California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 24, 1996
Student v. Fresno Unified School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 366-96, SN 235-96 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote
Fresno Unified must reimburse $1,090 for private counseling and pay limited mileage; independent assessment and language therapy claims denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The decision notes that a related federal lawsuit (E.D. Cal.) was dismissed with prejudice on February 9, 1996, by stipulation that referred the IDEA and Section 504 claims to due process. The decision itself records no later history.
Summary
The parent and the Fresno Unified School District each filed for a hearing after a federal lawsuit was dismissed by stipulation. The two cases were consolidated. The student was a 14-year-old eighth grader who uses a wheelchair. Under an October 1995 IEP at Fort Miller Middle School, he received resource specialist program (RSP) instruction, adapted physical education, and counseling. The Hearing Officer first ruled that the hearing office had no power to decide Section 504 claims or to award attorney's fees.
Private psychologist Dr. Robert Wells had recommended two or more hours a week of language processing therapy. The Hearing Officer found the student did not need it, relying on district speech-language specialist Dianne Long, who said his needs could be met in the RSP class. The student did need individual counseling. However, the IEP did not state how often or in what form, and there was no evidence the district provided counseling after a Mental Health referral stalled. The district was ordered to hold an IEP meeting on counseling and to repay $1,090 for private sessions with Gordon Ogden. Test and assignment changes were already in the IEP. The mother could be repaid mileage for up to 20 documented trips in 1994-95, not the $2,000–$5,000 she sought. The Hearing Officer denied payment for Dr. Wells's assessment because the district's 1993 assessment was appropriate and the mother had not consented to the district's 1995 assessment plan. Placement issues were not decided because neither party disputed the placement.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled a promise of counseling that the IEP did not define and the district did not deliver. The parent was repaid for private therapy on equitable grounds. It also shows that a parent's refusal to consent to a district assessment plan can defeat a claim for independent assessment costs.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1a. Does STUDENT require the auxiliary aids and therapy recommended by Dr. Wells — specifically, does an appropriate education include two or more hours of language processing therapy per week?
The district speech-language specialist's assessment and testimony showed that the student's language needs could be met through a Communication Lab program in the RSP class, so weekly language processing therapy was not required.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1b. Does an appropriate education for STUDENT include individual psychological therapy?
The student needed individual counseling. The IEP did not state its nature, frequency, or goals, so the IEP team was ordered to meet and set them.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 1c. Does an appropriate education for STUDENT include modification of assignments and test-taking procedures?
The student needed the modifications, but they were already in his IEP and were being implemented, so no relief was ordered.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2. Is MOTHER entitled to reimbursement for the costs of therapy provided by Gordon L. Ogden, M.F.C.C., from October 3, 1995, to January 5, 1996?
The district agreed to provide counseling but offered no evidence that it did. Equity favored reimbursing $1,090 for private counseling that benefited the student.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. Is MOTHER entitled to reimbursement for the costs she incurred in transporting STUDENT to and from school during the 1994-95 school year?
The mother may receive mileage reimbursement for up to 20 trips at the district's employee rate once she submits a declaration of dates and mileage. Her $2,000–$5,000 claim was denied as unsupported.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 4. Is MOTHER entitled to reimbursement for the cost of an independent assessment conducted by Dr. Wells on April 20, 1995?
The district's 1993 assessment was appropriate, no reassessment was yet due, and the mother had not consented to the district's March 1995 assessment plan, so the district did not have to pay for the independent assessment.
- Not reachedPlacement and LRE
Issue 5. Is STUDENT entitled to remain in his current educational placement at Fort Miller Middle School?
Neither party sought to change the placement, so there was no dispute to decide.
- Not reachedDistrict-filed: implement IEP
Issue District 1. Is STUDENT's current educational placement at Fort Miller Middle School appropriate?
Neither party disputed the appropriateness of the Fort Miller program, so the issue was not decided.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, the District must convene an IEP team to determine the nature and frequency of individual counseling services and to develop counseling goals and objectives.
- Reimbursement. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, the District must reimburse the mother $1,090.00 for counseling sessions with Dr. Ogden from October 3, 1995, through January 5, 1996, per the April 8, 1996 invoice.
- Reimbursement. Within 15 calendar days of receiving the mother's written declaration of dates and actual mileage, the District must reimburse her for transporting the student to and from Wawona Middle School at the District's employee mileage rate. The decision limits this to no more than 20 trips.
Total: $1,090 ordered
Key authorities
Rowley; Burlington School Committee v. Department of Education of Massachusetts; Education Code § 56329(b); Education Code § 56381; Education Code § 56507
People named in the decision
- Colleen K. Torgerson, administrative coordinator for special education programs, Fresno Unified School District
- Gerre Gurland-Jones, program specialist and vice principal, Fresno Unified School District
- Michael N. Coy, Ed.D., special education administrator (filed District's hearing request), Fresno Unified School District
- Robert D. Wells, Ph.D., independent psychologist / independent assessor, Private
- Kiki L. Wells, independent assessor, Private
- S. Chester Faller II, advocate for parent and student, Private
- Norma Smith, special education teacher (1994-95), Wawona Middle School
- Richard Brown, Ph.D., school psychologist, Fresno Unified School District
- Dianne Long, speech, language, and hearing specialist, Fresno Unified School District
- Gordon L. Ogden, M.F.C.C., private marriage, family, and child counselor, Private practice
- Diane Parrish, principal (1994-95), Wawona Middle School
- Robbie Stirling, homeroom and RSP math teacher (1995-96), Fort Miller Middle School
- Bob Gross, school psychologist (1993 assessment), Fresno Unified School District
- Laidlaw, contracted bus transportation company, District contractor
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Fresno, California, on April 23 and 24, 1996.
STUDENT was represented by attorney Paul D. Farb. Also present on behalf of STUDENT was his mother. The Fresno Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Thomas P. Guarino. Also present on behalf of the District was Colleen K. Torgerson, administrative coordinator for special education programs. Gerre Gurland-Jones, program specialist, was present on behalf of the District for a portion of the second day of the hearing.
