California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 27, 2004
Panama Buena Vista Union School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 689-04 · Hearing Officer Deborah M. Cooke
Panama Buena Vista Union may assess a preschooler at school sites under its proposed schedule over the parents' objections.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The decision notes a prior District-filed due process case (SN03-02373) that settled on December 5, 2003. In that settlement the parents consented to assessment and the District agreed to reimburse private preschool tuition.
Summary
Panama Buena Vista Union School District filed for a hearing over how it would assess a four-year-old girl. She was eligible for special education under established medical disability, with autistic-like behaviors as a secondary category, and her parents had placed her at Sierra Montessori Children's Center, a private preschool. In a December 2003 settlement, the parents consented to District assessments to plan her fall 2004 program. The parties then disagreed about where testing would happen, how many sessions it would take, and how long each session would be. By the second hearing day, only the occupational therapy (OT), adaptive physical education (APE), and psychological and academic assessments were still disputed. The parents wanted most testing done at home in a few long sessions. The Hearing Officer sided with the District. Occupational therapist Debi Hazel credibly testified that three one-hour sessions at Buena Vista Elementary and at home, plus a short observation at Sierra, would get better cooperation from a preschooler and show how the child functions at school. APE specialist Byron Lewis persuasively explained why he needed to see her at school, playing near peers. School psychologist Denita Maughan justified two observations at Sierra and up to three sessions at the Richardson Center. The District may assess as proposed. It must give five calendar days' notice, plan around the child's schedule, and update the parents after each session.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO handled a dispute where parents consented to assessment but objected to its location and length. The Hearing Officer relied on assessor testimony about school-based needs and a young child's attention span. She also ordered the District to work around the family's schedule and keep the parents informed.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedDistrict-filed: assess without consent
Issue 1. Are the District's parameters for assessment in the areas of occupational therapy, adaptive physical education, and psychological and academic testing appropriate?
The District's proposed locations, number of sessions, and session lengths for the OT, APE, and psychological/academic assessments were appropriate, and the District may assess as proposed in its April 23, 2004 amended issue statement, with scheduling conditions to limit disruption to the child's routine.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order that district may assess without consent. District is entitled to assess the student as proposed in its amended issue statement dated April 23, 2004, consistent with the decision's findings: OT in three one-hour sessions (Buena Vista Elementary and home) plus an observation of under one hour at Sierra Montessori; APE in a single session at Sierra, with a possible second session; psychological/academic testing with two observations at Sierra, two sessions at the Richardson Center, and a possible additional session.
- District must set assessment dates with five calendar days' notice to parents, first obtain the child's daily and weekly schedules, and coordinate times and locations to minimize disruption; where more than one session is needed, District must update parents on progress after each session and estimate the time needed for any additional session. Parents must make the child reasonably available for assessment.
Key authorities
20 U.S.C. § 1414(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320; Cal. Educ. Code § 56507(d)
People named in the decision
- Janis Spinozzi, director of special education, Panama Buena Vista Union School District
- Rita Pierucci, coordinator of special education, Panama Buena Vista Union School District
- Gregory Rhoten, coordinator of special education; District witness, Panama Buena Vista Union School District
- Troy Tickle, speech therapist; District witness
- Ranee Gorman, director and owner of private preschool; District witness, Sierra Montessori Children's Center
- Barbara Melton, private preschool teacher; District witness, Sierra Montessori Children's Center
- Debi Hazel, occupational therapist and assessor, Kern County Superintendent of Schools
- Kathleen Finley, occupational therapist, Kern County Superintendent of Schools
- Byron Lewis, adaptive physical education specialist, Kern County Superintendent of Schools
- Denita Maughan, school psychologist, Panama Buena Vista Union School District
- Dr. Nina Kogan, private psychological evaluator
- Hand in Hand, private occupational therapy evaluator
- Sierra Montessori Children's Center, private preschool (unilateral placement)
- Richardson Center, assessment site / potential placement
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Bakersfield, California, on May 4 and 5, 2004.
