California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 10, 2000

Ventura Unified School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 515-00 · Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard

Ventura Unified may have its chosen school psychologist conduct a social-emotional assessment despite the parent's objection to that assessor.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

At the start of the hearing, the Hearing Officer denied the student's motion to dismiss, and the student declined a continuance. The Hearing Office had earlier denied a separate motion to dismiss on April 17, 2000. The student's own hearing request, SN 574-00, is mentioned but was not consolidated or decided here.

Summary

Ventura Unified School District asked for a due process hearing. It wanted permission to have its school psychologist, Susan Powers, conduct a social-emotional assessment of an 11-year-old sixth grader. The student was eligible for special education with a specific learning disability. Because of behavior problems, he had attended three schools that year and was attending Pacific Opportunity School 3.5 hours a day. The mother signed the District's assessment plan but wrote that Ms. Powers should not do the social-emotional assessment. The student did not challenge the assessment or Ms. Powers' qualifications. He argued that she was biased because she had already told the mother he had attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and should take medication, which the mother strongly opposed.

The Hearing Officer held that Education Code section 56322 lets the district decide who is competent to assess. Federal courts had also upheld a district's right to choose its own assessor. The legal rule against discriminatory assessment addresses racial or cultural bias, and there was no evidence of that. The Hearing Officer also found no evidence that Ms. Powers could not assess with an open mind. She cannot diagnose ADHD, and she offered to request reports from the doctors who had ruled it out. Other staff, including the psychologist the mother preferred, had raised the same concerns. The mother's distrust alone was not enough. The District was authorized to have Ms. Powers conduct the assessment without the parent's consent to that assessor.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO handled a parent's objection to a specific district assessor. The Hearing Officer relied on Education Code section 56322 and federal case law giving districts the choice of qualified assessors. A parent's distrust alone, without evidence that the assessor could not keep an open mind, did not limit that choice.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue 1. Whether the District has the right to have its school psychologist, Ms. Powers, conduct a social-emotional assessment of Student.

    Under Education Code section 56322 and federal case law, the District chooses its qualified assessor. There was no evidence of racial or cultural discrimination or that the psychologist could not assess with an open mind, and the parent's distrust did not limit the District's choice.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order that district may assess without consent. The District is authorized to conduct a social-emotional assessment of Student, and school psychologist Susan Powers may conduct it. The parent's consent to Ms. Powers as the assessor is not required.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Andress v. Cleveland Independent School District (5th Cir. 1995) 64 F.3d 176; Vander Malle v. Ambach (2nd Cir. 1982) 673 F.2d 49; Dubois v. Connecticut State Board of Education (2nd Cir. 1984) 727 F.2d 44; Ventura Unified School District v. Student, SN 1549-99 (Feb. 4, 2000); Education Code § 56322; Education Code § 56321; Education Code § 56320(a); Education Code § 56324(a); 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(3)(A)(i); 34 C.F.R. § 300.532(a)(1)(i)

People named in the decision

  • Susan Powers, school psychologist (proposed assessor), Ventura Unified School District, Pacific Opportunity School
  • Beverly McCaslin, assistant principal, Pacific Opportunity School
  • Don Bufon, resource specialist, Pacific Opportunity School
  • Riccardo Nargie, director of pupil services, Ventura Unified School District
  • Sheri Shoenwald, school psychologist (parent's preferred assessor), Ventura Unified School District
  • Bill Peckly, agreed assessor for functional analysis assessment
  • Ms. Block, regular education teacher, Ventura Unified School District
  • Ventura County Behavioral Health, county mental health agency (AB 3632 assessment), County of Ventura

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Ventura, California, on April 18, 2000.

Petitioner Ventura Unified School District (the District) was represented at the hearing by Donald F. Austin, General Counsel. Also present on the District's behalf was Susan Powers and Riccardo Nargie, who was present for a portion of the hearing.

Respondent STUDENT (STUDENT) was represented by attorney David L. Jones, Jones & Briggs, LLP. Respondent's mother, MS. PARENT, was also present on STUDENT's behalf for a portion of the hearing.

