California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 13, 2004

Modesto City Elementary School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 373-04 · Hearing Officer Paul E. Lacy

Modesto City Elementary may reassess a second grader early in speech, motor skills, and health after his mother gave only qualified consent.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

Footnote 1 states that the caption was corrected to name Modesto City Elementary School District, not Modesto City High School District, as Petitioner. No substantive changes were made to the decision.

Summary

Modesto City Elementary School District filed for due process in February 2004. It asked for permission to reassess an eight-year-old second grader at John Muir Elementary without his parent's consent. In kindergarten, the student had been found eligible as a child with a learning disability with speech-language and fine motor needs. He was in general education and received speech and occupational therapy. At a December 2003 IEP meeting, the team proposed new assessments in communication, sensory motor development, and health and developmental history. These would come before his triennial reassessment, which was due in February 2005. The mother later signed the plan. However, she also sent a letter asking that the assessment be "for educational purposes only." No one appeared for the student at the hearing. The Hearing Officer found that the parent had enough notice and went ahead.

The Hearing Officer found that the letter could reasonably be read as limiting the mother's consent, so the District needed an order. He then found that each assessment was justified before the triennial date. Speech therapist Claire Dial described new problems with language use, grammar, word meaning, and articulation. Occupational therapist Rosemary Davis described new fine motor and handwriting problems. School nurse Linda Cayabyab pointed to 23 absences and a change in the student's voice quality. The proposed tests and assessors met legal requirements. The District may assess after giving the parents ten days' notice, and the parents must make the student available.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO treated a signed assessment plan that came with a letter adding unclear limits. The Hearing Officer held that this was not unequivocal consent. The decision also shows the kind of evidence a district used to justify reassessing a student before the three-year deadline: new needs seen by service providers and possible health concerns.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue 1. Is the District entitled to assess Student pursuant to the written assessment plan dated December 18, 2003?

    The mother's signed plan, sent with a letter adding limiting language, was not unequivocal consent. The District showed a need to reassess communication, sensory motor, and health/development before the February 2005 triennial, using appropriate tests and qualified assessors.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order that district may assess without consent. The District is entitled to assess Student under the assessment plan (the order reads 'December 8, 20003'; the plan discussed throughout is dated December 18, 2003) in communication development, sensory motor development, and health and development history. The assessments must be given and used consistent with State and federal law.
  • The District must give the parents ten calendar days' notice before conducting the assessments. The parents must make Student reasonably available for the assessments.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

20 U.S.C. §1414(a); Cal. Educ. Code §56321; Cal. Educ. Code §56381; Cal. Educ. Code §56505(e); Cal. Educ. Code §56507(d)

People named in the decision

  • Camille Taylor, Director of Special Education; District witness, Modesto City Elementary School District
  • Claire Dial, speech and language therapist; District witness, Modesto City Elementary School District
  • Linda Cayabyab, school nurse; District witness, John Muir Elementary School, Modesto City Elementary School District
  • Rosemary Davis, occupational therapist; District witness, Modesto City Elementary School District
  • Jan Damesyn, attorney for District, Modesto City Elementary School District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard by Paul E. Lacy of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Modesto, California, on April 22, 2004.

Petitioner, Modesto City Elementary School District (“Petitioner” or “District”), was represented at the hearing by attorney Jan Damesyn. Camille Taylor, the District’s director of special education, was also present on behalf of the District. Respondent, STUDENT (“Student,” or “STUDENT ”), was neither present nor represented at the hearing.

The District called the following witnesses during the course of the hearing: Claire Dial, a speech and language therapist employed by the District; Linda Cayabyab, the school nurse; Rosemary Davis, an occupational therapist employed by the District; and Camille Taylor, the District’s Director of Special Education.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

No one appeared on behalf of STUDENT at the time the hearing was scheduled to begin. The District placed two telephone calls to MOTHER’s home telephone, but did not reach her. Thereafter, a clerk of the Hearing Office, at the request of the Hearing Officer, attempted to contact MOTHER again, but without success. The Hearing Officer delayed the commencement of the hearing for more than an hour to provide additional opportunity for MOTHER to arrive and participate. The Hearing Office later informed the Hearing Officer that MOTHER had ultimately been reached by telephone and reported that she thought the hearing had been taken off calendar. The Clerk informed MOTHER that she–MOTHER–had been advised in a minute order the day before that the hearing would go forward as scheduled. MOTHER was advised to proceed to the hearing site, but she did not arrive. The Hearing Officer determined that the parent had sufficient notice of the time and place for hearing. Because the District was the Petitioner in the case and had the right to have its case heard and decided in a timely manner, the Hearing Officer convened the hearing without MOTHER’s presence.