Oral and documentary evidence was received, the record was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
District's Motion to Consolidate
In July 1995, Mr. Farb filed a lawsuit on behalf of MOTHER and STUDENT against the Fresno Unified School District in the United States District Court, Eastern District of California. On February 9, 1996, the case was dismissed with prejudice by agreement of the parties. The stipulation states, in relevant part, that:
2. The Parties mutually agree to the referral of the matters below to a DUE PROCESS HEARING, at the District's option or upon written request by STUDENT through his Guardian ad litem within 30 days of entry of dismissal, the following issues:
A: The Second Cause of Action of the First Amended Complaint; VIOLATION OF THE INDIVIDUALS WITH DISABILITIES EDUCATION ACT (IDEA)...;
B: The Third Cause of Action of the First Amended Complaint; VIOLATION OF THE REHABILITATION ACT OF 1973...;
C: The most recent IEP completed prior to this stipulation will control the scope of the claims set forth above...; all prior claims are dismissed;
D: The damages recoverable will be limited to compensatory education [redacted] not to include punitive damages.
D(1) Compensatory education costs for services not provided by the District for which STUDENT or his Guardian ad litem suffered out of pocket expenditures for the 1994-95 school year for education or medical expenses;
D(2) Transportation expenses for services not provided by the District for which STUDENT or his Guardian ad litem suffered out of pocket expenditures for the 1994-95 school year.
(District's Exhibit A)
On March 13, 1996, the Hearing Office received a request for a special education due process hearing from attorney Paul D. Farb on behalf of STUDENT. (SN 235-96) The hearing was set for April 9 and 10, 1996, and by agreement of the parties, continued to April 23 and 24, 1996. On April 12, 1996, the Hearing Office received a request for a special education due process hearing on behalf of the District from Michael N. Coy, Ed.D., special education administrator. (SN 366-96) The District identified as issues for hearing "the appropriateness of assessments, placements and transportation offered to STUDENT." The District's case was set for hearing on May 9 and 10, 1996. On April 15, 1996, Mr. Farb identified the following issues for hearing: the appropriateness of STUDENT's special education services and placement; reimbursement to MOTHER for therapy and transportation during the 1994-95 school year; and reimbursement for an independent assessment procured by MOTHER.
On April 19, 1996, the Hearing Office received from attorney Thomas P. Guarino, on behalf of the District, a motion to consolidate cases SN 235-96 and SN 366-96, and to have the cases heard on April 23 and 24, 1996. Mr. Farb was provided an opportunity to respond to the motions before the hearing; however, his office indicated that he was unavailable. At the beginning of the hearing in SN 235-96 on April 23, 1996, Mr. Farb agreed to consolidate the hearings. Based on the agreement of the parties, the similarity of issues identified for the hearings, and the fact that the parties are the same in both cases, the Hearing Officer concluded that consolidation was appropriate and granted the District's motion to consolidate SN 235-96 with SN 366-96.
Claims Under Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973
States accepting funds under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) must establish a system of due process hearings to resolve disputes arising under the Act in regard to the identification, evaluation, placement, or the provision of a free, appropriate education to a student. 20 U.S.C. § 1415. The State of California has contracted with the California Special Education Hearing Office to adjudicate disputes arising under the IDEA. The Hearing Office does not have jurisdiction to hear matters arising under other federal statues, such as the Rehabilitation Act of 1973. For this reason, Mr. Farb's request that the Hearing Officer hear and decide a claim under Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 is denied.
Request for Attorney's Fees
As part of the relief requested on behalf of STUDENT, Mr. Farb has requested that the Hearing Officer award "reasonable costs and attorney's fees." Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the Hearing Officer must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided as a result of the due process hearing. The Hearing Officer, however, does not have authority to award attorney's fees. Subsection (b) of Section 56507 states that an award of attorney's fees to a prevailing parent or student "may only be made either with the agreement of the parties following the conclusion of the administrative hearing process or by a court of competent jurisdiction pursuant to paragraph (4) of subsection (e) of Section 1415 of Title 20 of the United States Code." The decision below indicates the prevailing party on each issue heard and decided; however, based on the lack of jurisdiction to award attorney's fees and costs, the Hearing Officer denies Mr. Farb's request for fees and costs.
ISSUES
STUDENT's Issues (1) Does STUDENT require the auxiliary aids and therapy recommended by Robert D. Wells, Ph.D., in his report dated April 20, 1995?
(2) Is MOTHER entitled to reimbursement for the costs of therapy provided by Gordon L. Ogden, M.F.C.C., from October 3, 1995, to January 5, 1996?
(3) Is MOTHER entitled to reimbursement for the costs she incurred in transporting STUDENT to and from school during the 1994-95 school year?
(4) Is MOTHER entitled to reimbursement for the cost of an independent assessment conducted by Dr. Wells on April 20, 1995?
(5) Is STUDENT entitled to remain in his current educational placement at Fort Miller Middle School?
The District's Issue (1) Is STUDENT's current educational placement at Fort Miller Middle School appropriate?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a 14-year-old student who is enrolled in the eighth grade at Fort Miller Middle School. STUDENT has myelomeningocele, a severe form of spina bifida, congenital hydrocephalus, and asthma. Shunts to drain cerebral spinal fluid were placed at birth and have been revised several times. STUDENT uses a wheelchair for ambulating and self-catheterizes for bladder control. STUDENT is eligible for special education and, pursuant to his current IEP developed on October 13, 1995, is entitled to the following: three periods of instruction in the resource specialist program (RSP); adaptive physical education; and counseling. STUDENT's IEP also calls for modifications for test-taking and weekly conferences between STUDENT's regular and special education teachers. His IEP goals and objectives address improving academic, language, and organizational skills. The IEP includes a transition plan. (District's Exhibit L)
STUDENT first received special education services from the District as an infant. From preschool through the sixth grade, STUDENT attended a special day class (SDC) at Ginsberg Elementary School. Ginsberg is a separate school that serves students with disabilities. During the second grade and for portions of other school years, STUDENT attended a regular education class at Powers Elementary School. In the fall of 1994, STUDENT entered the seventh grade at Wawona, a comprehensive middle school. He received special education services and was mainstreamed in several regular education classes.