Petitioner called the following witnesses: Beverly McCaslin, assistant principal at Pacific Opportunity School, an alternative education high school and middle school; Don Bufon, resource specialist from Pacific Opportunity; Susan Powers, school psychologist at Pacific Opportunity; and Riccardo Nargie, director of pupil services.

Respondent called MS. PARENT as its witness.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. At the conclusion of the hearing, the parties made oral closing arguments. The record was then closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUE (Footnote 1)

The sole issue is whether the District has the right to have its school psychologist, Ms. Powers, conduct a social-emotional assessment of STUDENT.

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The District contends that, by statute, it has the sole right to determine who is to conduct STUDENT's assessment. The District also outlines practical reasons to support its decision to have Ms. Powers conduct the assessment.

STUDENT does not dispute Ms. Powers' qualifications to conduct this assessment. He does not oppose the assessment itself. Rather, STUDENT contends that he has a right to a nondiscriminatory assessment. In his view, Ms. Powers has already determined that he has Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) and that he should be placed on Ritalin. This treatment is strongly opposed by his mother, Ms. PARENT. In his view, any assessment performed by Ms. Powers will simply confirm her preconceived notion that he has ADHD and should be medicated. STUDENT represented that he is willing to consent to the social-emotional assessment by any District school psychologist other than Ms. Powers.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is an eleven-year-old sixth-grader who was determined to be eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability in 1995. STUDENT currently attends Pacific Opportunity Program for 3.5 hours per day. This is his third school placement this year. He began the school year at Cabrillo Middle School, his home school. He briefly attended Anacapa Middle School, prior to a suspension. (Respondent's Exhibit 20) In late January 2000, STUDENT began attending Pacific.

On January 24, 2000, an annual review individualized education program (IEP) meeting was held. At the time, STUDENT was attending Anacapa Middle School. Placement was in the general education classroom with resource specialist program (RSP) consultation services. A mental health referral under AB 3632 to determine eligibility for services was to be initiated. (Footnote 2) The IEP indicated that STUDENT would be provided with independent study services pending his placement in the Opportunity Program.

On January 25, 2000, the District made a referral to Ventura County Behavioral Health (VCBH) for a mental health assessment of STUDENT. The parent did not follow up on this referral.

On March 2, 2000, the IEP team met to discuss STUDENT's progress at Pacific Opportunity School. STUDENT was described as "having significant difficulty with sustained concentration, distractability, assignment completion and self-control, even in a small class with modifications and teacher assistance." Team notes indicated that "parent has agreed to follow up with a medical diagnosis for ADHD." The team agreed to continue the IEP meeting on March 21, 2000. This IEP was signed by Ms. PARENT. (Respondent's Exhibit 21)

On March 21, 2000, the IEP team met to discuss concerns about STUDENT's progress and placement. Another referral to VCBH for an AB 3632 assessment was discussed. At that meeting, it was determined that STUDENT would receive a one-on-one aide. (Petitioner's Exhibit 3). The District also presented Ms. PARENT with an assessment plan which called for a social-emotional assessment by a school psychologist, and a functional analysis assessment by a school psychologist and a resource specialist teacher. (Petitioner's Exhibit 5)

On March 27, 2000, the District filed its request for due process hearing on the issue of whether it should be allowed to conduct an assessment of STUDENT.

On March 29, 2000, STUDENT filed his request for a due process hearing (SN 574-00) on a wide array of issues.

On March 30, 2000, the District amended and issued a new assessment plan due to STUDENT's ongoing behavior problems at school. This plan proposed assessing STUDENT in a number of areas and included a social-emotional assessment by a school psychologist. It also included occupational therapy and speech and language assessments which had been requested by STUDENT. (Petitioner's Exhibits 6, 13)

On April 7, 2000, Ms. PARENT returned the March 30, 2000 assessment plan with her signature. Next to the social-emotional behavior assessment, Ms. PARENT wrote the following: "not Susan Powers. I agree to Bill Peckly for this assessment." (Footnote 3) (Petitioner's Exhibit 7) Ms. PARENT also agreed to a mental health assessment of STUDENT by VCBH. (Petitioner's Exhibit 10).