ISSUE TO BE DECIDED

1. Is the District entitled to assess STUDENT pursuant to the written assessment plan dated December 18, 2003?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a boy of eight years and five months, who is presently living with his siblings and parents in Modesto, California. STUDENT attends the second grade in the District’s John Muir Elementary School. STUDENT began school in kindergarten at the District’s Englen Elementary School, and subsequently attended the first and second grade at John Muir, his present school. While in kindergarten, STUDENT was found eligible for special education services as a child with a learning disability with associated needs in speech and language and fine motor skills. STUDENT is presently served in a general education class and, amongst other things, receives speech and language and occupational therapy services.

Special education assessments were begun for STUDENT in December 2001 and completed in February 2002. His next triennial assessment was scheduled for February 2005. On December 18, 2003, the District convened an IEP team meeting to address STUDENT ’s progress and other issues pertaining to his program. At that meeting, which STUDENT ’s parents did not attend, the team determined that STUDENT required new assessments in the area of communication development, sensory motor development, and health and development history. A written assessment plan was developed and forwarded to MOTHER, STUDENT ’s mother. Initially MOTHER objected to the assessments, and she did not sign the plan right away.

On February 20, 2004, the District filed for a due process hearing requesting the authority to implement the assessment plan without parental consent. Thereafter, on April 8, 2004, MOTHER did in fact sign the plan. About the same time that MOTHER returned the signed consent form to the District, she also faxed a letter to the Hearing Office along with a copy to the District’s legal counsel. In that letter she requested that the Hearing Office dismiss the District’s right-to-assess case because of her written consent to the assessment. The letter, however, included additional language pertaining to her consent to the assessment. That language read as follows:

Parent only request that the assessment be for educational purposes only and not violate the Family Privacy Act as that is a part of a law suit filed against the school district at this time and is going to superior court.

The District took the position that the language in MOTHER’s letter was ambiguous and created an uncertainty in the minds of District administrators as to whether they had unequivocal parental consent to implement the assessment plan and utilize the results in accordance with State and federal special education law.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

The District requests an order for the right to assess STUDENT in the areas of communication development, sensory motor development, and health and development history. (Footnote 2)

State and federal special education law provide that reassessment of students with disabilities must be conducted at least every three years, or more frequently if conditions warrant. 20 U.S.C. §1414(a)(2)(A); Cal Educ. Code§56381(a). While the law provides that a local educational agency has the right and obligation to conduct assessments, parental consent is required before a school district may conduct assessments. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(2)(A)(i); Cal Educ. Code§56381(c). However, a school district can override a lack of parental consent to an assessment if it establishes the need to conduct an assessment at a due process hearing. U.S.C. §1414(a)(1)(A)(ii); Cal Educ. Code§56321(c); 56505(e).

While the law provides that a school district has the right and obligation to conduct these reassessments, parental consent for an evaluation is required before a school district can assess the child. Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(c); 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(1)(C)(i). To obtain consent, the school district must first develop an assessment plan to present to the student’s parents that complies with California Education Code section 56321(b). Section 56321(b) requires that the assessment plan (1) be in language that is easily understood by the general public; (2) be provided in the primary language of the parent; (3) explain the types of assessments to be conducted; and (4) state that no individualized education program will be developed from the assessment without the consent of the parents. Once the assessment is provided to the student’s parents, the parents must be allowed at least fifteen days to respond to the assessment plan. Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(a).

To determine whether the District is entitled to an order to assess STUDENT , the Hearing Officer will first analyze whether such an order is required or whether the parent has already provided unequivocal consent to the assessment plan. Second, if such an order is required, the Hearing Officer will determine whether the District has established the need to presently administer STUDENT the communication development, sensory motor development, and health and development history assessments rather than waiting until February 2005 –the month in which his triennial assessment is due.

