part of any special education program.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(a). If a parent consents to only part of a special education placement, the local educational agency must implement the parts of the placement to which the parent has consented. Id.

Although STUDENT’s September 2004 IEP team did not reach consensus regarding his goals and objectives or placement, the team agreed that STUDENT required OT services for one hour per week in the clinic and for one hour per week in class or on the playground. There is no dispute that the District provided STUDENT with the one hour per week of clinic-based OT. The Student contends that the District failed to provide him with the one hour per week of OT services that was to be provided in the classroom or on the playground. The District acknowledges that STUDENT was not provided these services, but contends that the PARENTS never made STUDENT available for its offered placement in the Preppy Plus class and, therefore, STUDENT could not have been provided those services.

The Hearing Officer finds the District’s argument persuasive. Although the PARENTS testified that they offered to bring STUDENT to school to receive his OT services, they never agreed to allow him to attend the Preppy Plus class. As was stated above, the IEP specifically states that the services would be provided in the classroom or on the playground. Additionally, the classroom identified in the IEP was the Preppy Plus classroom. Because STUDENT was never placed in the Preppy Plus classroom and therefore was not available for playground activities with his Preppy Plus class, he was not available for the OT services that were to be provided in the classroom or on the playground. Thus, the District had no obligation to provide STUDENT with those services.

****

In summary, it was found above that the District complied with all relevant procedural requirements during this time. Additionally, it was found above that additional assessments were warranted to determine STUDENT’s present levels of performance and his need for home-based services and behavior interventions, and that the District may conduct its assessments over the parents’ refusal of consent. Because the PARENTS inappropriately denied consent to assess, STUDENT was not entitled to a FAPE beginning in October 7, 2004, when the PARENTS denied consent to assess.

Regarding the District’s offer from the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year until October 7, 2004, it was found above that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE in all areas except the area of behavior. Similar to prior years, the District failed to develop goals and objectives for STUDENT in the area of behavior and it failed to develop a behavior plan for STUDENT. Regarding the Student’s contention that the District failed to provide him with agreed upon classroom-based OT services, it was found above that STUDENT was not placed by his parents in the Preppy Plus class and therefore he was not available to receive those services.

In conclusion, the District denied STUDENT a FAPE from the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year through October 7, 2004, because it failed to address STUDENT’s behavior needs. However, upon STUDENT’s return to the District in September 2004, conditions warranted an assessment of STUDENT and, thus, the District was entitled to assess STUDENT. Because the PARENTS improperly denied the District permission to conduct the assessment, STUDENT was not entitled to a FAPE beginning on October 7, 2004.

VII. Are the PARENTS entitled to reimbursement for the independent educational evaluations conducted by Dr. Susan Schmidt-Lackner, Dr. Avazeh Cherazi, and BECA?

The Student contends that the District’s March 2003 assessment was inappropriate and he requests reimbursement for the independent educational evaluations conducted by Dr. Susan Schmidt-Lackner, Dr. Chehrazi, and by BECA. The District contends that its March 2003 assessment was appropriate. Accordingly, the District requests that the Student’s request for reimbursement be denied.

California Education Code section 56329(b) provides that a parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation from a qualified specialist at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment conducted by the educational agency. However, if the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent evaluation. Id. As described above, for an assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of California Education Code sections 56320, 56322, and 56324.

The Student’s primary basis for requesting reimbursement for his IEEs is that, according to the Student, the District’s assessment did not contain sufficient information to aid in the development of an appropriate IEP for him. The Student’s contention is unpersuasive and does not provide a legal basis to warrant reimbursement of his independent educational evaluations. As was discussed above, the Student did not contend that the District’s March 2003 assessment was conducted inappropriately pursuant California Education Code sections 56320, 56322, and 56324, or dispute the validity of the information contained in the assessment report. Contrary to the Student’s contention, nothing in the law provides that a school district’s failure to provide appropriate placements and services results in the right to reimbursement for independent educational evaluations when the school district’s assessments are otherwise appropriate under the law.