On April 11, 2000, the Special Education Hearing Office received STUDENT's motion to dismiss this case on the ground that Ms. PARENT had signed the assessment plan, with the above-described amendment added by her. On April 17, 2000, the Hearing Office denied the motion to dismiss noting that "the only potential remaining dispute appears to be the extent of the participation of the school psychologist, Susan Powers, in conducting the assessment."

At the outset of the hearing, STUDENT made a motion to dismiss the entire case. The basis for the motion was that Ms. PARENT did not have 15 days required under Education Code § 56321(c) to consider the assessment without having the "gun" of the District's due process hearing at her head. The motion was denied. Thereafter, STUDENT declined an opportunity to request a continuance upon a showing of prejudice.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE: Does the District have the right to have its school psychologist, Ms. Powers, conduct a social-emotional assessment of STUDENT?

Summary of Relevant Testimony

Ms. PARENT testified as follows: Ms. Powers told her that STUDENT has ADHD, that Ms. PARENT should put him on medication, that Ms. Powers placed her own daughter on Ritalin, and that it helped her a lot. Ms. Powers told her only the positive aspects of Ritalin and advised her to ignore negative things she heard about Ritalin. Ms. PARENT told Ms. Powers that two doctors had examined STUDENT and concluded he did not have ADHD. Ms. Powers did not acknowledge this when she tried to convince Ms. PARENT to medicate STUDENT. At the IEP meeting of March 2, 2000, Ms. Powers spoke about this topic in STUDENT's presence, which made Ms. PARENT uncomfortable. According to Ms. PARENT, Ms. Powers cannot be unbiased because "she has already told me he is ADHD" and STUDENT should be assessed by someone who has not already "diagnosed" him. Ms. PARENT would prefer any other District psychologist, especially Sheri Shoenwald. Ms. PARENT testified that Ms. Shoenwald knows STUDENT better and STUDENT likes her. Ms. Shoenwald has never "drilled" her about ADHD.

Ms. McCaslin testified as follows: She is the assistant principle at Pacific Opportunity School. STUDENT's behavior at school have included showing little respect for authority, teachers and peers. He has no friends. He has trouble following directions, seldom completes his work and is defiant. Because STUDENT is only at school 3.5 hours per day, she makes every effort not to suspend him but to keep him in school. A one-on-one aide was recently provided to STUDENT at the request of his attorney. STUDENT did not want the aide and was disrespectful toward her. Since providing the aide, STUDENT's behavior has not improved. On February 11, 2000, Ms. McCaslin completed an administrative referral form on STUDENT due to his behavior. Under "action," she wrote "Called mom....Discussed Susan Power's phone call 2/10 about STUDENT's placements, meds, ADHD condition and diagnosis, and positive experiences at school today. Agreed not to suspend him...." According to Ms. McCaslin, she did not verify this information from Ms. PARENT with Ms. Powers nor did she tell Ms. PARENT that STUDENT had ADHD. Ms. PARENT asked her what ADHD means and how it is diagnosed. Ms. McCaslin told her that a psychiatrist or a medical doctor could diagnose ADHD.

Mr. Bufon testified as follows: He is a resource specialist at Pacific Opportunity School. At the IEP meeting of March 2, 2000, there was a discussion about ADHD and medication. Mr. Bufon and Ms. Powers were on the IEP team. The team encouraged Ms. PARENT to consult with a family doctor to discuss STUDENT's apparent hyperactivity and to explore the possibility of medication with her doctor. According to Mr. Bufon, Ms. Powers did not use a tone or exhibit a demeanor which aggressively pushed medication. In his opinion, Ms. Powers used a professional approach with Ms. PARENT. She explained that medication had helped others. She was forthright but not aggressive. Ms. Powers did not tell Ms. PARENT that STUDENT had ADHD. She mentioned that ADHD was a possibility, but that it was not her role to diagnose STUDENT's condition.

