California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 3, 1996

Student v. Clovis Unified School District (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 647-95, SN 642-95 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote

Clovis Unified must provide twice-weekly direct occupational therapy to a preschooler but may reassess her without parental consent.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 2 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. The District's separate assessment request (SN 1083-95) was not joined with this case, but the assessment issue was heard in this case.

Summary

Clovis Unified School District and the parents of a four-year-old preschooler filed due process requests that were consolidated. The student was eligible as other health impaired, based on a seizure disorder and general developmental delays. Under a mediated agreement, she attended a district special day class for 30 minutes one day a week, when the district's occupational therapist was present. She also attended a private preschool. The district provided occupational therapy (OT) only through a consultative model. The parents sought direct, individual OT. The district sought to reassess her without parental consent.

The Hearing Officer found that the consultative OT had not helped the student, apart from some gains in hand strength. Her fine motor skills remained well below age level. The consultative model relied on daily classroom follow-up, but she attended only once a week, and district staff had never consulted her private preschool teachers. Because of her short attention span, the Hearing Officer ordered direct, individual OT twice a week for 45 minutes per session, plus an IEP meeting. Both had to start within 15 days.

The district won on assessment. The three-year reassessment was not due until 1997, but the Hearing Officer found that conditions warranted an earlier one. The student's primary language is Farsi, and no earlier testing had used a qualified interpreter. Prior cognitive results also conflicted, and current health and peer-observation information was missing. The district may assess using a qualified, impartial interpreter.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO handled consultative OT that depended on classroom follow-up a student was not getting. It also shows how SEHO read the Education Code section 56381 phrase "if conditions warrant." The Hearing Officer allowed reassessment before the triennial because earlier testing used a family member as interpreter instead of a qualified one.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Student's Issue: What is the appropriate nature and frequency of occupational therapy (OT) for STUDENT?

    Consultative OT had not benefited the student, who lacked follow-up and has a short attention span; she requires direct, individual OT twice weekly for 45 minutes per session.

  2. Issue 2. District's Issue: Is the District entitled to conduct an assessment of STUDENT pursuant to the assessment plan contained in the District's Exhibit 18?

    Conditions warranted reassessment before the triennial because no prior testing used a qualified interpreter in the student's primary language (Farsi), results conflicted, and health and peer-observation data were lacking; the plan met Education Code sections 56320 and 56321.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to provide or change services. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, District shall begin providing direct, individual occupational therapy in twice-weekly sessions of 45 minutes each.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, District shall convene an IEP meeting to conform the IEP to the decision.
  • Order that district may assess without consent. District may assess under the assessment plan in District's Exhibit 18, using a qualified and impartial interpreter; if it assesses, it must complete the assessment and hold an IEP meeting within the Education Code section 56344 timelines.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(17); 34 CFR 300.16(b)(5); Education Code § 56381; Education Code § 56320; Education Code § 56321; Education Code § 56506(e)

People named in the decision

  • Janet Van Gelder, director of special education and psychological services, Clovis Unified School District
  • Carole Bence, assistant director of special education, Clovis Unified School District
  • Diane Sherman, contract occupational therapist (OTR), District witness, Clovis Unified School District (contract)
  • Jennifer Coles Kersten, special day class teacher, Jefferson School, Clovis Unified School District
  • Shirley Feasel, school psychologist, District witness, Clovis Unified School District
  • Beccy Powell, school psychologist (initial assessment), Clovis Unified School District
  • Jennifer Fisher, school nurse (initial assessment), Clovis Unified School District
  • Katie Lowe, language and speech specialist (initial assessment), Clovis Unified School District
  • Dennis G. Stuart, Ph.D., senior psychologist, psychological assessment, Central Valley Regional Center
  • H. Terry Hutchison, M.D., Ph.D., child neurologist, Valley Children's Hospital
  • Janice Archbold Smith, independent occupational therapist (OTR) assessor
  • Ramona McDonald, occupational therapist (OTR) evaluator
  • David M. Snyder, M.D., pediatrician, expert witness for Student, Valley Children's Hospital
  • Emily M. Devere, private occupational therapist (OTR), witness for Student
  • Horst D. Weinberg, M.D., physician recommending OT, Valley Children's Hospital
  • Howard J. Glidden, Ph.D., developmental neuropsychologist, independent evaluator
  • Orlantino G. Dyoco, M.D., student's pediatrician
  • Exceptional Parents Unlimited, in-home early intervention provider
  • Clovis Mountain View, private preschool

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Clovis, California, on November 16 and 17, 1995.

Petitioner was represented by attorney Paul D. Farb and advocate S. Chester Faller II. Also present on behalf of STUDENT were her parents. Respondent Clovis Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Diana K. Smith. Also present on behalf of the District were Janet Van Gelder, director of special education and psychological services, and Carole Bence, assistant director of special education.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open to allow the parties to submit written closing briefs. On December 1, 1995, the Hearing Office received the closing brief submitted on behalf of STUDENT. On December 4, 1995, the Hearing Office received the District's closing brief. Thereafter, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

Student's Issue: What is the appropriate nature and frequency of occupational therapy (OT) for STUDENT?

