California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 28, 2001
Ventura Unified School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 756-01 · Hearing Officer Michael F. Geary
Ventura Unified wins added emotional disturbance eligibility; Hearing Officer orders interim ED class placement and a comprehensive assessment.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
Ventura Unified School District filed for a hearing about a 10-year-old boy. He was eligible for special education as other health impaired because of ADHD and attended a learning handicapped special day class at Blanche Reynolds School. The District wanted him also found emotionally disturbed and moved to an emotionally disturbed (ED) special day class under his March 6, 2001 IEP. His mother represented him. She attended only part of the hearing and preferred home schooling.
The Hearing Officer found the boy eligible as emotionally disturbed. School psychologist Susan Nielsen's assessment and teacher Anne Magoon's reports showed a long-standing, marked, pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. They also showed a tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears tied to personal or school problems. Both harmed his schoolwork.
On the IEP, the Hearing Officer found too little evidence to say the offer provided a free appropriate public education (FAPE). The record lacked a solid behavior plan, motor-skills support and academic information. Still, the ED class had a small staff-to-student ratio and a full-time mental health liaison. It met his most urgent emotional and behavioral needs in the least restrictive environment, so it worked as an interim placement. The Hearing Officer ordered the mother to return him to school and the District to put the IEP in place on an interim basis. The District had to complete a comprehensive assessment, including a clinical psychologist and medical doctors, by August 24, 2001, without parent consent. It then had to hold an IEP meeting by August 31, 2001.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO handled a district-filed case when the record could not support a full FAPE finding. The Hearing Officer approved the placement only on an interim basis and ordered a comprehensive assessment without parent consent. The case also shows how a hearing went forward when a self-represented parent left the hearing or did not appear.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 1. Is STUDENT eligible for special education as a child who is emotionally disturbed?
Student showed a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression and a tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears, each over a long period, to a marked degree, and adversely affecting education; he qualifies as emotionally disturbed in addition to OHI.
- District prevailedDistrict-filed: implement IEP
Issue 2. Did the District offer a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) to STUDENT in the IEP dated March 6, 2001? (includes appropriate placement)
Evidence was inadequate to find the March 6, 2001 IEP offered FAPE, but the ED special day class met Student's most critical emotional and behavioral needs in the LRE as an interim placement; the Hearing Officer ordered interim implementation and a comprehensive assessment and declared no prevailing party.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Student's eligibility changed from 'other health impaired' to both 'other health impaired' and 'emotionally disturbed.'
- Order that district's offer may be implemented. Mother to immediately return Student to the District; District to immediately implement the March 6, 2001 IEP (ED special day class) as an interim IEP only, pending assessment and a new IEP.
- Order that district may assess without consent. By July 13, 2001, District to develop a plan for a comprehensive psychoeducational assessment in all areas of suspected disability, including assessment and diagnosis by a qualified clinical psychologist and appropriate medical doctor(s); may include Ventura County Behavioral Health; plan with schedule mailed to mother at least 7 days before first appointment; parent consent not required; mother must produce Student or request District transportation 72 hours in advance.
- Order to assess. Comprehensive psychoeducational assessment and reports to be completed no later than August 24, 2001.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. District to convene an IEP meeting by August 31, 2001 to review assessment results and select a placement for the 2001-2002 school year.
Key authorities
Rowley; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H.; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Larry P. v. Riles; 34 C.F.R. 300.7(c)(4); 5 Cal. Code Regs. 3030
People named in the decision
- Susan Nielsen, school psychologist; conducted June 2000 psychoeducational assessment, Ventura Unified School District
- Anne Magoon, special education teacher, learning handicapped special day class, Blanche Reynolds School
- Nancy Barker, principal, Blanche Reynolds School
- Susan Beattie, teacher, emotionally disturbed special day class, Blanche Reynolds School
- Keri Jafari, school psychologist and program specialist, K-5 ED program, Ventura Unified School District
- Maria Villarreal, school psychologist; 1997 psychoeducational report, Ventura Unified School District
- Kristi Moes, mental health liaison for ED special day class, Ventura County Behavioral Health (interagency agreement)
- Bruce Anselmo, regional center case worker, Tri-Counties Regional Center
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
The matter was heard before Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Ventura, California, on May 15 and 16, and June 6, 2001.
The Petitioner was represented by attorney Donald F. Austin, general counsel for Ventura Unified School District (District). Susan Nielsen, school psychologist, was also present for the District. Respondent STUDENT was represented at the hearing by his mother, PARENT.(Footnote 1)
The District called the following witnesses: Anne Magoon, the teacher of the STUDENT’s learning handicapped (LH) special day class (SDC) at Blanche Reynolds School for the 2000-2001 school year; Nancy Barker, the principal of Blanche Reynolds School; Susan Nielsen; Susan Beattie, a teacher of an emotionally disturbed (ED) SDC at Blanche Reynolds School; and, Keri Jafari, District school psychologist and program specialist for the ED program for children kindergarten through fifth grade. The Respondent called no witnesses.
Oral and documentary evidence was received at the hearing. The District submitted a written closing argument and the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision on June 13, 2001.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
No one appeared for Respondent STUDENT when the hearing was to commence at 9:30 a.m. on May 15, 2001. The District’s counsel advised the Hearing Officer that PARENT had called earlier that morning to state that she was ill and unable to attend. The District’s counsel placed a telephone call to the Parent on the record, but there was no answer. The Hearing Officer left a message on the answering machine regarding the scheduled hearing and requesting that she immediately call the District office to indicate whether or not she would be participating at the hearing. There was no return call within a reasonable time so the Hearing Officer requested that a District representative go to the Respondent’s home to try to make contact with his parent. The District later reported that PARENT was home and would answer a call.
