California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 23, 2003

Student v. San Rafael City School District (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 400-03 · Hearing Officer Vincent L. Pastorino

San Rafael City School District must reimburse about $63,000 for a residential placement at Devereux and an after-school program; assessment claim denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 3 of 6 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted in the decision.

Summary

San Rafael City School District and the parents of a 10-year-old boy each filed for due process in March 2003; the cases were consolidated. The student was eligible under "autistic-like behaviors." At Children's Learning Center, a nonpublic day school, he made academic progress near grade level. But his aggression at home and in the community was severe, and he could not carry behavior skills from school into other settings. In February 2003 the District offered Spectrum Center, another day program. The parents placed him at Devereux Glenholme, a residential school in Connecticut.

The Hearing Officer found the District responded appropriately on assessment by holding IEP meetings, testing adaptive behavior, and proposing a Diagnostic Center referral, so it need not pay for the private neuropsychological evaluation. The District denied FAPE in fall 2002 by letting a therapeutic after-school program lapse without replacement, and it owed $1,445. The February 2003 offer denied FAPE. Educational benefit includes using behavior skills outside school, and the District wrongly claimed no responsibility beyond the school day. A residential placement was the least restrictive setting that could meet his needs. The District must reimburse $57,590 for Devereux, $1,462.50 for occupational therapy, and $2,882.93 for travel. If Devereux is state-certified, it becomes his placement through February 3, 2004. The District's request for a Diagnostic Center assessment without parental consent was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO treated a student's inability to generalize behavior skills outside school as an educational need under the IDEA. The Hearing Officer rejected the view that a district's responsibility ends at the school door. He found a residential placement was required after intensive day, after-school, and home behavior programs had failed.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 1. Did the District fail to appropriately assess Student during the 2002-2003 school year?

    The decline in spring 2002 matched the student's history. In fall 2002 the District responded appropriately: it held IEP meetings, had an adaptive behavior assessment done, and proposed a Diagnostic Center referral. Reimbursement for the private neuropsychological reevaluation was denied under Ed. Code 56329(b).

  2. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2A. Did the District deny Student a FAPE from the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year through the February 3, 2003 IEP meeting by failing to provide Student a school day of sufficient length?

    Student needed services to generalize behavior skills outside school. The District let the TASC after-school program lapse from the IEP and gave nothing in its place, which denied FAPE. Parents were reimbursed $1,445 for TASC costs in September and October 2002.

  3. Issue 2B. Did the District deny Student a FAPE during the same period by failing to address Student's needs related to his independent living skills, his behavior, and his socialization?

    No findings made because no further relief was sought for this period beyond the TASC reimbursement already awarded.

  4. Issue 2C. Did the District deny Student a FAPE during the same period by failing to offer a residential placement?

    No findings made on whether residential placement was required before February 3, 2003, because no additional relief was sought for that period.

  5. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 3. Was the District's January 23/February 3, 2003 IEP an offer of FAPE?

    The Spectrum Center day placement could not meet the student's need to generalize behavior skills across settings, and it posed a high risk of harm. A 24-hour residential placement was the least restrictive appropriate environment. The District must reimburse Devereux, occupational therapy, and certain travel costs, and Devereux is the prospective placement if state-certified.

  6. Issue 4. Is the District entitled to conduct an assessment of Student through the California Diagnostic Center (CDC) over the parents' refusal of consent for the assessment?

    The District did not show a need for a CDC assessment because the parties had ample information about the student's educational needs.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days, District to reimburse parents $1,445.00 for TASC after-school program costs from September 1, 2002 through October 17, 2002.
  • Reimbursement. Within 60 calendar days, District to reimburse parents $57,590.00 for Devereux costs through August 2003, $1,462.50 for OT-related costs from March through July 24, 2003, and $2,882.93 in travel expenses ($1,296.76 for enrollment travel on March 2, 2003 and $1,586.17 for the April 2, 2003 initial IEP and parent seminar). Other travel and loan-interest claims denied.
  • Prospective funding of private placement. If Devereux is a state-certified nonpublic school or agency under Ed. Code 56366.1, the IEP team shall amend the IEP to designate Devereux as the prospective placement through February 3, 2004.
  • If Devereux is not state-certified, parents remain entitled to reimbursement for Devereux costs and reasonable travel costs at least until the District offers an alternative placement meeting FAPE. Any such alternative must be a 24-hour residential placement that addresses academics and behavior, enables generalization of behavior skills outside school, provides high structure, predictability, and consistency across settings, and includes age-appropriate peers suited to his academic level.

Total: $63,380.43 ordered

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist.; Burlington; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ.; W.G. v. Target Range; County of San Diego v. California Special Education Hearing Office; Cal. Educ. Code 56329(b); Cal. Educ. Code 56381; Cal. Educ. Code 56031; 5 C.C.R. 3042(a)

People named in the decision

  • Sharon Pincus, District director of special education, San Rafael City School District
  • Elizabeth Tyler, special education teacher, Children's Learning Center (nonpublic school)
  • Maryanne Richards Pearson, special education teacher, Children's Learning Center (nonpublic school)
  • Kathleen Hayes, elementary program director, Children's Learning Center (nonpublic school)
  • Angela Zamora-Castillo, assistant director, District's proposed nonpublic day school, Spectrum Center
  • Steven Daley, Ph.D., expert witness for District; professor of special education, California State University Sacramento
  • Jane Sanctuary, school psychologist, San Rafael City School District
  • Reed Connell, behavior technician, in-home behavior support, Parent-retained in-home program
  • Christina Miller, case manager, Golden Gate Regional Center
  • Elizabeth Isono, licensed occupational therapist, Private provider
  • Herbert Schreier, M.D., student's psychiatrist; expert witness for Student, Children's Hospital of Oakland
  • Ruth Serepca, Ph.D., pediatric neuropsychologist; independent evaluator and expert witness for Student, Private
  • Molly Baron, education specialist; parents' advocate, Private
  • Travis Boucher, special education teacher, Devereux Glenholme
  • Rebecca Rancourt, social worker, Devereux Glenholme
  • Virginia Bassie (Bassi), Ph.D., clinical psychologist; director of TASC/STARS after-school and summer programs, Therapeutic After School Care (TASC)
  • Gus Conklin, behaviorist who supervised home-based behavior program, Private
  • Jennifer Seymour, TASC staff (doctor), Therapeutic After School Care (TASC)
  • Dr. Tennant, TASC staff (doctor), Therapeutic After School Care (TASC)
  • Bonnie Rottier, student's psychotherapist, Private
  • Children's Learning Center, nonpublic school
  • Spectrum Center (Tara Hills campus, San Pablo), nonpublic day school offered by District
  • Devereux Glenholme, nonpublic residential school (Connecticut)
  • Therapeutic After School Care (TASC) / STARS, therapeutic after-school and summer program
  • Golden Gate Regional Center, regional center
  • Marin County Community Mental Health Services, county mental health agency (proposed referral)
  • California Diagnostic Center, state diagnostic center (proposed assessment)

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, on July 24, 25, 29, 30, 31, and August 1, 2003, in San Rafael, California.

The Petitioner and Cross Respondent, San Rafael City School District (District), was represented at the hearing by attorneys Amy R. Levine and Damara Moore from the office of Ruiz & Sperow, LLP. Also present on the District’s behalf was Sharon Pincus, District director of special education. The Respondent and Cross Petitioner, STUDENT (STUDENT or Student), was represented by attorney Kathryn Dobel. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was his mother, MOTHER, and his father, FATHER.

The District called the following witnesses: Sharon Pincus; Elizabeth Tyler, special education teacher at Children’s Learning Center (CLC); Angela Zamora-Castillo, assistant director at Spectrum Center (Spectrum); Steven Daley, Ph.D., professor of special education at California State University Sacramento; Jane Sanctuary, District school psychologist; Reed Connell, behavior technician; and Christina Miller, case manager at Golden Gate Regional Center (GGRC). The Student called the following witnesses: Maryanne Richards Pearson, special education teacher at CLC; Kathleen Hayes, elementary program director at CLC; Elizabeth Isono, licensed occupational therapist; FATHER; MOTHER; Herbert Schreier, M.D., chief of psychiatry at Children’s Hospital of Oakland; Ruth Serepca, Ph.D., pediatric neuropsychologist; Molly Baron, education specialist; Travis Boucher, special education teacher at Devereux Glenholme (Devereux); Rebecca Rancourt, social worker at Devereux; and Virginia Bassie, Ph.D., clinical psychologist.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open until the Hearing Office received closing briefs on August 19, 2003, and the matter was submitted for decision. ISSUES

Issue 1: Did the District fail to appropriately assess STUDENT during the 2002-2003 school year?

Issue 2: Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year through the date of the individualized education program (IEP) meeting on February 3, 2003, by:

A. Failing to provide STUDENT a school day of sufficient length,

B. Failing to address STUDENT’s needs related to his independent living skills, his behavior, and his socialization, and

C. Failing to offer a residential placement?

Issue 3: Was the District’s January 23/February 3, 2003 IEP an offer of FAPE?

Issue 4: Is the District entitled to conduct an assessment of STUDENT through the California Diagnostic Center (CDC) over the parents’ refusal of consent for the assessment? (footnote 1)

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT, born [date redacted], was initially found eligible for special education in 1996 under the category of speech and language disorder and thereafter began receiving services in a preschool for children with communicative deficits. He was later diagnosed with autism in 1997 and has also been diagnosed as having Tourette’s syndrome and Pica. (footnote 2) STUDENT’s current eligibility classification with the District is “autistic-like behaviors.” In March 2003, his parents enrolled him into Devereux Glenholme (Devereux), a nonpublic school, and he was continuing to attend Devereux at the time of hearing.

STUDENT commenced an intensive behavior intervention program in the fall of 1997 and completed his transition to a regular education preschool in January 1998. He attended various other preschools until being placed in a regular education kindergarten class at the commencement of the 1999-2000 school year. From the beginning of preschool through the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT demonstrated severe behavior difficulties. Incidents of physical aggression and threats to attack or kill people and destroy places or things were frequent at school, at home, and in the community. STUDENT was started on “atypical antipsychotic” drugs in an effort to control his aggressiveness, and later was prescribed other drugs to stabilize his mood, control tics from his Tourette’s syndrome, and enable sleep. Effectiveness of the drugs was marginal.