On March 31, 1995, Norma Smith, STUDENT's special education teacher at Wawona, sent home with STUDENT the District's proposed assessment plan for a triennial assessment of STUDENT.(Footnote 1) Ms. Smith contacted MOTHER regarding the plan; however, MOTHER did not return the assessment plan. (District's Exhibits U and W) On April 20, 1995, Kiki L. Wells and Robert D. Wells, Ph.D., conducted an independent assessment of STUDENT at the request of S. Chester Faller II, advocate for MOTHER and STUDENT. The assessment included the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-III, the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test, the Conners' Continuous Performance Test, the Achenbach Child Behavior Check List, the Personality Inventory for Children, the Piers Harris Self-Concept Scale, and the Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scales. Dr. Wells concluded that STUDENT had an attention deficit disorder without hyperactivity and was "experiencing a Major Depressive reaction to his ongoing unrelenting stress." Dr. Wells also concluded that STUDENT had a language processing disorder with "frequent difficulties understanding complex linguistic instructions and information." Dr. Wells recommended that STUDENT receive two or more hours of language processing therapy per week and individual psychological therapy. He also recommended that modifications be made at school to allow STUDENT unlimited time to complete tests and to accompany auditory instruction with written material. Dr. Wells indicated that a medical assessment by STUDENT's physician may be warranted for possible pharmacological treatment of STUDENT's attentional problems. (Parent's Exhibit E)
The District convened several IEP meetings during April and May 1995 to address issues raised by MOTHER regarding STUDENT's transportation, bathroom needs, and the learning problems identified by Dr. Wells. The IEP document dated May 8, 1995, includes the following modifications and services to address STUDENT's learning difficulties: a tape recorder and tapes will be provided for STUDENT to use to record his classes; a teacher assigned to work with students with orthopedic disabilities (OI teacher) will administer tests to STUDENT to allow him unlimited time to complete tests; daily assignment sheets will be completed by STUDENT; STUDENT's teacher will review the assignment sheets and complete them before sending them home with STUDENT; a weekly progress report will be prepared and sent home with a copy of STUDENT's corrected homework; the OI teacher will consult weekly with STUDENT's regular classroom teachers; and graded assignments will be sent home weekly. (Parent's Exhibit G)
On May 8, 1995, MOTHER consented to an assessment of STUDENT's social and emotional status. The assessment plan states that STUDENT's language processing skills will be assessed by a therapist "to be assigned." (District's Exhibit N) As part of the assessment conducted by school psychologist Richard Brown, Ph.D., in May 1995, STUDENT completed the Roberts Apperception Test for Children and Ms. Smith, STUDENT's special education teacher, completed the Achenbach Child Behavior Check List. Dr. Brown also consulted with STUDENT and his teacher. Dr. Brown concluded that STUDENT was experiencing social isolation at school resulting in depression and low self-esteem. Dr. Brown recommended that STUDENT receive counseling. He also recommended an assessment of STUDENT's language processing skills in response to concerns raised in Dr. Wells' report. In his report, Dr. Brown stated that the school and parent should work together to alleviate STUDENT's excessive absences from school. (District's Exhibit O)
On May 15, 1995, Dianne Long, speech, language, and hearing specialist, assessed STUDENT's language skills for the District. She administered the Expressive and Receptive One Word Peabody Vocabulary Tests, the Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills, the Listening Test, and the Test of Problem Setting. She also took a sample of STUDENT's language. Ms. Long identified weaknesses in reasoning, higher-level thinking skills, and pragmatics (social language). (District's Exhibit P)
On June 6, 1995, the IEP team reconvened to discuss the assessments and STUDENT's needs, and to plan his special education services and placement for the 1995-96 school year. As to STUDENT's academic achievement, the IEP states that "assignments have been modified both in class and homework but progress reports indicate a decrease in performance and lack of attendance. Math is at a 3.5 - 3.7 [grade] level. Reading is at grade level, comprehension is lower. (4.9 as measured by WIAT.)" Strengths are noted in vocabulary, visual attention to detail, and visual spatial problem-solving. Weakness are noted in fine-motor speed, control of attention, problem solving, and higher level reasoning. The IEP states that to improve STUDENT's academic and social skills, the following would occur:
STUDENT's teacher will turn on tape recorder for classroom lecture in mainstreamed classes when STUDENT is present and work toward self-monitoring goal for STUDENT. Checklist will be created and parent participation involved.
STUDENT will have mainstreamed class textbooks checked out to him from the library for the semester to remain at home for home use.
A weekly progress report will be mailed home to MOTHER as monitored by classroom teacher.
Student will develop Higher Level Reasoning Skills through question techniques will be used in mainstreamed classes as monitored by classroom aides as overseen by classroom teacher.
Curriculum will be modified and adjusted to STUDENT's academic and functional needs in mainstream subjects.
[STUDENT will] Improve math word problem comprehension skills in appropriate District approved text on STUDENT's level of performance as monitored by teacher.
To improve STUDENT's use of social language, the IEP states that "[staff] will use core communication skills (pragmatics) in all structured settings utilizing Communication Lab Program." (District's Exhibit C)
The IEP sets forth STUDENT's placement as two periods of SDC with the remaining periods in regular education with SDC support to address math, social skills training, and personal needs. The IEP states that STUDENT is entitled to counseling, transportation, extended school year services, adaptive physical education, modified classroom testing, and language services. As to STUDENT's bathroom needs, the IEP states that the "school district will conform to C.C.S. [California Children's Services] instructions for surface space and will ask C.C.S. if grab bars are necessary & if so where to place." The IEP was signed by MOTHER on June 7, 1995, and indicates that she approved of the placement but did not agree with other portions of the IEP.(Footnote 2)
On June 7, 1995, MOTHER also consented to a referral to Mental Health. STUDENT did not, however, receive services from Mental Health. MOTHER initially would not come in for an assessment when contacted by Mental Health. (District's Exhibit X) MOTHER testified that she later took STUDENT to Mental Health for an assessment and recalled that someone from Mental Health told her that STUDENT was not eligible for services because he was not depressed.
