California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 8, 2005

Student v. District (name not stated in decision text; schools named are Chaparral Elementary and Crown Valley Elementary) (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 577-05, SN05-00098, SN05-00577 · Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard

District must fund ABA home program, aide, private therapies and 85 compensatory hours for a kindergartner with autism after child find and FAPE violations.

Split decision: student prevailed on 11 of 22 issues (3 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parents of a six-year-old boy with autism filed for due process. The district then filed its own request to assess him without consent, and the cases were consolidated. Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard found that his preschool teacher at Chaparral Elementary suspected a disability by late October 2003. The district made no written referral, which denied FAPE from mid-January to April 22, 2004. The district's assessors were qualified, and its behavior and other testing were upheld. Its occupational therapy (OT) assessment, however, never evaluated sensory motor needs. The April 2004 IEP had speech goals and an OT-attention goal that could not be measured. It had no goals for self-care, sensory processing, motor planning (praxis) and key language skills. The offer was a general education class with limited intensive behavior intervention, 30 minutes of speech a week and OT consultation, and it did not meet his needs. He required a full-time 1:1 aide, about 25 hours a week of applied behavior analysis (ABA), and two hours a week each of speech and OT. The district also held a September 2004 IEP meeting without enough effort to include the parents. Claims about the procedural notice, observation limits, offer clarity and team membership failed. The district must reimburse the $1,200 OT IEE, the home ABA program, private therapies and preschool tuition. It must also fund the current program until fall 2005, provide 85 compensatory therapy hours, and hold a transition IEP. Its request to assess was denied because the parents were left out of developing the assessment plan.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled child find when a teacher only gave a parent a phone number. The duty to make a written referral fell on the district, not the parent. It also shows that a district request to reassess without consent could be denied when parents had no chance to help develop the assessment plan.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedChild find

    Issue 1. Did the District fail to identify and refer Student for an assessment pursuant to its child find obligation in the fall of the 2003-2004 school year?

    The preschool teacher suspected a disability by late October 2003, but the District made no written referral and gave no procedural safeguards. This denied FAPE from mid-January 2004 to April 22, 2004.

  2. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 2A. Whether the District's assessors (school psychologist, speech pathologist, occupational therapist) were qualified

    All three District assessors were properly credentialed or licensed and qualified to assess.

  3. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 2B. Whether the District used appropriate assessment materials (VMI-4 rather than VMI-5; Vineland Interview Edition)

    Using the VMI-4 within 12 months of the VMI-5's release was permissible, and the Vineland Interview Edition was administered appropriately.

  4. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 2C1. Whether the District failed to assess oral-motor planning skills

    Oral-motor planning was not a suspected area of disability at the time, because the private therapist needed months of therapy to identify it.

  5. Student prevailedAssessment

    Issue 2C2. Whether the District failed to conduct the sensory motor assessment by an occupational therapist that the parents consented to on the assessment plan

    The District's OT report contained no findings or analysis of sensory motor needs, so the OT assessment was not appropriate.

  6. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 2C3. Whether the District failed to assess or inadequately assessed Student's behavior

    The multidisciplinary assessment used multiple rating scales and observation, and leaving out the optional Vineland maladaptive domain was not improper.

  7. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 2D. Whether the school nurse conducted a health assessment without parental consent

    The vision and hearing screening was done in the mother's presence without objection, so consent was implied and there was no prejudice.

  8. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 3A. Did the District provide parents with a Notice of Procedural Rights that was substantially defective to a degree that constituted a denial of FAPE per se?

    The eight-page notice covered the required topics, and the represented parents understood and used their IEE rights, so there was no per se denial of FAPE.

  9. Issue 3B. Did the District fail to provide Student's independent assessors with an equivalent opportunity to observe and assess him as required by Education Code section 56329?

    As applied, the independent assessors had observation time roughly equal to what District assessors actually used. The Hearing Office cannot issue declaratory relief on the policy itself.

  10. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 3C1. Failing to provide a legally sufficient IEP on April 20, 2004

    Completing the IEP at a second meeting two days later was permissible and caused no prejudice.

  11. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 3C2. Failing to make a clear and coherent offer of speech and language and/or intensive behavior intervention (IBI) services

    The offers were less than precise, but the amount of services, which was the deciding factor for the parents, was clear. There was no procedural denial of FAPE.

  12. Student prevailed in partIEP content

    Issue 3C3. Failing to provide measurable goals and objectives to address all of his unique needs

    The speech goals and the OT attention goal were not measurable. Goals were missing for pronouns, multi-step directions, linguistic concepts, self-care, visual motor, sensory processing and praxis. The behavior and social skills goals were adequate.

  13. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3C4. Failing to offer behavioral supports of an applied behavioral analysis (ABA) home program with a one-to-one behavioral classroom aide

    General education with limited IBI was not designed to meet his needs. He required a full-time 1:1 aide and an intensive ABA program of about 25 hours a week.

  14. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3C5. Failing to offer adequate speech and language therapy

    Thirty minutes a week of speech did not meet his receptive, expressive and pragmatic needs. He required two hours a week of individual therapy.

  15. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3C6. Failing to offer adequate occupational therapy (OT)

    Monthly OT consultation was inadequate. He required two hours a week of direct OT plus consultation.

  16. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 3C7. Failing to offer an ESY program that was sufficient to allow recoupment

    The July 2004 addendum offered maintenance services so the break was no more than two weeks. The District acted appropriately on the break issue, although the services themselves were found insufficient elsewhere.

  17. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 3D. Failing to have Student's regular education teacher present at the addendum IEP team meeting of July 9, 2004

    The kindergarten teacher, Kristie Allard, attended as the regular education teacher, which met the requirement.

  18. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 4. Did the District deny Student a FAPE during the 2004-2005 school year by convening an IEP team meeting on September 23, 2004, without providing for parental notice or participation and failing to provide them with a copy of the IEP, and/or as outlined in Issue 3?

    The District made no follow-up calls to the represented parents and did not send them the IEP for six months, which denied them participation. The 2004-2005 offer also denied FAPE for the reasons given in Issue 3.

  19. Issue 5A. Is Student entitled to reimbursement for independent educational assessments and for educational services provided by his parents?

    Reimbursement was granted for the OT IEE ($1,200), the AIR home ABA program and aide, private OT and speech, and preschool tuition. Reimbursement was denied for the behavior intake assessment and for insurance payments.

  20. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5B. Is Student entitled to compensatory education?

    For about seven months of cumulative denial of FAPE, the Hearing Officer awarded 40 hours of OT, 5 hours of OT consultation and 40 hours of speech, plus continued funding of the current program.

  21. Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE

    Issue 5C. Is Student entitled to prospective placement?

    The current AIR, Kindercare and therapy program was ordered maintained only until the start of 2005-2006, with an IEP to plan the transition into a Chaparral first grade class.

  22. Issue 6. Is the District entitled to assess Petitioner pursuant to its February 16, 2005 assessment plan?

    Conditions warranted a reassessment, but the request was denied because the parents had no chance to help develop the assessment plan (Ed. Code 56304, 56381(b)).

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 25 calendar days of the decision, convene an IEP meeting to (a) plan Student's transition from Kindercare into a first grade class at Chaparral for 2005-2006, with input from current service providers and Chaparral first grade staff, and (b) schedule the compensatory services.
  • IEE at public expense. Reimburse the parents for Nancy Lin's occupational therapy IEE, $1,200, within 25 days of receiving proof of payment.
  • Reimbursement. Within 25 calendar days of receiving proof of payment, reimburse the parents' costs not paid by insurance, for 2004 and 2005 through the decision date, for: private OT from Cheri Francis/Pediatric Therapy Solutions; speech-language services from Speech Pathology Associates; the AIR home program including 1:1 aide, supervision and clinic hours; and preschool tuition at Country Village Preschool and Kindercare.
  • Prospective funding of private placement. From the decision date to the start of the 2005-2006 school year, maintain and pay for the current AIR program for up to 30 hours a week, including a 1:1 shadow aide at school, 8 hours a month of supervision and 12 hours a month of clinic; two hours a month each of clinic-based individual OT with Cheri Francis and speech therapy with Leora Shaffer; and Kindercare tuition.
  • Compensatory education. 40 hours of clinic-based OT plus 5 hours of OT consultation with Pediatric Therapy Solutions, to be used by the end of the 2006 ESY unless the parties agree otherwise.
  • Compensatory education. 40 hours of individual speech-language therapy with Leora Shaffer of Speech Pathology Associates, to be used by the end of the 2006 ESY unless the parties agree otherwise.

Total: 85 hours of compensatory services; $1,200 ordered

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Target Range Sch. Dist.; Burlington; Florence County Sch. Dist. Four v. Carter; Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist.; Adams v. State of Oregon; Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist.; Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist.; Hall v. Vance County Bd. of Educ.; Hoeft v. Tucson Unified Sch. Dist.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist.; Mrs. B. v. Milford Bd. of Educ.; Max M. v. Thompson

People named in the decision

  • Claudia Boessler, preschool teacher, District (Chaparral Elementary)
  • Ms. Hunt, preschool teacher (afternoon class) and classroom aide, District (Chaparral Elementary)
  • Gwyneth Chua, occupational therapist (assessor), District
  • Ann L. Roche, school nurse, District
  • Joan Sternberg, speech-language pathologist (assessor), District
  • Michelle Degn, resource specialist program teacher / case carrier, District
  • Jennifer Fant, autism program specialist, District
  • Sandra (Sandy) Garrison, school psychologist (assessor), District
  • Kristie Allard, regular education kindergarten teacher, District
  • Beryl Adams, autism specialist / IBI supervisor, District
  • Dr. Rafferty, principal / administrative designee, District (Chaparral Elementary)
  • Lupe Martinez, director of early childhood education, District
  • Dr. Fleming, superintendent (signed observation policy), District
  • Kim Gaither, legal specialist, District
  • Leora Ann Shaffer, private speech-language pathologist, Speech Pathology Associates
  • Barbara Moore, speech-language pathologist, executive director; expert witness for Student, Speech Pathology Associates
  • Nancy Lin, independent occupational therapist (IEE assessor), Pediatric Therapy Solutions
  • Cheri Francis, private occupational therapist, Pediatric Therapy Solutions
  • Anahita Parsi Renner, certified behavior analyst, clinical director (private ABA provider and assessor), Autism Interventions and Resources (AIR)
  • Dr. Mitchell D. Perlman, clinical psychologist; independent psychoeducational assessor and expert witness for Student, Private
  • Emily Molitor, private speech-language pathologist (assessor), Providence Speech and Hearing Center
  • Dr. Pauline Filipek, neurologist (diagnosing physician), University Children's Hospital, UC Irvine Medical Center
  • Autism Interventions and Resources (AIR), nonpublic agency providing home ABA program and 1:1 aide
  • Kindercare Preschool, private preschool
  • Country Village Preschool, private preschool

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter convened for hearing before Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in San Juan Capistrano, California, on March 17, 22-25, 29, 30, and April 19, 2005.

Petitioner/Cross-Respondent Student (Student or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorneys Paul M. Roberts and Ellen Bacon. Also present on Petitioner’s behalf were his parents, PARENTS. Respondent/Cross-Petitioner (District) was represented at the hearing by its attorney S. Daniel Harbottle. Also present on the District’s behalf at different times throughout the hearing were its legal specialist, Kim Gaither, and its consulting attorney, J. Anthony Smith.

Student called the following witnesses: his parents, PARENTS; private speech pathologists Leora Ann Shaffer and Barbara Moore; private occupational therapists Nancy Lin and Cheri Francis; certified behavior analyst and clinical director of Autism Interventions and Resources (AIR), Anahita Parsi Renner; and clinical psychologist Dr. Mitchell D. Perlman. The District called the following employees as witnesses: preschool teacher Claudia Boessler; occupational therapist Gwyneth Chua; school nurse Ann L. Roche; speech pathologist Joan Sternberg; resource specialist program (RSP) teacher Michelle Degn; program specialist Jennifer Fant; and school psychologist Sandra Garrison. Oral and documentary evidence was received. On May 10, 2005, the Hearing Officer received the parties’ closing briefs. The record was then closed and the matter submitted for a decision. ISSUES (Footnote 1)

1. Did the District fail to identify and refer STUDENT for an assessment pursuant to its child find obligation in the fall of the 2003-2004 school year?

2. Did the District appropriately assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability consented to by the parents during the 2003-2004 school year and 2004 extended school year (ESY)?

3. Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year and 2004 ESY on procedural and/or substantive grounds by:

A. providing his parents with a Notice of Procedural Rights that was substantially defective to a degree that constituted a denial of FAPE per se?

B. failing to provide STUDENT’s independent assessors with an “equivalent opportunity” to observe and assess him as required by Education Code section 56329;

C. denying him a FAPE on procedural and/or substantive grounds at the April 2004 individualized education program (IEP) team meetings by:

1. failing to provide a legally sufficient IEP on April 20, 2004; 2. failing to make a clear and coherent offer of speech and language and/or intensive behavior intervention (IBI) services; 3. failing to provide measurable goals and objectives to address all of his unique needs; 4. failing to offer behavioral supports of an applied behavioral analysis (ABA) home program with a one-to-one behavioral classroom aide; 5. failing to offer adequate speech and language therapy;

6. failing to offer adequate occupational therapy (OT); and/or 7. failing to offer an ESY program that was sufficient to allow recoupment?

D. failing to have STUDENT’s regular education teacher present at the addendum IEP team meeting of July 9, 2004?

4. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE on substantive or procedural grounds during the 2004-2005 school year by convening an IEP team meeting on September 23, 2004, without providing for parental notice or participation and failing to provide them with a copy of the IEP, and/or as outlined in Issue 3 A, B, or C?

5. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year, the 2004 ESY, and/or the 2004-2005 school year through April 2005, is he entitled to

A. reimbursement for independent educational assessments (IEEs) and for educational services provided by his parents, B. compensatory education, and/or C. prospective placement?

6. Is the District entitled to assess Petitioner pursuant to its February 16, 2005 assessment plan?

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

STUDENT is a six-year-old student with autism who was initially determined to be eligible for special education and related services by the District in April 2004. At the time of his initial eligibility determination, STUDENT was attending the District’s Chaparral Elementary School in its fee-based preschool program. In September 2004, STUDENT’s family unilaterally removed him from the District and began funding an applied behavioral analysis (ABA) program at home that was supervised and implemented by Autistic Intervention Resources (AIR). As part of his home program, was provided a one-to-one behavioral aide to accompany him to his preschool. STUDENT is currently attending Kindercare Preschool with his aide and he continues to receive ABA services at home, as well as two hours a week of speech and language services and one hour a week of occupational therapy. All of these services are funded by his parents.

In August 2003, STUDENT was enrolled in Chaparral’s preschool program, where he attended the afternoon class taught by Ms. Hunt. Approximately one month later, STUDENT switched to the morning session and joined Claudia Boessler’s preschool classroom. MOTHER and Ms. Boessler discussed STUDENT’s development and the parents’ concerns regarding his comprehension, social isolation, and inattentiveness. In approximately October 2003, MOTHER informed Ms. Boessler that she was seeking private assessments of STUDENT in speech and that she was trying to obtain an appointment with a neurologist due to her concern that STUDENT may have autism. In late October 2003, Ms. Boessler gave MOTHER the telephone number of the District’s school psychologist. A written request for special education assessment of STUDENT was not made at that time by either the parent or Ms. Boessler.

On January 14, 2004, STUDENT was privately assessed by Emily Molitor, a speech pathologist at Providence Speech and Hearing Center, to address his parents’ concern about his spontaneous speech and his difficulty following directions, staying on topic, attending in large groups, as well as his habit of making up words or using unintelligible words. From her assessment, Ms. Molitor determined that STUDENT had mild disorders in his oral-motor skills and significant disorders in receptive, expressive, and pragmatic language skills that required intensive therapeutic intervention. She diagnosed STUDENT as having an oral-motor speech disturbance and a receptive/expressive language disorder. Ms. Molitor recommended that STUDENT participate in individual speech and language therapy twice a week for six months, that he be assessed by a neurologist and by an audiologist, and that his attention be tested by a psychiatrist.

On January 28, 2004, STUDENT was neurologically assessed by Dr. Pauline Filipek at the University Children’s Hospital, University of California’s Irvine Medical Center, due to developmental and behavioral concerns. Dr. Filipek reported that STUDENT demonstrated “scripting and delayed echolalia with a lot of jargon intermixed.” She also noted that he had mild to moderate hypotonia. As part of this evaluation, a Childhood Autism Rating Scale (CARS) was completed and indicated that STUDENT was in the “mildly autistic range.” Dr. Filipek concluded that STUDENT met the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual - Fourth Edition (DSM-IV) criteria for autistic disorder because he demonstrated delays or abnormal functioning in at least one of the following areas: (1) social interaction, (2) language as used in social communication, or (3) symbolic or imaginative play. Dr. Filipek provided numerous recommendations to the family, including a referral to Speech Pathology Associates (SPA) for speech therapy, and a referral “to the local school district for the initiation of an IEP evaluation.”

On February 23, 2004, STUDENT’s parents submitted a written request for his assessment to Chaparral’s principal, based upon Dr. Filipek’s diagnosis and referral. On February 25, 2004, the District convened a preschool screening student study team (SST) meeting to discuss STUDENT. In attendance were school psychologist Sandy Garrison, resource specialist program (RSP) teacher Michelle Degn, STUDENT’s teacher Claudia Boessler, and MOTHER. Among the concerns articulated by the participants at the SST meeting were that STUDENT did not seem to respond to others, mimicked and used dialogue from videos, talked to himself, and toe walked. Additionally, STUDENT was reported to be academically on target only in a one-to-one context, had no conversational skills, had difficulty comprehending directions, “shut down,” over-focused, failed to respond to his name, pursued his own interests, was not aware of “stranger danger,” was just learning to advocate for himself when others bothered him, and repeated questions back. STUDENT was socially isolated but interacted with some peers (e.g., he was observed being “mothered” by another child). At the conclusion of this meeting, STUDENT was referred to the assessment team to consider special education eligibility.

On March 3, 2004, an assessment plan was developed by the District and signed by the parents. The assessment plan authorized the District to assess STUDENT in the areas of academic/pre-academic achievement, social/adaptive behavior, psychomotor development, communication development, intellectual/cognitive development, and “sensory-motor” by the occupational therapist. Thereafter, pursuant to the assessment plan, STUDENT was assessed by the District’s occupational therapist Gwyneth Chua, by school psychologist, Sandra Garrison, and by speech pathologist Joan Sternberg. In addition, on March 9, 2005, the District’s school nurse, Ann L. Roche, conducted a health screening of STUDENT that was not identified as an area for assessment on the assessment plan.

On March 23, 2004, STUDENT began individual speech therapy sessions with private speech pathologist Leora Shaffer at SPA. Although two hours a week of speech therapy had been recommended for STUDENT in the Providence speech assessment, Ms. Shaffer’s schedule through September 2004 only allowed her to treat STUDENT one hour a week.

