California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 11, 1997
Student v. Cupertino Union School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 926-97, SN 514-97 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote
Cupertino Union may conduct a triennial assessment without parent consent using a substitute psychologist; request for a District-funded independent assessment denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The parents' earlier case, SN 533-97, was withdrawn after a May 12, 1997 order that the District's case (SN 514-97) be heard first. SN 514-97 and SN 926-97 were joined by agreement.
Summary
Cupertino Union School District and the parents of a 10-year-old girl filed cases that were heard together. The student was eligible for special education because of a specific learning disability in reading. She attended a private religious school and received no District services. Her triennial reassessment was due in April 1997. The parent signed the District's assessment plan, but the family's advocate later revoked consent. The family distrusted District staff after a District assessment of the student's younger sister. They wanted an outside assessor, such as the California Diagnostic Center. The Hearing Officer denied the advocate's motions to dismiss, to order an impartial assessment, to keep the record open for a state compliance complaint, and to strike the assessment plan.
On the District's issue, the Hearing Officer found that a reassessment was warranted. The triennial was due, the last assessment was from 1994, and the parents were seeking services and reimbursement. The proposed tests were valid and nondiscriminatory and covered all areas of suspected disability. Qualified staff would give them. The Hearing Officer found no evidence of bias. However, investigations were pending and the family distrusted school psychologist Patricia Rose. As a precaution, the District had to use a different school psychologist with the same credentials. With that change, the District could assess without parent consent. The Hearing Officer denied the request for an independent assessment at District expense because the District's appropriate assessment had not yet been done.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled a district's request to reassess a parentally placed private school student over the parents' objection. General claims of bias did not disqualify district assessors. A parent's right to a publicly funded independent assessment arose only after the district completed its own assessment.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedDistrict-filed: assess without consent
Issue District's Issue. Is the District entitled to conduct a triennial assessment of STUDENT over the objection of her parents?
A triennial assessment was warranted, and the District's plan and qualified assessors met Education Code requirements, so the District could assess without parental consent. The Hearing Officer found no evidence of bias but ordered a different school psychologist to replace Ms. Rose as a precaution.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue Student's Issue. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to an independent assessment from qualified specialists at District expense?
The District proposed an appropriate assessment that has not yet been done, so the parent is not now entitled to an independent assessment at District expense under Education Code section 56329(b).
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order that district may assess without consent. The District is entitled to conduct STUDENT's triennial assessment as set forth in its proposed assessment plan signed by the parent on April 12, 1997 (District's Exhibit 3), using its proposed personnel.
- In place of school psychologist Ms. Rose, the District must appoint a similarly credentialed school psychologist with suitable experience assessing elementary-age children to do the cognitive, social, emotional, and perceptual portions of the assessment.
Key authorities
Education Code § 56381; Education Code § 56320; Education Code § 56322; Education Code § 56324; Education Code § 56329(b); Education Code §§ 56506(e) and 56321(c); Education Code § 56501.5; 5 CCR § 3001(x); IDEA Amendments of 1997 § 614
People named in the decision
- James P. Paul, Ph.D., District director of pupil services, Cupertino Union School District
- Susan Douglas, coordinator of pupil services, Cupertino Union School District
- Patricia Janet Rose, school psychologist (proposed assessor; ordered replaced), Cupertino Union School District
- Catherine Kalisvaart, RSP teacher (proposed academic assessor), Cupertino Union School District
- Cynthia Phillips, speech and language pathologist (proposed assessor), Cupertino Union School District
- Louise Faulkner, occupational therapist, private practice / certified nonpublic agency (proposed assessor), Private practice
- Terry Tellep, registered nurse (proposed health assessor), Cupertino Union School District
- Speech-Hearing-Learning Center (Gilroy), private assessment provider, Private
- Los Altos Christian School, private school currently attended, Private
- St. Joseph's, private religious school previously attended, Private
- Lincoln Elementary School, District school previously attended, Cupertino Union School District
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Santa Clara, California, on July 8, 9, and 28, 1997. STUDENT was represented at the hearing by advocate R.A. Drew. Also present on behalf of STUDENT was her mother. Cupertino Union School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Laurie E. Reynolds. Also present on behalf of the District was James P. Paul, Ph.D., District director of pupil services.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments on August 13, 1997, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
District’s Issue: Is the District entitled to conduct a triennial assessment of STUDENT over the objection of her parents?