The Student also contends that he is entitled to reimbursement for his IEEs because the District failed to timely respond to his request for IEEs. Federal law requires school districts to respond to a parent’s request for an independent assessment “without unnecessary delay.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b)(2). It is undisputed that the PARENTS requested the independent assessments at the beginning of June 2004 and that they obtained STUDENT’s IEEs at the end of June 2004, but the District did not provide them with written notice of its refusal to reimburse them for the assessments until November 2004. During these five months, the District wrote the PARENTS a letter requesting information to evaluate the parents’ request. Additionally, the District requested permission to assess STUDENT in September 2004. The PARENTS, however, refused to provide the District with specifics regarding their dispute with the District’s assessment other than that they did not trust the District’s assessment and they refused the District’s request for assessment.

While the five-month delay in responding to the PARENTS’ request suggests that the District did not respond “without unnecessary delay,” the law does not provide any clear guidance as to what an appropriate remedy might be under these circumstances. Although the Student contends that the procedural violation alone would entitle him to reimbursement, he provides no legal support for his contention, particularly when he would otherwise not be entitled to the reimbursement because most of the District’s assessments are appropriate. Furthermore, there is no nexus between the District’s delay in providing the PARENTS notice of its refusal to reimburse them for their IEEs and the PARENTS’ procurement of the IEEs. Rather, the IEEs were obtained within weeks of the PARENTS’ request for IEEs. However, the law is clear that reimbursement for IEEs is available when the District’s assessments are deemed to be inappropriate under the law. Additionally, as was discussed above, the District’s assessment was found to be inappropriate only in the area of behavior. Thus, the PARENTS might be entitled to reimbursement for independent assessments in the area of behavior.

Based on the Student’s alternative contention that the District failed to assess him in all areas of suspected disability, the Hearing Officer concludes that the Student is entitled to reimbursement for an independent educational evaluation in the area of behavior. To explain, it was found above that the District’s March 2003 assessment was appropriate, but that the District failed to initiate a behavior assessment of STUDENT in May 2003 when it was on notice that behavior was an area of suspected disability. Specifically, it was found above that many of the behaviors identified in the District’s March 2003 assessment were later exhibited at school and home and interfered with STUDENT’s education. Hence, although the District’s March 2003 assessment was appropriate at the time it was conducted, conditions warranted additional assessments in behavior beginning in May 2003 and the District inappropriately failed to assess STUDENT.

Of the Student’s IEEs, only one of the assessments, i.e., the BECA assessment, evaluated STUDENT’s behavior and made specific recommendations regarding how to address his behaviors. The BECA assessment was conducted at the end of June 2004 and was conducted by Janet Yi, the co-owner of BECA and a certified behavior analyst. As part of the assessment, Ms. Yi reviewed STUDENT’s educational records and conducted observations of STUDENT at school and home. From her assessment, Ms. Yi recommended that STUDENT receive behavioral services to teach him socialization and communication skills to increase appropriate social interaction, to teach him increased tolerance of teaching situations, to teach increased tolerance of frustration, and to teach replacement behaviors. Because BECA specifically evaluated STUDENT’s behavior difficulties, the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for this assessment.

However, the assessments by Dr. Schmidt-Lackner and Dr. Chehrazi are not reimbursable. Although each assessment discussed STUDENT’s behaviors to some extent, the assessments were not conducted for the purpose of assessing the nature and extent of STUDENT’s behavior difficulties. For example, Dr. Schmidt-Lackner’s report resulted from a consultation in her office and did not appear to include any direct behavior assessment of STUDENT. Rather, Dr. Schmidt-Lackner stated in her report that she recommends further behavioral assessments for STUDENT. Along the same lines, Dr. Chehrazi recommended in her report that a “functional assessment” be conducted for STUDENT as a “systematic process” to “operationally define the challenging behavior/s, identify factors that lead to the behavior, … identify variables that maintain the behavior…identify possible hypothesis as to the function of the behavior, and conduct direct observations to verify the hypothesis.” While Dr. Chehrazi recommended that a functional assessment be completed, she did not conduct such an assessment herself. Because neither of these IEEs addressed the area in which the District inappropriately failed to assess STUDENT, the request for reimbursement of these assessments is denied.