Primarily because of STUDENT’s continuing behavior problems, the District and STUDENT’s parents agreed to have STUDENT placed at the Children’s Learning Center (CLC), a nonpublic school, for the 2000-2001 school year. Related services for that school year included occupational therapy (OT), speech and language (S/L) therapy, and assistive technology (AT). At the parents’ request, STUDENT was observed at CLC in December 2000 by Ruth Serepca, Ph.D. Following her observations, Dr. Serepca stated that although STUDENT had shown improvement in reading, attention, and social participation compared to one year earlier, she was still concerned about writing, socialization, and language difficulties. (footnote 3) She stated her further concern that unless STUDENT received a behavior program implemented consistently across school and home environments, his behavior would eventually necessitate placement outside the home.

At the January 2001 individualized education program (IEP) meeting, the parents presented a written, detailed narrative of their impressions and observations regarding STUDENT’s status. STUDENT’s age at that time was 7 years and 5 months. In the narrative, the parents stated their opinions that “STUDENT receives the individualized instruction and behavioral supports he currently needs in the CLC placement”; that Dr. Serepca’s impression of the placement was generally positive; and that they were “glad” STUDENT was in a “safe appropriate educational setting,” especially after having been in five different schools prior to his placement in CLC. However, on the basis of Dr. Serepca’s impressions and the parents’ experience with STUDENT, the parents expressed their concern that STUDENT might soon require a residential placement if his ongoing behavior difficulties were not successfully addressed. The parents reported that a behaviorist, Gus Conklin, had been retained to staff and supervise a home-based behavior management program to commence in the near future. The parents were hoping that the program would be funded, at least in part, through the Golden Gate Regional Center (GGRC). STUDENT’s behavior was described by the parents as severe and as having recently worsened “sharply” in October 2000 and continuing thereafter. The parents noted that STUDENT’s most problematic behavior had occurred in the home and community. The parents stated that although behavior problems were present at CLC, those problems were “not nearly at the level of physical agitation and physical aggression that is seen at home.” They noted that STUDENT’s behavior with his respite workers and grandparents was assaultive and that STUDENT also had behavior problems, although less severe, with his OT and S/L therapists.

The January 2001 IEP described STUDENT’s deficits in behavior and included a behavior plan and behavior-related goals and objectives. There was no mention of concern, either within the text of the IEP or in the parents’ above-referenced narrative, that STUDENT’s behavior at CLC was so severe or unmanageable as to prevent STUDENT from achieving academic progress at CLC. Instead, notations in the IEP state that although STUDENT required multiple prompts, such as up to four prompts to write his name, he was meeting his grade-level (first grade) standards for reading, language arts, and math, and he was completing tasks as directed.

STUDENT’s new home-based behavior management program commenced in February 2001 under the supervision of Mr. Conklin. Threats and assaults by STUDENT continued at home, during community and recreational outings, and during transportation to and from school. The program was discontinued in July 2001, with Mr. Conklin reportedly concluding that the required intensity for a successful program for STUDENT could not be adequately implemented in a home program.

Dr. Serepca reevaluated STUDENT in November 2001. She concluded that STUDENT had shown academic success at CLC and had made progress at CLC in developing appropriate classroom behavior. She recommended that STUDENT continue at CLC. She believed that before the IEP team could realistically consider STUDENT’s transition to a less restrictive placement, STUDENT’s behavior and social skills must be further developed. She recommended restarting a home-based behavior program with appropriate consultation and support, having STUDENT participate in an after-school program emphasizing community and social skills development, and continuing OT and S/L therapy. She also described specific strategies to address social skills and anger management.

STUDENT’s January 8, 2002 annual-review IEP states that because STUDENT, age 8 years, was performing at grade level (second grade) in reading comprehension, math calculation, spelling, and language arts, no modification of curriculum would be made for STUDENT. The OT and S/L reports discuss STUDENT’s progress in those areas, and neither of those reports indicates that STUDENT’s behavior was interfering with therapy. Present levels of performance listed in the IEP state that STUDENT (at school) was making verbal threats or reacting inappropriately at an average rate of about one time per week. (footnote 4) The January 8, 2002 “parent report,” a five-page narrative attached to the IEP, lists STUDENT’s continuing behavior problems at home, in the community, and during transportation, including growling at others, being defiant and seriously noncompliant, shaking his finger in adults’ faces at close proximity, threatening, yelling, ordering, stomping his feet to wake people, slamming doors, running out of the house, throwing objects or hitting objects to damage them, brandishing objects (e.g. broomsticks, wrenches) at people, throwing objects at people, hitting people, grabbing wrists, grabbing throats, kicking, attempting to bite, spitting, and urinating on the floor and threatening to urinate in the car. In STUDENT’s time-out room, where STUDENT would intentionally urinate on the floor, the parents had been compelled for safety reasons to board or otherwise seal the window and closet. All of the above was occurring in spite of intensive efforts by the parents and in-home staff in implementing behavior strategies. The parents’ narrative also informed the District that the parents were continuing to seek information on residential placement for use in the event such placement eventually became necessary.

In February 2002, at age 8 years and 6 months, STUDENT was promoted to a new, more age-appropriate classroom at CLC, with more formal structure and higher demands of the students. MOTHER began to search for an after-school program for STUDENT to address socialization and recreation. The Therapeutic After School Care (TASC) program was added to STUDENT’s IEP on February 28, 2002. The TASC program was to be implemented for “up to” three hours per day, four days per week.

By the summer of 2002, STUDENT’s behavior had been in decline, especially outside of school. STUDENT had been making written and oral threats to his parents, and he warned his parents, in writing, not to send him to summer school. In July 2002, STUDENT’s mother reported to GGRC that more respite hours were needed because of STUDENT’s increased behaviors. The mother reported that STUDENT was having an increase in compliance problems at school, and she also reported that at home he was hitting and kicking family members many times each day. Instead of sleeping at night, he would often emerge from his bedroom, confrontational and aggressive. The mother again inquired of GGRC about recommendations for residential programs.

Following completion of the 2002 extended school year (ESY) program at CLC, STUDENT attended the STARS program for the remainder of the summer. STARS was the summer version of the TASC program, with both programs being under the supervision of Virginia Bassi, Ph.D.

In her August 13, 2002 letter to STUDENT’s service providers, MOTHER described STUDENT’s behavior status. The letter states that adverse behaviors had been increasing since March 2002. The current problems were “severe and have not let up at all.” STUDENT was reportedly being increasingly oppositional and noncompliant. One to five times daily, according to the letter, STUDENT was kicking, biting, hitting, hitting with objects, and throwing objects. His weight had increased to 80 pounds, and his size was preventing his mother from being able to safely restrain or contain STUDENT. The letter noted that the frequent and sustained physical aggression STUDENT displayed at home was not occurring in the TASC or CLC settings. The letter stated the parents’ belief that, absent sustained improvement in STUDENT’s behavior, safety considerations would soon dictate a residential placement.

Through the fall of 2002, STUDENT’s parents continued to provide in-home behavior support with various staff persons, most particular, Reed Connell. In his testimony, Mr. Connell described the continuing physical aggression displayed by STUDENT, which required physical restraint on a regular basis. Mr. Connell and STUDENT’s father, FATHER, also described the inherent dangers of transporting STUDENT by car due to his direct assaults on the driver and the futility of using special seats and straps designed to restrain STUDENT in the vehicle. Medication adjustments during the fall of 2002 were made for the purpose of attempting to control STUDENT’s behavior. As described by witnesses for both parties, the medication adjustments coincided with significantly increased disturbances in STUDENT’s sleep patterns, adversely affecting his alertness at school.

In addition to his increased behaviors outside the school setting during the summer and fall of 2002, STUDENT also showed significant deterioration of his willingness to be compliant at school and perform his school work. His CLC teachers testified that to address his lack of compliance at school and avoid provoking adverse behaviors, expectations for his work output were dramatically reduced. For example, one of the tasks that STUDENT has historically disliked is writing. In spite of his dislike for writing, in the spring of 2002 he had been able to write several appropriate sentences on particular topics. However, during the fall of 2002, according to the testimony of his CLC teachers, output requirements were significantly reduced to the point that, even with prompting, STUDENT was only expected to either write his name or merely touch his pencil to his paper.

On October 17, 2002, a documented incident of significant aggression finally occurred in a structured setting. While at TASC, STUDENT attacked Dr. Jennifer Seymour, grabbing her by the throat, and then he head-butted, kicked, and otherwise hit Dr. Tennant. During the same occasion, he made verbal threats ranging from “shaving” Dr. Tennant to going home to get a bat or knife. STUDENT’s mother was called, and the TASC doctors urged her to call the police and have STUDENT taken to a mental health clinic for possible hospitalization. STUDENT’s mother explained to TASC that the behavior they had just observed was similar to what the parents had been experiencing in non-school settings for the past three years, and she did not want STUDENT hospitalized, especially when inquiries were pending for a residential placement. Following that incident, STUDENT never returned to TASC.

The CLC progress report dated October 23, 2002, states that since his return to school in the fall of 2002, STUDENT had demonstrated a “marked decrease in his academic and behavioral performance.” He had demonstrated lack of motivation, “extreme lethargy,” and noncompliance across classroom activities. He had also shown lack of interest in the reinforcements used in his behavior program. The report stated that by utilizing the strategy of decreasing academic and behavioral demands and increasing levels of positive reinforcement, STUDENT had recently been increasing his class participation and work output. The plan was to gradually increase expectations and demands as his output increased. The report states that STUDENT occasionally responded to teacher directions with a verbal refusal and occasionally with threats of aggression or bodily harm. His frustrations occasionally escalated to physical disruption, and the report states that, on October 3, a physical restraint had to be used on STUDENT for his own safety. The report concludes by stating that, academically and behaviorally, STUDENT’s performance had decreased in several domains, but recent revisions to his program had resulted in STUDENT’s recovering from some of that decrease. He had improved in reading and telling time to five- and one-minute intervals. According to the report, he remained well-liked by his peers and his teachers enjoyed having him in the classroom.

On November 6, 2002, MOTHER met with the District director of special education, Sharon Pincus, to update Ms. Pincus on the TASC incident and discuss STUDENT’s recent difficulties in his educational program and his increased negative behaviors in non-school settings. In a follow-up letter to Ms. Pincus on December 2, MOTHER requested that an IEP meeting be convened as soon as possible instead of waiting for the January 23, 2003 due date of STUDENT’s annual IEP.