STUDENT’s Issue: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to an independent assessment from qualified specialists at District expense?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
At the beginning of the hearing, Ms. Drew made a motion to dismiss the District’s case. She asserted that PARENT had consented to an assessment and, therefore, the District’s issue for hearing was moot. The District opposed the motion based on the ongoing dispute regarding who would conduct the assessment. The District asserted that PARENT’s consent to an assessment was conditioned on the assessment being conducted by someone other than District employees. The District asserted that it has a right to determine who will conduct the assessment and that its employees are qualified and competent to assess STUDENT. Based on the lack of agreement regarding the District’s right to conduct a triennial assessment of STUDENT, the Hearing Officer denied the motion to dismiss.
During the course of the hearing, Ms. Drew made a motion for a continuance to allow for an impartial assessment under Education Code § 56501.5, which provides that “the hearing officer may do any of the following during the hearing: . . .(e) Order that an impartial assessment of the pupil be conducted for purposes of the hearing and continue the hearing until the assessment has been completed.” At the time of Ms. Drew’s request, there was no persuasive reason to order an impartial assessment under Education Code § 56501.5. The very issues for hearing are whether the District may conduct a triennial assessment and whether STUDENT is entitled to an independent assessment at District expense. An assessment resulting from either of these alternatives should provide sufficient information to address STUDENT’s educational needs. The Hearing Officer denied the request for an impartial assessment.
Following the hearing, Ms. Drew made a motion to keep the case open to allow her to pursue a compliance complaint to “substantiate” her assertion that one of the District’s proposed assessors is “simply incapable of administering an assessment that complies with Education Code 56320(b)(3).” Ms. Drew attached a copy of a complaint dated August 10, 1997, and is addressed to the Quality Assurance Unit, California Department of Education. The District contended that both parties had ample time to present witnesses at the hearing and that there was no legally sufficient reason to keep the record open to present additional evidence generated as the result of a compliance complaint filed after the hearing.
The parties presented witnesses and evidence on three days of hearing. The case was held open to allow the parties to submit written closing arguments on August 11, 1997. Ms. Drew did not provide any legal or factual basis for holding the record open while she pursues a compliance complaint. She also did not substantiate that any evidence relevant to the issues for hearing has been discovered following the hearing that was not available at the time of the hearing. In fact, her compliance complaint is based on the testimony at the hearing. Moreover, the results of a compliance complaint are not necessarily binding on due process hearing proceedings because compliance complaints are resolved through an investigatory process rather than through adjudication. To wait for results of a compliance complaint would also unduly delay rendering a decision in this matter. The Hearing Officer denied the request for a continuance and so informed the parties by telephone on August 27, 1997.
Following the hearing, Ms. Drew also made a motion to strike from the record the District’s proposed assessment plan (District’s Exhibit 3) and “any testimony, documents, argument and other evidence specifically dependant on and/or referring to the Assessment Plan . . . .” She asserted that the assessment plan is “confidential material of the Mediation.” The District contended that there has not been any mediation in this case and that the assessment plan was not executed as part of any mediation. The District asserted that the plan was mailed to the parents, who then returned it to the District.
There was no testimony at the hearing to substantiate Ms. Drew’s claim that the District’s proposed assessment plan contained in the District’s Exhibit 3 was a part of mediation. In fact, the parties did not mediate in STUDENT’s case. The assessment plan is relevant to the issues for hearing. Therefore, there is no basis to exclude the assessment plan or any testimony regarding the plan, and the Hearing Officer denies the motion to exclude the plan and strike testimony pertaining to it.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a 10-year-old student who will enter the fifth grade for the 1997-1998 school year. She is eligible for special education because of a specific learning disability in reading. STUDENT attends a private sectarian school and, at the time of the hearing, was not receiving any special education services from the District.