Sometime during the summer of 1995, MOTHER enrolled STUDENT at his home school, Fort Miller. Because STUDENT was already enrolled in a special education program at Wawona, District personnel advised MOTHER that an IEP meeting was required before STUDENT's placement could be changed. On September 27, 1995, the District sent a notice to MOTHER for an IEP meeting on October 13, 1995. (District's Exhibit S)(Footnote 3) On October 3, 1995, STUDENT began weekly psychological counseling with Gorden L. Ogden, a marriage, family, and child counselor in private practice. (Parent's Exhibit G)
The IEP team met on October 13, 1995, to facilitate STUDENT's move to Fort Miller. MOTHER, who was accompanied to the meeting by her attorney, consented to the contents of the IEP and to STUDENT's placement in regular education and three periods of RSP. (District's Exhibit L) On approximately October 16, 1995, STUDENT entered Fort Miller.
STUDENT's school attendance has been poor during the 1995-96 school year. Since October 16, 1995, STUDENT has attended school a total of 59 days. For the period from October through December 1995, the District's attendance report indicates that four of STUDENT's absences were due to illness and one was unexcused. For the period from January through March 8, 1996, the attendance report states that 21 absences were due to illness and one was unexcused. STUDENT has attended only one day of school since March 11, 1996. All of the absences since April 9, 1996, are marked unexcused. According to MOTHER, STUDENT presently is very ill and she does not expect STUDENT to return to school this school year.
STUDENT's grades during this school year have been poor. During the first quarter of school, STUDENT received only three grades. In art he received a "D," in RSP reading he received a "B," and in RSP study skills he received a "C." For the second quarter, STUDENT received three "Cs" and three "Ds." For the fourth quarter, STUDENT received four "Fs" and a "D" in RSP math. (Joint Exhibit 1)
The parties resolved some of their disputes through mediation and by stipulation in the case brought in District Court. As discussed in the "Procedural" section above, the Hearing Officer does not have jurisdiction to hear issues arising under Section 504. The remaining issues are addressed below.
SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY
STUDENT's Witness
STUDENT's mother, testified regarding a number of concerns about STUDENT's school program. Her primary concerns during the 1994-95 school year, when STUDENT attended Wawona, were related to bus transportation and toileting. According to MOTHER, the bathroom facilities at Wawona were unsuitable and resulted in STUDENT's falling and injuring himself on one occasion. Other problems were related to STUDENT's being locked out of the bathroom and the lack of privacy. There also was an incident when two men unfamiliar to STUDENT assisted him because STUDENT's regular assistant was unavailable.
MOTHER testified that transportation problems began when STUDENT enrolled at Wawona. According to MOTHER, the District did not initially offer to transport STUDENT to Wawona although it is several miles from their home. MOTHER testified that after she obtained counsel, the District agreed to provide bus transportation for STUDENT. MOTHER testified that the District contracted with an outside bus company, Laidlaw, to pick up STUDENT rather than providing their own bus, as they had agreed to. MOTHER testified that, at times, the bus did not pick up STUDENT from home in the morning and, at other times, would not bring him home from school in the afternoon. MOTHER testified that the morning driver would wait only one minute, which did not allow sufficient time for STUDENT to get to the bus. On one occasion, STUDENT soiled himself at school and was not allowed to ride the bus home. On other occasions, the bus driver would not allow STUDENT on the bus because, according to the bus driver, the brakes or wheels on his wheelchair were not safe. MOTHER testified that she had taken the wheelchair to be checked and repaired just prior to at least one of these incidents. She also testified that tightening the brakes is a matter of turning a screw. MOTHER testified that she believes the brake issue was actually to retaliate for her complaining about the bathroom. MOTHER testified that, on some occasions, she did not know where STUDENT was after school because no one from the District called her to let her know that he would not be on the bus. MOTHER did not recall how many times she actually transported STUDENT to or from school during the 1994-95 school year. MOTHER testified that she borrowed approximately $5,000 from her mother for out-of-pocket expenses related to taking STUDENT to and from school. Those expenses included gasoline, repairs to her van and, ultimately a car to replace her van. MOTHER testified that she did not complete District reimbursement forms because they were never made available to her.
MOTHER testified regarding other concerns related to the District's provision of a free, appropriate education to STUDENT. MOTHER contends that the District refused to address any of her concerns regarding STUDENT's learning disability. MOTHER testified that, because STUDENT does not have a locker, he must carry all of his personal items in his backpack. According to MOTHER, this has resulted in some students stealing STUDENT's personal hygiene items from his backpack. The students apparently then made fun of STUDENT in front of other students. MOTHER testified that STUDENT did not have a desk in his history class and was seated against the wall with two other students with disabilities. MOTHER objected to STUDENT being questioned by several persons at school regarding his father and whether he had been abused by either of his parents. This apparently occurred in response to teachers seeing one of STUDENT's drawings. MOTHER testified that STUDENT was fearful and said he would never draw again.
MOTHER' primary concerns regarding the 1995-96 school year are related to the District's ongoing failure to address STUDENT's learning disabilities, STUDENT's failing grades, and the fact that STUDENT will have to repeat the eighth grade. MOTHER testified that in shop class, STUDENT did not have an opportunity to actually build an engine like the other students because he could not reach the parts. STUDENT also was required to serve detention because MOTHER could not afford to pay his shop fee. MOTHER testified that STUDENT has been penalized for poor attendance, which primarily has been a result of health problems associated with his disability. MOTHER testified that STUDENT suffers from urological problems resulting from the fall he suffered at Wawona the prior school year. MOTHER testified that STUDENT's health is currently poor and that his kidneys are deteriorating, his shunt is malfunctioning, and he may require reconstructive bladder surgery. MOTHER testified that sometimes STUDENT does not want to go to school because he is fearful or depressed. MOTHER testified that STUDENT is tardy to class because of the time involved in getting to the bathroom and taking care of his needs. MOTHER testified that STUDENT does not seem to have problems toileting at Fort Miller. The room he uses is large enough for him to move around in his chair and there are handrails.MOTHER testified that she obtained an independent assessment from Dr. Wells because the District did not respond to her request for an assessment in early 1995. MOTHER testified that an assessment was needed before an appropriate program could be developed for STUDENT. MOTHER objected to the assessment the District ultimately undertook because she was not advised of who was assessing STUDENT and what measures were being used. According to MOTHER, at least a part of the assessment took place in STUDENT's classroom, which caused a great deal of embarrassment to STUDENT. MOTHER also asserts that one of the instruments used by the District was not age-appropriate for STUDENT.
