California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 18, 1999
Student v. Petaluma City Elementary School District et al.
SEHO Case No. SN 585-98 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote
Petaluma district and Sonoma County Office of Education denied a deaf student FAPE since 1995; placement search and compensatory sign instruction ordered.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The decision notes an earlier due process case, SN 197-97 (filed February 24, 1997), which settled through mediation and produced the summer 1997 ESY placement. No remand, vacatur or correction is noted.
Summary
A 10-year-old deaf student with significant developmental delays filed against the Petaluma City Elementary School District, the Sonoma County Office of Education (SCOE), Santa Rosa City Schools, the California School for the Deaf (CSD) and the California Department of Education (CDE). He argued he had never been taught an effective way to communicate. Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote barred claims before May 1995 under the three-year limitations period. Interpreters, Regional Center workers and rights notices had kept the parent informed. She found he was denied FAPE from May 1995 through the 1998-1999 school year. His classes lacked a teacher proficient in American Sign Language (ASL), signing peers at his developmental level, and qualified sign instruction. A preschool deaf class did not fit his age or needs. At La Fiesta Elementary, his aide had never received his behavior plan. CSD was not appropriate for now because he did not meet its admission criteria. She attributed that gap largely to the local agencies' failures. She denied daily speech therapy as a related service, punitive damages, an educational trust, and five extra years of services past age 21. Petaluma, SCOE and CDE must find a placement with listed features, in or out of state, by July 1, 1999. She also ordered daily one-to-one sign instruction, instruction during long breaks, transportation, and further compensatory services set by the IEP team through summer 2000.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied Education Code section 56000.5, California's findings on educating deaf children, alongside Rowley. Those findings call for teachers proficient in the child's language mode and peers of the same language, age and ability. It also shows a Hearing Officer bringing the state Department of Education into a placement search, in or out of state, when no local program fit.
Issues and holdings
Issue Procedural. Whether claims arising before May 4, 1995 (including the 1993-1994 school year) are barred by the three-year statute of limitations
Under Alexopulos, the three-year limitations period barred claims arising before May 1995; the parent had interpreters, Regional Center support and repeated rights notices, so she knew or had reason to know of the claims, and nothing tolled the period.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Did STUDENT receive a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1994-1995 school year?
From May 1995 forward, FAPE was denied: the student was ready to learn sign language but got no instruction from anyone qualified in sign language or deaf education, and he met none of his communication goals. Earlier claims were time-barred.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. Did STUDENT receive a FAPE during the 1995-1996 school year?
The Wilson SDC lacked a signing teacher, signing peers and qualified sign instruction. Thirty minutes a week of DHH consultation was not enough, and he made no more than minimal progress, so FAPE was denied.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 3. Did STUDENT receive a FAPE during the 1996-1997 school year?
The Wilson placement stayed substantially unchanged, did not meet the recommendations of the DHH teacher and the CSD assessor, and gave little benefit, so FAPE was denied. The 1997 ESY placement came from a mediated settlement and was not re-examined.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 4. Did STUDENT receive a FAPE during the 1997-1998 school year?
The Hidden Valley preschool deaf class did not fit his age, cognitive level or structure needs. At La Fiesta the teacher could not sign, there were no signing peers, and the aide had not received the behavior plan. FAPE was denied for the year.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 5. Did Respondents offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 1998-1999 school year?
Despite some recent gains with a deaf signing aide, the La Fiesta placement still lacked signing peers and a teacher proficient in ASL, and he had mastered no IEP goals, so FAPE was not offered.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 6. Should STUDENT be placed at the California School for the Deaf (CSD), Northern California, for the remainder of the 1998-1999 school year?
CSD is not currently an appropriate placement because the student does not meet all its admission criteria and its classes function above his level. The Hearing Officer found the gap was largely caused by the local agencies' failures.
- Not reachedFAPE: services offered
Issue 7a. If STUDENT should be placed at the CSD, does he require a one-to-one aide during all school hours while attending the CSD?
Not addressed because CSD was not found to be an appropriate placement.
- Not reachedFAPE: services offered
Issue 7b. If STUDENT should be placed at the CSD, does he require a one-to-one aide during all non-school hours while attending the CSD?
Not addressed because CSD was not found to be an appropriate placement.
- Not reachedFAPE: services offered
Issue 7c. If STUDENT should be placed at the CSD, does he require transportation services between his home and the CSD?
Not addressed because CSD was not found to be an appropriate placement.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 8. Does STUDENT require daily one-to-one speech and language therapy for 30 minutes per session?
No persuasive evidence showed he needed daily speech therapy as a related service, so the request was denied. Compensatory daily sign language instruction was handled under Issue 9.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 9a. What constitutes an appropriate placement for STUDENT?
Petaluma, SCOE and CDE must search within and outside California for a public or private placement with signing peers, a teacher proficient in ASL and other listed features, and place him by July 1, 1999. The current placement stays in place meanwhile.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 9b. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
Compensatory education was awarded for at least four years of denied FAPE: daily one-to-one sign instruction, instruction during long breaks, and other services the IEP team sets, through the 1999-2000 ESY. Five extra years past age 21 was denied as speculative.
- District prevailedThreshold and jurisdiction
Issue 9c. Is STUDENT entitled to punitive damages?
Punitive damages were denied: no statute or Ninth Circuit precedent allows them, and other circuits have held they are unavailable under the IDEA.
- District prevailedThreshold and jurisdiction
Issue 9d. Is STUDENT entitled to an educational trust fund?
The educational trust was denied because no authority supports it and the Petitioner did not explain what he meant by it.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 10 calendar days, Petaluma District must convene an IEP meeting including the parents, the classroom and DHH teachers, and SCOE and CDE representatives with expertise in educating deaf and developmentally delayed children. The team must set additional compensatory education (considering individual tutoring for the student and sign language instruction for the family) and choose a qualified provider and the daily length of compensatory sign instruction.
- Placement ordered. Right after the IEP meeting, Petaluma District, SCOE and CDE must find an appropriate public or private placement, in or out of state, with: signing peers at or near the student's age and developmental level; a teacher proficient in ASL; small-group and individual instruction; a low student-to-teacher ratio; a structured environment; specific ASL instruction; a structured behavioral intervention program; and a developmental-level curriculum covering independent living and social skills. The team may also take steps to make CSD appropriate. Petaluma and SCOE must enroll him no later than July 1, 1999 and maintain the placement through the 1999-2000 school year, including ESY.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Before July 1, 1999, Petaluma District must reconvene the IEP team to conform the IEP to the new placement and to consider revising the behavior intervention plan or writing a new one.
- Order to provide or change services. Petaluma District and SCOE must provide transportation between home and the school placement and, as appropriate, transportation for one parent to accompany the student.
- Compensatory education. Within 15 calendar days, Petaluma District and SCOE must begin daily individual sign language instruction by a person the IEP team finds qualified, for the rest of 1998-1999 (including ESY) and all of 1999-2000 (including ESY).
- Compensatory education. Within 15 calendar days, Petaluma District and SCOE must begin the additional compensatory services the IEP team sets to redress at least four years of denied FAPE, continuing through the 1999-2000 school year, including ESY.
- Compensatory education. Petaluma District and SCOE must provide individual sign language instruction and chances to practice signing during school breaks longer than 10 consecutive school days, through the summer 2000 ESY, by a person the IEP team finds qualified.
- If the student is placed outside the County, Petaluma District and SCOE remain responsible for locating and funding his compensatory services.
- Petaluma District and SCOE must keep the current placement, including the one-to-one aide, IEP services and compensatory services, until an appropriate placement meeting the ordered criteria is in place.
Key authorities
Rowley; Alexopulos v. San Francisco Unified School District; Wilson v. Garcia; Dreher v. Amphitheater Unified School District; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Capistrano Unified School District v. Wartenberg; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District; W.G. v. Target Range School District; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. Missouri; Todd D. v. Andrews; Heidemann v. Rother; Charlie F. v. Board of Education of Skokie; W.B. v. Matula; Education Code § 56000.5; Education Code § 59020
People named in the decision
- Gerald Klor, director of special services, Petaluma City Elementary School District
- Anita Ruesterholtz, director of special education, Sonoma County Office of Education
- Jacob Arcanin, assistant superintendent; witness, California School for the Deaf, Northern California
- Alan Kerzin, executive director; filed prior hearing request SN 197-97, Area IV Developmental Disabilities Board
- Cecilia Rossell, interpreter for parent, North Bay Regional Center
- Carmen Lish, interpreter for parent, North Bay Regional Center
- Nimrod Bonifacio, administrative assistant to Student's counsel; interpreter, Ruderman, Varma, & Clancy
- Teresa Poblete, certified Spanish language interpreter (hearing)
- John Marquez, certified Spanish language interpreter (hearing)
- Paz Perry, certified Spanish language interpreter (hearing)
- Tim O'Brien, special education teacher, SDC-SH at La Fiesta Elementary, Sonoma County Office of Education
- Jarvis McAllister, 1:1 signing aide (deaf, ASL user), La Fiesta Elementary SDC
- Jill Kantor, deaf and hard of hearing (DHH) teacher and assessor, Sonoma County Office of Education
- Jeri Maldonado, deaf and hard of hearing (DHH) teacher, Sonoma County Office of Education
- Ann Moxley, Ph.D., clinical psychologist and assessor, Northern California Assessment Center, California School for the Deaf
- Sharon Vickers, former principal of the infant, preschool and elementary programs; IEP coordinator, California School for the Deaf, Northern California
- Laureen Newman Feldhorn, credentialed teacher of the deaf, Hidden Valley DHH preschool class, Santa Rosa City School District program
- Lauren Taylor, speech and language pathologist, Sonoma County Office of Education
- Roberta Jue, speech and language pathologist and assessor, Sonoma County Office of Education
- Patricia Balthazor, private speech-language pathologist; expert witness for Student
- Ronnie Dietrick, Ph.D., clinical psychologist; expert witness for Student, Spectrum (nonpublic agency)
- Francie Tipon, principal, Sonoma County Office of Education
- Sara Vera, 1:1 aide at Hidden Valley, Hidden Valley Elementary DHH preschool program
- Andrew Bailey, conducted functional analysis assessment and wrote behavioral intervention plan, On Our Own (nonpublic agency)
- Mr. Rosshirt, administrator responsible for special education services, Santa Rosa City School District
- On Our Own, nonpublic agency (functional analysis assessment/BIP)
- Spectrum, nonpublic agency
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Petaluma, California, on August 25-28, September 24, 25, and 28, October 15, 16, 20, and 21, and November 13, 1998. Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorneys F. Richard Ruderman and Geralyn Clancy of Ruderman, Varma, & Clancy. Also present on behalf of Petitioner was his MOTHER. Petitioner, as well as, Petitioner’s FATHER and BROTHERS were present on the first day of hearing. Also present on different days during the course of the hearing to interpret for MOTHER and her attorneys were Cecilia Rossell and Carmen Lish from the North Bay Regional Center, and Nimrod Bonifacio, administrative assistant to Mr. Ruderman and Ms. Clancy.
Respondent Petaluma City Elementary School District (Petaluma District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Lenore A. Silverman of Ed-Law. Also present on behalf of the Petaluma District was Gerald Klor, director of special services. Respondents Santa Rosa City School District (Santa Rosa District) and Sonoma County Office of Education (SCOE) were represented at the hearing by attorney Joseph C. Kinkade of School & College Legal Services. Also present on the first day of the hearing on behalf of the SCOE was Anita Ruesterholtz, director of special education. Respondents California School for the Deaf, Northern California (CSD), and California Department of Education (CDE) were represented at the hearing by Edmundo Aguilar, deputy general counsel for the CDE. Also present on behalf of CSD was Jacob Arcanin, assistant superintendent. Certified Spanish language interpreter Teresa Poblete provided interpreter services on all of the days of the hearing except for two. Certified Spanish language interpreters John Marquez and Paz Perry each provided interpreter services for one day of the hearing.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments, the case was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES (footnote 1)
(1) Did STUDENT receive a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1994-1995 school year?
(2) Did STUDENT receive a FAPE during the 1995-1996 school year?
(3) Did STUDENT receive a FAPE during the 1996-1997 school year?
