California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 5, 2002

Student v. Saddleback Valley Unified School District (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 766-01, SN 01-01694 · Hearing Officer Van T. Vu

Saddleback Valley Unified denied FAPE to preschooler with autism; must fund CARD home ABA program, therapies, and reimburse parents.

Split decision: student prevailed on 4 of 5 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. The District withdrew its cross-filed assessment issue (SN 01-01694) on November 27, 2001.

Summary

The parents of a four-year-old with autism filed for due process against Saddleback Valley Unified School District after he moved from Regional Center services to preschool special education. The District cross-filed to assess him but withdrew that claim during the hearing. The student was receiving 40 hours a week of in-home applied behavior analysis (ABA) through the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), plus private speech therapy and occupational therapy (OT).

Hearing Officer Van T. Vu found that the District's January 2001 assessment missed fine motor, oral-motor, and sensory needs. The District never assessed oral-motor needs at all. The IEPs dated March 22 and June 1, 2001 denied FAPE for three reasons. First, the District offered a "nonsevere" special day class without naming which of three different classrooms was meant, and it did not prove that all three were appropriate. Second, the IEPs left out the duration of consultation services. Third, the District never gave the parents a complete written set of the goals the team had agreed to orally.

The Hearing Officer found that the CARD program met the student's needs and gave him educational benefit. He also needed direct speech therapy and direct OT. The District must reimburse the parents for private services from February 12, 2001, the date of the IEP meeting the District cancelled, and for Joanne Hein's speech evaluation. It must also fund CARD and the therapies through the 2002 extended school year. Reimbursement for two other independent evaluations was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO applied Union School District v. Smith. Offering a general class type, without naming a specific classroom, was not a valid written offer of placement. A district that offers several possible classrooms must prove each one is appropriate. Also, goals agreed to orally but never given to parents in complete written form denied FAPE.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedAssessment

    Issue I. Did the District assess STUDENT appropriately and in all areas of suspected disability?

    The January 2001 assessment did not adequately assess fine motor, oral-motor, and sensory integration needs, and oral-motor was never assessed; claims about gross motor, PLS-3 administration, and report contents were rejected.

  2. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue II. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2000-2001 school and extended school year and the 2001-2002 school and extended school year?

    The March 22 and June 1, 2001 IEPs denied FAPE: no specific SDC classroom was offered and the District did not prove all three possible classrooms were appropriate, service durations were missing, and a complete written set of goals was never given to the parents.

  3. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue III. Does STUDENT require continued placement in the Center for Autism and Related Disorders program with direct speech and language and occupational therapy services to receive a FAPE?

    The CARD program met the student's needs and gave him educational benefit; he also needs direct speech therapy (two hours a week) and direct OT (one hour a week), not consultation alone.

  4. Issue IV. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of privately procured educational services and independent educational evaluations?

    Parents get reimbursement for private services from February 12, 2001 and for the Hein speech-language IEE; reimbursement for the Furbush OT and Perlman psychological evaluations was denied.

  5. Issue District issue. Whether the District has the right to assess STUDENT (District's cross-filed case)

    The District withdrew its cross-filed assessment issue on November 27, 2001.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days of receipt of proof, reimburse parents for the cost of all educational services privately obtained for the student between February 12, 2001 and the date of the decision (CARD, speech-language, and OT services; limited to costs not paid by insurance or other entities).
  • IEE at public expense. Within 30 calendar days of receipt of proof, reimburse parents for the independent speech and language evaluation by Joanne Hein.
  • Prospective funding of private placement. From the decision date through the end of the District's 2002 extended school year, fund the CARD program at 40 hours per week, including supervision and clinic meetings.
  • Order to provide or change services. Provide one hour per week each of individual speech and language therapy, small-group speech and language therapy, and individual occupational therapy; the District may use its own vendors.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range; Clyde K. v. Puyallup; Glendale Unified School Dist. v. Almasi; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup; Roland M. v. Concord School Committee; Cleveland Heights-University Heights City Sch. Dist. v. Boss

People named in the decision

  • Dr. Rona Martin, director of special education, Saddleback Valley Unified School District
  • Dr. Bob (Robert) White, SELPA director, South Orange County SELPA
  • Mary Dean, school psychologist, Saddleback Valley Unified School District
  • Lisa Sherry, school psychologist and assessor, Saddleback Valley Unified School District
  • Jean Stace Nunz, speech and language pathologist and assessor, Saddleback Valley Unified School District
  • Becky Touchette, Intensive Behavior Intervention (IBI) class teacher, Saddleback Valley Unified School District
  • Diane Lappi, program specialist, Saddleback Valley Unified School District
  • Mindy Mulligan, occupational therapist and assessor, Saddleback Valley Unified School District
  • Eileen Donahue, preschool special day class teacher, La Tierra School, Saddleback Valley Unified School District
  • Charla Russ, preschool special day class teacher, Robinson Ranch School, Saddleback Valley Unified School District
  • Angela Davis, preschool special day class teacher, La Tierra School, Saddleback Valley Unified School District
  • Joanne Hein, private speech-language pathologist, independent evaluator, Hein Speech and Language
  • Mitchel Perlman, Ph.D., private psychologist, independent evaluator
  • Doreen Granpeesheh, Ph.D., director, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
  • Kathy Thompson, senior clinic supervisor, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
  • Susanne Johnson, case and workshop supervisor, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
  • Richard Furbush, occupational therapist, independent evaluator, Sky Pediatric
  • Dr. Ira Lott, diagnosing physician, University of California at Irvine Medical Center
  • Dr. Trice, pediatric neurologist
  • Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), private ABA provider
  • Orange County Therapy Services, private occupational therapy provider
  • South County Pediatric Speech, private speech and language provider
  • Newport Language and Speech Centers, Part C speech and OT provider
  • Star Physical Therapy, private occupational therapy evaluator
  • Regional Center of Orange County, Part C early intervention agency

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This consolidated matter was heard before Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Mission Viejo, California, on October 16-19, 25-26, November 1-2, 27-28, and December 13, 2001.

Student STUDENT (Student, STUDENT, or Petitioner) was represented at the hearing by attorney Shelli Lewis and his parents, PARENTS. Attorneys Don Gonzalez and Jonathon Barons were also present on his behalf at times during the hearing.

The Saddleback Valley Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Sharon Watt. Dr. Rona Martin, director of special education, and Dr. Bob White, director of the South Orange County SELPA, were also present on Respondent’s behalf.

The Student called the following witnesses: Mary Dean, school psychologist; Becky Touchette, Intensive Behavior Intervention (IBI) class teacher; Diane Lappi, program specialist; Jean Stace Nunz, speech and language specialist; Lisa Sherry, school psychologist; Joanne Hein, speech and language specialist from Hein Speech and Language; Mitchel Perlman, Ph.D., private psychologist; Doreen Granpeesheh, Ph.D., director of Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD); Kathy Thompson, CARD senior clinic supervisor; Susanne Johnson, CARD case and workshop supervisor; Richard Furbush, occupational therapist with Sky Pediatric; and, Mindy Mulligan, occupational therapist. The Student also called Dr. Rona Martin and MOTHER as witnesses.

The District called the following witnesses: Mindy Mulligan, Jean Stace Nunz, Mary Dean, Diane Lappi, Lisa Sherry, Becky Touchette, Robert White, director of the South Orange County SELPA, and Eileen Donahue, special day class (SDC) teacher.

Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of closing arguments. The District’s closing arguments were received on February 5, 2002, and the Student’s closing arguments were received on February 8, 2002. The record was then closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES (Footnote 1)

I. Did the District assess STUDENT appropriately and in all areas of suspected disability?

II. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2000-2001 school and extended school year and the 2001-2002 school and extended school year?

III. Does STUDENT require continued placement in the Center for Autism and Related Disorders program with direct speech and language and occupational therapy services to receive a FAPE?

IV. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of privately procured educational services and independent educational evaluations?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a four-year-old preschool student who is eligible for special education and related services as a child with autism. STUDENT is currently receiving in-home applied behavioral analysis (ABA) therapy under the auspices of the Center for Autism and Related Disorders. Additionally, STUDENT receives private occupational therapy (OT) and speech and language therapy through Orange County Therapy Services and South County Pediatric, respectively. STUDENT has never attended school or received educational services within the District.

In May 2000, when STUDENT was twenty-eight months old, his parents sought a developmental evaluation due to his language delays from the Regional Center of Orange County (Regional Center). The purpose of the assessment was to determine STUDENT’s eligibility for Early Intervention Services under Part B of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). (Dist. Exh. 7; Student Exh. 42; Test. of MOTHER.) According to the assessment, STUDENT’s expressive and receptive language skills were at the twelve- to fifteen-month level and his social and play skills at the fifteen- to eighteen-month level. (Id.) Additionally, the report noted that STUDENT’s cognitive skills were at the eighteen-month level, that his fine motor skills were scattered between the fifteen- to twenty-seven-month level, that he had sensory processing deficits, and that there was a question as to the existence of intra-oral tactile defensiveness. (Id.) Approximately one month after the evaluation, the Regional Center developed an individualized family services plan (IFSP) for STUDENT, which provided for combined group speech and language therapy and OT services from the Newport Language and Speech Centers for three two-hour sessions per week. (Dist. Exh. 7.)