Ms. Powers testified as follows: She is a school psychologist and STUDENT is assigned to her at Pacific Opportunity School. In her view, a social-emotional assessment is needed on STUDENT because of significant behavioral problems that are interfering with his learning, as well as the learning of his classmates. STUDENT has been in three different schools this year due to the same behavior problems. His impulsivity, poor self-control and short attention span are consistent with ADHD. Ms. Powers testified that she believes ADHD may be one part of STUDENT's behavioral problems. Ms. Powers denied that she "diagnosed" STUDENT as having ADHD or insisted he be placed on Ritalin. It is not her role to diagnose this condition. She will indicate if a child shows symptoms consistent with ADHD. Her typical practice is to tell parents to discuss this issue as well as the pros and cons of medication with their doctor or psychologist. She conceded that she may have "come on strong" because she was looking for solutions to help STUDENT succeed at school. The day before the March 2, 2000 IEP meeting, Ms. Powers attended a research conference on ADHD. One of the speakers discussed current research on the safety of Ritalin, which showed few serious side effects. This was fresh in her mind when the IEP meeting took place. Ms. Powers did tell Ms. PARENT about her personal experience with placing her child on Ritalin. She did so to let Ms. PARENT know that she could empathize with the difficulty of this decision. On the morning of the hearing, Ms. Powers was provided with some medical reports on STUDENT which Ms. PARENT had not previously provided to the District.

Ms. Powers testified that, as part of her assessment, she would complete ADHD rating scales as well as other behavior scales. Although Mental Health is doing a mental health assessment on STUDENT and will make any appropriate diagnosis, they need input from the school for their ADHD assessment. Parent rating scales are also included in the social-emotional assessment. These can be completed by the parent independent of the assessor.

Discussion

No assessment of a student shall be conducted by a school district without first obtaining the written consent of the parent, unless the District establishes the need to conduct such an assessment at a due process hearing. California Education Code §§ 56321(a), 56505(e). Pursuant to Education Code § 56322, the "assessment shall be conducted by persons competent to perform the assessment, as determined by the school district, county office, or special education local plan area." The courts have consistently affirmed a district's right to choose who it wishes to conduct an assessment. See: Andress v. Cleveland Independent School District (5th Cir. 1995) 64 F. 3d 176, 178 [no exception to the rule that a school district has the right to reevaluate a student using its own personnel]; Vander Malle v. Ambach (2nd Cir. 1982) 673 F.2d 49, 53 [the school is entitled to have student examined by qualified psychiatrist of their choosing]; Dubois v. Connecticut State Board of Education (2nd Cir. 1984) 727 F. 2d 44, 47 [school system may insist on evaluation by qualified professionals who are satisfactory to them]. As noted by the District, the Hearing Office has recently upheld the District's right to determine who will conduct a triennial assessment. Ventura Unified School District v. Student, Case No. SN 1549-99 (February 4, 2000).

In the present case, STUDENT's position is that he has a right to a nondiscriminatory assessment. Because Ms. Powers is fatally biased in favor of diagnosing him with ADHD and medicating him with Ritalin, the District should not be allowed to have her conduct the assessment.

The Hearing Officer has neither found nor been provided with any authority to limit the District's discretion to choose a particular assessor based on the assessor's opinion that a child may have or exhibit characteristics of a particular disability or medical condition. This, in fact, may be a vital part of the assessor's responsibilities. STUDENT's asserted right to an assessment which is "nondiscriminatory" appears to have its roots in provisions relating to test instruments. Both federal and state law prohibit the use of tests and other evaluation materials that are discriminatory. Tests must be "selected and administered so as not to be discriminatory on a racial or cultural basis...." 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(3)(A)(i); 34 C.F.R. § 300.532(a)(1)(i); California Education Code § 56320(a). In addition, a psychological assessment "shall be conducted by a credentialed school psychologist who is trained and prepared to assess cultural and ethnic factors appropriate to the pupil being assessed." California Education Code § 56324 (a). No evidence was presented, however, that any actions contemplated by the District through Ms. Powers are either racially or culturally discriminatory.