In conclusion, the District was found to have inappropriately failed to assess STUDENT only in the area of behavior. Because the BECA assessment specifically evaluated STUDENT’s behavior, the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for that assessment. However, the IEEs conducted by Dr. Schmidt-Lackner and Dr. Chehrazi were not behavior assessments and are not reimbursable. Additionally, the PARENTS are being granted reimbursement for the BECA behavioral assessment and, therefore, they are already being reimbursed for an assessment to remedy the District’s failure to assess STUDENT in the area of behavior. Accordingly, the Student’s requests for reimbursement for the IEEs from Dr. Schmidt-Lackner and Dr. Chehrazi are denied. (Footnote 24)

VIII. Are the PARENTS entitled to reimbursement for privately procured services from the UCLA Early Childhood Partial Hospitalization Program and from BECA?

The Student requests reimbursement for services from the UCLA Early Childhood Partial Hospitalization Program and from BECA. When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i). Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under IDEA and are reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 369; Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir 1994). The Burlington rule of reimbursement is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parents are found to be the exact proper placement or services required under the IDEA. Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). However, the parents’ placement still must meet certain basic requirements of the IDEA, such as the requirement that the placement addresses the child’s needs and provides him educational benefit. Florence County Sch. Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13-14, 114 S.Ct. 361 (1993).

It was found above that the District denied the Student a FAPE in March 2003 by failing to convene a timely IEP meeting (a denial of approximately eight days of school), and from October 2003 through October 7, 2004, by failing to assess STUDENT in the area of behavior, failing to develop positive behavioral interventions and strategies to address his behaviors, and failing to include goals and objectives in his IEPs to address his behaviors. It was also found above that, STUDENT’s behavior difficulties adversely affected his ability to access his education and that behavior interventions and supports were necessary components of STUDENT’s educational program.

Regarding the UCLA program, Dr. Schmidt-Lackner recommended STUDENT’s placement in this program for “a full interdisciplinary team evaluation and formulation of a treatment plan.” According to Dr. Paparella, the UCLA program is a medical evaluation and treatment program for children with autism. The children attend the program for part of each day over the course of three to eight weeks. STUDENT attended the UCLA program for six hours per day from July 1 through September 17, 2004. During his time at the UCLA program, STUDENT was taught academics and other skills in a “highly contextual manner in a classroom environment” and with multiple modalities. (Footnote 25) For example, the UCLA staff worked on many of STUDENT’s goals and objectives, such as recognition of colors and shapes. According to the UCLA report and the testimony of Dr. Paparella, STUDENT made progress on those goals and was able to master five different shapes in different contexts and identify seven colors receptively and expressively in generalized settings by the end of his placement at UCLA.

Dr. Paparella testified that she believed that STUDENT needed to stay in the program to address his maladaptive behaviors and his learning needs. According to the UCLA report and Dr. Paparella’s testimony, STUDENT’s behavioral needs were assessed and addressed during the program. For example, the specialists at UCLA used different approaches in different situations to teach STUDENT to control his behaviors, including increasing predictability by giving him visual and verbal warnings to facilitate transition difficulties, using a token economy system to encourage positive behavior, providing social skills instruction to teach more appropriate ways to communicate, and monitoring his behaviors to teach him positive responses. Because the UCLA program addressed STUDENT’s behaviors and was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit in this area, the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for those services.