Pursuant to MOTHER’s request, an IEP meeting was convened on December 13. The notes in the resulting IEP addendum indicate an acknowledgment by the IEP team that STUDENT’s recent behaviors were adversely affecting his progress in school, but there was disagreement regarding the degree that STUDENT’s progress was being affected. According to the IEP notes, Kathy Hayes from CLC stated that STUDENT had “ups and downs” and his recent behavior “hasn’t affected his school performance that much.” She reportedly stated that after reduction of the academic demands placed upon STUDENT in school, STUDENT’s “on task behavior” had recently been improving at school and he was gradually “catching up” to the work output levels he had been at in June 2002. For example, he had been writing four sentences independently in June 2002, and, after temporarily being at a level where he had only been writing his name in the fall of 2002, he was now writing two or three sentences independently. She acknowledged that STUDENT remained unable to “generalize things he has learned at school to home and after school programs.” The team discussed the changes that doctors had been made to STUDENT’s medications in the fall of 2002 in the doctors’ attempts to adjust STUDENT’s mood, behaviors, and sleep patterns. The parents characterized STUDENT’s setbacks in his school setting and related services as “unacceptable,” and although they remained willing to consider other alternatives, the parents stated their belief that STUDENT now required a residential placement.

Prior to the conclusion of the IEP meeting, the parents’ advocate, Molly Baron, presented the IEP team with a list of three potential residential placements, including Devereux Glenholme (Devereux) in Connecticut and two other schools on the east coast. The parents requested that a Vineland test be administered by the school psychologist, and the District agreed. (footnote 5) The parents also requested that the District pay for TASC services from September through October 2002. (footnote 6) Ms. Pincus, according to the IEP notes, stated the District’s position that the District was responsible for providing an educational program but not for providing other services (such as a residential placement). Ms. Pincus also suggested that referral be made to the “Diagnostic Center.”

By letter dated January 6, 2003, STUDENT’s parents informed the District that they would be visiting the Devereux school in Connecticut as soon as possible, and they requested that the District assist in the application process and place STUDENT at Devereux. The parents also informed the District that they were seeking an “independent reevealuation” by Dr. Serepca and they would seek reimbursement from the District for that reevaluation. By letter dated January 7, STUDENT’s parents informed Christina Miller at GGRC that they had asked the District to change STUDENT’s educational placement to Devereux, and the letter requested that GGRC place STUDENT at Devereux as soon as possible “in coordination with other agencies as appropriate.”

Liz Isono, STUDENT’s occupational therapist, issued a detailed progress report dated January 10, 2003. The report listed OT-related gains that STUDENT “has made in many areas over the course of the year.” Improvement in “activities of daily living” included progress in dressing and table-manner skills, and STUDENT reportedly had been successful in using some of those skills in a restaurant setting. The report referenced the difficulties that STUDENT had during the fall of 2002 and emphasized that his reaction to OT during that period confirmed a critical need for “repetition and consistency across environments” with a structured and consistent program addressing all of his OT needs, to include direct OT services “with consultation to school, staff, and his parents.” The report stated that “intense intervention across environments is needed to facilitate the registration of newly learned and previously learned information so that is [sic] will be assessable [sic] as needed to sustain his continued success.” Initiation of the “Alert Program” was recommended by Ms. Isono to assist STUDENT with his ability to regulate his behavior.

On January 16, 2003, the District submitted parent information and consent forms to STUDENT’s parents for the District’s proposed referral of STUDENT to the California Diagnostic Center (CDC).

STUDENT’s annual review IEP meeting was held on January 23, 2003. Dr. Serepca attended the meeting. She had reevaluated STUDENT earlier in January, and she explained her findings to the IEP team. (footnote 7) Dr. Serepca generally told the IEP team that notwithstanding STUDENT’s having received excellent services from a highly qualified team of providers, she could provide no persuasive reason to dissuade STUDENT’s parents from requesting a residential placement for STUDENT. She acknowledged to the IEP team that STUDENT had made “some really nice” academic gains and some gains in his receptive language skills. However, she stated that STUDENT had some regression in certain aspects of his expressive language in the area of speech fluency, manifested by his increased propensity for continually repeating the last syllable or sound of a word or phrase. She also believed that in the past year STUDENT had significantly regressed in his ability to produce work. She attributed STUDENT’s regression in those areas to a decrease in the executive function capacity of STUDENT’s brain. She stated that STUDENT’s impairment of executive function was so severe that the skills he was learning in the highly structured settings at CLC could not be generalized at home or in the community. She believed that STUDENT’s need for structure, repetition, and consistency across environments accounted for the fact that STUDENT’s adverse behaviors, including frequent aggression, most often occurred outside of CLC. Dr. Serepca also told the IEP team that STUDENT is endangering the community every day he remains at home.

At the January 23, 2002 IEP meeting, some of STUDENT’s teachers and other providers also expressed their opinions of STUDENT’s status and progress. Mr. Connell reported on STUDENT’s behaviors, stating that STUDENT’s aggressive behaviors had reached critical levels in the home. Mr. Connell stated that STUDENT was capable of inflicting harm on everyone in the home and had, in fact, inflicted harm on his family members. He reported that about nine out of every ten of STUDENT’s behavior-related interactions in the community were inappropriate and the home-based behavior management program had been ineffective. STUDENT’s psychiatrist, Herbert Schreier, M.D., stated his opinion that in spite of multiple medication adjustments, STUDENT’s impulsive and aggressive behaviors were “quite frightening” and posed a danger to family members and other persons present in STUDENT’s environment. He stated his opinion that STUDENT should either be hospitalized or placed residentially. Prior to the conclusion of the IEP meeting, the parents reiterated their intent to place STUDENT at Devereux. No resolution was reached regarding placement, and the team agreed to continue the meeting to February 3, 2003.

The IEP team next met on February 3, 2003, as scheduled. The District’s school psychologist, Ms. Sanctuary, discussed her recent assessment of STUDENT’s adaptive behavior skills. Her findings confirmed STUDENT’s having adaptive skills and coping skills below age level and performing better in the school environment than in the home environment. She concurred that STUDENT had the “ability” to do certain tasks as listed on the Vineland, but he frequently did not do them because of his impairments in attention and executive function. To the limited extent that he did show adaptive skills, he required help and timely prompting. Ms. Sanctuary believed that, academically, STUDENT was learning in his CLC environment. With respect to the question of why STUDENT was performing better at school than at home or in the community, Kathleen Hayes from CLC, Mr. Connell, and Dr. Serepca stated their opinions that the school environment’s high levels of structure and predictability, constant prompting by adults to help and direct STUDENT through each situation and task, and consistency in the reinforcement schedule and daily activities were all critical for STUDENT and could not be replicated in the home environment or mainstream community. His psychotherapist, Bonnie Rottier, offered that, developmentally, STUDENT was still in the “oppositional stage” and that he presently lacked the executive function necessary to enable him to move beyond the oppositional stage.

During the February 3, 2003 IEP meeting, the team was generally in agreement regarding STUDENT’s academic, communication, OT, and social/emotional goals and objectives and his behavior plan insofar as their application to STUDENT’s school days at CLC. However, fundamental disagreement arose between the parties regarding whether STUDENT’s goals and objectives, particularly with respect to behavior and adaptive skills, should be written to apply across not only the school setting but also the home and community settings. Dr. Serepca emphasized that if STUDENT could perform certain skills in the school environment but not outside the school environment, he was not really acquiring those skills and not receiving educational benefit in those particular skill areas. On behalf of the District, Ms. Pincus stated that the goals proposed by the District would be addressed by the school (CLC), S/L therapy, and OT and were designed to give STUDENT skills to function outside the school environment. She stated that she hoped, with sufficient time, that STUDENT would be able to generalize his skills outside the school environment. However, Ms. Pincus emphasized that the District could not control what was occurring beyond school settings and, therefore, the District would not agree to making STUDENT’s IEP goals and objectives applicable across home and community settings.

On behalf of CLC, Ms. Hayes stated at the February 3, 2003 IEP meeting that CLC’s expertise was academic instruction and CLC was not equipped to address all of STUDENT’s goals and objectives related to adaptive skills. Furthermore, CLC was concerned about the lack of generalization shown by STUDENT. Ms. Hayes stated that she had not seen another CLC student who made such progress in the school environment but was so unable to generalize his skills outside school, even after having just stepped outside the “school door” and into the car for transportation.

Ms. Pincus, anticipating the concerns of Ms. Hayes, had contacted the Spectrum Center (Spectrum) prior to the February 3, 2003 IEP meeting. Ms. Pincus reportedly had obtained assurances from Spectrum, a nonpublic day school in the area, that it had an appropriate class for someone with STUDENT’s relatively strong academic functioning and his behavior-related needs. Ms. Pincus had particularly considered Spectrum because it had programs available for instructing STUDENT in community settings. Ms. Pincus provided written materials to STUDENT’s parents regarding Spectrum and a visit was subsequently arranged. The IEP meeting concluded with the District offering Spectrum as STUDENT’s placement and denying the parents’ request for a residential placement. The District also offered a referral to Marin County Community Mental Health Services (Mental Health) for an assessment of STUDENT.

On February 4, 2003, the PARENTS were informed that STUDENT had been accepted by Devereux for placement in its residential school program in Connecticut. On February 6, STUDENT’s parents visited the District’s proposed placement at Spectrum on the Tara Hills campus in San Pablo. On February 11, MOTHER telephoned Mental Health and inquired about what Mental Health’s role could potentially be in STUDENT’s education. She was reportedly told that STUDENT would not eligible for Mental Health services if his problems were the result of autism. On February 12, MOTHER informed CLC that STUDENT’s last day at CLC would be February 28 and he would commence attending Devereux on March 3. She also informedand to the community. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs services designed to enable him to generalize his behavior-related skills outside the school setting. (footnote 13)

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDEN GGRC of her impressions of three local group homes that she had visited pursuant to information provided by GGRC and why she believed those group homes would not be appropriate for STUDENT. Also on February 12, MOTHER informed the District that she did not believe STUDENT was within the category of children who could be served by Mental Health and, therefore, she would not sign the referral to Mental Health. On February 18, MOTHER informed the District that because she believed STUDENT required a 24-hour per day residential placement, she was rejecting the District’s offer and STUDENT would commence at Devereux on March 3. She also informed the District of her intent to seek reimbursement from the District for the costs associated with Devereux, and she sent Dr. Serepca’s completed January 2003 evaluation report to the District and GGRC. Also on February 18, MOTHER sent a letter to GGRC requesting that GGRC collaborate with the District to fund their appropriate portions of STUDENT’s costs at Devereux.