On September 15, 2000, STUDENT was diagnosed with mild autism by Dr. Ira Lott from the University of California at Irvine Medical Center. (Student Exh. 2.) According to Dr. Lott, STUDENT had “language regression, some minimal difficulty with eye contact at present, parallel rather than interactive play for children his age, some compulsive behaviors, and a moderate degree of hyperactivity.” (Id.) Dr. Lott also noted that STUDENT “lacks sensitivity to loud sounds, and although transitions were very problematic for him early on, they were much better.” (Id.)

At the end of October 2000, STUDENT’s parents sought services from CARD. (Dist. Exh. 30.) According to MOTHER, a representative from CARD told her that there was a waiting list of six months to a year for CARD services. (Test. of MOTHER.) Unable to obtain CARD services immediately, the PARENTS hired approximately three independent home therapists from the local colleges in November 2000 to provide ABA therapy for STUDENT at his home. (Id.)

On November 29, 2000, the Newport Language and Speech Center issued a report regarding STUDENT’s progress from therapy. (Student Exh. 3.) According to the report, while STUDENT made “a lot of progress,” he continued to exhibit “moderate to severe receptive and expressive” language impairments, a moderate oral motor impairment, and moderate difficulty processing tactile and vestibular input. (Id.) The report recommended continued group therapy to address his receptive/expressive language skills, his sensory/developmental skills, and his oral motor/articulation skills. (Id.) The therapy was also to focus on encouraging appropriate interaction and initiation with his peers. (Id.)

In anticipation of STUDENT’s third birthday on January 25, 2001, the Regional Center convened a meeting with MOTHER and Lisa Sherry, school psychologist from the District, on December 15, 2000. (Student Exhs. 8 and 10.) The purpose of the meeting was to discuss STUDENT’s transition from Part C to Part B of the IDEA. (Student Exh. 8.) At the meeting, Ms. Sherry described the types of services that are available to special education students within the District. Ms. Sherry also recommended that MOTHER visit the three preschool “nonsevere” special day classes (SDC) that are offered within the District.

While discussing possible areas of need that the District might need to assess, MOTHER voiced her concerns regarding STUDENT’s “socialization, language, apraxia (possible), oral motor [and] fine motor,” and sensory processing difficulties. (Student Exhs. 8 and 10.) From the discussions, Ms. Sherry developed an assessment plan seeking to assess STUDENT in the areas of academic/preacademic achievement, social/adaptive behavior, psycho-motor development, communication development, and intellectual/cognitive development. (Student Exh. 10; Test. of Lisa Sherry.) Ms. Sherry also provided MOTHER with a release of information form to allow the District, Regional Center, and Newport Speech and Language Center to exhange information regarding STUDENT. (Student Exh. 11; Test. of Lisa Sherry.) MOTHER signed both forms at the meeting, thereby consenting to the assessments and the release of information. (Student Exhs. 10 and 11.)

The District conducted its initial assessment of STUDENT on January 8, 2001. (Student Exh. 24.) The assessment, which took about an hour and a half, was administered by Jean Stace Nunz, the District’s speech and language pathologist, and Lisa Sherry. (Id.) According to the assessment report, STUDENT was found to have average cognitive and gross motor abilities. Additionally, the report indicated that STUDENT’s receptive language skills were “severely below the average range,” that his expressive language skills were in the “below average range,” and that his fine motor skills were severely delayed. The Child Development Inventory (CDI) that was filled out by MOTHER indicated that STUDENT’s self-help/adaptive and social/emotional skills were also severely delayed. Moreover, the assessors noted in the report that STUDENT demonstrated “limited eye contact, perseverative behavior, and echolia.”

Sometime shortly after the District’s assessment, Susanne Johnson from CARD contacted the PARENTS to inform them that she would be able to provide case supervision services for STUDENT. During the next couple of weeks, Ms. Johnson trained MOTHER, STUDENT’s grandparents, and STUDENT’s home therapists on ABA principles and DTT techniques. From January 2000 through at least the end of the hearing, Ms. Johnson continued to be STUDENT’s case supervisor.

At the request of MOTHER, STUDENT’s initial IEP meeting was scheduled after his third birthday, which was on January 25, 2001. Although the IEP meeting was initially scheduled for February 12, 2001, the District cancelled the IEP meeting upon learning that the PARENTS would be represented by an attorney at the IEP meeting. The meeting was eventually rescheduled to, and held on, March 14, 2001. At the IEP meeting, the District presented the results from its assessment conducted by Lisa Sherry and Jean Stace Nunz and distributed to the IEP team copies of its draft goals and objectives for STUDENT.

During the course of the meeting, MOTHER and Susanne Johnson disclosed to the District for the first time that STUDENT had been receiving in-home CARD services. MOTHER also presented to the District a copy of an occupational therapy report from Star Physical Therapy and a report from STUDENT’s pediatric neurologist, Dr. Trice. Ms. Johnson then presented to the IEP team copies of CARD’s draft goals and objectives that had been developed for STUDENT by Ms. Johnson. After the IEP team discussed both sets of goals and objectives, it was agreed that Ms. Nunz and Ms. Johnson would communicate after the IEP meeting to combine the two sets of goals and objectives.(Footnote 2) Finally, the PARENTS signed a form consenting to the release of information to the District from CARD, Star Physical Therapy, and Dr. Trice. The PARENTS also consented to the District’s recommendation that it conduct an occupational therapy assessment on STUDENT. The IEP meeting was then adjourned and rescheduled to continue on March 22, 2001.

At the continued IEP meeting, the IEP team again discussed the integration of the District and CARD goals and objectives. During the discussions, the team members made recommendations regarding ways to modify the goals and objectives and, as a result of the discussions, the IEP team orally agreed to the goals and objectives. The team also agreed that Ms. Nunz would rewrite all of the goals and objectives, as agreed to, onto one District form and distribute the final version of the goals and objectives to the parties by March 30, 2001.

Once the goals and objectives were orally agreed upon, the District recommended that STUDENT be placed in Ms. Touchette’s intensive behavioral instruction (IBI) class for 2 ½ to 3 hours per day and in a special day class for 2 ¼ hours per day. Additionally, the District offered STUDENT speech and language consultation one time per week for an undesignated duration. Because the District’s occupational therapy assessment had not been completed, the District was unable to make recommendations regarding STUDENT’s occupational therapy needs. Moreover, although the District determined that STUDENT would be eligible for extended school year services, no specific program or services were offered. The PARENTS disagreed with the District’s recommended placement and services for STUDENT and requested that he be able to continue his in-home CARD program and direct speech and language and occupational therapy services.

On March 24, 2001, the PARENTS sent to the District a written “Dissent to IEP,” wherein they elaborated on the bases of their disagreements with the IEP. According to the dissent, the PARENTS indicated that they had not yet been provided the final written goals and objectives and had yet to provide consent to the goals as written. Additionally, the PARENTS disagreed that the District had assessed STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and they indicated their intent to seek independent educational evaluations (IEE) for which they would later seek reimbursement from the District. The PARENTS also indicated that the District’s ESY offer of four weeks of services was inappropriate because STUDENT requires a fifty-two-week-per-year program. Moreover, the PARENTS contended that STUDENT requires speech and language and occupational therapy services and continued placement in the CARD program (which is composed of 40 hours per week of “Lovaas” type therapy with supervision, therapist training, and bi-weekly clinic meetings). The PARENTS expressed the feeling that the District’s offered program in the SDC class was too restrictive for STUDENT. Furthermore, the PARENTS indicated their intent to seek retroactive reimbursement for the implementation of STUDENT’s CARD program.

On April 3, 2001, Mary Dean purportedly faxed to the PARENTS’ attorney, Shelli Lewis, a twenty-two page document that was to have included the consolidated goals and objectives verbally agreed upon at the March 24 IEP meeting. MOTHER testified, however, that only sixteen of the twenty-two pages of goals and objectives were ever received. On that same day, STUDENT’s grandfather picked up a copy of the goals and objectives from the District and provided the copy to speech and language pathologist Joanne Hein. It is unclear from the record how many pages were contained in the copy of the goals and objectives given to Ms. Hein; however, that copy contained four of the six pages that were missing from MOTHER’s copy.(Footnote 3)

Dr. Rona Martin, the District’s director of special education, responded to the PARENTS’ “Dissent to IEP” by letter dated April 10, 2001. In her letter, Dr. Martin requested more information as to the areas in which the PARENTS were seeking independent educational evaluations so that the District could consider the request. Dr. Martin also wrote that an IEP meeting would convene prior to June 22 to review STUDENT’s needs and to determine the duration of his extended school program. Additionally, Dr. Martin stated the District’s position that the District’s offered placement and program contained in the March 22 IEP constituted an offer of FAPE, pending the completion of the District’s occupational therapy evaluation. Also on April 10, the PARENTS obtained an independent speech and language assessment from Joanne Hein.