Regarding the BECA services, Ms. Yi testified that STUDENT began receiving BECA services at the end of August 2004 and continued to receive BECA services during the course of the due process hearing. During October 2004, Ms. Yi did an analysis of STUDENT’s behaviors and developed an assessment plan for him. At the time, STUDENT exhibited behaviors to seek attention, to escape demands, and to communicate his emotions and needs. After implementing the behavior plan for approximately one month, Ms. Yi and the BECA providers developed another behavior plan to address STUDENT’s changing behaviors. By that time, STUDENT’s behaviors had increased to stripping and aggression. According to Ms. Yi and Jason Baker, STUDENT’s other case supervisor, STUDENT’s behaviors have been so severe that they have interfered with his ability to work on most of his academic and social interaction goals and objectives. Mr. Baker testified that the increase in STUDENT’s behaviors were likely attributable to an “extinction burst” in which his behaviors increase as behavioral interventions are applied and the reinforcement for the behavior is removed. In theory, according to Mr. Baker, the Student’s behavior should decrease as he learns more appropriate replacement behaviors. According to the testimony of Ms. Yi, Ms. Paparella, and Dr. Chehrazi, the intensive home-based services provided by BECA were necessary to remediate the District’s failure to provide appropriate behavior services to STUDENT in the past. Because the BECA services included the development and implementation of behavior plans to address STUDENT’s behaviors, the Hearing Officer finds that those services were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.

Because the Student was denied necessary behavioral interventions and goals and objectives for approximately one school year spanning October 2004 through October 2005, the Hearing Officer finds that the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of BECA services, which were obtained close to the time of the denial. Specifically, the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for the BECA services from September 18, 2004, when the UCLA program ended, through the date of this Decision. In light of the order for reimbursement of the UCLA placement above, the PARENTS are not entitled to the BECA services provided during the same time period.

In conclusion, it was found above that the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the UCLA program and for the cost of the BECA services from September 18, 2004, through the date of this Decision.

IX. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?

The Student requests compensatory education from the date of the Decision through the end of the 2005 extended school year in the form of prospective placement in the Preppy Plus general education kindergarten class with the services a one-to-one aide from BECA for fifteen hours per week and intensive home-based ABA/DTT services from BECA for twenty hours per week, with ten to twenty hours per month of BECA consultation services. According to the Student, this combination of placement and services is both appropriate as a prospective offer of FAPE for him for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year and extended school year, as well as appropriate compensatory education services. The Student contends that this combination of placement and services would remedy the past denials of FAPE alleged for all time periods at issue in this case.

Courts have consistently held that the authority to award compensatory education is derived from 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i)(2)(B)(iii), which authorizes a court to grant such “relief as it determines is appropriate.” “The purpose of compensatory education is to replace lost educational services.” Moubry v. Independent School District Number 696, 951 F.Supp. 867 (D. Minn. 1996). Compensatory education may be an appropriate equitable remedy when the responsible educational authority has failed to provide a disabled child with an appropriate education as required by the IDEA. Todd v. Andrews, 933 F.2d 1576 (11th Cir. 1991). There is, however, no obligation to compensate the child by providing a day of education for each educational day lost. “Compensatory education is not a contractual remedy, but an equitable remedy, part of the Court’s resources in crafting appropriate relief...Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489 (9th Cir. 1994). Thus, when considering a request for compensatory education, it is first necessary to determine whether a school district failed to provide a FAPE. If that issue is answered in the affirmative, the subsequent question is not what precise services were missed but, rather, what compensatory services are necessary to provide an appropriate education under the law.

It was found above that the District denied the Student a FAPE in March 2003 by failing to convene a timely IEP meeting (a denial of approximately eight days of school), and from October 2003, through October 7, 2004, by failing to assess STUDENT in the area of behavior, failing to develop positive behavioral interventions and strategies, such as a behavior support plan, to address his behaviors, and failing to include goals and objectives in his IEPs to address his behaviors. Although the Student was able to make some educational progress while he attended school within the District, the evidence established that his behaviors were disruptive, frequently occurred for periods of up to five weeks, and that they impeded his learning and his ability to access his education.