Consent

As noted above, a District may seek an order from the Hearing Office to override a parent’s lack of consent to an assessment. In this case, MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother, signed the written assessment plan after the District filed for a due process hearing, but her consent was accompanied by the letter that included the language referenced above.

Ms. Camille Taylor, the District’s Director of Special Education, testified that she was not confident from MOTHER’s letter that she had given the District unequivocal parental consent to assess STUDENT and to use the assessment in the manner and for the purposes provided for under special education law. She added that she was confused by the language of the letter, which she found vague and ambiguous. Ms. Camille Taylor said that it wasn’t clear to her what limitations in the administration or use of the assessments MOTHER intended. Therefore, she believed that the District did not have authority without the order of the Hearing Office.

The Hearing Officer finds that it is reasonable to believe that the above-quoted language was intended to create some limitation on the District’s right to assess STUDENT or on how to use the assessments. Although it is possible that MOTHER only meant to remind the District to administer and utilize the assessments in a manner consistent with State and federal law, such is not clear from her language. Therefore, the signed assessment plan cannot clearly be understood as unequivocal consent to assess STUDENT in accordance with the assessment plan and State and federal law. Thus, the District’s right to assess STUDENT under the current assessment plan requires an order from the Hearing Office.

Assessment for Communication Development

Claire Dial, a speech and language therapist employed by the District for the past twenty one years, testified that she has been providing STUDENT with speech and language therapy services at John Muir since he was in the first grade. Ms. Dial reported that she provides STUDENT with twenty-minute therapy sessions three times each week. Ms. Dial explained that she works to implement goals and objectives that were set forth for STUDENT in his May 2003 IEP, the IEP that planned his special education program for the 2003-2004 school year. She further noted that the information pertaining to speech and language goals set forth in the May 2003 IEP was derived from the 2002 assessments and from her experience working with STUDENT .

Ms. Dial testified that although STUDENT has progressed toward achieving his goals and objectives over the course of the past school year, he has demonstrated new difficulties in the areas of pragmatics, syntax, semantics, and voice articulation. She observed that these difficulties were not evident at the time of the 2002 speech and language assessment and, therefore, were not accounted for in that assessment. Additionally, Ms. Dial stated that a child’s speech and language needs will change and vary considerably in the early grade school years. Ms. Dial also said that it would be imprudent to wait another year for those assessments. She explained that failure to identify and address STUDENT’s speech and language needs during these critical years of development could result in irreversible speech and language deficits. Thus, for her to accurately determine STUDENT’s speech and language abilities and present needs, as well as to address those needs in therapy, Ms. Dial believes that an updated speech and language assessment is needed.

To carry out such an assessment, Ms. Dial proposed to administer STUDENT the following tests: The Diagnostic Evaluation of Language Variation (DELV), The Structured Photographic Expressive Language Test (SPELT), and the Articulation Test of Sound Development. Ms. Dial credibly testified that all of these tests are standardized tests, validated for the purposes they are intended, and nondiscriminatory. She added that the tests will be administered to STUDENT in his native language (English), that she will follow the test directions, and that she is qualified to administer each of these tests.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District is entitled to administer STUDENT new speech and language assessments immediately rather than waiting until the February 2005 triennial assessments are due. The evidence establishes that STUDENT demonstrates speech and language difficulties that were not evident at the time of the initial assessment. Additionally, the District has demonstrated that failure to immediately identify the precise nature of STUDENT’s evolving speech and language difficulties could delay implementing appropriate services, resulting in greater, and perhaps, irreversible deficits. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer finds that the testing instruments the District proposes to utilize, as well as the qualifications of the test administrator, comport with special education law.

Assessment for Sensory Motor Development

Ms. Rosemary Davis, an occupational therapist employed by the District for the past three years, testified that STUDENT was last assessed for sensory motor development in February 2002. At that time, STUDENT was assessed in the areas of vestibular, motor planning, and visual processing. Ms. Davis reported that she is presently working with STUDENT on goals and objectives set forth in the May 2003 IEP. Those goals and objectives were derived in part from information garnered from the January 2002 occupational therapy assessment. However, Ms. Davis explained that STUDENT has since demonstrated new difficulties in fine motor skills, which he exhibits in the form of poor (and below grade level) handwriting. Ms. Davis also said that a new occupational therapy assessment primarily focused on visual and fine motor skills was imperative to understanding the nature and scope of STUDENT’s difficulties in these areas. She noted that because these issues were not evident in January 2002, and thus not accounted for in the initial assessment, a new assessment covering the area of fine motor was essential in order for her to plan occupational therapy goals and objectives for STUDENT and provide him appropriate services to address those needs.