Petitioner Panama Buena Vista Union School District (hereafter Petitioner or District) was represented by attorney Carol Grogan of School Legal Services. Also present on behalf of the District was Janis Spinozzi, director of special education for the District. Present on behalf of the District at various times during the hearing were Rita Pierucci and Gregory Rhoten, both coordinators of special education for the District. Respondent STUDENT (hereafter STUDENT or Student) was represented by attorney Debra Wright. Also present on behalf of STUDENT was her mother, MOTHER.
The District called the following witnesses: Troy Tickle, speech therapist; Ranee Gorman, director and owner of Sierra Montessori Children’s Center (Sierra); Barbara Melton, STUDENT’s teacher at Sierra; Debi Hazel, occupational therapist for the Kern County Superintendent of Schools; Kathleen Finley, occupational therapist for the Kern County Superintendent of Schools; Gregory Rhoten; Byron Lewis, adaptive physical education specialist for the Kern County Superintendent of Schools; Janis Spinozzi; and Denita Maughan, school psychologist for the District.
The Student called the following witness: MOTHER.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of the parties’ oral closing arguments, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUE (Footnote 1)
1. Are the District’s parameters for assessment in the areas of occupational therapy, adaptive physical education, and psychological and academic testing appropriate?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Petitioner District contends that the assessment parameters set forth in its amended issue statement dated April 23, 2004, are appropriate and that, therefore, the District should be allowed to assess STUDENT according to its proposed assessment parameters. (Dist.’s Exh. 109.) With respect to occupational therapy, the District argues that it requires three one-hour sessions. Two sessions would be at Buena Vista Elementary School, the location of STUDENT’s regular occupational therapy sessions, and one at Sierra Montessori Children’s Center (Sierra), her current school of attendance. An additional OT observation would be conducted at Sierra concurrently with the adaptive physical education (APE) assessment. In the area of adaptive physical education, the District proposed to conduct this assessment in a single session at Sierra. If the initial visit progressed well, a second visit would not be needed. And finally, the District proposed psychological and academic assessments that included two observations at Sierra, one session of play-based assessment at the Richardson Center, one session of academic testing and parent interview at the Richardson Center, and a final session at the Richardson Center to be used if something observed in an earlier session suggested the need for further observation/assessment.
The Student argues that the District’s proposed assessment parameters are unreasonable and therefore alleges that the assessments should be conducted in the following manner: occupational therapy assessment to be conducted at the STUDENT’S home in one three-hour session; adaptive physical education assessment to be conducted on a separate day in one two-hour session at the STUDENT’S home; and the psychological and academic testing to be conducted in one two-hour session at the STUDENT’S home, and one three-hour session at the Richardson Center.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
STUDENT is a four-year-old student who has a diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder, trichotillomania (pulling out and consuming one’s own hair and carpet, head banging, eye poking, etc.), pica (eating foreign substances) and seizure disorder. STUDENT resides within the Panama Buena Vista Union School District boundaries, but attends Sierra Montessori Children’s Center, a private school in Bakersfield, California, in which her parents unilaterally placed her. STUDENT qualifies for special education and related services under the primary category of established medical disability and secondarily, under the category of autistic-like behaviors.
STUDENT has lived with PARENTS since she was nineteen days old, and she has since been adopted by the PARENTS. A previous health report dated April 9, 2001, indicates that STUDENT was one of seven children, with her mother receiving only one prenatal visit. STUDENT’s mother reportedly used amphetamines, marijuana, and cigarettes during her pregnancy, and she may have taken other people’s prescription drugs. Although STUDENT tested negative for drugs at birth, she had symptoms of withdrawals and required hospitalization for seven to ten days. She was then placed into two foster homes prior to her placement with the STUDENT’S family.