According to Ms. Yi, the District’s failure to appropriately address STUDENT’s behaviors resulted in school staff inadvertently reinforcing STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors. To explain, she understood that STUDENT’s teacher and service providers would switch activities to those STUDENT liked in order to get him to behave. In her view, the teachers were rewarding STUDENT for his bad behaviors and did not teach him positive strategies and responses. Consistent with Ms. Yi’s testimony, the evidence established that STUDENT’s behaviors persisted and worsened through the years. Although Ms. Schilling and Ms. Litton tried to respond to STUDENT’s behaviors, they have not been trained in behavior modification and their responses to STUDENT have been inconsistent. Thus, there is no evidence that the strategies that they applied resulted in any reduction in STUDENT’s overall behaviors. As was described above, STUDENT’s tantrumming, noncompliance, and other transition difficulties were exhibited from the time he originally entered the District through the date of the hearing. According to Ms. Yi, the District’s failure to provide STUDENT with behavioral supports and goals and objectives resulted in behaviors that must now be remediated.

Similarly, according to Dr. Paparella, who assessed and worked with STUDENT at the UCLA program during his two month program, STUDENT requires at least one year of intensive behavioral interventions for STUDENT to “come close” to his peers. As was discussed above, Dr. Paparella and the UCLA assessment team evaluated STUDENT’s academic and behavioral needs for six hours per day over several weeks. From their extensive evaluation, they obtained detailed information about STUDENT’s deficits and present levels of performance. From her knowledge of STUDENT’s behavioral deficits, Dr. Paparella recommended that STUDENT receive one year of intensive behavioral interventions in the form of a minimum of twenty hours per week of home-based services and fifteen hours per week of aide services to accompany STUDENT at school. Ms. Yi, who implements the behavioral intervention program that Dr. Paparella recommended, also testified that at least twenty hours of supervision services is necessary to support the level of services recommended.

Although Dr. Paparella’s recommendation assumed that STUDENT also required remediation in the area of preacademics, which was not found to be true by the Hearing Officer, the credible and persuasive testimony of the PARENTS and the BECA providers indicates that STUDENT’s behaviors have dramatically increased recently. Mr. Baker and Dr. Paparella persuasively testified that the increase in behaviors could be due to an “extinction burst,” in which the negative reinforcement for STUDENT’s negative behaviors is removed and STUDENT is increasing his behaviors to get the desired response. Mr. Baker also credibly testified that part of STUDENT’s increased behaviors appear to be attributable to the persistence of his behaviors.

In light of Dr. Paparella’s undisputed recommendation and the current severity of STUDENT’s behaviors, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT requires as compensatory education some of the services recommended by Dr. Paparella. (Footnote 26) The Hearing Officer notes first that it was found above that the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for the UCLA program and approximately six months of reimbursement for the BECA services. However, the Hearing Officer concludes that additional services are required to compensate STUDENT for lost educational opportunity. Thus, although the Student was granted some reimbursement, he also requires compensatory education services as recommended by Dr. Paparella from the date of this Decision through the end of the 2005 extended school year. Accordingly, the services STUDENT has already received, combined with the compensatory education award above, would approximate the year of intensive behavioral interventions recommended by Dr. Paparella.

In conclusion, the Student is entitled to compensatory education in the form of twenty hours per week of home-based services and fifteen hours per week of classroom-based aide services, with twenty hours per week of supervision services. Moreover, these compensatory education services are to be provided through the end of the District’s 2005 extended school year. Given STUDENT’s difficulty with transitions, the fact that the school year is nearing an end, and because BECA has been working with STUDENT on controlling his behaviors for several months, the Hearing Officer orders that the District provide the foregoing compensatory education services through BECA.

ORDER

1. The District shall, within ten calendar days of receipt of proof from the PARENTS, reimburse the PARENTS for the cost of the BECA behavioral observation assessment conducted in June 2004.

2. The District shall, within ten calendar days of receipt of proof from the PARENTS, reimburse the PARENTS for the cost of the UCLA program provided from July 1 through September 17, 2004, and for the cost of the BECA services provided from September 18, 2004, through the date of this Decision.

3. The District shall provide, as compensatory education services, twenty hours per week of home-based BECA services and fifteen hours per week of BECA aide services in STUDENT’s classroom. These services are to also include twenty hours per month of BECA supervision services. Moreover, these compensatory education services are to be provided from the date of this Decision through the end of the District’s 2005 extended school year.