One week later, the PARENTS requested a special education due process hearing.

On May 4, 2001, the District’s occupational therapist, Mindy Mulligan, conducted STUDENT’s occupational therapy assessment. STUDENT’s IEP team convened for a third time on June 1, 2001, in order to review the assessment results. At the IEP meeting, the District reiterated its previous offer of placement, but clarified that its offer now contained three hours of IBI services rather than the previously offered two-and-a-half-to three hours. The District also offered speech and language therapy in a small-group setting for two thirty-minute sessions per week rather than the previously offered speech and language consultation once per week for an undesignated duration. In light of the occupational therapy assessment, the District also offered “specially designed” physical education, OT consultation services to the classroom twice per month for an undesignated duration, and consultation services to the parent for twice per month for fifteen- to sixty-minute sessions. The PARENTS did not consent to the District’s offered program and placement for STUDENT.

Also at the meeting, the PARENTS and Ms. Lewis notified the District members of the team that the goals and objectives received from Ms. Dean were incomplete in that they omitted three pages of goals and objectives that were verbally agreed to by the team on March 22. On July 9, 2001, Ms. Dean purportedly sent to the PARENTS and Ms. Lewis a revised set of goals and objectives, now totaling twenty-six pages, that included the missing pages and a cover letter explaining that those goals and objectives were included as enclosures. However, MOTHER testified that, although she and Ms. Lewis received the cover letter, neither person ever received an enclosed set of goals and objectives.

Also during July 2001, the PARENTS obtained independent educational evaluations from clinical psychologist Dr. Mitchel Perlman and occupational therapist Richard Furbush. Dr. Perlman conducted a “Psychodiagnostic Assessment” and Richard Furbush conducted an occupational therapy assessment.

On July 25, the District cross-filed for a due process hearing. The only issue the District raised for hearing was whether it has the right to assess STUDENT. By order dated August 6, 2001, the Hearing Office consolidated the Student’s case with the District’s case.

In September 2001, the PARENTS enrolled STUDENT at a private preschool, where he attends class with typical peers. One of STUDENT’s CARD therapists accompanies STUDENT to school and serves as his one-to-one aide. Through the end of the hearing, STUDENT continued to attend the private preschool. Additionally, STUDENT was receiving approximately forty hours per week of CARD therapy, three hours per week of private speech and language therapy, and one hour per week of private occupational therapy services.

The hearing in the consolidated matter convened for the first time on October 16, 2001. On November 27, 2001, the District withdrew its cross-filing and assessment issue against the Student.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

I. Did the District assess STUDENT appropriately and in all areas of suspected disability?

The District’s assessments of STUDENT were conducted by school psychologist Lisa Sherry, speech and language pathologist Jean Stace Nunz, and occupational therapist Mindy Mulligan. Ms. Sherry and Ms. Nunz conducted the psychoeducational assessment on January 8, 2001. That assessment included the Child Development Inventory (CDI), the Preschool Language Scale-3 (PLS-3), the Goldman-Fristoe Test of Articulation-2 (Goldman-Fristoe), and portions of the Bayley Scales of Infant Development (Bayley). Ms. Mulligan’s occupational therapy assessment, which was conducted almost four months after the district’s psychoeducational assessment, included observations of STUDENT, the Sensory Profile, and the fine motor subtests of the Peabody Developmental Motor Scales – II (Peabody).

In asserting that the District’s assessments were inappropriate, the Petitioner focused his allegations on the District’s psychoeducational assessment conducted by Ms. Sherry and Ms. Nunz rather than on the District’s later occupational therapy assessment. Specifically, Petitioner contends that the District failed to assess him in all areas of suspected disability, particularly with regard to his fine and gross motor abilities, oral-motor sensitivity, and sensory difficulties. Additionally, the Petitioner asserts that the District failed to administer the PLS-3 in conformance with the test instructions. Moreover, the Petitioner claims that the District’s psychoeducational assessment report is inappropriate because the report contains misleading information regarding the results of the Bayley, and because it lacks any historical information obtained from his parents or private service providers, and lacks any reference to his articulation difficulties.

For assessments to be appropriate, they must meet the statutory requirements set forth in California Education Code Sections 56320 et. seq. California Education Code ' 56320 states, in relevant part, that testing and assessment materials and procedures must be validated for the purpose for which they are used; administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; and are tailored to assess specific areas of need. Additionally, subsections (e) and (f) require that a student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability and that no single procedure is used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for an individual with exceptional needs. Following the assessments, districts must prepare a written assessment report that meets the requirements of California Education Code § 56327. Section 56327 requires that written assessment reports include, among other things, an indication of whether the student may need special education and related services, the basis for the determination that the student continues to need special education and related services, and the educationally relevant health and medical findings, if any.

Assess in all areas of suspected disability:

In this case, the evidence supports Petitioner’s allegation that the District failed to appropriately assess his fine motor abilities, oral-motor sensitivity, and sensory integration. When the District assessed STUDENT on January 8, 2001, it had information that these were suspected areas of disability. During the assessment planning meeting on December of 2000 with MOTHER and Ms. Sherry in attendance, MOTHER notified the District that she had concerns regarding STUDENT’s oral motor, fine motor, and sensory processing abilities. (Student Exhs. 7 and 8.) Additionally, MOTHER consented to the District’s receiving information from Newport Speech and Language Center, where STUDENT had been receiving speech and language therapy and occupational therapy. (Dist. Exh. 24.) The District therefore had access to STUDENT’s Newport Speech and Language Center report, which indicates that he had a moderate oral-motor impairment, moderate vestibular sensitivity, and moderate-to-severe tactile sensitivity. (Student Exh. 3.) Because the report also contained goals and objectives and references to STUDENT’s therapy, the District also knew, or should have known, that STUDENT had been receiving speech and language and occupational therapy services through the Newport Speech and Language Center to address those specific deficits. (Id.; see also Dist. Exh. 12.)

While the District’s December 2000 assessment plan indicates that STUDENT’s psycho-motor and communication development would be assessed, the January 2001 assessment did not significantly cover these areas with regard to oral-motor, sensory, and fine motor abilities. (Dist. Exhs. 11 and 13.) As noted on the District’s assessment report, Ms. Nunz attempted to conduct an oral-motor screening on STUDENT, but the screening could not be completed because of STUDENT’s non-compliance and resistance to tasks. (Dist. Exh. 11; Test. of Ms. Nunz.) The fact that STUDENT resisted the oral-motor evaluation lends credence to MOTHER’s concern that STUDENT had oral- motor issues. However, there is no indication from the record that the District ever attempted to reassess STUDENT in this area or completed an oral-motor assessment of STUDENT at any time thereafter. Similarly, there is no indication from the report or elsewhere that STUDENT’s sensory integration difficulties were assessed. In fact, there is no significant coverage of STUDENT’s sensory integration abilities in the January report.

Although the District spent comparatively more time assessing STUDENT’s fine motor abilities, the District’s assessment in this area is also inappropriate. In the assessment report, Ms. Sherry reported that STUDENT’s fine motor skills were between the 21- to 24-month range based on the testing from the Bayley. However, Ms. Sherry determined this skill range from her administration of the “mental scale” portion of the Bayley rather than the fine motor portion of the Bayley. While Ms. Sherry testified as to the specific items on the mental scale portion of the Bayley that addressed fine motor abilities and that she used in deriving STUDENT’s fine motor level, she also testified that the scoring on the Bayley is derived from a system of identifying the “basal” and “ceiling” levels on a particular subtest.(Footnote 4) Because the purpose of the mental scale portion of the Bayley is to determine a child’s intellectual functioning and not specifically fine motor ability, it logically follows that the cognitive subtest is normed to derive a cognitive abilities score and not a fine motor score. Furthermore, because the items regarding fine motor ability are scattered throughout the cognitive portion of the Bayley, it is impossible to obtain a basal or ceiling or to determine a separate fine motor score from this testing. While some useful information regarding STUDENT’s fine motor skills was derived from the administration of the mental scales portion of the Bayley, it is difficult to imagine how the assessor could have obtained a complete and reliable assessment of STUDENT’s fine motor abilities in this manner.