STUDENT previously received services funded by the Kern County Regional Center, which included a home program that consisted of discrete trial training, occupational therapy, and speech and language services. In October 2002, prior to STUDENT’s reaching age three, the District requested that the Kern County Superintendent of Schools (KCSOS) assess STUDENT to prepare for the transition of educational service responsibility to the District. The KCSOS conducted psychological and speech and language evaluations of STUDENT in November 2002, and an occupational therapy evaluation over a two-day period in December 2002 and January 2003. A health assessment was conducted by KCSOS in February 2003, and thereafter, the District convened its first IEP team meeting for STUDENT on April 3, 2003. At the April 3, 2003 IEP meeting, the team reviewed and discussed the KCSOS assessment reports and outside occupational therapy and psychological evaluations conducted by Hand in Hand and Dr. Nina Kogan, respectively. The District made an offer to place STUDENT in a special day class (SDC) operated by KCSOS, with an aide to shadow STUDENT during structured recess. The District also offered designated instruction and services in the area of occupational therapy (OT), one time each week for twenty-five minutes, and door-to-door transportation services. Although MOTHER indicated that she agreed with the goals and objectives in the IEP, she did not agree with what she believed to be a “restricted environment” that was offered. MOTHER told the IEP team that she was looking to place STUDENT in Sierra, a private preschool, beginning three mornings each week, as soon as a space became available. The District team members indicated that they would visit Sierra along with another potential placement at the Richardson Center, and thus decided to reconvene the IEP meeting on April 30, 2003.
When the IEP team reconvened on April 30, 2003, the team reviewed and discussed a private OT assessment that was obtained by the parents, and also discussed observations of various sites that had taken place since the initiation of the IEP meeting on April 3, 2003. There was no consensus with respect to a placement for STUDENT; however, the assessment team members recommended the SDC placement that was offered on April 3, 2003.
As a result of the parties’ disagreement regarding the IEP, the District filed for a due process hearing in November 2003, seeking a decision of whether the District had offered a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to STUDENT and whether the District was entitled to assess her in the areas of academic performance, self-help, social and emotional status, motor abilities, language and speech, general ability, health, development, vision and hearing, and behavior to determine her individual educational needs for placement for the 2004-2005 school year. That matter was given the Hearing Office case number of SN03-02373. On December 5, 2003, the parties entered into a settlement agreement, with the parents agreeing with the District’s assessment plan and giving their consent for the District to assess STUDENT effective March 15, 2004. The assessment was to be used to determine placement, program, and services for the fall of 2004. The parents also agreed not to withdraw their consent to assess, and the District agreed to reimburse STUDENT’s parents for her tuition at Sierra and for supervision hours at the preschool. The District also agreed to provide STUDENT with direct and consult OT services at Buena Vista Elementary School by an occupational therapist who was not involved in a prior assessment of STUDENT. To date, STUDENT has attended Sierra for approximately one year. She received approximately two months of the District-offered OT services, until the services were discontinued by the parent on or about March 4, 2004.
As part of the settlement agreement reached on December 5, 2003, the parties had agreed that at the assessor’s option, the parents could observe the assessments, if they desired, from a separate room with a two-way mirror, and with audio capabilities. According to District special education director Janis Spinozzi, this provision was included in the agreement because there had been problems in the past when assessments were conducted at the STUDENT’S home. Ms. Spinozzi testified that during one assessment, another child was also in the home and was singing to STUDENT and the assessor had indicated that they were unable to get a good assessment at that time.