District's Issue: Is the District entitled to conduct an assessment of STUDENT pursuant to the assessment plan contained in the District's Exhibit 18?

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

On June 29, 1995, the Hearing Office received a request for a special education due process hearing on behalf of the District from Janet Van Gelder, director of special education and psychological services. The District named STUDENT as respondent. (SN 642-95) The issues identified for hearing included placement, IEP goals and objectives, and consolidation of special education services.(Footnote 1) On June 30, 1995, the Hearing Office received a request for a hearing from MOTHER on behalf of her daughter regarding provision of occupational therapy (OT). The District was named as respondent. (SN 647-95) By agreement of the parties, the cases were consolidated on July 20, 1995.

On November 6, 1995, the Hearing Office received a second request from the District for a due process hearing on the issue of assessment.(Footnote 2) (SN 1083-95) The District indicated that STUDENT's parents had not consented to its proposed assessment plan. On October 27, 1995, the District had presented its proposed plan to the parents and, on October 30, 1995, had sent a copy of the plan via facsimile to STUDENT's attorney and advocate. (Parent's Exhibit N) The District requested that SN 1083-95 be set for hearing prior to the hearing in SN 647-95/642-95. In the alternative, the District requested that assessment be addressed at the pending hearing in SN 647-95/642-95. In its 10-day notice of issues for hearing in SN 647-95/642-95, the District had identified assessment as an issue. On behalf of STUDENT, Mr. Faller objected to SN 1083-95 being heard first. He also objected to the issue of assessment being addressed at the hearing in SN 647/642-95. In an order dated November 8, 1995, the Hearing Officer denied the District's requests to continue the hearing in SN 647-95/642-95 and to set SN 1083-95 for hearing in advance of SN 647-95/642-95. However, because the District is a petitioner in SN 647-95/642-95, and provided timely notice to the other party that assessment was an issue for hearing, the Hearing Officer determined that the issue of whether the District should be allowed to assess STUDENT without parental consent could be addressed at the hearing in SN 647/642-95.

On November 16, 1995, at the commencement of the hearing in SN 647-95/642-95, Mr. Faller renewed his motion to exclude the issue of assessment from consideration at this hearing. For the same reasons as discussed above, the Hearing Officer denied the renewed motion to exclude assessment as an issue for hearing.

In the closing brief submitted on behalf of STUDENT, her advocates requested that the Hearing Officer make a number of findings and orders, including the following: that STUDENT "would be harmed by placement in a special day class and...that such placement by CUSD is permanently barred" and that a physical therapy (PT) evaluation be undertaken "with intervention initiated as appropriate." The issue of PT was neither identified as an issue for hearing by either party nor addressed at the hearing. Prior to the hearing, the District had withdrawn the issues of placement and IEP goals and objectives and, in a telephone conference on November 13, 1995, the parties had agreed that the only issues for hearing would be the appropriate level of OT for STUDENT and whether the District should be allowed to conduct an assessment of STUDENT.(Footnote 3) Therefore, the decision below addresses only the issues of OT and assessment.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a four-year-old preschool student. She is eligible for special education services as other health impaired. STUDENT's IEP indicates that she has deficits in attention span, pre-academics, language, and psychomotor development. She also has a seizure disorder that is currently controlled by medication. STUDENT attends a special day class (SDC) at Jefferson School for one-half hour, one day per week. The District provides STUDENT with twice weekly speech and language therapy and weekly OT, which is delivered in a consultative model while STUDENT attends the SDC. STUDENT's parents have also enrolled STUDENT in Clovis Mountain View, a private preschool program.

From the age of 6 to 18 months, STUDENT received in-home services through Exceptional Parents Unlimited. The program was designed to develop STUDENT's cognitive and fine and gross motor skills to prepare her for preschool.

On October 11, 1994, Dennis G. Stuart, Ph.D., senior psychologist for the Central Valley Regional Center, completed a psychological assessment of STUDENT. STUDENT scored in the average range for verbal skills and in the borderline range for visual-motor tasks. She also had a short attention span and delays in fine and gross motor functioning. Dr. Stuart concluded that the "overall picture suggests a girl with normal intelligence...." In the assessment report, it was noted that STUDENT "does not speak any English and [mother] acted as interpreter. Unfortunately this made for some difficulties with the testing." (Parents' Exhibit H) H. Terry Hutchison, M.D., Ph.D., child neurologist of the Valley Children's Hospital, noted following his appointment with STUDENT on October 28, 1994, that she appeared to be functioning in the low normal range. (Parents' Exhibit K)