In the fall of 1993, STUDENT’s parents enrolled her in the first grade at St. Joseph’s, a private sectarian school. STUDENT’s parents obtained an assessment of STUDENT from the Speech-Hearing-Learning Center in Gilroy, California. (District’s Exhibit 6) In November 1993, STUDENT’s parents submitted the private assessment with their request to the District for a special education assessment. Patricia Janet Rose, school psychologist, conducted the psychoeducational portion of the assessment for the District and relied on the results of the private assessment regarding STUDENT’s academic achievement. In December 1993, the IEP team determined that STUDENT met eligibility criteria for special education because of a specific learning disability in reading and that she was entitled to services from the resource specialist program (RSP). Thereafter, STUDENT’s parents enrolled her in Lincoln Elementary School in the District for the remainder of the first grade. STUDENT also attended second grade at Lincoln during the 1994-1995 school year. STUDENT has attended Los Altos Christian School since her parents enrolled her there for the third grade at the beginning of the 1995-1996 school year.
On March 4, 1997, the District sent the PARENTS a proposed assessment plan and requested parental consent to conduct a triennial assessment of STUDENT, which was due in April 1997. (Testimony of Susan Douglas, coordinator of pupil services) The parents did not respond to the request and, on March 25, 1997, Ms. Douglas sent a second letter to the PARENTS requesting that they consider the proposed assessment plan and respond as soon as possible. (District’s Exhibit 2) On April 12, 1997, PARENT signed the proposed assessment plan and returned it to the District. The assessment plan included handwritten additions to the District’s proposed assessment plan, apparently granting permission for an “occupational therapy screening . . . such other assessments as appear needed as assessments are performed” and an AB 3632 assessment. PARENT also requested consideration of a Lindamood-Bell assessment and indicated her preference that the assessment take place at Los Altos.(Footnote 1) (District’s Exhibit 3) On April 27, 1997, before the assessment could be undertaken, R.A. Drew, on behalf of the parents, revoked consent to the triennial assessment of STUDENT, referring to a “Class Action for more information on parent’s reasoning.” (District’s Exhibit 4) Ms. Drew requested to be present during the assessment or to allow the assessment to be taped. The District would not agree. (Testimony of Ms. Douglas and PARENT) In a separate letter, Ms. Drew requested a special education due process hearing on issues including STUDENT’s right to an independent assessment at District expense, reimbursement for private services and an independent assessment procured by the parents, and STUDENT’s entitlement to Lindamood-Bell remediation by trained and competent professionals. (SN 533-97; District’s Exhibit 5)
On April 29, 1997, attorney Laurie E. Reynolds requested a due process hearing on behalf of the District on the issue of whether the District is entitled to conduct a triennial assessment of STUDENT over the objection of her parents. (SN 514-97) In a written order dated May 12, 1997, the Hearing Officer determined that the District’s case (SN 514-97) on the assessment issue should be heard and decided before SN 533-97. Thereafter, Ms. Drew withdrew SN 533-97. On June 23, 1997, Ms. Drew requested a new due process hearing on the issue of whether STUDENT is entitled to an impartial assessment from qualified specialists under Education Code § 56329(b).(Footntoe 2) (SN 926-97) By agreement of the parties, SN 514-97 and SN 926-97 were joined and heard together.
The District contends that it has the right and obligation to an assessment of STUDENT because she was last assessed by the District in April 1994, her triennial assessment was due in April 1997, and the PARENTS are now seeking from the District services for STUDENT and reimbursement for privately obtained services. The District asserts that its assessment plan is appropriate and that it has qualified and competent staff available to conduct STUDENT’s assessment.