In an attempt to begin the testing agreed upon in the settlement, the parties exchanged numerous letters of correspondence regarding the scheduling of the District’s various assessments; however, the parties were unable to agree upon the parameters set forth by the District to conduct the various tests. In particular, the parties disputed the locations where the assessments were to be conducted, the number of days, and the amount of time it would take to conduct the assessments. STUDENT’s parents believed that the parameters set forth by the District were unreasonable and therefore, would not consent to the District conducting the assessments as proposed. By letter dated March 26, 2004, the District requested another due process hearing, seeking a decision regarding its right to assess STUDENT and whether it could be insulated from any finding that it failed to provide a FAPE to STUDENT for the 2004-2005 school year until such time as the parents permitted the assessments to go forward. By letter dated April 6, 2004, Student’s counsel set forth a proposed revised assessment schedule, which indicated the parties’ differences with respect to the times and locations for the assessments. On the first day of hearing, the issues were narrowed down to the one issue of whether the District’s parameters for assessment as set forth in its amended issue statement dated April 23, 2004, were appropriate. Additionally, as stated in the footnote above, on the second day of hearing, the areas of speech and language, behavior, and health and development were no longer disputed areas of assessment and thus were removed as issues for hearing.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. Are the District’s parameters for assessment in the areas of occupational therapy, adaptive physical education, and psychological and academic testing appropriate?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.) The term Afree appropriate public education@ means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student=s individualized educational program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).) “Special education” is defined as “specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability…” (20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).)
In order to comply with its legal obligation to provide a FAPE, local educational agencies must gather information regarding students with disabilities through assessments. The IDEA and California law provide that the testing, assessment materials, and procedures must be: (1) selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; (2) provided and administered in the student’s primary language or other mode of communication; (3) validated for the purpose for which they are used; (4) administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; (5) tailored to assess specific areas of need; and (6) selected and administered to best ensure that, when administered to students with impaired speaking, the test produces results that accurately reflect the student’s aptitude, achievement level, or any other factors the test purports to measure and not the student’s impaired speaking skills. (20. U.S.C. § 1414(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(a)-(d).)
In this case, the Student does not contend that the District should not be allowed to conduct OT, APE, psychological and academic assessments. In fact, in the settlement agreement dated December 5, 2003, the parents consented to the District’s assessment plan that provided for assessments in these areas beginning March 15, 2004. Accordingly, the Student is not alleging that the District failed to comply with any of the evaluation procedure requirements set forth in state and federal law as noted above. Rather, Student disputes the location at which the assessments will be conducted, the amount of time, and the proposed scheduling of each assessment. The Hearing Officer will address each area of dispute separately below.
Occupational Therapy Assessment
The testimony of KCSOS occupational therapist Debi Hazel and the written record demonstrate that the District offered to conduct the OT assessment in three one-hour sessions – two sessions during STUDENT’s previously regularly scheduled OT session times at Buena Vista Elementary School (Buena Vista) and a third session at the STUDENT’S home. Additionally, the occupational therapist would conduct one assessment/observation of less than one hour at Sierra Montessori School, which would be conducted concurrently with the APE assessment. (Testimony of D. Hazel.)
The Student argued that the entire OT assessment could be conducted in one three-hour session at the STUDENT’S home. According to MOTHER, their home is equipped with everything that the occupational therapist would need to conduct the OT assessment. MOTHER testified that they have a room in their home that is dedicated to OT, with more than one dozen swings and many balls. She also stated that their equipment is sanitary, functional, and directed towards a four-year-old. MOTHER testified that she believed that the occupational therapist could obtain the same information from STUDENT at home since the parents have all of the necessary equipment there. According to MOTHER, there has only been one occasion when STUDENT was unsuccessful in completing an assessment in a single session and, therefore, she believes it would be easier if STUDENT could have this assessment performed during one session, and at home where STUDENT can feel safe.