On November 4, 1994, the District assessed STUDENT in response to a referral for special education. The assessment team included Beccy Powell, school psychologist; Jennifer Fisher, school nurse; and Katie Lowe, language and speech specialist. (District's Exhibit 5) On November 8, 1994, the IEP team concluded that STUDENT met special education eligibility criteria as "other health impaired" because of a seizure disorder and general developmental delays. District members of the team recommended that STUDENT be placed in an early intervention SDC preschool program with speech and language services and mainstreaming. STUDENT's parents did not agree with the District's recommended placement. The IEP team then agreed to place STUDENT in the Learn Program, which is a twice-weekly preschool program that focuses on language development. Beginning in November 1994, Diane Sherman, District registered occupational therapist (OTR), provided several home consultations to assist in the development of STUDENT's motor skills. (District's Exhibit 6) Approximately one month after STUDENT entered the Learn Program, the teacher requested an IEP meeting to address her concerns regarding STUDENT's placement. At a meeting in December 1994, the IEP team agreed that STUDENT would receive resource services (RSP) rather than participate in the Learn Program. In January 1995, the RSP teacher began seeing STUDENT thirty minutes per week to improve her: attention span and concentration; preacademic skills of sorting, grouping, problem solving, and sequencing; and psychomotor development. STUDENT's motor deficits were addressed in consultation with the District's occupational therapist. (District's Exhibit 8)

On March 1, 1995, Ms. Sherman conducted an OT assessment of STUDENT on behalf of the District. As part of her assessment, Ms. Sherman administered the Peabody Developmental Motor Scales. STUDENT was able to use a pincer grasp but did so inconsistently. She was able to hold a pencil with an age-appropriate tripod grasp but exhibited difficulty copying designs. She was able to move her wrist in isolation but not in conjunction with fine motor tasks. She used a slight forearm rotation but generally used shoulder rotation, which was age-appropriate. According to Ms Sherman, STUDENT was not developmentally ready to perform precision perceptual fine motor activities or complex motor patterns or coordinate combined movement patterns. (District's Exhibit 13)

Because of their concerns regarding STUDENT's motor development, the PARENTS obtained a number of independent assessments. On March 27, 1995, when STUDENT was approximately three years and five months old, Janice Archbold Smith, OTR, assessed STUDENT's fine and gross motor skills. Her assessment included the Hawaii Learning Profile for Preschoolers and additional information from MOTHER. Ms. Smith found that STUDENT's gross motor skills fell within the 24 to 30 month range and her fine motor skills fell between the 24 to 28 month range. Ms. Smith noted concern regarding STUDENT's "uncoordinated movements, difficulty with manipulating small objects and poor coordination of bilateral tasks." Ms. Smith recommended OT to increase coordination, fine motor manipulation, dexterity, and motor planning. (Parents' Exhibit B)

In a letter dated April 21, 1995, Dr. Hutchinson of Valley Children's Hospital recommended that STUDENT remain in her regular preschool program and be provided occupational and physical therapy through Valley Children's therapy units.(Footnote 4) (Parents' Exhibit C) In May 1995, MediCal approved three months of direct OT for STUDENT. In a letter dated July 25, 1995, Ramona McDonald, OTR, discussed her May 1995 evaluation of STUDENT, which had been the basis for the OT funded through MediCal. Ms. McDonald stated that therapy was recommended because of problems STUDENT "demonstrated in delayed oral motor skills, sensory defensiveness, and a significant two year delay in fine motor skills...." (Parents' Exhibit D)

The parties were unable to agree on placement and services at the end-of-the-year IEP meeting in June 1995. On June 29, 1995, the District filed its request for a due process hearing and, on June 30, 1995, the PARENTS filed their request for hearing.

On August 17, 1995, David M. Snyder, M.D., pediatrician at Valley Children's Hospital, assessed STUDENT. He found weaknesses in expressive language and fine motor development with relative strengths in cognition, social interaction, and receptive language. Dr. Snyder recommended that STUDENT continue in a regular preschool setting for peer language stimulation and socialization and be provided individual speech and language therapy and OT. (Parents' Exhibit F)

Through mediation on August 18, 1995, the parties agreed that beginning on September 5, 1995, STUDENT would attend the SDC at Jefferson on the day that the District's occupational therapist was available for consultation to the class. The additional components of STUDENT's placement, including speech and language services, were also agreed to through mediation and are incorporated in the IEP dated August 18, 1995. (District's Exhibit 11)

Emily M. Devere, OTR, provided STUDENT with direct OT that was funded by MediCal. Ms. Devere's report dated October 3, 1995, which she prepared at the end of the sessions, recommended that STUDENT continue to receive weekly OT for two more months. (Parents' Exhibit L) The PARENTS decided to pursue provision of OT for STUDENT through the special education hearing process and did not request that MediCal fund additional OT.

On October 27, 1995, the District presented its proposed assessment plan to STUDENT's parents. On October 30, 1995, a copy of the assessment plan was also sent via facsimile to STUDENT's attorney and advocate. The District proposed to assess STUDENT in the areas of health and development, motor/perceptual development, cognitive, academic/preacademic achievement, communicative development, and personal, social, and emotional development. The District also proposed to review medical and other records, and to update the OT assessment.(Footnote 5) (District's Exhibit N) STUDENT's parents have not consented to the proposed assessment plan.