On seven occasions in March and April 2004, the District’s school psychologist, Sandy Garrison, and its speech therapist, Joan Sternberg, conducted a multidisciplinary assessment of STUDENT that included observations, a review of independent assessments, parent interview, parent and teacher rating scales and checklists, and both informal and standardized assessments. From the Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scale of Intelligence - Third (WPPSI-III), STUDENT was determined to have a verbal intelligence quotient (IQ) of 70, at the 2nd percentile, and a performance IQ of 121 at the 92nd percentile. STUDENT’s full scale IQ was reported to be 84, at the 14th percentile, in the below-average range. Ms. Garrison noted that STUDENT’s subscales on the WPPSI-III ranged from significantly below average to significantly above average “indicating a significant range in skills.” On the Childhood Autism Rating Scale (CARS) completed by the parents, STUDENT was in the “severely autistic” range. From the parents’ responses on the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales: Interview Edition Survey Form (Vineland), Ms. Garrison reported that STUDENT’s overall adaptive functioning was “moderately low,” with a composite score at the 2nd percentile. Weaknesses were noted in the areas of self-help with “low” overall daily living skills at the 1st percentile, “moderately low” socialization skills at the 7th percentile, and “moderately low” communication at the 3rd percentile. On the Berry Buktenica Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration - Fourth Edition (VMI-4), Ms. Garrison reported that STUDENT’s visual-motor skills were at age level expectations (5.10 age equivalent, at the 82nd percentile). STUDENT’s academic achievement was assessed by the Woodcock Johnson Test of Achievement III (WJ-III).

Ms. Garrison reported that STUDENT was extremely reluctant to respond to test items, cooperated with some subtests, and refused or only partially responded to others. Nonetheless, Ms. Garrison reported that “observation and other assessments suggested that STUDENT is capable of performing within age-level expectancies in these areas when he responds.” In describing STUDENT’s testing performance, however, Ms. Garrison noted that he reluctantly responded only with repeated and considerable encouragement and coaxing. She summarized that “although it was possible with a great deal of encouragement and repeated presentations to elicit responses, STUDENT used several means (e.g., crawling on the floor, feigning sleep with snoring, moving toys around, etc.) to avoid tasks.”

To assess STUDENT’s speech and language skills, Ms. Sternberg administered the Preschool Language Scale - 4 (PLS-4) to STUDENT and also conducted informal assessments of his spontaneous oral language, articulation skills, oral-motor skills, and pragmatic language (social interaction) skills. On the PLS-4, STUDENT had a total language score at the 3rd percentile. Ms. Sternberg determined that STUDENT’s length of utterance was within the normal range for same-aged peers and that, while he used whole word repetitions in connected speech, these repetitions did not interfere with his overall communication. Ms. Sternberg also determined informally that STUDENT’s few articulation errors were within the developmental range and that his oral-motor structures were “sufficient for speech purposes.” Regarding his pragmatic language skills, Ms. Sternberg reported that STUDENT was able to use language “to direct attention, talk about what he was doing, greet someone or say goodbye, protest or complain, and answer when talked to” and that he needed prompting “to ask questions, talk about recent experiences, maintain conversation, use language to control others’ behavior as well as stay on topic.”

From their assessment, Ms. Garrison and Ms. Sternberg concluded that STUDENT required special education due to his autism. They provided no specific recommendations to the IEP team regarding placement or related services.

STUDENT’s occupational therapy needs were assessed and reported separately on April 19, 2004, by District occupational therapist Gwyneth Chua, who observed STUDENT, reviewed Ms. Garrison’s assessment data, conducted a telephone interview with the parents, and solicited teacher input. Ms. Chua concluded that STUDENT’s visual motor skills were above age-level expectations and that his motor skills were within the average range. From her assessment, Ms. Chua determined that STUDENT’s relative strengths were in age-appropriate pre-writing skills, ability to print his first name, knowledge of letters and numbers, and compliance with directions. His relative weaknesses were identified as difficulty in manipulating scissors, and distractibility and short attention span affecting participation in circle and/or big group activities. Ms. Chua determined that STUDENT required collaborative occupational therapy services to provide classroom support to assist classroom staff.

Following his assessment, STUDENT’s initial IEP team meeting was conducted in two parts. On April 20, 2004, the initial IEP meeting convened and was attended by STUDENT’s parents, their attorneys Paul Roberts and Ellen Bacon, the District’s assessors, Ms. Boessler, kindergarten teacher Ms. Allard, Autism Specialist/IBI supervisor Beryl Adams, RSP teacher Michelle Degn, and Chaparral’s principal/administrative designee Dr. Rafferty. The parents were provided copies of the District’s assessments for the first time as well as a copy of their procedural rights. Their attorney, Mr. Roberts, waived a review of their rights. After discussing assessments in the two hours scheduled for this meeting, the District asked to schedule a second IEP meeting to complete the IEP.

On April 22, 2004, the IEP team reconvened with the same participants, and autism program specialist Jennifer Fant. The District provided the parents with a copy of their procedural rights and Mr. Roberts again waived a reading/review of the rights. The IEP team determined that STUDENT was eligible for special education and related services based upon his autism spectrum disorder. After reviewing and disagreeing with District assessments, the parents requested that the District fund independent educational evaluations (IEE) in occupational therapy, sensory integration, and in all areas for a psychoeducational assessment except cognition. The District team members advised the parents that they would consider the request for IEEs and would “follow up with a response.” Draft goals and objectives were discussed and modified. STUDENT was offered thirteen goals in the areas of attention, fine motor, attention/behavior, social skills, expressive and receptive communication, categories, and pragmatics. Although the parents believed STUDENT needed writing and sensory integration goals, District team members disagreed. The parents disputed that the goals offered addressed sensory integration, and that there was sufficiently accurate baseline data to ensure that the goals were measurable.

The IEP team made an offer of placement and services for STUDENT for the annual period that encompassed the end of the 2003-2004 school year, the 2004 ESY, and the 2004-2005 school year through April 2005. Specifically, for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year, as well as for the 2004 ESY, STUDENT was offered placement in a regular education preschool for three and a half hours a day, to be provided at Chaparral through the end of the 2003-2004 school year and at Crown Valley Elementary School for the ESY. In addition, the District offered STUDENT occupational therapy consultation services twice a month for twenty-minute sessions each, direct speech and language services once a week for thirty minutes in class or pull out, “IBI” services for three days a week forty-five minutes each in the classroom to support large-group social activities, two hours a month of “IBI supervision/progress meeting,” and eight one-hour in-home parent training and skills generalization sessions to be completed by April 24, 2005. The IEP document also indicated that the IEP team would “re-address [STUDENT’s] need for IBI maintenance by July 9, 2004, once data collection and skill acquisition has been measured.”

For the 2004-2005 school year, the IEP team offered STUDENT placement in the regular education kindergarten at Chaparral for three hours fifteen minutes a day , five days a week, with ongoing occupational therapy consultation twice a month for twenty minutes each. Speech and language services offered were increased to two thirty-minute sessions a week, one individual and one group. STUDENT was also offered resource specialist program (RSP) services once a week for thirty minutes in a consultation model “to consult with classroom staff to monitor academics and modify curriculum as needed.” “IBI” services were offered for one hour a day in class “to support classroom socialization and large group activities.” In addition, for the first month of school, STUDENT was offered a daily one-to-one IBI tutorial of thirty minutes outside the classroom “for pre-teaching and skill practice.” The IEP indicated that IBI progress would be reviewed by September 25, 2004, and that the IEP team would meet by January 20, 2005, to review STUDENT’s OT goals and for a program review.

At the conclusion of the IEP meeting, STUDENT’s parents signed a “consent/dissent” page prepared by their attorney in which they asserted that the District had not offered STUDENT a FAPE, and indicated that they would provide him with supplemental educational services and seek reimbursement from the District. Nonetheless, the parents consented to STUDENT’s ongoing placement at Chaparral and to those goals which they had initialed at the IEP meeting. The parents disagreed with the District’s assessments and advised the District of their intention to seek IEEs at its expense in occupational therapy, speech and language, and psychoeducational, including social-emotional and behavior.

On May 21, 2004, autism program specialist Jennifer Fant wrote to the PARENTS in response to their request for IEEs and advised them that, while the District believed it had appropriately assessed STUDENT, it agreed to fund IEEs in the areas of psychoeducational, speech and language, and occupational therapy/sensory integration “to be conducted by one of the providers listed in each area....” The names and telephone numbers of three individuals/organizations was listed under each of these three categories. Ms. Fant also reiterated the District’s offer for STUDENT, specified that the IBI supervision of two hours a month was also offered for the 2004-2005 school year, and reiterated that STUDENT’s placement/services would be reviewed by September 25, 2004. On May 24, 2004, Petitioner’s attorney Ms. Bacon wrote to Ms. Fant to advise her that, due to the delay in the District’s response to the IEEs requested at the IEP team meeting, the parents had begun IEEs with Dr. Mitchell Perlman (psychoeducational), Anahita Parsi-Renner (behavior), and Nancy Lin (occupational therapy) and that the parents were not obligated to obtain an IEE from the list of assessors provided by the District.

From late April 2004 and through June 2, 2004, STUDENT was privately assessed by Anahita P. Renner, clinical director of Autism Interventions & Resources (AIR), to determine whether an applied behavior analysis (ABA) program would be appropriate. Ms. Renner observed STUDENT at home, at a community park, and at Chaparral preschool. She also interviewed the parents, reviewed psychological records, and administered the Assessment for Basic Language and Learning Skills (ABLLS) and the Brigance Diagnostic Inventory of Early Development. From her assessment, Ms. Renner recommended that STUDENT receive thirty hours a week of one-to-one ABA therapy to be provided and supervised by AIR in the home, school, and community to meet his needs in communication, socialization, motor, adaptive living, and behavioral skills, and that STUDENT be placed in a regular kindergarten with a one-to-one ABA shadow aide from AIR.

In May 2004, clinical forensic psychologist Dr. Mitchell Perlman conducted an independent psycho-diagnostic assessment of STUDENT that included observations of him both at home and at his Chaparral preschool. After reviewing existing assessments, Dr. Perlman administered standardized assessment instruments and behavior scales to understand STUDENT’s cognitive potential and processing strengths and weaknesses. From his assessment, Dr. Perlman concluded that STUDENT’s strengths include a near-gifted intellect or capacity to learn, as demonstrated in his successive and simultaneous processing, abstract reasoning, and expressive vocabulary for single words. STUDENT had at least above-average skills in immediate memory for auditory stimuli and phonemic awareness, and average skills in receptive vocabulary. Dr. Perlman also determined that STUDENT’s math readiness skills were above average and that his reading readiness was superior.

Dr. Perlman concluded that STUDENT’s deficits were in attention, fine-sensorimotor processing (manual dexterity, planning/coordination) and processing speed, likely caused by inattention. Dr. Perlman concluded that STUDENT’s greatest areas of educational need were in: (1) learning to interact cooperatively with environment by having a clear consistent behavior management system to provide appropriate reinforcement; (2) improving all areas of attention except alertness (i.e., in selective focus, filtering, and maintenance); (3) developing language and communication in a small-group speech and language therapy format with no more than two peers to learn social skill and communication; and (4) improving fine sensorimotor skills that required direct regular occupational therapy with consultative services to parents and teachers. Of these areas of need, Dr. Perlman concluded that attention, not language, was “the single most pertinent factor that contributes to his inability to benefit from his education.”

Dr. Perlman recommended that STUDENT participate in an intensive year-round ABA program for a minimum of twenty-five hours a week in home with supervision. He further recommended that this placement continue until STUDENT could understand and cooperate with expectations, substantially improve his attention to tasks upon demand, and be able to be more socially interactive. He then recommended that some of the home hours be shifted to participation in a regular education classroom, with a “trained and experienced shadow-aide (trained, coordinated, and supervised by the Home Program)....”

On May 27, 2004, STUDENT was independently assessed by Nancy Lin, an occupational therapist with Pediatric Therapy Solutions, to establish his current level of fine and sensory motor functioning. For her assessment, Ms. Lin reviewed records, observed STUDENT, interviewed the parents, and administered the newly standardized, fifth edition of the Developmental Test of Visual Motor Integration (VMI-5), the Peabody Developmental Motor Skills - 2nd (Peabody-2), and the Evaluation of Sensory Processing (ESP). On the fine motor skills subtest of the Peabody-2, STUDENT scored at the 16th percentile in both grasping and visual-motor. These scores were in the below average range, with an age equivalent (AE) of 46 and 50 months respectively compared to STUDENT’s chronological age of 63 months. STUDENT’s overall fine motor performance was at the 12th percentile, in the below average range. On the VMI-5, STUDENT scored at the 13th percentile, with an age equivalent of 51 months and SS of 83, significantly lower than the score he received on the District’s administration of the older, VMI- 4th edition. Ms. Lin also assessed STUDENT’s sensory processing to determine the way in which he registered and perceived information through various sensory channels. From her assessment, Ms. Lin concluded that STUDENT had difficulties in fine motor, sensory processing, visual-motor, self-care, and praxis, and she recommended that he receive direct occupational therapy services two hours a week to develop these skills and to function in academic, community and home setting, plus consultative services. Following this assessment, STUDENT began receiving one hour a week of occupational therapy from Cheri Francis, through Pediatric Therapy Solutions.

Because the parents had not consented to the placement, services, or some of the goals offered at the April 2004 IEP, STUDENT did not participate in extended school year services outlined in his IEP. He did, however, participate in a one-week District program called “Jump Start.” At the end of the extended school year, on July 9, 2004, an IEP team meeting convened to consider providing STUDENT with IBI services during the time after the conclusion of the ESY and before the start of the 2004-2005 school year. Because STUDENT was not receiving IBI services due to lack of consent, the parents declined to attend this IEP meeting. The District members of the IEP team acknowledged that STUDENT’s present levels of performance were unknown because he had not yet begun receiving IBI services; however, they offered him “IBI Maintenance” services of three one-hour one-to-one sessions a week for the period from July 26, 2004, through August 6, 2004, at Crown Valley IBI Clinic with parent transport.

On August 17, 2004, Petitioner’s attorney Ms. Bacon wrote to Ms. Fant to request that the District provide STUDENT with a one-to-one shadow aide trained in applied behavior analysis (ABA) for his full school day in kindergarten for the 2004-2005 school year. Ms. Bacon wrote that, “in the alternative,PARENTS request the District allow a shadow aide from an NPA [nonpublic agency] to accompany STUDENT to school.” The District was advised that, if this request was refused, the parents would enroll STUDENT in a private placement, with a one-to-one shadow aide from an NPA, and would seek reimbursement from the District for placement, services, and any related costs.

On August 23, 2004, Ms. Fant wrote to the PARENTS and denied their request for the District to provide STUDENT with a full-time shadow aide to provide classroom support, based upon the District’s position that his “needs do not support this excessive amount of support at this time.” Ms. Fant did not respond to the parents’ request to allow STUDENT’s aide to accompany him to his kindergarten class at Chaparral. To accommodate the parents’ concerns, the District offered to provide STUDENT with “an additional 30 minutes daily of IBI (ABA-trained personnel) support” in class during his initial transition, with a review of support at the meeting previously discussed to occur on or before September 25, 2004.

On September 8, 2004, a speech and language progress report was prepared by Leora Shaffer, the SPA speech pathologist who had provided one hour a week of individual speech therapy to STUDENT since March 23, 2004, and who had only recently begun providing him with two hours of individual therapy a week. Ms. Shaffer reported on the assessments she had administered to STUDENT over the course of therapy. From her assessment, Ms. Shaffer concluded that STUDENT had an ongoing expressive and receptive language disorder, significantly impaired meta-linguistic and pragmatic language skills, and a severe oral-motor planning disorder. Ms. Shaffer recommended that STUDENT “continue” receiving three sixty-minute individual speech and language sessions a week. In addition, she recommended that STUDENT be enrolled in a small group of no more than two to three peers once a week for an hour to practice skills with facilitation.

On approximately September 13, 2004, STUDENT was enrolled in Country Village Preschool, a private school, by his parents, which he attended with his one-to-one aide from AIR.

On September 23, 2004, an IEP team meeting convened to review STUDENT’s IEP. Only District team members were in attendance. In its meeting notes, the District members of the IEP team indicated that the parents were sent a letter by certified mail offering three IEP meeting dates, that there was no response, and that the District then proceeded without them on the last date as indicated in the letter. The District IEP team made the same offer of placement and services to STUDENT for the 2004-2005 school year through April 2005 as that contained in the April 2004 combined IEP, except that the additional thirty minutes of one-to-one IBI tutorial for a one month transitional period was not included. The IEP notes indicated that a copy of this IEP would be sent to the parents.

On October 18, 2004, STUDENT was enrolled in his current private school, at Kindercare, which he attends with his AIR one-to-one aide.

On January 14, 2005, the Hearing Office received Student’s request for a due process hearing.

On February 16, and 17, 2005, in preparation for the upcoming annual IEP review, Ms. Fant wrote to STUDENT’s parents about the annual review and enclosed copies of the District’s assessment plan for their review and signature. Ms. Fant clarified that the District was seeking their written consent to assess STUDENT for the upcoming annual review, and that observation of STUDENT in his ABA program at home and at school would be part of the assessment.

On March 8, 2005, the Hearing Office received the District’s request for a due process hearing on the issue of whether it was entitled to assess STUDENT pursuant to its February 16, 2005 assessment plan. The District asserted that assessment was warranted because STUDENT had not attended a District classroom since June 9, 2004, and his annual IEP was due on or before April 20, 2005. The District asked to consolidate its case with the Student’s case.

On March 9, 2005, during a prehearing conference, the District’s request to consolidate its case, SN05-00577, with that of Petitioner, SN05-00098, was granted.

On March 17, 2005, the consolidated due process hearing commenced.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE 1: Did the District fail to identify and refer STUDENT for an assessment pursuant to its child find obligation in the fall of the 2003-2004 school year?

The federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), as amended in 1997, (Footnote 2) and State law impose upon each school district the duty to actively and systematically identify, locate, and assess all children with disabilities, including children with disabilities who are not enrolled in a public school program, who require special education and related services. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(3); 34 C.F.R. § 300.125; Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56300 and 56301. The obligation set forth in this statutory scheme is often referred to as the “child-find” or “seek and serve” obligation. Under State law, the school district must establish written policies and procedures for a continuous child-find system. Cal. Educ. Code § 56301. The policies and procedures must include written notifications to all parents of their rights and the procedure for initiating a referral for assessment. Id. Identification procedures shall include “systematic methods of utilizing referrals of students from teachers, parents, agencies, appropriate professional persons, and members of the public,” and shall be coordinated with school site procedures for referral of pupils with needs that cannot be met with modification of the regular education program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56302. Further, under State law, a child may be referred for special education only after the resources of the regular education program have been considered and, where appropriate, utilized. Cal. Educ. Code § 56303.

A referral for assessment means any written request for assessment made by a parent, teacher, or other service provider. Cal. Educ. Code § 56029. All referrals for special education and related services shall initiate the assessment process and must be documented. Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3021(a). “When a verbal referral is made, staff of the school district, special education local plan area, or county office shall offer assistance to the individual in making a request in writing and shall assist the individual if ...request[ed]...” Id. “All school staff referrals shall be written...” Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3021(b). In addition, upon initial referral for assessment, parents shall be given a copy of their rights and procedural safeguards. Cal. Educ. Code § 56301.

Petitioner asserts that the District violated its child find obligation by failing to refer him for a special education assessment in September or October 2003, after his August 2003 enrollment in the District’s preschool at Chaparral Elementary School. Specifically, Petitioner asserts that the District should have suspected that he had a disability of autism or pervasive developmental disorder based upon his behaviors in the classroom of his general education teacher, Claudia Boessler, as well as upon the frequent discussions about him between Ms. Boessler and his mother. The District asserts that STUDENT’s parents were timely referred to its school psychologist for an assessment by Ms. Boessler when she gave MOTHER the name and telephone number of District school psychologist Sandra Garrison in approximately October 2003. Further, the District contends that Ms. Boessler appropriately interpreted MOTHER’s statement that she was pursuing a private assessment to mean that MOTHER wanted Ms. Boessler to take no further steps regarding an assessment.