STUDENT and the District each submitted due process hearing requests on March 3, 2003, and the cases were later consolidated for the current hearing. STUDENT commenced his enrollment at Devereux on March 3. According to Devereux status reports and the testimony of his parents and Devereux staff, STUDENT is making good progress academically and behaviorally at Devereux and has performed well on Devereux-supervised community outings. STUDENT has remained at Devereux through the dates of the current hearing.

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

In Issue 1, STUDENT asserts that the District failed to appropriately assess him during the 2002-2003 school year. More specifically, STUDENT asserts that he was regressing in his academic work output and in his behavior from February 2002 through the fall of 2002, and the District was therefore required to assess him because of that regression. As the remedy for the District’s failure to assess STUDENT appropriately during the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT’s parents seek reimbursement for the private neuropsychological assessment performed by Dr. Serepca in January 2003. The District asserts that it offered and conducted an appropriate assessment.

Issue 2 covers the period from the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year through February 3, 2003. STUDENT’s basic assertion in Issue 2 is that the District failed to offer a program that appropriately addressed his inability to generalize his behavior-related skills outside the school setting. The only remedy sought by STUDENT in Issue 2 is reimbursement for the September and October 2002 costs of his enrollment in the TASC after-school program.

In Issue 3, covering the annual IEP period from February 3, 2003 through February 3, 2004, STUDENT asserts that the District failed to offer a program that appropriately addressed his inability to generalize his behavior-related skills outside the school setting. STUDENT asserts that a residential placement was required for a FAPE, and he requests reimbursement for the costs associated with his enrollment at Devereux from March 2003 through the date of the hearing. STUDENT also seeks an order for prospective placement at Devereux from the date of the hearing through February 3, 2004. The District asserts that STUDENT does not require a residential placement and that the placement offered by the District was appropriate.

Issue 4 concerns the District’s proposal for an assessment by the California Diagnostic Center.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue 1: Did the District fail to appropriately assess STUDENT during the 2002-2003 school year?

Specific legal requirements for special education assessments are set forth by statute and regulation. “Before any action is taken with respect to the initial placement of an individual with exceptional needs in special education instruction, an assessment of the pupil’s educational needs shall be conducted . . .” Cal. Educ. Code § 56320. Reassessment of a pupil, based upon procedures specified in section 56320, “shall be conducted at least once every three years or more frequently, if conditions warrant a reassessment, or if the pupil’s parent or teacher requests a reassessment and a new individualized education program to be developed.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56381. A pupil must be “assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f). A parent has a right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil from qualified specialists if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency. However, if the district’s assessment, through a due process hearing, is determined to be appropriate, the parent is not entitled to have the independent assessment at public expense. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b).

As listed in the July 23, 2003 Prehearing Conference Order, the Student made numerous contentions regarding alleged deficiencies in the District’s assessment of STUDENT applicable to the 2002-2003 school year. Notwithstanding the list of contentions in the Prehearing Conference Order, the Student’s actual contentions regarding assessment, as presented at the hearing, are that the Student was regressing in his academic work output and in his behavior from February 2002 through the fall of 2002 and the District was therefore required to assess the Student because of that regression. As a remedy for the District’s alleged failure to appropriately assess, the Student’s parents seek reimbursement for the private neuropsychological assessment performed by Dr. Serepca in January 2003.

The District asserts that given STUDENT’s circumstances in the spring and fall of 2002, it appropriately addressed any matters related to assessment by having its school psychologist conduct an assessment of STUDENT’s self-help skills and adaptive functioning in January 2003, offering a referral to the California Diagnostic Center in January 2003, receiving and discussing reports from STUDENT’s S/L therapist, occupational therapist, and CLC at the January 23 and February 3, 2003 IEP meetings, and offering a referral for assessment by Mental Health on February 3, 2003.

As legal authority for his assertions regarding assessment, the Student cites the “seek and serve requirements of Cal. Educ. Code section 56302.” Section 56302 provides, in general, that districts are required to provide procedures for the identification and assessment of an individual’s exceptional needs and for the planning of an instructional program to meet those needs. The statute basically addresses the duty of districts or SELPAs to have procedures for seeking out and identifying pupils with exceptional needs so that those needs can be met through special education and related services. The Hearing Officer considers section 56302 to be largely inapplicable to the present situation, where STUDENT has already been identified as an individual with exceptional needs and has been receiving special education services for several years. Instead, the pertinent question is whether conditions warranted reassessment. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381.

The evidence confirmed that adverse changes in STUDENT’s work output and behavior occurred in the spring of 2002. However, extensive testimony by MOTHER and documents pertaining to STUDENT’s performance in earlier school years confirmed that STUDENT has a long-standing history of experiencing temporary declines in his performance levels, with such declines persisting for several months. The evidence showed that the nature and degree of STUDENT’s decline in performance during the spring and summer of 2002 was consistent with STUDENT’s longstanding history. Thus, the decline in performance was not so remarkable as to warrant a reassessment at the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year. Whether new conditions arising during the fall of 2002 warranted reassessment will now be addressed.

Testimony from Herbert Schreier, M.D., Dr. Serepca, MOTHER, and CLC staff confirmed that during the fall of 2002, STUDENT continued to display an increasingly hostile attitude toward attending school. Their testimony also confirmed that increases in STUDENT’s oppositional behaviors at school during the fall of 2002 were causing STUDENT’s work output to decrease. Their testimony also showed that sleep disturbances during the fall of 2002 were adversely affecting STUDENT’s ability to attend to task while at school. Elizabeth Tyler and Maryanne Richards Pearson, STUDENT’s teachers at CLC, testified regarding the diminishment of STUDENT’s work output to the eventual degree that instead of having STUDENT write multiple sentences as he had been doing in the spring of 2002, in the fall of 2002 he was considered to be meeting expectations if he merely wrote his name or even touched his pencil to his paper. STUDENT also began displaying assaultive behaviors toward staff at CLC and TASC in October 2002. (footnote 8) Testimony and documentary evidence confirmed that the District was regularly informed of these events by written reports, oral accounts, and/or letters from CLC and MOTHER. One of the more recent examples of such information was the October 23, 2002 progress report from CLC that began by stating that “since STUDENT’s return to school in the fall, he has demonstrated a marked decrease in his academic and behavioral performance.”

CLC staff testified that during the fall of 2002 they had taken action to address STUDENT’s decreased performance by decreasing the expected work output. Whether due to the strategy of decreasing work-output expectations, adjustment of STUDENT’s medication, other factors unknown, or a combination thereof, the testimony of CLC staff confirmed that STUDENT’s work output thereafter began to gradually increase. They testified that by December 2002, STUDENT’s work output levels were approaching STUDENT’s spring 2002 output levels.

STUDENT’s IEP team met on December 13, 2002. The meeting was attended by, among others, two members of the CLC staff, Dr. Bassi from TASC, and Ms. Miller from GGRC. The meeting notes recount that STUDENT’s work output levels had been increasing after adjustment to the work output expectations, and the notes state that STUDENT’s classroom behavior had been improving. The team agreed to have the school psychologist, Ms. Sanctuary, reassess STUDENT’s adaptive behavior/self-help skills. Ms. Pincus suggested at the December 13 IEP meeting that STUDENT be referred to the CDC for assessment, and referral forms for CDC were submitted to the parents on January 16. Meanwhile, STUDENT’s parents notified the District on January 6, 2003, that they intended to have STUDENT reassessed by Dr. Serepca and they demanded reimbursement for the reassessment. Dr. Serepca performed her reassessment, the the IEP team subsequently met on January 23 and February 3, 2003. Dr. Serepca, Dr. Schreier, and CLC staff attended one or more of those IEP meetings and presented their input.

The above facts show that by the end of October 2002, the nature and magnitude of STUDENT’s decrease in academic and behavioral performance warranted a meeting by the IEP team to discuss STUDENT’s lack of anticipated progress. Cal. Educ. Code § 56343(b). This need was recognized by MOTHER, and she requested an IEP meeting. When the team met on December 13, the “regression” upon which the Student bases his assertion that the District failed to appropriately assess him was subsiding. The District and the IEP team thereafter used information from STUDENT’s teachers and other professional providers to formulate adjustments to STUDENT’s IEP. Many of the persons who participated in the IEP meetings from December to February had fresh knowledge of STUDENT, having engaged in ongoing interaction with STUDENT for months or years, either as his teacher, doctor, evaluator, or therapist. Furthermore, additional reports in the areas of OT and S/L had recently been written and submitted in preparation for STUDENT’s annual review IEP, due in January 2003. Interjected within the above scenario was the parents’ announcement on January 6 that they would be seeking a private reassessment by Dr. Serepca and demanding reimbursement for that assessment.

On the basis of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that with regard to the matter of assessment, the District acted appropriately through the 2002-2003 school year. The District responded to negative changes in STUDENT’s performance by convening a series of IEP team meetings through February 2003, having the IEP team receive and consider current information from STUDENT’s various providers, arranging for reassessment of STUDENT’s adaptive behavior skills, and recommending a referral to the CDC. Although Dr. Serepca’s January 2003 evaluation was helpful for understanding STUDENT’s deficits and needs, the Hearing Officer has found that the District’s actions regarding assessment were appropriate. Consequently, the provisions of Cal. Educ. Code section 56329(b) mandate denial of the parents’ request to be reimbursed for costs associated with the January 2003 assessment by Dr. Serepca, her subsequent report, and her appearances at the subsequent IEP meetings.

Issue 2: Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year through the date of the individualized education program (IEP) meeting on February 3, 2003, by: (A) Failing to provide STUDENT a school day of sufficient length, (B) Failing to address STUDENT’s needs related to his independent living skills, his behavior, and his socialization, and (C) Failing to offer a residential placement?

Individuals with exceptional needs have the right to a “free appropriate public education.” 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d), Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” (FAPE) means “special education” and “related services” available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards and conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). State law further defines the term “special education” as meaning specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of individuals with exceptional needs whose educational needs cannot be met with modification of the regular instruction program, and “related services” that may be needed to assist these individuals to benefit from specially designed instruction. Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. In accordance with the student’s unique needs and present levels of performance, the student’s IEP must provide for the student to be involved and progress in the general curriculum and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d), 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a).

Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and the decision of the Supreme Court in Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S.176 (1982), an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to meet the student’s unique needs and provide the student with some educational benefit. Rowley, at 207-208.

To determine whether a school district has offered a student a FAPE, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of a district's proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If a district's proposed program addresses the student’s unique needs, provides some educational benefit, and comports with the IEP, then that district has offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would likely result in greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314. (footnote 9)

Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and mandates that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be satisfactorily achieved. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.

The elements of FAPE that are applicable to the parties’ dispute in Issue 2 (and also in Issue 3) are whether the District’s program was designed to meet STUDENT’s behavior-related unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit in the least restrictive environment. (footnote 10) To determine whether the District’s program met those elements of FAPE, the Hearing Officer will first proceed to review the scope and magnitude of the behavior-related deficits that arise from STUDENT’s disability. The Hearing Officer will then proceed to identify STUDENT’s unique educational needs that arise from those behavior-related deficits. Finally, the Hearing Officer will evaluate, within the context of the parties’ contentions, whether the District’s program was designed to meet those needs.

STUDENT’s behavior-related deficits

The evidence showed that STUDENT’s behavior-related deficits leading up to commencement of the 2002-2003 school year and continuing throughout the fall of 2002 were multiple and profound. (footnote 11) Those deficits were manifested by STUDENT’s frequent verbal threats to kill people, such as teachers; to destroy places, such as by blowing up the school; and to destroy other various things. His occupational therapist, Elizabeth Isono, testified that STUDENT frequently threatened to smash her and blow up her and the school with a bomb. Other manifestations included, beyond mere threats, physically aggressive and assaultive behaviors. STUDENT also exhibited oppositional and noncompliant behaviors, including but not limited to refusal to do schoolwork, refusal to do what his teachers at CLC asked him to do, and resistance to attending summer school, all accompanied by threats of aggression that, if executed, would include fatal consequences.

Present levels of STUDENT’s behavior-related performance, as listed on the January 23, 2003 IEP, state that according to the “time out log,” STUDENT had three incidents of threatening behavior and three incidents of aggression at CLC from September 2002 through January 2003. Present levels of performance listed in the IEP also state that during a total of two hours and fifteen minutes of observation on December 12-13, STUDENT had 5 incidents of noncompliance, 13 incidents of being redirected back to work, 24 incidents of making off-topic comments, and 3 incidents of being out of his seat. The testimony of STUDENT’s teachers from CLC verified that the above-listed rates of occurrence were consistent with STUDENT’s behavior throughout the fall of 2002.

On October 2, 2002, STUDENT became assaultive while being sent to the time-out area at CLC and injured his hand. Due to STUDENT’s continuing aggression, the CLC staff was unable to administer first aid. In addition to the above, STUDENT had the October 2003 incident during his TASC after-school program wherein his behavior was so dramatic that the TASC staff, including psychologists who are well-acquainted with such issues, recommended to MOTHER that the police should be called and that STUDENT should be admitted to a hospital for psychiatric evaluation.

The incidence of STUDENT’s above-referenced behaviors at CLC and TASC was actually quite sparse in comparison to what was occurring at home and in the community. Adverse behaviors at home and in the community were more frequent and severe in spite of extensive efforts by CLC staff to teach STUDENT skills that were intended to be generalized outside the school setting, similar efforts by TASC, and extensive efforts by the PARENTS to modify and control STUDENT’s behavior, including the PARENTS’ hiring of behavior specialists to provide daily services in the home. STUDENT’s conduct outside the school setting was reflected in MOTHER’s statement to TASC that the October 17 incident at TASC was consistent with what STUDENT’s parents had been contending with for the past three years. Testimony by Reed Connell showed that such behavior requiring physical restraint occurred on nearly a daily basis and often on multiple occasions in a single day. FATHER’s testimony on that subject was similar, although FATHER stated that STUDENT’s behavior could fluctuate to the degree STUDENT might be nonaggressive for several days and then be aggressive for several consecutive days.

Undisputed testimony from witnesses for both parties showed that STUDENT’s aggressive and assaultive behaviors were manifested by kicking, hitting, grabbing, and choking. Testimony from the parents and Mr. Connell showed that, at home, STUDENT has brandished objects as weapons, including a golf club, a wrench, and an axe. (footnote 12) The evidence showed that STUDENT has an obsession for explosives and he frequently threatens to blow up places, such as the school. Several witnesses testified that STUDENT commonly threatens to do other fatal acts, such a putting his teachers through a paper shredder. According to the testimony of STUDENT’s parents, they live in such fear for STUDENT’s safety, their own safety, and their other children’s safety that they routinely lock interior doors to prevent STUDENT from accessing and harming them during the night and to prevent STUDENT’s escaping from the house.

Dr. Serepca and Dr. Schreier testified that STUDENT’s behaviors such as those mentioned above are a direct result of STUDENT’s autism and his Tourette’s syndrome. In particular, STUDENT lacks the executive function in his brain that would be necessary for him to be able to act appropriately in his environment and especially across multiple settings. This problem is compounded by STUDENT’s deficits in distinguishing reality from fantasy and his deficits in interpreting what occurs in his environment. Testimony by Dr. Serepca and Dr. Schreier on those matters was credible and undisputed. They characterized STUDENT’s behaviors as frightening and dangerous. Dr. Bassi from TASC testified that because of STUDENT’s behaviors, STUDENT should either be hospitalized or placed in a residential facility. All of the above experts concur that STUDENT is a danger to himself and to others, and the District presented no persuasive evidence to the contrary. Finally, as testified to by CLC staff, by Dr. Serepca, and by STUDENT’s parents, STUDENT demonstrated a nearly complete inability to generalize whatever behavior skills he acquired at CLC into the home and community.

STUDENT’s unique educational needs

There is no dispute that STUDENT’s educational needs include a highly structured school environment to address STUDENT’s behavior. This was demonstrated by the fact that although STUDENT’s behavior deficits are severe, the structure at CLC served to regulate STUDENT’s behaviors at least to an extent that enabled STUDENT to make academic progress near grade level in multiple subjects. Witnesses for both parties attributed those results to the expertise of the CLC staff and the consistency of behavioral prompts, rewards, and other aspects of STUDENT’s behavior plan as implemented in the school setting.

The primary dispute between the parties, with regard to STUDENT’s unique educational needs, is whether STUDENT needs services to directly address his inability to generalize behavioral skills across settings. STUDENT asserts that his inability to generalize is an area of educational need the District must address through IEP goals and objectives and/or services applicable to settings outside the school environment. The District asserts that districts in general are not required to write IEP goals across all settings or to otherwise modify an IEP only because of the student’s failure to generalize his knowledge from school to the home or community.

This dispute can be addressed through a review of what is meant by “educational benefit” as that term is used in federal and State special education law. Educational benefit refers to more than academic progress. A stated purpose of the IDEA is to “ensure that all children with disabilities have available to them a free appropriate public education that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs and prepare them for employment and independent living.” 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A), 34 C.F.R. § 300.1. Accordingly, the law provides that IEP goals and objectives must apply not only to meeting needs for enabling the child to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum, but also to “meeting each of the child’s other educational needs that result from the child’s disability.” 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(ii).

Courts have confirmed that appropriate goals and objectives in IEPs may include areas other than academic growth. For example, the Ninth Circuit has held that educational benefit for a particular student may also encompass the student’s social and emotional needs that affect academic progress, school behavior, and socialization. Thus, if appropriate to a student’s individual needs, IEP goals and objectives may also address behavioral and emotional growth. County of San Diego v. California Special Education Hearing Office, 93 F.3d 1458 (9th Cir. 1996).

State and federal special education law also address the reality that a student’s behavior is inextricably connected with the IDEA’s long-term goal of preparing individuals with exceptional needs for some measure of employability, independent living, and integration into the community. Thus, special education law addresses the matter of a student’s behavior both within and outside the school environment. For example, State law provides that in certain situations following a functional analysis assessment, “behavioral intervention plans” (BIPs) are to be included within a student’s IEP for the purpose of addressing behaviors across multiple settings outside the school environment. BIPs specify the behavioral interventions to be used in the home, residential facility, work site, or other noneducational settings. State law provides that BIPs may have both district and/or nondistrict employees or agencies listed in the IEP as being responsible for BIP-related goals and objectives to be achieved in noneducational settings. Title 5, C.C.R. § 3001(d)(e)(f) and § 3052.

The implementation of behavior plans, BIP or otherwise, outside the school setting is consistent with the State definition of special education as including a “full continuum of program options, including instruction conducted in the classroom, in the home, in hospitals and institutions, and in other settings . . . to meet the educational and service needs of individuals with exceptional needs in the least restrictive environment.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. The provision of services outside the school environment is also consistent with the State definition of “educational placement” as meaning that unique combination of facilities, personnel, location, or equipment necessary to provide instructional services to an individual with exceptional needs, as specified in the student’s IEP, in any one or a combination of public, private, home and hospital, or residential settings. Title 5, C.C.R. § 3042(a). Thus, the District’s contentions that it cannot control what occurs outside a school setting and therefore is not responsible for implementing goals and objectives outside the classroom and regular school hours are contrary to law. For example, a district can design an IEP to control what occurs outside the classroom setting or outside regular school hours through the use of residential placements. Less restrictive settings, if appropriate to meeting a student’s unique educational needs, are also available such as nonpublic agency (NPA) services obtained by contract through a district to provide after-school services as designated in an IEP.

In summary, the IDEA emphasizes preparation for employment, independent living, and integration into the community. Educational benefit, within the context of an IEP and as dictated by the student’s unique needs, may include social and emotional growth in addition to academic growth. There is no requirement that social and emotional growth must be addressed only within the confines of a school environment. Thus, if necessary for meeting a student’s unique needs and providing educational benefit, an IEP may provide for goals and objectives to be implemented and measured in settings outside the classroom environment. Those settings may even include a residential placement if the child’s educational needs cannot be met in a less restrictive environment.