(4) Did STUDENT receive a FAPE during the 1997-1998 school year?
(5) Did Respondents offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 1998-1999 school year?
(6) Should STUDENT be placed at the California School for the Deaf (CSD), Northern California, for the remainder of the 1998-1999 school year?
(7) If so, does STUDENT require:
(a) a one-to-one aide during all school hours while attending the CSD? (b) a one-to-one aide during all non-school hours while attending the CSD? (c) transportation services between his home and the CSD?
(8) Does STUDENT require daily one-to-one speech and language therapy for 30 minutes per session?
(9) What are appropriate remedies if the Petaluma District and the SCOE failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE?
(a) What constitutes an appropriate placement for STUDENT?
(b) Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
(c) Is STUDENT entitled to punitive damages?
(d) Is STUDENT entitled to an educational trust fund?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
Petitioner raised as issue for hearing whether he has received a FAPE from the 1993-1994 school year to the present. Respondents objected to the adjudication of any issues arising prior to May 4,1995, because Petitioner failed to request a due process hearing regarding the 1993-1994 school year until May 4, 1998. Respondents contend that a three-year statue of limitations applies to special education matters and that any claims that arose prior to May 4, 1995, are time-barred.
At the time Petitioner filed this request for hearing, neither state special education law nor the federal Individuals with Disabilities Act contained a specific statute of limitations for initiating special education due process hearing procedures. (Footnote 2) In the absence of such a statute, a court must identify the state cause of action that is most analogous to the federal statute and adopt its limitation period if it is consistent with the policy of the federal cause of action. Wilson v. Garcia (1985) 471 U.S. 261, 266-267, 105 S.Ct. 1983. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has previously held that the three-year statue of limitations contained in Code of Civil Procedure § 338(a) applies to claims brought under IDEA in California. (Footnote 3) See Alexopulos v. San Francisco Unified School District (9th Cir. 1987) 817 F.2d 551, 555. In Alexopulos, the Court held that a cause of action accrues and the statute of limitations begins to run when the plaintiff knows or has reason to know of the facts underlying it. Id. at 555. (Footnote 4)
The enactment of IDEA 1997 gave rise to the question of whether a four-year statute of limitations might apply to claims arising under IDEA 1997 pursuant to the Judicial Improvements Act of 1990. (Public Law 101-650) Section 1658 of the Judicial Improvements Act adopts a uniform statute of limitations of four years for claims created by Congress after December 1, 1990, the effective date of the Act. 28 U.S. C. § 1658. Any question about whether the enactment of IDEA 1997 changed the applicable statute of limitations need not be resolved here. In accordance with the general rules against retroactive application of laws, the law in effect at the time the disputed issues applies in this case. Langraff v. USI Film Products (1994) 511 U.S. 244. Therefore, the three-year statute of limitations established in Alexopulos would apply for those issues occurring prior to enactment of IDEA 1997. Whether a three-year or four-year statute of limitations applies to claims accruing under IDEA 1997 (i.e., claims related to the 1997-1998 and 1998-1999 school years) is irrelevant in this case because Petitioner filed his request for hearing on May 4, 1998. Therefore, pursuant to Alexopulos, the three-year period of limitations runs from the time that the Petitioner knew or had reason to know of the facts underling the cause of action. In this case, it must be determined when MOTHER knew or had reason to know of the facts that provide the basis for claims related to STUDENT’s education under the IDEA.
MOTHER contends that she was not aware of her rights as a parent of a child eligible for special education services until she was so informed in January 1997 by Alan Kerzin, executive director of Area IV Developmental Disabilities Board. In support of her contention, MOTHER raised the fact that she speaks Spanish and requires an interpreter to communicate with persons speaking other than Spanish and to translate documents that are not written in Spanish. She asserted that not all information related to STUDENT’s individualized educational program (IEP) was interpreted for her.
The evidence establishes that interpreters were present at STUDENT’s IEP meetings. STUDENT’s initial IEP from Sonoma County, which is dated November 23, 1993, is written in English; however, the signatures on the document indicating those in attendance at the IEP meeting, include an individual who identified himself as “interpreter.” (Petitioner’s Exhibits at 72.) Subsequent IEPs also indicate that an interpreter was present at each meeting and some of the IEPs are written in Spanish. The IEPs also indicate that Petitioner’s case managers from the North Bay Regional Center (Regional Center) accompanied MOTHER to the meetings. (Petitioner’s Exhibits at 3, 23, 34, 36, 48, 57, and 68.) IEP meetings have been held annually or more frequently. One of the responsibilities of the Regional Center is to provide advocacy to secure educational services and other benefits to which their clients are entitled. See Welfare and Institutions Code §4685(c)(1). Additionally, a box is checked on the IEPs indicating that the parent had received the Summary of Parent Information, Rights, and Appeals Procedures and that they were explained to her. (Petitioner’s Exhibits at 3, 36, 48, 57, and 72.) The Hearing Officer notes also that MOTHER attended IEP meetings while STUDENT was enrolled in the Vista Unified School District, beginning in January 1991. Some of the IEP documents are in Spanish and all indicate that MOTHER had received a copy of parental rights. (See e.g. Petitioner’s Exhibits at 125.)
The evidence also establishes that a due process hearing request was filed on February 24, 1997, on behalf of STUDENT by Mr. Kerzin. (SN 197-97) It is the practice of the Hearing Office to include a written copy of procedural safeguards with the notice of hearing dates sent to the parties. Thus, MOTHER would have received information regarding special education rights in January 1997. Moreover, Petitioner could have pursued relief for prior school years at the time of the filing in SN 197-97 and did not do so.
Based on the fact that Petitioner’s parent was provided with Spanish language interpretation at IEP meetings, was accompanied to IEP meetings by Regional Center workers, advocates, and/or an attorney, and was informed of her rights on multiple occasions, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner’s parent knew or had reason to know of the alleged injury and the right to due process at or near the time the alleged injury occurred. There was no evidence to substantiate a tolling of the statute of limitations. Therefore, the three-year statute of limitations adopted by Alexopulos applies to bar Petitioner’s claims originating prior to May 1995 and Petitioner’s IDEA claims arising prior to May 1995.
BACKGROUND FACTS
Petitioner STUDENT is a 10-year-old student who is eligible for special education because of a profound bilateral hearing loss and developmental delays. STUDENT’s cognitive skills have been described as “mildly to moderately” delayed. (Footnote 5) He also has mild cerebral palsy and a seizure disorder, which may be related to his having meningitis when he was approximately five months old. STUDENT currently attends a special day class for students with significant disabilities (SDC-SH) at La Fiesta Elementary School. The class is taught by Tim O’Brien. STUDENT receives the following services pursuant to his IEP: a full-time one-to-one signing aide (Jarvis McAllister); direct speech and language therapy 30 minutes weekly; adapted physical education (APE) consultation for 30 minutes weekly; occupational therapy (OT) collaboration for 15 to 30 minutes weekly; and deaf and hard of hearing (DHH) consultation for two hours weekly. A behavioral intervention plan (BIP) was developed for STUDENT in November 1997. (Footnote 6) (Petitioner’s Exhibits at 169 to 182.) STUDENT’s IEP includes goals and objectives to improve gross motor skills, behavior, self-help skills, language, and cognition. Additional goals are specifically designed to increase STUDENT’s receptive and expressive sign language vocabulary, to increase making simple requests and correct responses to simple questions, to improve oral motor skills, and to string signed words together. (Petitioner’s Exhibits at 3 to 30.)
STUDENT was initially determined eligible for special education in January 1991. He attended school in the Vista Unified School District in southern California prior to moving with his family to Petaluma in approximately April 1993. STUDENT’s educational program at Vista immediately before he moved to Petaluma included placement in an SDC, weekly speech and language therapy, and twice-weekly APE. (See Petitioner’s Exhibits at 88-129.) It is unclear whether STUDENT received any educational services from April 1993 until the fall of 1993, when STUDENT was enrolled pursuant to a 30-day interim placement in an SDC-SH operated by the SCOE. The SDC was located on the campus of Valley Vista, an elementary school within the Petaluma District. STUDENT’s IEP at the end of the 30-day interim placement, which is dated November 23, 1993, continued STUDENT’s placement in the SDC-SH and added the weekly services of 60 minutes of speech and language consultation and 30 minutes of adapted physical education (APE). (Petitioner’s Exhibits at 72.) Following an assessment by Jill Kantor, an SCOE DHH teacher, the IEP team adopted her recommendations and added 15 minutes of DHH consultative services to STUDENT’s IEP in June 1994.
For the 1994-1995 school year, STUDENT entered an SDC-SH operated by the SCOE at McKinley Elementary School, which is within the Petaluma District. STUDENT’s IEP dated December 15, 1994, indicates that he was entitled to weekly consultative services of 30 minutes of DHH, 40 minutes of speech and language therapy, and 30 minutes of APE. (Petitioner’s Exhibits at 57.)
For the 1995-1996 school year, STUDENT attended an SDC-SH at Wilson Elementary, which is located within the Wilmar Union Elementary School District. In January 1996, Ms. Kantor reassessed STUDENT. STUDENT’s IEP developed in January 1996 calls for weekly DHH consultation for 30 minutes, speech and language direct/consultation services for 30 minutes, and APE consultation for 30 minutes. At an IEP meeting in June 1996, STUDENT’s DHH services were increased to 45 minutes each week of direct services.
STUDENT continued to attend the SDC at Wilson during the 1996-1997 school year. STUDENT’s IEP indicates that APE continued at the same level, DHH services were increased to 120 minutes per week, and speech and language was increased to 60 minutes of direct and consultative services. Additionally, the IEP calls for a full-time one-to-one signing interpreter. In October 1996, the Petaluma District and SCOE referred STUDENT to the Northern California Assessment Center, which is located at the California School for the Deaf in Fremont (CSD).
On February 24, 1997, a due process hearing was requested on behalf of STUDENT. (Case No. SN 197-97.) The Northern California Assessment Center at the School for the Deaf completed an assessment of STUDENT during the week of May 12 through May 16, 1997. (Petitioner’s Exhibits at 192.) Pursuant to a mediation agreement reached in SN 197-97, STUDENT was placed for the extended school year program (ESY) during the summer of 1997 in a DHH class for preschool students. The class was located at Lincoln Elementary School in the Santa Rosa District. For the 1997-1998 school year, STUDENT continued in the preschool SDC for DHH students. During the regular school year, the program was located at Hidden Valley Elementary School, which also is within the Santa Rosa District. STUDENT’s IEP dated August 21, 1997, added four hours per week of “sign language support” and continued speech and language and APE. DHH services were discontinued because the class was taught by a teacher credentialed to teach deaf students. Because of behavioral problems STUDENT experienced shortly after the beginning of the school year, SCOE contracted with On Our Own, a nonpublic agency (NPA), to conduct a functional analysis assessment (FAA) of STUDENT’s behavior and to develop a BIP. The report of the FAA and the BIP were completed on November 10, 1997. (Petitioner’s Exhibits at 169 to 182.) On February 17, 1998, the CSD informed STUDENT’s parents that he was not eligible to attend CSD.
At an IEP meeting on February 11, 1998, the IEP team agreed to change STUDENT’s placement from Hidden Valley to an SDC-SH at La Fiesta Elementary School. La Fiesta is located within the Cotati-Rohnert Park Unified School District. The SDC-SH is operated by the SCOE. The IEP team also added 120 minutes each week of DHH and increased weekly speech and language services to 60 minutes. The IEP indicates that speech and language therapy would be done by a therapist using American sign language (ASL). (Petitioner’s Exhibits at 21 to 30.) Another IEP meeting was convened on March 27, 1998. The IEP team agreed to additional goals and objectives and to the services set forth in the first paragraph above under “Background Facts.” The IEP states that MOTHER consented to the placement “but feels [STUDENT’s] communication needs are not being met.”
On May 5, 1998, Petitioner requested a second due process hearing. Petitioner contends that since moving to Petaluma, he has not had meaningful access to his educational program because he has not been taught an effective means to communicate. Petitioner contends that there is not an appropriate placement available for him in the Sonoma County SELPA and that, because the CSD offers an appropriate program for students who are deaf, he should be placed there.
