California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 20, 1996

Murrieta Valley Unified School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 406-96 · Hearing Officer Mark Paxson

Murrieta Valley Unified denied permission to assess two privately placed brothers for special education over their mother's objection.

Student prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

Murrieta Valley Unified School District filed for due process to get permission to assess two brothers, ages 11 and 12, for special education without their mother's consent. Neither boy was eligible for special education. In 1994–95 the District provided home/hospital tutoring, which is a general education service for students who miss school for medical reasons. It sent the mother assessment plans twice, and she never signed them. The boys later enrolled in Sunland Christian School, a private school, and received home instruction through it. The mother refused all public school services and opposed any assessment. At her request, the Hearing Officer combined the two cases into one hearing.

The District pointed to its child find duty. As evidence, it cited the mother's earlier hearing request, her complaint to the State Department of Education, and reports from home teachers that the boys were behind academically. Hearing Officer Mark Paxson found this evidence insufficient. The teachers' reports were secondhand (hearsay) and gave no details, and hearsay alone cannot support a finding. The mother credibly testified that her earlier actions sought home teaching, not special education. No evidence showed that the boys' medical conditions affected their ability to benefit from regular education. The Hearing Officer also questioned whether the law lets a district force assessment on children in private school whose parent refuses services. The District's request was denied. It may have the right to assess if the mother later asks for District services.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled a district's request to assess privately placed children without parental consent. The Hearing Officer required evidence of a suspected disability that would hold up in court, not hearsay. He also doubted that child find duties let a district force assessment on children whose parent refuses all public services.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue 1. Does Murrieta Valley Unified School District have the right to conduct an assessment of STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2?

    The District did not show, with evidence admissible in a civil action, a suspected disability that interfered with the students' education. The Hearing Officer also found it unclear whether a district may force assessment on privately placed children whose parent refuses services, so the District's request was denied.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • The District's request to assess both students for special education without parental consent was denied. The decision notes the District may have the right to assess if the mother later seeks District services.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Education Code 56300; Education Code 56302; Education Code 56320(f); Education Code 56321(c); Education Code 56506(e); Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, 3082(b); 34 CFR 76.650-76.662

People named in the decision

  • Barbara Moore-Brown, Director of pupil services, Murrieta Valley Unified School District
  • Jim Hite, School psychologist (developed assessment plans), Riverside County SELPA
  • Renate Jefferson, Coordinator of child welfare and attendance, Murrieta Valley Unified School District
  • Virginia Russell, Educational consultant for Students
  • John Pritchette, Intern present on Students' behalf, Rutherford Institute
  • Garfinkel, Hearing Officer in prior dismissed matter, California Special Education Hearing Office
  • Sunland Christian School, Private school