MOTHER testified that she arranged for Dr. Ogden to provide therapy to STUDENT because she understood from Mental Health that they would not provide therapy because STUDENT was not depressed. She testified that STUDENT "enjoyed" the opportunity to meet with Dr. Ogden because it made him feel better about himself and also helped renew his interest in art. MOTHER also liked the way in which Dr. Ogden utilized a computer to "bring STUDENT's interests to the surface."
No other witnesses appeared on behalf of STUDENT.
The District's Witnesses
Diane Parrish was the principal of Wawona during the 1994-95 school year. Ms. Parrish participated in IEP meetings regarding STUDENT and spoke with MOTHER. Ms. Parrish testified that the District offered bus transportation to STUDENT and also agreed that if MOTHER drove STUDENT to or from school, she would be entitled to reimbursement. Ms. Parrish testified that she is aware that MOTHER transported STUDENT on several occasions; however, as far as she knows, MOTHER did not complete any of the District's forms to request reimbursement for STUDENT's transportation. Ms. Parrish stated that the forms were available at the school. As to MOTHER' concerns regarding bus transportation, Ms. Parrish testified that she met several times with the bus driver and set up a specific time that the bus driver would pick up STUDENT from his home. Ms. Parish testified that STUDENT often was not ready and that, no matter what was done, it was not acceptable to MOTHER.
Ms. Parrish testified that the District responded to MOTHER' concerns regarding the bathroom. For example, a back-up plan was developed in the event that STUDENT's regular assistant was absent. According to Ms. Parrish, MOTHER changed her mind several times as to what was appropriate for STUDENT and even disagreed with the information provided by her advocate, Mr. Faller. The District ultimately agreed to provide for whatever was recommended by C.C.S. following its assessment of STUDENT's needs.
Norma Smith, STUDENT's special education teacher during the 1994-95 school year, testified that, at times, STUDENT appeared isolated and depressed. Ms. Smith expressed concern regarding the significant number of times STUDENT was absent from school and the resulting difficulty he had completing his school work and adjusting upon his return. Ms. Smith testified that, to address STUDENT's learning problems, the school assigned an aide to accompany STUDENT to his regular education classes and provided him a tape recorder to record each of his classes. During sixth period, special education teachers were available to provide assistance to STUDENT. Ms. Smith testified that she obtained tests and other materials from STUDENT's regular classes so that she could help STUDENT with his work. Additionally, either she or the instructional assistant took notes for STUDENT in his regular education classes and prepared assignment sheets for him.
Ms. Smith testified that District personnel attempted to comply with MOTHER' wishes in regard to providing STUDENT with acceptable bathroom facilities. The topic was addressed with MOTHER and her advocate, Mr. Faller, at an IEP meeting in November 1994 and at an in-service in December 1994. Ms. Smith stated that she made space in a locked cabinet for STUDENT's personal items. Ms. Smith recalled MOTHER bringing STUDENT to school on approximately 12 occasions. It was her understanding that STUDENT was not always ready when the bus came to pick him up. As to the reasons for STUDENT's absences, Ms. Smith testified that sometimes STUDENT was sick and, on other occasions, she understood that MOTHER simply did not send him to school.
Gerre Gurland-Jones, program specialist and vice principal, concurred with the testimony of other District witnesses regarding transportation. She testified that during the 1994-95 school year, she personally spoke with MOTHER regarding her need to complete forms to be reimbursed for transporting STUDENT to school. She also discussed with MOTHER what would be the easiest way for MOTHER to obtain the forms and to return them to the District. Ms. Gurland-Jones testified that, based on her conversation with MOTHER, she took the forms to Wawona the next day so that they would be available at the school for MOTHER. Ms. Gurland-Jones testified that she understood that MOTHER had rejected services from Mental Health because MOTHER did not believe therapy was necessary for STUDENT at that time.
Dianne Long (language, speech, and hearing specialist) assessed STUDENT in May 1995. She testified that STUDENT has age-appropriate expressive and receptive language skills; however, he has weaknesses in higher level thinking and reasoning skills and in the social use of language. Ms. Long testified that STUDENT's language deficits can be addressed in the resource program. Ms. Long testified that she has shared information with STUDENT's teachers regarding appropriate techniques to use to enhance STUDENT's thinking skills and has provided the teachers with a social skills lab to incorporate into the RSP class. Ms. Long testified that she did not know on which basis Dr. Wells determined that STUDENT has a language processing disorder because he did not administer any measures of language processing.
Richard Brown, Ph.D., testified that he discussed with MOTHER at the IEP meeting on May 8, 1995, the type of testing he would be utilizing in his assessment of STUDENT. Dr. Brown testified that he did not observe any signs of an attentional problem during his assessment of STUDENT. He also testified that some of the problems identified by Dr. Wells may be related to anxiety, low-self esteem, or other emotional problems. Dr. Brown testified that he spoke with MOTHER regarding the need for a speech and language assessment to confirm or rule out language processing problems. Dr. Brown recommended counseling for STUDENT and arranged for services at Fort Miller, pending Mental Health's processing of STUDENT's referral for services.
Colleen K. Torgerson, District special education administrator, testified that MOTHER and her attorney concurred with the recommendations of the October 1995 IEP team, including addressing STUDENT's language processing and pragmatic deficits through language instruction in the RSP program.
Robbie Stirling has been STUDENT's homeroom and RSP math teacher during the 1995-96 school year. Ms. Stirling testified that the IEP team determined on October 13, 1995, that STUDENT's language processing deficits could be appropriately addressed through RSP services and that a pull-out speech and language program might actually be detrimental for STUDENT because it would single him out from his peers. Ms. Stirling stated that implementing a program to address language deficits in the RSP classes would also allow STUDENT opportunities to practice in class the skills that he is learning. For example, STUDENT can use the social skills training with his RSP peers. Ms. Stirling testified that MOTHER and her attorney concurred with the recommendations of the IEP team.