Additionally, the District’s reliance on the Newport assessment information does not cure its failure to appropriately assess STUDENT in this area. The Newport report only indicates that STUDENT’s fine motor abilities were at the 19- to 27-month range on the Developmental Programming for Infants and Young Children assessment. It does not elaborate on the testing in any manner. According to Ms. Sherry, she did not contact anyone from Newport to discuss STUDENT’s educational needs or the assessment report. Thus, because the Newport assessment report contained only limited information on STUDENT’s fine motor abilities, it would not have added significantly to the District’s assesment. Moreover, the District did consider MOTHER’s responses to the CDI regarding STUDENT’s fine motor skills, which indicated that STUDENT’s abilities were at the 17-month level. However, in light of the disparity between the CDI scores and the District’s estimation of STUDENT’s fine motor abilities level, as well as the inadequacy of using the Bayley mental scales portion alone to determine STUDENT’s fine motor abilities, the District should have assessed STUDENT further in this area. Because it did not, the District did not adequately assess this suspected area of need.

On the other hand, Petitioner’s contention that the District’s assessment was inappropriate because it did not include an assessment in the areas of gross motor abilities is not supported by the evidence. There is no indication from the record that STUDENT’s gross motor ability was a suspected area of disability. During the assessment planning meeting with Ms. Sherry, MOTHER did not indicate any concerns regarding this area. Additionally, the Newport Speech and Language Center report indicates that STUDENT’s gross motor abilities were in the average range. Despite the foregoing, the District’s assessment included observations of STUDENT’s gross motor movements and information from MOTHER in response to the CDI. Given that there was no significant information to suggest that STUDENT had a need in the gross motor area, the District’s observations and information from the CDI was a sufficient assessment of STUDENT’s gross motor needs.

In summary, the District failed to assess Petitioner’s oral-motor sensitivity, sensory integration difficulties, and fine motor abilities as part of its psychoeducational assessment in January 2001. As of the date of the hearing, the District had never assessed STUDENT’s oral-motor sensitivity. The Hearing Officer notes, however, that the District later assessed Petitioner’s fine motor and sensory integration abilities as part of its occupational therapy assessment in May 2001. Although Petitioner disagreed with the District assessor’s substantive findings and recommendations regarding STUDENT’s fine motor abilities, he did not raise any significant challenges to that OT assessment that warrant addressing in this decision.

Administer PLS-3 in conformance with the test instructions:

Petitioner claims that Ms. Nunz administered the PLS-3 inappropriately in that she started testing him at the wrong location in the testing booklet. At the time of the District’s assessment, STUDENT was two years eleven months and fourteen days old. According to Joanne Hein, a private speech pathologist who assessed STUDENT, the PLS-3 manual states that the student should be assessed at the level one year before the student’s actual chronological age. Thus, STUDENT should have been assessed starting at the one year eleven month level on the PLS-3. On the auditory comprehension subtest, this level would correspond to item thirteen on the testing protocol. (See Student Exh. 14.) It is undisputed that Ms. Nunz started STUDENT at item seventeen on the protocol, which would correspond to the two-year level.

The District asserts that Ms. Nunz did not err in starting STUDENT at item seventeen rather than item thirteen. According to Ms. Nunz’s testimony with regard to the test instructions for the PLS-3, the suggested starting point is at the level one year prior to the student’s chronological age, but the assessor has the discretion to start the student at an earlier or later point in the test booklet. Ms. Nunz testified that the decision to start at a point other than the suggested starting point should be based on the assessor’s knowledge of the student’s abilities and other factors. Although Ms. Hein acknowledged that the assessor has the discretion to start at an earlier point in the booklet, she disagrees that the test instructions allow any discretion in starting testing at a later point.

Given that that the issue boils down to what the PLS-3 test instructions actually requires, that neither party produced the test instructions, and that both speech pathologists testified credibly to opposite interpretations, the evidence does not support one party’s contention over the other’s. Because the District has not met its burden of proof on this matter, it cannot be found that Ms. Nunz conformed her assessment to the test instructions of the PLS-3. However, the Hearing Officer finds that, even had Ms. Nunz started at item seventeen when she should have started at item 13, such an error does not necessarily invalidate her assessment of STUDENT. Because the scoring of the PLS-3 is based on a “basal” and “ceiling” rule (and a ceiling is reached when the child misses five items in a row), STUDENT could have missed all four items from thirteen to sixteen and he still would not have hit a ceiling. Thus, Ms. Nunz would have continued to test him, and STUDENT would have scored the same way he did on her original assessment. In light of the above, any error Ms. Nunz made in starting STUDENT at a later point in the testing booklet would not have significantly affected his assessment. For those reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s administration of PLS-3 was appropriately done. Information contained in assessment report:

Petitioner’s remaining allegations are not supported by the evidence or the law. First, Petitioner argues that the District reported misleading information by reporting an overall score on the Bayley when only one portion of the test was administered. While the report failed to indicate that only the mental scales subtest was administered to STUDENT, most of the information reported from the Bayley was contained in the “cognitve” skills section of the report. In light of the limited context in which most of the Bayley was reported and the consistency of the Bayley scores with STUDENT’s other cognitive testing, the Hearing Officer does not find persuasive Petitioner’s argument that such reporting overestimated Petitioner’s abilities.

Second, Petitioner alleges that the District’s report was inappropriate because it lacked any historical information obtained from his parents or private service providers. While the report did not contain any historical information from these sources, it did contain some historical information derived from prior reports and other sources. Thus, there does not appear to be any prejudice to Petitioner, because historical information was in fact included in the report. Because of the above, and because the Hearing Officer is unaware of any requirement that the report contain historical information from these specific sources, the Hearing Officer finds unpersuasive the Petitioner’s allegation that the report was inappropriate on this basis.

Petitioner’s last allegation (i.e., that the District’s report lacked any reference to his articulation difficulties) is equally unpersuasive. In this instance, Petitioner appears to disagree with the findings of Ms. Nunz rather than to challenge the appropriateness of the assessment report. The Hearing Office has commonly held that disagreements with the assessment conclusions alone are insufficient bases to challenge propriety of the assessment. Despite Petitioner’s dispute with the results of the assessment, the report appropriately indicates that the Goldman-Fristoe Test of Articulation – 2 was administered, it lists STUDENT’s scores on the assessment, and it elaborates on STUDENT’s performance on that assessment. Thus, the report did reference STUDENT’s articulation abilities, and is not generally inappropriate simply because the assessor failed to find any difficulties in this specific area.

****

In conclusion, the District did not appropriately assess STUDENT in January 2001 in the areas of fine motor, oral-motor, and sensory integration abilities. Although the District later assessed STUDENT’s fine motor and sensory integration needs in May 2001, it has never assessed his oral-motor needs. For these reasons, the District’s assessments were inappropriate.

II. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2000-2001 school and extended school year and the 2001-2002 school and extended school year?

Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. ' 1400; Education Code ' 56000. The term Afree appropriate public education@ means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student=s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. ' 1401(a)(8).

The right to a FAPE also includes the important entitlement to certain procedural protections during the process of developing an individualized education program for a disabled child. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992); Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 205 (1982). Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, the Supreme Court recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA as part of the provision of FAPE. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 205 (1982).

Accordingly, the analysis of whether a student has been provided a free appropriate public education (FAPE) is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to consider both whether procedural steps have been followed and whether the proposed placement and program are substantively appropriate. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206﷓208. At the administrative hearing, the burden of persuasion is on the school district to establish that it complied with the IDEA and Rowley. Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist., No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994).

A. Procedural Appropiateness

The procedural rights that extend to parents under the IDEA include the right to participate in the development of the child’s IEP and the opportunity for mediation and a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).

Petitioner alleges that the District committed a number of procedural violations that resulted in the denial of FAPE. Among his allegations, Petitioner claims that the District failed to make a written offer of placement and that it convened IEP meetings without necessary members of the IEP team. Additionally, Petitioner claims that his IEPs were defective because they did not designate the duration of his related services and they did not include a complete set of written goals and objectives. Petitioner’s allegations will be addressed in turn below.

1. The District’s Written Offer of Placement

Among the procedural violations that may constitute a denial of FAPE is the failure of a school district to make a formal, written offer of placement in compliance with the IDEA=s procedural requirements. Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert denied, 513 U.S. 965, 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994); see also 20 U.S.C. ' 1415(b)(3) (1997). “Placement” is defined in California as “that unique combination of facilities, personnel, location or equipment necessary to provide instructional services to an individual with exceptional needs, as specified in the individualized education program.” 5 C.C.R. § 3042(a). In Union, the Ninth Circuit stated, AWe find that this formal requirement has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe it should be enforced rigorously.@ Union, 15 F.3d at 1526. The Court went on to discuss the reasons for imposing the requirement: (1) to alert the parents of the need to consider seriously whether the school district=s proposed placement is appropriate under the IDEA; (2) to help the parents determine whether to oppose or accept the placement with supplemental services; and (3) so that the school district is more prepared to introduce sufficient relevant evidence of the appropriateness of the placement at a due process hearing. Id. The Court was unequivocal in stating that “this formal requirement has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe it should be enforced rigorously.” Id.