Respondents Petaluma District and SCOE contend that appropriate placements have been made available to STUDENT since he entered the District. The CSD contends that it does not have an appropriate placement for STUDENT. Respondents assert that STUDENT’s primary needs are related to his substantial developmental delays rather than to his being deaf and that, for this reason, STUDENT requires an educational program that focuses on functional and self-help skills.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Did STUDENT receive a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1994-1995 school year?
Under both state law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400; California Education Code § 56000.) The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18).)
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the students’ abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Rowley, 458 at 207-208.)
In determining whether the school district has offered a FAPE, the focus is on the adequacy of the district’s proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview School District (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307. If the district has offered a FAPE, the district is not required to place the student in the program preferred by the parents, even if their preferred program is likely to result in greater educational benefit to the student than the district’s program. Id.
In summary, under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student's unique needs, provide the student with some educational benefit, and conform with the IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176.)
California has adopted additional provisions specifically related to students who are deaf. Education Code § 56000.5(b) provides:
(1) Deafness involves the most basic of human needs--the ability to communicate with other human beings. . . .It is essential for the well-being and growth of hard-of-hearing and deaf children have appropriate, ongoing, and fully accessible educational opportunities.
(2) It is essential that hard-of-hearing and deaf children, like all children, have an education in which their unique communication mode is respected, utilized, and developed to an appropriate level of proficiency.
(3) It is essential that hard-of-hearing and deaf children have an education in which special education teachers, psychologists, speech therapists, assessors, administrators, and other special education personnel understand the unique nature of deafness and are specifically trained to work with hard-of-hearing and deaf pupils. It is essential that hard-of-hearing and deaf children have an education in which their special education teachers are proficient in the primary language mode of those children.
(4) It is essential that hard-of-hearing and deaf children, like all children, have an education with a sufficient number of language mode peers with whom they can communicate directly and who are of the same, or approximately the same, age and ability level.
(5) It is essential that hard-of-hearing and deaf children have an education in which their parents and, where appropriate, hard-of-hearing and deaf people are involved in determining the extent, content, and purpose of programs.
(6) Hard-of-hearing and deaf children would benefit from an education in which they are exposed to hard-of-hearing and deaf role models.
It has been determined above that claims prior to May 1995 are barred by the statute of limitations; however, it is necessary to address the 1994-1995 school year to determine whether STUDENT received a FAPE from May 1995 through the end of the school year, including the extended school year (ESY). It is STUDENT’s position that he did not receive an appropriate education during that period because his unique and individual language needs were not met. STUDENT asserts that he required instruction in sign language from a qualified professional to access instruction and to benefit from his education. Respondents Petaluma District and the SCOE contend that during the 1994-1995 school year, STUDENT’s multiple seizures and poor attentional skills precluded him from benefitting from sign language instruction. They assert that a combination of a picture communication book, the use of some signed words, and gestures sufficiently addressed STUDENT’s communication needs.
It is necessary to have an understanding of STUDENT’s unique and individual needs to determine whether Respondents have offered STUDENT a FAPE at all relevant periods at issue. There is no dispute that STUDENT has a profound hearing loss. Hearing aids have been tried; however, they have not proven successful and, in any case, their use would not result in STUDENT’s hearing sufficiently to discern spoken language or to develop speech. Ann Moxley, Ph.D., the clinical psychologist who conducted an assessment of STUDENT in May of 1997 at the Northern California Assessment Center for the Deaf and Hard of Hearing, concluded that STUDENT has a neurological impairment that also results in seizures, motor problems, and cognitive limitations. At the heart of the dispute are conflicting opinions of STUDENT’s “primary” disability and the extent of his “cognitive limitations.” The parties argue that this dispute is relevant to determining the type of educational program STUDENT requires to receive a FAPE. Petitioner contends that his primary disability is deafness and that his cognitive potential cannot be fully determined because he has never participated in an educational program that has adequately addressed his language needs. Respondents contend that Petitioner’s primary disability is related to mild to moderately delayed cognitive functioning.
Respondents’ witnesses did not agree on STUDENT’s “primary” disability. For example, Jill Kantor, SCOE teacher of the deaf and hard of hearing (DHH), supported Petitioner’s position that his “first” or “primary disability” is deafness. (Footnote 7) Witnesses from the CSD focused on STUDENT as a student with mild to moderate delayed cognitive functioning. (Testimony of Dr. Moxley and Sharon Vickers, former principal for the CSD.) It is unnecessary to determine STUDENT’s “primary” disability. Once STUDENT was determined eligible for special education, the District was required to address his unique and individual needs, if doing so was necessary for him to benefit from his education. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 188-189; Capistrano Unified School District v. Wartenberg (9th Cir. 1995) 59 F.3d 884. In Wartenberg, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal concluded that the school district was required to address the emotional needs of the student regardless of his eligibility designation. Thus, in this case, the Petaluma District was responsible for ensuring that STUDENT received an educational program that addressed his needs as a student who is deaf, cognitively impaired, and who also has motor deficits. (Footnote 8) As discussed below, during subsequent school years, STUDENT also exhibited behavioral problems.
Assessments completed just prior to STUDENT’s IEP dated December 15, 1994, provide specific information regarding STUDENT’s needs during the 1994-1995 school year. (Footnote 9) The evidence establishes that during the 1994-1995 school year, when STUDENT was six years old, his cognitive and adaptive skills fell at a developmental age of two years to two years and four months. Social skills were described as a “relative strength.” STUDENT’s receptive language skills fell within the range of 13 to 15 months, and his expressive language skills fell within the 17- to 20-month range. The speech pathologist who assessed STUDENT described his communication skills as “pre-receptive” and “pre-expressive.” (Petitioner’s Exhibits at 214 - 221.) A summary of STUDENT’s then-present levels of performance is also set forth in his IEP dated December 15, 1994. The IEP states that STUDENT knew the routine of the class. He was described as “having an excellent memory and being impatient when waiting for his turn.” In academic areas, STUDENT was able to do some sorting. In self-help areas, STUDENT was having an average of one toileting accident per month. He was able with prompting to put on clothing and to wash his hands. The IEP also states that STUDENT loved being in a group and was able to sit in a group for “20 to 30 minutes without getting up and eloping.” (Petitioner’s Exhibits at 59.) Based on this evidence, it is concluded that STUDENT’s significant deficits fell in the areas of receptive and expressive language, adaptive skills, and cognition.
The importance of STUDENT’s learning sign language to address receptive and expressive language deficits and as a means of communication was discussed by a number of witnesses called by the several parties. Laureen Newman Feldhorn, credentialed teacher of the deaf, testified that STUDENT required sign language instruction as part of an appropriate educational program. Ms. Newman Feldhorn was STUDENT’s teacher in the fall of 1997 and previously was employed at the CSD. Lauren Taylor, SCOE speech and language pathologist who has provided STUDENT with speech and language therapy, concurred with the testimony of Ms. Newman Feldhorn. Roberta Jue, SCOE speech and language pathologist, who had assessed STUDENT in November 1993 and December 1994, recommended that STUDENT receive two 20-minute sessions weekly of direct speech and language therapy and 20 minutes weekly of consultation services to focus on increasing STUDENT’s ability to sign names, pictures, and objects and increasing communication of wants and needs through signing. (Petitioner’s Exhibits at 214 - 215.) It is also noted that included in Ms. Jue’s recommendations in 1993 was for the classroom staff to consult with the DHH specialist as to the kind of sign language to teach STUDENT. (Petitioner’s Exhibits at 237.) Witnesses testifying on behalf of CSD, including Dr. Moxley and Joseph Arcanin, assistant superintendent of CSD, concurred that STUDENT required sign language as a component of his educational program. They did not agree with recommendations made the following school year that STUDENT required emersion in a program with deaf peers.
Patricia Balthazor testified on behalf of Petitioner. Ms. Balthazor is a speech and language pathologist in private practice. Ronnie Dietrick, Ph.D., also testified on behalf of Petitioner. Dr. Dietrick is a clinical psychologist employed by Spectrum, a nonpublic agency. Ms. Balthazor and Dr. Dietrick testified that cognitive development is related to language and that STUDENT’s ability to develop cognitive skills has been compromised because he has not been taught language. Ms. Balthazor explained that when a child does not have language, there is no system to organize information and that, therefore, whatever information that is taken in, goes to short-term memory rather than being stored in long-term memory for later use.
The essentially undisputed testimony discussed above establishes that a component of an appropriate program for STUDENT included instruction in sign language. There was consensus among the witnesses that American Sign Language (ASL) is the appropriate mode of communication for STUDENT because Signing Exact English (SEE) is too complicated for STUDENT. (Footnote 10) (Testimony of Ms. Balthazor, Petitioner’s expert; Ms. Kantor and Jeri Maldonado, SCOE DHH teachers; and Dr. Moxley, CSD assessor.)
Ms. Kantor testified that she advocated for STUDENT’s placement with deaf peers, a signing teacher, and instruction in sign language beginning in 1996; however, Ms. Kantor also testified to her belief that during the 1994-1995 school year, STUDENT would not have benefitted from instruction in sign language. She testified that STUDENT did not require direct DHH services during the 1994-1995 school year because he was having multiple seizures, which affected his ability to learn and to attend. She described STUDENT as “lacking focus and attention” and as being “visually distractible.” In her opinion, STUDENT could not sufficiently sustain his attention to learn signs. Ms. Kantor testified that STUDENT was having up to 20 petit mal seizures daily; however, she admitted personally having seen only one seizure that lasted approximately 10 seconds. Her understanding regarding the number of seizures STUDENT was having was based on information from his teacher, who did not testify at the hearing. A summary by a school nurse of STUDENT’s health in November 1994 does indicate that STUDENT was experiencing seizures, which she described as “partially controlled by medication.” (Petitioner’s Exhibits at 216.)
Francie Tipon, SCOE principal, observed STUDENT’s class every two weeks during the 1994-1995 school year. She contradicted Ms. Kantor’s testimony regarding STUDENT’s seizures. Ms. Tipon testified that she did not recall STUDENT’s seizures “being an issue” and had not observed STUDENT to have any seizures during her frequent visits to his class. She did observe STUDENT’s teacher signing to him and STUDENT imitating signs. Ms. Tipon also observed STUDENT using gestures and picture symbols to communicate. The reports of several assessments and STUDENT’s IEP, all of which were written in November of 1994, are consistent with Ms. Tipon’s testimony and also contradict Ms. Kantor’s recollection of STUDENT’s ability to focus and attend during the 1994-1995 school year. These documents describe STUDENT as being able to maintain eye contact, attend, respond to stimuli, and to imitate despite seizure activity. The school psychologist stated in her report that STUDENT “maintains increased eye contact.” (Petitioner’s Exhibits at 221.) STUDENT’s IEP dated December 15, 1994, also states that STUDENT “[is] very aware of facial expressions. . .imitates people in a funny way.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit at 59.) The speech and language evaluator, Ms. Jue, reported that STUDENT was generally aware, localized and searched mainly through the mode of vision, attended and maintained eye contact, was able to respond to stimuli, followed signed commands, responded to stimuli, gestures, and imitated. He also was beginning to answer signed questions, to imitate signal sequences, and to combine signals. An earlier report prepared by Ms. Jue in November 1993 states that STUDENT was utilizing “eye-contact to gain another’s attention” and that he was “adept at reading contextual cues in his environment.” (Petitioner’s Exhibits at 236.) Of the two witnesses who testified regarding their direct observations of STUDENT and of his educational program during the 1994-1995 school year, the Hearing Officer finds Ms. Tipon’s testimony persuasive because her testimony is based on numerous direct observations of STUDENT in class and because her testimony is supported by reports of STUDENT’s functioning made by a speech and language pathologist and a school psychologist contemporaneous to Ms. Tipon’s observations. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT possessed sufficient skills during the 1994-1995 school year to be engaged in a program to teach him sign language. As to the appropriateness of the program provided to STUDENT during the 1994-1995 school year, Ms. Maldonado testified that a trained sign language instructor would have been necessary to teach STUDENT language. She testified that because of STUDENT’s motor difficulties, it would have been difficult for someone not specifically trained to work with deaf individuals or qualified to teach sign language to recognize STUDENT’s precursors to signs or emerging signs. Thus, in Ms. Maldonado’s opinion, STUDENT would not have received appropriate encouragement or support in his learning to sign from staff who were not specialists in teaching deaf students. Ms. Taylor, a speech and language pathologist who has provided services to STUDENT, also testified that instruction should have been provided by professionals who have an understanding of how language is developed and who, themselves, sign. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Maldonado’s testimony persuasive regarding STUDENT’s need for qualified staff to address his needs as a deaf student. Ms. Maldonado is a qualified DHH teacher and has worked with STUDENT. Moreover, the need for qualified personnel to work with deaf students was recognized by the State as “essential.” Education Code § 56000.5(b)(3) states that it is essential that deaf children have an education in which special education teachers, psychologists, speech therapists, assessors, administrators, and other special education personnel understand the unique nature of deafness and are specifically trained to work with hard-of-hearing and deaf pupils.