The Hearing Officer made another call to PARENT, who answered and explained that she was too ill to attend the hearing. The Hearing Officer explained that if she wanted to make a motion to continue the proceeding, he would administer an oath to her to determine the factual bases for the motion. PARENT agreed. The oath was administered to her. She testified that she had become ill at approximately 1:30 a.m. that morning. Her symptoms were a fever of 102 degrees and vomiting, which had shown no improvement in the previous two hours. She had not seen a doctor, and did not have the funds to see a doctor, but she believed that a friend would take her to a doctor that afternoon and pay for the services. PARENT stated that she did want to represent her son at the hearing, and had every intention of doing so that morning until she unexpectedly became ill. She testified that she had arranged for an appearance and testimony by Bruce Anselmo, an employee of Regional Center (TRC), on May 16 at 9:30 a.m. When asked if she had any documents to offer into evidence, she stated that she did not, and that “everything is in the file.” The Hearing Officer found that there was good cause for a short continuance and the parties were ordered to appear the following morning at 9:30 a.m.
On May 16, 2001, the Hearing Officer was ready to proceed with the hearing as scheduled. At approximately 9:40 a.m. PARENT called. She explained on the record that she was still not well enough to participate at the hearing. She then began to state a series of objections to the proceedings and reasons why the matter should not go forward as scheduled. When asked if she could appear at the hearing to state her position in person, she said that she could if she was allowed time to get ready. It was agreed that the hearing would recess until 10:30 a.m.
At approximately 10:30 a.m., PARENT appeared for hearing. PARENT then made what amounted to another motion to continue the proceedings based upon her contention that she had not been allowed an adequate time to retain counsel or otherwise prepare for the hearing. She stated that she did not realize that the due process hearing was to occur on May 15 and 16. Under questioning by the Hearing Officer, she admitted that she had done nothing to prepare for the hearing before the preceding day when she had spent one and one-half hours talking on the telephone with the assigned mediator and had made a single call to the regional center to ask about representation.
In response, counsel for the District argued that the file showed that all appropriate notices had been sent to PARENT and that her own statements to the District representatives and to the Hearing Officer demonstrated that she knew that the hearing was to occur on these dates. The District questioned whether PARENT was ill on May 15, and viewed the motions to continue as consistent with her history of requesting postponements of meetings at the last minute and not appearing for scheduled meetings.
Respondent did not establish good cause for a continuance. The hearing was properly noticed by the Hearing Office on April 19, 2001, and a telephone reminder message was left at the Respondent’s home on May 9, 2001. PARENT stated during the telephone conference on May 15 that she was aware that a due process hearing was to take place on that and the following day and that she had arranged for a witness to testify at the hearing. She also stated that she would have no documents to offer into evidence that were not already “in the file.” PARENT knew that the hearing was to occur and, by her own statement, would have been ready to proceed but for the unexpected illness. None of the concerns she expressed at the time of this motion was mentioned that day. It further appeared that PARENT had done little or nothing to mitigate her own stated concerns since the hearing request was served. The Hearing Officer denied the motion on the ground that there was no good cause for the requested continuance. However, out of an abundance of caution, in recognition of the unrepresented status of the Respondent, and as an accommodation to one of the District’s witnesses who was unable to appear on the May 16 date, it was agreed that an additional day for hearing would be scheduled a sufficient time in the future to allow PARENT an opportunity to collect and give proper notice regarding her evidence. The new date was to be selected at the conclusion of that day’s proceedings. The hearing then proceeded.
Midway through the first day of hearing, PARENT stated that she was leaving because she was tired. She also stated that things were not going well for her at the hearing and that she would be appealing the Hearing Officer’s decision in any event. The Hearing Officer had noticed no signs of fatigue or that PARENT was having difficulty remaining attentive to the evidence and the discussions regarding the case. The Hearing Officer urged her to remain and to continue to represent her son’s interests. Counsel for the District estimated that he had no more than two hours of testimony to offer that day. The Hearing Officer explained that her departure would not prevent the District from continuing with its case and that the hearing would proceed in her absence. She was advised that the Hearing Officer would render a decision, which would be binding on the parties subject to appeal rights. She agreed that the next hearing day would be June 6, 2001. She then left the hearing.
The hearing reconvened as agreed on June 6, 2001. PARENT did not appear at the continued hearing and did not notify the Hearing Office or the District of either her intentions in this regard or any need for a further continuance. The Hearing Officer made two telephone calls to Respondent’s home on the record and before any new evidence was taken on June 6. No one answered the calls, and no answering machine was operating. The District’s counsel stated that he had called Respondent’s home twice twenty minutes earlier. On the first call, the line was busy. On the second call, the answering machine picked up the call, and counsel left a message reminding PARENT that the hearing was to take place that morning. The last day of hearing then proceeded in her absence.