In a prescription dated October 28, 1995, Horst D. Weinberg, M.D., from Valley Children's Hospital, recommended that STUDENT receive OT two to three times a week. (Parents' Exhibit Ia) In a subsequent letter dated November 13, 1995, Dr. Weinberg recommended three session of OT per week. (Parents Exhibit Ib)

On October 30, 1995, Howard J. Glidden, Ph.D., developmental neuropsychologist, conducted an evaluation of STUDENT.(Footnote 6) Dr. Glidden administered the Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scale, 4th edition, interviewed MOTHER, and observed STUDENT. He concluded that STUDENT was functioning "variably" in the slow learner level of ability with some scores falling in the low average range. Dr. Glidden noted that STUDENT found visual-spatial and visual-motor tasks to be especially difficult. Dr. Glidden's recommendations include placement in a regular classroom with speech and language therapy to address language processing deficits. He also recommended that STUDENT be provided OT to address coordination, visual-motor integration, and visual-spatial information processing, and that a physical therapy (PT) assessment be undertaken to address limitations he noted in STUDENT's gait and ambulation. (Parents' Exhibit J)

The current dispute is regarding whether the District can conduct an assessment of STUDENT and regarding the nature and frequency of OT services STUDENT requires. The District contends that an assessment is warranted primarily because of discrepant findings in previous assessments and because a qualified interpreter has not been utilized in any assessments. STUDENT's native language is Farsi. The PARENTS object to any testing of STUDENT on the basis that there is sufficient information contained in prior assessments. The PARENTS contend that STUDENT requires direct OT to benefit from her education. They propose that OT be delivered by an OTR directly to STUDENT in individual sessions three times per week for 45 minutes each.(Footnote 7) The District contends that STUDENT does not require direct OT and that her deficits in fine and gross motor can be met by the SDC teacher and aide in consultation with the District's occupational therapist. The District asserts that STUDENT has the ability to perform the basic motor patterns required for school activities and that she only needs to practice these movements to enhance her strength. The District also asserts that STUDENT's motor delays are commensurate with delays in other areas of her development.

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY

Testimony Regarding OT

MOTHER testified that STUDENT requires direct OT to bring her motor skills up to the same level as her academic skills. MOTHER testified that STUDENT is unable to cross the midline of her body, to copy a circle, to cut on a line, or to button and unbutton. She also has a poor gait and is uncoordinated. To meet these needs, MOTHER asserted that STUDENT requires direct OT provided three times per week for 45 minutes each. MOTHER testified that STUDENT requires one-to-one therapy because she has a short attention span. MOTHER testified that her request for OT services is consistent with the recommendations of all of the professionals who have assessed STUDENT.

David Snyder, M.D., pediatrician, testified on behalf of STUDENT. Based on his assessment of STUDENT during the summer of 1995, Dr. Snyder concluded that STUDENT requires direct, individual OT to address fine and visual motor deficits. He testified that these deficits affect STUDENT's ability to perform certain tasks, some of which are educational. Dr. Snyder stated the following in support of his recommendation: STUDENT benefits more from individualized instruction than from group instruction; an OTR has more training and experience working with children with motor deficits than an aide or classroom teacher; and an OTR can provide the parents with activities to do at home to support OT. Dr. Snyder noted that trained aides and teachers monitored by an OTR may be used after a period of time to support the activities introduced by the OTR.

Dr. Snyder stated that he generally recommends an intensive initial OT program. For example, participation in more than one session allows opportunities for the student to have concepts reinforced and to participate in follow-up activities. Dr. Snyder noted that, given STUDENT's short attention span, a session of 60 minutes duration may be too long for her. He stated that additional factors to consider in determining the frequency and duration of OT include the specific goals being addressed in therapy, the support available in the classroom setting, and the follow-up provided at home.

Emily Devere, OTR, testified on behalf of STUDENT. Through MediCal, Ms. Devere provided STUDENT four sessions of direct, individual OT. She also assessed STUDENT at the end of the sessions. Ms. Devere testified that, although nearly four years old, STUDENT scored a mean age of 21 months on fine motor tasks and was not able to perform at age level on any measures of the Peabody. Ms. Devere testified that the fine motor tasks assessed by the Peabody--using scissors, separating beads, picking up small objects, turning pages, copying circles, and buttoning and unbuttoning--are all skills that are necessary for learning. Ms. Devere testified that STUDENT also lacks intrinsic strength in her hands and she fatigues in a sitting position after two minutes. Ms. Devere testified that development of these skills is essential for STUDENT to be able to write and to sit in class. Ms. Devere stated that STUDENT also has gross motor needs. She concluded that OT is necessary for STUDENT for educational purposes.

Ms. Devere testified that one-half hour of consultative OT is not sufficient to meet STUDENT's OT needs. She testified that to address STUDENT's fine motor deficits and hand and upper body weaknesses, she requires one or two direct OT sessions per week of 45 to 60 minutes each. She recommended that, to reinforce the concepts taught in direct OT, STUDENT should participate in 45 to 60 minutes of daily follow-up activities with an aide, parent, or teacher.

