California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 29, 2002
Los Angeles Unified School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 388-02 · Hearing Officer Joseph T. Macaluso
Los Angeles Unified's sixth grade general education offer with resource support at Mark Twain Middle School provided FAPE.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
Los Angeles Unified School District filed for due process to confirm that its October 10, 2001 IEP offer gave a 12-year-old student a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year. The student had been eligible for special education since third grade under the specific learning disability category. She had weaknesses in attention, auditory processing, memory, reading decoding, spelling and math computation. The District offered sixth grade general education at Mark Twain Middle School with resource specialist program (RSP) support. The offer included an RSP math class, English with RSP support, an elective reading class, and accommodations such as extra time, graphic organizers, cue sheets and color coding. The parents left the IEP meeting without signing. They said the campus was unsafe and asked that the student repeat fifth grade. The student later re-enrolled in fifth grade at Clover Avenue Elementary. The parents did not appear on any of the three hearing days, and the Hearing Officer denied their requests to continue the hearing. Based on the District's uncontested testimony, the Hearing Officer found that the offer was designed to meet the student's needs and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit under Rowley. Crime data showed that Mark Twain was as safe as other District middle schools. Witnesses agreed that the student did not need to repeat fifth grade. No one disputed that the offer conformed to the IEP or was the least restrictive environment (LRE). The District prevailed and was ordered to immediately make a sixth grade seat available at Mark Twain.
Why it matters
This case shows how SEHO handled a district-filed case to confirm an IEP offer when the parents chose not to take part. The Hearing Officer decided the case on the district's uncontested evidence. Parents' concerns about school safety and their request to hold the student back a grade were weighed against crime statistics and staff testimony.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedDistrict-filed: implement IEP
Issue 1. Did the District's offer on October 10, 2001 to place Student in a sixth grade general education class with resource specialist collaboration/services at Mark Twain Middle School constitute a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year?
The sixth grade general education placement with RSP support at Mark Twain was designed to meet the student's needs, was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, conformed to the IEP, and was the LRE; the campus was as safe as other District middle schools and retention in fifth grade was not needed.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order that district's offer may be implemented. The District's October 10, 2001 offer of a sixth grade general education class with resource specialist collaboration at Mark Twain Middle School constituted a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year.
- The District shall immediately make a seat available for Student in the sixth grade general class with RSP services at Mark Twain Middle School.
Key authorities
Rowley
People named in the decision
- Lily Ellison, resource specialist teacher, Clover Avenue Elementary School, LAUSD
- Tracy Ohkawahira, fifth grade general education teacher, Clover Avenue Elementary School, LAUSD
- Meredith Adams, teacher advisor, LAUSD
- Jody Molodow, special education administrator, LAUSD
- Susan Tandberg, special education coordinator for instructional services, LAUSD
- Charlotte Sewell, due process coordinating specialist, LAUSD
- Victoria McKendall, administrative coordinator for due process, LAUSD
- Marueern Melvold, principal, Clover Avenue Elementary School, LAUSD
- Catherine Redding, school psychologist, LAUSD
- Linda Dinerstein, special education administrator, LAUSD
- Alex Schnitzler, resource specialist teacher, Mark Twain Middle School, LAUSD
- Yvonne Noble, principal, Mark Twain Middle School, LAUSD
- Lainey Rogers, operations administrator, LAUSD
- Lisa M. Millman, school psychologist (initial and triennial assessments), LAUSD
- Sharon Calkin, special education teacher (Woodcock-Johnson III testing), LAUSD
- Ms. Caine, proposed RSP teacher, Mark Twain Middle School, LAUSD
- Mr. Thiel, proposed English and reading teacher, Mark Twain Middle School, LAUSD
- Ms. Tentza (also spelled Tenza), proposed math teacher, Mark Twain Middle School, LAUSD
- Rick Selan, parents' advocate at October 2001 IEP meeting
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Joseph T. Macaluso, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Encino, California, on March 14 and 15, 2002 and April 18, 2002. Appearing on behalf of Petitioner Los Angeles Unified School District (District) were attorney Cynthia Floyd from the law offices of Lozano Smith, Victoria McKendall, District administrative coordinator for due process, and Charlotte Sewell, District due process coordinating specialist. No one appeared on behalf of Respondent Student.