Ms. Stirling testified that she has personally spoken with all of STUDENT's teachers to inform them that STUDENT is to be allowed additional time to complete assignments and tests, to use a tape recorder if needed, to take his textbooks home, and that tests are to be administered in the RSP. Ms. Stirling stated that she informed the teachers that they need to be certain that STUDENT understands what is expected of him. Ms. Stirling testified that to address STUDENT's distractibility, she has reduced distractions in the classroom. There are also fewer students in the RSP--generally 8 to 14--than there are in regular classes.
Ms. Stirling testified that STUDENT's first quarter grades were based on the work he actually completed. As to STUDENT's grades for the second and third quarters, Ms. Stirling testified that, after meeting with the principal, it was determined that the teachers would give STUDENT grades even though he had been absent a great deal. Ms. Stirling testified that STUDENT received failing grades, except in her math class, because he had completed very little work during those periods.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
STUDENT's Issues
ISSUE NO. 1: Does STUDENT require the auxiliary aids and therapy recommended by Robert D. Wells, Ph.D., in his report dated April 20, 1995?
Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the student's individualized educational program. "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child...." 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the student. 458 U.S. 175, 200.
The term "related services" includes transportation and other services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(17). California Education Code § 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." Included in the list of related services are speech and language, orientation and mobility, physical and occupational therapy, counseling, health and nursing services, social worker services, adapted physical education, and psychological services.
STUDENT contends that an appropriate education includes the services set forth in Dr. Wells' report dated April 20, 1995. Dr. Wells recommended that STUDENT receive two or more hours of language processing therapy per week and individual psychological therapy. He also recommended that modifications be made for STUDENT's test-taking at school, including waiving of time limitations for testing, and that auditory instruction be accompanied with written material. (Parent's Exhibit E) Each of these recommendations is addressed separately below.
Does an appropriate education for STUDENT include two or more hours of language processing therapy per week?
As a result of his assessment of STUDENT in April 1995, Dr. Wells identified significant deficits in language processing. To address these deficits, Dr. Wells recommended two or more hours of language processing therapy per week. (Parent's Exhibit E) Ms. Long, District speech, language, and hearing specialist who assessed STUDENT in May 1995, identified weaknesses in reasoning, higher-level thinking skills, and pragmatics. She testified that STUDENT does not have significant deficits in language processing that require two or more hours weekly of language processing therapy. Ms. Long testified that STUDENT's needs to develop thinking skills and to improve pragmatic skills can best be met through a language program in the RSP. Dr. Brown testified that, from his review of STUDENT's educational records and prior assessments, he did not see any history of STUDENT's having a language processing problem.
The Hearing Officer gives significant weight to Ms. Long's testimony in determining that STUDENT does not require two or more hours of language processing therapy per week. As indicated above, Ms. Long testified at the hearing that STUDENT's language needs can be appropriately addressed in the RSP. Dr. Wells did not testify at the hearing. None of the other witnesses supported Dr. Wells' recommendation for intensive language therapy. Ms. Long based her opinion on the results of her assessment of STUDENT, which included a number of measures of STUDENT's language skills. Dr. Wells' assessment did not. Dr. Wells is a psychologist and conducted a psychological evaluation that consisted of measures of cognitive ability, academic achievement, and social/emotional status. Ms. Long is a credentialed speech, language, and hearing specialist, and, therefore, is better qualified to administer measures of speech and language skills and to make recommendations regarding the need for therapy than is Dr. Wells.
Under Rowley, the District is not required to provide STUDENT with the "best" education. The District is required only to provide STUDENT with the 'basic floor of opportunity' consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services individually designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. In this case, the IEP team determined that STUDENT's language needs could be addressed by implementing a District Communication Lab program within STUDENT's resource class. The Hearing Officer notes also that the testimony of Ms. Long and other District members of the IEP team establishes that MOTHER and her attorney concurred with the decision to address STUDENT's language needs through resource services. For all of these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that to receive an appropriate education, STUDENT does not require two or more hours of weekly language processing therapy.
Does an appropriate education for STUDENT include individual psychological therapy?
In his report dated April 20, 1995, Dr. Wells recommended individual psychological therapy for depression. (Parent's Exhibit E) Dr. Brown, who assessed STUDENT on behalf of the District in May 1995, recommended counseling for STUDENT to address low self-esteem, social isolation, and depression. (Testimony of Dr. Brown and District's Exhibit O) STUDENT's teachers both observed STUDENT to exhibit signs of depression. The IEP team determined that STUDENT required counseling and, to that end, referred STUDENT to Mental Health to determine if he was eligible for Mental Health services. STUDENT's current IEP reflects that STUDENT is, in fact, entitled to counseling. Based on the agreement among the assessors and STUDENT's teachers regarding STUDENT's need for individual counseling, the Hearing Officer finds that, to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs and to provide him with educational benefit, STUDENT requires individual psychological counseling. The IEP does not indicate the nature and frequency of counseling nor does it include counseling goals and objectives. None of the witnesses could provide specific information regarding counseling services. For these reasons, it is necessary for the IEP team to convene to determine the nature and frequency of the counseling and to develop counseling goals and objectives.
Does an appropriate education for STUDENT include modification of assignments and test-taking procedures?
Dr. Wells recommended in his report of April 20, 1995, that certain modifications be made to STUDENT's assignments and test-taking procedures. No one disputed Dr. Wells' recommendations and STUDENT's current IEP, as well as his IEP from the prior school year, indicates that STUDENT will be allowed to take tests in a non-distracting setting and will be allowed unlimited time to complete tests. Additional modifications are set forth in his IEPs and include allowing STUDENT to tape his class, having someone else take notes in class for him, accompanying oral information with written explanation, and extending the time allowed for STUDENT to complete assignments. STUDENT may also take tests in the RSP class, and the curriculum is to be modified in STUDENT's mainstream subjects. Ms. Stirling, STUDENT's homeroom and RSP teacher, testified that she personally met with each of STUDENT's regular class teachers to provide them with this information. Thus, there is no dispute that STUDENT requires modifications of assignments and test-taking procedures. The Hearing Officer finds, therefore, that not only does STUDENT require modifications of assignments and test-taking procedures to meet his unique and individual needs and to allow him to benefit from his education, but that the modifications are currently included in his IEP and are being implemented in his educational program.