Application of the above principles of law to the facts in the present case confirms that STUDENT’s inability to generalize across settings is a major area of need. STUDENT’s progress in terms of behavior and social and emotional growth, if any, has been limited to the school environment. Although STUDENT may have demonstrated some scattered and intermittent progress in behavior-related skills within the day program at CLC, he has been thoroughly unable to generalize those skills outside the CLC setting. Dr. Serepca testified that, in her opinion, there is no utility to school learning if the student cannot use that learning in everyday life. Dr. Serepca’s opinion is consistent with the IDEA. For students with exceptional needs, the IDEA emphasizes preparation for employment, independent living, and integrationinto the community. STUDENT has demonstrated, at least through the present, that he can perform academically at grade level. Therefore, from an academic perspective, STUDENT has the potential for achieving meaningful progress toward eventual employment, independent living, and integration into the community as envisioned by the IDEA. However, STUDENT will have made no meaningful progress toward those IDEA goals if he remains unable to generalize behavior-related skills outside the school setting, and he will persist in being a danger to himself T’s chief educational need for purposes of the issues in this case is a program to address the adverse behaviors arising from his disability. To address that need, STUDENT requires a highly structured environment. An appropriate program designed to meet STUDENT’s behavior-related needs will not only address STUDENT’s behaviors in the school environment, but will also be designed to make STUDENT’s progress meaningful by enabling STUDENT to generalize his behavior-related skills outside the school setting.

A. Failing to provide STUDENT a school day of sufficient length.

Having determined STUDENT’s unique educational needs as pertinent to the issues in the present case, the Hearing Officer will now proceed to examine the parties’ contentions regarding the District’s program and determine whether the program was designed to meet those unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit.

In this subpart (A) of Issue 2, STUDENT asserts that from the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year through February 3, 2003, the District denied him a FAPE by failing to offer a school day of sufficient length. More particularly, STUDENT asserts that to address his needs related to behavior, the District was required to provide more than the approximately five hours of daily instruction received in the CLC placement. For that specific denial of FAPE, the only remedy sought by STUDENT is reimbursement to his parents for the September and October 2002 enrollment costs in the TASC program.

The evidence showed that at the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year and through the date of the February 3, 2003 IEP meeting, the District’s program for STUDENT basically consisted of his day class at CLC, with OT and speech and language services. The TASC program had previously been added to STUDENT’s IEP on February 28, 2002, as a 12-hour-per-week after-school program to address STUDENT’s behaviors related to socialization. The IEP provided for the TASC program only through May 2002. At the hearing, MOTHER asserted that she believed the TASC program would continue through the date of STUDENT’s next annual IEP meeting in February 2003. Thus, she enrolled STUDENT in the STARS summer version of the program and then continued STUDENT in the TASC program in September. STUDENT attended the TASC program until he was asked to leave following the assault incident in October 2003. MOTHER testified that when she received a bill for TASC in the fall of 2002, she thought it had been sent to her in error and forwarded it to the District. The District, asserting that TASC was neither an IEP service nor a service required to meet STUDENT’s needs, refused to pay the bill.

The District’s position on this matter was succinctly described by the testimony of Dr. Stephen Daley. Dr. Daley, a professor of special education as CSUS, testified that he was familiar with TASC. He described TASC as a social/therapeutic/recreation type classroom for children with autism providing after-school activities in a structured setting. He indicated that although the need for STUDENT to learn socialization skills should be undisputed, the District was not responsible for teaching such skills in an after-school environment. Therefore, according to the District and Dr. Daley, TASC was not an educational program and the District was not required to provide it as part of an IEP.

The District’s position on this matter is inconsistent with the applicable law. STUDENT needs services designed to enable him to generalize his behavior-related skills outside the school setting. STUDENT’s worsening behavioral performance from February 2002 through the end of the school year confirms that STUDENT’s day-class program at CLC, even in combination with some OT and speech and language services and the TASC after-school program, was not meeting STUDENT’s need for generalization of behavior-related skills outside the classroom setting. In this situation, more services were required to address the need for generalization. Instead, the District reduced the effective length of STUDENT’s school day by allowing the TASC program to be dropped from the IEP. The fact that the February 2002 IEP provided for TASC services only through May 2002 is no defense to the District. The District was aware of STUDENT’s needs at the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year and had a continuing obligation to make program adjustments as necessary for the provision of a FAPE. The District’s error was compounded by the fact that the TASC services had been the only services in the IEP that gave STUDENT an opportunity to generalize his skills across non-school settings. Moreover, the District made no adjustments to STUDENT’s IEP to compensate for the elimination of the TASC program. (footnote 14) Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to resume the TASC program in September and October 2002 was a denial of FAPE.

When a school District denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is appropriate in light of the purposes of the IDEA. Burlington, supra, at 369. Parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement of the services they have procured for their children when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement or services and the services provided by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, supra, at 370. The Burlington rule is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parent are found to be the exact proper placement or services under the IDEA. Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). Although courts have recognized that the parent’s placement does not have to meet a standard as high as the school districts must meet, the parent’s placement must still meet other requirements of the IDEA, such as providing a placement that addresses the student’s needs and provides the student educational benefit. Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13 (1993). Testimony of several witnesses, including Dr. Serepca and STUDENT’s parents, confirmed that the purpose of the TASC program was to address STUDENT’s need to generalize his behavior-related skills outside the school environment. The witnesses also confirmed that the parents’ actions of keeping STUDENT in the TASC program during September and October 2002 were intended to continue addressing that area of need. Testimony of the TASC director, Dr. Bassi, confirmed that TASC was providing services intended to give STUDENT opportunities for generalizing his skills. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reimbursement by the District for costs of the TASC program from September 1 through STUDENT’s last date of attendance on October 17, 2003. That amount was proven by documentary evidence to be $1,445.00.

B. Failing to address STUDENT’s needs related to his independent living skills.

Except for TASC reimbursement, no applicable request for relief has been made by STUDENT in Issue 2. There is no claim in Issue 2 for compensatory education, other reimbursement, or other remedies for the denial of FAPE from the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year through February 3, 2003. Reimbursement for TASC has already been awarded. With no further relief being sought in Issue 2, additional findings by the Hearing Officer regarding subpart (B) of Issue 2 would be of no consequence to the outcome of this Decision. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer will reach no findings with respect to subpart (B) of Issue 2.

C. Failing to offer a residential placement.

The matter of residential placement was the central focus of this case, and it will be thoroughly addressed in Issue 3. However, for the same reasons applicable to subpart (B) above, the Hearing Officer will reach no findings with respect to whether a residential placement was required prior to February 3, 2003.

Issue 3: Was the District’s January 23/February 3, 2003 IEP an offer of FAPE?

(1) STUDENT’s unique needs.

The evidence showed that STUDENT’s unique educational needs were basically the same in February 2003 as they had been during the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year. Specifically, as has previously been found under Issue 2, STUDENT’s primary area of need for purposes of the issues in this case is a program designed to address the adverse behaviors arising from STUDENT’s disability. STUDENT requires a highly structured environment designed to enable progress in the school environment and also designed to make that progress meaningful by enabling STUDENT to generalize his behavior-related skills outside the school setting.

(2) The District’s offer.

The District’s February 3, 2003 offer included placement at Spectrum’s Tara Hills campus for both a “functional” and academic curriculum; continuance of OT and speech and language services, each for two hours per week and with one hour of consult per month; assistive technology; transportation; ESY; referral to Marin County Mental Health for a mental health assessment; review of the IEP in June 2003 to assess STUDENT’s progress; and referral to the CDC to investigate whether STUDENT has an emotional disturbance.

STUDENT asserts that the District’s proposed January 23/February 3, 2003 IEP, hereafter referred to as the February 3, 2003 IEP, was not an offer of FAPE. STUDENT asserts that the day-placement offered at Spectrum was not designed to meet his unique needs for generalizing behavior strategies across settings. STUDENT seeks an order of prospective placement at Devereux for the remainder of the term of the February 3, 2003 IEP, including payment of tuition and continuing transportation costs. The term of the February 3, 2003 IEP is through February 3, 2004. The District asserts that its offer for placement at Spectrum would have provided a FAPE in the least restrictive environment.

The District’s evidence. In asserting its position, the District presented testimony from Angela Zamora-Castillo, assistant director at Spectrum. Ms. Zamora-Castillo testified that Spectrum is a day program specifically designed to serve children with educational and behavioral challenges. She testified that Spectrum teaches social skills and adaptive living skills. Spectrum uses applied behavior analysis (ABA) techniques supported with a token economy system and high levels of praise. (footnote 15) Her description of the children enrolled at Spectrum was consistent with STUDENT’s profile insofar as behavior in the school setting. The social skills program at Spectrum includes community outings. She believed that Spectrum could successfully implement the goals proposed for STUDENT by the District. She also believed that Spectrum could implement all of the residential placement goals proposed for STUDENT by Devereux. She testified that she has never seen an IEP that sets goals for in the home. She also stated that, in her experience, goals are written for school and the skills are hopefully generalized into the home and other settings.

Dr. Daley testified that his expertise includes the development of behavior plans for children with autism. He testified that he had been retained by the District to review the available materials regarding STUDENT and observe the proposed placement at Spectrum. Dr. Daley stated that STUDENT’s unique needs can be met without a residential placement. He testified that the day program at Spectrum would be an appropriate placement because of its strong programs that he observed in academics, behavior skills, and social skills. Dr. Daley acknowledged that STUDENT’s behavior at home was significantly different from his behavior in the school setting. He attributed those differences to the fact that the home environment does not provide as high a level of structure as a setting such as CLC. His opinions regarding an educational placement to meet STUDENT’s unique needs were premised on his indicated belief that the school’s responsibility for STUDENT’s performance extends only to performance in school and during transportation to and from school. Dr. Daley indicated that although generalization of STUDENT’s skills across settings would require coordination among the persons responsible for STUDENT in different settings, nothing occurring outside either the school setting or transportation to and from school should be within the domain of STUDENT’s IEP.

District school psychologist Jane Sanctuary testified that STUDENT does not require a residential placement in order to learn and generalize his adaptive behavior skills. She testified that the CLC placement had not specifically addressed adaptive behavior skills in its program. Consequently, she believes that STUDENT’s performance at CLC was not necessarily indicative of how STUDENT would perform in adaptive behavior through the Spectrum program. (footnote 16) Ms. Sanctuary stated that STUDENT should first be given an opportunity to learn and generalize those skills in the less restrictive setting of Spectrum.

The Student’s evidence. On behalf of STUDENT, Dr. Schreier testified that he is quite familiar with STUDENT, having been his psychiatrist for several years. He testified that the information available about STUDENT is as “clinically good” as one can get, and that no further assessment is needed at this time. Dr. Schreier testified that STUDENT is a danger to himself and others. He testified that STUDENT’s ability to understand consequences and use his cognitive functioning to suppress his behaviors was diminishing up to the time that Dr. Serepca prepared her report in January 2003. Dr. Schreier believes that the diminishment has been due to a decrease in executive function in the frontal lobe of the brain and that, along with STUDENT’s becoming larger and more powerful, is making STUDENT even more of a danger to himself and others. Dr. Schreier testified that, to a fair degree of clinical certainty, if STUDENT were to have continued in a day-class program instead of being put into a residential placement by his parents, an incident would inevitably occur at school that would cause serious harm to STUDENT and/or others. He characterized that potential harm as “enormously dangerous.”