ISSUES PRESENTED(Footnote 2)
1. Is STUDENT eligible for special education as a child who is emotionally disturbed?
2. Did the District offer a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) to STUDENT in the IEP dated March 6, 2001?(Footnote 3)
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
STUDENT’s current eligibility classification is OHI. The District contends that STUDENT should also be classified as ED. The District asserts that STUDENT’s unique needs require a change of placement from the learning handicapped special day class (LH SDC) to the emotionally disturbed special day class (ED SDC) that was offered in the March 6, 2001 IEP. The District contends that the offer made in that IEP document was an offer of FAPE and that the Hearing Officer should order placement pursuant to that IEP.(Footnote 4)
The Respondent’s position regarding whether he was eligible for special education under the ED classification was not clear. Some of PARENT’s statements indicated that she agreed that STUDENT needed services to help him to deal with his emotional and behavioral issues. She stated that she was could not agree that the ED SDC was an appropriate placement because she had not attended and observed the class. When asked if she was prepared to state her position regarding whether that class was an appropriate placement for STUDENT, she said that if the Hearing Officer needed a “yes or no, then no.” PARENT then said she wanted home schooling. No further explanation or reasoning was offered. On the second issue, FAPE, PARENT agreed that the offer contained in the March 6, 2001 IEP was an offer of a FAPE. It appeared from PARENT’s responses to questions that she understood what the law required of the District insofar as an offer of a FAPE was concerned, and that she agreed that the District’s offer met this requirement. She was adamant, however, that the recommended placement in the ED SDC, while probably appropriate under the law, was not acceptable. She felt her son was entitled to more than the “minimum requirements” of the law and that her son should not be placed in the ED SDC at Blanche Reynolds School.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a 10-year-old boy who is currently eligible for special education under the “other health impaired” (OHI) category. He resides with his mother and his older brother within the geographical boundaries of the District. His home school is Blanche Reynolds School. STUDENT’s current placement is in the LH SDC at that school.
STUDENT has a significant medical history. He was born more than three months premature and with serious pulmonary difficulties. He remained hospitalized after birth for four and one-half months and required oxygen for his first year. STUDENT has continued to suffer from compromised health, including a duodenal tear that required surgery and at least one bout of bilateral pneumonia. His vision has been tested at 20/30, and it is not clear whether this has been corrected.
STUDENT was diagnosed with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and has been taking Ritalin since midway through his kindergarten year. One of the concerns of the school staff was the inconsistent administration of the medication by his mother. As early as his kindergarten year in 1997, the school psychologist Maria Villarreal was recommending that his medication be closely monitored. These concerns have persisted to the present. For a time, PARENT allowed the school staff to administer one or two of the doses while STUDENT was at school. However, this system broke down when she stopped providing the medication to the school. PARENT would take STUDENT off his medication completely at times, or it would appear from STUDENT’s behavior and demeanor that the medication was inconsistently administered. The school staff credibly testified that STUDENT’s psychological problems and disruptive behaviors were made worse by the inconsistent administration of medication, but that the emotional and psychological problems and disruptive behaviors were present and caused significant difficulty for STUDENT and others at school even when the medication was administered.
STUDENT was initially referred for special education assessment midway through his kindergarten year when there was some concern about his distractability and language skills. A speech and language assessment was done in late August 1996 which revealed articulation skills within normal limits but auditory comprehension at the fourth percentile for his age group. Pursuant to an Individualized Education Plan (IEP) dated November 19, 1996, STUDENT’s eligibility category was determined to be speech and language impaired, and speech and language services were to be delivered to STUDENT twice per week at thirty minutes each. In June 1997, STUDENT underwent psychoeducational assessment in preparation for the IEP meeting to plan for his next year in the second grade. From the results of the Woodcock Johnson-Revised (WJ-R), it was concluded that he was delayed in all areas, justifying a change of eligibility to developmentally delayed. As a result of this meeting, a new IEP was developed and STUDENT was offered, and accepted, the services of a resource specialist one hour per day four days per week, to work with him on reading, written language and math. They planned to review this placement at the end of September with the possibility of recommending a switch to an SDC. At that review, it was decided that STUDENT was doing well and would remain with the resource specialist.
In April 1998, another IEP meeting was held. No parent or surrogate was present at the meeting. Those present thought STUDENT was doing well in both academic and social skills, despite his being frequently absent or late. His WJ-R grade equivalent scores in reading, math and written language were at K.8, K.5 and 1.1, respectively. However, fine motor and visual motor skills were lagging and interfering with his performance. It was agreed by all present that there would be no changes to the placement or services. New goals and objectives were drafted.
PARENT was present at the next IEP meeting on November 3, 1998, during STUDENT’s second grade year. The team concluded that the resource specialist was not meeting his needs. STUDENT was having increasing difficulty staying on task. He continued to be frequently absent or late. His emotional difficulties began to stand out as an impediment to learning. His eligibility classification was changed to OHI, and he was offered placement in an LH SDC. It was hoped that he would benefit from the more structured and smaller-group environment, where there would be greater opportunity for individualized attention. He was also offered an extended school year (ESY) and seventeen percent integration with the general education students for lunch, recess and assemblies. The team also recommended that STUDENT be referred to Ventura County Behavioral Health (VCBH), the local mental health agency, to determine his need for mental health services, but the parents declined the referral. PARENT signed and agreed with the placement and services offered in all other respects.
At the end of STUDENT’s second grade year in March 1999, the IEP team met again. PARENT was present. The team discussed the frequent emotional outbursts by STUDENT. He would yell out things that were not appropriate to the circumstance and would often refuse to do his work. He was becoming more verbally and physically aggressive toward students and staff. STUDENT required close supervision to control his anger and impulsiveness. A change of placement to home teaching was considered, but the team ultimately recommended continuing with the LH SDC and incorporating a behavioral goal and a positive behavior support plan to address his emotional, psychological and behavioral needs. The behavior plan was instituted by early April, and revised in September 1999.
At the time of the March 13, 2000 IEP meeting near the end of his third grade year, STUDENT’s behavior was still a primary concern. Cognitive functioning and academic and pre-academic skills were believed to be adequate. He had become increasingly responsible for homework and was showing improvement in his emotional state and social skills, but he still had frequent outbursts and “unrealistic thoughts.” He had met his goals, so new ones were developed and adopted. Placement in the LH SDC continued with the parents’ consent.