On behalf of STUDENT, Ms. Drew concurred that an assessment is warranted to determine STUDENT’s educational needs and to ensure that those needs are properly addressed. Ms. Drew asserts that the parents’ refusal to allow the District to assess STUDENT is based on their mistrust of the District, particularly related to incidents surrounding the District’s assessment of STUDENT’s younger sister.(Footnote 3) Ms. Drew asserts that an “impartial” assessor should conduct the assessment based on the sincere fear of STUDENT’s parents that STUDENT, whom she described as a “sensitive child,” will be in a “bad” position if she is required to participate in an assessment against the wishes of her parents. Ms. Drew proposed that the California Diagnostic Center assess STUDENT.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
District’s Issue: Is the District entitled to conduct a triennial assessment of STUDENT over the objections of her parents?
California special education law provides that a reassessment of the pupil shall be conducted at least every three years or more frequently if conditions warrant or the student’s parent or teacher requests a new assessment and that an IEP be developed. Education Code § 56381. In order for the District's assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of California Education Code § 56320, which states in relevant part that testing and assessment materials and procedures must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; provided and administered in the student's primary language or other mode of communication; administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; and validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. Assessment and testing materials must also not measure the student's impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills unless that is what the test purports to measure.
Subsection 56320(e) states that “no single procedure is used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for an individual with exceptional needs.” Subsection 56320(f) requires that the student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional status. Pursuant to subsection (g), the assessment must be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the student's disability. Psychological assessments must be conducted by credentialed school psychologists, and health assessments must be conducted by a credentialed school nurse or physician. These assessors must be trained and prepared to assess cultural and ethnic factors appropriate to the pupil being assessed. Education Code § 56324(a) and (b).
Federal special education law includes similar provisions. See Individuals with Disabilities Education Act Amendments of 1997 § 614(a) and (b). Federal law also provides that the district shall “use a variety of assessment tools and strategies to gather relevant functional and developmental information, including information provided by the parent . . . [and] including information related to enabling the child to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. . . .” Section 614(b)(2)(A). (Footnote 4)
Assessments must be conducted by “competent” persons. It is the District’s responsibility to determine who is competent. Education Code § 56322. “Competent” is not further defined. Education Code § 56520 states that assessments shall be conducted by “qualified” persons. “Qualified” is defined as
. . . a person has met federal and state certification, licensing, registration, or other comparable requirements which apply to the area in which he or she is providing special education or related services, or, in the absence of such requirements, the state-education-agency-approved or recognized requirements, and adheres to the standards of professional practice established in federal and state law or regulation. . . .
Title 5 California Code of Regulations § 3001(x).
Special education law is silent as to whether a school district’s obligation to conduct triennial reevaluations applies to children with disabilities whose parents have elected to enroll them in private schools and who are not receiving special education services from a public school district. In this case, STUDENT’s parents concur that an assessment of STUDENT is warranted and, in a separate case, are seeking reimbursement and/or services from the District for her. (Testimony of PARENT; District’s Exhibit 5) STUDENT’s triennial assessment was due in April 1997 and the last psychological assessment of STUDENT took place in 1994, when she was in the second grade. Moreover, because STUDENT has not attended school in the District since the end of the 1994-1995 school year, the District’s firsthand knowledge of STUDENT’s current needs is limited. The parent has also revoked consent for Los Altos to release information regarding STUDENT to the District. The Hearing Officer concludes that additional data are needed to determine whether STUDENT continues to be a child with a disability, what her present levels of performance and educational needs are, whether she continues to need special education and related services, and what additions or modifications she requires to her educational program. Therefore, in this case, because STUDENT’s triennial is due and because additional information is needed, the Hearing Officer finds that an assessment is warranted.