Dr. Schreier stated that STUDENT, now at the age of 10 years, has “an extraordinary amount of brain malfunction,” and he now believes that STUDENT should have been placed in a residential treatment facility two or three years ago. He believes that it would be far preferable to start a residential placement for STUDENT now than to wait. Dr. Schreier testified that in his opinion and experience as a clinician, if a child such as STUDENT is going to be able to benefit academically and achieve benefit behaviorally with regard to his ability to suppress impulses, the chances of productive treatment are better if a structured 24-hour-per-day program is implemented sooner rather than later. He testified that a primary goal sought through residential placement would be to teach STUDENT to generalize his skills outside the residential setting by instilling a set of responses that cause STUDENT to stop and think about the consequences of his behavior before he acts.

Elizabeth Isono testified that she had been STUDENT’s occupational therapist for one year ending in February 2003, seeing him one hour per week. She stated that because of STUDENT’s executive function deficits, he was unable to take what he was learning and apply it across environments. She testified that she had attempted to help STUDENT generalize his skills across settings, but her time with him was insufficient. She testified, generally, that repetition could enable STUDENT to use his working memory to recall appropriate responses across settings instead of having to rely on executive function. She testified that because of the severity of STUDENT’s deficits in executive function, STUDENT would need repetition and consistency across environments by a professional staff in a residential placement, twenty-four hours per day and seven days per week, to enable him to generalize his skills or otherwise act appropriately across settings. She also emphasized that early intensive intervention was critical for STUDENT.

Dr. Serepca testified that during STUDENT’s placement at CLC, STUDENT received services from highly qualified professionals at CLC and that those teachers and other providers gave STUDENT excellent services in the CLC environment. However, she also testified that notwithstanding STUDENT’s access to those excellent providers, STUDENT remains unable to generalize his behavior-related skills outside the school environment. She testified that STUDENT’s failure to generalize outside the school environment is chiefly the result of STUDENT’s severe deficits in executive function. She testified that strict consistency in behavior management strategies across structured settings for 24 hours per day is necessary if STUDENT is to develop the ability to generalize behavior and academic skills at a level enabling him to function in his home and community. Thus, Dr. Serepca concludes that a residential placement with a 24-hour-per-day program is required for meeting STUDENT’s unique needs.

Findings. Having considered all of the evidence, the Hearing Officer was not persuaded that a day program, such as the proposed Spectrum placement, would meet STUDENT’s needs related to generalizing behavior skills across multiple environments. Similarly, the Hearing Officer was not persuaded by arguments that STUDENT should at least be given an opportunity to have his needs met in a day placement such as Spectrum before relegating him to the more restrictive environment of a residential placement. The reasons are multiple.

First, there is no basis for expecting that another day program such as Spectrum, even with its ABA strategy, community outings, and other social skills training, will meet STUDENT’s needs. Dr. Serepca convincingly explained that STUDENT already has had intensive behavioral support in his home and in the community through behavior specialists retained by the parents, at an intensity level as high as 30 hours per week. Those services, rendered in combination with services by highly qualified professionals within the school setting at CLC and also in combination with the TASC after-school program, have failed to enable STUDENT to generalize his skills outside the school environment. Instead, STUDENT’s behaviors have worsened. Accordingly, Dr. Schreier and Dr. Serepca were persuasive in presenting their opinion that because STUDENT’s inability to generalize skills across settings is a consequence of such severe deficits in executive function, STUDENT will need repetitive learning across all environments in a highly structured program so that he can learn and/or recall appropriate responses to various situations.

In contrast, the District’s witnesses failed to satisfactorily explain why a predominantly lateral move, in terms of hours of services, from CLC to the proposed day placement at Spectrum would be sufficient to produce progress in STUDENT’s behavior and generalization skills. Additionally, the District and its witnesses were consistent in premising their arguments upon the erroneous assumption that the District had absolutely no means of monitoring or controlling STUDENT outside the school environment and therefore no responsibility to implement goals and objectives across non-school settings. That premise was contrary to the fact that special education law gives districts the ability to implement programs in a “full continuum” of program options or settings, including non-school settings, and that educational placement may include placement in a combination of settings ranging from public schools to the child’s home to a nonpublic residential placement. Cal. Educ. Code § 56031, Title 5, C.C.R. § 3042(a).

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer is persuaded by the testimony of Dr. Schreier, Dr. Serepca, and Ms. Isono that STUDENT will need a consistent and structured 24-hour-per-day program across all environments if he is to acquire the ability to generalize his behavior skills outside the school environment, thereby achieving educational progress as defined in the IDEA and related law. Moreover, having considered the failure of programs that included behavior specialist services for as many as 30 hours per week in home and community settings, in addition to the other evidence, the Hearing Officer further agrees with Dr. Schreier, Dr. Serepca, and Ms. Isono that STUDENT requires implementation of the 24-hour-per-day program in the controlled environment of a residential facility. Thus, a residential placement is currently the least restrictive placement wherein STUDENT’s educational needs can be met.

Finally, the Hearing Officer was persuaded that time is of the essence for STUDENT. In addition to testimony from multiple experts that intervention is generally more effective in the earlier years of a child’s life than in later years, the testimony from Dr. Schreier, Dr. Serepca, Mr. Connell, STUDENT’s parents, and CLC staff confirmed that having STUDENT in a day-school setting is a situation laden with danger. In his younger years, STUDENT’s verbal threats to inflict fatal harm upon people may have been considered cute or amusing by some of the people he encountered at school and in the community, but STUDENT, now at age 10 years, is rapidly becoming bigger and stronger. His lack of executive function leaves him unable to understand the consequences of what he is threatening to do. Adding to this dangerous situation is the fact that STUDENT frequently cannot distinguish reality from fantasy, a condition that often causes him to act aggressively or threaten bodily harm, especially when he misinterprets what is occurring in his environment. Those factors, in addition to STUDENT’s aggressive and threatening outbursts, his fixation with explosives, and his routine threats to inflict fatal harm, all combine to render STUDENT a danger to himself and to others. Such danger is a consequence of his disability and the danger is present 24 hours per day. Thus, waiting to place STUDENT in a residential facility could easily have injurious and even fatal consequences to STUDENT and/or students and teachers in other schools that he might otherwise attend. As testified to by Dr. Schreier, STUDENT would inevitably have a major behavioral breakdown in a day-school environment, and the consequences when that occurs could well be “enormous.”

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed February 3, 2003 IEP was not an offer of FAPE. The day placement offered at Spectrum was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs for generalizing behavior strategies across settings, and it also would have placed STUDENT in a setting where the likelihood serious of harm to teachers, himself, and his fellow students was inappropriately high. A 24-hour-per-day residential placement with classrooms and related services available on the premises is currently the least restrictive environment designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.

(3) Remedies.

For the denial of FAPE arising from the District’s February 3, 2003 offer, STUDENT’s parents request reimbursement for the costs of the private placement at Devereux, including tuition costs through the end of the 2003 ESY, the cost of the OT component of the program, the cost of transporting STUDENT to and from Devereux, and the transportation, food, and lodging costs of STUDENT’s parent and siblings for their visits to STUDENT at the Devereux facility in Connecticut. STUDENT also seeks an order for prospective placement at Devereux for the remainder of the term of the February 3, 2003 IEP, including payment of tuition and continuing transportation costs. The term of the February 3, 2003 IEP is through February 3, 2004. The District asserts that the private placement at Devereux was made for family reasons, not educational reasons, and that, therefore, reimbursement is not required, even if the District failed to offer a FAPE. Furthermore, the District asserts that reimbursement is unwarranted because STUDENT’s parents refused to allow the District to conduct necessary assessments, the parents acted unreasonably, and the costs claimed for the placement at Devereux are unreasonable. (footnote 17)

As stated above, parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district fails to provide a FAPE and the placement or services are determined to be appropriate under the IDEA. Equitable considerations may be weighed in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting such relief. See Burlington, supra. Among the factors to consider is the conduct of the parties. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist., 960 F.2d 1479, 1486 (9th Cir. 1992).

In the present case, the Hearing Officer rejects the District’s assertion that STUDENT’s parents sent STUDENT to Devereux for family reasons, not educational reasons. The Hearing Officer has already determined that STUDENT requires a residential placement for purposes of FAPE. The fact that STUDENT’s removal to Devereux may have altered the FAMILY family’s interactions at home is irrelevant to the finding that a residential placement is required to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs.

The District further asserts that the parents should be denied reimbursement because of their failure to allow the CDC and Mental Health assessments recommended by the District. Referral forms for a CDC assessment were submitted by the District to STUDENT’s parents on January 16, 2003. Mental Health assessment was offered in the February 3, 2003 IEP. (footnote 18)

There is no legal or factual basis for concluding that STUDENT’s parents acted unreasonably or that either a CDC assessment or a Mental Health assessment was necessary prior to the IEP team’s making its determination that STUDENT required a residential placement to meet his needs. By January 2003, ample information was available to the District and the IEP team to know that a residential placement was required. The primary remaining question at that time should have involved the selection of a specific residential placement. Instead, by continually asserting that it had no responsibility for providing services outside a day-class environment, the District gave STUDENT’s parents every reason to believe that it would never offer STUDENT a residential placement. Given the District’s inflexible position at that time with respect to disclaiming any and all responsibility for providing services outside the school environment, the District’s offer to refer STUDENT for a Mental Health assessment was insufficient to indicate that a residential placement might eventually be considered by the District. Meanwhile, the dangers of having STUDENT remain in a day program were imminent and potentially catastrophic. After conducting an exhaustive search of potential residential settings, with no assistance by the District, and also after viewing the District’s proposed placement at Spectrum, STUDENT’s parents appropriately selected Devereux. Progress reports and the testimony of Devereux staff demonstrated that STUDENT has been making good progress academically and behaviorally at Devereux, even to the extent that he has become a preferred student for the teachers at Devereux to include on community outings. On the basis of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for STUDENT’s placement at Devereux through the date of this Decision.