While it is not clear exactly when it happened, it was apparently in early April that STUDENT became a client of Tri-counties Regional Center (TRC). His case worker, Bruce Anselmo, attended some of the later IEP meetings. Despite PARENT’s statement that she had arranged for him to testify on May 16, he did not appear at the hearing.
In June 2000, a psychoeducational assessment was done by Susan Nielsen, the District’s school psychologist, in preparation for the triennial IEP meeting. The assessment included a record review and interviews of the Respondent, parents and teacher by Ms. Nielsen. STUDENT’s teacher completed the Behavioral Evaluation Scale-2 (BES-2) and the Behavior Assessment System for Children (BASC).(Footnote 5) Ms. Nielsen administered the Roberts Apperception Test, the WJ-R, and the Sentence Completion Test. There were also classroom and school observations by the psychologist, teacher, principal, school nurse and others. As a result of the testing and other data, the psychologist concluded that STUDENT’s emotional disturbance was the primary factor interfering with his learning. Ms. Nielsen found that there were significant emotional, psychological and behavioral problems and that STUDENT met four of the five criteria for eligibility as an emotionally disturbed student.(Footnote 6)
The triennial IEP meeting was on June 16. Those attending included Ms. Nielsen and Bruce Anselmo, STUDENT’s case manager from Tri-counties Regional Center. The meeting had been scheduled on this date at the mother’s request, but she did not attend. Staff confirmed in a telephone call to her that day that she was unable to get off work. She asked that a copy of the draft plan be sent to her for review and that another meeting be scheduled prior to the start of the new year. The District participants at the meeting agreed that STUDENT met the eligibility criteria for both OHI and ED. Options considered included continued LH SDC placement with a referral to VCBH, an ED SDC placement, and referral to the California Diagnostic Center to determine STUDENT’s primary educational disability. Mr. Anselmo advised the team that there was a plan by TRC to provide in-home behavior intervention services. No changes in eligibility or placement were made at this time, but there was an indication that the team expected to revise the positive behavior support plan in the fall.
There was another IEP meting on August 28. The parents were not present at the time, but Bruce Anselmo was there. The purpose of this meeting is unclear. The only changes to the documents generated as a result of the June 16 meeting were a new page 1 on which STUDENT’s eligibility category was listed as ED, the recommended placement was in an SDC for five hours per day with an additional one hour integrated for lunch and recess, and an AB 2726 referral to VCBH for assessment was offered.(Footnote 7)
On September 18, there was a “continued” meeting to allow STUDENT’s parents to comment on the June 16 IEP as modified on August 28. Mr. and Mrs. PARENT and Bruce Anselmo were present. PARENT stated that she had taken STUDENT off medication during the summer and that, in her opinion, he had done well. The notes state that STUDENT met the criteria for both OHI and ED, but neither his eligibility category nor his placement were changed. A referral to VCBH was proposed, but the parents said they would think about it before deciding. Goals and services were continued.
PARENT never consented to the referral to VCBH. By later in September, STUDENT’s disruptive behavior was resulting in suspensions. The District requested that PARENT meet with staff to discuss “strategies to address STUDENT’s academic and behavioral needs.” In mid- December, Susan Nielsen explained in a letter to PARENT that the school had been unable to complete a positive behavior support plan because of STUDENT’s inconsistent attendance.(Footnote 8) Efforts to schedule a meeting continued until January 12, 2001, when the meeting finally took place. The results of that meeting included a number of interventions that the participants hoped would help STUDENT to benefit from his education. Those interventions included opportunities to “cool down” or to burn off excessive energy by allowing him to engage in various physical activities outside the classroom. If these interventions could not be implemented successfully, it was agreed that PARENT would be asked to remove STUDENT from the campus until he was more under control. There was to be frequent communication, with PARENT keeping the school staff advised of potential indicators of negative behavior and the staff reporting on STUDENT’s school behavior. These efforts to address STUDENT’s behavior were ineffective.
The most recent IEP meeting was on March 6, 2001. PARENT did not attend. Attendees included Susan Nielsen, Anne Magoon, Nancy Barker, Keri Jafari, Susan Beattie and Kristi Moes, the mental health liaison who works with the ED SDC. Bruce Anselmo was not present. Eligibility was listed as OHI because PARENT “would not agree to emotionally disturbed eligibility.”(Footnote 9) The recommendation was placement in the ED SDC, which is located on another campus, for a “full day” with one hour of lunch and recess integrated. The SDC was to include instruction in “language arts, math, physical education, science, social studies, health etc.” An extended school year for 2001-2002 was included, but no other information is provided regarding the length of that session. There was also an AB 2726 referral for an assessment through VCBH.
New present levels of performance were drafted, but these provided little information regarding academic/pre-academic skills, and vocational skills/community access. Rather, it was indicated that since STUDENT was unable to stay on task for more than three minutes at a time, these levels were difficult to determine. Cognitive functioning continued to be estimated at borderline, but it was noted that he could read near grade level when focused.(Footnote 10) It is noted that STUDENT had difficulty with fine and gross motor skills. Self-help and domestic skills were adequate, and language skills were estimated to be within the average range.
STUDENT’s social and emotional performance was described in two narrative attachments to the March 6 IEP. These outline what was described as a lengthy history of emotional disturbance. The first, by an unknown author, makes specific reference to four of the five factors which would support a determination of ED eligibility. The second is a narrative by teacher Anne Magoon who describes with some specificity STUDENT’s lack of progress during the current school year and the behaviors which are interfering with his education. Among the behavioral problems noted were difficulty focusing, difficulty interacting with others, dramatic mood swings, unwillingness to take responsibility for his conduct, disruptive class behavior, impulsiveness, hypersensitivity to noise from others, anxiety, verbal and physical tantrums and verbal and physical aggression toward other students. She states that “It has become increasingly difficult to deal with STUDENT’s needs and behaviors without totally disrupting the rest of the class’ routine.” STUDENT’s emotional, psychological and behavioral problems were said to impact his ability to complete even basic assignments that are at his academic level.