In STUDENT’s case, despite the findings above, recommendations from the speech and language pathologists, and STUDENT’s readiness to learn to sign, STUDENT did not receive instruction from an individual qualified to teach sign language or from someone with expertise in educating students who are deaf. Ms. Kantor testified that STUDENT’s teacher was not proficient at sign language and there was no evidence that the teacher had specific training to work with deaf students. Ms. Kantor did not provide STUDENT with direct services during the 1994-1995 school year. Her services were limited to assisting STUDENT with his hearing aids and there was no evidence that she consulted with the teacher or other school staff regarding a sign language program for STUDENT.
In conclusion, the evidence establishes that STUDENT’s educational program during the 1994-1995 school year was deficient because it failed to address adequately his most fundamental need to develop receptive and expressive language skills. Furthermore, while STUDENT did meet IEP objectives related to drawing a line, cutting a strip of paper, touching his name when given three choices, and putting on his shoes, he did not meet the one goal and four objectives on his IEP to improve receptive and expressive communication skills. Given the lack of appropriate staff, services, and instruction in sign language, it is not surprising that STUDENT did not meet these goals and objectives. Therefore, because the program STUDENT received did not satisfy the requirements of the IDEA and Rowley, it is concluded that STUDENT did not receive a FAPE during the 1994-1995 school year.
ISSUE NO. 2: Did STUDENT receive a FAPE during the 1995-1996 school year?
As stated above, an appropriate educational program must (a) be designed to meet the student’s unique and individual needs, (b) provide the student with some educational benefit, and (c) conform with the student’s IEP. Petitioner contends that for the 1995-1996 school year his educational program was not appropriate because it failed to address adequately his communication needs. Petitioner asserts that his lack of communication skills precluded him from meaningful access to instruction. Petitioner asserts that an appropriate program for this school year would have included signing peers, a teacher proficient in sign language, and curriculum at his developmental level. Respondents maintain that Petitioner’s needs were met in the SDC-SH classroom at Wilson Elementary School and through speech and language and DHH services provided by SCOE. Respondents assert that STUDENT did not require a class with deaf peers and that he benefitted from placement with a heterogenous population and from instruction and materials provided at his developmental level.
Regarding STUDENT’s unique and individual needs during the 1995-1996 school year, when assessed in January 1996, STUDENT’s receptive language skills fell within the 13 to 16 month range and his expressive language skills fell within the 18 to 21 month range. (Petitioner’s Exhibits at 210 - 211.) Each of these scores represents growth of approximately one month from the assessment the prior year. They also continue to show that STUDENT had significant deficits in receptive and expressive language. STUDENT also continued to exhibit significant cognitive delays. STUDENT’s present levels of performance as described on his IEP dated January 11, 1996, indicate that he had good imitation skills and was beginning to interact in a more “communicative manner.” STUDENT’s eye contact had increased, he was imitating signs on his own, and he was beginning to play and work alongside peers during small-group activities. (Footnote 11) (Testimony of Ms. Kantor, the DHH teacher, and Petitioner’s Exhibits at 48-55.) Ms. Kantor testified that during the 1995-1996 school year, she “changed her mind” about STUDENT and concluded that he was, in fact, capable of learning sign language. The evidence establishes that STUDENT’s needs remained essentially unchanged from the prior school year and that STUDENT continued to require a program that included instruction in sign language by a qualified person and instruction to address developmental deficits.
In the middle of the 1995-1996 school year, Ms. Kantor raised for the first time that STUDENT required an educational program that offered him a teacher who signs and access to peers who sign. In her report dated January 11, 1996, Ms. Kantor stated that because “there is a minimal amount of sign language used in class or home, he [STUDENT] has not had the opportunity to use signs in a conversational mode.” She estimated that STUDENT knew ten signs, which represented the only language input STUDENT received. Ms. Kantor also stated that “since STUDENT cannot understand oral instruction, he is constantly guessing what the adults in his class want him to do. This makes his placement in the SDC class a ‘most restrictive environment’ because he cannot communicate with his [classroom] teacher or peers except on a limited basis.” Ms. Kantor also stated that an appropriate program included instruction at a developmentally appropriate level. (See also Petitioner’s Exhibits at 209.) Ms. Maldonado, who first observed STUDENT during the 1995-1996 school year at the request of Ms. Kantor, concurred with Ms. Kantor’s recommendations regarding the components of an appropriate placement for STUDENT. Petitioner’s expert witnesses, Ms. Balthazor and Dr. Dietrick, also expressed the opinion that an appropriate placement for STUDENT included signing teachers and peers. Neither Ms. Balthazor nor Dr. Dietrick has worked with STUDENT; however, they based their placement recommendations on their understanding of STUDENT’s needs and their experience working with other deaf children. Dr. Dietrick offered an additional reason for placing STUDENT with signing peers, namely that STUDENT needs appropriate peers so that he will have opportunities to develop social skills. Other witnesses who later worked with STUDENT, including Ms. Newman Feldhorn, his classroom teacher, and Ms. Taylor, a speech pathologist, also concluded that STUDENT would have benefitted from being with signing peers and a signing teacher. They described an “ideal program” as one that served students who are both deaf and have mental disabilities.
Witnesses from the CSD testified that it was not necessary for STUDENT to be emersed in sign language or to participate in a class with signing peers to benefit from his education. Mr. Arcanin testified that some children who are deaf, including STUDENT, may be precluded from benefitting from immersion in sign language because of minimal perceptual skills. (Footnote 12)
STUDENT’s teacher during the 1995-1996 school year did not testify. Therefore, the Hearing Officer gives substantial weight to the testimony of Ms. Kantor and Ms. Maldonado regarding STUDENT’s needs as a deaf student during the 1995-1996 school year because they both observed STUDENT in his educational environment and worked directly with him during the 1995-1996 school year. Both also hold appropriate credentials to teach deaf students and are experienced DHH teachers. Conversely, the witnesses who testified that deaf peers and a signing teacher were not necessary to meet STUDENT’s needs were not directly involved in educating STUDENT and had not observed STUDENT in his educational program during the 1995-1996 school year. In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that a signing instructor, signing peers, and instruction at his developmental level were necessary to meet STUDENT’s significant language and developmental deficits. It has already been concluded above in the issue regarding the 1994-1995 school year that STUDENT also required specific instruction in sign language from an appropriately qualified person.
Ms. Kantor’s testimony establishes that the SDC included 10 to 14 students with various disabilities. Some students had autism and some had multiple disabilities. Ms. Kantor and Ms. Maldonado, STUDENT’s DHH teachers, concluded that the class did not meet STUDENT’s educational needs because it lacked appropriate peers and a signing teacher. Ms. Maldonado testified that was unable to receive direct instruction from the teacher because the teacher could not communicate in a way that allowed STUDENT to access information. According to Ms. Kantor, the teacher did not know as many signs as STUDENT. Dr. Moxley, who assessed STUDENT following his application to CSD, observed STUDENT’s placement at Wilson in 1997. She independently concluded that the Wilson SDC was not appropriate because of the lack of structure and the lack of direct instruction to STUDENT by someone trained to teach deaf children. Although her observation of the SDC occurred in 1997, her opinion regarding STUDENT’s placement during the 1995-1996 school year is relevant because the placement was substantially the same the subsequent school year.
The Hearing Officer finds particularly compelling the testimony of Ms. Kantor, Ms. Maldonado, and Dr. Moxley regarding STUDENT’s inability to access instruction. From all the evidence available regarding the 1995-1996 school year, it is concluded that STUDENT possessed requisite skills for learning sign language but he still did not receive direct instruction in sign language from a qualified individual to the extent necessary to address his significant language deficits. Until June of 1996, DHH services were limited to 30 minutes per week of consultation. The DHH services were insufficient to teach sign language to STUDENT, who was now seven years old. It is noted that STUDENT’s parents were not proficient in sign language and he was not provided sign language in any other environment. For the reasons discussed above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s placement during the 1995-1996 school year was not designed to meet his unique and individual needs.
Additionally, there was no evidence that STUDENT made more than de minimis progress during the 1995-1996 school year, particularly in acquisition of language. There was no evidence that the ESY program was different than the program STUDENT received during the regular school year. Because STUDENT’s program did not meet his unique and individual needs and did not allow him to make sufficient progress, it is concluded that STUDENT did not receive an appropriate education during the 1995-1996 school year.
ISSUE NO. 3: Did STUDENT receive a FAPE during the 1996-1997 school year?
Wilson Elementary School
STUDENT continued to attend the same SDC at Wilson during the regular 1996-1997 school year. STUDENT’s placement for the ESY during the summer of 1997 changed and is discussed below. Ms. Kantor testified that Wilson continued to be inappropriate because it lacked a teacher who signed and signing peers. Ms. Kantor continued to believe that STUDENT should be placed at the CSD. Other witnesses concurred with Ms. Kantor. The CSD assessment, which was completed by Dr. Moxley in May 1997, included the following recommendations:
Ideally, STUDENT would benefit from a Deaf multi-handicapped classroom. If such a situation is not available to STUDENT he should be placed in an environment that takes into account his current developmental needs and provides communication through sign language. . . .
STUDENT, ideally, would benefit from the opportunity to interact with deaf peers functioning at or slightly above his developmental level which would include other developmentally delayed deaf peers or those currently at a preschool level.
(Petitioner’s exhibits at 193 and 196.)
Other than the fact that STUDENT’s DHH services increased during the regular school year, there was no persuasive evidence that substantial changes were made to STUDENT’s class or that the teacher changed. Thus, STUDENT’s placement at Wilson did not satisfy either the recommendations of STUDENT’s DHH teacher or those of Dr. Moxley. Therefore, for these reasons and for all of the reasons discussed above regarding STUDENT’s placement at Wilson during the 1995-1996 school year, it is concluded that the 1996-1997 regular school year program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs. Moreover, the results of Dr. Moxley’s assessment in May 1997 showed that STUDENT had shown little growth since his prior assessment. There was no persuasive evidence to the contrary. Therefore, STUDENT also did not benefit from his placement at Wilson. In conclusion, Wilson was not an appropriate placement for STUDENT because it failed to meet the requirements of IDEA and Rowley.
Extended School Year (ESY)
As a result of mediation in SN 197-97, STUDENT’s program for the ESY was changed to a class for deaf preschool students. Because this placement was made to settle due process procedures in a prior case, it is not appropriate to readdress the issue. .
ISSUE NO. 4: Did STUDENT receive a FAPE during the 1997-1998 school year?
Hidden Valley Elementary School
During the fall of 1997, STUDENT attended the DHH preschool program, which was located at Hidden Valley Elementary School in the Santa Rosa City School District. Petitioner contends that Hidden Valley was not an appropriate placement because it lacked suitable peers. All of the students were preschool age and had normal cognitive abilities, whereas Petitioner was nearly nine years old and cognitively impaired. Petitioner also asserts that the class was not sufficiently structured to meet his needs.