The District’s child find duty is not dependent on any request by the parent for special education testing or referral for services. Rather, the duty arises with the District’s knowledge of facts tending to establish a suspected disability and a need for IDEA special education services. Thus, the Hearing Officer must examine the circumstances regarding STUDENT’s participation and performance in preschool beginning in August 2003, to determine whether his performance should have prompted the District to assess him for special education in the fall of 2003. The evidence regarding this issue was provided by the testimony of MOTHER and Ms. Boessler, both of whom testified that they had frequent conversations about STUDENT’s behavior in the preschool classroom.

MOTHER testified that she first became concerned about STUDENT’s development when he was two and a half to three years old, due to the marked difference in his behavior from that of same age peers. For example, STUDENT did not interact with other children, could not imitate their behavior, did not explore the environment like his younger brother, was fine when left by himself,and exhibited blank stares. This behavior had not changed when, at four and a half years of age, his parents enrolled him in preschool at Chaparral to improve his socialization skills. MOTHER did not tell STUDENT’s preschool teacher, Ms. Hunt, about her concerns in August 2003 because she wanted an objective opinion about his development. One month later, when Ms. Boessler became STUDENT’s teacher, however, MOTHER told Ms. Boessler “right away” that she felt he had comprehension problems, because of his performance in Ms. Hunt’s class.

MOTHER testified that STUDENT did not interact with other students during an initial forty-five-minute free play time at the beginning of the day in Ms. Boessler’s preschool class. As a consequence, MOTHER began to stay in class to teach him how to interact with other children. She eventually remained in class for “circle time” and sometimes for “center time” because STUDENT could not focus and would not participate in the center activities without assistance. MOTHER spent up to ten hours a week in STUDENT’s classroom, where she observed additional concerning behavior by STUDENT in class. He seemed not to know why he was at circle time and would not notice the teacher talking unless MOTHER specifically pointed this out to him; he consistently had to be told and redirected to go from one center activity to another; he engaged in solo activities; he did not generally use words except for simple requests; he responded inappropriately to questions and appeared not to understand; he had no finger strength and wrote very lightly; and he was happy and tried to please until asked to do a difficult task, at which time he would “shut down” and engage in avoidance behavior like falling off the chair and pretending to be asleep.

MOTHER testified that, after STUDENT enrolled in preschool, a friend suggested that she investigate a website relating to autism and pervasive developmental disabilities. She was also given the name of Dr. Filipek, a neurologist with “For OC Kids” at University Children’s Hospital at the University of California’s Irvine Medical Center. After determining that STUDENT demonstrated many of the symptoms of autism indicated on this website, MOTHER made appointments to see STUDENT’s pediatrician and Dr. Filipek. During her daily conversations with Ms. Boessler, MOTHER told Ms. Boessler that she was concerned that STUDENT may have autism and told her about the appointments she had made for him with a speech and language specialist and with Dr. Filipek. According to MOTHER, Ms. Boessler told her that she was just a teacher and did not have any credentials to diagnose a student with autism.

In contrast, Claudia Boessler testified that in many ways, STUDENT’s behavior and deficits in her classroom appeared to be similar to those of any preschool child who was first entering school. Ms. Boessler’s opinion was reflected in her generally positive preschool report card (“Desired Results Developmental Profile”) for STUDENT that she completed in October 2003. Ms. Boessler also testified that STUDENT was a quiet student who never exhibited behavior problems and that he responded to redirection. Ms. Boessler testified that some of the preschool students in her class had already established friendships, so it was difficult for STUDENT, as it would be for any student, to make friends. Nonetheless, from her observations and her conversations with MOTHER in the fall of 2003, Ms. Boessler testified that she suspected STUDENT had a disability “to a degree.”

The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Boessler’s generally positive ratings of STUDENT’s abilities on the Desired Results Developmental Profile does not contradict her testimony that she suspected STUDENT had a disability. Rather, Ms. Boessler’s own testimony established that she had a credential to teach preschool, but had no training in special education, psychology, speech pathology, or occupational therapy. In addition, Ms. Boessler’s testimony that she suspected STUDENT had a disability is persuasive and was reinforced by that of clinical psychologist Dr. Perlman, who testified that he is frequently hired by school districts to conduct mediated assessments when there is a dispute with parents, and that in this context, he has conducted investigations and rendered opinions regarding the child find obligation. Dr. Perlman testified that, in his opinion, based upon the facts of this case, including STUDENT’s isolating behavior and language, one month in Ms. Boessler’s classroom was a sufficient time for her to develop a suspicion that STUDENT had a disability. Dr. Perlman testified that, from this suspicion, Ms. Boessler should have made a referral for an assessment of STUDENT, in approximately late October 2003. The Hearing Officer gives great weight to Dr. Perlman’s testimony in light of his considerable expertise and experience in assessing students with autism, his detailed review of STUDENT’s educational records, assessment and observation of STUDENT for his independent assessment in 2004, and his previous experience in analyzing facts underlying child find claims to determine whether a district has met its child find obligation.

From the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the weight of the evidence, including the testimony of MOTHER, Dr. Perlman, and Ms. Boessler, establishes that, by late October 2003, it was reasonable for Ms. Boessler to have suspected that STUDENT had a disability that required more resources than were available to him in the regular education setting. The Hearing Officer further finds that the District should have initiated a written referral for his assessment by late October 2003. The Hearing Officer next examines the evidence regarding whether the actions the District took in light of Ms. Boessler’s knowledge were sufficient to satisfy its child find obligation.

Ms. Boessler’s testimony was the only evidence provided by the District regarding how it met its child find obligation. (Footnote 3) Ms. Boessler testified that if she suspected a student had a disability, she understood that her concern should be referred to the school’s site administrator. Ms. Boessler followed this procedure after MOTHER asked her for a formal assessment of STUDENT in late October 2003, due to her concern about potential autism. Ms. Boessler advised MOTHER that she could not assess STUDENT herself but she informed Lupe Martinez, the director of early childhood education, about STUDENT and about MOTHER’s concern. Ms. Martinez told Ms. Boessler to give MOTHER the telephone number of the District’s school psychologist and to have the psychologist conduct an assessment. Ms. Boessler testified that she then provided MOTHER with the phone number for the school psychologist, Sandy Garrison. Ms. Boessler was not advised by Ms. Martinez to provide the school psychologist with MOTHER’s name and telephone number to ensure follow-up action by the District. It was Ms. Boessler’s understanding that the parent was responsible to call the school psychologist to arrange for the assessment. Sometime after this episode, when Ms. Boessler asked MOTHER if she had contacted Ms. Garrison, MOTHER told her that she wanted STUDENT privately assessed because she did not want him “labeled.” Later, MOTHER advised her that she had not been able to get an appointment for the private assessment in November or December 2003, but that the assessment would take place after the Christmas holiday. Ms. Boessler testified that, from this conversation, she understood that MOTHER was voluntarily choosing not to contact the District for an assessment but to pursue a private assessment. Ms. Boessler testified that she did not place an assessment request in writing, did not provide MOTHER with any procedural rights for special education assessment, and had no personal knowledge of those rights to explain to the parent. (Footnote 4)

While MOTHER did not dispute that Ms. Boessler gave her a telephone number to contact in response to her concerns in October 2003, her testimony regarding the details of this exchange differed. MOTHER denied that Ms. Boessler ever gave her any contact information that she identified as that of District school psychologist Sandy Garrison. MOTHER testified that after she told Ms. Boessler about her appointment with Dr. Filipek, Ms. Boessler “gave me a number to use if I wanted to at this point [but] I had no idea school had anything to do with STUDENT’s health -- this is the reason I went to a neurologist.” MOTHER did not know whose telephone number Ms. Boessler gave her or if Ms. Boessler said it was for an assessment, and she did not understand the purpose of the telephone number. In her view, the phone number given to her was similar to information shared between friends. MOTHER also testified that she had no recollection of a conversation with Ms. Boessler in which she allegedly declined assistance from the District in assessing STUDENT because she wanted him privately assessed to avoid labeling him as disabled. MOTHER testified that Ms. Boessler did not give her a notice of procedural rights relating to special education and that she first heard the word IEP and learned of the assessment and IEP process from Dr. Filipek in late January 2004.

Despite the differences in the testimony of these witnesses, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to take appropriate action to meet its child find obligation in late October 2003 after Ms. Boessler became aware of STUDENT’s suspected disability. Specifically, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to make a written referral for an assessment of STUDENT after Ms. Boessler became aware of STUDENT’s suspected disability and that its child find procedures failed to document a referral in writing. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56029, 56301. The Hearing Officer finds that a further consequence of the District’s failure to make a written request for assessment was that it failed to provide the parents with a copy of their rights and procedural safeguards. Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3021(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56301. The Hearing Officer finds no merit to the District’s argument that Ms. Boessler acted appropriately by not making a formal referral for assessment after she herself suspected that STUDENT had a disability, based upon a belief that the PARENTS had “voluntary withdrawn” from District assessment to pursue a private assessment. This argument ignores the fact that the duty to child find rests squarely on the school district, not the parent. As a consequence of this failure, STUDENT’s disability was not assessed until after the parent’s formal request to initiate the IEP process in February 23, 2004. The evidence persuasively established, and Petitioner does not contest, that the District acted in a prompt and timely manner to assess STUDENT after it received the parents’ written referral for assessment.

However, the evidence is clear that the District should have referred STUDENT for an assessment by no later than the end of October 2003. If the District had referred STUDENT for an assessment at the end of October 2003, it would have been obligated to develop a written assessment plan within fifteen calendar days of the referral and the parents would have had fifteen calendar days to decide whether or not to consent to the assessment. Cal. Educ. Code § 56043(a), (b). The District would then have been obliged to convene an IEP team meeting to discuss its assessments and to determine whether STUDENT was eligible for special education within fifty calendar day from its receipt of the parents’ written consent for assessment, not counting the days between regular school sessions and school vacations in excess of five school days. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56043, 56344. (Footnote 5) In this case, following their February 23, 2004 request for assessment and the District’s prompt response, STUDENT’s parents immediately signed the assessment plan on the day it was developed, March 3, 2004, or eight days from the date of initial referral for assessment. In addition, there was a winter school break from approximately the end of the third week of December 2003 and the beginning of the first full week of January 2004, a period of approximately sixteen calendar days. From the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District should have convened an initial IEP team meeting to determine STUDENT’s eligibility by no later than the middle of January 2004. Instead, STUDENT’s initial IEP team meeting was convened on April 20, 2004, and concluded on April 22, 2004. As discussed below, if the referral had been made in a timely fashion, there is sufficient evidence that the IEP team would have determined that STUDENT was eligible for special education on the basis of his autism. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District denied STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from the middle of January 2004, through April 22, 2004, a period of approximately three months. (Footnote 6)

ISSUE 2: Did the District appropriately assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability consented to by the parents during the 2003-2004 school year and 2004 ESY? Under the IDEA and state law, before providing special education and related services, a local educational agency must conduct a full and individual initial assessment of a student with a suspected disability to determine his eligibility for special education and his educational needs. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(1)(A), Cal. Educ. Code § 56320. Parental consent must be obtained before the assessment is conducted. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(1)(C), Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(c). The child must be assessed “in all areas related to the suspected disability, including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, including low vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional needs.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f), 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(3)(C).

The assessments must be conducted by “qualified” persons in conformity with the requirements of California Education Code section 56320 as follows: testing and assessment materials and procedures used for assessment and placement of individuals with exceptional needs must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory (§ 56320, subdiv. (a)); tests and assessment materials must (1) be provided and administered in the student’s native language or other mode of communication; (2) be validated for the purpose for which they are used; (3) be administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions (§ 56320, subdiv. (b)); include those tests and assessment materials that are tailored to assess specific areas of educational need and not merely those designed to provide a single general intelligence quotient (§ 56320, subdiv. (c)); and be selected and administered to best ensure that, when administered to a pupil with impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills, the test produces results that accurately reflect the student’s aptitude, achievement level, or any other factors the test purports to measure and not the student’s impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills unless those skills are the factors the test purports to measure (§ 56320, subdiv. (d)). In addition, no single procedure may be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for an individual with exceptional needs. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320 (e). The assessment shall be conducted by persons competent to perform them. Cal. Educ. Code § 56322. Any psychological assessment of a student must be conducted by a credentialed school psychologist who is trained and prepared to assess cultural and ethnic factors appropriate to the pupil being assessed. Cal. Educ. Code § 56324 (a).

Petitioner asserts that the District’s multidisciplinary assessment conducted for his initial IEP was defective in several ways. First, Petitioner asserts that the District’s multidisciplinary psychoeducational, speech and language, and occupational therapy assessments were not appropriate because none of the assessors had appropriate qualifications. Second, Petitioner asserts that the District conducted the social-emotional and occupational therapy assessment using inappropriate assessment materials. Third, Petitioner asserts that the District failed to assess him in all areas of suspected disability because it did not assess his oral-motor planning skills, did not conduct a sensory motor assessment that his parents had consented to on the assessment plan, and either did not assess him or inadequately assessed his behavior. Petitioner asserts that he was appropriately assessed in these areas by Nancy Lin in her May 2004 occupational therapy assessment and by Ms. Renner in her June 2004 intake assessment. Fourth, because a health assessment was not indicated on the assessment plan to which his parents consented, Petitioner asserts that the District conducted a health assessment by its school nurse without parental consent.

The District contends that it conducted full and appropriate assessments of STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability by qualified personnel. In addition, despite the appropriateness of its assessments, the District asserts that it agreed to fund and did fund an independent psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT by Dr. Perlman.

A. Qualifications of the District’s Assessors

Petitioner challenged the qualifications of the three District employees who conducted his multidisciplinary assessment – school psychologist Sandra Garrison, speech pathologist Joan Sternberg, and occupational therapist Gwyneth Chua. Petitioner provided no evidence, however, to support a finding that the District used unqualified personnel to conduct STUDENT’s assessments. Rather, the evidence supports a finding that the test instruments utilized for his assessment were administered by trained and qualified personnel. Specifically, it was undisputed that Ms. Garrison is a credentialed school psychologist and that any tests of intellectual or emotional functioning administered to STUDENT for the initial assessment were in fact administered to him by Ms. Garrison in her capacity as school psychologist, as required by California Education Code section 56320(b)(3). Ms. Sternberg testified that she had been a licensed speech pathologist since 1979, or more than twenty-five years. Further, Ms. Chua testified that at the time she assessed STUDENT, she had been a licensed occupational therapist for one and a half years. While Petitioner clearly disagrees with the type and level of DIS services recommended for STUDENT by the IEP team based upon the assessments of Ms. Sternberg and Ms. Chua, this is not a basis for finding the District’s assessors to be unqualified. Rather, the uncontradicted evidence established that the District’s assessors were each appropriately trained, certified and/or licensed, respectively, in speech pathology and occupational therapy, and were therefore qualified to conduct assessments within their area of specialization. See: Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, 3001(y). (Footnote 7) From the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s assessors were qualified to assess STUDENT.

B. Use of Appropriate Assessment Materials

Petitioner asserts that the District failed to use assessment materials that were validly administered and tailored to assess a student’s specific areas of educational need, as required by California Education Code section 56320. Specifically, Petitioner asserts that school psychologist Sandy Garrison used the outdated Fourth Edition of the Visual Motor Integration (VMI) test instrument, rather than the newer VMI - Fifth Edition, to assess STUDENT’s visual-motor integration skills and that the newer version clearly demonstrated his deficits in fine motor skills. Petitioner further argues that Ms. Chua then relied on this outdated VMI as well as on the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales - Interview Edition (Vineland) administered by Ms. Garrison to assess his fine and gross motor skills for her OT assessment.

The Hearing Officer notes that because the District funded Dr. Perlman’s independent psychoeducational assessment, the appropriateness of its psychoeducational assessment is not directly at issue. (Footnote 8) Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b). However, because Ms. Chua did not conduct any independent standardized assessments for her occupational therapy assessment but instead relied on Ms. Garrison’s VMI-4 and Vineland test results, the appropriateness of the use and administration of these two assessment instruments is at issue.

Regarding the VMI, independent occupational therapist Nancy Lin testified that it was not appropriate for the District to use the outdated VMI-4. The testimony of both Ms. Chua and Dr. Perlman, however, persuasively established that the use of an earlier version of a standardized assessment is permissible within twelve months of its replacement by a newly standardized version and that the District acted appropriately in using the VMI-4 on STUDENT. In this case, there was no dispute that Ms. Garrison administered the VMI-4 to STUDENT after the test manufacturers had replaced it with the VMI-5, but did so less than twelve months after the VMI-5 had been issued. All District personnel familiar with this issue (Ms. Chua, Ms. Garrison) as well as Dr. Perlman testified that the use of the VMI-4 was not prohibited by the manufacturer’s instructions. The Hearing Officer finds that while the differences in test results between the VMI-4 and the VMI-5 may be relevant to the weight to be given to the respective test results, the use of the VMI-4 by the District was appropriate.

Regarding the Vineland, MOTHER testified that many of the answers Ms. Garrison recorded on her protocol were incorrect. Dr. Perlman testified that administration of the Interview Edition of the Vineland requires much more practice than the regular Vineland, because the examiner completes the answers from his or her notes taken during a discussion with the parents, rather than in a question - answer format. Ms. Garrison persuasively testified, however, that she has been a school psychologist since 1986, that she has used the Vineland Interview Edition in virtually every assessment, that she is competent to administer it, and that she recorded answers based upon information provided by the parents. The Hearing Officer find that the District’s administration of the Vineland Interview Edition was appropriate.

C. Appropriate Assessment in All Areas of Suspected Disability

1. Oral-Motor Planning Skills

Petitioner asserts that the District failed to assess him in all areas of suspected disability during its initial assessment in March and April 2004, because it did not assess his oral-motor planning skills. Ms. Sternberg testified that, as part of the District’s initial multidisciplinary assessment, she informally assessed STUDENT’s oral-motor structures to determine their sufficiency to produce speech and found them to be within normal limits. She also testified that she did not assess STUDENT’s oral-motor planning skills.

The evidence persuasively established that STUDENT had (and continues to have) oral-motor planning needs that affected his speech and that could therefore have affected the level of speech services he required. Specifically, MOTHER testified that STUDENT made up words when he spoke or was unintelligible. Her testimony was corroborated by Providence’s January 2004 assessment of STUDENT’s expressive speech, when Ms. Molitor reported her observation that STUDENT used unintelligible language or made up words when he did not know an answer or when asked to repeat a sentence of eight words or more. Ms. Shaffer also testified that STUDENT used jargon and that his longer utterances (connected speech) broke down and were difficult to understand. In September 2004, Ms. Shaffer administered the Oral-motor Assessment Scale (Riley) and determined that STUDENT’s performance was within the severe range for oral-motor planning skills. She also testified that oral-motor planning skills can cause either dysfluencies (repetitions), jargon or both. In her September 2004 assessment report, Ms. Shaffer noted that “the existence of a severe oral-motor planning disorder means that any unintelligible utterance should not be stereotypically judged to be jargon, as both exist for STUDENT.” Pet. Ex. 24, p. 7

Nonetheless, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not fail to assess STUDENT in this area of suspected disability in April 2004 because it could not reasonably have been aware of this disability at that time. First, while the Providence assessment found that STUDENT had mildly disordered oral-motor skills, it did not identify oral-motor planning skills as a deficit for STUDENT. Second, Ms. Shaffer testified that she began providing one hour a week of direct speech therapy to STUDENT on March 23, 2004. While Ms. Shaffer testified that the District did not properly assess STUDENT’s oral-motor planning needs, she also testified that it took her several months of providing direct therapy to STUDENT to identify this area of suspected disability. The Hearing Officer finds that the District cannot be held liable for failing to assess STUDENT in an area of disability it could not reasonably have suspected at the time of its assessment based upon a hindsight analysis. Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999). Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that, because oral-motor planning was not an area of suspected disability at the time of STUDENT’s initial assessment, the District was not required to assess him in this area.