The IEP states that STUDENT’s behavior interferes with learning. It specifies the implementation in the classroom of a positive behavior reinforcement plan and the goals and objectives for behavior. The IEP also states that support for school personnel will consist of consultation with the school psychologist. Of the ten annual goals, three relate to academic/pre-academic skills. Those annual goals require STUDENT to (1) compute addition and subtraction with one regrouping using pencil and paper, (2) ask questions and support answers by connecting prior knowledge with literal and inferential information in text, and (3) write 4-5 complete simple sentences independently using a “word wall” and/or basic dictionary for spelling. There are also two intermediate benchmarks for each goal. The social and emotional goals require STUDENT, within one year, to (1) independently generate options to reach a goal or solve a problem while using verbal communication skills, (2) identify strategies to reduce anxiety, (3) attend to task without bothering or talking to peers, (4) make relevant comments when speaking to adults or peers, (5) keep his hands to himself as appropriate, (6) maintain appropriate behavior during group lesson, and (7) choose appropriate interactions with peers during free time. The special education teacher is listed as the “responsible discipline” for all goals. All annual goals also have three benchmarks, including the final goal. These are represented in terms of percentages, with the ranges being between 40% and 70%.
The District filed for a due process hearing on April 16, 2001.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSION OF LAW
Eligibility As Emotionally Disturbed
Under both federal and State law, a child is deemed to suffer from an emotional disturbance if he or she exhibits one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree which adversely affect his educational performance: (1) an inability to learn which cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors; (2) an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers; (3) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations; (4) a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression; and (5) a tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems. Mere social maladjustment, without other qualifying characteristics, is not sufficient for ED eligibility. 34 Code of Federal Regulations 300.7(c)(4); 5 California Code of Regulations § 3030. While the California law still contains reference to “serious” emotional disturbance, that reference was eliminated from the federal law, though the comments to that amendment make it clear that the elimination of the reference was not intended to have any substantive or legal significance. The factors are the same. The student does not need to satisfy every criterion to be eligible. He need only satisfy one.
In this case, there is no dispute between the parties regarding whether STUDENT is eligible for special education services. The District asserts that STUDENT is eligible on the basis of both an other health impairment, ADHD, and on the basis of emotional disturbance. More specifically, the District contends that STUDENT satisfies the second through fifth criteria set forth in the California regulation governing ED eligibility. The Hearing Officer addresses two of the criteria that clearly establish that eligibility.
General Pervasive Mood of Unhappiness or Depression
STUDENT does exhibit a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression which makes him eligible for special education services under this criterion. Ms. Nielsen’s report indicates that STUDENT has a poor self-image. He often comments that he is “stupid” or that he can’t do things. His social difficulties clearly bother him, and he complains that nobody likes him. He worries excessively about his family. His teacher states that he often seems unhappy, although there are times when he appears to be excessively happy, loud and talkative. He becomes sad and easily frustrated in new learning situations. He has stated that he hated and wanted to kill himself. According to the narrative report of the teacher that is attached to the March 6, 2001 IEP, STUDENT has stated often that he never has a good day and never will, and that he should be dead.
The evidence also shows that STUDENT’s unhappiness and depressed mood have been present for a long time. There are references in the record to his being withdrawn and sad as early as June 16, 2000. The Hearing Officer also has a 1997 psychoeducational report that contains references to the Burks’ Behavior Rating Scales, Preschool and Kindergarten Edition, which indicated that STUDENT’s excessive withdrawal and sense of suffering and persecution fell within the “significant” range. It also showed that his excessive self-blame, anxiety and dependency, and excessively poor ego strength all fell within the “very significant” range. These emotional problems are present to a marked degree. The teacher, who had the opportunity to observe STUDENT over a long period of time, stated that STUDENT is usually withdrawn. She rates “withdrawal” on the BES-2 referred to in Ms. Nielsen’s report as “clinically significant” at all times while observed. STUDENT felt disliked by his peers, persecuted by his teachers and the school staff, and incapable of the simplest of tasks, such as riding a bike.
There is no question that STUDENT’s sad and depressed mood adversely affected his educational performance. The testimony showed that he will not put forth the effort to learn or to demonstrate his achievement because he is convinced that he is incapable or unworthy. He ruminates about his lack of friends and he obsesses about his perceived failure, which distract him from his education.
The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT does exhibit a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression that has been present for a long period of time and to a marked degree, and that it has had a significantly adverse effect on his educational performance.
Physical Symptoms or Fears Associated with Personal or School Problems
According to the report and testimony of Ms. Nielsen, STUDENT has expressed excessive fears related to news events such as tornadoes and floods. He is afraid of spiders and has claimed that the ones in his house kept him up and did something to his eyes. He is so afraid of failing at school that his teacher had to stop using competition as an academic teaching tool. His fear of failure extends to many activities. STUDENT simply will not participate in any activity in which he lacks confidence, which, unfortunately, includes most activities, even riding a scooter or bike. He has expressed excessive fear that his aunt was going to die in an airplane crash, that his uncle would be in a wheelchair and never be a rock star, that people at school were trying to starve him, that his brother would kill him if he didn’t get him a VCR from the classroom, and that the school nurse and secretary were trying to kill him. STUDENT worries about and feels responsible for his family. When it was suggested that he needed to go home until he was over an emotional episode, he panicked and lost control, knocking over furniture and pushing others as he ran away. In addition to his fears, STUDENT frequently has complained of physical symptoms at school, including stomach aches, headaches, toothaches, eyes hurting, legs hurting, small scratches or other marks. He has continually scratched and picked at small marks on his skin until they are raw. There have been occasions when a teacher’s story about insects has cause STUDENT to imagine that he was infested with the insects or to be afraid of leaving the classroom for fear he would be attacked by insects. The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT does exhibit a tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.