The following witnesses were called by the District: Lily Ellison, District resource specialist teacher at Clover Ave. Elementary School (Clover); Tracy Ohkawahira, District fifth grade general education teacher at Clover; Meredith Adams, District teacher advisor; Jody Molodow, District special education administrator; Susan Tandberg, District special education coordinator for instructional services; Charlotte Sewell, District due process coordinating specialist; Marueern Melvold, District principal at Clover Ave. Elementary School; Catherine Redding, District School Psychologist; Linda Dinerstein, District special education administrator; Alex Schnitzler, District resource specialist teacher at Mark Twain Middle School; Yvonne Noble, District principal at Mark Twain Middle School; Lainey Rogers, District operations administrator.
Respondent neither called any witnesses, presented any written evidence, nor appeared at the hearing.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of the District’s closing brief on May 7, 2002, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
-1-
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
On February 21, 2002, the District filed its request for a due process hearing. On February 25, 2002, the Hearing Office sent all parties notice of the due process hearing on March 14 and 15, 2002. On March 7, 2002, the Hearing Office received a motion to continue the hearing from Student. Her parents contended that they had no time to prepare for the hearing on Student’s behalf because of another due process hearing for her sister. On March 12, 2002, the Hearing Office received the District’s opposition to Student’s motion to continue the hearing. After reviewing both the parties’ pleadings, a Hearing Officer denied the Student’s motion for a continuance for lack of good cause.
On March 13, 2002, the Hearing Office received a motion from Student to reconsider the order denying her request for a continuance. The Hearing Officer ordered that he would not rule on Student’s motion for reconsideration until the commencement of the hearing on March 14, 2002.
On March 14, 2002, at 9:30 a.m., Student did not appear for the first day of hearing. The Hearing Officer requested that the District contact Student’s parents and determine if either they or a representative on Student’s behalf intended on appearing at the hearing. Ms. Cynthia Floyd, counsel for the District, telephoned Student’s parents. After speaking with Student’s mother, Ms. Floyd advised the Hearing Officer that neither Student nor a representative for Student would appear for the hearing. Thereafter, the Hearing Officer reviewed Student’s motion for reconsideration of the original order denying Student’s request for a continuance. The District opposed the motion. After reviewing the merits of Student’s motion and the District’s opposition, the Hearing Officer denied Student’s motion on the ground that it presented no new facts. Subsequently, the Hearing Officer proceeded with the first day of hearing.
On March 15, 2002, at 9:30 a.m., Student did not appear for the second day of hearing. The Hearing Officer requested that the District contact Student’s parents and determine if they or a representative on Student’s behalf intended on appearing at the hearing. Ms. Floyd telephoned Student’s parents. After speaking with Student’s mother, Ms. Floyd advised the Hearing Officer that neither Student nor a representative for Student would appear for the hearing. Thus, the Hearing Officer proceeded with the second day of hearing.
On March 21, 2002, the Hearing Office scheduled a third day for hearing on March 28, 2002. On March 27, 2002, the Hearing Officer received a motion from District counsel to continue the hearing. Before the Hearing Officer could rule on the motion, the parties stipulated to continue the hearing to the next available date. Thus, the hearing date was vacated.
On April 5, 2002, the Hearing Office re-scheduled the case for hearing on April 18 and 19, 2002. On April 18, 2002, at 9:30 a.m., Student did not appear for the third day of hearing. The Hearing Officer requested that the District contact Student’s parents and determine if either they or a representative on Student’s behalf intended on appearing at the hearing. Ms. Floyd telephoned Student’s parents. After Ms. Floyd and the Hearing Officer spoke to Student’s father on a speaker phone with his permission, he advised the Hearing Officer that he had received notice of the hearing but had no intention on attending the hearing. Thus, the Hearing Officer proceeded with the hearing. The District concluded its case in chief on the third day of hearing and rested. Neither Student nor a representative on behalf of Student was present to begin Student’s case. The record remained open for the parties to file closing briefs on or before May 3, 2002. The Hearing Office received no correspondence from Student to set additional days for hearing to present Student’s case prior to the receipt of closing briefs. On May 7, 2002, the Hearing Office received the District’s closing brief but did not receive a closing brief from Student. Thus, the record closed on May 7, 2002.
ISSUE
Did the District’s offer on October 10, 2001 to place Student in a sixth grade general education class with resource specialist collaboration at Mark Twain Middle School constitute a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2001-2002 school year?
BACKGROUND FACTS
Student is a twelve-year-old Student who has been eligible for special education and related services since the third grade because of a specific learning disability. She resides with her parents within the jurisdictional boundaries of Petitioner’s local district D and presently attends Clover Avenue Elementary School (Clover) as a fifth grade student. Student has continued to receive special education and related services from the third grade to the present.