Turning to whether the District has proposed an appropriate assessment plan and has designated qualified persons to conduct the assessment, the plan proposes to assess STUDENT in the areas of academic achievement, social/adaptive behavior, motor development, communication development, intellectual development, and health and developmental history. The assessment plan also indicates that the District will observe STUDENT at Los Altos. (District’s Exhibit 3)
Ms. Rose, school psychologist, testified that she would assess STUDENT’s cognitive, social, emotional, and visual-motor-perceptual skills. Ms. Rose provided the following undisputed testimony. She is a credentialed school psychologist and holds master’s degrees in counseling and school administration. She has been employed by the District since 1990 and previously was employed by the San Jose Unified School District. Ms. Rose testified that she would administer the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-III (WISC-III) to measure STUDENT’s cognitive abilities. To assess STUDENT’s social and emotional status, she would do the following: administer the Draw-A-Person or Human Person to STUDENT; have STUDENT’s teacher complete the Burkes Behavior Rating and the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales; and have STUDENT’s parent complete the Burkes and the Vineland. To assess STUDENT’s attentional problems, Ms. Rose would have the teacher and/or parent complete the Connors Rating Scale. To assess STUDENT’s perceptual abilities, Ms. Rose would administer either the Berry Visual Motor Test or the Bender Visual Motor Gestalt Test to STUDENT. Ms. Rose testified that she has administered these tests hundreds of times and that none of the tests are racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. She also testified that the tests are valid, are approved by the State and District, and are widely used by school psychologists. They are also reliable and accurately measure information about the child. Ms. Rose testified that she never deviates from instructions contained in the test manuals when administering the test.
Catherine Kalisvaart, RSP teacher, testified that she would be responsible for assessing STUDENT’s academic achievement. Ms. Kalisvaart testified that she holds a master’s degree in special education and has been an RSP teacher in the District for four years. She previously served as an RSP aide and as a teacher in a private school. Ms. Kalisvaart testified that she would administer the Woodcock-Johnson (W-J) and the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT) to measure STUDENT’s academic achievement. She would also observe STUDENT. The undisputed testimony of Ms. Kalisvaart establishes that the W-J and WIAT are standardized measures of academic achievement. They are not racially, culturally or sexually discriminatory, are validated for use with female elementary-age students, and are reliable. Ms. Kalisvaart has administered the W-J and the WIAT approximately 50 times over each of the past four years. On direct, PARENT testified that she likes Ms. Kalisvaart, who was STUDENT’s teacher when she attended Lincoln. PARENT testified that Ms. Kalisvaart appeared to care about STUDENT and wanted the best for her.(Footnote 5)
Dr. Paul’s testimony established that Cynthia Phillips, speech and language pathologist, who would assess STUDENT’s speech and language development, holds a credential and a master’s degree in speech and hearing. She has been employed by the District for approximately 11 years. Dr. Paul testified that Ms. Phillips may utilize the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test, Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals, Tests of Language Development, observations and language samples. Dr. Paul’s testimony that all of the tests are valid, reliable, and non-discriminatory, and are used throughout the state was undisputed. PARENT does not know Ms. Phillips and did not express an opinion regarding her qualifications or ability to assess STUDENT.
Louise Faulkner, an occupational therapist in private practice for approximately 18 years, testified that she holds general and special education credentials and previously was employed by Santa Clara County Office of Education. She is certified by the State as a nonpublic agency to provide OT. Ms. Faulkner testified that she has assessed hundreds of elementary-age students and has been trained to administer tests properly and in accordance with their instructions. Ms. Faulkner testified that the purpose of her assessment is to gather information to determine areas of (1) concern, (2) whether STUDENT has a cluster of problems, (3) when the problems occur, whether they interfere with her classroom functioning, and (4) whether she requires occupational therapy (OT). To gather this information, Ms. Faulkner testified that she would want to consult with PARENT, STUDENT’s medical providers, and her teacher. She would also administer the Bruiniks Oseretsky and possibly the Berry to assess STUDENT’s motor skills, sensory processing, and sensory integration skills, and she would observe STUDENT for motor and sensory functioning and handwriting skills. PARENT testified that Ms. Faulkner appears impartial and is easy to talk to. She did not raise any concerns regarding her ability or qualifications to assess STUDENT.