There is no dispute that STUDENT continued to have significant deficits in communication and cognitive areas. STUDENT also had deficits related to independent living skills and socialization. The testimony of Ms. Newman Feldhorn, STUDENT’s teacher at Hidden Valley, and Sara Vera, STUDENT’s one-to-one aide, establishes that STUDENT also exhibited significant behavioral problems during the fall of 1997. They described his behavior as “aggressive.” STUDENT kicked, head-butted, pulled hair, and bit when he did not get what he wanted. Ms. Vera described STUDENT’s behavior toward her as “so intense” that she sometimes had to use “physical interaction” to curb his behavior. She also removed him from the class until he calmed down. In Ms. Vera’s opinion, she served as STUDENT’s “behavioral aide” rather than his “instructional aide.” There also was persuasive testimony by Mr. Bailey and by Ms. Maldonado that STUDENT’s aggressive behavior was “communicative in nature” and that there was a direct relationship between STUDENT’s poor communication skills and his behavior. Mr. Bailey’s testimony is based on his observations of STUDENT while conducting his functional analysis assessment. Ms. Maldonado has provided DHH services to STUDENT for a number of years and is familiar with his needs. It is concluded that STUDENT’s inappropriate behavior is directly related to the failure of the LEAs to address adequately his communication deficits for a number of years. In summary, STUDENT’s needs during the 1997-1998 school year were in the areas of communication, cognition, behavior, independent living skills, and socialization.
It has been determined above that STUDENT required specific instruction in sign language, a signing teacher, and signing peers. STUDENT’s teacher at Hidden Valley, Ms. Newman Feldhorn, persuasively described additional components of an appropriate class for STUDENT. She stated that STUDENT needed peers functioning at his developmental level and the classroom environment needed to be structured and have a low student-to-teacher ratio. She also stated that STUDENT required an environment with reduced stimuli and a predictable schedule. STUDENT’s inappropriate behavior resulted in the need for a behavioral intervention plan (BIP) and a one-to-one aide.
Mr. Rosshirt, who is responsible for special education services in the Santa Rosa District, Ms. Newman Feldhorn, and Ms. Vera testified about the Hidden Valley DHH preschool program. Mr. Rosshirt described it as a “highly regarded” program for children who are deaf and hard of hearing. It is located on a regular elementary school campus and serves students from the county and surrounding communities. The program uses a total communication system, which means that students and staff both sign and voice. There were approximately 10 preschool students in the class ranging in age from three years to five years and five months old. Ms. Feldhorn was assisted by one full-time assistant and there was one part-time assistant. Ms. Vera was STUDENT’s one-to-one aide. The students in the class were able to process multi-word information and could communicate with each other. Their functional levels were described as ranging from “readiness and preschool” to “pre-academic and pre-kindergarten readiness.” STUDENT did not receive services from the DHH teacher while attending Hidden Valley. The IEP team concluded that Ms. Newman Feldhorn, the classroom teacher, was qualified to provide DHH services because she holds a credential to teach deaf students and previously was employed at the CSD.
Andrew Bailey, who conducted a functional analysis assessment of STUDENT in November 1997 and designed a behavioral intervention plan for him, concluded that Hidden Valley did not meet STUDENT’s needs. Other witnesses, including Ms. Balthazor, who testified on behalf of STUDENT, Ms. Newman Feldhorn, the classroom teacher, Ms. Taylor, the speech and language pathologist, Mr. Rosshirt, and Dr. Moxley, testified as to the reasons they also concluded that Hidden Valley preschool DHH class was not an appropriate placement for STUDENT. They all testified that class was not appropriate because all of the students in the class were of preschool age and were not cognitively impaired. STUDENT was eight years old, whereas the other children in the class ranged in age from three to five years old. STUDENT was cognitively impaired whereas his classmates in the DHH were not. Because the program was designed to be a stimulating and “fluid” preschool program, it was not sufficiently structured to meet STUDENT’s needs. Finally, the placement did not include an intensive behavioral intervention program. (See also STUDENT’s IEP dated November 17, 1997, which states “the IEP team finds that the current DHOH preschool program placement is not appropriate for STUDENT’s needs.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit at 32.))
Ms. Newman Feldhorn testified that the class was not appropriate for STUDENT for the following additional reasons: STUDENT had more social needs and engaged in more disruptive behavior than the other students; he required the assistance of an aide at all times; the physical environment was too distracting; and except for snack and lunch and “free time,” STUDENT rarely participated in activities with other students in the class. Ms. Newman Feldhorn stated that modifications to the class would not have made it appropriate for STUDENT. Moreover, because Ms. Newman Feldhorn did not provide STUDENT with direct instruction and DHH services were discontinued, all of STUDENT’s instruction in sign language and other areas was delivered by Ms. Vera. Ms. Vera is a community college student with several courses in sign language. She is not an experienced or qualified teacher of the deaf. Additionally, Ms. Vera testified that she spent a great deal of time dealing with STUDENT’s behavioral problems rather than instructing STUDENT in sign language and other areas. Finally, the preschool program was approximately three hours daily, which is a shorter school day than is provided to elementary school students. No explanation was given at the hearing as to why STUDENT did not receive the same number of hours of instruction as other elementary school students.
The Hearing Officer notes that Education Code § 56500.5(b)(4), states that deaf children should be placed with peers “who are of the same, or approximately the same, age and ability level.” This was not the case at Hidden Valley. Moreover, the essentially unrebutted testimony discussed above establishes that the Hidden Valley program did not meet STUDENT’s needs.
In reviewing the evidence, there also is little, if any, evidence that STUDENT benefitted from his placement at Hidden Valley. Ms. Vera testified that STUDENT learned new signs while at Hidden Valley; however, Ms. Taylor, who provided speech and language therapy to STUDENT in the fall of 1997, testified that STUDENT’s overall communication skills fell in the 16- to 18-month range. She noted that while working with her, STUDENT did not use basic communication skills such as eye contact or reciprocal interactions, thereby indicating that STUDENT had lost rather than gained skills since prior school years, when it had been reported that STUDENT made eye contact and communicated to some extent using pictures and other means. STUDENT’s behavior also deteriorated while attending Hidden Valley, which according to Ms. Vera and Ms. Newman Feldhorn, interfered with STUDENT’s ability to benefit from his instruction. Based on the evidence discussed above, the Hearing Officer concludes that Hidden Valley did not meet STUDENT’s needs or provide him with educational benefit and, therefore, did not provide him with a FAPE during the first semester of the 1997-1998 school year.
La Fiesta Elementary School
Since February 1998, STUDENT’s placement has been the SDC at La Fiesta Elementary School. Petitioner contends that La Fiesta is not an appropriate placement because his communication needs are not addressed sufficiently. Petitioner asserts that he is the only student in the class who signs and he knows more signs than the teacher. Petitioner also asserts that his social and behavioral needs are not addressed. Respondents contend that La Fiesta offers STUDENT an appropriate placement because he receives instruction at his developmental level and his communication and behavioral deficits are being addressed. Respondents also assert that STUDENT has made progress in those two areas since attending La Fiesta.
Tim O’Brien, STUDENT’s teacher at La Fiesta SDC, and Jarvis McAllister, STUDENT’s aide at La Fiesta, testified regarding STUDENT’s placement. Their testimony establishes the following: Mr. O’Brien holds a master’s degree in special education and is credentialed to teach students with severe disabilities. There are three instructional assistants in the class. Mr. McAllister replaced Ms. Vera as STUDENT’s aide in April 1998. Mr. McAllister is deaf and communicates using ASL. Because Mr. O’Brien’s signing abilities are limited, he and Mr. McAllister communicate regarding STUDENT by gesturing and writing. Mr Bailey meets one to two times a month with Mr. McAllister and Mr. O’Brien to discuss how to work with STUDENT.
There are six students in the class, all of whom are boys. They range in age from 5 to 10 years old. All of the students are mentally retarded, and some of the students have autistic or autistic-like characteristics. The students have varying language abilities that range from beginning communication skills to highly skilled use of language. As to the class schedule, the students arrive at 8:00 a.m. After they put their items away and use the restroom, the students receive individual instruction. They then gather in a group for circle time that includes counting, calendar, and weather activities, and roll call. Circle is followed by snack and recess. The students return from recess to do individual activities. STUDENT works with Mr. McAllister to develop sign language and computer skills. The students then have physical education activities and lunch. A second session of individual work occurs next, which is followed by snack and a “good-bye” circle.
Mr. O’Brien testified that STUDENT’s goals and objectives are addressed throughout the school day. According to Mr. O’Brien, the primary focus of the class is to develop the communication and social skills of the students. To address STUDENT’s communication deficits, Mr. O’Brien testified that he uses a picture communication system. The system allows STUDENT to select activities from pictures in a book which STUDENT can carry with him and which also are on a sheet of paper at his desk. Mr. McAllister works with STUDENT on learning to sign ASL. STUDENT receives 30 minutes each week of direct speech and language services and 120 minutes each week of consultative DHH services.
CSD witnesses concluded that Mr. O’Brien’s class addresses STUDENT’s needs. Dr. Moxley and Ms. Vickers testified that the class has appropriate peers and a developmentally appropriate curriculum, offers small-group and individual instruction, and is structured. They also testified that the BIP addresses STUDENT’s behavioral needs and that the assistance of Mr. McAllister, who is fluent in ASL, enables STUDENT to participate in the class. Ms. Taylor, STUDENT’s speech and language pathologist, also testified that STUDENT’s needs are being met in Mr. O’Brien’s class.
Petitioner’s witnesses, including Ms. Maldonado and Ms. Balthazor, do not disagree that some of STUDENT’s needs are being addressed at La Fiesta. For example, Petitioner’s witnesses concur that the students in the class have development needs that are similar to STUDENT’s and that the curriculum is designed to address those needs. However, Petitioner’s witnesses testified that La Fiesta is not an appropriate placement because STUDENT’s communication, social, and behavioral deficits are not being met.
The evidence establishes that Mr. O’Brien does not sign proficiently and knows fewer signs than STUDENT. Mr O’Brien’s testimony establishes that he has taken one class in sign language. He knows approximately 50 signs and can express himself using 20 to 30 signs. Petitioner’s witnesses testified that STUDENT “pretty much” spends his entire school day with Mr. McAllister, which precludes STUDENT from having full access to his educational program. (Testimony of Ms. Maldonado and Ms. Balthazor.) Mr. O’Brien testified that he provides direct instruction to STUDENT approximately 20% of the school day; however, Mr. McAllister disputed Mr. O’Brien’s testimony and stated that STUDENT receives direct instruction from him and does not receive direct instruction from Mr. O’Brien. Mr. McAllister’s testimony is credible, especially given Mr. O’Brien’s testimony regarding his limited ability to sign. Even taking the most favorable estimate of the amount of instruction Mr. O’Brien provides STUDENT, the instruction constitutes less than one quarter of the total instruction STUDENT receives. Thus, during a school day, STUDENT receives at least 75% of his instruction from Mr. McAllister. As to Mr. McAllister’s ability to address STUDENT’s communication deficits, there is no doubt that Mr. McAllister is a proficient ASL signer. He is a fifth-generation deaf person and attended the CSD. However, Mr. McAllister does not have any formal training to teach sign language. He also does not hold any teaching credentials, nor does he have any formal training to teach deaf students who also have cognitive deficits. Moreover, because an interpreter has not been provided to facilitate communication between Mr. O’Brien and Mr. McAllister, their ability to effectively communicate and to plan STUDENT’s educational program is limited.
Petitioner’s witnesses testified that STUDENT is isolated from classmates and is unable to communicate with any of the students because he is the only deaf child in the class. Hence, STUDENT also does not have opportunities to develop appropriate social skills. There was no persuasive evidence that a particular program has been designed or implemented to address STUDENT’s poor social skills.