These symptoms and fears have been present for a long time. Many began to be expressed more than one year ago. Some were at least suggested as tendencies as early as 1997 when Maria Villarreal did her psychoeducational report that suggested excessive anxiety within the “very significant” range. They are present to a marked degree. They distract and preoccupy STUDENT. They cause him to panic and lose control. They cause him to hide inside the classroom from imagined threats of insect attacks. He is afraid to try new things. He is afraid to learn and afraid to play. His fears even cause him pain, real or imagined, and self-inflicted injury. Finally, they have a significantly adverse effect on his educational performance. The testimony established that STUDENT cannot learn when he is afraid to try something that he does not already know how to do well. To progress, STUDENT must learn new things -- things which he does not yet know how to do. This scares him. He gives up easily or won’t try at all. When he is distracted and preoccupied with fears for his family and himself, his ability to concentrate on the task at hand are compromised. When he is scratching himself raw or in pain, his educational performance suffers.The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT does have a tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems that has been present for a long period of time and to a marked degree, and that has a significantly adverse effect on his educational performance.
There is adequate evidence to establish that, at the present time, STUDENT is emotionally disturbed and is eligible for special education services under that classification.(Footnote 11) While the Hearing Officer is satisfied that this is an appropriate classification at this time, he is concerned that STUDENT’s emotional and psychological problems may be more complex and profound than the available evidence discloses. This concern is addressed in more detail below.
Did the District offer a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) to STUDENT in the IEP dated March 6, 2001?
PARENT agreed that the offer contained in the March 6, IEP did “meet the minimum legal requirement under the law.”(Footnote 12) However, she is adamant that her son not be placed in the ED SDC. While she agrees that it is an appropriate “alternative” placement, she believes that home schooling will give him the “one-on-one attention” he needs.(Footnote 13) This placement was the only FAPE issue raised by Respondent.
The federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), and State law require that students with disabilities be offered a FAPE in the least restrictive environment. 20 U.S.C. Sections 1400 (d) and 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code Sections 56000 and 56031. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. Section 1401(8). It consists of educational instruction specially designed to meet the unique needs of the disabled child, supported by such services as are necessary to permit the child “benefit” from the instruction. Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176,188-189. The IDEA does not require that the states “maximize the potential of each handicapped child commensurate with the opportunity provided non-handicapped children.” Id. at 200-201. Finally, in determining whether the student is being educated in the least restrictive environment, the courts have indicated factors to be considered. Those include: (1) the educational benefits available to the child in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared to the educational benefits of a special education classroom; (2) the non-academic benefits to the handicapped child of interaction with nonhandicapped children; (3) the effect of the presence of the handicapped child on the teacher and other children in the regular classroom; and (4) the costs of supplementary aids and services necessary to mainstream the handicapped child in a regular classroom setting. Sacramento City Unif. School Dist. v. Rachel H., (Holland) (9th Cir. 1994) 14 F.3d 1398
In order to comply with the IDEA as interpreted by the court in Rowley, an educational program must meet the following four requirements: (1) It must have been designed to meet the student’s unique needs; (2) It must have been designed to provide the student with some educational benefit; (3) It must have conformed to the student’s IEP; and, (4) It must have been designed to provide the student with all of the above in the least restrictive environment (“LRE”). If the program offered by the District meets the above requirements, the Hearing Officer must determine that the District offered the student a FAPE, even if the parents preferred another placement and even if the parents' preferred placement could have resulted in greater educational benefit to Emily. Gregory K. v. Longview School District (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307, 1314.
What Are STUDENT’s Unique Needs?
STUDENT is a child with many special needs. Some of those which must be met if he is to benefit from his education were apparent from the evidence. He needs assistance with his emotions and how he acts on them. He needs to have available in his learning environment someone who is willing and able (i.e., qualified) to help him with his perception of his environment and how he processes and reacts to what he perceives. He needs individual counseling. Group counseling may also be needed now or in the near future. He needs someone who can effectively work with his parents and others outside of the school community who are involved in the medical and psychological management of his physical, emotional and behavioral needs. He needs assistance with the management of his medications.(Footnote 14) He needs a behavior plan that is designed to encourage positive behaviors at school and elsewhere. He needs close supervision and control in the classroom. STUDENT needs help with his fine and gross motor skills. Finally, like all students receiving special education, he needs an academic program that is suited to his learning style and that will ensure some progress.
Despite all that is known about STUDENT’s unique needs, it is obvious from the evidence, or from the lack of evidence, that there is inadequate information available to allow the District to design an IEP for him, or for the Hearing officer to determine the adequacy of an IEP. STUDENT needs immediate placement and services, but it may be even more imperative that he be thoroughly assessed and diagnosed, medically and psychologically, to ensure that the District will have the information it needs to develop and implement an appropriated IEP.