The Petitioner argued that the District’s general offer of a “non-severe” SDC class was not a legally sufficient written offer of placement because the offer did not indicate the specific SDC classroom that was offered to him. According to MOTHER, she visited three SDC classrooms at the recommendation of District staff, and those classroom placements were later discussed at the IEP meetings. However, MOTHER contends that she was unclear as to which placement to consider because she was never notified as to which classroom was offered to STUDENT.

The evidence supports the Petitioner’s position. On STUDENT’s IEPs, it was written that STUDENT was offered a placement in the IBI classroom for 2 ½ to 3 hours per day and in a “nonsevere” SDC classroom for 2 ¼ hours per day.(Footnote 5) However, nowhere in the document does it state which nonsevere SDC classroom was offered within the District. The inconsistent testimony of the various IEP team members also supports MOTHER’s contention that confusion still existed, even among the District members of the IEP team, as to what specific classroom placement was actually offered by the District. According to school psychologist Mary Dean and speech and language pathologist Jean Stace Nunz, the three placements that were considered and offered were the preschool SDC classes of Eileen Donahue, Charla Russ, and Angela Davis. Ms. Donahue’s class and Ms. Davis’s class were located at the La Tierra School campus, whereas Ms. Russ’s class was located at the Robinson Ranch School. District specialist Diane Lappi and IBI teacher Becky Touchette both understood that only Ms. Donahue’s SDC class was offered at the March 22 IEP meeting. Dr. Rona Martin, the District’s director of special education, testified that the District’s offer of placement was limited to either of the two SDC classrooms on the La Tierra School campus. Dr. Martin elaborated that, while all three classes were discussed, Ms. Donahue’s class was most commonly mentioned. Given the confusion amongst the District members of the IEP team, it is apparent that there was never a consensus regarding one placement offer for STUDENT. Without a consensus among the team as to the specific offer of placement and a clear written offer indicating that offer of placement, the District violated the requirements of Union.

The District argues that Union only requires that it offer students a written offer of one type of program rather than one placement. According to the District, its offer of a “nonsevere” SDC classroom for 2 ¼ hours per day was an offer of one type of program that met the requirements of Union. In support of its position, the District offered the testimony of Mary Dean. Ms. Dean testified generally that each of the three SDC classrooms offered had children with similar types of disabilities and similar class schedules. While Ms. Dean describes the classrooms generally as similar, no significant specific information was provided regarding the classrooms of Ms. Davis or Ms. Russ and how STUDENT’s needs could have been met in those classrooms. What information that was provided, however, establishes that the programs are different. For example, the classrooms at La Tierra offered mainstreaming and reverse-mainstreaming during the school day. However, this type of mainstreaming and reverse-mainstreaming is not offered at Robinson Ranch. There, the teachers arrange for children at the “after-school daycare” to intermix with the students in the SDC. Additionally, the IBI program that was offered in conjunction with the SDC placement is located on the La Tierra campus. Although STUDENT could have transitioned from the IBI classroom to one of the SDC classrooms also at La Tierra, there was no indication from the record how STUDENT would have been transitioned from the IBI classroom at La Tierra to the Robinson Ranch SDC class. From the above, the evidence establishes that the placements offered were different programs rather than similar ones. The Hearing Officer also notes that the District’s contention that Union requires a written offer of a program rather than a placement is contrary to the wording of Union, which specifically references a written offer of “placement.” Additionally, the District’s interpretation would be contrary to the definition of “placement” in California, where placement is defined by that “unique combination of facilities, personnel, location or equipment.” For all of these reasons, the Hearing Officer does not find the District’s argument that it made an adequate Union offer persuasive.

Moreover, the danger in offering multiple placements is that the District is required to prove at the administrative hearing the appropriateness of each of its offers should the appropriateness of the District’s offers be challenged. In Union, both the hearing officer and the courts were unable to determine the appropriateness of the programs offered by the district because the district failed to set forth sufficient evidence concerning those programs. When faced with the same situation, the Ninth Circuit Court in Glendale Unified School District v. Talar Almasi et al. stated that the law simply does not impose upon parents the duty to ferret out from multiple inappropriate placements the one placement that may be appropriate for the their child. Glendale Unified School District v. Talar Almasi et al., 1022 F. Supp. 2d. 1093, 1107 (9th Cir. 2000). Here, the District made the same error. The District presented little or no specific evidence regarding the placements in Ms. Russ’s class and Ms. Davis’s class. The bulk of the District’s evidence was focused on establishing the appropriateness of Ms. Donahue’s class. As discussed above, Ms. Dean testified generally that each of the SDC classrooms offered had children with similar types of disabilities, staff with similar training, and similar class schedules, but she did not elaborate as to what those similarities were. Without specifics regarding those programs, the Hearing Officer can not determine that they were substantively appropriate for STUDENT and, therefore, that the District’s entire offer was appropriate. In fact, Dr. Martin’s testimony that Ms. Donahue’s class was preferred over Ms. Davis’s class because the children in Ms. Davis’s class were more language impaired, suggests that Ms. Davis’s class may not be appropriate for STUDENT because it did not offer appropriate role models. Because the burden of persuasion is on the District to establish that its offer complied with the IDEA, it was required at hearing to establish the appropriateness of its entire offer. By failing to provide evidence on the appropriateness of the placements in the classrooms of Ms. Russ and Ms. Davis, the District failed to meet its burden of proof.

In conclusion, the District failed to make a written offer of placement as required by Union. Additionally, the District failed to meet its burden of proof that the range of placement options it offered was substantively appropriate under the IDEA and Rowley. For these reasons, the District’s March 22 and June 1 IEPs were defective, resulting in a denial of a FAPE to STUDENT for the 2000-2001 school and extended school year and for the 2001-2002 school year.

2. Frequency and Duration of Related Services

California Education Code Section 56345(3) states that IEPs must include a statement of the special educational instruction and related services and supplementary aids and services to be provided to the pupil. Additionally, subsection (6) states that the IEP must also indicate the projected date for the beginning of the services and the anticipated location, frequency, and duration of those services. Petitioner claims that his March 22 IEP does not indicate the duration of the speech consultation services, and the June 1 IEP does not indicate the duration of the occupational therapy consultation services. The evidence supports Petitioner’s allegations.

The face of the March 22 IEP designates that STUDENT will receive speech and language consultation services one time per week. However, the IEP is silent as to the duration of such consultative services. There is no indication that any other document exists to clarify the duration of such services. Additionally, no witness testified as to whether any specific duration of the services was offered or clarified for the PARENTS. Ms. Nunz testified only that she did not recommend direct speech and language services because most of STUDENT’s needs could be addressed in an SDC setting. According to Ms. Nunz, the consultation services would consist of the speech and language therapist consulting with the classroom teacher regarding STUDENT’s communication needs. However, without any indication of the duration of her consultation services, the District theoretically could have provided only one minute per week of consultation services per week for STUDENT. Because the law requires that the duration of the services be indicated on the IEP and the District failed to indicate such, the Hearing Officer finds that the March 22 IEP was defective in this regard.(Footnote 6)

The same error can also be found in the June 1 IEP relating to the occupational therapy consultation services in the classroom. Although the recommended consultation services to be provided with STUDENT’s parents sets forth a duration for those services, there is no indication from the record of what duration of services to the classroom was recommended. Again, there is no indication from the record that the duration of these services was ever clarified in another writing or by any member of the IEP team.

In summary, the District committed violations when it failed to designate the duration of speech and language therapy services in the March 22 IEP and when it failed to designate the duration of classroom OT consultation services in the June 1 IEP. Without this information, the PARENTS had insufficient information as to the amount and level of services that were actually offered to STUDENT.

3. Inclusion of Goals and Objectives in the IEP

State law provides that, prior to the placement of a student with exceptional needs, an LEA must ensure that the student’s regular education teachers, among others, are knowledgeable of the contents of his or her IEP. Cal. Educ. Code § 56347. California Education Code Section 56345(a)(2) and Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations Section 300.346(a)(2) require that IEPs include annual goals and objectives. Annual goals are “statements that describe what a child with a disability can reasonably be expected to accomplish within a twelve month period in the child’s special education program. Short-term instructional objectives (i.e., IEP objectives) are measurable, intermediate steps between the child’s present levels of educational performance and the annual goals that are established for the child. 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, App. C, Q. 39 (1996). The objectives should be developed based on a logical breakdown of the major components of the annual goals and should be projected to be accomplished over an extended period of time, such as a school quarter or semester. Id. IEP objectives are necessary in order to provide general benchmarks for measuring the student’s progress toward meeting the annual goals and otherwise gauging the efficacy of the services provided. Id.; see also Cleveland Heights-University Heights City Sch. Dist. v. Boss, 44 F.3d 391, 399 (6th Cir. 1998) (holding that omission of appropriate objective criteria in IEP was significant violation that “went to the heart of the substance of the plan”).