Essentially, STUDENT's claim is that Ms. Powers has prejudged his condition and cannot assess him with an open mind. Even assuming that this might, in some circumstances, be a legitimate basis for limiting the District's discretion, the Hearing Officer finds that there was no evidence that Ms. Powers cannot approach her assessment of STUDENT with an open mind. First, the evidence was uncontradicted that Ms. Powers cannot actually diagnose STUDENT with ADHD. Second, Ms. Powers evidenced a willingness to consider new information on the issue of whether STUDENT has ADHD from professionals Ms. PARENT has consulted and who apparently have concluded that he does not have ADHD. Ms. Powers testified that, in her opinion, STUDENT exhibits many characteristics which are consistent with ADHD. However, based upon her review of medical reports provided by Ms. PARENT on the morning of the hearing, Ms. Powers testified that she would like to see if there are any additional medical reports and would request them from the doctors who had ruled out ADHD. This is indicative of open-minded professionalism.

Third, the Hearing Officer notes that there appears to be consensus among school personnel that STUDENT is exhibiting characteristics of ADHD-like behavior. This is information which must be considered by any assessor of a child's social-emotional condition. On January 25, 2000, Ms. Shoenwald, the psychologist who is preferred by Ms. PARENT, wrote a letter to VCBH referring STUDENT for a mental health assessment. In that letter, she expressed her opinion that "STUDENT is a boy who could benefit from an evaluation by a psychiatrist in an effort to consider medication for, what I perceive to be, an Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder." (Respondent's Exhibit 7) Ms. PARENT's disbelief that STUDENT had this condition and her opposition to medication were also mentioned by Ms. Shoenwald. It is apparent that Ms. PARENT had strong feelings on this subject which predated Ms. Powers' involvement with STUDENT. In addition, as noted by Mr. Bufon, the school members at the IEP team meeting of March 2, 2000, encouraged Ms. PARENT to consult with her doctors about STUDENT's apparent hyperactivity and to explore possible medication. Ms. Powers was only one of six school team members at that meeting. These included Mr. Bufon, Ms. McCaslin and STUDENT's regular teacher, Ms. Block.

The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Powers testified in an extremely candid and persuasive manner regarding her concerns about STUDENT and her comments to Ms. PARENT. The Hearing Officer also has no reason to doubt Ms. PARENT's testimony that she does not trust Ms. Powers. Even when Ms. PARENT was advised that Ms. Shoenwald also believed that STUDENT may have ADHD and that medication should be considered, she preferred that Ms. Shoenwald conduct the assessment. Although Ms. PARENT clearly feels distrust for Ms. Powers, her perception is not a sufficient basis to limit the District's discretion in choosing its assessor. (Footnote 4) Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's choice of Ms. Powers to conduct the social-emotional assessment is not in violation of the law and is consistent with its right to choose who will conduct assessments. It is unnecessary to consider Mr. Nargie's testimony about the administrative reasons for the District's decision to choose Ms. Powers as the assessor.

ORDER

1. The District is authorized to conduct a social-emotional assessment of STUDENT.

2. This assessment may be conducted by school psychologist Susan Powers. The parent's consent to Ms. Powers as the assessor is not required.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

On the sole issue, the District prevailed.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

Dated: May 10, 2000 _____________________________________ Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. The issue presented differs from those noticed by the parties before the hearing. After the District filed its request for hearing, the scope of issues narrowed. This issue reflects the discussion held with the parties on the day of the hearing.

2. Legislation enacted in 1996 (AB 2726) amended or enacted provisions of chapter 26.5 of the California Government Code, Section 7570, et seq., which governs the interagency responsibilities for providing services, including mental health services, to children with disabilities. The commonly used term "AB 3632" will be used to refer to mental health services under this chapter.

3. Dr. Peckly is the agreed upon assessor for STUDENT's functional analysis assessment.

4. Given Ms. PARENT's historical mistrust of special education services and her current agreement to many other assessments for STUDENT, the District may wish to reexamine whether its insistence on Ms. Powers is likely to foster working relationships in the future.