ISSUE NO. 2: Is MOTHER entitled to reimbursement for the costs of therapy provided by Gordon L. Ogden, M.F.C.C., from October 3, 1995, to January 5, 1996?
Parents are entitled to reimbursement for the costs they have expended for private special education services for their child if it is ultimately determined that the district failed to offer or provide such services, and that the services the parents provided rather than the services provided by the school district were appropriate under the IDEA. Courts have broad discretion in granting relief and must take equitable factors into consideration. Burlington School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education of Massachusetts (1985) 471 U.S. 358.
MOTHER contends that she is entitled to reimbursement in the amount of $1,090.00 for counseling sessions STUDENT received from Dr. Ogden from October 3, 1995, through January 5, 1996. (See Parents' Exhibit G) MOTHER asserts that Mental Health informed her that STUDENT did not meet their criteria for services. The District contends that it is not responsible for funding the independent counseling services procured by MOTHER because it offered counseling services for STUDENT.
Based on the information contained in the report of Dr. Wells' independent assessment and the District's assessment by Dr. Brown, the IEP team determined that STUDENT should be referred to Mental Health for services. On June 7, 1995, MOTHER consented to the referral to Mental Health. However, because of the actions of MOTHER, the assessment process could not be completed by Mental Health and no determination has ever been made regarding STUDENT's eligibility for services from Mental Health. However, the District agreed to provide STUDENT with counseling during the period Mental Health was processing the referral. On August 22, 1995, the District was made aware that Mental Health had not completed the assessment process with STUDENT. (District's Exhibit X) Thus, at the IEP meeting on October 13, 1995, when the IEP team reaffirmed STUDENT's entitlement to counseling, the District was aware that Mental Health was not providing STUDENT with any services.
Dr. Brown was not assigned to STUDENT's school. Therefore, he was unable to provide any information regarding counseling services available for STUDENT at his school or whether counseling services have been provided to STUDENT during the 1995-96 school year. None of the other witnesses called by the District had any information regarding counseling. Therefore, there is no evidence available to the Hearing Officer that the District provided STUDENT with counseling as it had agreed to. No one contradicted MOTHER' testimony that she later returned to Mental Health and was informed that STUDENT did not qualify for services. There also is no evidence that the District made further efforts to have STUDENT assessed by Mental Health or that MOTHER rejected services the District offered to provide to STUDENT. The Hearing Officer notes also that STUDENT's IEP does not indicate the nature and frequency of counseling nor does the IEP include counseling goals and objectives.
MOTHER testified that STUDENT benefitted from the individual sessions provided by Dr. Ogden and looked forward to meeting with him. MOTHER' testimony is supported by the reports prepared by Dr. Ogden. (Parent's Exhibit G) The Hearing Officer finds that equity weighs in favor of reimbursing MOTHER for the private services she obtained for STUDENT given the following: STUDENT's depression and his need for counseling, which has been acknowledged by the District; the success of the therapy noted by Dr. Ogden and MOTHER; MOTHER' apparent misunderstanding regarding the Mental Health referral process; the District's agreement to provide counseling; and the lack of persuasive evidence that the District has provided STUDENT with counseling either pending the Mental Health assessment or at any other time following the IEP in October 1995.
ISSUE NO. 3: Is MOTHER entitled to reimbursement for the costs she incurred in transporting STUDENT to and from school during the 1994-95 school year?
Transportation is a related service to which STUDENT was entitled during the 1994-95 school year while attending Wawona. STUDENT is in a wheelchair and lives some distance from the school. Although the District provided STUDENT with bus transportation, MOTHER provided transportation to STUDENT on some days. The District agreed to reimburse her for the costs she expended to transport STUDENT to and from school. Thus, there is no dispute as to her entitlement to some form of reimbursement for those times she drove STUDENT either to or from school. The District requires that parents complete a form indicating the date and mileage for which they are seeking reimbursement. The evidence establishes that MOTHER was aware of this policy, since she had provided STUDENT's transportation and received reimbursement from the District the prior school year. Ms. Gurland-Jones testified credibly that she spoke with MOTHER regarding the need for her to fill out the same forms during the 1994-95 school year and that she personally took the forms to Wawona. MOTHER did not complete any forms requesting reimbursement for the transportation she provided for STUDENT.
The District's requirement that MOTHER and other parents complete forms when requesting reimbursement is reasonable since the District must have records of expenditures for accounting purposes. Moreover, MOTHER' claim regarding the expenses she incurred in transporting STUDENT to and from school was not reliable. MOTHER requested from $2,000 to $5,000 reimbursement and did not recall the number of times she actually transported STUDENT. At one point, MOTHER recalled that she had driven STUDENT numerous times and, at other times, she recalled only a few times that she had driven STUDENT either to or from school. In her deposition, MOTHER stated that she had transported STUDENT fewer than 20 times. MOTHER did not present any documentation to the District in the evidence packet or during her testimony to substantiate the number of times she provided transportation for STUDENT either to or from Wawona. Ms. Smith, STUDENT's teacher, recalled approximately 12 times that MOTHER had driven STUDENT to or from school during the time he was in her class.
For the above reasons, MOTHER' request that the District reimburse her for $2,000 or more is denied. However, based on the District's agreement to reimburse MOTHER for transporting STUDENT to or from school, and subject to receipt of a written declaration from MOTHER setting forth the dates and actual mileage, the District shall reimburse MOTHER for transporting STUDENT to and from school. There is no evidence that the number of trips made by MOTHER exceeds 20. Therefore, the District is only required to reimburse MOTHER for up to 20 trips. The rate of reimbursement is the rate at which the District reimburses its employees for actual mileage they have incurred.
ISSUE NO. 4: Is MOTHER entitled to reimbursement for the cost of an independent assessment conducted by Dr. Wells on April 20, 1995?
California Education Code § 56329(b) provides that a parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation from a qualified specialist at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment conducted by the educational agency. If the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent evaluation.