On October 10, 1998, Ms. Lisa M. Millman, District psychologist, assessed Student upon her initial referral for special education. Ms. Millman’s assessment revealed that Student’s cognitive ability was within the average range. Student demonstrated average ability in non-verbal and verbal reasoning, visual perception, auditory discrimination perception, and comprehension. Although her academic skills were in the deficient to below average range, Student was motivated to learn. With regard to her language arts, Student read words at a second grade level and her written language skills were not well developed. Her math computation skills were also below grade level. The results of the evaluation established that there was a severe discrepancy between Student’s cognitive ability and academic achievement in the areas of written expression and math computation. Ms. Millman determined that the severe discrepancy was related to psychological processing disorders in auditory-visual integration and memory. Thus, she concluded that Student was learning disabled and needed special education services.
On October 19, 1998, an initial IEP meeting was held for Student. The IEP team discussed the results of Ms. Millman’s assessment. The IEP team found Student eligible for special education and related services under the qualifying category of a specific learning disability. The IEP team wrote goals and objectives in reading, math, and vocational education to address Student’s unique needs. It placed her in a regular third grade classroom with one hour of resource support services (RSP) four times a week. Student’s program was implemented at Walgrove Avenue Elementary School (Walgrove), which she attended during the third grade for the 1998-1999 school year.
In October 1999, Student began the fourth grade at Walgrove. She continued in a regular education class with one hour of RSP services four times per week. On November 22, 1999, the IEP team convened an IEP meeting to review Student’s progress. The IEP team determined, pursuant to a recent educational evaluation, that Student had made good progress in the third grade. With regard to her math skills, the IEP team determined that Student improved her knowledge in math by more than a year’s grade equivalent, from 2.2 to 3.4 years; her computation skills increased by two years; she was able to add and subtract two digit numbers, multiply three digits and perform single digit division; and her ability to apply math to everyday problems increased from a grade equivalence of 2.4 to 3.0 years. While Student continued to have problems with fractions and double digit division, the IEP team concluded that Student met her math goals.
In reading, Student also improved by one year, moving from a first grade to a second grade equivalent. Her decoding and spelling improved one year and her comprehension improved one and one-half years. While she continued to exhibit weakness in the areas of consonant and vowel digraphs and dipthongs and was approximately one and one-half years behind her peers in reading, the IEP team concluded that Student had met her reading goals. Thus, the IEP team wrote new goals and objectives in math, reading, and vocational education and continued her placement in a regular education classroom at Walgrove with one hour of RSP services four times a week. Student successfully completed the fourth grade at Walgrove.
In October 2000, Student began the fifth grade at Walgrove. On October 19, 2000, the IEP team convened an IEP meeting to review Student’s progress. The IEP team determined that Student had met her goals in reading, math, and vocational education. With regard to her reading, Student made four months’ progress in reading decoding and spelling and a year’s progress in her reading comprehension. While the IEP team noted that her reading composite placed her at a third grade level, it pointed out that Student needed to continue her work in decoding, spelling, and comprehension techniques.
In math, the IEP team determined that she had made one year’s progress. With regard to her computational skills and ability to apply math to everyday problems, she had made a four month gain and a year’s gain. Both of these gains placed her at a fourth grade level in math. Thus, the IEP team wrote new goals and short-term objectives in reading, math, and vocational education for the 2000-2001 school year. Finally, the IEP team concluded that promotion to the fifth grade was appropriate and continued Student’s placement in a regular education classroom at Walgrove with one hour of RSP services four times a week.
Student attended Walgrove from October 2000 until March 2001, when her parents removed her from the elementary school because of alleged abuse by the school’s staff. On March 26, 2001, the District received a request for a special education assessment from Student’s mother. On April 19 and May 7, 2001, the District convened IEP meetings at Student’s parents’ request to discuss a change of placement because of the alleged abuse at Walgrove. Although District and local police investigations determined that the allegations of abuse were without merit, the District still agreed to transfer Student to a fifth grade classroom at Clover Elementary School (Clover). On May 8, 2001, Student began to attend Tracy Ohkawahira’s fifth grade classroom at Clover and received the RSP services from Ms. Lilly Ellison. On June 4, 2001, after attending Clover for seventeen days, Student’s parents removed her from Clover. When the school year ended in June, Student still had not returned to school.