At no time has the District provided Petitioner with a complete set of written goals and objectives for inclusion in his IEP as part of its offer of placement and services. At the March 14, 2001 IEP meeting, the District and the PARENTS exchanged copies of draft goals and objectives developed by the District and CARD, and discussed the appropriateness of the goals and objectives. At the end of the meeting, the team agreed both sets of goals and objectives would be integrated and presented at the March 22 IEP meeting. Thus, by the end of the March 14 IEP meeting, no final written goals and objectives were offered to the parents.

At the March 22 meeting, the goals and objectives were discussed and amended further and the team was able to orally agree on the goals and objectives. Additionally, the team agreed that Ms. Nunz would draft the agreed-upon goals and objectives on one District form for final review and consent by the PARENTS. On April 3, 2001, Mary Dean faxed to the PARENTS’ attorney twenty-two pages of the redrafted goals and objectives. According to the testimony of MOTHER, only the first sixteen of the twenty-two pages were received by fax. On that same day, MOTHER’s father picked up a copy of the goals and objectives from the District. He then provided the goals and objectives to speech pathologist Joanne Hein. The copy Ms. Hein possessed contained four of the six pages that MOTHER claimed were not provided to her.

Assuming, arguendo, that MOTHER can be attributed to have had the complete April 3 set of goals and objectives, that set still did not include all of the goals and objectives discussed and agreed-upon by the IEP team. Upon reviewing the goals and objectives further, the PARENTS determined that a number of CARD’s goals and objectives that were orally agreed upon by the IEP team were also omitted from the set of goals and objectives that they were provided. At hearing, she testified that the goals and objectives did not include, among others, CARD goals numbered 16, 18 and 19 contained in the Student’s Exhibit 31. (See also Test. of Mary Dean.) At the June 1 IEP meeting, the PARENTS notified the District of the omission. The District agreed that it would review the goals and objectives to determine if any of the orally agreed-upon goals and objectives were inadvertently left out of the set provided to the PARENTS on April 3. On July 9, 2001, the District purportedly sent to the PARENTS a revised set of goals and objectives that totaled twenty-six pages. Acccording to Ms. Dean, the additional four pages of goals and objectives added by the District were District goals and objectives originally discussed with the PARENTS at the March 14 IEP meeting. Thus, the District’s addition of four more pages of goals and objectives still did not include the missing CARD goals and objectives the PARENTS were concerned about. Furthermore, with regard to the July 9 set of goals and objectives, MOTHER testified that only the District’s cover letter was received and not the “enclosed” goals and objectives.

The Hearing Officer finds it particularly revealing that the District was not able to produce at the hearing the complete set of goals and objectives from April 3 or July 9.(Footnote 8) Although the District asserted that its Exhibit Number 5 contains the twenty-two pages of goals and objectives from April 3, pages 17 through 19 were actually duplicates of other goals and objectives contained earlier in the same exhibit. Additionally, although the District asserted that the PARENTS received the full April 3 set of goals and objectives, which they later gave to Ms. Hein, Ms. Hein’s set was also incomplete. Additionally, the District’s version of the April 3 set of goals and objectives are different from the set provided to Ms. Hein, which appears to contain goals and objectives that neither the PARENTS nor the District possessed. Thus, the District’s Exhibit 5 is clearly not the same set of goals and objectives that were provided to MOTHER’s father on April 3. In comparing all of the goals and objectives produced at hearing, approximately two of the twenty-six pages of goals and objectives are not accounted for, as well as some goals and objectives recommended by CARD.(Footnote 9) In light of the District’s inability to produce the very goals and objectives it claimed were sent to the PARENTS, and in light of MOTHER’s persuasive and credible testimony that she did not receive them, the Hearing Officer finds that the District never provided the PARENTS with the goals and objectives. Because a complete set of goals and objectives were never produced for inclusion in STUDENT’s IEP, the District violated the requirement that the IEP contain the student’s present levels of performance and measurable annual goals and short-term objectives.

The fact that the parties orally agreed upon the goals and objectives at the March 22 IEP meeting does not change this Hearing Officer’s conclusion that the District’s failure to produce those goals and objectives in writing is an error that seriously infringed on the PARENTS’ right to participate in the IEP process. The IEP is the foundation and the road map of the special education student’s education. It defines the direction the student’s program must take and the services that are necessary to meet the student’s needs. Without the complete set of goals and objectives, the PARENTS were not provided a clear offer of services that they could consider. Given the large number and complexity of STUDENT’s goals and objectives, a written set of goals and objectives is necessary to confirm the agreements made orally at the IEP meetings.

More importantly, the Hearing Officer also finds that the failure to produce the complete set of written goals and objectives resulted in a denial of educational opportunity for STUDENT. Without a complete set of goals and objectives, there was insufficient information to guide STUDENT’s teachers and service providers in the implementation of his educational program. In fact, there was no complete educational program to implement. Even if the PARENTS had agreed to place STUDENT in the District’s SDC class and to receive the offered related services, there would have been no method for evaluating whether the program he would have been provided would have addressed his needs or for evaluating whether he would have made progress. Given that none of the SDC teachers was present at the IEP meeting, and that some of STUDENT’s prospective service providers from the District may not have been members of the IEP team, the reliance on any oral agreement to the goals and objectives at the IEP meeting is misplaced. The very people who require the copy of the goals and objectives to perform their job would not have been privy to that information. Because the complete set of goals and objectives were not even produced at the hearing, months after the IEP meetings, it logically follows that those goals and objectives would also not have been available to these persons. It was not until the evidence was collected at the hearing from the parties (who obtained some of the information through subpoenas from STUDENT’s outside providers) and a comparison was made of all of the exhibits that the Hearing Officer was able to compile most of the District’s goals and objectives. It is unlikely that STUDENT’s teachers and service providers would also have been able to acquire STUDENT’s goals and objectives. From the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that Respondent’s failure to provide Petitioner with a complete set of goals and objectives also resulted in a denial of educational opportunity for STUDENT. Because this failure seriously infringed on the PARENTS’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process and resulted in a denial of educational opportunity to STUDENT, this failure resulted in a substantive denial of FAPE.

In W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals concluded that an incomplete and an insufficient IEP resulted in the denial of a FAPE and that it was unnecessary to address the issue of whether the student’s placement satisfied the requirements of a FAPE set forth in Rowley. The same is true in this case. Because it has been concluded that the District’s March 22 and June 1 IEPs offers failed under Union and did not offer STUDENT a FAPE, it is unnecessary to address Petitioner’s other allegations of procedural and substantive violations.(Footnote 10)

III. Does STUDENT require continued placement in the CARD program with direct speech and language and occupational therapy services to receive a FAPE?

Because it was found above that the District’s March 22 and June 1 IEPs were not offers of FAPE, the Hearing Officer turns next to whether STUDENT requires continued placement in his CARD program and the provision of direct speech and language and occupational therapy to receive a FAPE.

It is noted first that the District’s offered program and services contained in the March 22 and June 1 IEPs expire on March 22, 2002, less than three weeks from the date of this decision. Additionally, because it was found above that the District failed to comply with Union or to make a substantive offer of FAPE, the Hearing Officer does not have an effective program from the District for which to consider regarding STUDENT’s prospective program. Because there is currently no offer of services past the March 22, 2002, and the issues in this matter relate to the entire 2001-2002 school year and extended school year, the Hearing Officer finds it appropriate to focus on whether STUDENT’s private placement at CARD should be continued through the end of his term and whether he requires direct speech and language and occupational therapy services.

As discussed above, both State law and the IDEA entitle students with disabilities the right to a free appropriate public education in the form of related services and specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. ' 1400 et seq.; Education Code ' 56000 et seq. Additionally, the Supreme Court in Rowley, determined that the student=s educational program must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982).

To determine what educational services STUDENT requires, it is first necessary to determine STUDENT’s unique and individual needs. The parties do not dispute that STUDENT is mildly autistic. Additionally, the parties do not generally dispute what STUDENT’s educational needs are. Because of his autism, STUDENT has needs related to language, pre-academic, social, adaptive, fine motor, and sensory processing functioning. With regard to language development, STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language skills are in the below average to severely impaired range. Specifically, STUDENT has difficulty with pragmatics and functional language. Although his articulation for one-and two-word utterances appears to be in the average range, STUDENT has weak anterior tongue strength and tongue mobility difficulties that affect his ability to articulate longer phrases and sentences.

With regard to pre-academic skills, STUDENT has average cognitive abilities and can sit at a table and work with an adult for approximately an hour with little redirection. However, STUDENT has difficulties with “executive functioning,” which is manifested in difficulties attending to information in his environment, distinguishing what information from his environment to attend to, and processing that information in a meaningful manner. Thus, STUDENT requires individual or small-group instruction to assist him with processing information in his environment.