STUDENT’s history in special education underscores the need for a comprehensive assessment. In the middle of his kindergarten year in 1996, the District was concerned about distractability and language skills. By August 1996, there are references to auditory comprehension problems. In November 1996, he was found eligible for special education as speech and language impaired. In June 1997, his eligibility was changed to developmentally delayed. In November 1998, he was reclassified again to other health impaired. The first referral by the District to VCBH was at this time. That recommendation has been repeated many times since then. By March, the District was attempting to address STUDENT’s frequent emotional outbursts with a positive behavior support plan. A year later, there seemed to be some improvement, but the frequent emotional outbursts continued and STUDENT was having “unrealistic thoughts.” In April, STUDENT became a client of Tri-counties Regional Center. In June, following the assessment by Susan Nielsen, the District recommended the change to the emotionally disturbed classification and placement. By September 2000, STUDENT was suffering suspensions because of his behavior, and the District was asking that he be removed from the campus when the staff were no longer able to calm him sufficiently to allow his return to the classroom. By March 2001, STUDENT’s teacher was simply no longer able to deal with his problems and still be an effective manager and teacher to the rest of the class. In addition to all of his apparent psychological, emotional and behavioral difficulties, STUDENT has a myriad of physical complaints that may or may not be psychosomatic. Those should be diagnosed by a physician.(Footnote 15)
The District has long recognized the need for a psychological/emotional assessment and diagnosis. It has been recommending to PARENT that STUDENT be evaluated by VCBH for over two and one-half years. It is through no fault of the District that this recommendation has not been accepted. It’s options, such as referrals to Child Protective Services or other agencies or authorities, were limited and approached by the District with understandable reluctance. The threat to STUDENT’s educational rights has become critical. This critical need must be met.
The Hearing Officer continues with his analysis of the March 6, 2001 IEP solely to determine whether it is an adequate interim placement.
Is the Program Designed to Meet Those Needs?
STUDENT needs assistance with his emotions and how he acts on them. According to the testimony of various District witnesses, there is a trained and qualified mental health liaison who is available to work with and assist the students and staff with emotional and behavioral issues. Both Nancy Barker, the principal at Blanche Reynolds, and Keri Jafari, another of the District’s school psychologists and the program specialist for the District’s K-5 ED program, praised the commitment and contributions of the liaison, who is provided to the school under an interagency agreement with VCBH. This person is present full-time to assist the teachers and staff. She conducts both group and individual counseling, each one time per week. She meets with the students’ families twice per month, acting as a connection between family and school and assisting with the development and implementation of treatment plans. She has accompanied students and families to doctor and therapist appointments and is available to assist with the management of medications. This component of the ED SDC should meet, at least on an interim basis, most of STUDENT’s needs for assistance with his perception of the world and how he reacts to those perceptions.
STUDENT needs a good behavior plan. The proposed program as described in the testimony and other evidence does not include this. There has to be a concerted effort to develop and implement a plan, with the assistance of the mental health liaison, which is designed to help STUDENT to adapt his behavior in a way that will better allow him to progress socially and academically. While there was evidence that there were positive behavior support plans attempted, there was inadequate evidence that these were effectively implemented.
The ratio of students to staff must be such that STUDENT will receive adequate individual attention. Susan Beattie is one of the teachers of the class. She holds a bachelor’s degree in psychology, a second bachelor’s degree in child development and a multi-subject teaching credential. She also has six years of experience working at a residential facility and regional treatment center for emotionally disturbed children. She does not yet have a special education credential. Ms. Beattie explained that there are eleven students in her class at Blanche Reynolds, who are managed and taught by five adults: two teachers, three aids and the mental health liaison. This ratio of staff to students should provide STUDENT with the individual attention he needs to help him to stay on task and in control, at least until the completion and consideration of a comprehensive assessment.
According to the March 6, 2001 IEP, STUDENT needs help with his fine and gross motor skills. It is clear from the evidence whether this is an area of disability. The IEP states that these needs can be adequately met in the classroom and through a specially designed physical education program. However, the record does not support a conclusion that the placement will meet these needs.
STUDENT needs an academic program that is suited to his learning style and that will ensure some progress. There is little information in the evidence, however, to indicate what STUDENT might need in his academic program to ensure some progress. Susan Nielsen states in her report: “Although STUDENT has a history of learning problems, as well as some sensory issues, these are not the primary barriers interfering with his educational experience.” She later states that STUDENT’s “emotionality is the primary factor interfering with his learning.” According to the same report, he was found by TRC to be delayed in three of seven domains, but the areas of delay are not stated. The June 2000 WJ-R results confirm that STUDENT has not kept pace academically with the peer control group in some areas, but that he tested at “average” or “low average” in seven of thirteen areas. According to the testimony, STUDENT’s academic performance and achievement cannot be determined due to his distractability and the impact of his emotional and behavioral difficulties. It may be that the aspects of the program discussed above will meet STUDENT’s needs sufficiently to allow him to progress in the “regular academic day” described by the witnesses, but the evidence is not sufficient to allow the Hearing Officer to conclude that. The Hearing Officer does conclude, however, that STUDENT’s emotional, psychological and behavioral needs must be met first, before there can be a reliable assessment of his academic needs and the formulation of an academic program that will assure him some progress in his education. The offered program does address those critical emotional, psychological and behavioral needs on an interim basis.
The Hearing Officer can only conclude that the ED SDC at Blanche Reynolds School will meet STUDENT’s most critical needs on an interim basis.
Is the Program Designed to Provide an Educational Benefit?
STUDENT’s teacher testified that he is bright and has potential. He has demonstrated through past educational achievement that he can learn when his emotional, psychological and behavioral difficulties do not significantly interfere with the process. A comparison of the WJ-R scores from 1997 and 2000 demonstrates that STUDENT did make some progress during these years despite the difficulties. It remains unclear, however, whether STUDENT would need any other modifications or accommodations in the learning environment to receive an educational benefit from the ED SDC. Based on this record, it can only be concluded that the placement will adequately meet STUDENT’s emotional, psychological and behavioral needs, and thereby provide some educational benefit pending completion and consideration of a comprehensive assessment.