2. Sensory Motor Assessment

Petitioner asserts that the District failed to conduct a sensory motor assessment by an occupational therapist as specifically outlined on the March 3, 2004 assessment plan to which his parents had consented. (Footnote 9)

The record establishes that when the student study team referred STUDENT for special education assessment, it specifically included “sensory motor skills” as one of his identified areas of suspected disability. District occupational therapist Gwyenth Chua testified that she was aware of this area of suspected disability and that the March 3, 2004 assessment plan specified that STUDENT’s “sensory motor” skills were to be assessed by the occupational therapist. In April 2004, Ms. Chua conducted an occupational therapy (OT) assessment of STUDENT as part of the District’s initial assessment. From the concerns reported to her by the parents in telephone interviews the day before the April 20, 2004 IEP meeting, Ms. Chua testified that she understood that STUDENT’s toe walking, his faint handwriting, weak hand muscles, enjoyment of being held tightly, and of movement could relate to sensory processing. In response to the parents’ questions at the IEP meeting, Ms. Chu indicated that she had assessed STUDENT’s sensory processing through clinical observation and interviews.

For her assessment, Ms. Chua observed STUDENT in class for forty-five to sixty minutes, during which she noted that STUDENT demonstrated tactile sensitivity when using glue and that he played by himself. Ms. Chua also reported that “no interaction with other kids was observed at any time” during her observation. In addition, during circle time, Ms. Chua “observed [STUDENT] to ‘zone out’ about 70% of the entire circle time.” These observations were similar to those of Ms. Boessler, who completed an “Educator’s Checklist” of STUDENT’s behaviors and reported that he was quiet and obedient in class, that he tended to hide in the library looking at books instead of participating, played with two children in his class and “mostly plays by himself.” Ms. Chua administered no independent standardized assessments herself, but reviewed the VMI-4 and the Vineland administered by Ms. Garrison. From STUDENT’s score of 114 at the 82nd percentile on the VMI-4, Ms. Chua determined that he performed above age-level expectations in visual-motor integration skills [CA=5.1, AE=5.10]. From the Vineland, Ms. Chua reported that STUDENT’s overall adaptive functioning was moderately low, but that his motor skills were within the adequate range, at the 25th percentile with an age equivalent of four years and six months, approximately six months below his chronological age. Ms. Chua’s report did not discuss STUDENT’s sensory motor needs.

The importance of a detailed assessment of STUDENT’s sensory motor needs was underscored by the testimony of his current private occupational therapist Cheri Francis and by IEE occupational therapist Nancy Lin. According to Ms. Lin, it was important to assess STUDENT’s sensory processing because he was a “major sensory seeker,” which indicated that he needed help to modulate his system. Ms. Francis testified that sensory issues are important to a student’s ability to self-regulate and to focus on what is relevant. She also testified that these issues can relate to a student’s arousal difficulties, such as was observed by Ms. Chua in STUDENT’s “zoning out” in class. Ms. Francis testified that low arousal can be related to sensory processing and can result in missed educational opportunities.

The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Chua failed to adequately assess STUDENT’s suspected area of disability in sensory motor as expressly identified on the assessment plan. In reaching this conclusion, the Hearing Officer relies on Ms. Chua’s occupational therapy report itself. A review of this report reveals that it included no findings and contained no analysis of STUDENT’s sensory motor needs. In fact, the report included only a single reference to STUDENT’s sensory needs. In recommending once-monthly consultation services, Ms. Chua noted that, in STUDENT’s case, the IEP team “needs the [OT] support to address the sensory-based needs that influence behavioral organization and attention....” While Ms. Chua attached a sensory diet, the Hearing Officer finds that this does not in any way substitute for an assessment, particularly given the complete lack of findings or discussion regarding any sensory issues in the report and the fact that the diet appears to be a standardized list modified only by the inclusion of STUDENT’s name.

The Hearing Officer further finds that the testimony of independent occupational therapists Nancy Lin and Cheri Francis support the conclusion that the District did not assess STUDENT’s sensory motor issues. Their testimony established that a detailed observation in multiple settings and an analysis of a student’s sensory system (i.e., tactile, proprioception, vestibular, auditory, visual, gustatory/olfactory systems) is an appropriate manner of assessment, as is the use of parent questionnaires like the Evaluation of Sensory Processing utilized by Ms. Lin. Their testimony also established that the Sensory Integration Praxis Test, or SIPT, is the best standardized assessment instrument for this area. From her review of Ms. Chua’s assessment, Ms. Lin concluded that there was insufficient time spent observing STUDENT to understand his sensory motor needs, that no standardized assessments were conducted in this area, and that no analysis was provided. In Ms. Lin’s opinion, Ms. Chua did not assess STUDENT’s sensory motor needs. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Lin’s testimony is credible and is entitled to greater weight than that of Ms. Chua. Ms. Lin testified that she has been an occupational therapist for eight years and that, prior to entering private practice, she was an occupational therapist for the District for four years. In addition, her knowledge of the occupational therapy field, including sensory motor issues, as reflected in her testimony and in her report was thorough and detailed. In contrast, at the time of her assessment, Ms. Chua had been an occupational therapist for less than two years, and her testimony provided little detailed information regarding her knowledge or assessment in this area.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT’s sensory motor needs as part of its occupational therapy assessment.

3. Behavior Assessment

It was generally undisputed that STUDENT is a happy, quiet, polite, and generally compliant young boy who does not exhibit negative behavior that causes adults to notice him. Nonetheless, the weight of the evidence established that STUDENT has behaviors arising from his autism that impedes his learning, including his ability to use his cognitive potential. For example, both Dr. Perlman and certified behavior analyst Anahita Renner testified that STUDENT has maladaptive behavior when confronted with academic tasks that make learning nearly impossible. Other witnesses, including school psychologist Sandy Garrison, reported observing STUDENT shut down or use extremely avoidant behavior when presented with challenging academic tasks or non-preferred tasks. As reported in the District’s multidisciplinary assessment, for example, STUDENT “used several means (e.g., crawling on the floor, feigning sleep with snoring, moving toys around, etc.) to avoid tasks.”

Petitioner asserts that the District either did not assess or inadequately assessed his behavior in its assessment and that his behavior was not assessed until AIR’s director, Ms. Renner, completed her intake assessment report. In response, the District asserts that it assessed STUDENT’s behavior using a variety of assessment tools during its multidisciplinary assessment. Further, the District notes that it has funded Petitioner’s IEE in this area by clinical neuropsychologist Dr. Perlman.

In its multidisciplinary assessment, Ms. Garrison used the following assessment tools and rating scales to understand STUDENT’s behavioral needs. MOTHER completed the Conners’ Parent Rating Scale -Revised, the Childhood Autism Rating Scale, and the Temperament and Atypical Behavior Scale (TABS). Ms. Boessler completed the Conner’s Teacher Rating Scale -Revised and the Teacher Social Skills Checklist (TSSC). Ms. Hunt, who was STUDENT’s teacher for one month and acted as an aide in Ms. Boessler’s classroom, also completed the TSSC. Ms. Garrison completed the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales: Interview Edition Survey Form, from her interview with the parents. Ms. Garrison also conducted a behavioral observation of STUDENT, which she recorded in detail in her assessment report. Dr. Perlman characterized her behavioral observations as “excellent.”

STUDENT was rated “severely autistic” on the Childhood Autism Rating Scale completed by the parent. On the Connors’ rating scale, which provides an attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) Index, a “global index” for restless-impulsive and emotional ability, and a score on DSM-IV criteria for inattentive and hyperactive-impulsive, STUDENT’s only significantly elevated scores were reported by Ms. Boessler in the categories of “anxious-shy” and “social problems.” Ms. Boessler also reported that STUDENT had high frequency behaviors of restlessness in the ‘squirmy’ sense and distractibility or attention span problems. MOTHER did not rate STUDENT as significantly elevated in any area. On the TABS, MOTHER reported that STUDENT seemed to look through or past people, resisted eye contact, acted as if others were not there, appeared be in his ‘own world,’ often stared into space, “tune[d] out” and lost contact with what was going on, became overly interested in toys/objects, and did not sit still or react to his own name. On the Vineland Interview Edition, Ms. Garrison reported that parental responses indicated STUDENT’s overall adaptive functioning to be “moderately low,” and with weaknesses in self-help, daily living skills, socialization, and communication.

One of Petitioner’s primary concerns was that Ms. Garrison did not complete the “maladaptive behavior domain” on the Vineland. This domain, composed of twenty-seven separate questions, elicits information about a variety of behaviors including, for example, whether a student withdraws, exhibits tics, has poor eye contact, has poor concentration and attention. Pet. Ex. 33, p. 10. Ms. Garrison testified that, in her opinion, she could obtain better information regarding STUDENT’s behavior from the assessment instruments described above than on the maladaptive domain of the Vineland. The Hearing Officer notes that, on its face, the Vineland protocol indicates that the administration of this domain is optional and is for students who are age 5.0 and older. At the time of this assessment, STUDENT had just turned five years old. As indicated on the protocol as well as in the testimony of Dr. Perlman, there was nothing inappropriate about administering the Vineland in all areas except the optional maladaptive behaviors domain. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s multidisciplinary assessment, including its behavioral assessment, was appropriate.

Furthermore, the Hearing Officer notes that the District agreed to fund and did actually fund an independent psychodiagnostic assessment by Dr. Perlman after the parents disagreed with Ms. Garrison’s report and requested an IEE in this area. For his comprehensive assessment, Dr. Perlman administered the Adaptive Behavior Assessment System - 2nd Edition (ABAS-II), the Attention-Deficit Disorders evaluation Scale - Home Version (ADDES) and the Behavior Assessment System for Children - Parent Version (BASC). In addition, he had the parents complete four separate rating scales to determine STUDENT’s probability of autism and/or Asperger’s Disorder. His report itself also comprehensively discusses issues relating to STUDENT’s behavior that impede his ability to use his cognitive potential.

From the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that while Ms. Renner’s assessment will be considered in determining the appropriateness of the District’s offered program, the District did not fail to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability by insufficiently assessing his behavior needs.

D. Health Assessment by its School Nurse Without Consent

There is also no dispute that parental consent is required prior to any assessment of a student for special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(1)(C), Educ. Code § 56321(c). (Footnote 10) It is also undisputed that the March 3, 2004 assessment plan signed by Petitioner’s parents did not indicate or authorize a health assessment. Nevertheless, on March 9, 2004 during the District’s multidisciplinary assessment, school nurse Ann Roche conducted a vision and hearing test on STUDENT in his mother’s presence. These results were reported in a “Health Summary for Preschool Initial IEP” form that was incorporated into the District’s multidisciplinary assessment report.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District conducted a health assessment for STUDENT’s initial special education assessment. The Hearing Officer also finds that because this assessment was conducted in the presence of and without any objection from MOTHER, Ms. Roche acted in the reasonable belief that the parent had consented to the assessment and there was no prejudice by the District’s action. * * *

In summary, the Hearing Officer has found that the District assessed STUDENT using qualified assessors and appropriate assessment instruments; that at the time of the initial assessment, it had no reason to suspect that STUDENT had an oral-motor planning disability that required assessment; that it assessed him in the area of suspected disability relating to behavior, and that it conducted a health assessment with his parents’ implied consent. The Hearing Officer has also found that the District did not assess STUDENT’s sensory motor area of suspected disability.

ISSUE THREE: Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year and/or 2004 extended school year (ESY) on procedural and/or substantive grounds?

Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Education Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no cost to the parents, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401 (25) (1997). The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). Education Code section 56363 (a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”

In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S.C. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirement of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. Id. at 198 - 200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instructional and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201. De minimus benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d at 130 (2nd Cir. 1998). Rather, a student’s academic progress must be viewed in light of thelimitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F. 3d 1114, 1121 (2nd Cir. 1997). The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 205.

The IDEA also provides that children be educated in the least restrictive environment or LRE. Specifically, the IDEA requires that “to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular educational environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.” 20 U.S.C. § 1412 (a)(5)(A), 34 C.F.R. § 300.550. See also Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.

The analysis of whether STUDENT has been provided a FAPE is twofold. The Hearing Officer must determine whether the procedural safeguards of the IDEA have been satisfied and whether the FAPE offered was substantively appropriate. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-207. To constitute a FAPE as required by the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s offer must meet the following substantive requirements: (1) have been designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs; (2) have been reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit; and (3) have comported with his IEP. Because there is no contention in this case that the program provided to STUDENT by the District did not comport with his IEPs, it is not necessary to address this third element. (Footnote 11)

It is well-established that the school district has the burden of proving that it has complied with the IDEA, including that it has offered an appropriate educational placement for the student, at the administrative hearing. Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist. No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994).

Procedural Appropriateness

III A. Did the District provide Petitioner’s parents with a Notice of Procedural Rights that was substantially defective to a degree that constituted a denial of FAPE per se?

Under the IDEA and State law, the responsible educational agency must provide the parents with a procedural safeguards notice that must include “a full explanation of the procedural safeguards, written in the native language of the parents, unless it clearly is not feasible to do so, and written in an easily understandable manner,” relating to the thirteen itemized topics, including independent educational evaluations (IEEs). 20 U.S.C. § 1415(d)(2), Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(a).1 (Footnote 12) The educational agency must provide parents with a copy of the procedural safeguards notice, at a minimum, upon initial referral for assessment, upon notification of each IEP meeting, upon reassessment of the student, and upon registration of a complaint. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(d)(1). In addition, California law specifies that parents must be provided with a copy of their rights and procedural safeguards “upon filing for prehearing mediation conference...or a due process hearing request....” Cal. Educ. Code § 56301.

Petitioner asserts that the District’s notice of procedural safeguards was so substantially defective in its explanation of parental rights and safeguards that it constituted a denial of FAPE per se. Petitioner further argues that as a consequence of the District’s defective notice, his parents were not able to understand or exercise their procedural rights. In support of his argument, Petitioner cites Hall v. Vance County Board of Education, 774 F. 2d 629 (4th Cir. 1985) for the proposition that the failure to provide parents with notice of their rights constitutes a denial of FAPE per se, and Carnwath v. Bd. of Education, 33 F. Supp. 2d 431 (D.C. Md. 1998), for the proposition that providing inaccurate and incomplete information about parents’ rights may also constitute a denial of FAPE. Petitioner’s primary concern is that his parents were not fully informed of their rights relating to IEEs. In support of this contention, MOTHER testified that she first received the District’s procedural safeguards, “Notice to Parents/Guardian/Surrogate” (hereafter, Notice), on March 3, 2004, with STUDENT’s assessment plan. She further testified that, after reading the Notice, she did not understand that she had a right to an IEE, and did not understand how she could obtain an IEE, how long she had to wait to obtain an IEE after requesting it from the District, or how long the District had to respond to her request for an IEE.

The District asserts that its Notice covers each of the topics required by federal and State law on its face. The District accurately points out that courts have determined that simply providing the “unembellished technical language” of the procedural rules and regulations does not comport with the requirement that it notify parents of the procedural safeguards of the Act. Max M. v. Thompson, 592 F.Supp. 1437 (1984 N. D.Ill.). The District asserts that it has satisfied the notice requirement in a manner that balances providing the amount of detailed information contained in the statutes and regulations with complying with the mandate to keep the notice accessible to the general public. As a consequence, the District asserts that Petitioner’s issue is without merit. In addition, the District contends that Petitioner has failed to make any showing that his parents were prejudiced in any way by the District’s notice of procedural safeguards and parental rights.

A review of the District’s Notice reveals it to be an eight-page document written in understandable English that addresses each of the relevant areas outlined in 1415(d), as well as in section 56321(a).1 (Footnote 13) In describing independent educational evaluations (IEEs), the District’s Notice states that the parents may have a right to an IEE at district expense if they disagree with the District’s assessment. The Notice further provides that the “school district may request a hearing before a hearing officer to dispute your request for reimbursement. The hearing officer will then decide whether reimbursement is appropriate.” Pet. Ex 45, p. 7

The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s Notice is not substantially defective to a degree that constituted a denial of FAPE per se and that Petitioner’s reliance on Hall v. Vance is seriously misplaced. In Hall, a Fourth Circuit case, the school district failed to give the parents any notice of their rights for several years after their child’s initial IEP. The court of appeal noted that both the State Hearing Review Officer and the district court found that the school had “consistently failed to inform” the parents of their rights in a manner the district court had characterized as egregious. Id. at 633. Clearly, the facts of the present case are vastly different than those before the court in Hall.

First, the record in this case established that Petitioner’s parents were provided with the District’s Notice on March 3, 2004, and Petitioner did not assert that the District subsequently failed to provide him with a copy of the Notice at any required time. Second, it is undisputed that, at both the IEP team meetings of April 20, and 22, 2004, Petitioner’s attorney waived a reading of the parents’ procedural rights on their behalf.1 (Footnote 14) Third, at this combined IEP meeting, both of Petitioner’s parents initialed the following statement: “I have been informed of and received my parental rights and procedural safeguards and I understand them.” (Resp. Ex. 27, D 00190). Fourth, Petitioner had sufficient information and understanding, either directly or through his two attorneys, to request IEEs in psychoeducational, speech and language, and occupational therapy based upon his disagreement with the District’s assessments. Fifth, approximately one month later, on May 21, 2004, autism program specialist Jennifer Fant wrote to the parents and advised them that the District agreed to fund these IEE assessments because of its admitted delay in responding to the parents’ IEE request. Sixth, in her May 21, 2004 letter, Ms. Fant also specifically advised the parents of sources and telephone numbers they could contact to obtain assistance in understanding their rights, including both herself and Chaparral’s principal/ administrative designee, Dr. Rafferty. From the above, the Hearing Officer finds that there is no factual basis and no relevant precedent to support a finding that the District denied Petitioner a FAPE per se based upon its Notice as it relates to informing parents of their right to an IEE.1 (Footnote 15)

From the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not deny Petitioner a FAPE per se due to asserted deficiencies in its notice of procedural safeguards.

III B. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide independent assessors with an equivalent opportunity to observe and assess him as required by California Education Code section 56329?

Effective January 1, 2004, California Education Code section 56329 was amended to provide both parents and school districts with an equivalent opportunity to observe students in their educational setting. For parents, the right to an equivalent opportunity to observe comes into play when the parent disagrees with an assessment by the school district and requests an independent educational assessment (IEE) at public expense as discussed in 56329 (b), or when the parent obtains an IEE at private expense following a determination that the public assessment was appropriate, as discussed in section 56329(c). Specifically, both subdivisions (b) and (c) of Education Code section 56329 provide as follows:

If a public education agency observed the pupil in conducting its assessment, or if its assessment procedures make it permissible to have in-class observation of a pupil, an equivalent opportunity shall apply to an independent educational assessment of the pupil in the pupil’s current educational placement and setting, and observation of an educational placement and setting, if any, proposed by the public education agency, regardless of whether the independent educational assessment is initiated before or after the filing of a due process hearing proceeding. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b) and (c).

It is undisputed that the District’s operational letter #1.7, entitled “procedures regarding classroom observations for independent assessors,” was intended to establish the District’s policy with respect to the “equivalent observations” authorized by this amendment to Education Code section 56329. (Dist. Ex.33; Pet. Ex. 60). The District’s operational letter was signed by Superintendent Fleming, with an effective date of January 2004.1 (Footnote 16) By its terms, in-class observation of the student who is the subject of an observation is “strictly limited” to watching that student and does not include (1) conversations with the student or with any classroom or school room personnel, or (2) inspection of any classroom documents or student work samples in the classroom. The policy further provides that, if observation of the student is determined to be an appropriate part of any assessment, the assessment plan “should indicate the location and the maximum duration of the [District] observation.” In the event of a subsequent IEE assessment, the policy provides that the IEE “will be limited to an equivalent observation in terms of time and location.” The policy requires that the observation be conducted in a manner not to disrupt or interfere with the educational program and that a site administrator or designee be present at all times during the observation.