On June 1, 2001, Student underwent a triennial evaluation at Clover by school psychologist Lisa Millman. The results of the evaluation were discussed at an IEP meeting on June 25, 2001 (Footnote 1). The triennial evaluation revealed that Student had an average range of cognition with strengths in visual processing and comprehension. However, she did exhibit a weakness in visual sequential processing. The triennial evaluation also found low average to average range scores in auditory memory, auditory discrimination and auditory reasoning. Student’s visual-motor integration was within normal age-expectancy. Her language skills in picture and oral vocabulary, listening comprehension and in verbal analogies were within the low average to average range. Academic skills were measured in the areas of reading decoding, arithmetic computation and spelling. Student’s reading skills were in the low average range and her arithmetic skills and spelling skills were in the below average range.
At the June IEP meeting, the IEP team reviewed the goals and objectives from the October 2000 IEP. While the IEP team could not determine whether Student had met her goals because of her excessive absences during the 2000-2001 school year, they determined that she had made some progress toward them. Thus, the IEP team wrote goals and objectives in English, math, and vocational education that strove to build upon her present levels of performance and to meet her unique needs. Furthermore, the IEP team determined that Student possessed both the academic and social skills to matriculate to Mark Twain Middle School (Mark Twain) for the sixth grade. Student would continue to attend a general education class with RSP services.
In August 2001, Ms. Catherine Redding, District psychologist, conducted an additional assessment of Student as requested by her parents. The evaluation revealed that while Student’s cognitive abilities were average, her achievement in reading decoding, math computation, and spelling continued to lie within the low average range and math fluency and spelling of sounds continued to lie within the below-average range. Thus, Ms. Redding concluded that Student continued to demonstrate a significant discrepancy between ability and achievement in basic reading skills, oral expression, written expression, and math calculation because of disorders in auditory processing and attention.
In September 2001, the 2001-2002 school year began. However, Student did not appear for the first day of sixth grade at Mark Twain because her parents did not enroll her. On October 10, 2001, the IEP team held an IEP meeting to discuss Student’s placement for the new school year. Student’s parents and her advocate, Rick Selan, appeared for the IEP meeting. The IEP team discussed Student’s present levels of performance in language arts, math and vocational education and wrote goals and short-term objectives to address them. The parties also discussed continuing RSP services for Student. However, when the discussion moved to Student’s placement and the District members of the IEP team suggested that Student attend sixth grade at Mark Twain, Student’s parents and her advocate disagreed with this proposal because they thought the school was not safe. Thus, they left the IEP meeting without signing the IEP document. The District continued to make attempts after the IEP meeting to resolve the impasse but to no avail.
After the October 2001 IEP meeting, Student did not attend a District school to the end of the calendar year. In January 2002, Student still did not appear at school. Thus, the Los Angeles District Attorney’s Office became involved in the case and met with Student’s parents. The District Attorney’s Office gave them the choice of enrolling Student back into the fifth grade at Clover or into the sixth grade at Mark Twain. Student’s parents chose the former option and re-enrolled Student into the fifth grade at Clover. Pursuant to her October 2000 IEP, she was once again placed in Mr. Ohkawahira’s general education fifth grade classroom even though she had matriculated to the sixth grade the prior year. Furthermore, she continued to receive RSP services one hour per day. Because the parties were unable to resolve the impasse regarding Student’s placement for the 2001-2002 school year, the District filed a request for a due process hearing in February 2002.
LEGAL ANALYSIS
ISSUE 1: Did the District’s offer on October 10, 2001 to place Student in a sixth grade general education class with resource specialist services at Mark Twain Middle school constitute a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free and appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400; California Education Code § 56000). Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18), “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that conform with the student’s individualized educational program. “Special education” is defined as “Specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child...” 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central District, et. al. vs. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized education program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. Finally, the court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. (Rowley, 458 at 201-208.)
In Summary, under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley, one must determine whether the District’s offer of a FAPE was designed to meet the student’s unique and individual needs, was reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, comports with the Student’s IEP, and ensures that the student’s placement is in the least restrictive environment. 1. Appropriateness of District Placement
In determining whether the placement offered by the District for the 2001-2002 school year would provide Student with a FAPE, one must identify Student’s unique and individual needs at the time the District’s offer on October 10, 2001. As outlined above, Student has exhibited delays in reading, math, and vocational educational skills. On August 21, 2001, Ms. Catherine Redding, District psychologist, assessed Student’s cognitive functioning and academic aptitude (Footnote 2).