4. The District may conduct an assessment of STUDENT based on its September 2004 assessment plan. The District must convene an IEP meeting to discuss the results of the assessment and to revise STUDENT’s IEP, as necessary, within fifty calendar days of the date of this Decision, excepting days between the pupil’s regular school sessions, terms, or days of school vacations in excess of five schooldays.

5. All other requests for remedies are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

I. Did the District fail to timely locate and identify STUDENT as a child with autism pursuant to its “child-find” obligation from September 2002 through January 11, 2003, when it first initiated an assessment of STUDENT at his mother’s request? -The District prevailed on this issue.

II. Did the District appropriately assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability from March 2003 to the present? -The Student prevailed to the limited extent that the District failed to initiate an assessment of him in the area of behavior beginning May 29, 2003, through September 16, 2004, when the District offered to assess his behavior. The District predominantly prevailed on this issue in that it was found above that it assessed STUDENT appropriately in all other areas.

III. Did the District commit procedural and substantive violations that resulted in a denial of a FAPE to STUDENT during the 2002-2003 school year and extended school year? -The Student prevailed on this issue only to the extent that a denial of FAPE was found due to the District’s failure to convene a timely IEP meeting by eight school days. Although it was found that the District also failed to initiate an assessment of STUDENT’s behaviors by May 29, 2003, this failure did not result in a denial of FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year. The District prevailed on all of the other contentions raised by the Student.

IV. Did the District commit procedural and substantive violations that resulted in a denial of a FAPE to STUDENT during the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year? -The Student prevailed on this issue only to the extent that a denial of FAPE was found due to the District’s failure to assess his behaviors, to develop positive behavioral interventions and strategies, and include goals and objectives regarding behavior in his IEPs. Additionally, the Student prevailed on the procedural claim that the District failed to provide his educational records in a timely manner, but this violation did not result in any prejudice to the Student and was unrelated to the remedies sought in this case. The District prevailed on all of the other contentions raised by the Student.

V. Is the District entitled to conduct an assessment of STUDENT pursuant to its September 16, 2004 assessment plan? -The District prevailed on this issue.

VI. Did the District commit procedural and substantive violations that resulted in a denial of a FAPE to STUDENT during the 2004-2005 school year and extended school year? -The District prevailed on all procedural issues raised by the Student, many of which were unrelated to the remedies sought in this matter. Regarding the Student’s substantive claims, the Student prevailed to the extent that it was determined that the District denied him a FAPE from the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year through October 6, 2004, by failing to assess his behavioral needs, provide positive behavioral interventions and strategies, and include behavior goals and objectives in his IEP. The District prevailed to the extent that it was determined that the Student was not entitled to a FAPE beginning October 7, 2004.

VII. Are the PARENTS entitled to reimbursement for the independent educational evaluations conducted by Dr. Susan Schmidt-Lackner, Dr. Avazeh Cherazi, and BECA? -The Student prevailed on this issue to the extent that reimbursement was ordered for the June 2004 assessment conducted by BECA. The District substantially prevailed on this issue to the extent that reimbursement for the assessments by Dr. Schmidt-Lackner and Dr. Chehrazi was denied.

VIII. Are the PARENTS entitled to reimbursement for privately procured services from the UCLA Early Childhood Partial Hospitalization Program and from BECA? -The Student prevailed on this issue to the extent that reimbursement was awarded for the cost of the UCLA program and for the cost of the BECA services from September 17, 2004, through the date of the Decision.

IX. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?

-The Student prevailed on this issue to extent that compensatory education was awarded in the form of continued in-home and classroom aide services from BECA, with accompanying consultation services from BECA, from the date of the Decision until the end of the 2005 ESY.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Date: April 3, 2005 Van T. Vu, Hearing OfficerCalifornia Special Education Hearing Office

1 For purposes of organization and proper analysis, the Hearing Officer has reorganized and renumbered the issues raised by the parties. The Student raised all of the issues listed. Additionally, the District, in its own filing, also raised issues II and VII.