Petitioner asserts that this District’s written policy regarding classroom observations for independent assessors is arbitrary and violates Education Code section 56329. Specifically, Petitioner asserts that this policy limited the ability of his independent assessors because it prohibited conversations with the student or any classroom or school personnel, prohibited inspection of student work samples in the classroom, and limited the time for observations.1 (Footnote 17) Petitioner notes that District assessors testified they were allowed access to STUDENT’s classroom for an unlimited amount of time for observation, were not accompanied by an administrator, and had an opportunity to both speak with STUDENT’s teachers and to look at his work samples. By contrast, Dr. Perlman was only allowed to observe STUDENT in his classroom at Chaparral for forty-five minutes, Ms. Renner was allowed to observe for only thirty minutes, and neither independent assessor was allowed to speak to the teachers during the observation or to review any of STUDENT’s work samples. In addition, Petitioner elicited testimony from the District’s assessors, Ms. Garrison, Ms. Sternberg, and Ms. Chua, that they could have observed STUDENT for longer periods and that no one in the District established a limit to their observation time.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s policy, as applied to the facts of this case, did not violate section California Education Code section 56329. Specifically, the weight of the evidence established that Petitioner’s IEE assessors were provided an opportunity to observe STUDENT in his classroom setting for amounts of time roughly equivalent to those actually used by the District’s assessors. In addition, the Hearing Officer notes that, by this issue, Petitioner in effect seeks a declaratory judgment of the illegality of the District’s observation policy. It is well-established that the Hearing Office does not have the power to issue declaratory relief. Although the California Administrative Procedure Act (APA) authorizes administrative agencies to issue declaratory relief (Cal. Gov’t. Code § 11465.20), the California Department of Education specifically opted special education due process hearings out of this provision of the APA. Cal. Code. Regs., tit. 5, § 3089.

III C. Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year and 2004 ESY on procedural and/or substantive grounds at the April 2004 individualized education program (IEP) team meetings by:

III C 1. failing to provide a legally sufficient IEP on April 20, 2004?

Petitioner argues that the April 20, 2004 document is not a legally sufficient IEP because it did not contain the information that is required to be in an IEP, including present levels of performance, measurable annual goals, specific special education instruction, and supplementary services to be provided to him, as outlined in California Education Code section 56345. As a consequence, Petitioner asserts that the District denied him a FAPE. The District asserts that, because the IEP team reconvened and completed STUDENT’s initial IEP two days later, Petitioner’s claim is patently frivolous.

A review of the April 20, 2004 IEP and the audiotape for that meeting establishes that, after the two hours scheduled for the initial IEP team meeting had passed, the District requested to schedule a second “Part II” IEP meeting to complete STUDENT’s initial IEP. The IEP noted that the meeting would reconvene on April 22, 2004, and the IEP team did in fact reconvene and provide the information required by section 56345 on that date. Petitioner cites no authority that an IEP cannot be developed over several days to ensure full discussion and completion as long as the IEP is developed within the timelines established by federal and State law. (34 C.F.R. § 300.343, Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56043, 56344). In addition, Petitioner does not assert that the result of this two-day continuance resulted in an untimely IEP or that he was in any manner prejudiced by it.1 (Footnote 18)

The Hearing Officer finds that this two-day continuance between Part I and Part II of the initial IEP did not deny Petitioner a FAPE.

III C 2. failing to make a specific clear and coherent offer of speech and language and intensive behavior intervention (IBI) services?

“The IDEA explicitly requires written prior notice to parents when an educational agency proposes, or refuses, to initiate or change the educational placement of a disabled child.” Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 513 U.S. 965, 115 S. Ct. 428 (1994); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3). Pursuant to this obligation, a school district must make a formal written offer of placement to the parents of a student with a disability. Referring to the “great importance” the Supreme Court in Rowley placed on such procedural components of the IDEA, the Union court found that “this formal requirement [of a written offer of placement] has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and ...should be enforced vigorously.” Id.

Petitioner contends that the District violated Union’s mandate of a clear coherent written offer both regarding its offer for speech and language therapy and for “IBI” therapy. Specifically, Petitioner contends that the April 22, 2004 offer of speech therapy is ambiguous because it does not specify the type and location of services but, rather, provides that he will receive one thirty-minute session of speech therapy “in class or pull out, on campus, weekly.” Petitioner’s position was supported by the uncontradicted testimony of independent speech pathologist Leora Shaffer, who testified, based upon her seven years of experience as a speech therapist for a different school district, that an offer in the alternative which does not specify the service delivery model (individual, group, consultative) is inappropriate. In Ms. Shaffer’s opinion, such an offer is both very confusing to parents and not based upon a student’s unique needs but leaves the type of service to the therapist’s discretion. As a consequence, in this case, Petitioner’s parents were not able to determine from the IEP whether STUDENT would be provided speech on an individual or a group basis, whether the therapy would be in a small group or a large group, and whether it would be provided in the classroom or on a pull-out basis.

Further, Petitioner contends that the District’s offer of IBI services also failed to comply with Union because it was insufficient to clearly relay to the parents the offer that was being conveyed. The combined April 2004 IEP offered STUDENT“IBI” services for forty-five minutes a day for each of the three days a week he attended school through the end of the 2004 extended school year, and “IBI supervision/student progress meeting two hours per month.” Petitioner asserts that this was his parents’ first IEP team meeting and that IBI was not explained to his parents except in general terms that it was behavioral intervention. This assertion was supported by the testimony of MOTHER. A review of the IEP document indicates that while the term “IBI” is not defined, the IEP notes record that “IBI described in nature and how sup [sic] in the classroom with language/social skills areas could occur...to support large group social activities.” The Hearing Officer’s review of the audiocasssette of the IEP team meeting reveals only a brief explanation to the parents of IBI services.

As described by the court in Union, there are three important purposes behind the requirement for a specific written offer. First, “the requirement of a formal, written offer creates a clear record that will do much to eliminate troublesome factual disputes many years later about when placements were offered, what placements were offered, and what additional educational assistance was offered to supplement a placement, if any.” Second, “a formal, specific offer from a school district will greatly assist parents in ‘presenting complaints with respect to any matter relating to the...educational placement of the child’...by alerting [them] to the need to consider seriously whether [the school offered] was an appropriate placement under the IDEA” and whether they should oppose it or accept it with the supplement of additional educational services. Third, “by making a formal offer, the District would have been more prepared to introduce sufficient relevant evidence to the hearing officer of the appropriateness” of the placement.

The Hearing Officer finds that, while its offers of speech therapy and IBI services were less than precise, there was no ambiguity in the amount of speech or behavior services offered by the District. It was clear from the evidence presented at hearing, including the testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Shaffer, Ms. Moore, Dr. Perlman, and Ms. Renner, that the deciding factor in determining whether to accept, reject, or further negotiate with the District about these offers was the total amount of time offered. The testimony of these witnesses that the offer was insufficient to address STUDENT’s speech and behavior needs was reiterated by Petitioner’s statement in his closing brief that his parents “would not have consented to the offers anyway,” due to their belief, that they were “insufficient to address STUDENT’s significant speech and behavior deficits.” [Pet. Closing Brief, p. 23, ftn. 14]. The Hearing Officer finds that the District provided Petitioner with enough information, on the critical issue of the amount of offered services, to determine whether to accept or reject its offers and its offers thus satisfied a key purpose behind Union. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that there was no procedural denial of FAPE on this basis.

Substantive Appropriateness

As discussed above, to meet its burden of proof, the District’s offer must have been designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and to provide him with some educational benefit.

Was the District’s April 2004 offer designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?

STUDENT’s unique needs

Before a determination can be reached regarding whether the educational program the District offered was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, the Hearing Officer must first ascertain what STUDENT’s unique needs were at the time of the April 2004 initial IEP team meetings.

It is undisputed that STUDENT is a student with a high cognitive potential. Both the WPPSI administered by the District and the CAS and NEPSY administered by Dr. Perlman clearly reveal a student who may have skills within the gifted range, if he can access his cognitive abilities. The Hearing Officer notes that, at the April 2004 combined IEP meetings, the team concluded that the nature and severity of STUDENT’s disability required special education in the areas of attention, fine motor skills, receptive and expressive language, pragmatics, categories, attention and behavior, and social skills. (Dist. Ex. 27, D190). In addition, the testimony of Ms. Chua and Ms. Lin establishes that at the time of the April 2004 IEP team meetings, in addition to his fine motor needs, STUDENT had unique needs in self-care, visual motor, praxis, and sensory processing. The parties in this case do not dispute that these are the general areas in which STUDENT has unique needs. Instead, the essential dispute is over the intensity of his needs and whether the program offered him by the District was of a sufficient intensity to meet his needs.

From the above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has unique needs in attention, fine motor, self-care, visual motor, praxis, sensory processing, receptive, expressive, and pragmatic language, categories, attention/behavior, and social skills.

Designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?

At the April 22, 2004 IEP team meeting, the District offered STUDENT placement in a regular education preschool for three and a half hours a day, at Chaparral through the end of the 2003-2004 school year and at Crown Valley Elementary School for the ESY. In addition, the District offered STUDENT two twenty-minute occupational therapy consultation sessions a month, one thirty- minute session of direct speech and language services in class or pull out, forty-five minutes of “IBI” services three days a week in the classroom to support large-group social activities, two hours a month of “IBI supervision/student progress meeting,” and eight one-hour in-home parent training and skills generalization sessions to be completed by April 24, 2005. Petitioner challenged the appropriateness of the goals, placement, and services offered as discussed below.

Prior to addressing Petitioner’s specific claims, the Hearing Officer notes that the overarching dispute between the parties was the severity of STUDENT’s autistic disorder. As previously noted, STUDENT was rated “mildly autistic” on the Childhood Autism Rating Scale (CARS) that was completed in January 2004, and “severely autistic” on the CARS that was completed by his parents for the District’s assessment in April 2004. Ms. Garrison testified that the level of severity of STUDENT’s autism would affect the form and amount of services recommended. The District suggested that the parents inflated the severity of STUDENT’s autism for its assessment, noting that a CARS completed during his January 2004 assessment with Dr. Filipek rated him in the mildly autistic range. However, no evidence was produced at the hearing regarding who actually completed the January 2004 CARS. Ms. Garrison testified that she assumed, but was not certain, that the CARS was completed by Dr. Filipek. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that there was no evidence that the January 2004 “mild autism” rating on the CARS was a finding actually made by a neurologist, rather than a score derived from the completion of the CARS by the parents. It is also noteworthy that the parents completed four rating scales in April 2004 for Dr. Perlman’s assessment to determine the likelihood that STUDENT was autistic or that he had Asperger Syndrome, and that, together, these scores indicated both that he did and did not have autism or Asperger Syndrome with varying degrees of probability. Dr. Perlman’s uncontradicted testimony established that it was not unusual to obtain discrepant scores from the same responders on these types of scales. The Hearing Officer also notes that another factor that caused confusion regarding the severity of STUDENT’s disability was his relative strength in expressive language for single sentences or vocabulary when he wanted to make statement or ask questions. However, as indicated by Dr. Perlman and MOTHER, STUDENT rarely conversed or responded to language on demand. The Hearing Officer finds that, in April 2004, STUDENT required an intense level of services based upon the severity of his attention, behavior, social and language needs, particularly in light of his relatively late autism diagnosis.

III C 3. Failing to provide measurable goals and objectives?

Under federal and State law, an IEP must contain measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short term objectives, related to both (1) meeting the child’s needs that result from the child’s disability to enable the child to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum, and (2) meeting each of the child’s other educational needs that result from the child’s disability. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(ii); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(2)(A),(B). The IEP “shall show a direct relationship between the present levels of performance, the goals and objectives, and the specific educational services to be provided.” Cal. Code Regs. tit. v, § 3040(c). In addition, the IEP must include “appropriate objective criteria, evaluation procedures, and schedules for determining, on at least an annual basis, whether the annual goals are being achieved,” and a statement of how the student’s progress toward the goals will be measured. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(7), (9).

At the combined April 2004 IEP team meetings, the District offered STUDENT thirteen goals in the areas of attention, fine motor, attention/behavior, social skills, expressive/receptive language, categories, and pragmatics. Petitioner argues that the goals the District offered were not measurable because they did not include accurate present levels of performance, and that the District failed to propose goals to address all his areas of need. The District contends that Petitioner’s parents, while in the presence of their counsel at the April 2004 IEP team meetings, expressly agreed to six of the thirteen goals presented and cannot retroactively challenge those goals because revocation of parental consent is not retroactive pursuant to Education Code section 56021(c). In addition, the District asserts that the present levels of performance for its goals were sufficiently measurable because trained professionals would be able to clarify and implement them. Finally, the District asserts that it offered goals in all areas of need identified for STUDENT at the April 2004 IEP meeting or that these areas were normally addressed in the regular classroom.

Speech and language goals

The record establishes that the following speech and language goals were drafted by Ms. Sternberg and offered to STUDENT by the District at the April 2004 IEP team meeting. First, in the area of expressive and receptive language, STUDENT’s goal was to be able to answer questions regarding hypothetical events by answering “wh” questions related to a curriculum-based story, asking and gaining information via “wh” questions to a story, and retelling a story in proper sequence using picture cues, with 80 percent accuracy. Second, in the areas of “categories,” STUDENT’s goal was to be able to produce familiar names and name combinations of words to complete categorization tasks with 80 percent accuracy (i.e., identify words that do not belong, and name five items in two familiar categories). Third, in the area of pragmatic language, STUDENT’s goal was to improve pragmatic skills by enhancing his basic skills needed to make requests, relate an experience, and ask a question about something he does not understand. Petitioner’s parents did not consent to any of these goals.

Petitioner makes two challenges to the District’s offered speech and language goals. First, Petitioner contends that the speech and language goals offered were not measurable. The District contends that the present levels of performance provided for those goals gave sufficient information for service providers to proceed in implementing the IEP, and that any lack of measurability was attributable to the fact that STUDENT is just beginning to work on these skills.

The Hearing Officer finds that the present levels of performance in the offered expressive - receptive, categories, and pragmatic speech goals were not measurable. This conclusion is based on the fact that the present levels of performance outlined for the expressive/receptive and categories goals only indicated that STUDENT had “difficulties” in these areas (i.e., understanding and responding to questions, sorting vocabulary and categories) without any affirmative indication of what he was capable of doing in these areas at the time of the initial IEP. The present levels for these goals were thus too vague to be of use in later determining where and in what manner he progressed on the goal. Similarly, the present level in the area of pragmatics is largely expressed in terms of STUDENT having “difficulty.” As indicated in the testimony of independent speech pathologist Leora Shaffer, there is no standardized assessment for pragmatic skills. As a result, it is imperative to have specific examples from observation delineating what STUDENT could and could not do in various environments. Independent speech pathologist Barbara Moore also testified that the present level fails to give any indication of STUDENT’s functional pragmatic level. As a consequence, it was not possible to determine a baseline was not possible or to measure his progress on the pragmatics goal.

The Hearing Officer finds that the testimony of both Ms. Moore and Ms. Shaffer is entitled to great weight. During Ms. Moore’s direct examination, the District stipulated that she is an expert in speech and language pathology. Her testimony and resume establish that Ms. Moore has thirty seven years of experience as a speech pathologist, has taught at both the public school and the college level, has assessed the speech and language needs of approximately one thousand autistic students and has provided direct services to hundreds of these same students. In addition, from her testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Shaffer has fifteen years of experience as a speech pathologist in both the public schools and in private practice, has extensive experience assessing and providing direct services to autistic students, and has over one year of consistent experience and personal observation of STUDENT in speech therapy. From the testimony of these witnesses, the Hearing Officer finds that the pragmatic language goal lacked sufficient specificity and was therefore not measurable.

Second, Petitioner contends that the speech and language goals offered were wholly insufficient to meet his areas of need as identified by the District’s own speech and language assessment. In support of his position, both Ms. Shaffer and Ms. Moore testified that the District’s proposed speech and language goals were not sufficient to address all of STUDENT’s unique areas of need. The District contends that STUDENT’s areas of need were appropriately addressed in its goals.

The Hearing Officer finds that the receptive-expressive goal did not sufficiently address STUDENT’s areas of need. Specifically, the CELF-P administered by Providence in January 2004 assessed STUDENT’s skills in the areas of semantics, syntax, morphology, auditory processing, and auditory memory. STUDENT’s 1st percentile total receptive language score on the CELF-P encompassed a 1st percentile score in the subtest of understanding “linguistic concepts.” Ms. Sternberg testified that in preparing her goals, she had read and reviewed the goals written by Ms. Molitor in the Providence speech and language assessment provided by the parents. From its assessment, Providence proposed goals for STUDENT to increase the use of pronouns, to demonstrate the ability to complete all steps in order on two- and three-step commands in novel situations, demonstrate an understanding of linguistic concepts (but not, when, and then, next to) by following a direction or answering a question containing these concepts. Despite Ms. Sternberg’s review of Providence’s goals for STUDENT, the speech goals she drafted do not address these specific areas, including linguistic concepts. As indicated in Ms. Shaffer’s testimony and assessment, linguistic concepts include concepts of coordination (and), inclusion/exclusion (one, either/or, but not, or, all except, either one), spatial relationships (next to, first, middle, last), temporal relation/order (first, and then, when, after, before), and quantity (all except, all, some). Ms. Shaffer testified that linguistic concepts were a significant deficit for STUDENT in April 2004 and continued to be a significant deficit.

The lack of goals to address pronouns, following two- and three-step directions, and understanding linguistic concepts is particularly troublesome because at the time it proposed its expressive and receptive language goals, the District was well aware of STUDENT’s extremely low scores on the CELF-P and the PLS-4, as well as the significant discrepancy between his verbal I.Q. of 70 and performance I.Q. of 121 on the WIPPSI-3 administered by Ms. Garrison. The Hearing Officer thus finds that the District failed to offer goals to address STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language needs in the area of pronouns, following two-to three-step directions, and understanding linguistic concepts.

The Hearing Officer finds that the pragmatic language goal (for STUDENT to enhance his basic skills needed to make requests, relate an experience, and ask a question about something he does not understand), while less than precise, was sufficiently comprehensive to address his pragmatic language needs. In support of Petitioner’s position, Ms. Shaffer testified that the District shouldhave developed pragmatic goals for STUDENT in specific areas such as greeting others, initiating play, turn taking, topic maintenance, on topic behaviors during task, increasing self-regulating responses in social situations, taking perspective of others, decreasing verbal stimulation and increasing normal voice usage. As indicated by Ms. Moore, however, the District’s pragmatic language goal suffered primarily from not being written in a specific enough manner to identify STUDENT’s “basic skills.” As a consequence, it could only be measured anecdotally. Nonetheless, Ms. Moore characterized the pragmatic goal as “not bad.” The Hearing Officer gives Ms. Moore’s testimony significant weight regarding the appropriateness of the pragmatic language goal due to her recognized expertise in speech and language pathology. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the offered pragmatic language goal covered significant areas of need for STUDENT and was capable of being implemented by a qualified speech pathologist.

From the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the offered categories, receptive-expressive, and pragmatic language goals were not measurable, and that the receptive-expressive goal should have but failed to address using pronouns, following two- to three-step directions, and understanding linguistic concepts.