Does the Program Conform to STUDENT’s IEP?
Since the program has not been implemented, it is necessary to look at the program as described in the testimony and other evidence to determine whether it conformed to STUDENT’s IEP. The description in the testimony and other evidence shows that the program is consistent with the IEP with respect to actual placement, services, duration, academic subjects, integration, accommodations and supports. Although the testimony provided more detail, particularly concerning staffing and the psychological and related services that will be provided, the program which the District seeks to implement, and which it should be able to implement, does conform to the STUDENT’s IEP.
Is the Program to Be Implemented in the Least Restrictive Environment?
It has not been argued or suggested by PARENT that the ED SDC at Blanche Reynolds School was not the LRE for STUDENT. It was less restrictive than home schooling, the placement urged by PARENT. The March 6, 2001 IEP calls for “integration” at lunch and recess, totaling 60 minutes (17%) per day. It appears from the evidence that STUDENT was receiving little or no benefit from his education in the LH SDC during his last year. While there might, at some later date, be some benefit to STUDENT from increased time with the general education students, the evidence strongly suggests that this is not the time. STUDENT has difficulty relating to the students and adults at school. In light of the remarkable array of emotional, psychological and behavioral difficulties STUDENT has experienced in his education, it is clear that, at the present time, the proposed program is designed to provide him with the least restrictive environment for his education.
In summary, there is inadequate evidence to allow the Hearing officer to conclude that the offer contained in the March 6, 2001 IEP was an offer of FAPE. The only conclusion supported by the evidence is that the recommended placement and services are the most suitable for STUDENT at this time, on an interim basis only, pending the necessary assessment and diagnosis.
ORDER
1. STUDENT’s eligibility is changed from “other health impaired” to both “other health impaired” and “emotionally disturbed.”
2. STUDENT’s mother shall immediately return him to the District for interim placement pursuant to the March 6, 2001 IEP.
3. The District shall, upon the return of STUDENT as ordered above, immediately implement the March 6, 2001 IEP as an interim IEP only pending completion of assessments and development of a new IEP as ordered below.
4. By July 13, 2001, the District shall develop a plan for the comprehensive psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT. STUDENT shall be assessed in all areas of suspected disability, including those identified in the last six years. The plan may include the participation of Ventura County Behavioral Health. The plan shall include assessment and diagnosis of STUDENT by a qualified clinical psychologist and appropriate medical doctor(s). The plan shall also include a schedule of the date(s), times(s) and location(s) of each session of the assessment, and a written notice to STUDENT’s mother that she is required by this order to either produce STUDENT at each such session or to notify the District at least seventy-two hours in advance that transportation by the District will be necessary. A copy of the plan shall be mailed to STUDENT’s mother at least seven calendar days prior to the first scheduled appointment. The consent of STUDENT’s parent for this assessment is not required.
5. STUDENT’s mother shall either produce STUDENT at each session of the assessment or shall make STUDENT available to the District for transportation by it to each session.
6. The comprehensive psychoeducational assessment, including the reports of the same, shall be completed no later than August 24, 2001.
7. The District shall convene an IEP meeting to review the results of the assessment and select an appropriate placement for the 2001-2002 school year by August 31, 2001.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
1. Is STUDENT eligible for special education as a child who is emotionally disturbed?
The District was the prevailing party on this issue.
2. Did the District offer a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) to STUDENT in the IEP dated March 6, 2001?
There was no prevailing party on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code Section 56505(i).
Dated: June 28, 2001 Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnote 1: PARENT was present during only part of the hearing, as explained below. Footnote 2: The exact wording and order of the issues have been changed for clarity and ease of analysis. Footnote 3: This issue includes the appropriate placement for STUDENT, which was listed as a separate issue by the District. Footnote 4: While it is unclear when or how the offer contained in the March 6, 2001 IEP was delivered to PARENT, statements made at the hearing confirmed that she had received it. Footnote 5: According to the report of the assessment, the mother did not return the version that was sent home for her to complete. The report notes that input from the parents was minimal regarding STUDENT’s behavior and emotionality at home. Footnote 6: There was an effort with this assessment to determine the effect of the Ritalin on STUDENT’s behavior. The teacher did two sets of responses to the BASC, one to reflect her observations when STUDENT was medicated and one when he was not. It is not clear how the staff knew when STUDENT was medicated. This results of this comparison were mixed and unreliable . Footnote 7: The SDC is not specifically identified as an ED SDC. Footnote 8: According to a November 27, 2000 letter to PARENT from Nancy Barker, PARENT stated on November 17 that STUDENT would not be attending Blanche Reynolds School. There was no indication that he attended school elsewhere. Footnote 9: The District offered placement in th ED SDC without a change in eligibility classification. Footnote 10: STUDENT could not be tested pursuant to Larry P. v. Riles (N.D. Cal.1979) 495 F. Supp. 926, aff'd in part, rev'd in part, (9th Cir. 1984) 793 F.2d 969 Footnote 11: STUDENT also remains eligible for special education services under the OHI category. Footnote 12: It is not clear when or how the IEP offer was delivered to the Respondent, but the statements made at the hearing confirmed that she had received it and was aware of the terms. Footnote 13: PARENT never expressed any specific disagreement with the program or services offered, but asserted that STUDENT should receive home schooling, without making any effort to show that such a placement was appropriate. Footnote 14: Not all needs discussed are a product of the emotional disturbance. Footnote 15: The IDEA requires the use of a physician’s services if necessary to determine a child’s medically related disability. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); 300 C.F.R. § 300.24(b)(4).