With regard to the matter of a prospective placement that will provide STUDENT with a FAPE through February 3, 2004, STUDENT needs a 24-hour-per-day residential placement that addresses his unique educational needs, including his educational needs in the areas of academics and behavior. A residential placement designed to meet STUDENT’s behavior-related needs will not only address STUDENT’s behaviors in the school environment, but will also be designed to make STUDENT’s progress meaningful by enabling STUDENT to generalize his behavior-related skills outside the school setting. The residential placement must provide for high levels of structure, predictability, and consistency in addressing STUDENT’s behavior-related needs across settings, 24 hours per day. STUDENT must be placed with age-appropriate peers in the classroom and residential environment, and the placement must be appropriate to STUDENT’s level of academic skills.

Testimony from STUDENT’s parents, testimony from Devereux staff, and documentary evidence from Devereux confirmed that Devereux is providing STUDENT with a program that meets the above-stated criteria and is thereby designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit in what is currently the least restrictive environment. STUDENT’s parents and documentary evidence consisting of some literature from Devereux indicated that Devereux is a nonpublic, nonsectarian school or agency that is State-certified within the meaning of Cal. Educ. Code sections 563661.1 and 56505.2. However, it remains unknown whether Devereux is or will in fact be State-certified during the period at issue for prospective placement. Having considered that the District has offered no appropriate alternative placement, that STUDENT is making progress at Devereux, that STUDENT needs stability and consistency in his environment, and that safety for STUDENT and those within his environment is a major concern, the Hearing Officer will order that if Devereux is State-certified, Devereux shall be the prospective placement through February 3, 2004. If Devereux is not State-certified, STUDENT’s parents will remain entitled to reimbursement for the costs at Devereux until such time the District offers an alternative placement meeting the requirements of FAPE as delineated above.

With respect to the amount of reimbursement, STUDENT presented a list of the claimed costs. The cost incurred to Devereux for services from March through May totaled $28,470.00. STUDENT’s parents produced documentary evidence confirming that amount had been paid. The Hearing Officer considers the actual payment of that amount by STUDENT’s parents to be evidence of the reasonableness of the charges made by Devereux. The District presented no persuasive evidence to the contrary. The cost incurred to Devereux from June through August 2003 totaled $29,120.00, and the Hearing Officer similarly finds those charges to be reasonable. STUDENT’s parents are therefore entitled to reimbursement in the amount of $57,590.00 for the costs incurred to Devereux. (footnote 19) In addition, STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reimbursement in the amount of $1,462.50 for the OT-related costs incurred from March through July 24, 2003. Regarding travel expenses, the Hearing Officer considers the reimbursement request to be excessive insofar as transportation, meal, and lodging costs are sought for six visits to Devereux from January 19, 2003 through June 28, 2003, including, in some instances, costs for STUDENT’s siblings. The Hearing Officer finds that the reimbursement claims in the amount of $1,296.76 for enrollment-related travel on March 2, 2003, and $1,586.17 for an “initial IEP and parent seminar” on April 2, 2003, are reasonable, and reimbursement in those amounts will be ordered. The parents’ request to be reimbursed for loan-interest expenses is denied.

Issue 4: Is the District entitled to conduct an assessment of STUDENT through the California Diagnostic Center (CDC) over the parents’ refusal of consent for the assessment?

The need for an assessment by CDC at the present time has not be demonstrated by the District. Except for the above-referenced referral for Mental Health assessment, pertinent to the matter of prospective placement options, the parties have ample information for determining STUDENT’s educational needs.

ORDERS

1. If Devereux is a State-certified nonpublic school or agency within the meaning of Cal. Educ. Code section 56366.1, STUDENT’s IEP team shall amend the IEP to designate Devereux as STUDENT’s prospective placement through February 3, 2004.

2. If Devereux is not State-certified, STUDENT’s parents will remain entitled to reimbursement for the costs at Devereux and associated reasonable travel costs at least until such time as the District offers an alternative placement meeting the requirements of FAPE.

3. For purposes of Order 2 above, any alternative placement meeting the requirements of FAPE for STUDENT must be a 24-hour-per-day residential placement that addresses STUDENT’s unique educational needs, including his educational needs in the areas of academics and behavior. A residential placement designed to meet STUDENT’s behavior-related needs must not only address STUDENT’s behaviors in the school environment, but must also be designed to make STUDENT’s progress meaningful by enabling STUDENT to generalize his behavior-related skills outside the school setting. The residential placement must provide for high levels of structure, predictability, and consistency in addressing STUDENT’s behavior-related needs across settings, 24 hours per day. STUDENT must be placed with age-appropriate peers in the classroom and residential environment, and the placement must appropriate to STUDENT’s level of academic skills.

4. Within 30 calendar days from the date of this Decision, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the costs of the TASC program from September 1, 2002, through October 17, 2002, in the amount of $1,445.00.

5. Within 60 calendar days from the date of this Decision, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents for costs incurred to Devereux in the amount of $57,590.00 through August 2003; OT-related costs in the amount of $1,462.50 for the period from March through July 24, 2003; and travel-related expenses in the amount of $2,882.93.

6. All other requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided.

Issue 1: Did the District fail to appropriately assess STUDENT during the 2002-2003 school year? The District prevailed on this issue.

Issue 2: Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year through the date of the individualized education program (IEP) meeting on February 3, 2003, by: (A) failing to provide STUDENT a school day of sufficient length, (B) failing to address STUDENT’s needs related to his independent living skills, his behavior, and his socialization, and (C) failing to offer a residential placement? STUDENT prevailed on subpart (A) of this issue. No findings were made on subparts (B) and (C).

Issue 3: Was the District’s January 23/February 3, 2003 IEP an offer of FAPE? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.

Issue 4: Is the District entitled to conduct an assessment of STUDENT through the California Diagnostic Center (CDC) over the parents’ refusal of consent for the assessment? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Dated: September 23, 2003 ____________________________________ Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. The above-stated issues were delineated in a prehearing conference order dated July 23, 2003, and confirmed during discussions at the hearing prior to the presentation of evidence. The parties’ more specific contentions and requests for relief will be stated below.

2. Pica, in general, refers to the eating of non-food objects.

3. Dr. Serepca is a pediatric neuropsychologist. Her first neuropsychological evaluation of STUDENT was performed at the parents’ request in November 1999.

4. The above-cited information in the IEP is consistent with the January 25, 2002 progress report from CLC covering behavior and also covering “academic achievement” in the areas of reading, oral and written communication, gross- and fine-motor skills, and self-help skills.

5. An adaptive functioning assessment plan ( for administration of the Vineland) was submitted by the District on December 19 and consented to by STUDENT’s parents on December 23, 2002.

6. The District had added TASC to STUDENT’s IEP in February 2002 only for the period through May 2002.

7. Dr. Serepca performed her reevaluation of STUDENT on January 10, 15, and 17, 2003. Her report had not yet been written at the time of the January 23 IEP meeting.

8. Unless the context indicates otherwise, as used by the Hearing Officer in this Decision the term “assaultive” refers not to the threat of inappropriate physical contact but to actual violent physical contact.

9. The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 201. Federal special education law requires states to establish certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which the student is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE. Procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. 960 F.2d at 1484. No such procedural violations were at issue in the present case.

10. There is no dispute that at the commencement of the 2002-2003 school year and thereafter, STUDENT needed services to address his deficits resulting in unique educational needs related to behavior, speech and language, and various OT areas such as gross- and fine-motor skills. The appropriateness of the District’s program, insofar as the provision of speech and language services and OT during regular school-day hours, is not disputed. Similarly, the appropriateness of the District’s behavior plan, as implemented in the school setting at CLC, is not disputed.

11. At the hearing, various terms used in reference to STUDENT’s behavior-related deficits and needs included social skills, self-help skills, adaptive skills, adaptive self-help skills, and adaptive behavior skills. For purposes of the present case, the distinctions between those terms as used by the witnesses and in the documentary evidence will generally not be elaborated upon. All of those terms are treated by the Hearing Officer as being within the broader category referred to herein as behavior. Treating them as otherwise would not affect the outcome of this Decision.

12. There was some dispute as to whether the golf club was real or a toy.

13. The District’s assertion that school districts are not required to address a child’s behavior outside the school environment may have application when those behaviors are unrelated to the disability that causes a child to be eligible for special education. Such is not the situation in STUDENT’s case.

14. The District characterized STUDENT’s set-backs in the fall of 2002 as temporary problems attributable to medication adjustments. Dr. Schreier confirmed that STUDENT’s medications were frequently being adjusted in ongoing efforts to address changes in STUDENT’s behavior and sleep patterns, especially during the fall of 2002. By attributing STUDENT’s problems to his medication adjustments, the District attempted to show that STUDENT is ready to resume the progress he was making at CLC. The Hearing Officer will not engage in circular speculation regarding what came first – i.e. medication adjustments, sleep disturbances, increased behaviors, etc. Even Dr. Schreier could offer no opinion on that question. Notwithstanding whatever interactions may have been occurring between STUDENT’s medication regimen and STUDENT’s performance, the evidence is undisputed that STUDENT consistently has needed a highly structured school environment. Moreover, the relevance of the District’s explanation for STUDENT’s decreased performance in the fall of 2002 hinges on a supposition that prior to the worsening of his behaviors and academic performance during the fall of 2002, STUDENT was making meaningful educational progress in areas other than academics. No such finding has been made.

15. Ms. Zamora-Castillo testified that ABA refers to the strategy of determining the antecedents of an adverse behavior, determining the function served by the adverse behavior, and then teaching an appropriate replacement behavior.

16. Ms. Sanctuary defined adaptive skills as meaning skills that are necessary to function independently on a day-to-day basis, including language, daily living skills such as eating and toileting, socialization, and the ability to interact with others. She defined social skills as pertaining more to interpersonal skills, including the ability to maintain a conversation, understanding of social rules and expectations, nonverbal language, and interpreting the social environment. She described behavior as including adaptive and social skills but also including rule-following behavior, compliance with directions, and behavior expectations necessary to function in a classroom.

17. See 34 C.F.R. section 300.403.

18. The District did not specify a legal basis for why the failure to agree to such assessments should result in denial of the claim for reimbursement.

19. Pursuant to statute, regulation, or interagency contracts, other public agencies may be responsible to the District for some of these costs. However, no other agency was a party to this hearing and the Hearing Officer makes no findings regarding interagency responsibilities.