Occupational therapy goals

Petitioner asserts that the District failed to offer goals to address all of his unique occupational therapy needs. Specifically, Petitioner asserts that the District’s occupational therapist, Ms. Chua, like independent occupational therapist/assessor Nancy Lin, testified that STUDENT’s areas of need were in fine motor, self-care, visual motor, praxis, and sensory processing. In Petitioner’s view, the two occupational therapy goals drafted by Ms. Chua for attention and fine motor skills were insufficient to address these needs. For the District, Ms. Chua testified that her two proposed goals covered these five areas in a functional manner. As proposed at the April 2004 IEP team meeting, STUDENT’s OT attention goal was to attend and finish at least 75 percent of any undesired classroom activity with no more than three verbal prompts during a fifteen minute period.1 (Footnote 19) In fine motor, STUDENT’s goal was to hold and manipulate scissors with one hand. At the April 2004 IEP, the parents consented to the fine motor goal but not to the attention goal.

In examining the sufficiency of the OT goals, the Hearing Officer notes an underlying conflict between Petitioner and the District over the extent of STUDENT’s OT needs that arises out of the different conclusions reached in the OT assessments of Ms. Lin and Ms. Chua. As referenced above, these assessors relied on different versions of the VMI, with the District using the older VMI-4, which scored STUDENT’s visual-motor skills within the average range at the 82nd percentile. By contrast, Ms. Lin used the newly normed and standardized VMI-5, which showed STUDENT’s skills to be delayed, at the 13th percentile. As discussed in section III C. 6 below, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Lin’s occupational therapy assessment is entitled to greater weight than that conducted by Ms. Chua and that this finding is relevant to both the OT goals and the level of OT services.

Specifically, the Hearing Officer finds that the fine motor goal proposed by the District was appropriate but that it was insufficient to address STUDENT’s fine motor needs, including grasping and visual-motor. (See III C. 6 below). From the results of the Peabody and VMI-5, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT required goals to address his grip on and use of writing instruments. (See, for example, Pet. Ex. 23, goals 2, 3, 7, 8). Further, the Hearing Officer finds that, while Ms. Chua testified that STUDENT had needs in the area of self-care, the District failed to offer STUDENT any self-care goals. This failure is particularly surprising in light of STUDENT’s score at the 1st percentile in daily living skills on the District’s Vineland. As acknowledged by Ms. Garrison, this placed STUDENT below 99 percent of his peers. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT required self-care goals. (See for example, Pet. Ex. 23, goals 4, 5, and 6).

In addition, the Hearing Officer has previously determined that the District failed to assess STUDENT’s sensory motor needs during its occupational therapy assessment. As a consequence, the Hearing Officer finds the District did not offer STUDENT any goals to address his sensory motor needs. From her sensory assessment, Ms. Lin concluded that, overall, STUDENT demonstrated difficulty with modulating his sensory input and output as evidenced by (1) frequent inability to attend to task, to remain seated, and exert the appropriate amount of pressure when using tools such as a pencil and a fork, and (2) sensory-seeking behaviors such as excessive jumping, fidgeting, squirming and movement. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT required goals in this area. (See for example, Pet. Ex. 23, goals 9, 10, and 11.)

Finally, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to offer STUDENT any goals to address his praxis or motor planning needs. As previously discussed, Ms. Chua testified that from her assessment she concluded that praxis was an area of need for STUDENT. Ms. Chua provided no explanation regarding how her two proposed goals addressed STUDENT’s praxis needs. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT required a goal in this area. (See, for example, Pet. Ex. 23 goals 12 and 13).

Petitioner also contends that the present level of performance of the OT/attention goal was not measurable. As discussed below, one of STUDENT’s greatest areas of need is that of attention. The District offered STUDENT one occupational therapy/attention goal and three attention/behavior goals. The present level of performance for the District’s OT attention goal for STUDENT was that he “displays distractiblity and short attention span affecting participation in circle and/or big group activities. Reg. Ed teacher reports that during a large group activity, STUDENT needs at least 3 prompts, often more.” From this baseline, STUDENT’s annual attention goal was to attend and finish at least 75 percent of an undesired activity with no more than three verbal prompts during a fifteen minute period by January 2005. Ms. Chu argued that the goal was “measurable” because she could see if he was able to respond with less than three prompts; however, she conceded that STUDENT’s present level of performance only indicated he required more than three prompts and that he could have required fifty prompts to attend at the time the goal was written. Thus, there was no direct relationship between the present levels of performance and the attention goal and the goal was not measurable. Cal. Code Regs. tit. v, § 3040(c).

From the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to offer STUDENT goals to fully address his fine motor needs, failed to offer goals to areas of needs in self-care, visual motor, praxis, and sensory processing, and failed to provide a measurable OT/attention goal.

Present Levels of Performance of Attention/Behavior and Social Skills Goals Petitioner also challenges the measurability and accuracy of the present levels of performance in the District’s goals 3 and 4, relating to STUDENT’s attention/behavior, and in its goals 5, 7, and 8, relating to social skills.2 (Footnote 20) STUDENT’s attention/behavior goals were to comply with novel teacher requests or directions, to leave a preferred activity, and to work in a small group with appropriate attention. His social skills goals were to engage in cooperative play, to independently join a group activity, and to state what is causing his fears or concerns and suggest a way to respond to it, and to identify a problem and state a prosocial way to resolve it. STUDENT’s parents consented to all social skills goals.

The Hearing Officer finds that while the present levels of performance for these goals were not expressed in quantitative terms, they were based upon input from the participants at the IEP team following a discussion of STUDENT’s abilities. In addition, as discussed below, the IEP team offered STUDENT some behavior services (IBI) and intended that data would be collected regarding his behaviors and skill acquisition during the provision of IBI services. Because STUDENT was just entering the program and the intention of the IEP team was to have IBI staff collect data following the inception of services, the Hearing Officer finds that the present levels of performance for these goals were sufficient to provide a starting point for trained professionals.

III C 4. failing to offer him behavioral supports in the form of an applied behavioral analysis (ABA) home program with a behavioral classroom aide?

At the April 2004 IEP meeting, to support STUDENT’s placement in the regular education preschool, the District also offered him 45 minutes a day of “IBI” services in the classroom “to support large group social activities” for each of his three school days, as well as two hours a month of “IBI supervision/student progress meeting.”

Petitioner contends that the District’s placement offer was not designed to meet his unique needs because he required an applied behavioral analysis (ABA) home program that included an ABA trained one-to-one behavior aide to assist him in the regular education classroom. In support of his contention, Petitioner relies on the assessments and testimony of Dr. Perlman and Anahita Renner, each of whom recommended that STUDENT participate in an intensive home ABA program on a year-round basis. In Dr. Perlman’s view, STUDENT required such a program for at least twenty-five hours a week. Ms. Renner testified that STUDENT required a thirty-hour a week program to meet his unique needs. Both Dr. Perlman and Ms. Renner recommended that STUDENT be accompanied to school by a trained one-to-one aide throughout his school day. As previously noted, the parents did not consent to the April IEP and removed STUDENT from Chaparral at the end of the 2003-2004 school year. Petitioner began a home program with AIR in September 2004, after the District rejected his parents’ request either to provide him with a one-to-one aide or to allow him to be accompanied to his District classroom by a one-to-one aide from a nonpublic agency.

The District contends that its offer of placement in a regular classroom with IBI services was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the least restrictive environment (LRE). In its view, a one-to-one aide and a home ABA program constitute an excessive amount of services for STUDENT’s needs.

Regular Classroom with IBI Services

Ms. Boessler testified that her preschool classroom at Chaparral during the 2003-2004 school year consisted of twenty-four students, herself and an aide. The classroom had various activities, including three circle times, numerous free choice/play times, three centers for art, writing, and math activities, snack, and recess. District program specialist Jennifer Fant testified that all of the District’s IBI tutors are trained in ABA techniques, including discrete trial training, breaking down skills, providing systematic reinforcement, and fading prompts. She also testified that IBI supervision includes developing the student’s program, breaking down the curriculum, determining the types of prompting and reinforcement required, and direct class observation of the student with his IBI tutors. IBI supervisors also work with the parents to ensure they have a good understanding of the program.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of placement in a regular education class for three and a half hours a day with forty-five minutes a day of IBI services was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of attention, behavior, and social skills. Rather, the weight of the evidence establishes that STUDENT required a full time one-to-one aide in his regular classroom to meet his unique attention, behavior, and social needs. In reaching this conclusion, the Hearing Officer places great weight on the testimony of Dr. Perlman. The record established that Dr. Perlman has nearly thirty years of experience as a clinical psychologist, has recognized expertise in psychoeducational assessment of students with disabilities, and has specific training and experience assessing students with autism who comprise approximately fifty percent of his clients. Dr. Perlman’s testimony also established his expertise in assessing autism specific classrooms and ABA programs in public and private settings. (Pet. Ex. 66)

Dr. Perlman’s detailed review of STUDENT’s educational records, as well as his independent assessment, and significant interaction with and observation of STUDENT, led to his conclusion that his placement in the preschool class at Chaparral without a one-to-one aide was not designed to meet his unique needs. Specifically, Dr. Perlman testified that two of STUDENT’s greatest areas of educational need were in attention and in learning to interact cooperatively with the environment in a placement with a clear and consistent behavior management system. From his review of the records, Dr. Perlman determined that STUDENT’s difficulty paying attention and sustaining attention surfaced as “a rather pervasive deficit area,” which he personally observed in multiple setting on multiple days. Dr. Perlman concluded that attention, not language, was “the single most pertinent factor that contributes to [STUDENT’s] inability to benefit from his education.” During his observation at Chaparral, Dr. Perlman noted that STUDENT had his back to the teacher 80 percent of the time and that there was no encouragement from any adults for him to be part of the group. From his observation, Dr. Perlman concluded that the “circle time” activity was of no educational benefit to STUDENT and that the “center time” was of very marginal value because he did not interact with the materials in the manner he was supposed to and because he was allowed to “space out.” Dr. Perlman expressed great concern about classroom staff inadvertently reinforcing STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors. For example, he observed STUDENT refusing to cooperate and staff members allowing him to do so without any consequences. He also observed staff to rephrase questions posed to STUDENT until he could respond with a ‘yes’ or ‘no’ answer rather than requiring him to speak.

The Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Perlman’s conclusion is corroborated by a number of other witnesses. First, from her experience in the classroom, MOTHER testified that STUDENT needed constant prompts to pay attention to circle time activities or to even notice that the teacher was talking. Second, occupational therapist Ms. Chua reported from her observation that STUDENT did not pay attention for approximately 70 percent of circle time in Ms. Boessler’s classroom. Third, during her classroom observation at Chaparral, Ms. Renner observed that STUDENT fidgeted repeatedly during circle time, lay on the floor up to three minutes while other students sat and attended, mumbled to himself, made repetitive arm motions with noises, and engaged in continuous verbal self-stimulating behaviors. Ms. Renner also observed that while STUDENT participated in group singing, he did not respond to questions regarding the story read, did not respond to any class directions from teacher, exhibited extremely low attention, and very high distractibility. In addition, STUDENT refused to comply with redirection, needed verbal and physical prompts to do so, did not hear his name to transition to center, put his head on the table during center time, and was not redirected to stop even though no other student did this.

The District argued that its offer of IBI services was sufficient to meet STUDENT’s needs in the classroom. In support of its contention that STUDENT did not require a full-time one-to-one aide in the classroom, the District relied on the testimony of preschool teacher Ms. Boessler and school psychologist Sandra Garrison. Ms. Boessler testified that a one-to-one aide in the classroom would be required only if the student was a danger to himself or to others and that, in her opinion, STUDENT did not require a one-to-one aide to benefit from his education. Ms. Boessler later clarified that a one-to-one aide might be required if the student could not walk from point A to point B by himself, or if he was not able to participate in class “at all” and needed constant reminders to complete a specific task or to move to another activity. Ms. Garrison testified that, in her opinion, a shadow aide would be more detrimental than beneficial to STUDENT because he did not exhibit aggressive behaviors and because he was watching other students and learning from them. Ms. Garrison testified that the practical effect of having a shadow aide would be to isolate STUDENT and, particularly due to his young age, pose a risk that he would over-identify with adults rather than take social cues from his peers.

The Hearing Officer does not find these arguments persuasive. Rather, the weight of the evidence mandates a conclusion that, in April 2004, STUDENT required a one-to-one aide to be aware of and to benefit from his education. In reaching this conclusion, the Hearing Officer also notes that the District repeatedly referenced and relied on its belief that fewer services were required to meet its obligation to provide STUDENT with an education in the least restrictive environment. While special education law requires that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE), the comments to the federal implementing regulations explain that “the regulations do not require that a child has to fail in the less restrictive options on the continuum before that child can be placed in a setting that is appropriate to his or her needs. Section 300.550(b)(2) of the regulations, however, does require that the placement team consider whether the child can be educated in less restrictive settings with the use of appropriate supplementary aids and services and make a more restrictive placement only when they conclude that education in the less restrictive setting with appropriate supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.” 64 Fed. Reg. No. 48, p. 12638 (March 12, 1999). In this case, the Hearing Officer finds that a full time one-to-one aide was a necessary supplementary service that would allow STUDENT to receive meaningful education in the regular classroom.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s placement offer of a regular education classroom with IBI services and without a one-to-one aide was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

Petitioner also contends that he required a home applied behavior analysis program to meet his attention, social, and behavior needs. Both Dr. Perlman and Ms. Renner testified that, in their opinion, a home ABA program was necessary to meet STUDENT’s needs arising from his autism. Specifically, Dr. Perlman testified that the program the District offered to STUDENT lacked an essential criterion of intensity because the total amount of IBI services it offered was less than five hours a week. According to Dr. Perlman, research has supported a minimum of twenty-five hours a week of one-to-one intervention for autistic children. In addition, he testified that there is a law of diminishing returns for programs between twenty-five and ten hours a week, and that programs of under ten hours of one-to-one behavior intervention are of questionable value. In STUDENT’s case, Dr. Perlman testified that, in his opinion, this level of intensity was required due to STUDENT’s inability to sustain attention to task as well as his inability to comply with what was expected of him, as demonstrated by his extreme avoidance of tasks on demand to the point of shutting down. In addition, Dr. Perlman testified that an intense program was required, in part, to ameliorate the effects of the negative behavioral reinforcement STUDENT had received from District staff. As a consequence, a home program was required for STUDENT to have a clear consistent behavior management system that would provide appropriate reinforcement so that he could learn to interact cooperatively within a school environment. Finally, the Hearing Officer notes that Dr. Perlman testified that STUDENT has a great cognitive potential that he is unable to access, but that with intensive intervention, he believed STUDENT could approximate a typically developing child.

The Hearing Officer notes that the District offered no persuasive evidence to contradict Dr. Perlman’s testimony regarding STUDENT’s need for a one-to-one program of this intensity. Ms. Fant testified that she was aware of research supporting thirty hours a week of one-to-one intervention (Pet. Exs. 64, 92) but that she could not comment on the relationship of that research to an individual child. Ms. Fant also testified that although she had attended an IEP for STUDENT, she had never met him.

From the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s placement offer of a regular classroom with IBI services and without a one-to-one aide was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs because he required an intense ABA program of twenty-five hours a week.

III C 5. failing to offer adequate speech and language therapy?

Petitioner asserts that the District’s offer of thirty minutes a week of speech and language services was not a sufficient amount of services to meet his unique needs. In support of his contention, Petitioner relies on the recommendation of the January 14, 2004 Providence speech and language assessment it provided to the District for his initial assessment, on the testimony of his private speech therapist from Speech Pathology Associates (SPA), Leora Shaffer, and on the testimony of SPA’s executive director, speech pathologist Barbara Moore. In response, the District argues that the amount of speech services it offered STUDENT was appropriate based upon the deficits identified by its speech pathologist, Joan Sternberg. In addition, in its closing brief, the District asserted that the amount of speech services it offered to STUDENT at the April 2004 IEP meeting –one hour a week– was the same level of services that he actually received from Ms. Shaffer from March 2004 through September 2004.

At the outset, the Hearing Office notes that the District’s assertion that it offered STUDENT one hour per week of speech and language services during this time period is erroneous. From the express terms of the combined April 2004 IEP admitted as District Ex. 27 (D00189), the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered STUDENT a total of one thirty-minute speech and language session a week, to be provided in class or pull-out on campus, for the end of the 2003-2004 school year (4/24/04-6/9/04) and for the 2004 ESY (6/14/04-7/9/04). The IEP’s separate offer of two thirty-minute sessions per week did not provide service dates; however, as clarified in Ms. Fant’s May 21, 2004 letter to the parent reiterating the District’s offer, that offer related to the 2004-2005 school year for the period from August 24, 2004, through the annual review on April 20, 2005. (Pet. Ex. 45, p. 2).

The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not offer STUDENT speech and language services in an amount designed to meet his unique speech and language needs for the end of the 2003-2004 school year and the 2004 ESY for the following reasons. First, the weight of the evidence demonstrates that at the time of the April 2004 IEP, STUDENT had a significant receptive and expressive language disorder as established by the findings of both the Providence speech and language assessment and the District’s speech assessment. Ms. Sternberg acknowledged the consistency between these assessment results at the April 22, 2004 IEP team meeting (D196) and in her testimony at the hearing. For example, STUDENT’s total language score on both the Preschool Language Scale - 4 (PLS-4) administered by Ms. Sternberg and on the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals - Preschool (CELF-Preschool) administered by Ms. Molitor for the Providence assessment was at the 3rd percentile. Ms. Sternberg testified that this meant that 97 percent of STUDENT’s same age peers scored higher than he. STUDENT’s receptive language, at the 1st percentile on the CELF-P and at the 4th percentile on the PLS-4, were characterized as “severely deficient” by Dr. Perlman, who concluded in his psychoeducational assessment that another appropriate basis for special education eligibility for STUDENT would be as speech and language impaired. While STUDENT’s expressive language was at the 10th percentile on the CELF-P and at the 5th percentile on the PLS-4, the Providence report noted that his expressive subtests ranged widely from “average,” with a relative strength in single-word vocabulary, to “significantly disordered,” with overall expressive skills significantly delayed. In addition, Ms. Moore testified that the District’s PSL-4 scores indicated that STUDENT had a significant receptive and expressive language disorder. Both Ms. Moore and Ms. Shaffer testified that the PLS-4 used by the District is more akin to a screening device, and that other assessment instruments go into more depth, particularly with a high functioning autistic student like STUDENT. Significantly, Ms. Shaffer testified that she was particularly concerned with STUDENT’s low scores on the PLS-4 because this assessment instrument gives students credit for knowing an entire concept based upon partial answers and thus tends to score high. As previously discussed, the Hearing Officer gives great weight to the testimony of Ms. Shaffer and Ms. Moore.

Second, the weight of the evidence establishes that STUDENT’s mean length of utterance, or MLU, at the time of the initial assessment was approximately 21 months below his chronological age and indicated a need for more intense speech services. The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT’s verbal “scripting and delayed echolalia with a lot of jargon intermixed” was reported by Dr. Filipek at the time of STUDENT’s initial diagnosis only three months prior to Ms. Sternberg’s assessment. During her assessment, Ms. Sternberg collected a language sample of 65 utterances, from which she concluded that STUDENThad an MLU of 6.8 morphological units. Ms. Sternberg testified that this score is within the normal range compared to same age peers. Ms. Sternberg also testified that she was aware that verbal stimulation is characteristic of autistic students, but she believed STUDENT’s verbal dysfluencies or repetitions were typical for a five-year-old and were included in her MLU. By contrast, STUDENT’s private therapist, Leora Shaffer, testified that she collected a 165-utterance language sample from STUDENT and that from this sample she determined that he had an MLU of 3.58, a score that was more than two years below his chronological age. Ms. Shaffer then removed all single-word yes/no answers and reanalyzed the language sample. This second analysis yielded an MLU of 4.11, or 21.6 months below STUDENT’s chronological age. Ms. Shaffer testified that she used the higher MLU because STUDENT spoke “a lot” and could use longer utterances. Nevertheless, this MLU indicated a significant area in need of remediation. Ms. Shaffer also testified that it is not appropriate to count verbal repetitions (dysfluencies or jargon), or perseverative speech more than once in an MLU. In her opinion, the District’s MLU was not accurate. The Hearing Officer finds that the MLU as determined by Ms. Shaffer is entitled to more weight than the MLU determined by Ms. Sternberg.