To undertake an occupational therapy assessment, Ms. Davis proposed to administer to STUDENT the Visual Motor Integration Test (VMI), the Motor Free–Visual Perceptual Test, and a handwriting sample. Ms. Davis testified that all three of these tests are standardized tests, validated for the purposes they are intended, and nondiscriminatory. She added that the tests will be administered to STUDENT in his native language (English), that she will follow the test directions, and that she is qualified to administer each of these tests.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District is entitled to administer STUDENT new occupational therapy assessments immediately rather than waiting until the February 2005 triennial assessments are due. The evidence establishes that STUDENT demonstrates new fine motor difficulties that were not evident at the time of his initial occupational therapy assessment. Additionally, the District has demonstrated that failure to immediately identify the precise nature of STUDENT’s fine motor deficits will delay implementing appropriate services, which would likely interfere with his ability to exhibit appropriate handwriting skills. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer finds that the testing instruments the District proposes to utilize, as well as the qualifications of the test administrator, comport with special education law.

Assessment Health and Development History

Ms. Linda Cayabyab, the school nurse assigned to John Muir Elementary School for the past four years, testified that STUDENT was not previously administered a health and development history. Ms. Cayabyab stated that such an evaluation was now needed for two reasons: First, STUDENT had missed 23 days of school since May 2003. Such an excessive number of absences could be indicative of a medical problem, which could interfere with STUDENT receiving a FAPE if he continues to miss too many days from school. A health assessment would help determine whether STUDENT had such a medical condition, or at least provide enough information to determine whether medical diagnostic assessments are required. Second, STUDENT has exhibited a voice quality abnormality. Ms. Dial, STUDENT’s speech and language therapist, observed that STUDENT’s voice was developing in such a way that his tone was becoming higher and more nasal. Ms. Cayabyab credibly explained that a health assessment was necessary to determine whether a medical assessment with an ear, nose, and throat doctor would be warranted. Thus, Ms. Cayabyab believed that a health assessment is necessary to determine whether STUDENT has any physical illnesses or impairments that are causing excessive absences or abnormalities in voice quality, or, in the alternative, determine whether STUDENT requires a medical assessment to address those issues.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District is entitled to administer STUDENT a health and developmental history assessment immediately rather than waiting for the February 2005 triennial assessments. The evidence established that the District has reason to suspect that STUDENT may have health problems that may interfere with his receiving a FAPE. Both the 23 absences and the abnormal voice tones create a reason to suspect that a health problem may exist. For that reason, the District has the right to undertake an assessment to determine the existence of a health problem, the absence of such a problem, or the need for a more thorough medical assessment.

Conclusion

The evidence established that new or updated assessments are required for STUDENT in the areas of communication development, sensory motor development, and health and development history in order to appropriately plan and implement STUDENT’s special education program, and that STUDENT’s parent did not give clear and unambiguous consent to those assessments. Thus, the Hearing Officer orders the District to undertake the assessments set forth in the assessment plan dated December 18, 2003. The assessments must be administered and utilized in a manner consistent with applicable State and federal laws.

ORDER

1. The District is entitled to assess STUDENT pursuant to the December 8, 20003 assessment plan.

2. Prior to conducting the assessments, the District shall give STUDENT’s parents ten calendar days notice.

3. STUDENT’s parents shall make him reasonably available for assessments.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code §56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. In accordance with this statute, the hearing Officer finds that the District prevailed on the only issue heard in this proceeding.

1. Is the District entitled to assess STUDENT pursuant to the written assessment plan dated December 18, 2003? The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

DATED: May 13, 2004 ____________________________ Paul E. Lacy, hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. The caption has been corrected to reflect that the Petitioner in this matter was Modesto City Elementary School District, not Modesto City High School District. No substantive changes were made to the Decision.

2. The assessment plan also called for STUDENT to be assessed in the area of academic achievement. The District informed the Hearing Officer that it had unequivocal consent for this assessment and, thus, it was not an issue for hearing.