Terry Tellep, registered nurse, testified that she would assess STUDENT’s health and development. Ms. Tellep has been a nurse for approximately 18 years and has been employed by the District for approximately seven years. She indicated that she currently needs to complete her thesis to earn a master’s degree. Ms. Tellep testified that the purpose of the health and development assessment is to evaluate their effect on STUDENT’s educational needs. Ms. Tellep testified that she would review STUDENT’s current school records and any reports from health care professionals; obtain health and developmental histories from STUDENT’s parent; and conduct hearing and vision screenings. Ms. Tellep stated that she would obtain information regarding STUDENT’s prenatal care and birth, developmental milestones, past and present health concerns, and inquire whether STUDENT takes medications and has any allergies. Ms. Tellep testified that the parent could observe hearing and vision screenings. PARENT does not know the nurse and did not express an opinion regarding her qualifications or ability to assess STUDENT.
Ms. Douglas, Dr. Paul, and each assessor testified that they are competent, ethical, trustworthy, professional, and objective, and that they would be able to conduct a fair and impartial assessment of STUDENT because they are trained to administer tests in accordance with the instructions, to analyze the results, and to write a report following the assessment.(Footnote 6) The assessors all testified that the fact that the parents have requested a hearing would not affect the way in which they will conduct STUDENT’s assessment. The assessors, as well as Ms. Douglas, also testified that they did not agree to allow Ms. Drew to observe or tape-record the assessment because to do so is contrary to general test practices, may be distracting, intimidating, or cause the assessor and/or the child to be nervous, and may skew the assessment results. All of the assessors testified that they would make referrals for further testing if so indicated. The assessors all testified that it would be more challenging to assess a child without the support of the parent; however, they all expressed confidence that they could conduct a fair, impartial, and valid assessment that would provide reliable information to develop an appropriate educational program for STUDENT
PARENT testified that she revoked consent for the District to assess STUDENT following the District’s assessment of her other daughter because she does not believe that the District can conduct a fair and impartial assessment. PARENT testified that her concerns originate primarily from comments her other daughter made to her following two separate days of testing. PARENT testified that following the first day of testing, her daughter told her something to the effect that “she had made only two mistakes on the test but that the nice lady fixed them for her.” PARENT testified that following the second day of testing, the daughter told her that she could not talk to her about the testing until Easter. PARENT assumed that someone told her daughter not to talk to her, which she believes was inappropriate. PARENT stated that it “felt like she picked up the wrong kid” from testing. She stated that her daughter is usually very talkative but that, on the days in question, she was extremely quiet. PARENT testified her fears that something improper occurred during the testing were confirmed by the testimony of Ms. Rose. PARENT testified that her concerns increased when the District would not allow Ms. Drew to observe or tape-record STUDENT’s assessment. PARENT’s concerns are also based on the fact that (1) the District’s assessment of her other daughter took place in the afternoon, when her attentional problems are greater, rather than in the morning as she had suggested; (2) the District failed to conduct an OT assessment of her other daughter until requested by Ms. Drew and it turned out that she qualified for OT; (3) the District was unable to write recommendations that are understandable to the parents; (4) and her belief the District delayed its initial assessment of STUDENT and did not provide her with an appropriate placement.
PARENT testified that she believes the District will not find that STUDENT has a learning disability so that it will not incur financial responsibility for services nor will it have to reimburse her for privately procured services. PARENT testified that she also believes the District cannot properly assess STUDENT because the District has a great deal of animosity toward Ms. Drew, who is her advocate. Beyond what is proposed in the District’s assessment plan, PARENT did not identify any additional areas in which STUDENT should be assessed. PARENT stated that she did not have any reason to doubt that the assessors proposed by the District have the appropriate training and experience to hold their respective positions.