Third, the weight of the evidence also establishes that STUDENT has significant pragmatic language needs that were not fully addressed by the District’s assessment and that this affected the level of services recommended. It is noteworthy that at the time of its assessment, the District had a copy of the Providence assessment that reported STUDENT demonstrated difficulty in “multiple components of pragmatic language,” including maintaining a topic, turn-taking in conversations, initiating and ending conversations, making friends and preferring isolated play, showing an unusual preoccupation with houses, and using scripted and perseverative language. The Providence report concluded that, “overall, [STUDENT’s] pragmatic language skills appear disordered and require further in-depth testing.” (Pet. Ex. 10, p. 2). While the evidence was undisputed that there is no standardized assessment instrument for pragmatic language, both Ms. Moore and Ms. Shaffer testified that a more in-depth assessment of STUDENT’s pragmatic language was required for the District to determine his functional levels. In Ms. Shaffer’s view, the lack of specific examples of STUDENT’s social skills via social interaction, observations, or play skills assessment made it extremely difficult for the District to understand STUDENT’s present levels of performance and his areas of need. In this regard, the Hearing Officer notes that Ms. Sternberg testified that she did not observe STUDENT in the classroom. Further, although STUDENT’s younger brother was present in the room during her assessment, Ms. Sternberg did not assess STUDENT’s interaction with him.

The Hearing Officer finds that the only testimony offered by the District explaining why a single thirty-minute weekly speech session was appropriate to meet STUDENT’s unique language needs was that STUDENT was easy to work with, was very polite, and did not exhibit atypical behavior. (Testimony of Ms. Sternberg). In contrast, both Ms. Shaffer and Ms. Moore testified that the level of speech and language services offered to STUDENT was not sufficient to meet his speech and language needs. In addition, the uncontradicted testimony of Ms. Moore established that, while some speech skills can be modeled by a behavior therapist, like an IBI aide, under the supervision of a speech pathologist, it would be inappropriate to have a behavior therapist substitute for a speech therapist. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the time offered by the District for IBI services cannot be considered in determining the appropriateness of its offer of speech services.

Accordingly, for the reasons outlined above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offer of thirty minutes a week of speech services was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique receptive, expressive, and pragmatic language needs and that STUDENT required two hours a week of individual speech and language services.

III C 6. failing to offer an adequate type and amount occupational therapy?

In considering the appropriateness of the occupational therapy services offered to STUDENT at the April 2004 IEPs, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Lin’s occupational therapy assessment is entitled to greater weight than that conducted by Ms. Chua for the following reasons. First, as indicated in Issue 2 above, Ms. Chua did not assess STUDENT’s sensory motor needs, an area discussed in depth in Ms. Lin’s assessment and in her specific goals written to address these needs. Second, the Hearing Officer finds that the VMI-5 scores obtained in Ms. Lin’s assessment are entitled to greater weight than those of the VMI-4 administered by the District. Although testimony established that use of the VMI-4 was still permissible for STUDENT’s assessment, it was undisputed that the VMI-5 was recently renormed and is therefore a more accurate depiction of STUDENT in relation to his peers. Further, the VMI-5 results were corroborated by the Peabody Developmental Motor Skills Test (Peabody), in the visual-motor component of the fine motor subtest administered to STUDENT by Ms. Lin for her assessment. Third, Ms. Lin testified that a Peabody should have been administered to STUDENT during the District’s assessment. In her testimony, Ms. Chua agreed that, as an occupational therapist, the Peabody is an assessment she typically administers for an OT assessment. Nonetheless, Ms. Chua offered no explanation regarding why she did not administer a Peabody to STUDENT for her assessment. Fourth, as indicted in Ms. Lin’s assessment, the results on the Peabody’s visual motor subtests were consistent with STUDENT’s age equivalent on the VMI-5. Both of these scores showed that STUDENT functioned approximately twenty months lower than on the District’s assessment, i.e., at an age equivalent of fifty months compared to the District’s age equivalent of seventy months. In addition, STUDENT’s overall fine motor performance on the Peabody fine motor subtest, which is comprised of grasping and visual-motor, was in the below average range, at the 12th percentile.

As discussed above, the Hearing Officer has determined that the District failed to assess STUDENT’s sensory motor needs, that its occupational assessment was entitled to less weight than that of independent occupational therapist Nancy Lin, and that it failed to offer STUDENT goals to address his areas of need in fine motor, self-care, visual motor, praxis, and sensory processing. In addition to the previous findings, the Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Lin and Ms. Francis to be persuasive that STUDENT required two hours of direct individual occupational therapy a week, as well as consultation services. From the testimony of these witnesses as well as the findings outlined above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of one twenty-minute occupational therapy consultation session each month was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

III C 7. failing to offer an ESY program that was sufficient to prevent regression?

Federal and State regulations provide for extended school year (ESY) services when a disabled student’s IEP team determines that such services are necessary to provide a FAPE. 34 C.F.R. § 300.309; Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043. Extended school year programming is educational programming that extends instruction beyond the normal school year to prevent serious regression over the summer months. Hoeft v. Tucson Unified School District, 967 F.2d 1298, 1301 (9th Cir. 1992); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(b).2 (Footnote 21)

In this case, there is no dispute that STUDENT is a student who requires ESY services. As indicated above, the District offered STUDENT the same amount and type of placement and services for the 2004 ESY as it did for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year. The Hearing Officer has determined that the District’s offer of placement and services to STUDENT for the end of the 2003-2004 school year and the 2004 ESY was not designed to meet his unique needs. Nonetheless, Petitioner contends that, in addition, the offer for the 2004 ESY was not appropriate because it provided STUDENT with too much time without services from the end of the ESY through the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year. Specifically, as indicated on the IEP, the ESY period extended from June 14, 2004, through July 9, 2004.

The weight of the evidence established that STUDENT requires year-round services with, at most, a break of no more than two weeks to avoid regression. (Testimony Ms. Shaffer, Ms. Lin, Dr. Perlman, Ms. Renner, Ms. Fant.) In this case, the District convened an IEP team meeting on July 9, 2004, to determine whether to extend IBI maintenance services for the period between the end of the ESY and the commencement of the 2004-2005 school years. As indicated in Ms. Fant’stestimony, even though the parents had not accepted the District’s offer, the District members of the IEP team met and provided an addendum to the offer to provide for IBI maintenance services after the conclusion of the ESY, from July 26, 2004, through August 8, 2004, in such a way that there would be no more than a two-week break in services. Thus, although the actual services offered to STUDENT have been found to be insufficient, the Hearing Officer finds that the District acted appropriately in offering additional services during this period to ensure that STUDENT had a break of no more than two weeks before the commencement of the next school year.

Was the District’s April 2004 offer reasonably calculated to provide STUDENTwith some educational benefit?

Because the April 2004 IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, the Hearing Officer now finds that the District’s offer was not reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit.

III D. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to have STUDENT’s regular education teacher present at the July 9, 2004 IEP team meeting?

Federal and state special education law require that at least one regular education teacher of a child with a disability be part of the IEP team, if that child is or may be participating in the regular education environment. 20 U.S.C. § 1414 (d)(1)(B)(ii), Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b)(2).

The Hearing Officer finds no merit to Petitioner’s contention that the District failed to have STUDENT’s regular education teacher present at the IEP team meeting of July 9, 2004. On its face, the July 9, 2004 IEP addendum indicates that Kristie Allard was present at the IEP team meeting in the capacity as regular education teacher. As indicated on the combined April 20 and 22, 2004 IEP, Ms. Allard also attended both of those IEP meetings in her capacity as a regular education kindergarten teacher. It is undisputed that STUDENT was completing preschool in the 2003-2004 school year and entering kindergarten in the 2004-2005 school year. Her participation in the IEP thus satisfied the requirements outlined above. * * *

In summary, the Hearing Officer has determined that the District did not provide STUDENT’s parents with a substantially defective notice of procedural rights, fail to provide his independent assessors with an equivalent opportunity to observe him the classroom, fail to provide a legally sufficient IEP on April 20, 2004, fail to make a clear written offer of speech and language or IBI services, or fail to have a regular education teacher present at the July 9, 2004 IEP. The Hearing Officer has concluded that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide measurable annual goals in all areas of need and by failing to offer him a placement designed to meet his unique needs. Specifically, the Hearing Officer has determined that STUDENT required a one-to-one aide in the classroom, an ABA program of at least twenty-five hours per week including his classroom time, two hours a week of individual speech and language therapy, two hours a week of occupational therapy, and a year-round program with no more than two weeks of break between sessions.

ISSUE 4: Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE on procedural or substantive grounds during the 2004-2005 school year by convening an IEP team meeting on September 23, 2004, without providing for parental notice or participation and failing to provide them with a copy of the IEP, and/or as outlined in Issue 3 A, B, or C?

The District’s April 2004 IEP offer to STUDENT for the 2004-2005 school year through April 2005, was substantially similar to that for the 2003-2004 school year and ESY with the following differences. First, STUDENT’s school day as he entered kindergarten increased from three and a half hours a day three days a week to three hours fifteen minutes per day five days a week, for a total of sixteen hours fifteen minute a week. Second, STUDENT was also offered thirty minutes of consultation resource specialist program (RSP) services once a week “to consult with classroom staff to monitor academics and modify curriculum as needed.” Third, his speech and language services were increased to two thirty-minute sessions a week, one individual and one group. Fourth, his IBI services increased to one hour a day in class “to support classroom socialization and large group activities,” or a total of five hours a week. In addition, for the first month of school until the IEP review in late September, STUDENT was offered a daily one-to-one IBI tutorial of thirty minutes outside the classroom “for pre-teaching and skill practice,” for an additional two and a half hours a week.

Despite these additional services and for the same reasons articulated in Issue 3 A, B, and C, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of services for the 2004-2005 school year through the April 20, 2005 annual review was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique attention, behavior, social, sensory/occupational therapy, or language needs, and that consequently it was not designed to provide him with some educational benefit. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE.

September 23, 2004 IEP Team Meeting

Under California law, an IEP team meeting may be conducted without a parent in attendance if the District “is unable to convince the parent... that he or she should attend.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(h) If a district is unable to convince the parent to attend the IEP meeting, it “shall maintain a record of its attempts to arrange a mutually agreed-upon time and place” for the IEP team meeting, as follows: (1) “detailed records of telephone calls made or attempted and the results of those calls;” (2) “copies of correspondence sent to the parents... and any responses received;” [and] (3) “detailed records of visits made to the home or place of employment of the parents...and the results of those visits.” Id. If a parent cannot attend the meeting, the district is required to use other methods to ensure participation, including telephone conference calls. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(g). The district is required to provide the parent with a copy of the IEP, at no cost. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(j).

STUDENT’s District case carrier, Michelle Degn, testified that she wrote to the PARENTS on August 27, 2004, to schedule an IEP meeting and enclosed three forms entitled Notice of IEP Team Meetings completed for the following dates: September 20, 22, and 23, 2004. In her letter, Ms. Degn encouraged the parents to choose an IEP date they could attend and to advise the District of that date by signing the appropriate notice. Ms. Deng also told the parents that if they were unable to come or if the District did not receive a reply, the IEP team meeting would be conducted on the last date without them. If this happened, she indicated that the parents would be provided a copy of the proposed IEP, as well as any minutes of the discussion at the IEP team meeting. Ms. Degn testified that she mailed this letter to the FAMILY’s address by certified mail, return receipt requested, on August 27, 2004. A return receipt bearing the same tracking number was signed by MOTHER on August 31, 2004, whose signature Ms. Degn verified for accuracy from her file. (Dist. Ex. 55).

MOTHER testified she had no recollection of signing this receipt and that she had never received the certified letter providing notice of the September IEP team meeting. She further testified that her practice when being notified of an IEP team meeting was to immediately contact her attorney, and that she did not do so regarding this IEP. MOTHER also testified that she never saw the September 27, 2004 IEP document until shortly before the hearing, in the District’s evidence package. District program specialist Ms. Fant testified that, if she does not receive a response from a parent in this type of situation, she calls the parent or sends a reminder letter. She also testified that the PARENTS had responded to all previous requests for an IEP team meeting.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to comply with the provisions of section 56341.5, because it failed to take additional affirmative action outlined in the statute to convince the parents to participate at the September 23, 2004 IEP team meeting. Specifically, a review of the evidence as a whole indicates that the District was aware that the parents were represented by counsel, and that the parents had previously advised the District in writing via their counsel when they did not intend to attend an IEP team meeting, as they did for the July 9, 2004 IEP team meeting. (See Resp. Exs. 35, 37). Nonetheless, the District failed to initiate any telephone communication with the parents or their attorneys to ensure their attendance at the IEP. In addition, after the IEP team meeting, the undisputed testimony of MOTHER established that the District violated section 56341.5(j) by failing to provide the parents with a copy of the September 23, 2004 IEP until some six months later, when the documentary evidence was exchanged for the hearing in this matter.

The Hearing Officer further finds that as a result of this failure to comply with section 56341.5, Petitioner was denied a FAPE because his parents were denied any opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process. W.G. v. Bd. Of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479.

ISSUE FIVE: If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year, the 2004 ESY, and/or the 2004-2005 school year through April 2005, is he entitled to reimbursement, compensatory education services, and/or prospective services?

A. Reimbursement

Reimbursement for IEEs

Petitioner requests reimbursement for the independent educational evaluations (IEEs) conducted by Ms. Renner in behavior and by Ms. Lin in sensory-motor integration. Pursuant to California Education Code section 56329, an IEE may be publically funded where the Hearing Officer determines that the District’s assessment is not appropriate.

As determined in Section 2, above, the Hearing Officer has concluded that the District failed to conduct an assessment in sensory motor as consented to by the parents on the March 3, 2004 assessment plan and that the occupational therapy assessment was therefore not appropriate. While the District argued that this issue was technically moot because it had agreed in its May 21, 2004 letter to reimburse Petitioner for his requested IEEs, there was no testimony that this offer was still open or that the District offered to reimburse Petitioner for assessments by professionals other than those identified in that letter. Therefore, the Hearing Officer now finds that Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for the cost of Ms. Lin’s assessment, in the total amount of $1,200. (Pet. Ex. 74). As further discussed in Section 2, however, the Hearing Officer concluded that the District’s behavior assessment was appropriate. Accordingly, Petitioner’s request for reimbursement for Ms. Renner’s Intake Assessment is denied.

Reimbursement for Educational Services

When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. Of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S.Ct. 1996 (1985); see also, 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997). Thus, parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement or services and the services provided by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370. In Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13, 113 S.Ct. 361 (1993), the Supreme Court specifically exempted parents from having to meet certain requirements of the IDEA in their unilateral placements. For example, parents are not required to conform their unilateral placement to the content of the student’s IEP or provide a placement that is certified by the state. Id. The Court has recognized that the parents’ placement does not have to meet a standard as high as a school district’s must meet; however, the parents’ placement must still meet other requirements of the IDEA, such as providing a placement that addresses the student’s needs and provides the student educational benefit. Id.

Petitioner requests reimbursement services paid for by his parents or by their insurance company due to the denial of FAPE. In light of the conclusion that the District did not offer Student a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year, the 2004 extended school year, or for the 2004-2005 school year through the April 20, 2005 annual review, the Hearing Officer must initially determine whether Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement and/or compensatory education. As discussed below, the weight of the evidence established that the educational services for which reimbursement is sought addressed STUDENT’s needs and provided him with educational benefit. Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter, Id.

1. Reimbursement for Home Program, including one-to-one aide, supervision, and clinic hours

Petitioner seeks reimbursement for the thirty-hour-a-week ABA home program provided to him by AIR, including the costs of his one-to-one behavior aide at preschool, an additional twelve hours a month of supervision and twelve to sixteen hours a month of clinic program, from September 2004 to the date of the decision. From the testimony of Dr. Perlman and Ms. Renner, the Hearing Officer finds STUDENT’s home program addressed his needs in communication, motor skills (fine motor and praxis), play, social skills, and behaviors. In addition, the Hearing Officer further notes that the testimony of these witnesses also persuasively established that STUDENT received educational benefit from his home program that was itemized in the “before and after” chart, prepared by Ms. Renner, which compared STUDENT’s entry level skills in September 2004 with his skills in March 2005. (Pet. Ex. 27). In addition, in his March 7, 2005 Assessment Update, Dr. Perlman reviewed STUDENT’s progress to determine if he was benefitting from his academic programs in his AIR ABA home and school program that began in September 2004. A review of that report and Dr. Perlman’s testimony establishes that STUDENT’s needs were addressed and that he received educational benefit in his home and school ABA program. (Pet. Ex. 29).

From the above, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for the cost of his home ABA program, including the costs of his one-to-one behavior aide at preschool, an additional twelve hours a month of supervision and twelve to sixteen hours a month of clinic program, from September 2004 to the date of this Decision.

2. Reimbursement for occupational therapy (OT)

Second, Petitioner seeks reimbursement for one hour a week of occupational therapy (OT) provided by Pediatric Therapy Solutions, a nonpublic agency, from July 2004 to the date of the Decision. Following his occupational therapy IEE assessment by Ms. Lin, STUDENT began to receive private occupational therapy from Cheri Francis one hour a week. These services began in July 2004 and continue currently. Although two hours a week of occupational therapy had been recommended by Ms. Lin, Ms. Francis testified that the parents were not able to fund the second hour per week.

Ms. Francis testified that she followed the OT goals outlined for STUDENT in Ms. Lin’s June 2004 assessment report and that STUDENT had met or made progress on these goals. (Pet. Ex. 23). For example, Ms. Francis testified that STUDENT had met his fine motor scissors goal (Goal 1) and had met a sensory processing goal (Goal 9) of attending to table top activities when he was in a structured one-to-one setting with her. Ms. Francis also testified that, in a school setting, STUDENT still required redirection by his aide and that he was able to access the curriculum due to the presence of the one-to-one aide.

From Ms. Francis’ testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that the occupational therapy services provided to STUDENT met his fine motor, self-care, visual motor, sensory processing, and praxis needs from which he received educational benefit. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for the cost of private occupational therapy services.

3. Reimbursement for Speech and Language Therapy

Third, Petitioner seeks reimbursement for speech and language therapy services from Speech and Language Associates (SPA) for one hour a week of individual therapy from February 2004 to September 2004, and two hours a week from September 2004 to the date of the Decision. From the testimony of Ms. Shaffer as well as a review of her reports dated September 8, 2004 (Pet. Ex. 24), and March 7, 2005 (Pet. Ex. 28), the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner’s parents provided him private individual speech therapy that was designed to meet his unique expressive, receptive, and pragmatic language needs and from which he also received educational benefit. For example, in her September 2004 report, Ms. Shaffer determined that STUDENT had demonstrated a significant improvement in overall receptive language skills on the CELF-P, which assesses semantics, syntax, morphology, auditory processing and auditory memory. Specifically, Ms. Shaffer reported that STUDENT received a receptive language score of SS 95, at the 37th percentile, an increase from a 1st percentile score when the test was administered to him in January 2004 by Providence. Similarly, STUDENT’s expressive language score was at the 21st percentile, up from the 10th percentile in January. STUDENT’s total language score on the CELF-P was at the 27th percentile (SS=91), up from the 3rd percentile (SS=71) in January. STUDENT had demonstrated no growth and had a continuing significant deficit in linguistic concepts, however. In February 2005, Ms. Shaffer administered the CELP-4 to STUDENT. In her March 2005 report, Ms. Shaffer indicated that on this test, STUDENT’s overall language scores were in the below average to the low average range. From a new language sample, STUDENT’s MLU had increased from 4.11 to 5.35.