According to Ms. Hazel, she determined that three one-hour sessions were appropriate for conducting the OT assessment because at that time, she saw STUDENT on a regular basis for her OT sessions and therefore planned to conduct two of the sessions during her regularly scheduled therapy sessions at Buena Vista. Since the weekly hour-long OT sessions had been a part of STUDENT’s routine and STUDENT was familiar with that setting, Ms. Hazel testified that STUDENT was more likely to cooperate and concentrate for a longer period during one-hour assessment sessions. (Footnote 2) According to Ms. Hazel, attending in a longer block of time is more difficult for a four-year-old and she could not expect one three-hour session to produce a valid assessment. With respect to location, Ms. Hazel testified that Buena Vista has a swing set, large climbing octagonal bolsters, balls for sitting and balancing, paint, mats, bathrooms, sinks, a scooter board, an area for standing and floor activities, and a variety of equipment that allows the assessor to put the student through different planes of movement and challenge the student’s vestibular system. Moreover, at the school site, the assessor can control the environment and set up the equipment in advance of the evaluation. (Testimony of D. Hazel.) In addition, Ms. Hazel stated that research supports conducting an OT assessment across settings. Therefore, although she could conduct a component of the educationally based assessment at the STUDENT’S home if the parent has the equipment, she could not accurately and completely obtain the necessary information if she did not also assess the child in a school setting.
KCSOS occupational therapist Kathleen Finley testified that she and another occupational therapist had previously attempted to assess STUDENT’s OT needs in a single session at the STUDENT’S home, but were unsuccessful. According to Ms. Finley, when they arrived at the STUDENT’S home, STUDENT was napping for thirty minutes and when she arose, she had to have a snack. It took forty-five minutes before they could begin the evaluation and they were unable to complete it in a single session.
Although the Student argues that Buena Vista does not provide a typical school setting because there would be no students receiving classes during the time STUDENT’s assessment would be conducted, the Hearing Officer finds persuasive Ms. Hazel’s testimony that the Buena Vista school site nevertheless, provides an environment where the assessor can consider STUDENT’s ability to transition from the classroom to the restroom and her abilities while inside an actual classroom on a school site. In addition, in STUDENT’s last IEP dated April 3 and April 30, 2003, the District proposed placing STUDENT in a special day class at a public school location. Thus, it would be beneficial for the IEP team to obtain information about STUDENT’s occupational therapy needs while on a school site.
The testimony persuades the Hearing Officer that the OT assessment schedule and locations proposed by the District are appropriate. The testimony of Ms. Hazel establishes that conducting the OT assessment over three one-hour sessions will enable her to obtain better cooperation and performance from a preschooler like STUDENT. The Hearing Officer considers Ms. Hazel’s testimony convincing considering the fact that Ms. Hazel previously worked with STUDENT for one-hour blocks of time during her weekly OT sessions at Buena Vista. (Footnote 3) Moreover, the Hearing Officer finds conducting the entire OT assessment in the home to be inappropriate since the District is considering STUDENT’s school-based needs and therefore will need to observe and assess her in a school environment. Understanding that some of STUDENT’s academics are currently provided in her home, the District proposes assessing STUDENT across all settings, including at the STUDENT’S home and at Buena Vista and Sierra, thus providing a balanced view for the assessor. (Testimony of D. Hazel.)
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposal to assess STUDENT over three one-hour sessions at home and Buena Vista, and during a separate observation of less than one hour at Sierra, for purposes of determining her occupational therapy needs to be appropriate assessment parameters. The Hearing Officer notes, however, that considering the testimony from MOTHER regarding STUDENT’s daily routine that includes instruction at home, nap and snack time at home, instruction at Sierra, and private OT services at home, the District is required to first obtain from the parents STUDENT’s daily and weekly schedules and then coordinate assessment times and locations so that there is minimal interruption to STUDENT’s daily routine.
Adaptive Physical Education Assessment
The District has proposed to conduct an APE assessment in a single session at Sierra Montessori School, which would be conducted concurrently with the OT assessment/observation. If the initial visit progressed well, the District contends that a second visit would not be needed. (See Dist.’s Exhs. 54 & 109.) The Student argues that the APE assessment can be conducted during one two-hour session at the STUDENT’S home. (Dist.’s Exh. 80.)