As to whether the SDC addresses STUDENT’s behavioral needs, Dr. Dietrick testified that STUDENT’s behavioral intervention plan (BIP) is not designed to address his inappropriate behaviors identified by the functional analysis assessment. Dr. Dietrick also testified that STUDENT’s BIP does not identify any specific replacement behaviors or specific responses which would ensure that the staff consistently addresses STUDENT’s inappropriate behavior. Dr. Dietrick testified that if the motivation for STUDENT’s behavior is to escape from having to do work, the BIP reinforces that behavior. For example, the BIP calls for staff to ignore “low level” behavior and to remove STUDENT from the class for more serious behavior. Hence, STUDENT has gained what he wants, namely, escaping work by engaging in more significant behavior. Dr. Dietrick testified that the assessment suggests that STUDENT’s behavior is communicative in nature; however, the BIP does not specifically address teaching communication skills as a means to improve STUDENT’s behavior. Dr. Dietrick further criticized the BIP because it suggests delaying reinforcement, which he does not believe would be effective with STUDENT because he acts impulsively. The BIP also does not include prevention strategies and, because of its complexity, may be difficult for staff to implement. Moreover, the BIP has not been implemented since Mr. McAllister has been STUDENT’s aide. Mr. McAllister, who has been primarily responsible for implementing STUDENT’s educational program since April 1998, testified that he did not receive a copy of the behavioral intervention plan until after the hearing had commenced late in 1998. On the last day of hearing, Mr. McAllister had not yet completed reading the plan. Therefore, STUDENT’s behavior is not being addressed according to the BIP. Moreover, the BIP may need revising to address Dr. Dietrick’s concerns and to reflect STUDENT’s behavioral needs in the La Fiesta class. It is noted that the BIP was developed while STUDENT was attending the DHH preschool class.
As discussed in issues related to prior school years, the evidence establishes that STUDENT requires a placement that includes specific instruction in ASL, a signing teacher, signing peers at STUDENT’s developmental level, a structured classroom with a low student-to-teacher ratio, a structured behavioral program, a one-to-one instructional assistant, and a developmentally appropriate curriculum that addresses deficits in communication, cognitive, independent living socialization, motor, and behavioral areas. The fact that STUDENT has peers in his class who are developmentally delayed is insufficient to meet his needs. Because an appropriate placement must provide opportunities for STUDENT to communicate with classmates, they must both sign and have developmental needs similar to STUDENT’s. The fact that Mr. O’Brien is trained to provide a developmentally appropriate curriculum is insufficient to meet STUDENT’s needs. Because Mr. O’Brien does not have sufficient signing skills, he provides only minimal instruction to STUDENT. It also is important that STUDENT’s behavior, which has become problematic because of his lack of communication skills, be addressed vigorously. A plan that was designed to be implemented in a very different educational environment and that has not even been read by the person who is responsible for implementing the plan cannot be deemed to meet STUDENT’s needs. Moreover, the persons who have continued to identify STUDENT’s needs, Ms. Maldonado and Ms. Newman Feldhorn in particular, are the persons who have worked with him over time and who also are trained and experienced working with deaf students. What distinguishes Ms. Maldonado and Ms. Newman Feldhorn from CSD witnesses, who also are qualified and experienced with deaf students, is that they have worked with STUDENT and his family for a number of years. They have seen STUDENT in a number of different educational environments. These experiences have given them the necessary insight into STUDENT’s needs.
Mr. Klor has acknowledged that there is not an appropriate placement for STUDENT in the SELPA. The recommendations included in Dr. Moxley’s report following her assessment of STUDENT in May 1997 were also consistent with the recommendations of STUDENT’s DHH teachers. (Petitioner’s Exhibits at 193 and 196.) For all of the reasons discussed above, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s placement at La Fiesta does not adequately address his communication, social, and behavioral needs. Moreover, there is no persuasive evidence that STUDENT benefitted from his placement at La Fiesta during his first semester there. Therefore, because neither Hidden Valley nor La Fiesta met STUDENT’s needs or provided him sufficient benefit, it is concluded that STUDENT did not receive a FAPE during the 1997-1998 school year.
ISSUE NO. 5: Did Respondents offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 1998-1999 school year?
STUDENT has continued to attend Mr. O’Brien’s class at La Fiesta during the 1998-1999 school year. Mr. McAllister has also continued as STUDENT’s one-to-one aide. STUDENT’s needs have not changed since the prior school year, nor has the class or the services provided to STUDENT. Ms. Newman Feldhorn, Ms. Maldonado, Ms. Balthazor, and a number of other witnesses continued to describe the appropriate placement for STUDENT as one where he is with signing children who are at his developmental level and where the teacher is proficient in ASL.
Ms. Newman Feldhorn and Ms. Maldonado testified that there has been a concerted effort to meet STUDENT’s needs in Mr. O’Brien’s class and that, since Mr. McAllister has been the aide, STUDENT has made some gains in using and understanding sign language. STUDENT is signing spontaneously, more frequently, to himself, and is signing things that were not directly taught to him. STUDENT’s behavior also has shown improvement. (Testimony of Mr. Bailey, Mr. McAllister, and Ms. Maldonado.) Despite these belated efforts to meet STUDENT’s needs, STUDENT’s placement remains deficient for all of the reasons discussed above in Issue No. 5. Those reasons include, but are not limited to, the fact that STUDENT is not placed with signing peers and does not have a teacher proficient in ASL. Additionally, Mr. O’Brien reported that STUDENT has been making progress toward meeting several goals and objectives; however, as of the date of the hearing, STUDENT had not mastered any of his IEP goals and objectives. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s placement at La Fiesta does not satisfy the requirements of an appropriate placement as set forth in the IDEA and Rowley.
ISSUE NO. 6: Should STUDENT be placed at the California School for the Deaf (CSD), Northern California, for the remainder of the 1998-1999 school year?
Petitioner contends that the CSD offers an appropriate placement because it has the two essential components that have not been identified as being available at any other placement. Petitioner asserts that the CSD offers teachers who are proficient at ASL and deaf peers of the same age and abilities as Petitioner. Petitioner contends that he meets the criteria of persons served by the CSD--he is deaf, he lives in a relatively sparsely populated area, he has been educationally deprived, he is from a culturally different background, and there is no appropriate program for him in the county. Petitioner asserts that the criteria being used to exclude him from CSD “have been exaggerated.”
Respondents Petaluma District and the SCOE have pursued placing Petitioner at the CSD. Mr. Klor testified that there are no classes in the District, the SELPA, the County, or in neighboring SELPAs with deaf students at the same developmental level as STUDENT. (See also statements made by the District on STUDENT’s IEP dated February 2, 1998, which describe CSD as the “most desirable placement option for STUDENT.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit at 22.))
Respondent CSD contends that it does not offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT because he does not possess the following characteristics: the ability to learn simple mobility patterns, to communicate basic needs, to be aware of and respond appropriately to life threatening situations, to function in an instructional group setting (not requiring constant one-to-one), to care for basic personal needs, and to be free of severe acting out or aggressive behaviors that pose a danger to self or others. (Respondent CSD’s Exhibits b and c.) In short, the CSD also contends that does not have an appropriate program for STUDENT.
The CSD is part of the public school system of the State. Its stated purpose is the education of the deaf “who, because of their severe hearing loss and educational needs, cannot be provided an appropriate educational program and related services in the regular public schools.” Education Code § 59001. Pursuant to Section 59020, “every deaf person between the ages of 3 and 21 years” and who meets certain criteria is entitled to an education at the CSD. Priority for admission is given to elementary age deaf minors residing in sparsely populated regions for “whom appropriate comprehensive educational facilities and services are not available or cannot be reasonably provided by their local school districts or county educational agencies.” Education Code § 59020. The Superintendent of Public Instruction determines admission criteria to the CSD. Section 5210 of the California Department of Education’s Specialized Programs Branch Administrative Manual describes the admissions policy to State special schools, including the CSD. The following persons can be served by the CSD:
1. Deaf individuals with or without additional handicapping conditions. 2. Deaf individuals with moderate behavioral problems who are not considered a danger to self or others. . . . 3. Deaf individuals who are educationally deprived or from culturally different backgrounds, including recent immigrants. . . . 6. Hard of hearing individuals with an educationally significant hearing loss who live in rural or other areas without an appropriate educational program.
The Manual also states that the CSD cannot serve students with the following characteristics (emphasis added):
1. Those in need of a 24-hour psychiatric treatment program. . . . . 2. Those developmentally delayed individuals who require a custodial program. Characteristics include: severe retardation, lack of self-help skills, or in need of one-to-one supervision. (Self-help skills include: ability to learn simple mobility patterns around campus, communicate basic needs to staff members, respond appropriately to life threatening situations, and function in a group setting; and demonstration of the potential to eat and dress without assistance and otherwise tend to personal care needs.) 3. Those with severe acting out/aggressive behaviors. Characteristics include: danger to self or others, assaultive, repeated contacts with law enforcement agencies, or in need of one-to-one supervision. . . .
(Respondent CSD’s Exhibit a)
Sharon Vickers, former principal of the CSD infant, preschool, and elementary programs, provided most of the information regarding the CSD. Ms. Vickers currently is the IEP coordinator for the CSD. The CSD serves approximately 500 students from birth through 22 years old. The school has a residential component that houses students who do not live within commutable distances from the school. One of the residential “cottages” is for deaf students with special needs. ASL is the language employed by teachers. There are approximately 100 elementary students at CSD. Three elementary school classes service deaf students with special needs. There are a maximum of five students in each of those three classes. All of the students have some signing ability. At the time of the hearing, all of the classes were full. All of the students initially are placed at CSD for an extended period of assessment. At the end of 50 days, the students are evaluated as to whether their continued placement at CSD is appropriate.
The testimony of Ms. Vickers and Ms. Maldonado establishes the following regarding the three elementary classes at the CSD that serve deaf students with additional disabilities. The first class has four students who are 9 and 10 years old. The students have behavioral and learning needs. The students’ signing skills range from receptively understanding 5 to 10 word phrases to being fluent expressively. Ms. Maldonado testified that on the day she observed the class, the students were sitting and attending and engaged in an activity selecting small tiles of letters to use in a word game.
The second class has four to five students who are 11 to 12 years old. There is one credentialed teacher and one assistant in the class. One student has a one-to-one aide to help the student stay seated, focused, and attending, and to help with work and with ambulation. One student was described as “developmentally delayed” and another student is mentally retarded. Ms. Vickers expressed the opinion that the developmentally delayed student was not benefitting from placement at CSD. Ms. Maldonado observed the students engaged in a graduation activity. They were following instructions, learning a song, and moving on stage.
The third class has students ranging from approximately six to eight years old. All of the students have cognitive delays. At least one students has an individual aide. There also is a classroom aide. Some of the students need assistance with self-help tasks. Other students have behavioral difficulties. Ms. Vickers testified that one student with developmental delays was not benefitting from his placement at CSD because he was unable to participate in group activities.
Petitioner’s witnesses all believed that the CSD would offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT. For example, Ms. Balthazor testified that STUDENT would benefit from placement at the CSD for the following reasons: he would be exposed to ASL constantly; the staff has the expertise to teach deaf children; and STUDENT’s aggressive and acting out behavior will diminish when he is able to communicate with peers and teachers, and when the program is meeting his needs. (See Petitioner’s Exhibits at 160.) Mr. McAllister, who is a graduate of the CSD, testified that STUDENT would benefit from placement at the CSD. He stated that STUDENT would try to communicate if he were around other students who were signing. Several witnesses, including Mr. McAllister and Dr. Dietrick, had not observed the CSD for a number of years. Many of these witnesses referred to a “special needs program” that had existed at the CSD. According to the CSD witnesses, this program no longer exists in the format with which the witnesses were familiar. Moreover, after observing the current programs at the CSD, none of Petitioner’s witnesses testified credibly that the program meets STUDENT’s needs.
Ms. Maldonado, who has advocated for STUDENT’s placement at the CSD, testified that she believes that the CSD would offer STUDENT access to language, a community that respects deafness, and opportunities for his language skills to be reinforced throughout the school day and in the residential component; however, based on her observations of CSD, Ms. Maldonado testified that a great deal of modification to the curriculum would be necessary to meet STUDENT’s needs. She also testified that it would be necessary to implement a strong behavioral program for STUDENT. In regard to the first class Ms. Maldonado observed, she testified that it would require “a huge leap to accommodate STUDENT’s academic level and independent living skills.” Ms. Maldonado concluded that the second class that she observed also would not be appropriate for STUDENT because the students’ linguistic, social, and cognitive skills, and their on-task behavior were more developed than STUDENT’s. Mr. O’Brien visited the CSD with Ms. Maldonado. His opinion regarding the appropriateness of the classes was similar to Ms. Maldonado’s opinion. Mr. O’Brien testified that STUDENT would require “adjustments” to be successful in the program because the students’ skills are more advanced than STUDENT’s.