Socially, STUDENT demonstrates limited eye contact and has difficulty with social initiation and play skills. According to Susanne Johnson, STUDENT does not initiate play with peers, primarily engages in solitary play, and isolates himself from others. Additionally, she testified that STUDENT becomes frustrated and aggressive when he is unable to expressively communicate with other children and that he sometimes hugs others with too much force. Moreover, STUDENT has difficulty engaging in imaginary play.

In the area of adaptive functioning, STUDENT has difficulty with dressing and with using eating utensils. Additionally, STUDENT still requires training to toilet himself independently.

In the area of fine motor functioning, STUDENT has difficulty cutting with scissors in a straight line, stringing beads, and lacing a string through a hole. According to Ms. Mulligan, STUDENT’s difficulties in these areas may be caused by poor bilateral coordination skills. Additionally, STUDENT cannot operate buttons or imitate a horizontal line. Although Ms. Mulligan found that STUDENT primarily used a digital grasp on writing utensils, with a static tripod grasp emerging, Mr. Furbush found that STUDENT demonstrated inconsistent grasp patterns.

Finally, STUDENT also has sensory processing needs. According to Ms. Mulligan, STUDENT has mild problems with tactile sensitivity and motor planning. Ms. Mulligan also indicated that the information from the Sensory Profile indicated that STUDENT engaged in sensory seeking behavior. Accordingly, Ms. Mulligan recommended that STUDENT be provided with a sensory diet to help him to organize his senses. Mr. Furbush also found that STUDENT exhibited tactile sensitivity and motor planning difficulties. Additionally, Mr. Furbush found that STUDENT had difficulty modulating sensory input and responding to it, and that became distractible when there were multiple types of sensory input from his environment.

In summary, STUDENT is a high functioning autistic student who has language, preacademic, social, adaptive, fine motor and sensory processing deficits. STUDENT appears most delayed in the area of expressive and receptive language. Because of his problems with executive functioning and multisensory processing, STUDENT requires close and individualized attention to assist him with making sense of his environment. Additionally, STUDENT requires a sensory diet throughout his day to enable him to organize his senses and modulate his behavior.

Petitioner requests, among other things, CARD services in the form of 40 hours per week of therapy in the home, with the accompanying supervision services and clinic meetings. According to Ms. Johnson, STUDENT’s CARD therapists work with him on “drills” in the areas of receptive and expressive language, self-help skills, socialization, and play skills. Additionally, one of STUDENT’s therapists accompanies him to his private preschool to assist STUDENT in generalizing the skills he learned in his home program. At the preschool, STUDENT’s therapist also facilitates STUDENT’s social interaction with his peers.

The evidence established that the CARD program is designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. Although the District disputes that STUDENT requires such an intensive program, it did not dispute that the CARD program is designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and no significant evidence was offered to establish that the CARD services would be inappropriate to address STUDENT’s needs. On the contrary, a review of the program and STUDENT’s instructional program indicates that each of his areas of need are addressed, particularly his expressive and receptive language. Additionally, by the very nature of the CARD program, STUDENT would receive the individualized attention that he requires. Dr. Perlman testified that the CARD program has been successful for STUDENT and that its individualized instruction addresses STUDENT’s problems with executive functioning. Furthermore, the CARD services, when combined with STUDENT’s private preschool program, addresses STUDENT’s socialization difficulties and problems attending to and processing information in his environment.

There is also evidence from the record that STUDENT has benefitted educationally from the CARD program. According to Ms. Johnson, STUDENT has exhibited significant progress since he started his services in January 2001. Ms. Johnson testified that STUDENT was able to learn so quickly that she had to modify his program to reflect his progress. Additionally, Ms. Johnson testified that by December 2001, STUDENT had met or made substantial progressed towards most of the nineteen annual goals and objectives that CARD developed for STUDENT in March of 2001. (Student Exh. 72.) According to witnesses from both parties, most if not all of these goals and objectives were discussed and accepted by STUDENT’s IEP team. Given STUDENT’s progress in his CARD program, the Hearing Officer concludes that he will likely derive educational benefit from continued placement there.

The Hearing Officer turns next to what related services STUDENT requires in his program. In his closing brief, Petitioner requests that he be allowed to continue with his “clinic based speech therapy at South County Pediatric Speech at the rate of 60 minutes of individual speech therapy and 60 minutes of small group (2 children) speech therapy per week.” Additionally, Petitioner requests 60 minutes per week of clinic-based OT therapy from Orange County Therapy Services. The Hearing Officer grants Petitioner’s request only with regard to the frequency and duration of speech and language and occupational therapy services that are to be provided.

As was discussed above, STUDENT has below average to severely impaired receptive and expressive language. Ms. Nunz from the District recommended that STUDENT receive only speech and language consultation services. Her recommendations were based on her report from January 1, 2001. In July 2001, assessors from South County Pediatric Speech recommended in an evaluation report that STUDENT receive one hour per week of individual speech and language services to work on expressive language and oral-motor difficulties. The South County Pediatric Speech assessor also recommended further testing to determine goals to address his receptive language difficulties. Additionally, Ms. Hein, who assessed STUDENT in April 2001, recommended that STUDENT receive three hours per week of direct speech and language services to address all of his language and oral-motor needs.

The Hearing Officer finds persuasive the reports and recommendations of Ms. Hein and the South County Pediatric Speech assessor over the recommendations of the District. First, both Ms. Hein’s report and the South County report are more recent and likely better reflect STUDENT’s current needs. Additionally, the assessors from South County Pediatric Speech had a more thorough knowledge of STUDENT’s language needs because he had been receiving services there for some time prior to his assessment. Additionally, Ms. Hein’s assessment, which took about four hours to complete, was provided more detail and specifics regarding STUDENT’s language needs.

From the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires two hours per week of direct speech and language therapy to meet his needs. Although Ms. Hein recommended three hours of speech and language therapy, her recommendation was made prior to STUDENT’s making great strides in his home CARD program in the area of language and prior to STUDENT receiving direct speech and language therapy from South County Pediatric Speech. South County Pediatric Speech recommended only one hour of direct therapy. However, the recommended services were to address only STUDENT’s expressive language and oral-motor deficits. The assessors expressly reserved making a recommendation for receptive language until further assessments could be done. Because both the District and Ms. Hein found STUDENT’s receptive language to be moderately to severely delayed, the evidence established that STUDENT would need additional services over the one hour recommended by South County to address those needs. In comparing the two recommendations, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires two hours per week of individual therapy to address all of his language and oral-motor needs.

Lastly, with regard to STUDENT’s occupational therapy services, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires one hour per week of direct OT services to meet his needs. Although the District recommended only OT consultation services to the home and classroom for STUDENT, the Hearing Officer finds that these services would not be appropriate. Under the District’s approach, remediation for STUDENT’s fine motor and sensory processing deficits would be left up to the classroom teacher and parents, none of whom is a specialist in occupational therapy. Additionally, under the District plan, the OT consultation would not be to assist with any set goal of improving his needs in those areas, but would be to address whatever concerns the teacher or parent had during any given week. Thus, the District’s recommendation for consultation services appear to be sufficient only to address concerns that may arise rather than to address STUDENT’s existing deficits. According to the persuasive testimony of Mr. Furbush, consultation services alone would not be appropriate because there would be no method in place for an occupational therapist to monitor STUDENT’s needs. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires direct occupational therapy services rather than consultation services.

With regard to the frequency and duration of services required, the Hearing Officer finds that one hour per week of services is appropriate to meet STUDENT’s needs. With regard to the amount of services, the Hearing Officer finds persuasive the recommendations of the Orange County Therapy Services, the providers of STUDENT’s OT services since July 2001. Because Orange County Therapy Services has knowledge of STUDENT’s progress in the therapy, the Hearing Officer gives the recommendations of its assessors great weight. Although Mr. Furbush recommended two to three hours of direct services, STUDENT’s occupational therapy needs can be met with only one hour per week.

In conclusion, STUDENT’s needs can be met in his existing CARD program with the accompanying supervision services. Additionally, STUDENT requires individual speech and language therapy for two hours per week, and direct occupational therapy for one hour per week. Although Petitioner requests that his speech and language services continue to be provided through South County Pediatric Speech and his occupational therapy continue to be provided through Orange County Therapy Services, there was no evidence from the record that such agencies are certified by the state as nonpublic agencies. Thus, the District may provide these services through its own vendors.

IV. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of privately procured educational services and independent educational evaluations?

Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under IDEA and are reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir 1994).

Petitioner alleges that he has been denied a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school and extended school years and the 2001-2002 school year and, therefore should be reimbursed for the cost of educational services privately procured to provide him with an appropriate educational program. Additionally, Petitioner alleges that the District failed to assess him appropriately. Accordingly, Petitioner requests reimbursement for his independent educational evaluations.