Diane Sherman, OTR, testified on behalf of the District. Ms. Sherman is in private practice and contracts with the District to provide OT services to students in the District and in-service training for District staff. Ms. Sherman consulted with STUDENT's parents and, in March 1995, assessed STUDENT for the District. Ms. Sherman described the SDC that STUDENT attends one day per week as a "play-based" class that is taught by a transdisciplinary team. Ms. Sherman stated that she shares responsibility with the SDC teacher and speech and language therapist for planning activities to address all of the students' developmental domains. From 8:30 a.m. to 9:00 a.m. on each Tuesday, Ms. Sherman works directly with the students in the SDC and provides consultation to the SDC teacher regarding the student's needs. The students participate in thematic play activities to develop fine and gross motor skills. For example, all of the activities during one week were related to fire engines. Ms. Sherman stated that students' coordination and muscle skills were enhanced by putting on fire hats and by climbing on a fire truck. Ms. Sherman testified that STUDENT is benefitting from her participation in the program. Specifically, she stated that STUDENT's hand strength is improving. Ms. Sherman noted that because STUDENT attends the class only one day per week, she does not receive the benefit of practicing the targeted skills throughout the rest of the week. Ms. Sherman stated that she has not consulted with any of the staff at the preschool STUDENT attends.

Ms. Sherman testified that in determining whether a student requires OT for educational purposes, she reviews and evaluates prior testing of the student, the classroom environment and the type of activities occurring in the classroom, the student's abilities in the educational environment, road blocks to accomplishing IEP goals, and the student's overall level of functioning. Ms. Sherman testified that direct OT is not required for preschool students unless a student lacks the underlying motor skills necessary for the task. Ms. Sherman testified that, if the skills are present, it is the job of the teacher to establish patterns of use through developmentally appropriate activities in consultation with the occupational therapist. Ms. Sherman testified that STUDENT does not require direct OT services because she has the underlying skills that are necessary for her to participate in preschool educational activities. She also noted that STUDENT is similarly delayed in other areas of development. Ms. Sherman also testified that STUDENT does not require the expertise of an OTR to provide developmentally appropriate activities.

Jennifer Coles Kersten is the SDC teacher at Jefferson. Ms. Kersten testified that Ms. Sherman consults with her regarding the students' weaknesses and instructs her how to facilitate activities to address them during the remainder of the week. Ms. Kersten stated that she has not consulted with any of the staff of the preschool STUDENT attends.

Shirley Feasel, school psychologist, reviewed STUDENT's school records and assessments and concluded that STUDENT's gross and fine motor skills are commensurate with current measures of her overall development.

Testimony Regarding Assessment

Shirley Feasel, school psychologist, testified on behalf of the District regarding its proposed assessment of STUDENT and the reasons District personnel believe that a reassessment of STUDENT is needed. Ms. Feasel testified that an assessment is warranted because of concerns regarding the validity of prior testing. Ms. Feasel testified that STUDENT's native language is Farsi; however, testing of STUDENT was conducted either in English or with STUDENT's mother used as an interpreter. Ms. Feasel stated that in the field of psychology, it is not considered a good practice to have tests interpreted by other than objective and trained persons. According to Ms. Feasel, family members do not meet this criteria and are never used in administering standardized psychological tests. Ms. Feasel stated that, if it is allowed to assess STUDENT, the District would utilize a trained and objective interpreter. Ms. Feasel testified that an assessment of STUDENT's communication skills is warranted because prior testing was completed without the use of a qualified interpreter.

Ms. Feasel also testified that the results of prior psycho-educational testing are inconsistent and that, for this reason, an assessment is necessary. Ms. Feasel testified that prior assessors have placed STUDENT's cognitive abilities in average, slow learner, or mentally retarded ranges. The findings are also discrepant as to whether STUDENT has delays that affect all areas of her development. Ms. Feasel testified that it is important to understand the nature of STUDENT's delays because of the effect on the type of services she requires, the way in which services are delivered, and the staffing needed to provide services. For example, Ms. Feasel stated that OT would be offered if there is a discrepant delay in the development of STUDENT's motor skills in comparison to her overall development. However, if her delays are global, deficits in motor development would be addressed as part of the overall classroom curriculum and she would need to be taught at a slow pace and in a concrete manner. Skills would also need to be reinforced throughout the curriculum and repeatedly addressed to assist STUDENT to learn to generalize the skills to other environments. Ms. Feasel noted that classes for students with lower cognitive abilities generally have a lower student-to-teacher ratio than classes for students with other disabilities. As part of the preacademic readiness testing, the District proposes to have STUDENT's preschool teacher and OTR assess STUDENT's preacademic fine and gross motor skills--copying, building, lacing, and cutting.