APE specialist Byron Lewis testified that the appropriate place to conduct the APE assessment would be at the school that the child attends because a school has a playground, grass, walls, backstops, and enough room so that there are no obstructions. According to Mr. Lewis, his preference has always been to do an APE assessment in a school setting so that he can conduct hands-on testing as well as observe the child during parallel play with other students. Mr. Lewis testified persuasively that children are usually less guarded during parallel play and that he will be able to obtain information that he otherwise would not get when working one-on-one with a child. (Footnote 4) Mr. Lewis indicated that the estimated time needed for his assessment is less than one hour.
MOTHER testified that she was concerned about STUDENT being stigmatized by other students if they see her being assessed by the APE specialist on the Sierra campus playground. MOTHER also indicated that their home has the same environment that the APE specialist indicated he needed, including a blacktop, sixty feet of lawn, and a basketball hoop. However, the Hearing Officer is not convinced that a hands-on assessment and observation by the APE specialist of approximately one hour would stigmatize STUDENT, much less attract the attention of a class of children ages three through five during play time. Additionally, the mere fact that the STUDENT’s home may have some of the environmental attributes that could be used by the APE specialist during his assessment does not warrant conducting the APE assessment there. The fact that the District is attempting to obtain information about STUDENT’s school-based APE needs is a much more convincing argument for conducting the APE assessment at her school site.
The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the District’s proposal to conduct an APE assessment during a single session at Sierra is appropriate. This assessment is to be conducted concurrently with the OT assessment/observation. An additional session at Sierra may also be warranted should the initial visit not progress well and additional testing is deemed necessary by the assessor.
Psychological and Academic Assessment
According to the District, the psychological assessments/observations typically do not take more than two hours. However, in this case, the psychologist would also be performing the academic testing. Therefore, in total, the psychologist would conduct two observations at Sierra for a total of four hours, one play-based assessment at the Richardson Center, academic testing and parent interview at the Richardson Center, and one extra session at the Richardson Center only if something observed in an earlier session suggested the need for further observation/assessment. The psychologist would also go to the STUDENT’S home, along with the school nurse. (Testimony of Denita Maughan; Dist.’s Exh. 109.) The home visit is important for the psychologist to hear the health information and ask additional questions so as to avoid redundancy. (Testimony of Denita Maughan.) (Footnote 5)
District psychologist Denita Maughan testified that her observation of STUDENT at Sierra would be her first opportunity to observe her and to consider what assessment tools she would later use with her. Additionally, the observations would allow her to see how STUDENT interacts with other children and determine STUDENT’s ability to comply with requests and maintain on-task behavior. Academic and cognitive testing and the parent interview would be conducted at the Richardson Center. Ms. Maughan stated that standardized academic testing was necessary to determine STUDENT’s pre-kindergarten readiness skills. According to Ms. Maughan, the play-based assessment at the Richardson Center would be conducted in a semi-structured environment that is set up to illicit social communication from STUDENT. Additionally, Ms. Maughan testified that the speech and language assessor would also be present and would serve as a scribe to write down any verbalizations STUDENT made during the assessment. Ms. Maughan indicated that she reserved one last session if certain issues arose that warranted further exploration. For instance, if she observed STUDENT having certain memory deficits, Ms. Maughan testified that she might later decide to conduct a memory test on her.
The Hearing Officer finds convincing Ms. Maughan’s testimony regarding the amount of time and the locations necessary to assess STUDENT’s psychological and academic functioning. (Footnote 6) The District presented persuasive evidence that STUDENT’s complex diagnoses of autism, obsessive compulsive behavior, and other behaviors of concern to both the family and the District warrant two observations at Sierra, two sessions of psychological and academic testing at the Richardson Center, and the possibility of one other session at the Richardson Center. STUDENT has never attended a District school and, as stated earlier in this Decision, the District previously proposed placing STUDENT in a District special day class. Thus, it is important that the District have sufficient information about STUDENT’s classroom needs in order to make an appropriate offer of placement for the 2004-2005 school year. Although the Student argued that the psychological and academic testing should be conducted in one two-hour session at the STUDENT’S home, and one three-hour session at the Richardson Center, no persuasive evidence was presented as to why the District’s proposed psychological and academic assessment parameters were not appropriate. The Hearing Officer also notes that MOTHER testified that she later agreed to allow the psychologist to observe STUDENT at Sierra, but it is unclear as to how many hours the parent agreed.