From the above, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for speech services provided and paid for by his parents. The Hearing Officer finds that there was not sufficient evidence produced regarding the nature of Petitioner’s parent insurance, including the existence of a lifetime cap, to order the District to reimburse their insurance company.

4. Reimbursement for Preschool

Fourth, Petitioner seeks reimbursement for the cost of his tuition at Country Village Preschool from September 9, 2004, through October 17, 2004, in the amount of $1,452.50 (Pet. Ex. 83), and at Kindercare Preschool from October 18, 2004, to the date of the Decision. From the testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Renner, and Dr. Perlman, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT received educational benefit attending these preschools with the services of his one-to-one aide. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for the tuition costs paid for by the parents from September 9, 2004, to the date of this Decision.

B. Compensatory Education

In addition to reimbursement for services provided, Petitioner also requests compensatory education in the form of academic remedial tutoring, additional applied behavioral analysis, speech and language, and/or occupational therapy services. Petitioner couples this request with a request for prospective relief to (1) continue his home ABA program (including supervision and clinic hours) with a shadow aide in a District first grade classroom for the 2005-2006 school year, (2) provide two hours per week of clinic-based OT, plus one hour a month OT consultation, with the same provider; (3) provide three one-hour sessions a week of individual speech and language therapy, with the same provider; (4) provide one hour a week of social skills group, and (5) convene an IEP team meeting to develop a transition plan from Kindercare to the District’s first grade class at Chaparral, with STUDENT’s current service providers and staff from the District’s first grade class at Chaparral in attendance.

As previously indicated, when a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. Of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997). Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have also extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See, e.g. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3rd Cir. 1990) 916 F. 2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.) Compensatory education is an equitable remedy. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for-hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the Student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir.1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1497.

While the evidence demonstrates that STUDENT has received educational benefit from his home program, his need for compensatory services is still apparent. For example, in his March 2005 update assessment, Dr. Perlman reported that STUDENT continued to show significant social and attention issues as indicated from the parent’s completion of the BASC, and from his own observations of STUDENT at Kindercare, with his one-to-one aide. Specifically, Dr. Perlman noted that STUDENT was inattentive during circle time and tuned out his teacher completely except when she read a story. At the learning centers, he was on task for only three to five minutes, and “absent prompts by his shadow-aide, STUDENT began to disengage, space-out, and/or daydream.” Dr. Perlman observed that, “in all, STUDENT appeared to have difficulty with virtually all aspects of attention, beginning with general arousal.” As soon as STUDENT was seated, the frequency by which he required prompting increased. For example, during a fifteen-minute observation period, STUDENT required eight prompts to attend. A similar level of prompting “was not necessary during singing or during any of the circle time activities that involved standing and/or physical movement.” Socially, Dr. Perlman noted that STUDENT only rarely spontaneously engaged peers in conversation, but that he liked the proximity of peers and appeared excited when peers approached him. While STUDENT constantly verbalized, his communication was quite low. He sang to himself constantly even when peers tried to engage him, and peers appeared to be “put off” by his video-talk. While STUDENT’s academic skills as measured by the Kaufman Test of Educational Achievement (KTEA-II) revealed that, with few exceptions, STUDENT’s reading, math, written language, and listening comprehension skills all were in the average range, STUDENT demonstrated a pervasive lack of understanding. Dr. Perlman reported that, even when STUDENT’s attention was directed at his teacher, “unless directives were routine,” he rarely understood them, his responses were off-topic, and even though he “appeared to want to understand ... appeared to be totally confused as well.” On a positive note, STUDENT took cues by observing his peers. Similarly, while STUDENT made progress in speech and occupation therapy, the testimony of Ms. Francis and Ms. Shaffer established that he continued with significant areas of deficit.

The Hearing Officer finds that compensatory education is appropriate to compensate STUDENT for the denial of FAPE attributable to the District’s failure to timely refer him for an assessment at the end of October 2004. The Hearing Officer has previously determined that this denial resulted in a delay of approximately three months – from mid January 2004 to April 22, 2004 -- in STUDENT’s receiving any special education and related services. In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that compensatory education is appropriate to compensate STUDENT for the denial of FAPE from April 23, 2004, through the extended-ESY period in mid-August 2004, a period of approximately four months. The Hearing Officer finds that these denials of FAPE were particularly significant in light of STUDENT’s late diagnosis and well-established principles emphasizing the importance of early intervention services for an autistic child. In considering the seven month cumulative denial of FAPE, however, the Hearing Officer is also mindful that, by the order of reimbursement, STUDENT has already received approximately eleven months of intensive services from AIR.

To compensate for these denials of FAPE, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is entitled to an order for prospective relief maintaining his current placement and service configuration until the start of the 2005-2006 school year. Specifically, during this period, the District shall maintain and fund STUDENT’s program with AIR for up to thirty hours a week, including a one-to-one shadow aide at school, with an additional eight hours of supervision and twelve hours of clinic each month; costs of tuition at Kindercare, and two hours a month each of clinic based individual occupational therapy with Cheri Francis of Pediatric Therapy Solutions and speech therapy with Leora Shaffer of Speech Pathology Associates. In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is entitled to forty (40) hours of compensatory clinic-based occupational therapy, plus five hours of OT consultation, and forty (40) hours of compensatory individual speech and language therapy, with the same providers to ensure continuity of services. These compensatory services shall be used by the end of the 2006 extended school year, unless the parties agree otherwise. Finally, the Hearing Officer will order the District to convene an IEP team meeting to develop a transition plan for STUDENT from Kindercare to the District’s first grade class at Chaparral. The District shall invite STUDENT’s current service providers and staff from the District’s first grade class at Chaparral to attend this IEP meeting.

DISTRICT ISSUE SIX: Is the District entitled to assess Petitioner pursuant to the February 16, 2005 assessment plan?

It is undisputed that on February 16, 2005, the District prepared and provided an assessment plan to STUDENT’s parents seeking their consent for assessments in preparation for his annual and transition IEP that was due in late April 2005. Specifically, the District’s assessment plan identified the following areas for assessment: academic/pre-academic achievement; social/adaptive behavior; psycho-motor development “including sensory” assessment by the occupational therapist; communication development; intellectual/cognitive development; health assessment/development; and other: observation. In a letter to STUDENT’s parents dated February 17, 2005, District autism program specialist Jennifer Fant clarified that the observation referenced in the assessment plan would be in STUDENT’s current ABA program at both home and school. Because parental consent was not provided, the District seeks an order authorizing it to assess STUDENT without consent.

Under special education law, a reassessment of a student with a disability must be undertaken by the district “at least once every three years or more frequently, if conditions warrant....” 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(2); Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(a). Parental consent is required before a district can conduct the assessment, unless the district “can demonstrate that it had taken reasonable measures to obtain such consent and the child’s parent has failed to respond.” 20 U.S. C. § 1414 (c)(3); see, Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56381(f), 56506(e). If the parent refuses to consent to a proposed assessment, the District may request a special education due process hearing to determine whether it may proceed with the assessment without the consent of the parent. Cal. Educ. Code § 56501(a)(3). The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has held that if parents want their child to receive special education and related services, they must allow the responsible educational agency to assess their child. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist. (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307, 1315.

The District asserts that “conditions warrant” its assessment of STUDENT pursuant to the February 16, 2005 assessment plan because its has been nearly a full year since he has been in a District program and because he has allegedly made “amazing progress” in his private ABA home program and preschool placement. In response, Petitioner’s parents assert that STUDENT’s triennial is not due and that conditions do not current warrant additional assessment. In their view, STUDENT has been extensively assessed since March 2004 by a variety of District and independent assessors. In addition, Petitioner asserts that the District did not involve his parents in the development of the assessment plan.

The Hearing Officer has previously determined that the District has not offered STUDENT a FAPE. The Hearing Officer now finds that conditions warrant an assessment to provide the District with accurate knowledge of STUDENT’s current present levels of performance necessary to allow it to make an offer of FAPE. It is undisputed that STUDENT has not been in a District program since September 2004, a period that encompasses an academic year. In addition, according to all of his current home program and service providers, STUDENT has made tremendous strides in his home program, as well as in his speech and language and occupational therapy. In addition, several witnesses testified that some assessment of STUDENT is appropriate at this time. (For example, see testimony of Cheri Francis, Leora Shaffer, Gwenyth Chua).

Despite this finding, the Hearing Officer finds that an order for assessment is not appropriate at this time because the evidence established that the District failed to provide STUDENT’s parents with an opportunity to participate in the development of the assessment plan. Whenever a school district seeks to reevaluate a student with a disability, certain procedures must be followed. First, members of the IEP team and other qualified professionals, as appropriate, are required to review the existing assessment data, current classroom-based assessments and observations, and observations of teachers and related service providers. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(b)(1); 20 U.S.C. § 1414(c)(1)(A). Relying on the information obtained through this review and input from the student’s parents, the IEP team and appropriate qualified professionals shall identify what, if any, additional data are needed to determine, among other things, the student’s present levels of performance and educational needs, and whether additions or modifications to the student’s program are required to enable him/her to meet the measurable annual goals set out in the IEP and to participate, as appropriate, in the general curriculum. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(b)(2); 20 U.S.C. § 1414(c)(1)(B). From this review, the IEP team develops an assessment plan that should be focused on producing the data identified by the team as necessary to make determinations about the Student’s program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(c). The parents of an eligible student with a disability “shall be afforded an opportunity to participate in meetings with respect to the [Student’s] ... assessment ....” Cal. Educ. Code § 56304.

Parental input into the development of the assessment plan is of particular importance in this case precisely because STUDENT has been assessed by and received services from independent professionals whose observations and opinions can help guide the IEP team. For example, both Ms. Francis and Ms. Lin recommended that the District assess STUDENT’s sensory processing using the Sensory Integration Praxis Test (SIPT). Ms. Shaffer testified that some informal assessment of STUDENT would be appropriate at this time, but that a repetition of standardized tests she administered should be avoided. Both Ms. Moore and Ms. Renner acknowledge the need for a detailed assessment of STUDENT’s pragmatic skills.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer denies the request for an order authorizing assessment without parental consent at this time because the assessment plan was not developed in accordance with California Education Code sections 56304 and 56381(b)(1).

ORDER

1. Within twenty-five (25) calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting to accomplish the following:

a. develop a plan to transition STUDENT from his current placement at Kindercare into a first grade classroom at Chaparral for the 2005-2006 school year with input from STUDENT’s current service providers and staff from the first grade regular education class at Chaparral; and b. develop a schedule for implementation of compensatory education services, as identified in this Decision or as mutually agreed upon by the parties.

2. Within twenty-five (25) calendar days of receipt of proof of payment, the District shall reimburse the Petitioner’s parents for their costs for the following educational services incurred during the 2004 and 2005 calendar years through the date of this Decision that were not paid for by private insurance:

a. Occupational therapy assessment by Nancy Lin;

b. Occupational therapy services from Cheri Francis/Pediatric Therapy Solutions; c. Speech and language services from Speech Pathology Associates; d. Home program tuition and costs from Autism Intervention Services, including one-to-one aide, supervision hours and clinic hours. e. Costs of preschool tuition at Country Village Preschool and Kindercare.

3. The District shall provide STUDENT with the following services to compensate him for the denial of FAPE:

a. From the date of this Decision to the start of the 2005-2006 school year, the District shall maintain and pay for STUDENT’s current placement and services with Autism Intervention Resources for up to thirty hours a week, including one-to-one shadow aide at school, with eight hours for supervision and twelve hours for clinic per month; two hours a month each of clinic based individual occupational therapy with Cheri Francis of Pediatric Therapy Solutions and speech therapy with Leora Shaffer of Speech Pathology Associates; and costs of tuition at Kindercare;

b. forty hours of compensatory clinic-based occupational therapy, plus five hours of consultation services with Pediatric Therapy Solutions, to be provided by the end of the 2006 extended schoolyear unless otherwise agreed by the parties; and c. forty hours of compensatory individual speech and language therapy, with Leora Shaffer of Speech Pathology Associates; to be provided by the end of the 2006 extended school year unless otherwise agreed by the parties.

4. All of Petitioner’s remaining requests are denied.

5. The District’s request for an order authorizing its assessment of STUDENT is denied.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

The Petitioner/Cross-Respondent prevailed on the following issues:

Issue I Petitioner prevailed Issue II Petitioner partially prevailed on II C (2)

Issue III Petitioner substantially prevailed on III C (3)

Petitioner prevailed on III C (4) through III C (6)

Issue IV Petitioner prevailed Issue V Petitioner substantially prevailed Issue VI Petitioner prevailed

The Respondent/Cross-Petitioner prevailed on the following issues:

Issue II Responded prevailed on II A, II B, and II D, Respondent partially prevailed on II C Issue III Respondent prevailed on III A, III B, III C (1), (2), and (6), and on III (D)

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

Dated: July 8, 2005

_____________________________________ Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1 The issues as outlined in the prehearing conference order and as amended at the hearing have been reorganized for clarity of analysis. Issue 6 is the sole issue raised by the District

2 With limited exceptions not relevant to this case, the Individuals with Disabilities Education Improvement Act of 2004 (IDEIA) became effective on July 1, 2005. Consequently, all statutory references to federal special education law in this Decision are to the IDEA.

3 The District withdrew a proposed exhibit describing its policy on child find.

4 Ms. Boessler testified that she provided MOTHER and all parents with the District’s general handbook of rights. MOTHER acknowledged receiving this handbook, but testified that she did not recall anything in the general handbook that discussed what a parent should do if she suspected that her child had a disability. The District did not seek to introduce the general handbook and did not elicit any testimony regarding its contents.

5 AB 152, an omnibus bill to further align the California Education Code with the IDEA and its regulations, amended sections 56043 and 56344 to conform with 34 C.F.R. § 300.343. Pursuant to this amendment, a meeting to develop an initial IEP for a student must be conducted within thirty days of a determination that the child needs special education and related services. This amendment was not in effect until July 15, 2004, after the relevant events in this case.

6 The Hearing Officer finds no merit to the District’s assertion that it should not be responsible for the approximately one-month period between STUDENT’s diagnosis by Dr. Filipek on January 28, 2004, and the parents’ written request for a referral to the District on February 23, 2004, based on its theory that the parents did not want STUDENT“labeled” as a student with a disability.

7 As indicated below, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Chua did not assess STUDENT’s sensory motor skills. While testimony indicated that the Sensory Integration Praxis Test or SIPT was the best test to use for such an assessment and that Ms. Chua did not possess the requisite certification to administer or to interpret the SIPT, there was no evidence to establish that this was the only manner in which STUDENT’s sensory motor skills could be assessed by a licensed occupational therapist. 8 Petitioner also challenged Ms. Garrison’s failure to mention in her report that STUDENThad received three raw scores of zero on the WPPSI subtests for word reasoning, coding, and comprehension. Dr. Perlman testified that an individual subtest cannot be interpreted with a raw score of zero, but that the manufacturer allows inclusion of raw scores to compute a global score. Ms. Garrison testified that this asserted error had little practical effect on her test results. Because the District’s psychoeducational assessment is not at issue and the WPPSI was not used in the occupational therapy assessment, it is not necessary to address this claim.

9 The area of “sensory motor” was described in the testimony of independent occupational therapist Nancy Lin as how individuals receive/perceive sensory input from their environment and how their body processes that input by responding with praxis (motor planning). Praxis involves three steps of ideation, motor planning, and execution of a motor activity. Sensory motor responses are the result of sensory processing. In her assessment report, Ms. Lin indicated that “intact sensory processing is foundational for maintaining organized participation in school activities and routines.” 10 California’s regulations provide that “all pupils being assessed for initial and three-year review for special education services shall have had a hearing and vision screening, unless parental permission was denied.” Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3027.

11 Petitioner does not directly raise any LRE issues; however the District raises LRE in defense of its offer.

12 The IDEA lists the topics to be explained in the procedural safeguards as follows: independent educational evaluations; prior written notice; parental consent; access to educational records; opportunity to present complaints; placement during the pendency of due process proceedings; procedures for students subject to placement in an interim alternative educational setting; requirements for unilateral placement by parents of children in private schools at public expense; mediation; due process hearings, including requirements for disclosure of evaluation results and recommendations; State-level appeals, if applicable; civil actions; and attorneys’ fees. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(d)(2). Under State law, the notice of procedural safeguards must also include an explanation of the rights and procedures under Education Code section 56500, including information on the procedures for requesting an informal meeting, prehearing mediation conference, mediation conference, or due process hearing; the timelines for completing each process; whether the process is optional; and the type of representative who may be invited to participate.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(a).

13 On March 22, 2005, following discussion of the scope and appropriateness of this issue and written briefs by the parties at the District’s request, the Hearing Officer ruled that the Petitioner may not challenge the accuracy of provisions in the Notice that were not relevant to this hearing. For example, in his statement of issues and in the prehearing conference order, Petitioner asserted that the Notice was defective, including in areas relating to placement in an interim alternative educational setting, and that this should be considered by the Hearing Officer. It is well established that the Hearing Office does not have jurisdiction to issue declaratory judgments. See section III B, infra. Accordingly, these arguments are not considered.

14 The audiotape of the April 20, 2004 IEP team meeting indicates a wry comment by Petitioner’s attorney Mr. Roberts that otherwise the meeting “would go on forever.”

15 It is well-established that not all procedural violations constitute a denial of FAPE. However, “procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity, ... or seriously infringe the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process, ..clearly result in a denial of FAPE.” W.G. v. Bd. Of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479. At the hearing, including during clarification of issues, Petitioner argued that the District’s asserted defective notice of procedural safeguard constituted a denial of FAPE per se. In his closing brief, however, Petitioner asserted in a conclusory manner that his parents were seriously prejudiced by their inability to understand their rights as described by the District. Petitioner cannot now change his issue.

16 The Hearing Officer granted the District’s request to quash the appearance subpoena for Dr. Fleming, because there was no dispute that this memo was in effect and because the issue was the appropriateness of the policy within the facts of this case rather than Dr. Fleming’s interpretation of the letter.

17 In a letter dated May 27, 2004, the District’s attorney provided Petitioner with a copy of its “Operation Letter #1.9" outlining “Procedures Regarding Visitors/Outsiders” (Dist. Ex.33) that only allows twenty-minute observations. This Operational Letter implements Education Code section 51101(a)(1) and predates the equivalent opportunity amendment to section 56329. The purpose of this policy is to minimize interruption of classroom instruction by establishing rules for visitation including two days advance notice to teacher, an a time limit of twenty minutes “unless the principal believes there are compelling circumstances for a longer visitation.” In addition, the policy requires that the visitor be accompanied by a District employee throughout the observation.

18 Moreover, the Hearing Officer notes that Petitioner expressed concern over the fact that his parents had only received the District’s multidisciplinary report on April 20, 2004. This two-day hiatus would have allowed them time to read the reports and prepare for the April 22, 2004 meeting.

19 The Hearing Officer notes that while the District also offered STUDENT three attention/behavior goals, this was the only attention goal for which the occupational therapist had some responsibility.

20 The District’s goals were numbered at the hearing on District Exhibit 27, pp. D00200-00206.

21 In California, ESY services must be provided to students with handicaps which are likely to continue indefinitely or for a prolonged period and when “interruption of the pupil’s educational programming may cause regression, coupled with limited recoupment capacity, rendering it impossible or unlikely that the pupil will attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that would otherwise be expected in view of his or her handicapping condition.” Cal. Code Regs. tit 5, § 3043.