(a) Student’s unique and individual needs
Cognitive functioning
To assess Student’s cognitive functioning, Ms. Redding employed the Developmental Neuropsychological Assessment (NEPSY) and the Wide Range Assessment of Memory and Learning (WRAML). The NEPSY revealed that Student had both strengths and weaknesses in her psychological processing. Her strengths were in visual spatial processing, visual learning, the ability to comprehend whole relationships and ability to understand concepts. Tracy Ohkiwahara, Student’s fifth grade teacher at Clover, testified that these strengths were evidenced in Student’s comprehension in reading and math. However, the NEPSY revealed that Student exhibited weaknesses in attention, organization, planning, problem solving, applying complex rules in approaching a task, and working memory. Ms. Redding testified that if, for example, a math task had a series of steps, Student recalled the first few steps but forgot the remaining ones. Student also exhibited trouble with unstructured tasks as compared to tasks with precise directions. District witnesses testified that these weaknesses were evidenced in her inability to read detailed texts and solve detailed math problems. Thus, Student had good ability to “see the larger picture” but encountered problems “with the details.”
The NEPSY also revealed weaknesses in Student’s language and memory. With regard to her language, the test revealed that Student showed weaknesses in organizing and producing oral sequences from memory, in processing verbal instructions which were semantically and syntactically complex, in phonological decoding and encoding of prefixes, suffixes, and sound patterns (word attack), in articulating complex and unfamiliar words and in spelling. Ms. Redding testified that Student had trouble stringing together and remembering multi-syllabic words. When performing language arts related tasks, Student also had trouble pacing herself. Overall, her language score was in the low average range. With regard to her memory, Student exhibited weaknesses in the memory of names and the speed with which she recalled names. Ms. Redding noted that this weakness might suggest difficulties in auditory processing speed, in the acquisition and retrieval of verbal labels, attention, and planning. Her memory score fell in the average range. Ms. Redding interpreted these results to confirm that Student had weaknesses in auditory processing and attention.
The WRAML revealed that Student had both strengths and weaknesses in her ability to learn and memorize a variety of information using both verbal and visual modalities. When Ms. Redding tested Student’s ability to remember and recite progressively longer letter and number strings, she demonstrated greater skills in visual memory than verbal memory. Ms. Redding noted that Student performed better when she could attach meaning to information presented to her as compared to working with rote information. When Student was required to relate and memorize symbols, her performance was weaker. Furthermore, Student appeared better at recalling information after a period of time as compared to immediately after presentation. Finally, Student’s greatest strengths lay in her ability to recall a meaningful story presented verbally from memory. Overall, Student’s learning and general memory scores fell within the average range.
Academic achievement
To assess Student’s academic achievement, Ms. Redding reviewed the results from the Woodcock-Johnson III that were obtained by Ms. Sharon Calkin, District special education teacher. The test results indicated that Student had the following weaknesses: slow information processing; difficulty pacing herself during tests and lengthy tasks; difficulty manipulating sound patterns; difficulty in phonemic awareness and processing and with phoneme/grapheme relationships; poor attention to detail; and weakness in spelling of sounds and verbal comprehension. In both reading and spelling, Student both interjected and omitted letters, added incorrect sounds in words, and had difficulty manipulating sound patterns. The summary of scores revealed that Student had average scores in the areas of passage comprehension (reading), applied problems (math reasoning), and in sound awareness. She had low average skills in the areas of spelling and word attack (reading nonsense words). Finally, Student had significantly below- average skills in math fluency (timed math tasks) and in spelling of sounds. Because Student has weaknesses in attention, auditory memory, auditory processing, organizing, planning, and working with rote information, Ms. Redding concluded that these weaknesses affected her academic achievement.
District witness observations regarding Student’s needs
Language
The District’s witnesses’ observations of Student in class corroborated Ms. Redding’s findings regarding Student’s academic weaknesses. With regard to her language needs, Ms. Lily Ellison, Student’s RSP teacher at Clover, testified that Student had good reading comprehension because she was able to get the “gist” of what she read. However, if Student were asked to provide details about a story, she performed poorly. Ms. Ellison attributed this problem to Student’s weaknesses in phonics, sound blending, spelling, reading fluency, and careless mistakes. Ms. Ellison estimated that Student read at a fourth grade level because of the aforementioned problems. Thus, she recommended that Student continue with RSP language services in the sixth grade.
Tracy Ohkawahira, Student’s fifth general education teacher, also corroborated Ms. Redding’s findings regarding Student’s language strengths and weaknesses. Mr. Ohkawahira confirmed that Student has good oral comprehension skills. However, these strong oral comprehension skills did not translate themselves onto paper. To accommodate her needs, he recommended that Student use a “leveled reader” that is one year below grade level. Furthermore, Mr. Ohkawahira suggested that Student be assigned fewer pages to read, fewer questions to answer, and extra time to complete her assignments. He noted that if she learned to write with greater detail and use different types of sentence structures and paragraphs to better express herself, her reading would also improve. Mr. Ohkawahira estimated that Student reads one to two years below grade level. Finally, he testified that the work in the RSP class has a high interest level for her, is visually based, and provides feedback to insure that she understands what she reads. Thus, Mr. Ohkawahira recommended that Student continue with her RSP language services.