To be appropriate, the District's assessment must meet the requirements of California Education Code § 56320, which states in relevant part that the assessment must be administered by trained personnel, draw information from a variety of sources, and may not include instruments or procedures that are racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. Tests must also have been validated for the purpose for which they are used. Tests and other assessment materials must also be "provided and administered in the pupil's primary language...unless the assessment plan indicates reasons why such provision and administration are not clearly feasible." Education Code § 56320(b)(1).
The District assessed STUDENT in May 1993. The psychoeducational portion of the assessment was conducted by Bob Gross, school psychologist. Mr. Gross administered the Wide Range Achievement Test, the Test of Non-Verbal Intelligence, the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-revised, the Expressive One Word Picture Vocabulary Test, the Visual Motor Integration Test, the Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills, and the Bender Gestalt Motor Test. These assessments are regularly utilized by school personnel in the assessment of special education students. There is no evidence that the assessment instruments are racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory, or that they were administered in a manner other than set forth in their respective manuals. Mr. Gross drew conclusions based on the assessment and also made recommendations in his report. (Parent's Exhibit 4) MOTHER did not specifically disagree with this assessment nor did she assert or present any evidence that the District's assessment failed to comply with the requirements of an appropriate assessment as set forth in the Education Code.
There also was no evidence that the District had an obligation to assess STUDENT at any time prior to the assessment conducted by Dr. Wells. California Education Code § 56381 addresses the circumstances under which a school district may assess a special education student. Section 56381 provides that:
A reassessment of the pupil...shall be conducted at least every three years or more frequently, if conditions warrant, or if the pupil's parent or teacher requests a new assessment and a new individualized education program to be developed.
The last assessment of STUDENT by the District prior to Dr. Wells' independent assessment took place in May 1993. Therefore, the District was not required to conduct another triennial of STUDENT until May 1996. There was no evidence that MOTHER had requested that the District assess STUDENT, that the District had refused to assess STUDENT, or that circumstances warranted an assessment of STUDENT.
Sometime in March 1995, the District did determine that it would assess STUDENT, in light of the number of concerns expressed by MOTHER. Ms. Smith testified credibly that on March 31, 1995, she sent MOTHER the District's proposed assessment plan and on April 3, 1995, spoke with MOTHER regarding that plan. (See also District's Exhibit W) According to Ms. Smith, MOTHER did not return the plan or indicate that she consented to the District's proposed assessment. There were some vague references by MOTHER' counsel that an original signed assessment plan was filed with the Court and that the District would not accept a copy of the assessment plan. No evidence was presented, however, in support of this reference. The evidence suggests that MOTHER did not consent to the District's assessment of STUDENT until after Dr. Wells' assessment was completed and the District had sent a second proposed assessment plan. (Parent's Exhibit G) In any case, MOTHER did not consent to the District's original proposal to assess STUDENT. Instead, she obtained an independent assessment, which Dr. Wells completed on April 20, 1995.
MOTHER did specifically disagree with the District's last assessment of STUDENT that took place prior to Dr. Wells' independent assessment and, as determined above, the District's 1993 assessment was appropriate. There also was no evidence presented that the District was required to assess STUDENT because of changed circumstances or because a triennial assessment was due. Moreover, when the District did propose to assess STUDENT, MOTHER did not initially consent to the assessment. Under these circumstances, the Hearing Officer finds that the District is not legally obligated to pay for the independent assessment obtained by MOTHER.
ISSUE NO. 5: Is STUDENT entitled to remain in his current educational placement at Fort Miller Middle School?
The District's Issue: Is STUDENT's current educational placement at Fort Miller Middle School appropriate?
The District has not attempted to change STUDENT's placement from Fort Miller, nor has MOTHER requested that STUDENT's placement be changed. The parties do not disagree regarding the appropriateness of the program in place for STUDENT at Fort Miller.(Footnote 4) Therefore, there is no dispute regarding STUDENT's placement, and it is not necessary to make a determination on either STUDENT's Issue No. 5 or the District's Issue as set forth above.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
STUDENT's Issues (1) Does STUDENT require the auxiliary aids and therapy recommended by Robert D. Wells, Ph.D., in his report dated April 20, 1995?
The auxiliary aids and therapy recommended by Dr. Wells are currently included in STUDENT's IEP. For this reason, there is no prevailing party on this issue.
(2) Is MOTHER entitled to reimbursement for the costs of therapy provided by Gordon L. Ogden, M.F.C.C., from October 3, 1995, to January 5, 1996?
STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
(3) Is MOTHER entitled to reimbursement for the costs she incurred in transporting STUDENT to and from school during the 1994-95 school year?
The District prevailed as to the amount of reimbursement to which MOTHER is entitled.
(4) Is MOTHER entitled to reimbursement for the cost of an independent assessment conducted by Dr. Wells on April 20, 1995?
The District prevailed on this issue.
(5) Is STUDENT entitled to remain in his current educational placement at Fort Miller Middle School?
This issue was not heard and decided. Therefore, there is no prevailing party.
The District's Issue (1) Is STUDENT's current educational placement at Fort Miller Middle School appropriate?
This issue was not heard and decided. Therefore, there is no prevailing party.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
ORDER
(1) Within 15 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP team to determine the nature and frequency of individual counseling services for STUDENT and to develop counseling goals and objectives.
(2) Within 15 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall reimburse MOTHER in the amount of $1,090.00 for the counseling sessions provided by Dr. Ogden from October 3, 1995, through January 5, 1996, as set forth in the invoice dated April 8, 1996 and contained in Parent's Exhibit G.
(3) Within 15 calendar days of receipt of a written declaration from MOTHER setting forth the dates and actual mileage she transported STUDENT to and from Wawona Middle School, the District shall reimburse MOTHER at the rate it reimburses its employees for mileage.
(4) The remaining requests for relief are denied.
DATED: May 24, 1996 _____________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES
1. STUDENT's last triennial was in May 1993.
2. During testimony, MOTHER stated that she did not believe that the IEP adequately addresses STUDENT's learning disabilities
3. According to the District, this date was agreed to by MOTHER and the District.
4. The Hearing Officer does have grave concerns regarding the effect of STUDENT's absences on his ability to benefit from his education and the fact that there are no provisions in the IEP to address absences. This is especially notable given the number of STUDENT's absences and the fact that at least some of the absences are related to STUDENT's disability.