The Hearing Officer understands that the exact amount of time for the psychological and academic testing may be difficult to determine at the outset. However, the Hearing Officer finds that in order to coordinate scheduling of the sessions with the parents and to minimize the interruption to STUDENT’s daily routine, the District must provide the parents an update of the progress made in each assessment session and provide the parents an approximate amount of time necessary for any additional session.
The District has established that its assessment parameters set forth in its amended issue statement dated April 23, 2004, are appropriate. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District may assess STUDENT as proposed in its amended issue statement dated April 23, 2004, and consistent with the findings in this Decision.
ORDERS
1. The District is entitled to assess STUDENT as proposed in its amended issue statement dated April 23, 2004, and consistent with the findings in this Decision.
2. The District shall set dates for the assessments and shall provide STUDENT’s parents with five (5) calendar days notice of the dates for those assessments. In setting the assessment dates, the District shall first obtain from the parents STUDENT’S daily and weekly schedules and then coordinate assessment times and locations so that there is minimal interruption to STUDENT’s daily routine. Additionally, where certain areas of assessment may require more than one session, the District must provide to the parents an update of the progress made in the preceding session and an approximate amount of time necessary for any additional session.
3. The parent shall make the child reasonably available for the District’s assessment.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
The District prevailed on the sole issue heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. (California Education Code § 56505(i).)
Dated: May 27, 2004 ____________________________________ Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
On the second day of hearing, Student’s counsel indicated that after hearing the testimony of the speech therapist and the behaviorist, Student no longer disputed the parameters for conducting the speech and language assessment, functional behavioral assessment, or the health and development assessment as set forth by the District in its amended issue statement dated April 23, 2004. As there was no longer any dispute between the parties regarding the speech and language and behavior assessments, the Hearing Officer informed the parties that she would not address those undisputed areas of assessment in this Decision.
2 As of March 2004, MOTHER notified the District that STUDENT declined to continue to receive the District’s OT services at Buena Vista because MOTHER believed that the services had not been productive. (See Dist.’s Exhs. 59 and 67.)
3 Ms. Hazel testified that she has a Bachelor of Science degree in occupational therapy and is currently enrolled in an occupational therapy doctoral program at Crayton University at Omaha, Nebraska. According to Ms. Hazel, she has worked as an occupational therapist with KCSOS since 1994. She possesses a California occupational therapist license and assistive technology certification through Kern County’s Assistive Technology Program. (See also Dist.’s Exh. 9.)
4 Mr. Lewis testified that he has a Bachelor of Science degree in physical education, a clear severely handicapped credential, and a clear adaptive physical education credential. He has worked as an APE specialist for eight years and has been trained in performing APE assessments. (See also Dist.’s Exh. 10.)
5 The Hearing Officer notes that during the hearing, the Student indicated that the psychologist’s visit to the STUDENT’S home with the school nurse was not in dispute.
6 Ms. Maughan testified that she has a Bachelor of Science degree in psychology, a master’s degree in clinical psychology, and a Ph.D. in school psychology. She has worked as a school psychologist for the District since the fall of 2002. During the 2001-2002 school year, Ms. Maughan worked as a school psychologist for the Jordan School District in Sandy, Utah. (See also Dist.’s Exh. 12.) Ms. Maughan testified that she assesses approximately one hundred students each year, and of those students she spends the same amount of assessment time with approximately ten to twenty percent of them, as the District proposes to spend with STUDENT.