The District also proposes to assess STUDENT's personal, social, and emotional development by observing her with a facilitator and in the preschool setting with peers. Ms. Feasel testified that personal, social, and emotional areas have not been addressed in previous assessments. Ms. Feasel testified that an assessment is warranted in this area because the District has not had an opportunity to observe STUDENT in her private preschool. Such an observation would provide information regarding STUDENT's attention span and social skills with peers. Ms. Feasel testified that the brief period STUDENT attends the SDC is insufficient to allow for these observations.

According to Ms. Feasel, there are also questions regarding STUDENT's seizure activity. Ms. Feasel testified that current health information is important because the various reports from physicians submitted by the PARENTS contain disparate information regarding the number and severity of seizures STUDENT has and also regarding the medication she is receiving to control her seizures. A current health assessment is also warranted because the District has not conducted a health assessment following the onset of a serious seizure as reported by MOTHER. Ms. Feasel testified that the school nurse would gather pertinent information regarding STUDENT's health from the family and health-care providers. Ms. Feasel testified that information in all of the proposed areas would also be gathered from STUDENT's mother, her preschool teachers, and medical and school records.

MOTHER does not believe that the District should be allowed to conduct additional testing. She testified that the District assessed STUDENT within the last year. She has also obtained a number of independent assessments. MOTHER concedes that STUDENT is more fluent in Farsi than she is in English. In Farsi, STUDENT uses sentences of four to seven or more words. STUDENT uses three- to five-word sentences in English. MOTHER testified that English and Farsi have different syntax and that adjectives are used in different places. She testified that no one has ever told her the test results would be invalid either because an interpreter was not used or because she interpreted during testing.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

STUDENT's Issue: What is the appropriate nature and frequency of occupational therapy (OT) for STUDENT?

Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the student's individualized educational program. "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child...." 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).

Related services are those required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(17); Education Code § 56363. Included in the list of related services is OT. OT is provided to address:

(i) Improving, developing or restoring functions impaired or lost through illness, injury, or deprivation; (ii) Improving ability to perform tasks for independent functioning when functions are impaired or lost; and (iii) Preventing, through early intervention, initial or further impairment or loss of function.

34 CFR 300.16(b)(5).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the student. 458 U.S. 175, 200.

The parties agree that in order to benefit from her special education, STUDENT requires the related service of OT. Accordingly, OT is included as a related service on her most recent IEP. (District's Exhibit 11) Goals and objectives developed in June 1995 address fine and gross motor skills. The fine motor objectives state that by June 1996, STUDENT will be able to build a tower using 10 blocks; complete a puzzle consisting of at least eight pieces; trace along vertical and horizontal lines; and learn basic concepts through sensorimotor movement activities. The gross motor objectives are for STUDENT to: be able to walk down stairs alternating feet while holding on to a handrail; stand on either foot momentarily without support; and stand on one foot for five seconds without support. (District's Exhibit 15)

To be appropriate, related services must be designed to provide STUDENT with benefit. According to the testimony of Dr. Snyder, M.D., pediatrician, and Ms. Devere, OTR, STUDENT requires direct, individual OT to address deficits in fine motor and visual motor areas that affect her ability to perform certain educational tasks. Those tasks include using scissors, separating beads, picking up small objects, turning pages, copying circles, and buttoning and unbuttoning. STUDENT also exhibits fatigue sitting and has poor muscles strength in her hands.

Ms. Sherman, the District's OT, testified that consultative OT services meets STUDENT's needs. Ms. Sherman found that STUDENT's mean motor skills fell at the 31-month level when she assessed her in March 1995. STUDENT was functioning at the fourth percentile in eye-hand coordination, at the sixth percentile in manual dexterity, and in the 49th percentile in overall hand use. STUDENT was 40 months old at the time of testing. (District's Exhibit 13) Ms. Sherman testified that STUDENT has shown improvement in hand strength. Ms. Devere, who recently provided direct OT to STUDENT, testified that on her testing of STUDENT in October 1995, STUDENT scored a mean age of 21 months on fine motor tasks and was not at age level on any measures of fine motor skills. The scores obtained by Ms. Devere were not contested. The evidence establishes that STUDENT continues to have deficits in fine motor skills.

STUDENT received four sessions of direct OT from Ms. Devere, which were funded by MediCal. The bulk of the OT she has received has been through the District's consultative model. Beginning in the fall of 1994, the District has provided STUDENT with consultative OT services at home, through an RSP teacher who consulted with the District's OTR, and in the SDC during the current school year. Based on the lack of improvement in STUDENT's fine motor skills, except in the area of hand strength, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT has not benefitted from consultative OT as provided by the District.

In order to be appropriate, related services must be designed to meet the unique and individual needs of STUDENT. Ms. Devere, who has provided direct services to STUDENT and recently assessed her, testified persuasively that because of STUDENT's attention span and the lack of follow-up services available to STUDENT, the consultative model of OT is not designed to meet STUDENT's needs. Dr. Snyder also testified that STUDENT requires individual OT, rather than group or consultative OT, because of her short attention span. STUDENT's short attention span has been noted in numerous educational records and by nearly all of the professionals, including District personnel, who have worked with her.