A. the cost of educational expenses

Petitioner requests reimbursement for privately procured educational services from CARD and various providers of speech and language and occupational therapy services.(Footnote 11) It was found above that the District’s offers of placement contained in the March 22 IEP and June 1 IEP were not offers of FAPE. Additionally, it was found above that STUDENT’s CARD services are designed to meet his needs and provided him with educational benefit. Moreover, it was found above that STUDENT requires direct speech and language services and OT services to address his language and occupational therapy needs. The evidence also established that STUDENT benefitted from his privately procured speech and language and OT services. Because the PARENTS provided STUDENT with these services when the District denied them a FAPE, they are entitled to reimbursement for these services.

However, the reimbursement Petitioner is entitled to is limited to the expenses arising after February 12, 2001, the date of the first scheduled IEP meeting for STUDENT. It is undisputed that STUDENT’s IEP meeting was scheduled past his first birthday at the request of the PARENTS. Thus, the District was not required to provide him with educational services until it convened the IEP meeting to make the offer of placement. However, the February 12 IEP meeting was cancelled unilaterally by the District when it learned that the PARENTS’ attorney would be present. As there is no indication from the record that the PARENTS consented to the delayed IEP meeting or the extension of the timeline for conducting that IEP meeting, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was responsible for STUDENT’s education as February 12, 2001, when the meeting should have occurred.

B. the cost of independent educational evaluations

Petitioner also requests reimbursement for independent educational evaluations conducted by Joanne Hein, Dr. Mitchel Perlman, and Richard Furbush. Pursuant to special education law, a parent has the right to obtain an independent educational assessment of the student if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by a district. If a request for such an independent assessment is made, a district must either agree to pay for it, or it must file for a due process hearing requesting a determination that its assessment was appropriate. However, if the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent evaluation. In such a situation, the parent still has the right to an independent educational assessment, but not at public expense. If the parent obtains an independent educational assessment at private expense, the results of the assessment shall be considered by the public education agency with respect to the provision of free, appropriate public education to the child, and may be presented as evidence at a due process hearing pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 56500) regarding the child. Ed. Code Section 56329(b); 34 CFR Section 300.502(b).

As discussed above, the Petitioner made specific contentions regarding why the District’s assessments were inappropriate. In determining the appropriateness of the District’s assessment, the Hearing Officer focused on Petitioner’s specific allegations. It was determined above that the District inappropriately assessed STUDENT in January 2001 because it failed to assess him in all areas of suspected disability. Specifically, the District failed to assess STUDENT’s oral motor sensitivity, fine motor difficulties, and sensory integration deficits. Because the District’s assessment was inappropriate, Petitioner may be entitled to reimbursement for his independent educational evaluations. Because Ms. Hein conducted an oral-motor assessment of Petitioner when the District failed to do so, the Hearing Officer grants Petitioner’s request for reimbursement for Ms. Hein’s speech and language assessment.

However, the Hearing Officer denies Petitioner’s request for reimbursement for the assessments of Mr. Furbush and Dr. Perlman. Prior to Mr. Furbush’s assessment, the District conducted an occupational therapy assessment, at which point STUDENT’s fine motor and sensory integration needs were assessed. Because the District corrected its failure prior to Petitioner’s obtaining his independent educational evaluation, there was no longer a need for the IEE. As there was no significant challenge to or disagreement with the District’s OT assessment, the Hearing Officer finds no basis to award reimbursement for Mr. Furbush’s OT assessment and report.

With regard to Dr. Perlman’s report, the Petitioner has not alleged any nexus between the District’s failure to appropriately assess him and the need for an independent psychological assessment. While Petitioner claims that Dr. Perlman discovered many areas of need that were not found by the District, the law does not require that the District’s assessment uncover all conceivable educational needs. Rather, the law only requires that the District assess him in “all areas of suspected disability.” Additionally, the evidence presented by the District indicates that the psychological portions of its assessment were appropriate in all of the areas challenged by Petitioner. For the foregoing reasons, the request for reimbursement for Dr. Perlman’s assessment is also denied.

ORDER

1. Within thirty calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse the PARENTS for the independent educational evaluation conducted by Joanne Hein, and the cost of all educational services privately procured for STUDENT between February 12, 2001, and the date of this decision.

2. From the date of this decision through the end of the District’s 2002 extended school year, the District shall fund Petitioner’s continued placement in the CARD program for forty hours per week, along with the supervision and clinic meetings services. Additionally, the District shall provide STUDENT with one hour per week each of individual speech and language therapy, speech and language therapy in a small group, and individual occupational therapy services.

3. All of Petitioner’s other claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

I. Did the District assess STUDENT appropriately and in all areas of suspected disability? -The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

II. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2000-2001 school and extended school year and the 2001-2002 school and extended school year? -The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

III. Does STUDENT require continued placement in the CARD program with direct speech and language and occupational therapy services to receive a FAPE? -The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

IV. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of private procured educational services and independent educational evaluations? -The Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the extent that reimbursement was ordered for educational expenses and one out of the three educational evaluations.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: March 5, 2002 ____________________________________ Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnote 1: The issues presented here are only the issues of the Student. On November 27, 2001, the District withdrew its sole issue raised in its cross-filed case (i.e., case number SN 01-01694) pertaining to its right to assess STUDENT. For purposes of clarification and organization, the Hearing Officer has reorganized the Student’s statement of issues Footnote 2: Ms. Johnson testified that she did communicate with Ms. Nunz between the two IEP meetings regarding STUDENT’s IEP goals and objectives, but that she was never provided a copy of the revisions to the goals and objectives developed as a result of those communications. Footnote 3: Ms. Hein’s copy of the goals and objectives, contained in the District’s Exhibit 29, totals twelve pages. Ms. Hein’s copy includes only the odd-numbered pages between page 1 and page 15 of the District’s and the Student’s versions and four additional pages that are not contained in either version. Footnote 4: According to Ms. Sherry, the testing instructions suggest what item to start assessing the child with in the testing booklet (i.e. testing protocol). A “basal” score is established on the mental scale portion of the Bayley when the child correctly responds to five consecutive items in an “item set.” When the child responds incorrectly to three consecutive items, a “ceiling” is reached. To obtain the raw score on the test, one takes the score from the last item set where the child got all items correct, then adds a score for each item correct after that. The raw score is then used to obtain the standard score for the test. Footnote 5: The Petitioner did not dispute that the District made a written offer of the IBI program. Footnote 6: It should be noted that the District changed its offer of speech and language services in the June 1 IEP, wherein it indicated that speech and language services would be provided twice per week in thirty-minute sessions. Thus, the above procedural violation was corrected by the June 1 IEP meeting. However, as is discussed above, the District committed the same procedural violation at the June 1 IEP meeting with regard to its recommendation for OT consultation services to the classroom. Thus, neither IEP is without defect. Footnote 7: At hearing, Ms. Mulligan testified that she provides OT consultation services for all students at La Tierra and that Ms. Donahue brings her class to her clinic for two ½ hour sessions per week. Although Ms. Mulligan provided some insight into her services, her testimony was not specific to the needs of STUDENT and it did not describe what services would have been provided to STUDENT had he been placed at Robinson Ranch at one of the other classrooms apparently offered to him. Moreover, the Hearing Officer notes that Ms. Mulligan confirmed that STUDENT was not offered any goals and objectives related to the offer of OT consultation services. According to Ms. Mulligan, the consultation would involve discussion about any concerns raised by the classroom teacher or the PARENTS, and would not necessarily have been driven by STUDENT’s goals and objectives. Footnote 8: Because the District never provided the entire set of goals and objectives (i.e., at least 26 pages) at hearing, the District is essentially asking the Hearing Officer to determine the appropriateness of its offer without the essential information as to what that offer consists of. Because the burden of proof is on the District to establish that “it complied with the IDEA,@ the District has failed to meet its burden by failing to provide those goals and objectives as evidence of its offer. Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist., No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994). Footnote 9: Both parties had pages 1 through 16 of the goals and objectives. As noted above, the District’s Exhibit 29, which were the set obtained from Ms. Hein, contained four additional pages of goals and objectives not contained in either the Petitioner’s or the District’s set of goals and objectives. The District’s Exhibit 5, date stamped pages 35 through 37, were the same as the additional four pages of goals and objectives added to the July 9 set of goals and objectives. Thus, at least two of the 26 pages of goals and objectives are not accounted for, which may or may not contain the missing goals and objectives from CARD as described above. Footnote 10: The District also argued that its draft goals and objectives presented at the March 14 IEP were sufficient to address STUDENT’s needs. However, as was found above, the District did not assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability in January 2001, prior to the development of those goals and objectives. Additionally, as found below, STUDENT has needs in areas that were not appropriately assessed by the school district at that time. Footnote 11: At hearing, Petitioner expressly limited his request for reimbursement to the actual cost of the services that were not paid for by insurance or other entities. The accounting and receipts for most of the reimbursement requested is contained in the Student’s Exhibit 63.