Petitioner asserts that modifications to the CSD program could be made so that he could be successfully placed there. Dr. Dietrick testified that Spectrum has worked with the CSD designing and modifying its program to meet the needs of individual children. He stated that Spectrum has helped to modify the length of an activity, devised different activities, modified the way in which an activity was presented, and designed materials. Currently, Spectrum provides such services to three students attending the CSD. Dr. Dietrick has not met STUDENT, has not visited the CSD recently, and does not directly work with the students at the CSD. Therefore, Dr. Dietrick’s opinion about modifications to the CSD and whether they could meet STUDENT’s needs is too speculative and cannot be relied on to determine whether modifications to the CSD program would meet STUDENT’s needs.
Ms. Vickers testified that STUDENT was not found eligible for the extended evaluation at the CSD. To attend the CSD, STUDENT needs to be able to do the following: (1) to get around the school unescorted, including from the residential cottage to the classroom and from the classroom to where medication is dispensed; (2) to tell someone if he is hurt, to provide information about himself, and to respond to yes and no questions; (3) to respond to threats of fire and earthquakes and to be aware of potential dangers, (4) to participate in a group setting because otherwise he would miss out on instruction from the teacher and opportunities to participate in the deaf culture, and (5) to go independently to the bathroom and take care of his personal hygiene. Ms. Vickers testified that STUDENT did not meet any of the above criteria. Additional factors that weighed against accepting STUDENT to the CSD were his acting out behavior, his inability to function academically, the need for a one-to-one aide, and the inability to function in a group. Dr. Moxley’s testimony was essentially the same as Ms. Vickers’ testimony as to the appropriateness of STUDENT’s attending the CSD.
As to whether STUDENT meets the criteria for acceptance by the CSD, Ms. Maldonado testified that STUDENT’s ability to learn mobility patterns depends on his motivation and STUDENT is not consistently able to express his basic needs using language. Mr. O’Brien testified that STUDENT is not able to get around the school by himself. STUDENT is not aware of dangers because he is deaf and impulsive. Mr. O’Brien testified that STUDENT would be disruptive to the group. Mr. McAllister testified that STUDENT can go to the bathroom by himself; however, he cannot go to the school’s cafeteria independently. STUDENT is able to make his basic needs known. For example, STUDENT asks “why?” and says “I want” and “give me.” STUDENT cannot string sentences together. Mr. McAllister does not know whether STUDENT recognizes a dangerous situation. MOTHER testified that STUDENT is able to dress himself, toilets independently, and completes chores at home such as clearing the dining table and putting the dishes in the sink, and folding clothes. Ms. Vera confirmed that when she worked with STUDENT during the 1997-1998 school year, he independently went to the toilet, ate, and dressed himself.
The evidence establishes that STUDENT exhibits behavioral problems that may be dangerous to himself or others. Because of his behavior, STUDENT requires the assistance of a one-to-one aide and implementation of a behavioral intervention plan. The evidence establishes that STUDENT presently does not successfully participate in group activities. Because of the lack of appropriate instruction in sign language, STUDENT does not currently possess the skills to sufficiently communicate his wants and needs or to recognize dangerous situations. STUDENT can meet some of the criteria for admittance established by the CSD; however, given that STUDENT does not meet all of the admittance criteria and taking into consideration the level of instruction and functional levels of the students in the CSD classes as described at the hearing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the CSD does not currently offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT.
This conclusion leaves STUDENT in a most unfortunate situation. The criteria for admission imposed by the CSD have excluded STUDENT from the only potential placement identified at the hearing that offers some of the components he requires to address his unique and individual needs and to provide him with educational benefit. It is even more disturbing that STUDENT’s lack of skills necessary for admission to the CSD is attributable, in great part, to the failure of the local educational agencies to address adequately his needs for a number of years. In fact, it has been concluded above that STUDENT has not received an appropriate education since at least the 1994-1995 school year. In essence, because of the failure of the Petaluma District and the SCOE to provide STUDENT with an appropriate educational program since at least May 1995, STUDENT has not developed the skills that would allow him to participate in the only potentially appropriate educational program identified in California. Appropriate remedies to redress four years’ denial of FAPE are discussed below in Issue Number 9.
ISSUE NO. 7(a): If STUDENT should be placed at the CSD for the remainder of 1998-1999 school year, does he require a one-to-one aide during all school hours while attending the CSD?
ISSUE NO. 7(b): If STUDENT should be placed at the CSD for the remainder of 1998-1999 school year, does he require a one-to-one aide during all non-school hours while attending the CSD?
ISSUE NO. 7(c): If STUDENT should be placed at the CSD for the remainder of 1998-1999 school year, does he require transportation services between his home and the CSD?
It has been determined that the CSD does not currently have an appropriate placement for STUDENT. Therefore, it is unnecessary to address these issues.
ISSUE NO. 8: Does STUDENT require daily one-to-one speech and language therapy for 30 minutes per session?
Respondents may be required to provide STUDENT with daily one-to-one speech and language therapy as a related service if the service is necessary for him to benefit educationally from his instructional program. Education Code § 56363. There was no persuasive evidence that Petitioner specifically requires daily speech and language therapy to benefit from his instructional program. Therefore, Petitioner’s request for daily speech and language as a required related service is denied. However, in Petitioner’s closing brief, he requests daily speech and language therapy as a compensatory remedy for the alleged failure of the Respondents to provide the speech and language services in the manner called for by his IEP. Whether Petitioner is entitled to daily speech and language therapy as a compensatory remedy is addressed below in Issue No. 9.
ISSUE NO. 9: What are appropriate remedies if it is determined that the Petaluma District and the SCOE failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE?
ISSUE NO. 9(a): What constitutes an appropriate placement for STUDENT?
It has been concluded that Respondents Petaluma District and the SCOE have failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE since at least May 1995. The Hearing Officer now turns to the task of determining appropriate remedies that both will address STUDENT’s significant needs and redress the egregious conduct of Respondents. The Hearing Officer has authority to order appropriate relief for the failure to provide FAPE. School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359, 369. In Burlington, the Supreme Court concluded that equitable considerations are relevant in determining relief under the IDEA. See also Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496.
No appropriate placement has been identified for STUDENT for the 1998-1999 school year. Because STUDENT is both deaf and developmentally delayed, he is a member of a very small population of students. In fact, witnesses testified that there are no appropriate programs in the District, SELPA, County, or in the counties surrounding Petaluma. It also has been determined that the CSD presently does not have an appropriate placement for STUDENT. STUDENT has already missed many developmental milestones and opportunities to develop language. If he is going to acquire skills that will allow him to communicate, to develop academic and functional skills, and to achieve independence to the level of which he is capable, steps must be taken immediately to address his needs. The urgency of locating an appropriate placement for STUDENT cannot be overemphasized.
It may take some time to identify an appropriate placement for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer notes that the 1998-1999 school year is nearly over and STUDENT has shown some progress since working with Mr. McAllister. Moreover, STUDENT has had multiple placements since entering the District. For these reasons and to ensure that there is some stability to STUDENT’s educational placement until an appropriate placement is identified, the Hearing Officer concludes that the Petaluma District and the SCOE shall maintain STUDENT in his current placement for the remainder of the regular school year 1998-1999. STUDENT’s placement includes his one-to-one aide and other services identified on his IEP. The Petaluma District and the SCOE shall also implement the compensatory services awarded below for the remainder of the 1998-1999 school year.
As mentioned above, STUDENT’s residence since 1993 has been within the Petaluma School District. The SCOE provides STUDENT’s special education services as the local educational agency serving students with significant disabilities. The Hearing Officer determines that the Petaluma District and the SCOE are responsible for locating and providing STUDENT with an appropriate placement. Neither the Santa Rosa School District nor the CSD has current responsibility to educate STUDENT. STUDENT previously attended a program located in the Santa Rosa School District; however, the Santa Rosa District has no ongoing obligation to educate STUDENT. The CSD also does not have any ongoing obligation for STUDENT’s education. Because of the unique circumstances of this child--he has very few peers with similar needs, he has not received an appropriate education for multiple years, he has significant needs, and no one has identified an appropriate placement for him--the Hearing Officer concludes that the California Department of Education (CDE) also shall participate in locating an appropriate placement for STUDENT. As to the State’s participation in identifying a placement for STUDENT, the Hearing Officer recognizes that, as a matter of law, the State is ultimately responsible for STUDENT’s education. Section 1412(11) of the IDEA provides that it is the responsibility of the State educational agency to ensure that the requirements of the IDEA are met for students receiving special education in the State. Moreover, the State raised no objection to being a party in this case and participated in the hearing.
Given the absence of an appropriate program, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District, the SCOE, and the CDE must undertake a comprehensive search both within and outside the State for a public or a private placement for STUDENT that has all of the following components: signing peers at or near STUDENT’s age and developmental level; a teacher proficient in ASL; opportunities for small-group and individual instruction; a low student-to-teacher ratio; a structured environment; specific instruction in ASL; a structured behavioral intervention program; curriculum and instruction at STUDENT’s developmental level that address independent living and social skills; and curriculum and instruction to develop STUDENT’s skills that may ultimately allow him to attend the CSD.
To this end, the Petaluma District shall convene an IEP meeting that includes, but is not limited to, the parents and representatives from the Petaluma District, the SCOE, and the CDE who are familiar with STUDENT and who have expertise in educating deaf and developmentally delayed children. The IEP team shall identify potential placements for STUDENT in public and private schools both within and outside the State. The IEP team may also consider undertaking steps to make the CSD an appropriate placement for STUDENT.
To ensure that STUDENT is placed appropriately within a reasonable amount of time, the Hearing Officer concludes that no later than July 1, 1999, the Petaluma District, the SCOE, and the CDE must have identified an appropriate placement and secured STUDENT’s enrollment in that placement. The Hearing Officer also concludes that STUDENT shall be entitled to remain in that placement for the 1999-2000 school year, including the ESY during the summer of 2000.
ISSUE NO. 9(b): Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See, e.g. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.) (Footnote 13) Petitioner contends that he is entitled to compensation remedies for Respondents’ failure to provide him with a FAPE. Petitioner requests five additional years of special education services beyond age 21 years, daily individual speech and language services, and year- round services as compensatory educational services for the failure of the Petaluma District and the SCOE to provide him a FAPE since the 1994-1995 school year.
As stated above, equitable factors may be considered in determining appropriate remedies and the conduct of the parties must be considered in determining whether compensatory relief is appropriate. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District (9th Cir.) 960 F.2d 1479, 1486. As previously noted, STUDENT moved with his family to Petaluma in 1993. The family is Spanish-peaking and has limited resources. Since enrolling in the Petaluma District and SCOE programs, STUDENT has been moved from one placement to another. He entered the District and SCOE with sufficient skills to be taught sign language; however, he was not provided appropriate sign language instruction. In essence, STUDENT has been denied the only functional means to communicate with the rest of the world. He now has significant needs in areas that transcend his poor communication skills. STUDENT has significant behavioral, social, and developmental deficits. STUDENT’s current behavioral problems and his need for a one-to-one aide are related to his lack of communication skills and the failure of the Respondents to provide him with appropriate special education. Therefore, it is concluded that STUDENT is entitled to compensatory educational services. The type of compensatory educational services and the duration of those services must be determined next.
Traditionally, compensatory educational services have been available to students who reach the age at which they no longer are eligible for special education services. Awards have been made to younger students when appropriate. Todd D. v. Andrews (11th Cir. 1991) 933 F.2d 1576; Lester H. v. Gilhool (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865, cert. denied, 111 S. Ct. 1317 (1991). Given the developmental phases STUDENT has passed through since moving to Petaluma, it is not entirely clear whether the deficits caused by Respondents’ failure to provide FAPE are remediable. However, the Hearing Officer concludes that any further delay to STUDENT’s receiving compensatory special education services would diminish the opportunities for STUDENT to benefit from his education and to make progress. Therefore, the Petaluma District and the SCOE must provide STUDENT compensatory educational services presently and through the 1999-2000 school year, including the ESY.