The District's preschool SDC is designed to allow students who participate in the program to receive OT, as well as other services, in a consultative model wherein the students attend the class every day of the week and the teacher provides ongoing activities in consultation with the OT and speech and language specialists to address the students' deficits. STUDENT attends the class only one day during the 30 minutes that the OTR is present in the class.(Footnote 8) Ms. Sherman, the OTR, and Jennifer Coles Kersten, the SDC teacher, testified that they have never consulted with STUDENT's preschool teachers and there was no evidence that STUDENT receives follow-up activities to support the minimal time she is present at the SDC. At the hearing, Ms. Bence, assistant director of special education, indicated that the District would be willing to consult with STUDENT's teachers. However, other District witnesses testified that they were uncertain of the ability of private preschool teachers to provide appropriate follow-through activities.

The District witnesses attributed STUDENT's delayed motor skills to a global developmental delay. The Hearing Officer notes that the District witnesses testified, as discussed more fully below in the issue regarding assessment, that prior assessments of STUDENT place her in average to retarded ranges of cognitive ability and are of questionable validity due to the way testing was conducted. For these reasons, the District has proposed additional testing of STUDENT. Even if further testing shows that STUDENT has broad developmental delays, the District did not present persuasive legal authority to support its position that direct OT is not appropriate for students with developmental delays. According to 34 CFR 300.16(b)(5), OT may be provided to improve, develop, or restore functions.

Based on the evidence regarding STUDENT's distractibility and short attention span, STUDENT's lack of improvement while receiving services through the consultative model, her continued delay in fine motor skills that are necessary to succeed educationally, and the absence of follow-up under the District's current consultative model, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT requires direct, individual OT to meet her unique and individual needs.

As to the number of sessions per week, during testimony, Ms. Devere recommended one or two sessions per week of 45 to 60 minutes duration. Dr. Snyder testified that, given STUDENT's short attention span, a session of 60 minutes would be too long for her. Dr. Weinberg recommended two to three sessions per week but did not specify the length of the sessions. Because District witnesses did not believe that STUDENT requires direct OT, they did not testify as to the appropriate length or frequency of such services. Ms. Devere is the only witnesses who has provided direct OT to STUDENT. Therefore, based on her testimony, taken in consideration with the other recommendations regarding the appropriate length and frequency of OT services, as well as STUDENT's short attention span, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT requires two sessions each week of direct OT of 45 minutes each.

District's Issue: Is the District entitled to conduct an assessment of STUDENT pursuant to the assessment plan contained in District's Exhibit 18?

California Education Code § 56381 addresses when a school district may assess a special education student. Section 56381 provides that:

A reassessment of the pupil...shall be conducted at least every three years or more frequently, if conditions warrant, or if the pupil's parent or teacher requests a new assessment and a new individualized education program to be developed.

Prior written consent of the student's parent must be obtained before the district may conduct an assessment of the student unless the District prevails in a special education due process hearing regarding the right to assess the student over the objection of the parent. California Education Code § 56506(e).

In order to be appropriate, the proposed assessment plan must meet the following requirements: It must be in a language easily understood by the general public; be provided in the primary language of the parent; explain the types of assessments to be conducted; and state that an IEP will not be developed as a result of the assessment without the consent of the parent. Education Code § 56321(b)(1)-(4). The assessment itself must meet the requirements of California Education Code § 56320, which states, in relevant part, that the assessment must be administered by trained personnel, draw information from a variety of sources, utilize instruments that are not racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory and that have been validated for the purpose for which they are used. Tests and other assessment materials must also be "provided and administered in the pupil's primary language...unless the assessment plan indicates reasons why such provision and administration are not clearly feasible." Education Code § 56320(b)(1).

The initial assessment of STUDENT by the District was in November 1994. A triennial assessment is, therefore, not due until November 1997. A reassessment may occur when requested by a parent or teacher. No such request has been made in this case. Other than every three years or when requested by a parent or teacher, section 56381 allows for reassessment when requested by a student's parent or teacher or "if conditions warrant." The phrase "if conditions warrant" provides little guidance as to what "conditions" give a district the right to conduct an assessment in advance of the next regularly scheduled triennial reassessment. The phrase appears to refer to circumstances that are unusual or out-of-the-ordinary. For example, an assessment may be warranted when there is a substantial change in the student's academic performance or disabling condition.

STUDENT has been assessed on a number of occasions since 1994. Prior to the District's assessment, the Regional Center conducted a psychological assessment of STUDENT in October 1994. The assessment consisted of the Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scale, Fourth Edition, and the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales. (Parents' Exhibit H) The District's initial assessment of STUDENT in November 1994 assessed STUDENT's cognitive and pre-academic skills using the Developmental Activities Screening Inventory and the Battelle Developmental Inventory. The District also conducted a health assessment. The report notes STUDENT's seizure activity. The District also assessed STUDENT's fine motor skills on the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scale Expanded Edition and Developmental Test of Visual Motor Integration, and her gross motor skills on the Learning Accomplishment Profile-Diagnostic Edition and the Vineland. The Vineland also provided information on STUDENT's social, emotional, and self-help skills. The District used MOTHER as an interpreter in its assessment of STUDENT's language skills. (District's Exhibit 5) The most recent psychological assessment of STUDENT by Dr. Glidden on October 30, 1995, included administering of the Stanford-Binet IV. (Parents' Exhibit J) STUDENT's fine and gross motor skills were assessed by the District in March 1995, and by independent OTRs in March 1995, May 1995, and October 1995.