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Murrieta, California, on August 20, 1996 Petitioner Murrieta Valley Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Karen Gilyard. Also present on behalf of the District was Barbara Moore-Brown, director of pupil services. Respondents STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 were represented by attorney Michael Murray. Also present on respondents' behalf were MOTHER, their mother; John Pritchette, intern with the Rutherford Institute; and Virginia Russell, educational consultant. Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was closed and the matter submitted for decision. PROCEDURAL MATTERS On June 28, 1996, MOTHER requested that the two cases be consolidated. At the time, the Hearing Office denied the request. MOTHER renewed her request at the beginning of the hearing on August 20, 1996. Ms. Gilyard, on behalf of the District, supported MOTHER's request. Although there are two children involved, the facts surrounding both cases are similar and for purposes of efficiency, the Hearing Officer granted MOTHER's request to consolidate the cases. ISSUE Does Murrieta Valley Unified School District have the right to conduct an assessment of STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2? BACKGROUND FACTS STUDENT 1 is eleven years old and is currently not eligible for special education services. STUDENT 2 is twelve years old and also is currently not eligible for special education services. In September 1994, MOTHER requested a home/hospital program for STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2. Home/hospital is a home tutoring program for children who are unable to attend school for medical reasons. Home/hospital is not a special education service. The District provided several home teachers over the next six months. On March 29, 1995, Jim Hite, a school psychologist with the Riverside SELPA, developed assessment plans for both STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2. These assessment plans were provided to MOTHER. However, MOTHER did not consent to the assessment plans. The plans called for assessment in the areas of academic/pre-academic achievement, social/emotional/adaptive behavior, psychomotor development, intellectual development, and vision and hearing. In the spring of 1995, the District filed a complaint with Child Protective Services regarding MOTHER' treatment of her children. Although the charges that arose from the complaint were eventually dismissed, MOTHER's children, including STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2, were taken from her home for a short period of time. On February 8, 1996, the assessment plans previously developed on March 29, 1995, were again sent to MOTHER for her consent. MOTHER again did not consent to the assessment plans. On April 24, 1996, Renate Jefferson, the District's coordinator of child welfare and attendance sent a letter to MOTHER requesting information on the school attendance of STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2. Ms. Jefferson specifically requested that MOTHER provide her by May 8, 1996 with the name of the private school STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 were attending. On April 29, 1996, MOTHER provided information that STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 were enrolled in a private school, but did not provide the name of the school. At the hearing, MOTHER submitted into evidence a document dated May 3, 1996, on Sunland Christian School letterhead which states that STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 are enrolled with that school. This letter was not provided to the District until the hearing. SUMMARY OF TESTIMONY District Witnesses James Hite Jim Hite is a school psychologist employed by the Riverside County SELPA. Mr. Hite testified that he was asked by Barbara Moore-Brown, the District's director of pupil services, in March 1995 to develop assessment plans for STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2. Mr. Hite testified that Ms. Moore-Brown did not give him any information regarding the two boys and that he was expected to conduct a "blind" assessment. Mr. Hite testified that a "blind" assessment consists of a developmental history, a conversation with a student's parents, and testing. In essence, a blind assessment starts at the beginning and the assessor uses the information he or she obtains to assess areas of suspected disability. Mr. Hite testified that if a student's disability involved only medical issues he would refer that student to a medical professional. However, Mr. Hite also stated that a student could have learning disabilities secondary to the medical issue so an educational assessment may also be necessary. Mr. Hite testified that if a student has a suspected "other health impairment" a multidisciplinary assessment should be conducted to determine if the medical disability affects the student's ability to benefit from his or her education. Barbara Moore-Brown Barbara Moore-Brown testified regarding the events relating to STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2. Ms. Moore-Brown testified that MOTHER contacted the District in September 1994 and requested home/hospital services for STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2. At that time, the District agreed to provide such services and provide home tutors for STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 for approximately six months. Ms. Moore-Brown testified that these services were not offered pursuant to individualized education programs (IEP). Ms. Moore-Brown testified that MOTHER requested a due process hearing in early 1995 and that the parties held a telephone conference on March 13, 1995 which resolved that request. According to Ms. Moore-Brown, the parties agreed that MOTHER would withdraw her hearing request and the District would be allowed to conduct assessments of STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2. The District agreed to have personnel from the Riverside SELPA conduct the assessments. Ms. Moore-Brown testified that the District never received the required written consent from MOTHER to conduct the assessments. Ms. Moore-Brown testified that her opinion that STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 need to be assessed is based on conversations with MOTHER in which MOTHER has stated that STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 have disabilities. Ms. Moore-Brown also pointed to several procedural events as evidence that MOTHER wants special education services for STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2. Ms. Moore-Brown testified that in January 1996, MOTHER filed a complaint with the State Department of Education alleging that the District was failing to serve STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2. Ms. Moore-Brown also points to MOTHER's requests for due process hearings as evidence that MOTHER wants special education services for STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2. Ms. Moore-Brown also testified that the home teachers who have worked with STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 told her that the children are behind academically. Respondents' Witnesses MOTHER MOTHER was the only witness who testified on behalf of STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2. MOTHER testified that she does not want STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 to receive special education services from the District. Regarding why she filed for a due process hearing on the issue of home/hospital instruction, MOTHER testified that she was not sure if home/hospital was within the jurisdiction of the Special Education Hearing Office if she was not requesting the instruction as a special education service. MOTHER testified that her request was dismissed because Hearing Officer Garfinkel ruled that the Hearing Office does not have jurisdiction over home/hospital instruction. (Footnote 1) MOTHER also testified that her contact with the State Department of Education in January 1996 was made because she was hoping to get a home teacher from another school district without going through the District. MOTHER testified that STUDENT 1 has cystic fibrosis. He requires IVs for nutrients on an almost daily basis and is on multiple medications. MOTHER testified that STUDENT 1 also has a chemical sensitivity which is the primary reason for placing him on home instruction. Finally, STUDENT 1 has a thyroid condition. MOTHER testified that STUDENT 2 has the same thyroid condition and chemical sensitivity as STUDENT 1. MOTHER testified that home instruction is necessary for both STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 because they need an environmentally clean setting for their education. MOTHER testified that STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 were enrolled in Sunland Christian School on May 3, 1996, and that they receive home instruction through that school. MOTHER testified that she is currently refusing all public education services for STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 and she does not want them assessed by the District. MOTHER testified that the District filed charges against her with Child Protective Services (CPS) and, as a result, CPS conducted an assessment of STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2. MOTHER testified that the CPS assessment was a behavioral and psychological