As to Petitioner’s request for daily individual speech and language services as compensatory educational services, it has been determined above that STUDENT needs instruction in sign language. Because of the many years STUDENT has not received appropriate sign language instruction and because communication is one of STUDENT’s pressing needs, it is concluded that an appropriate compensatory remedy is additional daily instruction in sign language. Because STUDENT presently requires individual instruction due to attentional and behavioral problems, the sign language instruction must be provided one-to-one. Mr. McAllister currently is responsible for providing sign language instruction to STUDENT. Mr. McAllister is well-suited to work with STUDENT and to supplement sign language instruction; however, it has been determined that STUDENT’s instruction must be from an appropriately qualified person. There was no persuasive evidence that the only person qualified to provide instruction is a speech and language pathologist. The Hearing Officer finds that the IEP team is in the best position to determine who is appropriately qualified to provide the services and to determine the appropriate length of the daily instruction. (See State of Conn. U.S.D. No. 1 v. State Dept. of Education (Conn. Super. Ct. 1997) 699 A.2d 1077.)
Petitioner asserts that he also is entitled to compensatory education in the form of special education services during all intersession breaks from his regular school program. There was significant testimony regarding the need for STUDENT to continue learning sign language and to use the signs he has learned as much as possible and in a number of environments. For this reason, and because STUDENT’s family is not proficient in signing, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT is entitled to receive sign language instruction and opportunities to use his emerging signing skills during intersessions from school. The Hearing Officer defines “intersession” as any break from school that is longer than 10 school days. Therefore, during breaks of more than two weeks, the Petaluma District and the SCOE are responsible for providing STUDENT with daily instruction in sign language and opportunities that will allow him to practice sign language.
Because of the number of years STUDENT has not received an appropriate education, the Hearing Officer finds that he is entitled to additional compensatory remedies. As determined above, the IEP team is best suited to make this decision. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the IEP team shall determine additional compensatory remedies. In making this decision, the IEP team shall first weigh STUDENT’s individual needs and his ability to tolerate a longer school day with his right to compensation for the denial of FAPE for at least four years. The IEP team shall then consider, as options, individual tutoring for STUDENT and sign language instruction for STUDENT’s family.
As to the period of time the District and SCOE are required to provide these compensatory services, the Hearing Officer finds the appropriate length of a compensatory award in this case is for the remainder of the 1998-1999 school year and through the 1999-2000 school year, including the ESY. The obligation of the Petaluma District and the SCOE to provide these services is not alleviated should STUDENT’s placement during that period be located outside the geographical area of the County. If STUDENT is placed outside the County, the Petaluma District and the SCOE shall be responsible for locating and funding the compensatory services to which STUDENT is entitled pursuant to this decision.
As to Petitioner’s request for five additional years of special education services beyond age 21, it has been concluded that STUDENT requires compensatory services presently and that compensatory educational services should not be delayed until he is an adult. Moreover, the Hearing Officer concludes that it is too speculative at this point in time to determine STUDENT’s need for an educational program beyond age 21 years, given that STUDENT currently is an elementary school student. Therefore, Petitioner’s request for compensatory education for five years beyond age 21 years is denied at this time. Petitioner is not precluded from raising at a later date his need for compensatory educational services beyond the ESY of the 1999-2000 school year.
ISSUE NO. 9(c): Is STUDENT entitled to punitive damages?
Petitioner contends that he is entitled to an award of punitive damages because of the failure of Respondents Petaluma District and the SCOE to provide him with a FAPE since entering their programs. The Respondents contend that the Hearing Officer does not have authority to award punitive damages.
There are no specific provisions in special education statutory law, nor is there precedent in the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, for an award of punitive damages. A number of other Circuit Courts of Appeal have concluded that punitive damages are not available as a remedy in claims raised under the IDEA. (See e.g. Heidemann v. Rother (8th Cir. 1996) 84 F.3d 1021, 1033; Charlie F. v. Bd. of Ed. of Skokie Schl. Dist. (7th Cir. 1996) 98 F.3d 989; and Hall v. Knott Co. Bd. of Ed. (6th Cir. 1991) 941 F.2d 402.) (Footnote 14) For these reasons, Petitioner’s request for punitive damages is denied.
ISSUE NO. 9(d): Is STUDENT entitled to an educational trust fund?
Petitioner did not provide any authority, nor is the Hearing Officer aware of any authority, that would allow the Hearing Officer to order a compensatory remedy in the form of an educational trust. Petitioner also did not specify what he meant by an “educational trust.” For these reasons, the request for an educational trust is denied.
ORDER
(1) Within 10 calendar days of the date of this decision, the Petaluma District shall convene an IEP meeting. The IEP team shall include, but not be limited to, the parents, STUDENT’s classroom and DHH teachers, and representatives from the SCOE and the CDE with expertise in educating deaf and developmentally delayed children. The IEP team shall do the following:
(A) Determine additional compensatory education for STUDENT. The IEP team shall weigh STUDENT’s individual needs and his ability to tolerate a longer school day with his right to compensation for the denial of FAPE for at least four years. As to appropriate forms of compensation, the IEP team shall consider, as options, individual tutoring for STUDENT and sign language instruction for STUDENT’s family.
(B) Determine a qualified individual to provide compensatory sign language services to STUDENT and determine the length of the daily services both during regular school sessions and during breaks from school of more than 10 school days.
(2) Immediately following the IEP meeting, the Petaluma District, the SCOE, and the California Department of Education shall undertake to identify an appropriate placement for STUDENT to ensure that he is placed no later than July 1, 1999. The IEP team members shall consider placement within and outside the State in either a public or a private school that includes all of the following components: signing peers at or near STUDENT’s age and developmental level; a teacher proficient in ASL; opportunities for small group and individual instruction; a low student-to-teacher ratio; a structured environment; specific instruction in ASL; a structured behavioral intervention program; and curriculum at STUDENT’s developmental level that addresses independent living and social skills. The IEP team may also consider undertaking steps to make the CSD an appropriate placement for STUDENT.
(3) Prior to July 1, 1999, the Petaluma District shall reconvene an IEP meeting to conform STUDENT’s IEP to reflect STUDENT’s placement as of July 1, 1999. The IEP team shall also consider the need to revise STUDENT’s BIP or to develop a new BIP following his enrollment in the new placement.
(4) The Petaluma District and the SCOE shall enroll STUDENT in the placement that meets the criteria set forth above no later than July 1, 1999. The Petaluma District and the SCOE shall be responsible for maintaining this placement through the 1999-2000 school year, including the ESY. The Petaluma District and the SCOE also shall be responsible for STUDENT’s transportation between his home and his school placement and, as appropriate, transportation for one parent to accompany STUDENT.
(5) Within 15 calendar days of the date of this decision, the Petaluma School District and the SCOE shall begin to provide STUDENT with daily individual sign language instruction for the remainder of the 1998-1999 school year, including the ESY, and for the 1999-2000 school year, including the ESY. The therapy shall be provided individually and by a person or persons determined qualified by the IEP team.
(6) Within 15 calendar days of the date of this decision, the Petaluma District and the SCOE shall begin to provide STUDENT with the additional compensatory services the IEP team has determined are appropriate to redress the denial of FAPE that has occurred for at least the past four years. The Petaluma District and the SCOE shall continue to provide the services through the 1999-2000 school year, including the ESY.
(7) The Petaluma District and the SCOE shall provide STUDENT individual sign language instruction and opportunities to practice his sign language during breaks from school that are longer than 10 consecutive school days through the ESY during the summer of 2000. Instruction shall be provided by a person or persons determined qualified by the IEP team.
(8) If STUDENT is placed outside the County, the Petaluma District and the SCOE shall be responsible for locating and funding the compensatory services to which STUDENT is entitled pursuant to this decision.
(9) The Petaluma District and the SCOE shall maintain STUDENT’s current placement, including his one-to-one aide and the services identified on his IEP, including the compensatory services, until STUDENT is placed in an appropriate placement that meets the criteria set forth above.
(10) Petitioner’s remaining requests for relief are denied at this time.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
(1) Did STUDENT receive a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1994-1995 school year?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue as of May 1995.
(2) Did STUDENT receive a FAPE during the 1995-1996 school year?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
(3) Did STUDENT receive a FAPE during the 1996-1997 school year?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
(4) Did STUDENT receive a FAPE during the 1997-1998 school year?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
(5) Did Respondents offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 1998-1999 school year?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
(6) Should STUDENT be placed at the California School for the Deaf (CSD), Northern California, for the remainder of the 1998-1999 school year?
Respondent CSD prevailed on this issue.
(7) If so, does STUDENT require:
(a) a one-to-one aide during all school hours while attending the CSD? (b) a one-to-one aide during all non-school hours while attending the CSD? (c) transportation services between his home and the CSD?
No one prevailed on this issue because the CSD was not found to be an appropriate placement for STUDENT.
(8) Does STUDENT require daily one-to-one speech and language therapy for 30 minutes per session?
No one prevailed on this issue.
(9) What are appropriate remedies if it is determined that the Petaluma District and the SCOE failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE?
(a) What constitutes an appropriate placement for STUDENT?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
(b) Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
(c) Is STUDENT entitled to punitive damages?
Respondents prevailed on this issue.
(d) Is STUDENT entitled to an educational trust fund?
Respondents prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
DATED: March 18, 1999 ________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The issues listed here differ slightly from the issues noticed by Petitioner before the hearing. Some changes were made for purposes of appropriate analysis and for efficient adjudication. Other issues were dismissed. (See “Procedural Matters.”) Finally, issues related to whether STUDENT requires a placement with staff and students proficient in ASL are addressed under the issues related to FAPE.
2. Pursuant to California Education Code § 56505(j), which became effective January 1, 1999, any request for a due process hearing “shall be filed within three years from the date the party initiating the request knew or had reason to know of the facts underlying the basis for the request.”
3. At the time Alexopulos was issued, the IDEA was the Education of the Handicapped Act (EHA) and Section 338(a) of the California Code of Civil Procedure was known as Section 338(l). For purposes of this decision, the term “IDEA” is used to refer to both the EHA and the IDEA. On June 4, 1997, the IDEA was amended. The 1997 amendments to the IDEA will be referred to in this decision as “IDEA 1997.”
4. The Ninth Circuit also addressed the applicability of a statute of limitations to IDEA claims in Dreher v. Amphitheater Unified School District (9th Cir. 1994) 22 F.3d 228. As in Alexopulos, the court applied the State’s three-year statue of limitations. 22 F.2d at 232.
5. Petitioner disputes the accuracy of the estimates of his cognitive skills because of his “minimal exposure to any form of language prior to January 1997. . . .” (Petitioner’s Closing Brief.)
6. The extent to which the BIP has been implemented is discussed in issues below regarding the 1997-1998 and 1998-1999 school years.
7. Ms. Kantor first observed STUDENT during May or June of the 1993-1994 school year, Since then, she has assessed him and provided consultative DHH services to him for several years.
8. The school district in which the parents of the student reside is responsible for educating the student. Education Code § 48200. In this case, Petitioner’s parents reside within the Petaluma District. Respondent SCOE provides special education services to Petaluma students with severe disabilities.
9. There was no IEP immediately preceding the beginning of the 1994-1995 school year. The last IEP had been developed in November 1993 when STUDENT attended Valley Vista Elementary School.
10. Ms. Balthazor explained that SEE has a sign for each word, whereas ASL has its own grammar structure and is not as complicated. For example, a person using SEE would sign each word in the phrase “My name is Pat.” In ASL, the phrase would be signed as “me Pat.”
11. No new IEP was drafted prior to the beginning of the 1995-1996 school year, when STUDENT moved to a different SDC with a different teacher. The class was located in a new school in a different school district. The prior IEP had been developed in December 1994.
12. Mr. Arcanin has held his present position since 1971 and has worked with deaf children since 1959.
13. The right to compensatory education does not create an obligation to provide day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for the opportunities missed. Parents of Student W. ex rel. Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. D. No. 3 (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489.
14. The Third Circuit Court of Appeals concluded that remedies available under the IDEA should not be limited; however, the Court cautioned that “in fashioning a remedy for an IDEA violation, a district court may wish to order educational services, such as compensatory education beyond a child’s age of eligibility, or reimbursement for providing at private expense what should have been offered by the school, rather than compensatory damages for generalized pain and suffering.” W.B. v. Matula (3d. Cir 1995) 67 F.3d 484.