Math
While the District’s witnesses uniformly testified that Student’s strength is in math comprehension, they also pointed out that her math computation is weak. They attributed this weakness to poor math fluency that results from errors due to sign confusion. Her assessment results indicated that she is approximately one year below grade level with regard to her math computational skills. The District’s witnesses confirmed this fact in their testimony. Ms. Ellison and Mr. Ohkawahira testified that Student understands mathematical processes and has thus improved her multiplication, division, and decimal skills. However, both teachers noted that Student makes careless computational errors and has attention problems that impact her overall performance in math. Mr. Ohkawahira pointed out that Student’s weaknesses in math can be remedied with appropriate modifications and accommodations. He recommended that Student be allowed to work at a slower pace, that she be assigned fewer and simpler math problems that illustrate the math concept, and that Student trace the math signs, tap through the operations, and use cue sheets. Both teachers estimated that Student is at a fifth grade level in math, which is one year below her sixth grade level. Finally, Mr. Ohkawahira and Ms. Ellison testified that Student should continue with RSP math to help her reach a sixth grade level.
In summary, Student has strengths in visual learning and in reading and math comprehension because of her ability to comprehend spatial and whole relationships and understand concepts. However, she exhibits weaknesses in attention, auditory memory, auditory processing, organizing, planning, pacing herself, and working with rote information. These limitations adversely impact her knowledge and performance in language arts and mathematics. Student’s math skills are at a fifth grade level and her language arts skills are a year to a year and a half below grade level. Finally, she requires accommodations and modifications to access the general curriculum and additional services in an RSP class to bring her language and math skills up to grade level.
(b) Is the proposed placement at Mark Twain Middle School Designed to Meet Student’s unique and individual needs?
In determining whether the placement offered by the District for the 2001-2002 school year would provide Student with a FAPE, it is next necessary to determine if the proposed placement at Mark Twain Middle School is designed to meet Student’s unique and individual needs in the areas of reading and math. The evidence at the hearing established that, at the IEP meeting on October 10, 2001, the parties agreed that language arts and math were Student’s areas of unique need and also agreed upon goals and objectives to address those needs. However, they disagreed that the offer of placement at Mark Twain Middle School was designed to meet these needs.
At the IEP meeting on October 10, 2001, the District first offered Student placement in a sixth-grade general education classroom at Mark Twain, her local middle school, for the 2001-2002 school year. Second, the District offered the following accommodations in the area of language arts: repetition of direction; use of multi-sensory cues such as color coded prefixes, suffixes, words and paragraphs; instruction in visualization skills; use of visuals to support instruction; use of a graphic organizers to assist in organizing her thoughts; additional time for written assignments and tests; use of a peer buddy to assist in writing down assignments; fewer pages to read and fewer questions to answer. Second, the District offered the following accommodations in the area of math: have Student trace the sign before beginning a computational problem; talk through the operation; use cue sheets and color coded mathematical signs; connect math instruction to meaningful problems; assign fewer math problems; and have additional time for math assignments and tests. Finally, the District proposed that Student receive the following instructional accommodations to help her progress in the general education curriculum: repetition of directions for clarification; use of graphic organizers to assist in organizing her thoughts; additional time for written assignments; and use of a peer buddy in writing down assignments. Ms. Linda Dinerstein, District special education administrator and Mr. Alex Schnitzler, Mark Twain RSP teacher, testified that the IEP team explained the sixth-grade general education and RSP classes offered to Student’s parents at the October 10, 2001 IEP meeting. They informed the parents that the school day was divided into six classes, one of which would be in the RSP program. The core subject areas were as follows: (1) RSP programmed math; (2) general education English with RSP support; (3) elective English and reading; (4) general education history with RSP support; (5) general education science with RSP support; and physical education. Student’s core academic subjects would utilize the District’s sixth-grade curriculum modified to Student’s present levels of performance. Finally, Ms. Dinerstein and Ms. Yvonne Noble, District principal at Mark Twain, testified about the teachers who would be assigned to Student. They testified that Ms. Caine would be Student’s RSP teacher. Ms. Caine is a fully credentialed teacher who is experienced in special education and is presently working toward her special education credential. Mr. Thiel would be Student’s English and reading teacher. He is a fully credentialed teacher who is experienced in special education and has RSP training. Furthermore, the teachers in history and science are fully credentialed and have RSP support. Finally, Ms. Tentza, who would be Student’s math teacher, is a fully credentialed teacher who is experienced in special education and is presently working toward her special education credential.