As to whether the District’s proposed assessors are qualified to conduct the assessment, the evidence establishes that Ms. Rose is a credentialed school psychologist, Ms. Kalisvaart is a credentialed teacher, Ms. Phillips is a credentialed speech and language pathologist, Ms. Faulkner is a licensed occupational therapist, and Ms. Tellep is a registered nurse. All the assessors have a great deal of experience in their respective fields and have assessed hundreds of children. They are trained to administer the assessment instruments they propose to administer to STUDENT. Ms. Drew did not have anyone testify to the contrary; however, she did raise a number of objections to Ms. Rose’s participation in the assessment and PARENT expressed her lack of confidence in Ms. Rose because of statements Ms. Rose allegedly made to STUDENT’s sister while assessing her.(Footnote 7) The allegations regarding Ms. Rose’s conduct during the assessment of STUDENT’s sister were unsubstantiated at the hearing; however, it has come to the attention of the Hearing Officer that police and District investigations have been initiated on this matter at the request of Ms. Drew. In an abundance of caution, given pending investigations and the level of suspicion and distrust aimed at Ms. Rose, the Hearing Officer concludes that Ms. Rose should step aside for this particular assessment. It is within the discretion of the District to determine who is competent to perform an assessment. Education Code § 56322. Dr. Paul testified that other school psychologists with appropriate credentials and experience assessing young children are available within the District. The District shall appoint another school psychologist to participate in STUDENT’s assessment in the place of Ms. Rose. The school psychologist must be similarly credentialed and suitably experienced conducting psycoeducational assessments of elementary-age children with learning disabilities.
Ms. Drew asserted that Ms. Kalisvaart is also not qualified to conduct an assessment because she has not read the entire manual for one of the tests. Ms. Kalisvaart testified that she did not read all of the data regarding statistical correlations; however, there is no evidence that Ms. Kalisvaart is required to read the statistical data or that she is in any other way unqualified to administer any of the instruments she proposed to employ with STUDENT. The Hearing Officer concludes that all of the persons designated by the District are qualified to assess STUDENT pursuant to the criteria set forth in 5 CCR § 3001(x).
Ms. Drew also asserted that District assessors generally are biased and will not conduct an impartial assessment of STUDENT because of monetary implications associated with finding that she continues to qualify for special education services or because of alleged animosity against the advocate and/or the parent. The Hearing Officer is unaware of any provisions in special education law that address potential “bias.” Additionally, Ms. Drew did not provide a standard of bias to apply in this situation. No matter what standard that is applied, the evidence does not support an objective conclusion that bias exists. The District is required by law to provide services to students with disabilities and does so. The District’s witnesses all testified that they will conduct STUDENT’s assessment in the same professional and unbiased manner in which they assess other children. There was no credible evidence to the contrary. It is unfortunate when school districts and parents cannot reach agreement regarding the education of their children; however, there is no evidence that the filing for a due process hearing has resulted in the District’s inability to perform an assessment of STUDENT in accordance with the requirements of the individual tests and with the requirements of the Education Code. The fact that advocates, parents, and districts often hold strong opinions in special education matters also does not disqualify District personnel from assessing STUDENT.
As to whether the proposed assessment plan is appropriate, the undisputed testimony of the District’s witnesses establishes that the test materials and procedures that will be employed in assessing STUDENT are not discriminatory and will be administered in STUDENT’s native language, English. The testimony also establishes that the tests will be administered in conformance with test instructions. The many assessment instruments are validated for the purpose for which they will be used. The District has proposed to assess STUDENT on a number of instruments measuring cognitive, academic, perceptual, motor, speech, and language skills. The assessment also will address STUDENT’s social and emotional functioning using a variety of instruments that include information from STUDENT’s parents and teachers. In addition to tests, the District’s assessment includes observations of STUDENT. STUDENT is a student with a learning disability. Her parent has expressed concern regarding her motor skills and social/emotional status. No other areas of suspected disability have been identified. The District’s proposed assessment addresses all of these areas. Therefore, the evidence also establishes that the District’s proposed assessment will assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability. The Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s proposed assessment satisfies the requirements of an appropriate assessment as set forth in the Education Code and the IDEA.