2 Pursuant to section 452, other matters that can be judicially noticed and that are not relevant to this issue are: (a) The decisional, constitutional, and statutory law of any state of the United States and the resolutions and private acts of the Congress of the United States and of the Legislature of this state; (b) Regulations and legislative enactments issued by or under the authority of the United States or any public entity in the United States; (c) Official acts of the legislative, executive, and judicial departments of the United States and of any state of the United States; (d) Records of (1) any court of this state or (2) any court of record of the United States or of any state of the United States; (e) Rules of court of (1) any court of this state or (2) any court of record of the United States or of any state of the United States; (f) The law of an organization of nations and of foreign nations and public entities in foreign nations.

3 MOTHER could not recall the exact date of her call to the District.

4 STUDENT’s overall cognitive development was uneven and delayed at the 30- to 36-month range. His pre-academic skills were also delayed and uneven at the 18-24 month range, with scattering through the 36-month level. Additionally, STUDENT’s language development was significantly delayed, with his auditory comprehension ranked in the 1st percentile and his expressive language ranked in the 3rd percentile. Moreover, STUDENT’s fine motor skills were delayed at the 24- to 30-month range, and his gross motor skills in the 25- to 30-month range.

5 Mr. Wyner cited 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b)(4), (e)(2).

6 To the extent the Student asserts that the District failed to timely assess him upon his mother’s referral for assessment in December 2003, the assertion is addressed in Issue No. 3, where it is found that the District inappropriately delayed initiating the assessment at that time.

7 See District’s Exhibit 23 at page 5.

8 To be more specific, Ms. Litton provided STUDENT twenty minutes per week of speech and language services from April 2003 through the end of the 2002-2003 school year in June 2003, for approximately one month during the 2003 extended school year, from the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year in September 2003 through the latter part of October 2003, and from April 2004 through approximately July 2004.

9 The 1997 Amendments to the IDEA also included other requirements that are not at issue in this case. For example, the student’s IEP must provide for the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum in accordance with the student’s unique needs and present levels of performance and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a).

10 The Student also claims, apparently in the alternative, that the District failed to provide the PARENTS with notice of any IEP meeting that was held to amend his IEP in May 2003. However, as was determined below, no IEP meeting was held to amend STUDENT’s IEP at that time and, therefore, there was no meeting for which notice needed to be given. Thus, it is unnecessary to resolve whether the District failed to provide the PARENTS with notice of an IEP meeting

11 The Student also contends that the District predetermined his placement and services rather than determining the Student’s placement at the IEP meetings based on his unique needs. The Student’s allegation is directly linked to his parents’ ability to participate in the IEP process and the development of his IEP. However, the District witnesses who attended the IEP all testified that they did not predetermine STUDENT’s placement, but came to the IEP meeting with their assessment findings and proposed goals and objectives. Additionally, the PARENTS acknowledge that they participated in the IEP meeting and had the opportunity to provide input and ask questions. For example, each of the goals and objectives were discussed with the PARENTS and they provided their initials at the bottom of each page of the goals and objectives to indicate that they had reviewed and approved the goals. Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that the PARENTS were aware that the recommendations of the District members of the IEP team were subject to their approval and thus were provided a meaningful opportunity to participate in the IEP process. See 64 Fed. Reg. 48 at 12478 (stating that school staff may come to IEP meeting prepared with evaluation findings and proposed recommendations regarding IEP content so long as there is full discussion with parents before finalization of IEP). In any event, because the placement has already been provided to the Student, and the Student now disputes the appropriateness of that placement, the parents’ ultimate concerns over the appropriateness of the program will be addressed below.

12 MOTHER testified that she could not recall the exact date of her call to the District.

13 The District presented no evidence as to the exact dates of the 2002-2003 winter break.

14 The Hearing Officer also notes that the Student did not request any remedy for this violation. Thus, it is puzzling why the issue was raised at all.

15 The Hearing Officer notes that at the April 2004 IEP meeting, the parents requested another SDC placement (the Preppy Plus Plus special day class) for the 2004-2005 school year.