Linda Dinerstein, District administrative coordinator for special education, testified about the RSP program at Mark Twain. First, she explained that Student would receive daily RSP intervention in all of her classes. Second, Student, who has near grade-level ability in math and English, would be programmed into an English class with RSP support five days per week for 250 minutes and a programmed RSP math class five days per week for 250 minutes also. Ms. Dinerstein testified that Student would initially begin in the programmed resource math class and would eventually move from that class into a collaborative model where she will receive RSP support in a general education math class. Furthermore, the resource teacher and aide are present in the general education history and science classes to assist in instruction, clarify directions, provide hand outs, modify lessons and make any other accommodations necessary for Student to bridge the gap between her present levels of performance and the sixth grade curriculum. Finally, Ms. Jody Molodow, District special education administrator, testified that Student will have access to RSP support groups and individual RSP attention in any of her areas of need.
Mr. Schnitzler and Ms. Dinerstein testified that Mark Twain would be able to provide Student with all the accommodations specified in her IEP to meet her unique and individual language arts goals. First, all of Student’s teachers will be trained in and use the “Rewards Program” that strengthens decoding, encoding, fluency and word attack skills by helping students to learn phonics, consonant pairs, suffixes and prefixes. Mr. Thiel, who would be Student’s English teacher, would teach Student how to break down multi-syllabic words that will help improve her spelling, reading, writing, and fluency. Student will also take part in the “Rewards Program” that will teach her to attach meaning to what she reads and to raise the level of her reading fluency, vocabulary, comprehension, and written language. Her elective English language class will provide Student with additional help with her decoding, spelling, reading, writing and comprehension skills. The regular education English class and the elective reading class together will provide Student with a combined 100 minutes of language per day. Finally, the district’s witnesses testified that Mr. Thiel is a skilled and enthusiastic English teacher who utilizes graphic organizers, multi-sensory cues, overhead projectors, and elaborate visuals which address Student visual learning strengths.
Mr. Schnitzler testified that Mark Twain will be able to provide Student with all the accommodations specified in her IEP to meet her unique and individual math needs. Ms. Tenza, her math teacher, will review basic math skills, conduct daily math drills, monitor homework, and teach her the foundation for algebra and pre-algebra skills. Ms. Tenza will also help Student with her organization, provide her with fewer problems and extra time to do her math, help her to trace mathematical signs, use cue sheets, and teach her to decode symbols and to increase her math reading and fluency. Furthermore, Student will have the RSP teacher, an aid and peer buddies available to help her. Finally, Mr. Schnitzler testified that as Student’s math fluency increases, so will Student’s comprehension in reading, math, and in all of her other academic subjects.
Ms. Molodow, Ms. Tandberg and Ms. Dinnerstein testified that the vocational education goals and objectives will also provide an overlay for Student’s history and science classes. With regard to her assignments in history and science, the teachers will adjust and modify them by shortening the tasks and providing her with extra time to complete them, provide her with preferential seating, and repeated oral and written directions. They will also highlight key ideas and paragraphs and give her a smaller number of paragraphs to read. Second, the staff will also make technology available to Student to help her in all of her classes. She will have access to the computer lab to listen to assignments and books on CD Rom. Finally, Student will have access to low technology supports to help her with her processing weaknesses. Her work will be color-coded so she will be able to use different colored markers, graphic organizers, and collages to illustrate main ideas of her work.
During the hearing, the District’s witnesses discussed whether Student needed to be retained in the fifth grade for the 2001-2002 school year because her parents had made this request at the October 2001 IEP meeting. Ms. Redding, Ms. Tandberg, Ms. Dinnerstein, and Mr. Schnitzler testified that Student did not need to be retained in the fifth grade. They uniformly stated that Student is socially and emotionally more mature than her other fifth grade classmates, is very friendly and outgoing, and would have no problem assimilating into a sixth grade class. Academically, as discussed above, Ms. Ohkawahira and Ms. Ellison testified that Student’s knowledge of math is only one year below grade level and her knowledge of language arts is approximately a year to a year and a half below grade level. Ms. Redding and Ms. Dinnerstein testified that RSP support, intensive services in language, and accommodations and modifications would meet Student’s unique and individual math and language arts needs and help her to bridge the gap between her present levels of performance and the sixth grade curriculum. Thus, the District’s witnesses concluded that Student did not need to be retained in the fifth grade.