The Hearing Officer has concluded that, except for Ms. Rose, the District is entitled to use the assessors it has designated to conduct STUDENT’s assessment. The District’s proposed assessment plan has also been found appropriate. Therefore, the District is entitled to perform the assessment as proposed despite lack of parental consent. Education Code §§ 56506(e) and 56321(c).
STUDENT’s Issue: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to an independent assessment from qualified specialists at District expense?
The Education Code sets forth a remedy should the parents disagree with the District’s assessment of STUDENT. The parents have the right to obtain an independent assessment at the District’s expense following the District’s assessment; however, the District may demonstrate at a subsequent due process hearing that its assessment was appropriate. If the District prevails at the hearing, it does not have to pay for the independent assessment procured by the parents. The IEP team must take into consideration the results of the independent assessment regardless of how the assessment is funded. Education Code § 56329(b). In other words, the parent still has the right for an independent educational assessment, but not at public expense unless it is subsequently established at a due process hearing that the District did not conduct an appropriate assessment.
Because it was determined above that the District proposed an appropriate assessment for STUDENT and the assessment has not yet been undertaken, the Hearing Officer concludes that the parent is not now entitled to an independent assessment at District expense.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
District’s Issue: Is the District entitled to conduct a triennial assessment of STUDENT over the objection of her parents? The District prevailed on this issue.
STUDENT’s Issue: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to an independent assessment at District expense from qualified specialists? The District prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(I).
ORDER
(1) The District is entitled to conduct a triennial assessment of STUDENT as set forth in its proposed assessment plan signed by PARENT on April 12, 1997. (District’s Exhibit 3)
(2) The District is entitled to use the proposed personnel to assess STUDENT; however, in place of Ms. Rose, the District shall appoint a school psychologist, who is similarly credentialed and has suitable experience assessing elementary-age children, to perform those portions of STUDENT’s assessment in cognitive, social, emotional, and perceptual areas.
(3) STUDENT’s request for an independent assessment at District expense is denied.
DATED: September 11, 1997 _____________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES
1.PARENT signed the assessment plan. The handwritten modifications to the District’s plan were made by Ms. Drew. 2.Code §56329(b) provides for an “independent” assessment rather than an “impartial” assessment. 3.In February 1997, STUDENT’s parents requested a special education due process hearing on behalf of their other daughter, seeking reimbursement for an independent assessment and for her tuition at Los Altos. (SN 493-97) The parties agreed to an assessment of STUDENT’s sister by the District, which took place over six sessions from March 17, through March 27, 1997. 4.Section 614(c)(1)(A) and (B) provide that as part of any reevaluation, the IEP team and other qualified professionals shall review existing evaluation data and “identify what additional data, if any, are needed to determine whether the student continues to meet eligibility criteria, the present levels of performance, the educational needs of the student, whether the student continues to need special education and related services, and whether modifications or additions are needed for the student to meet goals and objectives and to participate in the general curriculum.” Subsection (2) of Section 614(c)(1)(B) provides that the district shall administer tests and other evaluation materials as needed to obtain the above information or, if it is determined that no additional data are needed to determine whether the student continues to be a child with a disability, the school district shall notify the child’s parents of that determination, the reasons for it, and inform the parents of the right to request an assessment. The district is not required to conduct an assessment unless requested to by the student’s parents. Section 614(4). Federal law apparently provides greater flexibility than California law in conducting triennial assessments. California has not adopted a provision allowing a district to determine whether additional data are needed for a triennial evaluation. Because current California law requiring a full assessment every three years affords more protection to the student, the Hearing Officer concludes that California law applies. 5.On rebuttal, PARENT stated that she no longer trusted Ms. Kalisvaart based on her assertion that Ms. Kalisvaart did not tell the truth about the reasons PARENT removed STUDENT from the District. 6.Ms. Phillips did not testify.
7. Ms. Rose testified that she did not change answers on the test and denied telling STUDENT’s sister, who is six years old, not to tell her mother about the testing or that she could not talk about it until Easter.