assessment. MOTHER testified that she has not provided the CPS assessment to the District because of her pending civil rights lawsuit against the District. MOTHER testified that the CPS psychologist and other therapists who have worked with STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 are of the opinion that additional assessments would be harmful to STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2. DISCUSSION Education Code  56300 requires that school districts actively and systematically seek out all individuals with exceptional needs, ages 0 through 21 years, including children not enrolled in public school programs, who reside in the district or are under the jurisdiction of a special education local plan area or a county office. Section 56302 provides that [e]ach school district ... shall provide for the identification and assessment of an individual's exceptional needs, and the planning of an instructional program to meet the assessed needs. Section 56320 provides that [b]efore any action is taken with respect to the initial placement of an individual with exceptional needs in special education instruction, an individual assessment of the pupil's educational needs shall be conducted... Section 56320 goes on to list the criteria under which such assessments should be conducted. Included in the criteria is that [t]he pupil is assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability... Education Code  56320(f). Finally,  56321(c) provides that [n]o assessment shall be conducted unless the written consent of the parent is obtained prior to the assessment except pursuant to subdivision (e) of Section 56506. Section 56506(e) grants to a school district the right to conduct assessments over the objections of the parents only if the school district prevails on the issue of assessment at a due process hearing. Pursuant to Education Code  56300 and 56302, the District has a statutory obligation to seek out all children within its jurisdiction who are in need of educational services, regardless of whether those children are enrolled in public school or nonpublic school. While the statutory language does not provide specific criteria under which a District should assess a child, the language of  56320(f) establishes that assessments should address suspected disabilities. Therefore, if there is reason to suspect that a disability exists which is affecting a child's ability to benefit from his or education, the District may have the obligation under  56300 and 56302 to offer an assessment to the child. The District contends that STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 may have disabilities that could qualify them for special education and related services. The District contends that  56300 requires the District to assess STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 and offer any special education services they may need. The District contends that the fact that STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 are in private school does not relieve the District of its responsibility under  56300. As evidence that STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 may require special education services, the District points to three factors: 1. MOTHER requested a due process hearing in early 1995 and, in settling that dispute, agreed to assessments in March 1995. 2. MOTHER filed a complaint with the State Department of Education. 3. STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2's home teachers told Ms. Moore-Brown that STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 appeared to be behind academically. The problem with the District's argument is that there was essentially no reliable evidence presented at the hearing to suggest that STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 are in need of special education services. The information from the home teachers was hearsay and included no specific details regarding the basis for those teachers' opinions. Furthermore, while Ms. Moore-Brown testified to her interpretation of MOTHER's actions over the past year and a half, MOTHER provided credible testimony that contradicted Ms. Moore' Brown's testimony. For instance, Ms. Moore-Brown testified that she believed that MOTHER' hearing request was a request for special education services for STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2, thereby supporting the District's position that STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 may be in need of such services. However, MOTHER testified that she only requested the hearing to continue home teaching and she was not sure if home teaching was within the jurisdiction of the Hearing Office. Ms. Moore-Brown also testified that MOTHER agreed on March 13, 1995, to allow the District to conduct assessments of STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2. However, MOTHER never signed the assessment plans and there was no other information presented to establish that MOTHER did, in fact, consent to the assessments at that time. California Code of Regulations, Title 5,  3082(b) provides that in due process hearings [h]earsay evidence may be used for the purpose of supplementing or explaining other evidence but shall not be sufficient in itself to support a finding unless it would be admissible over objection in civil actions. The District presented little, if any, evidence to support its position that STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 require assessments for special education services. The District's contention that certain actions by MOTHER raise the possibility that STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 require such services was contradicted by MOTHER's testimony. Even without MOTHER's testimony, the Hearing Officer would question whether the evidence presented by the District would justify conducting an assessment for special education services. Additionally, Ms. Moore-Brown's testimony regarding the home teachers' opinions of STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2's performance was hearsay and unsupported by any direct evidence. The Hearing Officer notes that there was evidence presented regarding the medical condition of STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2, including cystic fibrosis (STUDENT 1), chemical sensitivities (STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2), and a thyroid condition (STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2). However, there was no evidence presented that any of these medical conditions are of the type that may impact either STUDENT 1 or STUDENT 2's ability to benefit from a regular education program. Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not present sufficient evidence admissible in a civil action to find that STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 may have disabilities which are interfering with their ability to benefit from their education and would, therefore, warrant assessment by the District. Furthermore, even if the District had established that STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 have suspected disabilities which warrant assessment, it is unclear whether the District would have the right to conduct those assessments. While there are provisions of federal law which require in certain circumstances that school districts provide special education services to eligible children enrolled in private schools when their parents request such services, it is unclear whether special education law allows public schools to force such services on children who are unilaterally enrolled in private schools whose parents are not requesting such services and are actively asserting that they do not want such services. See 34 CFR  76.650-76.662. Considering the circumstances of this case -- that the District filed child neglect charges against MOTHER; that those charges were dropped by the courts; that MOTHER presently has no interest in educational services from the District; that there is insufficient evidence of a need to conduct an assessment; and that the District has not established that the law entitles them to force services on STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 -- the Hearing Officer finds that the District has not established the right to conduct assessments of STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 at this time. The Hearing Officer notes, however, that if MOTHER chooses at a later date to avail herself of the District's services for STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2, the District may at that time have the right to conduct an assessment. ORDER Murrieta Valley Unified School District's request to assess STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 for special education services is denied. PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE Pursuant to Education Code  56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: Respondents prevailed on the sole issue heard and decided. RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code  56505(i). DATED: September 20, 1996 ____________________________ Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnotes: 1) Other than MOTHER's testimony, no evidence was presented regarding why her request was dismissed. The Hearing Office notes that if MOTHER was, in fact requesting home/hospital services, but not requesting them as special education services, her request would most likely not fall within the jurisdiction of the Hearing Office.