16 See Student’s Exhibit 34 at page 13.

17 The Student also contends that the March 2004 goals and objectives were significantly similar to the ones developed for the prior IEP. However, the Student did not specifically allege that his present levels of performance were different from those determined by the District in March 2004 or that the goals and objectives were inappropriate because they failed to reflect his present levels of performance. Rather, the Student appears to contend that the similarity of the goals and objectives indicate that he did not make progress from the prior year. As was discussed above, this contention is not supported by the evidence. The Student also appears to assert that the March 2004 goals and objectives were inappropriate because some of the annual goals were met after his six-week placement at UCLA. However, while meeting goals might warrant the creation of additional goals and objectives at a later time, this fact alone does not establish that the goals as written in March 2004 were inappropriate. As was discussed above, the Student did not significantly challenge the District’s findings as to his present levels of performance at that time. 18 The Hearing Officer notes that it would be particularly difficult for the District to rely on, or evaluate the appropriateness of, BECA’s functional analysis assessment of STUDENT because BECA has never drafted a written report of its assessment and has amended its assessment and findings several times.

19 The Student also asserts that the District failed to timely request a due process hearing when the PARENTS refused consent to portions of the September 2004 IEP. Although the Student is correct that a school district is required to file for a due process hearing when consent to an IEP offer is refused and the district believes that the declined services are required to provide the student with a FAPE, the law does not define exactly when the District must file for due process. Regardless, the fact remains that the District in this case in fact filed for a due process hearing in December 2004 and the District used the time between September and December to attempt to resolve informally the dispute with the PARENTS without the need for a due process hearing, as is encouraged by federal and State special education law. The Student asserts only the technical violation of a rule and does not assert any prejudice that resulted. Additionally, any determination regarding whether a student was denied a FAPE is generally best determined by looking at the appropriateness of the district’s offer, rather than by speculating as to what could have happened had the matter proceeded to hearing more expeditiously.

20 It appears that the Student is contending that the District refused to consider the BECA information because the District declined to adopt the draft goals and objectives that were developed by BECA. As was discussed above, the District sought to conduct its own assessment in order to determine STUDENT’s present levels of performance to revise his goals and objectives. The Hearing Officer notes that the District’s request to assess proved to be prudent because, according to Ms. Yi and Mr. Baker from BECA, many of the goals and objectives BECA developed reflected skills that were too high for STUDENT to be implemented at that time.

21 Nevertheless, when asked about the aide, the District did provide the PARENTS at the September 2004 IEP meeting information about the minimum qualifications of an aide that would be provided to STUDENT.

22 Even if the District’s failure to provide prior written notice constituted a procedural violation, it is unclear what the remedy for such a violation would be. In any event, the Hearing Officer notes that the parents are awarded reimbursement for both the UCLA placement and the BECA services, as requested, in Issue No. 8 based on other reasons.

23 Although the Student raised FAPE issues through the end of the 2004-2005 school year and extended school year, all of his IEPs pertaining to the 2004-2005 school year offer educational programming only through March 12, 2005. Therefore, the District has only made an offer to STUDENT through that date and there is no evidence that by the close of the record in this matter the District was obligated to make an offer for STUDENT that would be effective past that date. March 12, 2005, would have been the date of STUDENT’s annual IEP review.

24 There was testimony at hearing that BECA eventually conducted a functional analysis assessment of STUDENT’s behaviors and developed a plan to address STUDENT’s behaviors. However, BECA never wrote a report summarizing its assessment and findings and the Student has not specifically asked for reimbursement for BECA’s FAA. To the extent that the Student requests reimbursement from BECA for behavioral services, including the FAA, the Hearing Officer will address the Student’s right to that reimbursement request below.

25 See Testimony of Dr. Paparella.

26 The Hearing Officer also notes that, pending the District’s assessments that will be conducted pursuant to its September 2004 assessment plan, the District has not offered to provide STUDENT with any positive behavioral interventions and strategies, behavior support plan, or behavior goals and objectives to address his behavioral needs.