There is no dispute that STUDENT's primary language is Farsi and that she is currently more fluent in Farsi than she is in English. The Regional Center assessor, who completed a psychological assessment of STUDENT on October 11, 1994, stated that STUDENT did not speak any English at the time of her assessment. MOTHER interpreted during the assessment. The assessor noted that these factors "made for some difficulties with the testing." (Parents' Exhibit H) There was no evidence to rebut Ms. Feasel's concerns regarding the validity of prior testing because of the lack of an interpreter or her testimony that family members should not be used as interpreters when administering standardized testing.(Footnote 9) None of the assessments of STUDENT have been administered with the use of a qualified interpreter. There also was no persuasive evidence to rebut Ms. Feasel's testimony regarding the significance of having reliable information regarding STUDENT's functional levels to develop an appropriate educational program for STUDENT. Moreover, pursuant to Education Code § 56320(b)(1), tests and other materials must be "provided and administered in the pupil's primary language...." Given that STUDENT's primary language is Farsi and the unrebutted testimony of Ms. Feasel, the Hearing Officer concludes that unusual or out-of-the-ordinary circumstances exist in this case to warrant an assessment of STUDENT in advance of the triennial. In reaching this determination, the Hearing Officer also considered the fact that STUDENT is a preschool student whose needs are rapidly changing, that current health information is necessary because of STUDENT's seizure disorder, and that none of the prior assessments of STUDENT have included an observation of STUDENT with her peers in an educational setting.

No objections were raised by the parents regarding the assessment plan, the assessors, or the specific assessment procedures the District proposed to utilize in its assessment of STUDENT. The assessment will be conducted by a school nurse, school psychologist, language and speech specialist, and special education teacher. There was no evidence that the assessment procedures would be administered other than by trained personnel or that the assessment instruments or materials are racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. The plan proposes to obtain information from a variety of sources--medical and educational records, testing, parents, STUDENT's current private preschool teacher, and District personnel who are providing services to STUDENT. The District has proposed to utilize a qualified interpreter to satisfy the requirement of Education Code § 56320(b)(i) that tests and assessment materials are administered in STUDENT's primary language. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District's proposed assessment satisfies the requirements of Education Code Sections 56320 and 56321.

Therefore, for the reasons stated above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District is entitled to conduct a reassessment of STUDENT in accordance with the assessment plan set forth in the District's Exhibit 18 and with the use of a qualified and impartial interpreter.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

STUDENT's Issue: What is the appropriate nature and frequency of occupational therapy (OT) for STUDENT?

The parents prevailed on this issue.

District's Issue: Is the District entitled to conduct an assessment of STUDENT pursuant to the assessment plan contained in the District's Exhibit 18?

The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

ORDER

(1) Within 15 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall begin providing STUDENT with direct, individual occupational therapy for twice weekly sessions of 45 minutes each.

(2) Within 15 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to conform STUDENT's IEP to this decision.

(3) The District may conduct an assessment of STUDENT in accordance with the assessment plan set forth in the District's Exhibit 18. If the District undertakes the assessment, it must be completed and an IEP meeting convened to discuss the assessment within the required time lines as set forth in Education Code § 56344.

DATED: January 3, 1996 _____________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES

1. The District later withdrew these issues from consideration at the due process hearing.

2. The District's new request for hearing has not been joined with this case. 3. As discussed above, Mr. Faller continued to object to the inclusion of assessment as an issue for hearing in SN 647-95/642-95.

4. In a letter dated August 17, 1995, Orlantino G. Dyoco, M.D., STUDENT's pediatrician since infancy, stated that he concurred with Dr. Hutchinson's recommendations that STUDENT be "placed in an integrated classroom with normal children, as well as be provided with special help as needed." (Parents' Exhibit G)

5. On the second day of the hearing, the District amended its assessment plan. The revised assessment plan does not include the areas of cognitive and motor/perceptual development. The proposal to update the OT assessment was also not included in the revised assessment plan.

6. STUDENT had been referred to Dr. Glidden by Dr. Snyder.

7. At various times during the hearing, different levels of OT were proposed for STUDENT. During her testimony at the hearing, MOTHER requested three sessions per week of 45 minutes each.

8. Although no determination is made in this decision regarding the appropriate placement for STUDENT, the Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT attends the SDC only one day per week by agreement of the parties. This agreement was reached through mediation and subsequently incorporated into STUDENT's IEP.

9. The concerns regarding the use of a family member as an interpreter during testing do not in any way imply any criticism of MOTHER. There are certain accepted practices in the field of psychology which are adopted to ensure the validity of testing.