During the hearing, the District’s witnesses also discussed the safety of Mark Twain’s campus because Student’s parents raised it as an issue both before, during and after the October 10, 2001 IEP meeting. Ms. Yvonne Noble, principal at Mark Twain, testified that Mark Twain’s campus is safe. Ms. Noble stated that the campus has a police officer and full-time security on campus. Furthermore, all gates but the main gate into the school are locked during school hours, and a visitor must pass through and sign in at the main office before entering the campus. Finally, Ms. Lainey Rogers, District operations administrator, brought and reviewed crime data on schools within the District, which included similar data from Mark Twain. Her review of the statistics revealed that the majority of the problems on Mark Twain’s campus were for fighting, student disobedience, and petty theft. The statistics revealed that the problems Mark Twain experienced on its campus were typical of other middle school campus within the District. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that pursuant to the statistics provided at the hearing, Mark Twain’s campus is as safe as other middle schools within the District and would be able to provide Student a FAPE.
In summary, the evidence at the hearing established that the sixth-grade general education class with RSP services at Mark Twain offers Student an appropriate program to meet her unique and individual needs. As indicated by the undisputed evidence, the program offers Student a general education curriculum with experienced general and RSP teachers, a general education curriculum with individualized accommodations and modifications to meet her needs in math and language arts, and additional time in the RSP reading program to improve her reading and language skills, all of which are geared to her unique and individual needs. Finally, the Hearing Officer did not find that Student needed to be retained in a fifth-grade classroom because the placement at Mark Twain Middle School will provide Student with the accommodations, and modifications she needs to be successful in a sixth-grade setting. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed offer of a sixth-grade general education class with RSP support and pull-out was designed to meet Student’s unique and individual needs for the 2001-2002 school year.
(c) Is the proposed placement at Mark Twain Middle School reasonably calculated to provide Student with educational benefit?
In determining whether the placement offered by the District for the 2001-2002 school year would provide Student with a FAPE, it is next necessary to determine if the proposed placement at Mark Twain Middle School would provide Student with educational benefit. As discussed previously, the Hearing Officer found that the District’s offer was designed to meet Student’s needs in the areas of math and language arts by providing her with the modifications, accommodations, individualized attention and supports she requires to meet her unique and individual needs. Finally, the IEP team drafted goals and objectives in math, language arts, and vocational education to address Student’s identified needs.
The District’s witnesses who have either assessed or worked directly with Student testified that she will benefit both academically, socially, and emotionally by placement in a sixth-grade general educational curriculum with RSP support services. Ms. Redding testified that while Student is presently a grade level to a grade level and a half below her chronological age in math and language arts, placement in the sixth-grade provides the best chance of bringing Student up to her expected grade level. Furthermore, District witnesses uniformly testified that Student would benefit socially from being in a classroom with peers of her same age and similar academic level. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed placement in a sixth-grade general education class with RSP support services is reasonably calculated to provide Student with educational benefit.
(d) Does the proposed placement at Mark Twain Middle School conform to Student’s IEP?
There is no dispute that the District’s offer conformed to Student’s IEP of October 10, 2001. Furthermore, there is no dispute that the District was willing to provide the placement, services, and implementation of goals and objectives specified in the IEP. Thus, this issue is moot.
(e) Is the proposed placement at Mark Twain Middle School the least restrictive environment for Student?
There is no dispute that the District’s offer of placement at Mark Twain Middle School is the least restrictive environment for Student. Thus, this issue is moot.
(f) Conclusion
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s October 10, 2001 offer of placement in a sixth-grade general education class with RSP services and RSP pull-out was designed to meet Student’s unique needs, was reasonably calculated to provide Student with educational benefit, conforms to Student’s IEP, and is the least restrictive environment. Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District offered Student a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year.
ORDER
1. The District’s offer on October 10, 2001 to place Student in a sixth grade general education class with resource specialist collaboration at Mark Twain Middle School constituted a free and appropriate public education for the 2001-2002 school year.
2. The District shall immediately make a seat available for Student in the sixth grade general class with RSP services at Mark Twain Middle school.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
The District prevailed on the sole issue in this case.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: May 29, 2002 _____________________________________ Joseph T. Macaluso, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The IEP team noticed this IEP meeting at the request of Student’s parents, who then failed to appear for the IEP meeting.
2. Ms. Redding also assessed Student’s social/emotional functioning. Because the District’s witnesses testified that Student’s social/emotional skills were a strength, the Hearing Officer shall not address this aspect of the assessment which arrived at the same conclusion.
